TAMPA CITY COUNCIL
THURSDAY, AUGUST 17, 2023, 5:01 P.M.
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.
5:05:16PM [ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
5:05:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I WOULD LIKE TO CALL THIS TAMPA CITY
5:05:21PM COUNCIL EVENING MEETING TO ORDER.
5:05:23PM IF WE COULD HAVE A ROLL CALL, PLEASE.
5:05:26PM >>BILL CARLSON: HERE.
5:05:28PM >>LYNN HURTAK: HERE.
5:05:28PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HERE.
5:05:30PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: PRESENT.
5:05:32PM >>LUIS VIERA: HERE.
5:05:34PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HERE.
5:05:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
5:05:36PM >>THE CLERK: WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
5:05:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:05:38PM IF I CAN GET A MOTION TO OPEN ALL PUBLIC HEARINGS.
5:05:40PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SO MOVED.
5:05:42PM >> SECOND.
5:05:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON,
5:05:46PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
5:05:48PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:05:49PM THE FIRST ONE IS A NON-QUASI-JUDICIAL PROCEEDING.
5:05:52PM BEFORE WE GO THROUGH THE AGENDA, WE'LL TAKE UP ITEM NUMBER
5:05:55PM 1, LaCHONE -- WE'LL DO HOUSE KEEPING AFTER ITEM -- GO
5:06:03PM AHEAD, MA'AM.
5:06:05PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
5:06:06PM McLANE EVANS, ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY.
5:06:08PM THIS IS AN APPLICATION FOR BROWNFIELD DESIGNATION.
5:06:11PM TONIGHT IS THE FIRST OF TWO HEARINGS.
5:06:17PM THE PROPERTY IS GENERALLY LOCATED IN THE VICINITY OF 1306
5:06:20PM EAST 4th AVENUE.
5:06:21PM THE PROPERTY DEVELOPER KS YBOR MASTER DEVELOPER LLC IS
5:06:26PM REQUESTING DESIGNATION OF THESE PROPERTIES AS BROWNFIELD
5:06:29PM AREA TO ASSIST IN THE ASSESSMENT AND REMEDIATION OF
5:06:32PM ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS THAT MAY EXIST ON THE PROPERTY.
5:06:34PM DETAILS OF THE DESIGNATION HAVE BEEN OUTLINED IN A DOCUMENT
5:06:37PM ENTITLED STAFF REPORT ON YBOR GATEWAY REDEVELOPMENT AREA
5:06:40PM PROPOSED BROWNFIELD AREA DESIGNATION, WHICH IS AVAILABLE FOR
5:06:43PM PUBLIC REVIEW BOTH IN THE CLERK'S OFFICE AND ON SIRE,
5:06:46PM ASSOCIATED WITH THIS EVENING'S HEARING.
5:06:48PM TONIGHT, NO ACTION IS REQUIRED FROM COUNCIL OTHER THAN TO
5:06:52PM HOLD THE HEARING AND ACCEPT PUBLIC COMMENT.
5:06:54PM AT THE CONCLUSION OF THE SECOND PUBLIC HEARING, WHICH IS
5:06:58PM SCHEDULED ON SEPTEMBER 7th, 2023 AT 9 A.M. OR AS SOON
5:07:03PM THEREAFTER, COUNCIL WILL HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO PASS A
5:07:05PM RESOLUTION DESIGNATING THIS SITE YBOR GATEWAY REDEVELOPMENT
5:07:10PM AS A BROWNFIELD AREA.
5:07:12PM STAFF AND I ARE AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
5:07:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME?
5:07:15PM I HEAR AND SEE NONE.
5:07:18PM IF THERE'S ANYBODY FROM THE PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON
5:07:20PM ITEM NUMBER 1, NOW IS YOUR OPPORTUNITY.
5:07:23PM IF NOT, WE'LL HAVE THE SECOND PUBLIC HEARING SEPTEMBER 7,
5:07:26PM 2023, AT 9 A.M. HERE IN THE CHAMBERS.
5:07:28PM ALL RIGHT.
5:07:31PM WE DON'T CLOSE ANYTHING.
5:07:32PM WE JUST KEEP IT OPEN, CORRECT?
5:07:35PM >> YOU CAN CLOSE THIS ONE IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO.
5:07:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS THERE ANYONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK?
5:07:40PM MS. SANCHEZ, ARE YOU WALKING UP?
5:07:42PM ARE YOU COMING UP TO SPEAK?
5:07:44PM NO?
5:07:45PM ALL RIGHT.
5:07:45PM CAN I GET A MOTION TO CLOSE.
5:07:48PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
5:07:51PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
5:07:52PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:07:53PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:07:54PM SECOND PUBLIC HEARING SEPTEMBER 7, 2023, 9 A.M. OR SOON
5:07:58PM THEREAFTER HERE AT 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR,
5:08:01PM TAMPA, FLORIDA.
5:08:02PM ALL RIGHT.
5:08:05PM WE'VE OPENED THE PUBLIC HEARING, SO WE'LL GO TO LaCHONE TO
5:08:08PM GO THROUGH THE AGENDA FOR THIS EVENING AND THEN SWEAR
5:08:10PM EVERYBODY IN.
5:08:11PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES, GOOD EVENING CHAIRMAN AND COUNCIL,
5:08:13PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:08:15PM IF I MAY, I JUST HAVE A COUPLE OF HOUSEKEEPING ITEMS BEFORE
5:08:18PM WE GET TO CLEAR THE AGENDA.
5:08:19PM THE FIRST IS I WOULD LIKE TO MENTION ON THE STAFF REPORTS
5:08:22PM THAT YOU RECEIVED, YOU'LL NOTICE THAT SOME OF THE STAFF
5:08:25PM REPORTS HAVE A NEW FORMAT.
5:08:27PM JUST BRIEFLY TO GO INTO THE FORMAT OF THE STAFF REPORT, IT
5:08:31PM HAS BEEN RECONFIGURED TO PROVIDE YOU THE INFORMATION THAT
5:08:34PM NORMALLY IS PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH FORMAT IN A TABLE.
5:08:39PM SO ON THE NEW REPORTS, WHAT WILL HAPPEN IS ON THE OLDER
5:08:43PM REPORTS THAT WERE ISSUED ON CONTINUED CASES, YOU'LL SEE THE
5:08:46PM OLDER FORMAT AND EVENTUALLY YOU'LL SEE THE NEW FORMAT ON ALL
5:08:50PM OF THE CASES.
5:08:51PM THE PROJECT INFORMATION REGARDING THE LOT SIZE, YOUR SQUARE
5:08:53PM FOOTAGES, ALL THE PARKING INFORMATION WILL BE FOUND IN THAT
5:08:57PM TABLE.
5:08:58PM THEN WE PROVIDE A TABLE FOR THE SURROUNDING USES.
5:09:01PM THE SUMMARY AREA IS THE SAME, BUT IT WOULD NOT REPEAT THE
5:09:04PM INFORMATION PROVIDED BEFORE.
5:09:06PM ONE OTHER CHANGE YOU WILL NOTICE IS UNDER THE GENERAL STAFF
5:09:10PM FINDINGS, IT'S LOCATED IN ONE AREA ON THE REPORT.
5:09:14PM SO THE ONE TABLE, FOR THE STAFF, WHICH IS NOT CONCERNING
5:09:17PM COUNCIL, BUT IN THE BACKGROUND, THESE BECOME DROP-DOWNS FOR
5:09:20PM URBAN PLANNERS TO SELECT WHEN THEY ARE CREATING THE REPORT
5:09:23PM AND ANY MODIFICATIONS ARE CONTAINED WITHIN EACH DEPARTMENT
5:09:26PM AREA IF THEY HAVE SITE PLAN MODIFICATIONS.
5:09:30PM THE ANALYSIS IS THE SAME.
5:09:31PM BUT IF YOU NOTICE ANYTHING THAT'S MISSING OR YOU WANT
5:09:33PM ANYTHING ADDED, JUST LET ME KNOW.
5:09:35PM WE CAN CERTAINLY REVISE AND UPDATE AS NEEDED AS WE MOVE
5:09:39PM ALONG.
5:09:39PM THE OTHER ITEM I'D LIKE TO ANNOUNCE IS WE HAVE A NEW STAFF
5:09:44PM MEMBER TO ANNOUNCE THAT HAS JOINED OUR TEAM.
5:09:46PM I WOULD LIKE TO ANNOUNCE SAMUEL THOMAS.
5:09:50PM HE'S COMING TO US.
5:09:52PM SAM, YOU RECOGNIZED HIM.
5:09:54PM HE WAS WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
5:09:56PM WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION, HE WAS AN URBAN PLANNER THERE.
5:09:59PM SAM IS AN URBAN PLANNER II.
5:10:02PM IN THAT POSITION, IN THIS NEW ROLE, HE WILL PROCESS REZONING
5:10:05PM SPECIAL USE 2 AND ALCOHOL BEVERAGE SALES PETITIONS.
5:10:08PM FOR THE NEXT COUPLE OF HEARINGS, YOU'LL SEE SAM PRESENT ON
5:10:12PM SOME OF THE REPORTS THAT WERE ALREADY PREPARED AND THEN
5:10:15PM EVENTUALLY HE'LL HAVE HIS OWN SET OF CASES THAT HE WILL RUN
5:10:18PM EACH NIGHT.
5:10:19PM WITH THAT, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR ALLOWING ME TO DO THAT
5:10:22PM HOUSEKEEPING.
5:10:23PM I'LL GO AHEAD AND CLEAR THE AGENDA.
5:10:25PM SO THERE'S ONE ITEM ON THIS EVENING'S AGENDA TO REMOVE, AND
5:10:29PM THAT IS ITEM NUMBER 12.
5:10:31PM ITEM NUMBER 12 IS REZ 23-54.
5:10:36PM THIS IS A MISNOTICE, SO THIS WILL BE REMOVED FROM THE
5:10:40PM AGENDA.
5:10:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION TO REMOVE ITEM NUMBER
5:10:42PM 12.
5:10:43PM MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:10:45PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
5:10:46PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:10:47PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:10:48PM ANYTHING ELSE OR IS THAT IT?
5:10:51PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THAT'S IT.
5:10:52PM WE'RE READY TO START WITH ITEM 2.
5:10:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:10:54PM IF YOU ARE GOING TO SPEAK ON ANY OF THE ITEMS ON THE AGENDA
5:10:57PM THIS EVENING, PLEASE STAND UP, RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND WE
5:11:01PM WILL SWEAR YOU IN.
5:11:08PM >>THE CLERK: DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THE TESTIMONY YOU ARE
5:11:10PM ABOUT TO GIVE IS THE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH?
5:11:13PM >> I DO.
5:11:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER 2.
5:11:16PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU AGAIN, COUNCIL.
5:11:18PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:11:19PM ITEM NUMBER 2 IS REZ-22-76.
5:11:22PM THIS IS FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2406 WEST NORTH B
5:11:26PM STREET.
5:11:27PM THE APPLICANT IS REPRESENTED BY STEVE MICHELINI.
5:11:29PM THE REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY FROM RM 16 RESIDENTIAL
5:11:33PM MULTIFAMILY TO PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT FOR RESIDENTIAL
5:11:37PM SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED USES.
5:11:39PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO EMILY TO GIVE HER REPORT AND I'LL COME
5:11:42PM BACK AND GIVE MY REPORT.
5:11:50PM >> BEFORE I GET STARTED WITH MY REPORT, THE PLANNING
5:11:53PM COMMISSION NEEDS TO SUBMIT A REVISED STAFF REPORT INTO THE
5:11:57PM RECORD.
5:11:57PM THERE WERE TWO CHANGES.
5:12:02PM THERE WERE TWO CHANGES THAT NEEDED TO BE MADE TO THE STAFF
5:12:07PM REPORT.
5:12:07PM THE FIRST ONE REMOVES THE REFERENCE TO NORTH A STREET AND
5:12:11PM CORRECTS IT WITH NORTH B STREET AND THE CALCULATION OF BLOCK
5:12:14PM DENSITY SENTENCE CONTAINED IN THE STAFF ANALYSIS.
5:12:17PM AND THE SECOND ONE IS CORRECTING THE STATEMENT THAT THE SITE
5:12:21PM IS ONE BLOCK FROM KENNEDY.
5:12:22PM THE SITE IS ACTUALLY TWO BLOCKS FROM KENNEDY.
5:12:24PM SO THE SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING
5:12:39PM DISTRICT.
5:12:39PM THE WEST TAMPA URBAN VILLAGE AND THE ARMORY GARDENS
5:12:42PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:12:42PM THE SITE IS WITHIN THE COASTAL PLANNING AREA AND
5:12:46PM SPECIFICALLY EVACUATION ZONE C.
5:12:47PM THE SITE IS RIGHT HERE, OUTLINED IN PURPLE.
5:12:52PM THE SURROUNDING AREA IS RESIDENTIAL IN CHARACTER WITH SOME
5:12:55PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED AND SOME MULTIFAMILY AS WELL.
5:12:58PM THE PORTION OF WEST NORTH B STREET BETWEEN NORTH TAMPANIA
5:13:04PM AVENUE CONTAINS JUST A MIX OF EVERYTHING AND THERE ARE
5:13:10PM MULTIFAMILY USES.
5:13:13PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE OUTLINED HERE, AS REPRESENTED BY
5:13:16PM THE RESIDENTIAL 20 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
5:13:20PM AND THE DESIGNATION IS TO THE NORTH, SOUTH, EAST AND WEST OF
5:13:23PM THE SITE.
5:13:24PM IT SURROUNDS IT.
5:13:25PM FURTHER TO THE SOUTHEAST IN THE PINK COLOR IS COMMUNITY
5:13:28PM MIXED USE 35.
5:13:30PM AND FURTHER SOUTH ALONG WEST KENNEDY IS THE URBAN MIXED USE
5:13:35PM C DESIGNATION.
5:13:36PM THE SEGMENT OF NORTH B STREET BETWEEN NORTH TAMPANIA AVENUE
5:13:43PM AND NORTH ARMENIA AVENUE IS DEVELOPED AT 15.01 DWELLING
5:13:46PM UNITS PER ACRE BASED ON 15 SAMPLE SITES, WHICH IS
5:13:49PM APPROXIMATELY 75% OF THE DENSITY ANTICIPATED IN THE AREA.
5:13:54PM THE PD PROPOSED AS 19.5 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE, WHICH IS
5:13:58PM CONSISTENT WITH THE DENSITY PLANNED FOR UNDER THE
5:14:02PM RESIDENTIAL 20 DESIGNATION CONSISTENT WITH LAND USE POLICY
5:14:05PM 8.14.1.
5:14:06PM THE REQUEST SUPPORTS MANY POLICIES IN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
5:14:10PM AS IT RELATES TO HOUSING THE CITY'S POPULATION.
5:14:13PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ENCOURAGES NEW HOUSING ON VACANT AND
5:14:16PM UNDERUTILIZED LAND TO ENSURE AN ADEQUATE HOUSING SUPPLY IS
5:14:19PM AVAILABLE TO MEET THE NEEDS OF TAMPA'S PRESENT AND FUTURE
5:14:22PM POPULATIONS.
5:14:23PM THE REQUEST IS ALSO CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPACT CITY FORM
5:14:26PM STRATEGY WHICH ENCOURAGES INFILL DEVELOPMENT WITHIN
5:14:29PM PROXIMITY TO TRANSIT AND EMPLOYMENT SERVICES.
5:14:31PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ENCOURAGES SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED
5:14:35PM DEVELOPMENTS TO BE DESIGNED TO INCLUDE ORIENTATION OF THE
5:14:38PM FRONT DOOR TO A NEIGHBORHOOD SIDEWALK OR STREET.
5:14:41PM THE PROPOSED ENTRANCES TO UNITS ONE AND EIGHT ARE ORIENTED
5:14:45PM TOWARD THE SIDEWALK ON NORTH B STREET.
5:14:47PM INTERNAL PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIONS ARE PROVIDED TO
5:14:50PM INTERNAL-FACING UNITS WITH SIDEWALK CONNECTIONS TO NORTH B
5:14:53PM STREET, MEETING THE INTENTS OF LAND USE POLICY 9.2.6.
5:14:57PM THE PROPOSED PLANNED DEVELOPMENT WOULD ALLOW FOR DEVELOPMENT
5:15:00PM THAT IS COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH THE DEVELOPMENT
5:15:04PM PATTERN ANTICIPATED UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL 20 FUTURE LAND USE
5:15:06PM DESIGNATION.
5:15:07PM AND THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION IF YOU HAVE ANY
5:15:10PM QUESTIONS.
5:15:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME?
5:15:11PM NO.
5:15:12PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:15:12PM YES, MA'AM.
5:15:20PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, AGAIN, COUNCIL.
5:15:21PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:15:23PM THIS PD REZONING WOULD ALLOW FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE
5:15:28PM PROPERTY WITH 8 RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED UNITS.
5:15:32PM THE SITE CONTAINS 17,909 SQUARE FEET.
5:15:35PM THERE ARE TWO RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED STRUCTURES
5:15:41PM THAT ARE PROPOSED ON-SITE, AND EACH STRUCTURE WOULD CONTAIN
5:15:46PM 4 UNITS.
5:15:46PM LET ME SHOW THE SITE PLAN JUST SO YOU HAVE IT.
5:15:49PM HERE ARE THE TWO STRUCTURES ON-SITE.
5:16:00PM EACH SITE HAS THE FOUR UNITS.
5:16:03PM VEHICULAR ACCESS TO THE SITE IS FROM THE SOUTH FROM THE
5:16:05PM ALLEY.
5:16:07PM THERE ARE TWO PARKING SPACES PROPOSED, WHICH ARE SURFACE
5:16:10PM PARKING SPACES, SOUTH OF EACH BUILDING.
5:16:13PM INSIDE OF EACH BUILDING, TWO-CAR GARAGE PARKING IS PROVIDED
5:16:17PM FOR EACH UNIT.
5:16:18PM AND THE SITE IS LOCATED IN THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY, SO IT
5:16:23PM MUST COMPLY WITH THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY STANDARDS AT THE
5:16:26PM TIME OF PERMITTING.
5:16:27PM ON THE STAFF REPORT IT DOES MENTION WITHIN ON PAGE 2 OF THE
5:16:31PM STAFF REPORT THAT THERE IS ONE WAIVER THAT THE OVERLAY
5:16:34PM REQUESTED, BUT ALL THE OVERLAY STANDARDS WERE MET.
5:16:37PM THAT WAIVER REGARDING THE ORIENTATION OF THE FRONT DOORS,
5:16:41PM AND THAT'S FOR THESE UNITS OR FOR 27-282.
5:16:46PM >> WHERE IS NORTH B?
5:16:48PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THIS IS NORTH B STREET.
5:16:49PM I'M SORRY, TO ORIENT YOU ON THAT.
5:16:51PM THIS IS NORTH B.
5:16:52PM AND SO THESE UNITS, WHICH ARE IDENTIFIED AS UNIT 2, 3, 4, 5,
5:16:58PM 6, AND 7, THOSE DOORS ORIENT TOWARDS THE INTERNAL DRIVE.
5:17:02PM ONLY UNITS 1 AND UNIT 8, WHICH ARE THESE TWO MOST NORTHERN
5:17:08PM UNITS ORIENT -- THE FRONT DOOR ORIENTS TO NORTH B.
5:17:12PM AND SO THIS SITE IS IN THE R-20 DESIGNATION FOR THE FUTURE
5:17:16PM LAND USE CATEGORY, AS EMILY HAS MENTIONED, SO IT DOES ALLOW
5:17:20PM UP TO 18 DWELLING UNITS BY RIGHT AND YOU CAN HAVE 20
5:17:24PM DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE WITH BONUS PROVISIONS MET.
5:17:28PM SO THE APPLICANT HAS ENTERED INTO A BONUS AGREEMENT TO ALLOW
5:17:31PM ONE ADDITIONAL UNIT.
5:17:33PM WITH THE SQUARE FOOTAGE OF THE LAND THAT THEY HAVE
5:17:35PM CURRENTLY, THEY ARE ALLOWED 7 DWELLING UNITS.
5:17:38PM SO THEY ARE REQUESTING A BONUS TO ALLOW ONE ADDITIONAL UNIT.
5:17:41PM AND THAT BONUS IS IN THE AMOUNT OF $35,146.80 TO ACHIEVE
5:17:47PM THAT ONE ADDITIONAL UNIT.
5:17:48PM ON SITE.
5:17:50PM ALSO, LET ME SHOW YOU THE ELEVATIONS PROVIDED.
5:17:56PM SO THE STRUCTURE PROPOSED IS A THREE-STORY STRUCTURE.
5:18:00PM SO FIRST, THIS IS THE NORTH ELEVATION THAT IS PROVIDED.
5:18:04PM SO THIS IS THE VIEW ON NORTH B STREET.
5:18:07PM AND THAT'S THE FRONT DOOR THAT'S ORIENTED ON THAT UNIT TO
5:18:10PM NORTH B.
5:18:12PM AND THEN THIS PROVIDES YOU WITH THE ELEVATION, THE INTERNAL.
5:18:19PM SO THIS WOULD BE TOWARDS THE INTERNAL DRIVE.
5:18:22PM AND THE BUILDINGS ARE IDENTICAL, SO THIS IS YOUR SOUTH
5:18:28PM ELEVATION AND THEN THAT ALSO IS THE OTHER SIDE OF THE
5:18:35PM STRUCTURE.
5:18:36PM AND THEN I HAVE THE ZONING ATLAS, SHOW YOU THE ZONING MAP OF
5:18:41PM THE PROPERTY.
5:18:42PM SO TO ORIENT YOU ON THIS SITE ON THIS MAP, THIS IS THE SITE,
5:18:49PM WHICH IS OUTLINED IN RED.
5:18:51PM THIS IS WEST NORTH B STREET.
5:18:53PM THIS IS TAMPANIA.
5:18:55PM THIS IS ARMENIA.
5:18:56PM THIS IS KENNEDY.
5:18:57PM SO YOU CAN SEE SURROUNDING THE SITE HAS THAT RM 16 ZONING.
5:19:02PM YOU HAVE THE RM 18, WHICH IS LOCATED TO THE NORTH, TO THE
5:19:06PM WEST, AND I HAVE PICTURES OF THE SITES, BUT YOU HAVE THAT
5:19:10PM RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY ZONING IN THE AREA.
5:19:14PM AS YOU MOVE EAST TO ARMENIA, YOU HAVE THE COMMERCIAL ZONING
5:19:17PM AND THE COMMERCIAL USES, AND SOME CN AND PD USES.
5:19:22PM ALONG ARMENIA.
5:19:25PM AND THIS IS THE SITE ON NORTH B.
5:19:32PM THIS IS WEST.
5:19:46PM THIS IS WHAT YOU SEE IN THAT RM 18 DISTRICT THAT'S TO THE
5:19:53PM NORTH IN THAT ZONE.
5:19:54PM THIS IS ALSO NORTH.
5:20:00PM THIS IS THE VIEW IF YOU'RE LOOKING EAST ON NORTH B.
5:20:06PM SO THE SITE ON THIS PICTURE IS TO THE RIGHT, OFF ON THE
5:20:10PM RIGHT SIDE OF THE PICTURE.
5:20:12PM THIS IS EAST OF THE SITE.
5:20:15PM THE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND
5:20:20PM FINDS THE REQUEST INCONSISTENT.
5:20:22PM THE FINDINGS ARE RELATED TO COMPATIBILITY WITH THE USE
5:20:26PM PROPOSED, NOT NECESSARILY THE USE BUT THE SCALE.
5:20:31PM ON THE STAFF REPORT, YOU'LL FIND THE ANALYSIS, WHICH IS
5:20:34PM PROVIDED ON PAGES 4 AND 5 WITHIN THAT REPORT.
5:20:37PM IT DOES SPEAK TO THE AREA SURROUNDING THE SITE, ALTHOUGH IT
5:20:40PM HAS RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY ZONING, THE PREDOMINANT USE IS
5:20:44PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY.
5:20:45PM THERE ARE SOME TWO-FAMILY USES THAT ARE WITHIN THAT AREA,
5:20:50PM BUT THE ZONING IS NOT CONSISTENT WITH THE ACTUAL USES OUT
5:20:54PM ON-SITE.
5:20:55PM SO THE PD REQUEST FOR 8 SINGLE-FAMILY UNITS IS OUT OF
5:20:58PM CHARACTER WITH THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:21:01PM ALSO, THE APPLICANT, I JUST WANT TO NOTE, DID WORK WITH
5:21:04PM STAFF TO REDESIGN THE SITE.
5:21:06PM INITIALLY, THE SITE WAS DESIGNED WITH ENTRY ON NORTH B.
5:21:11PM THEY CHANGED IT.
5:21:13PM THE EFFORT WAS TO TRY TO MEET ALL OVERLAY STANDARDS AS MUCH
5:21:17PM AS THEY COULD.
5:21:17PM SO THIS IS HOW THEY HAVE THE DESIGN WHICH IS BEFORE YOU
5:21:22PM TODAY WITH THE ALLEY ACCESS.
5:21:23PM ON-SITE.
5:21:25PM BUT GIVEN THE NUMBER OF UNITS AND THE THREE-STORY STRUCTURES
5:21:29PM IN THE SURROUNDING AREA WHICH DO NOT HAVE THAT HEIGHT AND
5:21:32PM THAT NUMBER OF UNITS ON-SITE, STAFF FOUND THE REQUEST
5:21:36PM INCONSISTENT.
5:21:38PM THERE ARE REVISIONS TO BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
5:21:41PM READING.
5:21:41PM I HAVE A REVISED REVISION SHEET, WHICH I WILL PROVIDE TO
5:21:44PM YOU.
5:21:44PM AND I'M AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
5:21:47PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
5:21:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME?
5:21:50PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:21:55PM WE'LL BRING THE APPLICANT UP.
5:22:02PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
5:22:03PM STEVE MICHELINI.
5:22:04PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
5:22:05PM THIS PROJECT STARTED OFF PROBABLY ABOUT EIGHT OR NINE MONTHS
5:22:10PM AGO.
5:22:10PM AND IT'S BEEN REVISED SEVERAL TIMES TO TRY TO ACCOMMODATE
5:22:16PM COMMENTS FROM BOTH THE STAFF AND FROM THE NEIGHBORS.
5:22:18PM THE LAND USE IS RESIDENTIAL 20, WHICH ALLOWS UP TO 20 UNITS
5:22:26PM PER ACRE.
5:22:26PM WE'RE PROPOSING 8 UNITS WITH THE BONUS PROVISION.
5:22:30PM 7 UNITS COULD BE BUILT BY RIGHT.
5:22:32PM IT'S LIKE 7.2 UNITS AND SINCE YOU ROUND DOWN, THE 8 UNITS
5:22:40PM REQUIRE A BONUS DENSITY AGREEMENT.
5:22:43PM TWO UNITS ON THE NORTH SIDE OF NORTH B FACE THE STREET AND
5:22:52PM THE REMAINING UNITS FACE AN INTERIOR WALKWAY AND ROAD.
5:22:57PM AS YOU HEARD FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSION, IT WAS FOUND TO
5:23:02PM BE COMPATIBLE AND CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN.
5:23:06PM THE 35 FEET IN HEIGHT I THINK WHEN THE STAFF IS TALKING
5:23:10PM ABOUT THREE STORIES, THEY SHOULD BE TALKING ABOUT THE
5:23:13PM HEIGHT, WHICH IS THE SAME AS SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL.
5:23:17PM SO I DON'T KNOW THAT YOU COULD GET FOUR STORIES OR I DON'T
5:23:20PM KNOW THAT YOU COULD GET MORE, BUT THE ISSUE IS, WHAT IS THE
5:23:25PM MAXIMUM HEIGHT, AND IT IS THE SAME AS SINGLE-FAMILY
5:23:27PM RESIDENTIAL.
5:23:30PM WITH RESPECT TO PROMOTING THE EFFICIENT AND SUSTAINABLE USE
5:23:33PM OF THE LAND AND THE INFRASTRUCTURE, IT WAS FOUND TO BE
5:23:36PM CONSISTENT.
5:23:38PM WITH RESPECT TO ENCOURAGING FLEXIBLE LAND DEVELOPMENT, IT
5:23:42PM REDUCES TRANSPORTATION NEEDS, IT WAS FOUND TO BE CONSISTENT.
5:23:44PM IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT IT'S ONLY TWO BLOCKS AWAY FROM A
5:23:49PM TRANSIT CORRIDOR, WHICH COUNCIL IN THE PAST HAS SAID WE WANT
5:23:53PM TO ENCOURAGE AND FIND HIGHER DENSITY CLOSE TO AND ON THESE
5:23:58PM TRANSIT CORRIDORS.
5:23:59PM TO PROMOTE AND ENCOURAGE DEVELOPMENT WHERE APPROPRIATE IN
5:24:05PM LOCATION, IT HAS BEEN FOUND TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THAT.
5:24:07PM WITH RESPECT TO PROMOTING DESIRABLE LIVING AND WORKING
5:24:14PM CONDITIONS THROUGH THE APPLICATION OF MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS
5:24:17PM OF OTHER ZONING DISTRICTS, IT IS A WORKING-CLASS AREA THAT
5:24:22PM WOULD PROVIDE ADDITIONAL HOUSING.
5:24:24PM AND COUNCIL AGAIN HAS GONE ON RECORD AS SAYING WE NEED
5:24:27PM HOUSING.
5:24:28PM THIS PROPOSAL IS REQUESTING THE ONE ADDITIONAL UNIT.
5:24:32PM IT'S NOT A HUGE PROJECT.
5:24:34PM IT'S A RELATIVELY SMALL AND MODERATE PROJECT.
5:24:37PM PROMOTE THE ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES AND ELEMENTS.
5:24:39PM I HAVE SOME COLORED ELEVATIONS TO SHARE WITH YOU TO SHOW
5:24:48PM THAT IT DOES MEET WITH THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY DISTRICT WITH
5:24:52PM A ROOF PITCH.
5:24:53PM PREVIOUSLY WE HAD FLAT ROOFS AND SOME OTHER THINGS LIKE
5:24:57PM THAT, BUT THEY WERE REMOVED AND, AGAIN, THIS WAS AS A RESULT
5:25:01PM OF DISCUSSIONS WITH THE STAFF, AND WE WENT BACK AND HAD AN
5:25:05PM ADDITIONAL DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMITTEE AND REVISED THE SITE
5:25:08PM PLAN.
5:25:09PM THE DESIGN CRITERIA IS A PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT AND UNIQUE AND
5:25:14PM THEREFORE IN NEED OF WAIVERS.
5:25:16PM THE WAIVER WE'RE REQUESTING IS THE ORIENTATION OF THE DOORS,
5:25:20PM WHICH YOU FOUND FREQUENTLY YOU CAN'T HAVE ALL OF THESE UNITS
5:25:24PM FACING THE SIDE STREET.
5:25:28PM WHEN WE TRIED TO ORIENT ALL OF THE UNITS TOWARD NORTH B, WE
5:25:34PM RAN INTO SOME CONSISTENCY PROBLEMS REGARDING THE USE OF THE
5:25:37PM ALLEY AND THE ACCESS.
5:25:38PM THE WAIVER IF ALLOWED WOULD SUBSTANTIALLY NOT INTERFERE AND
5:25:42PM INJURE THE RIGHTS OF OTHER.
5:25:44PM THE INTERIOR ACCESS FOR THE DOORWAYS DOES NOT INJURE OR
5:25:49PM AFFECT ANY OTHER ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNER.
5:25:52PM THAT'S AN INTERNAL ISSUE THAT ONLY AFFECTS THE RESIDENTS OF
5:25:56PM THIS UNIT OR THESE UNITS.
5:25:57PM THE WAIVER IS IN HARMONY WITH AND SERVES THE GENERAL INTENT
5:26:02PM AND PURPOSES OF THE CHAPTER.
5:26:03PM I DON'T THINK THE CHAPTER WAS INTENDED TO STOP ALL TYPES OF
5:26:06PM DEVELOPMENT JUST BECAUSE THE DOORWAYS DIDN'T FACE NORTH B
5:26:10PM STREET OR ANY OTHER STREET.
5:26:12PM ALLOWING THE WAIVER WILL RESULT IN SUBSTANTIAL JUSTICE BEING
5:26:15PM DONE AND ALLOW A MODERATE DENSE DEVELOPMENT TO MOVE FORWARD
5:26:21PM WITH THE ISSUE REGARDING THE WAIVER OF THE DOORWAYS AND THE
5:26:25PM ORIENTATION.
5:26:25PM I'LL DRAW YOUR ATTENTION TO SEVERAL OF THE COMMENTS MADE BY
5:26:30PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION THAT INCLUDE THAT YOU COULD BUILD,
5:26:34PM FIRST OF ALL, YOU COULD BUILD SEVEN UNITS BY RIGHT.
5:26:38PM THE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OF THE TAMPA
5:26:41PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN TO CREATE INSPIRED URBAN DESIGN AND
5:26:44PM LIVING CONDITIONS WITH THE HUMAN SCALE.
5:26:48PM AGAIN, THE HEIGHT IS 35 FEET.
5:26:52PM THAT IS WHAT SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SCALE IS.
5:26:58PM REGULATE THE LEVEL OF BUILDING INTENSITY AND ACCORDING TO
5:27:00PM THE STANDARDS.
5:27:01PM THE STANDARDS ARE AFFECTED BY THE LAND USE DESIGNATION,
5:27:04PM WHICH IS RESIDENTIAL 20, AND WE ARE BELOW THAT REQUESTED
5:27:08PM RESIDENTIAL 20 DENSITY.
5:27:10PM GRANTED, WE HAVE TO HAVE A DENSITY BONUS OF ONE UNIT TO GET
5:27:15PM THERE.
5:27:15PM HOWEVER, IT'S STILL BELOW THE MAXIMUM DENSITY THAT'S
5:27:18PM ALLOWED.
5:27:18PM ENCOURAGE COMPACT HIGHER DENSITY DEVELOPMENT THAT IS
5:27:23PM COMPATIBLE WITH THE SURROUNDING CHARACTER.
5:27:25PM DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET AND SURROUNDING THIS ARE OTHER
5:27:28PM MULTIFAMILY PROJECTS AND COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES TO THE SOUTH
5:27:33PM AND ALSO TO THE EAST.
5:27:35PM THE USE OF LIMITED LAND RESOURCES MORE EFFECTIVELY PURSUE
5:27:39PM THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN THAT IS ECONOMICALLY SOUND AND
5:27:44PM ENCOURAGED BY INFILL DEVELOPMENT.
5:27:46PM THIS PROJECT COMPLIES WITH THAT REQUEST TO PROVIDE ADEQUATE
5:27:50PM INFILL DEVELOPMENT.
5:27:51PM SUPPORT THE URBAN VILLAGE DESIGNATIONS THAT PRODUCE A
5:27:57PM DISTINCTIVE HIGH-QUALITY BUILT ENVIRONMENT.
5:28:00PM THIS WILL UTILIZE THE EXISTING INFRASTRUCTURE, AND IT WILL
5:28:04PM PROVIDE FOR ADDITIONAL UNITS THERE FOR LIVING.
5:28:09PM THE URBAN VILLAGE IS CONTAINED MOST OF THE FOLLOWING USES
5:28:12PM WHICH ARE TYPICALLY MADE UP AND CONSIDERED TRADITIONAL
5:28:15PM LIVABLE COMMUNITY, SINGLE AND MULTIFAMILY RESIDENTIAL
5:28:18PM NEIGHBORHOODS SERVING COMMERCIAL, SCHOOLS, PARKS, AND
5:28:21PM CENTRAL GATHERING PLACES, MASS TRANSIT, SAFE, WALKABLE
5:28:25PM PATHWAYS THAT CONNECT PEOPLE TO AREAS OF THE VILLAGE.
5:28:28PM THIS SITE DOES ALL OF THOSE THINGS.
5:28:30PM AND, AGAIN, THESE ARE THE FINDINGS THAT ARE FROM YOUR
5:28:33PM PROFESSIONAL PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
5:28:34PM ENSURE THAT THE DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS IN THE URBAN VILLAGES
5:28:37PM ARE DESIGNED FOR PEDESTRIAN TRAFFIC AND CONNECT TO THE
5:28:40PM CITYWIDE TRANSIT.
5:28:42PM THIS CONNECTS TO THE EXISTING AND PROPOSED SIDEWALKS THAT
5:28:45PM WILL HAVE TO BE DEVELOPED.
5:28:46PM THESE ARE ON-SITE SIDEWALKS AND THE CONNECTIONS THAT IT WILL
5:28:51PM HAVE TO MAKE SO THAT INDIVIDUALS CAN ACCESS KENNEDY
5:28:55PM BOULEVARD IN PARTICULAR.
5:28:56PM DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS IN THE URBAN VILLAGE MUST BE ORIENTED
5:29:01PM AND INTEGRATED IN SCALE WITH THE SURROUNDING COMMUNITY.
5:29:04PM AGAIN, SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL IS ALLOWED TO BE 35 FEET IN
5:29:07PM HEIGHT.
5:29:07PM WE'RE NOT ASKING FOR ADDITIONAL HEIGHT, AND THIS WOULD BE 35
5:29:11PM FEET IN HEIGHT.
5:29:12PM OBJECTIVE -- AN EXISTING FUTURE LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATION
5:29:17PM SHALL BE CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
5:29:19PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF HAS FOUND THAT IT IS
5:29:22PM CONSISTENT.
5:29:23PM DEVELOPMENT SHALL NOT EXCEED THE DENSITIES AND INTENSITIES.
5:29:26PM AGAIN, THIS DOES NOT -- IT'S BELOW THE R-20 OF THE
5:29:29PM DESIGNATION.
5:29:29PM EACH LAND USE CATEGORY SHALL BE UNIQUE SET OF ZONING
5:29:33PM DISTRICTS THAT MAY BE PERMITTED.
5:29:36PM THIS IS ALLOWABLE UNDER THE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
5:29:39PM COMPATIBLE DEVELOPMENT AND REDEVELOPMENT TO SUSTAIN STABLE
5:29:45PM NEIGHBORHOODS.
