TAMPA CITY COUNCIL
THURSDAY, APRIL 28, 2022
5:01 P.M.
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.
17:06:55 [GAVEL SOUNDING]
17:06:56 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GOOD AFTERNOON.
17:06:59 I WOULD LIKE TO CALL THIS TAMPA CITY COUNCIL MEETING TO
17:07:03 ORDER IF WE CAN HAVE ROLL CALL PLEASE.
17:07:05 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
17:07:08 >>CLERK: DINGFELDER -- SORRY, LOOKING AT THE WRONG
17:07:11 ONE.
17:07:13 LET'S START OVER.
17:07:15 >>ORLANDO GUDES: HERE.
17:07:17 >>JOSEPH CITRO: HERE.
17:07:18 >>LUIS VIERA: HERE.
17:07:19 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HERE.
17:07:20 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
17:07:23 >>CLERK: WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
17:07:25 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. SHELBY.
17:07:27 >>MARTIN SHELBY: YES, THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN AND
17:07:28 MEMBERS OF CITY COUNCIL.
17:07:32 MARTIN SHELBY, THURSDAY APRIL 28, 2022.
17:07:38 AND WE ARE HERE AT CITY -- AT OPENED CITY HALL FOR
17:07:42 TONIGHT'S QUASI JUDICIAL AND LAND USE HEARINGS.
17:07:44 THE PUBLIC AND THE CITIZENS OF TAMPA ARE ABLE TO WATCH,
17:07:48 LISTEN AND VIEW THIS MEETING SPECTRUM 640, FRONTIER
17:07:50 CHANNEL 15 AND INTERNET AT TAMPA.GOV/LIVESTREAM.
17:07:56 MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC MAY PARTICIPATE AT CITY COUNCIL
17:08:00 EITHER IN PERSON HERE IN THE CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS 315
17:08:03 EAST KENNEDY OR VIRTUALLY THROUGH VIDEO TELL
17:08:08 CONFERENCING AS COMMUNICATION MEDIA TECHNOLOGY.
17:08:11 PREREGISTRATION IS NECESSARY TO PARTICIPATE VIRTUALLY
17:08:15 ON A QUASI OR JUDICIAL MATTER.
17:08:18 FOR MORE INFORMATION, THAT IS ON THE WEB SITE AT
17:08:24 TAMPA.GOV/QUASI WHICH IS ON THE SAME PAGE AS
17:08:27 TAMPA.GOV/CITYCOUNCIL.
17:08:32 A REMINDER TO PARTICIPANTS ON THE VIRTUAL PLATFORM, YOU
17:08:34 MUST HAVE ACCESS TO A COMMUNICATION MEDIA TECHNOLOGY
17:08:38 DEVICE SUCH AS A COMPUTER OR CAMERA EQUIPPED WITH A
17:08:43 CAMERA AND MICROPHONE TO BE SEEN AND HEARD BY CITY
17:08:45 COUNCIL AND OTHER PARTICIPANTS.
17:08:49 SPECIFIC TWO-WAY VIRTUAL VIDEO FOR MAT, SMARTPHONES ARE
17:08:52 NOT COMPATIBLE AS THEY NOT ALLOW TO YOU SHARE YOUR
17:08:54 CAMERA WHEN CONNECTED.
17:08:57 WITH REGARD TO THE GO TO MEETING PLATFORM, THERE IS A
17:08:59 CHAT BOX AVAILABLE.
17:09:02 MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC, I ASK THAT YOU ONLY USE THAT FOR
17:09:03 TECHNICAL PROBLEMS.
17:09:11 DO NOT USE THE CHAT TO COMMUNICATE WITH CITY COUNCIL
17:09:12 DURING THE MEETING.
17:09:14 LIKEWISE THE SAME FOR E-MAILS AND TEXT.
17:09:18 IF ANY CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS GET E-MAILS OR TEXTS THAT
17:09:21 ARE RELATED TO TONIGHT'S HEARING, THAT YOU DO NOT LOOK
17:09:24 AT THEM OR YOU IMMEDIATELY IF YOU HAD, YOU DO DISCLOSE
17:09:24 THEM.
17:09:28 WITH REGARD TO EX-PARTE COMMUNICATIONS, ANY VERBAL
17:09:31 EX-PARTE COMMUNICATIONS PRIOR TO THE START OF THE
17:09:38 HEARING, PLEASE BE SURE TO DISCLOSE WITH WHOM THAT
17:09:41 HAPPENED AND SUM AND SUBSTANCE AND WHEN THAT HAPPENED
17:09:46 AND ALSO LASTLY THAT YOU ADOPT THESE RULES FOR CMT, TO
17:09:49 WAIVE THE RULES THAT ARE YOUR STANDING RULES AND ADOPT
17:09:53 THE RULES THAT ARE YOUR NOTICE AND IN THE INSTRUCTIONS
17:09:54 FOR TONIGHT'S HEARINGS.
17:09:57 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION TO ADOPT THE MOVE.
17:09:58 >>JOSEPH CITRO: SO MOVED.
17:09:59 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
17:10:01 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR.
17:10:02 ANY OPPOSED.
17:10:04 >>MARTIN SHELBY: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
17:10:06 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: JUST FOR THE RECORD, TWO ABSENCES
17:10:10 THIS EVENING AND MEMOS RECEIVED BY BOTH OFFICES.
17:10:13 COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK SENT A MEMO SHE WOULD NOT BE ABLE
17:10:17 TO ATTEND THIS EVENING'S MEETING DUE A PRIOR OBLIGATION
17:10:20 AND COUNCILMAN CARLSON HERE FOR THIS MORNING'S SESSION
17:10:23 WILL NOT BE ATTENDING THIS EVENING'S MEETING AND THEY
17:10:30 HAVE BOTH SENT MEMOS FOR THE RECORD.
17:10:31 ALL RIGHT, THERE YOU GO.
17:10:35 A MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA TO RECEIVE AND FILE AND
17:10:37 A SECOND BY COUNCILMAN GUDES.
17:10:38 ALL IN FAVOR.
17:10:38 OPPOSED.
17:10:40 WE HAVE A COUPLE OF CONTINUANCES.
17:10:44 WE ONLY HAVE FIVE COUNCILMEMBERS HERE THIS EVENING.
17:10:49 THERE IS A REQUEST FROM RUSSELL OTTENBERG FOR ITEM
17:10:54 NUMBER 7 THAT THIS HEARING BE CONTINUED TO JUNE 23,
17:10:55 2022.
17:11:01 THIS IS ITEM NUMBER 7, REZ 21-130.
17:11:06 MAY WE HAVE A MOTION -- YES?
17:11:10 OH, CAN WE GET A MOTION TO MOVE ITEMS 1-12.
17:11:13 A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA WITH A SECOND FROM
17:11:14 COUNCILMAN CITRO.
17:11:15 ALL IN FAVOR.
17:11:16 AYE.
17:11:17 ALL HEARINGS ARE OPEN.
17:11:21 ITEM NUMBER 7 THAT THEY WISH TO HAVE A CONTINUANCE.
17:11:26 WE HAD A MOTION FROM -- ANYBODY THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON
17:11:27 ITEM NUMBER 7.
17:11:28 JUST THE CONTINUANCE.
17:11:31 NOT THE SUBSTANCE OF THE CASE BUT JUST THE CONTINUANCE.
17:11:35 DO WE HAVE SOMEONE ON LINE?
17:11:36 ALL RIGHT.
17:11:40 MR. OTTENBERG, WE NEED TO SWEAR HIM IN JUST FOR THIS
17:11:42 CONTINUANCE?
17:11:43 >>MARTIN SHELBY: NO.
17:11:46 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. OTTENBERG, IF YOU WERE ON,
17:11:51 PLEASE TURN ON YOUR CAMERA AND UNMUTE YOURSELF.
17:11:51 >> GOOD EVENING.
17:11:53 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
17:11:55 >> I NEED TO BE SWORN IN?
17:11:57 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NOT ON THE CONTINUANCE.
17:11:58 GO AHEAD.
17:11:59 >> THANK YOU, CHAIRMAN.
17:12:03 AS THE LETTER SUBMITTED STATES, WE ARE -- WE REQUEST
17:12:06 THE ADDITIONAL TIME TO ADDRESS SOME CONCERNS THAT WE
17:12:10 BELIEVE WILL APPLY TO THIS APPLICATION THAT WERE RAISED
17:12:13 ON A COUPLE OF OTHER REZONINGS IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO
17:12:14 THIS.
17:12:20 AND THAT ARE -- THAT WERE VERY SIMILAR TO THIS FOR 306
17:12:24 SOUTH ALBANY AVENUE AND 3407 AND 409 SOUTH ALBANY
17:12:27 AVENUE THAT WAS HEARD A COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO.
17:12:31 WE WOULD LIKE SOME TIME TO WORK ON THESE ITEMS AND
17:12:34 ADDRESS CITY COUNCIL AND THE RESIDENTS' CONCERNS THAT
17:12:37 WERE BROUGHT UP DURING THOSE HEARINGS.
17:12:39 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN
17:12:40 REGARDING THE CONTINUANCE.
17:12:42 >>ORLANDO GUDES: MOVE TO CONTINUE.
17:12:43 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO NEED TO CLOSE IT.
17:12:46 MOTION TO CONTINUE FROM COUNCILMAN GUDES.
17:12:47 SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
17:12:50 >>MARTIN SHELBY: STATING THE DATE AND TIME.
17:12:54 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: JUNE 23, 2022 AT 5:01 P.M.
17:13:01 ROLL CALL.
17:13:02 >>JOSEPH CITRO: YES.
17:13:05 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
17:13:06 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
17:13:07 >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
17:13:08 >>ORLANDO GUDES: YES.
17:13:12 >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY WITH HURTAK AND
17:13:15 CARLSON BEING ABSENT.
17:13:16 >> THANK YOU.
17:13:18 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NEXT ITEM REQUEST FOR CONTINUANCE.
17:13:25 LETTER BY JULIA MANDELL REQUESTING THAT AB 2-21-21,
17:13:29 ITEM NUMBER 11 BE CONTINUED FOR JUNE 23, 2022 AT 5:01
17:13:30 P.M.
17:13:32 ANYBODY HERE TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 11.
17:13:34 JUST THE CONTINUANCE.
17:13:37 SEEING NONE, HEARING NONE, DO WE HAVE ANYBODY
17:13:41 REGISTERED FOR ITEM NUMBER 11.
17:13:49 >> MR. CHAIR, AB 2-21-21 BE MOVED TO JUNE 23, 2022.
17:13:53 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION BY COUNCILMAN CITRO, SECOND
17:13:54 BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
17:13:57 ROLL CALL.
17:13:59 >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
17:14:01 >>JOSEPH CITRO: YES.
17:14:05 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
17:14:07 >>ORLANDO GUDES: YES.
17:14:08 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
17:14:11 >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY WITH HURTAK AND
17:14:14 CARLSON BEING ABSENT.
17:14:15 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT, THOSE ARE THE
17:14:17 CONTINUANCES I HAVE FOR NOW.
17:14:29 WE WILL BEGIN WITH ITEM NUMBER 1.
17:14:42 DO WE HAVE ANYBODY FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSION?
17:14:45 >>CLERK: THEY ARE ONLINE.
17:14:46 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER 1.
17:14:48 GO AHEAD, SIR.
17:14:56 >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCILMAN, DIEGO VERA.
17:14:57 ITEM NUMBER 1.
17:15:00 I WOULD LIKE TO SHARE MY SCREEN FOR A QUICK
17:15:10 PRESENTATION.
17:15:12 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE CAN SEE IT.
17:15:13 JUST GOT TO MAKE IT BIGGER.
17:15:16 GO AHEAD.
17:15:24 >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
17:15:28 FILE NO. TA/CPA 21-23, TEXT AMENDMENT OF THE TAMPA
17:15:32 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN REGARDING THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD
17:15:33 AREA.
17:15:38 THIS IS A LOCAL AMENDMENT AND STATE WITH THE COASTAL
17:15:40 HIGH HAZARD AREA RECENTLY.
17:15:47 THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA IS SET BY -- ON THE SCREEN
17:15:49 COASTAL MANAGEMENT POLICY.
17:15:55 THIS A POLICY THAT WAS UPDATED WITH STATE LAW AND THE
17:15:58 WHEN THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA BECOMES EFFECTIVE.
17:16:02 GENTLEMEN, THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
17:16:06 PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDS CITY COUNCIL ADOPT THE
17:16:10 TEXT AMENDMENT TO.
17:16:13 AT THIS TIME I AM AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
17:16:15 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN AT
17:16:16 THIS TIME?
17:16:17 HEARING NONE.
17:16:23 ANYONE WHO WANTS TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 1.
17:16:26 DO WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE.
17:16:29 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION BY COUNCILMAN GUDES AND
17:16:32 SECOND BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
17:16:34 COUNCILMAN MIRANDA, READ THE SUBSTITUTE ORDINANCE FOR
17:16:42 ITEM NUMBER 1.
17:16:45 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: ITEM NUMBER 1, FILE NO. TA/CPA
17:16:47 21-23.
17:16:49 ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING
17:16:50 CONSIDERATION.
17:16:57 ORDINANCE AMENDING THE IMAGINE 2040 MANAGE FUTURE LAND
17:17:01 USE AMENDMENT FOR POLICIES 1.1.2 PROVIDING FOR REPEAL
17:17:06 OF ALL ORDINANCES AND CONFLICT, PROVIDING FOR SEVERAL
17:17:10 SEVERABILITY, PROVIDING FOR EFFECTIVE DATE.
17:17:11 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM?
17:17:21 [INAUDIBLE]
17:17:27 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: MY COLLEAGUE GOT ME THERE.
17:17:28 OKAY.
17:17:33 THIS DOESN'T HAVE A NUMBER ON IT AT ALL.
17:17:38 >>ORLANDO GUDES: IT IS ON THE AGENDA, RIGHT?
17:17:39 IT'S ON THE AGENDA.
17:17:42 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YOU WANT ME TO READ WHAT IS ON THE
17:17:42 AGENDA.
17:17:44 >>MARTIN SHELBY: IT IS NOT THE SAME.
17:17:51 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: ORDINANCE NUMBER 20-22, I WOULD
17:17:53 IMAGINE THE SAME NUMBER.
17:18:01 TA/CPA 21-23, ORDINANCE AMENDING THE IMAGINE 2040:
17:18:05 TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN COASTAL MANAGEMENT ELEMENT TO
17:18:10 AMEND COASTAL MANAGEMENT ELEMENT 1.1.2 PROVIDING FOR
17:18:13 REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT, PROVIDING FOR
17:18:18 SEVERABILITY PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
17:18:18 >>JOSEPH CITRO: SECOND.
17:18:19 >>JOSEPH CITRO: YES.
17:18:21 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
17:18:22 >>ORLANDO GUDES: YES.
17:18:23 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
17:18:26 >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY CARLSON AND HURTAK
17:18:32 BEING ABSENT SECOND READING AND ADOPTION MAY 19, 2022
17:18:34 AT 9:30.
17:18:40 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT, ITEM NUMBER 2.
17:18:45 >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCILMEN, DIEGO GUERRA, PLANNING
17:18:47 COMMISSION STAFF.
17:18:49 FILE NO. TA/CPA 21-24.
17:18:51 AMENDMENT FOR THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA.
17:18:55 THIS IS A PUBLIC INITIATED AMENDMENT.
17:18:59 THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA OF THE CITY OF TAMPA AND
17:19:03 THE UPDATE IS REQUIRED TO BE REFLECTED IN THE
17:19:05 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
17:19:11 THERE IS NO DESCRIPTION AT THE LOCAL LEVEL AS A COASTAL
17:19:12 HIGH HAZARD AREA.
17:19:15 THIS AMENDMENT UPDATES THE FUTURE LAND USE MAPS AND
17:19:20 PUBLIC ACCESS MAP AS DISPLAYED ON THE SCREEN.
17:19:27 THIS AMENDMENT ON THE SCREEN CURRENTLY ADOPTED IN THE
17:19:30 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
17:19:34 THIS UPDATED MAP NOW AVAILABLE AND DISPLAYED ON YOUR
17:19:39 SCREEN.
17:19:42 GENTLEMEN, THE PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDS CITY
17:19:48 COUNCIL ADOPT THE MAP AMENDMENT 8.1.24.
17:19:51 AT THIS TIME THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION AND I AM
17:19:53 AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
17:19:54 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE
17:19:55 GENTLEMAN?
17:19:59 ANYONE IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER
17:19:59 2?
17:20:02 DO WE HAVE ANYBODY REGISTERED?
17:20:03 >>ORLANDO GUDES: MOVE TO CLOSE.
17:20:04 >>JOSEPH CITRO: SECOND.
17:20:06 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR.
17:20:07 ANY OPPOSED.
17:20:10 COUNCILMAN VIERA, READ ITEM NUMBER 2.
17:20:13 >>LUIS VIERA: I MOVE AN ORDINANCE PRESENTED FOR FIRST
17:20:20 CONSIDERATION, THE IMAGINE 2040 TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE
17:20:26 PLAN AND COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA CHHA AND PROVIDING
17:20:30 FOR SEVERABILITY AND PROVIDING FOR EFFECTIVE DATE.
17:20:34 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
17:20:36 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
17:20:37 >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
17:20:39 >>JOSEPH CITRO: YES.
17:20:40 >>ORLANDO GUDES: YES.
17:20:40 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
17:20:44 >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY WITH CARLSON AND
17:20:53 HURTAK BEING BE A DENT.
17:21:00 >>CLERK: SECOND READING AND ADOPTION MAY 19, 9:30 A.M.
17:21:01 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER 3.
17:21:04 >>DANNY COLLINS: DANNY COLLINS.
17:21:06 MAY I SHARE MY SCREEN.
17:21:14 DANNY COLLINS WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
17:21:17 THE NEXT THREE AMENDMENTS ARE PARK AMENDMENTS.
17:21:21 I WILL GO THROUGH EACH ONE INDIVIDUALLY.
17:21:25 LET'S GET STARTED.
17:21:28 THE NEXT THREE AMENDMENTS WE ARE LOOKING AT FILE NO.
17:21:39 TA/CPA 21-31, 21-32, RECREATION CENTER, AND FILE NO.
17:21:44 TA/CPA 21-33.
17:21:44 USA PARK.
17:21:47 ALL THREE AMENDMENTS IN PUBLICLY INITIATED.
17:21:49 WHOOPS, SORRY ABOUT THAT.
17:21:52 ALL THREE AMENDMENTS ARE PUBLICLY -- WERE PUBLICLY
17:21:56 INITIATED FOR THE EXISTING CITY OF TAMPA PARKS.
17:21:59 EACH PARK IS LISTED ON THE CITY OF TAMPA DEDICATED PARK
17:22:03 LIST AND 16-91 OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
17:22:05 AND ALL SITES WILL BE RECOGNIZED THROUGH THE
17:22:09 RECREATIONAL/OPEN SPACE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
17:22:13 ALL PARKS -- THE PLANNING COMMISSION REVIEWED ALL PARKS
17:22:16 AND FOUND CONSISTENT WITH PROMOTING RECREATION AND OPEN
17:22:18 SPACE OPPORTUNITIES THROUGHOUT THE CITY.
17:22:22 OUR FIRST PARK IS FILE NO. TA/CPA 21-31.
17:22:26 INTERBAY POOL IN THE SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT AND
17:22:29 MORE SPECIFICALLY WITH THE HEIGHTS NEIGHBORHOOD.
17:22:32 HERE IS AN AERIAL MAP OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND
17:22:33 SURROUNDING PROPERTIES.
17:22:36 SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED AT THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF
17:22:40 NOUGHT MANHATTAN AVENUE AND WEST ESTRELLA STREET.
17:22:44 THE USE IS TO THE WEST OF THE SITE, SOUTH MANHATTAN
17:22:46 AVENUE ARE PRIMARILY RESIDENTIAL.
17:22:49 THERE ARE RESIDENTIAL USES TO THE NORTH AND SOUTH OF
17:22:52 THE SUBJECT SITE.
17:22:57 THIS IS AN IMAGE LOOKING AT THE SITE FROM SOUTH
17:22:59 MANHATTAN AVENUE.
17:23:02 ANOTHER IMAGE LOOKING -- SORRY ABOUT THAT.
17:23:05 ANOTHER IMAGE LOOKING AT THE ENTRANCE TO THE POOL.
17:23:09 THE SUBJECT SITE IS CURRENTLY RECOGNIZED UNDER THE
17:23:14 PUBLIC/SEMI-PUBLIC LAND USE DESIGNATION.
17:23:16 PRESENT TO THE NORTH, EAST AND SOUTH OF THE SITE.
17:23:19 DIRECTLY TO THE WEST OF THE SITE ARE PARCELS RECOGNIZED
17:23:20 UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-10.
17:23:23 AND SOUTHWEST OF THE SITE, OUR PARCEL IS RECOGNIZED
17:23:29 UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-6 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
17:23:32 HERE IS THE PROPOSED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
17:23:35 RECOGNIZE THE ENTIRE SITE UNDER THE RECREATIONAL/OPEN
17:23:40 SPACE DESIGNATION.
17:23:45 CURRENTLY THE SUBJECT SITE, WE CAN NOT DETERMINE THE
17:23:51 MAXIMUM INTENSITY UNDER THE PUBLIC-SEMI PUBLIC
17:23:52 DESIGNATION.
17:23:54 THOSE ARE TYPICALLY DETERMINED AT THE TIME OF
17:23:57 PERMITTING AND THIS AMENDMENT WILL REMOVE ANY POTENTIAL
17:24:00 RESIDENTIAL OR NONRESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT ON THE
17:24:00 SUBJECT SITE.
17:24:03 BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION
17:24:08 RECOMMENDS THAT THE PROPOSED MAP AMENDMENT TO FILE NO.
17:24:13 TA/CPA 21-21 ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE POLICIES OF THE
17:24:15 TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
17:24:17 THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
17:24:19 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN.
17:24:22 ANYONE WANTING TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 3.
17:24:24 ANYONE REGISTERED FOR 3.
17:24:25 >>JOSEPH CITRO: MOVE TO CLOSE.
17:24:26 >>ORLANDO GUDES: SECOND.
17:24:28 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR.
17:24:31 ANY OPPOSED.
17:24:32 COUNCILMAN CITRO.
17:24:36 >>JOSEPH CITRO: FILE NO. TA/CPA 21-31, ORDINANCE BEING
17:24:38 PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION.
17:24:42 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE IMAGINE 2040: TAMPA
17:24:48 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT, FUTURE
17:24:51 LAND USE MAP FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED 4321 WEST
17:24:56 ESTRELLA STREET OTHERWISE KNOWN AS INTERBAY POOL FROM
17:25:03 PUBLIC/SEMI-PUBLIC, P/QP TO RECREATIONAL/OPEN SPACE,
17:25:08 R/OS, PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCES IN
17:25:10 CONFLICT, PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY.
17:25:12 PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
17:25:14 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
17:25:16 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN CITRO AND
17:25:17 SECOND BY MIRANDA.
17:25:19 >>ORLANDO GUDES: YES.
17:25:20 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
17:25:21 >>JOSEPH CITRO: YES.
17:25:22 >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
17:25:23 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
17:25:26 >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY WITH HURTAK AND
17:25:27 CARLSON BEING ABSENT.
17:25:30 SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MAY 19,
17:25:35 2022 AT 9:30 A.M.
17:25:36 >>JOSEPH CITRO: THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR.
17:25:37 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
17:25:39 MR. COLLINS, NUMBER 4.
17:25:43 >>DANNY COLLINS: NEXT CASE IS FILE NO. TA/CPA 21-32.
17:25:45 FOR MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. RECREATIONAL COMPLEX IN THE
17:25:49 CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT AND MORE SPECIFICALLY
17:25:50 IN THE WEST RIVER NEIGHBORHOOD.
17:25:54 HERE IS AN AERIAL MAP OF THE SURROUNDING SITE AND
17:25:54 SURROUNDING PROPERTIES.
17:25:57 THE SUBJECT SITE IS GENERALLY NORTH AND WEST OF SPRUCE
17:26:01 STREET AND TO THE NORTH OF WEST OREGON AVENUE.
17:26:06 HERE IS AN IMAGE LOOKING AT THE SITE FROM SOUTH OREGON
17:26:07 AVENUE.
17:26:12 THIS IS ANOTHER SHOT LOOKING AT THE SITE FROM SOUTH
17:26:14 OREGON AVENUE AS WELL.
17:26:18 HERE IS THE ENTRANCE TO THE FACILITY.
17:26:22 CURRENTLY THE SUBJECT SITE IS RECOGNIZED AS A
17:26:25 NEIGHBORHOOD MIXED USE 35 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
17:26:28 THAT DESIGNATION TO THE NORTH, EAST AND SOUTH OF THE
17:26:32 SUBJECT SITE, TO THE WEST OF THE SITE IS UNDER THE
17:26:33 RESIDENTIAL-35 DESIGNATION.
17:26:37 AS PROPOSED, THE SUBJECT SITE WILL BE RECOGNIZED UNDER
17:26:41 THE RECREATIONAL/OPEN SPACE DESIGNATION.
17:26:44 THIS MAP AMENDMENT WOULD REMOVE THE CONSIDERATION OF
17:26:50 THE 191 DWELLING UNITS FOR 356,755 SQUARE FEET OF
17:26:52 RESIDENTIAL OR NONRESIDENTIAL USES FROM THE SUBJECT
17:26:56 SITE.
17:27:00 COUNTY COMMISSION REVIEWED THE PROPOSED MAP AMENDMENT,
17:27:04 FILE NO. TA/CPA 21-32 AND RECOMMEND THAT IT IS FOUND
17:27:09 CONSISTENT WITH THE GOALS OBJECTIVE AND POLICIES OF THE
17:27:12 IMAGINE 2040: TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
17:27:15 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN?
17:27:18 ANYONE WISHING TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 4?
17:27:19 ANYONE REGISTERED.
17:27:21 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: MOVE TO CLOSE.
17:27:21 >>ORLANDO GUDES: SECOND.
17:27:23 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR.
17:27:23 OPPOSED.
17:27:26 COUNCILMAN GUDES, ITEM NUMBER 4.
17:27:28 >>ORLANDO GUDES: THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN.
17:27:29 FILE NO. TA/CPA 21-32.
17:27:33 ORDINANCE FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION AMENDING THE
17:27:37 2040: TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, FUTURE LAND USE
17:27:41 ELEMENT, FUTURE LAND USE MAP, FOR PROPERTY LOCATED 2200
17:27:46 NORTH OREGON AVENUE OTHERWISE KNOWN AS DR. MARTIN
17:27:47 LUTHER KING, JR. RECREATION COMPLEX FROM NEIGHBORHOOD
17:27:54 MIXED USE 35 TO RECREATIONAL/OPEN SPACE R/OS PROVIDING
17:27:56 FOR REPEAL.
17:27:59 PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
17:28:01 DATE.
17:28:06 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION BY COUNCILMAN GUDES AND.
17:28:08 >>JOSEPH CITRO: YES,
17:28:10 >>ORLANDO GUDES: YES.
17:28:11 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
17:28:14 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
17:28:16 >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY WITH CARLSON AND
17:28:18 HURTAK BEING ABSENT.
17:28:23 SECOND ADOPTION MAY 19, 2022 AT 9:30 A.M.
17:28:25 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER 5.
17:28:30 >>DANNY COLLINS: OUR LAST AMENDMENT FOR TONIGHT, FILE
17:28:37 NO. TA/CPA, IN THE CENTRAL PARTNERSHIP USF PARK.
17:28:41 IN THE CENTRAL BUSINESS DISTRICT PERIPHERY.
17:28:44 THE SUBJECT SITE ON THE AERIAL MAP IN THIS BLACK COLOR.
17:28:50 IT IS ALONG JUST TO THE WEST OF SOUTH DRIVE SOUTH OF
17:28:52 THE SELMON EXPRESSWAY.
17:28:55 THERE IS AN IMAGE LOOKING AT THE SUBJECT SITE FROM
17:28:57 SOUTH ASHLEY DRIVE.
17:29:01 THIS IS LOOKING AT THE -- LOOKING EAST FROM THE SUBJECT
17:29:03 SITE OF SOUTH ASHLEY DRIVE.
17:29:08 THE SUBJECT SITE IS CURRENTLY UNDER THE PUBLIC/SEMI
17:29:10 PUBLIC DESIGNATION.
17:29:14 THE DESIGNATION IS FOUND NORTH, EAST AND SOUTH OF THE
17:29:17 SUBJECT SITE, ACROSS FROM THE SUBJECT SITE TO THE WEST.
17:29:22 OUR PARCELS ARE RECOGNIZED UNDER THE RMU-100 AND
17:29:25 RECREATIONAL/OPEN SPACE ALONG THE WATER.
17:29:27 THIS MAP AMENDMENT WILL RECOGNIZE THE ENTIRE SITE UNDER
17:29:31 THE RECREATIONAL/OPEN SPACE DESIGNATION.
17:29:35 HERE IS A SLIDE SHOWING THE POTENTIAL IMPACTS OF THE
17:29:38 PROPOSED CHANGE WILL REMOVE ANY POTENTIAL RESIDENTIAL
17:29:40 OR NONRESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT FROM THE SUBJECT SITE.
17:29:43 THE PLANNING COMMISSION REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FOUND
17:29:46 IT CONSISTENT WITH THE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES
17:29:52 OF THE IMAGINE 2040 TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND THIS
17:29:53 CONCLUDES THE PRESENTATION.
