Tampa city Council
Thursday, December 1, 2022
9:00 a.m. Session
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.
09:04:05AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
DECEMBER 1, 2022.
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO, YOU WILL DO THE INTRODUCTION FOR THE
INVOCATION.
09:05:16AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR. CHAIRMAN.
MY PLEASURE TODAY TO INVITE AND WELCOME PASTOR CHRISTOPHER
HARRIS, A NATIVE OF POLATKA, FLORIDA AND PREVIOUSLY IN
EDUCATION ADMINISTRATION.
KNOWN AS A WISDOM TEACHER, SAVVY ADVOCATE AND ADMINISTRATOR.
LEADER WITH THE SHEPHERD'S HEART THAT LEADS ORGANIZATIONS TO
HEALTH AND SUSTAINABILITY.
ENERGETIC CREATIVE SPEAKER, AUTHOR, PODCASTER AND CONTENT
CREATOR.
LEADING PEOPLE, INSPIRING FAMILIES AND LEADING ORGANIZATIONS
WITH MULTIMILLION DOLLAR BUDGETS.
AND MANAGES COMMUNITY, LASTING CHANGE AND TRANSFORMATION.
HE CURRENTLY SERVES AS CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER OF CROSSOVER
CHURCH OF TAMPA, FLORIDA.
HE RESIDES IN TAMPA, FLORIDA, WITH HIS WIFE OF OVER 20 YEARS
AND FOUR CHILDREN.
DIRECTOR OF ADMINISTRATION AND VISION FOR FULL GOSPEL
BAPTIST CHURCH FELLOWSHIP INTERNATIONAL AND AS FOUNDER.
THE PODCAST TO 29 NATIONS IN THE WORLD AND AUTHOR AND
CO-AUTHOR OF THREE BOOKS.
ALSO INVOLVING HIM BEING THE FOUNDER AND CHIEF CONTENT
CREATOR FOR INSPIRED GROUP LCC, THE TIMOTHY PROJECT AND THE
HEALTHY URBAN CHURCH INITIATIVE.
AN ALUM OF FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY WITH A MASTER'S DEGREE
AT THE UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH FLORIDA.
SEMINARY TRAINING AT PRINCETON THEOLOGICAL.
AND SERVING AT DUKE DIVINITY SCHOOL AND DOCTORATE AT NOVA
SOUTHEASTERN UNIVERSITIES.
HIS COMMUNITY WORK WITH 400 HONORS, AWARDS AND COMMENDATIONS
INCLUDING BEING RECOGNIZED BY THE CITY OF TAMPA AND A BOARD
MEMBER OF CLOTHES TO KIDS, URBAN LEAGUE OF HILLSBOROUGH AND
MEMBER OF LEADERSHIP TAMPA.
IT IS MY PLEASURE TO WELCOME THIS GENTLEMAN HERE WHOSE LIFE
MISSION IS TO INSPIRE PEOPLE TO LIVE WISE LIVES.
WE PLEASE STAND AND PASTOR, TAKE IT AWAY.
09:07:25AM >> THANK YOU, CITY COUNCIL.
THIS IS MAYBE MY TENTH TIME, AND I APPRECIATE THE HONOR AND
OPPORTUNITY.
LET'S PRAY.
GOD OF PEACE, GIVER OF HOPE, SUSTAINER OF LIFE, SOURCE OF
HEALTH AND HEALING, WELL SPRING OF WISDOM AND AUTHOR AND
FINISHER OF OUR FAITH WE PAUSE IN THIS MOMENT TO ACKNOWLEDGE
OUR NEED FOR YOU.
WE DESPERATELY CLAIM OUR DEPENDENCE ON YOUR HEALTH TO LIVE
WELL, LOVE WELL AND LEGISLATURE AS WELL.
RELIANCE OF RIGHTEOUSNESS OF RIGHT AND WRONG AND NOT OUR
EGOS, POLITICAL PREFERENCES OR DISTORTED PERCEPTIONS.
WE THANK YOU, DEAR GOD FOR THE PEACE AND AUTHORITY WE ENJOY
TODAY IN THE PEACE NOT ONLY IN OUR CITY BUT OUR NATION.
WE OFTEN TAKE FOR GRANTED.
HOLY SPIRIT FILL OUR CITY LEADERS WITH UNDERSTANDING,
DISCERNMENT AND KNOWLEDGE.
GRANT THEM FAVOR, INCREASE THEIR FAITH, PREPARE THEM TO
PURSUE YOUR WILL FOR THE CITY.
CAUSE THEM TO KNOW AND FULFILL PURPOSES FOR THEIR LIVES
INDIVIDUALLY AND FOR OUR LIVES COLLECTIVELY.
FATHER, I ASK THAT YOU WILL PLACE PEOPLE IN THEIR PATHS THAT
WILL PROVIDE SOUND, GODLY ADVICE AND COUNSEL.
FOR WITHOUT YOUR COUNSEL, OUR PLANS WILL ALL GO AWRY.
DEAL WITH OUR LEADERS OF KEEPING THEIR HEARTS AND MOTIVES
PURE.
WE ASK THAT YOU WILL MAKE THEIR HEARTS PLIABLE AND WILLING
AND OBEDIENT TO YOUR WILL AND TO YOUR WAY AND CAUSE THEM
TO GLORIFY YOUR NAME.
GREAT GOD, PLEASE FORGIVE ALL OF US FOR OUR SINS OR
MISGIVINGS.
FORGIVE THOSE WHO DO NOT CONSULT YOU DAILY.
FORGIVE OUR LEADERS THAT OPERATE FROM GREED, HYPOCRISY,
PRIDE, ARROGANCE, SLANDER, ELITISM, IMPARTIALITY,
MANIPULATION, UNGODLINESS OR ANY ACTS OF SINFULNESS.
WE ASK THAT YOU RECEIVE OUR FORGIVENESS AND NOT PRAYING FOR
OUR LEADERS CONSISTENTLY AND OF THE THINGS THAT WE DO FOR
SELFISH MOVEMENTS AND NETWORK.
I ASK THAT WE ALWAYS PRIORITIZE PEOPLE OVER OUR POLITICS AND
OVER OUR REFERENCES.
GOD, YOU ARE THE GIVER OF LIFE AND HEALTH AND WE PRAY
COMFORT OF THOSE CHALLENGED WITH SERIOUS OR CHRONIC
ILLNESSES, MENTAL OR EMOTIONAL, AND I GIVE THE POWER OF YOUR
HEALING TO THOSE WHO MINISTER IN THEIR NEEDS AND STRENGTHEN
IN THEIR WEAKNESS AND HAVE CONFIDENCE IN THEIR LOVING CARE.
YOUR WISDOM PRODUCE IN THEM CREATIVE IDEAS, SOLUTIONS TO
PROBLEMS, NEW TECHNOLOGY AND NEW PRODUCTS.
GIVE US SOUND JUDGMENT TO MAKE GOOD DECISIONS AND GIVE US
GREATER KNOWLEDGE, UNDERSTANDING AND POWER TO LIVE
SKILLFULLY AND GIVE BACK IN THIS COMMUNITY.
BY NAME I CALL OUT EACH ONE OF OUR IF IT JOSEPH CITRO, ORLANDO
GUDES, CHARLIE MIRANDA, LYNN HURTAK, BILL CARLSON, GUIDO MANISCALCO
AND LUIS VIERA.
I PRAY THAT YOU BLESS THEM AND KEEP THEM AND SHINE YOUR FACE
ON THEM AND GRACIOUS TO THEM.
TURN YOUR FACE TOWARD THEM AND GIVE THEM PEACE.
IN JESUS'S NAME, AMEN.
[PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE]
09:10:59AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU, PLEASE BE SEATED.
ROLL CALL.
09:11:02AM >>BILL CARLSON:
HERE.
09:11:06AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
HERE.
09:11:07AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
HERE.
09:11:09AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
HERE.
09:11:10AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
HERE.
09:11:11AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
HERE.
09:11:12AM >>CLERK:
YOU HAVE OF A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
09:11:15AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
MR. SHELBY.
09:11:17AM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
YES, THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN, MEMBERS OF
CITY COUNCIL AND MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC.
MARTIN SHELBY, CITY ATTORNEY.
I WILL BE BRIEF.
BROADCAST ON SPECTRUM 640, FRONTIER CHANNEL 15 AND ON THE
INTERNET LIVESTREAMED TAMPA.GOV/LIVESTREAM.
YOU CAN APPEAR IN CHAMBERS OR VIRTUALLY AND REQUIRES
PREREGISTRATION AND THE PORTAL OF THAT AND ALL THE
INFORMATION IS AVAILABLE IN THE CITY COUNCIL NOTICE OF THIS
HEARING AND ON THE CITY COUNCIL'S WEB PAGE,
TAMPA.GOV/CITYCOUNCIL.
I ASK THAT THE RULES TO BE WAIVED TO ALLOW THE CONTINUED USE
OF CMT.
09:11:59AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
SO MOVED.
09:12:01AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
SECOND.
09:12:02AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ALL IN FAVOR.
THANK YOU.
LET'S DO OUR AGENDA REVIEW PLEASE, AND I BELIEVE OUR CHIEF OF
STAFF IS NOT GOING TO BE GIVING ANY TYPE OF UPDATE TODAY.
IN THAT PLACE, MISS TRAVIS.
CONSENT AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 41 IS BEING ASKED TO BE PULLED
AND PLACED YOU CAN UNDER STAFF REPORTS.
09:12:35AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
YES.
09:12:37AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THAT WILL BE THE FIRST ITEM THAT WE HEAR
UNDER STAFF REPORTS.
09:12:41AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
YES.
09:12:43AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THEN YOU HAVE A WALK-ON.
09:12:46AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
THAT'S CORRECT, SIR.
09:12:49AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THEN AGENDA NUMBER 2, WE ARE GOING TO KEEP
ON.
NUMBER 3.
09:13:02AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
YES, SIR -- MR. CHAIRMAN, CAN I BE
RECOGNIZED.
09:13:05AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
YES, SIR.
09:13:06AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I WOULD LIKE MR. BAIRD TO SPEAK OF
THIS.
I WAS SURPRISED AND WOULD LIKE THE PUBLIC TO KNOW IT.
09:13:16AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 4.
09:13:19AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YES, I ACTUALLY SPOKE WITH CHIEF O'CONNOR
THIS MORNING AND DUE TO SOME ADDITIONAL INFORMATION, SHE IS
ASKING FOR A CONTINUANCE SO WE HAVE MORE TIME TO FIGURE OUT
WHAT'S GOING ON.
SO SHE DID NOT SEND ME A DATE YET, SO I AM GOING TO
TENTATIVELY SAY JANUARY 5.
09:13:38AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
OKAY, JANUARY 5.
09:13:42AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
IF IT NEEDS TO BE UPDATED I WILL DO SO AT
ANOTHER TIME.
09:13:47AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
SECOND.
09:13:48AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ALL IN FAVOR.
MR.CARLSON, YOU ARE RECOGNIZED.
09:13:55AM >>BILL CARLSON:
I ENCOURAGE EVERYBODY TO READ JUSTIN
GARCIA'S ARGUMENT IN "CREATIVE LOAFING" AND THE FOLLOW-UP.
WE HAVE SEEN A LOT OF INFORMATION COMING OUT THAT MAY BE
TECHNICALLY ACCURATE AND MAY NOT BE ACCURATE AND MAY BE
MISLEADING.
I WOULD ENCOURAGE IN THE REPORT COMING BACK THAT WE BE
TRANSPARENT AND ACCURATE IN THE INFORMATION THAT IS GIVEN,
THANK YOU.
09:14:17AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU, AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 5.
KEEP THAT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 6, I HAVE SPOKEN WITH VIK BHIDE, HEAD OF
THE MOBILITY DEPARTMENT, AND I HAVE HAD MY QUESTIONS
ANSWERED.
DOES ANY OTHER MEMBER -- BOARD MEMBER -- EXCUSE ME,
COUNCILMEMBER WANT TO --
09:14:41AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
I WILL JUST MAKE A COMMENT, MR. CHAIRMAN,
THESE ARE THINGS THAT HAPPEN WITH THE PAST COUNCIL AND
FUTURE COUNCILS.
AND HAVE A SITUATION WHEN YOU PASS A ZONING AND YOU HAVE TO
HAVE THOSE, I GUESS.
WHAT HAPPENS IS IN GOOD FAITH, INDIVIDUAL WHO HAS THAT
DOESN'T DO ANYTHING.
HE COMPLIES, BUT SELLS IT TO SOMEONE ELSE, BUT NO TRACING
MECHANISM AS TO HOW THAT GOES BACK TO THAT INDIVIDUAL WHO
BOUGHT IT.
UNDERSTAND THAT IS WHAT WE HAVE TO FIX.
09:15:08AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
YES, SIR.
AND I PROBABLY WILL MAKE A MOTION LATER ON TODAY THAT WE
HAVE THIS ON A WORKSHOP WHERE WE CAN ACTUALLY ASK MOBILITY
AND LEGAL TO COME IN AND LET'S SEE WHAT CAN BE DONE IF THE
CITY CAN TAKE A ROLE IN.
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
09:15:29AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
THERE WAS NO ACTUAL WRITTEN INFORMATION OF
THIS AND I WOULD SAY, YES, I DEFINITELY WANT THEM.
BUT IF YOU ARE GOING TO PROPOSE THIS FOR A WORKSHOP ITEM, I
THINK THAT IS A MUCH BETTER TIME SO WE DON'T SPEND TIME
TODAY ON IT.
SO, YES --
09:15:44AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WE WILL MOVE AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 6.
09:15:49AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
WE CAN SET IT FOR A WORKSHOP NOW.
09:15:51AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WHEN IS THE WORKSHOP AFTER THE FIRST OF THE
YEAR.
LET'S GIVE 60 DAYS FOR THIS.
09:15:57AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
THAT WILL BE FEBRUARY.
09:15:59AM >>CLERK:
FEBRUARY --
09:16:05AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
FEBRUARY 23.
HOW FULL ARE WE WITH WORKSHOPS THAT DAY?
09:16:10AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
FIVE, SIX, SEVEN ITEMS.
09:16:12AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MARCH 23.
09:16:16AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
MOTION FOR MARCH 23.
09:16:19AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
A MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
ALL IN FAVOR.
THANK YOU.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 7.
09:16:27AM >>BILL CARLSON:
I WOULD LIKE TO -- I SENT A MEMO ON THIS.
I WOULD LIKE TO CONTINUE THIS UNTIL JANUARY 19.
TWO REASONS.
ONE, IT DOESN'T MENTION THE WORD "PURE" AND PEOPLE WERE
SURPRISED ABOUT IT.
09:16:40AM >> SECOND.
09:16:42AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MOTION MADE BY COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION?
09:16:49AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YES.
I KNOW WE HAVE ACTUAL COMMUNITY MEMBERS HERE TO TALK ABOUT
THIS TODAY.
SO I -- THE OTHER ISSUE WITH THIS IS I READ THE MEMO, AND IT
-- THIS DOES NOT SAY "PURE" BUT WE HAD AGREED TO STOP
CALLING THIS "PURE."
SO I DON'T DISAGREE WE NEED TO HAVE SOME TYPE OF WORDING SO
THE PUBLIC KNOWS.
DO YOU WANT TO KEEP THE "PURE" LABEL OR PREFER TO DO A
DIFFERENT LABEL.
09:17:22AM >>BILL CARLSON:
SORRY, I DON'T -- MR. CHAIR.
09:17:25AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
09:17:26AM >>BILL CARLSON:
I DON'T REMEMBER CHANGING THE LABEL ON IT.
BUT THIS ONE IS -- THIS IS THE CITY'S EXCUSE FOR DOING
"PURE."
SO I THINK THE PUBLIC KNOWS THE CITY IN YEARS PAST LOBBIED
TO GET THIS PASSED.
SO I THINK WE -- JUST FOR TRANSPARENCY REASON, I THINK WE
SHOULD CALL IT "PURE" BECAUSE IT IS RELATED TO "PURE" AND I
WOULD LIKE TO HEAR FROM THE PUBLIC TODAY AND WE HAVE PEOPLE
WHO LAST NIGHT CONTACTED ME WHO SAID WE WOULD LIKE TO TALK
ABOUT IT, BUT NOW WE HAVE ALREADY SCHEDULED OTHER THINGS.
IF WE KNEW IT WAS "PURE" WE WOULD FLAG IT AND TALK ABOUT IT.
WE CAN HEAR IT NOW AND ON JANUARY 19.
09:18:02AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I AM FINE WITH THAT.
IF YOU ARE ASKING FOR ANYTHING FROM THE "PURE" TAG I AM FINE
WITH THAT.
09:18:12AM >>BILL CARLSON:
NOT ALL WATER, BUT THINGS RELATED TO CURE.
MR. CHAIR.
09:18:17AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
PLEASE, MR. CARSON AND THEN I WILL HAVE A
COMMENT TO MAKE AFTER YOU ARE FINISHED.
09:18:23AM >>BILL CARLSON:
WE WILL ENTER INTO DEEPER DISCUSSIONS OF
PURE SOME TIME SOON, AND I ENCOURAGE MY COLLEAGUES TO LOOK AT
ALL THE LEGAL AND LOBBYING AVENUES WE CAN TO STOP IT.
I TALKED TO PEOPLE AROUND THE STATE AND NO REASON WHY TAMPA
SHOULD BE DOING IT, BUT IT SEEMS TO BE MOVING FORWARD IN A
VERY SUSPICIOUS WAY.
THANK YOU.
09:18:41AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MISS DUNCAN.
09:18:43AM >>JEAN DUNCAN:
YES, WE ARE PERFECTLY INTERESTED IN
ACCOMMODATING THE COUNCIL'S INTEREST AND REQUEST.
I WOULD JUST SAY ON THE LABELING OF "PURE."
IT WAS MADE VERY CLEAR BY THE COMMUNITY AND SOME OF THE
COUNCIL ANYWAY, THAT "PURE" AS IT WAS PRESENTED PREVIOUSLY
IN TERMS OF A CONTRACT WITH CERTAIN FRAMEWORK AND PARAMETERS
AND TIME FRAME WAS NO LONGER GOING TO BE ACTIVE IN THAT
STATE.
WHICH IS ACTIVE IN THAT STATE IS THE REMAINDER OF THE
CONTRACT DOLLARS TO ADDRESS THE MOTION MADE BY THIS BODY.
NO FORMER PURE PROJECT.
NO FORMER PURE PROJECT IN THAT SAME FRAMEWORK AND IN THAT
SAME CONDITION; HOWEVER, WE ARE STILL AS RESPONSIBLE EXPERTS
IN THE FIELD GOING TO PURSUE AND RESEARCH AND STUDY AND
COORDINATE WITH OTHER AGENCIES AND ALL THOSE OTHER DUE
DILIGENCE ACTIONS OF MAKING SURE WE HAVE A SAFE, RELIABLE
WATER SUPPLY, ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS FOR OUR WATER
RESOURCE AND ALL THOSE RELATED ASPECTS.
SO WITH THAT, WE WOULD SUGGEST THAT PURE ALREADY HAS A
CERTAIN CONNOTATION AND A CERTAIN SENSE OF UNDERSTANDING
WITH THE VERY LITTLE PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT WE WERE ABLE TO DO
AND WE WOULD RECOMMEND SOMETHING A LITTLE MORE GENERIC AND
IF THAT IS NOW KNOWN AMONG THE STAKEHOLDERS AND THE
INTERESTED PARTIES THAT LABEL IS REPRESENTING THESE WATER
TYPE OF CONVERSATIONS, THAT MIGHT BE A BETTER WAY TO GO.
BUT WE ARE FOLLOWING DO WHATEVER THE COUNCIL WOULD REQUEST.
09:20:20AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
09:20:24AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN.
MISS DUNCAN, WHEN ARE WE GOING TO BRING THIS TO A CLOSE.
THIS IS THE PROJECT.
THIS IS WHAT WE BELIEVE.
WE HEARD FROM THE PUBLIC.
THESE ARE THE CHOICES.
WHAT DOES COUNCIL WANT TO DO.
WHEN IS THAT -- SO WE CAN GET THE "PURE" NAME AND MOVE ON
WITH THIS WATER SITUATION.
IT HAS BEEN LINGERING FOREVER AND WHEN WILL WE HAVE A
DEFINITIVE PROJECT TO SAY THIS IS THE RECOMMENDATION WE
BELIEVE FROM OUR EXPERTS, VERSUS WHAT THE PUBLIC SAYS AND
HERE IT IS.
WHAT DO YOU WANT TO DO.
WHAT IS COUNCIL'S PLEASURE.
09:20:57AM >>JEAN DUNCAN:
THE ACTIVITY THAT IS OCCURRING NOW IS WORKING
ON THE VARIOUS MOTIONS THAT CAME OUT IN SEPTEMBER.
WITH THE MAY JOR ONE BEING IN FEBRUARY A WORKSHOP ON THE
WORK THAT OUR CONSULTANT IS DOING IN CONCERT WITH THE CITY
AND OTHER AGENCIES TO RESPOND TO THAT MOTION.
WE DO NOT HAVE A CONTRACT OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE THINGS ANY
FURTHER BECAUSE COUNCIL HAS NOT APPROVED ANYTHING FURTHER
FOR US.
SO THAT IS THE LANDING POINT FOR NOW IN TERMS OF A PUBLIC
DISCUSSION.
THE WORKSHOP IN SEPTEMBER.
09:21:28AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
THANK YOU.
09:21:30AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
09:21:32AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
JUST FOR THE EASING OF MIND, IF SOMETHING
IS FOR "PURE."
GOT TO HAVE THE NAME OF PURE ON IT AND THIS COUNCIL HAS TO
VOTE ON IT FOR ANY FUNDING, AM I CORRECT?
09:21:42AM >>JEAN DUNCAN:
YES, BUT NO MORE PURE PROJECT.
09:21:46AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
BUT I AM GETTING TO THE POINT.
THE POINT IS IF SOMEBODY WAS TO DO THAT, IT WOULD BE
DRASTICALLY IMPOSSIBLE TO UNDERSTAND THAT THE PUBLIC
UNDERSTANDS WHAT THAT INDIVIDUAL, HE OR SHE DID IN A HIGHER
OFFICE TO DO SOMETHING LIKE THAT.
IT WOULD BE INAPPROPRIATELY AT ANY TIME, NUMBER ONE.
23478 TWO -- NOT RELATED -- IF IT IS WATER EVERYTHING IS
RELATED BUT PURE IS NOT INVOLVED IN THIS.
LIKE EVERYBODY IN MY FAMILY HAVE THE LAST NAME OF MIRANDA.
THEY DON'T.
I HAVE A 50 SOME COUSINS AND ALL HAVE DIFFERENT LAST NAMES.
IT DOESN'T MEAN THEY ARE ME.
IT MEANS THEY ARE RELATED TO ME.
THE SAME THING HERE.
I TRY TO MAKE THINGS TO MAKE SURE I KNOW WHAT IS GOING ON.
IF IT DOESN'T HAVE THE FUNDING FOR PURE, IT CAN NOT BE PURE,
BECAUSE YOU CAN'T TRANSFER MONEY FROM SOMETHING THAT IS
APPROVED TO SOMETHING THAT IS NOT APPROVED BY THIS COUNCIL.
TO BE AFRAID OF SOMETHING, WE WILL BE STALEMATED.
OTHER WATER AGENCIES THINK 15, 20, 30, 40 YEARS AWAY TO PLAN
FOR GROWTH.
THEY HAVE ALL THOSE PLANNING.
YOU JUST GOT TO GO LISTEN TO THEM.
THEY COME UP ON CHANNEL 3.
I KNOW EVERYBODY DOESN'T HAVE CHANNEL 3 BECAUSE THAT IS A
NONAREA THAT YOU DON'T NEED THE INTERNET OR TPG OR WHATEVER
IT IS THEY GET ON.
THESE THINGS ARE EXPLAINED IN THOSE MEETINGS FORCEFULLY AND
THOUGHTFULLY AND THE PUBLIC SHOULD UNDERSTAND EXACTLY WHAT
IT IS.
I AM NOT SAYING VOTE IT UP OR DOWN.
IF IT IS UP TO EACH COUNCILMEMBERS.
IF IT IS PURE, IT SHOULD HAVE THE LABEL OF PURE.
NOT JUST BECAUSE IT IS WATER AND A MEMORY FAMILY OF WATER.
09:23:24AM >>BILL CARLSON:
MR. CHAIRMAN.
09:23:27AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
09:23:29AM >>BILL CARLSON:
I WOULD CALL IT TOILET TO TAP.
BUT MAYBE SOMEBODY ELSE WILL HAVE A DIFFERENT LABEL THAT
THEY WILL SUGGEST.
THE -- THE REASON WHY THIS IS TIED TO PURE, OVER THE LAST
THREE AND A HALF YEARS WE DISPROVEN EVERY ARGUMENT THAT THE
WATER DEPARTMENT MADE OF THIS PROJECT.
THE ONLY ONE LEFT THEY ARE FORCED TO DO IT BY THE STATE.
I CONTACTED THE STATE, THEY SAID THAT IS RUBBISH, THE STATE
RESPONDED NOW NEGATIVELY.
WHAT I BELIEVE TO BE A VERY SUSPICIOUS WAY.
WE CAN TALK WITH THAT IN JANUARY.
SO WHAT WE NEED TO DO IS FIGURE OUT HOW TO STOP THIS PROJECT
FROM -- THE TAMPA -- AS YOU THOUGH TAMPA BAY WATER HAS A
20-YEAR PLAN AND TEN-YEAR SUPPLY AND WE ARE PART OF THAT.
WE DON'T NEED 50 MGD FOR 100 YEARS AND DOESN'T MAKE THE
SENSE TO SPEND THE MONEY TODAY THAT WE WON'T NEED FOR 100
YEARS.
WE CAN TALK ABOUT THAT IN JANUARY, AND TIED TO PURE -- OR
WHATEVER WE CALL THE PROJECT -- ONLY BECAUSE THE
JUSTIFICATION THAT WE HAVE TO MOVE FORWARD BY STATE LAW.
WE HAVE A LEGAL TEAM.
WE HAVE A LOBBYING TEAM.
THE LOBBYISTS SAY THE CITY HAS BEEN WORKING IN FAVOR OF THIS
IN THE PAST, WE AS CITY COUNCIL SHOULD HAVE SOME INFLUENCE
TO STOP THEM FROM DOING THAT OR ASK THEM TO GIVE US AN
EXCEPTION.
CRAZY TO PUT IT ON THE BACKS OF OUR RATE PAYERS, THANK YOU.
09:24:47AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MISS DUNCAN.
09:24:49AM >>JEAN DUNCAN:
I WOULD LIKE TO SAY WE HAVE WORKED VERY HARD
TO BE AS TRANSPARENT AS WE CAN CONSIDERING WE TONIGHT HAVE
FUNDING FOR A PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT PLAN TO HAVE REALLY TRUE,
PROPER, COMPREHENSIVE ENGAGEMENT.
PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT IS VERY LIMITED TO A FEW PEOPLE THAT TAKE
THEIR PRECIOUS FREE TIME AND GET INVOLVED WITH THESE TOPICS.
WE APPRECIATE THAT.
THAT IS NOT REPRESENTING THE ENTIRE CITY'S VIEWPOINT OF THIS
I THINK SO.
WE HAVEN'T HAD A CHANCE TO HAVE THAT PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT.
I WOULD LIKE TO SAY -- AND I TAKE EXCEPTION THE WORD
"SUSPICIOUS."
WE HAVE WORKED VERY HARD TO BE TRANSPARENT TO INCLUDE ALL
PARTIES OF INTEREST, TO INCLUDE THE APPROPRIATE AGENCIES.
NO INFORMATION OR EVIDENCE THAT WE HAVE DONE SIGNIFICANCE
THAT SHOULD BE CONSIDERED SUSPICIOUS.
I WOULD APPRECIATE IF WE KEEP OUR CONVERSATIONS FACTUAL AND
PROFESSIONAL AND NOT BRING IN ACCUSATIONS THAT CAN'T BE
PROVEN.
09:25:50AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK AND THEN COUNCILMAN
MIRANDA.
09:25:53AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I AM PERSONALLY FINE HEARING IT TODAY.
I AM ALSO -- ALSO IF COUNCILMAN CARLSON REALLY WANTS IT IN
JANUARY, I AM HAPPY TO DO JANUARY.
THE ONLY THING I ASKED -- I SPOKE WITH MISS DUNCAN LAST
NIGHT AND THE ONLY THING I ASKED IS THAT THE ACTUAL
LITERATURE THAT -- THAT WE SENT TO THE -- TO THE STATE AND
THAT THE STATE SENT BACK TO US BE ADDED TO SIRE.
YOU SAID YOU COULD DO THAT AT SOME POINT TODAY.
SO THAT THE PUBLIC HAS A CHANCE TO GO AND LOOK AT IT IF THEY
ARE LISTENING RIGHT NOW OR LISTENING LATER.
THEY WILL HAVE A CHANCE TO LOOK AT THOSE DOCUMENTS.
09:26:35AM >>JEAN DUNCAN:
THAT IS DEFINITELY PHYSICALLY POSSIBLE.
THE CONCERN I HAD AFTER WE SPOKE LAST NIGHT IS THAT THIS IS
REALLY A VERBAL ADMINISTRATIVE UPDATE.
WASN'T ANY PROTOCOL OR PROCESS THAT THIS TYPE OF THING WILL
BE LOADED IN SIRE.
WE PERSONALLY E-MAILED, AND IT DIDN'T COME IN THE THOUGHT
PROCESS OF DOING THAT.
WE NEED TO BE THOUGHTFUL OF WHERE DO WE DRAW THAT LINE AND
WHAT IS THE PROCESS FOR SOMETHING REACHING THE LEVEL OF
BEING PUT INTO SIRE AND HOW DO WE ALL KNOW WHAT IT IS SO WE
DON'T HAVE ONE BE INTERPRETATION AND COUNCIL HAS ANOTHER.
SO I HAVEN'T PUT THE ITEMS IN SIRE JUST BECAUSE I WANTED TO
HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO OFFER THAT THOUGHT OF COUNCIL
HAVING, OF WHERE DO WE HAVE DRAW THAT LINE.
I DON'T MEAN THAT IN A NEGATIVE WAY, BUT WHAT IS THAT POINT
OF DECISION TO PUT IT IN OR NOT.
09:27:32AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I WOULD SAY WITH THIS PARTICULAR ISSUE SINCE
WE ARE TALKING OF THEIR RESPONSE, THAT IT WILL BE NICE TO
SEE THE RESPONSE.
SO I AM -- I DEFINITELY THINK THE LANGUAGE SHOULD BE
INCLUDED.
SO IT'S COUNCIL'S PLEASURE.
I AM FINE HEARING IT TODAY.
I AM ALSO -- BUT IF WE DO HEAR IT TODAY, I WOULD ALSO LIKE
TO BE ABLE TO HEAR IT IN THE FUTURE BECAUSE FOLKS DIDN'T
HAVE NECESSARILY TIME TO LOOK AT THE DATA OR THE
INFORMATION.
09:28:05AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
09:28:11AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
I WILL HOLD UNTIL JANUARY.
LIKE COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK SAID, I AM FLEXIBLE.
09:28:18AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMEMBERS, WE TALKED MORE ABOUT THIS
ISSUE THAN WHAT WOULD PROBABLY HAVE BEEN PRESENTED.
MAY I SEE IN COUNCIL CHAMBERS A SHOW OF HANDS OF PEOPLE WHO
ARE HERE TO SPEAK OR LISTEN TO THIS STAFF REPORT?
JUST A SHOW OF HANDS.
COUNCILMEMBERS, IF I MAY, WHY DON'T WE JUST HEAR THIS, AND
IF SOMEBODY WISHES TO MAKE THIS A WORKSHOP ON THE 17th, WE
CAN DO THAT.
WHAT IS THE PLEASURE OF COUNCIL?
09:28:50AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
SO MOVED, MR. CHAIRMAN.
09:28:52AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
SECOND, HEAR IT TODAY.
THE PEOPLE ARE HERE.
I WOULD HATE TO SEE THEM HAVE TO COME BACK AGAIN.
09:28:58AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
TALK ABOUT AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 8.
09:29:02AM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
BEFORE WE DO THAT, THE PUBLIC BEING
CLEARING WITH THE STAFF REPORT, COUNCIL'S PROTOCOL THAT TO
BE HEARD UP FRONT DURING GENERAL PUBLIC COMMENT.
IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON THAN PARTICULAR ITEM, THE TIME TO DO
IT IS IN PUBLIC COMMENT.
09:29:19AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
09:29:22AM >>BILL CARLSON:
ONE OF THE REASONS I WANTED TO DEFER IT
BECAUSE IT DIDN'T SAY "PURE."
AND WE WILL DEAL WITH THAT.
AND THE DOCUMENTS WERE NOT ATTACHED TO SIRE.
IF THERE IS A DOCUMENT FROM THAT A BOARD MAY REJECT OUR
APPLICATION.
WE SHOULD HOLD THIS UNTIL IT COMES.
IT HAS CIRCULATED IN PUBLIC RECORD THAT WE GOT A COUPLE OF
E-MAILS FROM A PERSON AND REALLY THAT IS WHAT THE REPORT IS
TODAY.
I FEEL IF WE ARE GOING TO MOVE A $6 BILLION PROJECT FORWARD
BECAUSE A PERSON SENT A ONE OR TWO-LINE E-MAIL, THEN THAT
DEFINITELY COULD BE A PUBLIC RECORD THAT WILL BE SHOWN TO
THE PUBLIC IN ADVANCE.
THANK YOU.
09:30:03AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
09:30:04AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
IT IS COMING -- THE -- WE WERE SUPPOSED TO
HAVE THE 17 QUESTIONS FROM THE FRIENDS OF THE RIVER ANSWERED
TODAY AND THAT HAS BEEN CONTINUED TO JANUARY 19 WHICH IS WHY
I KNOW YOU WANTED TO CONTINUE THIS UNTIL JANUARY 19.
CAN WE ADD THAT AS WELL TO JANUARY 19.
CAN WE HEAR THE REPORT AND ABLE TO TALK ABOUT IT ON THE 19.
09:30:27AM >>BILL CARLSON:
I WILL WITHDRAW MY MOTION.
09:30:29AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 8.
MISS TRAVIS.
WE WILL BE HEARING THAT.
NOPE?
LET'S --
09:30:39AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
I PROVIDED A WRITTEN REPORT.
THANK YOU.
09:30:41AM >>BILL CARLSON:
ON NUMBER 8, I WOULD LIKE TO -- I WOULD LIKE
TO BRING THIS BACK ON APRIL 16 FOR AN UPDATE.
09:30:52AM >> SECOND.
09:30:54AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MOTION MADE BY COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
ALL IN FAVOR.
THANK YOU.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 9, WE WILL BE HEARING THAT, MISS REBECCA
JOHNS WILL BE DISCUSSING THAT.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 10, YES.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 11.
09:31:11AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I GOT -- I GOT THE WRITTEN UPDATE AND I AM --
SORRY -- I GOT THE WRITTEN UPDATE AND I AM FINE WITH THE
WRITTEN UPDATE.
09:31:20AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WHAT IS THE PLEASURE OF COUNCIL.
09:31:22AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THAT'S FINE.
09:31:24AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MOVE THAT FROM THE AGENDA.
11.
09:31:26AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YES, BECAUSE THAT IS ON A QUARTERLY BASIS AND
WILL BE COMING BACK TO US IN FEBRUARY.
SO JUST A QUARTERLY REPORT.
09:31:34AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MOTION MADE BY COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
SECONDED BY --
09:31:37AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I MEAN IT IS ALREADY --
09:31:39AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
FINE.
WE ARE GOOD.
09:31:40AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
RECEIVE AND FILE.
09:31:42AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 12.
NUMBER 13.
09:31:47AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOTION TO CONTINUE THAT UNTIL DECEMBER
15 UNDER STAFF REPORTS.
09:31:53AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU, MOTION MADE BY --
09:31:56AM >>BILL CARLSON:
IS THAT --
09:31:58AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MOTION MADE BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
SECONDED BY COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
ALL IN FAVOR.
NUMBER 13.
09:32:03AM >>BILL CARLSON:
I WOULD LIKE TO CONTINUE THIS UNTIL JANUARY
19 AT REQUEST OF STAFF.
09:32:09AM >> SECOND.
09:32:09AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MOTION MADE BY COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
ALL IN FAVOR.
09:32:15AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MR. CHAIRMAN.
09:32:17AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
09:32:19AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
ALL DUE RESPECT, WE KICKED THIS ITEM DOWN
THE ROAD ON NUMEROUS OCCASIONS.
SOMEBODY WITH UNFORESEEN CIRCUMSTANCES BUT I WOULD LIKE TO
BRING THIS HOPEFULLY TO A CLOSURE.
IT NEEDS TO BE BROUGHT TO A CLOSURE.
MR. SHELBY, YOU AND ME HAD A DISCUSSION IN THE BACK, SIR.
WITH THE DISCUSSION WE HAD, I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT YOU
INCLUDE OUR DISCUSSION IN REFERENCE TO -- THERE WAS A -- A
MOTION PUT ON THE FLOOR BACK A WHILE AGO.
AND I KNOW YOU ARE A HUMBLE GUY, BUT SOMETIMES YOU CAN BE
HUMBLE, BUT YOU NEED TO BE FORTHCOMING FOR WHAT NEEDS TO BE
DONE.
SO I AM HOPING THAT YOU WILL DISCUSS THAT ISSUE THAT WAS PUT
BEFORE US BEFORE WITH US YOU HERE.
BECAUSE THAT NEEDS TO BE DISCUSSED.
I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE GET IT ALL IN ONE SHOT SO THE
PUBLIC CAN KNOW, THIS COUNCIL CAN KNOW, AND THAT WAY YOU CAN
TO YOUR JOB MORE EFFECTIVELY.
09:33:16AM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
THANK YOU, COUNCIL, I APPRECIATE THAT.
I WANT TO YOU KNOW THAT I HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TO
MOST MEMBERS OF COUNCIL REGARDING THIS, AND I UNDERSTAND THE
NEED FOR CLOSURE AND I TALKED TO THE MAKER OF THE MOTION,
AND WE WILL BE PREPARED TO MOVE FORWARD ON THE 19th.
09:33:33AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
THANK YOU, SIR.
09:33:34AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 14.
09:33:36AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOVE TO CONTINUE APRIL 20, 2023.
09:33:41AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MOTION MADE BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
SECONDED BY COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
09:33:45AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOTION TO CONTINUE ITEM 15 TO FEBRUARY
23, 2023 PER REQUEST OF STAFF.
09:33:52AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MOTION MADE BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
ALL IN FAVOR.
MOTION FOR AGENDA ITEM 16 TO BE CONTINUED TO JANUARY 19.
09:34:10AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
SO MOVED.
09:34:12AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
SECOND.
09:34:13AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ALL IN FAVOR.
AGENDA ITEM ITEM NUMBER 17, REQUEST FOR FEBRUARY 2.
09:34:19AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
SO MOVED.
09:34:20AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MR. CHAIRMAN.
09:34:22AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
09:34:23AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I DID SPEAK WITH MISS HILLS IN REFERENCE TO
THIS ITEM I WAS GOING TO HAVE HER TALK ABOUT IT, BUT AFTER
GETTING HER EXPLANATION WE WILL CONTINUE THIS FOR 60 DAYS.
09:34:42AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO AND SECONDED
BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
ALL IN FAVOR.
FEBRUARY 2.
09:34:59AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANY OTHER CHANGES TO THE ADDENDUM.
MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN GUDES.
ALL IN FAVOR.
THANK YOU.
AT THIS TIME, WE WILL NOW TAKE PUBLIC COMMENT.
ANYONE WISHING TO GIVE PUBLIC COMMENT AT THIS TIME, IF YOU
COULD PLEASE FORM A LINE ON MY LEFT, YOUR RIGHT ANYONE
WISHING TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT.
09:35:35AM >> GOOD MORNING.
09:35:50AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
GOOD MORNING.
09:35:51AM >> MY NAME IS JUSTIN TRAMBLE.
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF TAMPA BAY WATER KEEPER.
WE ARE A NONPROFIT THAT FIGHTS FOR CLEAN WATER NOT ONLY IN
HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY BUT PINELLAS COUNTY.
WE REPRESENT THE COMMUNITY'S RIGHT TO CLEAN WATER.
I'M HERE TODAY TO DISCUSS THE ITEM THAT YOU GUYS WERE JUST
TALKING ABOUT THERE.
TAMPA BAY WATER KEEPER APPRECIATES THE -- THE QUESTIONS
REGARDING THE DISCHARGE PROJECT.
WE APPRECIATE THE STRICT SCRUTINY THAT THE COMMUNITY AND
ORGANIZATIONS HAVE PROVIDED YOU ALL.
BUT BIG PICTURE.
THE CITY OF TAMPA CURRENTLY DISCHARGES AT PINEY POINTS
CRISIS WORTH OF NUTRIENTS A YEAR INTO HILLSBOROUGH BAY.
WE SUPPORT THE CONVERSATION REGARDING WAYS TO LARGELY REDUCE
OR ELIMINATE THE AVERAGE 50 MILLION GALLONS OF TREATED
RECLAIMED WATER BEING DISCHARGED DAILY.
WE SUPPORT THE CONVERSATION.
AND WE APPRECIATE THE CONVERSATION.
ELIMINATING OR SIGNIFICANTLY REDUCING THESE NUTRIENTS ARE
GOOD FOR TAMPA BAY.
BECOMING A MORE RESILIENT AND SUSTAINABLE REGION PROTECTS
NOT ONLY OUR WATERSHED BUT OUR COMMUNITY, ENSURING FISHABLE,
SWIMMABLE, AND DRINKABLE WATER FOR ALL.
WE APPRECIATE THE CONVERSATION.
WE SEE IT AS AN OPPORTUNITY.
SO THANK YOU.
09:37:23AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
IS THAT A SNOOK OR TARPON ON YOUR HAT.
09:37:27AM >> A TARPON.
COOL HAT, RIGHT.
09:37:29AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
09:37:31AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
THANK HIM FOR COMING UP.
I NEVER MET HIM.
370 TONS OF THOSE NUTRIENTS THAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT.
THANK YOU.
09:37:41AM >> GOOD MORNING, NANCY STEVENS, CONSERVATION CHAIR FOR THE
TAMPA BAY SIERRA CLUB AND MEMBER OF THE PURE STAKEHOLDER
GROUP.
TALKING ITEM 7.
THANK YOU, WE AGREE.
WE WANT CLEAN WATER GOING INTO THE BAY.
DON'T DISAGREE WITH THAT.
WHAT WE WANT TO TALK ABOUT TODAY THE STATE MANDATES THAT
MANDATES TO TAKE ALL OF OUR WASTEWATER AND DO SOMETHING ELSE
WITH IT INSTEAD OF PUT IT IN THE BAY.
YOU HAVE TO REMEMBER THAT TAMPA IS A ESTUARY.
ONE OF THE OUTSTANDING ESTUARIES IN THE UNITED STATES.
A ESTUARY IS A SEMI ENCLOSED BODY OF WATER WHERE FRESH WATER
FROM THE RIVER MIXES AND MEETS WITH THE SALT WATER FROM THE
OCEAN.
ESTUARIES ARE TRANSITION ZONE FROM LAND TO SEA AND SUPPORT A
SPECTACULAR ABUNDANCE AND DIVERSITY OF WILDLIFE.
CONSIDERED ONE OF THE MOST PRODUCTIVE ENVIRONMENTS IN THE
WORLD AND OFTEN REFERRED AS A NURSERY ROUND FOR FISH,
CRUSTACEANS AND SHELL FISH AND TO HIDE FROM PREDATORS.
BAY WASTEWATER PROVIDES A FLOW TO THE ESTUARY REPLACING SOME
OF THE FRESH WATER THAT TAMPA AND TAMPA BAY WATER WITHDRAW
FROM THE HILLSBOROUGH RIVER AND BYPASS CANAL FOR DRINKING
WATER.
THE BILL 64 THAT REQUIRES THE ELIMINATION OF SURFACE WATER
HAS A BIG GAP WITH UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES.
DOES NOT COVER THE ECOLOGICAL BENEFIT TO ESTUARIES EVEN
THOUGH THEY RELY ON FRESHWATER FLOW.
LUMPING ESTUARIES AS PART OF MARINE WATERS.
ESTUARIES ARE QUITE DIFFERENT FROM OCEANS AND HAVE DIFFERENT
NEEDS.
THEREFORE, WE A PROPOSED LEGISLATION TO ADD LANGUAGE TO
ALLOW USING RECLAIMED WATER TO PROVIDE FRESH WATER FLOWS TO
ESTUARIES.
WE ARE ASKING THIS TO BE ONE OF YOUR LEGISLATIVE PRIORITIES.
IF TAMPA WERE FORCED TO REDUCE ALL 50 MILLION GALLONS OF DAY
OF WASTEWATER A HUGE COST TO TAMPA TAXPAYERS AND BILLIONS OF
DOLLARS AND IMPACT THE ESTUARY DEPRIVING OF THE CONSTANT
FRESH WATER FLOW THAT WE HAVE COME TO A RELY ON.
BUT ALLOWING THE CONTINUATION OF THE CURRENT DISCHARGE AS
PART OF THE SOLUTION INTO THE ESTUARY IS A BENEFICIAL USE
WILL GIVE TAMPA FLEXIBILITY TO PURSUE USING THE RECLAIMED
WATER FOR NEEDED PURPOSES THAT ARE IN THE BEST PUBLIC
INTEREST.
AND TREATING THE WATER TO THE APPROPRIATE LEVELS TO MAKE IT
SAFE FOR THAT PURPOSE.
AND THIS WILL RESULT IN A LOWER COST OVERALL SINCE THE
RECLAIMED WATER WILL BE TREATED ONLY IF NEEDED.
AND CONTROLLING NITROGEN IN THE BAY IS KEY TO THAT.
AS WELL.
WE ASK THE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL TO LISTEN TO CITIZENS'
CONCERNS AND MAKE IT ONE OF YOUR TOP LEGISLATIVE PRIORITIES.
PLEASE DON'T ALLOW THE STATE TO FORCE TAMPA RESIDENTS TO
SPEND BILLIONS OF DOLLARS TO TREAT AND REROUTE LARGE
QUANTITIES OF WASTEWATER REUSE THAT WE DON'T NEED AND CAN
POTENTIALLY BE HARMFUL TO THE WATER RESOURCES, HUMAN HEALTH
AND THE ENVIRONMENT OF OUR REGION.
THANK YOU.
09:40:42AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
09:40:44AM >> WELL, GOOD MORNING.
MY NAME IS SID FLANNERY.
A LONG-TIME RESIDENT OF THE TAMPA AREA AND A RETIRED CHIEF
ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENTIST WITH THE SOUTHWEST WATER MANAGEMENT
DISTRICT WHERE I WORKED FOR NEARLY 30 YEARS STUDYING AND
MANAGING FRESH WATER FLOW TO ESTUARIES, INCLUDING THE
ESTABLISHMENT OF MINIMUM FLOW RULES TO RIVERS THAT FLOW TO
TAMPA BAY.
IN RESPONSE TO THE REQUIREMENT OF SENATE BILL 64 PASSED BY
THE FLORIDA LEGISLATURE IN 2021, CITY STAFF RECENTLY
SUBMITTED A REQUEST FOR THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION TO DETERMINE IF DISCHARGES FROM THE
CITY'S HOWARD F. CURREN WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT PROVIDED
ECOLOGICAL BENEFITS TO TAMPA BAY.
WITH THAT REQUEST, STAFF SUBMITTED A 20-PAGE TECHNICAL
REPORT AND PREVIOUSLY SUBMITTED TO CITY STAFF FOR THEIR
REVIEW.
THE DEP DENIED THEIR REQUEST TO RECOGNIZE THE ECONOMIC
DISCHARGE FROM THE AWT PLANT TO TAMPA BAY.
IN A SHORT E-MAIL RESPONSE, DEP REPLIED AND I QUOTE, THE
ECOLOGICAL BENEFIT PROVISION IN SENATE BILL 64 ADDRESSES
WATER QUANTITY OF MINIMUM FLOW AND HE MINIMUM LEVEL MFL
REQUIREMENTS.
MARINE DOES NOT HAVE A MFL CLASSIFICATION, THE DISCHARGE
FROM THE HOWARD F. CURREN WATER TREATMENT FACILITY DOES NOT
QUALIFY FOR THE ECOLOGICAL BENEFIT PROVISION IN SENATE BILL
64.
THIS FINDING BY DEP REFLECTS THE SHORTCOMING IN THE LANGUAGE
IN SENATE BILL 64 EVEN THOUGH A MINIMUM FLOW RULE HAS NOT
BEEN ESTABLISHED SPECIFICALLY FOR TAMPA BAY, FRESH WATER
FLOW IS CRITICAL OF MAINTAINING THE WATER QUALITY, ECOLOGY
AND BIOLOGICAL PRODUCTIVITY OF THE BAY.
THE FACT THAT THE CITY'S DISCHARGE IS LOCATED ON SEVEN
CHANNEL THAT DEP CATEGORIZED AS MARINE WATER DOES NOT NEGATE
THE IMPORTANCE OF THIS DISCHARGE TO TAMPA BAY.
IN MY OPINION, DEP'S CONCLUSION WAS NOT SUFFICIENTLY SCIENCE
OR RESOURCE-BASED BUT INSTEAD WAS BASED ON A TECHNICAL,
BUREAUCRATIC AMBIGUITY THAT RESULTED FROM A LACK OF CLARITY
IN SENATE BILL 64.
AFTER CAREFUL REVIEW, I, AND MEMBERS OF SEVERAL
ORGANIZATIONS THAT ARE ON THE CITY'S PURE STAKEHOLDERS
GROUP, BELIEVE THAT ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE NEED TO BE PASSED BY
THE OF FLORIDA LEGISLATURE AND ADOPTED IN FLORIDA STATUTES
TO REMEDY THE INACCURACY OF SENATE BILL 64.
ACCORDINGLY, WE HAVE PREPARED A DRAFT DOCUMENT AND
RECOMMENDED LANGUAGE THAT CAN BE ADDED TO THE STATUTE TO
ALLOW FOR MORE COMPREHENSIVE ASSESSMENT OF THE BENEFICIAL
EFFECTS OF SURFACE DISCHARGES TO WATER BODIES INCLUDING
ESTUARYS SUCH AS TAMPA BAY.
WE WILL BE HAPPY TO SHARE OUR DOCUMENT WITH YOU AND DISCUSS
THE STRAIGHTFORWARD LANGUAGE WE HAVE PROPOSED THAT CAN
REMEDY THIS PROBLEM.
WE HOPE THAT AFTER CAREFUL CONSIDERATION, THE CITY CAN
SUPPORT OUR RECOMMENDED ADDITION TO THIS STATUTE IN YOUR
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA FOR 2023.
I HAVE TO WRAP UP MY COMMENTS NOW.
BUT I WILL BE HAPPY TO REMAIN IN THE CHAMBER WHEN THIS TOPIC
COMES UP ON YOUR AGENDA LATER TODAY.
IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OF OUR RECOMMENDED ADDITIONS TO
THE STATUTE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR TIME.
09:44:03AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
09:44:04AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MR. CHAIRMAN.
09:44:05AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
09:44:07AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MISS DUNCAN, HAVE YOU SEEN THIS GENTLEMAN'S
RECOMMENDATION SINCE HE IS AN EXPERT IN REFERENCE TO THE
LEGISLATIVE LANGUAGE BEING LOOKED AT?
09:44:18AM >>JEAN DUNCAN:
I HAVE NOT SEEN THE REFERENCE INFORMATION
THAT MR. FLANNERY IS TALKING ABOUT.
I AM SURE HE WILL BE PROVIDING IT TO US.
09:44:25AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MAKE SURE WE GET THAT.
THE LEGISLATIVE SESSION IS COMING UP, THE LOCAL BODY HERE
AND AS YOU REVIEW THAT PROBABLY BEFORE THE WORKSHOP, MAYBE
GET THAT TO OUR LEGISLATIVE PEOPLE HERE TO GIVE IT TO THE
DELEGATION.
MAYBE THE RULE IS THERE BUT MAYBE JUST LIKE HERE, WE PASS
THINGS AND HAVE TO COME BACK TO LOOK AT THINGS THAT ARE NOT
TEA TOLLY -- TOTALLY CLEAR.
I HOPE THAT WE GET THAT INFORMATION TO MOVE FORWARD.
09:44:55AM >>JEAN DUNCAN:
OKAY.
09:44:56AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
09:44:57AM >>BILL CARLSON:
I WANT TO SAY FIRST OF ALL, THANK YOU FOR
ALL THE HARD WORK YOU PUT INTO THE LETTER THAT WAS SENT.
AND THANK YOU TO CHUCK WAGNER AND STAFF FOR SUBMITTING YOUR
LETTER.
WHEN I MENTIONED THE WORD "SUSPICIOUS," I DIDN'T MEAN TO
INFER THAT SOMETHING WAS HAPPENING AT THE WATER DEPARTMENT
ARE, BUT WE KNOW IN THE PAST THE CITY LOBBYING DEPARTMENT
WERE IN FAVOR OF IT AND TOLD ME OUTRIGHT THEY WERE IN FAVOR
NOT AGAINST IT.
THEY WERE RELUCTANT TO LET THE WATER DEPARTMENT SEND OUT
YOUR MEMO.
SO I THINK WE SO FAR HAVE MULTIPLE VOTES OF CITY COUNCIL
AGAINST THIS PROJECT.
AND BY NOW, IF THE CITY WAS OPERATING AS ONE ENTITY, THE
LOBBYING TEAM AND LEGAL TEAM WILL BE LOOKING FOR SOLUTIONS
TO TRY TO STOP THIS.
AND THEY HAVEN'T.
UNFORTUNATELY NEITHER ONE REPORTS TO CITY COUNCIL.
WE NEED TO DO EVERYTHING WE CAN TO STOP IT.
THE SUSPICIOUS PART I TALKED ABOUT WAY YOU JUST REFERENCED
IS A STATE LAW, BUT SOMEHOW THE TWO OR THREE SENTENCE EXCUSE
WAS THAT IT DOESN'T HIT MFL.
WHAT ABOUT CITIES AND COUNTIES THAT DON'T HAVE RIVERS?
THAT IS LANGUAGE THAT LOOKS LIKE IT WAS PUT IN THERE BY
TAMPA LOBBYISTS YEARS AGO.
I KNOW THAT TAMPA LOBBYISTS WERE THERE BECAUSE LOBBYISTS IN
TALLAHASSEE THAT TALK TO LEGISLATORS AFTER THEY TALKED TO
THEM.
I CAN GET MY LOBBYIST AND SEE IF ANYONE HAS REACHED OUT TO
THEM IN THE LAST MONTH.
THE PUBLIC DOESN'T WANT THIS.
A HUGE BURDEN FOR TAXPAYERS.
PEOPLE ARE PAYING TOO MUCH AND THEY BE DON'T WANT THEIR
WATER BILL DOUBLED AND TRIPLED.
THE ADMINISTRATION AND THE CITY COUNCIL NEEDS TO STOP THIS.
09:46:40AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
I WILL GIVE YOU REBUTTAL.
09:46:41AM >> NOT A REBUTTAL BUT A POINT I DIDN'T HAVE TIME IN MY THREE
MINUTES.
RECOGNIZE THE ECOLOGICAL BENEFITS TO THE DISCHARGE OF TAMPA
BAY, THAT DOES NOT PRECLUDE PURSUANT OF RECLAIMED WATER
PROJECTS.
RECLAIMED WATER PROJECTS CAN BE REVIEWED FOR THE QUANTITY
THAT YOU NEED.
YOU KNOW, WHATEVER THE QUANTITY IS, BUT IT MEANS WHERE THE
DISCHARGE IS OCCURRING NOW IS ACTUALLY OKAY, OKAY.
AND WE CAN STILL PURSUE RECLAIMED WATER PROJECTS
INDIVIDUALLY ON A CASE-BY-CASE BASIS.
SIMILARLY IF THE TAMPA BAY ESTUARY PROGRAMS AS WE NEED TO DO
MORE NUTRIENT PRODUCTION, THAT CAN BE PURSUED.
AMENDING THE STATUTE, WHAT WE SUGGEST, WHAT IT DOES DO, GET
THE CITY OUT WITH THE HAMMER WITH EVERYTHING FROM 50 MGD IN
TEN YEARS.
ALLOW OPERATIONAL ABILITIES TO REVIEW RECLAIMED WATER
PROJECTS ON A CASE-BY-CASE BASIS.
09:47:33AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU, COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
09:47:37AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I WILL ASK IF YOU SEND THAT INFORMATION TO
ALL OF US, THAT WILL BE WONDERFUL.
09:47:42AM >> IT WILL BE TODAY PROBABLY BY LUNCHTIME.
09:47:45AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
ONE QUESTION.
09:47:46AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
09:47:47AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
MR. CAMPBELL TALKED OF THE AMOUNT OF
NUTRIENTS GOING INTO THE BAY.
WHAT IS THE AMOUNT OF CONTINUAGE.
AS AN EXPERT TELL ME -- I WANT CLARITY, HOW MANY TONS OF
NUTRIENTS GO INTO THE BAY EVERY YEAR?
09:48:01AM >> I DO NOT KNOW THAT PRECISELY.
I HAVE READ THE DOCUMENTS AND REPORT I GOT HAVE GRAPHICS OF
NUTRIENTS -- NITROGEN LOADING INTO THE BAY.
ONE THING WE SHOULD BE HAPPY ABOUT, TAMPA BAY IN LONG TERM
HAS BEEN IMPROVING IN LONG PART WITH THE WATER TREATMENT AT
HOWARD F. CURREN PLANT.
WILL NOT PRECLUDE NUTRIENTS STUDIES.
IT CAN IMPROPER, IF NECESSARY.
09:48:31AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
IT WAS BETTER NOW THAN IT WAS IN THE
'50s.
09:48:33AM >> VERY MUCH SO.
09:48:34AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
APPRECIATE YOUR SINCERENESS.
09:48:37AM >> THANK YOU.
09:48:38AM >> GOOD MORNING.
I AM PHIL COMPTON WITH FRIENDS OF THE HILLSBOROUGH RIVER,
BUT TODAY I AM SHARING WITH YOU SOME COMMENTS FROM SIERRA
CLUB'S VICE-CHAIR GABBY GIBBONS WHO IS THE CHAIR OF OUR
POLITICAL COMMITTEE WHO IS UNABLE TO ATTEND TODAY'S CITY
COUNCIL MEETING DUE TO SCHEDULING CONFLICT.
GARY WANTS ME TO TELL YOU THAT I HAVE PRACTICED LAW FOR 45
YEARS.
AND EACH YEAR, ATTORNEYS NEED TO REVIEW THE SESSION LAWS TO
SEE WHAT CHANGES HAVE BEEN MADE TOO EXISTING LAW.
MANY TIMES A TWEAK OF THE LANGUAGE IN AN EXISTING LAW THAT
HAS A DEFECT FOR OMISSION OR NEEDS CLARIFICATION BECAUSE OF
AN AM GIG GUTIERREZ IS CAUSING LITIGATION.
SENATE BILL 64 IS A PRIME EXAMPLE OF THE TYPE OF STATUTE
THAT NEEDS FURTHER CLARIFICATION.
SENATE BILL 64 WAS A ONE SIZE FITS ALL AMBITIOUS WAY TO DEAL
WITH A COMPLEX ISSUE TO SAFELY REPURPOSE WASTEWATER FOR
BENEFICIAL USES ACROSS THE STATE TOO LARGE AND TOO DIVERSE
IN TOPOGRAPHY TO ALLOW A ONE SIZE FITS ALL APPROACH.
IN ONE OF OUR MANY STAKEHOLDER MEETINGS WITH CITY STAFF OVER
THE PAST TWO YEARS, FORMER ATTORNEY JAN MCLEAN DESCRIBE
SENATE BILL 64 AS A SOLUTION LOOKING FOR A PROBLEM.
I AGREE WITH HER INTERPRETATION, IT IS NOW LAW AND THE TIME
TO ASK THAT OMISSIONS BE STICKSED BY LEGISLATION THAT WILL
REVISE IT.
SID FLANNERY WHO DEVOTED HIS LIFE'S WORK AS A SCIENTIST ON
S.W.F.W.M.D. AND MINIMUM FLOWS ON THE RIVERS AND EFFECTS ON
ESTUARY WATERS LIKE TAMPA BAY HAVE SEEN SHORTCOMINGS IN
SENATE BILL 64 THAT NEEDS TO BE REVISED.
AND HURRIED PASSED IN 2021 AND DEALING WITH APPROACHING
DEADLINES, IT IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN EVER TO FIX THE
OMISSIONS.
AND HE NOT ONLY FIXED BUT HAVE IT TO FIX A GLARING
OMISSION AND PROVIDED MUCH-NEEDED FLEXIBILITY FOR THE CITY
OF TAMPA TO DEAL WITH THE SITE-SPECIFIC ISSUE THAT ARE
COMPLETELY DIFFERENT THAN THOSE BEING DEALT WITH IN MIAMI OR
THE PANHANDLE.
AND STAKEHOLDERS SEEKING REVISIONS OF CITY STAFF ON MANY
LOCATIONS.
TODAY, WE, THE STAKEHOLDERS, ASK CITY COUNCIL TO MAKE A
FORMAL REQUEST TO THE MAYOR TO HAVE THE REVISIONS OF SENATE
BILL 64 TO BE THE TOP PRIORITY OF THE CITY OF TAMPA'S
LOBBYISTS TO SEEK THE LANGUAGE PROPOSED BY MR. FLANNERY AND
THE STAKEHOLDERS WE SEE AS A WIN-WIN FOR EVERYONE IN THE
CITY OF TAMPA.
LET'S TAKE A PROACTIVE STEP TO FIX THE STATUTE SO THE CITY
WILL HAVE THE FLEXIBILITY THAT IT NEEDS TO EXPLORE ALL
ALTERNATIVES FOR THE SAFE REUSE OF ITS TREATED WASTEWATER.
THANK YOU.
09:51:31AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MR. COMPTON OPINION.
09:51:33AM >> YES, SIR.
09:51:35AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
09:51:36AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
CAN YOU PLEASE ASK MR. GIBBONS SEND HIS
LEGISLATIVE SOLUTION TO ALL OF US?
09:51:42AM >> I BELIEVE WHAT HE WAS REFERRING TO IS THE LANGUAGE THAT
MR. FLANNERY HAS DRAFTED WHICH WE WERE JUST DISCUSSING ALONG
WITH HIS REPORT, WHICH IDENTIFIES THE SITUATION.
09:51:50AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
PERFECT.
09:51:52AM >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MAY I ADD PLEASE, YEARS AGO I WORKED WITH JAN MCLEAN FOR
FERTILIZER ORDINANCE HERE WHICH HAS BEEN EXTREMELY
SUCCESSFUL.