5:29:45PM THIS WILL NOT DISRUPT THAT NEIGHBORHOOD IN ANY RESPECT.
5:29:48PM IT IS THE INTENT OF THE CITY FOR NEW RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
5:29:53PM PROJECTS SHALL BE MINIMALLY DISRUPTIVE.
5:29:55PM IT'S DIFFICULT TO SEE IF YOU HAVE DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET
5:29:58PM TOWN HOUSES WITH FRONT DRIVEWAYS THAT ARE NOT ALLEY ACCESS,
5:30:02PM THAT THE STAFF SHOWED YOU A PICTURE OF.
5:30:04PM THIS WOULD BE DISRUPTIVE WHEN YOU'RE SHOWING THE ACCESS VIA
5:30:07PM THE ALLEY.
5:30:08PM ACCOMMODATE THE GREATEST CONCENTRATION OF HOUSING AND
5:30:12PM DESIRABLE PEDESTRIAN ORIENTED URBAN AREAS HAVING CONVENIENT
5:30:16PM ACCESS TO LOCAL AND REGIONAL TRANSIT.
5:30:19PM THIS IS ALSO CONVENIENTLY LOCATED AND ACCESSIBLE TO THOSE
5:30:22PM REGIONAL TRANSIT AREAS.
5:30:25PM ENCOURAGE HIGHER DENSITY MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT AND
5:30:27PM PEDESTRIAN ORIENTED URBAN AREAS.
5:30:30PM ENCOURAGE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT IN MEDIUM AND LARGE SCALE WITH
5:30:33PM HEIGHTS GREATER THAN THOSE IN THE LOW-RISE AREA.
5:30:35PM ALTHOUGH THE SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES CAN GO UP TO 35 FEET,
5:30:40PM THEY MAY NOT BE, BUT THIS DOES NOT EXCEED THE HEIGHT
5:30:44PM REGULATIONS AS PROVIDED FOR SINGLE-FAMILY.
5:30:46PM ACCOMMODATE LARGER SCALE STRUCTURES WHILE MAINTAINING
5:30:50PM LIVEABILITY OF THE COMMUNITIES, INCLUDING MEASURES WHICH
5:30:52PM MINIMIZE THE APPEARANCE OR BOTH.
5:30:55PM AND YOU CAN SEE THIS IS VERY SIMILAR TO WHAT YOU HAVE
5:30:59PM DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET IF YOU REFER BACK TO THE
5:31:02PM PHOTOGRAPH THAT I HAVE ON THE OVERHEAD.
5:31:03PM PROMOTE HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT IN BUSINESS
5:31:08PM CENTERS AND URBAN VILLAGES.
5:31:10PM IT DOES THAT, AND IT IS CONSISTENT WITH THAT OBJECTIVE.
5:31:13PM ENSURE THAT ADEQUATE SUPPLY OF HOUSING IS AVAILABLE.
5:31:16PM DESIGNATE SUFFICIENT LAND FOR RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT TO
5:31:20PM ACCOMMODATE THE SHARE AND THE NEED FOR INCREASING DEMAND FOR
5:31:24PM HOUSING.
5:31:25PM CONTINUE TO MONITOR RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT TO ENSURE THAT
5:31:28PM ADEQUATE SITES ARE THERE TO ACCOMMODATE THAT NEED.
5:31:30PM ENCOURAGE THE NEW HOUSING ON VACANT LAND AND INFILL.
5:31:35PM IT DOES ALL OF THAT.
5:31:36PM CONTINUE TO COORDINATE AN ORDERLY PROVISION OF PUBLIC
5:31:40PM FACILITIES, AND THIS RELIES ON THE PUBLIC FACILITIES THAT
5:31:43PM ARE THERE, IF THEY ARE FOUND TO BE INSUFFICIENT, THEN THE
5:31:47PM DEVELOPMENT WILL HAVE TO PAY FOR AND UPGRADE THE FACILITIES
5:31:50PM INCLUDING WATER, SEWER -- I GUESS I GOT A COMMENT THERE.
5:31:56PM [ LAUGHTER ]
5:31:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THEY WERE NOT SWORN IN.
5:32:00PM CAN'T ADMIT THAT TO THE RECORD.
5:32:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IT'S BEEN A RUNNING COMMENT, BY THE WAY,
5:32:03PM MR. MICHELINI.
5:32:05PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: I UNDERSTAND.
5:32:06PM CONTINUE TO MONITOR AND ENCOURAGE NEW HOUSING, GOALS AND
5:32:08PM OBJECTIVES TO THE PROVISION OF PUBLIC FACILITIES AS I
5:32:13PM ALREADY SAID.
5:32:13PM PROMOTE THE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT PATTERN CONSISTENT WITH
5:32:15PM THE REST OF THE CITY.
5:32:16PM I DON'T SEE HOW YOU CAN FIND THIS INCONSISTENT WHEN THERE
5:32:20PM ARE PROPERTIES ALL AROUND THIS THAT ARE VERY SIMILAR SIZE,
5:32:23PM SCALE, AND ARE FOUND TO BE COMPATIBLE.
5:32:27PM A STREET IS CONSISTENT WITH THE DENSITY OF ANTICIPATED PLAN
5:32:31PM UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL 20 DESIGNATION.
5:32:33PM THE REQUEST WILL PROVIDE MORE INFILL DEVELOPMENT ON THE SITE
5:32:37PM AND DESIGNATION PRESENTLY UTILIZED UNDER LAND USE POLICIES
5:32:41PM 1.26, 2.11, 2.12, 5.11, 5.14, 9.38, AND THE REQUEST IS
5:32:51PM CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY'S POLICY AND THEIR GOALS AND
5:32:54PM OBJECTIVES WITH COMPACT CITY STRATEGY THAT ENCOURAGES AND
5:32:59PM PROMOTES HOUSING DENSITIES.
5:33:01PM MOVING FORWARD, AS YOU ALL KNOW, THE CITY IS FACING A
5:33:10PM HOUSING PROBLEM AND PROVIDING ADDITIONAL UNITS THAT GO
5:33:15PM TOWARD MEETING THE SPIRIT OF THE CODE IS REALLY THE
5:33:18PM DIRECTION, AT LEAST THAT'S WHAT I'VE HEARD FROM THE COUNCIL
5:33:22PM IN THE PAST, WHAT YOU WANT IS TO MEET AS MANY OF THOSE AS
5:33:26PM YOU CAN.
5:33:26PM LET ME JUST RUN THROUGH THE THINGS THAT WE'VE CHANGED SINCE
5:33:31PM THE FIRST SITE PLAN WAS SUBMITTED.
5:33:33PM WE MOVED THE FRONT SETBACK BACK TO MEET THE FRONT AVERAGE ON
5:33:39PM NORTH B STREET.
5:33:40PM CHANGED THE SIDE YARD SETBACK FROM 7 TO 5 FEET TO MEET THE
5:33:43PM OVERLAY DISTRICT REQUIREMENTS AND STANDARDS.
5:33:45PM REMOVE THE ROOFTOP PATIOS AND LOWER THE MAXIMUM BUILDING
5:33:48PM HEIGHT TO 35 FEET.
5:33:49PM CHANGE THE ROOF FROM A FLAT ROOF TO A 4/12 PITCH MEETING THE
5:33:54PM OVERLAY DISTRICT DESIGN STANDARDS.
5:33:56PM REMOVE THE DRIVEWAY ACCESS FROM NORTH B SO THAT THE ALLEY
5:33:59PM ACCESS IS THE ONLY ONE PROVIDED.
5:34:02PM REPLACE PREVIOUSLY PAVED AREAS WITH VEHICLE ACCESS ON NORTH
5:34:05PM B AND EXCHANGE THAT FOR GREENSPACE.
5:34:08PM DRIVEWAYS BETWEEN BUILDINGS TWO AND THREE -- SORRY, BETWEEN
5:34:12PM THE TWO BUILDINGS, WIDER AND ADDED SIDEWALKS CONNECTING ALL
5:34:15PM UNITS TO THE SIDEWALK ORIENTED TOWARD NORTH B STREET.
5:34:19PM REDESIGN THE FLOOR PLAN TO CHANGE THE FRONT DOOR ENTRANCES
5:34:22PM ON THE TWO UNITS FACING NORTH B STREET SO THAT THEY ARE TRUE
5:34:27PM FRONT DOORS AND NOT FAKE DOORS.
5:34:29PM ADDED FRONT PORCHES TO THE FRONT TWO FACING NORTH B IN ORDER
5:34:33PM TO HAVE IT MORE AESTHETICALLY PLEASING, INCREASE THE FLOOR
5:34:38PM -- TO 24 INCHES ABOVE GRADE, THE FINISHED FLOOR ELEVATION.
5:34:43PM AND TO COMPLY WITH THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY DESIGN STANDARDS.
5:34:46PM ADDED TWO VISITOR PARKING SPACES AMOUNTING TO DOUBLE THE
5:34:51PM PARKING REQUIREMENTS THAT ARE PROVIDED FOR IN THE CODE.
5:34:54PM REDESIGN THE ELEVATIONS FROM CONTEMPORARY AESTHETIC AND
5:34:57PM MODERN FARMHOUSE TO BETTER MATCH THE CHARACTER OF THE
5:35:00PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:35:00PM I BELIEVE THAT WE HAVE GONE A LONG WAY TOWARD TRYING TO MEET
5:35:05PM ALL OF THE PROVISIONS IN THE CODE.
5:35:07PM WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL.
5:35:10PM I WOULD BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE.
5:35:12PM WE HAVE ENDEAVORED TO ADDRESS ALL OF THE ISSUES THAT WERE
5:35:15PM RAISED WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THE DENSITY ISSUE AND THE FRONT
5:35:18PM DOORS THAT ANYONE HAS DISCUSSED WITH US.
5:35:20PM I'D APPRECIATE YOUR CONCERN OR ANY COMMENTS YOU MIGHT HAVE
5:35:25PM AND RESERVE MY TIME FOR REBUTTAL.
5:35:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FROM THE COUNCIL MEMBERS?
5:35:34PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: DO YOU HAVE THE OTHER ELEVATIONS FROM THE
5:35:36PM ALLEY SIDE?
5:35:37PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: ACROSS THE STREET?
5:35:39PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: NO.
5:35:40PM FOR THESE TWO BUILDINGS.
5:35:40PM WHAT ABOUT FROM THE ALLEY PERSPECTIVE?
5:35:49PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THAT'S FROM THE ALLEY.
5:35:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SO THE UNITS -- THAT DRIVEWAY IS
5:35:56PM ACCESSIBLE FROM THE ALLEY, CORRECT?
5:35:57PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: YES, SIR.
5:35:59PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OKAY, GOOD.
5:36:02PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THIS IS THE NORTH B ELEVATION.
5:36:03PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I'VE GOT THAT.
5:36:05PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: SHOWING THE DOOR.
5:36:06PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WITH EUCLIDEAN -- SO YOU SAID IN AN EFFORT
5:36:10PM TO ACCOMMODATE PROBABLY THE WIDER DRIVE IN THE MIDDLE, WHICH
5:36:13PM IS GOOD, YOU MOVED THE SIDE YARD SETBACKS FROM -- IS THAT
5:36:17PM WHY YOU MOVED THEM FROM 7 TO 5?
5:36:19PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY IS 5 FEET.
5:36:21PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: 5 FEET, OKAY.
5:36:23PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: SO WE HAD A WIDER SIDE YARD SETBACK, IS
5:36:27PM BUT BY MOVING THE BUILDINGS BACK FOR THE DRIVEWAY, WE GAINED
5:36:32PM A COUPLE OF FEET AND MADE IT WIDER SO YOU COULD MAKE THE
5:36:36PM TURN EASIER OFF OF THE ALLEY.
5:36:37PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OKAY.
5:36:39PM AND SO WILL THESE ELEVATIONS BE SUBMITTED WITH THE SITE PLAN
5:36:43PM MAYBE AS A COUNCIL CONDITION THAT THIS IS BUILT THE WAY IT'S
5:36:46PM DISPLAYED, YOU KNOW, AT LEAST SUBSTANTIALLY THE WAY IT'S
5:36:49PM DISPLAYED.
5:36:50PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: YES, SIR.
5:36:51PM WE'VE MADE THIS PART OF THE RECORD.
5:36:52PM THE ONLY DIFFERENCE WAS THE OTHER ELEVATIONS WEREN'T IN
5:36:55PM COLOR.
5:36:56PM BUT I'LL BE HAPPY TO INCLUDE THIS AS PART OF OUR PACKAGE.
5:37:00PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YEAH, OKAY.
5:37:01PM VERY GOOD.
5:37:02PM OKAY.
5:37:02PM THANK YOU.
5:37:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
5:37:03PM IF NOT, WE'LL GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT.
5:37:05PM ALL RIGHT.
5:37:05PM LET'S GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT.
5:37:07PM IF YOU ARE HERE TO SPEAK, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:37:09PM YOU'LL HAVE THREE MINUTES.
5:37:10PM YES, MA'AM.
5:37:43PM >> BEFORE I START, I WAS JUST ASKING, MAY WE USE THOSE TWO
5:37:48PM ELEVATIONS THAT MR. MICHELINI JUST PRESENTED?
5:37:50PM BECAUSE THEY WEREN'T IN THE RECORD.
5:37:53PM BUT THEY APPARENTLY ARE GOING TO BE PART OF THE RECORD.
5:37:56PM SO MAY WE BORROW THEM OR IS THAT NOT ALLOWED?
5:38:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. MICHELINI, CAN YOU CLARIFY?
5:38:07PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: YES, SIR.
5:38:07PM THEY ARE IN THE RECORD.
5:38:08PM THEY ARE JUST NOT COLOR.
5:38:10PM I'LL BE HAPPY TO ALLOW THEM TO USE THEM.
5:38:13PM >> THANK YOU.
5:38:23PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: CAN I STAND HERE AND HELP YOU?
5:38:25PM >> I THINK I WILL BE FINE.
5:38:26PM THANK YOU.
5:38:26PM BUT I APPRECIATE THE OFFER.
5:38:34PM >> [INAUDIBLE]
5:38:36PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: DELPHINE JONES.
5:38:42PM AND JEROME ADCOCK.
5:38:46PM THANK YOU.
5:38:47PM TWO ADDITIONAL MINUTES, PLEASE.
5:38:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:38:50PM YOU HAVE FIVE MINUTES TOTAL.
5:38:51PM YES, MA'AM.
5:38:52PM >> THANK YOU SO MUCH.
5:38:54PM DEBBIE ZOMERMAAND, 192 CORSICA STREET, AND I'VE BEEN SWORN.
5:39:04PM BY WAY OF BACKGROUND, I THINK SOME OF THE -- NOT OLDER
5:39:07PM COUNCIL MEMBERS, BUT COUNCIL MEMBERS THAT HAVE BEEN ON THE
5:39:08PM BOARD FOR LONGER PERIODS OF TIME MAYBE FAMILIAR WITH MY
5:39:12PM BACKGROUND.
5:39:13PM BUT BY WAY OF BACKGROUND, I MOVED TO FLORIDA IN 1993.
5:39:16PM I'VE BEEN IN THE AREA OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING FINANCE FROM A
5:39:19PM MUNICIPAL LEVEL OR AN INVESTMENT BANKING LEVEL FOR MY ENTIRE
5:39:24PM CAREER IN FLORIDA.
5:39:25PM BONNIE WISE, WHICH MANY OF YOU KNOW, WAS MY CONTEMPORARY.
5:39:28PM I'M WITH RBC CAPITAL MARKET.
5:39:31PM SHE WAS WILLIAM R. HOUGH.
5:39:33PM I HAVE A SIMILAR STARTING BACKGROUND AS MS. WISE.
5:39:36PM IN TEXAS, WHERE I MOVED FROM, I WAS IN INVESTMENT BANKING
5:39:39PM AND TRADITIONAL BANKING IN THE REAL ESTATE BANKING GROUP
5:39:42PM DATING BACK TO 1980.
5:39:44PM SO THIS HAS BEEN MY CAREER.
5:39:46PM IT'S WHAT I DO EVERY DAY.
5:39:48PM I'M IN MY 20th YEAR OF A MAJOR LARGE COUNTY HOUSING
5:39:51PM FINANCE AUTHORITY.
5:39:52PM I'M THEIR MUNICIPAL FINANCIAL ADVISOR, SO I LOOK AT THIS
5:39:56PM TYPE OF STUFF ALL DAY, EVERY DAY.
5:39:59PM WITH REGARDS TO THE PACKAGE THAT I HANDED OUT TO YOU, I
5:40:02PM WON'T GO INTO A LOT OF DETAIL BETWEEN ITEMS 1 AND 2.
5:40:08PM THEY ARE PROVIDED AS BACKGROUND TO DEMONSTRATE BASIC
5:40:11PM FINDINGS AND FACTS.
5:40:14PM TAB 1, I THINK LaCHONE DOCK EXPLAINED THAT VERY CLEARLY.
5:40:17PM THERE'S SIGNIFICANT BASIS FOR THE INCONSISTENT FINDING IN
5:40:20PM THE STAFF REPORT, AND TAB 2 IS VERY IMPORTANT BECAUSE IT'S
5:40:24PM VERY CLEAR THAT THIS IS A TOWNHOME-STYLE DEVELOPMENT.
5:40:28PM AND I'LL GET INTO WHY THAT MATTERS IN JUST A MINUTE.
5:40:31PM THE INTENT OF MY PRESENTATION IS TO DEMONSTRATE FACTS, NOT
5:40:37PM OPINIONS.
5:40:38PM WE ALSO ARE DEMONSTRATING THE FACTS ON THIS SITE, NOT ANY
5:40:42PM OTHER SITES AROUND IT, BECAUSE AS WE TALK ABOUT ALL THE
5:40:44PM TIME, THIS ZONING REQUEST PERTAINS TO THIS SITE AND WE DON'T
5:40:49PM KNOW THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE OTHER SITE SO THAT SHOULD BE
5:40:51PM IRRELEVANT INFORMATION.
5:40:53PM SO NOW WHAT I'D LIKE TO DO IS GO INTO THE TAB 3, WHICH IS
5:41:00PM THE BONUS PROVISION SECTION, AND START ADDRESSING SOME
5:41:05PM ISSUES.
5:41:06PM AND ACTUALLY, AS I -- AND I'M GOING TO LEAVE THIS PICTURE UP
5:41:10PM HERE.
5:41:10PM WHEN I'M TALKING AND WHEN YOU'RE LOOKING AT THIS PICTURE,
5:41:14PM KEEP IN MIND THAT THESE PEDESTRIAN WALKWAYS ARE RIGHT IN
5:41:17PM FRONT OF THE GARAGES.
5:41:19PM SO WE SEE THE BEAUTIFUL CHILDREN IN THE BACK.
5:41:22PM IF THEY WANTED TO GO NEXT DOOR AND VISIT THEIR FRIEND,
5:41:26PM PRESUMABLY THIS IS A PEDESTRIAN WALKWAY, THE PEDESTRIAN
5:41:29PM CHILDREN WOULD WALK ON IT AND THERE ARE GARAGE DOORS
5:41:31PM IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO THE WALKWAYS.
5:41:33PM SOMETHING AS SIMPLE AS THAT IS A BASIC FINDING OF POTENTIAL
5:41:37PM SAFETY CONCERNS THAT ARE, AS A GRANDMOTHER AND A MOTHER OF
5:41:40PM THREE CHILDREN, FIVE GRANDCHILDREN, I FIND ARE SIGNIFICANT
5:41:44PM BECAUSE A CHILD COULD GET HURT BECAUSE YOU WON'T BE ABLE TO
5:41:47PM SEE THEM WHEN YOU'RE BACKING OUT OF YOUR GARAGE.
5:41:50PM BUT BACK TO THE BONUS PROVISIONS, WHAT I HAVE HERE -- IS
5:41:56PM THAT THE RIGHT --
5:41:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: UPSIDE DOWN.
5:41:59PM >> OKAY.
5:41:59PM I TEND TO DO THAT ALL THE TIME.
5:42:01PM THE CODE HAS SOME VERY SPECIFIC PROVISIONS -- I'M SORRY.
5:42:06PM I DID THE WRONG ONE.
5:42:07PM MY APOLOGIES.
5:42:08PM THIS ONE IS WHAT I WANT.
5:42:10PM THE CODE HAS VERY SPECIFIC PROVISIONS WITH REGARDS TO THE
5:42:17PM BONUS PROVISIONS.
5:42:18PM WITH THIS REQUEST, YOU HAVE KIND OF A CHICKEN AND AN EGG.
5:42:25PM THE PD HAS 8 UNITS.
5:42:27PM IF YOU DON'T HAVE THE BONUS PROVISION, THE PD WON'T BE ABLE
5:42:30PM TO BE BUILT.
5:42:32PM THE BONUS PROVISION HAS ISSUES THAT ARE QUITE SIGNIFICANT,
5:42:35PM AND IF YOU DON'T HAVE THE BONUS PROVISIONS, YOU KNOW, BOTH
5:42:37PM OF THEM HAVE TO COME IN TANDEM.
5:42:39PM AND THE BONUS PROVISIONS, PER THIS PROCESS, WILL BE
5:42:44PM ADDRESSED AFTER THIS FIRST READING IF THE PD IS APPROVED.
5:42:47PM I THINK IT NEEDS TO BE VERY CLEAR THAT THERE'S NO
5:42:50PM INSINUATION OR ANY KIND OF DEMONSTRATED PRECEDENT THAT THESE
5:42:57PM BONUS PROVISIONS WILL GO THROUGH.
5:42:59PM AND, IN FACT, THE CODE SAYS THIS SECTION, HOWEVER, DOES NOT
5:43:02PM MANDATE THE AWARD OF A BONUS PROVISION.
5:43:04PM SO WITH A PD, YOU'RE DOING A WORK-AROUND OF THE CODE, AND
5:43:10PM YOU'RE ALSO CREATING A MECHANISM TO GET A BONUS PROVISION
5:43:13PM THAT YOU WOULD NOT GET IF THIS WAS AN RM 16.
5:43:16PM BECAUSE IF YOU LOOK UP HERE, IT SAYS THAT COMPLIANCE ALL NEW
5:43:22PM DEVELOPMENTS REQUESTING, AND THEY HAVE SEVERAL DEVELOPMENT
5:43:24PM OR ZONING CATEGORIES, ONE OF WHICH IS A PD.
5:43:27PM THERE'S NO RM 16 IN THERE.
5:43:29PM SO YOU WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO GET THE EXTRA UNIT WITH AN RM
5:43:32PM 16.
5:43:33PM I BETTER GET QUICK.
5:43:36PM PLEASE LOOK AT THE CODE -- I THOUGHT I HAD MORE TIME -- AND
5:43:41PM YOU WILL -- DO NOT HAVE VESTED RIGHTS IN THE BONUS
5:43:44PM PROVISION.
5:43:44PM THAT'S TERRIBLE.
5:43:45PM AND THE CODE DOES NOT -- THE PLAN DOES NOT MEET THE
5:43:48PM REQUIREMENTS OF A TOWNHOME DEVELOPMENT.
5:43:50PM SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED, YOU CAN HAVE TWO CATEGORIES, ONE IS
5:43:52PM TOWN HOUSE AND ONE IS CONDOMINIUM.
5:43:54PM THIS DOES NOT IDENTIFY THE SINGLE -- THE INDIVIDUAL LOTS FOR
5:43:58PM A TOWNHOME, AND THAT WOULD BE IN TAB -- WAIT, SORRY.
5:44:06PM THE TIME WENT BY SO QUICKLY.
5:44:08PM I'M SORRY.
5:44:08PM THAT IS IN -- 27 -- IT'S IN THE EARLIER ONE, SORRY.
5:44:21PM 27-282-9.
5:44:24PM SECTION B-1.
5:44:26PM WHEN YOU BUILD THESE, YOU GET ONE OR THE OTHER.
5:44:28PM I'M SORRY I RAN OVER AND I'M AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS IF
5:44:33PM YOU HAVE THEM.
5:44:33PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
5:44:34PM NEXT SPEAKER.
5:44:47PM >> FIVE MINUTES?
5:44:48PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I'M TOLD YOU DID.
5:45:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THREE MINUTES.
5:45:13PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME AND GO AHEAD.
5:45:15PM >> HI.
5:45:16PM MY NAME IS CARROLL ANN BENNETT.
5:45:17PM I'D LIKE TO DIRECT YOUR ATTENTION TO THE LAST CITY STAFF
5:45:20PM REPORT THAT WAS SUBMITTED ON 8/14.
5:45:22PM WITH ALL THESE INCONSISTENCIES, I DON'T KNOW HOW COUNCIL CAN
5:45:25PM APPROVE THIS PD.
5:45:26PM THE CITY STAFF FINDS THE PROPOSED PLAN INCONSISTENT SAYING
5:45:32PM IT IS INCOMPATIBLE WITH THE SURROUNDING COMMUNITY.
5:45:35PM CITY STAFF CITED THE FACT THAT THE FRONT DOORS DO NOT MEET
5:45:38PM THE REQUIRED STANDARD.
5:45:40PM STAFF FINDS THIS PD IS OUT OF CHARACTER WITH THE SURROUNDING
5:45:44PM COMMUNITY.
5:45:44PM THE REPORT STATES THESE THREE-STORY STRUCTURES ARE
5:45:48PM INCOMPATIBLE WITH THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT AND THAT THE
5:45:50PM PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT OF 8 UNITS IS NOT APPROPRIATE IN A
5:45:53PM LOCATION WITH SURROUNDING PARCELS THAT CONTAIN ONE OR TWO
5:45:56PM UNITS.
5:45:56PM THEY ALSO SAY THE PROPOSED SCALE OF THREE STORIES IS OUT OF
5:45:59PM CHARACTER WITH THE SURROUNDING AREA.
5:46:01PM WHAT IS INTERESTING ABOUT THE REPORT FROM THE PLANNING
5:46:03PM COMMISSION, WHICH IS PAGE 2, AND AS YOU CAN SEE, THEY
5:46:06PM CORRECTED THE PROBLEM WITH THE ADDRESS, SO I MARKED OUT WHAT
5:46:09PM I'M NO LONGER GOING TO REFER TO, IS THAT IT IS IN DIRECT
5:46:14PM CONFLICT WITH THE CITY STAFF REPORT AND EVEN THE PLANNING
5:46:16PM COMMISSION'S OWN CITATIONS.
5:46:18PM THEY APPEAR TO IGNORE THE COMP PLAN WHICH STATES THE GUIDING
5:46:22PM PRINCIPLES TOWARD SHAPING THE CITY'S FUTURE INVOLVES
5:46:25PM STEERING GROWTH AND CHANGE TO SPECIFIC PARTS OF THE CITY
5:46:27PM WHILE STRENGTHENING AND PROTECTING OUR RESIDENTIAL
5:46:30PM NEIGHBORHOODS FROM DEVELOPMENT PRESSURES.
5:46:31PM LU POLICY 1.2.3 SAYS, RELATE NEW BUILDINGS AND DEVELOPMENT
5:46:36PM TO THE CONTEXT OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND COMMUNITY.
5:46:38PM THIS PZ DOES NOT DO THAT.
5:46:42PM LU POLICY 1.2.17 SAYS, ENSURE THAT THE ZONING CODE
5:46:45PM REINFORCES QUALITY URBAN DESIGN AS IT RELATES TO THE CONTEXT
5:46:49PM OF THE AREA.
5:46:49PM AGAIN, THIS PD DOES NOT DO THAT.
5:46:51PM THEY CITE LU POLICY 9.2.6, WHICH SAYS ENCOURAGE
5:46:57PM SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED AND MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENTS TO BE
5:47:00PM DESIGNED AND INCLUDE ORIENTATION OF THE FRONT DOOR TO A
5:47:03PM NEIGHBORHOOD SIDEWALK AND STREET.
5:47:05PM EVEN THOUGH 6 OF THE DOORS DO NOT MEET THIS CODE, THEY FIND
5:47:09PM IT CONSISTENT.
5:47:10PM THIS DESIGN HAS 8 ENTRANCES BUT ONLY TWO FACE THE STREET IN
5:47:15PM COMPLIANCE WITH LU 9.2.6.
5:47:17PM BUT THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF'S COMMENT ABOUT THE FRONT
5:47:20PM DOORS IS VERY CONFUSING.
5:47:22PM THE REPORT SAYS BOTH UNIT ENTRANCES ARE ORIENTED TOWARD AND
5:47:27PM CONNECT TO THE SIDEWALK ON WEST NORTH A STREET, BUT THERE
5:47:31PM ARE 8 DOORS, NOT 2.
5:47:34PM SO I'M CONFUSED ABOUT WHAT EXACTLY THEY MEAN BY BOTH UNIT
5:47:39PM ENTRANCES.
5:47:40PM IT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE.
5:47:41PM THIS PROJECT IS NOT COMPATIBLE WITH THE SURROUNDING AREA.
5:47:43PM THE CITY STAFF FINDS IT REPEATEDLY INCONSISTENT,
5:47:46PM INCOMPATIBLE, IN APPROPRIATE, AND OUT OF CHARACTER.
5:47:49PM PLEASE DENY THIS PD WITH ITS SUBSTANDARD SITE PLAN.
5:47:54PM SO THIS SITE CAN BE DEVELOPED WITH SOMETHING THE
5:47:56PM NEIGHBORHOOD CAN BE PROUD OF.
5:47:57PM THANK YOU.
5:47:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:47:58PM NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:48:02PM >> ADRIAN LARAMIE.
5:48:04PM I LIVE IN THE ARMORY GARDENS NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:48:06PM TODAY I AM HERE TO EXPRESS MY CONCERN ABOUT THE REQUEST TO
5:48:17PM THE REZONING OF THE PROPERTY AT 2406 WEST NORTH B STREET.
5:48:22PM APPLICATION NUMBER REZ-22-76.
5:48:25PM THE BUILDINGS THAT ARE BEING PLANNED FOR THIS ADDRESS WILL
5:48:28PM HAVE SOME SERIOUS IMPACTS ON THE ARMORY GARDEN NEIGHBORHOOD,
5:48:32PM THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD, AND THE BLOCK WHERE I LIVE.
5:48:34PM I LIVE AT THE END OF THE ALLEY, WHICH IS RIGHT HERE WHERE
5:48:39PM THE ALLEY WOULD BE ENDING UP ON TAMPANIA AVENUE.
5:48:42PM THE VEHICLE ACCESS TO THIS PROJECT WILL BE THE ALLEY.
5:48:48PM IT IS ESTIMATED THAT ONCE THIS IS PUT IN, THERE WILL BE
5:48:53PM APPROXIMATELY 46 CARS USING THE ALLEYWAY ON A DAILY BASIS.
5:48:58PM THAT WILL BE APPROXIMATELY 92 TRIPS GOING IN AND OUT OF THE
5:49:03PM ALLEY.
5:49:04PM THIS IS THE BACK OF THE HOUSE, AND THIS IS THE PROPERTY
5:49:11PM ACROSS THE ALLEY FROM WHERE THE PROPERTY IS.
5:49:16PM SHOWING A LITTLE BIT GOING DOWN THE ALLEY, THIS IS THE
5:49:20PM PROPERTY HERE, AND THIS IS THE ALLEY GOING TOWARDS ARMENIA
5:49:24PM AVENUE.
5:49:24PM WHEN YOU GET TO THE END HERE, THERE IS A DIP THAT GOES DOWN.
5:49:30PM REMEMBER THAT ARMENIA AVENUE IS 40 MILES AN HOUR, THE
5:49:33PM TRAFFIC GOING THROUGH THERE.
5:49:34PM SO THEY CAN ONLY TURN TO THE RIGHT.
5:49:36PM SO IT MEANS A LOT OF THE PEOPLE THAT GO -- GOING TOWARDS
5:49:40PM WEST OR NORTH WILL ACTUALLY GO OUT THE OPPOSITE END OF THE
5:49:44PM ALLEY.
5:49:45PM AND THIS IS A LITTLE BIT MORE INFORMATION ABOUT THE ALLEYWAY
5:49:48PM HERE GOING DOWN, AND THIS IS ON THE OPPOSITE SIDE OF ARMENIA
5:49:52PM AVENUE.
5:49:52PM NOW GOING TO THE OTHER DIRECTION AND THIS IS A GARAGE
5:49:57PM APARTMENT IN THE BACK OF THE PROPERTY, AND THIS IS THE ALLEY
5:50:00PM RIGHT HERE, AND THIS IS GOING WEST, AND THIS IS THE PROPERTY
5:50:03PM HERE.
5:50:03PM SO AS YOU GO THAT WAY, MOST OF THE PEOPLE EXITING THE
5:50:09PM PROJECT WILL BE GOING OUT THAT DIRECTION ON A DAILY BASIS.
5:50:12PM CURRENTLY, THERE ARE -- THERE ARE SEVERAL BUILDINGS THAT ARE
5:50:21PM EXITING ON THE PROPERTY.
5:50:22PM THERE ARE THREE PROPERTIES THAT HAVE TWO UNITS ON THE
5:50:27PM PROPERTY THAT ARE EXITING THAT AREA AS WELL, AND THOSE ARE
5:50:32PM NEW TOWN HOUSES.
5:50:33PM PLUS ADDITIONAL BUSINESSES ON THE FAR END TOWARDS ARMENIA
5:50:36PM THAT WILL BE USING THE EXIT.
5:50:38PM AND THEY WILL BE GOING OUT -- THEY CURRENTLY GO OUT BOTH
5:50:41PM DIRECTIONS, AND PARKING IS ALSO GOING TO BE AN ISSUE ON ALL
5:50:46PM THE STREETS, BECAUSE WHEN THEY ARE PARKING ON THE STREET,
5:50:50PM THERE'S ALSO THE DUMPSTERS THAT ARE GOING TO BE PUT OUT ON
5:50:53PM TUESDAYS AND FRIDAYS, SO THERE'S NO PARKING THERE BECAUSE
5:50:57PM EVERYONE HAS TO GET THEIR DUMPSTERS OUT THERE AS WELL.
5:50:59PM AND I JUST ASK YOU NOT TO PUT THIS PD INTO THE AREA BECAUSE
5:51:09PM IT'S DEFINITELY GOING TO MAKE AN OVERFLOW OF TRAFFIC ONTO
5:51:12PM THE ALLEYWAY, WHICH IS DANGEROUS FOR EVERYBODY, AND MY HOUSE
5:51:17PM IS RIGHT ON THE END OF IT.
5:51:18PM THANK YOU SO MUCH.
5:51:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:51:20PM NEXT SPEAKER.
5:51:21PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:51:22PM YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
5:51:24PM >> GOOD EVENING, CITY COUNCIL.
5:51:25PM MY NAME IS DENNIS CRAIG.
5:51:27PM I REPRESENT THRIFTY RENTS.
5:51:30PM THE OWNER WAS UNABLE TO MAKE THIS BECAUSE OF SICKNESS, SO HE
5:51:35PM ASKED ME TO FILL IN.
5:51:36PM NOW, I HAVE PRESENTLY RENTED AT 208 NORTH ARMENIA, WHICH IS
5:51:41PM ON THE END, ON THE EAST SIDE OF THIS PROPOSED PROPERTY.
5:51:46PM IT'S COMMERCIAL OFFICE THERE THAT COMES IN RIGHT OFF OF
5:51:51PM ARMENIA.
5:51:52PM THERE IS A SMALL ENTRANCE TO THIS ALLEY.
5:51:57PM AS YOU KNOW OR NOT, THERE AS BUILT-UP WALL ALONG ARMENIA
5:52:01PM RIGHT THERE, AND IT ENDS WHERE THE ALLEY IS.
5:52:04PM SO ON MANY OCCASIONS, I WAS LEASED OUT OF THAT OFFICE FOR AT
5:52:08PM LEAST 10, 15 YEARS.
5:52:09PM I SAW MANY TRUCKS, CARS GOING THROUGH THERE THAT WERE
5:52:12PM HITTING THIS RETAINING WALL.
5:52:15PM ALSO, THERE WAS A PROBLEM WHEN I WAS LEASING THAT OFFICE FOR
5:52:18PM MANY YEARS, AND THIS GOES BACK SIX, SEVEN YEARS SINCE I'VE
5:52:22PM BEEN IN THAT LOCATION, WE HAD MULTIPLE PARKING PROBLEMS.
5:52:26PM HIS PROPOSED USE IS GOING TO BE NEXT DOOR.
5:52:31PM VISITORS, WHATEVER COMING IN THERE, OUR PARKING LOT IS RIGHT
5:52:34PM NEXT.
5:52:35PM WE'VE GOT 8 PARKING SPOTS.
5:52:36PM EVEN WHEN I WAS THERE, PEOPLE WERE CONSTANTLY COMING IN
5:52:40PM EITHER OVER THE WEEKEND OR THEY WOULD HAVE VISITORS AROUND
5:52:43PM THAT.
5:52:43PM THEY WOULD PARK THEIR CARS IN OUR PARKING LOT, AND IF I CAME
5:52:47PM IN THE NEXT MORNING, THERE WOULD BE TWO OR THREE CARS THERE.
5:52:50PM BY THE TIME WE GOT TOWING PEOPLE OUT THERE, THEY SNUCK IN
5:52:54PM AND MOVED THEIR CARS.
5:52:56PM WITH ALL THIS -- WITH EIGHT UNITS THERE AND ALL THESE CARS
5:52:58PM COMING THROUGH THERE, IT IS JUST -- THERE'S NOT GOING TO BE
5:53:02PM THE -- THAT ALLEY IS NOT GOING TO SUPPORT THIS.
5:53:04PM YOU KNOW, AND ANOTHER THING, TOO, IS EMERGENCY VEHICLES
5:53:07PM TRYING TO GET INTO THIS ALLEYWAY OFF ARMENIA IS ALMOST, YOU
5:53:13PM KNOW, VERY DIFFICULT FOR THEM TO TURN UP IN THERE OR EVEN
5:53:16PM COME IN OFF TAMPANIA STREET.