17:29:56 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. COLLINS?
17:29:58 ANYBODY FROM THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM
17:29:59 NUMBER 5?
17:30:02 DO WE HAVE ANYBODY REGISTERED.
17:30:04 >>ORLANDO GUDES: MOTION TO CLOSE.
17:30:05 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
17:30:06 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR.
17:30:07 OPPOSED.
17:30:11 COUNCILMAN MIRANDA, ITEM NUMBER 5.
17:30:16 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: ITEM NUMBER 5, FILE NO. TA/CPA
17:30:17 21-33.
17:30:20 ORDINANCE PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION,
17:30:26 ORDINANCE AMENDING THE IMAGINE 2040 TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE
17:30:32 PLAN, FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT, FUTURE LAND USE MAP FOR
17:30:36 THE PROPERTY LOCATED 225 SOUTH ASHLEY DRIVE OTHERWISE
17:30:43 KNOWN AS USF PARK FROM PUBLIC/SEMI-PUBLIC P/QP TO
17:30:48 RECREATION/OPEN SPACE R/OS PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ALL
17:30:53 ORDINANCES AND PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY.
17:30:55 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA AND
17:30:57 SECONDED.
17:30:59 >>ORLANDO GUDES: YES.
17:31:04 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
17:31:05 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
17:31:08 >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY WITH HURTAK AND
17:31:11 CARLSON BEING ABSENT.
17:31:14 SECOND READING MAY 19, 2021 AT 9:30.
17:31:17 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE GO INTO QUASI JUDICIAL HEARING
17:31:19 ON 6-IT.
17:31:23 IF YOU ARE HERE TO SPEAK ON ANY ITEMS 6-12, PLEASE
17:31:27 STAND UP AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND WE WILL SWEAR
17:31:28 EVERYBODY IN.
17:31:32 [SWEARING IN]
17:31:33 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
17:31:39 YOU HAVE BEEN SWORN IN AND SO HAVE THE PEOPLE ON THE
17:31:40 SCREEN.
17:31:40 THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
17:31:44 ITEM NUMBER 6.
17:31:46 >>ERIC COTTON: GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
17:31:49 ERIC COTTON, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
17:31:56 ITEM NUMBER 6, FILE NUMBER REZ-21-127.
17:31:57 A CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING.
17:32:01 A REQUEST TO REZONE AT 3003 WEST CYPRESS STREET FROM
17:32:06 CG, COMMERCIAL GENERAL, TO PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, TO
17:32:08 DEVELOPMENT ARE RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED.
17:32:12 NOW I WILL TURN IT OVER TO MR. COLLINS FROM THE
17:32:18 PLANNING COMMISSION.
17:32:21 >>DANNY COLLINS: DANNY COLLINS, AGAIN, WITH THE
17:32:21 PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
17:32:22 I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN.
17:32:27 THE FIRST CASE IS IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING
17:32:30 DISTRICT IN THE WEST TAMPA URBAN VILLAGE.
17:32:33 CLOSEST TRANSITS 130 FEET WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE WEST
17:32:35 OF CYPRESS STREET.
17:32:38 THE SITE IS SERVED PROVIDING CONNECTIONS TO TAMPA
17:32:42 INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AND DOWNTOWN TAMPA.
17:32:46 CLOSEST RECREATION FACILITY VILA BROTHERS PARK TO THE
17:32:47 SOUTHEAST OF THE SITE.
17:32:51 THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE LEVEL E
17:32:53 EVACUATION ZONE.
17:32:54 AERIAL MAP OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND SURROUNDING
17:32:55 PROPERTIES.
17:32:59 IT IS GENERALLY EAST OF MACDILL, AT THE INTERSECTION OF
17:33:01 MACDILL AND WEST CYPRESS STREET.
17:33:04 THERE ARE NONRESIDENTIAL USES DIRECTLY TO THE WEST OF
17:33:05 THE SUBJECT SITE.
17:33:10 TO THE NORTH, EAST AND SOUTH ARE RESIDENTIAL USES.
17:33:14 HERE IS THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
17:33:18 THE ENTIRE SITE UNDER THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35 LAND
17:33:20 USE DESIGNATION.
17:33:24 CMU-35 IS PRESENTS ALONG THE NORTH SIDE OF WEST
17:33:28 CYPRESS STREET AND NORTH SIDE OF CYPRESS STREET.
17:33:31 PREDOMINANTLY RECOGNIZED UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-20 LAND
17:33:32 USE DESIGNATION.
17:33:35 YOU TRANSITION SOUTH AND ALSO NORTH OF THE SUBJECT
17:33:38 SITE, IT TRANSITIONS TO A RESIDENTIAL-10 SINGLE-FAMILY
17:33:40 NEIGHBOR.
17:33:43 THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE
17:33:45 INFORMATION AND FOUND NO IMPACTS TO THE SURROUNDING
17:33:46 NEIGHBORHOOD.
17:33:49 THE PORTION OF WEST CYPRESS IS DEVELOPED AT 27% OF THE
17:33:53 DENSITY UNDER THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE DESIGNATION.
17:33:57 THIS IS PRIMARILY DUE TO WEST CYPRESS STREET PRIMARILY
17:34:00 CONSISTING OF SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED HOMES AND
17:34:02 COMMERCIAL USES ALONG THE SEGMENT.
17:34:05 THE REQUEST PROPOSES 47 SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED UNITS
17:34:09 WITH OVERALL DENSITY OF 23 UNITS PER ACRE WHICH IS
17:34:13 BELOW THE DENSITY THAT IS ANTICIPATED UNDER THE CMU-35
17:34:14 DESIGNATION.
17:34:17 ADDITIONALLY THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED ON A COLLECTOR
17:34:20 ROADWAY WHERE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED UNITS ARE
17:34:23 ENCOURAGED IN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
17:34:26 THE PLAN DEVELOPMENT ADDRESSES THE MIXED USE POLICIES
17:34:30 BY PLACING PROPOSED RESIDENTIAL UNITS CLOSE TO THE
17:34:33 PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAYS, AND INCLUDING THE ORIENTATION OF
17:34:38 THE FRONT DOOR, RIBBON SIDEWALK AND STREET.
17:34:41 PD HAS INTERNAL CONNECTIONS THAT HELP ENSURE PEDESTRIAN
17:34:44 SAFETY, ACCESSIBILITY AND MORE WALKABLE URBAN
17:34:46 ENVIRONMENT ALONG CYPRESS.
17:34:47 THE REQUEST SUPPORTS MANY.
17:34:50 POLICIES IN THE COMP PLANS A IT RELATES TO HOUSING THE
17:34:53 CITY'S POPULATION BY DEVELOPING THE SITE AT A DENSITY
17:34:57 OF 23.26 UNITS PER ACRE, THE REQUEST WILL ADD
17:35:00 ADDITIONAL HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES TO THE GROWING CENTRAL
17:35:02 PLANNING DISTRICTS.
17:35:05 THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ENCOURAGE NEW HOUSING ON
17:35:10 VACANT LANDS TO MEET THE NEED OF CONTINUE'S FUTURE --
17:35:12 CURRENT AND FUTURE POPULATIONS.
17:35:14 BASED ON THE CONSIDERATION, THE PLANNING COMMISSION
17:35:16 STAFF FINDS THE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH THE
17:35:17 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
17:35:21 AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
17:35:22 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
17:35:25 DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. COLLINS?
17:35:27 ALL RIGHT, MR. COTTON, I SEE YOU ARE ON.
17:35:28 >>ERIC COTTON: YES, SIR.
17:35:30 THANK YOU, CHAIR.
17:35:34 ERIC COTTON, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
17:35:37 MAY I SHARE MY SCREEN, PLEASE.
17:35:40 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD, SIR, WE CAN SEE IT.
17:35:41 >>ERIC COTTON: THANK YOU.
17:35:50 A REZONING REZ-21-127 FOR PROPERTY 3003 WEST CYPRESS
17:35:50 STREET.
17:35:53 AS MR. COLLINS ALLUDED TO, THE APPLICANT IS SEEKING TO
17:35:55 DEVELOP THE PROPERTY WITH SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED
17:35:58 ELEMENT.
17:36:02 THE APPLICANT IS ASKING FOR FOUR WAIVERS.
17:36:05 FIRST TO REDUCE THE SOUTHERN SETBACK ALONG THE FRONT
17:36:09 YARD SETBACK, AND THIS IS IN WEST TAMPA BASED ON BLOCK
17:36:11 AVENUE FROM 25 DOWN TO 10 FEET.
17:36:16 REDUCE THE BACK-UP WIDTH FROM SIX FEET TO TWO FEET AND
17:36:20 I SHOW THE SITE PLAN SO COUNCIL KNOWS WHERE THE REQUEST IS
17:36:20 AT.
17:36:24 TO ALLOW FOR THE 40 TO 47 GROUND FLOOR ENTRANCES NOT TO
17:36:26 FACE THE COMING STREET, AND REDUCE THE BUILDING
17:36:31 SEPARATION FROM 15 FEET TO NINE FEET FOR BUILDINGS H, G
17:36:35 AND F.
17:36:39 SO THIS IS -- PROPERTIES ON THE CORNER OF NEW JERSEY
17:36:40 AND CYPRESS.
17:36:43 THIS IS THE ORIGINAL PLAT.
17:36:48 IT WAS PLATTED BACK IN 1919 TEN UNITS FOR TEN LOTS.
17:36:50 THE PROPERTY SURROUNDING THIS DEVELOPMENT.
17:36:52 THE DEVELOPMENT HERE IS HIGHLIGHTED IN THE RED.
17:36:58 TO THE NORTH IS SINGLE-FAMILY DEVELOPMENT ALONG THE
17:37:01 WEST, WHICH IS OVER HERE IS DEVELOPED WITH COMMERCIAL
17:37:03 -- COMMERCIAL PROPERTY.
17:37:07 ACROSS NEW JERSEY -- ACROSS CYPRESS ON THE SOUTH SIDE
17:37:13 IS A MIXTURE OF COMMERCIAL AND SOME RESIDENTIAL.
17:37:17 AND LET'S SEE -- SORRY ABOUT THIS.
17:37:22 AND -- SO THE ZONING ACROSS THE STREET IS CN AND PD
17:37:24 ALONG WITH SINGLE-FAMILY.
17:37:29 PROPOSED USES FOR EIGHT SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED PLANS.
17:37:32 THIS IS THE EXISTING SITE PLAN.
17:37:35 LET ME GO TO THE ACTUAL DEVELOP -- THE PROPOSED
17:37:36 DEVELOPED PLAN ON HERE.
17:37:40 THIS IS THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT ON THE SITE.
17:37:44 SO JUST GOING THROUGH THE WAIVERS AND LOOKING AT THE
17:37:48 SITE PLAN ITSELF.
17:37:52 THE REQUIRED SETBACK ALONG CYPRESS IS -- SHOULD BE 25
17:37:53 FEET.
17:37:56 YOU SEE THIS AREA RIGHT THROUGH HERE IS ONLY THE 10.
17:37:59 AGAIN, THIS IS BASED ON BLOCK AVERAGE.
17:38:02 THE BACK-UP SPACE AS SOMEBODY BACKS OUT OF THE GARAGES
17:38:06 ON THIS TOWN HOME ALONG NEW JERSEY.
17:38:10 THIS IS SUPPOSED TO BE -- SIX FEET IS ONLY SUPPOSED TO
17:38:11 BE TWO.
17:38:17 THE ONLY HOMES THAT HAVE FRONTAGE FACING THE STREET ARE
17:38:18 ALONG CYPRESS.
17:38:22 THE REMAINING PROPERTIES ARE ALL INWARD FACING.
17:38:25 THAT IS ONE OF THE OTHER WAIVERS AND THE LAST WAIVER IS
17:38:29 THE BUILDING SEPARATION FOR -- BETWEEN LOTS BUILDINGS
17:38:39 H, G AND F.
17:38:43 STAFF FOUND THE OVERALL REQUEST INCONSISTENT WITH
17:38:47 REVISIONS REQUIRED BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
17:38:51 THE REVISION SHEET HAS BEEN ATTACHED TO THE STAFF
17:38:53 REPORT THAT HAS BEEN SUBMITTED TO COUNCIL.
17:38:56 THIS TO REVIEW THE PROPOSED ELEVATIONS.
17:39:03 THE HOMES -- THE BUILDINGS ARE ABOUT 35 FEET TALL.
17:39:06 THEY ARE USING TWO-CAR GARAGES IN THE MAJORITY OF THEM
17:39:11 AND THEY WILL HAVE REQUIRED THE VISITOR PARKING SPACES.
17:39:14 THE EXISTING SITE AS THE TAMPA LETTER CARRIERS BUILDING
17:39:19 AND VIEWS LOOKING WESTWARD DOWN CYPRESS.
17:39:20 THIS IS THE REAR OF THE BUILDING.
17:39:24 THIS IS ALONG NEW JERSEY.
17:39:28 AGAIN, THIS IS CYPRESS AND NEW JERSEY.
17:39:33 AND THIS IS LOOKING EAST BACK TOWARD DOWNTOWN.
17:39:37 AGAIN, FINDING WAS INCONSISTENT.
17:39:40 MODIFICATIONS MUST BE MADE TO THE SITE PLAN AS STATED
17:39:43 IN THE REVISION SHEET BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
17:39:48 IF COUNCIL IS INCLINED TO APPROVE IT, A APPLICANT NOTE
17:39:50 TO GO THROUGH THE TAME PROCESS.
17:39:53 NO CONSTRUCTION IN THE EASEMENT AREA UNTIL THE EASEMENT
17:39:56 IS APPROVED.
17:39:58 THAT COMPLETES MY PRESENTATION.
17:40:00 DO YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR ME?
17:40:03 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. COLLINS.
17:40:05 HEARING NONE?
17:40:07 APPLICANT, YES, SIR.
17:40:10 >> GOOD EVENING, MR. CHAIRMAN, COUNCILMEMBERS.
17:40:15 MY NAME IS DAVID MECHANIK, SOUTH BOULEVARD, TAMPA,
17:40:15 FLORIDA.
17:40:19 I'M HERE ON BEHALF THE APPLICANT ONYX AND EAST.
17:40:22 WITH ME IS JACOB EGAN WITH ONYX AND EAST.
17:40:27 ALSO WITH ME WITH GREG ROTH, ENGINEER WITH BOWLER ENGINEERS.
17:40:35 MICHAEL YATES, A CERTIFIED TRANSPORTATION PLANNER.
17:40:38 ERIN BARKE, AN ARCHITECT.
17:40:43 I WOULD ASK TO ENTER THEIR RESUMES INTO THE RECORD.
17:40:49 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
17:40:54 >> SINCE WALKED AWAY FROM THE MIC, I DIDN'T ENTER MY
17:40:55 SENTENCE.
17:40:58 BUT ENTER THE RESUME AS EXPERT WITNESSES IN THIS CASE.
17:41:01 I WOULD LIKE TO MENTION THAT I WAS JUST HANDED SOME
17:41:03 FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION DOCUMENT.
17:41:08 I HAVE NO IDEA WHAT IT IS OR HOW IT PERTAINS TO THIS
17:41:09 PROJECT.
17:41:15 SO I CANNOT ADDRESS IT, OF COURSE.
17:41:21 BEFORE I INTRODUCE MR. ROTH, I WANT TO MAKE A FEW KEY
17:41:22 POINTS.
17:41:26 OUR PERMITTED DENSITY ON THIS SITE IS 60 UNITS.
17:41:29 AND WE ARE ONLY PROPOSING 47 UNITS.
17:41:33 WE ARE WELL BELOW THE PERMITTED DENSITY.
17:41:38 I ALSO WOULD LIKE TO POINT OUT THAT THE STAFF, BOTH
17:41:41 THE CITY ZONING STAFF AND PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF,
17:41:45 DETERMINE THAT THE USES THAT WE ARE PROPOSING ARE
17:41:48 COMPATIBLE WITH THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
17:41:54 AND THEY ALSO POINTED OUT THAT WE FURTHER AN OBJECTIVE
17:41:58 OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN TO PROVIDE FOR INFILL HOUSING
17:42:01 IN TAMPA, WHICH IS SORELY NEEDED.
17:42:07 I WOULD LIKE TO ADDRESS ONE OF THE WAIVERS AND GREG
17:42:11 ROTH WILL SPEAK IN MORE DETAIL ABOUT THIS, BUT ABOUT
17:42:14 THREE WEEKS AGO, CITY COUNCIL AMENDED THE CITY CODE TO
17:42:23 ALLOW FOR HOUSES TO NOT BE REQUIRED TO FACE A PUBLIC
17:42:24 RIGHT-OF-WAY.
17:42:26 THEY ONLY HAD TO FACE EITHER A PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY OR
17:42:28 AN INTERNAL DRIVEWAY.
17:42:34 THAT CODE SECTION WAS NOT AMENDED TO AFFECT
17:42:36 SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED HOUSING, WHICH IS ESSENTIALLY
17:42:38 THE SAME HOUSING TYPE.
17:42:41 SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED, AS MY CLIENT IS PROPOSING TO
17:42:44 BUILD IT, IS A TOWN HOME.
17:42:47 AND SO FOR THAT REASON, WE DON'T UNDER STAND WHY THERE
17:42:50 WOULD BE A DISTINCTION.
17:42:53 AND THIS, ALONE, WOULD JUSTIFY THE WAIVER THAT WE ARE
17:42:54 ASKING FOR.
17:42:59 AT THIS TIME, I WOULD LIKE TO ASK MR. ROTH TO ADDRESS
17:43:00 THE PROJECT IN GENERAL AND THE WAIVERS.
17:43:01 THANK YOU.
17:43:07 >>MARTIN SHELBY: MR. MECHANIK.
17:43:07 >> YES.
17:43:10 >>MARTIN SHELBY: YOU GAVE ME TWO IDENTICAL COPIES.
17:43:14 ONE FOR THE CLERK AND ONE TO BE PASSED AROUND?
17:43:17 >> WHATEVER IS THE PREFERENCE, THANK YOU.
17:43:19 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD AND STATE YOUR NAME.
17:43:23 >> GREGORY ROTH WITH BOLLER.
17:43:25 LICENSED CIVIL ENGINEER.
17:43:32 3820 NORTHDALE BOULEVARD AND WE HAVE BEEN SWORN IN.
17:43:35 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I KNOW ONYX EAST.
17:43:37 >> THERE YOU GO.
17:43:42 HOW I DO CONTROL THIS.
17:43:49 IS THERE A WAY TO CHANGE THE SLIDE HERE FROM MY ANGLE.
17:43:51 MAYBE NOT?
17:43:52 DOES THIS CONTROL THE SLIDE?
17:43:53 PERFECT.
17:43:54 THERE WE GO.
17:43:54 OKAY.
17:43:56 PERFECT.
17:43:59 SO FIRST WANT WOULD WALK THROUGH THE SITE PLAN.
17:44:02 AND JUST SO -- TO BRING EVERYBODY BACK TO WHERE WE ARE.
17:44:06 AN EXISTING STRUCTURE ON-SITE WITH SOME SURFACE PARKING
17:44:10 AND TWO EXISTING DRIVEWAYS THAT ACCESS CYPRESS STREET.
17:44:13 AS MENTIONED, THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT IS 27 TOWN HOME
17:44:17 UNITS, FEE SIMPLE TOWN HOMES AND TWO DRIVEWAYS, ONE ON
17:44:21 CYPRESS AND ONE ON NEW JERSEY.
17:44:25 THE SITE -- THE SITE PLAN ITSELF MEETS ALL RESIDENTIAL
17:44:26 AND GUEST PARKING REQUIREMENTS.
17:44:31 WE MEET ALL PUA AND GREEN SPACE REQUIREMENTS AND TREE
17:44:34 PRESERVATION REQUIREMENTS WHICH I AM HAPPY TO REPORT
17:44:36 NOT A TON ON THIS PROJECT.
17:44:39 WE ARE PROPOSING UNDERGROUND STORMWATER AND KIND OF
17:44:42 WANT TO GET THROUGH INTO THE WAIVERS TO TALK ABOUT A
17:44:44 COUPLE OF THEM IN PARTICULAR.
17:44:48 THE FIRST WAIVER IS THE BLOCK AVERAGE SETBACK FOR THE
17:44:52 BUILDINGS ALONG CYPRESS FROM 25 FEET DOWN TO 10 FEET.
17:44:55 WORTH NOTING FOR THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY, THE PARCEL
17:44:59 TAKES UP THE ENTIRE BLOCK, AND SO IT WILL ESTABLISH THE
17:45:00 BLOCK AVERAGE.
17:45:05 THE 25-FOOT SETBACK IS REFERENCED FROM THE RM-24 ZONING
17:45:05 REQUIREMENTS.
17:45:09 THE SECOND WAIVER IS THE BACK-UP WAIVER FROM SIX FOOT
17:45:11 TO TWO FEET IN WIDTH.
17:45:13 WE CAN PHYSICALLY PROVIDE AND YOU CAN SEE TWO AREAS
17:45:16 WHERE WE ARE ASKING FOR THAT ALONG NEW JERSEY.
17:45:18 WHERE YOU BACK OUT FROM THE GARAGES FROM THE TOWN
17:45:19 HOMES.
17:45:23 WE COULD PHYSICALLY PROVIDE THE SIX FEET, BUT INSTEAD
17:45:26 OF ASKING FOR THIS WAIVER, WE WOULD ACTUALLY BE ASKING
17:45:32 FOR A LANDS SCAPE PUA BUFFER WAIVER.
17:45:36 WE STUDIED BOTH OPTIONS TO SEE WHAT IS THE LEAST
17:45:37 INTRUSIVE.
17:45:43 AND SO WE RAN AUTO TURN WITH A F-150 SUPER CAB TRUCK
17:45:45 BACKING OUT OF THAT WESTERNMOST GARAGE.
17:45:48 AND YOU CAN SEE IN THE LOWER RIGHT CORNER THERE, A ZOOM
17:45:51 IN ON THE EXHIBIT, SHOWING THAT TRUCK PULLING OUT AND
17:45:55 HAD NO ISSUE BACKING OUT, GETTING INTO AND OUT OF THE
17:45:57 GARAGE IN THE WESTERNMOST SPOT.
17:46:00 CONSIDERING THE FACT THAT WE ARE ABLE TO FULLY ACCESS
17:46:04 THAT WESTERN GARAGE WITH THE TWO-FOOT BACK-UP INSTEAD
17:46:08 OF THE SIX, WE DECIDED SEEKING THIS WAIVER WAS LEAST
17:46:11 INTRUSIVE AND ALLOWED US TO KEEP THE GREEN SPACE AND
17:46:13 NOT ASK FOR ANY NATURAL RESOURCE WAIVERS.
17:46:18 THE THIRD WAIVER IS THE NUMBER OF FRONT DOORS FACING
17:46:21 THE RIGHT-OF-WAY WHICH DAVE DID MENTIONED THE CODE
17:46:23 CHANGE IN HIS OPENING REMARKS.
17:46:26 BUT JUST TO TALK TO IT FROM A SITE PLAN STANDPOINT.
17:46:31 THERE PHYSICALLY WOULD BE NO WAY TO LAY THIS SITE OUT
17:46:34 AT A CORNER PARCEL THE WAY IT IS TODAY WITH MEETING OR
17:46:38 ACHIEVING THE DENSITY THAT WOULD BE ALLOWED BY CODE
17:46:40 WITHOUT ASKING FOR THIS WAIVER.
17:46:42 THERE IS JUST NO WAY TO MAKE THAT WORK.
17:46:47 WE DID LOOK AT MULTIPLE OPTIONS FOR A SITE PLAN AS WELL
17:46:50 AS TO TRY TO SEE IF THERE WAS A WAY TO REDUCE THE
17:46:51 WAIVER.
17:46:55 BUT BY DOING THAT, WILL REQUIRE US TO ADD OTHER WAIVERS
17:46:58 REDUCING SOME OF THE PARKING AND IMPACTING SOME OF THE
17:47:01 EXISTING TREES THAT WE WERE TRYING TO SAVE WITH THE
17:47:02 SITE PLAN.
17:47:07 SO, AGAIN, THAT -- THAT IS THE REASON FOR THAT BACK-UP
17:47:08 OR THE WAIVER.
17:47:11 THE FINAL WAIVER IS REDUCE THE BUILDING SEPARATION FROM
17:47:13 15 FEET TO 9 FEET.
17:47:16 WE CAN ACCOMMODATE THIS ONE, BUT WHAT WOULD HAPPEN
17:47:19 IMPACT THE TREES THAT ARE LOOK TO PRESERVE NORTH OF THE
17:47:22 EASTERN ROAD BUILDINGS AND THE SOUTH THEN.
17:47:25 FOR NOW, I WILL TURN IT OVER TO MICHAEL YATES TO
17:47:30 DISCUSS TRAFFIC.
17:47:33 >> GOOD EVENING, MICHAEL YATES WITH TRAFFIC.
17:47:35 AND I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
17:47:38 I AM GOING TO GO BRIEFLY THROUGH THE TRAFFIC NUMBERS.
17:47:41 SO BASICALLY AS YOU CAN SEE ON THE SCREEN, WE ARE A
17:47:44 SLIGHT INCREASE OVER THE EXISTING OFFICE USE THAT IS ON
17:47:47 THE SITE TODAY.
17:47:49 IT IS 123 DAILY TRIPS.
17:47:54 A REDUCTION OF 21 A.M. PEAK-HOUR TRIPS AND INCREASE OF
17:47:57 ONLY SIX P.M. HOUR TRIPS.
17:48:02 WHAT THAT EQUATES TO THE LESS OF 1% INCREASE OF TRAFFIC
17:48:04 ON CYPRESS STREET.
17:48:08 SO VERY MINOR INCREASE OF THE CAPACITY.
17:48:12 AND THEN WHAT WE ALSO DID IS LOOK AT SOME ALTERNATIVE
17:48:14 USES THAT CAN BE DONE UNDER CG.
17:48:17 AS YOU CAN SEE FROM THE TRIP GENERATION TABLE THERE IN
17:48:25 THE LOWER LEFT, IT IS 105 FOR A RESTAURANT, 145 FOR A
17:48:28 FAST CASUAL RESTAURANT, AND WE LOOKED AT AN APARTMENT
17:48:32 COMPLEX OF 140 UNITS AND 81 TRIPS COMPARED TO THE 21
17:48:35 P.M. PEAK-HOUR TRIPS THAT WE HAVE.
17:48:38 WE ARE A SUBSTANTIAL REDUCTION IN ANY OF THE USES A
17:48:40 THAT CAN BE DONE ON-SITE.
17:48:44 WE ALSO LOOKED AT THE LEVEL OF SERVICE TABLES THAT ARE
17:48:47 PRODUCED BY THE MPO.
17:48:51 IT IS SHOWING THAT THE VO -- THE VOLUME TO CAPACITY OF
17:48:53 ROAD IS AT .55.
17:48:57 ONLY HALF OF THE CAPACITY IS BEING USED TODAY BASED ON
17:49:00 THE LEVEL OF SERVICE REPORT.
17:49:12 I AM GOING TO TURN IT OVER TO JACOB.
17:49:18 >> TO CHANGE THE SLIDE.
17:49:23 >> HELLO, ERIN BARKER, AND I AM THE DESIGN DIRECTOR
17:49:25 FOR SHARP DESIGN STUDIO IN TAMPA.
17:49:29 AS THEY MENTIONED THE SITE CONSISTS OF SINGLE-FAMILY
17:49:35 ATTACHED HOMES ENTRY RAISED 24 ABOVE GRADE AND
17:49:37 BUILD-TO OF 35 FEET FOR LESS.
17:49:40 ALL THE HOMES HAVE A FRONT GREEN SPACE OF A SMALL FRONT
17:49:42 YARD OR A COURTYARD.
17:49:44 THE HOMES ARE DESIGNED IN A HISPANIC ECLECTIC
17:49:47 ARCHITECTURE.
17:49:51 THE SLOPED ROOFS INCORPORATE FIVE TO SIX AND 12 PITCHES
17:49:54 AND BARREL TILE ROOF.
17:49:58 AT THE TOP OF THE BUILDING IS A PARAPET WHICH IS
17:50:01 CONSISTENT TO THE NEIGHBORING ARCHITECTURE.
17:50:05 TO THE WEST A COMMERCIAL BUILDING WITH A SMALL PARAPET.
17:50:08 ACROSS THE STREET IS A BUSINESS WITH A PARAPET WALL.
17:50:13 AND I BELIEVE ALESSI HAS ONE WITH AN APPLIED ROOF TO
17:50:14 IT.
17:50:16 THE BUILDING -- THE ADDITIONAL SPANISH DETAILING
17:50:22 INCORPORATES THE USE OF BRACKETS, SCORED STUCCO, THE
17:50:26 TILE ROOF, AND TILE -- EXCUSE ME TILE ACCENTS AND THE
17:50:29 HALF ROUND OPENINGS AT THE FRONT PORCHES.
17:50:32 AND THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION AND I WILL TURN IT
17:50:37 OVER TO JACOB.
17:50:40 >> GOOD EVENING, JACOB EGAN.
17:50:43 2002 EAST 4TH AVENUE.
17:50:46 ONYX AND EAST, THE APPLICANT.
17:50:48 FLIP THROUGH A COUPLE OF SLIDES HERE.
17:50:51 I WANT TO TALK VERY BRIEFLY ABOUT THE SITE AND LOOKING
17:50:54 AT IT AND THE INTENTION PUT INTO IT TO BLEND IN WITH
17:50:55 THE USES.