AND THAT WAS PART OF THE SIERRA CLUB'S STATEWIDE EFFORT TO
GET FERTILIZER ORDINANCES PASS IN OVER 100 CITIES AND
COUNTIES BUT NEVER SAID THAT THE STATE OF FLORIDA SHOULD
HAVE ONE FERTILIZER TYPE OF RULE BECAUSE THE STATE IS TOO
BIG AND DIVERSE AND IN SOME PLACE IT IS WOULDN'T MAKE SENSE.
SAME THING IS TRUE HERE.
THANK YOU.
09:52:21AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
MY MEMORY SERVES ME CORRECT, THE MAY TO
NOVEMBER ORDINANCE.
09:52:25AM >> SORRY?
09:52:26AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
ORDINANCE CALLED THE MAY TO NOVEMBER.
09:52:29AM >> YEAH, IT IS JUNE THROUGH --
09:52:33AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
WAS THE FIRST TO PASS.
09:52:40AM >> AND PINELLAS HAS THE SAME RULE.
09:52:42AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MR. MR. COMPTON, HAPPY BIRTHDAY.
09:52:45AM >> IT WAS YESTERDAY, THANK YOU.
YOU CAN NOW PUT UP CHRISTMAS DECORATIONS BECAUSE IT IS AFTER
MY BIRTHDAY.
THANK YOU.
[LAUGHTER]
09:52:54AM >> GOOD MORNING.
MY NAME IS CAROL CAMISA, AND I'M HERE AS A MEMBER OF THE
STAKEHOLDERS GROUP AND REPRESENTING THE LEAGUE OF WOMEN
VOTERS OF HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY.
MY INTEREST IS IN ENGAGING THE PUBLIC IN ISSUES, POLICY, AND
SO ON, THAT IMPACT PEOPLE'S LIVES.
TO DO THAT WE EDUCATE PEOPLE.
WE ARE ALSO INTERESTED -- AND I AM VERY PLEASED THAT THIS
BODY REFLECTS AN INTEREST IN TRANSPARENCY, ACCURACY OF
INFORMATION GOING TO THE PUBLIC AND SO ON.
AND I AM SORRY, I -- I -- KIND OF WATER UNDER THE BRIDGE,
BAD CHOICE OF WORDS BUT I FEEL IT IS NECESSARY TO CORRECT.
THE STAKEHOLDERS GROUP HAVE DONE AN AWFUL LOT IN TERMS OF
PUBLIC EDUCATION AND WE HAVE REACHED OUT TO A LOT OF
DIFFERENT GROUPS.
I WOULD VENTURE TO SAY THAT BEFORE THE SEPTEMBER CITY
COUNCIL MEETING, WE DID MORE IN A MONTH'S TIME WITH NO MONEY
REACHING OUT TO COMMUNITY GROUPS THAT HAVE BEEN DONE TO DATE
WITH REGARDS TO THIS PROJECT.
AND I HAVE YET TO HEAR ANY ACCOUNTABILITY IN TERMS OF THE
FUNDING THAT WAS GIVEN TO THE WATER DEPARTMENT FOR TWO
SPECIFIC TASKS UNDER PURE.
ONE OF WHICH WAS PUBLIC EDUCATION.
SO I JUST FEEL LIKE IT IS IMPORTANT TO CORRECT THAT RECORD.
IN ANY CASE, YOU, NO DOUBT, REMEMBER PREVIOUS DISCUSSIONS
WHEN TAMPA CITIZENS SPOKE UP ABOUT THEIR CONCERNS ABOUT THE
COST, ABOUT THE SAFETY OF WATER, POTABLE WATER SUPPLY IN
TAMPA AND MY CONCERN NOW IS THAT THIS -- THIS SENATE BILL 64
SEEMS TO JEOPARDIZE THESE OBJECTIVES.
SO WE ARE PURSUING SOME ALTERNATIVE LANGUAGE TO FIX THAT, AS
YOU HEARD FROM MY COLLEAGUES.
SO -- THE CURRENT LAW UNDER SENATE BILL 64 DOESN'T REALLY
ADDRESS ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES RELATED TO TREATED WASTEWATER
DISCHARGES INTO THE BAY.
AND THAT'S NOT SOMETHING THAT IS WELL UNDERSTOOD BY CITY
RESIDENTS.
THEY ARE CONCERNED OF HOW MUCH THEY ARE GOING TO PAY WHEN
THEY OPEN THE TAP THAT IT IS SAFE.
YOU WOULD AGREE THAT IT IS REALLY YOUR JOB TO UNDERSTAND
THOSE TYPE OF THINGS AND REPRESENT TAMPA'S BEST INTEREST.
SO WE TALKED ABOUT THE PREVIOUS COMMENTS THAT THIS IS A
RATHER BLUNT INSTRUMENT, A ONE SIZE FITS ALL KIND OF
APPROACH THAT REALLY DOESN'T MEET THE NEEDS OF TAMPA WE NEED
MORE FLEXIBILITY.
WE NEED TO BE ABLE TO ADAPT TO SPECIFIC LOCAL CONDITIONS AND
-- THAT ARE DIFFERENT IN DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE STATE.
AND I FURTHER SORT OF OBJECT THAT THIS IS KIND OF AN
UNFUNDED MANDATE OUT OF TALLAHASSEE THAT TELLS YOU TO FIX
SOMETHING AND THERE IS NO FUNDING INVOLVED.
SO THE LEGISLATIVE PROPOSAL FOR WHICH WE ARE SEEKING YOUR
SUPPORT WOULD ALLOW TAMPA THE FLEXIBILITY TO MEET THE INTENT
OF SB 64 WHILE ALLOWING FOR NECESSARY FLEXIBILITY AND
ADAPTABILITY.
THANK YOU.
09:56:07AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
09:56:09AM >> HI, CARROLL ANN BENNETT, AND I AM A LIFELONG RESIDENT TO
TAMPA THE ADDITION TO FLORIDA STATUTES THAT WE ARE RECOMMEND
ALSO ALLOW THE RECOGNITION OF THE BENEFITS OF THE DISCHARGES
TO TAMPA BAY AND WILL NOT PRECLUDE THE EVALUATION OF OTHER
RECLAIMED WATER PROJECTS.
INSTEAD, IT WILL GIVE THE CITY MUCH GREATER FLEXIBILITY TO
EVALUATE THESE PROJECTS IN QUANTITIES THAT ARE NEEDED, THAT
ARE COST EFFECTIVE, THAT PROTECT THE WATER RESOURCES IN THE
NATURAL ENVIRONMENT.
AND THEY ARE IN THE BEST PUBLIC INTEREST.
THIS IS MUCH DIFFERENT THAN REQUIRING THE CITY TO ELIMINATE
AND REROUTE 50 MILLION GALLONS OF DISCHARGE A DAY IN THE
NEXT TEN YEARS, WHICH THE CURRENT STATUTE DOES.
OUR ADDITIONS TO THE STATUTE WILL REMEDY THIS DILEMMA.
WE ARE ASKING CITY COUNCIL TO MAKE A FORMAL REQUEST TO THE
MAYOR TO MAKE THIS THE TOP PRIORITY FOR THE CITY'S LOBBYISTS
AND SEEK LANGUAGE BY MR. FLANNERY AND THE STAKEHOLDERS THAT
WE SEE AS A WIN-WIN FOR EVERY CITIZEN IN OF TAMPA.
TAKE A PROACTIVE STEP TO FIX THIS SO THE CITY HAS THE
ABILITY TO EXPLORE ALL ALTERNATIVES FOR THE SAFE REUSE OF
ITS TREATED WASTEWATER.
I, LIKE CARROLL, TAKE THE STAKEHOLDERS AS BEING JUST A FEW
PEOPLE.
WE ALL REPRESENT ORGANIZATIONS THAT AMOUNT TO TENS OF
THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE.
WE HAVE ALL GONE THROUGH THE PROCESSES THAT THESE
ORGANIZATIONS REQUIRED TO BE ABLE TO REPRESENT THEM IN FRONT
OF YOU.
I AM THE T.H.A.N. REPRESENTATIVE IN THE CITY'S PURE
STAKEHOLDER GROUP.
T.H.A.N.'S MEMBERS AND ALL TAMPA RESIDENTS ARE VERY, VERY
CONCERNED OF THE SAFETY OF THEIR WATER AND HOW MUCH IT
COSTS.
THERE WAS A RECENT UNANIMOUS T.H.A.N. VOTE TO THAT EFFECT.
YOU ALL ALSO RECEIVED MANY E-MAILS EXPRESSING THE UNANIMOUS
CONCERNS OF THE CITIZENS.
HOW MANY E-MAILS DID YOU RECEIVE SUPPORTING PURE?
THE CITIZENS AND MEMBERS OF T.H.A.N. HAVE NOT BEEN MADE
AWARE OF THIS THING THAT WE ARE ADDRESSING TODAY.
THEY HAVE NOT BEEN MADE ABOUT IT YET, BUT WHEN THEY DO, THEY
WILL BE WRITING TO CITY COUNCIL AND THE MAYOR ASKING YOU TO
MAKE THIS A TOP LEGISLATIVE PRIORITY.
WE WILL ALL BE HAPPY TO WORK WITH THE CITY TO MAKE SURE THAT
THE CITIZENS' VOICES ARE HEARD.
ON A PERSONAL NOTE THAT CHARLEY MENTIONED ABOUT THE BAY.
WHEN I WAS A KID, OUR CAR DIDN'T HAVE AIR CONDITIONING.
AND NO MATTER HOW HOT IT WAS, WHEN WE HAD TO DRIVE DOWN
BAYSHORE WE DROVE WITH THE WINDOW ROLLED UP BECAUSE THE
STENCH WAS ABSOLUTELY NAUSEATING.
AND I KNOW CHARLIE PROBABLY REMEMBERS THAT TOO.
I REMEMBER LOOKING AT THE BEAUTIFUL HOUSES -- SOME AT THAT
TIME WERE ACTUALLY ABANDONED.
THE BEAUTIFUL HOUSES ON BAYSHORE BOULEVARD AND WONDERING HOW
DO THEY LIVE WITH THIS?
HOW CAN THEY DO THIS?
MAYBE THAT IS WHY SO MANY HOUSES WERE ABANDONED.
WE HAVE COME A LONG WAY AND MADE ADVANCES IN OUR ECOLOGICAL
BENEFITS TO THE BAY.
THANK YOU.
09:59:07AM >> HELLO, EVERYBODY, JAME CLAPHOLT.
I AM A RESIDENT OF THE CITY OF TAMPA FOR OVER TEN YEARS AND
I'M HERE TO SPEAK OF AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 19, WHICH IS THE
PROPOSED LANGUAGE TO PROVIDE AN INDEPENDENT COUNSEL FOR THE
CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD.
I THINK I APPLAUD ALL OF YOU FOR MOVING THAT FORWARD BECAUSE
I THINK AN INDEPENDENT COUNSEL FOR THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD
IS CRUCIAL TO MAINTAIN ITS INDEPENDENCE AND PREVENT
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST.
I WOULD LIKE TO READING IS APPLICABLE FROM THE WEB SITE OF
THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT OF LAW
ENFORCEMENT WITH RESPECTS TO THE IMPORTANCE OF INDEPENDENCE.
IT SAYS ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT AND DEFINING CONCEPTS OF
CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT OF LAW ENFORCEMENT IS INDEPENDENCE.
IN ITS BROADEST SENSE, REFERS TO THE ABSENCE OF REAL OR
PERCEIVED INFLUENCE OF LAW ENFORCEMENT, POLITICAL ACTORS AND
OTHER SPECIAL INTERESTS LOOKING TO AFFECT THE CIVILIAN
OVERSIGHT AGENCY.
IN ORDER TO HAVE LEGITIMACY, THE RESPECT AND
INDEPENDENCE OF THE OVERSEEING LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY.
ESPECIALLY WITH THE HIGH-PROFILE INCIDENTS.
WITH THAT I WOULD LIKE TO ADDRESS THE SPECIFIC LANGUAGE
PRESENTED TO YOU BY THE CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE FOR THIS
PROPOSED ORDINANCE CHANGE OR PROPOSED CHARTER CHANGE RATHER.
CURRENT LANGUAGE BEFORE YOU FROM THE CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
WOULD PROVIDE THAT THE CITY HAS THE SOLE POWER TO SELECT,
HIRE AND FIRE, ESSENTIALLY, THE ATTORNEY FOR THE CITIZENS
REVIEW BOARD, WHICH WOULD REALLY NOT CORRECT THE PROBLEM
ABOUT CONFLICT OF INTEREST THAT CURRENTLY EXISTS WITH IT
BEING STAFFED BY AN ASSISTANT ATTORNEY.
AND I SENT AN E-MAIL WITH THE REQUEST TO MAKE TWO
MODIFICATIONS OF THAT LANGUAGE.
THE FIRST MODIFICATION TO PROVIDE THAT THE CITIZENS REVIEW
BOARD IS THE BODY THAT HAS SOLE SHORT TO HIRE AND FIRE ITS
OWN ATTORNEY.
AND THE SECOND MODIFICATION TO DELETE LANGUAGE FROM THE END
OF THAT PROPOSED SENTENCE THAT IS UNNECESSARY AND
POTENTIALLY CONFUSING AS DETAILED IN THE E-MAIL.
THE LANGUAGE OFF THE TOP OF MY HEAD WAS FOR THE TAMPA POLICE
DEPARTMENT, I BELIEVE, WHICH IS REALLY AN UNNECESSARY PART
OF THAT SENTENCE.
I HOPE THAT YOU ALL MAKE THOSE TWO MOTIONS TO MAKE THOSE
MODIFICATIONS AND MOVE THE LANGUAGE FORWARD AS I DETAILED IN
THAT E-MAIL.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:01:33AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
10:01:35AM >> HELLO.
MY NAME IS PASTOR FRANK WILLIAMS.
LOCATED AT 1112 EACH SCOTT STREET, PARADISE MISSIONARY
BAPTIST CHURCH.
I HAVE BEEN COMING DOWN HERE WEEK AFTER WEEK, MONTH AFTER
MONTH.
DON'T SEEM TO GET NOTHING DONE.
BUT I THANK GOD WE ARE HERE TO SEE ANOTHER DAY.
WHAT IS YOUR NAME.
10:02:11AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
GUIDO MANISCALCO.
WHEN THE CHAIRMAN STEPS OUT AS THE VICE-CHAIR, I TAKE OVER
THE MEETING.
10:02:16AM >> OKAY.
BECAUSE -- I AM GOING TO READ SOME SCRIPTURE.
I SAID TO YOU, HE WHO BELIEVETH IN ME, JESUS TALKING.
WHO DON'T BELIEVETH ON ME AND THE WORK THAT HE DO SHALL --
SHALL HE DO ALSO.
WORK THAT I SHALL DO ALSO.
AND GATHER -- AND GREATER WORK THAN THEE.
BECAUSE I AM MY FATHER AND WHO SOEVER ASKS IN MY NAME, THAT
I WILL GIVE UNTO THEE.
MY FATHER IS GLORIFIED IN THE SON.
THANK YOU, JESUS, THAT HE IS.
YOU KNOW, WE GOT MANY PROBLEMS HERE IN THE UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA.
AND IT DON'T SEEM TO BE GETTING NO BETTER.
IT IS GETTING WORSE AND WORSE AND WORSER.
GOT A RETENTION -- THEY CALL IT A RETENTION POND OUT THERE
IN BELMONT HEIGHTS.
AND PRIME PROPERTY OUT THERE WHICH THEY TOOK FROM BLACK
FOLKS AND DECIDED TO PUT RETENTION PONDS.
I WANTED TO KNOW SOMETHING.
WHY DON'T Y'ALL FILL IN THOSE RETENTION PONDS AND LET ME
BUILD A NICE CONVENTION CENTER OUT THERE.
YOU CAN DO IT BECAUSE IF YOU HAVE ANY POWER AT ALL, YOU CAN
DO ANYTHING ELSE, YOU WILL BE ABLE TO DO THAT FOR ME IN THE
NAME OF JESUS.
I HAVE A LITTLE QUOTE TOMORROW.
AND I WILL BRING ALL THAT STUFF UP.
AND I WOULD LIKE FOR ALL OF YOU SHOW UP TOMORROW AT 9:00,
WHAT THEY CALL -- JUDGE EDGECOMB COURT.
YOU KNOW, I JUST WILL HAVE SO MUCH TO SAY, BUT WHEN I GET UP
HERE, I FORGET ABOUT IT.
BUT YOU KNOW WHAT, WE GOT TO LEARN TO RESPECT ONE ANOTHER.
AND NOT DISRESPECT CERTAIN PEOPLE BECAUSE OF THE COLOR OF
THEIR SKIN.
RESPECT ALL PEOPLE THAT WE WILL BE ABLE TO DO WHAT WE NEED
TO DO AND YOU ALL DO WHAT YOU ALL NEED TO DO FOR US.
I KNOW YOU ARE NOT GOING TO CALL ME BACK UP HERE BECAUSE YOU
ALL DON'T WANT TO HEAR WHAT I AM SAYING.
BUT I GIVE GOD THE GLORY FOR EVERYTHING.
THAT IS THE WAY I AM.
AND GOD HAS BEEN MIGHTY GOOD TO ALL OF US.
I JUST WANT TO PRAISE HIM EVERYWHERE I GO.
WE HAVE -- YOU KNOW, JUST LIKE I SAID, I WANT TO TALK ABOUT
SO MUCH.
I WANT TOP TALK -- THEY ARE RINGING THE BELL ON ME.
THAT MEANS Y'ALL DON'T WANT TO HEAR WHAT I GOT TO SAY.
OKAY, I WILL SIT DOWN.
LET ME GET MY BIBLE AND GET OUT OF HERE.
THANKS FOR THE LITTLE BIT Y'ALL HEARD.
10:05:01AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU, SIR.
10:05:02AM >> GOOD MORNING, COUNCIL.
10:05:14AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
GOOD MORNING.
10:05:15AM >> GRETCHEN CATHERINE.
I AM A TAMPA NATIVE.
I AM ALSO AN ATTORNEY AND A WRONGFUL CONVICTION SPECIALIST.
I'M HERE TO SPEAK ON AGENDA NUMBER 19, THE INDEPENDENT
COUNSEL FOR THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD.
THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD NEEDS A COUNSEL THAT IS NOT
ASSOCIATED WITH THE CITY DUE TO CONFLICT OF INTEREST.
EVEN IF WHOLEHEARTEDLY THE CITY ATTORNEY ASSIGNED TO THE
CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD STAYS AWAY FROM THE OTHER TASKS OF ITS
OFFICE, IT STILL GIVES THE PUBLIC PERCEPTION HE OF THE CITY
-- OF THE ATTORNEY WORKING FOR THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD
ALSO WORKING FOR THE CITY.
IT'S A CONFLICT OF INTEREST TO HAVE THE SAME OFFICE ON BOTH
SIDES OF AN INVESTIGATION.
AND AS AN EXAMPLE, THE CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE RECENTLY
SETTLED THE LAWSUIT FOR THE DEATH OF ARTHUR GREEN.
SO TO HAVE AN ATTORNEY FROM THAT OFFICE WORK BOTH ON THE
SETTLEMENT PROTECTING THE CITY'S INTEREST AND THE AMOUNT OF
MONEY THAT THE CITY IS GOING TO PAY OUT FOR HIS DEATH, TO
ALSO BE THE SAME OFFICE THAT WORKS WITH THE CITIZENS REVIEW
BOARD, WHICH IS TASKED ON INVESTIGATING WHETHER OR NOT TAMPA
POLICE DEPARTMENT ACTED PROPERLY WHEN ARTHUR GREEN DIED,
THAT IS A COMPLETE CONFLICT OF INTEREST.
THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD NEEDS ITS OWN INDEPENDENT COUNSEL
THAT IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH THE CITY.
AND AS ANOTHER EXAMPLE, WE DID SEE RECENTLY, CITY ATTORNEY'S
OFFICE REFUSING TO PROTECT THE INTEREST OF CITY
COUNCILMEMBERS WHEN THE OFFICE IS TASKED WITH PROTECTING
CITY COUNCIL AND PROTECTING THE CITY.
AND I FEAR THAT HAVING THE CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE AS THE
ATTORNEY FOR THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD WILL PUT THAT
ATTORNEY IN THE SAME POSITION.
THAT IS ALL THAT I HAVE.
THANK YOU.
10:07:15AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
10:07:15AM >> MORNING.
MY NAME IS THEY.
AND I AM SPEAKING AGAINST THE PROPOSED LANGUAGE IN AGENDA
ITEM 19.
AS IT STANDS RIGHT NOW, THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD'S ATTORNEY
ALSO REPRESENTS THE CITY, WHICH IS A CONFLICT OF INTEREST,
ESPECIALLY GIVEN OUR EX-POLICE CHIEF MAYOR AND IT WILL
HINDER -- IT HINDERS THEIR ABILITY TO PROPERLY GIVE POLICE
OVERSIGHT.
AND THE PROPOSED LANGUAGE MAKES SO THAT THE CITY GETS TO
CHOOSE THEIR ATTORNEY AS OPPOSED TO HAVING THE SAME
ATTORNEY.
WHICH DOESN'T SOUND INDEPENDENT TO ME AT ALL.
WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO SEE IS FOR THEM TO HAVE THEIR OWN
ATTORNEY TO BE ABLE TO HIRE AND FIRE WHOEVER THEY WANT AS
THEIR ATTORNEY.
GIVEN THE MAYOR'S OFFICE OR THE MAYOR PICKS HALF AND YOU ALL
PICK HALF OF THE CRB, OF THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD, YOU
WOULD THINK YOU WOULD BE ABLE TO TRUST THEM ENOUGH TO HAVE
POWER OVER THAT THEMSELVES.
I THINK IT IS VERY IMPORTANT FOR THEM TO BE INDEPENDENT,
ESPECIALLY IF, YOU KNOW, THEY ARE GOING TO BE LOOKING OVER
POLICE CASES AND GIVING THOSE RECOMMENDATIONS.
WE WANT TO HAVE THEM BE ABLE TO BE TRANSPARENT AND ABLE TO
CARRY OUT THEIR JOBS TO HAVE SOME SORT OF POLICE
TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE CITY.
THANK YOU.
10:08:51AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
10:08:52AM >> GOOD MORNING.
I HAVE A VISUAL AID ON THE ELMO, IF WE COULD SWITCH TO IT.
JAMES MICHAEL SHAW, JR. I AM WITH THE LOCAL ACLU CHAPTER.
I WANT TO ECHO WHAT ATTORNEY COTHERN AND CLAPHOLT SAID ON
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 19.
I DON'T KNOW HOW TO SWITCH TO THE ELMO.
IS THERE A BUTTON.
10:09:20AM >> IT IS THERE NOW.
10:09:21AM >> I WRITTEN OUT THE LANGUAGE DRAFTED BY THE CITY ATTORNEY'S
OFFICE WITH THE MODIFICATIONS WE ARE ASKING FOR.
THE THEY WAY DRAFT IT, THE CITY WILL PROVIDE LEGAL COUNSEL.
THE CITY WHO?
THE MAYOR, YOU ALL, ATTORNEY'S OFFICE, IT DOESN'T SPECIFY.
MOTION MADE AND PASSED IS TO MODEL THE LANGUAGE OFF OF THE
SIMILAR LANGUAGE FROM OTHER ORDINANCES AND OTHER
MUNICIPALITIES.
IN MIAMI-DADE CITY CODE, 11.5-34-B, ORANGE COUNTY CODE
2-195F, KEY WEST, 3.097.
ALL OF THEM SAY THE CRB IS THE BODY THAT RETAINS THE
ATTORNEY.
FOR IT TO BE TRULY INDEPENDENT BY THE PUBLIC YOU CAN'T HAVE
AN ATTORNEY ASSIGNED TO IT BY SOMEBODY ELSE.
THEY NEED TO BE ABLE TO RETAIN THEIR OWN ATTORNEY WHO CAN
ACT INDEPENDENTLY AND ASK THAT THAT MODIFICATION BE MADE TO
THE LANGUAGE.
THE OTHER ONE -- GOING BACK TO THE ELMO.
SAYS TO SERVE AS THE LEGAL ADVISOR FOR THE CITIZENS REVIEW
BOARD FOR THE TAMPA POLICE DEPARTMENT.
THE LANGUAGE IS UNNECESSARY.
ONLY ONE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD.
YOU DON'T HAVE TO SPECIFY THE ONE FOR THE POLICE DEPARTMENT.
AND IT IS -- AND IT IS CONFUSING TOO, BECAUSE COULD BE READ
TO SERVICE THE LEGAL ADVISOR FOR THE TAMPA POLICE DEPARTMENT
TO THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD.
THAT LANGUAGE DOESN'T NEED TO BE THERE AND I ASK THAT
SOMEBODY MOVE TO STRIKE IT.
OTHER THAN THAT, I WAS STRUCK BY THE WORD OF THE INVOCATION
THIS MORNING WHEN HE SAID THAT YOU SHOULD BE GUIDED BY WHAT
IS BEST FOR THE CITIZENS.
AND NOT WHAT IS BEST FOR YOUR NETWORKS.
I WANT TO REMIND YOU -- AND WE SENT THIS TO YOU SEVERAL
TIMES, 68% OF TAMPA VOTERS WANT TO -- WANT THERE TO BE AN
INDEPENDENT ATTORNEY FOR THE CRB.
68% OF THE VOTERS.
DON'T POSITION YOURSELF IN BETWEEN THE WILL OF THE WILL OF
68% OF THE VOTERS AND THE RIGHT TO VOTE ON THIS ISSUE.
I NOTICE TODAY THERE IS NOT A PHALANX OF PAID POLICE
OFFICERS BEHIND ME AND THEY ARE OKAY WITH THE CIVIL RIGHTS
ACTIVISTS TO HAVE THIS ONE.
NOT ANYTHING RADICAL AND ALREADY IN MIAMI, ORANGE COUNTY AND
KEY WEST.
I ASK THAT YOU ALLOW THE VOTERS TO VOTE ON THIS AND NOT
POSITION YOURSELVES IN BETWEEN THE VOTERS IN SOMETHING THAT
THE VOTERS WANT TO VOTE ON EVEN THOUGH 68% OF VOTERS FAVOR
THIS PRO VICTIMS, 82% FAVOR VOTING ON IT.
SO EVEN THOSE WHO ARE AGAINST IT FAVOR VOTING ON IT.
FAVOR PUT IT TO A VOTE AND SAY I MIGHT NOT BE PERSONALLY IN
FAVOR OF THIS, BUT IF EVERYBODY ELSE IS, I AM NOT GOING TO
STAND IN THE WAY.
I ASK YOU TO BE LIKE THE VOTERS.
I WILL BE WATCHING AND THE VOTERS WILL BE WATCHING LAND
NOTICE IF YOU DON'T LET US VOTE ON THIS.
10:12:13AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, IF I SEE NO ONE ELSE STANDING TO SPEAK
FOR PUBLIC COMMENT.
I WOULD ASSUME THAT BISHOP PATTY IS THE LAST PERSON
SPEAKING?
I BELIEVE YOU ARE HANDING OUT SOMETHING FROM BISHOP PATTY?
10:12:43AM >> THAT WOULD BE CORRECT.
10:12:45AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
BISHOP PATTY, PLEASE PROCEED.
10:13:00AM >> GOOD MORNING, BISHOP MICHELLE B. PATTY, AND I STAND BEFORE
YOU AS A TAXPAYER.
I COME TO ASK THIS CITY COUNCIL TO MAKE A MOTION TO WITHHOLD
THE $100,000 THAT YOU HAVE ALLOTTED FOR THE NAACP.
REASON BEING, FOR THE PAST THREE YEARS, THERE HAS NOT BEEN
AN AUDIT OF THE NAACP.
PRESIDENT YVETTE LEWIS, BE THERE, HAVE VIOLATED THE BYLAWS
OF THE NAACP.
THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO HAVE AN AUDIT EVERY YEAR.
THAT HAS NOT BEEN DONE.
NOW YOU THE COUNCIL WANTS TO GIVE $100,000 TO AN
ORGANIZATION WHERE THERE IS NO TRANSPARENCY AND NO
ACCOUNTABILITY.
WHAT I PASSED OUT TO YOU A LETTER FROM TOBA.
A TAMPA ORGANIZATION OF TAMPA BLACK BUSINESS AFFAIRS.
AND THEY HAVE BEEN A PART OF POLITICAL PROCESS WITH
THE NAACP FOR MANY YEARS.
AS YOU SEE FROM THEIR LETTER THEY WITHDRAW THE SPONSORSHIP
OF THIS ORGANIZATION BECAUSE NO TRANSPARENCY AND NO
ACCOUNTABILITY OF FUNDS.
THEY ARE ASKING -- AND I AM ASKING AS A TAXPAYER THAT YOU
ALL DO YOUR DUE DILIGENCE -- I AM OFTEN HEARING THE WORD
"TRANSPARENCY," "ACCOUNTABILITY" SO $100,000 TO AN
ORGANIZATION THAT FEEL LIKE THEY ARE ABOVE THE LAW FEEL THAT
THEY DO NOT HAVE TO ADHERE TO ACCOUNTABILITY.
FEEL LIKE THEY DON'T HAVE TO ADHERE TO THE RULES, THEN NO
MONIES SHALL BE GIVEN UNTIL YOU ALL CAN SEE WHAT HAS
TRANSPIRED WITH MONIES THAT HAVE ALREADY BEEN PUT IN PLACE.
THERE ARE NO SCHOLARSHIPS GIVEN TO CHILDREN AS OF LATE.
THERE ARE NO BUSINESSES THAT THEY CAN POINT TO.
SO ALL THIS WILL COME OUT IN AN AUDIT.
AND THE AUDIT NEEDS TO BE ASKED BY IN COUNCIL.
BECAUSE WE, THE VOTERS, VOTED FOR YOU TO ENSURE THAT OUR
FUNDS ARE BEING LOOKED AFTER AND NOT JUST SQUANDERED AWAY.
AS THE PRAYER WAS, YOU DO WHAT IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF
THE CITIZENS AND NOT WHAT YOU ARE THINKING IS GOING TO HELP
PROPEL YOU INTO YOUR NEXT ARENA AS A POLITICAL FIGURE.
SO I AM HOPING THAT EACH ONE YOU WILL DO YOUR DUE DILIGENCE.
THAT YOU WILL DO WHAT IS RIGHT.
THAT YOU DO RIGHT BY THE PEOPLE OF THE PEOPLE OF THE CITY OF
TAMPA WHO IS COUNTING ON YOU NOT TO SQUANDER $100,000 TO AN
ORGANIZATION THAT WILL NOT ADHERE TO TRANSPARENCY AND
ACCOUNTABILITY.
THANK YOU.
10:15:51AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
10:15:52AM >> MENTESNOT.
GOOD MORNING.
FOR THOSE PEOPLE WHO SAY GOOD MORNING.
UHURU, THAT IS FREEDOM IN SWAHILI.
WE, AS AFRICANS, NEED TO BE THINKING OF OUR FREEDOM.
BAFOON, A CLOWN.
THE CLASS CLOWN.
A STRAIGHT BAFOON.
NOTHING MORE.
NOTHING LESS.
WHEN IN THIS WORLD DO YOU HEAR AFRICAN PEOPLE HATING ON
AFRICAN PEOPLE.
AND AFRICAN PERSON HATING A CHLOE CONEY.
AN AFRICAN PERSON HATING ON ORLANDO GUDES WITH ALL THE
DISCREPANCIES.
AN AFRICAN PERSON HATING ON TAMPA SHAUMBURGER WHEN THEY
CAN'T CONTROL THE SITUATION.
A BAFOON, NOTHING MORE, NOTHING LESS.
NOT REPRESENTATIVE OF ANYTHING.
AND TO TELL ALL THE WHITE PEOPLE IN THIS CITY, IF YOU GO ON
MICHELLE PATTY'S SHOW, ON THAT SATURDAY MORNING, THAT CLOWN
CENTRAL, THAT IS WHAT IT IS.
WITH JOE ROBINSON, CLOWN CENTRAL, ALWAYS TALKING OF PUTTING
THE FBI AND POLICE ON PEOPLE.
A BLACK PERSON.
ANN, A NEGRO, WHERE IN THIS WORLD DO YOU EVER HEAR NEGROES
TALKING ABOUT CALLING THE POLICE ON PEOPLE.
WE KNOW WHAT THE POLICE TO DO US!
BUT THESE CLOWNS, IF THEY CAN'T HAVE IT THEIR WAY, THEY ARE
LIKE GOSSIPERS.
THEY ARE GARBAGE.
NOTHING MORE, NOTHING LESS.
STRAIGHT GARBAGE OPERATING IN THE HOOD.
WHERE IN THE HOOD CAN YOU GO.
ASK REAL AFRICANS IN HERE.
WHERE IN THE HOOD CAN YOU TALK OF CALLING THE POLICE ON
SOMEBODY.
IT IS CALLED SNITCHING.
AND BLACK PEOPLE DON'T DO IT.
EVEN WHEN OUR FAMILY MEMBERS GET KILLED.
BLACK PEOPLE DON'T DO IT.
DON'T TELL.
AM I RIGHT OR AM I WRONG?
WE DON'T DO IT.
A CLOWN!
CLOWN CENTRAL.
Y'ALL ARE ALLOWING IT TO HAPPEN.
DON'T GO ON HER SHOW ANYMORE BECAUSE REPRESENTATIVE OF THE
HATRED YOU HAVE FOR AFRICAN PEOPLE.
NOTHING MORE.
NOTHING LESS.
BEING USED AS A BAFOON AND A CLOWN.
THE OLDEST CIVIL RIGHTS ORGANIZATION IN THE HISTORY OF THE
WORLD TRYING TO TAKE SOMETHING AWAY FROM THEM.
THIS CITY OWE US TRILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN REPARATIONS AND WE
AIN'T GOT THAT!
AND A CLOWN DOWN HERE.
A SHE-MALE CLOWN TALKING ABOUT $100,000!
THE CITY OWES US THAT A HUNDRED TIMES OVER.
THEY OWE US AFRICAN PEOPLE THAT A HUNDRED TIMES OVER.
WE ARE 26% OF THE POPULATION.
STOP COMING DOWN HERE AND TALKING GARBAGE!
STOP COMING DOWN HERE TALKING OF SPEED BUMPS AND MONEY FOR
PARKS AND JUNETEENTH.
THAT IS GARBAGE.
THAT IS BEGGING.
NOW COMING DOWN WITH THAT CONFUSION.
BRINGING THAT CONFUSION OFF YOUR RADIO SHOW RIGHT DOWN TO
CITY COUNCIL.
IT IS NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.
NOT IN THIS CITY.
NOT IN THIS CITY, IT IS NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.
THANK YOU.
10:19:01AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
10:19:08AM >> WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE TALKING TO WITH YOUR
DISRESPECTFUL SELF.
10:19:15AM >> I AM NO BULLY; I AM AN AVERAGE GUY.
10:19:20AM >> GOOD MORNING, COUNCIL.
ROBIN LOCKETT.
HERE TO TALK ABOUT THE BILL OF RIGHTS.
I GOTTEN SEVERAL -- TENANT BILL OF RIGHTS.
I GOTTEN SEVERAL CALLS FROM COMMUNITY PEOPLE INDICATING THAT
FOR ONE WHOLE APARTMENT COMPLEX -- A LOT OF PEOPLE IN AN
APARTMENT COMPLEX, RATHER, THAT THIS APARTMENT COMPLEX IS NO
LONGER ACCEPTING VOUCHERS, SECTION 8.
GOT ANOTHER CALL FROM SEVERAL PEOPLE STATING THAT THEIR
LANDLORD WILL NO LONGER ACCEPT R-3 MONEY -- R-3 PROGRAM,
ASSISTANCE.
THEY WANT THE TENANTS TO PAY THE MONEY OUTRIGHT.
ISN'T THE TENANT PILL OF RIGHTS SUPPOSED TO PROTECT THEM
FROM THAT?
WHAT IS THE ENFORCEMENT ON IT.
HOW DO WE ENFORCE IT.
WE PUT ORDINANCES IN PLACE BUT NO ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM.
THAT IS WHAT IS NEEDED.
SO WE CAN PUT A LOT OF STUFF IN WRITING SAYING, HEY, AND THE
BIGGEST CONVERSATION TO DATE HAS BEEN GETTING INFORMATION
OUT TO THE COMMUNITY.
HOW MANY OF THOSE APARTMENT COMPLEXES KNOW THAT THIS IS --
THIS IS, IN FACT, AN ORDINANCE, SOMETHING THEY SHOULD BE
ABIDING BY.
HOW DO YOU GET THAT INFORMATION OUT?
SO IT IS A REAL PROBLEM WITH PUTTING THINGS IN WRITING WITH
NO -- NO ABILITY TO ENFORCE IT.
IT MAKES IT A WORTHLESS DOCUMENT.
10:20:56AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MR. CHAIRMAN.
10:20:58AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
10:21:00AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
IS MISS TRAVIS STILL HERE.
SHE IS THERE?
I HATE TO PUT YOU ON THE SPOT.
10:21:09AM >> HEY, MISS TRAVIS.
10:21:11AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
HI, MISS LOCKETT.
[LAUGHTER]
10:21:16AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
YOU HEARD MISS LOCKETT'S QUESTIONS?
10:21:20AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
YEP.
10:21:21AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
DO WE HAVE A RESPONSE FOR HER.
I KNOW YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL TO US.
THAT IS WHY I CALLED YOU UP.
10:21:27AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
THE TENANT BILL OF RIGHTS IS AN ORDINANCE
AND YOUR POWERS ARE LIMITED IN WHAT YOU CAN DO.
IT IS COMPLAINT-DRIVEN, NUMBER ONE.
SO PEOPLE HAVE TO FILE A COMPLAINT.
CODE ENFORCEMENT GOES OUT AND YOU GET A FINE.
AND THE MOST WE CAN FINE THE LANDLORD IS $450.
WHAT IS WRITTEN IN THE TENANT BILL OF RIGHTS IS HONESTLY THE
MOST THAT YOU CAN DO AS A LOCAL MUNICIPALITY.
WE DON'T HAVE THE POWER -- WE DON'T HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO DO
MORE THAN THAT.
BUT IT IS COMPLAINT-DRIVEN.
SO IF THERE ARE COMPLAINTS, LIKE SOME OF THE ONES THAT MISS
LOCKETT BROUGHT UP, THEY NEED TO CONTACT CODE ENFORCEMENT,
FILE THE COMPLAINT -- WE HAVE HAD SOME COME THROUGH.
IT IS COMPLAINT-DRIVEN AND WE WILL FOLLOW UP AND
INVESTIGATE.
BUT TO THINK THAT THE TENANT BILL OF RIGHTS IS GOING TO
SOLVE IT ALL, IT'S NOT.
10:22:25AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
ALL RIGHT, QUESTION NUMBER TWO.
I KNOW THEY HAVE THIS APARTMENT ASSOCIATION, CORRECT.
IS THE APARTMENT ASSOCIATION -- DO WE HAVE ANY LITERATURE TO
GIVE OUT TO THE APARTMENTS IN THE CITY TO KNOW THE RULES.
HAVE WE DONE THAT?
10:22:37AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
YES.
ACTUALLY OUR ATTORNEY, REBECCA JOHNS, HAS DONE TWO SEMINARS
WITH THE LANDLORDS AND THE RENTAL ASSOCIATIONS.
AND THEY HAVE PROVIDED INFORMATION TO THEM.
SO WE WENT THERE, GIVEN THEM THE INFORMATION.
SO, YES, WE HAVE PROVIDED THAT INFORMATION.
10:22:56AM >> ALL THE APARTMENT COMPLEXES?
10:22:59AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
NOT TO THE COMPLEX, HE WAS ASKING OF THE
ASSOCIATIONS.
10:23:02AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I GUESS THERE ARE TWO PARTS OF THAT.
IS IT POSSIBLE THAT MAYBE THE HOUSING DEPARTMENT OR -- CAN
CREATE SOME TYPE OF PALM CARD OR CARD THAT CAN BE TAKEN WITH
CODE ENFORCEMENT TO STOP BY THESE APARTMENT COMPLEXES AND
MAKE SURE THE APARTMENT COMPLEXES.
I AM SURE THE -- MR. VIERA'S DISTRICT BUT EVEN CALLING ME,
PEBBLE WOOD.
THEY KNOW WHAT THE RULES ARE AND WHAT -- WHAT THE ORDINANCES
ARE.
IS THAT POSSIBLE TO DO SOMETHING LIKE THAT?
10:23:33AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
YES, ABSOLUTELY.
IT IS ALWAYS POSSIBLE FOR US TO CREATE DIFFERENT WAYS TO GET
THE INFORMATION OUT TO THE PUBLIC.
WE CAN DEFINITELY GO AND CREATE A FLIER.
WE HAVE A FLIER WITH INFORMATION AS FAR AS RESOURCES.
BUT WE CAN ALSO CREATE SOME KIND OF EDUCATION MATERIAL ON IF
YOU FEEL LIKE YOU HAVE BEEN DISCRIMINATED AGAINST.
IF YOU FEEL LIKE YOUR APARTMENT IS SUBSTANDARD AND PROVIDE
THAT IN A DIFFERENT LITERATURE.
WE CAN WORK ON THAT.
10:24:01AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
LOOKING -- THAT TOO.
BUT MAKING SURE THAT THE APARTMENT MANAGEMENT KNOWS THAT
THERE IS AN ORDINANCE, A RULE IN THE CITY, AND THAT WAY WHEN
CODE ENFORCEMENT GO -- TO THESE APARTMENTS, THEY CAN HAND
THAT OUT.
10:24:13AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
I SEE WHAT YOU ARE SAYING.
ONCE A COMPLAINT IS MADE, ONCE CODE ENFORCEMENT COMES OUT --
LITERATURE TO GIVE TO THE APARTMENT MANAGER IS WHAT YOU ARE
SAYING.
10:24:22AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
OR JUST -- IT DOESN'T HAVE TO BE A
COMPLAINT.
ON THEIR REGULAR DUTIES AS THEY ARE DRIVING AROUND AND HAVE
AN APARTMENT -- AN APARTMENT COMPLEX IN THEIR AREA TO HAND
IT AND -- GIVE THAT TO THEM SO THEY WILL KNOW.
MAYBE SOMETIMES THE APARTMENT PEOPLE ARE OUT OF STATE AND
SOMEBODY IN THE OFFICE WHO ARE RUN IT AND THEY DON'T KNOW
FOR THEMSELVES.
TO HAVE SOMETHING TO KNOCK ON THE DOOR OF THE APARTMENT
COMPLEX MANAGER.
HERE IS THE ORDINANCE.
SO THEY WILL BE INFORMED.
10:24:51AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
WE WILL WORK ON THAT.
10:24:53AM >> SO QUESTION.
SO THE CODE ENFORCEMENT CAN GO TO AN APARTMENT COMPLEX MORE
THAN FOUR UNITS?
10:25:02AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
YES.
THEY CAN GO.
BUT IN ORDER FOR THEM TO -- IN ORDER FOR CODE ENFORCEMENT TO
GO INTO AN APARTMENT, SOMEONE HAS TO INVITE THEM INTO THE
APARTMENT.
SO IF A TENANT IS IN THE APARTMENT AND THEY HAVE A COMPLAINT
ABOUT THEIR UNIT BEING SUBSTANDARD, THEY HAVE TO INVITE CODE
ENFORCEMENT IN.
CODE ENFORCEMENT WILL DOCUMENT IT.
THEY WILL -- THEY WILL PROVIDE A VIOLATION.
BUT WE ALSO SEND IT TO THE STATE.
SO, YES.
10:25:31AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
THANK YOU.
10:25:33AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
ANY MORE QUESTIONS OF PROCESS?
GOOD SEEING YOU.
10:25:40AM >> YOU TOO.
I GUESS THAT IS SETTLED -- WE WILL SEE IF IT IS SETTLED.
HOPEFULLY -- I TRUST -- I TRUST THAT YOU WILL.
OKAY.
THAT IS ALL I NEEDED.
THANK YOU.
10:25:50AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
10:25:51AM >> GOOD MORNING, CONNIE BURTON.
I JUST WANT TO SAY THE REASON WE DON'T TELL IS WE KNOW WE
DON'T RECEIVE JUSTICE.
WE DON'T GET JUSTICE HERE.
WE DON'T GET JUSTICE IN THE COURTHOUSE.
SO THE COMMUNITY HAS TRIED TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO SOLVE OUR
OWN ISSUES.
ONE OF THE BIGGEST PROBLEMS THAT I WANT TO SPEAK TO QUICKLY
IS THAT THE CITY SHOULD NOT BE THE ONE THAT CONTROLS THE
LEGAL COUNSEL OF AN INDONESIA PENITENTIARY COUNSEL.
THE CITY AND THE MAYOR MADE A DETERMINATION EVEN WHEN
CHOOSING WHO THE NAACP WOULD SEND TO REPRESENT THE INTEREST
OF OTHER COMMUNITIES.
SHE WOULD HAVE A HAND IN THAT AS WELL SO NO INDEPENDENT
AROUND -- INDEPENDENCE AROUND THE BOARD OR THIS COMMUNITY.
THE VERY LEAST THIS COUNCIL CAN DO IS LIFT YOURSELF UP WITH
REAL TRANSPARENCY AND SAY THAT THE CITIZENS OF THIS
COMMUNITY SHOULD HAVE A RIGHT TO UP OR DOWN THAT VOTE AND
THAT COUNSEL SHOULD BE INDEPENDENTLY CHOSEN BY THE CITIZEN
REVIEW BOARD.
NOTHING ON YOUR AGENDA TODAY SPOKE TO THE NAACP ISSUE.
I WOULD HAVE RESPECTED THE ADMINISTRATION THAT IF YOU DIDN'T
WANT TO GIVE THE NAACP ANY MONEY, DON'T GIVE IT TO THEM.
FOR SO LONG THE NAACP HAS BEEN ABLE TO WORK WITH A LIMITED
BUDGET NOW WHAT WE SEE THAT THE ADMINISTRATION HAS HIRED
OUTSIDE SOURCES TO DO THEIR WORK.
IT'S AWFUL.
IT IS HYPOCRITICAL.
THE COMMUNITY IS SUFFERING.
WHETHER IT IS AROUND THE ISSUE OF NOT HAVING AFFORDABLE
HOUSING IN EAST TAMPA.
ALL WE SEE IN EAST TAMPA IS A TEMPERATURE IN OF HOUSES THAT
WE WILL NEVER BE ABLE TO PURCHASE.
$300,000, $450,000 NEXT TO HOUSES THAT NEED, WHAT?
REAL REHAB.
AND WE CAN'T GET THAT DONE.
FOR THE LAST FIVE YEARS, WE HAVE BEEN TRYING TO PUSH A REHAB
BILL THAT IS ALMOST LIKE A SHELL GAME.
IT IS NOT BEING DONE.
SO WHAT I AM BELIEVING NOW IS AN UNDERMINING ATTEMPT TO
REMOVE ALL POOR PEOPLE OUT OF EAST TAMPA.
BECAUSE IT IS THE CLOSEST THEY CAN BE TO YBOR, THE
RIVERWALK, FRIENDS OF THE RIVER, WHATEVER YOU WANT TO CALL
IT, WE ARE NOT ENJOYING ANY OF THE BENEFIT.
THE PERSON WHO HAS HAD THE SHORTEST MEMBERSHIP OF THE NAACP
RECEIVED A SUSPENSION FROM THE NATIONAL.
YOU KNOW WHY?
BECAUSE THE NATIONAL IS NOT GOING TO ALLOW A MICHELLE PATTY
TO CONTROL THE NAACP.
THAT IS REAL.
SO HOPEFULLY YOU DON'T GET CAUGHT UP IN IT AND LET THE NAACP
AND ITS LEGAL COUNSEL DEAL WITH THE MICHELLE PATTYS OF THIS
WORLD.
THANK YOU.
10:29:07AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
10:29:08AM >> SIT DOWN.
10:29:13AM >> YOU SIT DOWN.
10:29:14AM >> DON'T THINK WHO YOU IS.
10:29:17AM >> MICHELLE B. PATTY.
10:29:19AM >> NOTHING.
10:29:20AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
PLEASE.
THANK YOU.
MR. ROBINSON.
10:30:06AM >> YOU HAVE THE DOCUMENTS.
I WANT THOSE DOCUMENTS RECEIVED AND FILED IN THE PUBLIC
RECORDS BY THE CITY COUNCIL, WHENEVER YOU ACCEPT THOSE.
I WANT THOSE RECEIVED AND FILED.
FIRST OF ALL, I AM JOE ROBINSON, AND I AM NOT A CONVICTED
FELON.
DO NOT LET CONVICTED FELONS SIT HERE AND TELL YOU WHAT
TAXPAYERS WHO PAY THEIR TAXES WANT OR DON'T WANT.
I AM NOT A CONVICTED FELON.
I AM NOT A CONVICTED FELON.
WHOM THE GODS MAKE ANGRY.
CHARLIE IS RIGHT ON THE FIRST ISSUE ABOUT WATER ISSUES.
I WANT TO SAY LET THE SCIENCE, THE PRO IF EGGSAL ENGINEERS,
THE PEOPLE THAT KNOW ABOUT WATER DICTATE THIS, NOT POLITICS.
LET'S LOOK AT POSSIBILITY LIKE THEY SAID CHANGING SENATE
BILL 64.
NO PRESSURE THERE.
THE REASON THAT SERVE IS ARGUING ABOUT IT BECAUSE WE SAID
THAT THE STATUTE SAYS WE GOT TO DO SOMETHING.
LET'S TRY TO CHANGE THE STATUTE.
THAT IS A COMPROMISE.
OTHERWISE I SAT ON S.W.F.W.M.D. BASIN BOARD.
I KNOW ABOUT WATER, RECLAIMED WATER AND ALL THE MONEY FOR
THE CITY TO GET TO WHERE THEY ARE AT.
20 YEARS AGO, RIGHT, CHARLIE?
NOW LET'S GET TO WHY I'M HERE.
I'M HERE BECAUSE I AM ASK CITY COUNCIL MAKE A MOTION THAT
TAMPA CITY COUNCIL WILL REQUEST FOR A FORENSIC AUDIT OF
THE NAACP, HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY BRANCH FINANCES AND BE
PROVIDED TO THEM BY THE NAACP, HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY BRANCH AT
THE BRANCH'S EXPENSE.
AND SAMPLE CITY COUNCIL SHOULD REQUEST AN AUDIT BE PERFORMED
OF THE CITY AUDITORS OF FUNDS GIVEN TO THE NAACP
HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY BRANCH OF THE LAST THREE YEARS OF THE
2023 BUDGET OF $100,000 BE RELEASED TO THE HILLSBOROUGH
COUNTY BRANCH.
THE REASON ABOVE REQUEST FOR THE CITY COUNCIL FROM THE
FINANCES OF THE NAACP BRANCH AND THAT IT BE AN AUDIT FOR THE
LAST THREE YEARS IS BECAUSE THE TAMPA CITY COUNCIL'S
POSSIBILITY FOR TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY, MR. CARSON,
FOR TAXPAYER DOLLARS BEING BUDGETED, RECEIVED, AND SPENT BY
NONPROFIT PUBLIC CHARITY ENTITIES WITH FUNDS COME FROM THE
CITY'S BUDGET.
THE ATTACHED PRESS RELEASE DATED NOVEMBER 16 THAT YOU ALL
HAVE AND ASKED TO BE RECEIVED AND FILED GIVE MORE REASONS
WHY THIS SHOULD BE CONDUCTED.
IF YOU LOOK AT THE PAGE -- THE SECOND PAGE OF THE AUDIT'S
REQUEST IN YELLOW.
IN YELLOW.
IN YELLOW.
IN YELLOW.
IT SAYS, QUOTE, WE ARE NOT ENGAGED TO AND DID NOT CONDUCT AN
AUDIT FOR REVIEWING ENGAGEMENT THAT IS EXPRESSION OF AN
OPINION OR CONCLUSION.
NO AUDIT DONE.
REVIEW IN ITS ISSUES, AND I TAKE OFFENSE IS EVERYBODY
TALKING OF JOE ROBINSON AND THE FBI.
NOW THE FBI WILL BE INVOKED NOW BY SAYING WHAT YOU SAID, YOU
ACCIDENTALLY COME TO INVESTIGATE.
PLEASE DO NOT BE PART OF PUBLIC CORRUPTION OR AIDING AND
ABETTING IN THE EFFORT BY THE NAACP.
NOT THE ORGANIZATION, THE PUBLIC CORRUPT INDIVIDUALS.
10:33:20AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
ANYONE ELSE IN CHAMBERS WHO WISH TO SPEAK DURING PUBLIC
COMMENT?
10:33:27AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MR. CHAIRMAN.
MR. CHAIRMAN.
10:33:30AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
10:33:32AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I DIDN'T WANT TO SAY ANYTHING, BUT THERE
ARE SOME ISSUES THAT ARE HAPPENING OVER THERE AND IT IS
UNFORTUNATE.
THE LONGEST BLACK ORGANIZATION THAT STANDS UP FOR THE RIGHTS
OF PEOPLE, AS YOU ALL KNOW.
ALL PEOPLE.
NO MATTER WHAT.
I DID RECEIVE A MESSAGE THAT THE NATIONAL OFFICE WILL BE IN
TOWN.
ALL THE BIG WIGS ARE COMING IN TOWN.
AND MY UNDERSTANDING IS THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE AN OPEN
INVITATION -- IF IT IS A CLOSED MEETING, I WILL UNDERSTAND,
BUT ALL ELECTED OFFICIALS TO HAVE QUESTIONS OF THE NAACP
AGENDA.
I DON'T KNOW WHEN THAT IS COMING BUT A FEW WEEKS THEY WILL
BE HERE IN TAMPA TO DEAL WITH ANY ISSUES MUCH THE LOCAL
BRANCH OR ANY QUESTIONS THAT PEOPLE MAY HAVE AND I AM
INFORMED WITH THAT.
10:34:24AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
WILL THEY BE REACHING OUT TO US?
10:34:27AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MY UNDERSTANDING THEY WILL BE REACHING OUT
TO ELECTED OFFICIALS WHO MAY WANT TO ASK QUESTIONS.
AT THAT TIME IF ANYBODY HAVE ANY QUESTION -- I DON'T KNOW
WHICH NATIONAL OFFICERS ARE COMING -- I DON'T KNOW IF IT IS
PRESIDENT -- BUT I WAS INFORMED THAT THE NATIONAL OFFICE IS
COMING TO TAMPA TO, I GUESS, TALK AND SEE WHAT IS GOING ON.
10:34:47AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MR. SHELBY.
10:34:49AM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THAT TO COUNCIL'S
ATTENTION, COUNCILMAN GUDES.
I WILL JUST ASK BASED JUST WHAT I AM HEARING, I BE KEPT IN
THE LOOP.
I DON'T WANT ANY SUNSHINE ISSUES.
CERTAINLY SOMETHING THAT IS RELEVANT TO CITY COUNCIL AND
PUBLIC BUSINESS, SO I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT EVERYBODY'S
BASES ARE COVERED.
SO I APPRECIATE YOUR AWARENESS AND BRINGING IT TO MY
ATTENTION.
THANK YOU.
10:35:12AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANYONE ELSE IN CHAMBERS THAT WOULD LIKE TO
MAKE ANY COMMENTS DURING PUBLIC COMMENT?
SEEING NONE.
I BELIEVE WE HAVE THREE MEMBERS -- THREE PEOPLE WHO WISH TO
SPEAK VIRTUALLY.
MR. RANDOLPH, ARE YOU THERE?
10:35:30AM >> YES, GOOD MORNING.
HOW IS EVERYBODY TODAY.
I'M HERE FOR A FOLLOW-UP TO THE MEETING WE GAVE ON OCTOBER
31.
REDUCING STREET VIOLENCE, A NATIONAL APPROACH.
HEALTH, PUBLIC SAFETY, SOCIO AND ECONOMICAL DEVELOPMENT,
CONNECTING THE DOTS.
I WILL DO A FOLLOW-UP MEETING ON DECEMBER 30 AT 6 P.M. WE
GOT A LOT OF FOLKS WHO ARE IN THE COMMUNITY THAT COULDN'T
MAKE THAT MEETING, BUT THEY WANTED US TO DO AN EVENING
MEETING AND WE WILL DO THAT ON DECEMBER 30 AT 6 P.M. AS YOU
KNOW THE LEVEL OF VIOLENCE IS NOT STOPPING.
ANY TIME YOU READ THE NEWSPAPER IT INCREASED.
USING IMPROPER THAT ATTRACT, EXCITE, EDUCATE AND TRANSFORM
THE ALL CORE YOUTH ON THE CORNER.
I AM ASKING EVERYBODY THAT CAN ATTEND THAT PARTICULAR
MEETING TO LEARN ABOUT WHAT IS GOING ON ACROSS THE COUNTRY
IN TERMS OF REDUCING THE LEVEL OF VIOLENCE.
I WANT TO PERSONALLY THANK COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK FOR ATTENDING
THAT MEETING.
I APPRECIATE YOU ATTENDED THAT MEETING.
THAT WAS A NATIONAL MEETING WITH PEOPLE FROM AROUND THE
COUNTRY TO TALK ABOUT HOW TO REDUCE VIOLENCE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:36:46AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
MISS STROHMEYER.
10:36:51AM >> GOOD MORNING.
10:36:55AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
GOOD MORNING.
10:36:56AM >> YEAH, MY NAME IS JEAN STROHMEYER, SOUTH OF GANDY FOR 31
YEARS.
TAMPA FOR 52 YEARS.
I AM CALLING -- I AM JUST GOING TO GO OVER THE AGENDA A
LITTLE BIT BUT I WAS SHOCKED ABOUT NUMBER 7 THAT WAS EVEN ON
THE AGENDA BECAUSE Y'ALL KNOW, I ENCOURAGE THE AGENDA, AND I
DON'T HAVE TIME TO GO INTO EACH AND EVERY ITEM, BUT WHEN
THAT WAS BEING DISCUSSED AS I WAS COMING BACK FROM WALKING
MY DOG, I WAS ABSOLUTELY SHOCKED.
Y'ALL SEEN THE E-MAIL THAT I SENT BECAUSE I WAS REALLY UPSET
ABOUT THAT, NOT KNOWING BASED ON WHAT IT SAID ON THE LITTLE
BLURB THAT YOU ALL HAVE.
PLEASE MAKE THAT MORE CLEAR.
I APPRECIATE THAT.
AND ON THE AGENDA.
STORMWATER UPDATE.
I WILL LISTEN TO THAT UNLESS YOU DID IT WHEN I WAS WALKING
MY DOG.
I DON'T THINK SO.
WE HAVE -- LET'S SEE, TEN.
BLOOMBERG, I AM DYING TO HEAR THAT ONE.
NUMBER 11, TENANT ADVOCACY REPORT.
I AM LISTENING TO THAT.
BUT ALL THESE -- NUMBER 13 AND THE OTHER ONES REQUESTING
ATTORNEYS TO REPRESENT THEM BY OUR TAX DOLLARS.
I JUST AM NOT OKAY WITH THAT.
I JUST DON'T THINK -- AND THEN -- I DO BELIEVE THE CITY
COUNCIL SHOULD BE -- YOU KNOW, HAVE THEIR ATTORNEYS, YOU
KNOW, SEPARATE BASED ON WHAT HAPPENED TO COUNCILMAN
DINGFELDER.
I THINK NOT ALL THESE UNELECTED GROUPS NEED TO HAVE THEIR
OWN ATTORNEYS PAID FOR BY YOURS TRULY.
I WANT YOU TO PAY FOR MY ATTORNEY FOR ANYTHING I NEED.
I DON'T THINK THAT IS RIGHT.
LET'S SEE.
HILLSBOROUGH RIVER.
I SPOKE WITH A GUY ABOUT THE HILLSBOROUGH RIVER, AND HE USED
TO WORK FOR HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY, SCIENTIST GUY, AND HE SAID
THAT THE SPRAYING WE DO IN THE RIVER IT REALLY BAD FOR THE
RIVER.
HE SUGGEST THAT OTHER CITIES ARE ACTUALLY REMOVING THEIR
DAMS, AS FAR AS THE MINIMUM FLOWS AND ALL THAT.
I DON'T KNOW IF THAT IS IS AN OPTIONS FOR DOING SOMETHING TO
BETTER THAT.
BUT APART RENTSLY THERE ARE TWO THINGS THAT WAS BROUGHT TO
MY ATTENTION RECENTLY.
ONE IS THAT WE ARE USING THE RIVER FOR HEAT IT SHALL WHAT IT
CALLED, ENERGY THAT IS HEATING UP THE RIVER WAY TOO HOT FOR
THE WILDLIFE AND THIS HEAT IS WHAT CAUSING THESE ALGAE
BLOOMS AND THINGS LIKE THAT.
TWO DIFFERENT ISSUES I SPOKE WITH TWO DIFFERENT PEOPLE ABOUT
THE WATER AND I WOULD LIKE THAT LOOKED INTO.
I THINK THAT IS KIND OF IT AND THANK YOU.
HAVE A GREAT DAY.
10:39:38AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
I SEE CARROLL ANN BENNETT IS ON THE LIST; HOWEVER, SHE IS IN
THE AUDIENCE.
DO WE HAVE ANYBODY ELSE ONLINE?
YES, I AM SORRY, MISS MATZ, ARE YOU THERE?
10:39:53AM >>CLERK:
MISS MATZ, PLEASE UNMUTE YOURSELF.
10:39:56AM >> THANK YOU, MY NAME IS MARY MATZ.
AND I AM --[ INAUDIBLE ]
-- MY EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND INCLUDES A MASTER IN SCIENCE
AND INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE WITH A MINOR IS ENVIRONMENTAL
SCIENCES.
AND I AM A MEMBER OF THE PURE STAKEHOLDER GROUP AND A MEMBER
OF THE TAMPA BAY SIERRA CLUB.
AND I AM SPEAKING ON ITEM NUMBER 7.
I SUPPORT THE RECOMMENDATIONS LAID OUT BY MR. FLANNERY IN
THE DOCUMENT THAT YOU WILL SOON RECEIVE AND THAT IS
SUPPORTED BY THE STAKEHOLDER GROUP.
I ASK YOU TO MAKE A FORMAL REQUEST TO SUPPORT LEGISLATION
THAT INCLUDES RECOMMENDATIONS IN YOUR 2023 LEGISLATIVE
PRIORITIES.
GREAT POTENTIAL FOR SERIOUS UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES THAT THE
STATUTE NOW READS.
I WILL ADDRESS THE TWO RECOMMENDATIONS FROM FLORIDA FLANNERY
ON SENATE BILL 64.
FIRST OF ALL, ESTUARIES PROVIDE A NURSERY AND HABITAT FOR
IMPORTANT FISH AND SHELLFISH SPECIES.