5:53:18PM IT IS A VERY NARROW ALLEY, AND IT'S A LOT NARROWER THAN
5:53:24PM NORTH B STREET IS.
5:53:25PM THRIFTY RENTS ALSO OWNS THE PROPERTY BEHIND OURS, WHICH IS
5:53:30PM ON NORTH B STREET AND ARMENIA AND OWN THE PROPERTY NEXT TO
5:53:37PM THIS PROPOSED PROPERTY.
5:53:38PM SO WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TWO PROPERTIES ADJOINING THIS THING.
5:53:40PM LIKE I SAID, WITH NO PARKING ON NORTH B STREET OR ANYTHING
5:53:45PM LIKE THIS IT'S ALL GOING TO END UP IN OUR PARKING LOT,
5:53:50PM BECAUSE THIS HAPPENED SIX, SEVEN YEARS AGO, AND THERE WASN'T
5:53:53PM HALF THE DEVELOPMENT IN THAT AREA TODAY, BECAUSE I DROVE
5:53:57PM THROUGH THERE AGAIN JUST TO REFRESH MY MEMORY.
5:54:00PM AND THIS IS OUR BIGGEST CONCERN THERE.
5:54:02PM OUR TENANTS THAT ARE PAYING MONEY FOR THIS THING ARE JUST
5:54:06PM NOT GOING TO PUT UP WITH IT.
5:54:09PM YOU KNOW, AND HERE AGAIN, FEDERAL EXPRESS, AMAZON COMING IN,
5:54:16PM TO MAKE DELIVERIES TO THESE UNITS, THERE'S NO PARKING FOR
5:54:18PM THEM.
5:54:19PM THEY ARE GOING TO PARK IN OUR PARKING.
5:54:21PM THERE'S JUST NO WAY -- IT'S NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.
5:54:24PM SO THAT IS ONE OF OUR BIGGEST CONCERNS.
5:54:27PM AND AS FAR AS THIS BEING -- BRINGING HOUSING INTO IT, I CAN
5:54:32PM ALMOST GUARANTEE YOU, ANYONE WHO BUYS THESE UNITS WILL NEVER
5:54:35PM SEE A BUS.
5:54:35PM THEY ARE NOT GOING TO BE USING PUBLIC.
5:54:39PM USING THEIR VEHICLES, THEIR CARS.
5:54:41PM FROM WHAT I UNDERSTAND, THESE GARAGES ARE PARKED BACK TO
5:54:43PM BACK.
5:54:43PM THEY ARE NOT SIDE TO SIDE.
5:54:45PM HOW ARE THEY GOING TO GET IN AND OUT OF THE LITTLE SPACE?
5:54:47PM SHE BROUGHT UP THE CHILDREN IN THERE.
5:54:49PM AND THERE'S GOING TO BE CHILDREN IN THERE.
5:54:51PM AND WE ARE CONCERNED ABOUT IT.
5:54:54PM LIKE I SAID, WE WANT TO SEE GROWTH AND WE WANT TO SEE THAT
5:54:57PM NEIGHBORHOOD COME UP ALSO, BUT NOT IN THIS TYPE OF
5:54:59PM DEVELOPMENT.
5:55:00PM SO WE DEFINITELY ARE AGAINST THAT.
5:55:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
5:55:03PM >> SIR.
5:55:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:55:04PM NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:55:06PM YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
5:55:07PM >> HI THERE, ESTEEMED COUNCIL WOMEN AND MEN.
5:55:12PM MY NAME IS GEOFFREY BALL, RESIDENT OF THE ARMORY GARDENS
5:55:16PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND PRESIDENT OF THE CIVIC ASSOCIATION.
5:55:18PM I'M ALL FOR SUSTAINABILITY AND DEVELOPMENT IN THE
5:55:20PM APPROPRIATE WAYS.
5:55:21PM AS THE FIRST COUPLE OF SPEAKERS AND THE CITY PLANNING TALKED
5:55:25PM ABOUT THE INCONSISTENCIES WITH THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD
5:55:28PM AND THE PD REQUEST THAT DOESN'T FIT IN WITH THE INTERIOR OF
5:55:31PM THIS NEIGHBORHOOD AS IT SITS.
5:55:33PM THE COMBINED DESIGN CHANGE AND THE DENSITY CONCERNED ME AND
5:55:38PM I'VE HEARD FROM MANY RESIDENTS AS A LEADER IN THE
5:55:40PM NEIGHBORHOOD, OF THEIR CONCERNS, BECAUSE WE'VE SEEN KIND OF
5:55:44PM INSTANCES OF THIS IN OTHER NEIGHBORHOODS THAT HAVE CAUSED
5:55:48PM VARIOUS PROBLEMS WITH SAFETY CONCERNS AND EYESORES AND
5:55:53PM THINGS OF THAT NATURE THAT COME WITH THE CHALLENGES OF A
5:55:54PM DEVELOPMENT LIKE THIS.
5:55:55PM I HAVE A PICTURE I'LL SHOW A LITTLE LATER, THERE'S ACTUALLY
5:55:59PM A PRETTY SIMILAR DESIGN, JUST OUTSIDE, BLOCK AWAY, EAST SIDE
5:56:05PM OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD ON ARMENIA.
5:56:07PM I'VE GONE BY THERE, AND TRASH CANS AND ACCESS AND PARKING
5:56:09PM ARE CLEAR THAT MAYBE THERE'S GARAGES, BUT I THINK AS WE ALL
5:56:14PM KNOW, NOBODY USES THEIR GARAGE TO PARK CARS.
5:56:17PM I THINK YOU HIT ON IT.
5:56:20PM THAT WILL CAUSE OVERFLOW INTO THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:56:22PM THERE ARE NO CONTINUOUS SIDEWALKS ON THIS CURRENT BLOCK.
5:56:25PM IT HAS LOTS OF SIDEWALKS TO NOWHERE.
5:56:27PM UNFORTUNATELY NONE OF THOSE CONNECT, SO IT WILL CREATE
5:56:29PM PARKING WITH PEDESTRIANS HAVING TO ACCESS, WALK IN THE
5:56:33PM STREET.
5:56:34PM ALREADY KIND OF A LAND GRAB BECAUSE DEVELOPMENTS ON THE
5:56:38PM BLOCK USE TRASH CANS TO SAVE PARKING SPOTS.
5:56:42PM THERE ARE COMPETING CHALLENGES WITH FINDING PARKING ON THAT
5:56:44PM STREET ALONE WHICH WILL PROBABLY DRIVE INTO OTHER AREAS.
5:56:47PM SIMILARLY, UNFORTUNATELY, WE DO HAVE VISIBILITY RISKS COMING
5:56:51PM OUT OF OUR NEIGHBORHOOD ONTO ARMENIA.
5:56:54PM I THINK THIS WILL CONTRIBUTE TO THAT WITH MANY BLIND SPOTS
5:56:58PM AS PEOPLE ALSO END UP PARKING IN DESIGNATED SPOTS ON THE
5:57:01PM ARMENIA CORRIDOR, BLOCKING THE ABILITY TO LOOK OUT AT THE
5:57:04PM ONCOMING TRAFFIC AND MERGE INTO IT.
5:57:06PM I'LL SHOW YOU KIND OF A SIMILAR DESIGN.
5:57:10PM THIS IS THE ONE I WAS TALKING ABOUT.
5:57:11PM YOU CAN SEE IT'S ANOTHER SHOOT-THROUGH WHICH WOULD BE THE
5:57:16PM FIRST ONE IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:57:17PM WE DON'T HAVE ANYTHING LIKE THAT CURRENTLY.
5:57:18PM SO LIKELY INCOMPATIBLE AND INCONSISTENT WITH THE RESIDENTIAL
5:57:23PM DESIGNS CURRENTLY IN THERE.
5:57:25PM YOU CAN SEE THE TRASH CANS, AND THIS ONE I THINK HAS 12
5:57:27PM UNITS, SO IT'S A LITTLE BIGGER THAN WHAT THIS ONE WOULD BE.
5:57:30PM YOU CAN SEE PEOPLE WILL PUT THE TRASH CANS OUT AND BLOCK THE
5:57:33PM ABILITY TO PARK THERE.
5:57:34PM YOU CAN ALSO SEE IN THIS ONE, OVERFLOW.
5:57:40PM THERE'S NO OTHER RESIDENTIAL ON THIS BLOCK BETWEEN ARMENIA
5:57:43PM AND HOWARD, SO YOU CAN SEE THOSE CARS ARE FROM THE RESIDENTS
5:57:47PM THAT DO LIVE THERE.
5:57:49PM EVERYTHING ELSE AROUND THERE IS COMMERCIAL IN NATURE, AND --
5:57:54PM THOSE CARS ARE OVERFLOWING, WHICH SOME PARKING SHOULD
5:57:56PM HAPPEN.
5:57:57PM BUT UNFORTUNATELY, ON THAT BLOCK, THERE'S NOT A LOT OF
5:57:59PM AVAILABLE PARKING TO BEGIN WITH.
5:58:02PM SO WITH THAT IN MIND, THIS SECTION OF NORTH B ALREADY IS
5:58:06PM KIND OF DANGEROUS WITH SOME OF THE PARKING AND LACK OF
5:58:09PM SIDEWALKS.
5:58:09PM I REQUEST THAT YOU DENY THE PROPOSED REZONING.
5:58:12PM THE PD REZONING AND THEN ALSO THE BONUS REQUEST IF THE
5:58:17PM ZONING DOESN'T GET DENIED.
5:58:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:58:20PM NEXT SPEAKER, STATE YOUR NAME.
5:58:24PM >> [INAUDIBLE] ALSO A RESIDENT OF ARMORY GARDENS, 2714 WEST
5:58:29PM GRAY STREET --
5:58:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU SAID IT WAS JOE --
5:58:32PM >> JOELLYN.
5:58:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: JOELLYN ROBLES.
5:58:37PM YOU WEREN'T AT THE MICROPHONE, SO THEY COULDN'T PICK IT UP
5:58:40PM ON THE AUDIO.
5:58:41PM >> I'M A RESIDENT OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD, AND I AM ALSO
5:58:44PM REQUESTING THIS REZONING BE DENIED FOR SOME OF THE REASONS
5:58:49PM STATED BY THE PREVIOUS SPEAKERS, THE OBVIOUS DENSITY ISSUE
5:58:54PM FRONT DOOR, PARKING, ET CETERA.
5:58:57PM I FEEL THE BUILDING ITSELF IS INCONSISTENT WITH THE
5:59:01PM NEIGHBORHOOD, AND I BEG TO DIFFER WITH MR. STEVE, I BELIEVE,
5:59:05PM THE FIRST SPEAKER FOR THE PROJECT, WHERE HE STATES THIS IS
5:59:10PM SIMILAR TO WHAT'S ACROSS THE STREET.
5:59:13PM IT IS NOT SIMILAR TO WHAT'S ACROSS THE STREET.
5:59:17PM ACROSS THE STREET HAS TOWNHOMES WITH A DRIVEWAY ALONG WITH
5:59:20PM PARKING.
5:59:21PM THESE UNITS HAVE THE PARKING INSIDE THE GARAGE, ALONG THE
5:59:23PM BUILDING.
5:59:24PM SO PARKING IS A MAJOR ISSUE.
5:59:28PM AS A PREVIOUS SPEAKER STATED, TWO-CAR GARAGE, GREAT, BUT HOW
5:59:31PM MANY OF US REALISTICALLY PARK BOTH OF OUR CARS IN OUR
5:59:34PM GARAGES?
5:59:34PM NOT MANY OF US.
5:59:35PM WE'RE LUCKY IF WE CAN FIT ONE CAR.
5:59:38PM SO THAT'S GOING TO LEAVE AT 8 UNITS WITH EACH PERSON HAVING
5:59:43PM TWO VEHICLES.
5:59:44PM 16 VEHICLES THAT WILL BE UTILIZING PARKING IN THIS AREA.
5:59:49PM SO TAKE HALF OF THOSE VEHICLES PARKING IN THEIR GARAGE, THE
5:59:52PM OTHER HALF PARKING ON THE STREET, PARALLEL PARKING SPOTS ARE
5:59:57PM GENERALLY ABOUT 24 FEET IN LENGTH.
6:00:00PM SO IF YOU HAVE 8 CARS PARKING ALONG THE STREET, THEY ARE
6:00:04PM GOING TO EXCEED THE PROPERTY BOUNDARY LINE OF 110 FEET.
6:00:08PM THEY ARE GOING TO BE TAKING UP ALMOST 200 FEET PARKING 8
6:00:11PM CARS.
6:00:11PM SO WHERE ARE THOSE EXTRA CARS FOR THE RESIDENT AND THE
6:00:14PM VISITORS GOING TO BE PARKING?
6:00:15PM ALL ALONG THE OTHER NEIGHBOR'S PROPERTY.
6:00:21PM THE GARBAGE ISSUE THAT JEFF JUST BROUGHT UP, 16 GARBAGE CANS
6:00:27PM ON A FRIDAY.
6:00:30PM AND PER THEIR PLANS, I DIDN'T SEE ANYTHING ON THE PLAN THAT
6:00:36PM HAD A DESIGNATED SPACE TO STORE THE GARBAGE CANS.
6:00:41PM MEANING THEY WILL MOST LIKELY BE PUTTING THOSE GARBAGE CANS
6:00:47PM IN THEIR GARAGE, WHICH ALREADY, FROM THE DRAWING, LOOKS VERY
6:00:50PM SMALL AND CAN BARELY FIT TWO VEHICLES.
6:00:53PM SO THOSE ARE JUST A FEW OF THE REASONS.
6:00:55PM IN ADDITION, I ALSO BELIEVE THESE PLANS ARE NOT CONSISTENT
6:00:58PM WITH THE CITY OF TAMPA 2040 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, SPECIFICALLY
6:01:09PM -- AND THIS WILL BE MY LAST COMMENT -- SPECIFICALLY PAGE 34,
6:01:14PM LAND USE POLICY 1.2.28 OF THE 2040 PLAN ADOPTED APRIL OF
6:01:20PM THIS YEAR, LIMIT THE USE OF PLANNED DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT
6:01:23PM REZONING PETITIONS TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT CONSISTENT WITH
6:01:26PM FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION, BUT NOT OTHERWISE NOT PERMITTED
6:01:31PM IN THE CURRENT ZONING STANDARD.
6:01:32PM THIS DEVELOPMENT ISN'T EVEN CONSISTENT WITH CURRENT OR
6:01:35PM FUTURE PLANS, THEREFORE, THIS REQUEST SHOULD BE DENIED.
6:01:38PM THANK YOU.
6:01:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:01:39PM NEXT SPEAKER.
6:01:40PM YES, MA'AM.
6:01:42PM >> HELLO.
6:01:43PM MY NAME IS JANAE CALLAWAY.
6:01:45PM I LIVE AT 205 NORTH TAMPANIA, ALSO IN THE ARMORY GARDENS
6:01:51PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:01:51PM MY PROPERTY SITS DIRECTLY BESIDE THE PROPERTY IN QUESTION TO
6:01:55PM THE WEST.
6:01:56PM I'M HERE TO VOICE MY CONCERN ABOUT THE REQUEST TO REZONE AND
6:02:01PM REQUEST TO DENY THE PD REZONING.
6:02:03PM WITH THE REZONING, THE NEW PROPERTY WILL BE FIVE FEET FROM
6:02:06PM MY PROPERTY LINE AND MY BACKYARD.
6:02:09PM TO BE CLEAR, THIS PROJECT IS LIKE NO OTHER PROPERTY IN THE
6:02:15PM IMMEDIATE AREA.
6:02:15PM THIS THREE-STORY BUILDING WOULD NOT ONLY BE OUT OF CHARACTER
6:02:18PM FOR THE NEIGHBORHOOD, BUT IT WILL ALSO PEER DIRECTLY INTO MY
6:02:24PM BACKYARD, INVADING MY PRIVACY, MY FAMILY'S PRIVACY AS A
6:02:27PM HOMEOWNER.
6:02:28PM IN ADDITION, THERE IS SIMPLY NOT ENOUGH ROOM FOR THE AMOUNT
6:02:32PM OF PEOPLE THIS PROJECT WILL BRING.
6:02:34PM ON NORTH B STREET, THERE'S ALREADY A SURPLUS OF VEHICLES AND
6:02:37PM TRASH CANS THAT CROWD THE STREET, MAKING IT HARD TO TURN
6:02:40PM ONTO THE BLOCK COMING FROM ARMENIA AND IT CREATES A HAZARD
6:02:44PM DAILY.
6:02:44PM THIS PROJECT WILL ALSO BRING ADDITIONAL GUEST PARKING
6:02:49PM OUTSIDE OF THE DESIGNATED PARKING SPACES, INCREASING THE
6:02:52PM DRIVING HAZARD FOR THE AREA AND AS A MOTHER OF A TEENAGE
6:02:56PM DRIVER WHO IS JUST LEARNING TO DRIVE, IT CONCERNS ME.
6:02:59PM I ASK THAT YOU ALL CONSIDER KEEPING THIS SPACE ZONED FOR
6:03:03PM RESIDENTIAL MULTIPLE FAMILY 16.
6:03:05PM THANK YOU.
6:03:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:03:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:03:13PM >> GOOD EVENING.
6:03:13PM STEPHANIE POYNOR.
6:03:15PM I WANTED TO POINT OUT SOMETHING THAT I TOTALLY FORGOTTEN
6:03:17PM ABOUT UNTIL LaCHONE PUT IT UP HERE.
6:03:20PM I HAD DRIVEN PAST THE PROPERTY, AND THIS IS THE NOTIFICATION
6:03:24PM SIGN.
6:03:25PM TURN TOWARDS THE HOUSE.
6:03:26PM I DON'T KNOW HOW FAR -- THAT IS THE NOTIFICATION.
6:03:32PM TECHNICALLY, THIS SHOULD BE A MISNOTICE.
6:03:34PM DEBBIE GAVE ME SOME THINGS I WANT TO MAKE SURE I PASS ON.
6:03:42PM THIS BONUS AGREEMENT, THE PD, YOU ARE NOT SUPPOSED TO DO IT
6:03:45PM WITH RM-16, 18, WHATEVER, SHE RAN OUT OF TIME, SO I GET TO
6:03:50PM DO IT.
6:03:51PM THE OTHER THING THAT DEBBIE DIDN'T GET TO WAS THIS THING
6:03:54PM ABOUT THE TOWN HOUSES VERSUS CONDOS.
6:03:57PM AND SO THIS IS SUPPOSED TO FOLLOW THESE GUIDELINES FOR THE
6:04:03PM TOWN HOUSES, AND YOU PROBABLY WANT TO TAKE A LOOK AT THAT
6:04:07PM BECAUSE THERE IS A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN WHAT'S BEING PRESENTED
6:04:10PM AND WHAT'S IN THERE.
6:04:11PM LET'S SEE.
6:04:12PM LAST BUT NOT LEAST.
6:04:13PM OH, AND THIS IS THE AGREEMENT.
6:04:18PM I DON'T KNOW WHO BENEFITS FROM IT.
6:04:20PM THE DIRECT NEIGHBORHOODS -- LOIS AVENUE WHICH IS NOT NEXT
6:04:27PM DOOR.
6:04:27PM IT'S FUNNY, BECAUSE I'M PRETTY SURE THIS IS A BONUS
6:04:30PM AGREEMENT THAT WE SAW LIKE A MONTH AGO FOR DIFFERENT
6:04:33PM PROPERTY.
6:04:33PM AND IT WAS ALMOST THE SAME PRICE.
6:04:36PM IT WAS THE ONE THAT WAS THE NIGHT OF THE GARDEN CLUB STUFF.
6:04:40PM SO I'M JUST SAYING.
6:04:41PM I WAS VERY INTERESTED IN THE FACT THAT MR. MICHELINI SAID HE
6:04:45PM CHANGED -- I'M SORRY.
6:04:47PM HE CHANGED THE ROOFTOPS.
6:04:50PM HE CHANGED THE DENSITY.
6:04:53PM THEY CHANGED THE SETBACK.
6:04:54PM THEY CHANGED THIS, THAT, AND THE OTHER.
6:04:56PM BUT MY ISSUE IS, WHY WAS IT WRONG TO START WITH?
6:05:01PM EVERYBODY KNOWS THAT WEST TAMPA HAS AN OVERLAY.
6:05:04PM WE GOT SOME ISSUES WITH PARKING, AND I THINK SOME OF THAT
6:05:08PM WAS RESOLVED BY MOVING THE BUILDINGS AROUND.
6:05:10PM BUT, YOU KNOW, I GOT TO AGREE WITH DEBBIE THAT PUTTING
6:05:13PM SIDEWALKS IN FRONT OF GARAGE DOORS IS JUST A DEATH TRAP
6:05:18PM WAITING TO HAPPEN.
6:05:21PM YOU CAN SEND A LITTLE PERSON BACK THERE WITHOUT RUNNING THEM
6:05:24PM OVER.
6:05:25PM YOU CAN'T SEE GARBAGE CANS.
6:05:27PM THEY'LL TEAR UP YOUR CAR.
6:05:29PM THESE ARE PICTURES OF THE TOWN HOUSES RIGHT ACROSS THE
6:05:32PM STREET.
6:05:33PM IT'S UGLY, AND WHY PEOPLE DON'T PARK, I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY
6:05:37PM THEY PARK ON THE STREET.
6:05:38PM OH, WAIT, THERE'S NO PARKING SPACES FOR THEM THERE.
6:05:41PM SO MY BIG THING IS, WHERE ARE THEY GOING TO PUT THE GARBAGE
6:05:47PM CANS?
6:05:48PM I CAN TELL YOU THAT IS A PROBLEM IN MY NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:05:50PM MOST OF YOU HAVE BEEN THERE.
6:05:51PM I THINK THAT WE NEED TO ADDRESS THAT, BECAUSE THEY ARE 36 BY
6:05:55PM 33.
6:05:56PM SO YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT 18 SQUARE FEET THAT HAVE TO BE
6:05:59PM DEDICATED TO YOUR TRASH CANS AND YOUR RECYCLING BINS.
6:06:03PM WHERE DO THEY GO?
6:06:03PM CAN'T PUT THEM IN THE GARAGE?
6:06:04PM DRAG THEM THROUGH THE HOUSE TO GET TO YOUR BACKYARD?
6:06:07PM BECAUSE THESE FENCES DON'T OPEN TO THE INDIVIDUAL PROPERTY,
6:06:12PM SO ARE YOU GOING TO DRAG THE GARBAGE CANS THROUGH?
6:06:14PM AND YOU CAN'T EVEN BACK UP IN THERE.
6:06:17PM I MEAN, I COULD.
6:06:17PM I'D LIKE TO ALSO SAY THERE'S ONE OF THESE DOWN THE STREET
6:06:20PM FROM ME, AND IT TURNS OVER AT LEAST ONCE A YEAR.
6:06:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:06:28PM YES, MA'AM.
6:06:29PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:06:32PM YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
6:07:00PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: MS. SANCHEZ, THAT'S FOUR NAMES.
6:07:12PM I'LL TRY TO READ THEM OFF.
6:07:14PM JANICE KATZ.
6:07:15PM THANK YOU.
6:07:15PM SHARON GENUARDI.
6:07:19PM THANK YOU.
6:07:19PM BETH CARTER.
6:07:22PM AND ROBIN LOCKETT.
6:07:25PM THANK YOU.
6:07:25PM FOUR MINUTES PLUS THREE EQUALS SEVEN.
6:07:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
6:07:32PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:07:33PM GO AHEAD.
6:07:34PM >> GOOD EVENING, CITY COUNCIL.
6:07:35PM MY NAME IS SANDY DEDIEGO SANCHEZ.
6:07:39PM 2705 WEST FIG STREET.
6:07:41PM I'M A RESIDENT OF THE ARMORY GARDENS COMMUNITY, HOME OF THE
6:07:44PM BEAUTIFUL VILA BROTHERS PARK.
6:07:46PM LET ME BE CLEAR, I AM A NEIGHBORHOOD ACTIVIST FOR ANY
6:07:51PM NEIGHBORHOOD THAT ASKS AND CALLS ME FOR HELP.
6:07:54PM I JUST HAPPEN TO LIVE IN THE ARMORY GARDENS COMMUNITY.
6:07:58PM I AM A VOLUNTEER.
6:07:58PM FIRST I'D LIKE TO TALK TO YOU ABOUT THE FIRST PICTURE,
6:08:03PM NUMBER ONE THAT I GAVE YOU.
6:08:05PM THIS IS AN OVERVIEW, LIKE A BIRD'S-EYE VIEW LOOKING DOWN.
6:08:10PM WHEN YOU SEE NORTH B, YOU CAN SEE THE FOUR DUPLEXES THAT ARE
6:08:15PM ACROSS THE STREET.
6:08:16PM THERE ARE 11 DRIVEWAYS THERE.
6:08:18PM THAT MEANS THERE IS NO PARKING ON THE SOUTH SIDE -- NORTH
6:08:22PM SIDE OF THE STREET AND BECAUSE OF THOSE, THERE'S NO PARKING
6:08:25PM ALLOWED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF THE STREET.
6:08:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO YOU HAVE SOMETHING ON THE OVERHEAD?
6:08:31PM >> NO.
6:08:31PM YOU SHOULD HAVE THESE.
6:08:32PM PAGE 1.
6:08:33PM PAGE 1.
6:08:35PM SO YOU WILL SEE THE PROPOSED UNIT, THE GREEN AND WHITE ONE
6:08:43PM THERE ONTO THE ALLEY.
6:08:44PM NEXT TO IT IS ANOTHER THREE UNIT ON THE BOOKS MAYBE COMING
6:08:48PM BEFORE YOU.
6:08:49PM I DON'T KNOW.
6:08:50PM THERE IS ANOTHER DUPLEX COMING UP.
6:08:53PM THEY JUST BROKE GROUND.
6:08:54PM THE ONE FURTHER DOWN TO THE SOUTH OF IT IS JUST ABOUT TO BE
6:09:00PM FINISHED.
6:09:01PM THIS IS THE ALLEY.
6:09:03PM THERE ARE THREE DUPLEXES.
6:09:05PM TWO DUPLEXES THAT ARE THERE.
6:09:08PM MEANS THERE IS A TOTAL OF ALMOST 12 CARS THAT ARE USING THE
6:09:13PM ALLEY.
6:09:13PM THERE ARE BUSINESSES ON EACH END OF THIS ALLEY.
6:09:16PM SO I JUST WANTED YOU TO UNDERSTAND WHAT'S COMING INTO THAT
6:09:20PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND WHY WE ARE SO OPPOSED TO THIS UNIT.
6:09:23PM MS. POYNOR ALSO SHOWED YOU A PICTURE OF -- LET'S SEE WHAT
6:09:29PM PAGE IT IS.
6:09:34PM LET'S GO TO PAGE 2.
6:09:36PM PAGE 2, IT SHOWS THE BLOCK ON NORTH B AND WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE
6:09:41PM IN THE MORNINGS BEFORE TRASH COMES.
6:09:43PM THE TRASH CANS ARE THERE AND LOOK AT THE PARKING -- THE
6:09:46PM ILLEGAL PARKING THAT'S ON THE STREETS.
6:09:48PM IF YOU ALSO NOTICE THE BOTTOM LEFT-HAND PICTURE THERE, THERE
6:09:51PM IS A BOARDING HOUSE ON THAT CORNER, WHICH IS ANOTHER 8 OR 10
6:09:54PM CARS.
6:09:55PM BASICALLY, THERE IS NO LEGAL PARKING ON NORTH B NOR
6:10:00PM TAMPANIA.
6:10:02PM ALSO THROWN IN JUST FOR GRINS, YOU GET A COPY OF THE PARKING
6:10:09PM STATUTES IN THE CITY.
6:10:10PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND FRIENDS THAT SPOKE BEFORE ME SHOW THAT
6:10:15PM THE DEVELOPMENT COORDINATOR FOR THE CITY OF TAMPA FOUND
6:10:18PM NUMEROUS ITEMS TO BE INCONSISTENT.
6:10:20PM INCLUDING THAT IT DOES NOT BLEND IN WITH THE SURROUNDING
6:10:26PM COMMUNITY.
6:10:27PM I'VE SHOWN YOU THE OVERHEAD SHOT WITH THE COMPLETED PROJECTS
6:10:29PM AND WORK IN PROGRESS THAT GIVE YOU A VIEW OF THE DENSITY AND
6:10:32PM PARKING ISSUES.
6:10:33PM THERE SHOULD BE LITTLE DOUBT THAT ADDING THIS PROJECT TO THE
6:10:39PM MIDST WOULD BE UTTER CHAOS.
6:10:41PM YOU ALSO SHOWED THE EXISTING PARKING AREAS THAT INCLUDED
6:10:46PM TRASH CANS.
6:10:46PM IMAGINE ON RECYCLE DAY A TOTAL OF 48 TRASH CANS OUT ON THE
6:10:51PM STREET.
6:10:52PM AND JUST AS A SIDE REMARK, THE UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE
6:10:55PM DOES NOT REQUIRE THAT THEIR PEOPLE GET OUT AND MOVE THOSE
6:10:59PM TRASH CANS TO GET THEIR MAIL.
6:11:00PM IF YOU'RE BLOCKING YOUR MAILBOX, YOU DON'T GET THE MAIL.
6:11:05PM WE'VE EXPLAINED THE REASONS WHY THIS PROJECT WILL NOT
6:11:15PM ACCOMMODATE 16 TO 20 CARS.
6:11:17PM IF YOU LOOK ON PAGE 4, AGAIN, AS MS. POYNOR SAID, PLEASE
6:11:21PM NOTE THIS IS A ONE-WAY DRIVEWAY.
6:11:25PM THERE IS NO EXIT TO NORTH B.
6:11:28PM SO IMAGINE IN THE MORNING LEAVING FOR WORK AND SOMEBODY WHO
6:11:32PM IS COMING IN FROM WORK THAT HAS WORKED THE NIGHT SHIFT, WHAT
6:11:35PM IS THE PROTOCOL?
6:11:36PM WHO BACKS UP?
6:11:37PM WHO GOES FIRST?
6:11:38PM WHAT DO YOU DO WHEN SOMEBODY IS COMING OUT TO WALK THEIR
6:11:42PM KIDS TO SCHOOL?
6:11:43PM THIS IS A DRIVEWAY; IT'S NOT A PATIO.
6:11:47PM OKAY?
6:11:48PM IT'S IMPOSSIBLE AND AS WAS SHOWN, THE PICTURE THAT SHE
6:11:53PM SHOWED OF THE OTHER ONE ON 2315 NORTH A, I TALKED TO THE
6:11:57PM PEOPLE THAT PARK IN THE STREET, THAT'S 12 UNITS, AND IT'S
6:12:00PM FIVE FEET WIDER THAN THIS PROPOSED PROJECT.
6:12:04PM I ALSO HAVE TWO CITY STAFF THAT RODE WITH ME TO SHOW THAT
6:12:08PM YOU CANNOT MAKE THAT TURN INTO THE DRIVEWAY UNLESS YOU BACK
6:12:13PM OUT A NUMBER OF TIMES.
6:12:15PM SO WHEN I ASKED THE PEOPLE WHO WERE ACTUALLY LIVING IN A
6:12:19PM TUNNEL DESIGN WHY THEY PARK IN THE STREET, THEY CAN, AND
6:12:24PM BECAUSE IT'S EASIER.
6:12:25PM BECAUSE WHEN THEY COME HOME FROM WORK OR THEY HAVE BEEN OUT
6:12:28PM PLAYING, THE LAST THING THEY WANT TO DO IS HAVE TO SEESAW
6:12:32PM INTO THAT PARKING.
6:12:34PM THIS DESIGN WILL PRESENT CHAOS.
6:12:37PM THE CITY OF ORLANDO HAS BANNED THIS DESIGN FOR THIS
6:12:42PM PARTICULAR REASON.
6:12:42PM IT CAUSES CHAOS WITHIN THE UNITS.
6:12:45PM THEY CANNOT UTILIZE THE PARKING SPACE THAT IS THERE.
6:12:48PM THE APPLICANT ACTUALLY ADDED TWO MORE PARKING SPACES FOR
6:12:54PM GUEST PARKING, BUT GUESS WHAT, THOSE ARE GOING TO BE TAKEN
6:12:56PM UP BY THE SECOND CAR PERMANENTLY.
6:13:01PM THERE ARE NOT GOING TO BE ANY CARS THAT ARE GOING TO BE
6:13:03PM THERE FOR OTHER PEOPLE TO USE.
6:13:05PM WE HAVE SHOWN YOU THE EXAMPLE OF THE OTHER AND WE'VE SHOWN
6:13:15PM YOU ALL THE REASONS WHY THIS WILL WREAK HAVOC WITHIN OUR
6:13:18PM COMMUNITY.
6:13:19PM THERE IS NO GUARANTEE THAT THEY ARE GOING TO BE ABLE TO PARK
6:13:22PM IN THIS, AND WE HAVE PROOF FROM THE OTHER ONE THAT IS
6:13:25PM EXISTING DOWN THE STREET THAT IT DOES NOT WORK.
6:13:27PM THIS IS A POORLY DESIGNED PROJECT.
6:13:31PM ALSO THIS IS NOT AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
6:13:37PM IT IS NON-AFFORDABLE HOUSING CRAMMED INTO A VERY SMALL BOX.
6:13:41PM ANOTHER EXAMPLE OF PUTTING TOO MANY EGGS INTO A SMALL
6:13:45PM BASKET.
6:13:45PM FOR ALL OF THESE REASONS, PLEASE DENY THIS APPLICANT'S
6:13:49PM REQUEST FOR REZONING OF THE PD.
6:13:51PM ONE MORE THING.
6:13:52PM IF YOU GO TO PAGE 5, I BELIEVE IT IS, VERY QUICKLY, IT WILL
6:14:01PM SHOW YOU THE OVERVIEW OF PDs, PAGE 5.
6:14:07PM PLEASE NOTE, THOSE ARE ALL PDs -- EXCUSE ME, RM-16s AND
6:14:12PM RM-18s.
6:14:13PM THERE ARE TWO PDs ON ARMENIA AVENUE.
6:14:17PM THIS AREA ALONE BETWEEN ARRAWANA AND ARMENIA HAS 15 DUPLEXES
6:14:23PM AND THREE TRIPLEXES.
6:14:25PM NONE OF THEM NEEDED THE PD ZONING TO BUILD THOSE.
6:14:28PM THIS PD IS FRIVOLOUS.
6:14:30PM IT SHOULD NOT BE ALLOWED.
6:14:32PM PLEASE DENY THIS.
6:14:34PM THIS DESIGN AND ALL THE ISSUES THAT I HAVE MENTIONED WILL BE
6:14:38PM KAY -- WILL BRING CHAOS TO THE ARMORY GARDENS COMMUNITY.
6:14:41PM THANK YOU.
6:14:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:14:42PM ANYBODY ELSE?
6:14:47PM THERE'S NOBODY REGISTERED TO SPEAK ONLINE.
6:14:49PM QUESTIONS FROM COUNCIL MEMBERS.
6:14:51PM YES, MA'AM, MS. DOCK.
6:14:54PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES, COUNCIL.
6:14:55PM THANK YOU.
6:14:56PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:14:57PM THERE ARE A COUPLE OF ITEMS JUST TO POINT OUT, COUNCIL.
6:15:00PM ONE IS REGARDING THE HEIGHT.
6:15:03PM IT HAS BEEN MENTIONED THAT 35-FOOT HEIGHT IS ALLOWED IN A
6:15:07PM RESIDENTIAL AREA BY THE APPLICANT.
6:15:10PM JUST NOTE THAT THAT IS CORRECT.
6:15:14PM 35-FOOT IS THE MAXIMUM HEIGHT, BUT WE'RE LOOKING AT THE
6:15:18PM MASSING THAT IS PROPOSED.
6:15:20PM THE THREE-STORY STRUCTURES THAT ARE PROPOSED, AND THAT IS
6:15:23PM LISTED WITHIN THE STAFF REPORT.
6:15:25PM ONE THING ALSO JUST TO MENTION, I KNOW THAT THERE WAS A
6:15:28PM REQUEST TO SUBMIT THE CONCEPTUAL ELEVATIONS THAT WERE
6:15:33PM PROVIDED BY THE APPLICANT IN COLOR.
6:15:37PM THOSE WERE NOT SUBMITTED WITH THE ORIGINAL PACKET.
6:15:39PM SO IF THAT IS THE DIRECTION OF COUNCIL, I WOULD ADD THAT TO
6:15:42PM THE REVISION SHEET.
6:15:43PM IF IT IS COUNCIL'S DESIRE TO APPROVE.
6:15:47PM BUT I JUST WOULD NEED TO KNOW IF THAT IS THE DIRECTION OF
6:15:51PM COUNCIL.
6:15:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IF WE GET TO THAT POINT, I WOULD MAKE THE
6:15:56PM MOTION TO INCLUDE IT WITH THE REVISION SHEET, WHEN WE GET TO
6:15:59PM THAT POINT.
6:15:59PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU.
6:16:00PM I HAVE THE REVISION SHEET READY.
6:16:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:16:03PM MR. MICHELINI.
6:16:04PM YOU HAVE REBUTTAL.
6:16:06PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THANK YOU, SIR.
6:16:07PM I LISTENED VERY CAREFULLY TO WHAT THE NEIGHBORS WERE MAKING
6:16:11PM COMMENTS ABOUT, AND IF YOU LOOK AT THE EXHIBIT THAT THEY
6:16:17PM PROVIDED, THIS TOWN HOUSE PROJECT HAS ALL THE DRIVEWAYS ON
6:16:24PM NORTH B STREET.
6:16:25PM EVERY ONE OF THEM.
6:16:26PM AND THE CRITICISM THAT I HEARD WAS WE'RE USING THE ALLEY.
6:16:31PM WELL, I DON'T HAVE A CHOICE.
6:16:33PM YOU KNOW, IF THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY SAYS YOU MUST USE THE
6:16:37PM ALLEY, I HAVE TO USE IT.
6:16:39PM THERE ARE TOWN HOUSES HERE.
6:16:44PM THERE ARE ALL OF THESE TOWN HOUSES HERE.