17:50:57 DIRECTLY TO THE WEST AS WE DESCRIBED IS A GROCERY STORE
17:50:59 WITH INTENSIVE COMMERCIAL.
17:51:03 TWO BUILDINGS DOWN TO THE EAST IS ALESSI BAKERY, HEAVY
17:51:04 COMMERCIAL.
17:51:06 TO THE NORTH OF US IS SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL AS HAVE
17:51:07 BEEN DESCRIBED PREVIOUSLY.
17:51:10 WE VIEW THIS AS A GREAT BLEND BETWEEN THE VARIOUS USES.
17:51:14 WE ARE UNDER ITS DENSITY ALLOWED OF 60 UNITS.
17:51:16 WE ARE AT 47.
17:51:18 SO WE ARE CARRYING FROM THE COMMERCIAL INTO THE
17:51:20 RESIDENTIAL COMPONENT OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
17:51:24 I ALSO WANTED TO POINT OUT, THAT WITH THE ARCHITECTURAL
17:51:28 THAT ERIN JUST DESCRIBED, THIS WAS VERY INTENTIONALLY
17:51:31 DESIGNED TO MATCH THE WEST TAMPA DISTRICT IN GENERAL
17:51:35 HISTORICALLY AS A HEAVY SPANISH, MEDITERRANEAN
17:51:37 ARCHITECTURAL STYLE.
17:51:40 SO THE REASONING FOR THE ELEVATIONS IS TO BLEND IN WITH
17:51:41 THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
17:51:44 WITH THAT, I AM GOING TO HAND IT BACK OVER TO DAVID
17:51:46 MECHANIK WHO WILL WRAP UP FOR US.
17:51:48 THANK YOU.
17:51:51 >> THIS IS DAVE MECHANIK AGAIN.
17:51:55 JUST BRIEFLY, I NEGLECTED TO MENTION THAT THE URBAN
17:52:02 DESIGN DEPARTMENT FOUND THE WAIVERS THAT AFFECT THEIR
17:52:05 DEPARTMENT TO BE ACCEPTABLE AND THEY WERE NOT OBJECTING
17:52:07 IN ANY WAY TO THIS APPLICATION.
17:52:09 WITH THAT, WE WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
17:52:10 THANK YOU.
17:52:13 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. MECHANIK?
17:52:15 NONE AT THIS TIME.
17:52:18 IS THERE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON
17:52:20 THIS ITEM?
17:52:22 ALL RIGHT.
17:52:27 IF YOU WERE NOT SWORN IN, WHEN YOU APPROACH THE
17:52:29 LECTERN, SWEAR YOU IN.
17:52:32 ALMOST EVERYONE WITH THE EXCEPTION WERE SWORN IN.
17:52:33 YES, MA'AM.
17:52:35 >> IS THERE A MIC?
17:52:37 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: INTEGRATED THERE.
17:52:42 >> SANDY SANCHEZ AND I HAVE TWO PEOPLE WHO ARE GOING TO
17:52:46 -- WHO HAVE SIGNED TO GIVE ME SOME OF THEIR TIME.
17:52:48 I HAD THREE OTHER PEOPLE BUT THE WEATHER HAS KEPT THEM
17:52:51 BACK, SO I WILL TRY TO DO THE BEST I CAN.
17:52:54 I THINK IT IS ONE OF THE SITUATIONS WHERE DAVID AND
17:52:55 GOLIATH HERE.
17:52:58 BUT NEVERTHELESS, WE WILL TRY DO SOMETHING WITH THE
17:52:59 MATERIAL WE HAVE.
17:53:02 >>MARTIN SHELBY: IF I CAN, MISS SANCHEZ, YOU ALSO
17:53:05 HANDED OUT MATERIAL TO COUNCILMEMBERS TODAY?
17:53:06 >> YES, I DID.
17:53:08 >>MARTIN SHELBY: YOU HAVE ONE FOR THE RECORD, I
17:53:10 UNDERSTAND.
17:53:10 >> YES.
17:53:14 >>MARTIN SHELBY: THE NAME AIDAN -- ADRIAN, LAST NAME,
17:53:15 SIR.
17:53:17 LARAMIE.
17:53:20 AND MARK -- HOOP.
17:53:26 TWO EXTRA MINUTES PLEASE FOR MISS SANCHEZ.
17:53:28 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM, PLEASE GO AHEAD AND
17:53:33 STATE YOUR NAME.
17:53:35 >> I DON'T KNOW IF YOU CAN SEE THAT.
17:53:38 >>MARTIN SHELBY: NO, NOT YET.
17:53:40 >> BUT I CAN BEGIN.
17:53:42 >>MARTIN SHELBY: YOU WANTS TO GO TO THE OVERHEAD.
17:53:44 I DON'T KNOW IF YOU CAN DO THAT FROM THE CONTROL ROOM,
17:53:45 PLEASE.
17:53:46 >> I HAVE GOT IT HERE.
17:53:47 I DON'T KNOW WHAT ELSE TO DO WITH IT.
17:53:49 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
17:53:49 >> OKAY.
17:53:51 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE CAN MAKE IT BIGGER ON OUR
17:53:53 SCREEN, PERFECT.
17:53:55 >> YOU ARE JUST ASKING THE IMPOSSIBLE AND TAKING UP OUR
17:53:55 TIME.
17:53:57 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IT IS GOOD.
17:53:59 YOUR TIME HAVEN'T STARTED.
17:54:01 WE CAN SEE -- WE CAN SEE IT.
17:54:04 >> YOU HAVE THE PACKET IN FRONT OF YOU SO YOU SHOULD BE
17:54:04 FINE.
17:54:06 OKAY.
17:54:10 MY NAME IS SANDY SANCHEZ FROM THE GARDENS CIVIC
17:54:13 ASSOCIATION AND I'M HERE TO ASK TO YOU DENY THE WAIVERS
17:54:15 NEEDED FOR THIS DEVELOPMENT TO PROCEED.
17:54:17 SORRY, I AM SOAKING WET.
17:54:20 ANYWAY, LOOK AT ITEM NUMBER 1.
17:54:23 I CAN'T BELIEVE BOTH THE CITY PLANNING AND
17:54:26 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN FOLKS MISSED THE WHITE ELEPHANT IN
17:54:27 THE ROOM.
17:54:30 THE 2020 REPORT FROM THE FDOT PLANNED FOR THE
17:54:33 RENOVATION OF I-275 THAT IS GOING THROUGH OUR CITY.
17:54:36 THIS PART OF THE PLAN THAT INCLUDES THE INTERMODAL
17:54:39 TRANSPORTATION CENTER TO BE BUILT ON WEST CYPRESS.
17:54:44 HOW CAN THIS POSSIBLY HAVE BEEN MISSED?
17:54:47 YOU WILL NOTE THAT REPORT IS IN 2020, JUST TWO YEARS
17:54:47 AGO.
17:54:51 AT A GENERAL MEETING OF NEIGHBORHOODS THIS PAST MONDAY,
17:54:54 MR. VIK BHIDE OF CITY OF TAMPA MOBILITY DEPARTMENT
17:54:58 EXPLAINED THAT EVEN THOUGH THE FDOT PLAN WAS NOT IN HIS
17:55:01 CONTROL, HE DID CONFIRM CYPRESS STREET TO BE THE
17:55:04 TRANSIT CORRIDOR BETWEEN DOWNTOWN TAMPA AND THE
17:55:05 AIRPORT.
17:55:08 CYPRESS IS THE ONLY POSSIBILITY FOR THIS CORRIDOR.
17:55:10 THINK ABOUT IT.
17:55:15 IRONICALLY, I HAD ALREADY EXCHANGED E-MAIL WITH KRISTIN
17:55:18 CARSON OF THE FDOT MARCH 23 OF THIS YEAR AND SHE
17:55:22 CONFIRMED, DOT STILL OWNS THE PROPERTY ACROSS FROM
17:55:24 JEFFERSON HIGH SCHOOL ON CYPRESS.
17:55:27 AND THERE ARE STILL PLANS TO GO FORWARD WITH INTERMODAL
17:55:31 TRANSPORTATION CENTER.
17:55:34 THIS ITEM FOR CONFIRMATION OF THIS INFORMATION.
17:55:38 NOW I WILL LOOK TO YOU LOOK AT ITEMS 2 AND 3, WHICH ARE
17:55:41 THE TRANSPORTATION, THE TRAFFIC REPORTS SUBMITTED BY
17:55:43 THE DEVELOPER.
17:55:45 THE FRONT PAGE OF THIS DOCUMENT STATES THE REPORT WAS
17:55:48 SUBMITTED IN AUGUST OF 2021.
17:55:52 BUT IF YOU LOOK FURTHER TO THE THIRD PAGE, YOU WILL SEE
17:55:56 THAT THE -- FOR THIS REPORT WAS FROM 2017.
17:55:59 GENTLEMEN, THAT IS FIVE YEARS AGO.
17:56:02 MIDTOWN WAS NOT BUILT.
17:56:08 NEITHER WAS THE FOUNDRY ON ARMENIA.
17:56:13 TO FURTHER THE EMPHASIS ON THE OBSOLETE MATERIAL, THE
17:56:16 LAST PAGE OF THE REPORT HAVE THE TAMPA LEVEL OF SERVICE
17:56:19 REPORT FROM 2015, AGAIN, SEVEN YEARS AGO.
17:56:22 AT THIS POINT, IT WAS RATED AS A D.
17:56:23 E IS FAILING.
17:56:29 WITH THE TRAFFIC TODAY, THIS -- THAT REPORT WOULD FAIL.
17:56:32 >> IT CLEARS ITEMS NUMBER 4 AND 5.
17:56:33 THE TRAFFIC.
17:56:36 THE REAL TRAFFIC THAT IS IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
17:56:53 I ALSO INCLUDED -- A COPY, A MAP, FOR OUR
17:56:54 NEIGHBORHOOD.
17:56:58 GENTLEMEN, I WOULD LIKE YOU TO TAKE A LOOK AT THIS.
17:57:02 THE YELLOW LINE IS GOING NORTH AND SOUTH.
17:57:04 THEY ARE THE MAJOR THOROUGHFARES THROUGH OUR
17:57:05 NEIGHBORHOODS.
17:57:08 THE GREEN LINE GOING AROUND IT IS THE NEIGHBORHOOD
17:57:11 ITSELF THAT IS EXPECTED -- THAT IS GOING TO BE
17:57:15 INFLUENCED BY THIS DECISION THAT YOU MAKE.
17:57:18 THE PINK LINES GOING THROUGH ARE THE LINES THAT OTHER
17:57:21 PEOPLE TAKE TO CUT THROUGH OUR NEIGHBORHOODS.
17:57:24 PLEASE NOTICE ALL THE STOP LIGHTS AROUND OUR
17:57:25 NEIGHBORHOOD.
17:57:28 AND YOU WILL SEE THAT ON THE CORNER OF HABANA AND
17:57:34 KENNEDY, THERE IS A NEW STOPLIGHT GOING UP AND NEW
17:57:38 STOPLIGHT AT ARCH WHEN MIDTOWN PUTS IN THEIR 16-STORY
17:57:38 BUILDING.
17:57:42 THOSE ROADS GO DIRECTLY INTO THE NEIGHBORHOOD, NORTH OF
17:57:44 CYPRESS.
17:57:56 THE TRAFFIC IS SO BAD ON CYPRESS THAT THE COMMUNITY
17:57:59 HAS SPOKEN TO VIK BHIDE, DIRECTOR OF MOBILITY, FOR HELP
17:58:03 AT THE CORNER OF HABANA AND CYPRESS, 400 FEET AWAY FROM
17:58:04 THIS PROPOSED PROJECT.
17:58:08 THIS IS A CONTINUAL OCCURRENCE OF ACCIDENTS AND NEAR
17:58:11 MISSES AT THIS CORNER, AND EVEN HAD A TRAFFIC FATALITY.
17:58:14 AGAIN, MISSED INFORMATION.
17:58:17 CURRENT TRAFFIC REPORTS WILL BE ABLE TO CONFIRM SOME OF
17:58:19 THIS IF THESE REPORTS WERE CURRENT.
17:58:24 AGAIN, HOW THE CITY PLANNERS AND COMPREHENSIVE PLANNERS
17:58:27 DID NOT REMEMBER THE TRANSIT CORRIDOR ON CYPRESS AND
17:58:31 NOT NOTICE THAT THESE TRAFFIC REPORTS ARE OBSOLETE IS
17:58:33 BEYOND MY COMPREHENSION.
17:58:36 NONE OF THE ABOVE ITEMS MENTIONED IN THE STAFF REPORT
17:58:38 AND THE COMPREHENSIVE PLANS.
17:58:38 WHY IS THAT.
17:58:42 I COULDN'T HELP BUT NOTICE 24 DUPLICATE LETTERS FROM
17:58:44 THE LETTER CARRIERS.
17:58:46 ONLY ONE PROBLEM WITH THAT, NONE OF THEM LIVE IN OUR
17:58:47 COMMUNITY.
17:58:51 I AM ALWAYS AMAZED WHEN ONE DEPARTMENT MARKS A PLAN
17:58:52 CONSISTENT.
17:58:53 THE DEVELOPER DOES NOTHING.
17:58:57 AND THE FOUND IS -- THE PLAN IS FOUND CONSISTENT.
17:58:59 BOTH REPORTS ARE MOVING TARGETS.
17:59:01 NOTHING CHANGED FROM THE CITY PLANNING REPORT.
17:59:04 THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY IS STILL IN EFFECT.
17:59:07 WE WILL HAVE TO REALIZE HOW THEY REMAIN AND GET RESPECT
17:59:10 FOR THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY IS IGNORED.
17:59:12 CAN I KEEP GOING?
17:59:14 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO, THAT'S IT.
17:59:15 MA'AM.
17:59:16 THAT WAS THE FIVE MINUTES.
17:59:22 >> ONE LAST LITTLE NOTE, PLEASE.
17:59:24 IF YOU GRANT THESE WAIVERS, WHICH ARE ALSO TOTALLY
17:59:27 OPPOSED TO THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY, YOU WILL JEOPARDIZE
17:59:30 THE ABILITY TO COMPLY WITH THE D.O.T.'S PLANS.
17:59:35 YOU WILL NOT BE ABLE TO CLAIM EMINENT DOMAIN AND
17:59:40 SQUELCH THE OPPORTUNITY TO GIVE RELIEF FROM HEAVY
17:59:42 TRAFFIC AND OVERBUILDING AND THE ABILITY TO MOVE
17:59:45 FORWARD WITH MASS TRANSPORTATION IS SO BADLY NEEDED.
17:59:51 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
17:59:57 MR. COTTON WAS FROM THE CITY AND COLLINS WAS FROM THE
17:59:59 PLANNING COMMISSION.
18:00:01 YOU WANT TO ASK A QUESTION?
18:00:02 ERIC COTTON.
18:00:05 MR. COTTON, IF YOU WERE ON THE LINE, A QUESTION FROM
18:00:06 COUNCILMAN GUDES.
18:00:09 >>ERIC COTTON: YES, SIR.
18:00:12 >>ORLANDO GUDES: LISTENING TO MISS SANCHEZ WHO IS --
18:00:16 ONE OF THE PIONEERS OVER THERE AT THAT COMMUNITY.
18:00:18 IS THIS PROPOSAL CONSISTENT WITH THE WEST TAMPA
18:00:22 OVERLAY?
18:00:25 >> THE ONLY WAIVER -- KEVIN JOHNSON FROM THE URBAN
18:00:26 DESIGN GROUP.
18:00:29 THE ONLY WAIVERS THEY ARE ASKING FOR IS THE FRONT YARD
18:00:31 SETBACK FOR THE BLOCK AVERAGE ON THE SOUTHERN PORTION
18:00:33 FROM 25 DOWN TO 10.
18:00:41 THE REST OF THE OVERLAY DISTRICT WAS FOUND TO BE IN
18:00:45 COMPLIANT.
18:00:46 >> YES, SIR I WAS.
18:00:47 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: STATE YOUR NAME.
18:00:51 >> CHRISTOPHER SWIGON, THE VICE PRESIDENT FOR THE
18:01:17 NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION.
18:01:20 >> CATEGORIES TO MAINTAIN THE CURRENT DENSITY OF
18:01:22 CHARACTER OF EXISTING SINGLE-FAMILY AREAS.
18:01:25 PROTECT AREAS OF THE LOWEST INTENSITY OF DEVELOPMENT
18:01:27 THAT ARE CURRENTLY AND PREDOMINANTLY SINGLE-FAMILY
18:01:32 RESIDENTIAL USE OR HAVE ENVIRONMENTAL INFRASTRUCTURE
18:01:36 CONSTRAINTS SUCH AS ENVIRONMENTALLY CRITICAL AREAS AND
18:01:39 RESPOND TO COMMUNITY PLAN POLICIES FOR REDEVELOPMENT OR
18:01:41 INFILL DEVELOPMENT THAT MAINTAINS THE SINGLE-FAMILY
18:01:46 CHARACTER OF AN AREA BUT ALLOWS FOR GREATER HOUSING
18:01:47 TYPES.
18:01:49 WE WOULD ASK CITY COUNCIL TO PROTECT THE DESIRE TO
18:01:52 REMAIN A LOWER DENSITY NEIGHBORHOOD.
18:01:57 .TWO, CITY OF TAMPA 2040 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PAGE 173,
18:01:59 POLICY 2.2.3.
18:02:02 DEVELOP COMMUNITY PLANS FOR THOSE AREAS OF THE CITY
18:02:05 EXPECTED TO EXPERIENCE SIGNIFICANT GROWTH.
18:02:08 EACH PLAN SHALL REFLECT THE NEIGHBORHOOD HISTORY,
18:02:14 CHARACTER, CURRENT CONDITIONS, NEEDS, VALUES.
18:02:17 THEIR CHARACTER IF SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED HOME.
18:02:20 THEIR CURRENT CONDITION IS 90% SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED
18:02:21 HOMES.
18:02:23 THEIR VISION AND GOALS ARE TO REMAIN SINGLE-FAMILY
18:02:25 DETACHED HOMES IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD.
18:02:30 POINT THREE, LAND USE POLICY 9 BE 1.2 WHICH IS TO
18:02:33 ENCOURAGE SENSITIVE DESIGN AND SITE PLANS IN URBAN
18:02:35 NEIGHBORHOODS THAT MITIGATE THE SCALE OF LARGER
18:02:40 BUILDINGS THROUGH CAREFUL USE OF BUILDING MASS
18:02:46 SETBACKS, ARTICULATION, FENESTRATION AND ARCHITECTURAL
18:02:48 DESIGNS.
18:02:49 SORRY.
18:02:51 THE WEST TAMPA NEIGHBORHOOD DOES NOT CONTAIN ANY
18:02:53 FOUR-STORY RESIDENTIAL HOMES.
18:02:56 FOR THAT MATTER, THIS NEIGHBORHOOD DOES NOT CONTAIN ANY
18:02:59 BUT ONE THREE-STORY HOME AT THIS POINT.
18:03:01 THE WEST TAMPA.
18:03:05 .4, 9.5.2, MAINTAIN THE CHARACTER OF SINGLE-FAMILY
18:03:08 RESIDENTIAL AREAS AND DISCOURAGE THE DEMOLITION OF
18:03:10 SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES, RESIDENTS AND DISPLACEMENT OF
18:03:13 RESIDENTS IN A WAY THAT ENCOURAGES REHABILITATION AND
18:03:16 PROVIDES HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE CITY.
18:03:19 FOR THE CHARACTER OF SINGLE-FAMILY AREA INCLUDES USE
18:03:21 DEVELOPMENT AND DENSITY CHARGE STATISTICS.
18:03:24 WE ASK CITY COUNCIL TO MAINTAIN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD'S
18:03:27 DENSITY CHARACTERISTICS.
18:03:29 THANK YOU, GENTLEMEN.
18:03:32 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
18:03:35 MA'AM, YOU WERE NOT SWORN IN.
18:03:36 >> NO, I WAS NOT.
18:03:39 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND.
18:03:40 WE WILL SWEAR YOU IN.
18:03:42 ANYONE WHO HAS COME IN SENSE.
18:03:43 I SEE A FEW PEOPLE.
18:03:46 IF YOU PLAN ON SPEAKING, PLEASE STAND AND RAISE YOUR
18:03:48 RIGHT HAND.
18:03:52 [SWEARING IN]
18:03:54 >> I DO.
18:03:55 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
18:03:56 PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
18:03:59 >> MAY I PRESENT SOME DOCUMENTS?
18:04:40 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SURE.
18:04:41 YES, MA'AM, GO AHEAD.
18:04:49 >> DEBBIE ZABERMAN, CITY OF TAMPA CORSICA STREET.
18:04:51 AND I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
18:04:54 I PROVIDED TWO LETTERS INTO THE RECORD THAT I HAVE
18:04:56 PASSED OUT TO ALL OF YOU.
18:04:59 THEY GO INTO QUITE A BIT OF DETAIL THAT INCLUDES CASE
18:05:02 AND POINT AND DIFFERENT SECTIONS OF THE CODE THAT NEED
18:05:03 TO BE LOOKED AT.
18:05:05 I WOULD LIKE TO START OFF BY SAYING THAT THE CITY
18:05:08 ACTUALLY ISN'T BEING BUILT ACCORDING TO THE CODE.
18:05:11 THIS IS A GREAT PICTURE THAT CITY STAFF WAS ALLOWED TO
18:05:13 SHARE HOW TO ACCESS THIS.
18:05:15 YOU CAN SEE THE ENTIRE NEIGHBORHOOD ALL OVER THE CITY
18:05:16 BEING BUILT BY PD.
18:05:19 WE COME IN FRONT OF YOU OVER AND OVER AND OVER AGAIN
18:05:21 SAYING THAT THE CITY IS NOT BEING BUILT ACCORDING TO
18:05:22 CODE.
18:05:25 IT IS BEING BUILT ACCORDING TO EXCEPTION.
18:05:26 THIS IS NO DIFFERENCE.
18:05:30 SOMEONE IN STAFF NEEDS TO GO THROUGH THE WEST TAMPA
18:05:31 OVERLAY.
18:05:34 A NUMBER OF POINTS THAT ARE LISTED OUT IN DETAIL THAT I
18:05:37 WON'T HAVE TIME TO GO THROUGH IN THREE MINUTES, BUT THE
18:05:40 STAFF REPORT NEEDS TO CONSIDER EVERY DETAIL IN THAT
18:05:43 REPORT AND SAY WHY THEY ARE NOT REQUIRING THAT.
18:05:46 THE OTHER THING IS, WE NEED A LOT OF LEGAL HELP IN THE
18:05:47 COMMUNITY.
18:05:50 IT SEEMS LIKE WORDS MEAN SOME THINGS IN ONE MEETING.
18:05:53 AND IN ANOTHER MEETING, WORDS MEAN SOMETHING ELSE.
18:05:57 THE CODE IS VERY CLEAR THE WORD "SHALL"THAT IS USED IS
18:06:00 MANDATORY AN INTERPRETATION 27.41.
18:06:04 WITHIN THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY, SUSPENDERS AND TWO
18:06:07 ZIPPERS BECAUSE IT SAYS THAT WAIVER OF THESE
18:06:10 REQUIREMENTS IS NOT AN OPTION AS THE CODE SPECIFICALLY
18:06:13 STATES SHALL -- SHALL COMPLY WITH THE STANDARDS AND
18:06:17 CLARIFIES THAT CASES OF CONFLICT, THE MORE RESTRICTIVE
18:06:19 STANDARDS APPLY.
18:06:22 AND FURTHER, IT STATES THAT MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS THAT
18:06:26 MUST BE MET IN ORDER TO GAIN APPROVAL.
18:06:29 HOW THOSE WORDS THAT WE WORKED SO HARD TO GET IN THE
18:06:31 CODE AREN'T FOLLOWED IS A MYSTERY US TO THAT WE NEED
18:06:32 HELP WITH THAT.
18:06:36 THE OTHER THING IS, I DON'T UNDERSTAND WITH ANASTASIA
18:06:42 BARNES LETTER OF MARCH 1, 2022.
18:06:45 GOES AND SAYS STAFF WILL SUPPORT WAIVING CERTAIN ITEMS.
18:06:47 WHY ARE THEY SUPPORTING IT?
18:06:50 THEY ARE IN CONFLICT WITH THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY THAT
18:06:53 THE NEIGHBORHOOD WORKED SO HARD TO GET AND ALSO THE PD
18:06:55 IS NOT APPROPRIATE FOR THE SITE.
18:06:58 WE SAID IT OVER AND OVER AND OVER AGAIN.
18:07:00 THE OTHER THING IS JUMPING THROUGH HERE, YOU GOT A
18:07:04 PARKING REQUIREMENT THAT SAYS THAT IT COULD CREATE SOME
18:07:06 POTENTIAL SAFETY ISSUES.
18:07:08 WHENEVER THERE IS A STAFF REPORT THAT HIGHLIGHTS
18:07:12 POTENTIAL SAFETY ISSUES, I THINK THE CITY NEEDS TO
18:07:15 QUANTIFY AND CHARACTERIZE DO YOU HAVE ANY EXPOSURE FOR
18:07:16 THAT.
18:07:21 AND ALSO PLEASE LOOK AT THE SECTION 27-241-G WHICH
18:07:24 TALKS ABOUT MAXIMIZING EFFICIENT MASS TRANSIT
18:07:28 OPPORTUNITIES AND THE POTENTIAL FOR EASEMENT DEDICATION
18:07:29 AND TRANSIT SHELTERS.
18:07:32 I DON'T SEE THAT ON THE RECORD.
18:07:34 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR LISTENING TO US.
18:07:38 WE ALMOST FEEL LIKE OUR DISCUSSION IS MEANINGLESS,
18:07:40 BECAUSE WHEN WE COME IN FRONT OF YOU, THE CODE DOESN'T
18:07:40 MATCH.
18:07:44 ONE OTHER THING, IF I MAY, MISS BARNES ACTUALLY SAID
18:07:47 THAT THE 14 FEET -- MAY I FINISH.
18:07:49 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM, GO AHEAD.
18:07:51 >> I HAVE FOR YEARS SAID THAT THE FOOTNOTE TO SECTION
18:07:56 27-156 MEANS THAT THE YARDS ARE SUPPOSED TO INCREASE BY
18:07:59 HEIGHT OVER 30 FEET ON ALL YARDS.
18:08:03 MISS BARNES SAYS THAT IN THIS MEMO SHE HAS, AND THAT IS
18:08:04 NOT BEING APPLIED.
18:08:06 THEY ARE DOING A WEDDING CAKE.
18:08:07 NOWHERE IN THE CODE.
18:08:11 ALSO THAT SAME INFORMATION WAS PROVIDED TO NEW BEACH
18:08:13 PARK IN THE EXPERT WITNESS REPORT.
18:08:15 AGAIN, WE GET IGNORED ALL THE TIME ON THAT.
18:08:18 WE NEED HELP TO MAKE SURE YOUR CODE IS BEING FOLLOWED
18:08:22 AND WHEN WE SHOW UP HERE AND THE WORK WE DO WITH YOUR
18:08:26 WONDERFUL STAFF ACTUALLY RESULTS IN ACTIONS THAT MATCH
18:08:29 THE CODE AND THE OVERLAY DISTRICTS.
18:08:30 THANK YOU SO MUCH.
18:08:32 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
18:08:34 >> OH, YES.
18:08:36 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
18:08:38 PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
18:08:40 >> MY NAME IS ANDREW LAWRENCE.
18:08:41 I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN.
18:08:44 WEST NASSAU STREET THAT DIRECTLY SHARES THE BOARD WE
18:08:48 ARE THIS POTENTIAL PROPERTY AND A RESIDENT OF THE TAMPA
18:08:50 BAY AREA FOR THE LAST 37 YEARS.
18:08:54 I AM SPEAKING TODAY TO ECHO THE 40-PLUS RESIDENTS WHO
18:08:58 WROTE IN TO OPPOSE THIS REDISTRICTING PROJECT.
18:09:00 DOES NOT HAVE 47 HOMES PACKED CONTINUE TO.
18:09:04 I AM PERFECTLY ACQUAINTED TO CHANGE IN PROGRESS.
18:09:07 FOUR OR PERHAPS SIX UNATTACHED AT THE MAXIMUM.
18:09:12 THE NUMBER 47 DOESN'T CROSS THE BOUNDARY OF ABSURD BUT
18:09:15 CROSSES THE BOUNDARY SEVERAL TIMES.
18:09:21 THIS IS THE NEIGHBORHOOD PUSHED IN A SINGLE LOT.
18:09:26 TRAFFIC, CYPRESS IS UNUSABLE DURING PEAK HOURS AND MY
18:09:28 CARS SPEEDING DOWN IT.
18:09:33 WE DON'T HAVE SIDEWALKS, AND I RISK MY LIFE GOING IN
18:09:33 THE ROAD.
18:09:37 MY NEXT-DOOR NEIGHBOR HAD HER MAILBOX LEVELED WHICH I
18:09:40 WOULD LIKE TO SUPPLY HERE BECAUSE WE HAVE NO SIDEWALKS
18:09:42 AND EVERYBODY SPEEDS DOWN OUR ROAD.
18:09:46 THIS PROJECT -- IN OVERREACH WOULD EASILY ADD 100 NEW
18:09:49 VEHICLES AROUND THE CORNER TO SKIRT CYPRESS AND USE OUR
18:09:52 STREET WHICH IS A DANGEROUS AND POSSIBLY DEADLY
18:09:53 DISASTER.