COMMON SENSE TO SEE THAT STOPPING THE DISCHARGE OF A LARGE
AMOUNT OF WATER FLOW INTO TAMPA BAY THAT HAS BEEN OCCURRING
FOR MANY, MANY YEARS TO CRITICALLY HARM OUR ESTUARY SYSTEM.
A DISTURBING PART OF SENATE BILL 64 IS THAT IT DOESN'T EVEN
ADDRESS ESTUARINE BODIES OF WATER THAT ARE IMPACTED.
NEW LEGISLATION MUST BE PROPOSED TO ADDRESS THESE MISSING
ELEMENTS.
ALSO ITEM TWO, WE LIVE IN FLORIDA.
EXCUSE ME.
ITEM 7, BUT ANOTHER POINT IS THAT WE LIVE IN FLORIDA AND WE
ALL KNOW A LARGE FLUCTUATION OF RAINFALL THROUGHOUT THE YEAR
CREATING VARIATIONS IN OUR HYDROLOGIC MISSIONS.
AS WELL, WE ALSO KNOW OUR WATER QUALITY FLUCTUATES DEPENDING
ON MANY FACTORS BOTH INDUSTRY AND ENVIRONMENTAL WITH A
AMOUNT OF YOU HAVE FLUENT TO BE REPURPOSED, AND CONDITIONS
SUCH AS SUMMER RAINS BLESS THE MILLIONS OF GALLONS OF WATER
MAY OVERWHELMING A SURFACE WATER SYSTEM THAT ASSISTS THAT
EXTRA WATER.
IN COMMON SENSE TO ALLOW FOR VARIATIONS IN QUANTITY FEES OF
EFFLUENT DISCHARGE TO BE REROUTED OR REUSED.
AND I AM ASKING YOU TO PLEASE SUPPORT LEGISLATION THAT
INCLUDES THESE RECOMMENDATIONS IN YOUR 2023 LEGISLATIVE
PRIORITIES.
AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
10:42:46AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
DO WE HAVE ANYONE ELSE ONLINE?
THANK YOU, MISS SULING.
MISS TRAVIS.
10:42:55AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
GOOD MORNING.
10:43:01AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
GOOD MORNING.
WE WILL PULL AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 41 FOR DISCUSSION AT YOUR
REQUEST.
IF.
10:43:13AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
GOOD MORNING, COUNCIL.
NICOLE TRAVIS, DEVELOPMENT ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY.
MY PLEASURE TO BRING DAVID INGRAM FOR CONFIRMATION AND A
RESIDENCY OF OUR NEW EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE TAMPA
CONVENTION CENTER.
I ASK THAT YOU EXPEDITIOUSLY CONFIRM HIM SO HE DOESN'T RUN
AWAY AFTER SITTING HERE THIS MORNING.
SO DAVID SPENT MOST OF HIS -- HE IS A TAMPA NATIVE.
HE WENT TO HIGH SCHOOL IN TAMPA.
HE WENT TO USF.
GO BULLS.
10:43:45AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
GO BULLS.
10:43:47AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
DAVID SPENT MOST OF HIS HOSPITALITY CAREER
OVER AT THE ORLANDO CONVENTION CENTER AS RECENTLY AS GENERAL
MANAGER ACTING -- I AM PROBABLY GOING TO BUTCHER IT -- I AM
BUTCHERING IT.
ACTING EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR AND WORKED HIS WAY UP TO DO GREAT
THINGS AND WE ARE ECSTATIC HE IS HERE.
HIS FIRST DAY IS ON MONDAY.
COUNCIL, I APPRECIATE IT.
SOME OF YOU HAVE MET WITH DAVID ALREADY AND SOME HAVE PUT
CALENDAR APPOINTMENTS TO MEET WITH HIM IN THE FUTURE.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR INDULGENCE AND MR. INGRAM.
10:44:22AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MR. INGRAM, LIKE TO TAKE A COUPLE OF MINUTES
AND SHARE YOUR WORDS.
10:44:27AM >> THAT THANK YOU FIRST AND FOR MOST FOR THIS
RECOMMENDATION.
GLAD TO BE BACK IN TAMPA SURROUNDED BY BLACK AND COLD FOR 20
YEARS.
GOOD TO BE BACK IN GREEN AND GOLD COUNTRY.
I WANT TO THANK MY STAFF WHO IS HERE TODAY.
THEY HAVE DONE A GREAT JOB WELCOMING ME.
SUCH A GREAT EXPERIENCE COMING IN AND LOOKING FORWARD TO
WORKING WITH ALL OF YOU.
ANYTHING YOU NEED FEEL FREE TO REACH OUT TO ME ONCE I GET MY
CELL PHONE AND EVERYTHING SETTLED, I WILL BE MORE THAN HAPPY
TO TAKE CARE OF ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU NEED.
IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, FEEL FREE.
10:44:58AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
10:45:00AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
I HAVE A PLEASURE TO MEET WITH YOU THE
OTHER DAY.
AND YOU HAVE VERY IMPRESSIVE BACKGROUND AND RESUME.
I KNOW YOU WILL HIT THE GROUND RUNNING WITH THE EXPERIENCE
YOU HAVE, THE PEOPLE YOU WORKED WITH AND FOR, AND IN THE
DIFFERENT COMMUNITIES.
SO WE ARE GLAD THAT YOU ARE HERE.
AND WE WISH YOU THE BEST OF LUCK.
10:45:18AM >> APPRECIATE IT.
10:45:19AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
10:45:21AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
WELCOME.
WE ARE THRILLED TO HAVE YOU.
CAN'T WAIT.
WE KNOW WE HAVE SOME REN VIOLATIONS GOING ON.
SO WE ARE EXCITED WHAT IS GOING.
AND REALLY LOOKING FORWARD TO HAVING FRESH EYES.
AND I -- I AM SO GLAD YOUR TEAM WAS ABLE TO COME.
THEY ALL LOOK VERY HAPPY.
SO I -- CONGRATULATIONS AND I LOOK FORWARD TO MEETING WITH
YOU AND TALKING TO YOU ABOUT HOW YOU ARE GOING TO MAKE OUR
WONDERFUL CONVENTION CENTER EVEN BETTER.
10:45:45AM >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
IF IT WASN'T FOR THEM IN, I WOULDN'T BE SUCCESSFUL WITHOUT
THE STAFF.
REALLY ALL ON THEM.
10:45:51AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
EXACTLY.
10:45:52AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MR. MIRANDA.
10:45:54AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
YOU HAVE BEEN HERE AN HOUR AND 45 MINUTES
AND MORE IN THAT HOUR AND 45 MINUTES THAN ANYONE HERE CAN
EVER PUT INTO YOUR HEAD.
AND I KNOW YOU COME FROM A CONVENTION CENTER, ABOUT SIX
TIMES LARGER THAN OURS, OVER MILLION.
OURS IS 220,000 SQUARE FEET.
BY EXPERIENCE, YOU ARE VERY SMART, BECAUSE YOU DIDN'T
MENTION WHICH HIGH SCHOOL.
10:46:14AM >> GAITHER HIGH SCHOOL.
10:46:15AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
NEVER HEARD OF THEM.
10:46:20AM >> WHAT?
OH!
10:46:22AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
GO FALCONS.
10:46:24AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
I UNDERSTAND OF THAT.
I AM ONLY JOKING WITH YOU.
I COME FROM JULYJE AND -- YOU FIGURE IT OUT.
SINCERITY.
20 YEARS, WE LOST ONE OF OUR SECOND OF COMMAND TO OUR
CONVENTION CENTER TO YOUR CONVENTION CENTER.
NOW OUR CONVENTION CENTER IS GETTING ONE OF YOURS, SO
CONGRATULATIONS.
10:46:47AM >> JUST A QUICK STORY.
ORANGE COUNTY, I HAD TO SIT THROUGH A THREE-HOUR PUBLIC
COMMENT BEFORE THEY WENT TO CONSENT AGENDA.
THIS WAS PRETTY EASY TODAY.
10:46:57AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
I HATE TO LIVE WHERE YOU CAME FROM.
10:46:59AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
10:47:01AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
WELL, YOU COME HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
MISS TRAVIS IS EXCITED WITH YOU COMING HERE AND APPARENTLY
YOU ALREADY HIT THE GROUND RUNNING, MY UNDERSTANDING.
NORMALLY I LIKE TO MEET THE CANDIDATES BEFORE WE COME HERE,
BUT MISS TRAVIS SAID THAT THEY CALLED MY OFFICE, BUT I
DIDN'T HAVE A CHANCE TO GET BACK.
I APOLOGIZE FOR NOT PERSONALLY HAD A CHANCE TO MEET WITH YOU
AND I LIKE TO MEET THE CANDIDATES BEFORE I MAKE A VOTE.
I TRUST MISS TRAVIS' RECOMMENDATION, WHEN I LOOK AT THE
ORLANDO AREA, I SAY TAMPA IS GROWN AND WE ARE BEHIND IN
TIMES WITH ORLANDO WITH THE THINGS THEY HAVE GOT GOING ON.
BUT WE ARE TRYING TO CATCH UP.
WITH YOUR EXPERTISE OF HAVING LARGE CONVENTIONS TO BRING A
GREAT ECONOMIC IMPACT IN THAT AREA TO YOUR KNOWLEDGE IS
GOING TO HAPPEN HERE.
EVERYONE GOES TO ORLANDO FOR CONVENTIONS.
FINALLY GET MY -- MY FRATERNITY WILL BE THE NEXT ONE TO HAVE
A BIG CONCLAVE AND SOME ARE RIGHT BEHIND US.
WE ARE GLAD TO SEE WE ARE MOVING IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION AND
HOPEFULLY GET US TO THE TOP PINNACLE LIKE ORANGE COUNTY.
10:48:05AM >> AS LONG AS I HAVE YOUR SUPPORT, WE WILL MOVE THAT
FORWARD.
10:48:10AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
10:48:11AM >>BILL CARLSON:
I SPENT A LOT OF TIME IN THE ORLANDO
CONVENTION CENTER.
THE PROPERTY WAS RUN VERY WELL.
I HAVEN'T HAD A CHANCE TO MEET YOU.
WE HAVE SOMETHING ON THE CALENDAR AND TRYING TO SCHEDULE
SOMETHING.
I TRUST NICOLE'S JUDGMENT AND I HAVE SEEN YOUR BACKGROUND,
IT IS VERY IMPRESSIVE.
MY ONLY REQUEST THAT YOU HELP US BRING STAR WARS CELEBRATION
-- PUT US IN ROTATION.
I KNOW WE ARE TOO SMALL FOR IT, BUT THERE ARE -- THERE ARE
OTHER VENUES WE CAN WORK WITH TO MAKE IT HAPPEN.
LET'S WORK TOGETHER AND GET THAT.
10:48:40AM >> I AM A BIG STAR WARS FAN AS WELL.
I WORKED THAT SHOW TWICE WHEN IT WAS IN ORLANDO SO WE WILL
SEE WHAT WE WILL DO.
10:48:47AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
IF THAT A MOTION, I WILL SECOND.
[LAUGHTER]
10:48:50AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
CONGRATULATIONS.
WHAT A TIME TO PROVE YOURSELF.
YOU HAVE GOT RENOVATIONS AND REMODELS GOING ON.
THE HOLIDAY SEASON.
JUMP IN THE WATER.
IT'S FINE.
WELCOME ABOARD.
10:49:03AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
MOVE 41.
10:49:06AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
YOU WANT TO MOVE IT NOW?
MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
ANY OPPOSED?
CONGRATULATIONS.
10:49:16AM >> THANK YOU.
[APPLAUSE]
10:49:20AM >> IF YOU DON'T MIND, I WILL TAKE THE STAFF BACK.
10:49:23AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
GET BACK TO WORK, WILL YOU.
[LAUGHTER]
THANK YOU.
10:49:27AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
THANK YOU, SIR.
NEXT ITEM I HAVE FOR YOU -- THANK YOU, GUYS.
THANK YOU.
THE NEXT ITEM I HAVE FOR YOU IS A WALK-ON ITEM.
I HAVE SPOKEN TO EACH OF YOU ABOUT THIS ITEM.
THIS IS A MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT BETWEEN BELMAR
PARTNERS LLP AND THE CITY OF TAMPA.
WHAT IT IS THAT WE ARE ASKING -- THIS PROPERTY HAS A
HISTORIC STRUCTURE ON IT.
IT IS A NATIONAL LANDMARK.
IT IS NOT LOCALLY DESIGNATED.
NOT IN A HISTORIC DISTRICTS HERE.
BUT BECAUSE OF THAT, IN ORDER FOR THE PROPERTY TO BE
REDEVELOPED, THERE HAS TO BE A NOTICING PERIOD FOR 30 DAYS
THAT THE DEMOLITION OF THE HISTORIC STRUCTURE WILL TAKE
PLACE AND THAT THE REDEVELOPMENT OF THAT PROPERTY WOULD BE
100 AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS.
THIS CAME TO YOU BACK IN 2021 IN YOUR ACTION PLAN.
IT RECENTLY CAME IN AN AGREEMENT SOME TIME OVER THE SUMMER.
FOR YOU TO -- FOR THAT FUNDING AGREEMENT AND OUR
PARTICIPATION IN THIS AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROJECT.
SO I -- WE DON'T LIKE TO DO WALK-ONES UNLESS THEY ARE TIME
SENSITIVE AND CONSIDERATION THAT THIS IS AFFORDABLE HOUSING
PROJECT AND THE WEEK OF THANKSGIVING, WE FOUND OUT THE DATE
OF THE CLOSING IN JANUARY.
SO IN ORDER TO KEEP THAT CLOSING DATE, WE ARE RESPECTFULLY
ASKING FOR YOUR APPROVAL OF THIS MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT SO
WE CAN CONTINUE TO MOVE FORWARD WITH THIS REDEVELOPMENT
PROJECT.
10:51:05AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
10:51:08AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MISS TRAVIS.
AS MUCH AS I HATE DEMOLISHING ANYTHING OF HISTORIC
SIGNIFICANCE, I DRIVE BY THIS.
THIS HAS -- THIS WILL NOT AFFECT MY DECISION.
I DRIVE BY THIS EVERY DAY WHEN I TAKE MY STEPDAUGHTER TO
SCHOOL.
ONE OF THOSE MIDCENTURY STRUCTURES.
I EVEN PHOTOGRAPHED IT AND PUT IT ON SOCIAL MEDIA OF ALL THE
CHURCHES IN THE AREA.
A HEAVILY POPULATED AREA; HOWEVER, I DON'T KNOW HOW THE --
HOW THE -- THE STORY OF THE CHURCH, THE CONGREGATION, HOW
LONG IT HAS BEEN OPERABLE, WHATEVER.
BUT THE BRIGHT SIDE IS -- AGAIN, YOU KNOW, I AM ABOUT
HISTORIC PRESERVATION, BUT THE BRIGHT SIDE IS 100 -- EVEN
THOUGH WE NEED 10,000 OR MORE AFFORDABLE UNITS, THIS MOVES
US FORWARD TOWARD THAT GOAL OF PROVIDING AFFORDABLE HOUSING
IN AN AREA THAT IS VERY DESIRABLE.
IN A GOOD PART OF TOWN.
SO, YOU KNOW, I UNDERSTAND THE TRADE-OFF HERE AS MUCH AS.
AS I AM HESITANT AND I HATE TO SEE ANYTHING DEMOLISHED BUT
FOR A GOOD PUBLIC PURPOSE.
AND SEVERE NECESSITY THAT WE OBVIOUSLY NEED WITH AFFORDABLE
HOUSING.
10:52:20AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
TO YOUR POINT, I AM A PRESERVATIONIST AT
HEART.
SO THE MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT HAS STIPULATIONS IN IT THAT
REQUIRES BEFORE BELMAR IS ABLE TO DEMOLISH THE PROPERTY,
THEY HAVE TO DOCUMENT, ARCHIVE, TAKE PICTURES.
THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION -- THE STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION
OFFICE HAVE STRICT REQUIREMENTS IN DOCUMENTING HISTORICAL
STRUCTURES.
I HAVE BEEN THROUGH THAT SEVERAL TIMES ON OTHER PROJECTS,
AND IT IS VERY DETAILED.
YOU HAVE TO HAVE A SPECIFIC PHOTOGRAPHER TYPE OF -- TYPE OF
CAMERA TO DOCUMENT THE HISTORY OF THE CHURCH BEFORE IT IS
ULTIMATELY DEMOLISHED.
THAT IS OUTLINED -- THOSE STIPULATIONS ARE OUTLINED AND HAVE
TO BE COMPLETED BEFORE THEY CAN DEMO THE PROPERTY.
THANK YOU.
10:53:09AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANY OTHER COMMENTS OR HE IS QUESTIONS?
10:53:15AM >> MOTION.
10:53:17AM >> SECOND.
10:53:18AM >> POINT OF PROCEDURE, THIS IS NOT ON THE AGENDA, COMMENTS
FROM THE PUBLIC?
10:53:23AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
PLEASE COME TO THE FRONT AND ASK YOUR
QUESTION SO IT CAN BE HEARD FOR THE RECORD.
MR. SHELBY.
10:53:29AM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
YES, SIR.
IF THIS IS GOING TO BE SOMETHING THAT THE COUNCIL IS GOING
TO BE VOTING ON, THAT IS IS A WALK-ON.
WAS IT ON THE ADDENDUM.
IT WAS ON THE ADDENDUM, SO THE PUBLIC DID HAVE HAVE AN
OPPORTUNITY -- WAS IT AVAILABLE?
10:53:49AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
LET HIM SPEAK.
10:53:50AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
SECOND.
10:53:51AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
AT THIS TIME WE WILL TAKE PUBLIC COMMENT
CONCERNING THE WALK-ON AGENDA ITEM.
10:53:57AM >> BOB WHITMORE WITH CITY TREE.
THIS FEELS LIKE THIS IS BEING SLIPPED UNDER THE DOOR A
LITTLE BIT TO ME.
I AM NOT AWARE OF THE SITUATION.
BUT IT IS A HISTORIC PROPERTY, I ASSUME OR -- OR THERE MAY
BE TREES ON THIS PROPERTY THAT MAY NEED TO BE TAKEN INTO
CONSIDERATION.
THERE IS AN AWFUL LOT OF QUESTIONS THAT THE PUBLIC WOULD
HAVE BEFORE WE ACTUALLY JUST PRESS AHEAD AND SAY, NO, I
DIDN'T LIKE THE LOOKS OF THAT, SO LET'S TAKE IT DOWN.
IF THIS DEEMS TO BE IMPORTANT ENOUGH TO HAVE SOMEBODY COME
INSIDE AND ARCHIVE IT FOR HISTORY, PERHAPS THERE IS SOME
HISTORY THAT NEEDS TO BE PRESERVED BY KEEPING THIS BUILDING
OR CONSIDERING -- AT LEAST PUT INTO CONSIDERATION SO WE --
SO WE CAN ACTUALLY GIVE IT SOME REAL GOOD THOUGHT AND SOME
PUBLIC SCRUTINY.
THAT IS ALL I ASK.
10:54:59AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MISS TRAVIS.
10:55:02AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
YES, COUNCIL.
THANK YOU.
I AM GOING TO PUT ON THE ELMO AN AERIAL OF THE PROPERTY.
JUST FOR COUNCIL'S AWARENESS, THE DEVELOPMENT -- THE
AGREEMENT TO DEVELOP THIS PROPERTY HAS ALREADY BEEN APPROVED
BY COUNCIL.
THIS IS SIMPLY THE MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT THAT REQUIRES THE
DEVELOPER TO TAKE PICTURES OF THE HISTORIC STRUCTURE PRIOR
TO THE DEMOLITION.
IT HAS ALREADY BEEN APPROVED AS A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT.
IN YOUR ACTION PLAN, YOU HAVE APPROVED THE DEVELOPMENT
AGREEMENT ALREADY.
THIS IS JUST A PROCEDURAL OF THE DOCUMENTATION AS WE DON'T
WANT TO JUST -- THE STATE IS ASKING US TO DO THIS, TO
DOCUMENT THE BUILDING OTHERWISE THE BUILDING WILL BE
DEMOLISHED WITHOUT ANY PHOTOGRAPH.
SO THERE IS NO SLIPPING ANYTHING THROUGH.
10:55:55AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENT?
10:56:01AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOVE TO CLOSE.
10:56:05AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
SECOND.
10:56:06AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ALL IN FAVOR.
THERE IS STILL A MOTION.
MADE BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:56:12AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
NO MIRANDA MADE IT.
I SECONDED IT.
10:56:17AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
BEFORE WE DO THAT.
ALL THIS COMES -- ALL THE THINGS ABOUT TREES COME BEFORE YOU
-- BEFORE YOU BUILD YOU HAVE TO HAVE A PLAN.
10:56:25AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
THAT'S CORRECT.
YOU HAVE TO HAVE AN APPROVED SITE PLAN.
A PROCESS TO GO THROUGH.
IF THERE WERE -- IF -- ONCE THE DEVELOPER IS READY TO MOVE
FORWARD, THEY HAVE TO HAVE AN APPROVED SITE PLAN AND ALL OF
THAT WILL BE MITIGATED IF THAT IS THE CASE.
10:56:41AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
ANY OPPOSED?
THANK YOU, MISS TRAVIS.
DOES THAT TAKE CARE OF ALL THE WALK-ONES AND THE PULLED?
10:56:52AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
YES.
I HAVE ONE NOTE, WHEN YOU GUYS APPROVED THE AGENDA, ITEM
NUMBER 39 HAS A CONTINUANCE ON IT AND RELATED TO THE CRA
THAT WE DIDN'T TAKE CARE OF.
39.
BECAUSE OUR NOVEMBER MEETING WAS CANCELLED.
10:57:06AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ASK TO BE CONTINUED UNTIL DECEMBER 15.
10:57:12AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
SO MOVED.
10:57:12AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
SECOND.
10:57:14AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
A MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO, SECONDED
BY COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
ANY OPPOSED.
10:57:22AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
I SAW A FACE OF CONFUSION BECAUSE
PROCEDURALLY IT HAS TO GO TO THE CRA FIRST.
THANK YOU FOR THE INDULGENCE.
10:57:30AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
LET THE RECORD REFLECT THAT COUNCILMAN VIERA
IS WITH US IN PERSON NOW.
BECAUSE I KNOW HE WAS LISTENING ON HIS PHONE.
10:57:37AM >>LUIS VIERA:
ALWAYS.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 2.
10:57:40AM >>ADRIANA COLINA:
GOOD MORNING, COUNCIL, ADRIANA COLINA
DIRECTOR OF LOGISTICS AND ASSETS MANAGEMENT.
TO EXTEND THE CONTRACT WITH MANCON OF OUR FLEET DIVISION.
I PROVIDED YOU WITH A DETAILED MEMO OF OUR REQUEST AND
SPOKEN TO EACH OF YOU INDIVIDUALLY.
BUT I WANTED TO MAKE MYSELF AVAILABLE TO YOU TODAY TO ANSWER
ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE.
SIMPLY PUT, IT IS EXTENDING THE CONTRACT.
A CONTRACT THAT ORIGINATED IN 2014.
IT WAS A FIVE-YEAR CONTRACT WITH FIVE ALLOWABLE ONE-YEAR
EXTENSIONS.
I AM ASKING FOR YOU TODAY TO APPROVE THE SECOND TO THE LAST
EXTENSION AND ALSO ASKING FOR AN ALLOWABLE 8.5% CIP INCREASE
WHICH IS ALLOWED IN THE CONTRACT AND RIGHT SIZE IT TO ADD
ONE CUSTOMER SERVICE PERSON IN OUR FLEET, MAINTENANCE AREA
THAT SERVICES OUR FIRE TEAM.
10:58:52AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANY COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS?
10:58:57AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOVE THE RESOLUTION.
10:58:59AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
SECOND.
10:59:00AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
A MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
SECONDED BY COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
ALL IN FAVOR.
ANY OPPOSED.
THANK YOU.
10:59:06AM >>ADRIANA COLINA:
THANK YOU, ALL.
10:59:08AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 3.
10:59:16AM >>BRAD BAIRD:
GOOD MORNING, COUNCIL.
BRAD BAIRD, DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR OF INFRASTRUCTURE.
HERE TO REQUEST APPROVAL FOR FOUR CONTRACTS ASSOCIATEDED
WITH CITYWIDE HYDRANT AND VALVE INSTALLATION AND REPLACEMENT
TO THE TUNE OF $6.5 MILLION EACH FOR A TOTAL OF $26 MILLION.
I VERY MUCH APPRECIATE COUNCILMAN GUDES ASKING ME TO SPEAK
BRIEFLY ON THIS, BECAUSE, AS YOU KNOW, THE ADMINISTRATION
HAS PUT A FOCUS ON DIVERSITY, EQUITY AND INCLUSION AND THE
ENTIRE ADMINISTRATION HAS WORKED VERY HARD ON INCREASING EBO
PARTICIPATION.
AND THIS CONTRACT SHOWS THE FRUITS OF OUR LABOR.
WE HAVE AS MUCH AS 26.1 PARTICIPATION ON ONE OF THE
CONTRACTS AND THE OTHER CONTRACTS ARE VERY -- HAVE VERY GOOD
PARTICIPATION AS WELL.
SO I APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT ON IT.
11:00:19AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
11:00:22AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
FIRST, THANK YOU.
AND I AM GLAD TO SEE THIS AND THE NUMBERS THAT YOU ARE JUST
DISCUSSING.
I AM GLAD COUNCILMAN GUDES BROUGHT THIS UP, BECAUSE THIS --
THIS IS EQUITY.
A HAND-UP IN THE COMMUNITY AND LIFTING PEOPLE UP BECAUSE --
IS THIS PART OF PEER -- PIPES.
NOT THE -- NOT THE 2016 STORMWATER, BUT MULTI BILLION DOLLAR
PROGRAM.
THERE IS MORE THAN ENOUGH MONEY TO GO AROUND TO HELP BENEFIT
MINORITY GROUPS, PEOPLE IN THE COMMUNITY AND A PERFECT
EXAMPLE.
AND THIS IS NOT THE FIRST BECAUSE YOU HAVE BROUGHT UP
CONTRACT AFTER CONTRACT WITH INCREASED AND IMPRESSIVE
MINORITY PARTICIPATION NUMBERS.
SO WE ARE VERY GRATEFUL FOR THAT.
THANK YOU FOR LISTENING TO US, BECAUSE I KNOW THIS WAS
BROUGHT UP BY THE COUNCIL.
AND THESE ARE THE RESULTS THAT PEOPLE WANT TO SEE.
SO THANK YOU, SIR.
11:01:16AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
11:01:19AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I WANT TO ECHO COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO'S
CONGRATULATIONS ON THIS.
BUT I ALSO WANT TO HIGHLIGHT THE FACT THAT YOU ARE USING
FOUR.
WHEN WE TALKED ABOUT IN THE BRIEFING, AND YOU SAID THAT YOU
DIDN'T THINK THAT YOU WOULD GET THIS MANY PEOPLE
PARTICIPATING, BUT I LOVE IT.
BECAUSE IT MEANS THAT WHEN SOMETHING HAPPENS IN THE MIDDLE
OF THE NIGHT, WE HAVE NOT JUST ONE PERSON TO CALL BUT FOUR
DIFFERENT ENTITIES.
I THINK THAT IS REALLY WONDERFUL.
YOU WORKED WITH ALL FOUR OF THOSE BEFORE SO WE ALREADY KNOW
THE QUALITY OF THE WORK.
I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU FOR NOT ONLY INCLUDING OR GETTING
GREAT EBO NUMBERS BUT INCLUDING MORE ORGANIZATIONS IN THIS.
I THINK THAT IS A REALLY EXCITING WAY TO GO FORWARD AND I
WANT TO SAY CONGRATULATIONS.
11:02:09AM >>BRAD BAIRD:
THANK YOU.
11:02:11AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
11:02:13AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
BRAD, WE WANT TO SAY THANK YOU.
WE ARE WATCHING UP.
I WAS INVITED TO A GALA LAST NIGHT OF DIVERSITY AND
INCLUSION OF CONTRACTORS AND DEVELOPERS.
THEY INVITED ME TO THIS GALA LAST NIGHT AT THE ITALIAN CLUB,
ACTUALLY.
AND I DON'T KNOW WHY HILLSBOROUGH WASN'T THERE, BUT ORANGE
COUNTY CAME HERE.
SOME OF THEIR ELECTED OFFICIALS.
SOME OF THEIR CONTRACTORS.
THEIR EBO OFFICE, OSCEOLA, PINELLAS.
AS THEY WERE DOING THEIR SCHEMATIC AND TALKING ABOUT WHAT
THEY WERE DOING, I MEAN, WE ARE CATCHING UP TO THEM, BUT
STILL A LITTLE BIT BEHIND AND I AM GLAD THAT WE ARE MOVING.
BUT I CAN TELL YOU ORANGE COUNTY, THEY HAVE THE BEST PLAN I
HAVE EVER SEEN AND I WAS GOING TO TALK TO OCEA ABOUT THAT.
MISS HURTAK WAS SAYING, THEY COMBINE A LOT OF DIFFERENT
AGENCIES TO GET IT DONE.
THEY COMBINE A LOT OF DIFFERENT AGENCIES TO GET IT DONE AND
GET THOSE NUMBERS AND THEY DON'T -- AND -- ONCE ALL THE
VERBIAGE, NOT THAT GOOD FAITH.
IT IS SHALL.
NOT GOOD FAITH.
IT IS SHALL.
AND PEOPLE KNOW WHEN THEY GO TO PUT IN THAT BID, THEY MAKE
SURE THAT THEY HAVE WHAT IT TAKES TO DO IT.
AND WHAT I LIKE ABOUT IT, THEY HAVE TRAINED TO MAKE SURE
FOLKS -- I TALKED ABOUT IT, SOMETIMES SMALLER BUSINESSES,
THEY DON'T KNOW THE LINGO AND LANGUAGE, BECAUSE THEY DON'T
HAVE THE MONEY FOR THE BIG-TIME ATTORNEYS AND GET LEFT OFF
ALL THE TIME.
A TRAINING PROGRAM TO HAVE SMALL BUSINESSES COME IN TO LEARN
HOW TO DO THE CONTRACTS, THE REMEMBER BADGE, THE LANGUAGE,
HOW TO GET A PROCUREMENTS, WHAT THAT REALLY MEANS.
THE BIGGEST THING THEY TALKED ABOUT AND I HAVE SAID THIS
SINCE DAY ONE, SOMETIMES A CHALLENGE AND HAVE BEEN WORKING
ON THAT AND A FEW OTHER COUNTIES WERE TALKING ABOUT THIS,
THE BOND ISSUE.
BECAUSE THE SMALL GUY CAN'T GET THE NICE BIG JOB BECAUSE HE
CAN'T GET THE BOND.
HE DOESN'T HAVE THE CAPITAL.
SO THAT IS SOMETHING THAT I AM GOING TO PREACH FOR US TO
WORK ON.
HOW CAN WE FINDS A PROGRAM.
I KNOW MR. MIRANDA HAS BEEN WORKING ON THIS -- TO DEAL WITH
THAT SO WE CAN BE ABLE TO HELP THE SMALLER GUYS AND HAVE A
MULTITUDE OF THOSE FOLKS TO GET WHAT I CALL NOT BE HUNGRY
AND THIS VISIT AT THE TABLE.
I AM GRATEFUL TO PUT THIS FOOT FORWARD AND I AM GLAD OF THE
NUMBERS THAT ARE HAPPENING AND THE COMMUNITY IS HAPPY AND BY
THE WAY, GENTLEMEN -- I DID GO BY -- I WAS INVITED TO THE
HANNA PROJECT.
I THINK ALL OF YOU WILL TAKE A TOUR OUT THERE.
WE HAD A LOT OF CONTROVERSY.
I KNOW SOME THINGS WASN'T DONE THE WAY THE WAY THIS BOARD
THINKS IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN DONE.
THAT IS JUST THE WAY IT IS, BUT I THINK THE COMPANY IS
UNDERSTANDING AND TRYING TO GET THERE TO WHAT THIS COUNCIL
WANTS.
I SAW A LOT OF HBCU GRADUATES OUT THERE WORK ON THIS PROJECT
IN MAJOR POSITIONS.
AND I WAS IMPRESSED UPON THAT -- I AM A COOKMAN GUY, BUT A
LOT OF HBCU WORKERS DOING -- WHAT I CALL WORK THAT I CAN'T
DO, THAT YOU NEED TO HAVE EXPERTISE TO DO.
I WAS HAPPY TO SEE THAT COMPANY, DPR, IS HEARING AND GOT --
AND HAVE SOME OF THOSE GUYS ON -- AFFORDABLE PROJECTS OUT
THERE.
TO SEE HOW IT IS BEING DEVELOPED AND TO COME BACK IN THE
BACK END.
MANCON.
AND A WHOLE MINORITY FIRM.
I'M HAPPY ABOUT THAT AND GLAD THAT THE ADMINISTRATION IS
LISTENING AND WE NEED TO KEEP MOVING AND SEE WHAT OTHER
PEOPLE ARE DOING SO MATCH EVERYBODY ELSE.
AGAIN, THANK YOU FOR THE EFFORTS.
11:05:53AM >> THANK YOU.
11:05:54AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
11:05:56AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
AID COUPLE OF CALLS OF ONE OF THE
DEVELOPERS HAVING COFFEE AT WEST TAMPA SANDWICH SHOP AND
LOOKING AT THE WORK BEING DONE.
TO THEIR SURPRISE, WHOEVER IS THERE COME HERE, I WANT TO
SHOW YOU, HOW THE PIPE GOES IN INCH AT A TIME THROUGH THE
OTHER PIPE AND THEY WERE AMAZED THEY GOT A 20 TO 30-MINUTE
SESSION LEARNING AND SEEING HOW A PIPE PUTTING A PIPE INSIDE
A PIPE.
AND THEY WERE JUST -- AT AWE THAT THESE THINGS CAN HAPPEN.
I SAID THAT IS TECHNOLOGY, BABY.
THAT'S ALL THAT IS.
I APPRECIATE EVERYTHING.
AND WHOEVER THE DEVELOPER WAS, COME THANK YOU ON BEHALF THE
CITIZENS OF WEST TAMPA HAD THE TIME SHOW THEM WHAT THEY ARE
DOING AND HOW THEY DO IT.
11:06:38AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
11:06:40AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
A QUESTION TO COUNCILMAN GUDES BECAUSE
WE CAN'T TALK PRIVATELY.
YOU WENT TO THE HANNA PROJECT.
WHAT DID YOU NOTICE WITH REGARDS TO -- WE HAVE THE
APPRENTICESHIP ORDINANCE AND WHATNOT.
WHAT DID YOU NOTICE AS FAR AS THE PARTICIPATION THERE.
11:06:56AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I DIDN'T GO TOO FAR THERE.
THEY HAD FOLKS OUT THERE.
I KNOW WE ARE WITH THE APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAM, GRATEFUL FOR
THAT.
I SEE GUYS WALKING DOWN THE STREET AND I WANT PEOPLE TO COME
TO APPLY TO WORK.
GET THEM ON THE SITE AND GET THEM WORKING AND THEN BE ABLE
TO BE A PART OF THE STATE CERTIFICATION AND THOSE TYPE OF
THINGS.
I DON'T WANT A GUY WHO IS HUNGRY TO WAIT TO FIND A WAY TO
GET CERTIFIED.
IF WE GOT PEOPLE WHO NEED TO WORK, LET THEM WORK AND PUT
THEM IN AN APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAM SO THAT WAY THEY CAN FEED
THEIR FAMILIES AND I AM IMPRESSED SO THEY ARE STARTING TO
GET FOLKS -- AND I TOLD THEM -- I DON'T KNOW THE CITY
PORTION OR WHATEVER, BUT I TOLD THEM THAT PEOPLE ARE VISUAL
LEARNERS SOMETIMES.
WHEN THEY SEE THINGS, THEY BELIEVE THINGS.
I TOLD THEM THEY NEED TO FILM THE PROJECT.
FILM SOME OF THE HBCU GUYS DRAWING UP THE PLANS, DRAWING UP
THE STUFF.
SHOW PEOPLE WHO ARE PEOPLE FROM THE COMMUNITY, STRATEGISTS,
WHATEVER THEY CALL THEM, THAT THEY HAVE THE COMPUTERS AND
WORKING.
THEY ARE ACTUALLY MAKING SURE THAT THAT PART IS SUPPOSED TO
FIT WHERE IT IS SUPPOSED TO GO AND THINGS LIKE THAT.
I WAS AMAZED WHAT I SAW.
AND FILM THAT YOU HAVE PEOPLE FROM THAT COMMUNITY ON THE
PROJECT WORKING.
WHY ARE WE NOT DOING THAT TO SHOW WHAT IS HAPPENING AND A
LOT OF THE SCUTTLE BUTT GOING ON.
AND THE FACES TO SAY I KNOW HIM I TAUGHT HIM AT SCHOOL.
WALKING DOWN THE STREET AND HE IS WORKING ON THE BIG
PROJECT.
WE CAN'T BE AFRAID TO SHOW THOSE TYPE OF THINGS AND WE HAD
NEED TO HAVE CCTV OUT THERE SHOWING THAT YOU HAVE ALL TYPES
OF MINORITIES WORK ON THIS PROJECT AND WE ARE STARTING TO
GIVE EVERYBODY AN OPPORTUNITY AND A PIECE OF THE PIE.
11:08:43AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOVE THE RESOLUTION.
11:08:45AM >>BRAD BAIRD:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
11:08:46AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
ALL IN FAVOR.
ANY OPPOSED.
THANK YOU.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 5.
11:08:55AM >> GOOD MORNING, CITY COUNCIL, JEAN DUNCAN, ADMINISTRATOR OF
INFRASTRUCTURE AND MOBILITY.
VIK BHIDE IS ON THE LINE AND A QUARTERLY REPORT THAT
GENERALLY DOESN'T HAVE DISCUSSION.
WE ARE HAPPY TO HAVE ANY DISCUSSION.
BASICALLY A SUMMARY OF ACTIVE STORMWATER PROJECTS BEING DONE
THAT COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO MENTIONED A FEW MINUTES AGO
APPROVED IN 2015.
[INAUDIBLE]
11:09:38AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MR. VIK BHIDE, ARE YOU THERE?
11:09:43AM >>VIK BHIDE:
YES, SIR, GOOD MORNING, COUNCIL.
VIK BHIDE, DIRECTOR OF MOBILITY DEPARTMENT.
SORRY ABOUT THAT.
I'M HERE TO ADDRESS ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU MAY HAVE ABOUT
ITEM 5, A MEMO WITH THE QUARTERLY REPORT WAS SUBMITTED TO
COUNCIL FOR REVIEW, AS WAS REQUIRED BY A MOTION A FEW YEARS
BACK.
11:10:12AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
11:10:14AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
GOOD MORNING, VIK.
THE ONLY QUESTION I HAVE -- I WANT YOU TO BE ABLE TO FIX A
PROBLEM THAT THERE IS.
WHEN WE GO OUT AND TEAR UP THESE ROADS AND GO TO PUT THEM
BACK, CAN WE MAKE SURE THE ROAD IS DRIVABLE?
BECAUSE I CALLED YOU -- I WANTED TO FILE A LAWSUIT SAYING
YOU FOR MY CADILLAC AND I RODE DOWN THAT FLORIDA AVENUE --
AND I ALMOST FOR THE CAR UP.
I DON'T UNDERSTAND -- I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE PROCESS IS, BUT
I DO HAVE A PROBLEM.
WE GO AND TEAR UP A ROAD.
AND WE DON'T FIX THE ROAD.
I MEAN, WE JUST DO A -- A PATCH-UP JOB OF A ROAD.
I HAVE A PROBLEM WITH THAT.
SO I DON'T KNOW IF THAT NEEDS TO BE INCORPORATED IN THE
DOLLARS AND CENTS WHEN YOU TEAR UP THE ROAD THAT THE ROAD IS
DRIVABLE SO PEOPLE DON'T TEAR THEIR CARS UP.
A SERIOUS PROBLEM AND ANY TIME WE GO DOWN THESE PLACES AND
GO AND DO GREAT WORK ON THE UNDERGROUND, BUT THE TOP LAYER
-- I HAVE A PROBLEM WITH THAT.
I THINK WE -- WE GOT TO ADDRESS THAT.
WE NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT THE ROAD IS PROPERLY PAVED AND
DONE RIGHT.
HAS TO BE INCLUDED IN THE PROJECT, BUT I AM JUST SORRY, WE
HAVE TO FIX THAT PROBLEM.
11:11:26AM >>VIK BHIDE:
COUNCILMAN, I UNDERSTAND AND I REMEMBER THE
CONCERN YOU HAD CITED ON FLORIDA AVENUE REGARDING THAT.
THE CHALLENGE THERE WAS THAT WITH -- SO FIRST TO CLARIFY,
WITH EVERY STORMWATER PROJECT, IF WE DO TEAR UP A ROAD, IT
IS IN THE SCOPE TO PUT IT BACK AND RESURFACE IT.
USUALLY THE ROAD IS OPENED UP FOR LAYING PIPE AND SO ON,
WHICH WAS THE CASE ON FLORIDA.
SOMETIMES WHAT HAPPENS IS THERE IS AN ADDITIONAL WORK THAT
NEEDS TO BE DONE.
AND SO WE DON'T COMPLETELY REPAVE OR RESURFACE THE STREET
UNTIL ALL THE WORK THAT NEEDS TO BE DONE ON THE PAVEMENT IS
DONE.
BUT WE WILL BE MINDFUL OF YOUR CONCERN.
AND I WILL MAKE SURE THAT I WORK WITH BOTH OUR PROJECT'S
TEAM AND CONTRACT ADMINISTRATION TO MAKE SURE THAT THE
ROADWAY SURFACE, EVEN IF IT IS INTERIM, IS SAFE AND GOOD TO
DRIVE.
11:12:26AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
EVEN THE NONARTERIALS, I MEAN -- I THINK --
I MEAN, TO ME, THAT CREATES HAZARDS FOR PEOPLE WITH BUMPS
AND GOUGES.
IT NEEDS TO BE PROPERLY DONE REGARDLESS IF YOU HAVE TO COME
BACK.
LET'S MAKE SURE AT LEAST WE HAVE A SMOOTH SURFACE, YOU MAY
NOT GET ALL THE LAYERS SO PEOPLE CAN DRIVE ON THE CAR AND
DON'T HAVE AN ACCIDENT.
I CAN TELL YOU I WAS ON THE ROAD -- I CALLED YOU RIGHT AWAY.
I SAID THIS IS UNACCEPTABLE.
BUT THANK YOU FOR AT LEAST ADDRESS IT.
11:12:57AM >>VIK BHIDE:
YES, SIR.
11:12:58AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
11:13:00AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
COUNCILMAN GUDES, WE ARE IN RIGHT OF THE COMPLAINT OF THE
ROAD.
YOU ARE NOT -- YOU ARE NOT THE FIRST PERSON.
A GENTLEMAN -- A GENTLEMAN NAMED NEAL SENT SOME PHOTOS A
COUPLE OF HOURS AGO.
AND MY AID WAS ALREADY GOING TO CONTACT THE CONTRACTOR AND
REACH OUT TO EVERYBODY.
I KNOW EXACTLY WHAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT.
RIGHT IN FRONT OF THE BAKERY.
11:13:21AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MAN.
11:13:23AM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
WE ARE WORKING ON IT AND OUR OFFICE
REACHED OUT TO THE CONTRACTOR.
BUT AS MR. BHIDE SAID, THEY DID THE ROAD WORK, THEY PAVED
HOW THEY PAVED IT IN ORDER TO OPEN THE ROAD BUT ONCE IT IS
COMPLETE, IT WILL BE FIXED.
THIS HAPPENED ON HIMES AND THE INTERSTATE NEAR THE MIDTOWN
PROJECT WHERE WE -- THE CITY CAME AND REDID HIMES.
BEAUTIFULLY PAVED AND HAD TO TEAR PARTS OF THE ROAD AND IT
WAS LIKE A TEMPORARY FIX.
IT WAS AWFUL.
COULD YOU SEE THE PATCHES IN THE ROAD AND THEY CAME OVER AND
DID IT RIGHT.
IF YOU GO THERE NOW, IT IS SMOOTH.
BUT A SIMILAR SITUATION LIKE FLORIDA AVENUE.
AGAIN, MY AID WAS REACHING OUT TO THE CONTRACTOR A LITTLE
WHILE AGO TO GET THAT TAKEN CARE OF.
11:14:04AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
11:14:06AM >>BILL CARLSON:
ONE OTHER THING.
I TALKED TO VIK ABOUT THIS LAST NIGHT, BUT AS WE ARE DOING
THESE PROJECTS AND THE IDEA OF PUTTING STORMWATER AND
TRANSPORTATION UNDER VIK TO HAVE COORDINATION AND ALL OF
THAT INCLUDING POTABLE WATER IS UNDER JEAN.
LAST NIGHT, WE HAD ANOTHER KIND OF CARMAGEDDON SOUTH OF
GANDY WHERE THREE ROADS WERE CLOSED AT THE SAME TIME AND
MAYBE TWO OF THEM BY THE CITY AND ANOTHER BY ANOTHER PARTY.
BUT THE OTHER THING -- WITHOUT GETTING SPECIFICS OF THIS, I
GOT A LOT OF E-MAILS AND CALLS AND ANYTHING WE CAN TO DO TRY
TO HELP PLAN WITH OTHER AGENCIES THE IMPACT ON THE -- THE
RESIDENTS, ESPECIALLY IF -- IF -- DURING RUSH HOUR AND IF
MULTIPLE ROADS ARE BEING TAKEN OUT.
I KNOW VIK IS WORKING HARD TO CORRECT THIS SPECIFIC PROBLEM
BUT ANYTHING WE CAN TO DO AVOID THAT BECAUSE TRAFFIC IS
ALREADY BAD ENOUGH.
AND WE FIGURED OUT A COUPLE OF YEARS AGO THAT THE WHOLE CITY
OF TAMPA IS IN A TRANSPORTATION CONCUR KEN SEE EXCEPTION
AREA AND WE ARE AT RISK EVERYWHERE IF WE START SHUTTING DOWN
ROADS.
11:15:17AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANYONE ELSE.
11:15:20AM >>VIK BHIDE:
THANK YOU, COUNCILMAN.
CHAIR, IF I CAN ADDRESS THAT.
COUNCILMAN, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR SUPPORT ON THAT.
WE ARE ENSURING THAT WILL NOT HAPPEN AGAIN TODAY.
YESTERDAY'S OCCURRENCE WAS REGRETFUL.
WE HAD PERMITTED THE CONSTRUCTION TO BE COMPLETED BEFORE
RUSH HOUR.
I WOULD LIKE TO CLARIFY THAT.
WE DID ANTICIPATE THE NEED OF TRAFFIC FLOW DURING RUSH HOUR
LIKELY BECAUSE OF THE WEATHER THAT EVENING, SOME OF THAT
WORK MAY HAVE BEEN DELAYED, BUT GOING FORWARD, WE ARE
COGNIZANT ANY GIVEN TIME WITH 400 WORK ZONES WITHIN THE CITY
AND INVESTING IN A MORE PLATFORM.
AND TWO-WAY INFORMATION TO IN REALTIME MANAGE WHAT IS GOING
ON IN THE STREET RATHER THAN HAVING TO DEPEND ON A WHOLE LOT
OF TECHNICIANS DRIVING AROUND THE CITY.
HAVING SAID THAT WE ARE INCREASING THE NUMBER OF
TECHNICIANS.
WE ARE AWARE OF THE CHALLENGE AND GROWING RAPIDLY AND DOING
WHAT WE CAN TO ADDRESS IT.
11:16:30AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR. BHIDE.
WE LOOK FORWARD TO YOUR NEXT REPORT ON MARCH 16, 2023.
11:16:38AM >>VIK BHIDE:
THANK YOU.
11:16:39AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 7.
11:16:53AM >> GOOD MORNING, COUNCIL, CHAIR.
CHUCK WEBBER, WATER DEPARTMENT DIRECTOR.
I THINK BRAD BAIRD JUST HANDED OUT THE DOCUMENTATION THAT
WAS REQUESTED EARLIER.
IT IS JUST ONE PAGE FRONT AND BACK COMMUNICATION.
I WOULD LIKE TO START BY ADDRESSING SOME OF THE COMMENTS
MADE EARLIER JUST TO POINT OUT SOME CLARIFICATIONS THE CITY
IS NOT PROPOSING A $6 BILLION PROJECT.
AS IT STANDS TODAY NO PROJECT TO VOTE NO ON OR YES, SIR.
THERE IS NO PROPOSED TWO TO THREE TIMES PERCENT RATE
INCREASE THAT IS NOT WHAT WE ARE ADDRESSING.
SOME OF THE COMMENTS OF PUBLIC OUTREACH WE NEED TO RESPOND
TO.
WE HAVEN'T ADDRESSED THOSE 17 QUESTIONS YET.
AND THOUGH I APPRECIATE THE COMMUNITY OUTREACH THAT HAS BEEN
DONE REGARDING THE PROJECT, THE FACTS HAVE NOT BEEN FROM
THOSE 17 QUESTIONS HAVE NOT BEEN DELIVERED TO THE PUBLIC AND
WE NEED TO DO THAT AND THAT IS AN IMPORTANT PART OF THE
PROJECT.
THOSE QUESTIONS INVOLVE SAFETY AND COST OF THE PROJECT AND
WE NEED TO GO OUT TO AND GIVE THAT INFORMATION.
THE REASON WE HAVEN'T GIVEN THAT INFORMATION SO FAR, BECAUSE
WHEN THE CURRENT SCOPE OF THE ENGAGEMENT WITH THE CONSULTANT
WAS APPROVED IN FEBRUARY, THE SCOPE THAT WAS BROUGHT TO THE
FEBRUARY BOARD WAS TO EVALUATE TWO ALTERNATIVES, COUNCIL,
WHEN THEY APPROVED THAT ASKED US TO REVIEW ALL THE
ALTERNATIVES OF THE REPORT WHICH WERE MORE LIKE FIVE.
WHEN WE WENT BACK TO REDO THE SCOPE SO WE COULD ADDRESS FIVE
OF THOSE OPTIONS INSTEAD OF TWO, WE CAME BACK IN JULY AND
THIS IS WHEN COUNCIL CONTINUED UNTIL DECEMBER AND CONTINUED
FOR THE SCOPE.
THAT IS WHY PUBLIC OUTREACH IS NOT DONE AT THE LEVEL WE DO.
WE HAVEN'T ENGAGED ON THE 17 QUESTIONS.
BUT HOPE.
WE HAVE THE WORKSHOP SCHEDULED IN JANUARY OF STAKEHOLDERS
AND FEBRUARY WITH COUNCIL.
WHERE WE WILL ADDRESS THE 17 QUESTIONS AND ADDRESS QUESTIONS
LIKE COST AND QUESTIONS LIKE SAFETY AND SO DURING THE
CONVERSATION I AM HOPEFUL THAT WE CAN RESOLVE SOME OF THOSE
QUESTIONS.
THERE WAS A CHALLENGE WITH SOME OF THE QUESTIONS BECAUSE
EXTENSIVE ENGINEERING WORK NEEDS TO BE DONE BEFORE SOME OF
THEM CAN BE ANSWERED DIRECTLY LIKE EXACTLY HOW MUCH IS THIS
GOING TO COST.
IS THIS GOING TO COST A FEW MILLION OR 100 MILLION.
THE LIFE CYCLE COST.
WE ARE NOT ABLE TO NAIL AT THAT DOWN UNTIL WE DO ENGINEERING
WORK, AND WHEN WE DO THAT WE NEED FUNDING.
WE DO THE WORKSHOPS IN JANUARY, WE WILL FOCUS ON HERE IS THE
NEED FOR THE PROJECT.
THE ONE NEED WE HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT TODAY A LOT IS THE
-- YOU KNOW, THE NEED TO COMPLY WITH SENATE BILL 64.
I APPRECIATE THE WORK THAT SID FLANNERY DID WORKING WITH HIM
THE LAST TWO OR THREE MONTHS WITH ENGAGEMENT WITH THE
STAKEHOLDERS.
I THOUGHT WE HAD REALLY GOOD CONVERSATIONS OF HOW TO BEST
USE WATER AND WATER IN THE CITY OF TAMPA IS A VERY COMPLEX
THING.
NOT AN EASY.
YOU CAN'T MAKE ONE NARROWED FOCUS DECISION INVOLVES
WASTEWATER AND NOT STORMWATER OR POTABLE WATER.
WE NEED TO LOOK AT WATER RESOURCE AS HOLISTIC.
SO AS WE MOVE FORWARD WITH THESE CONVERSATIONS, I AM HOPEFUL
THAT WE WILL BE ABLE TO DO THAT SO WE DON'T MAKE A
NARROW-MINDED FOCUSED DECISION THAT COST IN ONE AREA THAN
ANOTHER BECAUSE WE HAVEN'T DISCOVERED THE OVERALL FACT.
WITH THAT IN MIND, TWO OTHER DRIVERS FOR THE PROJECT.
ONE OF THEM IS SULPHUR SPRINGS IS BECOMING SALTIER.
WE USE THAT AS A SOURCE OF MINIMUM FLOWS FOR THE LOWER
HILLSBOROUGH RIVER AND THE INDICATION FROM THE SOUTHWEST
FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT THAT WE MAY NEED TO
REPLACE THAT AND THAT IS THE MAJOR SOURCE.
WITH WE REPLACE THAT SOURCE OF WATER IT AND ANY OTHER WAY, A
COST ASSOCIATED WITH IT AND WILL ALSO EFFECT OTHER AREAS OF
WATER MANAGEMENT WITHIN THE CITY.
WE DO NEED TO ADDRESS THAT ISSUE AND THE ISSUE OF DROUGHT.
WHEN WE HIT A REALLY SEVERE DROUGHT, WE CAN PURCHASE WATER
FROM TAMPA BAY WATER AND IT HAS BEEN SUCCESSFUL IN THE PAST.
THAT IS AN OPTION TO RELY ON IT MOVING IN THE FUTURE, WE
NEED TO LOOK AT COSTS OF CONTINUED RELIANCE ON THAT.
SO SI DIDN'T WANT TO GO TOO DEEP IN THE ISSUES TODAY AND
EXCITED TO DISCUSS THEM IN JANUARY AND FEBRUARY AT THE
WORKSHOP.
SO WITH THAT, I GUESS, I WILL ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU HAVE.
11:21:46AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
11:21:48AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I GUESS WHAT BOTHERING ME ABOUT THIS WHOLE
WATER SITUATION IS THERE IS NO SOLUTION.
BUT I AM HEARING FROM A 30-YEAR EXPERT -- AND I ALWAYS SAY
EXPERIENCE IS YOUR BEST TEACHER.
HE IS A SCIENTIST.
I LOOK AT -- THOSE ARE THE FACTS.
DATA, YOU CAN OBSCURE DATA.
BUT ASK SOMEBODY WHO KNOWS THE ACTUAL SUBJECT MATTER, IT
MAKES A DIFFERENCE.
FOR ME TO HEAR THAT WHEN WE MAKE RULES ON THIS DAIS,
SOMETIMES THE ORDINANCE JUST DOESN'T FIT SOMETIMES AND WE
HAVE TO GO AND FIX IT MAYBE IT NEEDS TO BE TWEAKED.
WHEN THEY DID IT MAY BE BLANKET -- BUT IT DOESN'T FIT
EVERYBODY NOW.
MY THING IS, WHY DON'T WE PUMP THE BRAKES, GET A LOBBYIST OR
HIRE A LOBBYIST TO GO TO TALLAHASSEE TO BE ABLE TO FIND OUT
AND LOBBY TO SAY THIS NEEDS TO BE TWEAKED AND IT SEEMS THERE
IS AMBIGUITIES HERE.
AND SOME ISSUES HERE AND LET THEM WORK THAT OUT AND THEN
COME BACK AND TRY TO WORK.
TO ME TO TRY TO PUT OUR FOOT ON THE GAS HERE, WE -- WE ARE
NOT GETTING TO A STOP SIGN HERE.
11:23:11AM >> I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE SAYING, COUNCILMAN, BUT I WILL
STRESS THAT SENATE BILL 64 IS AN ISSUE THAT CAN CERTAINLY BE
ADDRESSED THAT WAY, BUT THE OTHER TWO ISSUES NEED TO BE
ADDRESSED AS WELL.
AND WE HAVE TIME FOR THAT.
THAT IS WHY I AM LOOKING FORWARD TO DISCUSS WHY -- WHY DO WE
NEED TO DO THIS -- AT THE WORKSHOP IN JANUARY AND FEBRUARY.
I THINK IT WILL BE A GOOD DISCUSSION ENGAGING WITH THE
STAKEHOLDERS AND THERE ARE VERY MANY EXPERTS IN THIS FIELD,
PEOPLE WITH 30 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE AND MORE THAT WE WILL
BRING TO THE WORKSHOP.
11:23:46AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
CHUCK, I HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH THAT BUT WE
HAVE A PROBLEM HERE.
WE CAN TALK ABOUT WHATEVER THE THREE DIFFERENT CATEGORIES.
BUT HERE I HAVE A PROBLEM WITH THE LAW AND LET THE
LEDGIZATION KNOW A PROBLEM WITH THE LAW OR THE
INTERPRETATION.
CHARTER MEMBERS THAT SOME OF OUR INTERPRETATIONS ARE WRONG
AND WE HAVE TO FIX -- MAKE THEM RIGHT TO UNDERSTAND WHAT THE
EXACT VERBIAGE TO BE CARRIED OUT.
I WILL BE ASKING THAT WE LOOK AT MAKING SURE THAT THE
LEGISLATIVE TAKES IT TO TALLAHASSEE.
WE NEED TO DO THAT AS A CITY AND ONE SIZE DOESN'T FIT ALL.
I AM ASKING TO TAKE THIS BEFORE THE LEGISLATURE AND HAVE OUR
LOBBYIST TO MAKE SURE IT IS GOING TO WORK AND BE TWEAKED.
THAT IS WHAT I AM LOOKING FOR.
11:24:50AM >> I UNDERSTAND, COUNCILMAN.
TIME IS IMPORTANT WITH SENATE BILL 64 SQUEEZING A PROJECT IN
THAT WE HAVEN'T DECIDED ON YET IN TEN YEARS IS GOING TO BE
TOUGH.
THAT IS THE TIME DRIVER FOR THAT.
THE TIME DRIVER FOR THE MINIMUM FLOWS IS ACTUALLY QUITE A
BIT CLOSER EVEN IN TWO WEEKS WE WILL BE TALKING WITH
S.W.F.W.M.D. FOR THE RENEWALS, AND THE MINIMUM FLOWS ARE
TIED TO THAT PERMIT.
AND HAVING A SOLUTION FOR SULPHUR SPRINGS WILL BE ESSENTIAL
OF DISCUSSING CONCERNS AT THE TOP.
11:25:26AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
AGAIN, NO ISSUE WITH THAT.
YOU ARE STILL GOING TO WORK ON THAT.
I HAVE NO PROBLEM.
THE PROBLEM I HAVE IS THAT YOU HAVE TO ADDRESS THE BIGGER
ISSUE.
YOU WILL STILL HAVE PEOPLE COME AND COMPLAIN AND UNTIL WE
CAN ADDRESS THIS.
WE CAN STILL WORK AND TALK AND MEET AND GIVE IDEAS AND
WHATEVER BUT, AGAIN, A MAIN ISSUE WITH THE LAW AND THAT IS
WHAT I AM SEEING AND HEARING.
WE HAVE TO ADDRESS THE LAW.
SO I AM HOPING THAT WE DON'T GO ON DEAF EARS ON THAT.
WE GO AND ADDRESS THE LAW.
WE CAN STILL WORK, BUT WE NEED TO ADDRESS THE LAW.
11:25:57AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
11:25:59AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I AGREE.
WE DEFINITELY NEED TO DO BOTH AND I AM GOING TO ENCOURAGE
ALL OF MY COLLEAGUES TO REACH OUT TO THOSE REPRESENTATIVES
IN BOTH THE HOUSE AND SENATE UP IN TALLAHASSEE TO SEE WHAT
WE CAN DO REGARDING THAT BECAUSE I THINK THAT IS VERY
CRITICAL AND WE NEED TO CREATE SOME PARTNERSHIPS THERE IN
ADDITION TO GETTING OUR OWN LOBBYING TEAM WORKING ON THAT.
AND SO I -- WE -- WE CONTINUED THE ITEM ABOUT THE 17
QUESTIONS UNTIL THE 19th.
AND FROM WHAT I AM HEARING, WE MAY NOT HAVE COMPLETE ANSWERS
TO EVERY QUESTION.
AND I AM JUST -- I WANT TO SAY THAT I UNDERSTAND THAT.
AND I KNOW YOU ARE GOING TO BE TALKING TO IT THE
STAKEHOLDERS SOMEWHAT BEFORE WE BRING THAT FORWARD TOO.
AND TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ALL UNDERSTAND WE CAN AS MUCH OF
THE ANSWERS THAT WE POSSIBLY CAN DO WITHOUT SPENDING EXTRA
MONEY.
SO I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU FOR THAT.
AND I LOOK FORWARD TO THAT SESSION.
AND I AM GOING TO ENCOURAGE MY FELLOW -- MY COLLEAGUES THAT
RIGHT NOW THAT SESSION, JANUARY 19, ONLY HAS THREE STAFF
REPORTS THAT I SEE ON IT.
AND I WOULD REALLY APPRECIATE IF WE COULD LIMIT THE
ADDITIONAL STAFF REPORTS WE PUT ON THAT DAY, BECAUSE I HAVE
A FEELING THAT IS GOING TO BE A LONG DISCUSSION.
SO I JUST WANTED TO SAY THAT.
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING.
THANK YOU FOR THE DOCUMENTATION AS WELL.
11:27:33AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
11:27:37AM >>BILL CARLSON:
I WANT TO SAY, CHUCK, THANK YOU FOR YOUR
CANDID AND RELIABILITY OF INFORMATION.
IT IS REALLY DIFFERENT THAN THE CONVERSATION FROM A FEW
YEARS AGO AND I APPRECIATE THE OFF-LINE CONVERSATIONS.
YOU HAVE BEEN GOOD WORKING PROACTIVELY WITH ME AND THE
STAKEHOLDERS AN SENT THAT LETTER AND LET THE SIERRA CLUB
PARTICIPATE SO MUCH IS A GOOD SIGN OF OCTOBERTIVITY.
IT IS OBVIOUS AND FOLKS IN AND AROUND THE MAYOR SAY THEY
ABSOLUTELY WANT THIS PROJECT.
NO MATTER HOW OBJECTIVE OF THE WATER DEPARTMENT HAS BECOME,
THE MAYOR'S OFFICE WANTS THIS PROJECT.
JUST LIKE THE LAST MAYOR WANTS THIS PROJECT.
IRRATIONAL DECISION.