6:16:47PM I WOULD BE HAPPY TO NOT USE IT.
6:16:51PM WE HAD ONE CONCEPT THAT SHOWED US USING FRONT DRIVEWAYS ON
6:16:54PM NORTH B STREET, AND WE HAD STAFF OBJECTIONS, AND WE CHANGED
6:16:58PM IT.
6:16:59PM THIS IS TAMPANIA, 2303 -- OR 203 NORTH TAMPANIA.
6:17:11PM JUST APPROVED AT 35 FEET.
6:17:14PM HERE'S WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE.
6:17:16PM THREE STORIES.
6:17:21PM THIS IS ARRAWANA, THREE STORIES, 35 FEET.
6:17:25PM THIS IS RIGHT AROUND THE CORNER.
6:17:28PM WHEN WE START TALKING ABOUT MASSING AND SCALE, THE SCALE HAS
6:17:37PM TO DO WITH THE HEIGHT AND THE INTENSITY IN THE SETBACKS.
6:17:39PM WE'RE MEETING ALL OF THOSE REQUIREMENTS.
6:17:42PM SO I DON'T KNOW HOW WE GOT TO BE INCONSISTENT BECAUSE WE
6:17:46PM MEET THE REQUIREMENTS THAT ARE OUTLINED IN THE WEST TAMPA
6:17:49PM OVERLAY.
6:17:50PM THIS IS A PICTURE OF THE TOWN HOUSES DIRECTLY ACROSS THE
6:17:54PM STREET WITH THE DRIVEWAYS ON NORTH B STREET.
6:17:58PM YOU KNOW, WE CHANGED THAT.
6:17:59PM HERE IS THE PICTURE THAT THEY SHOWED YOU LOOKING DOWN THE
6:18:03PM STREET.
6:18:03PM AND OUR SUBJECT SITE IS IMMEDIATELY HERE TO THE RIGHT.
6:18:06PM THERE IS ANOTHER ONE.
6:18:11PM AND I DON'T THINK THAT YOU CAN ATTRIBUTE WHAT HAPPENS WITH
6:18:16PM SOME OTHER PROJECT WITH SOLID WASTE AND WITH GARBAGE CANS
6:18:23PM AND ACCESS.
6:18:25PM WE WIDEN THE ACCESS SO THAT YOU WOULDN'T HAVE A PROBLEM
6:18:31PM ACCESSING THE REAR ON THIS ALLEY.
6:18:32PM WE RECOGNIZE THAT IF IT REQUIRES ADDITIONAL IMPROVEMENTS,
6:18:37PM THIS DEVELOPMENT HAS TO PAY FOR IT ALONG THAT ENTIRE BLOCK
6:18:41PM OF THE ALLEY, NOT JUST ONE.
6:18:43PM THE BONUS PROVISION, THERE WERE SOME COMMENTS ABOUT THAT.
6:18:47PM THAT WAS REVIEWED AND APPROVED BY THE LEGAL DEPARTMENT.
6:18:50PM IF IT DIDN'T MEET THE CODE, THEY WOULDN'T HAVE APPROVED IT.
6:18:55PM EXCUSE ME, SANDY.
6:18:57PM EXCUSE ME.
6:18:58PM I MEAN, WOULD YOU HOLD MY TIME, PLEASE?
6:19:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE HOLD HIS TIME.
6:19:06PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: I DIDN'T INTERRUPT ANYBODY ELSE AND I
6:19:09PM DIDN'T SPEAK OVER ANYBODY ELSE AND IT'S RUDE AND
6:19:11PM INCONSIDERATE TO DO THAT.
6:19:12PM I DON'T APPRECIATE IT.
6:19:14PM IT INTERRUPTS MY TRAIN OF THOUGHT AND THEY REALLY SHOULDN'T
6:19:16PM BE ALLOWED TO DO THAT.
6:19:18PM IT HAPPENS ALL TOO FREQUENTLY AND YOU GET COMMENTS FROM THE
6:19:20PM BACK OF THE ROOM, COMMENTS ABOUT I'M LYING OR I'M
6:19:24PM MISREPRESENTING SOMETHING.
6:19:25PM IT'S NOT APPRECIATED, AND I WOULD APPRECIATE THE CHAIR TO
6:19:29PM STOP IT.
6:19:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
6:19:31PM GO AHEAD.
6:19:32PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: VEHICULAR ACCESS ON THE ALLEY IS A
6:19:34PM REQUIREMENT.
6:19:35PM I HAVE NO CHOICE.
6:19:36PM WHETHER YOU HAVE A COMMERCIAL OFFICE BUILDING, WHICH ONE OF
6:19:41PM THE GENTLEMAN SAID, HE HAS TO ACCESS THE ALLEY.
6:19:44PM THE ALLEY IS 18 FEET WIDE.
6:19:47PM WE'VE ADDED TWO ADDITIONAL VISITOR PARKING SPACES.
6:19:52PM AND THE TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT FOUND IT CONSISTENT.
6:19:55PM IF YOU'D LIKE TO ASK JONATHAN SCOTT ABOUT OUR CONSISTENCY
6:19:58PM FINDING, HE'S HERE.
6:20:00PM THE DENSITY IS WHAT IS ALLOWED UNDER THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:20:05PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION WENT TO GREAT LENGTHS, AND I READ
6:20:10PM INTO THE RECORD ALL OF THE DIFFERENT FINDING THEY HAD,
6:20:12PM FINDING CONSISTENCY AND COMPATIBILITY.
6:20:16PM THE WEST TAMPA CODE IS THE ONE THAT MADE US MOVE THE
6:20:22PM BUILDINGS TO FIVE FEET INSTEAD OF SEVEN FEET.
6:20:25PM THE GUEST PARKING WE'VE ADDED.
6:20:27PM WE DOUBLED THE NUMBER OF SPACES THAT WERE REQUIRED JUST TO
6:20:30PM MAKE SURE THAT WE DIDN'T AFFECT ANY OFF-SITE PROPERTIES.
6:20:34PM I HEARD THINGS ABOUT SOLID WASTE PICKUP AND GARBAGE CANS, WE
6:20:40PM HAVE TO PROVIDE THAT.
6:20:42PM THOSE ISSUES WILL BE HANDLED AT PERMITTING.
6:20:44PM THERE WAS NO ISSUE THAT I'M AWARE OF REGARDING ANY
6:20:48PM INCONSISTENCY OR INCOMPATIBILITY WITH MEETING THE WEST
6:20:50PM TAMPA, EXCEPT FOR THE FRONT DOOR FACING FOR ALL THE UNITS.
6:20:56PM AGAIN, I THINK, YOU KNOW, THIS DIAGRAM SPEAKS VOLUMES ABOUT
6:21:05PM COMPATIBILITY.
6:21:06PM YOU CAN'T COME IN AND SAY IT'S NOT COMPATIBLE WHEN ALL THESE
6:21:11PM OTHER PROJECTS ARE ALREADY HERE, AND THEY ARE ARGUING ABOUT
6:21:14PM HOW THEY DON'T MEET THE CODE.
6:21:15PM OR HOW THEY ARE IMPACTING THE RESIDENTS.
6:21:20PM I DON'T KNOW HOW YOU ARGUE BOTH WAYS.
6:21:23PM I GREATLY APPRECIATE YOUR CONSIDERATION.
6:21:27PM I THINK THAT WE'VE ADDRESSED THE ISSUES REGARDING STAFF AND
6:21:30PM THE NEIGHBORS AS BEST WE CAN, AND I'VE SHOWN YOU THAT THERE
6:21:34PM ARE OTHER PROJECTS SIMILAR SIZE AND SCALE IMMEDIATELY
6:21:38PM ADJACENT TO THIS PROPERTY.
6:21:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
6:21:41PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THANK YOU.
6:21:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
6:21:43PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I HAVE A QUESTION.
6:21:44PM SO YOU JUST SAID YOU SHOWED THAT THERE ARE DEVELOPMENTS
6:21:51PM CLOSE IN SIZE AND SCALE.
6:21:52PM BUT AT THE VERY BEGINNING OF YOUR PRESENTATION, YOU SAID YOU
6:21:54PM NEED THIS WAIVER BECAUSE THE DEVELOPMENT IS UNIQUE.
6:21:56PM SO WHICH IS IT?
6:21:59PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: IT IS UNIQUE BECAUSE OF THE ORIENTATION
6:22:02PM OF THE DOORS.
6:22:04PM DIDN'T HAVE TO HAVE ALL OF THE DIFFERENT CONDITIONS.
6:22:06PM I MEAN, THIS --
6:22:09PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WELL, THOSE DO, TOO.
6:22:11PM SO I'M JUST SAYING.
6:22:12PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: I DON'T KNOW HOW ARE WHY THEY WERE
6:22:15PM APPROVED.
6:22:16PM I HAVE NO IDEA.
6:22:17PM BUT I SHOWED YOU THAT ONE AT 203, WHICH IS IMMEDIATELY
6:22:22PM ADJACENT TO THIS PROPERTY, IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO IT.
6:22:26PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I DON'T BELIEVE THAT'S BEEN APPROVED YET.
6:22:28PM I THINK THAT WAS THE POINT.
6:22:29PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: IT'S BEEN APPROVED.
6:22:31PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I DON'T KNOW HOW IT COULD HAVE BEEN APPROVED
6:22:33PM IF THE DOORS -- YEAH, I'LL HAVE TO ASK STAFF ABOUT THAT.
6:22:36PM HAS THAT PROJECT BEEN APPROVED?
6:22:39PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: I HAVE A LETTER OF APPROVAL IF YOU'D LIKE
6:22:41PM TO SEE IT.
6:22:42PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THAT WOULD BE REALLY INTERESTING BECAUSE THAT
6:22:44PM DOESN'T LOOK LIKE IT HAS DOORS FACING THE STREET EITHER.
6:22:48PM SO WE WOULD HAVE HAD TO HAVE SEEN THAT.
6:22:52PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: I WILL BE HAPPY TO SHARE THE LETTER WITH
6:22:54PM YOU.
6:22:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: CAN YOU SHOW US THE LETTER?
6:22:59PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YEAH, I HAVE TO SEE THE LETTER.
6:23:00PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: I'M GETTING IT.
6:23:02PM JUST A SECOND.
6:23:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
6:23:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
6:23:05PM >>BILL CARLSON: COULD YOU POINT ALSO TO THIS MAP AND SHOW US
6:23:08PM WHERE IT IS ON HERE?
6:23:09PM YOU SAID IT IS ADJACENT.
6:23:10PM WHICH ONE IS IT?
6:23:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: RIGHT THERE TO THE LEFT.
6:23:13PM IT'S HIGHLIGHTED IN WHITE.
6:23:14PM >>BILL CARLSON: THAT ONE, OKAY.
6:23:16PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THERE'S NO DOORS.
6:23:17PM THAT COULDN'T HAVE PASSED WITHOUT OUR APPROVAL.
6:23:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WAS IT ADMINISTRATIVELY --
6:23:21PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WITH THE DOORS.
6:23:22PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: SORRY, FOLKS.
6:23:23PM SORRY FOR INTERRUPTING.
6:23:24PM MARTIN SHELBY, CITY COUNCIL ATTORNEY, IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS,
6:23:27PM PLEASE DIRECT THEM ON THE RECORD AND IF IT'S APPROPRIATE FOR
6:23:30PM STAFF, PLEASE DO SO TO GET THE RESPONSE PROPERLY SAID ON THE
6:23:34PM RECORD.
6:23:35PM THANK YOU.
6:23:38PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: COUNCIL, IT MAY HAVE BEEN A STAFF
6:23:40PM APPROVAL.
6:23:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I WILL ASK THE STAFF.
6:23:42PM STAFF, WAS THIS APPROVED ADMINISTRATIVELY?
6:23:50PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES.
6:23:50PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:23:52PM THIS WAS THROUGH A DESIGN EXCEPTION ONE.
6:23:54PM THAT WAS GRANTED FOR THE ORIENTATION OF THE DOORS.
6:23:58PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IF THEY ARE ALLOWED WITH DESIGN EXCEPTION ONE
6:24:01PM TO DO ORIENTATION, BECAUSE THIS IS A PD, IS THAT THE REASON
6:24:04PM THAT IT'S NOT A DESIGN EXCEPTION FOR THEM?
6:24:05PM LIKE, THAT'S UNCLEAR.
6:24:07PM WHY WOULD IT -- WHY IF THE WAIVER IS FOR THE DOORS FOR THIS
6:24:11PM PROJECT, BUT NOT FOR THAT PROJECT?
6:24:14PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: WELL, THERE ARE A COUPLE OF THINGS.
6:24:16PM CURRENTLY THE PROPERTY IS ZONED RM 16.
6:24:18PM SO THEY COULD GO TO PERMITTING AND DEVELOP UNDER THE RM 16
6:24:24PM STANDARDS.
6:24:25PM THEY ARE REQUESTING AN ADDITIONAL UNIT.
6:24:27PM >>LYNN HURTAK: AH, OKAY.
6:24:30PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YEAH.
6:24:30PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
6:24:31PM OKAY.
6:24:32PM THAT ANSWERS MY QUESTION.
6:24:33PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: WHEN THIS WAS ORIGINALLY SUBMITTED, THERE
6:24:36PM WERE OTHER WAIVERS THAT WERE INVOLVED, WHICH WE'VE REMOVED
6:24:40PM PURSUANT TO THE MEETINGS WITH THE STAFF.
6:24:41PM AT THE TIME --
6:24:44PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THAT WAS JUST MY QUESTION.
6:24:45PM IT WAS ABOUT UNIQUENESS.
6:24:46PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: AT THE TIME, THE PD WAS THE BEST ROUTE.
6:24:49PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
6:24:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN AND COUNCILWOMAN
6:24:54PM HENDERSON.
6:24:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I KNOW YOU SAID YOU WOULD RESOLVE THIS --
6:24:57PM AS I LOOK AT THE DESIGN -- LET ME STATE SOME OF MY POSITIONS
6:24:59PM AS I LOOK AT THIS FIRST.
6:25:02PM I AGREE WITH THE ASSESSMENT BECAUSE I'M ABOUT BUILDING ON
6:25:05PM TRANSPORTATION CORRIDORS, SO I'M VERY SENSITIVE TO THAT AND
6:25:08PM I'M ALSO, I LOOK AT THIS AS A STEP-DOWN DENSITY AREA, PART
6:25:14PM OF OUR PROBLEM AS WE BUILD OUT TAMPA AND CONFORM WITH PRIOR
6:25:19PM BUILDING PATTERNS, AS WE HAVE THESE VERY NARROW COMMERCIAL
6:25:23PM CORRIDORS AND WE DON'T HAVE THE ABILITY TO STEP DOWN DENSITY
6:25:26PM AWAY FROM THE COMMERCIAL CORRIDORS.
6:25:27PM SO I LOOK AT THESE TYPES OF DEVELOPMENTS THAT ARE IN CLOSE
6:25:29PM PROXIMITY TO THE CORRIDORS AS AN OPPORTUNITY TO CREATE THESE
6:25:32PM STEP-DOWN DENSITIES.
6:25:33PM BUT I'M ALSO KEENLY SENSITIVE TO SOME OF THE CONCERNS THAT
6:25:41PM THE NEIGHBORS HAD EXPRESSED, SPECIFICALLY, AGAIN, THE TRASH
6:25:46PM CAN ISSUE.
6:25:47PM I KNOW YOU CAN SAY YOU CAN RESOLVE THAT AFTER THE FACT, BUT
6:25:50PM WHAT ARE THE SOLUTIONS TO THAT?
6:25:52PM IN THE DRIVEWAY, DEFINITELY NOT ABLE TO PUT THEM IN THE
6:25:54PM DRIVEWAY AND CAN'T PUT THEM IN THE GARAGE AND STILL
6:25:56PM ACCOMMODATE THE REQUIRED PARKING.
6:25:57PM SO WHERE ARE THESE TRASH CANS GOING TO GO?
6:26:02PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THERE IS A CODE REQUIREMENT THAT THEY
6:26:03PM HAVE TO BE SCREENED AND STORED ON-SITE.
6:26:07PM SO YOU HAVE TO -- IN ORDER TO GET THROUGH PERMITTING, YOU
6:26:10PM HAVE TO SHOW EXACTLY HOW THAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN.
6:26:16PM YOU CAN'T WAIVE THAT.
6:26:17PM THAT'S NOT A WAIVABLE ISSUE.
6:26:21PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IS STAFF GOOD WITH THAT ANSWER?
6:26:23PM NOT TO BE SHOWN ON THE PLAN?
6:26:27PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES.
6:26:28PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:26:30PM WHAT TYPICALLY HAPPENS IS ON THE INTERNAL DIMENSIONS OF THE
6:26:34PM GARAGE, THEY ARE PROVIDING ADDITIONAL SPACE SO THEY COULD BE
6:26:37PM STORED INSIDE THE GARAGE.
6:26:39PM AND THAT IS ALLOWABLE.
6:26:44PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHAT ARE THE DEPTHS -- WHAT ARE THE SIZES
6:26:47PM OF THE GARAGES?
6:26:52PM >>LYNN HURTAK: MS. DOCK, CAN YOU SHOW US WHERE ON THE
6:26:55PM GARAGE, WHERE THE -- WHAT'S THE WIDTH OF THE GARAGE?
6:26:58PM IT'S NOT ON THE SITE PLAN.
6:27:03PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THIS IS YOUR PAPER.
6:27:07PM I'M SORRY.
6:27:29PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: MR. MICHELINI, WHILE SHE'S LOOKING, CAN I
6:27:32PM ASK YOU A QUESTION?
6:27:33PM WHY DIDN'T THIS PROPERTY DESIGN-BUILD FOR SEVEN INSTEAD OF
6:27:41PM EIGHT?
6:27:41PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THE OWNER WISHED TO HAVE ADDITIONAL UNIT,
6:27:48PM I DON'T HAVE ANY OTHER EXPLANATION OTHER THAN THEY WANTED
6:27:50PM ONE MORE UNIT SO THAT -- PART OF IT HAS TO DO WITH DESIGN.
6:27:54PM PART OF IT HAS TO DO WITH CONSTRUCTION.
6:27:58PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I'M CURIOUS, BECAUSE THAT COULD HAVE GIVEN
6:28:01PM MORE ROOM FOR PARKING FOR A GUEST AND OTHER AREAS IF HE
6:28:04PM WOULD HAVE GONE WITH THE SEVEN TO EIGHT.
6:28:07PM I CAN SEE IN THE -- I THINK ONE OF THE DIFFERENCES IS THAT
6:28:15PM THE OTHER TALLER STRUCTURES ON THAT STREET THAT FACE, THE
6:28:25PM STREET IS LIKE ONE OR TWO UNITS.
6:28:27PM I THINK THAT'S WHAT IT WAS LOOKING LIKE.
6:28:28PM FOUR UNITS, DUPLEXES IN THE BACK OFF THE ALLEY.
6:28:49PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION, 18
6:28:51PM BY 20 IS THE MEASUREMENT FOR THE GARAGE, INSIDE THE GARAGE.
6:28:57PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THAT'S ONLY BUILT JUST BIG ENOUGH TO
6:29:00PM ACCOMMODATE BARELY TWO CARS.
6:29:04PM NOT THAT I'M AN ARCHITECT, DESIGN ARCHITECT, I THINK THAT'S
6:29:09PM JUST BARELY ENOUGH TO FIT TWO CARS BUMPER TO BUMPER, CHEEK
6:29:14PM TO CHEEK.
6:29:14PM TRANSPORTATION.
6:29:20PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: JONATHAN IS HERE.
6:29:24PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WITH THOSE DIMENSIONS, HOW MUCH EXCESS
6:29:26PM ROOM WOULD WE HAVE FOR AN AVERAGE VEHICLE?
6:29:30PM >> JONATHAN SCOTT, MOBILITY TRANSPORTATION.
6:29:31PM NOW, THEY DO HAVE A NOTE OF COMPLIANCE THAT THEY HAVE TO DO
6:29:40PM THE CURBSIDE -- REQUIRED TO STORE THOSE IN THE GARAGE.
6:29:44PM NOW, WE SCALED THE DIMENSIONS BASED ON THE SITE PLAN.
6:29:49PM WE ESTIMATE TO BE 18 BY 20.
6:29:52PM NOW, THAT DOES LEAVE A LITTLE BIT OF ROOM, BUT WE DIDN'T
6:29:56PM HAVE THEM SHOW EXACTLY, BUT WE CAN HAVE THEM DO THAT.
6:30:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SO YOU BASICALLY SHOWED THE ROOM TO
6:30:05PM REQUIRE THE REQUIRED PARKING, NOT THE EXTRA ROOM FOR OTHER.
6:30:11PM >> THAT'S CORRECT.
6:30:11PM IN THIS CASE WE DIDN'T HAVE THEM DO THAT.
6:30:14PM THEY WOULD REASON REQUIRED, SOLID WASTE COLLECTION SHALL BE
6:30:18PM CURBSIDE.
6:30:19PM TENANT OF EACH RESIDENT SHALL BE RESPONSIBLE TO ROLL THE
6:30:22PM REFUSE CART TO AND FROM THE CURB.
6:30:24PM STORED IN CART, SCREEN ENCLOSURES OR INSIDE THE BUILDING.
6:30:28PM THEY HAVE A NOTE OF COMPLIANCE THAT THEY HAVE TO EITHER
6:30:30PM SCREEN THEM OR KEEP THEM INSIDE THE BUILDING.
6:30:33PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IF IT WAS THE WILL OF THE COUNCIL TO
6:30:35PM APPROVE THIS PROJECT, IT COULD A COUNCIL CONDITION THAT
6:30:38PM FIRST FLOOR BE REDESIGNED TO ACCOMMODATE BOTH -- ROOM FOR
6:30:41PM BOTH VEHICLES AND APPROPRIATE SPACE FOR GARBAGE, CORRECT.
6:30:55PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:30:57PM THAT COULD BE A CONDITION FOR THE APPLICANT TO PROVIDE THE
6:30:59PM DIMENSIONS ON THE INTERIOR BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING
6:31:02PM TO CALL THAT OUT ON THE SITE PLAN.
6:31:04PM AND JUST TO MAKE SURE IT'S PROVIDING ENOUGH.
6:31:09PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU.
6:31:09PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: IT COULD ALSO BE AN ENCLOSURE OUTSIDE OF
6:31:12PM THE GARAGES AS WELL.
6:31:14PM IF COUNCIL IS WILLING TO MAKE THAT MOTION, IT SHOULD BE TO
6:31:18PM SHOW THE ACCOMMODATION OF SOLID WASTE.
6:31:22PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IS THAT SOMETHING WITHIN OUR CURRENT CODE
6:31:24PM THAT WOULD PERMIT SOMETHING LIKE THAT IN THIS TYPE OF
6:31:26PM DEVELOPMENT?
6:31:31PM >> JONATHAN SCOTT, MOBILITY TRANSPORTATION.
6:31:34PM THEY HAVE A NOTE OF COMPLIANCE, AND THAT IS A REQUIREMENT
6:31:36PM PER THE CODE, THEY HAVE TO SCREEN IT FROM THE RIGHT-OF-WAY.
6:31:41PM BASICALLY, THEY HAVE THE OPTION OF EITHER PUTTING IT INSIDE
6:31:43PM THE BUILDING OR PUTTING IT IN AN ENCLOSURE.
6:31:45PM THAT IS THE REQUIREMENT OF THE CODE.
6:31:46PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: LIKE IN A MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT AND
6:31:49PM REALLY KIND OF LIKE TWO LOTS THAT WE'RE TURNING INTO EIGHT,
6:31:55PM ABLE TO PUT THAT MANY GARBAGE CANS OUTSIDE IN A SCREENED
6:31:58PM PLACE IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA?
6:32:01PM >> THE REQUIREMENT IS THAT THEY HAVE TO SCREEN IT FROM THE
6:32:03PM RIGHT-OF-WAY.
6:32:04PM THEY ARE ALLOWED TO DO THAT.
6:32:12PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?
6:32:13PM YES, SIR.
6:32:16PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I JUST WANT TO KNOW, THE ITEMS THAT WERE
6:32:18PM SHOWN IN THE OTHER AREA IN THE VICINITY, WHAT ARE THE SIZES?
6:32:21PM HOW MANY UNITS ARE THOSE?
6:32:22PM AND WHAT SIZE PROPERTY ARE THEY?
6:32:24PM I DON'T KNOW.
6:32:25PM WE SEE THESE THINGS HERE, BUT NOTHING TELLS US THE AMOUNT OF
6:32:27PM UNITS OR THE SIZE OR THE LENGTH OR THE WIDTH OR ANYTHING
6:32:30PM ELSE.
6:32:32PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: WELL THE NOTE ON THE PLAN, 8 TOWN HOUSES
6:32:35PM AND THESE ARE THREE UNIT TOWN HOUSES AND IT LOOKS LIKE
6:32:40PM THERE'S SEVEN, LOOKS LIKE THERE ARE SEVEN UNITS THERE.
6:32:44PM THE ONE THAT JUST GOT APPROVED ON TAMPANIA THAT I SHOWED YOU
6:32:50PM IS RIGHT HERE.
6:32:55PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: RIGHT WHERE?
6:32:56PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: IT'S RIGHT IN HERE.
6:32:57PM IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO THE -- PROPERTY.
6:33:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
6:33:07PM ANYTHING ELSE?
6:33:10PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THERE ARE OTHER ONES THERE -- TOWN
6:33:15PM HOUSES, DUPLEXES.
6:33:17PM I'M STRUGGLING TO FIND --
6:33:21PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SAME SIZE FOR SAME AMOUNT OF UNITS.
6:33:24PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: OR MORE.
6:33:25PM SAME NUMBER OF UNITS OR MORE.
6:33:26PM THAT'S WHY I'M STRUGGLING TO SEE HOW IT WASN'T COMPATIBLE.
6:33:31PM BUT I PROFICIENT YOUR CONSIDERATION.
6:33:38PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I'M STRUGGLING WITH THIS AS WELL.
6:33:44PM I'M ACTUALLY OKAY WITH THE INCREASED DENSITY.
6:33:47PM IN FACT, YOU'VE GOT ENTITLEMENT THERE FOR DENSITY.
6:33:50PM IT'S HOW IT'S DEVELOPED OUT.
6:33:53PM I'M ACTUALLY GOING TO LOOK INTO THIS ORLANDO SITUATION
6:33:56PM BECAUSE I'M NOT PARTICULARLY A FAN OF THIS TYPE OF
6:33:58PM DEVELOPMENT EITHER.
6:33:59PM THAT'S NOT FOR ME TO DECIDE RIGHT NOW, WHETHER I LIKE IT OR
6:34:03PM DON'T LIKE IT.
6:34:04PM WHETHER IT COMPLIES WITH THE SCALE AND CONFORMITY WITH THE
6:34:09PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:34:09PM I DO AGREE THAT WE -- I KNOW SOME OF THE NEIGHBORS AREN'T
6:34:15PM GOING TO LIKE IT.
6:34:16PM HONESTLY IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, WE'LL CONTINUE TO GROW, IF
6:34:19PM YOU LIVE ADJACENT TO TRANSPORTATION CORRIDORS, THINGS ARE
6:34:22PM GOING TO CHANGE.
6:34:24PM SOME OF THIS, ESPECIALLY THE NEXT PROPERTIES OVER SHOULD BE
6:34:28PM STEP-DOWN DENSITY AREAS, AND THIS WOULD DEFINITELY CONFORM
6:34:31PM WITH THE STEP-DOWN DENSITY.
6:34:33PM HOW COULD THIS HAVE BEEN DESIGNED?
6:34:43PM DID YOU HAVE PROPOSALS TO DESIGN THIS PROPERTY THAT YOU
6:34:46PM WOULD NOT REQUIRE A PD?
6:34:49PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: WELL, WHEN IT STARTED OFF, YES, BECAUSE
6:34:51PM OF THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY, WE WOULD HAVE FACED THE DRIVEWAYS
6:34:59PM ONTO NORTH B STREET.
6:35:00PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HOW MANY UNITS?
6:35:01PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: YOU WOULD HAVE HAD FOUR UNITS THAT FACE
6:35:04PM NORTH B AND FOUR UNITS THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN IN THE BACK IF
6:35:06PM YOU HAD EIGHT UNITS.
6:35:07PM AND FOUR ON THE BACK THAT WOULD HAVE FACED THE ALLEY.
6:35:12PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHY DID YOU REJECT THAT OR PIVOT FROM
6:35:15PM THAT?
6:35:16PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: BECAUSE WE RAN INTO OBJECTIONS FROM THE
6:35:18PM URBAN DESIGN SECTION REGARDING THE ACCESS AND USABILITY OF
6:35:22PM THE ALLEY.
6:35:23PM WE'RE IN A CATCH 22 HERE.
6:35:27PM WE'VE DISCUSSED THIS BEFORE IN FRONT OF COUNCIL, THAT IF YOU
6:35:30PM MEET THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY AND YOU DON'T HAVE A FUNCTIONAL
6:35:34PM ALLEY, THEN YOU HAVE A TRANSPORTATION OBJECTION.
6:35:37PM IF YOU MEET THE TRANSPORTATION ISSUE, THEN YOU POTENTIALLY
6:35:42PM HAVE AN URBAN DESIGN OBJECTION.
6:35:47PM IT'S SOMETHING THAT THIS IS SORT OF A SIDE COMMENT, BUT THE
6:35:51PM COUNCIL SHOULD REALLY LOOK AT THE USABILITY OF ALLEYS AND
6:35:54PM HOW THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY IS APPLIED.
6:36:00PM IT'S VERY DIFFICULT.
6:36:01PM AND AS I SAID, THIS PROJECT STARTED OFF ALMOST 8 OR 9 MONTHS
6:36:06PM AGO, AND IT'S BEEN THROUGH 3 OR 4 DIFFERENT REITERATIONS.
6:36:10PM AND EACH ONE TRIED TO ELIMINATE WAIVERS, AND THAT'S WHY IT
6:36:16PM CAME TO YOU AND I'VE STRESSED WITH MY CLIENTS WE NEED TO
6:36:20PM ELIMINATE THE WAIVERS AND RESTRICT THEM TO VERY FEW, AS FEW
6:36:25PM AS POSSIBLE SO THAT YOU'RE NOT FACED WITH MAKING HARD
6:36:29PM DECISIONS ABOUT DO YOU ACCEPT THIS WAIVER OR DO YOU NOT
6:36:32PM ACCEPT THIS WAIVER.
6:36:33PM SO WE'VE TRIED TO MINIMIZE THAT AND THE EFFORT THAT YOU SEE
6:36:37PM BEFORE YOU THIS EVENING IS THE RESULT OF THAT EFFORT.
6:36:41PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CLEARLY THIS DIDN'T COME BEFORE ME BECAUSE
6:36:44PM I WOULD HAVE RATHER SEEN THE FORWARD FACING AND REAR FACING
6:36:46PM UNITS, ONE FACING THE ALLEY, ONE FACING NORTH B IN AN URBAN
6:36:50PM DESIGN.
6:36:50PM BUT THAT'S JUST MY PREFERENCE.
6:36:54PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: NO, I UNDERSTAND.
6:36:55PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: BECAUSE YOU KNOW HOW I FEEL ABOUT PDs.
6:36:57PM NOT A BIG FAN.
6:36:59PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: YOU CAN SEE THE ISSUES THAT WE'RE
6:37:00PM STRUGGLING WITH.
6:37:01PM AND SOME OF THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY RESTRICTIONS IN THE CODE
6:37:07PM ARE NOT COMPATIBLE WITH THE WISHES THAT YOU ALL HAVE
6:37:09PM EXPRESSED.
6:37:09PM SO THEN WE'RE FACED, AND THE STAFF IS FACED, WITH EITHER
6:37:13PM FINDING IT CONSISTENT OR INCONSISTENT BASED UPON WHAT WE'VE
6:37:16PM TRIED TO DO.
6:37:17PM WE'RE DAMNED IF WE DO, AND DAMNED IF WE DON'T.
6:37:21PM IT'S A DIFFICULT POSITION TO BE IN.
6:37:24PM WITH ALL RESPECT TO THE COUNCIL, I HATE THAT YOU'RE PUT IN A
6:37:30PM POSITION OF TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO SPLIT THE BABY.
6:37:37PM IT'S JUST A DIFFICULT SITUATION.
6:37:39PM BUT WE TRY.
6:37:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
6:37:43PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I JUST HAVE TO ASK.
6:37:46PM I MEAN, YOU HAD TO COME TO US WITH WAIVERS AT SOME POINT.
6:37:50PM WHY DIDN'T YOU JUST DECIDE TO COME WITH THAT?
6:37:51PM BECAUSE I'M WITH COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:37:53PM IF HAD BEEN FOUR IN THE FRONT AND FOUR TO THE ALLEY, I WOULD
6:37:56PM HAVE HAD NO PROBLEM.
6:37:57PM I WOULD HAVE GIVEN YOU THE WAIVERS FOR THE DRIVEWAYS.
6:38:03PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: WE CAN ALWAYS CONTINUE THE HEARING AND
6:38:05PM COME BACK WITH A REVISED PLAN.
6:38:06PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I CAN'T DO THAT.
6:38:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: AFTER TWO HOURS.
6:38:11PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I'M JUST SAYING THAT -- I'M JUST CURIOUS WHY
6:38:14PM YOU CHOOSE ONE WAIVER OVER ANOTHER, I GUESS, IS --
6:38:18PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: BECAUSE TWO MONTHS AGO, WE RAN INTO
6:38:21PM EXACTLY THE SAME ISSUE AND COUNCIL WAS UPHOLDING THE WEST
6:38:25PM TAMPA OVERLAY AS OPPOSED TO --
6:38:27PM >>LYNN HURTAK: BUT THAT WAS A SINGLE-FAMILY HOME.
6:38:29PM I KNOW EXACTLY WHAT YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT.
6:38:31PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: IT WAS A TOWN HOUSE PROJECT.
6:38:36PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WITH THE REAR-FACING UNITS, DID YOU HAVE
6:38:38PM ISSUES WITH THE TURN RADIUS OF VEHICLES?
6:38:41PM WAS IT A SHORTER DRIVEWAY THAT YOU COULDN'T USE?
6:38:45PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: WE WOULD HAVE HAD A SMALLER AREA BETWEEN
6:38:48PM THE TWO BUILDINGS, SO IT WOULD HAVE BEEN MORE COMPACT, BUT
6:38:55PM WE DID HAVE THE MINIMUM DISTANCE OFF OF THE ALLEY FOR THE
6:38:58PM OTHER FOUR UNITS -- FOR THE DRIVEWAYS I'M TALKING ABOUT.
6:39:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
6:39:06PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
6:39:08PM WHAT IS THE PLEASURE OF COUNCIL?
6:39:13PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
6:39:15PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
6:39:17PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:39:17PM AYE.
6:39:18PM COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
6:39:25PM GO AHEAD.
6:39:26PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I'M JUST GOING TO -- I'M -- I'M JUST GOING TO
6:39:29PM START DENYING THESE.
6:39:30PM LIKE, I'M GOING TO WHOLEHEARTEDLY, THIS IS NOT THE DESIGN WE
6:39:35PM WANT TO SEE IN OUR CITY.
6:39:37PM WE DO NOT WANT TO SEE STREETS BUILT INTO BLOCKS.
6:39:41PM I'M JUST SPEAKING MY MIND.
6:39:45PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THEN I'M GOING TO STOP YOU.
6:39:47PM [ LAUGHTER ]
6:39:47PM AND THE REASON FOR DOING THAT IS BECAUSE I'M GOING TO ASK
6:39:52PM YOU TO NOT MAKE GENERALIZATIONS.
6:39:56PM THAT MAY BE FOR ANOTHER TIME FOR A POLICY DECISION IN
6:39:58PM ANOTHER PLACE.
6:39:59PM HERE ON THE RECORD, YOU HAVE THIS PROPOSAL THAT'S IN FRONT
6:40:02PM OF YOU.
6:40:02PM AND YOU HAVE THE CRITERIA.
6:40:04PM I SUGGEST THAT YOU LOOK TO THE CRITERIA AND I SUGGEST THAT
6:40:08PM YOU APPLY THE FACTS AS YOU FIND THEM TO BE.
6:40:10PM >>LYNN HURTAK: AND I WILL.
6:40:12PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I APPRECIATE THAT.
6:40:13PM I'M GOING TO CAUTION YOU AND CAUTION THE REST OF COUNCIL
6:40:15PM THAT IN ORDER FOR YOU TO MAKE THIS DECISION AND FOR WHATEVER
6:40:21PM DECISION YOU MAKE TO WITHSTAND LEGAL SCRUTINY THAT YOU DO IT
6:40:24PM BASED ON EVIDENCE IN THE RECORD AND NOT ON A BLANKET
6:40:29PM GENERALIZATION.
6:40:30PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
6:40:30PM BUT THIS IS CONSTANT.
6:40:33PM THIS IS CONSISTENT.
6:40:34PM WE ARE CONSTANTLY SEEING THESE PROJECTS THAT COMMUNITIES ARE
6:40:40PM CONCERNED ABOUT.
6:40:41PM SO I'M GOING TO MOVE TO DENY REZ-22-76 FOR THE PROPERTY
6:40:46PM LOCATED AT 2406 WEST NORTH B STREET DUE TO FAILURE OF THE
6:40:51PM APPLICANT TO MEET ITS BURDEN OF PROOF TO PROVIDE COMPETENT
6:40:54PM AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE THAT THE DEVELOPMENT AS CONDITIONED
6:40:56PM AND SHOWN ON THE SITE PLAN IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
6:40:59PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND CODE AND THE APPLICANT'S FAILURE TO
6:41:02PM MEET ITS BURDEN OF PROOF WITH RESPECT TO THE REQUESTED
6:41:04PM WAIVERS.
6:41:05PM MAINLY THAT THE APPLICANT TESTIFIED THAT THIS DEVELOPMENT IS
6:41:09PM UNIQUE AND IN NEED OF WAIVERS, BUT ALSO TESTIFIED THAT THIS
6:41:13PM IS SIMILAR TO OTHER PROPERTIES SURROUNDING IT.