18:09:56 I AM HOPING THIS MAILBOX DOESN'T BECOME A CHILD OR DOG
18:09:57 ONE DAY.
18:09:59 I AM CONCERNS OF INFRASTRUCTURE AS I RECENTLY PAID
18:10:03 $3,000 AS DID MY NEIGHBOR TO UN CLOG MY SEWER LINES AND
18:10:05 I HAVE NO IDEA HOW THE PROJECT WILL TAX A SYSTEM
18:10:07 ALREADY OVERWHELMED.
18:10:11 I AM CONCERNED OF THE LIFE OF OUR BEAUTIFUL OAK TREES.
18:10:14 TWO WHICH WILL BE CUT DOWN AS CONSTRUCTION STARTS.
18:10:16 CONCERNED ABOUT DRAINAGE AS THE GREEN SPACE IS PAVED
18:10:19 OVER AND HAVE TO WORRY HOW MUCH WATER USED TO BE SWEPT
18:10:22 AWAY IN THE DITCHES WILL BE COVERED BY CONCRETE.
18:10:24 I AM WORRIED ABOUT THE LAYOUT.
18:10:29 THE TRASH COMPACTOR OF THIS PROJECT IS SEQUESTERED AS
18:10:33 CLOSE TO OUR PROPERTY AS IT COULD POSSIBLY BE, EXEMPT
18:10:35 FLYING THE FACT THAT THE QUALITY OF LIFE OF EXISTING
18:10:38 RESIDENTS WAS NOT CONSIDERED ONE MOMENT BY THESE
18:10:39 DEVELOPERS.
18:10:41 I CHOSE THE NEIGHBORHOOD FOR THE QUAINT PEACEFUL NATURE
18:10:43 OF UNATTACHED HOMES.
18:10:46 PLEASE DO THE NOT PUT US THROUGH IN OR DEAL.
18:10:49 INCONSISTENT AND PRECEDENT FOR FUTURE INVASIONS OF ITS
18:10:50 SAME KIND.
18:10:51 THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
18:10:54 THE QUALITY OF LIFE OF OUR NEIGHBORHOOD IS IN YOUR
18:10:55 HANDS.
18:10:57 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
18:10:59 NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
18:11:03 STATE YOUR NAME.
18:11:08 >> JOHN DEORIO, 2120 NORTH WOODLAND AND CURRENT
18:11:10 PRESIDENT OF THE OAK PARK NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION
18:11:13 SPEAKING ON ALL OF MY NEIGHBORS THAT HEAVILY OPPOSE
18:11:14 THIS PROJECT.
18:11:17 SIMPLY PUT, THIS REQUEST DOES NOT DEMONSTRATE
18:11:21 COMPLIANCE WITH ALL APPLICABLE OVERLAY STANDARDS.
18:11:23 WAIVER IS NOT AN OPTION AS THE CODE SPECIFICALLY STATES
18:11:26 THAT APPLICATION SHALL COMPLY WITH THESE STANDARDS AND
18:11:29 CLARIFIES IN CASES OF CONFLICT, THE MORE RESTRICTIVE
18:11:34 CONFLICT SHALL APPLY AND MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS MUST BE
18:11:36 MET FOR DESIGN APPROVAL.
18:11:39 APPROVING THIS REQUEST UNDERMINES THE SAFEGUARDS TO
18:11:41 ACCOMPLISH THE INTENT OF THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY
18:11:42 DISTRICT.
18:11:44 ADDITIONALLY, THE APPLICANT HAS NOT DEMONSTRATED
18:11:47 CONSISTENCY WITH THE REQUIREMENTS ESTABLISHED IN
18:11:50 SECTION 27-241-E-2.
18:11:54 SIMPLY, WE HAVE WITNESS IN SUPPORT OF THE GROWTH OF THE
18:12:01 WA-WA AND COMPLEX GO UP AND OUR NEIGHBORHOOD AND.WEST
18:12:04 TAMPA IS NEGATIVELY IMPACTED BY ALL THIS GROWTH.
18:12:05 THE TRAFFIC SAFETY CONCERNS.
18:12:08 WE ARE CONTINUING TO MOVE FORWARD WITHOUT THE COMMUNITY
18:12:10 IN MIND, WITHOUT THE PEOPLE WHO LIVE HERE IN MIND.
18:12:13 WE ARE MAKING DECISIONS THAT DON'T PUT THE PEOPLE
18:12:13 FIRST.
18:12:16 ON TOP OF PUTTING THE CART BEFORE THE HORSE AS SANDY
18:12:19 SAID EARLIER, WE DON'T HAVE THE INFRASTRUCTURE TO
18:12:25 SUPPORT THIS AND ADD SOMETHING THAT CAN'T FORWARD TO
18:12:25 MOVE ON.
18:12:28 AND PEOPLE WHO LIVE THERE WON'T NAVIGATE THE STREETS.
18:12:31 WE HAVE TO MOVE FORWARD WITH THE PEOPLE IN MIND.
18:12:34 WE HAVE TO THINK QUALITY OVER QUANTITY AND TO ASK
18:12:37 OURSELVES HOW DOES THIS TYPE OF DEVELOPMENT HELP THE
18:12:38 NEIGHBORHOOD AND PEOPLE.
18:12:42 IF WE ARE NOT WITH THE PEOPLE IN MIND, IT IS OFF TRACK.
18:12:46 CITY WANTS TO MAKE GREAT PLANS AND TO MAKE THAT BETTER,
18:12:48 WE NEED TO MAKE BETTER DECISIONS.
18:12:50 IF CAN HE CARE ABOUT THE PEOPLE WHO LIVE HERE, WE HAVE
18:12:52 TO CARE AND RESPECT OUR DECISION.
18:12:54 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
18:12:59 NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
18:13:06 >> HI, CARROLL ANN BENNETT AND A LIFELONG RESIDENT OF
18:13:06 TAMPA.
18:13:09 IN ADDITION TO MANY INDIVIDUALS, NEIGHBORHOOD
18:13:16 ASSOCIATIONS DAVIS ISLAND, OAK PARK, AND OTHERS.
18:13:19 PD ZONINGS ARE A GREATER AND GREATER CONCERN FOR
18:13:23 NEIGHBORHOOD GROUPS BECAUSE PDS ARE BEING MISUSE AND
18:13:31 ABUSED 27-226 PDS SHOULD BE FOR UNIQUE SITUATIONS THAT
18:13:33 OTHER ZONINGS CANNOT ACCOMMODATE.
18:13:37 RM-24 ZONING ALLOWS 48 UNITS CONTINUE TO THIS POLICY.
18:13:42 1.2.28 SHOW THE PURPOSE IS FOR DEVELOPMENT CONSISTENT
18:13:45 WITH THE LAND USE DESIGNATION BUT NOT PERMITTED IN
18:13:46 STANDARD ZONING.
18:13:50 STANDARD RM-24 ZONING IS CONSISTENT WITH THE LAND USE
18:13:51 DESIGNATION OF THIS PROPERTY.
18:13:57 EUCLIDIAN RM-24 ALLOWS 48 UNITS.
18:14:00 WHY AREN'T THEY ASKING FOR THAT?
18:14:03 SLIDE OUT OF ZONING REQUIREMENTS EVER RM-24.
18:14:04 THEY WANT SPECIAL TREATMENT.
18:14:05 THEY WANT LOTS OF WAIVERS.
18:14:08 THEY WANT FIVE TREES ON TWO ACRES OF LANDS.
18:14:10 THEY WANT EXCEPTIONS.
18:14:14 THE WORSE WAY TO PLAN A CITY TO PLAN AN EXEMPTION.
18:14:18 THE WORST WAY TO GOVERN A CITY IS TO GOVERN BY
18:14:19 EXCEPTION.
18:14:22 NO WAY TO AVOID A PD BUT TO AVOID TAMPA ZONING
18:14:23 REQUIREMENTS.
18:14:26 IN WAIVER THEY ARE ASKING FOR THAT VIOLATES THE WEST
18:14:29 TAMPA OVERLAY FROM 25 TO 10 FEET.
18:14:31 THERE IS NO ROOM TO ADJUST THE INFRASTRUCTURE IN THE
18:14:35 FUTURE FOR THE TRANSIT CORRIDOR THAT VIK BHIDE SAYS IS
18:14:37 THE ONLY TRANSIT COO ARE DOOR FROM DOWNTOWN TO THE
18:14:38 AIRPORT.
18:14:41 YOU WON'T BE ABLE TO ADD A TURN LANE, BIKE LANE,
18:14:44 TROLLEY LANE, BUS STOP OR WIDER SIDEWALK TO MAKE THE
18:14:48 NEIGHBORHOOD MORE VALUABLE.
18:14:50 YOU TAKE AWAY OPTIONS FOR THE FUTURE.
18:14:53 THEY EMPHASIZE CM-U.
18:14:55 MU STANDS FOR MIXED USE.
18:14:57 WHERE IS THE MIXED USE THAT GETS PEOPLE OUT OF THEIR
18:14:59 CAR AS SOON AS THEY SAY THIS IS THE ONLY WAY TO SOLVE
18:15:01 THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING CRISIS.
18:15:03 WHERE IS THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
18:15:06 NEIGHBORHOODS ARE ALARMED AT THE LOSS OF COMMERCIAL
18:15:07 PROPERTY.
18:15:09 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROVIDES JOBS.
18:15:12 JOBS IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD GET CARS OFF THE MYSTERY.
18:15:16 NEIGHBORHOODS ARE ALARMED BY CITY PLANNING AND ZONING
18:15:19 THAT ARE BECOMING THE RULE INSTEAD OF THE EXCEPTION.
18:15:22 DEVELOPERS ARE ADDICTED TO PDS AND REZONINGS.
18:15:24 THEY DON'T WANT TO BUILD TO CODE.
18:15:26 THEY WANT EXCEPTIONS, WAIVERS AND VARIANCES.
18:15:29 LIKE A SPOILED CHILD IN THE CANDY AISLE.
18:15:32 ONE AT TO REDUCE YOUR CASELOAD, STOP FEEDING THE RAGING
18:15:34 ADDICTION TO REZONINGS.
18:15:36 YOU WANT TO SAVE MONEY?
18:15:39 STOP WASTING BUCKETS OF CITY RESOURCES AND TAXPAYER
18:15:43 MONIES ON REZONINGS AND PDS.
18:15:44 STOP FEEDING THEM CANDY.
18:15:47 THEY WILL ONLY COME BACK FOR MORE AND MORE AND MORE.
18:15:49 YOU CAN'T SATISFY AN ADDICTION.
18:15:51 IT IS NEVER ENOUGH.
18:15:54 THE MORE YOU FEED IT, THE BIG TER GETS.
18:15:57 REASONABLE USE FOR THIS PROPERTY IS COMMERCIAL THAT
18:15:58 PRODUCES JOBS.
18:15:59 RM-24.
18:16:01 REASONABLE USE SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES.
18:16:02 THANK YOU.
18:16:03 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
18:16:07 NEXT SPEAKER.
18:16:09 >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
18:16:10 NATHAN HAGAN.
18:16:13 I LIVE IN NORTH HYDE PARK AN ADJACENT NEIGHBORHOOD TO
18:16:13 THIS.
18:16:16 I AM VERY CONFLICTED ON THIS PROJECT.
18:16:17 FIRST OF ALL, I SUPPORT THE DENSITY COMPLETELY.
18:16:19 I THINK IT SHOULD BE MORE DENSE.
18:16:21 YOU GUYS PROBABLY KNOW THAT.
18:16:24 I WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO LIVE IN THIS PART OF TOWN IF I
18:16:27 DID NOT -- IF WE DID NOT HAVE TOWN HOMES IN NORTH HYDE
18:16:28 PARK.
18:16:29 I DON'T KNOW WHERE I WOULD BE, BUT NOT IN THAT
18:16:30 NEIGHBORHOOD.
18:16:34 TOWN HOMES ARE MORE AFFORDABLE THAN SINGLE-FAMILY
18:16:34 HOMES.
18:16:36 A DEVELOP WE ARE BUILDING A SINGLE-FAMILY HOME ON THIS
18:16:38 PROPERTY INSTEAD OF THIS, THAT HOME WILL BE MORE
18:16:41 EXPENSIVE THAN THE TOWN HOUSE THAT IS GOING TO BE IN
18:16:41 HERE.
18:16:45 WE TALK ABOUT AFFORDABLE HOUSING, KNOW THIS IS NOT WORK
18:16:49 FORCE HOUSING BUT WHAT GOES THERE INSTEAD IS A 800,000
18:16:54 OR 900,000 VILLA OR 700,000 VILLA AND MORE EXPENSIVE
18:16:56 THAN WHAT THESE TOWN HOMES.
18:16:59 SIX HOMES WILL BE MORE EXPENSIVE THAN IF WE PUT 47
18:17:01 HOMES CONTINUE TO.
18:17:03 THIS IS A DOWNTOWN NEIGHBORHOOD, YOU KNOW.
18:17:05 I UNDERSTAND THAT PEOPLE MOVED HERE THINKING IT WAS A
18:17:06 SUBURB.
18:17:07 WE ARE IN A CRISIS.
18:17:08 WE NEED MORE HOMES.
18:17:15 THIS IS IN THE MIDDLE OF OUR TWO BUSINESS DISTRICTS IN.
18:17:18 THERE IS JUST NO OTHER WAY AROUND IT.
18:17:22 A DOWNTOWN NEIGHBORHOOD, NOT A SUBURB.
18:17:25 AS TRAFFIC CORRIDOR, I -- YOU KNOW, I HAVE A LOT OF
18:17:28 RESPECT TO PEOPLE WHO SPOKE BEFORE ME, BUT WE TALK OF
18:17:31 TRANSIT-ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT, WE WILL TALK ABOUT MORE
18:17:32 HOUSING NOT LESS.
18:17:35 THE FACT THIS IS A TRANSIT CORRIDOR MEANS IT IS
18:17:38 APPROPRIATE FOR FOUR, FIVE OR SIX SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES.
18:17:41 A HUGE WASTED OPPORTUNITY WE BUILT SIX HOMES ON THIS
18:17:43 TRANSIT CORRIDOR.
18:17:45 SO I REALLY HOPE WE DON'T DO THAT.
18:17:49 BUT I SAY I AM CONFLICTED, BECAUSE I -- I THINK
18:17:50 PROJECT COULD BE A LOT BETTER.
18:17:52 I THINK THAT THE NEIGHBORHOOD COULD BE A LOT HAPPIER
18:17:55 WITH WHAT CAME -- WHAT COULD COME HERE.
18:17:56 I THINK IT SHOULD BE MIXED USE.
18:17:57 IT SHOULD BE AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
18:18:01 THEY ARE NOT USING A BONUS DENSITY FOR ANYTHING MUCH
18:18:02 LESS AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
18:18:03 A QUESTION WE SHOULD BE ASKING.
18:18:04 I AM VERY CONFUSED.
18:18:07 DOESN'T MAKE SENSE THAT THE DEVELOP WE ARE NOT
18:18:10 INCENTIVIZED TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF OUR AFFORDABLE
18:18:12 HOUSING BONUS IN THE CITY OF TAMPA.
18:18:15 SO, YOU KNOW, I HATE THAT THEY ARE DOING THIS BY PD.
18:18:17 AGAIN I COMPLETELY AGREE WITH THE NEIGHBORHOODS ON
18:18:17 THIS.
18:18:19 WE NEED TO STOP ALLOWING PDS.
18:18:21 WE NEED ZONING REFORM.
18:18:25 WE NEED AN ISSUE INHERITED BY THIS COUNCIL.
18:18:29 IN COUNCIL HAS AN WAY TO ADDRESS ISSUES.
18:18:33 AND WE SHOULD NOT BE DOING THIS BY PD AND LEGISLATE
18:18:36 WITH HOUSING IN OUR ZONING CODE.
18:18:38 ULTIMATELY I HAVE TO SUPPORT THIS PROJECT BECAUSE I
18:18:42 HAVE NO CONFIDENCE IF THIS PROJECT IS REJECTED TODAY
18:18:43 WHAT WILL COME NEXT WILL BE BETTER.
18:18:46 I BELIEVE LOOKING AT THIS, IF THIS DOES NOT GET
18:18:49 APPROVED AS IT IS, THE SOLUTION FEWER HOMES CONTINUE
18:18:49 TO.
18:18:50 AND THAT'S IT.
18:18:53 I DON'T REALLY KNOW WHAT -- WHAT THE ALTERNATIVE IS.
18:18:55 I DON'T THINK THEY WILL GO BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD
18:18:59 AND PUT A 60-UNIT APARTMENT BUILDING WITH MIXED USE.
18:19:02 IF IT IS BETWEEN THIS AND SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES, I CHOOSE
18:19:02 THIS.
18:19:04 BETWEEN THIS AND 30 HOMES, I CHOOSE THIS.
18:19:07 SO IF THAT IS WHAT THE CHOICE IS, I SUPPORT THIS
18:19:08 PROJECT.
18:19:10 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
18:19:15 NEXT SPEAKER.
18:19:19 >> HELLO, MY NAME IS BOBBY CREIGHTON.
18:19:21 MANY OF THE SPEAKERS HERE HAVE MADE VERY, VERY
18:19:23 EXCELLENT POINTS.
18:19:25 AND I DO NOT ENVY YOU ALL ON THE COUNCIL HAVING TO
18:19:29 DELIBERATE BETWEEN THESE DIFFERING PERSPECTIVES.
18:19:32 THE NEIGHBORHOOD DEFENDERS HAVE MADE SOME VERY GOOD
18:19:33 POINTS.
18:19:36 THEY CAME TO THIS NEIGHBORHOOD EXPECTING A CERTAIN WAY
18:19:39 OF LIFE, A CERTAIN ENVIRONMENT THAT THEY WANTED TO LIVE
18:19:41 IN, BUT AT SOME POINT, WE HAVE TO FACE THE FACT WE ARE
18:19:44 IN THE MIDDLE OF A HOUSING CRISIS RIGHT NOW.
18:19:47 AND THAT WILL NOT END ANY TIME SOON BASED ON THE
18:19:49 PROJECTIONS WE HAVE ALL SEEN.
18:19:53 ONE OF THE PREVIOUS SPEAKERS MENTIONED QUANTITY AS AN
18:19:53 ISSUE.
18:19:55 THE QUANTITY OF THE HOMES.
18:19:59 I THINK THAT IS ACTUALLY ONE OF THE POSITIVES OF THIS
18:20:00 PROJECT.
18:20:04 WE ARE NOT GOING TO GET OUT OF THIS HOUSING CRISIS BY
18:20:06 BUILDING LESS HOUSING, MORE EXPENSIVE HOUSING AND
18:20:08 BIGGER HOUSING ON THE SAME SIZE LOTS.
18:20:11 WE NEED TO BE THINKING STRATEGICALLY OF HOW TO ADVANCE
18:20:12 THE CITY.
18:20:15 RIGHT NOW WE ARE REALLY IN A CRUCIAL MOMENTS DECIDING
18:20:18 WHAT TAMPA IS GOING TO BECOME AND WHAT SORT OF CITY WE
18:20:19 ARE GOING TO BE.
18:20:25 INSTANCES LIKE THIS ARE A MICROCOSM OF THIS.
18:20:28 60% OF THE CITY ZONED FOR SINGLE-FAMILY.
18:20:31 YOU KNOW, YOU CAN BALLPARK WHICH IS COMMERCIAL AND
18:20:34 FIGURE HOW MUCH IS LEFT FOR MULTIFAMILY.
18:20:34 IT IS NOT A LOT.
18:20:38 THAT IS REALLY HOLDING TAMPA BACK.
18:20:41 THE PD ZONING.
18:20:44 SOMEONE HAD A GREAT QUOTE EARLIER WHEN THEY SAID WE ARE
18:20:48 BUILDING BY EXCEPTION AND NOT BUILDING BY THE CODE.
18:20:51 IF THAT IS THE CASE, YOU KNOW, WHY DON'T WE LOOK AT THE
18:20:54 CODE AND UPDATE THE CODE SO WE DON'T HAVE TO GO THROUGH
18:20:57 THIS PROCESS AGAIN AND AGAIN AND AGAIN AND FINALLY MAKE
18:20:59 A DETERMINATION OF WHAT WE WANT TO BE AS A CITY, WHAT
18:21:02 WE WANT OUR CITY TO LOOK LIKE, WHAT KIND OF PEOPLE WE
18:21:06 WANT TO WELCOME TO OUR CITY AND SO ON AND SO FORTH.
18:21:09 AND THIS EXTENDS TO THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, THAT
18:21:12 EXTENDS TO THE ZONING CODE, THAT EXTENDS TO
18:21:16 CONVERSATIONS WITH PLANNERS AND URBAN DESIGNERS,
18:21:17 OBVIOUSLY.
18:21:19 AND IT IS A DIFFICULT DECISION TO MAKE.
18:21:22 THIS IS A PROJECT THAT WOULD BRING HOUSING FOR PEOPLE
18:21:25 THAT DESPERATELY NEED IT.
18:21:28 IT IS NOT AFFORDABLE BUT MORE OF A SUPPLY WHETHER I
18:21:31 HOPEFULLY EASE SOME OF THAT DEMAND.
18:21:34 ULTIMATELY I WOULD SAY I HAVE TO SUPPORT THIS PROJECT
18:21:36 EVEN THOUGH I HEAR THE PEOPLE WHO LIVE IN THIS
18:21:39 NEIGHBORHOOD AND I DEFINITELY SYMPATHIZE AND EMPATHIZE
18:21:43 WITH THEIR POSITION, BUT ZOOMING OUT TO LOOK AT THE
18:21:45 CITY AS A WHOLE, I THINK IT IS IMPORTANT THAT WE
18:21:48 CONSIDER THE NUMBER OF UNITS AND HOUSING THAT WILL
18:21:50 BECOME AVAILABLE IF THIS IS BUILT.
18:21:51 THANK YOU.
18:21:52 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
18:21:57 NEXT SPEAKER.
18:21:59 >> GOOD AFTERNOON, EVERYONE.
18:22:03 ANDREW AUBRY, 505 NORTH GOMEZ.
18:22:06 I WILL INTRODUCE FACTS THINK THAT PULLED OFF THE GIS
18:22:07 SYSTEM FOR HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY.
18:22:11 85% OF THE HOMES -- WHAT I DID WAS LOOK AT HILLSBOROUGH
18:22:11 COUNTY.
18:22:13 I LOOKED AT 275 TO THE NORTH.
18:22:14 ARMENIA TO THE EAST.
18:22:16 KENNEDY TO THE SOUTH.
18:22:18 AND HIMES TO THE WEST.
18:22:20 86% OF THOSE PROPERTIES ARE SINGLE-FAMILY.
18:22:21 86%.
18:22:24 SO FOR SOMEBODY TO TELL YOU THAT, YOU KNOW, THE
18:22:26 NEIGHBORHOOD NEEDS TO BE CHANGING.
18:22:28 WE AGREE THE NEIGHBORHOOD IS CHANGING.
18:22:29 A LOT OF DEVELOPMENT GOING ON.
18:22:31 A LOT OF DOUBLE LOTS THAT HAVE BEEN PURCHASED.
18:22:34 A LOT OF THINGS HAVE HAPPENED IN THE LAST COMPREHENSIVE
18:22:38 REFORM THAT REZONE HUGE SWATHS OF LAND SO WE DIDN'T
18:22:41 HAVE TO DO THIS PD THING EVERY SINGLE TIME.
18:22:43 I COME BEFORE YOU SO MANY TIMES OVER THE LAST TEN YEARS
18:22:46 BECAUSE IT IS ALWAYS THIS EXCEPTION GAME WE ARE
18:22:46 PLAYING.
18:22:50 WHY NOT STICK TO THE COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE REFORM.
18:22:53 WHERE IS ALL THE STAFF RESOURCES AND TIME THAT GOES
18:22:55 INTO THOSE REPORTS AND EVERY TIME WE JUST DECIDE TO
18:22:56 CHANGE IT.
18:22:58 SO IF YOU SEE HERE OF THE TOWN HOMES IN THIS
18:23:01 NEIGHBORHOOD, THEY ARE 37 PROPERTIES.
18:23:04 TEN OF THOSE -- THEY ARE TEN DEVELOPMENTS TOTAL, OKAY.
18:23:07 OF THOSE, SEVEN ARE DETACHED.
18:23:10 SO THIS IS WHAT YOU GUYS DID EAST OF HABANA.
18:23:13 TAKE A PROPERTY, SINGLE-FAMILY HOME.
18:23:14 AND MAKE A TOWN HOME.
18:23:16 THEY ARE TWO STORIES TALL.
18:23:18 THIS IS FOUR STORIES.
18:23:18 FOUR.
18:23:20 THERE IS NOTHING IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
18:23:22 SO IF YOU WANT TO TALK OF BEING CONSISTENT WITH THE
18:23:25 NEIGHBORHOOD, WHERE IS ANOTHER FOUR-STORY BUILDING IN
18:23:26 OUR NEIGHBORHOOD?
18:23:29 AND WHERE IS THE NEXT ONE GOING TO BE?
18:23:31 BECAUSE WE KEEP DOING THIS PD THING OVER AND OVER AND
18:23:33 OVER AND IT WILL BE A HODGEPODGE.
18:23:37 LET'S GROW SOME POLITICAL MUSTER.
18:23:41 REZONE SOME HUGE SWATHS OF LAND AND LET THE DEVELOPERS
18:23:42 GO THERE AND PLAY.
18:23:46 BUT IT CAN'T JUST HAPPEN PIECEMEAL BY PIECEMEAL.
18:23:50 IT IS BREAKING UP THE CITY AND THE FABRIC.
18:23:54 THE REASON MOST OF US BOUGHT IN THIS HOME IS BECAUSE IT
18:23:55 IS SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES.
18:23:56 PARKING.
18:23:57 NOT ENOUGH PARKING.
18:23:59 THE STREETS THIS WILL BE ON, THE OVERFLOW, NO STREET
18:24:00 PARKING.
18:24:03 WHEN PEOPLE START HAVING PARTIES AT THIS PLACE AND
18:24:05 EVENTS, WHERE IS THE OVERFLOW GOING TO GO?
18:24:08 IN A ROAD THAT DOESN'T HAVE ON-STREET PARKING.
18:24:13 NOT ENOUGH PARKING.
18:24:16 A COUPLE MORE POINTS.
18:24:19 THIS -- THIS LOT WAS ORIGINALLY PLOTTED FOR TEN UNITS.
18:24:21 NOW PROPOSING 47.
18:24:23 I KNOW PEOPLE HAVE MENTIONED SIX.
18:24:26 IT IS TEN LOTS.
18:24:28 GOMEZ.
18:24:31 THE EXIT OF THIS IS GOING TO BE A LEFT ON LEFT
18:24:32 SITUATION ON CYPRESS.
18:24:33 IT WILL CAUSE ACCIDENTS.
18:24:37 THIS IS WHY WE WENT TO THE STATE AND GOT MONEY FOR
18:24:39 HIMES BECAUSE LEFT ON LEFT ACCIDENTS THAT CAUSED
18:24:41 FATALITIES.
18:24:44 THIS WILL CAUSE ANOTHER ONE.
18:24:46 AND, AGAIN, I CAN'T STRESS ENOUGH.
18:24:49 THIS IS NONCONFORMING FOR THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
18:24:51 NOT WHAT YOU SEE HERE.
18:24:53 I WOULD LIKE TO ENTER THIS INTO THE RECORD.
18:24:56 AND THAT'S ALL I HAVE.
18:24:58 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
18:25:02 ANYBODY ELSE IN THE PUBLIC?
18:25:06 >> MR. CHAIRMAN, THE TWO PEOPLE I WAS EXPECTING -- THAT
18:25:07 CAUGHT IN THE WEATHER ARE HERE.
18:25:09 I WOULD LIKE TO HAVE THAT ADDITIONAL TWO MINUTES.
18:25:11 IF THEY COULD SIGN THE PAPER PLEASE.
18:25:13 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. SHELBY, THE TWO PEOPLE THAT
18:25:17 WERE SUPPOSED TO GIVE UP THEIR TIME TO MISS SANCHEZ ARE
18:25:18 HERE.
18:25:22 CAN WE GIVE HER TWO MINUTES?
18:25:24 >> THEY WILL BE GLAD TO SIGN, MR. SHELBY.
18:25:27 >>MARTIN SHELBY: RATHER THAN SIGN -- IF THEY JUST
18:25:31 STAND UP AND IDENTIFY YOURSELF.
18:25:32 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE IDENTIFY YOURSELF.
18:25:35 >>MARTIN SHELBY: WHAT IS YOUR NAME.
18:25:39 >> KATHERINE ECHEVARIA.
18:25:41 >> NORMA SALTER.
18:25:43 >>MARTIN SHELBY: YOU HAVE NOT SPOKEN AND YOU ARE
18:25:45 WAIVING, YOU TIME, IS THAT CORRECT?
18:25:48 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT, TWO MINUTES, MA'AM.
18:25:50 >> I JUST WANT TO EXPLAIN SOMETHING.
18:25:54 OUR NEIGHBORHOOD IS DEVELOPED A PEDESTRIAN COMMUNITY.
18:25:58 WE WALK, RIDE, GOLF CARTS, SCOOTERS AND MOTORIZED
18:26:02 WHEELCHAIRS TO GO TO THE RETAIL ESTABLISHMENTS ON THIS
18:26:03 AREA OF CYPRESS.
18:26:07 THESE FOUR BLOCKS ON CYPRESS ARE OUR MINI MALL.