NOT BASED ON SCIENCE.
THAT THEY WANT THIS PROJECT.
I THINK THAT IS THE CONCERN THE PUBLIC HAS, NO RATIONAL
BASIS FOR IT.
A LOT OF REASONS THAT HAVE BEEN PUT FORWARD, BUT NO RATIONAL
BASIS.
AND THERE IS SOME EVIDENCE, AT LEAST -- AT LEAST THE PRIOR
ADMINISTRATION USED LOBBYISTS TO LOBBY FOR IT.
WHEN I ASKED THE ADMINISTRATION THIS ROUND IF WE COULD USE A
LOBBYIST AGAINST IT, THEY SAID NO.
AND BY THE WAY, I DON'T KNOW THAT YOU ALL HAVE SEEN -- EVERY
TIME I MAKE A COMMENT, SOMEONE FROM THE ADMINISTRATION MAKES
A CORRECTION.
JUST LIKE THE REPORT THAT WAS SUPPOSED TO BE GIVEN BY THE
POLICE DEPARTMENT, THE CORRECTIONS MAY BE FACTUAL, BUT THEY
ARE USING THEIR OWN SET OF FACTS THAT DON'T EXACTLY MEET
WHAT THOSE STANDARD CRITERIA FOR WHAT SHOULD BE USED.
THE EXAMPLE HERE, CHUCK, THAT YOU GAVE, IT IS TRUE NO
PROJECT BASED ON THE VOTES WHAT WE DID BEFORE.
HOWEVER, IF WE -- IF WE DON'T CHANGE THIS LAW -- COULD I ASK
A WHOLE BUNCH OF QUESTIONS.
IF WE DON'T CHANGE THIS LAW AND WE ADHERE TO THE LAW, THEN
WE WILL MOVE FORWARD WITH SOME KIND OF PROJECT.
THAT IS WHY I THINK THE THINGS ARE RELATED.
WE DON'T KNOW HOW MUCH THE NEW PROJECT WILL COST BECAUSE WE
DON'T KNOW WHAT IT IS.
THE ONLY INFORMATION WE HAVE IS CREATED TWO OR THREE YEARS
AGO.
2.1 TO 3.6 BILLION IN THAT RANGE LOOKING AT THE OPTION.
WE DON'T HAVE ANY UPDATED INFORMATION.
WHEN I STARTED USING THAT NUMBER, I GOT A LONG SCATHING
E-MAIL FROM MISS DUNCAN THAT I DON'T BELIEVE SHE WROTE,
BECAUSE SHE IS A NICE PERSON, BUT IT SAID, YOU UNDERSTAND WE
HAVE EDUCATED YOU -- I AM PARAPHRASING THAT -- THAT IT IS
CENTERED IN THE INDUSTRY TO USE CAPITAL COSTS NOT TOTAL COST
FOR 30 YEARS.
THAT IS NOT TRUE.
AND WHEN WE HAVE COME WITH A PROJECT WE NEED TO LOOK AT THE
TOTAL COST OF 30 YEARS.
IN THE ABSENCE OF SOME OTHER DATA BETWEEN $2 BILLION TO $6
BILLION, FROM THE PIPES PROGRAM, $3 BILLION, $2.9 BILLION,
AND INCREASED AND DOUBLED THE WATER RATE THAT WENT FROM $40
TO $80, SOMETHING LIKE THAT ON AVERAGE.
WE INCREASE TO $6 BILLION, MAY ADD $80 A MONTH.
MAY NOT COMPACTLY RIGHT, BUT WE DON'T HAVE OTHER INFORMATION
NOW.
THE POINT IS IF WE MOVE FORWARD AND ABIDE BY THIS LAW, IF WE
DON'T START FIGHTING THE LAW AND FIGHTING THE PROJECT NOW,
WE ARE GOING TO END UP IN A PLACE WHERE WE HAVE TO SPEND
MONEY AND EVENTUALLY HAVE TO RAISE RATES AND THAT IS WHAT
THE PUBLIC WANTS US TO TO DO PROTECT THE ENVIRONMENT.
THE SULPHUR SPRINGS THING, 11 AND 12 MGD.
THE SIMPLE SOLUTION IN THE SHORT RUN IS TO STOP PUMPING.
WE HAVE TO BUY FROM TAMPA BAY WATER, AND WE HAVE TO STOP
BUMPING, S.W.F.W.M.D., THE LAST TIME I CHECKED, DID NOT DO
ANY MODELLING WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IF WE STOPPED PUMPING.
STOPPED PUMPING IN THE CERTAIN PERIOD OF TIME AND WE HAVE
SALT WATER INTRUSION, THEN WE CAN LOOK AT SOME OTHER
SOLUTION.
MINIMUM FLOWS -- IF -- IF S.W.F.W.M.D. COMES BACK TO SAY
80 NGD THAN 82 MGD, WE HAVE TO BUY THE REST IN TAMPA BAY
WATER.
MINIMUM FLOWS ARE IMPORTANT BUT DOESN'T MEAN THAT OUR WATER
SUPPLY WILL BE SHUT OFF.
CHUCK DID NOT DO THIS, BUT SOME PEOPLE IN THE ADMINISTRATION
USING SCARE TACTICS.
WATER IS SCARCE IN THE FUTURE.
WATER IS OUR MOST IMPORTANT RESOURCE.
THAT IS RIGHT WHY TAMPA BAY WATER IN OUR REGION IS ONE OF
THE BEST -- AND MR. MIRANDA IS ON THE BOARD -- ONE OF THE
BEST EXAMPLES OF REGIONAL COOPERATION AND REGIONAL PLANNING
IN THE WORLD.
SO WE SHOULD WORK WITH THEM ON THAT.
NOT KILL IT.
WHAT -- WHAT HAS HAPPENED IN THE PAST THE LOBBYISTS OF THE
CITY BECAUSE THEY REPORT TO THE MAYOR, THE LAST TWO MAYORS
VOTED TO LOBBY IN FAVOR OF THIS, IT APPEARS.
IF WE PASS A RESOLUTION TODAY ASKING THE MAYOR TO GET THE
LOBBYIST TO WORK AGAINST IT, I AM NOT CONFIDENT THAT WILL
HAPPEN BASED ON WHAT THE STAFF TOLD ME IN THE PAST.
I WOULD LIKE TO FIND OUT HOW WE CAN GET THE MAYOR TO
COOPERATE WITH US IN STOPPING THIS LEGISLATION.
AT THE VERY LEAST AS THE PEOPLE IN THE PUBLIC SAID GIVES US
MORE TIME TO LOOK AT THE OPTIONS, WHY SHOULD WE BE FORCED TO
SPEND BILLIONS OF DOLLARS.
THE LAST POINT IS, DOESN'T MAKE SENSE FOR THE CITY OF TAMPA
TO DO THIS ANYWAY, AND -- I AM TALKING ABOUT THE PROJECT
DOWN THE ROAD IF WE HAVE TO DO ONE.
IF WE HAVE TO HAVE SOME KIND OF PROJECT, WHY SHOULD THE CITY
OF TAMPA'S RATE PAYERS OWN THIS.
HUNDREDS AND MILLIONS IN WATER.
PART OF THE REGIONAL COOPERATIVE.
LET THE BURDEN GO TO THE OTHER DEPARTMENTS.
AND NOT GO ALONE AND CONTROL OUR RESOURCES.
EVERY MEMBER OF TAMPA BAY WATER SOLD THEIR RESOURCE INTO THE
COOPERATIVE BACK -- BACK AROUND 1998.
TAMPA ARBITRARY WAS LEFT OUT.
AND THAT IS THE EXCUSE THAT WE SHOULD ALWAYS GO OUR OWN.
THAT SHOULDN'T BE.
WE HAVE PEOPLE THAT LIVE IN TAMPA, WORK IN PINELLAS.
PEOPLE ARE CROSSING THE BATHE ALL THE TIME AND WORK AS A
REGION AND TRY TO COOPERATE NOT TO START FIGHTS IN THE
REGION AND TRY TO GOUGE OUR RATE PAYERS.
THANK YOU.
11:33:32AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MR. CHAIR.
11:33:35AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
11:33:37AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I WENT IN THE BACK AND WAS PROCESSING A FEW
THINGS.
I AM PROBABLY GOING TO MAKE A MOTION, MR. CARLSON, LITTLE
BIT LATER, NEW BUSINESS, TO ASK THE FLORIDA LEAGUE OF CITIES
TO ALSO LOOK INTO THIS.
11:33:51AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THEY ARE.
I MENTION IT LAST TIME I WAS UP THERE AND I AM GOING UP
THERE THIS AFTERNOON.
11:33:57AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
GREAT, GREAT.
11:33:58AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WE AS THE BOARD OF THE FLORIDA LEAGUE OF
CITIES ARE ON THIS.
11:34:02AM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
THANK YOU, COUNCILMAN CITRO.
11:34:05AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
11:34:07AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
I AM NOT ONE OF THOSE PROLIFIC SPEAKERS WHO TRY TO USAGE I
HAVE IT.
I SPEAK WHERE I COME FROM, YBOR CITY, FROM THE HEART.
THERE IS GROUNDWATER.
THERE IS RIVER WATER.
THERE IS WELL WATER.
WATER FROM THE BYPASS CANAL.
SEA HELP.
WATER FROM THE SEA.
DE SAL WATER.
AND THEN THERE ARE DROUGHTS.
NO MATTER IF YOU THINK YOU KNOW IT ALL, YOU CANNOT CONTROL
ONE THING, AND THIS IS NATURE.
BACK IN THE OLD ADMINISTRATION BACK BETWEEN '95 AND 2003, WE
WERE, WHAT, A COUPLE OF DAYS -- I THINK MR. BAIRD WAS THERE
AT THE TIME HAVING ENOUGH WATER TO SERVICE THE SYSTEM THAT
WE HAVE.
NO ONE, INCLUDING TAMPA BAY WATER, HAD ENOUGH WATER AT THAT
TIME, IF I RECALL, TO GIVE WATER TO EVERYBODY.
BY THE WAY, IF I REMEMBER, THE CONTRACT BROUGHT UP BY A
COUNCILMEMBER, WHO IS THE LAST ONE THEY ARE GOING TO GIVE
WATER TOO.
CAN YOU TELL ME.
11:35:11AM >> AVERAGE ANNUAL BELOW 82, WE WILL BE THE LAST MEMBER
GOVERNMENT.
11:35:16AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
THE CITY OF TAMPA.
11:35:18AM >> CITY OF TAMPA, YES.
11:35:20AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THAT IS NUMBER ONE.
NUMBER TWO, THE BILL WE ARE TALKING ABOUT, THE WATER BILL,
INCLUDES MANY, MANY THINGS ALONG WITH THE COST OF WATER.
AM I CORRECT?
IT INCLUDES THE COST OF WATER.
TAMPA INCLUDES GARBAGE PICKUP.
AND INCLUDES SOMETHING THAT I WANT TO DO 25 YEARS AGO.
AT THAT TIME IT WAS $2 A MONTH BECAUSE IT WAS NEVER COST FOR
REPLACEMENT OF WHAT?
WATER PIPES UNDERTAKE GROUND AND THE PIPES GOING TO THE
CURREN WATER TREATMENT PLANT.
THEY WERE NEVER THERE.
WE WERE SPENDING 20 SOME MILLION DOLLARS A YEAR AND
INCREASING EVERY YEAR ON NOT REPLACING ONE PIPE BUT
REPLACING -- BUT REPAIRING THAT SAME PIPE FIVE TIMES A YEAR.
AND I AM NOT SAYING THAT IS THE ONLY PIPE WE ARE REPLACING,
MANY PIPES.
WE HAD BREAKS IN THE WATER LINE AND BREAKS IN THOSE PIPES
GOING TO THE HOWARD CURREN ON A CONTINUING BASIS.
AND IF YOU DID THAT FOR 30 YEARS, AT THE END OF THE DAY, YOU
WILL STILL HAVE THE SAME OL' -- EXCUSE THE LANGUAGE SHITTY
PIPE AND HOLES ALL OVER IT AND NOT ONE REPLACED PIPE.
AM I CORRECT?
11:36:42AM >> THAT'S CORRECT.
11:36:42AM >> LET'S TALK OF COST OF WATER, I WILL VENTURE THAT I BET
EVERYTHING THAT I OWN THAT THE CITY OF -- WATER RATE AND WHY
ARE WE CONSERVATIVE SO WE DON'T HAVE ABUSERS, THE MORE YOU
USE, THE HIGHER THE COST IT GOES, AM I CORRECT?
11:36:57AM >> YES, THAT'S CORRECT.
11:36:58AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
THAT IS BECAUSE WATER IS THE MOST
PRECIOUS RESOURCES ON EARTH, ALONG WITH THE AIR.
IF YOU DON'T HAVE CLEAN WATER AND CLEAN AIR, YOU CAN'T LIVE.
I DON'T CARE WHO YOU ARE.
HOW MUCH MONEY YOU HAVE.
I DON'T CARE WHAT YOUR STATUS IS AS A SOCIETY, YOU CANNOT
LIVE, PERIOD.
AM I CORRECT?
11:37:20AM >> THAT'S CORRECT.
11:37:20AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
SO LET'S TALK ABOUT THE QUALITY OF WATER
AND THE TASTE OF WATER.
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU BUY WATER FROM CERTAIN ENTITY AND
THEIR WATER COMES FROM A SOURCE OTHER THAN THE DIFFERENT
WATER TREATED AND YOU HAVE TO MIX IT.
DOES IT TASTE THE SAME?
11:37:38AM >> WELL, IF YOU WERE REFERRING WHEN WE PURCHASE WATER FROM
TAMPA BAY WATER --
11:37:42AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
REFERRING TO THE WHOLE -- NOT GOING TO
MENTION NAMES.
11:37:45AM >> WHEN THE CITY HAS PURCHASED WATER FROM OTHERS IN THE PAST
AND IT HAS BEEN DIFFERENT WATER QUALITY THAN THE WATER WE
PRODUCE, YES, THERE HAVE BEEN NUMEROUS TASTE AND ODOR
COMPLAINTS.
11:37:56AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
I REMEMBER THE CALLS -- AND HE IS NOT
HERE NOW, BUT MOSTLY IN DISTRICT 7.
11:38:01AM >> THAT'S CORRECT.
11:38:03AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
AM I CORRECT?
WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE COST OF WATER PER UNIT IT, I WOULD
VENTURE EVERYTHING THAT I OWN THAT WE ARE FAR, FAR UNDER THE
ENTITY YOU JUST SPOKE ABOUT.
11:38:17AM >> YES, SIR.
11:38:17AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
SO LET ME UNDERSTAND -- I AM NOT GOING TO
MENTION NAMES -- BUT IN OCTOBER, I THINK IT WAS, AND A BOND
ISSUE FOR 30 YEARS AND I SAW TWO YEARS OF WHICH -- I DIDN'T
SAY TOO MUCH.
I WANTED TO SEE WHAT WOULD HAPPEN.
THIS IS WHAT HAPPENED THE FOLLOWING MONTH.
THAT -- BY THE WAY, THAT WENT FROM POINT A TO POINT B, 30
YEARS, 120 MILLION.
AND ALL OF A SUDDEN -- I BELIEVE IN OCTOBER OR NOVEMBER -- I
FORGET WHICH ONE -- THE FIRST 16 YEARS -- AND I LEARNED THAT
HERE FROM CITYING HERE.
THEY WERE ONLY GOING TO PAY THE INTEREST.
THERE WAS ONLY ONE VOTE AGAIN IT.
AND YOU ARE LOOKING AT HIM.
NOT THE EXPERIENCE THAT I GOT THERE.
THE EXPERIENCE THAT I GOT HERE.
WHEN YOU PAY INTEREST FOR THE FIRST 16 YEARS FOR $6 MILLION
FOR $96 MILLION FOR 16 YEARS, SOME POOR INDIVIDUAL AT THE
END OF THE 14 YEARS -- I SAID OF THE 30 YEARS, YOU ARE GOING
TO HAVE TO PAY THE WHOLE COST OF THE INTEREST AGAIN FOR THE
FIRST 16 YEARS, AM I CORRECT?
11:39:41AM >> YES, SIR.
11:39:41AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
WHAT DO YOU THINK THOSE PEOPLE ARE GOING
TO HAVE TO PAY WHEN THAT INTEREST RATE HITS THAT THEY HAVE
TO PAY THE WATER RATE GOING UP FOR THE LAST 14 YEARS OF A
30-YEAR DEAL.
HOW DO YOU THINK I FEEL WHEN I SEE THAT?
NOT EASY TO VOTE NO.
FOR ME, IT IS.
SOMETIMES WHEN YOU GET TO MY AGE, IT IS VERY SIMPLE TO SAY
WHAT YOU ARE GOING TO SAY.
BECAUSE IN MY AGE, EVEN A LIFE SENTENCE IS A SHORT TIME.
LET'S FACE IT.
I AM A REALIST.
I AM NOT A DEMOCRAT OR REPUBLICAN, I AM A REALIST.
I UNDERSTAND ALL THAT.
SO WHEN I COME HERE AND SEE THESE RAZZLE DAZZLE AND THIS,
THAT AND THE OTHER, I DON'T PLAY NONE OF THOSE GAMES.
I GO BY THE FACTS I LEARNED ON THE STREET.
AND I SEE THAT COMING.
AND THAT WOULD BE THE WORST-CASE SCENARIO FOR ANYBODY AND
ANY GOVERNMENT TO GIVE UP THEIR COST.
THEY HAD TO DO IT BECAUSE THEY HAVE THE WATER SUPPLY.
THAT WAR WAS GOING UP WAY BACK UP THERE IN THE OTHER SIDE OF
THE RACETRACK ABOUT FIVE MILES WHEN SOME COUNTY COMMISSIONER
OF THE HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY BACK BEFORE ALEXANDER SET FORTH
IN THE WARS NINE MILLION YEARS AGO AND SOLD THE WELLS TO
PINELLAS COUNTY.
CITY OF TAMPA WAS NEVER THE WATER -- AND HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY
PINELLAS AND PASCO.
WE WERE JUST BYSTANDERS AND WE WERE ASKED TO GET IN.
BE DAMNED IF YOU DON'T AND DAMNED IF YOU DID AND SO WE GOT
IN.
FOR THAT WE WILL PAY THE PENALTY.
NOT THIS GUY.
I AM NEVER GOING TO VOTE TO SELL THE CITY OF TAMPA'S WATER
SUPPLY AS LONG AS IT IS RUN EFFICIENTLY.
AS LONG AS IT IS RUN WITH THE BEST KIND OF OPERATION.
AND BY THE WAY, HOW DO YOU FEEL IF YOU LIVED IN NEW ORLEANS
AND YOU DRANK THE WATER FROM THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER?
IT COMES FROM WHERE, MINNESOTA.
1,000 MILES I WOULD ASSUME OR CLOSE TO TAMPA HOW MANY CITIES
DOWN THE MISSISSIPPI PUT ON A DUMP -- THE TOO WATER.
WATER TO TAP, PISS WATER WHATEVER YOU WANT TO CALL IT INTO
THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER.
NEW ORLEANS, I WOULD IMAGINE THEY GET SOME OF THE WATER FROM
THE MISSISSIPPI OR HAVE GREEN GRASS FOR THE REST OF THEIR
LIFE.
I DON'T KNOW WHAT IS GOING ON.
WE GET OUR WATER FROM WHERE THE -- IF I REMEMBER FOLLOWS
INTO THE HILLSBOROUGH RIVER AND COMES ON DOWN.
I WONDER IF ANY OF THE CITIES UP NORTH OR EAST OF US ARE
DUMPING INTO THE AN AREA THAT GOES DOWN TO THE HILLSBOROUGH
RIVER.
ANYBODY THOUGHT OF THAT?
I HAVE.
SO IT IS UP TO EVERY DEPARTMENT IN THE WATER DISTRICT AND
THE WHOLE UNITED STATES TO DEAL WITH WATER TO MAKE IT SIMPLY
THE BEST AND SIMPLY THE CLEANEST, SIMPLY THE MOST HEALTHIEST
SO ALL OF US CAN CONSUME THAT WATER.
THERE HAS BEEN A WATER WAR BETWEEN COLORADO AND I FORGET
WHATEVER STATE FOR 100 YEARS AND I DON'T THINK IT IS OVER
YET.
WHEN YOU LOOK AT SOME OF THE THINGS IN THE BEAUTIFUL PARKS
THAT WE HAVE OUT WEST, THE FLOWS USED TO BE -- NOW 35 FEET.
35 FEET FROM THE WATER USED TO HAVE.
WE HAVE A SERIOUS PROBLEM IN THIS COUNTRY AND THE PROBLEM IS
US.
WE ALREADY HAVE SEVEN BILLION PEOPLE LIVING ON EARTH AND
EIGHT BILLION JUST AROUND THE CORNER.
SO WE BETTER UNDERSTAND WHAT WE ARE TALKING ABOUT.
AND REALIZE WHAT WE HAVE AND TO BE ABLE TO SUPPLY YOURSELF
WITH THAT WATER.
WE DID SO MANY THINGS.
THE CITY OF TAMPA IS ONE OF THE WORST IN FLORIDA TO HAVE THE
WATER.
AND STILL HAS -- IF I REMEMBER CORRECTLY, WE STILL HAVE
SOMEBODY GOING TO RUN A WATER -- I AM NOT HERE TO EMBARRASS
EVERYBODY.
IF I WAS TO ASK ANY ELECTED OFFICIAL HERE IN THE STATE WHAT
YOU WANT TODAY, 80% OF THEM DON'T KNOW.
SO WHAT THE HELL ARE WE TALKING ABOUT?
I AM GOING TO STOP GIVING A LECTURE, BECAUSE I AM NOT TRYING
TO LECTURE ANYONE.
I AM TRYING TO OPEN YOUR EYES.
THAT YOU HAVE TO TAKE CARE OF YOURSELF FIRST.
THE CITIZENS OF THIS CITY HAVE ALWAYS GOT THE BEST WATER AND
THE BEST WATER RATE.
ANYBODY WANTS TO PUT A GAMBLE WITH ME, COME ON, I WILL TAKE
YOU ON.
THE PRICE OF WATER VERSUS THE QUALITY OF WATER VERSUS THE
DISTRICTS OF ANYONE THEY WANT.
END OF STORY.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR. CHAIRMAN.
11:44:28AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANYBODY ELSE?
MR. WEBER, GO AHEAD AND THEN I HAVE MY COMMENTS WHICH WILL
BE TOUGH TO FOLLOW COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
11:44:36AM >> I APPRECIATE IT.
IN THE SPIRIT OF TRANSPARENCY I NEED TO CLARIFY A COUPLE OF
THINGS.
FIRST, THE LAST TWO TIMES WE HAVE PURCHASED WATER FROM TAMPA
BAY WATER, THEY HAVE PROVIDED US WATER QUALITY THAT IS
SIMILAR IN QUALITY AND WE HAD ZERO COMPLAINTS.
SO IT IS POSSIBLE RIGHT NOW TO PURCHASE THAT WATER.
TAMPA BAY WATER WILL NOT GUARANTEE THAT WATER.
THE ONLY WATER QUALITY THEY CAN GUARANTEE IS AN EXHIBIT B --
EXHIBIT D.
HOWEVER, TAMPA BAY WATER HAS BEEN WORKING TO ADDRESS WATER
QUALITY CONCERNS OF THE MEMBER GOVERNMENTS FOR THE LAST
THREE TO FOUR YEARS.
THEY ARE EMBARKING AND CONSIDERING A $500 MILLION CAPITAL
PROJECT TO, YOU KNOW, ENHANCE THEIR WATER QUALITY SO IT WILL
BE SIMILAR TO THE WATER QUALITY WE PRODUCE.
AND I JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT IT WAS CLEAR AND DIDN'T
COME OUT IN THE DISCUSSION.
ONE OTHER THING I WANTED TO CLARIFY IS THAT COUNCILMAN
CARLSON TO ADDRESS YOUR COMMENTS ABOUT THE ADMINISTRATION, I
DO REPRESENT THE ADMINISTRATION ON THIS PROJECT.
AND IF THE RATIONALE FOR THE PROJECT HAS NOT BEEN MADE
CLEAR, I AM REALLY LOOKING FORWARD TO DO THAT IN JANUARY AND
FEBRUARY THROUGH THE WORKSHOPS.
11:45:58AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA, ONE MORE BITE.
11:46:01AM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
I WANT TO SAY I AM NOT AGAINST TAMPA BAY
WATER.
WE JOINED BECAUSE WE WANTED TO BE HELPFUL TO HILLSBOROUGH
COUNTY RESIDENTS, PINELLAS COUNTY.
WE ARE ALL HUMAN BEINGS.
WE WANTED THAT.
AND WE ARE DOING A FINE JOB, BUT WHEN YOU TAKE THIS FORWARD
COMPARE WITH THEM, I AM NOT SELLING THIS.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
11:46:22AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
I WILL BE VERY QUICK WITH THIS.
I AGIE WITH MY COLLEAGUES THAT WE NEED TO LOOK TOWARD OUR
STATE REPRESENTATIVES.
FIRST QUESTION IS, HOW CAN THIS HAVE HAPPENED?
HOW CAN YOU HAVE DONE THIS?
I HAVE BEEN LIVING IN TAMPA SINCE 1974, I HAVE NOT SEEN THIS
BAY CLEANER THAN IT HAS EVER BEEN TO THIS DATE.
WE WANT TO TAKE THIS WATER.
THE STAKEHOLDERS WANT TO TAKE THIS WATER AND PURIFY TO THE
BEST IT CAN BE.
WHILE I AGREE AND I AGREE PHARMACEUTICAL, HEAVY METALS AND
NITRATES, BUT IF WE TAKE IT THAT FAR, WHY DON'T WE JUST USE
IT FOR DRINKING WATER.
AS I SEE A ANGLER OUT HERE AS I AM, WE KNOW THAT THE
ESTUARIES NEED TO BE FED WITH FRESH WATER.
I CANNOT WAIT UNTIL YOU COME BACK TO THIS WORKSHOP AND WE
CAN HAVE A SERIOUS DISCUSSION ABOUT IT.
THANK YOU, MR. WEBER.
THANK YOU, MR. BAIRD.
MISS JOHNS.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 9.
11:47:28AM >>REBECCA JOHNS:
GOOD MORNING, REBECCA JOHNS, LEGAL
DEPARTMENT.
WE WERE ASKED TO LOOK AT THE FEASIBILITY OF AN ORDINANCE
THAT WOULD PROTECT A TENANT FROM EVICTION FOR RENT THAT WAS
PAST DUE FOR MORE THAN SIX MONTHS.
EVICTIONS ARE GOLF ERWINED BY FLORIDA STATUTES CHAPTER 83.
CHAPTER 83 ALLOWS A LANDLORD TO EVICT A TENANT FOR A BREACH
OF A LEASE WHICH WOULD INCLUDE ANY FAILURE TO PAY RENT DUE
UNDER THE LEASE.
RENT IS DEFINED UNDER THE STATUTE AS ANY PAYMENT DUE TO THE
LANDLORD PURSUANT TO THE LEASE.
THERE IS NO LIMITING LANGUAGE AS TO A TIME PERIOD.
IF WE WERE TO ENACT AN ORDINANCE LIMITING THAT, WE WON'T
HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO DO IT BECAUSE WE WOULD BE LIMITING
LANDLORDS' RIGHTS UNDER THE STATUTE.
HOWEVER, BE AWARE, THAT PRIOR TO AN EVICTION PROCEEDING, A
LANDLORD HAS TO PROVIDE WRITTEN NOTICE TO A TENANT LETTING
THEM KNOW TO REPRESENT THE LANDLORD CLAIMS IS BACK DUE.
IF THE TENANT IS DISPUTING THAT AMOUNT OF RENT, THE EXACT
CASE THAT WE HAD THE BAY AREA LEGAL CONTRACT IN PLACE FOR.
SO WE CAN REFER TO TENANT TO BAY AREA FOR LEGAL
REPRESENTATION TO DISPUTE LANDLORD'S CLAIM OF RENT OWED.
I KNOW THAT COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK ASKED FOR A MEMO ON THIS, SO
I WILL PROVIDE THAT TO ALL OF YOU.
ANY QUESTIONS?
11:48:53AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANY QUESTIONS, COUNCILMAN VIERA.
11:48:54AM >>LUIS VIERA:
THANK YOU FOR YOUR WORK AND RESEARCH ON THIS.
YOU KNOW THIS WAS NECESSITATED BECAUSE OF TERRIBLE THINGS
HAPPENING AT TIMBER FALLS AND 113th STREET.
I WAS ACTUALLY TALKING TO THEIR PROPERTY MANAGER YESTERDAY.
TRY TO KEEP UP TO DATE WHAT IS HAPPENING AND ETC.
I AM GLAD TO HEAR THAT IN SIM ABOUT FALLS, A LITTLE UNDER
TWO DOZEN CODE CASES WHICH IS REALLY GOOD.
THE CITY IS TRYING TO HOLD ACCOUNTABILITY HERE.
WHAT HAPPENED ON THIS INSTANCE IS YOU HAVE A LOT OF
RESIDENTS THAT HEARD OUT OF NOWHERE THEY WERE UP $7,000,
$8,000, $10,000 IN BACK RENT WITH ASSORTED FEES AND ETC.,
ETC., AND A LOT OF IT WAS DUE TO CONFUSION AND MANY OF THOSE
CASES, THANK GOODNESS, HAVE BEEN SORTED OUT WHICH IS GOOD.
YOU KNOW THE -- AND I OBVIOUSLY UNDERSTAND THE -- SOME OF
THE ISSUES YOU TALKED ABOUT THERE.
AND IF YOU HAVE A CONTRACT AND IT IS ENFORCEABLE.
JUST THAT THERE IS A RIGHT WAY TO DO IT AND THAT IS WHERE
THE BULLY PULPIT COMES IN WITH A LOT OF THESE PROPERTY
OWNERS TO MAKE SURE THEY DO THINGS THE RIGHT WAY AND I THINK
TIMBER FALLS IS A GOOD EXAMPLE OF THAT IN TERMS OF HOW
PEOPLE MOVE DIGNITY FORWARD IN THAT REGARD.
I WILL LOOK AT THIS A LITTLE FURTHER TO SEE IF THERE IS
ANYTHING WE CAN DO ON THIS.
THERE MAY BE.
THERE MAY NOT BE IN TERMS OF AN ORDINANCE.
I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR YOUR WORK.
11:50:13AM >>REBECCA JOHNS:
THANK YOU.
11:50:15AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
11:50:18AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I REMEMBER PUTTING THE OFFICE OF TENANT
ADVOCACY TOGETHER THAT WE TALKED ABOUT ADDING THIS -- THE
PHONE NUMBER THAT -- THE CITY'S NUMBER FOR THE TENANT
ADVOCACY OFFICE POSSIBLY TO THE EVICTION NOTICES.
I KNOW BECAUSE -- IF I REMEMBER CORRECTLY, THERE ARE, LIKE,
SIX DIFFERENT PHONE NUMBERS AND FOLKS DON'T KNOW WHO TO CALL
BECAUSE THEY DON'T KNOW WHICH PERTAINS TO THEM.
AND OUR NEW AT WAS, HEY, JUST PUT THIS ONE NUMBER AND IF YOU
HAVE A PROBLEM, WE -- THE TENANT ADVOCACY OFFICE WILL HELP
DIRECT YOU TO THE CORRECT PERSON WHETHER IT BE BAY AREA
LEGAL OR THE APARTMENT COMPLEX.
AT THE PENDING ON STATE MONEY OR FEDERAL MONEY OR WHATEVER.
DO WE HAVE ANY ABILITY TO -- I MEAN, HOW DO THOSE OTHER
NUMBERS GET ON THERE AND HOW CAN WE GET OUR NUMBER ON THERE
THROUGH.
11:51:17AM >>REBECCA JOHNS:
I WANT TO CLARIFY WHICH EVICTION NOTICE YOU
ARE TALKING ABOUT.
A WRITTEN NOTICE THAT THE LANDLORD SENDS TO A TENANT PRIOR
TO EVICTION PROCEEDINGS THAT STATE YOU OWE $650 IN RENT.
YOU MUST PAY THAT WITHIN THREE BUSINESS DAYS OR TURN OVER
POSSESSION OF THE PROPERTY.
THAT NOTICE IS GOVERNED BY THE STATUTE.
THE STATUTE ACTUALLY INCLUDES THE LANGUAGE TO GO IN THAT
NOTICE.
SO IF THE TENANT DOESN'T PAY, THEN THE LANDLORD CAN PURSUE
EVICTION PROCEEDINGS.
THOSE EVICTION FORMS ARE GOVERNED BY THE STATE COURTS.
AND SO THAT FORM IS WHAT GOVERNS WHAT GOES.
SO THAT NOTICE THAT ACTUALLY GETS FILED WITH THE COURT AND
SERVED ON THE TENANT, THAT IS A FORM THAT IS GOVERNED BY THE
STATE COURTS.
I DON'T KNOW IF WE WOULD IN EITHER OF THE INSTANCES GOVERNED
BY THE STATE TO BE ABLE TO ADD OR REQUIRE THAT THE CITY OF
TAMPA LANGUAGE BE PUT ON THOSE NOTICES.
11:52:14AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I WOULD LOVE TO LOOK INTO THAT AND SEE IF
THAT IS SOMETHING WE CAN DO.
I WILL MAKE A MOTION LATER TODAY JUST TO DO THAT, TO COVER
ALL OF OUR BASES.
I KNOW WE JUST HAD MISS TRAVIS UP EARLIER TO TALK ABOUT
PASSING OUT THE INFORMATION TO DIFFERENT APARTMENT COMPLEXES
AND MAYBE SOMEHOW ADD THAT IN BECAUSE WE NEED TO START A
COMPONENT NOT ONLY FOR THE APARTMENTS BUT FOR THE TENANTS.
11:52:40AM >>REBECCA JOHNS:
NOW WHAT WE CAN DO IS ADD THIS INFORMATION
TO THE NOTICE OF TENANT RIGHTS THAT IS GIVEN TO EVERY TENANT
WHEN THEY LEASE AN APARTMENT.
BECAUSE THAT IS UNDER OUR JURISDICTION.
SO WE CAN ADD IT TO THAT.
11:52:53AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
WONDERFUL.
AND SO --
11:52:56AM >>REBECCA JOHNS:
I WILL ADD THAT AND WE WILL HAVE TO COME
BACK AN AMENDS AN ORDINANCE -- I CAN'T REMEMBER ORDINANCE OR
RESOLUTION TO APPROVE THAT NOTICE AND WE WILL BRING IT BACK
FOR YOUR APPROVAL.
11:53:07AM >>LYNN HURTAK:
ABSOLUTELY.
IF I NEED TO MAKE A MOTION FOR THAT, I WILL ABSOLUTELY DO
THAT.
I CAN TALK TO YOU -- OR I CAN -- IF KELLY WILL COME OUT.
MY WONDERFUL AIDE KELLY WILL COME OUT, YOU CAN TALK ABOUT
HOW YOU WANT AT THAT LANGUAGE BUT I WILL ABSOLUTELY MAKE
THAT MOTION AND THANK YOU SO MUCH BECAUSE THAT IS WHAT I WAS
THINKING OF, JUST SOME WAY ANY MORE WAY THAT WE CAN GET THAT
INFORMATION OUT TO THE PEOPLE WHO NEED IT AND GET THEM TO
KNOW ABOUT IT AHEAD OF TIME OR IF THEY DON'T KNOW ABOUT IT,
THE NEIGHBOR KNOW ABOUT IT, THE MORE WE GET THAT NUMBER OUT,
THE MORE WE CAN ACTUALLY HELP MORE PEOPLE WITH THIS.
SO THANK YOU SO MUCH COUNCILMAN VIERA FOR BRINGING THIS
FORWARD.
11:53:52AM >>REBECCA JOHNS:
ANYTHING ELSE?
11:53:54AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANY COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS?
THANK YOU, MISS JOHNS.
11:53:57AM >>REBECCA JOHNS:
THANK YOU.
11:53:58AM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 10.
11:54:05AM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
GOOD MORNING, AGAIN, COUNCIL.
NICOLE TRAVIS, DIRECTOR OF ECONOMICS DEVELOPMENT AND
OPPORTUNITY.
I WAS ASKED TO PROVIDE A PRESENTATION ON THE BLOOMBERG
CONTRACT AND WHERE WE ARE INCLUDING HOW MANY CONSULTANTS AND
DEPARTMENTS.
SO I HAVE A SLIDE -- THANK YOU.
YOU JUST ASK AND IT APPEARS.
SO WHAT I AM GOING TO GO THROUGH IN THE SLIDES ARE IDENTIFY
ALL THE DIFFERENT BLOOMBERG TEAMS AND NUMBER OF CONSULTANTS.
WE HAVE OVER 15 ACTIVE PROJECTS SINCE MARCH OF 2020.
AND BLOOMBERG AND ASSOCIATES, WHICH IS THEIR PHILANTHROPIC
ARM HAVE DONATED 3500 HOURS WITH OUR TEAMS.
THE ONE THING THAT YOU SHOULD UNDERSTAND ABOUT THE BLOOMBERG
CONTRACT IS THAT I AM THE ADMINISTRATOR THAT OVERSEES ALL OF
THE PROJECTS.
AND INTERFACES WITH BLOOMBERG ON WHICH PROJECTS ARE A GO AND
WHICH ONES ARE NOT IN ALIGNMENT WITH WHAT WE ARE TRYING TO
ACHIEVE.
SO I WORK WITH THE MAYOR ON THAT JUST TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
ARE NOT OFF DOING RANDOM THINGS.
SO I OVERSEE THIS -- THIS CONTRACT IN WHOLE.
AND LET ME KNOW -- YOU CAN STOP ME AT ANY POINT IF YOU HAVE
QUESTIONS.
SO WE HAVE A COUPLE OF PROJECTS WITH THE COMMUNICATION TEAM,
SPECIFICALLY WORKING ON THEIR BEST PRACTICES ON MEDIA
ENGAGEMENT, INCREASING IMPACT ON ENGAGEMENT AND SOCIAL
MEDIA, AND HOW TO IMPROVE STORY PITCHING.
THERE ARE EIGHT BLOOMBERG EXPERTS THAT ARE ON THIS TEAM THAT
YOU SEE THE AREAS OF EXPERTISE WITH HOW TO USE
CITY-CONTROLLED MEDIA, PRESS OUTREACH, SOCIAL MEDIA AND
CRISIS -- CRISIS RESPONSE PROTOCOLS.
SO THEY ARE WORKING WITH OUR COMMUNICATION DEPARTMENT AND
THE PORTFOLIO THAT HAVE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICERS IN THEM.
SO I HAVE A PIO IN MY OFFICE.
WHEN THEY DO A WORKSHOP AND TRAINING OF BEST PRACTICES, ALL
THE PIOs THAT ARE IN DIFFERENT DEPARTMENTS, THERE IS ONE IN
JEAN'S GROUP, OCEA, WE ALL COME TOGETHER TO MAKE SURE WE ARE
ALL ON THE SAME WAGE WITH BEST PRACTICES AND HOW TO MOVE
FORWARD.
THE OTHER PROJECT THAT WE HAVE IS WITH A CULTURAL ASSET
MANAGEMENT TEAM.
THREE -- THE EXPERTISE ON CULTURAL PROMOTION, OF PUBLIC ARTS
INVESTMENTS AND SECURING GRANTS AND OTHER FUNDING STRATEGIES
TO SUPPORT THE ARTS.
AND THE WORK THAT THEY HAVE DONE -- THEY ARE WORKING WITH
ROBIN NIGH RIGHT NOW ON THE COMMUNICATION AND MATERIALS THAT
WILL BE PRESENTED IN JANUARY FOR THE SOUL WALK'S LAUNCH IN
JANUARY OF 2023.
NEXT, WE HAVE THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TEAM.
I'LL TELL YOU A MAJORITY OF THE 15 PROJECTS ARE WITHIN MY
PORTFOLIO.
THE AREAS OF EXPERTISE ARE REALLY ON ECONOMIC STRATEGY,
START-UP AND SMALL BUSINESS SUPPORT, COMMERCIAL REGENERATION
PROJECTS, WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT, INDUSTRY CLUSTERS.
AND SO THERE ARE FOUR EXPERTS ON THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
TEAM.
THE ONE THING THAT YOU SHOULD KNOW ABOUT THE BLOOMBERG TEAM
IS THAT THEIR TEAM INCLUDES FORMER SENIOR LEADERS AT CITY
AND STATE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENTS.
THEY ARE FOCUSED ON IMPLEMENTATION AND HOW DO WE GET THINGS
FROM CONCEPT TO IMPLEMENTATION.
THEIR COMMITMENT IS TOWARDS HELPING ENSURE THAT ALL
RESIDENTS, PARTICULARLY THOSE FROM DISADVANTAGED GROUPS HAVE
ACCESS TO ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY.
THIS IS SOMETHING WE'VE BEEN WORKING REALLY CLOSE, AND WHEN
I SHOW YOU SOME OF THE PROJECTS THAT WE'VE BEEN WORKING ON,
PRIMARILY EAST TAMPA, YOU'LL SEE.
AND A LOT OF THE WORK THAT WE'RE DOING IS DATA DRIVEN. SO
OFTENTIMES BLOOMBERG STAFF WILL ASSIST US IN LOOKING AT THE
BEST PRACTICES OR EVEN TALKING THROUGH WHAT TYPE OF METRICS
WILL HELP US -- COUNCILMAN CARLSON HAS TALKED ABOUT THE
METRICS AND HOW WE MEASURE OUR ECONOMIC SUCCESS AND NOT
NECESSARILY DOING THAT AT MSA LEVEL, BUT HOW IS THE CITY OF
TAMPA PERFORMING ON THESE PARTICULAR METRICS.
IT'S BEYOND JUST THE POVERTY AND EDUCATION METRICS.
LIKE, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I WANT TO -- I'LL GO OFF ON A
TANGENT NOW.
BUT ONE OF THE THINGS I WANT TO ENSURE IS THAT WHEN WE
PROVIDE RESOURCES AND FUNDING FOR DIFFERENT PROJECTS OR
PARTNER WITH AGENCIES, WE REALLY SHOULD BE FIGURING OUT WHAT
IS THE RETURN ON THE INVESTMENT?
WHAT ARE THE CITIZENS GETTING FROM THAT?
ARE WE REALLY IMPROVING ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY FOR OUR MOST
DISADVANTAGED CITIZENS?
AND HOW DO WE MEASURE THAT?
AND SO THOSE ARE THINGS THAT JUST KIND OF WORKING THROUGH
THAT WITH BLOOMBERG.
THE LAST THING I'LL SAY ABOUT THE TEAM IS THAT THE LONG-TERM
COMMITMENT HELPS US TO SEE THIS OVER TIME AND TO PUT
STRATEGIES IN PLACE THAT WE CAN MEASURE THE SUCCESS.
SO THE PROJECTS THAT WE'RE WORKING ON, DEVELOPING A
SHORT-TERM ECONOMIC ROAD MAP.
THE MAYOR'S WORKFORCE COUNCIL, EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE.
YOU'LL SEE THAT THEY JUST HAD A WORKFORCE SUMMIT WITH BRENT
McKENZIE, THAT WORKING THROUGH THE DIFFERENT STRATEGIES
FOR HOW ARE WE ENSURING OUR WORKFORCE THAT WE ARE CAPTURING
AND TRAINING THE WORKFORCE, THAT'S WORKING WITH HIGHER
INSTITUTIONS TO MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE TRAINING OUR STUDENTS
AND GOING EVEN FURTHER INTO THE MIDDLE SCHOOL, HIGH SCHOOL
LEVELS TO MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE TRAINING OUR STUDENTS TO STAY
WITHIN OUR COMMUNITY AND WHAT THAT WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT
LOOKS LIKE.
EAST TAMPA, 22nd AND LAKE DEVELOPMENT, WE'RE LOOKING FOR
CATALYTIC PROJECTS IN EAST TAMPA TO REALLY REJUMP-START THE
DEVELOPMENT.
I'LL WEAR MY REDEVELOPMENT HAT FOR A MINUTE.
PRIVATE INVESTMENT FOLLOWS PUBLIC DOLLARS.
THEY FOLLOW PUBLIC INVESTMENT.
AND SO REALLY WE WANT TO JUMP-START -- EAST TAMPA NEEDS A
CATALYTIC PROJECT.
EAST TAMPA NEEDS A BIG WIN TO SHOW PRIVATE INVESTORS THAT
THEY SHOULDN'T BE AFRAID OF INVESTING INTO THE EAST TAMPA
AREA.
SO THAT'S WHAT WE'RE WORKING THROUGH WITH BLOOMBERG, LOOKING
AT DIFFERENT TAX CREDIT FUNDING PROJECTS THAT HAVE BEEN
SUCCESSFUL IN OTHER COMMUNITIES, BUT WE'RE WORKING ON THAT
WITH THEM.
AND ALSO USING OPPORTUNITY ZONES, WHICH IS A FINANCE
MECHANISM TO REALLY LOOK AT PROJECTS WITHIN EAST TAMPA TO BE
ABLE TO FOCUS ON THAT.
THERE IS AN INTERNAL MANAGEMENT TEAM.
THIS TEAM, THEIR EXPERTISE IS REALLY INTERNAL OPERATIONS AND
REPORTING PROJECT MANAGEMENT.
WE HAVE FOUR BLOOMBERG EXPERTS ON THIS THAT'S WORKING WITH
OCEA WYNN'S GROUP.
THIS IS AROUND THE PROJECT OF CUSTOMER-CENTRIC PERFORMANCE
SYSTEMS.
THEY RECENTLY HAD SOME DEPARTMENT INTERVIEWS, DIFFERENT
DEPARTMENTS WITHIN MY PORTFOLIO WERE INTERVIEWED TRYING TO
FIGURE OUT NOT ONLY EXTERNAL CUSTOMER INTERFACE, BUT
INTERNAL CUSTOMER INTERFACE AND HOW DO WE MEASURE OUR
PERFORMANCE AND RESPONSIVENESS.
SUSTAINABILITY TEAM.
ASSESS SUSTAINABILITY BUT A LOT OF IT IS REALLY AROUND
HOUSING AFFORDABILITY, THE HOUSING SUPPLY INVENTORY.
THE PROJECTS THAT WE HAVE THAT WE'RE ACTIVELY WORKING ON.
COMMUNITY LAND TRUST THAT ALIS DRUMGO IS LEADING AND HAS A
PRESENTATION COMING TO YOU IN THE BEGINNING OF 2023 ON THIS.
AND THEN THE HOUSING NEEDS ASSESSMENT, WRITING THE SCOPE AND
MAKING SURE THAT -- CRAFT A SCOPE FOR IN TRYING TO
UNDERSTAND WHAT EXACTLY THE DATA THAT WE WANT TO CAPTURE TO
MAKE SURE THAT THOSE THINGS WERE WRITTEN INTO THE SCOPE.
SO WE HAVE THE EXPERTISE TO WRITE SCOPE, BUT THEY HAVE
PROVIDED US WITH BEST PRACTICES AND OTHER MAJOR CITIES THAT
HAVE DONE NEEDS ASSESSMENT AND WHAT INFORMATION WAS HELPFUL
THEN FOR THEM TO ACCELERATE CERTAIN MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT
AND WE INCLUDED THOSE THINGS IN OUR RFP.
THE TRANSPORTATION TEAM, ROAD SAFETY, PEDESTRIAN
INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS, BIKE SHARE AND CYCLING
INFRASTRUCTURE.
THERE ARE FOUR BLOOMBERG EXPERTS ON THIS.
THEY WORK WITH VIK DIRECTLY ON THESE PROJECTS.
WE'RE LOOKING AT PROJECTS THAT ARE TRAFFIC CALMING AND
PEDESTRIAN SAFETY PROJECTS IN FOUR DIFFERENT AREAS.
ALSO LOOKING AT THE POTENTIAL OF STREET EXPANSION AND FUTURE
INTEGRATION OF BIKE LANES AROUND WHITING STREET AND ALSO
BEING PROACTIVE IN OUR TRAFFIC-CALMING AND PEDESTRIAN SAFETY
AROUND ANY FUTURE DEVELOPMENT THAT MAY HAPPEN AROUND THE
TAMPA UNION STATION.
THE BLOOMBERG URBAN PLANNING TEAM HAS THREE EXPERTS.
THEY DO A LOT OF THE LONG-RANGE PLANNING, ZONING,
NEIGHBORHOOD IMPROVEMENT DISTRICTS, WATER REVITALIZATION AND
ACCESS.
THEY HAVE THREE EXPERTS ON THAT TEAM.
AGAIN, THIS IS IN MY PORTFOLIO.
THEY WORK VERY CLOSELY WITH STEPHEN BENSON.
I'VE TALKED TO SOME OF YOU ABOUT IT IS THE LAND DEVELOPMENT
CODE.
YOU'VE HEARD IT FROM DEVELOPERS.
YOU FEEL IT AT YOUR EVENING MEETINGS.
WE HAVE A 30-YEAR LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE THAT HAS BEEN ADDED
TO AND FIXED TO.
AND ONE OF THE THINGS THAT NOT JUST FOR THE DEVELOPMENT
COMMUNITY, BUT FOR THE RESIDENTS AND CITIZENS TO UNDERSTAND
WHAT THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE IS, HOW TO USE IT, HOW TO
FOLLOW IT.
WE REALLY NEED TO UPDATE OUR LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
IT HASN'T BEEN TOUCHED IN 30 YEARS.
I SEE WHY.
ONE OF THE THINGS I SHARE -- I SHARED THIS WITH SOME OF YOU,
BEFORE TAKING THIS POSITION, SOMEONE THAT USED TO WORK HERE
CALLED ME AND SAID, YOU'RE VERY AMBITIOUS BUT DON'T TRY AND
SAVE THE WORLD.
LEAVE THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE ALONE.
IT'S A BEAST.
DON'T TAKE IT ON.
MY RESPONSE WAS, HOLD MY BEER.
WATCH ME DO IT, RIGHT?
I JUST KNOW THAT THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE IS SUPPOSED TO
WORK NOT JUST FOR DEVELOPERS BUT THE CITIZENS IN THE
COMMUNITY AND WHAT THEY WANT TO SEE WITH THE FUTURE, WHAT
THEY WANT IT TO LOOK LIKE.
I CHALLENGED THE BLOOMBERG TEAM TO, NUMBER ONE, GO IN AND DO
A FORENSIC AUDIT OF OUR CODE.
WHERE ARE THERE INEFFICIENCIES IN THE CODE?
ARE WE BRINGING THINGS TO COUNCIL THAT THEY ARE
AUTOMATICALLY APPROVING AND JUST BRINGING IT BECAUSE THE
CODE IS NOT EFFICIENT?
SO THEY ARE GOING THROUGH AND DOING A FORENSIC AUDIT.
THAT'S ONE OF THE FIRST THINGS WE'RE DOING.
THEY ALSO STARTED PHASE ONE OF THE PUBLIC -- STAKEHOLDER
INTERVIEWS, PEOPLE WHO USE THE CODE A LOT TO HEAR ANY
RECOMMENDATIONS.
HOW DO THEY FEEL ABOUT THE CODE?
SO WE COULD USE THAT INFORMATION TO GUIDE US IN NEXT STEPS
ON HOW DO WE APPROACH REHAULING THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
I COMPLETELY WENT OFF ON A TANGENT ON THAT.
MUNICIPAL INTEGRITY IS ONE OF THE OTHER TEAMS.
THERE IS A GROUP OF THREE BLOOMBERG EXPERTS ON THERE.
THEY SPECIALIZE IN CONTRACT, TRANSPARENCY, PROCUREMENT
PROCESS, OPTIMIZATION, INTERNAL OPERATIONS AND REPORTING.
THIS IS WHERE WE TALK ABOUT THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE
FORENSIC AUDIT.
THIS IS WHERE THEY ARE GOING THROUGH REZONING WAIVERS
SUBMITTED IN 2021 TO FIND THE DEFICIENCIES.
THE THINGS I SPOKE TO YOU ABOUT, IT'S REALLY THE MUNICIPAL
INTEGRITY TEAM THAT'S DOING THAT PIECE WHILE WE'RE DOING THE
STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS.
ALL OF THIS IS IN AN EFFORT TO MAKE OUR CODE EASIER FOR THE
CITIZENS AND FOR YOU AND YOUR LONG EVENING MEETINGS.
AND THEN LASTLY, THE LAST TEAM WE'RE WORKING WITH IS THE
REAL ESTATE TEAM.
THOSE ARE TWO BLOOMBERG EXPERTS ON THAT.
AGAIN, THIS IS IN MY PORTFOLIO.
WE REALLY NEED TO BE LOOKING AT REAL ESTATE AS A STRATEGIC
PLANNING DEPARTMENT AND TO NOT BE REACTIVE TO REAL ESTATE
TRANSACTIONS AND DEALS.
THEY ARE ALSO CONDUCTING INTERDEPARTMENTAL INTERVIEWS
BECAUSE THE REAL ESTATE DEPARTMENT HANDLES A LOT OF THE
TRANSACTIONAL THINGS FOR STORMWATER, MOBILITY, IF WE NEED
RIGHT-OF-WAY.
A LOT OF THOSE TRANSACTIONAL THINGS, THEY DO DAY TO DAY, BUT
WE ALSO NEED TO BE VERY STRATEGIC IN OUR LAND ACQUISITION
AND DISPOSITION AND HOW WE MANAGE ALL OF THOSE ASSETS.
SO WE'RE MOVING FORWARD WITH LOOKING AT BEST PRACTICES AND
ALSO SYSTEMS THAT'S IN PLACE TO MANAGE OUR ASSETS AND NOT AN
EXCEL SPREADSHEET, RIGHT?
THIS IS JUST A BRIEF OVERVIEW OF THE PROJECTS WE'RE WORKING
ON THAT STAFF WOULD OTHERWISE NOT HAVE TIME TO WORK ON THESE
TYPES OF INITIATIVES.
I HAVE TO TELL YOU THAT IT MAKES MY JOB A LITTLE EASIER
BECAUSE A LOT OF THE DAY TO DAY IS REACTIONARY TO WHO IS
CALLING NOW, WHAT'S HAPPENING NOW, AND SOME OF THE
STRATEGIC, FORWARD-FOCUSED, PLANNING-FOCUSED, I DON'T HAVE
THE TIME DAY TO DAY TO WORK ON THAT.
THIS ALLOWS US EXTRA HANDS TO DO THAT.
12:07:36PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
12:07:38PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I CAN'T SPEAK FOR MY COLLEAGUES BUT I'M GOING
TO REQUEST THAT THEY COME INTERVIEW ME ABOUT CODE
POSSIBILITY CHANGES BECAUSE I THINK THAT SPEAKING TO US WHEN
WE'RE UP HERE DOING IT ALL THE TIME WOULD BE REALLY
WONDERFUL.
12:07:58PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
IT'S -- YOU'RE GOING TO BE INTERVIEWED FOR
THIS.
THAT WAS JUST PHASE ONE THAT THEY WERE -- BECAUSE WE NEEDED
TO UNDERSTAND HOW PEOPLE FELT ABOUT THE CODE TO SHAPE THE
QUESTIONS FOR THE PEOPLE THAT ARE IMPLEMENTING THE CODE AND
THEN FOR THE RESIDENTS, INTERVIEW RESIDENTS TO SEE HOW THEY
FEEL ABOUT THE CODE, FIGURING IT OUT AND STUFF.
12:08:21PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
GREAT.
THANK YOU.
12:08:22PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
12:08:23PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
THANK YOU FOR THAT, COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE ECONOMIC TEAM, I THINK WE KIND OF SPOKE
ABOUT THAT A LITTLE BIT, AND I'M GLAD TO LOOK AT SOME
POINTERS IN THERE.
AGAIN, I WAS AT THAT GALA LAST NIGHT, RECEPTION AND WAS VERY
INTRIGUED ABOUT WHAT THEY WERE TALKING ABOUT.
I'M KIND OF PUZZLED NOW AND SAYING THIS FOR A WHILE IN MY
MIND.
OUR EBO DEPARTMENT SHOULD NOT BE UNDER MS. WYNN'S PORTFOLIO.
IT SHOULD BE UNDER THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OFFICE
PORTFOLIO.
AND THE REASON I SAY THAT, I JUST BELIEVE THAT ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT AND SMALL BUSINESSES, THAT'S A PART OF EBO.
AND THAT SHOULD BE CLOSE TO YOUR OFFICE.
IF I'M INTERVIEWED, I'M GOING TO SAY THAT BECAUSE, AGAIN,
WHEN I LOOKED AT SOME OF THE OTHER COUNTIES, WHO ARE A
LITTLE MORE PROGRESSIVE THAN US.
WE'RE TRYING TO MOVE.
THEIR DEPARTMENT HEADS CAN DO RFP, RFQ, RFI, IT HAS TO GO
OUT, IT HAS TO GO TO ANOTHER OFFICE TO OVERSEE AND LOOK AND
MAKE SURE THAT THE POINTS ARE THERE AND THAT THOSE NUMBERS
ARE THERE.
SO YOU HAVE A CROSS-CHECK OF SAYING, OKAY, YEAH, BUT YOU
MISSED THIS AND THIS AND THIS.
NO, THAT CAN'T GO OUT BECAUSE YOU'RE MISSING THIS, THIS AND
THIS.
12:09:46PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
TALKING ABOUT ENSURING THAT SMALL
BUSINESSES ARE ABLE TO PARTICIPATE?
12:09:49PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
THERE YOU GO.
OFF THE CUFF.
I'M HOPING THEY LOOK AT THAT STRATEGY AND TAKE THAT BACK TO
ADMINISTRATION.
I DON'T BELIEVE THE EBO OFFICE SHOULD BE UNDER THE
NEIGHBORHOOD ENHANCEMENT TEAM UNDER THAT PORTFOLIO.
TO ME, THAT'S ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT.
I BELIEVE THAT WORKS HAND IN HAND WITH WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO
DO WITH OUR SMALL BUSINESSES.
SO THAT WOULD BE MY SUGGESTION GOING FORWARD.
AGAIN, HOPING WE CAN MAKE THOSE CHANGES BECAUSE I BELIEVE IF
WE LOOK AT WHAT OTHER PEOPLE ARE DOING AND I'M GOING TO
SUGGEST THAT MAYBE YOUR OFFICE -- WON'T MAKE A MOTION, BUT I
KNOW THEY ARE LISTENING, THAT THEY GO AND LOOK AND SEE WHAT
THE ORANGE COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM IS DOING AND HOW THEY
ARE OPERATING AND HOW ORANGE COUNTY IS OPERATING WITH THEIR
SYSTEM.
EVERYBODY IN THE ROOM IS APPLAUDING SAYING THAT THEY ARE THE
NUMBER ONE PEOPLE, OUT OF MIAMI, HOW THEY ARE GETTING SMALL
BUSINESSES INVOLVED, THE MONEY PROCESS AND THE TRAINING THAT
THEY ARE DOING.
AGAIN, IT'S TO ME -- I ALWAYS LIKE TO GO TO TRAININGS
BECAUSE YOU ALWAYS CAN LEARN SOMETHING NEW.
WHEN YOU HEAR OTHER IDEAS WORKING AND EVERYONE IN THE ROOM
IS SAYING, WOW, AND THEY BE ABLE TO DEMONSTRATE HOW IT'S
WORKING, THAT'S SOMETHING I ALWAYS LOOK AT AND I THINK WE
SHOULD LOOK AT AS WELL.
IF YOU ARE ALL LISTENING, CHECK INTO WHAT THEY ARE DOING.
AND HOW THE EBO OFFICE IS WORKING.
THEY CALL IT MINORITY BUSINESS OVER THERE.
WE CALL IT EBO HERE.
AGAIN, TO ME, THEY HAD A GREAT SYSTEM.
THANK YOU.
12:11:22PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
12:11:24PM >>BILL CARLSON:
STATEMENT AND TWO QUESTIONS.
ONE, THANK YOU FOR DOING THIS.
A LOT OF MY CONSTITUENTS HAD CONCERNS ABOUT THIS CONTRACT
AND THE RELATIONSHIP OF BLOOMBERG EMBEDDED IN DEPARTMENTS,
AND THIS HAS GIVEN US SOME INSIGHTS INTO IT.
I'M SURE THERE WILL BE MORE DETAILS.
BEFORE I COMMENT, I WANT TO GET FEEDBACK FROM CONSTITUENTS,
SO ANYBODY WATCHING, PLEASE LET ME KNOW YOUR THOUGHTS ON
THIS.
THANK YOU, MS. TRAVIS FOR GOING THROUGH THAT.
TWO QUESTIONS.
ONE, CAN I ASSUME THAT ALL THE COMMUNICATION WITH THEM AND
ALL THE WORK PRODUCT IS BEING PRESERVED IN THE PUBLIC
RECORD?
12:11:59PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
OH, YEAH.
OH, YEAH.
IN FACT, THERE'S SOMEONE THAT REGULARLY E-MAILS ME THAT ASKS
FOR, LIKE, ANY FINAL DOCUMENTS AND I SEND THEM TO THEM.
YEAH.
12:12:12PM >>BILL CARLSON:
OKAY.
AND THEN THE SECOND THING IS WE'VE SEEN -- THEY HAVE BEEN
WORKING WITH US 18 MONTHS OR TWO YEARS.
12:12:23PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
WELL, I'VE BEEN HERE SINCE JANUARY AND THE
CONTRACT WAS APPROVED IN MARCH.
JUST SINCE THE BEGINNING OF THIS YEAR.
12:12:32PM >>BILL CARLSON:
I HAVE TO ASK THIS QUESTION, AND IT TOUCHES
A COUPLE OF -- YOU MENTIONED.
DURING THAT TIME, THE ATTACKS BY THE MAYOR'S OFFICE AGAINST
CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS HAS ESCALATED RAPIDLY.
THERE ARE CITY RULES AND STATE LAWS THAT PROHIBIT STAFF FROM
BEING INVOLVED IN THAT.
WE HAVE SEEN EVIDENCE FROM SEVERAL SOURCES THAT STAFF HAVE
BEEN INVOLVED.
I'M ASKING LEGAL ABOUT THAT.
BUT THE QUESTION IS, IS THERE ANYTHING IN THE CONTRACT WITH
BLOOMBERG THAT PROHIBITS THEM FROM PARTICIPATING IN
POLITICS.
THEY ARE NOT GETTING PAID.
SO PART OF THE PROHIBITION WITH THE EMPLOYEES IS THAT IF
THEY ARE WORKING ON CITY HOURS AND GETTING PAID BY THE CITY,
THEY SHOULDN'T BE POSTING ON SOCIAL MEDIA OR SENDING TEXTS
OR WRITING FOR A POLITICAL PURPOSE.
BUT IS THERE ANYTHING IN THE CONTRACT THAT PROHIBITS
BLOOMBERG PEOPLE FROM PARTICIPATING IN THAT?