6:41:16PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS SURROUNDED BY SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED
6:41:20PM USES TO THE SOUTH, EAST, AND WEST, AND SINGLE-FAMILY SEMI
6:41:24PM DETACHED TO THE NORTH.
6:41:25PM THE INTRODUCTION OF THE TWO THREE-STORY STRUCTURES FOR TOTAL
6:41:29PM DWELLING OF EIGHT UNITS DOES NOT PROMOTE OR ENCOURAGE
6:41:31PM DEVELOPMENT THAT IS APPROPRIATE IN LOCATION, CHARACTER, AND
6:41:34PM COMPATIBILITY WITH THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:41:36PM SPECIFICALLY WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE PHOTOS THAT WERE GIVEN TO
6:41:39PM US AND PUT INTO THE RECORD, THAT STAFF SHOWED, THAT PHOTO
6:41:44PM THAT WAS ACTUALLY ALSO USED BY THE APPLICANT THAT SHOWED ALL
6:41:47PM OF THE STREET FRONTAGE AND THE HOUSES FACING THE STREETS,
6:41:51PM EVEN THE ONES WITH DRIVEWAYS, WALKABLE, VERY STREET-FACING,
6:41:55PM AND THEN YOU LOOK AT THE PROPERTY AND THE PICTURES THAT WERE
6:41:57PM PROVIDED THAT SHOW TWO FRONTAGES AND THEN A BIG PIECE OF
6:42:01PM CONCRETE THAT IS NOT A DRIVEWAY, BUT IS ALSO NOT A HOUSE.
6:42:07PM THIS IS NOT -- THERE ARE -- THERE'S NO ACCESSIBILITY WITH
6:42:10PM SIDEWALKS.
6:42:13PM THERE'S NO BREAK BETWEEN THE DOORS AND THE GARAGES.
6:42:20PM SO I AM VERY CONCERNED WITH THAT.
6:42:23PM ONE OF THE REASONS I PARTICULARLY DISLIKE THIS PROJECT IS
6:42:28PM BECAUSE THE ENTRANCES FACE THAT INTERIOR CORRIDOR INSTEAD OF
6:42:32PM STICKING WITH THE 7-FOOT SETBACKS TO HAVE THE DOORS FACING
6:42:36PM THE OUTSIDE.
6:42:36PM THIS IS MUCH MORE DANGEROUS.
6:42:40PM AND THAT GOES ALONG WITH THE FACT THAT IT IS NOT UNIQUE AND
6:42:48PM DOES NOT FIT.
6:42:50PM IT ULTIMATELY DOES NOT FIT WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE BLOCK.
6:42:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
6:42:56PM >>BILL CARLSON: SECOND.
6:43:00PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THE SECTION OF THE CODE IS 27-136, PURPOSE OF
6:43:03PM THE SITE PLAN CONTROLLED AREA.
6:43:06PM THAT'S THE ONE.
6:43:07PM BUT I'LL LET COUNCIL MEMBER, SOUNDS LIKE HE WANTS TO ADD
6:43:10PM SOMETHING.
6:43:10PM >>BILL CARLSON: JUST FROM THE EXCERPT WE WERE GIVEN FROM THE
6:43:13PM STAFF REPORT, SECTION 27-136, THE STAFF REPORT HIGHLIGHT
6:43:18PM SAYS THIS PD REQUEST FOR 8 SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED UNITS IS
6:43:22PM OUT OF CHARACTER WITH THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:43:25PM IT SAYS THAT THE ELEVATION SUBMITTED DEPICT THREE-STORY
6:43:29PM STRUCTURES WHICH ARE INCOMPATIBLE WITH THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT
6:43:32PM AND THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT OF 8 UNITS IS NOT APPROPRIATE
6:43:35PM IN LOCATION SURROUNDING PARCELS WHICH CONTAIN ONE OR TWO
6:43:38PM UNITS AND ALSO THE REQUIREMENT THAT GROUND FLOOR ENTRANCES,
6:43:45PM FRONT DOORS TO THE DWELLING UNITS FACE A STREET
6:43:47PM RIGHT-OF-WAY, NOT INCLUDING ALLEYS AND THE STAFF REPORT SAYS
6:43:50PM THIS STANDARD IS NOT MET AS ONLY THE TWO MOST NORTHERN UNITS
6:43:56PM FRONT DOORS FACE NORTH B.
6:43:59PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I'LL ACCEPT THAT AMENDMENT AND ADD THAT THE
6:44:02PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF ALSO FOUND IT DID NOT --
6:44:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WAIT.
6:44:07PM PLANNING COMMISSION FOUND IT CONSISTENT.
6:44:09PM CITY FOUND IT INCONSISTENT.
6:44:11PM >>LYNN HURTAK: BUT PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF SAID IN THEIRS
6:44:13PM THAT BOTH DOORS ARE ORIENTED, SO THEY DID NOT PUT INTO
6:44:17PM CONTEXT THE OTHER SIX UNITS BECAUSE THEY USED THE WORD
6:44:21PM "BOTH."
6:44:21PM SO THAT'S WHY I FIND THE STAFF REPORT IS INCONSISTENT.
6:44:26PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: WELL, SO YOU'RE DISPUTING -- IF I
6:44:30PM UNDERSTAND YOU CORRECTLY -- AND I'M NOT TESTIFYING -- IF I
6:44:34PM HEAR YOU CORRECTLY, YOU'RE SAYING BASED ON WHAT YOU JUST
6:44:37PM STATED, YOU'RE DISPUTING THE FINDING OF CONSISTENCY.
6:44:39PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES, I'M DISPUTING THE FINDING OF CONSISTENCY
6:44:42PM BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T RULE -- THEY DIDN'T LOOK AT THE ACTUAL
6:44:45PM PLAN.
6:44:46PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: AND COUNCILMAN CARLSON, WHAT WERE YOU
6:44:48PM QUOTING THOSE FINDINGS FROM BEFORE --
6:44:51PM >>BILL CARLSON: IT WAS THE EVIDENCE -- EXCERPT OF CITY STAFF
6:44:55PM REPORT AS PRESENTED BY THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:44:57PM REPRESENTATIVES.
6:44:59PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: AND THAT'S IN THE STAFF REPORT.
6:45:00PM >>BILL CARLSON: YEAH, AND PART OF IT WAS FROM SECTION 27-132
6:45:06PM -- SORRY, 136.
6:45:08PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: OKAY.
6:45:08PM THANK YOU.
6:45:09PM >>LYNN HURTAK: AND IT IS NOT CONSISTENT WITH LAND USE POLICY
6:45:13PM 9.2.6 WITH RESPECT TO THE ORIENTATION OF FRONT ENTRANCES.
6:45:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN
6:45:21PM HURTAK WITH A SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
6:45:24PM LET'S TAKE A ROLL CALL VOTE.
6:45:26PM >>THE CLERK: CARLSON?
6:45:28PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
6:45:30PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
6:45:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
6:45:37PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
6:45:39PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
6:45:42PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
6:45:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
6:45:45PM >>THE CLERK: THE MOTION TO DENY CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
6:45:50PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
6:45:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:45:52PM NEXT UP, WE HAVE ITEM NUMBER 3, YES, SIR.
6:45:59PM WE'LL WAIT A MOMENT FOR THE ROOM TO CLEAR A LITTLE BIT.
6:46:07PM DO YOU WANT TO TAKE A RECESS?
6:46:12PM WE'RE GOING TO TAKE A FIVE-MINUTE RECESS.
6:46:17PM [RECESS]
7:04:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ROLL CALL, PLEASE.
7:04:53PM >>BILL CARLSON: HERE.
7:04:54PM >>LYNN HURTAK: HERE.
7:04:55PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HERE.
7:04:57PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: PRESENT.
7:04:58PM >>LUIS VIERA: HERE.
7:04:59PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HERE.
7:05:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
7:05:02PM >>THE CLERK: WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
7:05:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
7:05:05PM ITEM NUMBER 3.
7:05:06PM >> SAM THOMAS, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
7:05:09PM THIS IS AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 3, REZ-23-28, A REQUEST TO REZONE
7:05:16PM 3707 AND 3709 WEST McKAY AVENUE FROM RESIDENTIAL OFFICE TO
7:05:19PM PLANNED DEVELOPMENT FOR SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED.
7:05:20PM THE AUTHORIZED AGENT IS MR. MICHELINI.
7:05:22PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO EMILY WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
7:05:35PM >>EMILY PHELAN: EMILY PHELAN, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
7:05:37PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING
7:05:40PM DISTRICT IN THE GULFVIEW NEIGHBORHOOD.
7:05:42PM THE SITE IS SURROUNDED BY MULTIFAMILY AND LIKE COMMERCIAL AS
7:05:46PM WELL AS RESIDENTIAL OFFICES.
7:05:48PM SOME OF THE COMMERCIAL IS LOCATED ALONG SOUTH DALE MABRY AND
7:05:52PM ALSO SOME OF THE COMMERCIAL AND THE RESIDENTIAL OFFICE IS
7:05:55PM LOCATED ALONG SWANN.
7:05:57PM THIS IS THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
7:06:03PM IT'S REPRESENTED BY THE RESIDENTIAL 20 DESIGNATION.
7:06:07PM THIS SITE IS SURROUNDED BY THE RESIDENTIAL 20 DESIGNATION
7:06:10PM AND IT TRANSITIONS TO CMU 35 ALONG SOUTH DALE MABRY AND ALSO
7:06:14PM ALONG HENDERSON.
7:06:15PM ATTACHED SINGLE-FAMILY USES ARE ENCOURAGED IN THE R-20
7:06:20PM DESIGNATION, DUE TO THE PRESENCE OF MULTIFAMILY USES IN THE
7:06:24PM SURROUNDING AREA, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDS THE USE
7:06:26PM COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE AND THE REQUEST WILL CONTINUE TO
7:06:29PM MAINTAIN THE STABILITY OF EXISTING AREAS WHILE EXPANDING
7:06:33PM OPPORTUNITIES FOR HOUSING CHOICES, SUPPORTED BY THE
7:06:36PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN WITH LAND USE POLICIES 9.5.1 AND 9.5.3.
7:06:41PM THIS SITE IS PRESENTLY VACANT AND THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
7:06:44PM ENCOURAGES COMPATIBLE INFILL DEVELOPMENT ON VACANT AND
7:06:47PM UNDERUTILIZED LANDS.
7:06:49PM LU POLICY 9.2.6 ENCOURAGES ATTACHED SINGLE-FAMILY TO BE
7:06:54PM DESIGNED TO INCLUDE THE ORIENTATION OF THE FRONT DOOR TO
7:06:57PM NEIGHBORHOOD SIDEWALK OR STREET.
7:06:59PM THE PROPOSED ENTRANCES ARE ORIENTED AND CONNECT TO A
7:07:02PM SIDEWALK ALONG WEST McKAY AVENUE, MEETING THE INTENT OF
7:07:04PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
7:07:05PM HOWEVER, IF APPROVED, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REQUESTS
7:07:08PM THAT THE APPLICANT LABEL ALL FRONT DOORS AND SIDEWALKS
7:07:12PM BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
7:07:14PM PROPOSED PLANNED DEVELOPMENT WOULD ALLOW FOR DEVELOPMENT
7:07:17PM COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH THE CHARACTER OF THE
7:07:19PM SURROUNDING USES AND IS CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT
7:07:21PM PATTERN ANTICIPATED UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL 20 FUTURE LAND USE
7:07:25PM DESIGNATION.
7:07:25PM AND THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
7:07:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
7:07:28PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:07:29PM YES, SIR.
7:07:38PM >> START WITH AN AERIAL VIEW.
7:07:40PM HERE IS THE SUBJECT SITE OUTLINED IN RED.
7:07:44PM ALONG WEST McKAY AVENUE.
7:07:45PM IT IS TO THE WEST OF HENDERSON BOULEVARD, BUT TO THE EAST OF
7:07:49PM SOUTH DALE MABRY HIGHWAY.
7:07:51PM THE ZONING AROUND THE SUBJECT SITE IS LARGELY RESIDENTIAL
7:07:54PM OFFICE AND COMMERCIAL GENERAL.
7:07:56PM YOUR COMMERCIAL IS FOUND ALONG DALE MABRY HIGHWAY AND
7:07:58PM HENDERSON BOULEVARD AND THE RESIDENTIAL OFFICE TO THE SOUTH
7:08:01PM OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND TO THE NORTH, TO THE EAST AND WEST
7:08:05PM AND THEN THE COMMERCIAL GENERAL AS WELL AS YOU MOVE NORTH OF
7:08:08PM SWANN AVENUE, YOU DO HAVE SOME RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY 60.
7:08:12PM DIRECTLY NEXT TO THE SUBJECT SITE IS MULTIFAMILY.
7:08:15PM HERE AND HERE.
7:08:16PM HERE IS THE SITE PLAN PROVIDED BY THE APPLICANT.
7:08:30PM SO THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING SIX UNITS AND TWO DIFFERENT
7:08:38PM BUILDINGS.
7:08:38PM BOTH OF THE BUILDINGS ARE ORIENTED TO THE -- BOTH OF THE
7:08:43PM BUILDINGS ARE ORIENTED TO -- ORIENTED TO THE SOUTH WITH THE
7:08:50PM ENTRANCE OFF McKAY AVENUE.
7:08:51PM UNITS ONE AND TWO FACE McKAY AVENUE WHILE THE REST ARE
7:08:55PM INTERNAL.
7:08:55PM THERE ARE PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIONS ALONG THE OUTSIDE PERIPHERY
7:08:58PM OF THE SUBJECT SITE, PROVIDING THOSE CONNECTIONS TO McKAY
7:09:01PM AVENUE.
7:09:01PM THE SITE IS PROVIDING 14 PARKING SPACES AND 14 PARKING
7:09:06PM SPACES ARE REQUIRED.
7:09:07PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS 13,438 SQUARE FEET OR 0.31 ACRES.
7:09:14PM AND THE MAX BUILDING HEIGHT TO BE 35 FEET.
7:09:18PM AS EMILY NOTED EARLIER, THE SUBJECT SITE HAS A RESIDENTIAL
7:09:21PM 20 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION AND THAT ALLOWS THE SITE TO
7:09:24PM BE CONSIDERED FOR FIVE UNITS OR SIX UNITS WITH A BONUS
7:09:27PM AGREEMENT.
7:09:27PM THE APPLICANT HAS ENTERED INTO A BONUS AGREEMENT FOR THE ONE
7:09:30PM ADDITIONAL UNIT FOR AN AMOUNT OF $21,669.
7:09:34PM HERE ARE THE ELEVATIONS OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
7:09:41PM THIS WOULD BE LOOKING FROM McKAY AVENUE.
7:09:45PM THIS WOULD BE LOOKING FROM THE REAR OF THE SITE.
7:09:48PM THIS WOULD BE LOOKING FROM THE INTERNAL DRIVEWAY.
7:09:51PM AND THIS WOULD BE LOOKING FROM EITHER SIDES OF THE PARCELS
7:09:55PM NEXT TO THE SUBJECT SITE.
7:09:56PM HERE IS A PICTURE OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
7:10:12PM THIS IS THE EAST SIDE OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
7:10:15PM THIS IS THE WEST SIDE.
7:10:19PM THIS IS THAT MULTIFAMILY THAT I SPOKE ABOUT EARLIER JUST
7:10:27PM WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
7:10:28PM AND THIS IS THE OTHER MULTIFAMILY JUST SOUTHWEST OF THE
7:10:35PM SUBJECT SITE.
7:10:36PM DIRECTLY EAST OF THE SITE YOU HAVE A SCHOOL.
7:10:45PM THEN DIRECTLY SOUTH OF THE SITE YOU HAVE AN OFFICE BUILDING.
7:10:50PM AND THEN NORTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE ON SWANN AVENUE THIS IS
7:10:54PM WHAT THE SUBJECT SITE BACKS UP TO IS AN OFFICE BUILDING.
7:10:57PM HERE IS THE SITE PLAN AGAIN.
7:11:07PM THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING TWO WAIVERS.
7:11:09PM ONE TO REDUCE THE REQUIRED USE TO USE BUFFER FROM A 15-FOOT
7:11:13PM LANDSCAPE BUFFER WITH A 6-FOOT MASONRY WALL TO 8 FEET
7:11:18PM LANDSCAPE BUFFER WITH 6-FOOT PVC FENCE ON THE NORTH SIDE, A
7:11:21PM 3-FOOT LANDSCAPE BUFFER AND NO WALL ON THE EAST SIDE AND TO
7:11:24PM REDUCE THE REQUIRED 5-FOOT LANDSCAPE BUFFER TO 3 FEET ON THE
7:11:29PM WEST SIDE.
7:11:30PM THE SECOND WAIVER IS TO REQUEST TO ALLOW THE FRONT DOORS TO
7:11:33PM FACE THE SIDE YARD PROPERTY LINES.
7:11:35PM DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION AND COMPLIANCE STAFF REVIEWED THE
7:11:37PM APPLICATION AND FIND THE REQUEST INCONSISTENT WITH THE LAND
7:11:39PM DEVELOPMENT CODE.
7:11:40PM THIS IS DUE TO FINDINGS FROM DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION AND
7:11:43PM NATURAL RESOURCES.
7:11:44PM WHILE THE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE
7:11:46PM AREA, THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING TO DEMO ALL EXISTING
7:11:49PM BUILDINGS ON THE SUBJECT SIDE PROVIDING THEM WITH A BLANK
7:11:51PM SLATE TO DESIGN BUILDINGS WITH A MORE APPROPRIATE DESIGN
7:11:54PM THAT WOULD NOT REQUIRE WAIVERS WHILE REQUESTING A BONUS
7:11:56PM AGREEMENT.
7:11:56PM YOU CAN REVIEW THE FINDINGS FROM DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION
7:11:58PM AND NATURAL RESOURCES RELATING TO THE WAIVERS REQUESTED IN
7:12:01PM THE STAFF REPORT.
7:12:02PM NATURAL RESOURCES ANALYSIS CAN BE FOUND TOWARDS THE TOP OF
7:12:04PM PAGE 3, AND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION ANALYSIS CAN BE FOUND
7:12:07PM ON PAGE 4, ITEM 6.
7:12:09PM SHOULD COUNCIL APPROVE THE REQUEST, THE APPLICANT MUST
7:12:12PM PROVIDE REVISIONS AS STATED ON THE REVISED REVISION SHEET
7:12:15PM BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
7:12:16PM I'M AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
7:12:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
7:12:18PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:12:20PM APPLICANT?
7:12:31PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
7:12:32PM STEVE MICHELINI.
7:12:34PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
7:12:35PM THIS PROJECT CONSISTS OF REMOVING TWO OFFICES AND AS STAFF
7:12:42PM HAS POINTED OUT, IT'S IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO AND SURROUNDED
7:12:47PM BY COMMERCIAL OFFICES.
7:12:57PM I WANT TO KIND OF TAKE YOU ALONG A LITTLE TOUR HERE.
7:13:02PM THIS IS STERLING HERE AND THIS IS McKAY HERE.
7:13:10PM AND THIS IS McKAY IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO THE SUBJECT
7:13:15PM PROPERTY.
7:13:21PM THIS IS AT THE CORNER OF DALE MABRY AND McKAY.
7:13:23PM THIS IS ACROSS THE STREET.
7:13:28PM THIS IS THE PARKING LOT THAT'S ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE
7:13:32PM SUBJECT PROPERTY.
7:13:33PM HERE IS THE SUBJECT PROPERTY.
7:13:38PM THERE AND THERE.
7:13:39PM THERE'S MORE OFFICES.
7:13:41PM THIS IS IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO IT ON THE WEST SIDE.
7:13:46PM THIS IS THE APARTMENT BUILDING.
7:13:48PM AND THERE IS A PICTURE OF THE APARTMENT BUILDING.
7:13:51PM AND THEN THIS BACKS UP TO THE PROPERTY.
7:13:56PM THIS IS THE VERIZON CELL PHONE STORE.
7:14:01PM THIS IS ACROSS THE STREET.
7:14:06PM THIS IS DOWN THE STREET A LITTLE BIT TO THE WEST.
7:14:09PM AND THERE IS ANOTHER PICTURE OF IT TO THE WEST.
7:14:11PM THE PROPOSAL IS FOR SIX UNITS, 5.35 OR SOMETHING CAN BE
7:14:18PM BUILT BY RIGHT.
7:14:20PM THE REQUEST IS FOR THE BONUS PROVISION TO ALLOW SIX UNITS.
7:14:24PM IT MEETS THE PARKING CODE.
7:14:25PM THE HEIGHT IS LIMITED TO 35 FEET.
7:14:29PM ALL OF THE PARKING REQUIREMENTS ARE MET.
7:14:32PM THE TWO OFFICES ARE TO BE REMOVED.
7:14:37PM LET ME JUST GIVE YOU A LITTLE AERIAL ORIENTATION HERE.
7:14:43PM THIS IS THE PARKING LOT TO THE NORTH AND IT BACKS UP TO THE
7:14:58PM SUBJECT PROPERTY.
7:14:59PM BETTER VIEW.
7:15:05PM THIS GIVES YOU THE APARTMENT BUILDING HERE, APARTMENT
7:15:08PM BUILDING HERE.
7:15:08PM THESE ARE THE TWO BUILDINGS TO BE REMOVED AND THIS IS
7:15:12PM ANOTHER OFFICE DAY CARE IMMEDIATELY TO THE WEST.
7:15:14PM I LOST ONE.
7:15:25PM AGAIN, AERIAL VIEW, HENDERSON, STERLING, DALE MABRY IS RIGHT
7:15:30PM OVER HERE.
7:15:31PM THIS IS SWANN AVENUE, AND THE PROPERTY BACKS UP TO AN
7:15:36PM APARTMENT BUILDING WITH A PARKING LOT.
7:15:39PM A DIFFERENT VIEW A LITTLE CLOSER IN.
7:15:47PM APARTMENT BUILDING, PROPOSED REDEVELOPMENT SITE HERE AND THE
7:15:52PM OTHER OFFICES DOWN THE STREET.
7:15:53PM THIS IS THE SITE PLAN.
7:16:02PM THERE'S NO ALLEY OR ACCESS HERE.
7:16:05PM THIS IS ALL OFF OF McKAY.
7:16:07PM AND WE'RE PROVIDING THE GREENSPACE AND THE VISITOR PARKING
7:16:11PM AS REQUIRED.
7:16:14PM AS THE STAFF HAS POINTED OUT, THE R-20 IS DESIGNATED AS A
7:16:20PM REDEVELOPMENT AREA.
7:16:21PM THERE AREN'T ANY SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ANYWHERE AROUND
7:16:26PM HERE.
7:16:27PM THIS IS ALL COMMERCIAL OR MULTIFAMILY.
7:16:32PM WITH RESPECT TO MEETING THE CODE, IT SAYS TO PROMOTE -- AND
7:16:46PM THIS IS THE STAFF REPORT -- PROMOTE THE SUFFICIENT AND
7:16:50PM SUSTAINABLE USE OF LAND AND INFRASTRUCTURE.
7:16:52PM IT WAS FOUND THAT WE DO MEET THAT REQUIREMENT.
7:16:55PM I THINK THAT THE ISSUE REGARDING THE BUFFERS AND THE
7:16:59PM LANDSCAPING, WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE SURROUNDING PROPERTIES,
7:17:02PM WHAT ARE WE BUFFERING FROM?
7:17:03PM WE'RE BUFFERING FROM THE BACK OF AN APARTMENT BUILDING, A
7:17:06PM PARKING LOT ON THE NORTH SIDE OR AN EXISTING BUILDING ON THE
7:17:11PM EAST SIDE OR ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE COMMERCIAL
7:17:17PM PROPERTIES OVER THERE.
7:17:18PM ALLOW THE INTEGRATION OF DIFFERENT LAND USES AND DENSITIES.
7:17:22PM THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING TO MEET THAT THROUGH THE R-20
7:17:28PM FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION AS, AGAIN, FIVE UNITS BY RIGHT,
7:17:32PM ONE UNIT ADDITIONAL UNIT THROUGH THE BONUS DENSITY.
7:17:35PM ENCOURAGE FLEXIBLE LAND DEVELOPMENT.
7:17:37PM THE SITE IS DESIGNATED WITH PEDESTRIAN WALKWAYS SURROUNDING
7:17:40PM THE BUILDING, WHICH TAKES THE RESIDENTS OUT TO McKAY.
7:17:44PM PROMOTE AND ENCOURAGE DEVELOPMENT WHERE APPROPRIATE IN
7:17:49PM LOCATION.
7:17:50PM PROBABLY FEWER SITES THAT ARE BETTER SUITED FOR THAT THAN
7:17:54PM THIS ONE, JUST BASED UPON THE FACT THAT IT'S SURROUNDED BY
7:17:58PM COMMERCIAL AND MULTIFAMILY.
7:17:59PM PROMOTE THE MORE DESIRABLE LIVING CONDITIONS.
7:18:03PM THIS WILL TAKE AN UNDERUTILIZED PROPERTY, WHICH IS THE TWO
7:18:08PM RESIDENTIAL OFFICES AND CONVERT THEM INTO HOUSING.
7:18:12PM WE ARE BELOW THE RESIDENTIAL 20 DESIGNATION.
7:18:31PM AND THE F.A.R. IS .5.
7:18:34PM BASED ON THE ACREAGE THAT WE'RE ALLOWED.
7:18:38PM 6,719 SQUARE FEET.
7:18:40PM THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS SURROUNDED BY MULTIFAMILY, LIKE
7:18:45PM COMMERCIAL AND RESIDENTIAL OFFICES.
7:18:46PM THE OBJECTIVE THAT WE'RE MEETING IS REGULATE THE LEVELS OF
7:18:50PM BUILDING INTENSITY ACCORDING TO THE STANDARDS AND LAND USE
7:18:53PM DESIGNATIONS IN ORDER TO MEET THE PROJECTED POPULATION OF
7:18:56PM 150,000 PEOPLE AND 157,000 EMPLOYEES BY 2040.
7:19:02PM USE LIMITED RESOURCES FOR EFFICIENT IN PURSUIT OF
7:19:06PM DEVELOPMENT PATTERN AND MORE ECONOMICALLY SOUND.
7:19:07PM THIS IS AN UNDERUTILIZED PARCEL OF LAND AND BY PUTTING IN --
7:19:18PM MORE COMPATIBLE WITH THE SURROUNDING PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT.
7:19:20PM IMPROVE THE PEDESTRIAN CONNECTION THROUGH -- LESS THAN HALF
7:19:29PM A BLOCK OFF OF HENDERSON AND WE BACK UP TO SWANN.
7:19:34PM IF YOU'RE FAMILIAR WITH THIS, THIS AREA IS VERY HEAVILY
7:19:41PM COMMERCIALIZED.
7:19:42PM ALL EXISTING AND FUTURE LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS SHOULD
7:19:45PM BE CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
7:19:47PM WE HAVE MET THAT.
7:19:48PM DEVELOPMENT SHALL NOT EXCEED THE DENSITIES.
7:19:50PM WE ARE NOT EXCEEDING THE DENSITIES IN THE BONUS -- AND THE
7:19:53PM BONUS PROVISION ALLOWS FOR THAT ADDITIONAL UNIT.
7:19:56PM EACH LAND USE CATEGORY SHALL HAVE A UNIQUE SET OF ZONING
7:19:59PM DISTRICTS WHICH MAY BE PERMITTED AND THIS IS PERMITTED.
7:20:01PM THE HOUSING IS PERMITTED UNDER THIS DESIGNATION.
7:20:03PM ENSURE THAT THERE IS AN ADEQUATE AMOUNT OF LAND PLANNED FOR
7:20:07PM RESIDENTIAL PURPOSES TO ACCOMMODATE PROJECTED POPULATION.
7:20:10PM THIS IS AN UNDERUTILIZED PARCEL, WHICH WILL INCREASE THE
7:20:16PM INTENSITY OF THE DEVELOPMENT AND ALLOW FOR MORE RESIDENTIAL.
7:20:19PM ENCOURAGE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED AND MULTIFAMILY
7:20:23PM DEVELOPMENTS TO BE DESIGNED AND INCLUDE ORIENTATION OF THE
7:20:26PM FRONT DOORS.
7:20:27PM THE FRONT TWO UNITS FACE McKAY.
7:20:30PM THE OTHER FOUR UNITS DO NOT.
7:20:32PM THEY ARE INTERIOR ORIENTED BUT THEY DO HAVE CONNECTING
7:20:35PM SIDEWALKS AND THE SIDEWALKS ARE ON THE OUTSIDE OF THE
7:20:38PM BUILDING, NOT IN THE DRIVE AISLE.
7:20:40PM YOU CAN SEE THAT ON THE SITE PLAN HERE.
7:20:43PM GENERALLY LOCATION OF SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED SHALL BE
7:20:49PM LIMITED TO THE PERIPHERY OF ESTABLISHED SINGLE-FAMILY
7:20:51PM DETACHED NEIGHBORHOODS.
7:20:52PM HOWEVER, SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED MAY BE CONSIDERED AND
7:20:55PM DEMONSTRATED AS INTEGRATED.
7:20:57PM THERE AREN'T ANY SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED STRUCTURES IN THIS
7:21:00PM AREA.
7:21:00PM THEY ARE ALL COMMERCIAL, MULTIFAMILY OR OFFICE USES.
7:21:04PM AS I SAID, WE BACK UP TO THE PARKING LOT FOR ANOTHER
7:21:11PM MULTIFAMILY PROJECT, AND WE'RE DIAGONALLY ACROSS FROM THE
7:21:15PM BACK OF THE VERIZON CELL PHONE STORE.
7:21:19PM GENERALLY, THE LOCATION OR THE INTENT SHALL BE MINIMALLY
7:21:27PM DISRUPTIVE TO ADJACENT AREAS.
7:21:29PM THIS WILL NOT HAVE ANY ADVERSE IMPACT ON ANY ADJACENT
7:21:32PM PROPERTIES AS THEY ARE ALL EITHER MORE INTENSELY DEVELOPED
7:21:35PM OR EQUALLY INTENSIVE.
7:21:37PM MAINTAIN THE SUSTAINABILITY OF EXISTING AREAS WHILE
7:21:40PM EXPANDING OPPORTUNITIES FOR HOUSING.
7:21:42PM IT MEETS THAT CRITERIA.
7:21:43PM PROTECT THE LOW DENSITY AND SINGLE-FAMILY AREAS THAT PROVIDE
7:21:46PM OPPORTUNITIES FOR HOME OWNERSHIP THAT ARE ATTRACTED TO
7:21:49PM HOUSEHOLDS.
7:21:50PM THERE AREN'T ANY SINGLE-FAMILY HOUSES IN THIS IMMEDIATE
7:21:52PM VICINITY.
7:21:53PM ENSURE THE ADEQUATE SUPPLY OF HOUSING, DESIGNATE THE
7:21:58PM SUFFICIENT LAND FOR RESIDENTIAL GROWTH AND ACCOMMODATIONS.
7:22:02PM CONTINUE TO MONITOR THIS AS IT MOVES FORWARD.
7:22:06PM THE TWO OFFICES ARE TO BE REMOVED, WHICH ARE UNDERPERFORMING
7:22:10PM AND ADD VERY LITTLE TO THE ECONOMY IN THIS AREA.
7:22:14PM THE HOUSING WILL PROVIDE ADDITIONAL UNITS.
7:22:20PM THE POLICY IS TO ENCOURAGE RESIDENTIAL DESIGNATION AND WE'RE
7:22:24PM BELOW THE RESIDENTIAL 20 DESIGNATION.
7:22:25PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION HAS REVIEWED THIS AND FOUND NO
7:22:28PM ADVERSE IMPACTS ON THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD, AND THE
7:22:31PM REQUEST PROPOSES SIX ATTACHED SINGLE-FAMILY UNITS WHICH ALL
7:22:35PM MEET LAND USE POLICIES 2.1.2, 9.2.1, 9.3.8, AND LAND USE
7:22:42PM POLICY 9.26 ENCOURAGES ATTACHED SINGLE-FAMILY DEVELOPMENTS
7:22:46PM TO BE DESIGNED TO INCLUDE THE ORIENTATION TO THE FRONT.
7:22:50PM AND WE'VE DONE THAT EXCEPT FOR THE FOUR UNITS.
7:22:53PM WE HAVE A FIVE FOOT SIDEWALK PROPOSED ALONG McKAY AND THE
7:22:59PM CONNECTING SIDEWALKS FROM EACH OF THE UNITS GOING TO CONNECT
7:23:03PM TO McKAY.
7:23:04PM ADDITIONALLY, THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS VACANT; HOWEVER, IT
7:23:09PM ENCOURAGES COMPATIBLE INFILL DEVELOPMENT ON POLICIES 1.3.1,
7:23:13PM 1.3.3, 1.3.4, AND LAND USE POLICY 2.12.
7:23:19PM AND THE CONCLUSION FOUND BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION WAS THAT
7:23:24PM IF APPROVED THAT THE PLANNING COMMISSION HAD ASKED TO LABEL
7:23:29PM THE FRONT DOORS AND SIDEWALKS BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
7:23:32PM READING, AND THEY DID FIND IT CONSISTENT.
7:23:35PM THIS PROPERTY IS VERY SIMILAR TO OTHER PROPERTIES IN THE
7:23:40PM AREA.
7:23:40PM I BELIEVE THAT WE HAVE MET THE INTENT OF THE CODE, AND IT
7:23:46PM TRANSFORMS AN UNDERUTILIZED PARCEL AND MAKES IT MORE
7:23:50PM CONFORMING AND MAKES IT MORE PRODUCTIVE FOR THE
7:23:53PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
7:23:54PM RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL AND I WOULD BE HAPPY TO
7:23:58PM ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
7:23:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
7:23:59PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
7:24:02PM IS THERE ANYBODY FROM THE PUBLIC?
7:24:03PM YES, SIR.
7:24:06PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN HE GO THROUGH THE SETBACKS ON THAT?
7:24:08PM I TRIED TO READ THEM BUT IT'S KIND OF DIFFICULT.
7:24:17PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: 7.59.
7:24:19PM THIS IS ON THE WEST SIDE.
7:24:21PM AND 3 FEET ON THE EAST SIDE.
7:24:25PM AND THERE WAS A 6-FOOT PVC FENCE PROPOSED OVER HERE, AND PVC
7:24:31PM FENCE OVER HERE.
7:24:32PM THIS SIDE IS THE APARTMENT BUILDING SIDE.
7:24:34PM AND THAT'S --
7:24:39PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THAT'S THREE FEET FROM THE SIDEWALK.
7:24:40PM WHAT IS IT FROM THE BUILDING?
7:24:42PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THAT'S THAT ONE.
7:24:44PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: GO BACK TO THE SITE PLAN.
7:24:47PM IS THAT THREE FEET FROM THE SIDEWALK OR THREE FEET FROM THE
7:24:50PM BUILDING?
7:24:50PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: FROM THE BUILDING.
7:24:52PM THIS IS THREE FEET FROM THE SIDEWALK, AND THIS IS SEVEN
7:24:57PM FEET, ALMOST 8 FEET, 7.5 FEET FROM THE BUILDING.
7:25:01PM THERE IS A FOUR-FOOT BUFFER BEING PROVIDED HERE, AND THEN
7:25:08PM THERE IS A THREE-FOOT BUFFER BEING PROVIDED OVER HERE.
7:25:14PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: FROM THE LOT LINE TO THE BUILDING, WHAT IS
7:25:18PM THAT DISTANCE, ON THE OTHER SIDE?
7:25:19PM I SEE THAT SIDE.
7:25:21PM WHAT IS THAT?
7:25:25PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: 7.5 IT LOOKS LIKE.
7:25:29PM THE SIDEWALK INCLUDED.
7:25:30PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OKAY.
7:25:31PM I COULDN'T READ THAT.
7:25:33PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: 3 PLUS 4.5.
7:25:36PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: GOT IT.
7:25:37PM OKAY.
7:25:39PM THAT CLEARS IT UP.
7:25:40PM THANK YOU SO MUCH.
7:25:40PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: JUST FOR THE RECORD, WE HAVE NOT RECEIVED
7:25:44PM ANY CALLS OR COMMENTS REGARDING THIS PROJECT AND NO ONE HAS
7:25:48PM CALLED AND EXPRESSED ANY CONCERN.
7:25:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
7:25:52PM PUBLIC COMMENT?
7:25:53PM IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK -- YES, SIR.
7:25:56PM STATE YOUR NAME.
7:25:56PM PLEASE APPROACH THE LECTERN.
7:26:14PM >> FIRST OF ALL, I WOULD LIKE TO APOLOGIZE.
7:26:16PM I HAD TO BRING THEM DUE TO SOME TECHNICAL ISSUES.
7:26:18PM BUT MY NAME IS DAYTON BURCHFIELD.
7:26:22PM I'M SPEAKING AGAINST.
7:26:24PM SPECIFICALLY DUE TO THE PRESENCE OF WATERMELON SWIM SCHOOL
7:26:29PM DIRECTLY ADJACENT TO THIS PROPERTY.
7:26:31PM I FEEL LIKE NOT ENOUGH SURVEY HAS BEEN DONE WITH REGARD TO
7:26:35PM THE AMOUNT OF TRAFFIC THAT OCCURS IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD.
7:26:40PM SPECIFICALLY DIRECTLY NEXT DOOR TO THE WEST.
7:26:43PM WATERMELON SWIM SCHOOL HANDLES 30-MINUTE CLASSES.
7:26:47PM THERE ARE 6 PEOPLE -- THERE ARE 6 PARENTS AND TODDLERS PER
7:26:52PM CLASS IN 30-MINUTE PERIODS ON TOP OF AN ENTIRE TWO, THREE
7:26:58PM MORE OTHER CLASSES WITH A TOTAL OF 12.
7:27:02PM SO A TOTAL OF 18 CHILDREN IN THE POOL EVERY 30 MINUTES.