18:26:12 WE HAVE A ROLLING OATS, THE NEW COFFEE SHOP, MEDICAL
18:26:16 OFFICES, FITNESS STUDIO, SPA, SMALL CONVENIENCE STORE
18:26:20 AND BY ALESSI AND VILA BROTHERS PARK AND WE SUPPORT
18:26:21 THEM ALL.
18:26:24 WE WALK TO THE RESTAURANTS ON KENNEDY.
18:26:26 THIS DEVELOPER MET WITH SOME NEIGHBORHOODS, AND I
18:26:29 UNDERSTAND IT WAS A PRETTY NEGATIVE MEETING.
18:26:32 I COULD NOT ATTENDS BECAUSE I HAD OTHER CIVIC DUTIES
18:26:35 BUT THE ONYX GROUP NEVER REACHED OUT AGAIN OR MADE ANY
18:26:39 ATTEMPT TO COMPROMISE.
18:26:43 THE GOWN DRY WITH 250 UNITS OPENED IN MARCH.
18:26:45 THIS IS JUST A SIDEBAR.
18:26:49 60 DAYS LATER, THEY ONLY RENTED 50 OF THEM, AND THAT IS
18:26:51 BECAUSE THEY ARE UNAFFORDABLE.
18:26:53 THE SAME THING IS GOING TO HAPPEN IN THIS SITUATION.
18:26:56 NOT AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
18:26:59 THE STUDIO APARTMENTS RENT THERE FOR $1800.
18:27:02 THE THREE BEDROOMS ARE $5250.
18:27:05 COULD THAT BE THE REASON WHY THEY ARE EMPTY?
18:27:07 THEY ARE NOT AFFORDABLE.
18:27:11 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS THIS THE FOUNDRY?
18:27:12 >>ORLANDO GUDES: $5,000.
18:27:16 >> CHANGES FROM DAY TO DAY.
18:27:21 SO PLEASE DENY OR CONTINUE SINCE MOST OF THIS
18:27:24 INFORMATION THAT THEY HAVE GIVEN IS YOU OBSOLETE.
18:27:27 THEY HAVE NO INTEREST IN ACCOMMODATING YOUR
18:27:30 CONSTITUENTS OR CONTINUED INTERACTION WITH THE
18:27:31 COMMUNITY.
18:27:32 PLEASE DO THE RIGHT THING.
18:27:35 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
18:27:39 AT THE HERON DOWN WATER STREET FOR A THREE BEDROOM,
18:27:42 $9,000 OR $10,000.
18:27:48 >> I LIVE THERE -- NOT THERE BUT ON ANOTHER STREET.
18:27:48 [LAUGHTER]
18:27:49 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A FEW PEOPLE WHO ARE
18:27:51 ONLINE TO SPEAK.
18:27:54 I BELIEVE YOU WERE SWORN IN.
18:27:55 OKAY.
18:27:58 YES, MA'AM, STEPHANIE POYNOR.
18:28:00 >>ORLANDO GUDES: MR. CHAIRMAN -- YOU KNOW TAMPA WAS ON
18:28:01 CNN.
18:28:03 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: FOR WHAT?
18:28:05 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HOUSING CRISIS PROBLEM.
18:28:08 PHOENIX WAS NUMBER ONE.
18:28:09 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
18:28:10 GO AHEAD.
18:28:12 >> CAN YOU HEAR ME?
18:28:13 >>MARTIN SHELBY: MR. CHAIRMAN.
18:28:17 >> STEPHANIE POYNOR, NEIGHBORHOOD LEADER.
18:28:18 GOOD EVENING, GENTLEMEN.
18:28:21 FIRST OF ALL, I PREPARED THIS SPEECH A MONTH AGO BEFORE
18:28:24 THAT LAST-MINUTE CONTINUANCE WHICH I THOUGHT WE WERE
18:28:26 TALKING ABOUT GETTING RID OF.
18:28:30 THIS ALL HURRY UP AND GET READY AND BY THE WAY WE
18:28:31 CHANGED OUR MINDS.
18:28:34 I WANT TO TALK ABOUT TWO THINGS THAT ARE A LITTLE BIT
18:28:34 DIFFERENT.
18:28:40 ONE IS WAIVERS FOR SETBACKS AND SIDEWALKS.
18:28:42 I AM NOT AN EXPERT AND I FOUND NUMBERS.
18:28:46 THE LOT IS APPROXIMATELY 100 X 250.
18:28:50 THE 23-FOOT REDUCTION OF SETBACK TO THE SOUTH GIVES
18:28:54 THEM AN ADDITIONAL 2300 SQUARE FEET.
18:28:59 13-FOOT REDUCTION ON THE LEFT GIVES THEM 250 FEET.
18:29:03 THREE-FOOT REDUCTION ON THE EAST GIVES THEM 750 SQUARE
18:29:04 FEET.
18:29:07 THAT IS A TOTAL OF 6300 SQUARE FEET.
18:29:11 THAT IS WHOLE ANOTHER LOT THAT THEY ARE EXPECTING THE
18:29:15 CITY TO BLESS THEM WITH, TO GIVE THEM THAT.
18:29:18 I AM SORRY AS A CITIZEN, I AM OFFENDED THAT THEY EXPECT
18:29:22 YOU TO GIVE AWAY OUR LAND, THE LAND THAT WE ARE
18:29:26 PROBABLY GOING TO NEED FOR MASS TRANSIT ONE DAY.
18:29:28 PLEASE JESUS, LET US GET IT.
18:29:32 COUPLE OF FEET IS REASONABLE, BUT I AM NOT --
18:29:36 CARROLL ANN WAS ON IT.
18:29:39 I WANT TO SAY THIS OUT LOUD BECAUSE THIS RUBS ME WRONG.
18:29:41 THE APPLICANTS ARE ASKING FOR BASICALLY AN ENTIRE EXTRA
18:29:43 LOT OF SETBACK.
18:29:48 AND WE ONLY GET A FOUR-FOOT SIDEWALK ON THE EAST SIDE?
18:29:51 I ARGUE THAT THEY SHOULD BUILD SMALLER UNITS THAT WILL
18:29:55 BE MORE EFFICIENT WITH THE LAND THAT THEY HAVE THAT IS
18:29:57 NOT ENCROACHING ON OUR CITY'S GREEN SPACE.
18:30:00 I WILL ADD, WHY ARE THERE NO SIDEWALKS PLANNED FOR THIS
18:30:03 PROJECT THAT WILL SUPPORT PEDESTRIAN TRAFFIC INCLUDING
18:30:06 TO THOSE FOLKS WHO LIVE IN THE COMMUNITY.
18:30:09 DON'T ALLOW THESE RIDICULOUS WAIVERS.
18:30:12 SEND THE DEVELOPER BACK TO GET A BETTER PLAN.
18:30:15 AND HONESTLY, THEY SHOWED YOU PICTURES OF SIDEWALKS.
18:30:18 BUT THEY ARE NOT ON THE PLANS UNLESS THEY CHANGED
18:30:19 SOMETHING AND I DON'T KNOW ABOUT IT.
18:30:21 I AM NOT AN EXPERT.
18:30:23 BUT IN MY OPINION, IF YOU WERE GOING TO BUILD A HOUSE
18:30:26 AND YOU WANT TO BUILD ALL THESE UNITS, WHY ARE YOU NOT
18:30:28 BUILDING THE SIDEWALKS TOO?
18:30:30 I GUESS IT IS JUST TOO MUCH FOR THEM.
18:30:34 BUT IT IS GOING TO COST US 2.7 MILLION TO BUILD -- TO
18:30:36 BUILD TWO MILES OF SIDEWALKS A YEAR.
18:30:39 WE ARE NEVER GOING TO GET THEM UNLESS THESE DEVELOPERS
18:30:41 SUCK IT UP AND PAY FOR THE SIDEWALKS.
18:30:42 THANK YOU.
18:30:43 HAVE A GOOD NIGHT.
18:30:45 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
18:30:47 >> I'LL BE BACK LATER.
18:30:48 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
18:30:49 NEXT SPEAKER --
18:30:50 >>MARTIN SHELBY: MR. CHAIRMAN.
18:30:52 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. SHELBY.
18:30:54 >>MARTIN SHELBY: FOR THE PURPOSES OF MAKING SURE THE
18:30:57 RECORD IS CLEAR AND ADVISE COUNCILMAN -- COUNCILMAN
18:31:01 GUDES COMMENTS WITH REGARD TO INFORMATION THAT HE
18:31:05 LEARNED ON, I GUESS TELEVISION, I WOULD JUST ASK THAT
18:31:09 YOU REMEMBER THAT -- THAT DOESN'T HAVE SUBSTANTIAL
18:31:13 EVIDENCE AND DON'T LET THAT FACTOR INTO YOUR DECISION.
18:31:15 >>ORLANDO GUDES: MR. SHELBY, I WAS TELLING COUNCIL
18:31:18 THAT I SAW SOMETHING ON TV.
18:31:20 NOT FOR THIS PARTICULAR CASE.
18:31:24 >>MARTIN SHELBY: JUST AS COUNCIL UNDERSTANDS IT IS NOT
18:31:27 PART OF THEIR DECISION GUDES I AM NOT MAKING MY
18:31:29 DECISION ON SOMETHING THEY CALL.
18:31:31 I AM NOT SAYING IT WAS PART OF THIS CASE.
18:31:34 LET'S GET THAT STRAIGHT THE RECORD.
18:31:36 >>MARTIN SHELBY: YES, SIR.
18:31:40 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NEXT SPEAKER HUMERA.
18:31:43 >> HUMERA OSSOL.
18:31:45 I LIVE IN PRIMARY GARDENS.
18:31:50 I SENT AN E-MAIL AND I THROUGH MY PRESENTATION OUTS THE
18:31:52 WINDOW BECAUSE SO MANY PEOPLE FROM MY NEIGHBORHOOD
18:31:54 SPOKE ON A LOT OF KEY POINTS.
18:31:58 BUT WHAT I AM GOING TO FOCUS ON IS THIS.
18:32:01 CITY AND COUNTY PLANNERS TALK A LOT ABOUT WALKABILITY
18:32:05 OF NEIGHBORS AS A PRIORITY.
18:32:08 AND I ALSO WANT TO SAY THAT I AM NOT AGAINST URBAN
18:32:08 DENSITY.
18:32:13 I THINK URBAN DENSITY IS A GOOD THING BUT ONLY IF IT IS
18:32:13 DONE RIGHT.
18:32:19 NOT IF IT IS DONE IN A WAY THAT MAKES A NEIGHBORHOOD --
18:32:21 THAT NEGATIVELY EFFECTS THE EXISTING NEIGHBORHOOD.
18:32:26 I AM NOT AN EXPERT TRAFFIC ENGINEER OR A CITY PLANNER.
18:32:28 BUT I HAVE BEEN HIT BY A CAR.
18:32:33 AND I AM GOING TO TALK TO YOU ABOUT THE PERSPECTIVE OF
18:32:39 THIS PROJECT AS SOMEONE WHO TRIES TO DRIVE A CAR AS
18:32:40 LITTLE AS POSSIBLE.
18:32:43 MY MAIN MODE OF TRANSPORTATION IS I WALK, I TAKE MY
18:32:47 BIKE, OR I TAKE MY NEW ELECTRIC SCOOTER.
18:32:51 THIS PROJECT DOES CONTRIBUTE TO MORE OF THE SAME, THE
18:32:55 SAME MOLD, CAR-CENTRIC, DANGEROUS BY DESIGN.
18:32:59 WE ARE ALREADY ONE OF THE MOST DANGEROUS METRO AREAS IN
18:33:00 THE UNITED STATES.
18:33:05 AND THIS IS JUST MORE OF THE STATE.
18:33:08 PEOPLE HERE ALREADY TALKED ABOUT CONGESTION.
18:33:12 SO CONGESTION USUALLY JUST GIVES ME MORE MOTIVATION TO
18:33:15 EITHER WALK OR RIDE MY BIKE OR TAKE MY SCOOTER.
18:33:19 WELL, GUESS WHAT, ALL THAT CONGESTION MAKES IT EVEN
18:33:24 MORE DANGEROUS FOR ME TO DO ANY OF THOSE THREE THINGS.
18:33:29 I AM GOING TO FOCUS ON ONE EXAMPLE OF THIS PLAN AND
18:33:32 ANOTHER EXAMPLE OF HOW PROJECTS ARE DESIGNED AS CAR
18:33:33 CENTRIC.
18:33:39 TAKE A LOOK AT THAT DRIVE THAT ENTERS ON TO SEE PRESS.
18:33:43 THOSE CURVES -- THE DRIVE IS CURVED INSTEAD OF AT A
18:33:44 STRAIGHT ANGLE.
18:33:48 THOSE CURVES ARE DESIGNED TO MAKE IT SO THAT THE CARS
18:33:51 CAN WHIZ IN AND OUT MORE QUICKLY FROM THAT EXIT OR
18:33:52 ENTRANCE.
18:33:55 AND GUESS WHAT, THEY DON'T LOOK PEDESTRIAN.
18:34:02 THEY DON'T LOOK FOR PEOPLE IN WHEELCHAIRS OR PUSHING
18:34:05 STROLLERS OR ON ELECTRIC SCOOTERS.
18:34:06 THEY DON'T LOOK.
18:34:08 THEY WANT TO GET IN AND OUT OF THAT ENTRANCE AS QUICKLY
18:34:09 AS THEY CAN.
18:34:12 AND ALL OF THOSE PEOPLE WILL BE COMING AND GOING AS
18:34:18 QUICKLY AS THEY CAN IN RUSH HOUR, AT SCHOOL TIME, AND
18:34:22 THOSE TIMES WHEN TRAFFIC ON CYPRESS IS BACKED UP FOR A
18:34:23 WHILE.
18:34:24 DANGEROUS.
18:34:27 PEOPLE ARE GOING TO GET HIT.
18:34:27 I HAVE BEEN HIT.
18:34:31 I HAVE COME CLOSE TO BEING HIT MORE THAN ONCE AND NOT A
18:34:33 SINGLE ONE OF THOSE TIMES WAS IT MY FAULT.
18:34:37 IT WAS BECAUSE THE DRIVER WAS IN A RUSH TO GET ON OR
18:34:41 OFF OF THAT BUSY ROAD AS QUICKLY AS THEY COULD.
18:34:45 SO THIS IS MORE DANGEROUS BY DESIGN.
18:34:47 IT DOES NOT IMPROVE OUR NEIGHBORHOOD.
18:34:50 IT MAKES OUR NEIGHBORHOOD MORE DANGEROUS FOR ALL OF OUR
18:34:54 COMMUNITY MEMBERS WHO WALK, RIDE THEIR BIKES, DO ALL
18:34:56 THE THINGS TO KEEP CARS OFF OF THE ROAD.
18:34:58 YOU ARE JUST MAKING IT MORE DANGEROUS FOR US.
18:35:00 PLEASE DENY IT.
18:35:01 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
18:35:02 >> CLEAN UP THE CODE.
18:35:04 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
18:35:05 ANYBODY ELSE REGISTERED?
18:35:07 >>CLERK: NO ONE REGISTERED.
18:35:09 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THAT WILL CLONE CLUED PUBLIC
18:35:10 COMMENT.
18:35:13 MR. MECHANIK, IT IS YOUR REBUTTAL TIME, SIR.
18:35:17 >> YES, SIR, MR. CHAIRMAN, COUNCILMEMBERS, DAVID
18:35:18 MECHANIK.
18:35:19 WE WILL TRY TO BE AS BRIEF AS WE CAN.
18:35:21 THERE WERE A NUMBER OF COMMENTS.
18:35:25 AND I WOULD ASK YOUR INDULGENCE IF WE NEED AN EXTRA
18:35:26 MINUTE OR TWO.
18:35:30 IN A MOMENT I AM GOING TO ASK MICHAEL YATES TO ADDRESS
18:35:31 THE TRAFFIC ISSUES.
18:35:35 BUT I WOULD LIKE TO TRY TO RECAP OUR RESPONSES TO ALL
18:35:39 THE OTHER COMMENTS.
18:35:43 WE EMBRACE THE IDEA THAT CYPRESS STREET IS A TRANSIT
18:35:46 CORRIDOR AND A TRANSPORTATION CORRIDOR.
18:35:50 AND EVERY PLANNING BOOK WOULD YOU EVER READ INCLUDING
18:35:55 TAMPA'S COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ENCOURAGES HIGHER DENSITIES
18:35:59 IN TRANSIT AND TRANSPORTATION CORRIDORS.
18:36:03 THAT IS WHERE YOU WANT DENSITY IN ORDER TO PROMOTE THE
18:36:05 USAGE OF TRANSIT.
18:36:07 EVERYBODY KNOWS THAT.
18:36:11 BUT MY CLIENT IS NOT PUSHING THE ENVELOPE.
18:36:18 WE ARE ASKING FOR 78% OF THE DENSITY THAT IS ALLOWED ON
18:36:20 THIS PROPERTY WITHOUT A BONUS.
18:36:22 WE HAVEN'T EVEN THOUGHT OF A BONUS.
18:36:28 WE ARE LESS THAN THE PERMITTED DENSITY SIGNIFICANTLY.
18:36:31 THERE ARE COMPLAINTS ABOUT OUR PARKING AND ABOUT
18:36:33 IMPACTS TO TREES.
18:36:36 WE ARE FULLY COMPLYING WITH THE CODE.
18:36:38 THERE IS NO PARKING WAIVER.
18:36:40 THERE IS NO TREE WAIVERS.
18:36:44 THERE IS NO REQUEST TO TAKE DOWN A GRAND TREE.
18:36:49 MY CLIENT HAS TRIED DESPERATELY TO AVOID ASKING FOR
18:36:50 WAIVERS.
18:36:55 AND I WOULD POINT OUT THAT -- I THINK EVERY PERSON,
18:37:01 EVERY DEVELOP WEAR BE HAPPY IF YOUR EUCLIDIAN ZONING
18:37:05 DISTRICTS ALLOWED FOR REASONABLE URBAN DEVELOP, URBAN
18:37:06 INFILL DEVELOPMENT.
18:37:11 YOUR EUCLIDIAN ZONING DISTRICTS WERE DEVELOPED ABOUT 30
18:37:15 YEARS AGO AND THEY DO NOT ANTICIPATE OR ALLOW FOR THE
18:37:20 TYPE OF URBAN INFILL DEVELOPMENT THAT THE CITY IS
18:37:22 SEEKING TODAY.
18:37:26 AND SO MY CLIENT WILL BE MORE THAN HAPPY NOT TO HAVE TO
18:37:27 FILE A PD.
18:37:30 BUT THAT IS NOT THE CASE UNDER THE CURRENT CODE.
18:37:34 WITH THAT, I WILL LIKE TO ASK MR. YATES TO ADDRESS THE
18:37:37 TRAFFIC ISSUE.
18:37:40 >> GOOD EVENING, MICHAEL YATES WITH PALM TRAFFIC.
18:37:44 I AM GOING TO PUT UP ON THE ELMO THE SLIDE FROM OUR
18:37:45 PRESENTATION.
18:37:47 SO THE -- WE GOT A COUPLE OF COMMENTS ON THE TRAFFIC
18:37:48 STUDY.
18:37:51 ONE THAT WAS DONE IN AUGUST OF 2021.
18:37:55 YES, BECAUSE IT IS REQUIRED TO BE PART OF THE FILING.
18:37:57 WE HAVE TO DO IT IN ADVANCE OF THE FILING.
18:37:59 THAT IS HOW LONG IT TAKES TO GET HERE.
18:38:03 SO -- BUT THAT'S WHY IT WAS DONE AUGUST 2021.
18:38:06 NOTHING THAT HAS CHANGED IN THE REPORT THAT CHANGES IN
18:38:06 THAT TIME.
18:38:12 THERE WAS A SECOND COMMENT ABOUT THE DATA BEING USED
18:38:13 WAS EXTREMELY OLD.
18:38:17 WHAT IS BEING REFERENCED IS THE ITE TRIP GENERATION
18:38:18 MANUAL.
18:38:20 IT WAS PUBLISHED IN 2017.
18:38:25 THIS IS JUST THE TRIP GENERATION FOR VARIOUS USES.
18:38:29 AND SO IT IS -- THEY HAVE NOW COME UP WITH THE 11TH
18:38:31 EDITION IN JANUARY OF THIS YEAR.
18:38:34 BUT AT THE TIME OF THE FILING, THIS WAS THE LATEST
18:38:37 ADDITION OF THE ITE TRIP GENERATION.
18:38:42 IT IS CURRENT DATA AND A COMPENDIUM OF 20 YEARS OF
18:38:43 TRAFFIC DATA.
18:38:46 ALL OF THAT IS CONSISTENT WITH THE WAY WE DO IT.
18:38:49 THE SECOND COMMENT WE GOT WAS ON THE LEVEL OF SERVICE
18:38:49 REPORT.
18:38:54 THAT THE HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY MPO PRODUCES THE CITY OF
18:38:55 TAMPA PORTION OF IT.
18:39:00 THEY DO DO PERIODIC UPDATES TO THAT.
18:39:05 DATED LEVEL OF SERVICE REPORT AND AS THEY GET COUNTS,
18:39:07 THEY UPDATE THE COUNTS IN THERE.
18:39:09 NOT ALL DATA FROM 2015.
18:39:12 UNFORTUNATELY, WHEN THEY DO THE UPDATES, THEY DON'T
18:39:15 SPECIFY THE COUNT YEAR OF COUNTS IN THERE.
18:39:21 BUT, AGAIN, OF THE DATA IN THERE, WE WERE AT A V OVER
18:39:23 C, VOLUME OVER CAPACITY .55.
18:39:27 ONLY HALF OF THE CAPACITY WAS BEING UTILIZED BY THE
18:39:29 EXISTING TRAFFIC ON THE ROADWAY.
18:39:32 THAT'S ALL I HAVE, UNLESS YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS AND WE
18:39:36 WILL BRING UP DAVID MECHANIK AGAIN.
18:39:37 >> THANK YOU.
18:39:41 AND I WOULD JUST LIKE TO MAKE ONE FINAL POINT -- OR TWO
18:39:42 FINAL POINTS.
18:39:46 MR. YATES INITIALLY POINTED OUT THAT WE HAVE CG ZONING
18:39:49 ON THE PROPERTY, GENERAL COMMERCIAL.
18:39:54 THAT WOULD ALLOW COMMERCIAL USES FAR -- THAT WOULD
18:39:56 GENERATE FAR MORE TRAFFIC.
18:39:59 WE CAN PUT A MCDONALD'S ON THIS PROPERTY AND GENERATE
18:40:03 FAR MORE TRAFFIC THAN WHAT WE ARE GENERATING.
18:40:06 AND I WILL JUST REMIND COUNCIL, THE URBAN DESIGN
18:40:11 DEPARTMENT FOUND IN PROJECT CONSISTENT WITH THE WEST
18:40:12 TAMPA OVERLAY.
18:40:13 THANK YOU.
18:40:15 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
18:40:19 ANY QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME FROM ANY COUNCILMEMBERS?
18:40:22 IF NOT, IF WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE.
18:40:24 >>ORLANDO GUDES: MOVE TO CLOSE.
18:40:26 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION BY COUNCILMAN GUDES.
18:40:27 SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
18:40:28 ALL IN FAVOR.
18:40:29 AYE.
18:40:34 THIS IS ITEM NUMBER 6, ANYBODY LIKE TO READ THIS ITEM?
18:40:41 >>JOSEPH CITRO: MR. CHAIR, I WILL MAKE A ATTEMPT AT IT
18:40:44 BUT WITH YOUR PERMISSION, I WILL SAY THAT IT WILL NEED
18:40:49 FOUR AFFIRMATIVE VOTES TO BE APPROVED.
18:40:50 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
18:40:52 >>JOSEPH CITRO: I MADE IT STATEMENT.
18:40:57 THANK YOU VERY MUCH, FILE NUMBER REZ-21-127, ORDINANCE
18:41:00 FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, ORDINANCE REZONING
18:41:05 PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 3003 WEST CYPRESS
18:41:08 STREET, IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, AND MORE
18:41:09 PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1, ZONING DISTRICT
18:41:14 CLASSIFICATION, CG, COMMERCIAL GENERAL TO PD PLANNED
18:41:17 DEVELOPMENT, RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED
18:41:20 PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND THE PETITIONER PROVIDED
18:41:22 A BURDEN OF PROOF UNDER SECTIONS.
18:41:25 MEET WITH THE COMPLIANCE OF THE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND
18:41:28 POLICIES OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
18:41:30 THE APPLICATION, EXCUSE ME, IS CONSISTENT WITH HOUSING
18:41:34 CHAPTER 1.3, WHICH ASSURES THAT ADEQUATE AMOUNT OF
18:41:39 HOUSING IS NEEDED FOR THE CAPABILITY OF TAMPA HOUSING
18:41:42 UNDER THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE 27-136.
18:41:46 PROPOSED USE PROMOTES THE EFFECTIVENESS AND SUSTAINABLE
18:41:49 USE OF LAND AND INFRASTRUCTURE.
18:41:51 AS FOR THE WAIVERS, THE DESIGN OF THE PROPOSED
18:41:56 DEVELOPMENT IS UNIQUE, THEREFORE IT NEEDS THE WAIVERS.
18:41:59 AND REVISIONS BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
18:42:01 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
18:42:03 DO WE HAVE A SECOND.
18:42:07 >>LUIS VIERA: I WILL SECOND IT.
18:42:09 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ROLL CALL.
18:42:10 >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
18:42:12 >>ORLANDO GUDES: NO.
18:42:14 >>JOSEPH CITRO: YES.
18:42:16 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
18:42:21 MANISCALCO MAN MANISCALCO NO.
18:42:24 >>CLERK: MOTION FAILED BEING TIED WITH HURTAK AND
18:42:28 CARLSON BEING ABSENT.
18:42:31 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: CAN'T BE TIED.
18:42:33 >>CLERK: SORRY 3-2.
18:42:38 WITH CITRO, MIRANDA AND.
18:42:41 MANISCALCO AND GUDES VOTING NO AND HURTAK AND CARLSON
18:42:42 BEING ABSENT.
18:42:47 >>MARTIN SHELBY: PURSUANT TO RULE 6 H, A MOTION IN
18:42:52 QUASI FAILED TO RECEIVE FOUR VOTES THE MOTION FAILS.
18:42:54 ANOTHER MOTION IN ORDER, THE PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE
18:42:57 AUTOMATICALLY OPENED AND CONTINUED FOR A TIME CERTAIN
18:43:00 AT THE NEXT REGULAR SCHEDULED COUNCIL MEETING.
18:43:03 JUST A REMINDER, NEXT WEEK IS YOUR NEXT REGULAR MEETING
18:43:04 WHICH IS MAY 5.
18:43:08 WE KNOW OF ONE COUNCIL MEMBER BEING ABSENT.
18:43:11 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO TO MAY 19?
18:43:16 >>MARTIN SHELBY: NO OBJECTION, MAY 19, I SUSPECT WE
18:43:17 HAVE A FULL COUNCIL, PERHAPS.
18:43:19 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I THINK WE SHOULD.
18:43:22 >> WE WOULD AGREE TO THAT DAY, YES, SIR.
18:43:24 >>MARTIN SHELBY: WOULD BE --
18:43:27 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOVE TO REOPEN AND CONTINUE IT.
18:43:30 >>MARTIN SHELBY: YOU MAKE A MOTION TO REOPEN.
18:43:32 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: MAKE THE MOTION TO REOPEN.
18:43:34 >>JOSEPH CITRO: SECOND.
18:43:36 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR.
18:43:38 THE CASE -- THE HEARING IS REOPENED.
18:43:39 >>MARTIN SHELBY: YES.
18:43:42 NOW NO MOTION ON THE FLOOR, BUT OBVIOUSLY THE
18:43:45 COUNCILMEMBERS WHO ARE ABSENT WILL HAVE TO PREPARE AND
18:43:48 VIEW THE RECORD IN ADVANCE OF THE HEARING.
18:43:52 SO THAT WOULD BE -- WHAT TIME, MADAM CLERK ON MAY 19,
18:43:54 2022?
18:43:57 10:30 A.M.
18:43:58 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE A MOTION IN THAT
18:43:58 EFFECT.
18:44:00 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THAT IS FINE.
18:44:02 YOU HAVE TO HAVE A MOTION ON THE FLOOR TO CONTINUE TO
18:44:05 MAY 19 AT 10:30 A.M.
18:44:06 >>ORLANDO GUDES: SECOND.
18:44:09 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR.
18:44:16 ALL RIGHT ARE, MAY 19, 10:30 A.M.
18:44:18 >>MARTIN SHELBY: AGAIN, COUNCIL, THE WAY RULE 6 H
18:44:23 WORKS, THE COUNCILMEMBERS WHO ARE ABSENT WILL HAVE THE
18:44:24 OPPORTUNITY VIEW THE RECORD.
18:44:27 HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO REVIEW THE HEARING.
18:44:29 AND THERE WILL NOBODY ADDITIONAL PRESENTATION BECAUSE
18:44:32 IT IS FOR FIRST READING AND CONSIDERATION, BUT
18:44:36 COUNCILMEMBERS WILL BE ABLE TO ASK QUESTIONS OF THE
18:44:39 PEOPLE WHO ARE PRESENT IF THEY DO HAVE ANY --
18:44:42 PARTICULARLY OF STAFF OR WHOEVER IS PRESENT AND THEN A
18:44:44 MOTION WOULD HAVE TO BE MADE.
18:44:47 AND THEN -- TO CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING AND A MOTION
18:44:48 AND A VOTE THEN.
18:44:50 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT, THANKS.
18:44:51 >>MARTIN SHELBY: ANY QUESTIONS?