AND CAN YOU ENSURE ME THEY HAVE NOT BEEN INVOLVED IN THE
ESCALATION OF ATTACKS AGAINST COUNCIL MEMBERS?
12:13:34PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
I CAN ASSURE YOU THEY HAVE NOT.
I CAN ASSURE YOU THAT THEY HAVE NOT.
I HAVE TO GO BACK AND LOOK AT THE CONTRACT IN DETAIL TO SEE
ANY PROHIBITION AS FAR AS POLITICS.
BUT I INTERACT WITH ALL THE TEAMS, AND I ASSURE YOU THAT
THEY ARE NOT INVOLVED IN ANY OF THAT.
12:13:50PM >>BILL CARLSON:
THE EXAMPLE IS THAT FOR THE LAST EIGHT
MEETINGS OR SO, EVERY TIME I SPEAK, WE GET A CORRECTION
AFTERWARDS.
THE CORRECTIONS ARE ACCURATE, BUT IT'S OBVIOUSLY A POLITICAL
TOOL TO TRY TO --
12:14:02PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
-- COMMUNICATIONS OFFICE, BLOOMBERG --
12:14:05PM >>BILL CARLSON:
I WANT TO MAKE SURE BLOOMBERG -- SUDDENLY
THAT'S HAPPENED IN THE LAST FEW MONTHS.
I WANT TO MAKE SURE BLOOMBERG IS NOT PARTICIPATING IN THAT.
12:14:12PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
NO.
12:14:12PM >>BILL CARLSON:
THANK YOU.
12:14:13PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
12:14:14PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I FORGOT TO MENTION THIS EARLIER, THANK YOU
FOR THIS.
CAN WE GET A COPY OF IT?
12:14:19PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
OF COURSE.
12:14:20PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
AWESOME.
THANK YOU.
12:14:22PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN VIERA.
12:14:24PM >>LUIS VIERA:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
AND I'M GLAD COUNCILMAN CARLSON MADE THIS MOTION BECAUSE I
WAS GETTING A FEW QUESTIONS AND I DISCUSSED THIS WITH YOU
YESTERDAY AND PROVIDES A LOT OF CLARIFICATION.
FOR ME, A REAL DISPOSITIVE ISSUE IS WHEN YOU SAY THIS HELPS
ME DO MY JOB.
I THINK THAT'S VERY IMPORTANT.
YOU ARE VERY VALUED HERE, ET CETERA.
IF THIS HELPS YOU DO YOUR JOB, I THINK IT'S GREAT.
I THINK HOWEVER GIVEN THE NUMBER OF QUESTIONS, LIKE I SAID
YESTERDAY, THAT ARE PRESENTED ON THIS, IT WOULD BE GOOD TO
HAVE THIS COME BACK PERIODICALLY, MAYBE ONCE A YEAR,
WHATEVER, FOR UPDATES ON WHAT BLOOMBERG IS DOING, GIVEN
THOSE QUESTIONS, ET CETERA.
IT'S FUNNY WHEN THIS PASSED 6-1 IN RETROSPECT, I WISH, I CAN
ONLY SPEAK FOR MYSELF THAT MORE SCRUTINY WOULD HAVE BEEN
APPLIED TO THIS SO WE COULD HAVE MAYBE PREVENTED SOME OF
THOSE QUESTIONS AND DEALT WITH IT AS YOU'VE DONE IN YOUR
VERY COMPREHENSIVE REPORT.
IF SOMETHING DOES COME UP TO MAYBE HAVE THIS COME UP FOR
REVIEW ONCE A YEAR, WHATEVER IT MAY BE, I WOULD BE VERY
SUPPORTIVE OF THAT.
AGAIN, I THANK THE MOTION MAKER AND I THANK YOU FOR YOUR
PRESENTATION.
THANK YOU.
12:15:25PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
MY PLEASURE.
IF ANYONE THAT IS WATCHING, I KNOW MS. STROHMEYER SAID SHE
IS WATCHING, IF SHE HAS QUESTIONS, MORE THAN HAPPY TO SPEAK
WITH HER AND ANSWER ANY OTHER QUESTIONS THAT ANYONE MAY
HAVE.
12:15:37PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
12:15:38PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I DIDN'T MENTION, YOU TALKED ABOUT THE NEW
TAX CREDITS.
AND WHEN YOU LOOK AT IT AGAIN, I GO BACK TO ORLANDO AGAIN --
12:15:50PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
I'M GOING TO GET YOU TO STOP COMPARING.
12:15:53PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
YOU TOOK LAKELAND TO THE -- THEY USE A LOT
OF THE NEW TAX CREDITS TO DO A LOT OF THE PROGRAMS, HOUSING
AND STUFF LIKE THAT IN THE AREA WITH BBIF AND OTHER
ORGANIZATIONS TRYING TO COME TO TAMPA TO START MOVING THINGS
HERE.
THEY KNOW ABOUT YOU.
SO THEY WANT TO COME HERE BECAUSE THEY KNOW ABOUT YOU.
YOU'RE A SUPERSTAR.
PEOPLE WANT TO WORK AROUND YOU.
SO THAT'S A GOOD THING.
I'M HAPPY TO BE A PART OF THAT WITH YOU.
I WANT TO MAKE MENTION -- A PERSON TOLD ME, WHY ISN'T TAMPA
TAKING ADVANTAGE OF THAT?
WHY ARE WE NOT TAKING ADVANTAGE?
I KNOW YOU ARE THE GURU.
YOU'RE ALREADY LOOKING AT THAT SO WE CAN TAKE ADVANTAGE OF
THE NEW TAX CREDITS TO LEVERAGE OUR DOLLARS TO GET MORE
THINGS GOING.
AGAIN, THANK YOU FOR PUTTING THAT IN AND SAYING THAT.
12:16:44PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
ABSOLUTELY.
12:16:46PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANYONE ELSE?
THANK YOU, MS. TRAVIS.
12:16:50PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
12:16:55PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCIL, WE HAVE MS. JENNIFER COWAN HERE.
AND SHE HAS BEEN SITTING PATIENTLY HERE.
BEFORE YOU GET UP, I'M GOING TO MAKE A QUESTION, STATEMENT
HERE.
SHE IS WITH THE LEGAL FIRM OF BRYANT MILLER AND OLIVE.
SHE IS HERE TO ADDRESS AND PRESENT ITEMS 19 THROUGH 23.
I SEE THAT IT IS 12:20 NOW.
SHALL WE GET AS MUCH DONE AS WE CAN?
I.E., THE CONSENT AGENDA ITEMS NOW SO THAT WHEN WE COME BACK
AT 1:30 WE CAN TAKE OUR TIME WITH AGENDA ITEMS 19 THROUGH
23.
12:17:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
I'VE BEEN THINKING ABOUT THIS.
I THINK WE SHOULD BREAK FOR LUNCH UNTIL 1:30.
START UP WITH 18, GO RIGHT INTO 19, 20, FOR THE ATTORNEY
THAT IS HERE, AND THEN AFTER THAT, THE CONSENT AGENDA, WHICH
IS QUICK, AND THEN WE HAVE ONE REVIEW HEARING.
ONE REVIEW HEARING THAT STARTS AT 1:30 ANYWAY.
I THINK IF WE TAKE LUNCH NOW, WE CAN KNOCK OUT THE CHARTER
STUFF AND ITEM NUMBER 18, AND IT WILL BE SMOOTH SAILING.
MOTION TO GO INTO RECESS FOR LUNCH UNTIL 1:30.
12:18:23PM >> 1:
30 IS TIGHT.
I MEANT 1:45.
12:18:30PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WE ARE RECESSED UNTIL 1:30.
[ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
[LUNCH RECESS]
1:36:28PM >>THE CLERK:
WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
1:36:42PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, COUNCIL MEMBERS, THIS
IS MS. HAILEY JOHNSON.
I DON'T KNOW IF YOU'VE HAD THE PLEASURE OF MEETING WITH HER
AND WORKING WITH HER, BUT SHE HAS SERVED THE CITIZENS OF
TAMPA WELL.
I AM PROUD TO HAVE MET HER.
I'M PROUD TO HAVE WORKED WITH HER.
SHE HAS BEEN THE LEGISLATIVE AIDE FOR ME FOR HOW LONG NOW?
FOUR MONTHS, SIX MONTHS?
SINCE AUGUST.
BUT YOU'RE PART OF THE FAMILY AND I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR
BEING PART OF THE FAMILY.
SHE IS A JUNIOR AT USF -- GO BULLS -- AND, AGAIN,
MS. JOHNSON, THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING YOU'VE DONE FOR MY
OFFICE.
THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING YOU'VE DONE AND ASSISTED CITY
COUNCIL.
THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING YOU HAVE DONE FOR THE CITIZENS OF
TAMPA.
THANK YOU FOR BEING PART OF THE FAMILY.
[ APPLAUSE ]
TODAY IS HER LAST DAY, AND SHE IS LEAVING TO PURSUE HER
STUDIES.
SO THIS IS YOUR MOMENT.
ANYTHING YOU'D LIKE TO SAY?
1:37:51PM >> I JUST WANT TO SAY THANK YOU TO TIM AND YOU, ESPECIALLY.
IT'S BEEN INTERESTING LISTENING TO ALL YOU GUYS TALK ON
THURSDAYS.
[ LAUGHTER ]
IT'S BEEN INTERESTING, FUN HEARING ALL THE CONVERSATIONS.
I'VE APPRECIATED IT.
AND JUST PICKING UP ON THE TERMINOLOGY AND THE WORDS AND HOW
YOU GUYS SPEAK TO EACH OTHER AND WITH THE LIKE PUBLIC
SPEAKERS AND THE AUDIENCE AND ALL THE DEPARTMENT HEADS, I'VE
ENJOYED IT.
THANK YOU.
1:38:19PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
YOU ARE WELCOME.
ANY COUNCIL MEMBERS LIKE TO SAY ANYTHING?
1:38:25PM >> DO YOU WANT TO COME UP AND GET A PHOTO?
1:38:27PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
YES.
THANK YOU, COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
BRILLIANT IDEA.
1:38:34PM >> YEAH, TIM, YOU SHOULD BE IN THE PICTURE.
1:38:45PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
SHOULD BE GO BULLS.
[ LAUGHTER ]
IT'S THE ONLY TIME YOU CAN DO THAT.
1:39:08PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU, COUNCIL MEMBERS, FOR INDULGING ME
IN THAT.
MR. ROSNER, LET'S GO TO AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 18.
1:39:40PM >> GOOD AFTERNOON, COUNCIL, MR. CHAIR.
THAT'S OKAY.
DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR ALIS DRUMGO.
ROB ROSNER WILL COME BEFORE YOU TODAY WITH AN UPDATE TO THE
CBA COMMENTS THAT WERE PROVIDED TO US AT THE LAST MEETING.
HE WOULD PROVIDE A BRIEF OVERVIEW TO GO THROUGH ALL THE
COMMENTS AND WE'LL LET SUSAN CLOSE US OUT.
1:40:13PM >> CAN WE PULL UP THE PRESENTATION, PLEASE?
NEXT SLIDE.
THERE WE GO.
GOOD AFTERNOON.
THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME HERE.
WE ARE COMING BACK TODAY WITH A FIRST READING OF THE
ORDINANCE THAT YOU REQUESTED, AND WE TOOK ALL OF THE
COMMENTS THAT YOU MADE AND ALL THE PUBLIC COMMENTS THAT WERE
MADE AND HAVE ENCLOSED THOSE IN A MEMO.
THIS PRESENTATION WILL IDENTIFY WHAT WAS DIFFERENT FROM OUR
FIRST PRESENTATION TO TODAY'S PRESENTATION.
SO THESE FIRST COUPLE OF SLIDES ARE GOING TO BE REVIEW JUST
TO SHOW YOU THESE THINGS ARE STILL THE SAME AND WE'VE
HIGHLIGHTED IN HERE WHAT'S DIFFERENT.
SO WITH THAT, THE PURPOSE OF THIS ORDINANCE IS TO ENSURE THE
INCORPORATION OF AGREED UPON CBA ITEMS AS PART OF THE
COMMUNITY BENEFITS AGREEMENT THAT'S APPROVED BY CITY COUNCIL
AND TO ALSO BRING TRANSPARENCY TO PROJECTS BEFORE THEY COME
OUT OF THE GROUND.
IT STILL APPLIES TO THE SAME WITH THE P-3.
I'M NOT GOING TO REREAD THIS, BUT THIS IS STILL THE SAME AS
LAST TIME.
IT DOES APPLY TO NEW CONSTRUCTION, REDEVELOPMENT RENOVATIONS
AND REHABILITATION.
SO WHERE WE HEARD YOU IS WHERE WE CHANGED THE THRESHOLDS
WHERE THE MINIMUM AMOUNTS ARE AT.
SO INSTEAD OF ONE, TWO, AND -- OR TWO, FOUR AND EIGHT, WE
WENT WITH 5 MILLION AS THE BEGINNING WITH 20% AT 1 MILLION.
SO IF SOMEONE RECEIVES A MILLION DOLLARS ON A $5 MILLION
PROJECT, THEN IT WOULD TRIGGER THE CBA.
OR IF IT'S AN AUTOMATIC $10 MILLION, THAT'S STILL THE SAME.
THAT IS THE BIG PIECE HERE.
THE ONE THING IS THAT WAS ASKED BETWEEN IS THIS ONLY CRA OR
IS THIS ONLY CITY?
NO, IT IS NOW COMBINED.
THAT WAS ONE OF THE QUESTIONS THAT CAME UP.
AND WE INCLUDED IN THE LANGUAGE THAT IT'S EITHER-OR BECAUSE
THE INCENTIVE COULD COME FROM EITHER PLACE.
WE'LL MOVE ON.
THIS IS STILL THE SAME.
THE PREWORK IS STILL THE SAME, THE DEVELOPER.
SO ON THIS CHART, THIS SHOWS THE TIERS.
SAME THING I SHOWED IN THE FIRST ONE EXCEPT IT'S EXTENDED
OUT TO TIER ONE, TIER TWO, AND TIER THREE, SO IT'S
5 MILLION, 10 MILLION, AND 25 MILLION INSTEAD OF WHAT WE HAD
BEFORE.
THEN IT CAPS OUT BETWEEN 10 MILLION.
WE RAISED IT FOR TIER 2 FOR 20 MILLION AND FOR TIER 3,
30 MILLION.
THAT MOVED IT ALL UP A LITTLE BIT SO THAT WE CAN BE A FAIR
SIZE.
ANOTHER THING THAT WAS BROUGHT UP WAS -- AND I DIDN'T BOLD
IT HERE, AND I REALIZE I MISSED THAT -- WAS ON THE MBE-SLBE
REQUIREMENTS THAT IN WORKING WITH OUR EBO DEPARTMENT ABOUT
THE ORDINANCE THAT'S ALREADY IN PLACE FOR THAT, THAT THERE'S
A MINIMUM REQUIREMENT OF 15%.
THEN WE PUT STRETCH GOALS ON HERE.
EACH ONE OF THESE SAYS 15 TO 20, 15 TO 25, OR 15 TO 30 IN
THAT ORDER FROM TIER ONE THROUGH TIER THREE.
IN ORDER TO BE COMPLIANT WITH THAT ORDINANCE, THAT'S WHY
THERE ARE TWO NUMBERS ON THERE.
ONE IS THE MINIMUM GOAL AND ONE IS THE STRETCH GOAL.
OTHER THAN THAT, EVERYTHING ELSE IS STILL THE SAME ON THIS
MATRIX.
AND THIS IS TAKING IT AND APPLYING IT TO A PROJECT THAT WE
DID.
SO IF ROME YARD CAME TO US WHEN IT WAS NOT AN RFP, BUT IF
THEY WERE TO COME TO US, VALUING THE 18 ACRES AT ABOUT
MILLION AND A HALF AN ACRE IN 2020.
THAT WOULD GIVE US OVER $27 MILLION PROJECT.
SO THAT WOULD HAVE FIT CLEANLY INTO TIER 2.
THAT'S HIGHLIGHTED HERE TO SHOW YOU HOW THAT WOULD GET
APPLIED.
WHEN THEY COME TO US, HEY, WE NEED YOUR ACREAGE, WE WANT IT
FOR FREE OR A DOLLAR AN ACRE OR SOMETHING, WE'LL SAY THE
DIFFERENCE IS 27 MILLION.
YOU WOULD FIT IN TIER 2.
THIS IS JUST APPLYING IT AND GIVING YOU AN EXAMPLE OF HOW IT
WOULD BE APPLIED.
THIS IS STILL THE SAME SLIDE.
HIGHLIGHTED AT THE BOTTOM IS THAT IF IT'S LOCATED IN THE CRA
DISTRICT, THAT CRA CAC MEMBERS WOULD BE ELIGIBLE.
JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT YOU SAW THAT WE ARE TRYING TO
INCORPORATE BOTH TOGETHER.
MOVING ON, THIS IS STILL THE SAME.
THE PROCESS HADN'T CHANGED EXCEPT FOR WHO GETS INVOLVED.
AND THEN OUR NEXT RECOMMENDATION IS THE APPROVAL OF FIRST
READING TODAY, AND THEN PROCEEDING WITH A SECOND READING, I
WOULD GUESS ON THE 5th, BUT I THINK THAT'S A LEGISLATIVE
ISSUE.
WITH THAT, I'LL TAKE ANY QUESTIONS YOU HAVE.
1:44:27PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
1:44:29PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
WELL, WE'VE COME BACK TO WHAT WE CAN'T DO
TO WHAT WE CAN DO.
1:44:37PM >>ROB ROSNER:
YES, SIR.
1:44:38PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
IN 2019, WE WERE TOLD WE COULDN'T DO THIS,
ONLY WE IN THE CRA.
OTHER PEOPLE DID IT, SO I GUESS WE KIND OF WAS RIGHT FROM
THE GET-GO THAT WE COULD DO IT.
SO I'M GLAD THAT MS. TRAVIS CAME ALONG AND YOUR OFFICE TO
GET IT DONE FOR THE WHOLE CITY BECAUSE IT NEEDS TO BE DONE.
I'M GLAD I WAS ABLE TO PUT THIS ON THE TABLE AND THIS
COUNCIL WENT ALONG WITH THE FIRST TIME WITH OUR CRAs.
I THINK IT'S GOING TO BE GOOD FOR DEVELOPERS AS WELL.
1:45:15PM >>ROB ROSNER:
ABSOLUTELY.
1:45:16PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I THINK IT IS A WIN-WIN FOR BOTH PARTIES
AND COMMUNITIES TO GET SOME THINGS THEY MIGHT WANT TO SEE
AND DON'T GET A LOT OF FUSSING AND FIGHTING ABOUT A PROJECT
COMING IN THEIR COMMUNITY, TO WHERE WE'RE GIVING DOLLARS TO
A PROJECT, THEY'LL BE ABLE TO TALK ABOUT WHAT THEY WOULD
LIKE TO SEE AND HELP OUT WITH THE PROJECT IF THEY CAN.
I THINK IT IS A WIN-WIN.
GLAD WE HAVE THIS DONE AND MOVE THIS FORWARD.
IS JANUARY 5th THE QUICKEST DATE WE GET A SECOND READING
ON THIS?
1:45:43PM >>ROB ROSNER:
DEFER TO MS. VELEZ.
1:45:58PM >>SUSAN JOHNSON-VELEZ:
LEGAL DEPARTMENT.
A COUPLE OF THINGS, THE ORDINANCE BEFORE YOU FOR FIRST
READING TODAY DOES INCORPORATE ALL THE CHANGES AND REVISIONS
THAT WE BASED ON COUNCIL'S COMMENTS AT THE WORKSHOP AS WELL
AS COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC.
SO THE CLERK USUALLY ANNOUNCES SECOND READING, BUT I DID
WANT TO ADD THAT IN ADDITION, IF COUNCIL DOES FIRST READING
TODAY AND THE DATE SET FOR SECOND READING, WE'LL ALSO
PRESENT TO YOU THE TWO RELATED RESOLUTIONS THAT WE PRESENTED
AS PART OF THE PACKAGE AT THE OCTOBER WORKSHOP.
THE FIRST ONE WOULD BE TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY BENEFITS
ADVISORY COUNCIL FOR EACH PROJECT AND DESCRIBE HOW THAT IS
GOING TO BE, THOSE COUNCILS ARE GOING TO BE CREATED.
AND THEN ALSO APPROVE THE FORM OF THE COMMUNITY INFORMATION
SHEET THAT THE DEVELOPER AND THE CITY WOULD WORK THROUGH
TOGETHER TO DETERMINE WHAT THE BENEFITS ARE, ET CETERA.
1:46:48PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
IF WE MOVE FORWARD, WHAT WOULD BE THE
EARLIEST FOR SECOND READING?
1:46:53PM >>THE CLERK:
JANUARY 5th DUE TO PUBLICATION.
1:46:57PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
JANUARY 5th IT IS.
THANK YOU.
1:47:00PM >>SUSAN JOHNSON-VELEZ:
YOU'RE WELCOME.
I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS ON THE ORDINANCE.
IF COUNCIL FINDS IT ACCEPTABLE, WE WOULD ASK YOU TO PROCEED
WITH FIRST READING OF THE ORDINANCE THIS AFTERNOON.
1:47:08PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANY OTHER COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS?
1:47:10PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MOVE TO APPROVE.
1:47:12PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
GOT TO READ IT.
COUNCILMAN GUDES, IT SOUNDS LIKE YOU WANT TO READ THIS.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 18.
1:47:19PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
FILE NUMBER E2022-8 CH 2.
ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION.
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, RELATING TO THE
COMMUNITY BENEFIT PROGRAM, MAKING REVISIONS TO TAMPA CODE OF
ORDINANCES, CHAPTER 2 (ADMINISTRATION); CREATING ARTICLE XI,
SECTION 2-850 THROUGH SECTION 2-856; PROVIDING FOR
SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
1:47:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
SECOND.
1:47:49PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WE HAVE A MOTION MADE BY COUNCILMAN GUDES.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
ROLL CALL VOTE, PLEASE.
1:47:56PM >>LUIS VIERA:
YES.
1:47:57PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
YES.
1:47:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
YES.
1:47:59PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
YES.
1:48:01PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YES.
1:48:03PM >> CARLSON?
CITRO?
1:48:04PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
YES.
1:48:05PM >>THE CLERK:
MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY WITH CARLSON BEING
ABSENT AT VOTE.
SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON JANUARY 5th,
2023, AT 9:30 A.M.
1:48:13PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
THANK YOU, COUNCIL MEMBERS.
THIS IS A BIG DEAL.
1:48:17PM >> THANK YOU.
1:48:17PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN AND COUNCIL, I WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT
MS. JENNIFER COWAN.
DID I PRONOUNCE YOUR LAST NAME CORRECTLY?
COWAN.
THANK YOU.
SHE IS WITH THE ATTORNEY FIRM OF BRYANT, MILLER AND OLIVE.
AND SHE IS WITH US TODAY TO PRESENT ITEMS 19 THROUGH 23 AND
TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT MIGHT BE ADDRESSED BY COUNCIL.
SHALL WE START WITH AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 19?
1:48:54PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
GOOD AFTERNOON, COUNCIL.
AND WAS JUST SAID --
1:49:02PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
FOR THE RECORD, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
1:49:03PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
I'M SO SORRY.
I'M JENNIFER COWAN WITH BRYANT, MILLER AND OLIVE.
BMO WAS RETAINED FOR THE LIMITED PURPOSE OF DRAFTING THE
ORDINANCES THAT WOULD REFLECT THE FIVE CHARTER REVISIONS
THAT THIS COUNCIL PUT FORTH.
IN DRAFTING THOSE, WE REVIEWED THE MEETING VIDEOS, THE
SUMMARIES, AS WELL AS THE TRANSCRIPTS.
IN ADDITION, AFTER REVIEWING ALL OF THAT, SOME OF THE FIVE
WERE VERY CLEAR AND THERE WAS NO QUESTION AS TO WHAT THE
COUNCIL'S INTENT WERE.
THERE WERE OTHERS THAT WE BELIEVE THESE CAPTURE YOUR INTENT.
THERE WAS SOME QUESTION, SO I LEAVE IT TO THE COUNCIL TO
DETERMINE.
IN CREATING THESE ORDINANCES, WE DID REVIEW THIS BOTH WITH
YOUR CITY ATTORNEY AND YOUR CITY COUNCIL ATTORNEY, AND THEY
AGREED THAT THESE ORDINANCES CAPTURED THE COUNCIL'S INTENT.
SO TO THE FIRST ONE, THIS IS THE ORDINANCE --
1:50:08PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
YES.
I'M WAITING FOR HER TO LIFT HER HEAD.
MS. COWAN, COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK, YOU'RE RECOGNIZED.
1:50:16PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I JUST WANTED TO SAY THAT FOR COUNCIL, I HAD
MY ASSISTANT KELLY PRINT OUT A COPY OF EACH ORDINANCE.
I CIRCLED THE ACTUAL RELEVANT INFORMATION.
SO WHILE SHE'S TALKING ABOUT IT, I WILL PASS THEM OUT SO
EVERYBODY GETS A CHANCE TO ACTUALLY LOOK AT THE LANGUAGE.
I HAVE ENOUGH FOR ONE OF YOU.
IT'S GENERALLY ON THE SECOND PAGE.
SO THANK YOU.
I JUST WANTED TO GET THAT OUT OF THE WAY FIRST.
SO WE DO HAVE COPIES IN FRONT OF US.
1:50:52PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
THE WAY THAT THESE ARE STRUCTURED, SECTION
1 ACTUALLY HAS THE CHARTER LANGUAGE AND A STRIKE-THROUGH AND
UNDERLINE SHOWING THE CHANGE.
SECTION 2 HAS THE QUESTION THAT WILL BE POSED TO THE
ELECTORATE.
SO FOR THE ORDINANCE CHANGING SECTION 5.01, YOU'LL SEE THAT
THIS ORDINANCE WAS REVISED TO PROVIDE FOR THE HIRING OF
LEGAL COUNSEL WHO IS NOT A CITY EMPLOYEE TO SERVE -- I'M
SORRY, TO ADVISE THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD FOR THE TAMPA
POLICE DEPARTMENT.
THAT IS WHAT THE LANGUAGE SHOWS.
IN ADDITION TO THAT, ONE OTHER POINT THAT WAS DISCUSSED WITH
BOTH THE CITY ATTORNEY AND THE CITY COUNCIL ATTORNEY IS THAT
THERE IS AN EXISTING ORDINANCE THAT DEALS WITH THIS BOARD.
IT'S CODIFIED IN SECTION 18-8 OF THE CITY'S CODE, AND IT
PROVIDES FOR LEGAL COUNSEL FOR THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD.
SO SHOULD THIS BOARD DESIRE, THEY COULD ALSO AMEND THAT
ORDINANCE TO PROVIDE FOR THE DESIRED LEGAL COUNSEL THAT YOU
WANT, AND THAT WOULD ALLOW QUICKER AMENDMENT AND POTENTIALLY
IN LESS TIME AND WITH LESS EXPENSE THAN GOING TO REFERENDUM,
OR YOU CAN GO FORWARD WITH THE CHARTER AMENDMENTS THAT'S
BEFORE YOU.
1:52:25PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS?
1:52:30PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
THE ONLY, IF I MAY, IT SAYS PROVIDE LEGAL
COUNSEL, BUT IT DOESN'T SAY WHAT THE START, WHAT THE HOURLY
RATE IS GOING TO BE.
IT DOESN'T SAY ANYTHING ABOUT THE COUNSEL WE'RE GOING TO
HIRE, WHOEVER THAT PERSON MAY BE.
1:52:44PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
CORRECT, CORRECT.
1:52:46PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
A BLANK CHECK?
I DON'T KNOW WHAT IT IS.
1:52:49PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
NO, IT'S JUST THAT THE CITY WILL PROVIDE
THAT COUNSEL TO THE BOARD.
AS IT'S WRITTEN, IT JUST SAYS THAT THE CITY SHALL PROVIDE
COUNSEL.
IN MANY OTHER INSTANCES, YOU MAY HAVE THE CITY THAT PROVIDES
COUNSEL ON A UNIQUE ISSUE.
FOR INSTANCE, TODAY, WITH ME STANDING BEFORE YOU AND HAVING
DRAFTED THESE ORDINANCES, THIS WAS DONE UNDER SPECIAL
COUNSEL AGREEMENT THAT WE HAVE WITH THE CITY.
1:53:21PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
I REALIZE FROM TIME TO TIME THE CITY DOES
HIRE OUTSIDE COUNSEL, IF THEY HAVE A CONFLICT OR SOMETHING
OF THAT NATURE, BUT THIS IS JUST WIDE OPEN.
I DON'T KNOW.
I'M JUST ASKING A QUESTION.
1:53:35PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
1:53:37PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I AGREE WITH SOME OF THE SPEAKERS FROM
EARLIER THIS MORNING BECAUSE THE ENTIRE POINT, IS THE CITY
NOT PROVIDING, CRB ABLE TO RETAIN.
I ACTUALLY HAVE THE LANGUAGE FOR THE OTHER THAT I ASKED THIS
TO BE BASED ON.
THE MIAMI CITY CODE, THE ORANGE COUNTY CODE, AND THE KEY
WEST CHARTER.
AND THE MIAMI CITY CODE STARTS THE CIP BECAUSE THEY CALL IT
THE CITIZENS -- I CAN'T REMEMBER THE EXACT NAME.
BUT THEY CALL IT THE CIP INSTEAD.
IT SAYS THE CIP SHALL HIRE AN EXPERIENCED AND COMPETENT
ATTORNEY AT LAW.
IN THE ORANGE COUNTY CODE, IT SAYS THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD
IS AUTHORIZED TO RETAIN LEGAL COUNSEL.
KEY WEST CHARTER SAYS THE CRB MAY RETAIN THE SERVICES OF AN
ATTORNEY.
SO IN FOLLOWING THAT VEIN, MAKING SURE IT IS NOT THE CITY
RETAINING BUT THE BOARD TO KEEP IT COMPLETELY AUTONOMOUS.
SO I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE THAT CHANGE.
I ALSO WOULD LIKE TO TAKE OUT FOR THE TAMPA POLICE
DEPARTMENT BECAUSE THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD IS ABOUT THE
POLICE DEPARTMENT.
I DON'T SEE A NEED TO HAVE THOSE.
BUT I ALSO WOULD LIKE TO TAKE OUT THE LANGUAGE FOR THE
POLICE DEPARTMENT IN THE ACTUAL AMENDMENT BECAUSE, AGAIN,
THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD, THAT'S WHAT IT DOES ALREADY.
THOSE ARE THE CHANGES I WOULD MAKE.
1:55:00PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN VIERA.
1:55:01PM >>LUIS VIERA:
THANK YOU.
AND, YEAH, I'M FINE WITH THAT.
I MEAN, I LIKE COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK, I THINK YOU SAID THE
SECOND PART, WHERE IT SAYS THE CRB IS AUTHORIZED TO, SO THEY
MAY DO SO.
AND WITH REGARDS TO COUNCILMAN MIRANDA'S POINT, WHICH IS
VERY WELL TAKEN ON HAVING IT BE A BLANK CHECK, I MEAN, WHAT
THIS IS ESSENTIALLY IS GIVING THE CRB.
I USE THE TERM OUTSIDE COUNSEL AND EVERY ATTORNEY SHOULD BY
VIRTUE OF THEIR BEING A MEMBER OF THE FLORIDA BAR BE
INDEPENDENT AND HAVE LOYALTY AND WHATNOT TO THEIR CLIENT OR
CLIENTS.
BUT OUTSIDE COUNSEL FOR THE MEETINGS, WHICH I THINK SHOULD
BE PRETTY NARROWLY TAILORED, BECAUSE THE MEETINGS DON'T RUN
TOO DARN LONG.
THE RESEARCH ISSUES, IF ANY, WOULD BE VERY, VERY LIMITED.
THE GOING GOVERNMENT RATE IS PROBABLY -- I DON'T WANT TO SAY
A NUMBER, PROBABLY $200 FOR SOMETHING LIKE THIS, 205, 210,
SOMETHING OF THAT NATURE.
BUT IN OTHER WORDS, I'M FINE WITH THOSE CHANGES.
1:56:03PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
THANK YOU.
THAT'S ACTUALLY A REALLY GOOD POINT IS WE'RE NOT HIRING A
FULL-TIME ATTORNEY.
THEY DON'T -- THEY JUST NEED SOMEONE WHEN THEY NEED SOMEONE.
SO, YES.
THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THAT UP.
1:56:14PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I'M CONFUSED A LITTLE BIT.
1:56:16PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
1:56:16PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT MEANS.
ARE WE SAYING WHEN THEY MEET THEY HAVE THEIR ATTORNEY?
1:56:22PM >> YEAH.
1:56:22PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
IF THEY ARE MEETING, THEY HAVE THEIR
ATTORNEY, NOT THEY NEED AN ATTORNEY.
ALL RIGHT.
1:56:28PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
1:56:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
AND I AGREE WITH WHAT'S BEEN SAID, SPECIFICALLY COUNCILMAN
VIERA AND THE MAKER OR THE POTENTIAL MOTION THAT'S COMING.
THESE MEETINGS HAVE BEEN ONCE A MONTH.
IT'S NOT A HUGE AMOUNT OF MONEY BEING BILLED.
I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE HOURLY RATE WOULD BE, BUT THE MEETINGS
MIGHT BE OVER IN TWO HOURS, MIGHT BE AN HOUR, I DON'T KNOW.
SO THIS WOULD PROVIDE FOR THE BOARD TO BE TRULY INDEPENDENT.
HAVE A TRULY -- THERE IS NO PERCEPTION OF A BIAS.
THERE IS NO PERCEPTION OF, WELL, THE CITY CHOSE THIS
ATTORNEY.
IT KEEPS IT SEPARATE.
IT MAKES IT INDEPENDENT.
I DON'T SEE ANY HARM IN THIS.
I THINK IT HELPS KEEP THE BOARD AS INTENDED TO BE, AND THAT
IS INDEPENDENT OF THE OPINIONS OF WHOMEVER.
THEY RETAIN THE ATTORNEY, AND THAT'S IT.
THANK YOU.
1:57:30PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?
AND IT IS NOT DEFINED, BUT I'M CURIOUS TO COUNCILMAN
MIRANDA'S QUESTION, WHOSE BUDGET IS THIS COMING OUT OF?
IS THIS COMING OUT OF CITY COUNCIL'S BUDGET?
IS IT COMING OUT OF THE CITY OF TAMPA'S BUDGET?
BUT BEFORE -- MS. ZELMAN, YOU'LL GET UP AND ANSWER THAT, BUT
I WOULD LIKE AN OPINION FROM THE LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE.
THERE IS A CLAUSE THAT WE HAVE, AND IT STATES THAT THE CRB
CAN ASK FOR AN OUTSIDE INDEPENDENT ATTORNEY FOR A CONFLICT
OF INTEREST.
HOW DOES THIS DIFFER FROM CONFLICT OF INTEREST, AND CAN THAT
CONFLICT OF INTEREST -- CAN THE ATTORNEYS THAT ARE ON THE
LIST THAT THE CITY HAS FOR OUTSIDE INDEPENDENT ATTORNEYS BE
USED FOR THAT CONFLICT OF INTEREST?
DON'T WE ALREADY HAVE THAT IN PLACE NOW?
1:58:38PM >> I BELIEVE THAT WOULD BE A MORE APPROPRIATE QUESTION FOR
YOUR CITY ATTORNEY.
1:58:41PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU, THEN.
MS. ZELMAN.
1:58:47PM >>ANDREA ZELMAN:
JUST TO CLARIFY, ANDREA ZELMAN, CITY
ATTORNEY.
A COUPLE OF THINGS, LET ME ADDRESS ONE OF THE MORE MINOR
ISSUES FIRST.
TO THE PEOPLE THAT WERE ASKING WHY THE WORDS "FOR THE TAMPA
POLICE DEPARTMENT" WAS IN THERE, THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD
ORDINANCE, SECTION 18-8 OF THE CITY CODE, THE TITLE IS,
"CITIZEN REVIEW BOARD FOR THE TAMPA POLICE DEPARTMENT."
SO THAT LANGUAGE WAS JUST PUT IN TO MIRROR THE WAY THE
CURRENT CODE READS.
THERE WAS NOTHING INTENDED.
-- NOT INTENDED TO MISLEAD ANYONE.
I THINK THE ISSUE WE'RE GETTING AT IS IN THE CITY OF TAMPA,
THE ONLY ENTITY THAT CAN ENTER INTO CONTRACTS IS THE CITY OF
TAMPA.
THE CITY COUNCIL CAN'T INDEPENDENTLY CONTRACT WITH AN
ATTORNEY NOR CAN ANY BOARD, INCLUDING THE CITIZENS REVIEW
BOARD.
SO I THINK WHAT JENNIFER AND MARTY AND I DISCUSSED, WHAT WAS
TRYING TO BE ACCOMPLISHED HERE IS WHAT WE THOUGHT WAS
COUNCIL'S INTENT WAS SIMPLY THE ATTORNEY WOULDN'T BE AN
EMPLOYEE OF THE CITY OF TAMPA, SO THEY WOULD HAVE THAT LEVEL
OF INDEPENDENCE.
THEY CAN'T TRULY BE INDEPENDENT OF THE CITY OF TAMPA BECAUSE
THE CITY OF TAMPA HAS TO CONTRACT WITH THEM, PAY THEM, AND
THEY ARE REPRESENTING A BOARD OF THE CITY OF TAMPA.
PERHAPS A SUGGESTION MAY BE IF WHAT CITY COUNCIL IS TRYING
TO GET AT IS THAT THEY WANT TO SAY IN PICKING THE ATTORNEY
RATHER THAN OUR DEPARTMENT PICKING THE ATTORNEY, WE COULD
HAVE A PROCESS LIKE WHAT YOU ALL DID WITH THE SEARCH FOR
YOUR CRA DIRECTOR, WHERE THE BODY ITSELF AND IN THIS CASE, I
GUESS IT WOULD BE THE CRB COULD INTERVIEW THE ATTORNEYS THAT
THEY ARE SELECTING.
AGAIN, AT THE END OF THE DAY, IT'S STILL GOING TO BE A
CONTRACT WITH THE CITY OF TAMPA.
AND I THOUGHT THAT THE KEY THING THE COUNCIL WAS TRYING TO
ACCOMPLISH WAS THAT IT NOT BE AN EMPLOYEE OF THE CITY OF
TAMPA.
MY OFFICE, THE POLICE DEPARTMENT, WHATEVER.
AND THEN ONE FINAL COMMENT TO JENNIFER'S POINT, THIS COULD
BE ACCOMPLISHED BY AMENDING SECTION 18-8 WITHOUT TOUCHING
THE CHARTER, WHICH, AS SHE SAID, WOULD BE A LOT FASTER.
WOULDN'T REQUIRE A REFERENDUM.
WOULDN'T REQUIRE A RUSH TO GET IT ON THE BALLOT, JUST AS AN
ASIDE.
AGAIN, I THINK THAT'S WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH.
AND THEN, FINALLY, AS TO THE OTHER ORDINANCES THAT YOU
MENTIONED FROM ORANGE COUNTY AND KEY WEST, KEY WEST, THEY
HAVE A WHOLE CHARTER PROVISION FOR THEIR CITIZENS REVIEW
BOARD.
WE DON'T.
IF YOU LOOK AT SOME OF THOSE OTHER ONES, LIKE THE ORANGE
COUNTY ONE, IT BASICALLY SAYS THAT THE PANEL CAN SELECT THE
ATTORNEY WITH THE FUNDING TO BE PROVIDED BY THE COUNTY
COMMISSION.
SO I MEAN AT THE END OF THE DAY, IT'S STILL AS IT WOULD BE
HERE.
STILL THE CITY ATTORNEY WHO IS HIRING OR PAYING OR
CONTRACTING WITH THE ATTORNEY BUT IF YOU WANTED THE BOARD TO
HAVE MORE SAY IN THE SELECTION PROCESS, THERE WOULD BE A WAY
TO WRITE THAT IN.
PROBABLY BETTER TO PUT IT IN THE ORDINANCE THAN IN THE
CHARTER, BUT THAT'S FOR YOU ALL TO DECIDE.
2:02:16PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THAT GOES BACK TO MY QUESTION.
WE ALREADY HAVE THAT IN PLACE.
2:02:20PM >>ANDREA ZELMAN:
YOU HAVE IT IN PLACE FOR CONFLICT COUNSEL,
CORRECT.
2:02:23PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THEN THE BOARD CAN SAY, SORRY, WE DON'T WANT
YOU TO GET INVOLVED BECAUSE OF THIS CONFLICT OF INTEREST.
NOW WE'LL GO AND GO OUTSIDE WITH THE LIST OF ATTORNEYS WHO
ARE ALREADY THERE.
2:02:33PM >>ANDREA ZELMAN:
RIGHT.
NOW, THE WAY IT IS CURRENTLY WRITTEN, IT IS THE CITY
ATTORNEY WHO HAS TO MAKE THAT DETERMINATION.
JUST TO BE FAIR.
I THINK WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH IS YOU WANT THE
BOARD TO MAKE THE DETERMINATION.
2:02:44PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
STEP ASIDE, WE HAVE A CONFLICT HERE.
THAT'S HOW I'M READING IT.
2:02:50PM >> NO.
2:02:52PM >>ANDREA ZELMAN:
NO, NO.
2:02:53PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THAT'S WHAT I'M TRYING TO GET CLARIFICATION
ON.
2:02:55PM >>ANDREA ZELMAN:
WELL, CURRENTLY, THAT ONLY APPLIES TO WHEN
THERE IS A CONFLICT.
I THINK WHAT MS. HURTAK IS TRYING TO SAY IS WHAT THIS
PROPOSAL WAS INTENDED TO ADDRESS WAS JUST FULL-TIME.
JUST FULL-TIME, KIND OF AN OUTSIDE COUNSEL AS THE BOARD'S
ATTORNEY, NOT ONLY IN CASES OF CONFLICT.
2:03:15PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
FULL-TIME MEANING WHENEVER THEY ARE NEEDED,
NOT FULL-TIME, FULL-TIME.
2:03:21PM >>ANDREA ZELMAN:
CORRECT.
2:03:22PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
WOULD THIS LANGUAGE BE BETTER, THE CRB SHALL
RETAIN LEGAL COUNSEL WITH FUNDING TO BE PROVIDED BY THE CITY
WHO IS NOT A CITY EMPLOYEE TO SERVE AS A LEGAL ADVISOR TO
THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD.
IF WE ADDED THAT LANGUAGE JUST TO CLARIFY, YES, WITH FUNDING
TO BE PROVIDED BY THE CITY.
2:03:42PM >>ANDREA ZELMAN:
I'M SORRY.
CAN YOU SAY THAT AGAIN?
2:03:44PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
THE CRB SHALL RETAIN LEGAL COUNSEL WITH
FUNDING TO BE PROVIDED BY THE CITY WHO IS NOT A CITY
EMPLOYEE TO SERVE AS THE LEGAL ADVISOR TO THE CITIZENS
REVIEW BOARD.
2:03:56PM >>ANDREA ZELMAN:
AGAIN, RETAIN IMPLIES THEY WOULD BE
CONTRACTING WITH THAT ATTORNEY, BUT ONLY THE CITY CAN
CONTRACT WITH THE ATTORNEY.
SO I THINK SOMETHING LIKE SHALL SELECT, SOMETHING.
2:04:08PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
SELECT.
I'M HAPPY WITH THAT WORD "SELECT."
2:04:19PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
2:04:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
IF THIS WORKS, THIS WORKS.
I WAS GOING TO SUGGEST IF THIS WERE NOT TO WORK THAT THE CRB
NOMINATE AN ATTORNEY OF THEIR CHOOSING THAT'S NOT A CITY
ATTORNEY AND THEN IT COMES TO CITY COUNCIL FOR FINAL
APPROVAL, BEING THEY ARE CONTRACTING WITH THE CITY AND THE
MONEY IS COMING FROM US SO THERE IS A LEVEL OF OVERSIGHT.
I DON'T KNOW IF THAT'S NECESSARY OR POSSIBLE IF THIS DOESN'T
FLY.
2:04:45PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YEAH, THAT'S --
2:04:46PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN VIERA.
2:04:48PM >>LUIS VIERA:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
AND WHEN I SERVED ON THE CIVIL SERVICE REVIEW BOARD, WE HAD
AN ATTORNEY WHO WAS AN OUTSIDE ATTORNEY.
OURS WAS DELANO STUART, GOD BLESS HIM, A GREAT GUY.
IT WASN'T A FULL-TIME JOB.
PROBABLY DID IT TWO, THREE, FOUR HOURS A MONTH.
THAT'S KIND OF WHAT I THINK A REASONABLE INTERPRETATION OF
THIS IS.
AND ALSO REMEMBER, AGAIN -- AND I'LL LEAVE IT TO THE MAKER
OF THE MOTION -- THAT THE CRB DOESN'T NECESSARILY HAVE TO DO
THIS.
IT'S IF THEY CHOOSE TO DO THIS.
IN TERMS OF THE CONFLICT ISSUE, THERE'S WHAT I CALL SMALL C
CONFLICT AND BIG C CONFLICT.
THE BIG C CONFLICT IS IF THERE IS A DIRECT CONFLICT OF
INTEREST THAT GOES ON THAT IMPLICATES SOMETHING THAT STARTS
A LEGAL, ETHICAL PROCESS.
I THINK WHAT THE LARGER POINT THAT PEOPLE HAVE BEEN MAKING
HERE FOR A YEAR AND A HALF OR TWO YEARS ON THIS ISSUE IS
THAT THERE IS FOR A BOARD LIKE THIS, THERE OUGHT TO BE AN
OUTSIDE COUNSEL WHO IS NOT A CITY EMPLOYEE.
I THINK THAT IS A VERY REASONABLE POSITION TO TAKE.
I ALWAYS SUPPORTED THAT, ET CETERA, ET CETERA.
TO ENTER THE CHAIRMAN'S POINT, CHAIRMAN CITRO, THE POINT OF
CONFLICT, THIS IS NOT WHAT THIS IS ADDRESSING.
THIS IS ADDRESSING THE APPEARANCE OF NONINDEPENDENCE AND FOR
A BOARD LIKE THIS, APPEARANCE IS SOMETHING THAT'S VERY
RELEVANT.
SO THAT'S WHY I SUPPORT THIS AS SUCH.
THANK YOU.
2:06:20PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
2:06:21PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
THANK YOU.
I APOLOGIZE.
SO I WILL MAKE A MOTION TO CHANGE THE LANGUAGE AND I HAVE IT
FOR YOU.
FOR THE UNDERLINES TO BE THE CRB SHALL SELECT LEGAL COUNSEL
WITH FUNDING TO BE PROVIDED BY THE CITY, WHO IS NOT A CITY
EMPLOYEE, TO SERVE AS THE LEGAL ADVISOR TO THE CITIZENS
REVIEW BOARD.
2:06:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
SECOND.
2:06:48PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WE HAVE A MOTION MADE BY COUNCILWOMAN
HURTAK, SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
IS THERE ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION?
MR. SHELBY.
2:07:00PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
LOGISTICALLY, COUNCIL, I WANT TO BE CLEAR
HOW THIS IS HANDLED SO WE CAN PUT IT WITHIN THE TIME FRAME
NECESSARY TO GET IT TO THE SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS.
I SPOKE WITH THE CLERK THIS MORNING.
WE ALSO HAVE AN ISSUE OF PUBLICATION FOR SECOND READING.
AND THE DATE FOR PUBLICATION, THE WAY THE PUBLICATIONS WORK
IS DECEMBER 21st, IS THAT CORRECT?
THAT WOULD BE THE SOONEST IT COULD BE ADVERTISED.
2:07:25PM >>THE CLERK:
[INAUDIBLE]
2:07:28PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
OKAY.
ON DECEMBER 23rd IT GETS PUBLISHED.
THEN IT WOULD COME BACK TO COUNCIL JANUARY 5th BECAUSE
SHORTLY THEREAFTER I BELIEVE IT'S THE CUT OFF TIME.
IT HAS TO BE AT THE SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS I BELIEVE BY THE
20th.
I'LL DOUBLE CHECK.
IT DOES HAVE TO GO OVER TO THE MAYOR AND THE ADMINISTRATION
AS WELL.
2:08:02PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WE HAVE A MOTION MADE BY COUNCILWOMAN
HURTAK.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION?
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
I THOUGHT YOU WERE GOING TO PUT ON YOUR LIGHT.
2:08:15PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
JUST ONE MORE CLARIFICATION, THEN, AND I
GUESS THAT WOULD GO TO YOU, MS. COWAN.
IF THESE CHANGES ARE MADE TODAY TO THIS OR ANY OF THE OTHER
ORDINANCES, WHEN WOULD IT THEN BE APPROVED BY COUNCIL FOR
FIRST READING CONSIDERATION?
2:08:32PM >> I UNDERSTOOD THIS IS YOUR FIRST READING.
2:08:34PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
THIS IS CHANGE TO THE LANGUAGE --
2:08:38PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I WAS TOLD WE COULD MAKE CHANGES BETWEEN
FIRST AND SECOND READING.
THAT WAS THE WHOLE POINT OF THIS IS THAT SOME OF THIS WE
WERE GOING TO FLESH OUT HERE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
READING.
2:08:49PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
I WANT TO BE ABSOLUTELY CLEAR.
IF THAT IS THE UNDERSTANDING, I WANT TO BE ABSOLUTELY CLEAR
ABOUT THIS SO THERE'S NO MISUNDERSTANDING.
DOES -- IF IT REQUIRES A TITLE CHANGE --
2:09:01PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
IF YOU CHANGE THE LANGUAGE TO TAKE OUT
"FOR THE TAMPA POLICE DEPARTMENT," IT WILL REQUIRE ANOTHER
FIRST READING BECAUSE YOU'LL CHANGE THE TITLE BLOCK.
2:09:10PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
OKAY.
THEN WE CAN KEEP "FOR THE TAMPA POLICE DEPARTMENT."
THAT'S FINE.
OR I'M SORRY.
2:09:19PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
2:09:20PM >>BILL CARLSON:
IF WE DO THAT THEN BECAUSE THERE'S BEEN WHAT
I CONSIDER A LOT OF MISINTERPRETATIONS OF THE CHARTER, I
THINK WE SHOULD CLARIFY SOMEWHERE THAT IT -- THAT THIS
ATTORNEY WOULD WORK WITH THE CRB, NOT WITH THE POLICE
DEPARTMENT.
IT'S AN OBVIOUS THING, BUT WE HAD FOUR YEARS OF SETTLEMENTS
SIGNED OUTSIDE THE CHARTER REQUIREMENTS.
YOU NEVER KNOW WHAT WILL HAPPEN.
2:09:51PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
2:09:52PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I DON'T UNDERSTAND.
I JUST DON'T UNDERSTAND.
YOU HAVE A LEGAL DEPARTMENT THAT IS HERE RIGHT NOW.
YOU HAVE A LEGAL DEPARTMENT UPSTAIRS RIGHT NOW.
HOW MANY TIMES HAVE WE BEEN HERE AND THEY MADE A CHANGE AND
BROUGHT THE ORDINANCE RIGHT BACK DOWN THE SAME DAY AND WE
MAKE THE CORRECTIONS THE SAME TIME.
HOW MANY TIMES HAVE WE DONE THAT?
I DON'T UNDERSTAND THIS TIME FRAME BECAUSE IF SHE'S MAKING
THE CHANGES NOW, BY THE TIME WE GET DOWN TO PROBABLY THE
LAST CHARTER, NUMBER 23 OR WHATEVER, THEY CAN HAVE THAT BACK
TO US WITH THAT CHANGE.
2:10:23PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
THAT MAY BE TRUE, SIR.
BUT IN THIS CASE, AN OUTSIDE ATTORNEY'S FIRM WAS RETAINED TO
BE ABLE TO DO THIS, NOT THE LEGAL DEPARTMENT.
2:10:33PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
EXCUSE ME.
YOU CAN'T TELL ME SHE DOESN'T HAVE THE CAPABILITY --
2:10:38PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
THEY ARE ACROSS THE STREET.
I'M NOT DISAGREEING OR DISPUTING WHAT YOU'RE SAYING.
I'M SAYING THE LOGISTICS -- CLEAR ON IT.
THE CLERK HAD ANOTHER VERY INTERESTING WAY WE MAY BE ABLE TO
HANDLE THAT.
IF WE READ THE TITLE AND DONE THIS RECENTLY, READ THE TITLE
AS CORRECTED, THE CHANGES COULD BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST AND
SECOND READING TO COMPORT IT, IS THAT CORRECT?
2:11:03PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
WHAT I'LL TELL YOU IS NORMALLY WHEN YOU
HAVE AN ORDINANCE AND YOU GO AHEAD AND YOU PUBLISH THE
AGENDA TO THE PUBLIC AND IT'S A FIRST READING AND YOU CHANGE
THAT ORDINANCE, SO LONG AS THE CHANGES YOU MAKE ARE NOT
SIGNIFICANT ENOUGH TO CHANGE THE TITLE BLOCK, YOU DON'T HAVE
A PROBLEM MOVING FORWARD.
WHEN YOU CHANGE THE TITLE BLOCK IS NORMALLY WHEN YOU HAVE TO
COME BACK AND KIND OF START ANEW WHERE YOU HAVE YOUR FIRST
READING AGAIN AND THEN YOUR SECOND READING.
2:11:33PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
2:11:37PM >>BILL CARLSON:
NEVER MIND.
SORRY.
2:11:37PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN VIERA.
2:11:38PM >>LUIS VIERA:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
JUST REALLY QUICKLY, I SAY WE GO WITH THE ADVICE OF COUNSEL.
WE EITHER CHANGE SOMETHING THAT CHANGES THE TITLE, WHICH --
UNLESS IF I MISUNDERSTOOD COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK, SHE WISHED TO
GO AS WE HAVE IT NOW, OR WE CHANGE IT AND WE WAIT ANOTHER
WEEK.
WE HAVE LAND USE HEARINGS IN TWO AND A HALF HOURS.
SO I SUGGEST THAT WE GO.
I DEFER TO THE ADVICE ON COUNCIL -- ADVICE OF COUNSEL ON THE
CHOICES WE HAVE.
2:12:09PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
2:12:10PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
IF THIS IS PART OF THE TITLE BLOCK, THEN THAT
IS -- THE PROBLEM IS SEVERAL OF THESE ORDINANCE HAVE STUFF
IN THE TITLE BLOCK THAT SHOULDN'T BE THERE.
THAT'S QUITE HONESTLY AS I'M LOOKING THROUGH THESE AND AS WE
WILL BE DISCUSSING THEM, THERE ARE QUITE A FEW OTHER THINGS
THAT SHOULDN'T BE IN THE TITLE BLOCK.
WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO MAKE SOME CHANGES ANYWAY.
SO THE ISSUE IS --
2:12:47PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MR. SHELBY.
2:12:48PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
IF I COULD FINISH THAT SENTENCE AND NOT TO
INTERRUPT.
BUT THE ISSUE IS CAN THESE CHANGES BE MADE AND DONE IN A
FORM OR FASHION THAT COMPORTS WITH THE FLORIDA LAW THAT
REQUIRES HOW THIS WILL BE PASSED AND ADOPTED, IF THAT'S
COUNCIL'S PLEASURE, ON SECOND READING AND MAKE PUBLICATION.
SO WHY DON'T WE PROCEED AND THEN WE CAN SEE HOW THINGS CAN
WORK LOGISTICALLY.
YOU MENTIONED NEXT WEEK'S MEETING.
NEXT WEEK IS A CRA MEETING UNLESS YOU HAVE SOMETHING THAT
YOU WANT TO DO A SPECIAL CALL OR ADD TO THE NIGHT MEETING
AGENDA.
THERE ARE MANY WAYS TO ADDRESS THIS.
BUT LET'S SEE WHAT COUNCIL'S PLEASURE IS AND WE WILL SEE
WHAT WE CAN DO TO MAKE IT HAPPEN.
2:13:27PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
2:13:31PM >>BILL CARLSON:
CONSIDERING HOW THESE DATES HAVE BEEN PUSHED
AND PUSHED AND PUSHED, I WOULDN'T -- I WOULD PREFER NOT TO
PUSH IT AGAIN.
I DON'T WANT TO PUT LANGUAGE THAT MIGHT BE MISLEADING OR
CONFUSING IN THERE.
BUT CONSIDERING THAT THE CHARTER WAS CHANGED SUBSTANTIALLY
WITH TWO PARAGRAPHS IN A 2018 MEMO BY A CITY ATTORNEY, I
WOULD REQUEST -- YOU MADE A MOTION ON THIS, RIGHT?
MAYBE I WOULD ASK FOR YOU TO AMEND YOUR MOTION TO ADD THAT
YOU WOULD REQUEST -- IF YOU INCLUDE THE TITLE BLOCK THE WAY
IT IS, THAT YOU WOULD ADD TO IT A REQUEST THAT THE CITY --
THE CURRENT CITY ATTORNEY WRITE US A MEMO FOR THE FILE THAT
WOULD SAY THAT HER INTERPRETATION IS THAT THIS ATTORNEY
WORKS FOR THE CRB, NOT FOR THE POLICE DEPARTMENT.
BECAUSE SOME FUTURE CITY ATTORNEY MAY MISREAD THAT THE WAY
OTHERS HAVE.
2:14:33PM >>ANDREA ZELMAN:
IF I MAY, THE NAME OF THE BOARD IS THE
CITIZEN REVIEW BOARD FOR THE TAMPA POLICE DEPARTMENT.
FOR THE TAMPA POLICE DEPARTMENT MODIFIES CITIZEN REVIEW
BOARD.
IT DOESN'T MODIFY WHO THE ATTORNEY WORKS FOR.
THE ATTORNEY WORKS FOR THE CITIZEN REVIEW BOARD FOR THE
TAMPA POLICE DEPARTMENT.
THAT'S THE NAME OF THE BOARD.
WRAPPED AROUND THE AXLE ON SOMETHING ALREADY IN THERE.
THAT IS THE NAME OF THE BOARD.
2:15:00PM >>BILL CARLSON:
I THINK IT WOULD BE HELPFUL TO PUT IT IN
WRITING SO SOMEBODY IN THE FUTURE COULD REFER TO IT.
WE HAVE SO MANY WHAT I WOULD CALL MISINTERPRETATIONS LIKE
THE LINE THAT SAYS SOMETHING LIKE THE CITY ATTORNEY HAS THE
FINAL WORD ON LEGAL OPINIONS.
AND THAT'S BEEN MISCONSTRUED TO PRETEND -- TO IMPLY THAT THE
CITY ATTORNEY IS THE SUPREME COURT OF THE CITY AND MAKES
JUDGMENTS AND RULINGS, AND THEY ARE JUST LEGAL ADVISORS.
THERE'S EMPHASIS THERE ON FINAL OPINION VERSUS LEGAL ADVICE.
AND SO I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT NOBODY IN THE FUTURE
MISCONSTRUES THIS BECAUSE A LOT OF POWER HAS BEEN TAKEN AWAY
FROM CITY COUNCIL.
IT'S NOT ABOUT TAKING POWER AWAY FROM THE ADMINISTRATION.
ABOUT TAKING AWAY POWER -- RESTORING POWERS OF CITY COUNCIL
AND MAKING SURE NOBODY TAKES POWERS AWAY IN THE FUTURE.
THANK YOU.
2:15:44PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
2:15:46PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MR. SHELBY, THIS -- [INAUDIBLE]
LIKE I SAID BEFORE, THIS IS WHERE YOU COME IN.
I DON'T CARE ABOUT THE CITY ATTORNEY RIGHT NOW.
I CARE ABOUT YOU TELLING THIS BOARD AND GIVING US THE
DIRECTIVE TO MOVE ON.
THAT'S WHAT WE RELY ON YOU FOR.
NOT TO BE NICE OR PLAY NICE.
THEY ARE GOING TO DO WHAT THEY DO.
I NEED YOU TO BE THE COACH TO DO YOUR JOB TO TELL US WHAT
YOU BELIEVE MS. HURTAK ARE THE RIGHT DIRECTIVE TO MOVE, FOR
THIS LADY TO KNOW WHAT SHE NEEDS DO, FOR THIS COUNCIL TO
KNOW WHAT WE NEED TO DO.
THAT'S WHAT I'M LOOKING FOR.
I'M LOOKING FOR YOUR LEADERSHIP TO SAY, COUNCIL, IN MY
OPINION, THIS IS THE ROUTE WE SHOULD GO TO GET WHAT YOU WANT
ACCOMPLISHED TO GET IT ON THE BALLOT, WHATEVER NEEDS TO BE
MOVED TO GET THE JOB DONE.
I NEED YOU TO BE THE COACH.
2:16:29PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
YES, SIR.
WITH REGARD TO WHAT MS. ZELMAN SAID WITH THE NAME OF THE
TITLE BEING IN THERE FOR THE TAMPA POLICE DEPARTMENT, THAT
IS SOMETHING THAT I ACTUALLY BROUGHT UP BECAUSE OF THE FACT
THAT IS THE TITLE WITHIN THE CITY CODE.
THERE IS, AS WAS STATED BY THE CITY ATTORNEY, THE OTHER
JURISDICTIONS THAT WERE CITED, MIAMI, KEY WEST, THOSE ARE
PERHAPS A DIFFERENT FORM OF GOVERNMENT THAN WE HAVE IN THE
CITY OF TAMPA.
THAT IS OPERATING UNDER A DIFFERENT CHARTER.
OUR CHARTER HAS NOTHING ANYWHERE IN IT NOW THAT USES THE
WORD CIVILIAN REVIEW BOARD, CRB.
AND THAT COMES FROM HOW THIS BOARD WAS CREATED.
AND RATHER THAN, AND IF WE HAD MAYBE MORE OF THE LUXURY OF
TIME TO BE ABLE TO DO THIS, IF IT WERE COUNCIL'S PLEASURE
AND THE PROCESS WENT THROUGH AND IT WAS VETTED PROPERLY,
MAYBE SOMETHING LIKE WHAT YOU WANT TO HAVE, THAT HAVE BEEN
CITED BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC, RELATING TO A CIVILIAN
REVIEW BOARD, MAYBE THE NEXT CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION OR
HOWEVER COUNCIL WANTS TO DO IT.
2:17:43PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
BUT WHAT ABOUT NOW?
2:17:45PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
NOW I HAVE DIFFERENT VARIABLES THAT I AM
CONCERNED WITH.
IF YOU WANT TO CHANGE IT, IF YOU FEEL STRONGLY THAT YOU
DON'T WANT THAT IN THERE, IF YOU DON'T WANT -- WHAT YOU
DON'T WANT TO HAVE IS YOU DON'T WANT TO HAVE ANY
MISPERCEPTIONS OR MISCOMMUNICATIONS BY THE PUBLIC.
YOU DON'T WANT ANYTHING MISLEADING ON YOUR CHARTER BALLOT OR
THE BALLOT SUMMARY.