7:27:06PM THE PARKING LOT PICTURES THAT WERE PRESENTED ARE VERY
7:27:09PM MISLEADING BEFORE THE COUNCIL.
7:27:11PM ALL OF THOSE PARKING LOTS DIRECTLY ADJACENT ARE FULL.
7:27:17PM THERE ARE CARS IN THE LOT DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET TO THE
7:27:21PM SOUTH, AND THE ENTIRE AREA IS VERY BUSY, SPECIFICALLY DURING
7:27:26PM AND IMMEDIATELY AFTER RUSH HOUR.
7:27:29PM AND INCLUDING ON WEEKENDS AND LATE IN THE EVENING.
7:27:35PM I JUST WANTED TO BRING THAT TO THE COUNCIL'S ATTENTION AS IT
7:27:42PM DOES NOT SEEM TO BE WELL REPRESENTED ON THE DOCUMENTS
7:27:46PM PRESENTED.
7:27:47PM AND FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION.
7:27:49PM THANK YOU.
7:27:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
7:27:51PM >> ABSOLUTELY.
7:27:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
7:27:52PM NEXT SPEAKER.
7:27:53PM YES, SIR.
7:28:03PM >> HELLO, COUNCIL.
7:28:05PM MY NAME IS BOB WHITMORE.
7:28:07PM EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF CITY TREE.
7:28:09PM THIS IS A PICTURE FROM THE CITY TREE SATELLITE THAT WE HAVE
7:28:15PM HIGH ABOVE EARTH.
7:28:16PM AND IT SHOWS A COUPLE OF TREES, ONE IN THE FRONT, MOVE IT
7:28:22PM DOWN -- ONE TREE IN THE FRONT.
7:28:26PM I'M CURIOUS WHAT'S GOING ON WITH THAT.
7:28:30PM IT IS A BIG ONE IN THE BACK.
7:28:32PM I'M CURIOUS WHAT'S GOING ON WITH THAT.
7:28:33PM SINCE WE'RE HAVING TO FIGHT FOR THE CANOPY ONE TREE AT A
7:28:41PM TIME, I'M GOING TO GO AHEAD AND BRING THIS UP AS A
7:28:45PM POSSIBILITY THAT IT MIGHT HAVE BEEN OVERLOOKED, AND YOU ALL
7:28:49PM CAN ASK IF NATURAL RESOURCES HAS ANYTHING ON THIS.
7:28:53PM I WON'T TAKE UP ANY MORE OF YOUR TIME.
7:28:55PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
7:28:56PM >> YOU'RE WELCOME.
7:28:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
7:28:57PM GO AHEAD.
7:29:06PM >> GOOD EVENING.
7:29:07PM STEPHANIE POYNOR.
7:29:08PM I'D LIKE TO POINT OUT THAT THIS DRIVEWAY IS FOUR FEET
7:29:13PM NARROWER THAN THE PLANS WE SAW EARLIER TODAY.
7:29:16PM LET'S PUT OUR 18 SQUARE FEET OF GARBAGE CANS IN THERE AND
7:29:22PM SEE HOW THOSE FIT.
7:29:25PM IT WAS PROBABLY VACANT.
7:29:27PM I LOVE IT WHEN DEVELOPERS COME UP HERE AND TELL US IT'S
7:29:30PM VACANT LAND.
7:29:30PM WELL, YOU SHOWED US PICTURES WITH BUILDINGS ON IT, SO IT'S
7:29:33PM NOT VACANT.
7:29:33PM A THREE-FOOT BUFFER.
7:29:36PM PLEASE TELL ME HOW YOU'RE GOING TO PAINT THAT BUILDING.
7:29:39PM SERIOUSLY, THREE FEET.
7:29:40PM THIS WIDE.
7:29:42PM THOSE GUYS ARE GOING TO PAINT THAT BUILDING IN A THREE-FOOT
7:29:45PM BUFFER BECAUSE HE'S GOING TO PUT A FENCE THERE, YOU KNOW
7:29:48PM WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN, THEY ARE GOING TO TAKE THE FENCE
7:29:50PM DOWN TO PAINT THE BUILDING.
7:29:51PM WHAT HAPPENS IF THERE IS A STUCCO PROBLEM?
7:29:53PM YOU GOT TO TAKE THE FENCE DOWN TO FIX THE STUCCO.
7:29:56PM IF YOU GOT A BROKEN WINDOW, THAT WILL BE FUN.
7:29:59PM BUT I JUST WANTED TO POINT OUT SOME OF THE, LIKE, OBVIOUS
7:30:05PM STUFF.
7:30:05PM SOUTH TAMPA IS FULL.
7:30:07PM NOBODY WAS EVACUATING FROM THOSE TWO OFFICES.
7:30:12PM JUST SAYING.
7:30:12PM HAVE A GOOD EVENING.
7:30:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:30:14PM ANYBODY ELSE WISH TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 3?
7:30:17PM IF NOT, WE WILL ASK ERIN A QUESTION REAL QUICK REGARDING THE
7:30:24PM TREES ON THE SITE THAT WERE SHOWN.
7:30:33PM >>ERIN MAEHR: ERIN MAEHR, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
7:30:37PM I DON'T HAVE HIS IMAGE.
7:30:37PM THE TREE IN THE FRONT, IT IS A STREET TREE.
7:30:40PM THAT TREE IS BEING PRESERVED.
7:30:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE ONE ON THE BOTTOM PART OF THE PHOTO.
7:30:44PM >>ERIN MAEHR: YEAH, ALONG THE RIGHT-OF-WAY.
7:30:46PM THE TREE IN THE BACK WAS A 30-INCH LIVE OAK.
7:30:49PM THAT WAS SUBMITTED AND REMOVED UNDER A DANGEROUS TREE
7:30:52PM LETTER.
7:30:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IT WAS ALREADY REMOVED.
7:30:56PM >>ERIN MAEHR: IT WAS, YES.
7:30:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:30:57PM ANY QUESTIONS FROM COUNCIL?
7:30:59PM THERE WAS NOBODY ELSE REGISTERED.
7:31:02PM MR. MICHELINI, DO YOU HAVE REBUTTAL?
7:31:10PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: COUNCIL, HERE IS A PICTURE OF THE SWIM
7:31:14PM SCHOOL THAT'S ADJACENT TO THE PROPERTY.
7:31:16PM YOU CAN SEE BACK HERE IS THE PROPERTY THAT'S TO BE
7:31:20PM DEVELOPED.
7:31:20PM WE CAN'T BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR OFF-SITE PARKING FOR
7:31:25PM ANOTHER BUSINESS AND HOW THEY OPERATE OR WHAT PARKING THAT
7:31:28PM THEY ARE PROVIDING OR HOW MANY STUDENTS THAT THEY HAVE.
7:31:32PM I CAN TELL YOU THAT OUR PROPERTY WILL HAVE THE REQUIRED
7:31:35PM NUMBER OF PARKING SPACES, PLUS VISITOR SPACES, AND THERE'S
7:31:40PM NO WAIVER ON SOLID WASTE.
7:31:41PM WE HAVE TO MEET THE CODE.
7:31:43PM SO I DROVE THIS PROPERTY SEVERAL TIMES, AND DROVE ALL THE
7:31:51PM WAY AROUND THE ENTIRE PERIMETER OF THIS PROPERTY ALL THE WAY
7:31:55PM FROM SWANN TO DALE MABRY TO HENDERSON TO STERLING, AND
7:32:00PM PERSONALLY DID NOT FIND ANY INCOMPATIBLE USE THAT WOULD IN
7:32:04PM ANY WAY, THAT THIS PROJECT WOULD IN ANY WAY ADVERSELY AFFECT
7:32:09PM ANYBODY ELSE.
7:32:10PM AS I SAID, WE RECEIVED NO OBJECTIONS FROM ANYONE.
7:32:14PM NO ONE HAS CALLED.
7:32:15PM NO ONE SAID ANYTHING.
7:32:16PM THE GENTLEMAN I UNDERSTAND HE'S CONCERNED ABOUT CARS GOING
7:32:20PM IN AND OUT OF A SWIM SCHOOL.
7:32:22PM I CAN'T CONTROL THAT AND I CAN'T CONTROL OFF-SITE PARKING
7:32:27PM REQUIREMENTS.
7:32:27PM AS YOU SEE, IF YOU LOOK AT THAT, THEIR PARKING EITHER BACKS
7:32:34PM INTO OR DRIVES INTO THE RIGHT-OF-WAY ON BOTH SIDES OF THE
7:32:36PM STREET.
7:32:37PM IF THEY WERE TO GO THROUGH A REZONING OR PERMITTING, THEY
7:32:41PM WOULDN'T BE ALLOWED TO DO THAT.
7:32:44PM ANYWAY, OUR PARKING IS COMPATIBLE.
7:32:48PM IT DOES MEET THE CODE, AND WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR
7:32:52PM APPROVAL.
7:32:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FROM COUNCIL?
7:32:55PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: I WOULD BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS
7:32:57PM YOU MIGHT HAVE.
7:32:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NONE.
7:32:59PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE THE HEARING?
7:33:01PM MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
7:33:03PM SECOND BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
7:33:05PM ALL IN FAVOR?
7:33:06PM ANY OPPOSED?
7:33:07PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA, WOULD YOU LIKE TO READ ITEM NUMBER 3?
7:33:19PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I'M ULTIMATELY CONCERNED ABOUT THIS BECAUSE
7:33:24PM THEY ARE ASKING FOR MORE, AND THE PEOPLE WHO CAME UP TALKED
7:33:29PM ABOUT THINGS THAT OUR STAFF MENTIONED WERE A PROBLEM.
7:33:34PM THE AREA AROUND THE PROPERTY NOT ENOUGH GREENSPACE, AND THEN
7:33:39PM THE WAIVER FOR DOORS.
7:33:42PM I DON'T THINK IT FITS IN THE SPACE.
7:33:45PM I THINK THAT FIVE UNITS MIGHT FIT, BUT PROBABLY FOUR WOULD
7:33:47PM FIT BETTER.
7:33:48PM I THINK WE'RE JUST TRYING TO SHOEHORN TOO MUCH INTO AN
7:33:52PM ALREADY BUSY STREET.
7:33:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:33:53PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
7:33:55PM WE CLOSED THE HEARING.
7:34:05PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: FILE REZ-23-28, ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED
7:34:09PM FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE REZONING
7:34:11PM PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 3707, 3709 WEST McKAY
7:34:16PM AVENUE IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, AND MORE PARTICULARLY
7:34:18PM DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1, ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION RO-1
7:34:23PM (RESIDENTIAL OFFICE) TO PD (PLANNED DEVELOPMENT,
7:34:26PM RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED); PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
7:34:29PM DATE.
7:34:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THERE IS A REVISION SHEET AS WELL.
7:34:31PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THE COMPLIANCE -- THIS IS REZ-23-28,
7:34:38PM COMPLIANCE, IF APPROVED, SUBJECT SITE WILL BE DEVELOPED IN
7:34:41PM THE DENSITY OF 19.3 ACRES PER UNIT WHICH IS CONSISTENT WITH
7:34:45PM THE DENSITY APPLICABLE UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL LAND 20, LAND
7:34:51PM DESIGNATED AND WILL CONTINUE TO MAINTAIN CIVILITY IN
7:34:54PM EXISTING AREAS EXPANDING OPPORTUNITIES FOR HOUSING CHOICES
7:34:58PM WHICH IS SUPPORTED BY LAND USE 9.5.1 AND 9.5.3, REGARDING
7:35:05PM THE CODE SECTION 27-136, PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT SHOWING THAT
7:35:11PM THE SITE PLAN PROMOTES AND ENCOURAGES DEVELOPMENT THAT IS
7:35:13PM APPROPRIATE IN LOCATION, CHARACTER, COMPATIBILITY AND
7:35:16PM SURROUNDING NEIGHBORS.
7:35:18PM WAIVERS THE DESIGN OF THE WAIVERS DEVELOPED IS UNIQUE AND
7:35:22PM THEREFORE IN NEED OF WAIVERS.
7:35:23PM THE REQUESTED WAIVERS DO NOT SUBSTANTIALLY INTERFERE OR
7:35:26PM INJURE THE RIGHTS OF OTHERS WHOSE PROPERTIES WOULD BE
7:35:28PM AFFECTED BY THE WAIVER.
7:35:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS THERE A SECOND?
7:35:31PM WE HAVE A SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
7:35:35PM WE'LL DO A ROLL CALL VOTE.
7:35:40PM >>LYNN HURTAK: NO.
7:35:43PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN I EXPLAIN MY VOTE?
7:35:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD.
7:35:52PM WELL, THE HEARING IS CLOSED.
7:35:55PM HE'S NOT ASKING A QUESTION.
7:35:56PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I JUST WANT TO EXPLAIN MY VOTE.
7:35:59PM I'VE MADE IT VERY CLEAR THAT I'M NOT -- I THINK THAT WE
7:36:08PM APPROVE PDs WAY TOO OFTEN IN AREAS OF THE CITY OF TAMPA
7:36:11PM THAT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE CITY OF
7:36:13PM TAMPA AND THAT PEOPLE SHOULD BE DEVELOPING THEIR PROPERTY IN
7:36:15PM ACCORDANCE WITH THE EUCLIDEAN ZONING AND NOT SEEK THE
7:36:18PM SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS.
7:36:20PM THAT BEING SAID ON THIS PARTICULAR PIECE OF PROPERTY, THE
7:36:26PM AREA IS DEVELOPED SO ECLECTICALLY THAT I DON'T FEEL LIKE
7:36:33PM IT'S STRESSING THE NEIGHBORHOODS, NEIGHBORHOOD SPECIFICALLY.
7:36:37PM IDEALLY, I WOULD HAVE LIKED TO SEE A BETTER DEVELOPMENT, A
7:36:41PM BETTER BUILDING, BUT IT'S NOT UP TO ME TO MAKE THAT DECISION
7:36:44PM BASED ON THE LAND USE AND WHERE WE'RE AT RIGHT NOW.
7:36:46PM IN A PERFECT WORLD, I WOULD VOTE AGAINST THIS, BUT I'M GOING
7:36:51PM TO SAY YES.
7:36:52PM THANK YOU.
7:36:57PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
7:36:59PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
7:37:01PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
7:37:03PM >>BILL CARLSON: NO.
7:37:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
7:37:08PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION CARRIED WITH HURTAK, CARLSON VOTING NO.
7:37:14PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER 7,
7:37:18PM 2023, AT 9:30 A.M., LOCATED AT OLD CITY HALL BUILDING, 315
7:37:24PM EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, TAMPA, FLORIDA.
7:37:27PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
7:37:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:37:29PM ITEM NUMBER 4.
7:37:34PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
7:37:36PM ITEM NUMBER 4 IS REZ 23-50.
7:37:40PM THIS IS FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2529 WEST CURTIS STREET.
7:37:44PM THE APPLICANT IS REPRESENTED BY TRUETT GARDNER.
7:37:48PM THE REQUEST IS TO REZONE PROPERTY FROM RS 50 RESIDENTIAL
7:37:51PM SINGLE-FAMILY TO RO RESIDENTIAL OFFICE.
7:37:53PM AND I'LL TURN IT OVER TO EMILY TO GIVE HER REPORT.
7:38:13PM >>EMILY PHELAN: EMILY PHELAN, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
7:38:15PM THE SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING
7:38:18PM DISTRICT IN THE ST. JOSEPH'S HOSPITAL NEIGHBORHOOD.
7:38:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WAIT A MINUTE.
7:38:23PM MR. SHELBY.
7:38:24PM I DID NOT RECEIVE A NOTICE, BUT I LIVE RIGHT HERE -- I'M A
7:38:31PM BLOCK AWAY.
7:38:32PM THE ONLY THING THAT SEPARATES ME IS THAT WHITE BUILDING THAT
7:38:35PM YOU SEE RIGHT UNDER THE PARCEL IN QUESTION.
7:38:39PM I'M NOT THE FIRST UNIT.
7:38:41PM I'M THE THIRD UNIT IN.
7:38:44PM MAYBE I DIDN'T GET THE LETTER.
7:38:47PM MAYBE THE HOA GOT IT OR THE HOA PRESIDENT AND I DIDN'T GET
7:38:51PM IT TO MY MAILBOX.
7:38:52PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: IF IT IS A CONDO ASSOCIATION, I SUSPECT YOU
7:38:55PM WOULD HAVE GOTTEN A NOTICE FOR THAT, IS THAT CORRECT?
7:38:57PM WOULD YOU SAY YOU LIVE MORE THAN 250 FEET AWAY?
7:39:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IF I LOOK OUT MY WINDOW, I CAN PROBABLY
7:39:09PM SEE IT.
7:39:09PM MAYBE SOME TREES ARE IN THE WAY, NOT LOOK OUT MY WINDOW.
7:39:13PM IF I OPEN MY FRONT DOOR, I CAN LOOK DIRECTLY ACROSS.
7:39:17PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: COUNCIL, THE NOTICE IS SENT TO THE OWNERS.
7:39:19PM SO IT IS THE PROPERTY OWNERSHIP AS LISTED IN THE PROPERTY
7:39:22PM APPRAISER.
7:39:23PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YOU'RE NOT IN THE NOTICED AREA.
7:39:26PM MY QUESTION TO YOU IS, CAN YOU --
7:39:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I CAN BE FAIR AND IMPARTIAL.
7:39:31PM HOWEVER, OUT OF AN ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION, I SEE -- I'M JUST
7:39:37PM RIGHT OUTSIDE THAT 250 FEET.
7:39:39PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: IN OTHER WORDS -- I DON'T WANT TO PUT WORDS
7:39:42PM IN YOUR MOUTH -- BUT ARE YOU ASKING WHETHER YOU SHOULD OR
7:39:46PM YOU WANT TO -- LET ME REPHRASE IT -- DO YOU WANT TO ABSTAIN
7:39:49PM TO AVOID THE APPEARANCE OF A POTENTIAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST
7:39:52PM TO ASSURE A FAIR PROCEEDING FREE OF BIAS?
7:39:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I CAN BE FAIR AND IMPARTIAL BUT OUT OF
7:40:00PM AN ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION, I MEAN, IT'S RIGHT THERE.
7:40:05PM IT DOESN'T AFFECT ME.
7:40:08PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: IS IT YOUR DESIRE TO ABSTAIN?
7:40:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: AM I WITHIN MY LEGAL RIGHTS TO ABSTAIN?
7:40:15PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YES.
7:40:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MY WIFE PARKS RIGHT HERE.
7:40:20PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THANK YOU FOR DISCLOSING THAT.
7:40:22PM YOU WISH TO ABSTAIN.
7:40:24PM I'LL PREPARE THE PAPERWORK AND YOU'LL FILL THAT OUT AT A
7:40:29PM FUTURE MEETING IF I CAN'T GET IT DONE IN TIME TODAY.
7:40:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:40:32PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THANK YOU.
7:40:40PM >>EMILY PHELAN: I'M GOING TO RESTART.
7:40:42PM EMILY PHELAN, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
7:40:45PM THE SITE IS IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT AND THE
7:40:47PM ST. JOSEPH'S HOSPITAL NEIGHBORHOOD.
7:40:49PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE RIGHT HERE, AND IT IS PREDOMINANTLY
7:40:54PM RESIDENTIAL TO THE NORTH, AND THERE ARE COMMERCIAL USES
7:40:58PM ALONG HABANA AND ALSO FURTHER EAST JUST RIGHT OUTSIDE OF THE
7:41:04PM AERIAL IS NORTH ARMENIA AND THESE ARE COMMERCIAL USES AS
7:41:07PM WELL.
7:41:07PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS HERE REPRESENTED WITH THE RESIDENTIAL 10
7:41:14PM FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
7:41:15PM THAT DESIGNATION IS TO THE NORTH, EAST, AND SOUTH OF THE
7:41:19PM SUBJECT SITE.
7:41:19PM THE DARK BROWN COLOR ALONG HABANA IS RESIDENTIAL 35, AND
7:41:24PM FURTHER TO THE EAST ALONG NORTH ARMENIA IS THE CMU 35
7:41:29PM DESIGNATION.
7:41:30PM COMMERCIAL USES CAN BE CONSIDERED IN THE RESIDENTIAL 10
7:41:34PM FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION IF THE SUBJECT SITE MEETS
7:41:37PM COMMERCIAL LOCATIONAL CRITERIA.
7:41:39PM COMMERCIAL ZONING REPRESENTS APPROXIMATELY 58% OF THE BLOCK
7:41:43PM FACE BETWEEN NORTH HABANA AVENUE AND NORTH ARMENIA AVENUE.
7:41:47PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF HAS DETERMINED THAT THE SITE DOES
7:41:49PM MEET LOCATIONAL CRITERIA.
7:41:51PM LAND USE POLICIES 1.2.8 AND 15.2.4 ENCOURAGE A RANGE OF USES
7:41:58PM IN PROXIMITY OF EACH OTHER AND REQUIRES COMMERCIAL
7:42:01PM DEVELOPMENT TO BE BUFFERED FROM RESIDENTIAL USES.
7:42:03PM THE PROPOSED REZONING WILL NOT HAVE A NEGATIVE IMPACT ON THE
7:42:07PM SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD.
7:42:08PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PROMOTES PEDESTRIAN SAFETY AND
7:42:10PM ENCOURAGES COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT THAT ENHANCES THE CITY OF
7:42:13PM TAMPA'S CHARACTER AND AMBIENCE.
7:42:16PM THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PROMOTES COMPATIBLE DEVELOPMENT
7:42:18PM AND REDEVELOPMENT TO SUSTAIN STABLE NEIGHBORHOODS AND ENSURE
7:42:23PM THE SOCIAL ECONOMIC HEALTH OF THE CITY.
7:42:25PM WITH THOSE IN MIND, THE PROPOSED R.O. REZONING WOULD ALLOW
7:42:30PM FOR DEVELOPMENT THAT IS COMPATIBLE AND COMPARABLE TO THE
7:42:33PM SURROUNDING AREA.
7:42:34PM AND THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION, IF YOU HAVE ANY
7:42:37PM QUESTIONS.
7:42:37PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ANY QUESTIONS?
7:42:39PM NEXT.
7:42:42PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
7:42:43PM AGAIN, LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
7:42:45PM AND THIS REZONING REQUEST IS TO RESIDENTIAL OFFICE WHICH IS
7:42:50PM A EUCLIDEAN REQUEST.
7:42:52PM AT THE TIME OF PERMITTING, OUR STANDARDS MUST BE MET.
7:42:55PM THIS IS THE ZONING MAP FOR THE AREA.
7:42:58PM THIS IS THE LOCATION WHICH IS IDENTIFIED IN RED.
7:43:00PM THIS IS CURTIS STREET.
7:43:03PM JUST TO ORIENT YOU, THIS IS HABANA ON THE WEST.
7:43:06PM THIS IS ARMENIA AVENUE.
7:43:08PM YOU CAN SEE ALONG HABANA WHERE YOU HAVE THE RESIDENTIAL
7:43:12PM OFFICE, THOSE ARE THE TYPICAL USES THAT ARE ON HABANA.
7:43:16PM THE MEDICAL OFFICE USES.
7:43:18PM AND THEN THERE ARE A COUPLE OF RO-1 ZONINGS THAT ARE THERE.
7:43:22PM AND THEN AS YOU HEAD FURTHER EAST AND ON ARMENIA, YOU HAVE
7:43:26PM MORE OF YOUR COMMERCIAL USES THAT ARE THERE.
7:43:29PM BUT THIS IMMEDIATE AREA IS HISTORICALLY FOR MEDICAL OFFICE
7:43:32PM USES THAT EXIST.
7:43:34PM THE SITE HAS A FRONTAGE OF 125 FEET.
7:43:37PM AND THE LENGTH IS MEASURING AT 226 FEET.
7:43:41PM I HAVE PICTURES OF THE SITE JUST TO SHOW.
7:43:47PM SO THIS IS THE SITE ON HABANA.
7:43:50PM PRETTY WIDE.
7:43:54PM THIS IS THE OTHER END OF THE SITE.
7:43:57PM THIS IS EAST OF THE SITE.
7:44:00PM SO THIS IS THE VIEW IF YOU ARE ON CURTIS, YOU'RE LOOKING
7:44:07PM EAST, SO THE SITE IS ON THE PICTURE OFF TO THE LEFT.
7:44:11PM THIS IS ON CURTIS.
7:44:17PM THIS IS ACROSS THE STREET, SO THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE.
7:44:20PM THE PREVIOUS PICTURE WAS THE PARKING FOR THIS FACILITY,
7:44:26PM WHICH IS AT THE CORNER OF HABANA.
7:44:28PM THIS IS WEST OF THE SITE, SO THIS IS HABANA.
7:44:33PM THAT'S THE VIEW IF YOU'RE LOOKING NORTH ON HABANA.
7:44:35PM AND THEN WE'RE SWINGING BACK AROUND, THIS IS WEST OF THE
7:44:39PM SITE AT THE CORNER OF HABANA AND THEN THIS IS DIRECTLY WEST
7:44:42PM OF THE SITE.
7:44:43PM THE SITE IS TO THE RIGHT IN THIS PICTURE, OUTSIDE THE
7:44:46PM PICTURE.
7:44:47PM SO THE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND
7:44:49PM FINDS THE REQUEST CONSISTENT.
7:44:51PM I'M AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
7:44:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ANY QUESTIONS?
7:44:55PM HEARING NONE, REPRESENTATIVE OF THE APPLICANT.
7:45:06PM >> GOOD EVENING, TRUETT GARDNER, 400 NORTH ASHLEY DRIVE.
7:45:10PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
7:45:11PM HONORED TO BE HERE ON BEHALF OF DR. CABRERA CANCIO.
7:45:16PM I'VE HAD THE PLEASURE OF REPRESENTING HER FOR OVER 12 YEARS.
7:45:18PM SHE IS AN INFECTIOUS DISEASE DOCTOR AND DOES ABSOLUTELY
7:45:21PM WONDERFUL THINGS FOR OUR COMMUNITY.
7:45:23PM THIS IS HER PRIMARY OFFICE.
7:45:24PM SHE HAS OTHER OFFICES AS WELL.
7:45:26PM OUR REQUEST IS FOR EUCLIDEAN ZONING, EUCLIDEAN, NOT PD.
7:45:31PM WE HAVE NO NEED FOR ANY WAIVERS AT ALL.
7:45:34PM NORMALLY WE'RE HERE IN FRONT OF YOU WITH COMPLICATED PDs,
7:45:38PM BUT THIS IS A VERY CLEAN ONE, AND THE REQUEST AGAIN IS RS 50
7:45:42PM TO RO.
7:45:43PM AND WE'VE GOT A SLIDE THAT WILL SHOW YOU JUST HOW LIMITED
7:45:46PM THAT ZONING CATEGORY IS.
7:45:48PM AND THEN FINALLY, AT OUR LAST HEARING, WE WERE SUPPOSED TO
7:45:50PM BE HEARD IN JULY.
7:45:52PM WE REQUESTED A CONTINUANCE.
7:45:53PM WE SENT NOTICE OUT TO EVERYBODY WITHIN 250 FEET.
7:45:56PM I GUESS EXCLUDING CHAIRMAN MANISCALCO, AND DR. CANCIO AND
7:46:04PM SPOKE WITH ALL THE NEIGHBORS THAT SHE COULD WITHIN THAT.
7:46:06PM WE GOT A CONCERN RAISED TO US NIGHT BEFORE THE HEARING FROM
7:46:09PM THE CLERK'S OFFICE, SO WE REQUESTED TO SPEAK WITH NEIGHBORS
7:46:16PM OUTSIDE OF THE BOUNDARY WHICH WAS DONE.
7:46:17PM THAT WAS CULMINATED IN A LETTER MAKING ADDITIONAL
7:46:20PM COMMITMENTS THAT WE'LL SUBMIT FOR THE RECORD.
7:46:23PM WITH THAT, AGAIN, LOCATION, LaCHONE DID A GREAT JOB OF
7:46:28PM POINTING OUT HABANA BEING THIS MEDICAL CORRIDOR.
7:46:32PM I WANT TO POINT OUT ST. JOE'S TO THE SOUTH, DR. CANCIO'S
7:46:37PM PRACTICE HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH ST. JOE'S, BUT IT IS WITHIN
7:46:40PM THIS MEDICAL CORRIDOR.
7:46:43PM THE NEXT SLIDE HIGHLIGHTED WITH THE STAR IS THE PROPERTY IN
7:46:49PM QUESTION.
7:46:50PM YOU CAN SEE THE MEDICAL OFFICE TO THE WEST.
7:46:52PM PARKING ALSO TO THE WEST, AND THEN TO THE SOUTH IS MEDICAL
7:46:55PM OFFICE, WHICH ENCROACHES FURTHER INTO THE NEIGHBORHOOD THAN
7:46:59PM WHAT WE'RE PROPOSING TODAY.
7:47:00PM NEXT SLIDE, THE DEVELOPMENT AND INTENT OF THIS AND TO
7:47:06PM CLARIFY SOMETHING IS NOT FOR MEDICAL OFFICE.
7:47:09PM IT'S PURELY FOR ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE, FAR LESS INTENSE.
7:47:12PM WILL SERVE AS A TRANSITION TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD, AND IT WILL
7:47:16PM BE SERVICING THE OFFICE BUILDING OF DR. CANCIO TO THE WEST.
7:47:22PM ONE ADDITIONAL ASPECT OF THIS IS THERE IS AN ABUNDANCE OF
7:47:25PM PARKING ON HER PROPERTY TO THE WEST AND SO TO FURTHER
7:47:29PM PROTECT THE NEIGHBORHOOD, ALL PARKING WILL BE PROVIDED
7:47:31PM WITHIN THAT PARKING LOT AND NOT ON THE SITE.
7:47:34PM NEXT SLIDE.
7:47:36PM AGAIN, I MENTIONED HOW LIMITED THE RO USE IS.
7:47:41PM I KNOW THAT ON THE SLIDES THAT LaCHONE SHOWED, SHE SHOWED
7:47:44PM SOME RO 1.
7:47:46PM RO IS EVEN MORE RESTRICTIVE.
7:47:47PM SO YOU CAN SEE HERE WHEN COMPARED TO RS 50, THE CURRENT
7:47:51PM ZONING, REALLY THE ONLY THING THAT'S ALLOWED IS OFFICE,
7:47:56PM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL.
7:47:56PM AND WE COULD HAVE, WE HAVE A PD IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO
7:47:59PM THIS, WE COULD HAVE OPENED THIS UP AND PUT THIS PROPERTY
7:48:02PM WITHIN THE PD, BUT THAT PD ACTUALLY ALLOWS FOR MEDICAL
7:48:06PM OFFICE, GOING THE RO ROUTE WAS EVEN MORE LIMITING BECAUSE
7:48:09PM ALL WE'RE ALLOWED IS OFFICE, BUSINESS, AND PROFESSIONAL AS
7:48:12PM YOU CAN SEE DIRECTLY BELOW THE MEDICAL OFFICE IS NOT A
7:48:14PM PERMITTED USE NOR WILL IT BE.
7:48:16PM FINALLY, JUST WANT TO REPORT CONSISTENCY FROM ALL
7:48:21PM ORGANIZATIONS, INCLUDING DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION, THE
7:48:24PM PLANNING COMMISSION, AND NOTABLY TRANSPORTATION AS WELL.
7:48:27PM HERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE.
7:48:29PM THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION.
7:48:30PM WE'VE GOT THE PROJECT ARCHITECT AND DR. CANCIO WHO WOULD
7:48:37PM LIKE TO SPEAK AS WELL.
7:48:38PM THANK YOU.
7:48:39PM OH, ONE LAST THING, THE NEIGHBOR TO THE SOUTH HAS WRITTEN A
7:48:42PM LETTER OF SUPPORT THAT I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO INTRODUCE INTO
7:48:47PM THE RECORD.
7:48:50PM >> GOOD EVENING, MR. CHAIRMAN.
7:48:54PM I GUESS MR. MANISCALCO STEPPED OUT.
7:48:55PM HONORABLE MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL, MY NAME IS ANTONIO
7:48:57PM MALEO.
7:49:00PM MR. ATTORNEY, I HAVE NOT BEEN SWORN, SO IF YOU WOULD TAKE
7:49:02PM THE OPPORTUNITY TO DO THAT.
7:49:09PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE?
7:49:14PM [OATH ADMINISTERED BY THE CLERK]
7:49:20PM >> I DO.
7:49:20PM THANK YOU.
7:49:23PM AGAIN FOR THE OPPORTUNITY.
7:49:24PM I'M A REGISTERED ARCHITECT AND I'VE HAD THE PLEASURE AND
7:49:27PM PRIVILEGE --
7:49:29PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN YOU STATE YOUR NAME?
7:49:32PM >> ANTONIO MALEO.
7:49:33PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:49:34PM I'VE HAD THE PLEASURE AND PRIVILEGE OF KNOWING DR. CABRERA
7:49:38PM CANCIO FOR OVER 25 YEARS FROM HER WORK AT TAMPA GENERAL
7:49:41PM HOSPITAL WHEN I WAS DIRECTOR THERE, AND OVER THE YEARS FOR
7:49:44PM THE GREATER TAMPA COMMUNITY.
7:49:47PM I CAN ATTEST TO THE QUALITY AND ATTENTION TO DETAIL TO EVERY
7:49:52PM PROJECT SHE UNDERTAKES, WHICH IS TRULY A REFLECTION OF HER
7:49:58PM CHARACTER AND THE CARE FOR HER PATIENTS.
7:50:02PM I'D LIKE TO SHOW YOU EVIDENCE AND ENTER INTO THE RECORD
7:50:06PM EXAMPLES OF BEFORE-AND-AFTER PICTURES OF THE IMMEDIATE AND
7:50:10PM ADJACENT AREA TO 2529 WEST CURTIS, WHICH ATTESTS TO THE
7:50:14PM QUALITY AND ATTENTION TO DETAIL, SPECIFICALLY AS IT PERTAINS
7:50:18PM TO THIS APPLICATION AND THE BEAUTIFICATION OF CURTIS STREET
7:50:22PM AND THE SURROUNDING AREA.
7:50:24PM I'D LIKE TO START WITH THE ELEVATION OF THE PROPOSED
7:50:28PM PROPERTY, WHICH IN CHARACTER DOESN'T CHANGE.
7:50:31PM THERE'S NO ADDITION TO IT.
7:50:33PM THERE'S NO MODIFICATION OTHER THAN IMPROVEMENT OF THE
7:50:36PM PROPERTY, AS YOU CAN SEE.
7:50:42PM CAN YOU SEE THAT?
7:50:43PM NEW WINDOWS, NEW LANDSCAPING, NEW FENCING, AND OVERALL
7:50:51PM ATTENTION TO THE BEAUTIFICATION.
7:50:53PM I'D LIKE TO ALSO SHOW YOU BEFORE PICTURES OF THE IMMEDIATE
7:50:57PM AREAS THAT YOU CAN SEE OVER HERE.
7:50:59PM THIS IS THE PROPERTY OF THE EXISTING, ADJACENT TO THE
7:51:03PM EXISTING -- ACTUALLY, WITHIN THE EXISTING PROPERTY OF 4929
7:51:09PM HABANA.
7:51:10PM YOU CAN SEE ON THE TOP WHERE IT WAS AND NOW WHEN SHE
7:51:14PM PURCHASED THE PROPERTY HOW IT'S BEAUTIFIED AND HOW NICE IT
7:51:19PM LOOKS NOW IN 2023.
7:51:20PM CONTINUING, ALSO THE BEFORE PICTURE OF NORTH HABANA AND WEST
7:51:29PM CURTIS, 2012 AND NOW IN 2023.
7:51:32PM BEAUTIFUL GREEN AREA WITH PRESERVATION OF THE TREES.
7:51:37PM ANOTHER PICTURE OF HABANA AND WEST CURTIS WHERE EXISTING
7:51:45PM STRUCTURE WAS AND NOW IT WAS IN REALLY TERRIBLE SHAPE, SO IT
7:51:49PM WAS DECIDED TO BE REMOVED AND JUST IMPROVED AS A
7:51:53PM LANDSCAPING.
7:51:54PM AND THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW OF THE SAME AREA.
7:51:59PM THIS IS THE AREA ADJACENT TO THE SUBJECT PROPERTY WHERE IT
7:52:03PM WAS ALSO IN POOR LANDSCAPING SHAPE AND NOW IT'S BEEN
7:52:09PM IMPROVED TO ACCOMMODATE THE PARKING OF THE EXISTING OFFICE
7:52:14PM SPACE.
7:52:14PM AND THIS, AS REFERENCED, THIS IS THE ELEVATION OF HER
7:52:22PM EXISTING OFFICE, MEDICAL OFFICES, WHICH IS IN CHARACTER WITH
7:52:28PM EVERYTHING SHE HAS IMPROVED AROUND THE PROPERTY.
7:52:30PM I'D LIKE TO ASK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT AND APPROVAL OF THIS
7:52:35PM APPLICATION.
7:52:36PM IF THERE'S ANY QUESTION YOU MAY WANT TO ASK ME, I WOULD BE
7:52:40PM GLAD TO DO THAT.
7:52:41PM WITH THAT, I WOULD LIKE TO INTRODUCE DR. MARGARITA CABRERA
7:52:49PM CANCIO.
7:52:50PM >> THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY.
7:52:51PM WE ARE A MEDICAL PRACTICE.
7:52:53PM WE ARE A PRIVATE PRACTICE, BUT WE ARE NOT ASSOCIATED WITH
7:52:59PM ANY HOSPITAL, ANY HEALTH CARE GROUP OR ANY INSURANCE.
7:53:03PM WE'RE TOTALLY INDEPENDENT.
7:53:05PM OUR NAME IS INFECTIOUS DISEASE ASSOCIATES OF TAMPA BAY.
7:53:09PM 15 PHYSICIANS, 5 NURSE PRACTITIONERS AND WE EMPLOY 70
7:53:13PM INDIVIDUALS AT THREE DIFFERENT LOCATIONS.