18:44:52 OKAY, THANK YOU.
18:44:58 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER 7 IS CONTINUED AND GO
18:44:59 TO ITEM NUMBER 8.
18:45:03 DO WE NEED RECESS -- WE WILL TAKE A FIVE-MINUTE RECESS.
18:59:21 [GAVEL SOUNDING]
18:59:24 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I WOULD LIKE TO CALL THIS COUNCIL
18:59:26 MEETING BACK TO ORDER.
18:59:27 ROLL CALL PLEASE.
18:59:29 >>ORLANDO GUDES: HERE.
18:59:32 >>JOSEPH CITRO: HERE.
18:59:34 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HERE.
18:59:35 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
18:59:37 >>CLERK: WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
18:59:38 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHTY.
18:59:40 ITEM NUMBER 8.
18:59:42 >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
18:59:44 ERIC COTTON, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
18:59:52 ITEM NUMBER 8 IS REZ-21-135 FOR 3218 WEST PAUL AVENUE.
18:59:58 APPLICANT IS REZONING FROM RS-60 REC RESIDENTIAL
19:00:01 SINGLE-FAMILY TO RS-50, RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY.
19:00:03 AND TURN OVER TO DANNY COLLINS FROM THE PLANNING
19:00:04 COMMISSION.
19:00:06 >>DANNY COLLINS: GOOD EVENING, DANNY COLLINS WITH THE
19:00:07 PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
19:00:08 I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN.
19:00:11 OUR NEXT CASE IS IN THE SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT.
19:00:14 MORE SPECIFICALLY TO INTERBAY SOUTH OF GANDY
19:00:15 NEIGHBORHOOD.
19:00:19 THE CLOSEST PUBLIC TRANSIT IS THREE QUARTER OF A MILE
19:00:23 SOUTHWEST OF THE SITE AT THE INTERSECTION OF SOUTH DALE
19:00:25 MABRY AND WEST BALLAST POINT.
19:00:30 LOCATED ONE AND ONE QUARTER MILES WEST OF THE SUBJECT
19:00:30 SITE.
19:00:34 THE SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN EVACUATION ZONE B.
19:00:37 AND AN AERIAL MAP OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND THE
19:00:38 SURROUNDING PROPERTIES.
19:00:42 EAST OF WEST WALL AVENUE AND SOUTH SHERIDAN ROAD.
19:00:45 OPINION IT IS THE THIRD LOT EAST OF THAT INTERSECTION.
19:00:49 THE SURROUNDING AREA IS PREDOMINANTLY RESIDENTIAL IN
19:00:52 CHARACTER WITH SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES SURROUNDING THE
19:00:54 SUBJECT SITE.
19:01:01 HERE IS THE -- HERE IS THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
19:01:04 SUBJECT SITE UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-10 FUTURE LAND USE
19:01:05 DESIGNATION.
19:01:08 UP TO 10 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE.
19:01:13 TYPICALLY DESCRIBED AS LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL TO
19:01:15 SUPPORT DENSITY USES.
19:01:18 R-10 IS SURROUNDED -- SURROUNDS THE SUBJECT SITE ON ALL
19:01:22 SIDES THAT IS REPRESENTED THINK ABOUT ORANGE, TANNISH
19:01:22 COLOR.
19:01:26 THE CMU-35 IS TO THE NORTH OF THE SITE.
19:01:28 APPROXIMATELY TWO BLOCKS NORTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE
19:01:31 ALONG WEST GANDY BOULEVARD.
19:01:33 PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REVIEWED THE APPLICATION AND
19:01:34 FOUND NO ADVERSE IMPACTS TO THE SURROUNDING
19:01:36 NEIGHBORHOOD.
19:01:39 THE SEGMENT OF WEST PAUL AVENUE EXCLUDING THIS SITE HAS
19:01:44 AN EXISTING DENSITY OF 5.93 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE
19:01:47 BASED ON 19 SAMPLE SITES.
19:01:50 EXISTING DENSITY IS 59% OF THE DENSITY CONSIDERED UNDER
19:01:54 THE RESIDENTIAL-10 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION WHICH IS
19:01:58 WELL BELOW THE TEN DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE THAT IS
19:02:01 ANTICIPATED IN THE DESIGNATION.
19:02:06 ONE UNIT FOR .25 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE WHICH IS
19:02:10 CONSISTENT WITH THE DENSITY OF THE R-10 DESIGNATION AND
19:02:12 5% HIGHER THAN THE EXISTING BLOCK DENSITY OF THE
19:02:15 SEGMENT OF WEST PAUL AVENUE.
19:02:17 PLANNING COMMISSION PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REVIEWED
19:02:23 LOT WIDTHS ALONG THE OF WEST PAUL.
19:02:28 100 FEET TO 152 TO LOT RANGE 50 TO 60 FEET.
19:02:31 50 FEET FOR THE SUBMITTED SITE PLAN.
19:02:35 TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATION THE EXISTING BLOCK DENSITY
19:02:37 ALONG WEST PAUL AVENUE, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
19:02:40 FINDS THE REQUEST TO PROVIDE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
19:02:44 THAT WILL BE BUILT WITH AN EXISTING STREET BLOCK AND
19:02:45 CON FIGURES RAFF THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
19:02:47 BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION
19:02:49 FINDS THE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY OF TAMPA
19:02:51 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
19:02:54 THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION AND I AM AVAILABLE FOR
19:02:56 ANY QUESTIONS.
19:02:59 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. COLLINS.
19:03:00 HEARING NONE, MR. COTTON.
19:03:01 >>ERIC COTTON: THANK YOU, CHAIR.
19:03:09 MAY I SHARE MY SCREEN, PLEASE.
19:03:13 SO, AGAIN, THIS PROPERTY IS -- THIS REQUEST IS REZ 2
19:03:15 1135.
19:03:22 THE A MORNING MOBLEY REPRESENTED BY STEVE MACDILL.
19:03:26 THIS IS A EUCLIDIAN :ASK.
19:03:31 FROM RS-50 TO RS-50 RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY.
19:03:33 A PLATTED LOT.
19:03:40 THE LOT IS PLATTED WHICH IS APPROXIMATELY 50 X 134.
19:03:42 THE SURVEY OF THE PROPERTY.
19:03:46 YOU CAN YOU CAN TELL THIS HAS AN EXIST CAN ONE-STORY
19:03:47 GARAGE.
19:03:48 I BELIEVE IT BELONGS TO THE HOUSE IMMEDIATELY TO THE
19:03:55 EAST OF THE PROPERTY THIS IS THE ZONING -- THE AERIAL
19:03:58 FOR SHOWING THE ZONING TO THE NORTH.
19:04:00 RS-50 RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY.
19:04:04 TO THE SOUTH, EAST AND WEST ARE RS-60, ALTHOUGH -- IF
19:04:10 YOU GO DOWN THE BLOCK, AND RS-50 IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
19:04:14 AGAIN, THERE ARE NO WAIVERS.
19:04:16 THERE ARE NO SIGHT PLAN TO REVIEW.
19:04:21 THIS IS THE -- THE CONSISTENCY MAP THAT SHOWS THE
19:04:23 DEVELOPMENT PATTERN IN THE AREA.
19:04:25 THIS IS THE PROPERTY REQUEST QUESTION.
19:04:29 EVERYTHING IN THE -- IN THAT BLUISH COLOR IS 50 FEET.
19:04:32 BETWEEN 50 AND 54 FEET.
19:04:35 SO IDENTIFIED AS 37% OF THE BLOCKS IN THE STUDY AREA
19:04:36 WHICH IS SHOWN HERE.
19:04:42 65% OF THE SUBJECT BLOCK IS 71% OF THE BLOCK OF WEST
19:04:45 PAUL AVENUE, WHICH IS THIS AREA RIGHT THROUGH HERE.
19:04:50 AND 44% OF THE BLOCK FACE OF 60 FEET OR LESS.
19:04:53 STAFF FINDS THE REZONING CONSISTENT WITH THE
19:04:55 DEVELOPMENT PATTERN IN THE AREA.
19:05:00 REZONING THE PROPERTY FROM RS-60 TO RS-50 WILL MAKE
19:05:02 THIS A CONFORMING LOT.
19:05:05 60 FEET OF WIDTH AND 50.
19:05:06 AND RS-50.
19:05:09 COUNCIL HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR ME?
19:05:11 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. COTTON AT
19:05:11 THIS TIME.
19:05:14 MR. MICHELINI, YES, SIR.
19:05:17 >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL, STEVE MICHELINI REPRESENTING
19:05:22 MARK MOBLEY AND THEIR CUSTOM HOME COMPANY REGARDING THE
19:05:22 REZONING.
19:05:24 REQUESTING RS-50.
19:05:26 CURRENT ZONING IS RS-60.
19:05:29 AS THE STAFF HAS POINTED OUT FROM THE PLANNING
19:05:31 COMMISSION AND CITY STAFF, THEY FOUND IT CONSISTENT AND
19:05:33 HAD NO OBJECTIONS.
19:05:36 THIS IS AN EUCLIDIAN ZONING, UNLESS WE FILE FOR A
19:05:39 VARIANCE OF SOME OTHER KIND DURING DEVELOPMENT, WE WILL
19:05:43 HAVE TO MEET THE EXISTING CODES REGARDING SETBACKS AND
19:05:45 HEIGHT AND ALL THE OTHER DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS.
19:05:47 CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN WITHIN THE
19:05:49 AREA.
19:05:51 IT WAS PLATTED IN 1925.
19:05:55 AND AS THE STAFF HAS NOTED, THE LOTS ARE 50 FEET WIDE
19:05:57 AND 134 FEET DEEP.
19:06:00 GIVEN THAT, THESE LOTS ARE EXTREMELY LARGE.
19:06:02 AND THERE SHOULD BE NO DIFFICULTY WHATSOEVER REGARDING
19:06:08 THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN TO ENABLE THIS TO GO FORWARD.
19:06:10 THE -- I DON'T -- I MEAN IN THE PAST, I HAVE GONE
19:06:13 THROUGH AND LISTED ALL OF THE DIFFERENT CONSISTENCIES
19:06:17 THAT WERE FOUND BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION, BY THE CITY
19:06:18 STAFF.
19:06:21 INSTEAD OF READING ALL OF THEM AND GOING THROUGH EACH
19:06:24 ONE OF THESE NOTES, I REFER THAT YOU ASK THAT THESE BE
19:06:27 RECEIVED AND FILED AND BE MADE PART OF THE RECORD.
19:06:29 THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND THE CITY STAFF REPORT
19:06:31 FINDING IT CONSISTENT.
19:06:35 I KNOW IT IS LENGTHY, BUT, YOU KNOW, THE OBJECTIVE AND
19:06:39 LAND USES UNDER THE CITY'S PLANNING STRATEGY.
19:06:41 THE LAND USE OBJECT THAT I WAS ARE CONTAINED IN THE
19:06:44 DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS, GOALS AND OBJECTIVES AND
19:06:48 POLICIES AND THE LAND USE OBJECTIVES CONTAINED THEREIN
19:06:51 UNDER THE EIGHT-POINT PROCESS.
19:06:52 THE OVERALL RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT AND REDEVELOPMENT
19:06:56 LAND USE POLICIES, SINGLE-FAMILY AREAS, LAND USE
19:07:00 POLICIES, NEIGHBORHOOD COMMUNITY PLAN POLICIES, AND
19:07:04 THEIR OVERALL ANALYSIS FINDING IT WAS CONSISTENT.
19:07:08 LIKE I SAID, TO SAVE TIME AND -- IF YOU JUST ADOPT THIS
19:07:10 BY REFERENCE, I WOULD APPRECIATE IT.
19:07:12 IT IS PART OF THE RECORD ANYWAY.
19:07:14 WE ARE FOUND CONSISTENT.
19:07:16 WE BELIEVE THIS IS -- WOULD BE A GREAT ADDITION.
19:07:20 THIS IS UNDERUTILIZED BECAUSE ONLY A GARAGE ON THIS
19:07:22 PARTICULAR PARCEL.
19:07:25 AND THIS IS A PERFECT EXAMPLE OF UNDERUTILIZED PROPERTY
19:07:27 THAT CAN BE USED FOR SINGLE-FAMILY DEVELOPMENT.
19:07:30 I WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU MIGHT
19:07:34 HAVE AND RESPECTFULLY REQUESTING YOUR APPROVAL.
19:07:36 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE APPLICANT.
19:07:36 HEARING NONE.
19:07:43 ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 8?
19:07:44 ALL RIGHT, I SEE NO ONE.
19:07:48 NO ONE REGISTERED FOR NUMBER 8, IS THAT CORRECT.
19:07:50 MOTION TO CLOSE BY COUNCILMAN GUDES AND SECONDED BY
19:07:51 COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
19:07:53 ALL IN FAVOR.
19:07:55 OPPOSED.
19:07:57 WHO WAS NEXT.
19:07:58 COUNCILMAN -- COUNCILMAN GUDES.
19:08:03 WOULD YOU LIKE TO READ NUMBER 8?
19:08:07 >>ORLANDO GUDES: REZ-21-135.
19:08:09 ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING
19:08:12 CONSIDERATION, ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE
19:08:16 GENERAL VICINITY OF 3218 WEST PAUL AVENUE IN THE CITY
19:08:18 OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN
19:08:22 SECTION 1, ZONING DISTRICT RS-60 RESIDENTIAL
19:08:25 SINGLE-FAMILY TO RS-50 RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY
19:08:27 PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
19:08:29 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION AND A SECOND.
19:08:30 ROLL CALL.
19:08:34 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
19:08:36 >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
19:08:38 >>JOSEPH CITRO: YES.
19:08:39 >>ORLANDO GUDES: YES.
19:08:41 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
19:08:43 >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
19:08:47 SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD MAY 19, 2022
19:08:49 AT 9:30 A.M.
19:08:50 >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH, COUNCIL.
19:08:52 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
19:08:56 ITEM NUMBER 9, MR. COTTON.
19:08:58 >>ERIC COTTON: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR.
19:09:00 ERIC COTTON WITH LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
19:09:05 NUMBER 9, REZ-22-04.
19:09:10 FOR A PROPERTY ON 2303 NORTH JEFFERSON STREET TO REZONE
19:09:13 FROM RM-24 TO PD RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED
19:09:14 PROPERTY.
19:09:17 NOW REFER TO MR. COLLINS FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
19:09:20 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. COLLINS, GO AHEAD CANCER
19:09:22 CANCER THAT IS DANNY COLLINS WITH YOUR PLANNING
19:09:23 COMMISSION STAFF.
19:09:26 I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
19:09:28 TAMPA HEIGHTS URBAN VILLAGE.
19:09:30 THE CLOSEST TRANSITS STOP IS LOCATED EAST OF THE
19:09:35 SUBJECT SITE EAST 26TH AVENUE.
19:09:37 I AM SORRY.
19:09:39 I LOST MY PLACE.
19:09:42 AND SUBJECT SITE IS NOT LOCATED WITHIN AN EVACUATION
19:09:50 ZONE AND FERNANDO MESA SPARK LOCATED .12 MILES TO THE
19:09:51 SOUTHWEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
19:09:54 AERIAL MAP OF THE SURROUNDING SITE.
19:09:58 THE PROPERTY IS GENERALLY NORTHEAST OF EAST FRANCIS
19:10:00 AVENUE AND NORTH JEFFERSON STREET.
19:10:04 THE SURROUNDING AREA IS PREDOMINANTLY RESIDENTIAL IN
19:10:07 CHARACTER WITH SEVERAL OF THE SURROUNDING USES BEING
19:10:11 DETACHED SINGLE-FAMILY USES.
19:10:15 THERE IS -- I AM SORRY, THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE
19:10:16 MAP.
19:10:19 SUBJECT SITE UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-35 FUTURE LAND USE
19:10:20 DESIGNATION.
19:10:23 SURROUNDS ITS SUBJECTS SITE ON ALL SIDES.
19:10:28 AND PRESENT ALL THE WAY TWO BLOCKS NORTH OF THE SUBJECT
19:10:32 SITE AND SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE OF EAST ROSS AVENUE
19:10:35 NORTH OF EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE.
19:10:38 RECOGNIZED UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-10 DESIGNATION.
19:10:39 PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE APPLICATION
19:10:41 AND FOUND IN ADVERSE IMPACTS TO THE SURROUNDING
19:10:44 NEIGHBORHOOD OF THE PORTION OF NORTH JEFFERSON BETWEEN
19:10:48 EAST ROSS AVENUE AND EAST DEMILA AVENUE AS AN EXISTING
19:10:52 DENSITY OF 8.54 UNITS PER ACRE.
19:10:59 THE RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY 18 ZONING DISTRICTS --
19:11:02 SORRY, I AM ON THE WRONG THING.
19:11:05 EXISTING PORTION IS 24% OF THE ALLOWABLE DENSITY
19:11:12 PLANNED UNDER THE R-35 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
19:11:15 ONE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED UNIT CONSISTENT WITH THE
19:11:21 DENSITY UNDER THE R-35 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
19:11:24 PROPOSED REZONING AFFECTS MANY IN THE COMP PLAN WITH
19:11:27 HOUSING ITS CITY'S POPULATION.
19:11:30 TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ENCOURAGES NEW HOUSING ON
19:11:35 VACANT OR UNDERUTILIZED LAND TO HELP THE NEEDS OF
19:11:38 TAMPA'S FUTURE AND PRESENT POPULATION.
19:11:43 POLICY 1.17.62 SHARE OF ROADS AND URBAN CENTERS AND
19:11:47 VILLAGES, SUCH AS THE TAMPA HEIGHTS URBAN VILLAGE.
19:11:49 THE REQUEST SUPPORTS THIS POLICY DIRECTION AND WILL
19:11:52 PROVIDE ADDITIONAL HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES WITHIN THE
19:11:54 TAMPA HEIGHTS URBAN VILLAGE.
19:11:56 BASE ON THESE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION
19:11:57 FINDS IT CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY OF TAMPA
19:12:02 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION AND
19:12:04 AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
19:12:07 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. COLLINS?
19:12:09 MR. COTTON, GO AHEAD, SIR.
19:12:10 >>ERIC COTTON: THANK YOU.
19:12:11 CAN I SHARE MY SCREEN.
19:12:14 REZ 22-04.
19:12:17 THE APPLICANT IS CHRISTOPHER BECKWITH RENTED BY LORI
19:12:21 DUE VALUE AT 2303 NORTH JEFFERSON STREET.
19:12:25 REQUEST TO REZONE FROM RM-24 TO PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT.
19:12:28 THE REQUEST IS TO BUILD A SINGLE-FAMILY HOME ON THE
19:12:29 PROPERTY.
19:12:32 THE PROPERTY IT S A LITTLE UNDER 2,000 SQUARE FEET.
19:12:37 THE PROPOSED BUILDING WILL BE AROUND 995 SQUARE FEET.
19:12:38 THIS IS THE PROPERTY IN QUESTION.
19:12:42 IT IS IN THE HEART OF TAMPA -- IN TAMPA HEIGHTS, SOUTH
19:12:44 OF COLUMBUS DRIVE, ALONG JEFFERSON.
19:12:48 PROPERTY TO THE NORTH IS ZONED RM-24.
19:12:52 TO THE NORTH AND WEST, LOTS ARE CURRENTLY VACANT.
19:12:56 TO THE EAST AND THE SOUTH, THERE ARE ALSO ZONED RM-24
19:12:58 AND DEVELOPED WITH RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY.
19:13:00 THERE ARE SOME DIRECTIONS THAT NEED TO BE MADE BETWEEN
19:13:02 FIRST AND SECOND READING.
19:13:05 A REVISION SHEET ATTACHED TO THE STAFF REPORT.
19:13:08 ADDITIONALLY -- THERE IS ADDITIONAL REVISIONS THAT ARE
19:13:10 REQUESTED BY NATURAL RESOURCES.
19:13:12 THESE WERE DISCOVERED WHILE I WAS PREPPING FOR
19:13:14 TONIGHT'S HEARING.
19:13:17 I HAD E-MAILED BOTH THE APPLICANT AND THE CITY CLERK'S
19:13:18 OFFICE.
19:13:22 THOSE REVISIONS -- WOULD COUNCIL LIKE ME TO READ THEM
19:13:22 INTO THE RECORD.
19:13:25 LET ME SHOW YOU THE SITE PLAN FIRST.
19:13:27 THE PROPOSED SITE PLAN.
19:13:29 THE LOT WITH THE SINGLE-FAMILY HOME BEING PROPOSED.
19:13:31 TWO-STORY SINGLE-FAMILY HOME.
19:13:34 HANDS IT IS JUST THE ELEVATIONS OF THE PROPERTY ITSELF.
19:13:35 SORRY ABOUT THAT.
19:13:36 GETTING OUT OF PLACE.
19:13:39 SURROUNDING PROPERTIES CHURCH TO THE NORTH AND THE SITE
19:13:41 ITSELF IS CURRENTLY VACANT.
19:13:43 IT IS THE MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT.
19:13:49 AND, AGAIN, THIS PROPERTY OVER HERE IS VACANT.
19:13:51 IT IS CONSISTENT WITH FINDING WITH THE REVISIONS
19:13:53 REQUIRED.
19:13:56 WOULD COUNCIL LIKE ME TO READ THE ADDITIONAL REVISIONS
19:14:00 FROM NATURAL RESOURCES INTO THE RECORD OR SUFFICIENT.
19:14:03 AND I WILL GIVE THEM TO THE CLERK'S OFFICE AND TO THE
19:14:04 APPLICANT.
19:14:06 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IF YOU CAN READ THEM INTO THE
19:14:06 RECORD.
19:14:08 >>ERIC COTTON: WILL DO.
19:14:10 A NOTE TO THE SITE PLAN AS QUOTE 27.
19:14:17 284.2.4, THREE 20-INCH ROYAL OAKS AND SABLE PALM WERE
19:14:19 REMOVED WITHOUT A PERMIT.
19:14:24 VIOLATORS ARE SUBJECT TO TRIPLE -- TRIPLE PERMIT FEE OF
19:14:25 $369.
19:14:28 REQUIRED MITIGATION IS THREE TYPE ONE BE PENALTY TREES
19:14:34 AND DBH PAYMENT OF 4 50 PER TREE AND SIX TYPE ONE
19:14:37 MILLGATION TREES AT TWO AND A HALF DBH OR PAYMENT OF
19:14:38 $300.
19:14:42 TOTAL AM PAID IS $3519.
19:14:50 THIS REFLECTED FROM CODE CASE 22 -- COD-22-305.
19:14:53 SECTION 284.1.
19:14:58 PROVIDE THE FULL CITY OF TAMPA TREE TABLE OF THE TREE
19:14:59 TABLE.
19:15:03 SHOW SIX-FOOT NODES AS WELL.
19:15:06 AND SITE TABLE NEEDS TO BE REVISED SHOWING THE
19:15:09 REQUIREMENTS 27.284.3.
19:15:10 TABLE 3.3.
19:15:15 THE SITE PLAN REQUIRES TREES -- ONE TREE PER 2,000
19:15:18 SQUARE FEET OF PAR SET OF BUILDING FOOTPRINT.
19:15:22 THE CALCULATION SHOULD BE ONE TREE.
19:15:25 AND A NOTE TO THE SITE PLAN OF REGISTER CONSTRUCTION
19:15:27 FOR 27.281.
19:15:30 AND TECH MANUAL 8.2.
19:15:32 TREE PROTECTION.
19:15:35 AND PROVIDE TREE PROTECTION FOR GRAND TREES.
19:15:38 32 INCHES.
19:15:43 AND THE AGE OF IMPROVEMENT, SPECIMEN 24 FEET.
19:15:46 AND 15 FEET FROM THE EDGE TO THE CLOSEST EDGE OF THE
19:15:49 PAVEMENT AND PROTECTED TREES 23 INCHES OR LESS, 10 FEET
19:15:53 FROM THE EDGE OF TRUNK TO THE CLOSEST IMPROVEMENT.
19:15:57 AND TREES AND TREES WITHIN 20 FIGHTS OF THE PARCEL MAY
19:16:00 BE PROTECTED AND NOT IMPACTED BY CONSTRUCTION.
19:16:02 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
19:16:03 SIR.
19:16:04 >>ERIC COTTON: THANK YOU.
19:16:05 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
19:16:06 NO?
19:16:08 IF WE HAVE AN APPLICANT FOR ITEM NUMBER 9.
19:16:12 YES, SIR.
19:16:14 PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
19:16:21 >> CHRIS BECKWITH, 817 NORTH RIVER SHORE DRIVE.
19:16:23 I WOULD LIKE TO ADDRESS THE TREES FIRST.
19:16:24 I DON'T OWN THE PROPERTY.
19:16:28 I HAVE IT UNDER CONTRACT, DEPENDENT ON THE REZONING.
19:16:31 THE OWNERS TOOK THE TREE OUT BASED ON A TREE REPORT
19:16:32 THAT HE HAS.
19:16:36 SO HE ACTUALLY HAS A TREE CONSULTATION SCHEDULED WITH
19:16:40 THE CITY LAWYERS ON JUNE 1.
19:16:44 SO JUST WANTED TO MAKE THAT CLEAR.
19:16:47 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CITRO.
19:16:49 >>JOSEPH CITRO: ARE YOU OWNER OF THE PROPERTY?
19:16:50 >> NO, I HAVE IT UNDER CONTRACT.
19:16:52 I AM TRYING TO BUY IT.
19:16:54 >>JOSEPH CITRO: I AM SORRY, MR. CHAIR.
19:16:57 ARE YOU AUTHORIZED TO MAKE DECISIONS?
19:16:58 >> YES.
19:17:00 >>JOSEPH CITRO: DO YOU HAVE THAT IN WRITING?
19:17:03 >> NOT WITH ME.
19:17:05 >>MARTIN SHELBY: ARE YOU THE APPLICANT?
19:17:06 >> I AM APPLICANT.
19:17:08 I HAVE THE AUTHORITY FROM THE OWNERS.
19:17:15 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MISS WELLS, IS THAT CORRECT?
19:17:17 >>CATE WELLS: CATE WELLS.
19:17:23 PART OF THE APPLICANT, AN AGENT AUTHORIZATION OF MR.
19:17:24 BECKWITH.
19:17:25 >>CATE WELLS: YES.
19:17:27 THAT IS SOMETHING OUR OFFICE CHECKS BEFORE THESE
19:17:30 APPLICATIONS COME BEFORE YOU.
19:17:31 >> I WASN'T GOING TO PURCHASE THE PROPERTY WITHOUT
19:17:33 HAVING GONE THROUGH THIS PROCESS.
19:17:38 SO AS ERIC MENTIONED, SO WE ARE TRYING TO REZONE TO PD.
19:17:40 BECAUSE IT IS A NONCONFORMING LOT.
19:17:43 ONLY 35 FEET WIDE, 57 FEET DEEP.
19:17:48 SO IT IS VERY SMALL, BUT ORIGINALLY PLATTED THAT WAY.
19:17:52 SO IT DOESN'T -- IT WON'T MEET ANY OF THE CRITERIA FOR
19:17:54 RM-24.
19:17:56 I HAVE GONE TO THE ARC ALREADY.
19:17:59 GONE THROUGH HAVING THEM APPROVE THE SITE PLAN, WHICH
19:18:00 THEY HAVE.
19:18:03 I KNOW I HAVE TO STILL GO BACK THROUGH THEIR DESIGN
19:18:06 CRITERIA.
19:18:10 SO THE -- THE SETBACKS IN -- IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD --
19:18:12 NOT NECESSARILY THIS NEIGHBORHOOD, BUT THE SOUTH SIDE
19:18:14 WOULD BE FIVE FEET.
19:18:16 THE NORTH SIDE WILL BE THREE.
19:18:20 WHICH IS BASICALLY JUST LIKE A PORTICO ALL THE WAY DOWN
19:18:21 THE SIDE.
19:18:23 THE FRONT SETBACK IS 7.
19:18:26 AND THE REAR IS 11.
19:18:29 SO IF YOU SAW IN THE PICTURES, THERE IS A -- THE LOT
19:18:31 JUST TO THE SOUTH RIGHT HERE.
19:18:34 THIS IS A MULTIFAMILY UNIT.
19:18:38 AND THAT SETBACK ON JEFFERSON -- IT IS LITERALLY ON THE
19:18:39 SIDEWALK.
19:18:41 LIKE MAYBE ONE FOOT.
19:18:44 THE LOT TO THE NORTH IS VACANT.
19:18:48 AND THIS LOT RIGHT HERE, I BELIEVE, WAS ACTUALLY JUST
19:18:50 REZONED FOR A DUPLEX.
19:18:55 AND THEIR SIDE SETBACK -- WAS SEVEN FEET.
19:18:57 SO THIS HOUSE WILL BE CONSISTENT WITH THAT ONE AND
19:19:01 ACTUALLY SIT BEHIND THE -- THE APARTMENT COMPLEX RIGHT
19:19:02 THERE.
19:19:05 IT IS LIKE A FOUR-UNIT.
19:19:11 AND THE STRUCTURE ITSELF, AGAIN, THE SIDE SETBACK TO
19:19:14 THIS SIDE OF THE HOUSE, THIS WILL BE FIVE FEET AWAY.
19:19:17 THE STRUCTURE HERE WILL BE FIVE FEET AWAY.
19:19:20 THE PORTICO WOULD BE THREE.
19:19:23 AND THE PARKING -- THERE ARE TWO PARKING SPOTS.
19:19:26 WE DID THEM TANDEM BECAUSE HAVING THEM NEXT TO EACH
19:19:29 OTHER WOULD BASICALLY BE THE ENTIRE WIDTH OF THE LOT.