THAT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT THING.
YOU'RE ALSO LIMITED JUST BY WAY OF BACKGROUND, THE NUMBER OF
WORDS THESE THINGS CAN HAVE IN IT.
SO THAT ALL BEING SAID, MY MAIN CONCERN IS THERE IS ONE
PUBLICATION IN THE CITY THAT DOES LEGAL ADVERTISING THAT
THIS CITY RETAINS.
IT PUBLISHES ONE DAY A WEEK.
WE'RE IN A HOLIDAY SEASON, AND THAT'S WHY I'M CONCERNED THAT
THIS HAS TO BE SUCH THAT IF YOU'RE GOING THROUGH THESE
EFFORTS AND YOU WANT TO MAKE IT ON THE BALLOT, WE HAVE TO
MAKE SURE THAT WE FOLLOW THAT TIME.
MY SUGGESTION IS, MY RECOMMENDATION IS, STATE WHAT IT IS YOU
THINK IS NECESSARY AND THEN WE HAVE TO FIGURE OUT HOW WE'RE
GOING TO HANDLE THE TIME FRAME TO BE ABLE TO GET IT BACK TO
YOU.
SO MY SUGGESTION WOULD BE IF THAT LANGUAGE, IF YOU FEEL IT
IS MISLEADING AND IF MS. ZELMAN WOULD AGREE WITH THAT, I SAY
THEN EVEN THOUGH I BELIEVE IT IS IN THIS SECTION BECAUSE
THERE'S NO OTHER SECTION WHERE IT COULD FIT INTO, IT FITS
INTO THAT DEPARTMENT.
SO MY SUGGESTION IS, AS A COUNCIL, WITH YOUR LEADERSHIP, YOU
TELL US WHERE YOU WANT IT TO GO AND IF IT MEANS US HAVING TO
WORK WITH BRYANT MILLER AND OLIVE TO GET IT TO YOU IN A
TIMELY FASHION, IF IT MEANS CHANGING THE COUNCIL SCHEDULE TO
GET IT INTO A TIMELY FASHION, WE WILL DO WHAT IT TAKES IN
ORDER TO BE ABLE TO COMPLY WITH FLORIDA LAW TO GET THIS ON
THE BALLOT IN A TIMELY FASHION.
2:19:38PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
OKAY.
THEN I WILL STICK WITH MY MOTION AS STANDS.
2:19:46PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WE HAVE A MOTION MADE BY COUNCILWOMAN
HURTAK.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION?
ROLL CALL VOTE, PLEASE.
2:19:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
YES.
2:19:58PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
[INAUDIBLE]
2:19:59PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YES.
2:20:00PM >>BILL CARLSON:
YES.
2:20:02PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
YES.
2:20:03PM >>LUIS VIERA:
YES.
2:20:05PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
NO.
2:20:06PM >>THE CLERK:
THE MOTION CARRIED WITH CITRO VOTING NO.
2:20:10PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 20.
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
2:20:15PM >>BILL CARLSON:
DOES THAT MEAN WE NEED TO SCHEDULE ANOTHER
FIRST READING OR ARE WE OKAY?
IF WE SCHEDULE SOMETHING, WE HAVE TO DO IT NOW, TODAY.
2:20:24PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
WE'RE NOT AT FIRST READING YET.
2:20:33PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
2:20:34PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
BUT WE COULD HAVE A FIRST READING POSSIBLY ON
THE 8th.
2:20:41PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
WE COULD.
I HAVE NOT TALKED WITH COUNCIL ABOUT IT.
WE MAY EVEN BE ABLE TO HAVE A FIRST READING THIS EVENING IF
SUCH A THING WERE POSSIBLE.
I DON'T KNOW.
OR WE COULD HAVE IT NEXT WEEK.
BUT WE HAVE NOT GOTTEN TO THAT POINT.
AND WE DON'T KNOW WHAT'S AHEAD OF US IN TERMS OF --
2:21:02PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I THINK WE'RE PUTTING THE CART BEFORE THE
HORSE HERE.
2:21:09PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MS. COWAN.
2:21:10PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
OKAY.
THE NEXT ORDINANCE BEFORE YOU IS AMENDING SECTION 2.02,
QUALIFICATIONS.
AND IT'S ADDRESSING THE TERM LIMITS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
MEMBERS.
CITY COUNCIL'S MOTION WAS VERY CLEAR ON THIS, TO DELETE THE
END OF THE SECTION THEREBY LIMITING ALL MEMBERS OF THE CITY
COUNCIL TO SERVE TWO CONSECUTIVE FULL TERMS, ELIMINATING THE
ABILITY TO IMMEDIATELY RUN AND SERVE AS A COUNCIL MEMBER FOR
A DIFFERENT DISTRICT.
I BELIEVE IT WAS REFERRED TO AS DISTRICT HOPPING, AND THIS
PROPOSED LANGUAGE REMOVES THAT.
2:21:47PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANY QUESTIONS?
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
2:21:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
SO I WAS THINKING ABOUT THIS, AND I
THINK IT WAS MAYBE TEN YEARS AGO OR SO THE COUNCIL MADE A
MOTION IF PEOPLE RESIGNED FROM COUNCIL TO RUN FOR OTHER
SEATS, AND IF THEY LOST, THEY COULDN'T COME AND JUMP -- YOU
KNOW, IF IT WAS A NOVEMBER ELECTION THEY WERE RUNNING FOR,
THEY COULDN'T LOSE AND THEN COME BACK FOR THE MARCH
ELECTION.
THEY WOULD HAVE TO SIT OUT FOUR YEARS.
I THINK THIS GOES WITH THAT, ALONG THE LINES OF THAT.
WE HAVE TERM LIMITS.
WE HAVE TWO FULL CONSECUTIVE TERMS AND THEN A COUNCIL MEMBER
IS ALLOWED TO GO TO ANOTHER SEAT IF IT'S OPEN, BUT THIS
WOULD LIMIT IT BEGINNING IN 2027.
I DON'T SEE ANY HARM OR FOUL IN THIS.
THANK YOU.
2:22:40PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANY OTHER COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS?
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
2:22:44PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN.
LET'S SAY YOU HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO JUMP SHIP OR GO
SOMEWHERE ELSE, WHEREVER YOUR MIND MAY TAKE YOU, YOUR BODY
WANTS TO GO, RUN FOR ANOTHER OFFICE OUTSIDE THE CITY OF
TAMPA.
YOU WANT TO RUN FOR A JUDGE, RUN FOR STATE ATTORNEY, YOU
WANT TO RUN FOR COUNTY COMMISSION, YOU WANT TO RUN FOR
WHATEVER, THAT IF YOU LEAVE BEFORE YOUR TERM IS ENDING IN
THE CITY, THAT'S WHAT IT MEANS, THAT YOU HAVE TO WAIT OUT
FOUR YEARS BEFORE YOU CAN RUN.
THAT'S WHAT THAT MEANS, THIS SECTION HERE.
THIS IS A LITTLE DIFFERENT.
AND I'M NOT TALKING ABOUT MYSELF.
I'M SAYING THAT IF YOU DO THIS, YOU'LL HAVE VERY FEW
INDIVIDUALS THAT UNDERSTOOD WHAP TEN YEARS PAST THE TIME
YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT SOMETHING.
LEAVE LIKE THE LIBRARY IS EMPTY.
YOU GO FOR SOMETHING, NOT GOING TO FIND IT.
IN FACT, THERE'S A THING THAT I REALLY BELIEVE IN AND
ADMIRE, THAT EVERY FOUR YEARS YOU MAY WANT TO RUN BUT YOU
MAY NOT GET ELECTED.
THE PUBLIC HAS THE RIGHT TO DO THAT AND THE PUBLIC DOES IT
IN A WELL-MANNERED SITUATION.
SO I'M NOT GOING TO VOTE FOR THIS.
IT'S JUST THE PUBLIC HAS A RIGHT TO VOTE YOU UP OR VOTE YOU
DOWN.
AND I'M NOT GOING TO TAKE THAT RIGHT AWAY FROM THE PUBLIC.
2:24:06PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
2:24:09PM >>BILL CARLSON:
YEAH, I KNOW THERE WAS SOME DISCUSSION A
COUPLE OF MONTHS AGO ABOUT IDEAS THAT HAVE BEEN SUGGESTED
DURING THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION AND WERE REJECTED.
AND I DID NOT PROPOSE THIS ONE, BUT DURING JUST FOR
DISCLOSURE, DURING THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION, I
RECOMMENDED FOUR, NO MORE THAN FOUR CONSECUTIVE TERMS.
SO THAT WOULD ALLOW SOMEONE TO BE IN THE DISTRICT AND ROLL
TO A CITYWIDE.
I'M FINE WITH THIS ONE, BUT I WOULD LIKE EITHER THE FOUR
TERMS OR TWO TERMS, BECAUSE I LIKE TO SEE TURNOVER OF
PEOPLE.
2:24:48PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
2:24:49PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I'M OPEN TO THAT AMENDMENT AS WELL.
THAT'S FINE WITH ME.
BECAUSE I THINK THAT BALANCES KNOWLEDGE AND TIME.
SO I'M ABSOLUTELY FINE WITH THAT.
2:25:04PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
2:25:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA BRINGS UP A GOOD
POINT.
ELECTIONS HAVE CONSEQUENCES AND THERE ARE ELECTIONS EVERY
FOUR YEARS.
IF PEOPLE DON'T LIKE THE INDIVIDUAL, THERE IS ANOTHER
CANDIDATE.
THE OTHER CANDIDATE WINS.
I DON'T KNOW.
2:25:23PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MR. SHELBY.
2:25:24PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
JUST A REMINDER, COUNCIL, AND FOR WHATEVER
WEIGHT THIS HAS, I MAKE NO COMMENT.
BUT JUST A REMINDER THAT TAMPA IS UNIQUE IN ONE GREAT SENSE;
IT DOES NOT HAVE STAGGERED TERMS.
I'M NOT FAMILIAR, FRANKLY, WITH ANOTHER JURISDICTION IN THE
STATE THAT DOES NOT HAVE STAGGERED TERMS.
EVERYBODY IS ON THE BALLOT EVERY FOUR YEARS.
WHAT THE PRACTICAL EFFECT MIGHT HAVE IN TERMS OF
INSTITUTIONAL MEMORY OR THINGS DOWN THE ROAD, I CAN'T SAY
AND I'M NOT GOING TO SPECULATE, BUT JUST SO YOU KNOW THAT
IT'S UNLIKE ANY OTHER JURISDICTION THAT I'M FAMILIAR WITH.
2:26:01PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
2:26:02PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
WHEN I HEARD THE WORD, ALL THIS DOES NOT
COME FROM A CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION.
WE SOME YEARS BACK AND, IN FACT, PUT THE INDIVIDUALS IN THE
CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION, AND IT WAS OVER TEN.
I FORGET -- I KNOW THE MAYOR HAD SO MANY, THE COUNCIL HAD SO
MANY AND THEN WHATEVER.
THEY BROUGHT THE RECOMMENDATIONS TO US.
IN THIS CASE, IT'S US BRINGING THE RECOMMENDATIONS TO
OURSELVES.
AM I CORRECT?
SO THAT'S FLAWED IN ITSELF.
THAT'S NOT TRANSPARENCY.
THAT'S NOT COMING FROM SOMEBODY OTHER THAN THAT US.
NOT COMING FROM A GROUP OF PEOPLE THAT WE APPOINTED TO DO A
RESPONSIBLE -- AND THEY DID A FANTASTIC JOB.
IN FACT, FOUR OF THEM ARE HERE.
THREE HERE AND ONE THERE, IF I CAN COUNT TO FOUR.
AND THOSE ARE THE THINGS I SEE.
SO THAT COMMISSION IS NOT INVOLVED IN THIS.
IN ORDER TO HAVE TRANSPARENCY AND CLARITY, SOMEBODY OTHER
THAN US DOING THIS.
WE'RE DOING THIS OURSELVES.
THAT'S IN REVERSE OF WHAT THE WHOLE THING WAS WAY BACK FOUR,
FIVE YEARS AGO, IF I REMEMBER CORRECTLY.
THAT'S ALL I'M GOING TO SAY.
2:27:08PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I RESPECT WHAT MR. MIRANDA HAS JUST STATED,
BUT WHEN THAT COMMISSION WAS PUT IN ORDER, NO CITY COUNCIL
MEMBERS WERE ON THAT COMMISSION.
SO THEY DON'T UNDERSTAND WHAT WE WENT THROUGH AND THE
INFORMATION WE WAS GIVEN AND NOT GIVEN.
NOW SITTING AS A CITY COUNCIL MEMBER, I CAN SEE SOME OF THE
FLAWS IN THAT PROCESS.
AND THERE ARE A FEW.
AND NOW SITTING AS THE ACTUAL BOARD MEMBER, SEEING SOME OF
THE THINGS WE DIDN'T GET A CHANCE TO REALLY REVIEW ALL OF
THE CHARTER, BUT SEEING SOME OF THE INTERPRETATIONS OF HOW
WE OPERATE AND THIS BOARD WORKS, WE MISSED SOME THINGS.
I'M GLAD THAT I HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE HERE THIS TERM TO
SEE, TO BE ABLE TO ARGUE SOME POINTS, BUT, AGAIN, THE
CHARTER IS NOT PERFECT.
IT DOES HAVE SOME VAGUENESS TO IT AND INTERPRETATIONS TO
ONE.
SO I THINK BEING CLEAR ON SOME OF THE ISSUES MAKES IT
BETTER.
SO PEOPLE HAVE A CLEAR UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT IT MEANS VERSUS
BROAD PERSPECTIVE.
I CAN LOOK AT A POLICE SOP.
SOME THINGS ARE CLEAR CUT.
SOME THINGS LEFT TO INTERPRETATION.
THE WRITER WHO IS GIVING DISCIPLINE OR WHOEVER WRITES.
ANYBODY CAN BE DISCIPLINED.
DEPENDS ON HOW THE WRITER IS AND HOW THEY PERCEIVE THE
PERCEPTION OF IT.
NO DIFFERENT THAN SOME OF THE STUFF THAT'S IN THIS CHARTER.
SO, AGAIN, I SAT ON THAT BOARD.
SEVERAL MEMBERS HERE.
MS. ZELMAN SAT ON THE BOARD.
I STILL CONTEND THAT SOME OF THE STUFF IN OUR CHARTER WE
MISSED AND HAD WE KNOWN WHAT WE KNOW NOW, THINGS MIGHT HAVE
BEEN DIFFERENT AND MAYBE WE HAD SOME OF THE CONCERNS FROM
THE PREVIOUS COUNCIL THAT TELLS WHAT THEY THOUGHT WE MIGHT
ADDRESS SOME OF THE ISSUES.
I DON'T KNOW.
BUT I THINK WE MISSED A FEW THINGS.
BUT GLAD THAT WE ARE LOOKING AT WHAT WE'RE LOOKING AT NOW
JUST TO MOVE FORWARD.
2:29:18PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK AND THEN WE'LL GO TO
COUNCILMAN VIERA.
2:29:23PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
SO IF WE WANTED TO FOLLOW WHAT COUNCIL MEMBER
CARLSON SAID, WE COULD SIMPLY TAKE AWAY THE LINES THAT ARE
GONE THROUGH IN THIS LANGUAGE UP AT THE TOP OF WHAT YOU'RE
LOOKING AT AND JUST ADD, TO NOT EXCEED A TOTAL OF 16 YEARS
OR FOUR FULL TERMS.
SO THE LANGUAGE WE STRUCK THROUGH, EXCEPT FOR THAT PERSON
WHO IS REPRESENTED, WE COULD KEEP ALL OF THAT AND THEN JUST
ADD TO NOT EXCEED A TOTAL OF 16 YEARS OR FOUR FULL TERMS.
WOULD THAT WORK?
COULD WE DO THAT INSTEAD?
2:30:06PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
YOU CAN CERTAINLY MAKE THAT CHANGE.
IT WILL CHANGE EVERYTHING.
YOU'LL HAVE TO GO BACK TO FIRST READING ON THIS AS WE'VE
TALKED ABOUT BEFORE.
2:30:12PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
BUT THEN DOWN AT THE BOTTOM, THE ONLY ISSUE I
HAVE IS THE ACTUAL LANGUAGE WOULD BE CHANGED TO ELIMINATING
THE ABILITY OF MEMBERS OF CITY COUNCIL WHO HAVE SERVED FOUR
CONSECUTIVE FULL TERMS TO IMMEDIATELY RUN.
2:30:25PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
NO, I THINK THERE WOULD BE SOME OTHER
LANGUAGE THAT WOULD BE CHANGED IN THAT BECAUSE WE WANT TO BE
REALLY CLEAR TO THE VOTERS WHAT IT WAS VERSUS WHAT IT'S
BECOMING.
SO THERE WOULD BE SOME ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE PROPOSED FOR
THAT.
2:30:38PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON, DOES THAT WORK FOR
YOU?
DO YOU LIKE THAT AMENDMENT?
IF NOT, I CAN TAKE IT OUT.
I'M FINE WITH FOUR TERMS, FOR THE INSTITUTIONAL MEMORY OF
LIKE COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
2:30:49PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
2:30:50PM >>BILL CARLSON:
THE ONLY THING IS THERE ARE SITUATIONS LIKE
LOUIS FACED WHERE HE FILLED TWO YEARS OF AN EXISTING TERM.
IF HE GOT ELECTED, THE FIFTH TIME, THEN HE WOULD HIT 16
YEARS AND CAPPED OUT IN THE MIDDLE OF A TERM.
2:31:06PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YOU'RE CORRECT.
TO NOT EXCEED A TOTAL OF FOUR FULL TERMS.
2:31:12PM >>BILL CARLSON:
FOUR CONSECUTIVE TERMS.
2:31:15PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
FOUR FULL CONSECUTIVE TERMS.
2:31:18PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN VIERA.
2:31:19PM >>LUIS VIERA:
THE REASON I VOTED FOR THIS THE FIRST TIME, IT
MAKES THIS CONSISTENT WITH WHAT APPLIES TO THE MAYOR, AND I
THINK THAT'S GOOD.
I THINK TO CAP IT AT 16 YEARS WOULD BE MISGUIDED.
IT WOULDN'T BE A POISON PILL FOR ME BUT THINK MISGUIDED.
THERE IS SOMETHING FOR INSTITUTIONAL KNOWLEDGE.
I THINK WHEN YOU ALLOW SOMEONE TO HAVE A FOUR-YEAR BREAK,
LIKE WE DO WITH MAYOR, YOU OPEN THE FIELD, WHICH I THINK THE
WHOLE IDEA OF TERM LIMITS.
THERE'S ALWAYS ARGUMENTS FOR AND AGAINST TERM LIMITS AND
WHATNOT.
A LOT OF PEOPLE ARGUE FOR IT IN CONGRESS, BUT FOR 34 YEARS,
FROM 63 TO 97 WE WERE REPRESENTED IN TAMPA BY SAM GIBBONS,
ONE OF THE GREATEST MEMBERS OF CONGRESS AROUND WHO DID SUCH
GREAT WORK FOR TAMPA.
SO THERE'S ALWAYS GOOD, THINGS ON BOTH SIDES.
I THINK TO CAP IT AT 16 YEARS OR WHATEVER THAT MAY BE WOULD
BE MISGUIDED, AGAIN, NOT A POISON PILL FOR ME.
BUT I DO THINK THAT IS MISGUIDED.
WHAT I WAS LOOKING AT, IN SUPPORTING THIS THE FIRST TIME WAS
TO HAVE THIS CONSISTENT WITH WHAT WE DO FOR THE EXECUTIVE.
2:32:23PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO AND THEN COUNCILMAN
MIRANDA -- COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO AND THEN COUNCILMAN
MIRANDA.
2:32:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
I WAS THINKING OVER THE PAST 60, 70
YEARS.
HOW MANY COUNCIL MEMBERS SERVED MORE THAN THE TWO OR THREE
TERMS.
I CAN ONLY THINK OF FOUR.
SAUL-SENA, MIRANDA, COPELAND, AND DUNCAN.
COPELAND AND DUNCAN HAVEN'T BEEN IN OFFICE SINCE THE '70s.
WHATEVER.
YOU KNOW WHAT I'M SAYING.
THE CHANCES ARE SLIM -- YOU KNOW WHAT I'M SAYING?
AGAIN, ELECTIONS HAVE CONSEQUENCES, AND WE'VE HAD MANY
COUNCIL MEMBERS OVER THAT TIME PERIOD AND A VERY SMALL GROUP
HAS CONTINUED.
IS IT EVEN NECESSARY?
I DON'T KNOW.
2:33:10PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
2:33:10PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR. CHAIRMAN.
WHEN YOU LOOK AT ELECTIONS, LOOK AT THE CONGRESS AND THE
PRESIDENT.
THE PRESIDENT CAN ONLY SERVE TWO TERMS, PERIOD.
AS I UNDERSTAND IT, YOU CAN SERVE FOUR AND LOSE.
I GUESS YOU CAN COME BACK.
BUT THE HOUSE, THE SENATE, AND THERE'S WITH THAT KNOWLEDGE
STAYS.
WHETHER YOU LIKE THEM OR NOT, WHETHER YOU LIKE PELOSI OR
NOT, WHETHER YOU LIKE THE GENTLEMAN FROM KENTUCKY OR NOT,
THEY ARE THERE.
AND LIKE THE NEW SPEAKER COMING UP NOW, THAT'S ANOTHER --
WHOEVER WILL BE PRESIDENT OF THE SENATE, THAT'S THERE.
AND THOSE DON'T CHANGE BECAUSE THE GOVERNMENT CAN CHANGE,
BUT THAT'S THE LEADER.
THE REST OF THEM THEY HAVE TO NEGOTIATE.
SAME THING WE DO HERE IN A WAY.
SO WE WANT TO CHANGE IT AND THAT'S WHY I'M NOT GOING TO
SUPPORT THIS.
NEVER WENT BEFORE THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMITTEE THAT I KNOW
NOW.
WE'RE MAKING CHANGES NOT QUITE FOUR YEARS OUT WITH THE
CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION MADE THE RECOMMENDATION TO US AND
SUPPOSED TO BE OPEN ONCE EVERY TEN YEARS, IF I RECALL.
I HAVEN'T READ IT, BUT THAT'S WHAT I RECALL.
NOW WE'RE DOING IT IN THREE AND A HALF YEARS, AND THAT'S
WHAT -- THERE'S NO CHARTER COMMISSION.
WE'VE TAKEN OVER THAT.
NOT DIRECTLY, BUT INDIRECTLY.
2:34:24PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
2:34:25PM >>BILL CARLSON:
JUST A COMMENT ON THAT.
THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION CREATED THE CHARTER REVIEW
COMMISSION TO COME BACK, SO THE PROCESS BEFORE THAT WAS CITY
COUNCIL WOULD MODIFY AND THE LAST CITY COUNCIL, WHICH
SEVERAL OF YOU SERVED ON CREATED THE CHARTER REVIEW
COMMISSION.
SO WE'RE ACTUALLY FOLLOWING THE ORIGINAL RULES, NOT THE ONES
CREATED BY THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION.
AND WE HAPPEN TO HAVE UNIQUE EXPERTISE.
I WON'T REVISIT ALL THE THINGS THAT I HAD PROPOSED, BUT THE
INTENT OF WHAT I WAS SAYING A MINUTE AGO ABOUT THE FOUR
CONSECUTIVE TERMS IS IF YOU CHANGE THIS AND JUST TAKE OUT
TWO AND PUT FOUR, THEN ALL IT WOULD SAY IS AFTER FOUR
CONSECUTIVE TERMS YOU HAVE TO SIT OUT FOR FOUR YEARS.
SO IT DOESN'T -- I THINK THE PROPOSAL I HAD SEVERAL YEARS
AGO WITH THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION WAS FOUR TERMS TOTAL
EVER.
BUT IF WE WERE GOING TO MODIFY THIS, WHAT I WOULD PUT IS
THAT IT WOULD BE FOUR CONSECUTIVE FULL YEAR TERMS AND THE
REST SAME.
AFTER FOUR CONSECUTIVE TERMS, SIT OUT FOR FOUR YEARS BEFORE
THEY CAN RUN AGAIN.
I DON'T CARE.
I DON'T PLAN ON RUNNING MORE THAN TWO ANYWAY.
2:35:41PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
2:35:43PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I'M FINE WITH KEEPING IT AS-IS OR DOING FOUR.
IT'S REALLY THE PLEASURE OF MY COLLEAGUES.
I AGREE WITH COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
I'M FINE WITH EITHER.
2:35:56PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANY OTHER COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS?
I JUST HAVE TO MAKE THIS STATEMENT.
I MEAN TO OFFEND NO ONE, ESPECIALLY OUR OUTSIDE INDEPENDENT
ATTORNEY THAT IS HERE WITH US.
THERE ARE FOUR MEMBERS ON THIS COUNCIL THAT SERVED ON THE
CHARTER REVIEW, ESPECIALLY WITH OUR CITY ATTORNEY THAT
SERVED ON THE CHARTER REVIEW.
13 MONTHS -- 13 MONTHS WE SPENT DELIBERATING ON THE CHANGES
THAT THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION PUT TOGETHER.
AS WE'VE ALREADY SEEN HERE, WE'RE MAKING CHANGES NOW AS
WE'RE GOING.
I'M FEELING THAT THIS ALSO MIGHT BE RUSHED.
AGAIN, I MEAN NOTHING -- NO OFFENSE TO ANYBODY, ESPECIALLY
OUR OUTSIDE INDEPENDENT COUNSEL THAT WE HAVE NOW.
WE HAVE THE MAYOR.
WE HAVE CITY COUNCIL, ALL ELECTED AT THE SAME TIME.
I'VE HEARD MANY TIMES, WOULDN'T IT BE GREAT TO HAVE A NEW
MAYOR AND ALL NEW CITY COUNCIL.
WE CAN START AFRESH.
YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE 8 PEOPLE WHO HAVE NOTHING, NO KNOWLEDGE
OF INSTITUTIONAL WITHIN THE CITY.
AND THAT MAYOR MAY COME IN AND WIPE OUT THE WHOLE STAFF,
WHICH WOULD MEAN YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE TO HAVE AT LEAST TWO
YEARS OF GAINING THAT INFORMATION.
I CAN'T SUPPORT THIS AS WRITTEN.
I COULD SUPPORT THE FOUR TERMS, BUT NOT THIS.
WHAT IS THE PLEASURE OF COUNCIL?
2:37:39PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
MY MOTION WILL BE TO STRIKE THE STRIKES AND
ADD TO NOT EXCEED A TOTAL OF FOUR FULL CONSECUTIVE TERMS.
AND THEN THE LANGUAGE AT THE BOTTOM WOULD JUST CHANGE SERVE
FOUR CONSECUTIVE FULL TERMS TO TWO CONSECUTIVE FULL TERMS TO
FOUR CONSECUTIVE FULL TERMS.
2:38:04PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WE HAVE A MOTION MADE BY COUNCILWOMAN
HURTAK.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
ROLL CALL VOTE.
2:38:11PM >>BILL CARLSON:
YES.
2:38:12PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
YES.
2:38:14PM >>LUIS VIERA:
YES.
2:38:15PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YES.
2:38:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
NO.
2:38:17PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
NO.
2:38:19PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
NO.
2:38:20PM >>THE CLERK:
THE MOTION CARRIED WITH MANISCALCO, MIRANDA,
AND CITRO VOTING NO.
2:38:26PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 21.
2:38:33PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
THE NEXT ITEM BEFORE YOU IS AN ORDINANCE
ADDRESSING SECTION 9.01, AND THIS IS THE CREATION OF
STANDING BOARDS.
BASICALLY, THE ONLY CHANGE IN THIS ORDINANCE WAS CLARIFYING
THAT THE STANDING BOARD WILL BE CREATED BY CITY COUNCIL BY
ORDINANCE WITHOUT THE MAYOR'S RECOMMENDATION.
2:39:09PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
2:39:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
I THINK THIS GOES BACK TO THE SUMMER OF 2015 WHEN THE ISSUE
OF CREATING THE CITIZENS REVIEW BOARD THAT WE DISCUSSED
EARLIER TODAY, AND THERE WAS DISCUSSION BACK AND FORTH
BETWEEN THE CITY ATTORNEY, THE CITY COUNCIL ATTORNEY, THE
CITY COUNCIL AND THE MAYOR REGARDING WHO HAS THE AUTHORITY
TO CREATE BOARDS.
AND THE OPINIONS WE GOT, FROM WHAT I REMEMBER, NOW SEVEN AND
A HALF YEARS AGO, WAS THAT ONE OF THE OPINIONS WAS THAT THE
CITY COUNCIL HAD THE AUTHORITY TO CREATE THE BOARD.
THE MAYOR AT THE TIME DISAGREED WITH THAT PER THE RESPONSE
FROM THE CITY ATTORNEY THAT ONLY THE MAYOR HAD THE AUTHORITY
TO CREATE THE BOARD.
IT BECAME A HEATED DISCUSSION.
I THINK WE CAME TO A STALEMATE AND THE BOARD WAS CREATED BUT
IT CAME DOWN TO THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL AS TO HOW
MANY APPOINTEES TO THAT BOARD THEY WOULD HAVE IN ORDER TO
KEEP IT BALANCED.
WE CAME TO AN AGREEMENT.
WE'VE AMENDED THAT SINCE, AND NOW WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THE
CRB IN REGARDS TO INDEPENDENT ATTORNEY NOW.
SO THIS IS A SEVEN AND A HALF YEAR DISCUSSION, BUT FROM WHAT
I REMEMBER, THERE WERE DIFFERING OPINIONS.
ONE ATTORNEY SAID THAT WE HAD THE AUTHORITY.
THE CITY ATTORNEY SAID THAT, NO, AND THAT ONLY THE MAYOR
COULD CREATE THE BOARD.
I'LL WAIT TO HEAR WHAT OTHER COUNCIL MEMBERS HAVE TO SAY
ABOUT THIS, BUT THAT'S WHAT I REMEMBER AND MY UNDERSTANDING.
2:40:37PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
ANYONE ELSE?
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
2:40:40PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
WELL, MY UNDERSTANDING OF THIS NOW, THIS
COUNCIL DOESN'T NEED THE MAYOR'S APPROVAL TO CREATE A BOARD.
WE CAN DO IT BY ORDINANCE.
AM I RIGHT, MR. SHELBY?
2:40:50PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
THE FULL ANSWER IS UNDER THE HOME-RULE
AUTHORITY, YOU AND YOUR LEGISLATIVE ABILITY HAVE THE RIGHT
TO CREATE AN ORDINANCE.
THE QUESTION IS, WHAT IS THE MAYOR'S REMEDY IF SHE DOES NOT
LIKE THAT ORDINANCE?
THE ANSWER IS IN THE CHARTER AND THAT IS THE VETO.
AND THERE IS A PROCESS FOR A VETO AND THERE IS A PROCESS FOR
IN THE EXERCISE OF ITS LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITY IF IT DISAGREES
WITH THE MAYOR'S VETO, CITY COUNCIL CAN OVERRIDE IT.
THERE'S BEEN A QUESTION OF INTERPRETATION AS TO WHAT THIS
CHARTER -- EXCUSE ME, WHAT THIS PROVISION IN THE CHARTER
DOES.
DOES IT THEN LIMIT THE ABILITY OF THE CITY COUNCIL TO CREATE
A BOARD WITHOUT THE PRIOR APPROVAL, THE PRE-APPROVAL, IN A
SENSE, OF THE MAYOR, BUT EVEN AFTER THAT CASE, THE MAYOR
STILL HAS THE RIGHT TO VETO IT.
OR DOES IT MEAN THAT, FOR INSTANCE, THIS IS UNDER A SECTION
OF 9.01, IS THAT THE SECTION?
THAT'S UNDER THE SECTION OF BOARDS.
IT DOES NOT SAY CITY COUNCIL BOARDS.
IT DOES NOT SAY MAYORAL BOARDS, BUT THE QUESTION IS, DOES
THAT APPLY EQUALLY TO THE MAYOR AND TO THE CITY COUNCIL?
AND THERE WAS QUESTION AS TO WHETHER IT DID AND THERE WAS A
QUESTION -- AND THIS WAS RAISED IN I BELIEVE 2018, WAS IT?
WHAT THE INTERPRETATION OF THAT SENTENCE WAS AND HOW WAS IT
APPLIED?
AND THAT WAS THE SUBJECT OF AN INTERPRETATION QUESTION.
AND THIS WAS A PROPOSED FIX TO BE ABLE TO MAKE IT CLEAR AS
TO WHAT THE AUTHORITY IS RELATED TO STANDING BOARDS AND
AD HOC BOARDS.
2:42:28PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
AGAIN, GOING BACK TO MY QUESTION, WHAT I'M
READING RIGHT NOW, THIS PROVISION RIGHT NOW, IF PASSED
TODAY, THIS COUNCIL HAS THE AUTHORITY TO PUT A STANDING
BOARD IN PLACE AS ORDINANCE, CORRECT?
I NEED MY YES-NO ANSWER.
IF IT'S NOT CLEAR, THEN THAT'S THE POINT.
LET'S MAKE IT CLEAR IF WE'RE GOING TO PASS IT.
I DON'T WANT TO PASS SOMETHING AND STILL WE'RE NOT CLEAR ON
THE INTERPRETATION.
2:42:56PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
WELL, WHO HAS THE FINAL SAY TO THE
INTERPRETATION IN THE CITY IS THE QUESTION?
IS IT THE VOTERS OR IS IT -- THE QUESTION ULTIMATELY IS --
2:43:05PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I WANT TO MAKE SURE.
IF I PUT SOMETHING TO THE VOTERS, THE VOTERS KNOW WHAT THEY
ARE CHECKING, YES, NO, SAYING THIS COUNCIL HAS THE AUTHORITY
TO MAKE ANY BOARD THEY WANT IN THE CITY BY ORDINANCE.
THAT'S WHAT I'M ASKING.
I WOULDN'T CARE IF THE MAYOR DISAGREED WITH MY BOARD OR NOT,
IF THIS COUNCIL WANTED TO ENACT SOME TYPE OF BOARD, AND WE
PASSED IT, HE OR SHE COULD VETO ALL DAY LONG, BUT THIS BOARD
COMES BACK WITH A FIVE VOTE COUNT POINT, THAT BOARD PASSES,
CORRECT?
2:43:32PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
THAT WOULD BE MY INTERPRETATION.
THAT MIGHT BE A QUESTION YOU WANT TO POSE TO THE CITY
ATTORNEY.
2:43:38PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I DON'T NEED TO POSE IT TO THE CITY
ATTORNEY RIGHT NOW.
IF THIS BOARD RIGHT NOW, THIS YOUNG LADY RIGHT HERE TO WRITE
OUR CHARTER ORDINANCE TO PUT ON THE BALLOT, IS IT STANDING?
IF YOU CAN'T ANSWER THAT -- MA'AM, I'LL ASK YOU THAT
QUESTION.
IF THIS BOARD IS ASKING YOU TO WRITE IN THE CHARTER FOR THE
VOTERS THAT THIS COUNCIL HAS THE RIGHT TO ENACT ANY BOARD WE
WANT IN ORDINANCE AND THE VOTERS VOTED THAT, WOULD THAT BE
THE STANDING INTERPRETATION?
2:44:08PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
AS THE LANGUAGE IS CHANGED, IT WOULD BE
THAT, YES, THAT THE BOARD COULD BE CREATED BY ORDINANCE.
2:44:16PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN --
2:44:18PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
YES, THE BOARD WOULD BE CREATED BY
ORDINANCE AND THEN HOWEVER YOUR ORDINANCE PROCEEDS.
I'M NOT FAMILIAR WITH YOUR VETO POWERS AND ALL OF THAT.
2:44:24PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
2:44:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
I THINK I CAN CLARIFY.
I HOPE I CAN CLARIFY.
SO MY OPINION, THIS IS NO ATTORNEY'S OPINION.
WHAT I'VE UNDERSTOOD FROM BEING HERE IN 2015 WHEN THIS
DISCUSSION CAME UP, CITY COUNCIL HAS THE AUTHORITY TO CREATE
THE BOARD.
THE MAYOR HAS THE AUTHORITY TO VETO THAT.
WITH A FIVE VOTE SUPERMAJORITY, THE CITY COUNCIL CAN
OVERRIDE THE VETO.
WHAT HAPPENED IN THAT SITUATION WAS THE LAST ADMINISTRATION
NEVER USED THE VETO POWER.
IN THE SITUATION WITH THIS BOARD, AN AGREEMENT WAS MADE.
THE MAYOR PROPOSED WHO, WHAT AND WE SETTLED IT.
WHY?
BECAUSE I SPOKE TO THE MAYOR.
I KNOW SOMETIMES I WASTE MY TIME IN MEDIATING, BUT I WANTED
TO BRING IT TO A CLOSE.
I SPOKE TO THE MAYOR.
I REMEMBER HE CALLED ME.
WHAT ABOUT IF, YOU KNOW, YOU APPOINT THIS MANY.
WHAT ABOUT THAT?
I SAID I'M SURE COUNCIL COULD GO WITH THAT AND SETTLED IT.
IT NEVER GOT TO THAT VETO, OVERRIDING THE VETO ANYWAYS.
SO WE DON'T KNOW WHAT WOULD HAVE HAPPENED BECAUSE IT NEVER
GOT THERE.
WE REACHED A SETTLEMENT.
BUT THE POINT I'M TRYING TO MAKE IS, I DON'T THINK THIS IS
NECESSARY.
BECAUSE FROM SPEAKING WITH A VARIETY OF ATTORNEYS AT THE
TIME, MR. SHELBY, THE CITY ATTORNEY THAT WAS THERE AT THE
TIME, CITY COUNCIL HAS THE AUTHORITY TO CREATE THE BOARDS.
WE DON'T NEED TO DO THIS.
2:45:47PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
YOU'RE SAYING IT'S NOT NECESSARY BECAUSE
YOU NEVER EXERCISED YOUR POWER BECAUSE YOU FELT WHAT -- I
WAS HERE THAT WHOLE TIME WHEN IT ALL WENT ON, THAT THIS
BOARD AND THE INTERPRETATION OF MS. MANDELL WAS THE MAYOR
HAD ALL THE POWER TO DO WHATEVER.
THAT'S WHAT I INTERPRETED FROM MS. MANDELL AT THAT PODIUM.
YOU MAY HAVE MADE A BACK DEAL WITH THE LAST MAYOR.
MS. MANDELL AT THAT PODIUM SAID THE MAYOR HAD THE AUTHORITY
AND THIS COUNCIL DID NOT.
AM I RIGHT, MR. SHELBY?
2:46:17PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
THAT'S MY RECOLLECTION.
2:46:18PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
CORRECT.
TO SAY WE DON'T NEED IT.
MR. MANISCALCO, I DISAGREE.
THAT'S WHY I ASKED THIS YOUNG LADY WHAT IS THE
INTERPRETATION FROM THE ACTUAL, HER VERBIAGE.
THAT WAY THERE'S NEVER ANY DOUBT ABOUT IF THIS BOARD HAS THE
AUTHORITY OR NOT.
2:46:39PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
2:46:41PM >>BILL CARLSON:
YEAH, THAT'S THE WAY I REMEMBER IT, TOO,
MS. MANDELL SAID THAT -- AND I WAS AN ACTIVIST THEN, BUT
ONLY THE MAYOR HAD THE RIGHT TO IN WHATEVER WAY CREATE OR
APPROVE THE CREATION OF COMMITTEES.
AND THEN THEY HIRED AN OUTSIDE ATTORNEY, GLEN YOUNG, WHO WAS
A GREAT PERSON.
BUT ATTORNEYS, THIS IS WHY I HAD THE WHOLE DISCUSSION IN THE
CHARTER ABOUT ATTORNEYS.
IF YOU HIRE AN ATTORNEY, THE ATTORNEY WORKS FOR YOU.
AND TECHNICALLY THE CITY ATTORNEY WORKS FOR CITY COUNCIL AND
THE MAYOR.
IT'S DESCRIBED IN THAT DETAIL IN THE CHARTER.
BUT IN REALITY, ESPECIALLY AT THAT TIME, THE ATTORNEYS
DIDN'T.
AND I DON'T THINK THEY DID ANYTHING WRONG.
I THINK THEY WERE TOLD DO CERTAIN THINGS.
MARTY'S OPINION AT THE TIME WAS THAT IT WAS OUR POWER AND
COULD DO IT.
THEIR OPINION WASN'T.
THEY HIRED AN OUTSIDE ATTORNEY AS IF THAT AGAIN WAS THE
SUPREME COURT, AND IT'S NOT.
THAT'S THE KIND OF SITUATION WHY WE NEED A CONFLICT
RESOLUTION PROCESS, BECAUSE WE MAY BE HEADED TO ANOTHER ONE
OF THOSE AGAIN.
HOPEFULLY, MS. ZELMAN HAS A DIFFERENT VIEW THAN SOME OF HER
PREDECESSORS WHO MISINTERPRETED THE CHARTER.
IN THIS CASE WE ABSOLUTELY NEED THIS.
THERE ARE SO MANY MISINTERPRETATIONS OF THE CHARTER, WHETHER
CITY ATTORNEYS IN THE PAST WERE BULLIED, WHATEVER, THEY
MISINTERPRETED THE CHARTER AND IT'S PUT THE CITY AT RISK OF
LAWSUITS AND LIABILITY, AND WE NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT WE CAP
SOME OF THESE HOLES AND MAKE IT SPECIFIC.
SO THIS DOESN'T DO ANY HARM.
IT DOESN'T TAKE AWAY ANYTHING FROM THE STRONG MAYOR FORM OF
GOVERNMENT.
IT JUST CODIFIES WHAT IS THE REALITY FROM THE POINT OF VIEW
OF THE CITY COUNCIL.
THANK YOU.
2:48:23PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
2:48:25PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
THANK YOU.
I LOOK BACK, TRYING TO FIND IN MY MIND HOW MANY TIMES A CITY
COUNCIL HAS OVERRIDDEN THE MAYOR IN A 5-2 VOTE.
I CAN REMEMBER ONCE.
I'M TRYING TO THINK IT OUT HOW MANY OTHER TIMES, MAYBE SOME
OTHER PLACE I REMEMBER.
WHAT I'M TRYING TO SAY IS THAT WE'RE LOOKING HERE TO CHANGE
THE POWER OF WHAT WE HAVE IN THE MAYOR'S OFFICE.
I'M NOT SAYING THAT WE'RE RIGHT OR WRONG.
I UNDERSTAND BOTH SIDES.
BUT IF YOU WANT A STRONG MAYOR OF GOVERNMENT WHERE ONE
PERSON IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ADMINISTRATIVE STUFF AND SEVEN
INDIVIDUALS FOR THE LEGISLATIVE STUFF, THEN YOU HAVE TO HAVE
-- MAKES YOU WORK TOGETHER.
AND IN THE FUTURE, IT MAY BE SOMETHING THAT THE COUNCIL AND
THE MAYORS CAN WORK OUT TOGETHER, CANNOT WORK OUT TOGETHER
AND THE COUNCIL MAY WANT TO CREATE ALL KIND OF BOARDS
WITHOUT THE MAYOR'S PERMISSION, BLESSING, WHATEVER YOU WANT
TO CALL IT.
BUT THAT MAYOR STILL HAS VETO POWER.
IT'S ONLY BEING USED, I REMEMBER, AND YOU CAN CHECK HISTORY,
ONE TIME, IT WAS IN 1974.
AND IT WAS A RAISE BETWEEN THE FIRE DEPARTMENT AND THE
ADMINISTRATION.
AND IT WAS SETTLED ON THE COUNCIL OVERRIDING THE MAYOR.
THAT WAS THE ONLY TIME I CAN REMEMBER.
I'M NOT SAYING THERE'S NOT ANOTHER TIME, BUT THAT IS THE
ONLY ONE THAT I REMEMBER.
IT WAS LOCAL 755 AND SAM WAS THE PRESIDENT; ARTHUR WAS THE
VICE PRESIDENT.
I CAN TELL YOU WHAT HAPPENED.
THE OFFICE OF THE CLERK USED TO BE THE MAYOR'S OFFICE.
NOBODY REMEMBERS THAT.
I HATE TO TELL YOU THIS, THERE WAS NO PHONE BACK HERE.
THERE WERE NO OFFICES FOR COUNCIL MEMBERS.
THERE WAS A SLOT, LIKE A PIGEON COMES IN.
THAT'S WHERE YOU GOT YOUR MAIL AND ONE PHONE.
THAT WAS DIFFERENT TIMES.
ONLY ONE TIME I CAN REMEMBER WAS THE COUNCIL EVER OVERRIDING
THE MAYOR.
AND MAYBE THERE WAS ANOTHER TIME ON THE BUDGET, BUT I THINK
IT WAS SETTLED.
I'M NOT SURE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
BUT I'M NOT GOING TO SUPPORT ANYTHING THAT LEAVES THE MAYOR
OUT BECAUSE IT STARTS TO WITHER AWAY AND STARTS WITH TWO
DIFFERENT BODIES NOT COMMUNICATING WITH EACH OTHER AND I
DON'T WANT THE PUBLIC TO GO THROUGH THAT.
2:50:49PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MR. SHELBY.
2:50:51PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
I'M CONCERNED THAT THERE IS THE OPPORTUNITY
FOR MISINTERPRETATION HERE.
I THINK WHAT THIS DOES IS GOES TO WHAT COUNCILMAN GUDES HAD
TO SAY WITH ENSURING, AND YOU WERE ABLE TO DO THAT WITH
DIRECT QUESTIONING OF INDEPENDENT OR AN OUTSIDE COUNSEL AS
TO WHAT THE INTERPRETATION WOULD BE.
THIS CAME TO FORE WHEN THE CITY ATTORNEY PREPARED THIS LAST
TIME AROUND FOR CHANGES TO THE CRB, AND PREPARED A MEMO FOR
COUNCIL WHICH WAS RESPONDED TO BY AN ATTORNEY FOR THE ACLU.
AND IN THAT DISCUSSION, THERE WAS A DECISION ABOUT HOW THIS
PARTICULAR PROVISION WAS CHANGED.
MY CONCERN AS CITY COUNCIL ATTORNEY, WITH REGARD TO THE
CREATION OF THE BOARD TO GO BACK TO 2015 TO CLARIFY WHAT
COUNCILMAN CARLSON WAS TALKING ABOUT WAS THAT THE ISSUE CAME
UP WHEN THE PREVIOUS MAYOR WAS QUOTED IN THE NEWSPAPER AS
SAYING THE CITY COUNCIL DOES NOT HAVE THE POWER TO CREATE
THIS BOARD AND MY CITY ATTORNEY AGREES WITH ME, OR WORDS TO
THAT EFFECT.
AND THAT QUESTION IN MY MIND, AS YOUR ATTORNEY, YOUR HOME
RULE AUTHORITY TO BE ABLE TO CREATE AN ORDINANCE AND TO BE
ABLE TO CREATE A BOARD BY ORDINANCE BECAUSE THE MAYOR'S
REMEDY, AS COUNCILMAN MIRANDA CORRECTLY STATES, IS IN THE
VETO.
IN THIS SITUATION THERE WAS A PERIOD OF TIME WHEN THERE WAS
A GREAT DEAL OF DISCUSSION BETWEEN COUNCIL AND THE CITY
ATTORNEY IN WHICH I WAS INVOLVED, DOES THE MAYOR HAVE THE
ABILITY TO REMOVE THAT HOME-RULE POWER UNDER THIS CHARTER BY
PREEMPTING COUNCIL, BY CREATING AN EXECUTIVE ORDER, DOING
SOMETHING BEFORE COUNCIL HAS THE OPPORTUNITY TO ACT, WHICH
WAS THE PROCESS IN 2015.
BEFORE COUNCIL HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO ACT, AN EXECUTIVE ORDER
WAS CREATED AND THEREFORE THE ARGUMENT WAS MADE THAT COUNCIL
LOST ITS LEGISLATIVE HOME-RULE AUTHORITY.
THE SECTION THAT I RELIED UPON IN 2015 WAS CHANGED BY THE
CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION.
THIS SECTION, SECTION 9.01 WAS BOARDS.
AND THE QUESTION ULTIMATELY BECAME, BUT FOR THE LACK OF A
COMMA OR FOR THE LACK OF A PERIOD AND A CAPITAL STARTING THE
NEXT SENTENCE, IT WAS SUBJECT TO TWO DIFFERENT
INTERPRETATIONS.
AND THAT'S WHY FOR NO OTHER REASON BECAUSE OF THE FACT THAT
IT WAS SUBJECT TO INTERPRETATION, IN MY OPINION, THAT THAT
INTERPRETATION OR ONE OF THEM COULD HAVE BEEN USED TO
INFRINGE UPON WHAT I VIEWED AS COUNCIL'S RIGHTFUL HOME RULE
AUTHORITY BY AN INTERPRETATION OF THE CHARTER.
IT'S A CLARIFICATION.
YOU HEARD WHAT THE CLARIFICATION IS.
PLAIN READING BY AN INDEPENDENT ATTORNEY THAT COUNCIL, IT
DOESN'T TAKE ANYTHING AWAY FROM THE MAYOR, BUT IT RESTORES
TO CITY COUNCIL WHAT UNDER HOME RULE AUTHORITY, EVERY
LEGISLATIVE BODY WITHIN THE STATE HAS THE ABILITY TO DO.
2:53:49PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
2:53:51PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
THANK YOU FOR SUCCINCTLY SAYING EXACTLY WHAT
I WAS GOING TO SAY.
THAT'S THE WHOLE POINT OF THIS.
THIS TAKES NO POWER AWAY FROM THE MAYOR.
2:53:58PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
NONE.
2:53:59PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
BECAUSE THE MAYOR STILL HAS THE POWER TO VETO
IT.
2:54:03PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
ABSOLUTELY.
2:54:04PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
AS COUNCILMAN MIRANDA HAS SHARED WITH US,
VERY FEW OVERRIDING VOTES HAVE OCCURRED.
SO THIS REALLY IS ABOUT CLARIFICATION.
THAT'S WHY I MADE THIS MOTION, AND I AM PRESENTING IT AS IT
STANDS RIGHT NOW.
FOR APPROVAL.
2:54:23PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN VIERA.
2:54:24PM >>LUIS VIERA:
NO.
I JUST SAY THAT WE MOVE FORWARD.
I SECOND IT.
LET'S TAKE A VOTE.
I AGREE.
2:54:29PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MOTION MADE.
ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION?
MOTION MADE BY COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN VIERA.
ROLL CALL VOTE.
2:54:39PM >>BILL CARLSON:
YES.
2:54:40PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
YES.
2:54:41PM >>LUIS VIERA:
YES.
2:54:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
YES.
2:54:44PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
NO.
2:54:45PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YES.
2:54:46PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
NO.
2:54:48PM >>THE CLERK:
THE MOTION CARRIED WITH MIRANDA AND CITRO
VOTING NO.
DID YOU READ THE TITLE OF THE ORDINANCE?
YOU NEED TO READ THE TITLE OF THE ORDINANCE IF YOU'RE GOING
TO ADOPT THE ORDINANCE.
2:55:02PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I APOLOGIZE.
LET ME READ THE TITLE OF THE ORDINANCE.
APOLOGIES.
AN ORDINANCE RELATING TO THE GOVERNMENT OF THE CITY OF
TAMPA, FLORIDA, SUBMITTING TO THE ELECTORS OF THE CITY A
PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO THE REVISED CHARTER OF THE CITY OF
TAMPA OF 1975, AS AMENDED, TO AMEND SECTION 9.01 TO CLARIFY
THAT STANDING BOARDS SHALL BE CREATED BY CITY COUNCIL BY
ORDINANCE WITHOUT REQUIRING THE MAYOR'S RECOMMENDATION;
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
2:55:28PM >> SECOND.
2:55:29PM >>THE CLERK:
MOTION CARRIED WITH MIRANDA AND CITRO VOTING
NO.
SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON JANUARY 5th,
2023, AT 9:30 A.M.
2:55:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
JUST ONE FINAL COMMENT.
I DON'T THINK THIS MERITS A VETO.
AGAIN, IT DOESN'T TAKE AWAY POWER FROM THE MAYOR.
IT JUST OFFERS CLARIFICATION.
I SAT THROUGH THIS DISCUSSION FROM 2015 ON, AND I APPRECIATE
MR. SHELBY'S COMMENTS FROM 2015, BECAUSE I AGREE WITH WHAT
HE SAID AT THE TIME.
WE AVOIDED A FIGHT.
WE WORKED IT OUT TO A CERTAIN DEGREE, BUT THIS DOES NOT
MERIT A VETO AND HAVING TO GO THERE.
IT DOESN'T HURT ANYBODY.
BUT THAT'S JUST MY OPINION.
THANK YOU.
2:56:13PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 22.
2:56:17PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
YES, BEFORE YOU NOW IS AN ORDINANCE
REVISING SECTION 6.03, APPOINTMENTS, AND THIS IS ADDRESSING
THE APPOINTMENTS OF CITY DEPARTMENT HEADS.
THIS IS CLARIFYING THAT THE MAYOR WILL NOMINATE THE
DEPARTMENT HEADS AND COUNCIL WILL APPOINT OR DISAPPROVE THE
NOMINATION.
IF DISAPPROVED, THEN THE MAYOR WILL SUBMIT ANOTHER NOMINEE.
THE MAYOR MAY APPOINT AN EXISTING CITY EMPLOYEE TO SERVE AS
AN INTERIM APPOINTMENT FOR A PERIOD OF NOT MORE THAN 180
DAYS.
2:56:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
SO THIS IS ANOTHER ONE THAT I HAD
THOUGHT ABOUT THESE LAST FEW DAYS AND LOOKED AT AND READ THE
LANGUAGE HERE.
SO FROM MY UNDERSTANDING, THE MAYOR CAN ONLY APPOINT TO A
VACANCY FOR A CITY POSITION AN EXISTING CITY EMPLOYEE, IS
THAT CORRECT?
THE MAYOR HAS TO CHOOSE FROM THE EXISTING ACTIVE CITY
EMPLOYEES.
2:57:16PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
THE MAYOR MAY MAKE AN INTERIM APPOINTMENT
OF AN EXISTING EMPLOYEE WHO CAN SERVE FOR A PERIOD OF, YES,
NOT MORE THAN 180 DAYS.
2:57:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
BUT THEY CAN ONLY CHOOSE AN EXISTING
CITY EMPLOYEE OR THEY CAN PICK ANYBODY FROM WHOEVER THEY
CHOOSE TO?
2:57:33PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
THIS LANGUAGE WOULD HAVE THEM -- MAY MAKE
APPOINTMENT OF AN EXISTING CITY EMPLOYEE.
2:57:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
SO MY QUESTION IS THIS.
WE HAVE CHIEF OF STAFF JOHN BENNETT IN THE ROOM.
JOHN BENNETT WAS EMPLOYED BY THE CITY, RETIRED, AND WENT TO
ANOTHER JURISDICTION TO WORK.
THEREFORE, THE MAYOR, HAVING COME INTO OFFICE, WOULD NOT
HAVE BEEN GIVEN THE OPPORTUNITY TO APPOINT JOHN BENNETT AS
INTERIM CHIEF OF STAFF BECAUSE HE WASN'T AN ACTIVE CITY
EMPLOYEE BECAUSE HE HAD RETIRED.
THAT'S THE THING.
MY PROBLEM WITH THIS IS, YOU KNOW, ONE OF US BECOMES MAYOR,
AND WE HAVE A RIGHT-HAND PERSON THAT IS WHATEVER, OUR
PERSON.
THERE'S NOBODY BETTER FOR CHIEF OF STAFF POSITION.
I'M USING THAT AS AN EXAMPLE.
THAT MAYOR CANNOT APPOINT THAT PERSON BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT
AN EXISTING CITY EMPLOYEE.
EVEN THOUGH THEY ARE THE GREATEST, WHATEVER, BUT IT WOULD
PROHIBIT THE MAYOR FROM DOING THAT.
SO A MAYOR WOULD COME IN WITH THE NEW ADMINISTRATION AND NOT
REALLY BE ABLE TO APPOINT WHOEVER THEY WOULD WANT TO BECAUSE
THEY HAVE TO CHOOSE EXISTING CITY EMPLOYEES.
I JUST WANT CLARITY ON THAT.
2:58:44PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
2:58:45PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
THAT IS A GREAT QUESTION.
ACTUALLY, THIS ONLY APPLIES TO INTERIM.
YOU CAN NOMINATE ANYONE YOU WANT FROM, LIKE, THE WHOLE
WORLD, BUT THEY ARE SAYING THAT IN THE INTERIM IT SHOULD BE
A CITY EMPLOYEE SO THAT YOU CAN'T CHOOSE SOMEBODY, YOU KNOW,
THE WORLD'S BEST OF CHIEF OF STAFF FROM FRANCE AND YOU'RE
GOING TO BRING THEM OVER, AND THEN YOU'RE GOING TO MAKE THEM
AN INTERIM UNTIL THEY ARE VOTED ON, WHICH BASICALLY IS
SUBVERTING THE POWER GOING THROUGH COUNCIL.
2:59:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
OKAY.
2:59:21PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
SO IN THE INTERIM, YES, YOU HAVE TO CHOOSE
SOMEONE FROM STAFF, BUT YOU CAN STILL HIRE YOUR BEST FRENCH
CHIEF OF STAFF, BUT IT HAS TO GO THROUGH APPROVAL OF COUNCIL
BEFORE THAT PERSON CAN START WORKING.
2:59:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
OKAY.
2:59:37PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I KNOW THIS WAS MR. GUDES' ORDINANCE.
DID I GET THAT RIGHT?
2:59:47PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
IF YOU DON'T MIND, I WOULD LIKE TO GO TO
MS. COWAN.
WOULD YOU CONCUR WITH WHAT COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK JUST STATED?
2:59:54PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
YES, THAT THE MAYOR CAN NOMINATE ANYONE.
THERE'S NO RESTRICTION ON WHO THEY CAN NOMINATE FOR THE HEAD
OF DEPARTMENT OR ADMINISTRATIVE PERSONNEL.
BUT THOSE THAT THE CITY COUNCIL WILL THEN HAVE TO MAKE THAT
APPOINTMENT.
THE RESTRICTION BECOMES WITH REGARD TO THE INTERIM
APPOINTMENT AS THAT BEING ONLY AN EXISTING EMPLOYEE AND ONLY
FOR 180 -- NO MORE THAN 180 DAYS.
3:00:21PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO, DOES THAT ANSWER YOUR
QUESTION OR YOUR THOUGHTS?
3:00:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
I GUESS SO.
SO THE MAYOR REALLY WOULD NOT BE PROHIBITED FROM APPOINTING
WHOMEVER THEY WANTED TO.
3:00:31PM >> IS THAT THE ANSWER TO YOUR QUESTION OR YOUR THOUGHTS?
3:00:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
I GUESS SO.
SO THE MAYOR REALLY WOULD NOT BE PROHIBITED FROM APPOINTING
WHOMEVER THEY WANTED.
3:00:35PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
THE MAYOR DOESN'T APPOINT.
THEY ONLY APPOINT AN INTERIM.
THEY WOULD NOMINATE A PERSON THAT WOULD BE CONSIDERED BY
THEN THE CITY COUNCIL FOR APPOINTMENT, AND CITY COUNCIL WOULD
EITHER APPROVE THAT APPOINTMENT OR DISAPPROVE IT.
IF THEY APPROVE IT, THEY ARE APPOINTED. IF THEY DISAPPROVE
IT, THEN THE MAYOR WOULD NEED TO SEND ANOTHER NOMINEE.
3:00:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
WOULD THE MAYOR BE ABLE TO DIRECTLY
NOMINATE SOMEBODY, THIS IS THE PERSON THAT I WANT, AND BE
VOTED -- APPROVED BY COUNCIL OR NOT, CORRECT?
SO IF WE HAVE INTERIM THERE, WHATEVER, BUT IF THEY HAVE, YOU
KNOW, WHOEVER OF THEIR CHOOSING THAT IS NOT A CITY EMPLOYEE,
THEY CAN SAY THIS IS WHO I WANT, THIS IS MY NOMINEE, AND
COME TO US.
NOW, IF THAT NOMINEE IS SHOT DOWN OR VOTED DOWN, THE MAYOR
CANNOT RESUBMIT THAT INDIVIDUAL.
CORRECT?
3:01:29PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
AS IT'S WRITTEN NOW, IN WHAT'S BEFORE
YOU, THAT'S CORRECT.
SO THEY WOULD NEED TO SUBMIT ANOTHER NOMINEE.
3:01:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
I CAN UNDERSTAND THE ARGUMENT OF, WELL,
COUNCIL CAN VOTE THAT PERSON DOWN, AND NOW THEY WON'T HAVE
THE OPPORTUNITY TO GET TO KNOW THAT PERSON BETTER, YOU KNOW,
FOR A RESUBMISSION OF THAT NOMINATION.
IF YOU -- WHOEVER THAT NOMINEE IS, THEY SHOULD GO AROUND AND
MEET THE COUNCIL MEMBERS AHEAD OF TIME AND ALL THAT.
OKAY, THANK YOU.
MY QUESTIONS ARE ANSWERED.
3:02:04PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MR. SHELBY, YOU WERE GOING TO SAY
SOMETHING?
3:02:09PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
I WOULD RATHER GET OTHER COUNCILMEN.
3:02:13PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
THE INTENT OF THIS CHANGE IS SIMPLE.
YOU KNOW, YOU LOOK AT OUR FEDERAL AND OUR STATE, YOU ARE A
NOMINEE AND NOT APPOINTED, THEY ARE A NOMINEE.
AND A NOMINEE, THE PRESIDENT NOMINATES SOMEONE TO GO BEFORE
THE SENATE.
AND THE SENATE HEARS FROM THAT NOMINEE TO MAKE SURE THAT
NOMINEE FITS THE MOLD OF THE SENATE.
AND THEN THERE'S A CONFIRMATION FOR APPOINTMENT.
SO THE MAYOR CAN NOMINATE ANYBODY THEY SO CHOOSE.
WE APPOINT.
THAT'S THE ONLY POWER WE HAVE AT THE TIME.
WE APPOINT.
NOW, IF SOMEONE LEAVES OR RESIGNS, THE MAYOR CAN STILL
NOMINATE SOMEBODY, BUT IF YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT WAITING TO
NOMINATE TO GET AN APPOINTMENT FOR US, THERE SHOULD BE AN
ACTING PERSON THAT CAN RUN THAT DEPARTMENT UNTIL THAT PERSON
COMES BEFORE US WITH CONFIRMATION FOR THE APPOINTMENT, WHICH
MAKES SENSE.
YOU KNOW, YOU CAN'T HAVE SOMEONE ON THE OUTSIDE AND THAT
PERSON HAS NOT BEEN APPOINTED TO RUN CITY BUSINESS.