7:53:15PM ALL WE'RE TRYING TO DO IS IMPROVE OUR MEDICAL OFFICE BECAUSE
7:53:20PM WE NEED TO SOME RENOVATIONS INSIDE TO BETTER THE PATIENT
7:53:24PM CARE THAT WE PROVIDE.
7:53:26PM ALL WE'RE ASKING IS TO MOVE OUR ADMINISTRATIVE PERSONNEL
7:53:29PM THAT IS ONLY 6 TO 8 PEOPLE TO THIS HOUSE, AND WE'RE GOING TO
7:53:33PM BEAUTIFY IT AND MAKE IT AND IT'S NOT FOR ANY TYPE OF MEDICAL
7:53:42PM CARE OR ANYTHING ELSE BUT ADMINISTRATIVE DUTIES, AND WE'RE
7:53:47PM NOT PLANNING TO HAVE ANYBODY PARK THERE.
7:53:50PM THIS IS ONLY FOR ADMINISTRATION.
7:53:52PM WE HAVE GONE THROUGH BOTH CURTIS -- HAVE TALKED TO AS MANY
7:54:01PM OF THE INDIVIDUALS THAT LIVE IN THE DIFFERENT HOUSES TO MAKE
7:54:04PM SURE WE ANSWERED ALL THEIR QUESTIONS AND HAVE LEFT PAMPHLETS
7:54:09PM AND OPENED OUR OFFICE FOR THEM TO COME AND ASK US ANY
7:54:13PM QUESTIONS.
7:54:13PM I REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT IN TRYING TO ALLOW US IN
7:54:18PM OUR OFFICE TO IMPROVE THE CARE THAT WE PROVIDE TO OUR
7:54:23PM PATIENTS BY MOVING OUR ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE TO THE NEW
7:54:25PM LOCATION.
7:54:26PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:54:29PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
7:54:31PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THIS HAS NOTHING TO DO -- [INAUDIBLE] --
7:54:35PM BEEN HERE A LITTLE BIT OF TIME.
7:54:36PM I REMEMBER THE FIRST REZONING ON OSBORNE AND WE DID THAT
7:54:39PM ABOUT 15, 18 YEARS AGO.
7:54:41PM YOU HAD A PROBLEM, NOT YOUR PROBLEM, THE NEIGHBORHOOD WANTED
7:54:44PM NO TURN GATE AND YOU DID THAT.
7:54:47PM I REMEMBER THAT.
7:54:48PM I'M NOT VOUCHING FOR THIS.
7:54:49PM I'M JUST TELLING YOU, YOU DID IT IN THE PAST.
7:54:53PM CONGRATULATIONS TO YOU.
7:54:57PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?
7:54:59PM IS THAT ALL FROM THE APPLICANT?
7:55:02PM >> YES, TRUETT GARDNER, BUT ONLY TO STATE FEEL LIKE I'M
7:55:06PM GETTING AS OLD AS COUNCILMAN MIRANDA WHEN HIS STORIES ARE
7:55:10PM STORIES THAT I WAS A PART OF, TOO.
7:55:12PM SO THANK YOU.
7:55:12PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: WELL, EVIDENTLY, YOU KEPT YOUR HAIR.
7:55:16PM >> IT'S GRAYING QUICKLY.
7:55:18PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OKAY.
7:55:19PM PUBLIC COMMENT?
7:55:19PM ANYBODY HERE FROM THE PUBLIC?
7:55:39PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: EXCUSE ME, BUT THE PICTURES THAT WERE FROM
7:55:41PM THE PRIOR SPEAKER.
7:55:46PM >> ANTONIO MALEO.
7:55:50PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: COME UP TO THE PODIUM AND STATE YOUR NAME.
7:55:53PM YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
7:55:54PM >> MY NAME IS ADRIANA ENCINAS, AND I AM SPEAKING ON BEHALF
7:55:58PM OF MY GRANDFATHER WHO LIVES ADJACENT.
7:56:00PM HE'S IN THE BACK.
7:56:06PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: SIR, WHERE ARE YOU?
7:56:10PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:56:10PM ONE ADDITIONAL MINUTE.
7:56:12PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YOU HAVE FOUR MINUTES.
7:56:14PM >> MY NAME IS ADRIANA ENCINAS.
7:56:19PM ONE OF THE PROPERTIES NEXT TO IT THE BEAUTIFUL RED HOUSE IS
7:56:22PM MY GRANDFATHER'S.
7:56:23PM HE OWNED THE PROPERTY SINCE 1968.
7:56:26PM WE HAVE SEEN WHAT THIS AREA AND THIS COMMUNITY HAS BECOME
7:56:30PM AND WHAT WE HAVE SLOWLY UNFORTUNATELY OVER THE YEARS SEEN
7:56:32PM BUSINESSES AND MEDICAL PRACTICES EATING AWAY AT THESE
7:56:35PM RESIDENTIAL AREAS.
7:56:36PM AS YOU CAN SEE IN THAT PICTURE, IT'S ALREADY SMALL.
7:56:39PM YOU'RE GOING TO TAKE ANOTHER SINGLE-FAMILY HOME TO TURN IT
7:56:42PM INTO AN OFFICE SPACE FROM WHAT I'M HEARING ADMINISTRATIVE.
7:56:45PM THERE'S ALREADY ANOTHER PROPERTY.
7:56:48PM THEY OWN ANOTHER BUILDING ON THAT PROPERTY.
7:56:50PM TALKING ADMINISTRATIVE, WE'RE NOT SEEING PATIENTS.
7:56:52PM WHY CAN'T THIS BE DONE FROM HOME?
7:56:54PM WHY ISN'T THIS REMOTE?
7:56:56PM WHY ARE WE TRYING TO TAKE ANOTHER LOCATION TO HAVE ANOTHER
7:56:59PM FAMILY COME IN TO BUILD THEIR FAMILY LIKE I'M DOING.
7:57:04PM I LIVE SIX HOUSES DOWN FROM MY GRANDFATHER SO I LIVE ON THE
7:57:07PM STREET AS WELL.
7:57:08PM FOR OFFICE SPACES THAT I'M HEARING THEY ARE GOING TO WALK
7:57:13PM THROUGH AN AREA THAT DOES NOT HAVE A SIDEWALK THROUGH GRASS
7:57:16PM WHEN IT RAINS TO GET TO THE OFFICE.
7:57:19PM I FIND THAT VERY HARD TO BELIEVE THAT THEY ARE NOT GOING TO
7:57:22PM PARK ON THE PROPERTY.
7:57:23PM AND THE OTHER ISSUE THAT WE HAVE WITH BOTH OF THESE, I KNOW
7:57:27PM YOU POINTED OUT THE GATE ON OSBORNE, THE AMOUNT OF SPEEDING
7:57:31PM THAT WE HAVE ON CURTIS, I CANNOT HAVE MY CHILDREN IN THE
7:57:34PM FRONT OF MY HOUSE FOR FEAR THAT THEY ARE GOING TO GET HIT BY
7:57:37PM A CAR AND THE NUMBER OF TIMES THAT WE ASK INDIVIDUALS THOUGH
7:57:41PM PLEASE SLOW DOWN AND I GET BRANDED A WEAPON WHEN I AM TRYING
7:57:45PM TO RAISE MY FAMILY IN AN AREA THAT FOR PEOPLE IS JUST A
7:57:49PM PASS-THROUGH.
7:57:50PM DOESN'T HAPPEN IN YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD.
7:57:52PM HAPPENED IN YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD, YOU WOULD BE STANDING HERE
7:57:53PM SAYING WE DON'T WANT IT.
7:57:55PM THAT'S WHAT WE'RE SAYING.
7:57:56PM WE DON'T WANT TO LOSE ANOTHER HOME SOMEPLACE ELSE THAT CAN
7:57:59PM BECOME A FAMILY MOVING IN TO OFFICE SPACES FOR AN AREA THAT
7:58:05PM ALREADY -- SHE OWNS THE ENTIRE END PIECE.
7:58:07PM YOU'RE TELLING ME YOU CAN'T USE WHAT YOU ALREADY HAVE.
7:58:10PM IF ALL YOU NEED IS SOMETHING TEMPORARILY FOR ADMINISTRATIVE
7:58:12PM OFFICES, THAT JUST MAKES ME THINK WHAT IS THE FUTURE PLAN
7:58:15PM FOR THIS IS NOT WHAT'S BEING SAID.
7:58:17PM THEY ARE PRESENTING SOMETHING TO YOU FOR RIGHT NOW AND
7:58:21PM THEY'LL COME BACK AND TURN IT INTO SOMETHING BUT IT'S NOT
7:58:24PM WHAT IS INTENDED.
7:58:25PM THEY SAID THEY PASSED PAMPHLETS OUT.
7:58:27PM THE ONLY REASON THEY PASSED PAMPHLETS OUT IS THEY FOUND OUT
7:58:30PM AT THE LAST MEETING LAST MONTH THERE WERE SOME OF US WHO
7:58:33PM OBJECTED BECAUSE AS THE DISTRICT, TWO COUNCILMEN WHO
7:58:37PM ABSTAINED, WE DIDN'T RECEIVE ANYTHING EITHER.
7:58:40PM THE ONLY ONE WHO RECEIVED IT WAS MY GRANDFATHER.
7:58:45PM THAT'S HOW WE KNEW.
7:58:46PM SO PLEASE DON'T ALLOW ANOTHER FAMILY HOME TO BE TAKEN AWAY.
7:58:50PM WE WANT MORE FAMILIES IN THIS AREA.
7:58:52PM WE WANT TO RAISE OUR KIDS THERE.
7:58:54PM IT'S WHY WE LIVE THERE.
7:58:55PM WHY YOU LIVE WHERE YOU LIVE.
7:58:56PM YOU WANT TO RAISE YOUR KIDS THERE.
7:58:58PM THAT IS OUR HOPE.
7:58:59PM THAT IS OUR INTENT, NOT TO HAVE ANOTHER BUSINESS.
7:59:01PM THANK YOU.
7:59:04PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:59:05PM NEXT.
7:59:08PM >> HELLO AGAIN.
7:59:11PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YOU ARE BOTH SPEAKING, SO YOU GET SIX.
7:59:14PM >> YES, EXACTLY CORRECT.
7:59:15PM DAYTON BURCHFIELD, 2518 WEST CURTIS STREET.
7:59:19PM AS MY WIFE SAID, WE LIVE EXACTLY NINE ADDRESS NUMBERS DOWN
7:59:24PM THE STREET FROM HER GRANDFATHER.
7:59:26PM WE, IN FACT, LIVED WITH HIM FOR OVER A YEAR WHILE OUR HOME
7:59:31PM WAS BUILDING BUILT DOWN THE STREET.
7:59:33PM WE ARE VERY AWARE OF THE ISSUES THAT HAPPEN WITH REGARD TO
7:59:38PM HIGH-SPEED TRANSIT DOWN OUR STREET.
7:59:40PM THERE HAVE BEEN A NUMBER OF ISSUES THAT HAVE COME UP AS A
7:59:43PM RESULT OF THAT.
7:59:45PM IT'S BEEN REPORTED TO THE POLICE DEPARTMENT.
7:59:47PM IT'S BEEN REPORTED TO THE CITY TO TRANSPORTATION, AND WE ARE
7:59:53PM CONCERNED ABOUT THE TRANSIT DOWN THE STREET.
7:59:56PM CURRENTLY, AND I DON'T HAVE A COPY OF THE IMAGE, BUT YOU
8:00:01PM WERE PRESENTED AN IMAGE THAT SHOWS A SIDEWALK GOING DOWN THE
8:00:07PM STREET.
8:00:08PM HOWEVER, AT PRESENT, THERE IS NOT A SIDEWALK.
8:00:11PM THERE IS, IN FACT, VERY POOR ACCESS TO THE FRONT OF THE
8:00:15PM HOUSE.
8:00:16PM AND TO THAT POINT, THERE IS, IN FACT, A FAIRLY IMPRESSIVE
8:00:23PM DRAINAGE DITCH WHICH WILL FORCE INDIVIDUALS TO WALK DOWN AN
8:00:28PM UNIMPROVED STREET WITH NO SIDEWALK PRESENT TO ACCESS THE
8:00:33PM PROPERTY.
8:00:33PM ALSO, THIS PHOTO WAS TAKEN JUST THE OTHER DAY.
8:00:43PM THAT SIGN WAS PUT UP IN FRONT OF THE HOUSE.
8:00:47PM WHICH DOES NOT STATE TO THE NATURE OF THE PROPERTY.
8:00:55PM ADDITIONALLY, AS YOU CAN SEE IN THE IMAGE, HERE IS THE
8:00:58PM DRAINAGE DITCH THAT RUNS THROUGH THE FRONT OF THE PROPERTY
8:01:01PM WHERE THERE IS A PROPOSED SIDEWALK IN THE IMAGES THAT THEY
8:01:05PM PRESENTED.
8:01:06PM ALSO, FOR THE HABANA REAL ESTATE LLC HAS OWNED THE PROPERTY
8:01:18PM FOR 18 MONTHS, AND UP UNTIL THE HEARING ON JULY 22nd, DID
8:01:25PM NOT REACH OUT TO THE COMMUNITY.
8:01:27PM THEY REACHED OUT TO THE MINIMUM 250 FEET WITH NO REGARD FOR
8:01:33PM WHAT EFFECT IT WOULD HAVE UPON THOSE OF US WHO LIVE ON THE
8:01:37PM STREET THEY ARE PROPOSING TO BUILD ON.
8:01:39PM PEOPLE RACE DOWN THE STREET INTO THEIR OFFICE PARKING LOT
8:01:43PM WITH REGULARITY, IN FACT, TO THE POINT THAT I HAVE
8:01:47PM DOCUMENTED IT.
8:01:48PM NOW, I DON'T WANT TO GET ANYBODY IN TROUBLE, SO I HAVEN'T
8:01:51PM COMPLAINED ABOUT IT TOO TERRIBLY, BUT IT IS AN ISSUE.
8:01:54PM AND THE FACT THAT PEOPLE ARE GOING TO BE GOING TO WORK IN
8:01:57PM THAT SPACE, THE HABANA-ARMENIA CORRIDOR THROUGH CURTIS
8:02:05PM STREET IS A PROBLEM AND IS SOMETHING THAT WE WISH TO HAVE
8:02:09PM PROTECTED FOR OUR CHILDREN TO CONTINUE TO LIVE IN THAT
8:02:13PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
8:02:13PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
8:02:14PM I APPRECIATE YOUR TIME.
8:02:16PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU.
8:02:17PM REBUTTAL?
8:02:19PM I DIDN'T SEE YOU STANDING THERE.
8:02:24PM I'M SO SORRY.
8:02:25PM WE ACTUALLY HAVE MORE PEOPLE.
8:02:26PM NEVER MIND.
8:02:27PM >> I WILL BE THE GUY THAT CALLS BALONEY ON THIS BECAUSE IT
8:02:30PM IS BALONEY.
8:02:31PM I LIKE YOU GUYS --
8:02:34PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: STATE YOUR NAME.
8:02:36PM >> BOB WHITMORE, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR CITY TREE.
8:02:38PM SO THIS IS THE PROPERTY.
8:02:41PM THIS IS THE DOCTOR'S OFFICE.
8:02:47PM AND THIS IS TREES THAT I WILL BE FIGHTING FOR EVENTUALLY
8:02:52PM BECAUSE SHE OWNS THAT.
8:02:54PM SO WHAT WE'VE GOT, AND THEY ALSO OWN THAT HOUSE RIGHT THERE,
8:03:01PM WHICH I DON'T KNOW WHY THEY ARE NOT TURNING THAT INTO
8:03:05PM EXECUTIVE OFFICES.
8:03:06PM IT'S RIGHT ACROSS THE PARKING LOT.
8:03:08PM BUT I'D LIKE TO SAY THAT I AM FROM THE FUTURE AND YOU
8:03:14PM BELIEVE ME BECAUSE I'M FROM THE FUTURE, AND I WANT TO TELL
8:03:18PM YOU WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN.
8:03:20PM GOING TO TEAR THIS DOWN, AND THEN WHAT THEY ARE GOING TO DO
8:03:22PM IS THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE THIS BIG PIECE OF PROPERTY ON THE
8:03:26PM CORNER HERE THAT THEY CAN ACTUALLY PUT A WALGREENS, A CVS,
8:03:31PM WHO KNOWS WHAT THEY'LL COME AND REZONE.
8:03:34PM I'M NOT SURE THAT THERE'S ANYTHING A TREE GUY CAN SAY TO
8:03:38PM STAND IN THE WAY OF THIS.
8:03:41PM I WANT EVERYBODY TO KNOW THAT WE SEE THROUGH THIS.
8:03:45PM AND I KNOW YOU GUYS DO, TOO, AND YOU CAN'T SAY IT BECAUSE
8:03:48PM YOU SORT OF HAVE TO STICK TO A SCRIPT BUT THIS IS BALONEY.
8:03:52PM NOBODY IS GOING TO RENOVATE THAT HOUSE FOR CORPORATE
8:03:55PM OFFICES.
8:03:56PM IT'S NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.
8:03:57PM AND WHAT THEY ARE GOING TO DO IS THEY ARE GOING TO TEAR DOWN
8:03:59PM THE HOUSE AND I HAVE TO COME BACK HERE AND I'M GOING TO HAVE
8:04:02PM TO SAVE A CARBON SUCK LIKE THAT THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT WE ARE
8:04:09PM TRYING TO SAVE IN THE CITY OF TAMPA.
8:04:12PM I'LL LET YOU GUYS MAKE YOUR OWN CALL ON THIS ONE.
8:04:16PM I JUST WANT TO LET YOU KNOW, WE'RE ONTO IT.
8:04:19PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU, SIR.
8:04:20PM NEXT.
8:04:22PM >> MY NAME IS CARLA HARTLEY.
8:04:23PM 2525 WEST CURTIS STREET.
8:04:26PM MY CONCERN WITH THIS IS THE CONTINUED ENCROACHMENT INTO THE
8:04:29PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
8:04:30PM IF THIS HAPPENS, I WILL BE ONE OF THE THREE REMAINING
8:04:37PM RESIDENTIAL SPACES ON THAT SIDE OF THE STREET.
8:04:39PM I THINK EVENTUALLY IT'S JUST GOING TO BE ME SANDWICHED
8:04:42PM BETWEEN -- AND THE PODIATRY GUY DOWN THE STREET.
8:04:47PM MY CONCERN IS IT WILL CONTINUE AND CONTINUE AND I WILL BE
8:04:50PM LEFT WITH NOWHERE.
8:04:53PM THANKFULLY MY CHILDREN ARE GONE, SO I DON'T HAVE TO WORRY
8:04:56PM ABOUT THAT, BUT I DO HAVE A CONCERN ABOUT THE CONTINUED
8:04:59PM PROPERTY VALUE AS A RESIDENCE AS THIS MOVES FORWARD.
8:05:03PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU.
8:05:04PM NEXT.
8:05:04PM STATE YOUR NAME.
8:05:07PM >> GOOD EVENING, CITY COUNCIL.
8:05:09PM MY NAME IS COLBY ENLOW.
8:05:12PM I AM THE PRACTICE ADMINISTRATOR FOR DR. CABRERA CANCIO'S
8:05:17PM OFFICE.
8:05:17PM I WANTED TO SHARE SOME INFORMATION OF MY EFFORTS OF GETTING
8:05:41PM SUPPORT FROM SOME OF THE NEIGHBORS ON THIS REZONING.
8:05:46PM I HAVE THREE LETTERS THAT I'M GOING TO SUBMIT ON --
8:05:50PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN YOU HOLD ON ONE SECOND?
8:05:52PM MR. SHELBY, WOULD THIS BE CONSIDERED PART OF THE PLAINTIFF'S
8:05:57PM REBUTTAL OR IS THIS PUBLIC COMMENT?
8:06:00PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: WELL, I WAS CONTEMPLATING THAT MYSELF.
8:06:05PM HOW LONG HAD THE PRESENTATION GONE, DO YOU KNOW HOW MUCH
8:06:08PM TIME WAS LEFT?
8:06:10PM >>THE CLERK: THEY HAD ABOUT FIVE MINUTES AND 13 SECONDS.
8:06:16PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: RATHER THAN HAVE IT COUNT AGAINST REBUTTAL,
8:06:19PM WE CAN HAVE IT COUNT AGAINST THEIR TIME.
8:06:21PM FOR FUTURE REFERENCE, IT REALLY SHOULD HAVE BEEN PART OF THE
8:06:25PM SAME PRESENTATION.
8:06:26PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WE'LL CONSIDER THIS PART OF YOUR INITIAL
8:06:29PM PRESENTATION AND TAKE IT AWAY FROM THE TIME.
8:06:31PM >> TRUETT GARDNER, 400 NORTH ASHLEY DRIVE.
8:06:34PM TO CLARIFY WHAT COLBY IS DOING, ON BEHALF OF THE NEIGHBORS
8:06:38PM WHO SUPPORT IT, READING LETTERS IN.
8:06:41PM LETTERS OF SUPPORT FROM NEIGHBORS, WHICH IS WHY WE DIDN'T
8:06:44PM MAKE IT A PART --
8:06:45PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: DOES HE LIVE IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD?
8:06:48PM >> HE WORKS IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
8:06:49PM COLBY IS THE ONE WHO TALKED TO THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORS AND
8:06:52PM GARNERED THEIR SUPPORT.
8:06:53PM ON BEHALF --
8:06:55PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN WE JUST RECEIVE AND FILE THESE?
8:06:59PM >> SURE.
8:07:00PM COLBY, IF YOU WANT TO SHOW THE MAP SO THEY CAN SEE THE
8:07:09PM PROXIMITY.
8:07:10PM THESE ARE THE THREE HOMEOWNERS THAT SENT US LETTERS OF
8:07:12PM SUPPORT WITH THE GREEN CHECKS.
8:07:14PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WE CAN TAKE THE MAP WITH THE LETTERS AND
8:07:17PM RECEIVE AND FILE.
8:07:18PM ANY MORE PUBLIC COMMENT.
8:07:34PM >> I APOLOGIZE.
8:07:35PM I NEGLECTED ONE ITEM THAT WAS VERY IMPORTANT.
8:07:42PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WE STILL HAVE SOMEBODY ONLINE?
8:07:44PM I'M SORRY.
8:07:46PM I DON'T KNOW THAT WOULD BE APPROPRIATE.
8:07:47PM CAN YOU HAND THEM TO MR. SHELBY?
8:08:02PM >> IT IS AN ELECTRONIC COPY, UNFORTUNATELY.
8:08:05PM CAN I E-MAIL IT.
8:08:06PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: WELL, IT COULD GO INTO THE QUASI-BOX.
8:08:12PM AT THIS POINT IN TIME, I CAN'T THINK OF A WAY TO PUT THEM IN
8:08:22PM EVIDENCE NOW BEFORE A DECISION IS MADE.
8:08:24PM IF THIS DOES MOVE FORWARD, YOU'LL HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY AT
8:08:27PM SECOND READING.
8:08:28PM >> OKAY.
8:08:29PM THAT'S FINE.
8:08:29PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CLERK, I UNDERSTAND WE HAVE SOMEBODY
8:08:31PM ONLINE.
8:08:33PM >>THE CLERK: YES, WE DO.
8:08:34PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SEAN WILLIAMS, CAN YOU HEAR ME?
8:08:36PM STATE YOUR NAME, PLEASE.
8:08:38PM >> SEAN WILLIAMS.
8:08:39PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HAVE YOU BEEN SWORN IN?
8:08:41PM RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND, PLEASE.
8:08:42PM LET THE CLERK SWEAR YOU IN.
8:08:52PM >>THE CLERK: DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THE TESTIMONY YOU ARE
8:08:54PM ABOUT TO GIVE IS THE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH?
8:08:57PM >> YEP.
8:08:59PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
8:09:01PM STATE YOUR NAME.
8:09:01PM IF YOU CAN SPEAK UP A LITTLE LOUDER, PLEASE.
8:09:06PM >> MY NAME IS SEAN WILLIAMS.
8:09:07PM I LIVE ON CURTIS STREET.
8:09:11PM THE PEOPLE, THE DOCTOR CAME WITH HER BUSINESS MANAGER, THE
8:09:17PM LAST GUY WHO WAS TRYING TO SPEAK FOR TO PRESENT AND THAT WAS
8:09:23PM ONE OF THE FIRST TIMES I HEARD ABOUT THIS.
8:09:25PM NOT NECESSARILY HERE NOR THERE.
8:09:31PM I DON'T REMEMBER THE FIRST OR SECOND PERSON THAT TALKED ON
8:09:36PM THIS ISSUE TALKED ABOUT A RANGE OF USES IN THE AREA.
8:09:39PM THAT'S PART OF THE PLAN AND A RANGE OF USES IS MEDICAL.
8:09:44PM IT'S NOT NECESSARILY A RANGE OF USES IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD.
8:09:48PM THERE'S ONE RANGE OF USES IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD FOR THE MOST
8:09:53PM PART AND THAT'S MEDICAL AND ADDING MORE MEDICAL I DON'T
8:09:55PM THINK REALLY FOLLOWS ALONG WITH THAT PARTICULAR IDEA.
8:10:01PM ON TOP OF THAT, I THINK FUTURE USE, THE FUTURE USE CONCERNS
8:10:06PM THAT OTHERS HAVE BROUGHT UP IS SOMETHING THAT I'M AFRAID OF,
8:10:09PM THAT THERE'S GOING TO BE A SLIPPERY SLOPE SORT OF SITUATION
8:10:12PM WHERE WE'RE GOING TO HAVE IT ZONED RO NOW AND BUMP IT UP TO
8:10:16PM COMMERCIAL LATER AND ADD ON TO MORE SPACE, TO ADD ON TO THE
8:10:23PM ABILITY FOR PEOPLE TO WORK FROM HOME ADMINISTRATIVELY, IT IS
8:10:26PM SO EASY TO WORK FROM HOME, EVEN WITH HIPAA.
8:10:28PM PEOPLE DO MEDICAL CODING AND BILLING ON THAT.
8:10:31PM IT'S REAL SIMPLE.
8:10:32PM I WORK FROM HOME A LOT OF TIMES, WHICH BRINGS ME TO ANOTHER
8:10:35PM POINT.
8:10:35PM WHEN THEY CAME AROUND TO PEOPLE AROUND THE NEIGHBORHOOD,
8:10:38PM THEY DID IT IN THE MIDDLE OF THE DAY WHEN PEOPLE AREN'T
8:10:40PM USUALLY GOING TO BE HOME FROM WORK, WHICH ISN'T NECESSARILY
8:10:43PM OUTREACHING TO THE COMMUNITY.
8:10:45PM I THINK THAT'S ABOUT ALL I'VE GOT.
8:10:47PM I'M JUST CONCERNED THAT THEIR FUTURE USE IS GOING TO BE NOT
8:10:51PM NECESSARILY WHAT THEY ARE SAYING IT IS AND THAT THEY ARE
8:10:53PM GOING TO BE LEASING IT BACK UNDER THEIR LLC TO THEIR
8:10:56PM DOCTOR'S OFFICE AS SORT OF A TAX THING, TOO, TO KIND OF ADD
8:11:00PM ON.
8:11:01PM THANK YOU.
8:11:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU SO MUCH.
8:11:03PM THERE'S NOBODY ELSE ONLINE, CORRECT?
8:11:04PM THAT'S CLOSING PUBLIC COMMENT.
8:11:09PM APPLICANT, DO YOU HAVE REBUTTAL?
8:11:13PM >> YES.
8:11:14PM TRUETT GARDNER, 400 NORTH ASHLEY DRIVE.
8:11:17PM CERTAINLY RESPECT THE COMMENTS AND CONCERNS FROM THE
8:11:20PM NEIGHBORHOODS.
8:11:21PM WANT TO CLARIFY ONE THING.
8:11:23PM THERE ISN'T A NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION.
8:11:24PM ALL WE HAD TO GO BY AT FIRST WAS THE 250-FEET NOTICE AREA.
8:11:28PM DR. CANCIO CAN ATTEST TO THIS AGAIN.
8:11:30PM SHE WENT TO EACH OF THE NEIGHBORS.
8:11:32PM ONLY WHEN WE HEARD OF THE CONCERNS OUTSIDE OF THE 250 FEET
8:11:36PM DID WE REQUEST THE CONTINUANCE AND GO IMMEDIATELY TO THEM
8:11:39PM LITERALLY THE NEXT DAY.
8:11:41PM IT SEEMS LIKE THE BIGGEST CONCERN RAISED WAS TRAFFIC AND ON
8:11:46PM THIS, I BELIEVE THE GENTLEMAN SPOKE TO THIS, IN 2020, THERE
8:11:51PM WERE CALLS MADE I BELIEVE BY HIM, PERHAPS OTHER NEIGHBORS AS
8:11:55PM WELL, COMPLAINING ABOUT TRAFFIC AND SPEEDING ALONG CURTIS.
8:11:59PM THE CITY WENT OUT AND DID A STUDY, AND WHAT YOU SEE HERE IN
8:12:03PM GOOD GATOR COLORS, THE BLACK LINE, DOTTED LINE IS THE SPEED
8:12:07PM LIMIT OF CURTIS, WHICH IS 25, BLUE REPRESENTS EASTBOUND
8:12:12PM TRAFFIC, AND ORANGE REPRESENTS WESTBOUND TRAFFIC.
8:12:18PM THEY EXAMINED IT FOR 72 HOURS STRAIGHT.
8:12:22PM WHAT THEY DETERMINED IS THERE WERE NO SPEEDING PROBLEMS ON
8:12:25PM THE STREET AT ALL.
8:12:26PM THE CASE WAS CLOSED.
8:12:27PM THE FILE WAS CLOSED, AND OUR TRAFFIC ENGINEER IN OUR OFFICE
8:12:32PM REACHED OUT WHEN THIS CONCERN WAS RAISED TO SEE IF WE COULD
8:12:34PM GET THIS.
8:12:35PM THIS WAS THE FINDING.
8:12:37PM WHAT IS IN MY LETTER TODAY IS AN OFFER FROM DR. CANCIO
8:12:41PM CABRERA TO UTILIZE OUR TRAFFIC ENGINEER IN-HOUSE TO REACH
8:12:45PM BACK OUT TO THE CITY TO SEE IF WE CAN WORK TOGETHER AND LOOK
8:12:48PM AT THIS AGAIN TO SEE IF THERE IS AN ISSUE AND IF THERE IS,
8:12:51PM TO WORK WITH THE CITY TO ADDRESS IT.
8:12:53PM I THINK THAT IS THEIR BIGGEST CONCERN.
8:12:55PM AGAIN, COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE WAS DONE BY THE
8:13:00PM CITY TO DETERMINE THERE IS NO ISSUE BY OUR TRAFFIC ENGINEER
8:13:04PM TO CONFIRM THAT AND THEN ALSO TRANSPORTATION AND THE STAFF
8:13:08PM REPORT FINDING CONSISTENCY.
8:13:09PM SIDEWALK WAS MENTIONED.
8:13:10PM I KNOW THIS IS NOT A PD, SO WE CAN'T MAKE CERTAIN
8:13:14PM CONDITIONS, BUT DR. CANCIO SAYS IT IS THEIR INTENTION TO PUT
8:13:17PM A SIDEWALK IN FRONT OF THE STREET SO JUST WANTED TO STATE
8:13:20PM THAT FOR THE RECORD.
8:13:21PM VALUATIONS OF PROPERTIES, THIS WAS RAISED IN THE
8:13:24PM CONVERSATIONS.
8:13:26PM WE WENT OUT INDEPENDENTLY AND GOT A REALTOR WHO SPECIALIZES
8:13:31PM IN THAT AREA.
8:13:32PM HE STUDIED IT AND DETERMINED THAT THERE IS NO NEGATIVE
8:13:37PM EFFECT WHEN YOU HAVE RESIDENTIAL LOCATIONS -- LOCATED NEXT
8:13:41PM TO OFFICE OR COMMERCIAL, EVEN INCLUDING MEDICAL OFFICE IN
8:13:43PM THIS NEIGHBORHOOD.
8:13:44PM AS A MATTER OF FACT, IF YOU'RE ADJACENT TO IT, THERE IS
8:13:47PM ACTUALLY AN ENHANCEMENT IN VALUE PERHAPS BECAUSE OF THE
8:13:49PM POSSIBILITY OF THAT BECOMING COMMERCIAL, SO WE COULD PROVIDE
8:13:52PM THAT FOR THE RECORD ALONG WITH ALL OF HIS RESEARCH.
8:13:55PM AND THEN LASTLY, THE ENCROACHMENT INTO THE NEIGHBORHOOD, IF
8:13:59PM YOU RECALL THE EARLIER SLIDES AND ALSO THE INFORMATION
8:14:01PM PROVIDED BY MS. DOCK, IMMEDIATELY TO OUR SOUTH, IT ACTUALLY
8:14:06PM ENCROACHES FURTHER, SO WE'RE GOING NO FURTHER THAN THAT.
8:14:09PM AGAIN, TO THE SOUTH IS MEDICAL OFFICE.
8:14:12PM WE ARE ASKING FOR RO, WHICH DOES NOT ALLOW FOR MEDICAL
8:14:16PM OFFICE, AND ONLY FOR ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICES WHICH WILL SERVE
8:14:20PM AS MEDICAL OFFICE.
8:14:21PM WE WERE FOUND TO MEET LOCATIONAL CRITERIA.
8:14:25PM AGAIN, FINDINGS OF CONSISTENCY ON THIS VERY TOPIC FROM
8:14:29PM PLANNING COMMISSION AS WELL AS LAND DEVELOPMENT
8:14:29PM COORDINATION.
8:14:33PM LASTLY, I JUST WANTED TO STATE FOR THE RECORD THERE ARE NO
8:14:36PM CONSPIRACY THEORIES HERE, NO BALONEY.
8:14:41PM DR. CANCIO CABRERA CAN SPEAK TO HER INTENTIONS AND NEEDS.
8:14:45PM THE PROPERTY IMMEDIATELY TO THE WEST IS ZONED PD.
8:14:48PM THE REASON WHY, AS STATED BEFORE, WE DID NOT OPEN THE PD TO
8:14:51PM PUT THIS PROPERTY WITHIN IT IS TO PROVIDE THE PROTECTIONS
8:14:54PM FOR THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND SOLELY TO REQUEST RO, WHICH
8:14:58PM SPECIFICALLY DOES NOT ALLOW FOR MEDICAL OFFICE AND ONLY
8:15:01PM ALLOWS FOR ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICES, WHICH IS WHAT WE'RE
8:15:04PM REQUESTING TONIGHT.
8:15:05PM WITH THAT, DR. CANCIO HAS ONE OTHER STATEMENT TO MAKE AND
8:15:12PM THEN WE'LL CLOSE.
8:15:13PM APPRECIATE YOUR TIME AND ATTENTION.
8:15:15PM >> THE COMMENT ABOUT THE TREES WAS REALLY INTERESTING SINCE
8:15:18PM IF YOU LOOK AT WHAT I HAVE DONE IN THE CORNER OF HABANA AND
8:15:23PM CURTIS IS TO MAKE IT LIKE A PARK.
8:15:26PM WE HAVE CAREFULLY KEPT EVERY SINGLE TREE AND KEEP IT
8:15:29PM BEAUTIFIED.
8:15:30PM WE COULD BUILD IN THERE EXTRA BUILDINGS AND WE CHOSE NOT TO
8:15:34PM DO THAT.
8:15:34PM THAT'S ONE POINT.
8:15:35PM NUMBER TWO, ALSO INTERESTING THE POINT ABOUT WORKING FROM
8:15:38PM HOME.
8:15:38PM IF YOU HAVE 70 EMPLOYEES, WE DO HAVE A LOT OF PEOPLE WORKING
8:15:42PM AT HOME.
8:15:43PM BUT THERE ARE SOME ADMINISTRATIVE INDIVIDUALS THAT HAVE TO
8:15:46PM BE IN THE OFFICE.
8:15:47PM THERE ARE SOME FUNCTIONS THAT HAVE TO BE IN PERSON.
8:15:50PM WE'RE ONLY PLANNING TO HAVE SIX INDIVIDUALS IN THAT
8:15:53PM PROPERTY.
8:15:54PM AND WE'RE ONLY TRYING TO PROVIDE BETTER CARE FOR PATIENTS, I
8:16:01PM VERY MUCH APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT.
8:16:03PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
8:16:03PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
8:16:04PM MOTION TO CLOSE?
8:16:08PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
8:16:12PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN CHARLIE MIRANDA.
8:16:15PM ANY DISCUSSION?
8:16:15PM DO WE HAVE A MOTION?
8:16:19PM MR. VIERA.
8:16:21PM GO FOR IT.
8:16:30PM >>LUIS VIERA: THANK YOU, SIR.
8:16:32PM I MOVE AN ORDINANCE PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING
8:16:36PM CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL
8:16:38PM VICINITY OF 2529 WEST CURTIS STREET, IN THE CITY OF TAMPA,
8:16:41PM FLORIDA, AND MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1 FROM
8:16:44PM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION RS-50 (RESIDENTIAL,
8:16:48PM SINGLE-FAMILY TO RO RESIDENTIAL OFFICE); PROVIDING AN
8:16:52PM EFFECTIVE DATE.
8:16:53PM I FIND THAT THE APPLICANT MET BURDEN OF PROOF TO PROVIDE
8:16:56PM COMPETENT SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE AND THAT THE REZONING IS
8:16:58PM CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND CITY CODE ALSO
8:17:00PM ADOPT THE FINDINGS AND REASONING OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION
8:17:02PM AND THE STAFF REPORTS, INCLUDING THE COMPLIANCE WITH
8:17:05PM APPLICABLE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES IN THE
8:17:08PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AS NOTED IN PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
8:17:11PM REPORT AND COMPLIANCE WITH LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
8:17:16PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IS IT APPROPRIATE TO MAKE -- I HAVE A
8:17:23PM QUESTION.
8:17:24PM THE SIDEWALK PART OF THE MOTION?
8:17:25PM THE APPLICANT VOLUNTEERED TO MAKE IT PART --
8:17:30PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I THINK YOU SHOULD REOPEN THE HEARING AND
8:17:32PM HAVE A CONVERSATION WITH THE APPLICANT.