19:19:32 THAT IS THE ONLY WAY IT WOULD REALLY WORK.
19:19:35 THAT IS PRETTY MUCH ALL I HAVE FOR YOU.
19:19:37 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, COUNCILMAN CITRO.
19:19:40 >>JOSEPH CITRO: WHAT ARE THE SIDE AND REAR SETBACKS.
19:19:47 >> THE FRONT IS 7 AND REAR JUST OVER 11.
19:19:51 AGAIN, WHEN I WENT TO THE ARC, THEY LOOKED AT A LOT OF
19:19:55 HOUSES IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD THAT HAVE MUCH LESS SETBACKS
19:19:59 IN THE AREA IN TAMPA HEIGHTS.
19:20:00 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
19:20:01 ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?
19:20:02 THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
19:20:04 DO WE HAVE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON
19:20:06 ITEM NUMBER 9?
19:20:15 YES, SIR, MR. HAGAN.
19:20:16 >> MY NAME IS NATHAN HAGAN.
19:20:20 I WANT TO COMMENT WHEN WE TALK OF MIDDLE HOUSING AND
19:20:22 THE ISSUES OF ZONING CODE IN TAMPA.
19:20:25 THIS IS AN EXAMPLE OF WHAT WE NEED MORE OF IF WE WANT
19:20:26 TO HAVE MORE DENSITY.
19:20:29 I DON'T KNOW REALLY KNOW ANYTHING OF THIS PROJECT.
19:20:30 I NEVER TALKED TO THE APPLICANT.
19:20:33 I DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT THIS PROJECT UNTIL I LOOKED AT THE
19:20:36 AGENDA TODAY, BUT I WAS SURPRISED TO SEE THERE WAS AN
19:20:38 RM-24 GOING TO A PD.
19:20:40 THAT SEEMED VERY STRANGE TO ME.
19:20:44 SET UP ALARM IN MY HEAD AND I WAS PLEASED TO SEE A
19:20:46 2,000-SQUARE-FOOT LOT.
19:20:49 ONE OF THE WORST -- ONE OF THE MOST IMPACTFUL OF
19:20:52 EXCLUSIONARY ZONING, A WORD I HAVE BEEN TRYING TO
19:20:54 EDUCATES THE COMMUNITY ABOUT.
19:20:57 THE RULES WE SET IN PLACE 8 0 YEARS AGO THAT MAKE
19:21:02 HOUSING VERY UNAFFORDABLE IN THE CITY.
19:21:05 MINIMUM HOUSE.
19:21:09 MAKING HOUSING MORE EXPENSIVE AND APPLAUD THE
19:21:10 APPLICANT.
19:21:13 IT WASN'T UP TO THEM BECAUSE IT WAS PLOT THIS WAY, THIS
19:21:16 IS A GOOD EXAMPLE OF THE KIND OF HOUSES WE NEED TO
19:21:19 THINK OF LEGALIZING IN PARTS OF THE CITY.
19:21:22 I KNOW THERE IS AN ISSUE WITH THE TREES AND A VERY
19:21:24 NOVEL THING TO SEE, BUT I AM PLEASE TODAY SEE SOME
19:21:27 DIVERSITY OF HOUSING IN.
19:21:30 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
19:21:34 MR. CITRO, QUESTION FOR MR. COTTON.
19:21:37 >>JOSEPH CITRO: MR. COTTON, ARE YOU.
19:21:40 >>ERIC COTTON: YES, SIR.
19:21:42 >>JOSEPH CITRO: WAS THIS PLOTTED THIS WAY?
19:21:46 HOW DID IT GET BE TOO SMALL LOT.
19:21:49 >> THEY WENT TO A FORMAL DECISION BACK IN 2018.
19:21:51 IT IS PART OF A LARGER LOT.
19:21:54 IT WAS SPLIT OFF ILLEGALLY SOME TIME IN THE PAST.
19:21:56 IT WAS THEN PURCHASED.
19:21:59 THE PERSON WHO OWN TODAY IN 2018 CAME FOR A FORMAL
19:22:01 DECISION BUT THE ZONING ADMINISTRATOR TO DETERMINE THAT
19:22:04 THE LOT WAS A LEGAL LOT OF RECORD BUT WAS UNABLE TO DO
19:22:05 THAT.
19:22:09 THE WAY TO RECTIFY THE SITUATION IS COME BEFORE THE
19:22:11 COUNCIL IS A REZONING APPLICATION.
19:22:14 >>JOSEPH CITRO: THIS LOT CANNOT BE USED FOR ANYTHING
19:22:19 ELSE BUT IF THERE IS A CHANGE, CHANGE OF USE.
19:22:20 >>ERIC COTTON: CORRECT.
19:22:24 IF -- IF T WOULD HAVE STAYED VACANT UNLESS ACTION TAKEN
19:22:27 BY COUNCIL TO PROVIDE THE APPLICANT SOME RELIEF WITH
19:22:28 THE LOT SIZE.
19:22:29 >>JOSEPH CITRO: THANK YOU.
19:22:32 THANK YOU, MR. COTTON, THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR.
19:22:34 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE.
19:22:34 NO?
19:22:35 ANYBODY ELSE FOR PUBLIC COMMENT.
19:22:36 I DON'T SEE ANYBODY.
19:22:37 NO?
19:22:40 AND NOBODY REGISTERED, THAT'S CORRECT?
19:22:42 >>CLERK: THAT'S CORRECT.
19:22:43 >>ORLANDO GUDES: MOTION.
19:22:45 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
19:22:47 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
19:22:49 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THANK YOU MR. CHAIRMAN.
19:22:54 FILE NUMBER 9, REZ-22-04, MOVE AN ORDINANCE BEING
19:22:56 PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, ORDINANCE
19:23:00 REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 2303 NORTH
19:23:03 JEFFERSON STREET IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, AND
19:23:05 MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1, FROM ZONING
19:23:11 DISTRICT CLASSIFICATIONS RM-24 RESIDENTIAL MULHERN TO
19:23:13 PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY
19:23:17 DETACHED PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
19:23:18 >>ORLANDO GUDES: YES.
19:23:19 >>JOSEPH CITRO: YES.
19:23:22 >>MARTIN SHELBY: DID THAT INCLUDE BOTH -- SORRY IF I
19:23:23 MISSED IT.
19:23:25 DOES THAT INCLUDE THE REVISION SHEET AND THE -- AND THE
19:23:28 ADDITIONAL REVISED REVISION SHEET --
19:23:30 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I AM SORRY I FAILED TO LOOK.
19:23:32 YES, IT DOES, SIR.
19:23:34 >>MARTIN SHELBY: THANK YOU VERY MUCH SIR.
19:23:35 >>ORLANDO GUDES: YES.
19:23:36 >>JOSEPH CITRO: YES.
19:23:37 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
19:23:41 >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
19:23:42 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
19:23:45 >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
19:23:47 SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MAY 19,
19:23:49 2022 AT 9:30 A.M.
19:23:56 WITH CARLSON AND HURTAK BEING ABSENT.
19:23:58 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
19:24:01 NEXT ITEM IS ITEM NUMBER 10, MR. COTTON.
19:24:02 >>ERIC COTTON: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR.
19:24:08 NEXT UP ON AGENDA REZ 21-129 FOR A PROPERTY LOCATED AT
19:24:13 105, 17 AND 109 EAST 26TH AVENUE.
19:24:16 A COUPLE OF LOTS CURRENTLY ZONED RS-50.
19:24:19 THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING TO REZONE IT TO RM-18.
19:24:22 NOW I WILL REFER TO MR. COLLINS WITH THE PLANNING
19:24:23 COMMISSION.
19:24:26 >>DANNY COLLINS: GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL, DANNY COLLINS
19:24:28 WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
19:24:29 I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN.
19:24:32 NEXT CASE IS IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICTS
19:24:34 AND MORE SPECIFICALLY WITHIN THE TAMPA HEIGHTS URBAN
19:24:36 VILLAGE.
19:24:39 THE REQUEST IS TRANSIT STOP LOCATED ONE BLOCK EAST OF
19:24:41 THE SUBJECT SITE AT THE INTERSECTION OF EAST 26TH
19:24:43 AVENUE AND NORTH FLORIDA AVENUE.
19:24:46 THE TRANSIT SITE CONNECTING THE SUBJECT SITES OF
19:24:48 DOWNTOWN TAMPA AND THE UNIVERSITY.
19:24:51 THE CLOSEST PUBLIC RECREATION FACILITY IS ROBLES PARK
19:24:55 LOCATED QUARTER MILE TO THE EAST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
19:24:58 SUBJECT SITE IS NOT LOCATED WANT EVACUATION ZONE.
19:25:01 AN AERIAL MAP OF A SUBJECT SITE AND THE SURROUNDING
19:25:02 PROPERTY.
19:25:06 YOU WILL SEE THE SUBJECT SITE IS GENERALLY EAST OF THE
19:25:10 INTERSECTION -- SORRY, WEST OF THE INTERSECTION OF 26TH
19:25:12 AVENUE AND NORTH FLORIDA AVENUE.
19:25:15 THERE ARE NONRESIDENTIAL USES PREDOMINANTLY LOCATED
19:25:18 ALONG FLORIDA AVENUE AND TRANSITION TO RESIDENTIAL USES
19:25:22 AS YOU MOVE WEST OFF FLORIDA AVENUE.
19:25:27 THIS IS THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
19:25:31 THE SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN THE RESIDENTIAL-20 FUTURE
19:25:31 LAND USE.
19:25:36 R-20 TO THE NORTH, WEST AND SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
19:25:38 ALONG FLORIDA AVENUE, RECOGNIZED UNDER THE COMMERCIAL
19:25:42 35 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
19:25:45 AS YOU MOVE TWO BLOCKS WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE, OUR
19:25:49 PARCEL IS RECOGNIZED UNDER THE FUTURE LAND USE
19:25:50 DESIGNATION.
19:25:52 PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REVIEWED THE APPLICATION AND
19:25:54 FOUND NO ADVERSE IMPACTS.
19:25:57 THIS PORTION OF EAST 26TH AVENUE BETWEEN NORTH TAMPA
19:26:01 AVENUE AND IT IS PRESENTLY UNDER DEVELOPED.
19:26:06 SEGMENT AT 5.87 DWELLING UNITS WHICH IS 29% OF THE
19:26:09 DENSITY THAT IS ANTICIPATED UNDER THE R-20 FUTURE LAND
19:26:11 USE DESIGNATION.
19:26:13 RESIDENTIAL MULTI FAMILY ZONING DISTRICT IS CONSISTENT
19:26:17 WITH THE DENSITY ANTICIPATED UNDER THE R-20 DESIGNATION
19:26:19 AND WILL OFFER DEVELOPMENT COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE
19:26:23 WITH THE SURROUNDING AREA AND REQUEST THE BOARD OF THE
19:26:26 POLICIES AS IT RELATES TO THE CITY'S HOUSING CH
19:26:28 POPULATION.
19:26:32 ENCOURAGES NEW HOUSING OF VACANT AND UNDERUTILIZED LAND
19:26:36 AS A NEED OF TAMPA'S PRESENT AND FUTURE POPULATIONS.
19:26:39 ADDITIONALLY THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN SEEKS THE GROWTH TO
19:26:41 THE URBAN CENTERS AND VILLAGES.
19:26:43 THE PROPOSED PLANNED DEVELOPMENT OFFERS.
19:26:47 >> THE POLICY BY CREATING ADDITIONAL HOUSING
19:26:49 OPPORTUNITIES IN THE TAMPA HEIGHTS URBAN VILLAGE.
19:26:52 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ENCOURAGES MULTIFAMILY AND ATTACHED
19:26:56 RESIDENTIAL USES TO DESIGNED TO INCLUDE ORIENTATION OF
19:26:58 THE FRONT DOOR TO A NEIGHBORHOOD SIDEWALK AND STREETS.
19:27:03 AND THOSE ARE -- THAT IS LAND USE POLICY 9.2.6.
19:27:07 FUTURE DEVELOPMENT OF THE SITE FROM MULTIFAMILY OR
19:27:10 ATTACHED SHOULD ADDRESS THE POLICY AND DIRECTION IN THE
19:27:10 FUTURE.
19:27:12 BASED ON THESE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION
19:27:15 STAFF FINDS THE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY OF
19:27:17 TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
19:27:21 THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION AND AVAILABLE FOR ANY
19:27:21 QUESTIONS.
19:27:23 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. COLLINS.
19:27:25 MR. COTTON, GO AHEAD.
19:27:26 >>ERIC COTTON: THANK YOU.
19:27:28 ERIC COTTON, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
19:27:32 AGAIN, THIS IS REZ 21-129.
19:27:35 THE APPLICANT IS BENJAMIN BUCKLEY.
19:27:39 REPRESENTED BY ROBERTA CURRY.
19:27:45 THE ADDRESS IS 105, 17 AND 1 9TH AVENUE.
19:27:46 NO SITE PLAN.
19:27:51 EUCLIDIAN FROM RS-50 RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY TO RM-18
19:27:52 RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY.
19:27:54 THIS IS THE ORIGINAL PLAT.
19:27:58 UNFORTUNATELY IT IS ORIENTED WHERE NORTH IS TO THE
19:28:03 RIGHT, BUT IT IS THREE PLATTED LOTS OF THE PROPERTY.
19:28:08 SURROUNDING PROPERTY TO THE EAST IS ZONED CI.
19:28:09 IT IS DEVELOPED WITH COMMERCIAL USES.
19:28:15 TO THE NORTH AND SOUTH AND WEST ARE ALL RS-50.
19:28:19 ALL DEVELOPED -- THE PROPERTY TO THE NORTH IS DEVELOPED
19:28:23 AS MULTIFAMILY AND TO THE SOUTH AND WEST, SINGLE-FAMILY
19:28:25 ZONING DISTRICTS.
19:28:28 DEVELOPED AS SINGLE-FAMILY.
19:28:33 IF THIS IS GOING TO BE APPROVED BY COUNCIL, UP TO EIGHT
19:28:36 DWELLING UNIT ON THE SITE, GIVEN THE ITENS TEE ALLOWED
19:28:39 UNDER THE RM-18 WITHOUT ANY WAIVERS BEING GRANTED.
19:28:43 JUST AS -- AS A SIDE, THIS WOULD BE AN APPROPRIATE STEP
19:28:47 DOWN FROM REFERRING SINGLE-FAMILY GOING INTO
19:28:51 MULTIFAMILY FROM THE MORE INTENSE CI ZONING USES AS WE
19:28:53 GO INTO THE RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD.
19:28:56 AND THEN SOME PHOTOS OF THE SITE.
19:28:59 AGAIN, IT IS CURRENTLY VACANT.
19:29:04 THIS IS THE -- THIS IS THE SITE -- I TAKE THAT BACK.
19:29:06 BECAUSE OF THE SIZE OF THE SITE.
19:29:09 VACANT ALONG WITH A SINGLE-FAMILY HOME ON IT.
19:29:13 THIS IS THE VIEW TO THE WEST AND THE VIEW TO THE NORTH.
19:29:15 AND ACROSS -- AND THIS IS THE EAST.
19:29:17 THIS IS THE COMMERCIAL TO THE EAST.
19:29:20 AND THIS IS JUST THE VIEW LOOKING DOWN THE PROPERTY
19:29:23 GOING BACK TOWARD THE MAIN ROAD.
19:29:26 AGAIN, STAFF FOUND THE REQUEST CONSISTENT.
19:29:29 IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, I WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER
19:29:31 THEM FOR YOU.
19:29:34 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. COTTON.
19:29:37 MR. BUCKLEY OR YOUR REPRESENTATIVE.
19:29:37 THANK YOU.
19:29:41 >> GOOD EVENING, CHAIRMAN AND COUNCIL PEDRO RODRIGUEZ,
19:29:45 607 WEST MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. BOULEVARD IN TAMPA.
19:29:50 I AM REPRESENTING MISS CURRIE AND NATIONAL PROPERTY
19:29:52 REPORTS OF OTHER TWO LOTS.
19:29:54 MR. BUCKLEY IS HERE WITH ME.
19:29:56 THE PRESIDENT OF NATIONAL PROPERTY REPORTS.
19:29:59 WE ARE HERE ON A REQUEST FOR EUCLIDIAN REZONING TO
19:30:05 RM-18 FOR THE PROPERTIES LOCATED AT 105 TO 109 EAST
19:30:07 26TH STREET.
19:30:12 I DO HAVE A PRESENTATION I WOULD LIKE TO BRING UP.
19:30:15 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD.
19:30:26 YOU CAN BRING UP THE PRESENTATION.
19:30:33 SO IN THIS SURVEY, SHOWS THREE PARCELS OF PROPERTY.
19:30:36 THEY OWNED THE PROPERTY FOR TEN YEARS AND THEY WOULD
19:30:38 LIKE TO DEVELOP THE PROPERTIES TO CREATE A SETTING THAT
19:30:43 WILL ALLOW FOR SMALLER, YET MORE COMFORTABLE DWELLINGS
19:30:46 WITHIN THE CITY LIMITS, ADDRESSING THE MIDDLE --
19:30:50 MISSING MIDDLE HOUSING NEEDS AND FITTING WELL WITHIN
19:30:54 MAYOR CASTOR'S PLANNING INITIATIVES.
19:30:58 THERE IS ACTUALLY TWO SINGLE-FAMILY PROPERTIES ON THE
19:31:00 -- ON THESE THREE LOTS.
19:31:06 THERE IS ONE VACANT LOT.
19:31:10 THIS IS THE MIDDLE EXAMPLE.
19:31:16 THESE ARE EXAMPLES OF THE SIMILAR PROPERTIES AROUND
19:31:16 TAMPA.
19:31:23 THESE ARE IN THE SOHO DISTRICT WHICH ARE ZONED RM-24.
19:31:26 AS REQUIRED BY THE CITY, THE OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY
19:31:29 REQUEST MEETINGS WITH THE CIVIC ASSOCIATIONS WHO ARE
19:31:31 AFFECTED BY THE REQUESTED REZONING.
19:31:36 WE WERE ABLE TO SPEAK WITH THREE OF THEM.
19:31:40 TWO HAD SOME CONCERNS ABOUT HAVING A -- THE MAIN
19:31:43 CONCERNS WERE THERE WERE NO PLANS.
19:31:47 AND THAT THEY DON'T WANT TO HAVE A BOXY-LOOKING
19:31:49 STRUCTURE ON THE PROPERTY.
19:31:55 THIS IS A CONCEPTUAL DESIGN THAT WAS DESIGNED BY THE
19:31:58 LATE TOM LEVIN AT THE REQUEST OF MR. BUCKLEY THAT SHOWS
19:32:04 SEVERAL SMALLER PROPERTIES THAT WOULD BE BUILT ON -- ON
19:32:06 THIS PROPERTY.
19:32:11 SO THE OWNERS WOULDN'T WANT TO SPEND ANY MORE MONEY ON
19:32:16 THIS WITHOUT HAVING SOME ASSURANCES THIS IS WHAT THE
19:32:21 CITY WOULD BE -- WOULD APPROVE.
19:32:26 SO PROVIDED THE RM-18 WOULD GIVE THEM -- WOULD GIVE THE
19:32:29 OWNER INSURANCE THAT THE -- THAT THEY COULD ACTUALLY
19:32:32 BUILD THIS SORT OF THING.
19:32:38 MAY BE DIFFERENT, BUT THIS IS A CONCEPTUAL DESIGN.
19:32:42 WITH THE EUCLIDIAN REZONING THEY WILL HAVE TO MEET ALL
19:32:43 THE APPROPRIATE SETBACKS.
19:32:45 AND THE TYPE -- THE ISSUE WITH THE TYPE OF BUILDING
19:32:48 CONSTRUCTED WOULD BE AN ISSUE FOR THE CONSIDERATION OF
19:32:53 THE CITY OF TAMPA BUILDING OFFICIAL.
19:32:59 THERE ARE OTHER PROJECTS THAT ARE GOING OF A SIMILAR
19:33:02 NATURE ON NORTH FLORIDA AVENUE, TAMPA STREET, AS WELL
19:33:04 AS NORTH BOULEVARD, TO NAME A FEW.
19:33:10 THE AIR ROW SHOWS WHERE THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AND THE
19:33:12 OTHER PICTURES ARE TO THE SITE.
19:33:13 HERE ARE SOME MORE.
19:33:19 THOSE ARE, I BELIEVE, ON NORTH BOULEVARD AND FLORIDA
19:33:22 ALSO.
19:33:26 THE REQUESTED REZONING MEETS WITH THE LAND DEVELOPMENT
19:33:30 CODE, LONG-RANGE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND THE TAMPA
19:33:31 ENVISION PLAN.
19:33:35 THESE ITEMS -- THE ITEM HIGHLIGHTED IN YELLOW ARE
19:33:38 POINTS FROM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN USED BY COUNCIL IN
19:33:40 PRIOR REZONING REQUEST.
19:33:43 THE ONE MARKED WITH AN ASTERISK IN RED HAS BEEN
19:33:47 POSITIVELY REFERRED -- REFERENCED BY THE STAFF IN THE
19:33:49 REPORT TODAY.
19:33:55 THAT IS PART OF THE -- THE -- THE PRESENTATION.
19:33:59 THERE THERE ARE PRESENTLY -- THERE IS PRESENTLY ONE
19:34:03 HOUSE ON -- ON THE TWO LOTS, -- ON THE THREE LOTS,
19:34:04 SORRY.
19:34:08 BOTH OF THESE RESIDENCES ARE PRESENTLY RENTED AT NO
19:34:09 CHARGE.
19:34:13 TENANTS BASICALLY TO AVOID HAVING THE RESIDENCES VACANT
19:34:20 THE REZONING WILL GIVE THE OWNERS A POSSIBILITIES OF
19:34:23 BUILDING THREE SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTS AT EACH REZONE
19:34:26 THE PARCEL OR NINE DWELLINGS ON THE THREE REZONED
19:34:27 PARCELS COMBINED.
19:34:31 MULTIPLE SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTS PER PARCEL WILL LIKELY
19:34:34 ADDRESS COST CONCERN OF POTENTIAL BUYER AS LESS LAND IS
19:34:36 INVOLVED IN THE PURCHASE AND SALE.
19:34:39 TAMPA RESIDENTS WANT TO BE AS CLOSE TO DOWNTOWN AS
19:34:39 POSSIBLE.
19:34:44 APPROVING THIS REZONING REQUEST WILL HELP TOWARD THAT
19:34:47 AND IS HELPFUL IN THE CURRENT HOUSING SHORTAGE THAT WE
19:34:49 ARE EXPERIENCING.
19:34:54 THERE IS AN ALLEY.
19:34:57 AN ALLEY TO THE SOUTH, TO THE THREE PARCELS PROVIDING
19:34:59 ACCESS TO TAMPA STREET.
19:35:04 WE DO NOT FORESEE PARKING AS BEING AN ISSUE.
19:35:09 IT WILL BE ON-SITE AND THROUGH THE EXISTING ALLEY.
19:35:11 IT IS WIDER THAN THE TYPICAL STREET IN THE AREA AND A
19:35:17 ROAD WHERE THE FORMER TROLLEY USED TO RUN.
19:35:20 THE OWNERS WHICH TO BE CONTRIBUTORS OF THE ADVANCEMENT
19:35:24 OF THE CITY AND WE BELIEVE WHAT WE ARE REQUESTING IS IN
19:35:27 LINE WITH THE VISION CONTAINED IN THE COMPREHENSIVE
19:35:32 PLANS AND MAYOR CASTOR'S INTENTION FOR THE CITY.
19:35:40 WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST THAT YOU APPROVE OUR REQUEST.
19:35:44 WE PROVIDED 15 LETTERS OF SUPPORT.
19:35:48 ONE IS FROM JOHN WATSON TO RUNS THE HALFWAY HOUSE
19:35:52 ACROSS THE STREET ON NORTH BOULEVARD -- ON -- ON NORTH
19:35:53 FLORIDA.
19:35:55 THAT PROPERTY IS ZONED COMMERCIAL.
19:35:59 AND IT EXTENDS FROM FLORIDA AVENUE TO TAMPA STREET.
19:36:03 I HAVE ALSO IN THE PRESENTATION, HAVE INCLUDED
19:36:05 EXCERPTS FROM THE ENVISION PLAN THAT TALKS OF COMMUNITY
19:36:09 DEVELOPMENT IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, WHICH, WE BELIEVE,
19:36:11 SUPPORT OUR REQUEST.
19:36:13 MR. BUCKLEY IS HERE WITH ME TODAY.
19:36:16 WE WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU MAY
19:36:17 HAVE.
19:36:21 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN?
19:36:23 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I HAVEN'T SEEN MR. BUCKLEY IN A
19:36:24 LONG TIME.
19:36:25 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HE DOESN'T AGE.
19:36:27 HE LOOKS THE SAME.
19:36:28 >> THANK YOU.
19:36:31 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC THAT IS HERE
19:36:34 TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, ITEM NUMBER 10?
19:36:36 I SEE NO ONE AND NOBODY REGISTERED TO SPEAK.
19:36:38 IF NO OTHER --
19:36:39 >>ORLANDO GUDES: MOTION TO CLOSE.
19:36:42 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
19:36:43 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR.
19:36:45 ANY OPPOSE $.
19:36:48 COUNCILMAN VIERA, WOULD YOU MIND READING ITEM NUMBER
19:36:49 10.
19:36:51 >>LUIS VIERA: YES, SIR, I MOVE AN ORDINANCE PRESENTED
19:36:54 FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION REZONING PROPERTY IN
19:36:59 THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 105, 107 AND 109 EAST 26TH
19:37:01 AVENUE IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, AND MORE
19:37:03 PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1 FROM ZONING
19:37:06 DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION RS-50, RESIDENTIAL
19:37:09 SINGLE-FAMILY TO RM-18 RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY
19:37:11 PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
19:37:15 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
19:37:17 AND SECOND BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
19:37:18 ROLL CALL.
19:37:19 >>ORLANDO GUDES: YES.
19:37:21 >>JOSEPH CITRO: YES.
19:37:23 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
19:37:25 >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
19:37:27 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
19:37:29 >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY WITH CARLSON AND
19:37:31 HURTAK BEING ABSENT.
19:37:34 SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MAY 19,
19:37:40 2022 AT 9:30 A.M.
19:37:41 >> THANK YOU.
19:37:42 >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
19:37:42 GOOD EVENING.
19:37:44 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU TOO.
19:37:47 LAST ITEM OF THE NIGHT, ITEM NUMBER 12.
19:37:47 MR. COTTON.
19:37:50 >>ERIC COTTON: ERIC COTTON, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
19:37:57 THIS IS AB 22 -- OH, CAN I SHARE MY SCREEN, PLEASE?
19:37:59 SORRY.
19:38:00 THANK YOU.
19:38:08 THIS IS AB 22-06 FOR PROPERTY OF 3615 AND 3617 WEST
19:38:09 GANDY BOULEVARD.
19:38:13 THE APPLICANT IS DAVID SMITH FROM STEARNS WEAVER.
19:38:18 THIS IS A REQUEST FOR AN ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE FOR A LARGE
19:38:21 VENUE.
19:38:24 THE PROPOSED USE IS SHOPPERS GOODS.
19:38:28 LARGE VENUE FOR CONSUMPTION ON PREMISE AND OFF PREMISE
19:38:31 IN PACKAGE SALES.
19:38:34 SO THE PROPERTY CURRENTLY HAS TWO ALCOHOL PERMITS ON
19:38:35 IT.
19:38:37 ONE WAS A 2 ABS.
19:38:40 LET ME START -- THIS IS FOR A PUBLIX GROCERY STORE.
19:38:44 THERE IS THE -- THE MAIN STORE 2 APS.
19:38:50 THE LIQUOR STORE A 3 APS AND PROPOSING TO GO TO A LARGE
19:38:50 VENUE.
19:38:55 THEY ARE REQUESTING ROUGHLY 64,281 TOTAL SQUARE FEET.
19:38:59 61 500 WILL BE INDOORS AND 2800 SQUARE FEET WILL BE
19:39:00 OUTSIDE.
19:39:03 THEY DID RECEIVE A DESIGN EXCEPTION BACK -- BACK LAST
19:39:07 YEAR IN 2021 TO REDUCE THE REQUIRED PARKING SPACES.
19:39:12 SO THEY WERE GOING FROM 245 SPACES DOWN TO 228 SPACES.
19:39:15 THE HOURS OF OPERATION WILL BE PROPOSED TO BE FOR THE
19:39:19 MAIN STORE 7 A.M. TO 10 P.M. MONDAY THROUGH SUNDAY AND
19:39:23 A LIQUOR STORE FROM 10 A.M. TO 10 P.M. MONDAY THROUGH
19:39:24 SUNDAY.
19:39:26 THEY ARE ASKING FOR TWO WAIVERS FROM THE AB
19:39:29 REQUIREMENTS.
19:39:31 ONE IS A DISTANCE SEPARATION FROM OTHER PLACES THAT ARE
19:39:35 WET WHICH I BELIEVE THIS IS THE TARGET STORE FROM 250
19:39:41 -- 250 FEET TO 222 FEET AND RESIDENTIAL USES FROM 250
19:39:43 FEET TO 67 FEET.
19:39:47 AGAIN, THE TARGET STORE IS CLOSEST TO THEM.
19:39:52 AND SELLS ALCOHOL AND 2,-ABS.
19:39:55 AND CONDOMINIUM WHICH IS 67 FIGHTS.