THAT MAKES NO SENSE.
AT ALL.
BUT THE NUMBER TWO PERSON, NUMBER THREE PERSON, WHATEVER,
CAN RUN IT UNTIL THAT 90 DAYS.
I'M GOING A LITTLE STRETCH WITH 180 DAYS.
SO I AM GIVING YOU THAT ONE.
3:03:43PM >> MAY I?
NICOLE TRAVIS, ADMINISTRATOR OF DEVELOPMENT AND ECONOMIC
OPPORTUNITY.
THIS IS A LITTLE DIFFERENT WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT THE PRESIDENT
MAKES NOMINATIONS, IT'S THROUGH THE CONSTITUTION FOR THAT
PROCEEDING TO HAPPEN THAT WAY.
AND SO THERE IS A BIG DIFFERENCE IN OUR GOVERNING DOCUMENTS
ON HOW THIS WORKS.
BUT I WANT TO TALK TO YOU.
I AM NOT HERE TO TALK TO YOU ABOUT YOUR APPOINTMENTS, I AM
COMING TO TALK TO YOU FROM A RECRUITMENT PERSPECTIVE, AND A
PRACTICAL IMPLEMENTATION OF PERSPECTIVE.
YOU COUNCIL MEMBERS HAVE TALKED ABOUT RECRUITING THE BEST
AND THE BRIGHTEST.
THERE IS NO C SUITE EXECUTIVE THAT WILL TAKE A POSITION THAT
HAS TO WAIT ON CONFIRMATION FROM A POLITICAL BODY. NO ONE
WILL DO IT.
I WOULD NOT HAVE COME AND WAIT IN THE WINGS -- NOW, I
UNDERSTAND WHY THIS HAS COME TO A HEAD, AND I UNDERSTAND
WHICH APPOINTMENT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT AND WHICH -- YOU
CANNOT RECRUIT THE BEST AND BRIGHTEST IN POLITICAL
POSITIONS. I WOULD NOT HAVE GOTTEN MY DEPUTY -- WE HAVE
BEEN WORKING CLOSELY THE LAST SEVERAL MONTHS.
I WOULD NEVER HAVE TAKEN THIS JOB IF MY -- LEAVING A GOOD
EMPLOYER THAT HAD A GOOD RELATIONSHIP, CORDIAL RELATIONSHIP
TO COME TO WORK, FROM A PRACTICAL STANDPOINT, I AM JUST
TALKING TO YOU ABOUT THE IMPLEMENTATION OF WHAT MAY HAPPEN
HERE.
YOU CANNOT RECRUIT IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT WHERE THAT
APPOINTMENT IS DEPENDENT ON A POLITICAL FACTOR.
YOU CAN'T.
3:05:28PM >> COUNCILMAN VIERA.
3:05:34PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
WELL, SHE WAS SPEAKING TO ME FIRST.
3:05:36PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
3:05:37PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
SO I CAN AGREE WITH SOME OF YOUR POINT.
I DON'T AGREE WITH ALL OF IT.
BECAUSE IF I AM AT A JOB ALREADY, I AM APPLYING FOR ANOTHER
JOB, I AM NOT GOING TO LEAVE MY CURRENT JOB UNTIL I KNOW I
HAVE GOT THE OTHER JOB.
I DON'T THINK ANYBODY IS GOING TO DO THAT.
BE IT POLITICAL OR NOT.
AND I LOVE YOU TO DEATH.
BUT I'M NOT LEAVING MY JOB UNTIL I KNOW I GOT THAT JOB.
3:05:57PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
THAT'S NOT HOW IT WORKS IN THE PRACTICAL
ENVIRONMENT.
I'M TELLING YOU AS A C SUITE EXECUTIVE THAT IS NOT HOW IT
WORKS IN THE PRACTICAL IMPLEMENTATION.
I KNOW THAT -- IF I KNOW THAT THE JOB IS WAITING IN THE
WINGS, AND DEPENDENT ON A POLITICAL BODY, YOU ARE TALKING
ABOUT SOMEONE LEAVING THEIR JOB, PUTTING THEMSELVES OUT
PUBLICLY.
YOU ARE TELLING YOUR EMPLOYER THAT YOU ARE LEAVING AND YOU
DON'T HAVE CONFIRMATION, THAT YOU HAVE A JOB, YOU CANNOT
RECRUIT, TALKING WITH EXECUTIVES IN THAT COMPANY, YOU CAN'T.
JUST CAN'T.
EVEN WHEN YOU LOOK AT CITY MANAGER SEARCHES ACROSS THE
STATE, WHEN THEY HIRE RECRUITING FIRMS, THERE'S A CERTAIN
LEVEL OF ANONYMITY TO A CERTAIN POINT AND THEN IT'S PUBLIC
KNOWLEDGE.
YOU CAN LOOK AT THOSE CITY MANAGERS THAT APPLY, THAT APPLY
FOR THE POSITION THAT DIDN'T GET THE POSITION, AND SEE HOW
LONG THEY ARE STILL THERE.
YOU ARE PUTTING ON NOTICE YOUR EMPLOYER, I'M LEAVING, AND
THEN YOU HAVE NO CERTAINTY OF MOVING FORWARD.
SO I AM JUST TELLING YOU, LIKE I AM NOT WAITING -- YOU GUYS
KNOW ME.
I AM NOT GOING TO WEIGH IN ON THE POLITICS OF IT BUT FROM A
PRACTICAL STANDPOINT WHEN YOU SAY YOU WANT TO RECRUIT THE
BEST AND THE BRIGHTEST, DAVID INGRAM WHO WAS HERE WITH YOU
THIS MORNING WOULD NOT HAVE COME KNOWING THAT THIS -- HE HAS
TO COME BEFORE A POLITICAL BODY.
AND YOU HAD A RECENT EXPERIENCE OF SOMEONE SEEING WHAT
HAPPENS WITH POLITICAL BODIES.
YOU HAD A RECENT EXPERIENCE WITH THAT.
SO I AM TELLING YOU JUST FROM A PRACTICALITY STANDPOINT, THE
REST OF THIS STUFF I AM NOT GETTING TO, BUT THIS ONE I KNOW
THAT I HAVE A LOT IN MY PORTFOLIO THAT I RECRUIT FOR THE
BEST AND BRIGHTEST THAT HAVE TO BE APPOINTED AND I TRY TO
GET IT TO YOU MEDLEY.
I PUT THE MEMO OUT AND SAY THIS IS WHO IT IS, THIS IS WHO IS
COMING, AND I KNOW YOU GUYS HAVE A LOT OF TRUST AND THE
RELATIONSHIP THAT I BUILT, BUT I AM HERE TO TELL YOU THAT
THIS WILL BACKFIRE --
3:08:02PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I JUST BELIEVE IT'S TAKING SOME OF THE
COUNCIL -- YOU KNOW, COUNCIL, APPOINT SOMEONE, WE HAVE NO
AUTHORITY OVER THAT PERSON, IF WE DON'T LIKE THAT PERSON,
AND WHAT THEY DO, WE CAN'T FIRE THEM, WE CAN'T DO NOTHING.
SO TO ME TAKING IT AWAY FROM US SAYING WE WANT TO MAKE SURE
THAT THE PUBLIC IS OUTRAGED ABOUT SOME THINGS, YOU ARE
SAYING FIRST NOT TO BE ABLE TO HAVE A HOME RULE. I CAN'T
SUPPORT THAT.
3:08:33PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
BUT THERE IS AN ACCOUNTABILITY.
THE MAYOR IS THE EXECUTIVE AND ADMINISTRATIVE ARM OF THIS,
SO IN THE WAY THAT OUR GOVERNMENT IS SET UP, YOU HAVE THE
ADMINISTRATOR, THE ADMINISTRATIVE ARM, THE CEO, THE BUCK
ULTIMATELY STOPS WITH HER.
AND SO WHEN SOMEONE IS CALLING, IF SOMEONE IS UPSET WITH
THE -- IF SOMEONE IS UPSET WITH MR. DRUMGO OR ALIS OR ABBYE,
THEY CALL ME, THEY CALL US.
ULTIMATELY, YES, YOU CANNOT DO THE HIRING AND FIRING.
YOU HAVE ONE THE CITY ATTORNEY.
BUT THAT'S THE STRUCTURE OF GOVERNMENT.
AND TO DO THIS, YOU CAN CALL FOR ACCOUNTABILITY.
YOU CAN -- I UNDERSTAND.
I KNOW, AND WE CAN RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE.
IF I CAN'T RECRUIT THE BEST AND BRIGHTEST TO DO THE WORK
HERE, THEN I DON'T HAVE THE TOOLS TO BE SUCCESSFUL HERE, AND
I'M JUST TELLING YOU FROM THE THINGS THAT YOU WANT TO DO,
THAT THIS IS OUR CHALLENGE.
3:09:43PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN VIERA.
3:09:45PM >>LUIS VIERA:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
YEAH, I MEAN, I'M VOTING ON ALL THESE THE WAY I ORIGINALLY
VOTED, UNLESS SOMETHING HAPPENS TO CHANGE MY MIND.
I VOTED AGAINST THIS FOR A NUMBER OF REASONS, INCLUDING
THIS.
I BELIEVE THAT ULTIMATELY THIS WILL RESULT IN TOO MUCH OF A
BURDEN PLACED ON THE SEARCH PROCESS.
THERE'S ALREADY MECHANISMS IN PLACE.
I WISH -- AND I UNDERSTAND COUNCILMAN GUDES' CONCERNS WHO
MADE THIS VERY LEGITIMATE, VERY REASONABLE, VERY WELL MADE,
ET CETERA.
I JUST THINK AS PRESENTED WITHIN THE TIME THAT WE HAVE, IT'S
FAR TOO EXPANSIVE.
YOU HAVE AN EXECUTIVE THAT IS TRYING TO RECRUIT FOLKS,
ET CETERA, AND THIS WOULD PLACE BURDENS UPON THAT PROCESS
THAT WOULD ULTIMATELY PLAY HORRIBLY WITHIN THE PRIVATE
SECTOR OF SOMEONE MAKING A LATERAL PUBLIC SECTOR MOVE.
IT'S JUST SOMETHING AGAIN, I SEE THE CHALLENGES BEING
ADDRESSED HERE, BUT I VOTED NO FIRST TIME AND I WILL VOTE
RESPECTFULLY NO THIS TIME.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
3:10:46PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
3:10:47PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I FEEL THAT PEOPLE ARE CONFUSED.
WE ALREADY HAVE THIS POWER.
WE ARE NOT TALKING ABOUT THE POWER TO -- I MEAN, THE MAYOR
ALREADY HAS TO PUT THE PERSON IN FRONT OF US.
WE HAVE TO -- THAT IS NOT WHAT WE ARE TALKING ABOUT HERE.
WE ARE TALKING ABOUT INTERIM POWERS.
WE ARE TALKING ABOUT PEOPLE WHO ARE COMING IN AS INTERIM.
AND WE ARE ALSO SAYING THAT IF YOU NOMINATE SOMEONE ONCE,
YOU CAN'T NOMINATE THEM AGAIN.
SO WE ARE NOT SAYING -- I MEAN, THE ACTUAL POWER OF
NOMINATING SOMEONE AND THEN REQUIRING CITY COUNCIL APPROVAL,
WE AREN'T CHANGING ANY OF THAT.
THAT ALREADY EXIST IT.
AND THAT'S ALREADY THE WAY WE ARE SUPPOSED TO DO BUSINESS.
3:11:29PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
IF YOU ARE ASKING FOR THAT BEFORE THE
EMPLOYEE --
3:11:33PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
NO, WE AREN'T.
WE ARE JUST SAYING THAT THAT EMPLOYEE CAN COME IN AND BE AN
INTERIM HEAD OF SOMETHING BEFORE THEY ACTUALLY GET HIRED BY
US, BECAUSE WE ARE THE ONES THAT TECHNICALLY HIRE THEM IN
THE END.
THEY ARE NOMINATED BY THE MAYOR, AND THEN APPOINTED BY US.
3:11:50PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
THAT STILL MEANS THAT THE PERSON DOESN'T
HAVE THE JOB THAT YOU RECRUITED THEM FOR.
WHEN I CAME, BEFORE I WAS CONFIRMED BY COUNCIL, I
ESSENTIALLY WAS IN A PROCESS OF SELECTING BEFORE COUNCIL SO
I TOOK A JOB, I WAS AN EXISTING EMPLOYEE, SO I WOULD BE ABLE
TO BE SELECTED AS AN EMPLOYEE BECAUSE I STARTED, BUT YOU ARE
SAYING THAT THAT PERSON DOESN'T HAVE THE JOB UNTIL THE
CONFIRMATION IS FINAL.
SO I AM LEAVING MY CURRENT JOB, TAKING A NEW JOB, AND I'M
NOT CONFIRMED IN GETTING THAT POSITION.
I GET IT, BUT --
3:12:27PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
BUT WHAT HAPPENS IF WE DON'T CONFIRM YOU?
I MEAN, I'M JUST SAYING, BECAUSE WE COULD EASILY NOT
CONFIRM.
3:12:34PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
I UNDERSTAND THAT.
I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE SAYING AND THERE'S A PROCESS IN
PLACE.
WHY CHANGE IT IF YOU HAVE THE PROCESS IN PLACE, TO CHANGE IT
ANY DIFFERENTLY IS -- IT DOES NOT WORK.
3:12:51PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
SO I AM JUST GOING TO RESPOND, BECAUSE THE
RESPONSE TO ME IS THE ISSUE WAS OBVIOUSLY WITH THE LAST
APPOINTMENT THAT WE HAD TO DEAL WITH, I WASN'T ON COUNCIL
YET, BUT THE IDEA OF US NOT MAKING THE COUNCIL NOT MAKING
THAT DECISION, AND THAT QUITE FRANKLY THE DECISION WAS
ALREADY MADE, AND THEN COUNCIL REALLY DOESN'T GET THE
ABILITY TO ACTUALLY MAKE THE DECISION, AND THAT IS AS
COUNCILMAN GUDES SAID OUR ONLY OPPORTUNITY TO REALLY MAKE
SURE THAT WE HAVE CHOSEN THE RIGHT PERSON.
THAT'S BASICALLY ASKING US TO --
I TOTALLY SEE YOUR POINT.
BUT THERE'S VERY FEW WAYS THAT WE CAN MOVE ON IN THE
NOMINATION PROCESS, OR THE APPOINTMENT PROCESS.
3:13:46PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
BEFORE I GO TO COUNCILMAN CARLSON, CHIEF,
DO YOU WANT TO BE SAY SOMETHING?
3:13:55PM >>JOHN BENNETT:
JUST A FEW POINTS. SOMEBODY HAS JOINED ME.
LEAVING THE INTERIM PART OUT FOR A SECOND AND SPEAKING TO
COUNCILMAN GUDES, I KNOW WE AS WE WERE BRINGING ON EXECUTIVE
STAFF, THERE WAS A QUESTION ABOUT THE SEQUENCING, THE
PROCESSING, AND SO, IN OTHER WORDS, THE LANGUAGE WAS IN
PLACE, THE NOTION EXISTS, IT STILL EXISTS LIKE COUNCILWOMAN
HURTAK SAID, BUT I THINK WHAT COUNCIL WAS LOOKING FOR WAS
MORE ENGAGEMENT BEFORE WE GOT TO ACTUAL VETTING, AND I THINK
WHAT MS. TRAVIS IS SAYING FROM OUR SIDE OF THE HR SELECTION
RECRUITMENT CONTINUUM, AND WHEN YOU GET TO THAT POINT WHERE
YOU MAKE A CONDITIONAL OFFER AND YOU START FILLING IN THE
BACKGROUND AND ALL THOSE SCIENCES, IF YOU WILL, THAT
CANDIDATE IS THE GOING TO MAKE A DECISION, ESPECIALLY IF
THEY ARE ALREADY ATTACHED TO ANOTHER EXECUTIVE POSITION AND
THEIR CHILDREN ARE IN HIGH SCHOOL AND THEY LIVED THERE 15,
20 YEARS, THEY'VE MAKE A DECISION.
AND SO I THINK IT REALLY IS MORE ABOUT WORKING WITH COUNCIL
AS A PROCESS, BECAUSE WHEN WE GET TO CONFIRMATION, IT SHOULD
BE JUST LIKE IT WAS TODAY.
THERE WAS A 7-0 VOTE.
HAVE BEEN EVERYBODY WAS HAPPY.
NICOLE SENT IN THE RESUMÉ.
SHE SET UP MEETINGS.
SOME PEOPLE COULD, SOME PEOPLE COULDN'T.
BUT IT WAS REALLY A GOOD PROCESS.
AND WE LEARNED OVER TIME HOW TO DANCE THAT DANCE WITHIN THE
LANGUAGE.
SO NOBODY IS TRYING TO SAY THE CONFIRMATION SHOULDN'T HAPPEN
OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT.
I THINK REALLY IT'S MORE INCUMBENT ON US TO CONTROL THE
PROCESS, TO MAKE SURE THAT COUNCIL IS FULLY AWARE BY THAT
TIME THAT PERSON COMES AND TRYING TO HELP US WORK WITH YOU
TO FIGURE OUT WHERE IN THAT PROCESS IT'S SAFE FOR THE
CANDIDATE AND SAFE FOR THE CITY.
AND SO THAT'S KIND OF THE BALANCING ACT THAT I AM USING FROM
MY EXPERIENCE OF WORKING WITH YOU IN THIS OVER THREE YEARS,
AND IT'S NOT EASY.
THERE'S A LOT OF DYNAMICS IN IT.
AND RECRUITING IS GETTING HARDER.
WE ARE IN COMPETITION WITH FOLKS IN THE 300 AND $400,000
RANGE FOR A JOB THAT THEY ARE TAKING A CUT TO COME WORK IN
CIVIL SERVICE, SO IT'S A CHALLENGE, BUT I SEE IT MORE AS
WORKING TOGETHER ON THE PROCESS THAN TRYING TO CHANGE
LANGUAGE THAT MAY OR MAY NOT MAKE A DIFFERENCE.
3:16:14PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
CHIEF, THAT'S NOT MY ISSUE.
I'LL USE MR. MANISCALCO BECAUSE HE WAS THE SWING VOTE ON
THIS.
HE ASKED LEGAL, WELL, WHAT DO WE DO IF THIS BOARD SAYS NO?
THERE'S NOTHING IN THIS CHARTER THAT SAYS ANYTHING OF WHAT
THIS COUNCIL DOES, NOTHING.
SO IF THIS COUNCIL GOES THROUGH THE PROCESS, YOU GET WHO YOU
WANT, BUT THIS COUNCIL SAYS NO.
3:16:36PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?
3:16:39PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT.
I DON'T UNDERSTAND HOW THIS BODY AS A COUNCIL CAN SIT HERE
AND SAY NOTHING IS WRONG WITH THIS PROCESS.
I HAVE A REAL ISSUE WITH THAT.
FOR COUNCIL MEMBERS TO SIT HERE KNOWING THERE IS AN ISSUE
WITH THIS LANGUAGE, AND WE DO NOTHING.
I HAVE A PROBLEM WITH -- I'M A POLICEMAN.
I'M SORRY.
I GO BY THE RULES, JOHN.
THE RULES ARE THE RULES.
AND WHEN A POLICY IS NOT RIGHT, WE FIX THE POLICY.
WE'RE NOT FIXING THE POLICY HERE, GENTLEMEN.
IF COUNCIL VOTES SOMEONE DONE, THE MAYOR CAN BRING THE
PERSON BACK 50 MILLION TIMES FROM WHAT THE LAST CITY
ATTORNEY.
WE HAVE NO RECOURSE, BUT IT KEEPS GOING BACK AND FORTH.
LIKE CHIEF BENNETT SAYS, WHERE IS THE BALANCE?
HOW DO WE STOP THAT?
FOR ME AND THIS COUNCIL TO SIT UP HERE AND SAY NOTHING IS
WRONG WITH THIS.
SHAME ON YOU.
I RESPECT YOU ALL, BUT SHAME ON YOU.
3:17:36PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
COUNCILMAN GUDES, I THINK IN RESPONSE TO
WHAT I HEARD AFTER THE ONE PARTICULAR CONFIRMATION THAT KIND
OF DRUMMED THIS UP, RIGHT, WAS THE LENGTH OF TIME FOR
COUNCIL BEING AWARE, TO WHAT MR. BENNETT WAS JUST SAYING,
THE PROCESS IN INTRODUCING THE CANDIDATE TO COUNCIL AND
HAVING THAT OPPORTUNITY.
AND EACH CONFIRMATION, I THINK I PROBABLY AM THE ONLY
ADMINISTRATOR THAT HAS BROUGHT YOU THREE OR FOUR
CONFIRMATIONS SINCE THIS PERIOD OF TIME.
3:18:13PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
YOU DID IT THE RIGHT WAY.
3:18:14PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
BUT I'M SAYING -- BUT WE LEARNED BECAUSE WE
HEARD WHAT COUNCIL SAID ABOUT THE PROCESS AND I DIDN'T DO
THAT PROCESS INDEPENDENTLY.
I DID THAT PROCESS IN COMMUNICATION WITH CHIEF BENNETT, WITH
HR AND SAYING, OKAY, THIS IS THE FEEDBACK THAT WE HAVE.
AND SO EACH PROCESS, SO I ASKED YOU WHEN WE BROUGHT ALIS
DRUMGO AND ABBYE FEELEY TO YOU, AND SOME WERE SAYING, WELL,
THIS IS KIND OF QUICK, SOME WERE LIKE, OKAY, I'M LEARNING.
THEN I BRING THE OTHERS TO YOU, AND WE'RE TWEAKING AND
LEARNING.
WE'RE CONSTANTLY EVOLVING THE PROCESS.
IT'S NOT LIKE -- IT'S NOT ME DOING IT RIGHT.
IT'S US LEARNING THROUGH THE PROCESS AND TRYING TO WALK THAT
FINE LINE AND THAT BALANCE TO BE RESPONSIVE TO WHAT YOU'RE
ASKING FOR AND THE INTERACTION THAT YOU WANT TO HAVE WITH
THE CANDIDATES BEFORE NOMINATION.
3:19:13PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN CARLSON, YOU'RE GOING TO BE NEXT.
MS. COWAN, I SAW THIS LOOK ON YOUR FACE AS IF YOU HAD
SOMETHING TO SAY.
3:19:22PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
NO.
NO, I DID NOT.
3:19:24PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
OKAY.
COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
3:19:27PM >>BILL CARLSON:
WE CAN GO AROUND AND AROUND.
I THINK WE SHOULD MAKE A MOTION AT SOME POINT AND VOTE ON
IT.
MS. TRAVIS MENTIONED, YOU KNOW, I AGREE WITH YOU 99.9% OF
THE TIME, BUT YOU MENTIONED A FEW MINUTES AGO CEO AND KIND
OF COMPARING IT TO A COMPANY.
IF THIS WAS A COMPANY, WE WOULD BE THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
I THOUGHT ABOUT THIS A LOT.
AND THEN WE COULD FIRE THE MAYOR.
WE CAN'T DO THAT.
SO IF THE CRIME RATE GOES UP, THE BUDGETS GET SQUANDERED,
THINGS DON'T GO OUT FOR RFP, CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS GET
ATTACKED, WE CAN'T FIRE THE MAYOR.
ONLY THE CITIZENS CAN DO THAT.
3:20:02PM >>NICOLE TRAVIS:
CORRECT.
3:20:04PM >>BILL CARLSON:
IT IS A DIFFERENCE.
YOU SAW WHAT HAPPENED TO BOB CHAPEK; THE BOARD DOESN'T LIKE
HIM, SO HE'S GONE.
THE OTHER THING IS WHAT THIS -- ALL THIS IS DOING IS PUTTING
THE RIGHT WORDS IN FOR WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENS.
IF WE HAD DISAGREED WITH THE PERSON THIS MORNING, WE WOULD
HAVE MAYBE GONE FOR MULTIPLE ROUNDS ANYWAY WITHOUT THIS
LANGUAGE BEING CHANGED.
BUT BECAUSE THE PROCESS WENT WELL AND IT WAS A GOOD
CANDIDATE, DIDN'T.
WHAT HAPPENED THIS ONE TIME, AND THIS WAS WITH THE POLICE
CHIEF, IS THAT ONE REASON FOR THE WORD "NOMINATE" IS TO BE
RESPECTFUL TO THE PUBLIC BECAUSE THE CANDIDATE WAS PRESENTED
AS THE POLICE CHIEF TO THE PUBLIC.
AND I THINK THE REASON WHY I SUPPORTED THIS IS BECAUSE IT
WAS DISRESPECTFUL TO THE PUBLIC.
NOT THAT THE PERSON DID ANYTHING WRONG, BUT JUST THE PERSON
BEING PRESENTED AS THE FINAL PERSON, BECAUSE THE PUBLIC
THOUGHT WHY DON'T WE HAVE ANY INPUT, WHY DOESN'T THE PUBLIC
HAVE ANY INPUT.
THAT POSITION HAPPENS TO BE A REALLY IMPORTANT POSITION.
SO THE ADMINISTRATION PUSHED, PUSHED, PUSHED DESPITE ALL THE
COMMUNITY'S CONCERNS ABOUT THINGS THAT HAD HAPPENED IN THE
PAST AND THERE WERE PROMISES MADE THAT THINGS WOULDN'T
HAPPEN AGAIN.
SO WE WERE PUSHED AND I THINK IT WAS A 5-2 VOTE.
WE'LL SEE WHETHER THAT WAS A GOOD DECISION OR NOT, BUT I
THINK THERE HAS TO BE A COLLABORATIVE APPROACH.
ONCE THESE, AS MR. GUDES SAID, ONCE THESE FOLKS ARE
APPOINTED, WE HAVE NO POWER OVER THEM.
I TRIED IN THE CHARTER TO CHANGE TO GET US TO FIRE THE CITY
ATTORNEY, WHICH I THINK WE SHOULD BE ABLE TO.
BUT IF CITY STAFF AS THEY ARE, WE'VE GOT DOCUMENTS ON IT,
YOU KNOW, SET CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS UP AGAINST EACH OTHER OR
DO OPPOSITION RESEARCH ON US, WE CAN'T FIRE THEM.
WE CAN ASK THE STAFF, THE MAYOR AND THE ADMINISTRATION TO
FIRE THEM, BUT THEY DON'T.
I HEAR THAT MORE THAN HALF OF THE SENIOR STAFF DON'T HIT THE
RESIDENCY REQUIREMENT.
IT'S ULTIMATELY UP TO THE MAYOR AND HOW THE MAYOR RUNS
EVERYTHING.
I'M SURE THE MAYOR IS GOING TO BE ACCOUNTABLE, BUT THE
PUBLIC WANTS US TO BE ACCOUNTABLE, TOO, AND TO HAVE MORE
SCRUTINY OVER THINGS.
I THINK CHANGING A COUPLE OF WORDS IS NOT A SIGNIFICANT
CHANGE.
IT ONLY IS GOING TO REFLECT WHAT IS ACTUALLY HAPPENING IN
PRACTICE, EXCEPT THESE EXCEPTIONS.
AND WE ALSO HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT NOT WHETHER IF YOU LIKE THE
SITUATION NOW BETWEEN CITY COUNCIL AND THE MAYOR, YOU HAVE
TO THINK ABOUT WHAT IF IT IS EVEN WORSE.
I DON'T KNOW HOW IT COULD BE WORSE BUT WE HAVE TO THINK
ABOUT THAT POSSIBILITY.
3:22:40PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN VIERA AND THEN COUNCILWOMAN
HURTAK.
3:22:47PM >>LUIS VIERA:
[INAUDIBLE]
3:22:47PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
3:22:48PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I ONLY HAVE A QUICK EDITOR'S CHANGE,
SCRIVENER'S ERROR.
IN THE ACTUAL CHARTER LANGUAGE, THE WORD "SECTION" SHOULD BE
CAPITALIZED BEFORE 6.03 IN BOTH INSTANCES.
THAT IS MY ONLY REQUEST.
3:23:05PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
PLEASURE OF COUNCIL?
3:23:13PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I'M GOING TO MOVE IT.
ALL RIGHT.
FILE NUMBER E2022-8 CH 2.
ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION.
AN ORDINANCE RELATING TO THE GOVERNMENT OF THE CITY OF
TAMPA, FLORIDA, SUBMITTING TO THE ELECTORS OF THE CITY A
PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO THE REVISED CHARTER OF THE CITY OF
TAMPA OF 1975 AS AMENDED TO CLARIFY THAT THE MAYOR'S
NOMINATIONS FOR HEADS OF DEPARTMENTS AND OTHER CITY
EMPLOYEES AS SET OUT IN SECTION 6.03, MUST BE APPROVED BY
FOUR VOTES OF CITY COUNCIL AND TO PROVIDE FOR INTERIM
APPOINTMENTS OF EXISTING CITY EMPLOYEES BY THE MAYOR FOR A
MAXIMUM OF 180 DAYS; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
3:24:00PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
SECOND.
3:24:01PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WE HAVE A MOTION MADE BY COUNCILMAN GUDES.
SECONDED BY COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION?
ROLL CALL.
3:24:08PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
NO.
3:24:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
YES.
3:24:12PM >>LUIS VIERA:
NO.
3:24:14PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
YES.
3:24:15PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YES.
3:24:17PM >>BILL CARLSON:
YES.
3:24:18PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
NO.
3:24:20PM >>THE CLERK:
THE MOTION CARRIED WITH VIERA, MIRANDA, AND
CITRO VOTING NO.
SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON JANUARY 5th,
2023, AT 9:30 A.M.
3:24:31PM >>LUIS VIERA:
THAT WAS THE LAST ONE, CORRECT?
3:24:33PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
NO.
WE HAVE ONE MORE.
3:24:36PM >>LUIS VIERA:
I WANTED TO CLARIFY, IF I MAY, JUST REALLY
FAST ON THE TERM LIMITS ONE, WE PASSED THAT AS FOUR BECAUSE
COUNCILMAN CARLSON MENTIONED SOMETHING THAT'S TRUE.
FOUR CONSECUTIVE FULL TERMS, CORRECT?
3:24:48PM >> YES.
3:24:49PM >>LUIS VIERA:
THANK YOU.
3:24:52PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MS. COWAN.
3:24:56PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
ON TO THE LAST ITEM, AND THIS ORDINANCE
BEFORE YOU IS AMENDING SECTION 10.10 OF THE CHARTER REVIEW
ADDRESSING CHARTER REVIEW ADVISORY COMMISSION.
THE FIRST THING IT DOES IS CORRECT A SCRIVENER'S ERROR AND
THEN IT ALSO PROVIDES THAT BEGINNING IN 2025 AND EVERY FIVE
YEARS THEREAFTER THERE WOULD BE A CHARTER REVIEW ADVISORY
COMMITTEE ESTABLISHED.
LEGAL COUNSEL, WHO IS NOT A CITY EMPLOYEE, WOULD SERVE AS
LEGAL ADVISOR TO THE CHARTER REVIEW BOARD AND A PROFESSIONAL
FACILITATOR WOULD BE ENGAGED BY THE CITY WITH CITY COUNCIL
APPROVAL.
ONE OTHER ITEM I WANTED TO JUST LET YOU KNOW IS WHEN WE WENT
THROUGH THESE ORDINANCES AND IT WAS DISCUSSED WITH BOTH CITY
COUNCIL, CITY COUNCIL ATTORNEY AND YOUR CITY ATTORNEY, THEY
ASKED ME WHETHER OR NOT BMO CLIENTS HAD AMENDED THE
FREQUENCY IN WHICH THEIR CHARTER REVIEW ADVISORY COMMITTEES
MEET.
AND WE SAID, YES.
IN FACT, WE'VE HAD THIS BEFORE, SPECIFICALLY THE CITY OF
LARGO SEVERAL YEARS AGO HAD CHARTER REVIEW EVERY TEN YEARS,
AND THEN THEY CHANGED IT TO EVERY FIVE.
NOW, THEIR EXPERIENCE WAS THAT, AND THE FEEDBACK THAT THEY
RECEIVED FROM THEIR CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION WAS BY THE
TIME THEY HAD GONE THROUGH AN IN-DEPTH REVIEW HAD EVERYTHING
DONE, BACK TO THEIR COUNCIL, AND THEN ON THE BALLOT, THERE
WAS MAYBE A YEAR BREAK AND THEY WERE STARTING AGAIN.
SO THEY HAVE SUBSEQUENTLY CHANGED IT FROM FIVE TO SEVEN.
SO I JUST OFFER THAT AS INFORMATION TO YOU FOR YOUR
CONSIDERATION, BUT THE ORDINANCE AS DRAFTED IS EVERY FIVE
YEARS AS DIRECTED.
3:26:50PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
3:26:52PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I KNOW WE HAD DEBATED QUITE A BIT THE TIMING
JUST BECAUSE THESE WOULD HAVE TO BE AMENDMENTS ON SOME SORT
OF BALLOT.
AND IN HEARING EVERY SEVEN YEARS, MAYBE WE SHOULD POSSIBLY
LOOK AT EVERY EIGHT YEARS JUST BECAUSE IT WOULD FIT THE
FOUR-YEAR TIME LINE.
FOUR YEARS DOES SEEM A LITTLE SOON, BUT, AGAIN, EITHER WAY,
I WOULD LIKE IT TO BE IN SOME FORM OF A MULTIPLE OF FOUR SO
WE CAN MAKE SURE IT GETS ON THE BALLOT WITH THE MAYORAL AND
THE COUNCIL ELECTIONS, UNLESS WE WOULD WANT TO OPEN THE CAN
OF WORMS TO THE OTHER ELECTIONS.
BUT I KIND OF LIKE ALL MUNICIPAL STUFF TOGETHER.
3:27:39PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MR. SHELBY.
3:27:40PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
JUST FOR CLARIFICATION AND THANK YOU FOR
RAISING THAT.
-- A GENERAL ELECTION AS WELL, SO THAT WOULD BE EVERY TWO
YEARS.
IN THIS CASE, THE WAY THE DEADLINES HAVE FALLEN AND THE LIKE
AND COUNCIL'S SCHEDULE, IT'S ON THE MUNICIPAL ELECTION, BUT
IT IS EITHER CHOICE.
3:28:00PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
COUNCILMAN GUDES.
3:28:02PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
IS THE COUNTY CHARTER REVIEW EVERY FIVE
YEARS?
IS THAT CORRECT?
3:28:07PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
I HAVE NOT SPOKEN TO BRANDON WAGNER IN A
WHILE ABOUT THIS.
I SPOKE WITH HIM WHEN THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION WAS
FIRST FORMULATED AND HE WAS VERY HELPFUL TO ME IN THE
PROCESS, AND HE WAS TALKING ABOUT THE FACT THAT I HAVEN'T
VERIFIED THIS, AND I CAN DO THIS AND GET BACK TO COUNCIL,
BUT THE COUNTY'S POSITION WAS THAT FIVE YEARS DOES SEEM LIKE
IT COMES UP VERY QUICKLY TO THEM.
AND THEY ARE ALWAYS ALMOST IN A POSITION OF GOING ON TO THE
NEXT ONE.
AND IF HE HAD HIS DRUTHERS, HE EXPRESSED WITH ME AT THE TIME
AND HAVEN'T VERIFIED IT, BUT I'LL JUST RELAY IT, HE THOUGHT
THAT WAS A VERY QUICK TURNAROUND.
THAT WAS HIS OPINION AT THE TIME AND THAT WAS 2018, EARLIER.
3:28:50PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
DO YOU KNOW IF IT IS FIVE YEARS OVER THERE?
WOULD YOU KNOW OR MS. ZELMAN?
3:28:54PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
I DON'T KNOW.
I CAN LOOK IT UP REAL QUICK.
3:29:09PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MY OPINION, I THINK TEN IS TOO LONG.
THE TWO TERMS, I THINK TEN IS TOO LONG BECAUSE THINGS DO
COME UP AND WE NEED TO ADDRESS THEM.
NOTHING FURTHER, MR. CHAIRMAN.
3:29:23PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
THANK YOU.
YOUR ADDITIONS OR YOUR AMENDMENT TO THIS, HOW MANY YEARS?
3:29:34PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
SORRY.
I WOULD MAKE AN AMENDMENT TO MAKE IT EVERY EIGHT YEARS.
INSTEAD OF EVERY TEN YEARS, EVERY EIGHT YEARS.
WHICH ACTUALLY MEANS THAT THEY WOULD START PRETTY SOON, BUT
MAYBE NOT SUPER SOON.
SO, YES, EVERY EIGHT YEARS, WHICH MIGHT ALLOW THEM TO DO
KIND OF A MORE IN-DEPTH.
I'LL BE HONEST, 13 MONTHS WASN'T LONG ENOUGH.
TWO-YEAR PROCESS AND EVERY EIGHT YEARS, YOU HAVE ENOUGH
TIME.
3:30:09PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
I DO AGREE WITH YOU.
AFTER A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF TIME AND LET'S JUST SAY 24 YEARS,
THAT 13 MONTHS WILL GET SHORTER AND SHORTER BECAUSE EACH
TIME.
AND I LIKE THIS IDEA BECAUSE THEN EACH COUNCIL PERSON,
WHOMEVER THEY ARE, CAN APPOINT SOMEBODY WITH THEIR IDEAS,
THEIR THOUGHTS, WHAT THEY LIKE, WHAT THEY DON'T LIKE, WHAT
THEY WANT TO SEE CHANGED SO THAT MAYBE THE COUNCIL ITSELF
WON'T HAVE TO BE DOING CHARTER AMENDMENTS.
YES, COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
3:30:41PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
THE ONLY OTHER QUESTION IS JUST COMMENCING IN
WHAT YEAR?
PLEASE HELP ME WITH MATH BECAUSE I'M STILL SICK.
IT SAYS HERE IT WOULD BE COMMENCING IN 2025, BUT I DON'T
KNOW, MATH.
SOMEBODY HELP ME.
IT WOULD BE EIGHT YEARS FROM THE LAST ONE, WENT ON THE
BALLOT IN 2019, SO THAT WOULD BE '27 BECAUSE WE'RE UP FOR
VOTE IN '23.
SO IT WOULD BE UP FOR VOTE IN '27.
3:31:23PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
BUT YOU DO THAT, WON'T BE ON THE BALLOT
AT THE SAME TIME.
-- YOU GOT TO GO TO THE MARCH OF THE FOLLOWING YEAR.
3:31:36PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YES, WHICH WOULD BE 2027.
WE WOULD START THIS IN '26.
SO WE WOULD START MEETING IN '26.
HONESTLY, I WOULD STILL SAY '25.
YEAH, IT'S A TWO-YEAR PROCESS.
NEVER MIND.
WE'LL LEAVE IT AT '25.
THANK YOU, THOUGH, FOR HELPING ME WITH THE MATH.
3:31:54PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WHO IS GOING TO READ THIS?
3:31:57PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I WILL.
AN ORDINANCE RELATING TO THE GOVERNMENT -- DOES THIS -- CAN
I READ THIS AS IS?
I CAN'T, BECAUSE WE ARE CHANGING IT.
3:32:05PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
IT WILL HAVE TO CHANGE.
AND I JUST WANTED TO ANSWER THE QUESTION THAT YOU HAD.
HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY, IT APPEARS IT IS EVERY FIVE YEARS.
3:32:12PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
THAT DID SEEM A LITTLE TOO MUCH.
THEN MY MOTION IS TO CHANGE IT TO EVERY EIGHT YEARS.
3:32:22PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
WE HAVE A MOTION MADE BY -- CAN YOU READ A
FILE NUMBER, PLEASE?
3:32:27PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
THE FILE NUMBER IS E2022-8, CHAPTER 2.
THIS IS DEALING WITH SECTION 10.10.
3:32:39PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
AND THAT'S EVERY?
3:32:41PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
EVERY EIGHT YEARS.
3:32:42PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
MOTION MADE BY COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
ROLL CALL VOTE.
3:32:53PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YES.
3:32:54PM >>LUIS VIERA:
YES.
3:32:55PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
YES.
3:32:58PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
NO.
3:33:01PM >>BILL CARLSON:
YES.
3:33:02PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
YES.
3:33:04PM >>JOSEPH CITRO:
YES.
3:33:04PM >>THE CLERK:
THE MOTION CARRIED WITH MIRANDA VOTING NO.
3:33:12PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
ALL RIGHT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
3:33:13PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
MR. CHAIRMAN PRO TEM, IF I COULD FOLLOW UP
ON WHERE WE STAND WITH THIS NOW.
CHARACTER CLERK YOU HAVE THREE DIFFERENT ORDINANCES THAT
NEED TO BE BROUGHT BACK FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION.
3:33:34PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
MS. COWAN, COULD YOU COME UP HERE.
I WANT TO MAKE SURE WE'RE ALL ON THE SAME PAGE, ESPECIALLY
WHEN DEALING WITH TIME CONSTRAINTS.
3:33:43PM >>THE CLERK:
WE HAVE ITEMS 19, 20, AND 23 THAT NEED TO BE
BROUGHT BACK BEFORE COUNCIL FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION.
THE NEXT AVAILABLE DATE TO MEET PUBLICATION WOULD BE
DECEMBER 15, WHICH IS A REGULAR SESSION.
3:33:56PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
YOU COULD ACTUALLY BRING THOSE THREE BACK
THAT HAVE PASSED FOR SECOND READING ON THE 15th.
3:34:02PM >>THE CLERK:
THE ONLY THING THAT PASSED WERE THE CHANGES,
NOT THE ACTUAL FIRST READING CONSIDERATIONS.
3:34:08PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
LET ME SEE IF I UNDERSTAND THIS.
HOW MANY PASSED THAT ARE COMING BACK?
3:34:17PM >>THE CLERK:
THOSE THAT HAVE PASSED FOR FIRST READING
CONSIDERATION WAS ITEM NUMBER 18, 21, AND 22.
THOSE WILL BE BROUGHT BACK FOR SECOND READING AND ADOPTION
ON JANUARY 5th.
19, 20, AND 23 THAT COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK REQUESTED CHANGES
FOR THAT NEED TO BE BROUGHT BACK FOR FIRST READING
CONSIDERATION.
IT CAN BE DONE ON DECEMBER 15th.
3:34:45PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
NOW, WITH REGARD --
3:34:48PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
QUICK QUESTION.
COULD SECOND READING STILL BE JANUARY 5th?
3:34:52PM >>THE CLERK:
UM-HUM.
3:34:54PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
WELL, THEN, PROBLEM SOLVED.
3:34:55PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
THE QUESTION THEN IS, WITH REGARD TO THE
THREE THAT PASSED, THOSE CAN'T BE ADVERTISED TO COME BACK
THE 15th THE WAY THINGS ARE STRUCTURED.
3:35:06PM >>THE CLERK:
THOSE WERE ADOPTED ON FIRST READING
CONSIDERATION AND IT'S SCHEDULED FOR JANUARY 5th FOR
SECOND READING AND ADOPTION.
SO THE THREE THAT DID NOT PASS FOR FIRST READING
CONSIDERATION TODAY WILL NEED TO BE BROUGHT BACK FOR FIRST
READING CONSIDERATION ON DECEMBER 15th TO MAKE JANUARY
5th MEETING FOR SECOND READING AND ADOPTION.
3:35:29PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
MR. SHELBY, IT'S BECAUSE THE NEWSPAPER
DEADLINE WAS THE 21st.
SO THEY ALL COULD FIT UNDER THE 21st.
3:35:39PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
MY ONLY CONCERN THAT I HAVE TO THINK
THROUGH AND I COULD TALK WITH THE CITY ATTORNEY AND CONFIRM
THIS IS JUST THE PROCESS AFTER THE 5th, HOW LONG IT TAKES
FOR THE MAYOR TO MAKE THE DECISION AS TO WHAT THE MAYOR'S
DECISION IS WITH REGARD TO ANY OF THE ONES THAT PASSED AND
THEN THE PROCESS FOR IT COMING BACK IN WHAT FORM OR FASHION
AND WHAT DATE.
3:36:02PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
WE DON'T HAVE CONTROL OVER THAT.
3:36:16PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I SEE HIS POINT.
3:36:19PM >>JENNIFER COWAN:
I WANTED TO CONFIRM.
I DID HEAR THE READING OF THE TITLE WITH REGARD TO SECTION
9.1, WHICH WAS ITEM 21.
COULD THE CLERK CONFIRM THAT THEY DID READ THE TITLE ON ITEM
NUMBER 22?
3:36:40PM >>THE CLERK:
YES, I DO CONFIRM ITEM NUMBER 22, THE TITLE WAS
READ AND MOVED ON FIRST READING CONSIDERATION.
3:36:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THAT CONCLUDES THE DISCUSSION ON THE CHARTER.
WE WILL NOW GO TO THE CONSENT AGENDA.
FIRST UP IS COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
3:36:55PM >>LUIS VIERA:
YES, SIR.
I MOVE 24 THROUGH 28.
3:36:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
ALL IN FAVOR?
AYE.
ANY OPPOSED?
COUNCIL MEMBER GUDES, YOU ARE THE CHAIR OF PARKS, REC,
CULTURAL.
3:37:10PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MOVE ITEMS 29, 30.
3:37:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
ALL IN FAVOR?
ANY OPPOSED?
COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK, YOU ARE UP NEXT.
3:37:18PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I MOVE ITEMS 31-38.
3:37:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK,
SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
ALL IN FAVOR?
NEXT FINANCE COMMITTEE.
WE HAVE SOME WE ALREADY VOTED ON.
3:37:30PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
39 AND 41 WERE TAKEN CARE OF.
40, 42, AND 43.
3:37:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA,
SECONDED BY COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
ALL IN FAVOR?
ANY OPPOSED?
COUNCILMAN CARLSON, BUILDING PRESERVATION, 44-53.
MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON, SECONDED BY COUNCILWOMAN
HURTAK.
ALL IN FAVOR?
ANY OPPOSED?
ALL RIGHT.
ITEMS 54 AND 55 ARE REVIEW HEARINGS THAT NEED TO BE SET.
3:37:58PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
MOTION TO SET THE HEARINGS.
3:38:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER GUDES TO SET
54, WHICH IS FOR FEBRUARY 2nd, 2023, AT 1:30 P.M.
AND ITEM 55, WHICH IS SCHEDULED FOR FEBRUARY 2nd, 2023, AT
1:30 P.M.
SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
ALL IN FAVOR?
ANY OPPOSED?
MOTION TO OPEN ITEM NUMBER 56.
WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER GUDES.
SECONDED BY COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
ALL IN FAVOR?
ALL RIGHT.
NOW THAT WE HAVE THESE HEARINGS OPEN, CAN I GET A MOTION TO
REMOVE ITEM 57 FROM THE AGENDA?
MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN GUDES, SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN
MIRANDA.
ALL IN FAVOR?
THIS IS THE LAST ITEM OF THIS AGENDA FOR THIS MORNING THAT
HAS GONE INTO THE AFTERNOON.
MA'AM, WOULD YOU LIKE TO PRESENT?
ANYBODY THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 56, PLEASE STAND
AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND WE WILL SWEAR YOU IN.
WE'RE GOING TO SWEAR YOU IN AND HAVE A FIVE-MINUTE RECESS.
[OATH ADMINISTERED BY THE CLERK]
3:39:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
ALL RIGHT.
WE ARE IN RECESS FOR FIVE MINUTES.
WE'LL BE BACK AT LET'S SAY 3:45.
THANK YOU.
[RECESS]
3:39:19PM >> CASE 22-70 FOR THE PROPERTY --
3:48:49PM >>BILL CARLSON:
SINCE WE ONLY HAVE FOUR PEOPLE HERE, SHOULD
WE ASK THE APPLICANT BEFORE WE SPEND A LOT OF TIME ON IT,
SHOULD WE ASK THE APPLICANT IF THEY ARE OKAY WITH FOUR
PEOPLE OR WHAT DO THEY WANT TO DO WITH IT?
3:49:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
YOU WISH TO HAVE A FULL COUNCIL OR FINE
WITH FOUR PEOPLE.
3:49:03PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
THERE MAY BE PEOPLE -- I KNOW CHAIR CITRO
IS NOT COMING BACK.
3:49:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
CITRO IS GONE FOR THE DAY.
HURTAK IS COMING BACK.
WE HAVE FIVE MEMBERS.
AND VIERA WILL BE HERE.
3:49:18PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
WE HAVE FIVE NOW, MAYBE SIX.
ARE YOU COMFORTABLE WITH THAT?
FOUR YOU WOULD BE ABLE TO, IF YOU WANTED, UNDER THE RULES,
CONTINUE YOU GET AS A MATTER OF RIGHT, BUT NOW WE HAVE FIVE.
IT'S DISCRETIONARY.
IT'S YOUR CALL.
3:49:34PM >> JAIME MAIER WITH THE LAW FIRM OF HILL WARD HENDERSON.
I'LL TALK WITH THE CLIENT ONE MINUTE TO DISCUSS -- JUST TO
CONFIRM COUNCILMAN VIERA WILL BE RETURNING.
3:49:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
HIS KEYS ARE HERE.
3:49:51PM >> HE'S GOING TO BE BACK.
3:49:57PM >>BILL CARLSON:
I WANTED TO MAKE SURE WE DID THAT BEFORE WE
WENT THROUGH THE WHOLE CASE.
3:50:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOTION TO ADD IN THE BUDGET MONEY FOR A
TEAKETTLE.
3:50:35PM >>BILL CARLSON:
YOU TAUGHT ME SOMETHING.
I'VE BEEN HERE THREE AND A HALF YEARS.
3:50:38PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I HAD TO ASK.
I WAS TOLD THE HOT WATER WORKS.
3:50:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
ISN'T THERE AN OPTION FOR HOT WATER --
3:50:48PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
THERE IS ON THE WATER COOLER.
I DIDN'T KNOW HOW TO USE IT.
NOW I DO.
3:50:55PM >> JAIME MAIER:
WE'RE HAPPY TO GO FORWARD ONCE MR. VIERA
COMES BACK, IF THAT'S OKAY.
OR MOVE FORWARD NOW AND HE WILL BE HERE FOR THE VOTING
PROCESS.
WE WANT TO HAVE AS MANY FOLKS ON THE COUNCIL, IF THAT'S ALL
RIGHT.
3:51:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
WE'LL BEGIN THE PRESENTATION.
3:51:11PM >>JAIME MAIER:
SURE.
STAFF'S PRESENTATION.
3:51:14PM >> YES, MA'AM.
3:51:23PM >> WHILE SHE IS HANDING OUT THE PACKET, CAMARIA
PETTIS-MACKLE FROM THE LEGAL DEPARTMENT FROM THE CITY
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE.
AGAIN, I'M HERE REGARDING ITEM NUMBER 56, VRB-22-70 FOR THE
PROPERTY LOCATED AT 3122 WEST SAN JOSE STREET.
THERE WAS A PETITION FOR REVIEW FILED ON BEHALF OF THE
APPLICANT WHO IS MARC MOBLEY.
OWNS MOBLEY HOMES CUSTOM LLC.
MS. MAIER IS HERE REPRESENTING HIM AS AUTHORIZED AGENT.
THE REQUEST MADE TO THE VARIANCE REVIEW BOARD WAS REGARDING
APPROVAL TO REMOVE A GRAND TREE.
THE VARIANCE REVIEW BOARD HEARD THE REQUEST AND HELD A
PUBLIC HEARING ON SEPTEMBER 13, 2022, AND DENIED THE REQUEST
TO REMOVE THE GRAND TREE BASED UPON THE APPLICANT NOT
MEETING THE STANDARDS SET FORTH IN CODE SECTION 27-284.2.5
SUBSECTION F-4.
I PREVIOUSLY HANDED CITY COUNCIL OR PROVIDED CITY COUNCIL
THE RELEVANT CODE SECTION, WHICH IS CODE SECTION 27-61
SUBSECTION J-2-A THAT PROVIDES THE PARAMETERS IN WHICH CITY
COUNCIL CAN CONDUCT A REVIEW HEARING.
ALSO, THE RELEVANT CODE SECTION 27-284.2.5 WHICH ARE THE
FACTORS THAT CITY COUNCIL HAS TO CONSIDER IN WHETHER OR NOT
TO GRANT OR DENY A REQUEST TO REMOVE A GRAND TREE.
AS PREVIOUSLY STATED IN CODE SECTION 27-61 SUBSECTION J-2,
THE STANDARD OF REVIEW FOR THIS MATTER IS A DE NOVO STANDARD
OF REVIEW.
CITY COUNCIL, WHICH MEANS CITY COUNCIL SHALL NOT BE LIMITED
IN ITS REVIEW TO THE INFORMATION, DOCUMENTATION OR EVIDENCE
UPON WHICH THE BOARD BASED ITS DETERMINATION.
THERE ARE TWO STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT WHO WILL PROVIDE AN
EXPLANATION OF THE DECISION FROM THE VARIANCE REVIEW BOARD
AND WHAT THE APPLICATION WAS.
THOSE STAFF MEMBERS ARE JAYNE NMADU AND STEVEN EYSTER FROM
NATURAL RESOURCES.
AFTER CITY COUNCIL HEARS ALL THE EVIDENCE IN THE CASE AND
ALL THE DOCUMENTATION, CITY COUNCIL CAN TAKE THREE ACTIONS
AT THE CONCLUSION OF THE HEARING.
CITY COUNCIL CAN AFFIRM THE DECISION OF THE VRB IN CASE
VRB-22-70 AND DENY THE REQUEST TO REMOVE THE GRAND TREE.
CITY COUNCIL CAN REMAND THE MATTER BACK TO VRB WITH
DIRECTION, OR FINALLY, CITY COUNCIL CAN OVERTURN THE
DECISION OF THE VARIANCE REVIEW BOARD IN CASE VRB-22-70 AND
THEREBY GRANT THE REQUEST TO REMOVE THE GRAND TREE.
WITH THAT, I WILL TURN THE PRESENTATION OVER TO STAFF.
3:54:34PM >>MARTIN SHELBY:
IF WE CAN, MR. CHAIRMAN, BEFORE YOU BEGIN
YOUR PRESENTATION, JUST IF THERE HAVE BEEN ANY EX PARTE
VERBAL COMMUNICATIONS, PLEASE DISCLOSE THEM IF THERE ARE ANY
THAT NEED TO BE DISCLOSED PRIOR TO THE HEARING CONTINUING.
ALSO A MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE THE WRITTEN EX PARTE
COMMUNICATIONS.
3:54:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN GUDES.
ALL IN FAVOR?
ANY OPPOSED?
THANK YOU.
YES, SIR, GO AHEAD.
3:54:58PM >> STEVEN EYSTER WITH NATURAL RESOURCES.
I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN.
THIS IS THE RECAP.
HERE IS THE PROPERTY INFORMATION.
THE PROPERTY OWNER IS MOBLEY HOMES CUSTOM LLC.
THE APPLICANT IS MARC MOBLEY.
THE ADDRESS IS 3122 WEST SAN JOSE STREET.
THE ZONING IS RS 60.
THE VARIANCE REQUESTED IS TO REMOVE A GRAND TREE TO
CONSTRUCT A NEW SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE.
3:55:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
IF THEY COULD PUT THIS ON OUR SCREEN.
ALL WE SEE IS A CONSTRUCTION CONE.
THERE WE GO. THANK YOU.
3:55:33PM >>STEVE EYSTER:
THERE IS THE PROPERTY INFO, SO YOU GUYS CAN
SEE THAT.
THIS IS THE STANDARD REVIEW FOR A VARIANCE FOR GRAND TREE
REMOVAL.
IF YOU GUYS WANT TO READ THROUGH THAT.
IT'S BROKEN INTO THREE SECTIONS, A, B AND C, AND IT COVERS
THE BUILDING AREA, THE PROPOSED BUILDING, REDUCTIONS IN
SETBACKS, ALTERNATIVE CONSTRUCTION METHODS, THE COST OF
UTILIZING ANY ALTERNATIVE CONSTRUCTION METHODS AND THEN YOU
CAN CONSIDER THE EXISTING DEVELOPMENTS THAT ARE AROUND.
THIS IS THE VARIANCE BOARD'S DECISION, LIKE CAMARIA JUST
COVERED.
THE VARIANCE REVIEW BOARD HEARD THE CASE ON SEPTEMBER
13th.
AFTER TESTIMONY IT WAS DENIED 5-1 TO REMOVE THE GRAND TREE.
THE LOT IS IN THE SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT.
YOU CAN SEE THE OVERVIEW OF THE LOT.
THIS WAS THE EXISTING HOME ON THE LOT.
THAT HOUSE WAS DEMO'D BACK IN -- JUST A FEW MONTHS AGO AFTER
MR. MOBLEY PURCHASED THE LOT.
THIS IS THE NEW PROPOSED HOME.
A DESIGN EXCEPTION WAS APPLIED, SO HE CAN CONSTRUCT THE HOME
TO THE 20-FOOT SETBACK IN THE FRONT, AND THEN THE FRONT
PORCH.
THESE WERE THE TWO ALTERNATIVE DESIGNS SHOWING A
FRONT-LOADING GARAGE AND A SIDE-LOADING GARAGE.
AND THEN IT'S IN THAT L-SHAPED TO MOVE IT OUT OF THE 20-FOOT
PROTECTIVE RADIUS OF THE GRAND TREE THAT'S IN QUESTION.
THESE ARE SOME PHOTOS OF THE TREE.
JUST SO YOU GUYS CAN KIND OF SEE THE OVERALL SIZE.
THE DBH OF THE TREE WAS 43 INCHES.
THE CANOPY SPREAD WAS 57 BY 66, AND THE RATING ON THE TREE
WAS B-6.
AND IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
3:57:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE
GENTLEMAN?
NO.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
3:57:43PM >>STEVE EYSTER:
NO PROBLEM.
3:57:46PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
DO WE HAVE ANOTHER MEMBER OF CITY STAFF
THAT IS GOING TO BE PRESENTING OR THAT WAS IT?
THAT IS IT.
OKAY.
NEXT UP WE HAVE THE APPLICANT.
3:58:02PM >>JAIME MAIER:
GOOD AFTERNOON.
AGAIN, JAIME MAIER, REPRESENTING THE APPLICANT, FROM THE LAW
FIRM HILL WARD HENDERSON, 101 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, SUITE
3700 IN TAMPA.
I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
I HAVE A PowerPoint AS USUAL.
I KNOW THE CHANGES -- I'LL TRY HERE, I GUESS.
THAT WAS EASIER THAN LAST TIME.
I ALSO HAVE WITH ME HERE TODAY MR. RICKY PETERIKA WHO WILL
BE PROVIDING TESTIMONY.
I HAVE SUBMITTED A COPY OF HIS CV INTO THE RECORD, REQUEST
THAT HE BE ACCEPTED AS AN EXPERT.
BEFORE HE PROVIDES TESTIMONY, THOUGH, I WOULD LIKE TO WALK
YOU THROUGH MORE BACKGROUND IN ADDITION TO WHAT STAFF HAS
PROVIDED AND TO DISCUSS IN A LITTLE MORE DETAIL THE REASON
WE'RE APPEALING THIS DECISION.
AS YOU SAW, THE DECISION APPEALED WAS A DECISION OF THE
VARIANCE REVIEW BOARD TO DENY THE REQUEST TO REMOVE ONE
GRAND TREE FOR CONSTRUCTION OF A NEW SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE
IN THE RS-60 ZONING DISTRICT.
THE PROPOSED NEW STRUCTURE IS TWO STORIES, THAT IS PERMITTED
IN THE RS-60 ZONING DISTRICT.
THE SETBACKS WITH WHICH THE TREE DIRECTLY CONFLICTS ARE ALSO
THOSE THAT ARE PERMITTED IN THE RS 60 ZONING DISTRICT.
SO THE ISSUE IS THAT THE LOCATION OF THE TREE ON THE SITE IS
DIRECTLY WITHIN THE BUILDABLE ENVELOPE THAT IS PERMITTED BY
THE ZONING DISTRICT.
AS YOU CAN SEE FROM THE AERIAL, THE SITE IS HEAVILY WOODED.
ACTUALLY PROBABLY GOT THE MOST TREES GENERALLY ON OR AROUND
IT OUT OF THE ENTIRE BLOCK.
I WANT TO BE CLEAR, THERE ARE A NUMBER OF TREES, LIKE I
SAID, ON AND AROUND THE SITE THAT AFFECT THE SITE.
THE ONLY ONE BEING REQUESTED TO BE REMOVED I'LL SHOW YOU IN
A COUPLE OF SLIDES AND YOU'VE ALREADY SEEN FROM NATURAL
RESOURCES BUT I WANTED TO SHOW THE OTHER TREES THAT REMAIN
ON SITE.
THIS WILL NOT BE RAISED.
THERE WILL BE TREES REMAINING ON AND AROUND THE SITE.
LACK OF BETTER TERM, NAMED TREE A, B AND C AND LABELED THEM
RELATIVE TO THE SITE PLAN.
THIS TREE IS ALONG SAN JOSE STREET AND IS GOING TO REMAIN.
TREE B IS IN THE REAR CORNER OF THE SITE.
AND WILL REMAIN.
AND TREE C IS ON THE SIDE KIND OF TO THE REAR ALONG
ESPERANZA AND WILL REMAIN.
I DO HAVE ANOTHER MORE CLOSE-UP FOR YOU, BUT I WANTED TO --
I POINT OUT HERE THE TREE, THE REMOVAL TREE, I'LL CALL IT,
STANDING FROM THE STREET ON SAN JOSE.
YOU CAN SEE THE NUMBER OF OTHER TREES THAT WILL REMAIN.
AGAIN, IT'S CLEAR THAT FROM THE SITE PLAN, THIS TREE IS
WITHIN THE BUILDABLE ENVELOPE.
SO THE TREE IS LOCATED PRETTY CENTRALLY TO THE SITE.
AGAIN, WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING AT, WHAT YOU SEE IS PART OF THE
BY RIGHT BUILDING ENVELOPE THAT A STRUCTURE PROPOSED HERE
COULD BE BUILT ON UNDER THE ZONING.
THE CANOPY TAKES UP A LOT OF THE SITE AS WELL.
SO ALTHOUGH AS MS. PETTIS-MACKLE POINTED OUT THIS IS A
DE NOVO HEARING, I WANT TO TALK ABOUT THE REASON THAT WE ARE
APPEALING TO YOU TO ACHIEVE A DIFFERENT RESULT.
THE VARIANCE REVIEW BOARD DID ERR IN MULTIPLE WAYS IN ITS
DECISION MAKING.
THERE WAS A LOT OF TALK AND THEY ENDED UP RELYING ON, IN
LARGE PART, THE OUTDATED TREE CODE STANDARD, USING THE TERM
"REASONABLE USE."
THAT IS NOT EVEN IN THE CURRENT TREE CODE ANYMORE, THAT
TERM.
AND IT WAS USED -- MANY OF YOU ARE PROBABLY FAMILIAR WITH IT
BECAUSE THIS CHANGE WAS IN 2019.
BUT IT WAS USED THROUGHOUT THIS HEARING, AND IT WAS BLENDED
WITH THE CURRENT CODE THAT APPLIES, BUT THE CURRENT CODE
USES THE REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION STANDARD WHICH MR.
PETERIKA WILL DO A BETTER JOB OF WALKING YOU THROUGH THAN I
WOULD, BUT THEY MISAPPLIED THAT TERM AS WELL, AND WE'LL SHOW
YOU HOW.
ULTIMATELY, THEY ALSO RELIED ON INAPPROPRIATE BASES FOR
DENIAL THAT WERE NOT ROOTED IN THE CODE CRITERIA IN WHICH
THEY WERE REQUIRED TO APPLY.
NOW, THE CURRENT CODE IS DESIGNED PURPOSEFULLY TO BE
OBJECTIVE, BUT BY BLENDING THE OLD CODE AND MISAPPLYING THE
NEW CODE, THEY REACHED A TOTALLY SUBJECTIVE RESULT.
OUR FIRM WAS NOT AT THE VARIANCE REVIEW BOARD HEARING,
HOWEVER, WHEN WE REVIEWED THE TRANSCRIPT AND SAW HOW THE
CODE HAD BEEN MISAPPLIED, THE FIRST STEP WAS TO ASK RICKY
PETERIKA, WHO BETTER TO ASK BECAUSE HE WAS VERY INVOLVED IN
THE TRANSITION OF THE CODE AND APPLIED THEM BOTH.
HIS TESTIMONY WILL BE INVALUABLE.
AGAIN, TO REITERATE, THE CODE WAS OVERHAULED IN 2019 TO
CREATE AN OBJECTIVE PROCESS.
THERE WERE EVEN WORKSHOPS HELD TRAINING CITY BOARD MEMBERS
-- OR SITTING BOARD MEMBERS HOW TO APPLY IT BECAUSE IT WAS
SUCH A DIFFERENT RESULT.
AGAIN, THE OLD STANDARD WAS SUBJECTIVE.
IT WAS MORE FOCUSED ON ANY CONCEIVABLE STRUCTURE THAT COULD
BE BUILT ON THE PROPERTY, IN THIS CASE, IT WOULD BE A
SINGLE-FAMILY HOME, BUT ANY CONCEIVABLE CONFIGURATION OR
SIZE OF THAT STRUCTURE THAT YOU COULD WORK AROUND THE TREE,
THAT COULD BE CONSIDERED A REASONABLE USE UNDER THE CODE AND
THE TREE WOULD HAVE TO REMAIN.
THE NEW STRUCTURE, OR THE NEW STANDARD IS OBJECTIVE,
EVALUATING THE ACTUAL STRUCTURE THAT A GIVEN APPLICANT HAS
PROPOSED AND ASKING, CAN THIS STRUCTURE, NOT ANY CONCEIVABLE
STRUCTURE, BUT CAN THIS STRUCTURE BE REASONABLY
RECONFIGURED.
I'M USING QUOTES HERE BECAUSE THAT IS A DEFINED TERM IN THE
CODE SUCH THAT IT COULD SAVE THE TREE.
THE TERM REASONABLE CONFIGURATION IS NOT A SUBJECTIVE
STANDARD.
IT IS CLEARLY DEFINED.
IT EITHER IS OR IT IS NOT.
I'LL TURN IT OVER FOR A FEW MINUTES TO MR. PETERIKA TO
EXPLAIN THAT.
4:04:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
YES, SIR.
4:04:12PM >> THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
RICKY PETERIKA, 308 EAST 7TH AVENUE.
I'VE BEEN SWORN.
THERE ARE FIVE CRITERIA FOR GRAND TREE REMOVAL.
TABLE 284.2.5, THE TWO THAT APPLY MOST CLOSELY TO THIS CASE
ARE THE SMALL LOT CRITERIA, THE TRZ AND GRAND TREE REMOVAL
BY COMMISSION OR CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITY IMPACT REVIEWED BY A
COMMISSION, WHICH IS THE VRB OR YOUR BODY.
SMALL LOT CRITERIA WOULD APPLY TO THE LOT, BUT NOT TO THE
TREE BECAUSE IT'S NOT LOCATED IN THE TRZ.
SO -- WHICH IS WHY THEY WENT TO THE VRB.
SO THEY ARE SUBJECT TO THE OTHER CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITY
IMPACT CRITERIA, WHICH IS SHOWN ON THE SLIDE, BUT THE MAIN
COMPONENT THAT I'M SPEAKING TO IS ON THE BOTTOM, NO OTHER
REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION OF THE DEVELOPMENT.
SO THAT IS DEFINED IN FOOTNOTE FIVE OF TABLE 284.2.5, KIND
OF FIVE BULLET POINTS.
IF THESE THINGS CAN BE DONE TO THE BUILDING FOOTPRINT AS
PROPOSED, THEN IT SHALL BE CONSIDERED.
BASICALLY IT SHALL BE CONSIDERED REASONABLE.
OTHERWISE, IT WOULD BE UNREASONABLE.
SO IT DOES NOT ADJUST THE STRUCTURE MORE THAN ALLOWED BY THE
DESIGN EXCEPTION.
SO NOT MORE THAN 25% FRONT OR BACK OR ONE FOOT SIDE TO SIDE.
DOES NOT CHANGE THE NUMBER OF STORIES PROPOSED.
SO IT DOESN'T GO FROM TWO TO THREE OR ONE OR TWO TO ONE AND
DOES NOT ADVERSELY ALTER INTERNAL FLOW OR FUNCTION OF THE
PROPOSED STRUCTURE, WHICH IS VERY FLAVORFUL STATEMENT ON
WHAT INTERNAL FLOW AND FUNCTION IS, BUT I'VE ALWAYS
INTERPRETED IT IS THIS THE SAME PROGRAM OF THE BUILDING THAT
WE'RE PROPOSING IF JUST A DIFFERENT SHAPE OR DID WE LOSE
PROGRAM, LOSE ELEMENTS OF THE BUILDING FOR TREE
PRESERVATION?
LIKE I SAID, THE DESIGN EXCEPTION DOES NOT SHIFT THE
BUILDING FAR ENOUGH OUTSIDE FROM CAUSING THE TREE OR THE
BUILDING TO BE PRESERVED, OR THE TREE TO BE PRESERVED
WITHOUT THE BUILDING FOOTPRINT BEING AFFECTED.
SO IT DOESN'T MEET THE DESIGN EXCEPTION ADJUSTMENT.
TWO OPTIONS WERE PROPOSED AT THE VRB.
BOTH BASICALLY NOTCH OUT A QUARTER OF THE BUILDING, AND THIS
IS, WHICH IS SHOWN IN RED, WHICH IS APPROXIMATELY 30% OF THE
BUILDING'S GROSS SQUARE FOOTAGE LESSED OUT TO ACCOMMODATE
TREE A, WHICH I EVALUATED AS TREE ONE AND TERMED IT TO BE A
43-INCH TREE, B-6, NON-HAZARDOUS GRAND TREE, IN AGREEMENT
WITH NATURAL RESOURCES.
SO THERE'S NO DISPUTE ABOUT THE CONDITION.
JUST ABOUT WHAT REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION IS.
SO BOTH OF THESE EXAMPLE -- OR 30% OF THE BUILDING FOOTPRINT
IS LOST TO THE TREE PRESERVATION COMMITMENT.
WHICH IS ADDRESSED HERE.
ADDITIONALLY, BY SHOWING THE FLOOR PLAN OF THE BUILDING --
OF THE PROPOSED BUILDING, WE CAN BETTER UNDERSTAND WHAT
ACTUALLY IS LOST FROM THE INTERNAL FLOW OR FUNCTION.
WHICH IN THIS CASE, THE MASTER SUITE NO LONGER HAS THE
MASTER BATH OR CLOSET.
THE STAIRS ARE AFFECTED, WHICH COULD AFFECT THE SECOND
FLOOR.
IT GETS POTENTIALLY ESOTERIC AS WE APPLY THIS, BUT I THINK
AT THE EASIER REVIEW IS, IS THIS THE SAME BUILDING THAT WAS
PROPOSED?
COULD IT JUST BE MOVED ON THE SITE AND ACCOMMODATED?
NO.
COULD IT BE INCREASED IN FLOORS OR DECREASED IN FLOORS
WITHOUT LOSING SQUARE FOOTAGE?
NO.
SO BY THOSE CRITERIA, IN MY OPINION, IT'S NO LONGER
REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION.
THIS WAS PROPOSED BY STAFF, THIS OPTION, WHICH IS A SLIGHT
HYBRID OF WHAT WAS PROPOSED BY MR. MOBLEY, BUT IT LOCATES AN
ACCESSORY STRUCTURE FOR A GARAGE.
IN MY OPINION, THIS IS TECHNICALLY UNREASONABLE
RECONFIGURATION BECAUSE WE LOST THE 30% ROUGHLY OF THE LOT
AREA AND BY LITERALLY BREAKING THE BUILDING INTO TWO.
AND ALL THAT'S BEEN BROKEN OFF IS THE GARAGE.
SO THIS PROPOSAL FROM STAFF DURING THE HEARING, IN MY
OPINION, WAS AN EXAMPLE OF AN UNREASONABLE RECONFIGURATION
OPTION.
4:09:11PM >>JAIME MAIER:
JUST TO SUMMARIZE AND THANK YOU, MR.
PETERIKA, FOR YOUR TESTIMONY.
SO YOU HEARD HOW THE FACTORS THE BOARD WAS REQUIRED TO
CONSIDER, AND YOU SAW THEM IN THE STANDARD PROVIDED TO YOU
BY THE CITY ATTORNEY I'M SURE IN YOUR PACKETS.
THE BOARD WAS REQUIRED TO CONSIDER FACTORS IN THE CODE SUCH
AS THE IMPACT OF THE PROPOSED STRUCTURE ON THE TREE.
WELL, AS YOU'VE SEEN, IT WOULD BE GOING RIGHT THROUGH THE
TRUNK.
OBVIOUSLY, THAT JUST CANNOT COEXIST.
WHETHER IT CAN BE REASONABLY RECONFIGURED, AS THAT TERM IS
DEFINED IN THE CODE, WHETHER THE SETBACKS COULD BE REDUCED
TO PRESERVE IT, WHETHER ALTERNATIVE CONSTRUCTION OR THE COST
OF THAT ALTERNATIVE CONSTRUCTION COULD PRESERVE IT.
YOU'VE HEARD MR. PETERIKA'S PROFESSIONAL OPINION THAT THOSE
FACTORS WEIGH IN FAVOR OF REMOVING THE TREE BECAUSE THESE
POTENTIAL FIXES THAT THE CODE SUGGESTS AND RECOMMENDS -- OR
IT REQUIRES THE BOARD TO CONSIDER DON'T WORK HERE.
NOW, INSTEAD OF CONSIDERING ALL OF THE THINGS IT WAS
SUPPOSED TO CONSIDER AND ULTIMATELY WHAT IT MADE ITS
DECISION ON WERE THINGS THEY SHOULD NOT HAVE CONSIDERED.
AGAIN, THEY DISCUSSED AT LENGTH AND ASKED QUESTIONS OF
STAFF, THE REASONABLE USE STANDARD, SAYING A HOME IS A HOME.
ANY HOME, SUGGESTING THAT ANY HOME, INCLUDING THE
THOUSAND-SQUARE-FOOT HOME THAT WAS IT THERE BEFORE, VERY
SMALL, COMPLETELY DIFFERENT, HAS BEEN DEMOLISHED, WAS
REASONABLE USE.
UNDER THE OLD STANDARD, THAT PROBABLY WOULD HAVE BEEN THE
RESULT, BUT THAT IS NOT THE STANDARD ANY LONGER AND THAT WAS
A CONSCIOUS DECISION TO CHANGE THE CODE.
IT IS UNRECOGNIZABLE FROM THE STANDARD THAT EXISTED IN 2019
AND PRIOR.
ALSO, AS AN EXPRESSED REASON FOR DENIAL WHEN THEY LISTED
THEIR REASONS FOR DENYING THE APPLICATION, THEY EXPRESSLY
STATED THAT THE NUMBER OF SPEAKERS AND LETTERS IN OPPOSITION
COULD NOT BE IGNORED.
THAT WAS A REASON FOR DENIAL.
THERE IS WELL-ESTABLISHED CASE LAW THAT SAYS A LARGE NUMBER
OF RESIDENTS OPPOSING -- OR APPEARING TO OBJECT IS NOT A
VALID BASIS FOR DENIAL OF A PERMIT.
AND THEY STILL USED THAT AS A BASIS OF DENIAL OF A PERMIT.
IN SUMMARY, YOU'VE SEEN HOW THIS STRUCTURE CANNOT BE
REASONABLY RECONFIGURED, AGAIN, AS THAT TERM IS DEFINED IN
THE CODE, IT IS NOT SUBJECTIVE.
IT IS NOT ANYBODY'S IDEA OF WHAT REASONABLE COULD BE.
THE DICTIONARY DEFINITION OF THE TERM IS A DEFINED TERM WITH
CRITERIA.
AND YOU'VE SEEN WHO IT CANNOT BE REASONABLY RECONFIGURED.
THEREFORE, THE STRUCTURE THAT IS PROPOSED ON THIS SMALL LOT
WHERE SEVERAL TREES ARE AT ISSUE, THIS PARTICULAR ONE IS
CENTRALLY LOCATED.
IT IS LOCATED WITHIN THE BUILDABLE AREA THAT IS CREATED BY
THE ZONING CODE.
THE APPLICATION OF THE CORRECT CODE STANDARD WOULD HAVE
RESULTED IN AN OBJECTIVE FINDING THAT THE TREE MUST BE
REMOVED.
THEREFORE, WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST THAT CITY COUNCIL APPLY
THE CORRECT CODE STANDARD AND REVERSE THE VRB'S DECISION.
THANK YOU.
4:12:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE
PETITIONER?
HEARING NONE, MADAM CLERK, TO DO WITH WE HAVE ANY REGISTERED
SPEAKERS FOR PUBLIC COMMENT ON THIS OR NO?
WE'LL TAKE THE REGISTERED SPEAKER FIRST AND THEN TO THE
AUDIENCE.
IF STEPHANIE POYNOR IS ON THE LINE, UNMUTE YOURSELF AND BE
READY TO BE SWORN IN IF YOU HAVEN'T.
SHE'S ON.
4:12:37PM >>THE CLERK:
SHE NEEDS TO TURN ON HER CAMERA AND UNMUTE
HERSELF.
4:12:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MS. POYNOR, IF YOU CAN TURN YOUR CAMERA
ON, WE'LL SWEAR YOU IN AND BEGIN PUBLIC COMMENT.
THERE SHE IS.
WELL, THERE IS THE CAMERA.
OTHER WAY.
4:13:07PM >>THE CLERK:
THERE SHE IS.
4:13:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
ALL RIGHT.
IF YOU COULD BE SWORN IN AND UNMUTE YOURSELF.
4:13:13PM >>THE CLERK:
MS. POYNOR, YOU'RE UNMUTED ON THE PLATFORM, SO
YOU MAY NEED TO UNMUTE YOUR DEVICE.
4:13:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
YOU ARE STILL MUTED.
MS. POYNOR, WE'LL COME BACK TO YOU.
WE'LL START WITH THE PUBLIC COMMENT IN THE ROOM.
SO STAND BY.
IF YOU ARE HERE TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, PLEASE LINE UP, IF
YOU ARE ABLE TO.
AND YOU WILL HAVE THREE MINUTES TO SPEAK.
PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME BEFORE SPEAKING.
THANK YOU.
YES, MA'AM.
4:14:21PM >> GOOD AFTERNOON.
I'M MARY LEE MOTTO.
I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN.
I'M A GRADUATE OF THE MAYOR'S NEIGHBORHOOD UNIVERSITY CLASS
10 OF 2018, MEMBER OF PALMA CEIA NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION.
AND REGISTERED MEMBER OF THE CITY EMERGENCY RESPONSE TEAM,
BUT, MOST IMPORTANTLY, I BUILT A HOUSE THREE PROPERTIES AWAY
FROM THE PROPERTY IN QUESTION.
IT'S MY FIRST TIME IN FRONT OF YOU ALL.
LITTLE NERVOUS.
THE STREET IS VERY IMPORTANT TO ME.
IT PROVIDES IMPORTANT AND IMPACTFUL SHADE FOR OUR
NEIGHBORHOOD.
IT PROVIDES MY DOG'S PAWS WITH THAT SHADE AS WE WALK THEM
THROUGH THIS NEIGHBORHOOD.
IT IS ONE OF THE LARGEST TREES IN MY COMMUNITY.
I BELIEVE THE REMOVAL OF THIS TREE WOULD CAUSE MY FAMILY
DIRECT HARM IN THE FORM OF DIMINISHED PROPERTY VALUE DUE TO
REDUCTION OF THE VISIBLE TREE CANOPY.
THE NEIGHBORHOOD CHARM THAT I SPENT THE MONEY TO BUILD MY
HOUSE IN AND THE AVAILABLE SHADE TO WALK MY DOGS IN ON
SEVERELY HOT DAYS IN TAMPA.
OUR TREE CANOPY IS CRITICAL TO KEEPING OUR TEMPERATURES
DOWN.
PLEASE HELP PROTECT THE TREE CANOPY OF OUR CITY.
ACCORDING TO THE ARBORIST REPORT, THIS TREE WOULD HAVE TO BE
REPLACED BY 16 TREES.
16 TO GET THE VALUE IT PROVIDES AND THE IMPACT AVAILABLE
FROM IT TODAY.
OF THE 42 PROPERTY OWNERS LISTED IN THE PETITION FOR REVIEW
OF THE VRB DECISION DOCUMENT, I PERSONALLY CONTACTED THE
FOLLOWING PROPERTY OWNERS TODAY AND HAVE AUTHORIZATION FROM
EACH OF THEM TO ENTER THEIR NAME ON RECORD AS BEING OPPOSED
TO THE REMOVAL OF THIS TREE.
CAROLINE CARRIE, MARTIN FOWLER.
MARY ELLEN WALKER.
DORIS ANN PLATH.
IN ADDITION, NANCY BRYANT IS A HOMEOWNER IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD
AND AUTHORIZED ME TODAY TO ENTER HER NAME AS OPPOSED.
MEGAN LABEL ALSO GRANTED ME AUTHORITY TO ENTER HER NAME ON
RECORD FOR THE AGENDA ITEM AS BEING STRONGLY OPPOSED.
RESIDENT, PROPERTY RENTER IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO THE LOT
AND HAS E-MAILED HER STRONG OBJECTION AS WELL.
IT IS POSTED IN THE SUPPORTING MATERIALS FOR THIS AGENDA
ITEM.
NANCY CONFIRMED THAT THE PROPERTY OWNER OF 3119 WEST
PALMIRA, SHARON HIGGINBOTHAM IS OPPOSED TO THE REMOVAL OF
THE TREE AS WELL.
I THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE TO OUR CITY AND FOR YOUR
ATTENTION.
4:16:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
YES, MA'AM, NEXT SPEAKER.
4:17:15PM >> MY NAME IS CARROLL ANN BENNETT.
LIFELONG TAMPA RESIDENT.
SEVERAL YEARS AGO, THE BUILDING COMMUNITY WAS FED UP WITH
THE TAMPA TREE CODE.
THEY WANTED TO LOOK AT A PROPERTY AND KNOW WHAT THEY COULD
BUILD.
THEY NEEDED PREDICTABILITY TO EVALUATE THEIR PURCHASES.
SO FOR A YEAR AND A HALF, TREE SOMETHING SAY SOMETHING AND
BUILDERS AND CITY COUNCIL WORKED TOGETHER TO WRITE A NEW
TAMPA TREE CODE.
I AM HERE TODAY ASKING YOU TO UPHOLD THE CODE THAT YOU AND I
AND THE BUILDERS WROTE TOGETHER.
WE TREE ADVOCATES MADE A HUGE COMPROMISE AND AGREED TO A
LARGE TREE REMOVAL ZONE ON SMALLER LOTS, THE TRZ.
WE AGREED THAT A TREE IN THE BUILDABLE FOOTPRINT OF A
SMALLER LOT COULD BE CUT DOWN AND WE WOULDN'T FIND IT.
THESE ARE APPROVED ADMINISTRATIVELY.
WE SACRIFICED THE TREES INSIDE THE TRZ TO SAVE THE TREES
OUTSIDE THE TRZ.
BUT IF BUILDERS CAN CUT DOWN THOSE TREES, TOO, THEN WHAT DID
THEY GIVE UP?
WHAT HAPPENED TO THEIR COMPROMISE?
WE NEGOTIATED IN GOOD FAITH AND I BELIEVE CITY COUNCIL
NEGOTIATED IN GOOD FAITH WHEN THEY UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED THE
NEW TREE CODE.
ALL THE STAKEHOLDERS COMPROMISE TO ACHIEVE PREDICTABILITY SO
THAT TIME AND RESOURCES AREN'T WASTED.
AND YET HERE WE ARE AGAIN WASTING TIME AND RESOURCES.
THIS TREE IS NOT IN THE TRZ.
IT IS A VERY HEALTHY, B-RATED TREE THAT WILL LIVE FOR
CENTURIES.
THERE WAS A NORMAL SIZE HOUSE IN GOOD CONDITION ON THIS
PROPERTY.
MULTIPLE PEOPLE TESTIFIED TO THE VRB THAT THEY WOULD LOVE
AND BUY THE HOUSE FOR $515,000 THAT MR. MOBLEY PAID FOR IT
BUT THEY NEVER GOT THE CHANCE BECAUSE IT NEVER WENT ON THE
MARKET, SO THEY ARE STILL LOOKING FOR A HOME.
ARBORIST DAVID RILEY EVALUATED THIS TREE BEFORE THE SALE.
THE BUYER KNEW IT WAS A VERY HEALTHY GRAND OAK THAT WAS NOT
IN THE TRZ AND COULD NOT BE REMOVED.
THERE ARE VERY SPECIFIC CRITERIA YOU MUST CONSIDER.
YOUR DECISION BOILS DOWN TO THIS.
CAN A HOME BE REASONABLY CONFIGURED ON THIS LOT WITHOUT
KILLING THIS GRAND TREE?
THE ANSWER IS AN OBVIOUS YES.
THE CITY ARBORIST THINKS IT CAN BE SAVED JUST BY HAVING A
DETACHED GARAGE AND USING SOME OF THE PIER AND LINTEL
CONSTRUCTION.
THIS PROPERTY IS ON THE MARKET IN A PENDING STATUS AS A
SIX-BEDROOM, FOUR-BATH, 3,515-SQUARE-FOOT HOUSE WITH A PRICE
TAG OF $1,599,000.
ON A 50 BY 100 LOT.
A NEW HOUSE CAN BE BUILT THERE WITHOUT DAMAGING THE TREE.
IT MIGHT NEED TO BE SMALLER THAN SIX BEDROOMS, BUT THAT
SOUNDS LIKE REASONABLE CONFIGURATION TO ME.
WE HAVE A TREE CODE THAT TOLD HIM HE COULD NOT REMOVE THIS
TREE.
THE VRB EVALUATED THE CRITERIA AND VOTED 5-1 THAT HE COULD
NOT REMOVE THIS TREE.
PLEASE UPHOLD THE VRB RULING AND DENY THE VARIANCE.
IF EVERYONE KNOWS THE CITY IS GOING TO ENFORCE THE TREE CODE
THAT THE STAKEHOLDERS WROTE, PEOPLE WILL START BUILDING THE
RIGHT THING IN THE RIGHT PLACE AND YOUR TIME AND RESOURCES
WON'T BE WASTED ON VARIANCES AND APPEALS AND YOU WILL GIVE
BUILDERS THE PREDICTABILITY THAT THEY DEMANDED.
THANK YOU.
4:20:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
NEXT SPEAKER.
YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
4:20:23PM >> BOB WHITMORE WITH CITY TREE.
I'M GOING OFF SCRIPT.
GOING TO USE THE --
THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS.
EXPERTS COME IN WHEN A BUILDER WANTS TO BUILD ON PROPERTY
THAT IS IN THE WAY WITH A TREE THAT'S IN THE WAY.
I'M GOING TO BITE ON THIS REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION ISSUE.
THIS IS A COURTROOM RIGHT NOW, AND YOU GUYS HAVE GOT TO MAKE
A DECISION.
YOU DON'T WANT TO HEAR ABOUT SPARROWS, SQUIRRELS AND TREE
HUGGERS.
YOU WANT TO HEAR ABOUT A FACT.
MR. MOBLEY HAS THREE MODELS.
THAT'S WHAT PEOPLE CAN PICK OUT OF HIS CONFIGURATIONS.
THERE IS NOTHING THAT IS CUSTOM ABOUT MOBLEY CUSTOM HOMES.
HE WILL GO IN.
ELMO DOWN WHATEVER HAS TO BE TAKEN DOWN TO PUT HIS BOXES ON
THAT PROPERTY.
HE DID NOT TRY TO REASONABLY RECONFIGURE THIS HOUSE.
A SHARPIE MARKER SKETCH OVER OLD PLANS IS NOT REASONABLE
RECONFIGURATION.
MR. MOBLEY IN THE VRB ADMITTED HE HAS NO ARCHITECT ON STAFF.
HE HAS NOBODY THAT CAN GO IN AND SAY, YOU KNOW, MR. MOBLEY,
IF WE JUST SHIFT THIS OVER A LITTLE BIT, MAYBE WE CAN SAVE
THIS TREE.
IT'S NOT THERE.
SO HE CAN'T DO IT AND HE'S NOT GOING TO SPEND THE MONEY TO
DO IT, BECAUSE HE KNOWS WHAT IT COSTS TO BUILD A HOUSE ON
THIS PROPERTY WITH THE AMOUNT OF MATERIALS THAT HE USED FOR
EVERY OTHER SINGLE PROPERTY THAT HE IS PLOPPING DOWN ON
PIECES OF LAND THROUGHOUT SOUTH TAMPA, WITHOUT EVEN GIVING
ANY CONSIDERATION FOR DESIGN AND LOOKING AT THINGS THAT
ACTUALLY SORT OF FIT WITH THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
HE'S IN IT FOR THE MONEY.
HE'S BUILDING BOXES PEOPLE BUY FOR HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF
DOLLARS.
HE DOESN'T CARE ABOUT WHAT PEOPLE CAN AFFORD.
HE KNOWS HIS MARKET.
HE KNOWS PEOPLE CAN BUY HIS HOUSE YOU SEE.
WHAT IS HE TAKING AWAY?
HE'S TAKING AWAY -- MR. MIRANDA, YOU TALKED ABOUT YOU DON'T
WANT TO GIVE AWAY WATER.
HE'S TAKING AWAY AIR.
HE'S TAKING AWAY SHADE.
HE'S TAKING AWAY -- WE ARE SELLING THAT TO THE HIGHEST
BIDDER.
MR. MOBLEY IS ONE OF THE WORST OFFENDERS FOR GETTING THAT
AND GIVING NOTHING BACK TO THE CITY OF TAMPA.
HE IS LOOKING TO MAKE MONEY.
HE WANTS HIS WAY.
THE VRB SAID THEY COULD NOT HAVE HIS WAY AND THEY SAID WHY
HE COULD NOT HAVE HIS WAY.
THERE'S A LOT OF SMOKE AND MIRRORS, YEAH, THROWING VERBIAGE
UP.
YOU GUYS AREN'T GOING TO HAVE TIME TO LOOK INTO THAT.
THE FACT IS THE VRB SAID, LOOK, YOU CAN PUT THIS UP.
THE TREE IS THIS FAR AWAY FROM WHERE THE ENVELOPE IS.
MAYBE YOU CAN FIX IT SO THAT YOU CAN GO AHEAD AND BUILD A
HOUSE THERE.
DOESN'T WANT TO DO IT.
TOO MUCH TROUBLE.
BRINGS A LAWYER AND BRINGS AN EXPERT AND HE GOES AHEAD AND
HE THROWS IT OUT IN FRONT OF YOU GUYS AND HE'S GOING TO PLAY
YOU.
THEY ARE GOING TO PLAY YOU AND I HOPE THEY DON'T.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE.
4:23:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU, SIR.
NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
4:23:42PM >> ALEJANDRO WHITE.
I LIVE ON SAN JOSE STREET.
AND I'VE SEEN HOW MY BLOCK HAS CHANGED AND THE TREES ARE
GONE.
I DON'T WANT TO ALLOW THIS -- I DON'T WANT TO SEE THIS
HAPPEN AGAIN.
THANK YOU.
4:23:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THE NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
YES, MA'AM.
4:24:05PM >> CAROL ANN DEE.
PALMA CEIA RESIDENT.
THIS MORNING, I WALKED BY THE TREE IN QUESTION TWO BLOCKS
FROM MY HOUSE.
MY HUSBAND AND I OFTEN WALK BY IN THE EVENING AND ENJOY THIS
BEAUTIFUL OAK.
IT WOULD BE A GREAT INJUSTICE TO CUT IT DOWN FOR ANOTHER
GIANT HOUSE THAT GOES FROM LOT LINE TO LOT LINE.
THIS TREE IS IN WHAT WOULD BE KNOWN AS THE BACKYARD OF THE
LOT WHEN THERE WERE SUCH THINGS AS BACKYARDS.
IT'S NOT CENTRALLY LOCATED, AS THEY HAVE SAID.
IT'S TOWARDS THE BACK.
IT'S TOWARDS THE SIDE.
IT'S IN THE BACKYARD.
THE DEVELOPER, MR. MOBLEY, COULD BUILD AROUND THE TREE, BUT
THAT IS NOT WHAT HE DOES.
HE HAS HIS HOUSE PLANS, AND THE LOT NEEDS TO CONFORM TO HIS
COOKIE-CUTTER HOUSES, NOT THE OTHER WAY AROUND.
IT CREATES A HARDSHIP FOR HIM BECAUSE IT MIGHT INTERFERE
WITH HIS BOTTOM LINE.
THE COUNCIL WOULD DO WELL TO CONSIDER ALSO THE HARDSHIP TO
THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND THE COMMUNITY BY THE DESTRUCTION OF
ANOTHER GRAND TREE ON MR. MOBLEY'S BOTTOM LINE.
JUST MONTHS AGO IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD, AGAIN, JUST DOWN THE
STREET FROM MY HOUSE, WE LOST A BEAUTIFUL GRAND OAK FOR ONE
OF MR. MOBLEY'S HOUSES.
HE IS A FREQUENT VICTIM OF HARDSHIP AT CITY HALL, BUT I AM
HOPING THAT TODAY THE COUNCIL WILL CONSIDER THE HARDSHIP TO
THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND THE PLANET AND LISTEN TO THE VARIANCE
REVIEW BOARD AND CITY STAFF WHO HAVE WISELY RECOMMENDED THAT
THIS LOVELY TREE BE SAVED.
4:25:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
NEXT SPEAKER.
PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
4:25:56PM >> CAN YOU SEE THIS?
4:25:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
YES -- UH, IF WE COULD ACTIVATE THE
OVERHEAD.
IT'S STILL SHOWING THE PowerPoint.
OKAY.
NOW WE CAN SEE THEM.
THERE WE GO.
YES, MA'AM.
THE BOTTOM PICTURE IS OFF VIEW.
NO, NO.
THOSE PICTURES ARE FINE.
THE SINGLE BOTTOM PHOTO IS OUT OF VIEW.
THERE WE GO.
THANK YOU.
4:26:27PM >> BEFORE I BEGIN, I'D LIKE TO KNOW IF I COULD SHOW YOU ALL
AN 18-SECOND VIDEO OF THE TREE.
I TALKED TO TOM DEA AHEAD OF TIME AND HE SAID I WOULD HAVE
TO ASK YOU.
4:26:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THAT'S FINE WITH ME.
ANY OBJECTION FROM COUNCIL?
WHO HAS THE VIDEO?
4:26:43PM >> HE HAS IT.
4:26:46PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
OKAY.
IF YOU COULD PLAY THE VIDEO.
THERE WE GO.
4:26:49PM >> GOOD AFTERNOON.
MY NAME IS LORRAINE PERINO.
I LIVE IN SOUTH TAMPA.
I'M PRESIDENT OF THE TAMPA TREE ADVOCACY GROUP.
ON JULY 7th, 2022, THE NATIONAL WEATHER SERVICE ISSUED A
RARE WARNING TO TAMPA RESIDENTS TO EXERCISE CAUTION WHILE
OUTDOORS AS THE HEAT INDEX THAT DAY WOULD MEET THE 93-DEGREE
TEMPERATURE FEEL LIKE 110 DEGREES.
DESPITE THE CLIMATE CHANGE ALARM BELLS GOING OFF DAILY,
MOBLEY PETITIONED THE CITY TO RESCIND THE VRB DECISION AND
ALLOW HIM TO DESTROY ONE OF TAMPA'S MOST ESSENTIAL, VALUABLE
AND BEAUTIFUL TREES.
HEALTHY 50-FOOT TALL GRAND OAK LOCATED OUTSIDE OF THE
BUILDABLE AREA TO BUILD A LARGER STRUCTURE THAN THE CITY
CODE ALLOWS.
IS THIS THE BEHAVIOR OF A GOOD CORPORATE CITIZEN OR IS IT
GREED?
THE BUILDER ASSERTS THAT REMOVING THIS GRAND OAK WOULD ALLOW
THE PROPERTY TO BE USED IN THE SAME MANNER AS OTHER LOTS OF
THE SAME SIZE IN THE SAME AREA.
OTHER LOTS OF THE SAME SIZE DO NOT CONTAIN A HEALTHY 50-FOOT
GRAND OAK GROWING ON THEM.
NOTE THAT THE CITY ARBORIST PLAN PROPOSES AN ALTERNATE
DESIGN WHICH WOULD PRESERVE THE OLD GROWTH GRAND OAK FOR
FUTURE GENERATIONS TO ENJOY.
MOBLEY ADMITS TO PURCHASING THE PROPERTY WITH THE TREE ON
IT.
YET ASTONISHINGLY CLAIMS THAT THE GRAND TREE HAS CREATED A
HARDSHIP ON HIM.
EVEN THOUGH THE TREE IS PROTECTED BY THE CITY'S TREE
ORDINANCE, HE FIGURES HE CAN BEAT THE SYSTEM AND DESTROY THE
TREE BY APPEALING TO THE CITY.
REMOVING A TREE OF THIS SIZE AGAINST THE WISHES OF THE
NEIGHBORHOOD RESIDENTS WOULD ALSO NEGATIVELY IMPACT THEIR
HEALTH AS THE LOSS OF SHADE AND COOL AIR THAT THE TREE
PROVIDES WOULD CAUSE THE HEAT INDEX TO RISE DRAMATICALLY AS
REFERENCED ABOVE.
THE GRAND OAK'S REMOVAL WOULD ALSO INCREASE AIR POLLUTION IN
THE NEIGHBORHOOD, RESULTING FROM THE RELEASE OF CO2, WHICH
HAS BEEN STORED IN ITS TRUNK, AND THE CO2 WHICH IT WOULD
CEASE TO CAPTURE.
THE NEIGHBORHOOD WOULD ALSO BE DEPRIVED OF THE TREE'S BEAUTY
AND THE PURE OXYGEN WHICH IT PUMPS OUT DAILY AND SONGBIRDS,
SQUIRRELS, BUTTERFLIES, AND ALL WILDLIFE DEPENDENT ON THIS
GRAND OAK WOULD BE NEGATIVELY IMPACTED.
DESPITE THESE SERIOUS CONSEQUENCES, THE BUILDER FALSELY
ASSERTS THAT BY REMOVING THE TREE THE RIGHTS OF OTHERS ARE
NOT COMPROMISED OR INJURIOUS IN ANY WAY TO THE PUBLIC
HEALTH, SAFETY, AND GENERAL WELFARE.
MOBLEY HOMES ONLY CARES FOR THE SELFISH INTERESTS, NOT THE
GOOD OF THE COMMUNITY.
MOBLEY CLAIMS THAT THE PROPOSED VARIANCE IS IN HARMONY WITH
TAMPA'S COMP PLAN.
HOWEVER, THE COMP PLANS URBAN FORESTRY SECTION STATES, TREE
CANOPY IS A VITAL COMMUNITY AND ENVIRONMENTAL ASSET THAT IS
APPRECIATED AND DESIRED BY RESIDENTS IN NEW AND ESTABLISHED
NEIGHBORHOODS ALIKE.
THE PROTECTION AND SUPPLEMENTATION OF THIS CANOPY, TREE
CANOPY IS A NECESSITY IN ORDER TO SUSTAIN THE RESOURCE AND
MAINTAIN THE ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS SUCH AS COOLER
TEMPERATURES THAT THE CANOPY -- MATURE CANOPY PROVIDES.
THE 2011 URBAN FOREST ANALYSIS STATES, UNLIKE OTHER PUBLIC
INFRASTRUCTURE COMPONENTS, PROPERLY PLANTED AND MAINTAINED
TREES INCREASE IN VALUE OVER TIME.
PAST TIME TO STOP CATERING TO THE SELFISH DESIRES OF
BUILDERS BY NOT ALLOWING THEM TO DESTROY TAMPA'S OLD GROWTH
TREES AND NEGATIVELY IMPACT OUR OWN HEALTH.
INSTEAD, LET'S PRESERVE TAMPA'S GRAND TREES AND CHERISH THEM
FOR THE BEAUTY, HEALTH BENEFITS, AND QUALITY OF LIFE THAT
THEY PROVIDE FOR US AT SUCH A MINIMAL COST.
PLEASE VOTE NO TO THE SELF-SERVING APPEAL AND VOTE TO
PRESERVE ONE OF TAMPA'S MOST BEAUTIFUL OLD-GROWTH GRAND OAKS
FOR ALL OF TAMPA.
4:30:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
YES, MA'AM.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
4:30:10PM >> GOOD AFTERNOON.
CAROL CAMISSA, PALMA CEIA.
I'VE BEEN SWORN IN.
I'M ALSO A DOG GRANNY, AND I WALK IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD.
AND ENJOY THE SHADE, THE BEAUTY OF THE TREE, THE BRICK
STREETS.
MR. MOBLEY HAS CLAIMED THAT HIS -- ONE OF HIS THREE MODELS
THAT HE INTENDS TO PUT THERE WILL NOT CHANGE THE CHARACTER
OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND LOOKING AT THOSE PICTURES AND MY OWN
WALKS THERE, I WOULD DISAGREE WITH THAT STRONGLY.
IN MY DOG WALKS, I ALSO SEE OTHER PROPERTIES CONSTANTLY
BEING DEVELOPED IN SOUTH TAMPA.
THE LOTS THAT HAVE A MOBLEY SIGN ON THEM GENERALLY ARE ONES
THAT ARE FLAT, TREELESS, AND CAN ACCOMMODATE ONE OF HIS
THREE MODELS.
THERE ARE OTHER DEVELOPERS, AND I'M NOT HERE TO PROMOTE OR
NOT, ANY PARTICULAR DEVELOPER, BUT I SEE PLACES WHERE TREES
ARE ROPED OFF AND TRACTORS MOVE AROUND AND THAT KIND OF
THING.
IT IS POSSIBLE TO HAVE A REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION.
THIS IS A SMALLER LOT, BUT THAT'S NOT THE MODUS OPERANDI OF
THIS PARTICULAR DEVELOPER, AND I DON'T THINK THAT GIVEN THE
STRENGTH OF THE COMMUNITY'S FEELINGS AND CASE THAT THEY ARE
MAKING ABOUT SAVING THIS TREE, SOMEONE PUSHING SOMETHING, A
WAIVER THROUGH THE SYSTEM JUST BECAUSE THEIR BUSINESS MODEL
DOESN'T ACCOMMODATE THIS PARTICULAR LOT AND THIS PARTICULAR
TREE IS A GOOD CASE FOR A WAIVER.
SO I WOULD ASK YOU TO DENY THAT REQUEST.
THANK YOU.
4:31:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
STEPHANIE POYNOR, ARE YOU UNMUTED?
IS SHE LOGGED IN STILL?
4:32:27PM >>THE CLERK:
MS. POYNOR, JUST TURN ON YOUR CAMERA AND UNMUTE
YOURSELF, PLEASE.
4:32:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
WE APOLOGIZE, BUT THERE SEEMS TO BE SOME
TECHNICAL ISSUES.
4:32:49PM >> CAN YOU HEAR ME?
4:32:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
YES, MA'AM.
TURN YOUR CAMERA.
4:33:00PM >> CAN YOU HEAR ME?
4:33:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
WE CAN HEAR YOU, BUT WE CAN'T SEE YOU.
4:33:09PM >> NO WORRIES.
4:33:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THAT CONCLUDES PUBLIC COMMENT.
WE'LL GO TO ANY ADDITIONAL STAFF COMMENT, IF THERE IS ANY.
YES, MA'AM.
4:33:25PM >>JAYNE NMADU:
GOOD AFTERNOON.
JAYNE NMADU, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN.
I WOULD JUST LIKE TO PROVIDE THE COUNCIL WITH FURTHER
CLARIFICATION REGARDING SOME OF THE THINGS THAT THE LEGAL
REPRESENTATION FOR THE APPLICANT BROUGHT UP.
SHE DID MENTION, SHE TALKS ABOUT REASONABLE USE OR
REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION AS THE DISCUSSION THAT WENT ON
DURING THE VRB HEARING.
ULTIMATELY, THE DECISION OF THE BOARD WAS BASED ON SECTION
27-284.2.5 F.
THAT IS THE PARAMETER WITHIN WHICH THE BOARD HAS TO DECIDE
WHETHER OR NOT TO APPROVE A GRAND TREE.
AND THEY DID TALK ABOUT REASONABLE USE AS TO THE FACT THAT
THERE WAS A HOUSE PREVIOUSLY ON THIS PROPERTY AND THE
APPLICANT DID SAY THAT IT'S IMPOSSIBLE TO PUT A HOME ON THIS
PROPERTY WITHOUT REMOVING THE TREE.
AND THAT WAS HOW THAT CONVERSATION WENT.
THERE WAS ACTUALLY A HOUSE AND THE TREE WAS THERE.
SHE DID TALK ABOUT THE FACT THAT -- AND I THINK IT WAS THE
EXPERT THAT SPOKE ABOUT ALTERING THE INTERNAL FLOW OF THE
STRUCTURE OR THE PROPOSED DESIGN.
AGAIN, THAT SECTION SAYS ADVERSELY ALTERED, SO IF YOU'RE
ALTERING THE INTERNAL FLOW THAT YOU CANNOT FUNCTION IN THE
HOUSE IN THE WAY THAT YOU HAVE TO ALTER THE HOUSE, THEN IT'S
ADVERSELY ALTERED.
IT DOESN'T SAY YOU CANNOT ALTER THE FLOW OF THE INTERNAL
STRUCTURE.
THEY DID PROVIDE ALTERNATIVE SITE PLANS, AND I'VE BEEN DOING
THE VARIANCES FOR A LITTLE BIT AS IN PRIVATE HOMEOWNERS
SUBMITTING ALTERNATE SITE PLANS SHOW THAT THEY ARE ACTUALLY
TRYING TO PRESERVE THE TREE.
THAT IS THE WHOLE IDEA BEHIND ALTERNATIVE SITE PLANS THAT
YOU SHOW US THAT YOU'RE TRYING TO SEE HOW THIS TREE CAN BE
PRESERVED.
WITH THE SITE PLANS THAT THE APPLICANT PROVIDED, THEIR LEGAL
REPRESENTATION SAID THAT THE SITE PLANS SHOW THAT THIS TREE
CANNOT BE SAVED.
WHAT THE APPLICANT DID PROVIDE TO US IS THE PROPOSED PLAN
WITH A CUTOUT OF THE SECTION OF THE RADIUS OF THE TREE.
UNFORTUNATELY, WE DON'T SEE A LOT OF CREATIVITY OR EVEN THE
INTENT TO RECONFIGURE BECAUSE BASICALLY THE SAME THING
WITHOUT ACTUALLY MASSAGING THIS PLAN.
AND WE, AS STAFF, WE TAKE WHAT YOU GIVE TO US.
WE CAN'T SAY WE WOULD REJECT IT BECAUSE THE ALTERNATIVE SITE
PLANS ARE WHATEVER YOU CHOOSE THEN TO MAKE THEM.
WE SEE A LOT OF PLANS WHERE THE APPLICANT IS REALLY NOT
TRYING BECAUSE THEY FEEL THEY DON'T WANT TO PUT AN EFFORT TO
SAVE THE TREE.
BUT WE SEE THE SITE PLANS, PART OF WHAT THE CODE SAYS IS
THAT THE ALTERNATIVE SITE PLAN SHOULD ACCOUNT FOR THE
PROVISION OF THE CODE TO REDUCE YOUR SETBACKS TO SAVE A
TREE.
AND THAT IS IN SECTION 27-284, THE SECTION THAT THE BOARD
HAS TO LOOK AT, IT SAYS IN C, WHETHER THE REDUCTION OF THE
REQUIRED SETBACK FOR THE PARAMETER BUILDING OR STRUCTURE AS
PROVIDED IN SECTION 27-156, ALLOW THE LOCATION OF THE
BUILDING SUFFICIENT TO PRESERVE THE GRAND TREE REQUESTED FOR
REMOVAL.
THE ALTERNATIVE SITE PLANS THAT THE APPLICANT PROVIDED, THEY
DID NOT ACCOUNT FOR THE SETBACK REDUCTIONS PROVIDED BY THE
CODE.
SO THEY ARE NOT LOOKING TO SEE HOW THIS COULD -- AND THEY
COULD GET A LOT OF LATITUDE IF THEY DID TAKE CONCENTRATION
OF THE SETBACK REDUCTIONS TO SAVE A GRAND TREE THAT THE CODE
HAS PROVIDED.
THE OTHER THING IS THAT -- AND THEY DID MENTION THE PROPOSAL
BY NATURAL RESOURCES IN HIS PROPOSAL FOR HOW THEY COULD
MASSAGE THE BUILDING.
WHAT HE DID WAS BASED ON THE ALTERNATIVE SITE PLANS THAT
THEY PROVIDED.
THAT WAS NOT HIS PROPOSAL.
SO WHEN THEY SAY THAT THE NATURAL RESOURCES PROPOSAL FAILED
OR NOT BE VISIBLE, HE WAS JUST WORKING OFF OF WHAT THEY HAD
ALREADY PROVIDED TO US AND SAYING, IF THIS IS WHAT YOU'RE
LOOKING AT AS AN ALTERNATIVE, THERE ARE WAYS TO MAKE THIS
WORK.
DURING THE HEARING, I BELIEVE IT WAS -- I CAN BE CORRECTED
IF I AM WRONG.
I BELIEVE IT WAS THE BOARD MEMBER OONA JOHNSEN WHO POSED THE
QUESTION TO THE APPLICANT TO SAY WOULD YOU BE WILLING TO
CONSIDER ALTERNATIVE CONSTRUCTION METHODS IN ORDER TO SAVE
THE TREE.
HIS RESPONSE TO THAT WAS, NO, HE DECLINED.
THAT IS ONE OF THE REQUIREMENTS IN THE SECTION THAT SAYS IN
E, THE COST OF ANY ALTERNATIVE CONSTRUCTION METHODS OR
REDUCTION IN THE USE OF THE PROPOSED STRUCTURE, HE WAS NOT
WILLING TO EVEN CONSIDER ALTERNATIVE METHODS EVEN THOUGH
WITH PIER AND LINTEL CONSTRUCTION YOU COULD ENCROACH INTO
THAT PROTECTED RADIUS.
SO THE LAST THING I'LL SAY REGARDING WHAT THIS IS ABOUT,
ZONING SETBACKS AND THE BUILDABLE AREA TO SAY THAT WHAT THEY
ARE PROPOSING IS WITHIN THE BUILDABLE AREA.
CORRECT, YOU'RE WITHIN THE SETBACKS FOR YOUR ZONING.
HOWEVER, WE DO HAVE A CODE THAT PROTECTS GRAND TREES.
SO OUR ZONING SETBACK DOES NOT NEGATE THE FACT THAT WE HAVE
A TREE THAT IS PROTECTED BY THE CODE.
THE CODE DOESN'T CONTRADICT ITSELF.
SO WE HAVE SETBACK REDUCTIONS IN ORDER TO SAVE THE GRAND
TREE.
SO, YES, YOU ARE WITHIN THE SETBACKS, BUT WE ALSO HAVE A
CODE THAT WE HAVE TO RESPECT THAT PROTECTS THE GRAND TREES.
SO WHEN YOU COME ON THE SITE OR YOU'RE COMING TO, YOU KNOW,
CONSTRUCTION, WE CONSIDER HOW YOU ARE TREATING THAT SITE IN
RESPECT TO THE CODE.
SO, YES, YOU ARE WITHIN YOUR BUILDING ENVELOPE OF WHAT YOU
COULD POTENTIALLY BUILD ON THAT SITE, BUT WE ARE GIVING YOU
ALLOWANCES WITHIN THE CODE TO MOVE YOUR BUILDING IN ORDER TO
SAVE THE GRAND TREE.
AND THOSE ARE THE COMMENTS I JUST HAD IN RESPONSE TO STUFF
THAT THE LEGAL REPRESENTATION FOR THE APPLICANT HAD SAID AND
TO WHAT THEIR EXPERT WITNESS HAD SAID.
IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, SURE.
4:40:09PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
HAVE YOU SEEN THIS REPORT BY HILL WARD
HENDERSON THAT WAS PROVIDED TO COUNCIL?
4:40:15PM >>JAYNE NMADU:
NO.
4:40:16PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
I CAN'T REALLY ASK YOU QUESTIONS.
FROM WHAT I'M SEEING, I'LL ASK THE APPLICANT, I GUESS THEIR
CHIEF COMPLAINT IS SAYING THAT OUR VARIANCE REVIEW BOARD
ERRED ON THE TERMINOLOGY OR THE INTERPRETATION OF REASONABLE
CONFIGURATION.
BUT SINCE YOU HAVE NOT SEEN WHAT THEY BRIEFED, I'LL HAVE TO
WAIT TO COME BACK AND ASK THE QUESTION, BUT YOU CAN COME
BACK AFTER THAT SINCE YOU HAVE NOT READ WHAT THEY SUBMITTED.
4:40:43PM >>JAYNE NMADU:
I TRIED TO ADDRESS PART OF THE QUESTION OF
REASONABLE CONFIGURATION IN SAYING THAT ONE OF THE THINGS OR
PART OF WHAT THEY HAD HAD HIGHLIGHTED WAS THE FACT THAT IF
THEY WERE TO, YOU KNOW, CHANGE THE LAYOUT OF WHAT THEY ARE
PROPOSING, IT WOULD AFFECT THE INTERNAL FLOW OF THE BUILDING
OR INTERNAL FLOW OF THE DESIGN.
I'M SAYING THAT WHAT THAT PART OF THE CODE SAYS IS,
ADVERSELY ALTER.
SO IF YOU HAVE TO CHANGE THIS IN A WAY THAT YOU CANNOT
FUNCTION WITHIN THE BUILDING OR WITHIN THAT DESIGN, YOU
CANNOT GET FROM YOUR LIVING ROOM TO THE BEDROOM OR, YOU
KNOW, IT AFFECTS THAT, THEN IT IS ADVERSELY ALTERING THE
INTERNAL FLOW OF YOUR STRUCTURE.
THAT WE DON'T SEE BY WHAT THE APPLICANT HAS PROVIDED TO US.
THE OTHER THING THEY SAID, WE'RE NOT PROPOSING ANY CHANGES
TO THE HEIGHT OF THE STRUCTURE OF WHAT THEY ARE PROPOSING.
YES, THERE ARE LOW-HANGING BRANCHES, BUT NATURAL RESOURCE
EXPERT CAN SPEAK TO THE FACT THAT YOU CAN HAVE TREE PRUNING
AND ALL OF THAT THAT WOULD STILL PRESERVE THE TREE AND ALLOW
THEM TO BUILD WHAT THEY ARE PROPOSING.
BUT THOSE WERE PART OF THE THINGS THEY MENTIONED REGARDING
REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION AND STEPHEN CAN ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS REGARDING THE TECHNICAL ASPECTS OF PRUNING THAT
TREE OR -- I CAN COME BACK UP TO ADDRESS THAT.
4:42:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
ALL RIGHT.
IF THERE ARE NO OTHER QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME, WE HAVE
REBUTTAL FROM THE APPLICANT.
FIVE MINUTES FOR REBUTTAL.
YES, MA'AM.
4:42:20PM >>JAIME MAIER:
I WANT TO ADDRESS A COUPLE OF THINGS FIRST
THAT WERE SAID BY STAFF.
THE APPLICANT DID NOT SAY THAT -- ACTUALLY, I THINK I'LL
HAVE THE APPLICANT HIMSELF SPEAK TO THE ALTERNATIVE
CONSTRUCTION.
I WANT TO CLARIFY ACTUALLY A FEW THINGS THAT WERE SAID BY
EVERYBODY.
MOBLEY BUILDS A LOT OF HOMES IN THE AREA.
HE FREQUENTLY BUILDS THEM AROUND GRAND TREES.
HE DOES THAT.
THAT IS A FACT.
AND ALSO, HE IS A BUILDER.
THERE ARE CONTRACT PURCHASERS THAT COULD BUY THIS HOME.
THEY LIVE JUST DOWN THE STREET.
THEY WANT A BIGGER HOME.
SO FOR WHAT THAT'S WORTH, THERE IS A FACE -- THERE IS A
LIVING HUMAN BEING BUYING THIS WHO LIVES ON THE STREET
WANTING TO BUY THE HOME FOR WHATEVER THAT'S WORTH.
AND I THINK IT IS WORTH SOMETHING.
I'M GOING TO HAVE MR. PETERIKA REITERATE HOW THE CODE
APPLIES HERE, BUT WHAT STAFF IS SAYING IS, AGAIN, NOT
APPLYING THE REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION ANALYSIS WITH CODE.
THESE GRAND TREE REMOVAL CASES GET APPROVED A LOT SINCE
2019.
YOU DON'T SEE THEM BECAUSE THEY TYPICALLY ARE APPLIED
CORRECTLY.
THERE'S TYPICALLY NOT AS MUCH PUBLIC COMMENT, FRANKLY, AS
THERE WAS AT THIS ONE BECAUSE IT IS EASIER, FRANKLY, TO
REMOVE THE GRAND TREES NOW UNDER THIS CODE BECAUSE IT IS
OBJECTIVE.
THAT WAS THE WHOLE PURPOSE.
AND SAYING THE TRZ IS WHAT DICTATES EVERYTHING, NO.
THE TRZ IS A WAY TO REMOVE A TREE WITHOUT HAVING TO GET A
VARIANCE BASED ON A DEFINED AREA OF THE LOT.
AND THEN THE CODE SAYS, IF THE TREE, WHICH THIS TREE IS
EIGHT INCHES OUTSIDE OF THAT, IF THE TREE IS OUTSIDE OF THE
TREE REMOVAL ZONE, OKAY, THEN YOU HAVE TO GET A VARIANCE.
AND HERE ARE THE CRITERIA THAT YOU APPLY TO GET THAT.
BASICALLY SAYING, WELL, BECAUSE YOU HAVE TO ASK FOR A
VARIANCE IN ORDER TO REMOVE THIS TREE, THAT'S WHY IT SHOULD
BE DENIED.
WHY WOULD WE HAVE THAT AT ALL?
WHY WOULD THAT PROCESS EXIST?
THE PROCESS IS THERE IF IT CANNOT BE REMOVED BECAUSE OF THE
TRZ.
MR. PETERIKA, IF WE CAN CLARIFY, AGAIN, THE REASONABLE
RECONFIGURATION ANALYSIS, CAN YOU JUST READ THE CRITERIA OR
AT LEAST SUMMARIZE THEM.
I KNOW THE CRITERIA ARE IN FRONT OF YOU.
4:44:44PM >> RICHARD PETERIKA:
AS APPLICABLE TO THIS LOT AS MANY
LOTS, THE REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION CRITERIA ASKS SOMEONE
TO TAKE THEIR PROPOSED FOOTPRINT, EITHER, A, SHIFT IT TO THE
DESIGN EXCEPTION SETBACK, 10% TO THE FRONT OR THE BACK.
THAT WOULD BE TWO FEET.
25% TO THE SIDE, SEVEN FOOT SIDE SETBACKS, MAYBE THERE IS A
CORNER SETBACK THAT APPLIES.
BARELY A FOOT AND A HALF.
THE TREE IS CURRENTLY LOCATED ABOUT SEVEN FEET FROM THE
PROPERTY LINE AT THE SIDE SETBACK.
IT'S IN DIRECT CONFLICT WITH THE PROPOSED BUILDING WALL.
THE TREE TRUNK IS IN CONFLICT WITH THE BUILDING WALL, NOT --
THE BRANCHES MAY ALSO BE IN CONFLICT, BUT IF WE'RE CUTTING
OFF AN ARM AT YOUR CHEST, THE ARM IS LESS THE POINT.
THERE'S NO CHANGE IN STORIES.
I DON'T THINK THAT'S REALLY AN ISSUE, EXCEPT THAT BECAUSE OF
THE EXISTING STRUCTURE THAT WAS THERE, THE CANOPY HAD
ALREADY BEEN ELEVATED ON THAT SIDE.
THAT'S NOT REALLY THE POINT BECAUSE THE TREE IS LOCATED IN
THE BUILDING FOOTPRINT.
AND THE BUILDING CAN'T BE SHIFTED TO THE DESIGN EXCEPTION.
THE HEIGHT OF THE STRUCTURE IS NOT RELEVANT TO THIS
PROPOSAL, EXCEPT IF IT WAS REDUCED, IT WOULDN'T ACCOMMODATE
THE TREE ANY BETTER.
AND THE THIRD PORTION OF THIS SECTION, THE INTERNAL FLOW AND
FUNCTION, IS NOT ADVERSELY ALTERED.
MS. NMADU IS RIGHT IN STRESSING THAT POINT.
IT IS NOT ADVERSELY ALTERED.
WE'RE STATING IT IS A 30% REDUCTION IN THE HOUSE THAT WAS
PROPOSED.
ROOMS AND CIRCULATION ARE LOST BY PRESERVING THE ROOT SYSTEM
PROVIDED.
AND IN MY OPINION THAT IS AN ADVERSE ALTERATION TO THE
INTERNAL FLOW AND FUNCTION OF THE PROPOSAL.
THAT'S ALL WE HAVE.
THAT'S ALL THE CODE SAYS IN THE SECTION, 27-2,842.5,
FOOTNOTE 5, II 123.
THAT'S ALL WE CAN WORK FROM.
SO I APPRECIATE YOU OFFERING THE OPPORTUNITY TO KIND OF MAKE
THAT POINT.
4:47:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
4:47:09PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN.
MR. PETERIKA, YOU ARE VERY COMPETENT IN YOUR KNOWLEDGE OF
TREES AND EVERYTHING ELSE.
I'VE TAKEN ALWAYS YOUR TESTIMONY AS THE EVIDENCE OF A
PROFESSIONAL, WHICH YOU ARE.
REPRESENTED BY ONE OF THE HIGHEST ATTORNEY FIRMS, HILL WARD
HENDERSON.
I'VE SEEN MANY MOBLEY HOMES BUILT AND THEY ARE VERY, VERY
GOOD.
HOWEVER, AFTER LISTENING TO ALL THE TESTIMONY AND LISTENING
TO EVERYTHING I HEARD, NO ONE HAS MENTIONED THAT IT MIGHT BE
A HARDSHIP OF A HOUSE, BUT IT WAS A HARDSHIP BEFORE THE
HOUSE WAS DESIGNED.
YOU KNOW WHY?
BECAUSE IT IS A 50-FOOT LOT.
IF IT WAS A 60-FOOT LOT, WE WOULDN'T BE HERE.
AM I RIGHT?
4:47:52PM >>RICHARD PETERIKA:
YES, THERE WOULD BE SUFFICIENT SPACE ON
THE LOT.
4:47:55PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
I'M PRETTY LIBERAL ON A LOT OF THINGS,
BUT WHEN WE COME UP AND SAY A HARDSHIP, IT IS.
WHO CREATED THE HARDSHIP?
4:48:08PM >>RICHARD PETERIKA:
I DON'T KNOW IF I'M PREPARED TO ANSWER
THAT.
4:48:12PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
WHO CREATED THE HARDSHIP?
I'M A CRIMINOLOGIST.
WHO CREATED THE HARDSHIP?
4:48:22PM >>RICHARD PETERIKA:
WAS IT A LOT OF RECORD?
4:48:26PM >> YES.
4:48:27PM >>RICHARD PETERIKA:
WHEN WAS IT PLATTED?
1908.
THE DEVELOPER THEN SET THIS UP.
4:48:36PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
THANK YOU, SIR.
4:48:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
ALL RIGHT.
THAT CONCLUDES REBUTTAL.
AT THIS TIME, IS THERE A MOTION, IF THERE ARE NO OTHER
QUESTIONS, TO CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING.
4:48:48PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO CLOSE THE PUBLIC
HEARING.
4:48:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
WE HAVE A MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER
HURTAK.
SECONDED BY COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
ALL IN FAVOR?
WHAT IS THE PLEASURE OF COUNCIL?
WE HAVE THREE POSSIBLE ACTIONS, AFFIRM, REMAND, OR OVERTURN.
DOES ANYBODY WISH TO MAKE A MOTION AT THIS TIME?
4:49:10PM >>BILL CARLSON:
I MOVE TO AFFIRM THE VRB'S DECISION TO DENY
THE VARIANCE REQUESTED IN VRB-22-70 FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED
AT 3122 WEST SAN JOSE STREET BECAUSE THE PETITION DOES NOT
MEET THE CRITERIA IN SECTION 27-284.2.5 F FOR TO REMOVE THE
GRAND TREE.
4:49:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
CARLSON.
WE HAVE A SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
ROLL CALL VOTE, PLEASE.
4:49:41PM >>ORLANDO GUDES:
YES.
4:49:42PM >>LUIS VIERA:
YES.
4:49:44PM >>LYNN HURTAK:
YES.
4:49:45PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA:
YES.
4:49:49PM >>BILL CARLSON:
YES.
4:49:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
YES.
4:49:51PM >>THE CLERK:
THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
[ APPLAUSE ]
MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY WITH CITRO BEING ABSENT AT VOTE.
4:49:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THAT CONCLUDES OUR AGENDA.
MR. SHELBY, SINCE WE START AGAIN AT 5:01 P.M., IS THERE A
MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE OR JUST WE'RE IN RECESS?
I'LL LEAVE NEW BUSINESS UNTIL TONIGHT.
CAN I GET A MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE?
4:50:14PM >> SO MOVED.
4:50:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO:
MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN GUDES.
SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
ALL IN FAVOR?
AYE.
ALL RIGHT.
WE ARE IN RECESS -- WELL, THE MEETING IS 5:01.
IT MAY BE A FEW MINUTES LATER.
5:01.
THANK YOU.
[ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.