19:39:57 TWO WAIVERS REQUESTED.
19:39:59 THIS IS THE PROPOSED SITE PLAN.
19:40:06 AGAIN, IT IS A GROCERY STORE, SHOPPERS GOOD.
19:40:08 THIS IS THE LIQUOR STORE.
19:40:13 THIS IS THE MEZZANINE AND OUTDOOR SEATING AREA.
19:40:18 THIS IS THE EXISTING SIDES AT THE CORNER OF SOUTH HIMES
19:40:19 AND GANDY.
19:40:20 THIS IS THE TARGET IN QUESTION.
19:40:23 THE BAY VILLA CONDOMINIUMS.
19:40:27 AND THIS PICTURE -- THE PROPERTY UNDER CONSTRUCTION
19:40:28 RIGHT NOW.
19:40:31 AND SOME PHOTOS OF THE SURROUNDING PROPERTIES.
19:40:34 YOU CAN SEE THE CONDOMINIUM TO THE NORTH.
19:40:36 THE TARGET TO THE WEST.
19:40:41 AND ACROSS THE STREET IS STRIP COMMERCIAL OF A WA-WA
19:40:43 AND CHICK-FIL-A.
19:40:48 THE STARBUCKS IS ON THE SAME PROPERTY AS THE PUBLIX.
19:40:50 WE FOUND IT INCONSISTENT BECAUSE OF THE WAIVERS
19:40:54 REQUESTED FROM THE DISTANCE SEPARATION.
19:40:56 THERE ARE SOME MINOR CORRECTIONS TO THE SITE PLAN THAT
19:41:00 NEED TO BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
19:41:03 ALTHOUGH -- HOLD ON ONE SECOND, PLEASE.
19:41:07 I DON'T SEE A REVISION SHEET ATTACHED TO THE STAFF
19:41:11 REPORT.
19:41:13 WITHIN THE STAFF REPORT ITSELF, THERE ARE SOME
19:41:16 REVISIONS REQUESTED.
19:41:17 LIST WAIVERS.
19:41:20 ON THE SECOND PAGE.
19:41:21 DISTANCE SEPARATION.
19:41:24 UPDATE THE AERIAL MAP ON THE SITE PLAN.
19:41:29 UP DATE THE TITLE TO READ ALCOHOL BEVERAGE SALES.
19:41:31 AND PACKAGE SALES OFF.
19:41:35 PACKAGE SALES FOR CONSUMPTION OFF PREMISE AND TO UPDATE
19:41:36 THE ADDRESS.
19:41:37 COUNCIL HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR ME.
19:41:41 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. COTTON?
19:41:42 NO?
19:41:43 ALL RIGHT.
19:41:45 >>ERIC COTTON: THANK YOU.
19:41:46 YES, SIR.
19:41:50 >> GOOD EVENING, DAVID SMITH, 41 EAST JACKSON STREET A
19:41:53 PLANNER WITH STEARNS, WEAVER, MILLER.
19:41:56 ERIC HAS DONE A EXCELLENT JOB.
19:41:58 STAFF ALWAYS DOES DESCRIBING IT.
19:41:59 BUT I WILL GO THROUGH ORIENTATION.
19:42:06 HOPEFULLY THIS WILL SHOW ON THE ELMO FAIRLY CLEARLY.
19:42:09 PERFECT.
19:42:12 AS STAFF HAS INDICATED REQUEST FOR A LARGE VENUE,
19:42:18 BEER, WINE AND LIQUOR, CONSUMPTION ON PREMISE AND
19:42:19 PACKAGE SALES OFF-PREMISE.
19:42:22 KIND OF A LARGE DESCRIPTION THAT SOUNDS LIKE WE ARE
19:42:25 DOING A BIG BAR, BUT THIS IS A SIP AND STROLL CONCEPT
19:42:26 FOR PUBLIX.
19:42:29 BASICALLY WILL HAVE BEER AND WINE.
19:42:32 PEOPLE WILL BE ABLE TO SHOP, WALK AROUND AND ENJOY BEER
19:42:35 AND WINE AND GET THEIR GROCERIES AND GO HOME AND HAVE
19:42:36 PACKAGE SALES.
19:42:39 WHAT I AM SHOWING YOU HERE IS THE EXISTING -- WELL,
19:42:43 WHAT IS THE EXISTING PUBLIX IS DEMOLISHED AND UNDER
19:42:44 REDEVELOPMENT.
19:42:47 IT ORIGINALLY HAD A LIQUOR STORE ON THE WEST SIDE.
19:42:53 AND THE -- THE 2 PS FOR PACKAGE SALES WAS THE MAIN
19:42:53 STORE.
19:43:01 AS INDICATED BY THIS SITE PLAN, THE REASON FOR US TO
19:43:06 COME BACK IN OTHER THAN THE 2 COP ASPECT OF IT IS THAT
19:43:09 A DRIVE-IN WINDOW WAS PLACED ON THE WEST SIDE FOR
19:43:10 PHARMACY.
19:43:14 THAT CAME TO COUNCIL I BELIEVE IN A SPECIAL USE
19:43:15 APPROVAL NOT TOO LONG AGO.
19:43:20 THEY RELOCATED THE PACKAGE STORE TO THE EAST SIDE OF
19:43:22 THE PROPERTY, WHICH IS RIGHT HERE.
19:43:28 AND THIS IS THE REDEVELOPED STORE, THE MEZZANINE AREA
19:43:31 AND THE OUTDOOR SEATING.
19:43:35 THE OUTDOOR SEATING WITH A DELI SANDS WITCH AND GET A
19:43:38 BEER AND SIT IN THE SUNSHINE AND ENJOY THAT.
19:43:42 NOT INTENDED FOR SERVICE PER SE, OR PEOPLE SELLING BEER
19:43:46 IN THAT AREA ALTHOUGH THEY WILL BE CONSUMING IT.
19:43:50 WAIVERS WE HAVE REQUESTED HAVE BEEN ITEMIZED BY STAFF.
19:43:53 BUT THIS JUST GIVES AN ORIENTATION.
19:43:55 HERE IS THE PROPERTY LINE FOR TARGET.
19:44:00 HERE IS THE -- THE STORE LINE FROM THE -- NOT THE NEW
19:44:04 STORE, BUT WHAT WILL BE THE LOCATION THAT REQUIRES
19:44:06 DISTANCE SEPARATION.
19:44:07 AND ALSO IN THE BACK.
19:44:12 IT SHOULD BE NOTED BOTH OF THESE WAIVERS ESSENTIALLY --
19:44:15 THESE STORES HAVE BEEN IN RELATIONSHIP TO EACH OTHER
19:44:17 JUST LIKE THIS FOR 20 YEARS.
19:44:19 THERE ARE ADDITIONAL RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES THAT ARE
19:44:23 FURTHER AWAY ACROSS HIMES.
19:44:25 BUT ESSENTIALLY THE BUILDING IS NOT GETTING ANY CLOSER
19:44:27 TO THEM.
19:44:31 SO BASED UPON STAFF'S REVIEW, THE STANDARDS FOR MIXED
19:44:32 USE CORRIDORS.
19:44:35 WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST GRANTING THE WAIVERS AND
19:44:38 APPROVAL OF THE SPECIAL USE.
19:44:43 AGAIN THE INTENTS IS FOR THE MAIN STORE-BOUGHT ITEMS TO
19:44:47 BE SIP AND STROLL AND SMALL PACKAGE SALES FROM THE
19:44:48 LIQUOR STORE.
19:44:50 I WILL BE GLAD TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
19:44:52 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CITRO.
19:44:54 >>JOSEPH CITRO: HE DEFLECTED TO ME.
19:44:58 I AM GOING TO SEE IF I CAN GRASP THIS.
19:45:04 AND PLEASE -- I MEAN NO OFFENSE TO PUBLIX.
19:45:12 YOU ARE GOING TO HAVE ON SALE -- I MEAN ON-PREMISE.
19:45:13 >> CONSUMPTION.
19:45:17 >> BUT YOU ARE GOING TO HAVE A SEPARATE LIQUOR STORE.
19:45:19 YOU HAVE BEER AND WINE IN THE STORE, BUT YOU WILL HAVE
19:45:23 A SEPARATE HARD LIQUOR STORE.
19:45:24 >> YES, SIR.
19:45:28 >>JOSEPH CITRO: SO TO BE ABLE TO DRINK REGARDLESS --
19:45:31 REGARDLESS OF ALCOHOL CONTENT IN THE STORE, SOMEONE
19:45:35 WOULD HAVE TO FIRST GO TO THE PACKAGE STORE, PUT IT
19:45:38 UNDERNEATH THEIR ARM, GO IN THE STORE AND GET THEIR
19:45:43 TONIC FOR THEIR BEGIN OR GINGER BEER FOR THEIR MOSCOW
19:45:46 MULE TO HAVE A SIP AND STROLL.
19:45:47 >> LET ME --
19:45:49 >>JOSEPH CITRO: JUST LOOKING FOR A YES AND NO.
19:45:52 >> WELL, IT IS NOT A YES OR NO ANSWER BECAUSE THE --
19:45:55 THE LICENSING THAT IS ASSOCIATED WITH IT -- THE
19:45:58 DESCRIPTION IN THE TAMPA CODE FOR THE TYPE OF WET
19:46:02 ZONING YOU ASKED FOR DOES NOT NECESSARILY MATCH UP WITH
19:46:05 THE TYPE OF LICENSING YOU GET FROM THE STATE.
19:46:09 2 COP WOULD BE A BEER AND WINE ON-PREMISE CONSUMPTION
19:46:12 LICENSE WHICH IS WHAT PUBLIX WILL BE SEEKING FOR THE
19:46:13 LARGE VENUE SPACE.
19:46:18 AND THE PACKAGE SALES WILL BE SOLELY THE HARD LIQUOR
19:46:21 WILL BE IN A SEPARATE BUILDING AS REQUIRED BY STATE
19:46:23 LAW, A SEPARATE ENTRANCE IN ORDER TO HAVE PACKAGE
19:46:25 SALES.
19:46:28 NOT THE INTENT OF PUBLIX TO HAVE PEOPLE BUY HARD
19:46:32 LIQUOR, BRING IN THE STORE AND DRINK.
19:46:35 >>JOSEPH CITRO: AGAIN, IF I MAY, MR. CHAIR, NOTHING
19:46:38 AGAINST PUBLIX; HOWEVER, WHAT I JUST SAID MAY HOLD
19:46:39 TRUE.
19:46:43 SOMEBODY WANTS TO DO GROCERY SHOPPING AND DO A BEGIN
19:46:45 AND TONIC, THEY HAVE GOT TO GO TO THE LIQUOR STORE
19:46:49 FIRST AND THEN GO TO THE GROCERY STORE.
19:46:51 >> THEY COULD DO THAT, BUT UNDER THE LICENSE THAT IS
19:46:52 BEING REQUESTED --
19:46:54 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YOU CAN'T DO THAT.
19:46:57 >> 2 COP CONSUMPTION ON-PREMISE.
19:47:00 THEY CAN'T TAKE THEIR PACKAGE AND BRING IT IN.
19:47:04 SALE AND CONSUMPTION -- IT IS NOT A BOTTLE CLUB.
19:47:07 >>JOSEPH CITRO: I AM JUST -- I AM JUST READING WHAT I
19:47:08 AM -- WHAT I AM SEEING.
19:47:10 >>ERIC COTTON: IF I MAY, COUNCIL.
19:47:12 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. COTTON.
19:47:15 >>ERIC COTTON: YES, MR. CITRO, SO THROUGH THE ALCOHOL
19:47:19 LICENSING BY THE STATE, THEY WILL NOT BE ABLE TO SELL
19:47:22 PACKAGE AT THE LIQUOR STORE PORTION.
19:47:26 YOU CAN'T -- YOU CANNOT OPEN AND CONSUME WITHIN -- I
19:47:29 BELIEVE IT IS 500 FIGHTS BY CITY REGULATIONS.
19:47:34 THE BACK CADGE STORE -- THE PORTION OF THE LIQUOR STORE
19:47:36 IS SELLING PACKAGE-ONLY.
19:47:41 INSIDE OF THE GROCERY WHERE THE 3 A PS -- WHERE THE 3
19:47:43 APS.
19:47:46 IN THE GROCERY STORE WITH THE BEER AND WINE
19:47:49 CONSUMPTION, LIMITED TO BEER AND WINE.
19:47:53 THEY CAN NOT LEGALLY GO IN THE PACKAGE, BUY A BOTTLE OF
19:47:56 GIN AND TONIC AND BEGIN MIXING.
19:48:00 THAT IS AGAINST THE REGULATIONS.
19:48:02 >>JOSEPH CITRO: THE DEFINITIVE WORD IS LEGALLY.
19:48:06 OKAY, LET ME GO ABOUT IT FROM THIS ANGLE.
19:48:09 YOU WILL HAVE CONSUMPTION ON PREMISE IN A
19:48:18 61-PLUS-THOUSAND-SQUARE-FOOT BUILDING.
19:48:22 >>, LIKE GREEN WISE GROCERS.
19:48:24 LIKE TRADESER JOE'S.
19:48:25 WHOLE FOODS.
19:48:27 THOSE LOCATIONS HAVE SIP AND STROLL.
19:48:29 WE WILL CALL IT SIP AND STROLL.
19:48:31 >>JOSEPH CITRO: IN THE CITY OF TAMPA.
19:48:32 >> IN THE CITY OF TAMPA.
19:48:33 LARGE VENUE.
19:48:38 JUST A GREEN WISE APPROVED DOWNTOWN IN WATER STREET
19:48:41 THAT IS GREEN WISE, SIMILAR SIZE THAT HAS SIP AND
19:48:45 STROLL.
19:48:48 >>JOSEPH CITRO: I NEVER HEARD OF THAT.
19:48:52 I AM SORRY, THIS WHOLE CONCEPT IS JUST AMAZING TO ME.
19:48:55 EVEN IN MY STRONGEST DAYS OF DRINKING, I COULD NEVER
19:48:56 CONCEIVE THIS.
19:48:59 I WOULD HAVE NEVER LEFT THE STORE.
19:49:01 >> DOESN'T HAPPEN A LOT.
19:49:06 THIS IS A NEW -- THIS IS A NEW -- LUCKY'S WHO WAS ALL
19:49:09 OVER FLORIDA UNTIL THEY WENT BANKRUPT, BUT THEY HAD
19:49:10 THAT CONCEPT.
19:49:13 WHOLE FOODS HAVE BEEN DOING IT ACROSS THE STATE.
19:49:16 GREEN WISE GROCERS ARE DOING THIS.
19:49:19 THE ONLY DIFFERENCE HERE, THIS IS NOT A GREEN WISE
19:49:24 GROCER, A STANDARD PUBLIX FOR THE REQUEST OF SIP AND
19:49:24 STROLL.
19:49:28 NOT INTENDED TO BE A BAR, BUT INTENDSED TO ALLOW CLIENT
19:49:35 TO HAVE CRAFT BEERS FROM THE VENUE TO WALK AROUND AND
19:49:37 GO ON-PREMISE.
19:49:40 >>JOSEPH CITRO: THE CRAFT BEER IS BEING BREWED ON
19:49:43 PREMISE.
19:49:46 >> CRAFT BEER BREWED IN THE CAN.
19:49:48 THEY DON'T BREW THEIR OWN BEER.
19:49:50 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN GUDES.
19:49:53 >>ORLANDO GUDES: HE BROUGHT IT UP.
19:49:56 PUBLIX THE GROCERY STORE WILL HAVE AN AREA INSIDE THE
19:49:59 STORE WHERE PEOPLE CAN EATS AND DRINK?
19:50:02 >> BASICALLY THEY HAVE -- NOW THEY HAVE A DELI.
19:50:05 ALL -- PUBLIX HAS A DELI AREA.
19:50:09 MANY OF THEM HAVE A SEATING AREA WHERE PEOPLE EAT THEIR
19:50:10 DELI SANDWICHES.
19:50:14 THIS WILL ALLOW THE PEOPLE TO BUY A BEER OR GET A CLASS
19:50:20 OF WINE FROM THE POURS AREA AND CONSUME THAT WHILE THEY
19:50:25 ARE EITHER HAVING THEIR SANDWICH OR WALKING AROUND THE
19:50:30 STORE IN THE GROCERY STORE.
19:50:32 >>ORLANDO GUDES: I UNDERSTAND -- I UNDERSTAND NEW
19:50:33 CONCEPT.
19:50:38 I HAVE CONCERNS OF -- OF BEING ABLE TO DRINK -- YOU
19:50:39 KNOW.
19:50:42 I JUST -- IT IS A NEW CONCEPT, BUT KIND OF -- I AM
19:50:46 LOOKING AT KIDS AND FAMILIES AND -- AND PEOPLE INSIDE
19:50:49 OF A PUBLIX.
19:50:55 YOU KNOW, I -- IT IS NEW, I GUESS.
19:50:57 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
19:50:59 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I UNDERSTAND THAT THINGS CHANGE, I
19:51:00 REALLY DO.
19:51:02 AND I CAN JUST SEE IT NOW.
19:51:08 UNMANNED FOOD CART HAS AN ACCIDENT WHILE DRINKING.
19:51:09 I MEAN, THAT IS POSSIBLE.
19:51:12 NOTHING IMPOSSIBLE WHEN YOU START SOMETHING.
19:51:13 >> YES, SIR.
19:51:16 >>JOSEPH CITRO: THEY ARE TAKING A BIG RISK, IN MY
19:51:16 OPINION.
19:51:19 BUT IT IS THEIR RISK, NOT MINE.
19:51:19 >> YES, SIR.
19:51:22 THEY ARE DOING THIS CONCEPT ELSEWHERE.
19:51:25 THIS IS NOT THE FIRST ONE IN THE STATE.
19:51:28 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: JUST -- PEOPLE -- I DON'T -- I
19:51:29 MEAN, I VOTE FOR ALCOHOL.
19:51:31 I DON'T DRINK.
19:51:33 BUT IT IS JUST -- I NEVER DRANK.
19:51:35 DOESN'T MEAN I AM GOOD OR BAD.
19:51:39 BUT IT JUST --
19:51:42 >> I UNDERSTAND, SIR.
19:51:43 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CITRO.
19:51:46 >>JOSEPH CITRO: I CAN'T PREDICTS THE FUTURE AND I AM
19:51:47 KNOLL NOT GOING TO.
19:51:52 THIS IS FOR CONSUMER GOODS SALES ALONG WITH ALCOHOL
19:51:53 CONSUMPTION, FOR THE MOST PART.
19:51:55 >> ON-SITE.
19:51:59 BASICALLY SELLING ALCOHOL TODAY, PACKAGE SALES AND --
19:52:01 THIS ALLOWS THEM --
19:52:03 >>JOSEPH CITRO: THE ALCOHOL SALES REALLY STARTS
19:52:06 TICKING UP, THEN ALL YOU WILL SEE IN THE STORE IS
19:52:08 BRILLO PAD, CLEANER AND MAYBE BAG OF CHIPS.
19:52:11 AND THE REST WILL BE AISLES OF ALCOHOL.
19:52:14 I AM JUST -- I JUST -- I AM JUST ENVISIONING SOMETHING
19:52:17 CHANGING OVER THE COURSE OF TIME.
19:52:18 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THE LIABILITY IS THEIRS.
19:52:22 IT IS REALLY, REALLY BIG AND A BIG BRAND NAME.
19:52:24 >>JOSEPH CITRO: I WILL NEVER SAY ANYTHING AGAINST
19:52:24 PUBLIX.
19:52:27 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THE LIABILITY IS THEIRS.
19:52:28 THIS IS WHAT THEY WANT.
19:52:29 BE CAREFUL WHAT YOU ASK FOR.
19:52:31 REMEMBER THAT SAYING.
19:52:32 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
19:52:35 DO WE HAVE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK?
19:52:37 NOBODY IS HERE.
19:52:40 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: LADY IN THE THIRD ROW.
19:52:42 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE GHOST IN THE THIRD ROW.
19:52:49 WE HAVE STEPHANIE POYNOR REGISTERED ONLINE.
19:52:51 MISS POYNOR.
19:52:51 >> GOOD EVENING.
19:52:54 THIS IS NOT BRAND-NEW IDEA.
19:52:58 MY NAME IS STEPHANIE POYNOR.
19:53:00 THERE ARE GROCERY STORES ALL OVER THE STATE OF FLORIDA
19:53:02 WHO HAVE THIS CONCEPT.
19:53:05 THIS IS NOT SOMETHING BRAND-NEW.
19:53:08 PLEASE FOR THE LORD -- PLEASE HELP US OUT IN SOUTH
19:53:09 TAMPA.
19:53:09 WE HAVE NOTHING.
19:53:14 AT LEAST THIS IS THE ABILITY TO HAVE A COCKTAIL.
19:53:17 MY HUSBAND MIGHT ACTUALLY GO TO THE GROCERY STORE WITH
19:53:19 ME BECAUSE HE CAN BELLY UP TO THE BAR WHILE I AM
19:53:20 SHOPPING.
19:53:21 HE PROBABLY WON'T.
19:53:23 AT LEAST IT SOUNDS GOOD ON PAPER.
19:53:28 I MEAN, I AM JUST KINDS OF FLABBERGASTED OF ALL THE
19:53:31 CONVERSATION AROUND THIS BECAUSE SHOWS ME HOW LITTLE
19:53:33 YOU PEOPLE GO TO THE GROCERY STORE.
19:53:37 SHAME, SHAME, SHAME.
19:53:41 >>JOSEPH CITRO: MISS POYNOR, I HAVE BEEN TO THE
19:53:43 GROCERY STORE EVERY DAY.
19:53:45 >> GROCERY STORE, JOE.
19:53:47 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: BY TO THE GROCERY STORE.
19:53:50 >>JOSEPH CITRO: I GO TO THE GROCERY STORE EVERY DAY,
19:53:54 MISS POYNOR.
19:53:55 >> YOU HAVE A GOOD NIGHT.
19:53:57 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE.
19:53:59 I SEE AT WHOLE FOODS THEY DO IT.
19:54:02 THEY DO IT AT THE GREEN WISE DOWN HERE.
19:54:05 YOU KNOW, IT'S -- IT IS HOW IT IS.
19:54:08 AS COUNCILMAN MIRANDA SAID THE LIABILITY IS THEIRS.
19:54:10 IT IS ON THEIR PROPERTY.
19:54:14 AND, YOU KNOW, SO, IT IS WHAT IT IS.
19:54:16 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: MOVE TO CLOSE.
19:54:18 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA,
19:54:22 SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN GUDES.
19:54:25 >>JOSEPH CITRO: YOU MAY NOT LIKE WHAT I HAVE TO SAY.
19:54:28 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN GUDES, READ ITEM NUMBER
19:54:29 12.
19:54:33 >>ORLANDO GUDES: AB 2-22-06.
19:54:36 ORDINANCE PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING AND CONSIDERATION
19:54:42 ORDINANCE PROVIDING A SPECIAL USE PERMIT S-2IC BEVERAGE
19:54:46 SALES LARGE VENUE CONSUMPTION ON-PREMISE AND PACKAGE
19:54:51 SAILS OFF-PREMISE CONSUMPTION AND MAKING LAWFUL THE
19:54:54 SALE OF BEVERAGES OF BEER, WINE AND LIQUOR ON THAT
19:55:01 CERTAIN PLOTS OR TRACT OF LAND 3615/3617 WEST GANDY
19:55:05 BOULEVARD AND PROVIDING ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT ARE
19:55:10 REPEALED, REPEALING ORDINANCE 9429-A AND RESCINDING
19:55:17 SPECIAL USE 1, S-1 V 11-401 PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
19:55:18 DATE.
19:55:20 >>MARTIN SHELBY: REVISIONS THAT ARE IN THE SITE PLAN?
19:55:21 OR AM I CORRECT.
19:55:23 >>ERIC COTTON: ERIC COTTON.
19:55:27 THEY WERE ACTUALLY LISTED IN THE STAFF REPORT ON A
19:55:31 SEPARATE REVISION SHEET THAT I READ INTO THE RECORD.
19:55:33 >> WE AGREE WITH THE REVISIONS REQUIRED.
19:55:35 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN GUDES.
19:55:36 SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
19:55:37 ROLL CALL.
19:55:38 >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
19:55:40 >>JOSEPH CITRO: NO.
19:55:43 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
19:55:45 >>ORLANDO GUDES: YES.
19:55:46 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
19:55:50 >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED WITH CITRO VOTING NO.
19:55:53 HURTAK AND CARLSON ABSENT.
19:55:58 SECOND READING AND ADOPTION MAY 19, 2022 AT 9:30 A.M.
19:55:59 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
19:56:02 THAT CONCLUDES THE AGENDA AND GO TO NEW BUSINESS.
19:56:05 COUNCILMAN GUDES, ANYTHING?
19:56:08 GUDES THIS MORNING I MADE A MOTION IN REFERENCE TO HUD.
19:56:11 I HAD A CONVERSATION WITH MR. SHELBY AND ECONOMIC
19:56:14 ADVISORY ADMINISTRATOR AND LEGAL FOR HOUSING.
19:56:18 AND WE NEED TO MAKE SOME REVISIONS TO THAT.
19:56:21 A MOTION TO AMEND MY PREVIOUS MOTION MADE AT THE
19:56:24 WORKSHOP TODAY REGARDING THE LEADER TO HUD.
19:56:26 FOR THE CHAIR TO SEND A LETTER OF THE STATE DEPARTMENT
19:56:30 OF BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL REGULATIONS TO INTERCEDE
19:56:33 IN THE DEPARTMENTS REGARDING THE PROPERTY OWNER TO
19:56:38 EXPEDITE REMEDIATION AND TAKING ENFORCEABLE AGAINST A
19:56:42 NONTRANSIT APARTMENT LICENSE IF IT FAILS TO ADDRESS THE
19:56:46 DELAWARE MOREABLE LIVING CONDITIONS.
19:56:47 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
19:56:49 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A DATE OR ANYTHING?
19:56:51 [INAUDIBLE]
19:56:52 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: OKAY.
19:56:54 WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN GUDES.
19:56:55 SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
19:56:57 ALL IN FAVOR.
19:56:59 ANYTHING ELSE, SIR?
19:57:01 >>ORLANDO GUDES: LEGAL WILL DRAFT THAT.
19:57:04 >>JOSEPH CITRO: NOTHING FOR ME TONIGHT.
19:57:06 >>LUIS VIERA: JUST REALLY QUICK IF I MAY.
19:57:09 MEMORIAL DAY AT THE END OF MAY AND WE ALWAYS INVITE
19:57:12 SOME GOLD STAR FAMILIES TO COME AND BRIEFLY SPEAK.
19:57:15 I WOULD ASK THAT BE SET FIRST ON THE AGENDA ON -- I
19:57:17 THINK IT IS MAY 26, IF I MAY.
19:57:18 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SO MOVED.
19:57:20 A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
19:57:24 THIS IS -- A WORKSHOP DAY.
19:57:25 >>LUIS VIERA: IF THAT IS OKAY.
19:57:27 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NROTION COUNCILMAN VIERA.
19:57:31 SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
19:57:33 OPPOSED?
19:57:34 ANYTHING ELSE.
19:57:36 COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
19:57:38 COUNCILMAN VIERA, I HAVE JUST ONE ITEM.
19:57:41 I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO PRESENT A COMMENDATION
19:57:46 TO THE INTERNATIONAL PEACE RUN TEAM ON MAY 4 AT A
19:57:47 LOCATION TO BE DETERMINED.
19:57:49 >>JOSEPH CITRO: SECOND.
19:57:52 >>LUIS VIERA: A MOTION BY CHAIR MANISCALCO AND SECOND
19:57:53 BY CITRO.
19:57:55 ALL IN FAVOR.
19:57:56 ANY OPPOSED.
19:57:56 ANYTHING ELSE.
19:57:57 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THAT'S IT.
19:57:59 MR. SHELBY?
19:58:01 >>MARTIN SHELBY: YES, MR. CHAIRMAN.
19:58:06 LAST WEEK, COUNCIL VOTED TO PUT COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK ON
19:58:10 THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
19:58:14 AND THE MOTION WAS TO COME BACK NEXT WEEK, WHICH I
19:58:18 MISTAKINGLY SAID NEXT WEEK INSTEAD OF MAY 5.
19:58:23 SO IT APPEARS ON THE AGENDA FOR A VOTE TO A RESOLUTION
19:58:27 RATIFYING THE APPOINTMENT OF CITY OF TAMPA
19:58:33 COUNCILMEMBER LYNN HURTAK TO FILL A VACANCY FOR THE
19:58:37 REMAINDER OF A THREE-YEAR TERM ENDING SEPTEMBER 17,
19:58:39 2023 PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
19:58:43 I WILL GIVE THE COPY OF THE FIRST PAGE TO THE CLERK.
19:58:46 >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I WILL -- NOT TRYING TO CORRECT
19:58:46 ANYONE.
19:58:49 BUT A THREE-YEAR TERM.
19:58:53 >>MARTIN SHELBY: THREE-YEAR TERM?
19:58:55 REMAINDER OF A THREE-YEAR TERM.
19:58:55 THANK YOU.
19:58:57 >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION BY COUNCILMAN CITRO.
19:58:59 SECOND BY COUNCILMAN GUDES.
19:59:00 ALL IN FAVOR.
19:59:01 OPPOSE PREPONDERANCE OF THE EVIDENCE A MOTION TO
19:59:02 RECEIVE AND FILE.
19:59:05 MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA AND SECOND BY COUNCILMAN
19:59:06 CITRO.
19:59:09 WE ARE ADJOURNED.
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.