8:17:35PM >>LUIS VIERA: MOVE TO REOPEN.
8:17:36PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: AND ALSO TALK WITH STAFF AS TO WHETHER
8:17:38PM THAT'S PART OF THE SITE PLAN.
8:17:40PM >>CATE WELLS: THERE IS NO SITE PLAN.
8:17:43PM THEY ARE NOT REQUESTING A PD APPROVAL.
8:17:46PM WITH EUCLIDEAN REQUEST, THERE IS NOT THE OPPORTUNITY TO ADD
8:17:53PM --
8:17:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I MOVE TO CLOSE IT.
8:17:56PM >> SECOND.
8:17:56PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WE STILL HAVE A MOTION ON THE FLOOR.
8:18:02PM ALL IN FAVOR OF CLOSING?
8:18:04PM >> AYE.
8:18:05PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OPPOSED?
8:18:07PM >>LUIS VIERA: RESTATE THE MOTION IF I MAY.
8:18:09PM DO YOU WANT ME TO READ IT ALL?
8:18:16PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: NO.
8:18:17PM DO WE HAVE A SECOND.
8:18:18PM MOTION ON THE FLOOR FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
8:18:20PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
8:18:22PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
8:18:24PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: CAN YOU RESTATE THE MOTION?
8:18:26PM I THINK IT'S WHEN I WAS RUNNING DOWN THE HALL.
8:18:29PM >>LUIS VIERA: MOTION MOVING TO PASS ITEM NUMBER 4.
8:18:32PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES, GO AHEAD.
8:18:35PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
8:18:37PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
8:18:39PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
8:18:40PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
8:18:42PM >>BILL CARLSON: NO.
8:18:44PM >>LYNN HURTAK: NO.
8:18:48PM >>THE CLERK: MANISCALCO ABSTAIN.
8:18:49PM MOTION CARRIED WITH CARLSON, HURTAK VOTING NO, MANISCALCO
8:18:57PM ABSTAIN.
8:18:58PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER 7,
8:19:03PM 2023, AT 9:30 A.M. AT 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, TAMPA,
8:19:09PM FLORIDA.
8:19:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I WOULD LIKE TO FILE THIS FORM REGARDING
8:19:27PM MY ABSTAINING FROM THE VOTES.
8:19:28PM MOVE TO RECEIVE AND FILE, YES, SIR.
8:19:31PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
8:19:41PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE.
8:19:44PM WHO MADE THE MOTION?
8:19:57PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WE HAVE A MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE.
8:20:00PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
8:20:02PM ALL THOSE IN FAVOR AYE.
8:20:04PM OPPOSED?
8:20:04PM THE AYES HAVE IT.
8:20:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER 4.
8:20:19PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: NUMBER 5, I THINK.
8:20:21PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
8:20:25PM ITEM NUMBER 5 IS REZ-23-49.
8:20:29PM THIS IS FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 6603 SOUTH TRASK STREET.
8:20:34PM THE APPLICANT IS REPRESENTED BY KAMI CORBETT.
8:20:36PM THE REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY FROM PD PLANNED
8:20:39PM DEVELOPMENT, WHICH CURRENTLY ALLOWS FOR RESIDENTIAL
8:20:42PM MULTIFAMILY TO PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT FOR RESIDENTIAL
8:20:46PM MULTIFAMILY USE.
8:20:46PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO EMILY TO GIVE HER REPORT AND I'LL COME
8:20:50PM BACK AND GIVE MY REPORT.
8:20:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
8:21:03PM >>EMILY PHELAN: EMILY PHELAN, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
8:21:05PM THE SITE IS WITHIN THE SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT AND THE
8:21:07PM PORT TAMPA CITY NEIGHBORHOOD.
8:21:09PM PORTIONS OF THE SITE ARE LOCATED WITHIN THE COASTAL HIGH
8:21:12PM HAZARD AREA.
8:21:14PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS HERE, VERY LARGE.
8:21:16PM THE SURROUNDING AREA IS A MIXTURE OF MULTIFAMILY AND
8:21:21PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED THAT YOU CAN SEE TO THE NORTH AND THE
8:21:24PM EAST AS WELL AS THE SOUTH.
8:21:26PM THIS RIGHT HERE IS CSX RIGHT-OF-WAY.
8:21:33PM AND THIS IS THE PARK.
8:21:37PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS HERE.
8:21:39PM REPRESENTED BY THE TRANSITIONAL USE 24 FUTURE LAND USE
8:21:42PM DESIGNATION, WHICH DOES EXTEND TO THE WEST AS WELL.
8:21:45PM TO THE NORTH AND THE SOUTH IS THE RESIDENTIAL 10, AND THIS
8:21:51PM IS RESIDENTIAL 20 AND THIS IS RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE,
8:21:54PM WHICH IS WHERE THE PARK IS LOCATED.
8:21:56PM THE SITE WAS PREVIOUSLY APPROVED FOR 205 MULTIFAMILY UNITS
8:22:01PM THROUGH A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT PER REZ 19-94.
8:22:06PM PER THE APPLICANT, THERE WAS A DISCREPANCY IN THE LEGAL
8:22:10PM DESCRIPTION OF THE SITE AND THE TOTAL ACREAGE.
8:22:12PM THERE WAS A LOSS OF A 15-FOOT STRIP OF LAND THAT RESULTED IN
8:22:15PM A NEW TOTAL ACREAGE.
8:22:17PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDING HAS REMAINED CONSISTENT AS
8:22:20PM THE REQUEST REMAINS THE SAME.
8:22:21PM THE REQUEST SUPPORTS MANY POLICIES IN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
8:22:25PM AS IT RELATES TO HOUSING THE CITY'S POPULATION.
8:22:27PM THE REQUEST PROVIDES ADDITIONAL HOUSING IN THE PORT TAMPA
8:22:30PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
8:22:30PM PORTIONS OF THE SUBJECT SITE ARE WITHIN THE COASTAL HIGH
8:22:34PM HAZARD AREA AND EVACUATION ZONE A.
8:22:36PM REZONINGS IN THE COASTAL PLANNING AREA THAT INCREASE THE
8:22:39PM NUMBER OF RESIDENTIAL UNITS SHALL MITIGATE THE IMPACT ON
8:22:41PM SHELTER SPACE AND THEY SHALL CONTINUE TO COORDINATE ANY
8:22:45PM HURRICANE MITIGATION PAYMENTS WITH HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY AND
8:22:47PM THE CITY OF TAMPA.
8:22:48PM THE ADOPTED AUGUST 2016 GREENWAYS AND TRAILS PLAN UPDATED BY
8:22:53PM THE MPO, THE METROPOLITAN PLANNING ORGANIZATION, IDENTIFIES
8:22:57PM THE EXISTING CSX RIGHT-OF-WAY ADJACENT TO THE SUBJECT SITE
8:23:01PM AS A CONCEPTUAL TRAIL.
8:23:03PM THE APPLICANT HAS PROVIDED A NOTE ON THE SITE PLAN
8:23:06PM ADDRESSING A FUTURE CONNECTION AT THE TIME OF CONSTRUCTION
8:23:09PM AND CONSISTENT WITH RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE POLICIES 2.3.1
8:23:14PM AND 2.4.9.
8:23:15PM THE PROPOSED PLANNED DEVELOPMENT WOULD ALLOW FOR DEVELOPMENT
8:23:19PM THAT IS COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH THE CHARACTER OF THE
8:23:23PM SURROUNDING USES AND CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN
8:23:25PM ANTICIPATED UNDER THE TRANSITIONAL USE 24 FUTURE LAND USE
8:23:29PM DESIGNATION.
8:23:29PM AND THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
8:23:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
8:23:32PM ANY QUESTIONS.
8:23:34PM MS. DOCK.
8:23:36PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
8:23:37PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
8:23:39PM COUNCIL, THIS REZONING REQUEST, AS EMILY HAS MENTIONED AND
8:23:44PM HAS BRIEFED ON, SO THE USE CURRENTLY EXISTING ON THE SITE
8:23:49PM AND THIS PD IS APPROVED FOR RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY.
8:23:53PM THE REQUEST WHICH IS BEFORE YOU IS FOR THE SAME USE.
8:23:55PM THE SITE HAS BEEN DEVELOPED, BUT THIS PD REQUEST WILL
8:23:59PM ESTABLISH NEWLY CONFIRMED PROPERTY LINES WITH THE NEW
8:24:03PM PROPERTY BOUNDARY CONTAINING A REDUCTION OF A 15-FOOT STRIP
8:24:07PM OF LAND.
8:24:07PM AND THAT IS ON THE NORTHEAST SIDE OF THE SITE.
8:24:10PM AND WHAT I CAN DO IS SHOW YOU THE ZONING ATLAS OF THE SITE
8:24:17PM ITSELF.
8:24:17PM SO THIS IS THE SITE WHICH IS OUTLINED IN RED.
8:24:20PM THIS IS McCOY STREET.
8:24:22PM THIS IS WESTSHORE JUST TO ORIENT YOU ON THE MAP, AND THIS IS
8:24:26PM MANHATTAN AVENUE.
8:24:27PM SO YOU CAN SEE THIS IS THE PD AND THEN YOU'LL SEE THE SLIGHT
8:24:31PM MODIFICATION, WHICH IS OF THE BOUNDARY THAT'S ON THE
8:24:34PM NORTHEAST SIDE OF THE SITE.
8:24:36PM YOU HAVE IT SURROUNDED WITH RM 16, RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY
8:24:40PM ZONING TO THE EAST, AND THEN YOU HAVE RESIDENTIAL
8:24:43PM SINGLE-FAMILY THAT'S LOCATED NORTH AND SOUTH OF THE SITE
8:24:47PM ITSELF.
8:24:48PM FOR THE CHANGES THAT ARE INCLUDED IN THIS PD REQUEST,
8:24:52PM INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING: SO DUE TO THE ADJUSTMENT OF THE
8:24:55PM PROPERTY BOUNDARY, THE EAST SIDE YARD SETBACK IS NOW AT 25
8:25:00PM FEET, COMPARED TO IT PREVIOUSLY BEING AT 40 FEET.
8:25:04PM AND THE PERVIOUS AREA IS 4.48 ACRES, AND THAT'S COMPARED TO
8:25:08PM THE PREVIOUS AREA OF 4.59 ACRES.
8:25:11PM THE PROJECT AREA OVERALL IS NOW 10.21 ACRES, AND THAT'S
8:25:16PM COMPARED TO THE 10.32 ACRES PREVIOUSLY.
8:25:20PM THE GREENSPACE AREA IS 160,499 SQUARE FEET, AND THAT'S
8:25:26PM COMPARED TO THE PREVIOUS AREA OF 165,291 SQUARE FEET.
8:25:31PM THE UNITS PER ACRE CALCULATION IS ROUGHLY THE SAME FROM
8:25:35PM 20.08, AND THAT'S COMPARED TO THE PREVIOUS 20 ON-SITE.
8:25:41PM SO THE SITE IS DEVELOPED WITH FOUR BUILDINGS ON-SITE.
8:25:45PM LET ME SHOW YOU THE SITE PLAN.
8:25:46PM ON THE SITE -- MOVE IT UP A LITTLE BIT.
8:25:54PM THIS IS McCOY STREET THAT'S LOCATED ON THE SOUTH, AND THEN
8:25:58PM YOU CAN SEE THESE ARE THE BUILDINGS THAT ARE LOCATED
8:26:00PM ON-SITE.
8:26:01PM THIS IS BUILDING NUMBER 1, NUMBER 2, NUMBER 3, AND NUMBER 4.
8:26:05PM SO ENTRANCE TO THE SITE IS ON McCOY, AND THEN INTERNAL
8:26:10PM GATE ONE IS FOR RESIDENTS AND VISITORS AND THEN ONE GATE IS
8:26:14PM LOCATED HERE FOR RESIDENTS ONLY.
8:26:16PM SURFACE PARKING IS LOCATED HERE WITH SOME GARAGE PARKING.
8:26:20PM AND THEN THE AMENITIES ARE LOCATED THROUGHOUT THE SITE WITH
8:26:25PM -- AND THE POOL THERE.
8:26:26PM I HAVE PICTURES OF THE SITE.
8:26:28PM ELEVATIONS WERE SUBMITTED.
8:26:30PM THEY ARE THE SAME STRUCTURES WHICH ARE CONSTRUCTED.
8:26:32PM I CAN JUST SHOW YOU THE PICTURES OF THE SITE.
8:26:35PM SO THIS IS THE VIEW.
8:26:38PM THIS IS THE ENTRANCE.
8:26:39PM SO THE SITE, AND THAT IS THE VIEW IF YOU'RE LOOKING NORTH AT
8:26:44PM THE SITE.
8:26:45PM THAT'S ONE OF THE GATES THAT'S SHOWN THERE.
8:26:47PM AND THIS IS HEADED ON THE EAST SIDE OF THE SITE.
8:26:53PM THIS IS THE EASTERN BOUNDARY AND THAT IS IF YOU'RE LOOKING
8:26:56PM NORTH ON WALL STREET.
8:26:59PM ANOTHER VIEW RUNNING ALONG THE EAST BOUNDARY.
8:27:02PM SO THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE, ONE OF THE RESIDENTIAL
8:27:06PM SINGLE-FAMILY, AND THEN I HAVE ADDITIONAL PICTURES SOUTH OF
8:27:08PM THE SITE.
8:27:11PM THESE ARE SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES.
8:27:15PM AND THEN THIS IS FURTHER SOUTH, SOUTHWEST.
8:27:19PM THE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND
8:27:24PM FINDS THE REQUEST CONSISTENT.
8:27:25PM THERE ARE SITE PLAN MODIFICATIONS TO BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST
8:27:28PM AND SECOND READING AND THAT'S BEEN PROVIDED ON THE REVISION
8:27:31PM SHEET SUBMITTED.
8:27:33PM I'M AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
8:27:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
8:27:37PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I JUST WANTED TO CLARIFY, THIS PROJECT HAS
8:27:40PM ALREADY BEEN BUILT.
8:27:42PM THEY JUST DIDN'T HAVE THE SAME LINES THEY NEEDED OR THE SITE
8:27:48PM PLAN IS NOT -- WAS NOT CORRECT.
8:27:51PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: SO IT WAS DISCOVERED THROUGH ADDITIONAL
8:27:55PM TITLE SEARCH AND A NEW SURVEY THAT WAS DONE, NEW SURVEY WORK
8:28:01PM THAT THE PROPERTY BOUNDARY HAD CHANGED, THAT IT WAS A
8:28:04PM DIFFERENT ONE.
8:28:05PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
8:28:06PM I WANTED TO MAKE SURE I CLARIFIED THAT SO PEOPLE UNDERSTOOD.
8:28:10PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: ADMINISTRATIVELY WE CANNOT APPROVE SO --
8:28:15PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OF COURSE.
8:28:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: APPLICANT.
8:28:18PM >> GOOD EVENING.
8:28:19PM JAIME MAIER OF THE LAW FIRM HILL, WARD, HENDERSON.
8:28:20PM 101 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD.
8:28:23PM I'M REPRESENTING THE APPLICANT.
8:28:24PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
8:28:25PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MS. DOCK, FOR THE PRESENTATION AND THE
8:28:27PM STAFF REPORT.
8:28:27PM I'M GOING TO ADD A LITTLE BIT OF BACKGROUND.
8:28:29PM SO THIS WAS AN APPROVED AND FULLY CONSTRUCTED PD.
8:28:33PM THE LEGAL DESCRIPTION THAT WAS USED IN THE PD SITE PLAN MADE
8:28:37PM REFERENCE TO VACATED PLATTED RIGHTS-OF-WAY.
8:28:39PM SO IT WAS SUBJECT TO MULTIPLE INTERPRETATIONS.
8:28:42PM THE SURVEY THAT THE PD SITE PLAN WAS BASED ON AT THE TIME OF
8:28:45PM APPROVAL WAS AN INTERPRETATION THAT THE APPLICANT OWNED THAT
8:28:48PM 15-FOOT STRIP OF LAND IN QUESTION.
8:28:51PM SO THAT WAS INCLUDED IN THE SITE PLAN.
8:28:53PM THERE ARE, HOWEVER, NEIGHBORS WHO HAVE EXISTING SHEDS AND
8:28:57PM OTHER STRUCTURES WITHIN THAT AREA THAT ARE SHOWN ON THE
8:28:59PM SURVEY.
8:29:00PM AND THE APPLICANT APPROACHED THE NEIGHBORS REGARDING THOSE
8:29:03PM ENCROACHMENTS.
8:29:04PM SOME NEIGHBORS AGREED WITH THE APPLICANT'S INTERPRETATION
8:29:07PM THAT THE APPLICANT OWNED THE LAND AND OTHERS MAINTAINED THAT
8:29:11PM WAS NOT THE CORRECT INTERPRETATION AND THAT THE APPLICANT
8:29:13PM DID NOT OWN THAT LAND.
8:29:14PM SO THE APPLICANT DIRECTED THEIR SURVEYOR TO REVIEW IT AND
8:29:17PM THE SURVEYOR AGREED THAT THE NEIGHBOR'S INTERPRETATION WAS A
8:29:20PM REASONABLE INTERPRETATION, THAT THE APPLICANT DIDN'T OWN
8:29:23PM THAT 15-FOOT STRIP.
8:29:25PM AND SO THE APPLICANT HAS BEEN WILLING TO ACCEPT THAT
8:29:28PM INTERPRETATION, HENCE THE NEED TO REVISE THE PD TO REMOVE
8:29:31PM THAT PIECE OF LAND FROM THE PROPERTY AND THAT'S RESULTED IN
8:29:34PM THE CHANGES THAT MISS DOCK OUTLINED FOR YOU.
8:29:37PM AND THAT'S WHY WE'RE HERE, AND MY UNDERSTANDING IS THAT THE
8:29:41PM NEIGHBORS ARE IN SUPPORT.
8:29:42PM WE BELIEVE THIS IS OVERALL A GOOD RESOLUTION FOR EVERYONE,
8:29:45PM AND WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL.
8:29:47PM I'M HERE FOR QUESTIONS.
8:29:48PM THANK YOU.
8:29:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
8:29:50PM PUBLIC COMMENT?
8:29:57PM >> GOOD EVENING.
8:29:58PM STEPHANIE POYNOR.
8:30:02PM I'M HERE BECAUSE THIS IS A CASE OF THE DEVELOPER DOING THE
8:30:06PM RIGHT THING.
8:30:06PM THAT 15 FEET TOOK LIKE THREE-QUARTERS OF SOME OF THOSE
8:30:11PM FOLKS' BACKYARD.
8:30:12PM I MANAGE ONE OF THE PROPERTIES AND I'M FRIENDS WITH ANOTHER
8:30:15PM ONE OF THE PROPERTIES, AND WE ACTUALLY HAD QUITE A BIT OF
8:30:17PM INTERACTION WITH THE NEIGHBORS ON THIS.
8:30:19PM AND THE DEVELOPER MADE OFFERS TO PURCHASE IT AND ONE OF THEM
8:30:24PM HELD OUT.
8:30:24PM SO THEY ARE EXTREMELY EXCITED TO HEAR THAT THEY ARE HERE
8:30:30PM TONIGHT, AND ASKING TO LEAVE THE LAND WHERE IT IS.
8:30:36PM THOSE FOLKS HAVE LIVED THERE SINCE THE '90s.
8:30:38PM I THINK THERE ARE SIX HOUSES.
8:30:40PM FIVE OR SIX.
8:30:41PM AND OF THOSE, I THINK ALL OF THEM ARE THE ORIGINAL OWNER.
8:30:45PM SO THOSE HOUSES WERE BUILT.
8:30:47PM THESE PEOPLE PUT UP FENCES.
8:30:49PM THEY THOUGHT THAT WAS THEIR BACKYARD AND THEN THEY COME HOME
8:30:52PM ONE DAY AND THERE'S LIKE HALF THEIR BACKYARD IS GONE.
8:30:56PM THIS IS A CASE OF THE DEVELOPER DOING THE RIGHT THING.
8:30:58PM I THINK IT'S ALREADY SOLD ANYWAY.
8:31:00PM BUT THANK YOU.
8:31:01PM I JUST LIKE TO SUPPORT THINGS PERIODICALLY.
8:31:04PM THIS ONE AND MR. MANASSE HAS A LETTER FROM ME FOR THE LATER
8:31:08PM ONE.
8:31:08PM I'M GOING HOME.
8:31:09PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I'M GOING TO GO PLAY THE LOTTERY TONIGHT.
8:31:12PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YEAH, ME TOO.
8:31:14PM ANYBODY ELSE?
8:31:14PM ALL RIGHT.
8:31:18PM IF THERE ARE NO OTHER QUESTIONS, DO YOU HAVE REBUTTAL?
8:31:21PM >> I JUST WANT TO SAY THANK YOU TO MS. POYNOR FOR STAYING TO
8:31:24PM SPEAK ON THIS ITEM.
8:31:25PM I APPRECIATE IT AND I KNOW IT'S BEEN A LONG NIGHT.
8:31:28PM THANK YOU AND THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
8:31:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: CAN I GET A MOTION TO CLOSE?
8:31:31PM MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
8:31:32PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
8:31:34PM ALL IN FAVOR?
8:31:35PM AYE.
8:31:36PM ANY OPPOSED?
8:31:37PM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON, WOULD YOU MIND READING THIS ITEM.
8:31:43PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I MOVE FILE NUMBER REZ-23-49, I MOVE FILE
8:31:58PM REZ-23-49, AN ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL
8:32:05PM VICINITY OF 6603 SOUTH TRASK STREET IN THE CITY OF TAMPA,
8:32:09PM FLORIDA, AND MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1 FROM
8:32:12PM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION PD (PLANNED DEVELOPMENT) TO
8:32:16PM PD (PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, RESIDENTIAL, MULTIFAMILY);
8:32:20PM PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
8:32:21PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
8:32:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
8:32:24PM HENDERSON WITH A SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
8:32:26PM ROLL CALL.
8:32:28PM >>THE CLERK: HENDERSON?
8:32:29PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
8:32:31PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
8:32:33PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
8:32:35PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
8:32:36PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
8:32:38PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
8:32:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
8:32:41PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
8:32:43PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER 7,
8:32:48PM 2023, AT 9:30 A.M. AT THE OLD CITY HALL BUILDING, 315 EAST
8:32:53PM KENNEDY BOULEVARD, TAMPA, FLORIDA.
8:32:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
8:32:59PM SIX MORE TO GO.
8:33:00PM NUMBER 6.
8:33:05PM >>ZAIN HUSAIN: ZAIN HUSAIN, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
8:33:06PM AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 6, CASE REZ-23-57.
8:33:10PM THIS IS A REQUEST FOR A REZONING AT THE LOCATION 2917 EAST
8:33:14PM COLUMBUS DRIVE, PROPOSED REZONING FROM RM 24 TO PD,
8:33:21PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED.
8:33:22PM PASS ALONG TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
8:33:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
8:33:24PM YES, MA'AM.
8:33:35PM >>EMILY PHELAN: EMILY PHELAN, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
8:33:37PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE CENTRAL TAMPA
8:33:40PM PLANNING DISTRICT AND THE JACKSON HEIGHTS NEIGHBORHOOD.
8:33:43PM THE SURROUNDING AREA CONSISTS MOSTLY OF SINGLE-FAMILY
8:33:47PM DETACHED TO THE EAST AND THE SOUTH AND TO THE NORTH AND WEST
8:33:52PM ARE MULTIFAMILY USES.
8:33:53PM DO I NEED TO ZOOM IN?
8:33:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHAT IS THE CROSS STREET?
8:33:58PM 22nd AND COLUMBUS?
8:34:01PM >>EMILY PHELAN: I'M SORRY.
8:34:02PM THIS IS EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE AND THIS IS NORTH 26th STREET.
8:34:07PM 29th.
8:34:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: 29th.
8:34:09PM OKAY.
8:34:10PM THANK YOU.
8:34:10PM >>EMILY PHELAN: THE SUBJECT SITE IS HERE AND IT IS
8:34:17PM REPRESENTED BY THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35 DESIGNATION, WHICH
8:34:21PM ALLOWS UP TO 35 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE.
8:34:23PM AND IT IS THE SAME DESIGNATION, LOCATED TO THE EAST, THE
8:34:27PM SOUTH, AND THE WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND TO THE NORTH OF
8:34:30PM THE SUBJECT SITE DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET IS RESIDENTIAL
8:34:33PM 35.
8:34:35PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ENCOURAGES INFILL DEVELOPMENT TO HELP
8:34:38PM ENSURE AN ADEQUATE AMOUNT OF LAND AS PRESERVED IS PLANNED TO
8:34:43PM SUPPORT TAMPA'S GROWING POPULATION.
8:34:44PM WHILE THE PROPOSED DENSITY IS CONSISTENT WITH THE UNDERLYING
8:34:48PM FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION, THE REQUEST IS INCONSISTENT
8:34:51PM WITH SEVERAL COMPREHENSIVE PLAN POLICIES.
8:34:54PM LAND USE POLICY 6.1.2 AND 9.2.6 ENCOURAGE THE DESIGN AND
8:35:01PM DEVELOPMENT OF SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED PROJECTS TO INCLUDE
8:35:03PM THE ORIENTATION OF FRONT DOORS TO SIDEWALKS AND STREETS.
8:35:07PM THE SITE PLAN PROPOSES ONE OF THE UNITS FRONT ENTRY TOWARD
8:35:11PM THE RIGHT-OF-WAY BUT NO PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIONS ARE PROVIDED
8:35:15PM FROM THE UNIT ENTRANCES TO THE SIDEWALK ON EAST COLUMBUS
8:35:17PM DRIVE AND THERE ARE ALSO NO INTERNAL PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIONS.
8:35:21PM THE CURRENT DESIGN IS A SAFETY CONCERN BECAUSE RESIDENTS
8:35:24PM WILL BE FORCED TO WALK INTO THE DRIVE AISLE TO ACCESS THE
8:35:28PM PUBLIC SIDEWALK, WHICH DOES NOT MEET THE INTENT OF LAND USE
8:35:30PM POLICIES 4.3.2 AND 4.3.6.
8:35:34PM EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE IS A TRANSIT EMPHASIS CORRIDOR AND THE
8:35:38PM SITE IS WITHIN A MIXED USE CORRIDOR.
8:35:40PM THE MIXED USE CORRIDOR POLICY SUPPORT WALKING AND TRANSIT
8:35:43PM USES AND THE SITE PLAN IS NOT PROVIDING SAFE CONNECTIONS TO
8:35:46PM TRANSIT.
8:35:47PM OVERALL, THE PROPOSED PD IS INCONSISTENT WITH POLICY
8:35:50PM DIRECTION OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
8:35:52PM THE PD DOES NOT ENGAGE THE PUBLIC REALM OR PROVIDE SAFE
8:35:56PM PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIONS FROM THE THREE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED
8:35:59PM UNITS TO THE SIDEWALK ALONG EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE.
8:36:03PM THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
8:36:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
8:36:05PM ANY QUESTIONS?
8:36:06PM MR. HUSAIN.
8:36:13PM >>ZAIN HUSAIN: I'LL FIRST SHOW THE AERIAL VIEW OF THE
8:36:15PM PROPERTY AND TALK ABOUT THAT.
8:36:16PM AS YOU SEE, THE PROPERTY HERE OUTLINED IN RED.
8:36:23PM SURROUNDING THE WHOLE ENTIRE PROPERTY IS RM 24 ZONING.
8:36:26PM THESE ARE ALL A COMBINATION OF RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY AND
8:36:29PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY.
8:36:30PM ZOOM ON OUT JUST A LITTLE BIT, AS YOU LOOK TO THE SOUTH,
8:36:40PM YOU'LL HAVE THE INTERSTATE.
8:36:41PM IF YOU LOOK TO THE EAST, YOU'LL HAVE EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE.
8:36:44PM TO THE NORTH YOU'LL HAVE EAST 18th AVENUE AND TO THE WEST
8:36:48PM YOU WILL HAVE NORTH 28th STREET.
8:36:52PM I'LL NOW GO AHEAD AND SHOW THE SITE PLAN PROVIDED BY THE
8:37:02PM APPLICANT AND I'LL SPEAK ON THAT.
8:37:03PM THE PROPOSED REZONING IS TO ALLOW FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE
8:37:17PM PROPERTY WITH THREE RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED
8:37:21PM UNITS.
8:37:21PM THE SUBJECT SITE OF THE PROPERTY IS AT THE SOUTH SIDE OF
8:37:26PM EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE BETWEEN NORTH 29th STREET AND THE CSX
8:37:30PM TRACKS.
8:37:31PM VEHICULAR ACCESS TO THE SITE COMES FROM THE NORTH.
8:37:35PM YOU HAVE EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE.
8:37:39PM THE SQUARE FOOTAGE OF THE LOT IS 4,711 SQUARE FEET OR .11
8:37:49PM ACRES.
8:37:49PM THE MAXIMUM HEIGHT IS 35 FEET IN HEIGHT AND PROPOSED THREE
8:37:55PM STORIES.
8:37:55PM THE EXISTING USE OF THE LOT IS VACANT AT THIS TIME.
8:37:58PM THE NUMBER OF PARKING SPACES AS YOU SEE, YOU HAVE SIX
8:38:04PM PROVIDED BY THE APPLICANT, ONE, TWO, THREE, FOUR, FIVE, SIX,
8:38:08PM AND BY CODE THEY ARE REQUIRED TO HAVE SEVEN PARKING SPACES
8:38:11PM WHICH WILL REQUIRE A WAIVER.
8:38:13PM I WILL NOW SHOW THE ELEVATIONS PROVIDED BY THE APPLICANT.
8:38:21PM THE ELEVATION TO THE SOUTH.
8:38:34PM ELEVATION TO THE NORTH.
8:38:35PM ELEVATION TO THE EAST.
8:38:42PM AND ELEVATION TO THE WEST.
8:38:48PM AS I WENT OUT ON-SITE AND TOOK PICTURES, I WILL SHOW YOU
8:38:58PM WHAT I SAW.
8:38:59PM THIS IS THE VACANT SITE AS IS.
8:39:11PM DIRECTLY WEST OF THE SITE, RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY.
8:39:26PM IF YOU LOOK DOWN COLUMBUS DRIVE, YOU'LL SEE MORE RESIDENTIAL
8:39:41PM SINGLE-FAMILY AND MULTIFAMILY.
8:39:43PM AS YOU LOOK DIRECTLY EAST OF THE SITE, RESIDENTIAL
8:39:53PM SINGLE-FAMILY.
8:40:01PM AND NORTH OF THE SITE YOU'LL HAVE RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY.
8:40:05PM I WILL SHOW YOU THE SITE PLAN ONE MORE TIME.
8:40:14PM NOW THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING FIVE WAIVERS.
8:40:32PM THE FIRST WAIVER IS TO ALLOW THE FRONT DOORS TO FACE THE
8:40:35PM SIDE YARD PROPERTY LINES.
8:40:37PM THE SECOND WAIVER IS TO ALLOW A REDUCTION IN AISLE WIDTH
8:40:40PM FROM 24 FEET TO 20 FEET.
8:40:43PM THE THIRD REQUESTED WAIVER IS TO ALLOW THE PARKING TO GO
8:40:47PM FROM 7 REQUIRED SPACES TO 6 SPACES, WHICH IS ABOUT A 14%
8:40:51PM REDUCTION.
8:40:52PM THE FOURTH WAIVER IS TO REQUEST TO REDUCE THE REQUIRED
8:40:57PM 5-FOOT USE TO USE LANDSCAPE BUFFER FROM -- SORRY, TO 3.24
8:41:02PM FEET TO THE EAST ADJACENT TO SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL.
8:41:05PM AND THE FIFTH WAIVER IS TO REQUEST TO REDUCE THE REAR YARD
8:41:09PM FROM 15 FEET TO 5 FEET AND SIDE YARD FROM 5 FEET TO 3 FEET.
8:41:14PM DEVELOPMENT REVIEW AND COMPLIANCE STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE
8:41:19PM APPLICATION AND FINDS THE OVERALL REQUEST TO BE INCONSISTENT
8:41:21PM WITH THE LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS.
8:41:23PM FINDINGS FROM TRANSPORTATION, URBAN DESIGN TO HAVE THIS
8:41:27PM FINDING.
8:41:28PM SHOULD BE THE PLEASURE OF CITY COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE
8:41:30PM APPLICATION, THE APPLICANT MUST PROVIDE REVISIONS TO THE
8:41:33PM REVISION SHEET BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
8:41:35PM I'M HERE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
8:41:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
8:41:37PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
8:41:40PM APPLICANT.
8:41:50PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: STEVE MICHELINI, REPRESENTING THE
8:41:52PM PETITIONER.
8:41:53PM THERE WAS AN OVERSIGHT ON THE SITE PLAN WHICH I DISCUSSED
8:41:55PM WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REGARDING THE SIDEWALKS
8:41:59PM THAT WERE MISSING FROM THE SITE PLAN AND THE CONNECTIVITY TO
8:42:02PM COLUMBUS DRIVE.
8:42:03PM IF THIS IS THE PLEASURE OF COUNCIL TO APPROVE THIS, WE'LL
8:42:08PM MAKE THAT CORRECTION BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
8:42:11PM THE SITE I THINK AS STAFF HAD POINTED OUT, IS IMMEDIATELY
8:42:19PM NORTH OF INTERSTATE 4, AND THE INTERCHANGE COMING OFF OF THE
8:42:25PM PORT AUTHORITY.
8:42:26PM THERE IS THE PROPERTY.
8:42:31PM IT IS VACANT.
8:42:32PM AND THERE IS A LOT OF REDEVELOPMENT OCCURRING IN THIS AREA.
8:42:36PM THAT'S A BETTER PICTURE OF THE SITE.
8:42:39PM THIS IS DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET.
8:42:43PM I'M SORRY, IT'S ON THE BACK SIDE OF THE STREET.
8:42:46PM THOSE ARE TOWN HOUSES AND APARTMENT BUILDINGS.
8:42:54PM THIS IS DOWN AT THE OTHER SIDE OF THE STREET.
8:42:56PM IT'S SOME KIND OF APARTMENT BUILDING.
8:43:01PM THIS IS AT THE CORNER ON THE EAST SIDE WHERE IT'S A SERIES
8:43:05PM OF DUPLEXES, AND THEN THIS IS THE STREET GOING DOWN TO THE
8:43:10PM SUBJECT PROPERTY.
8:43:13PM SINCE THE OTHER PICTURES WERE TAKEN, IT'S NO LONGER ADJACENT
8:43:18PM TO A SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL.
8:43:21PM PROPERTIES HAVE BEEN REDEVELOPED FOR DUPLEXES.
8:43:27PM THAT YOU CAN SEE GOING DOWN, THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS
8:43:29PM IMMEDIATELY TO THE LEFT AND THERE IS A WHOLE SERIES OF
8:43:34PM DUPLEXES GOING ALL THE WAY DOWN TO THE END OF THE STREET.
8:43:37PM AS STAFF POINTED OUT, THIS IS RESIDENTIAL 35.
8:43:42PM YOU COULD BUILD THREE UNITS BY RIGHT.
8:43:45PM THE HEIGHT IS 35 FEET.
8:43:47PM WE DO HAVE SOME SLIGHT ELEVATION ISSUES REGARDING HAVING TO
8:43:52PM MEET THE FLOOD ZONE AREAS.
8:43:55PM AND AS I SAID, THE PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIVITY WILL BE RESOLVED
8:43:59PM IN A REVISED SITE PLAN.
8:44:01PM IT IS ADJACENT TO A TRANSIT CORRIDOR.
8:44:05PM THIS AREA DOESN'T HAVE A LOT OF NEW HOUSING GOING IN IT.
8:44:08PM THIS IS IN THE EAST TAMPA SECTION OF TOWN AND, QUITE
8:44:13PM HONESTLY, I WOULD SAY THAT IT IS -- IT'S A LEAP TO BE
8:44:19PM BUILDING NEW HOUSES IN THIS AREA, BUT THERE IS SOME ACTIVITY
8:44:24PM HERE AND APPARENTLY THERE ARE SOME BUILDERS WHO ARE WILLING
8:44:29PM TO GO IN HERE AND BUILD DUPLEXES, A SERIES OF DUPLEXES ALL
8:44:33PM THE WAY FROM THE SUBJECT SITE GOING EASTWARD FROM WHERE
8:44:37PM WE'RE REQUESTING, THE ABILITY TO GO TO THREE UNITS.
8:44:41PM THE PARKING REDUCTION IS BASICALLY BECAUSE WE'RE ADJACENT TO
8:44:47PM A TRANSIT CORRIDOR.
8:44:49PM IT'S A VISITOR PARKING SPACE THAT WE'RE ASKING TO REMOVE.
8:44:54PM WE DO HAVE TWO-CAR GARAGES FOR EACH UNIT.
8:44:58PM THERE ARE A MIX OF DUPLEXES, QUADPLEXES, AND A SERIES OF
8:45:04PM WHAT YOU NORMALLY WOULD HAVE AROUND THE UNIVERSITY AREA
8:45:07PM WHERE YOU HAD A SERIES OF DUPLEXES AND QUADPLEXES FOR
8:45:10PM HOUSING.
8:45:11PM SO IT DOES LEND ITSELF TO A LITTLE LESS EXPENSIVE HOUSING
8:45:16PM PRODUCT.
8:45:17PM I'LL READ FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSION REPORT ON THEIR
8:45:24PM FINDINGS AND IT'S OUR RESIDENTIAL 35 SO YOU'RE ALLOWED TO
8:45:29PM BUILD THE THREE UNITS.
8:45:32PM SURROUNDING AREA CONSISTS OF SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED -- I
8:45:36PM THINK THAT IS CHANGED NOW SO THAT A LOT OF THESE AREAS, BOTH
8:45:42PM ON THE EAST AND THE WEST SIDE OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY ARE
8:45:45PM DUPLEXES, TOWN HOUSE-STYLE QUADPLEXES.
8:45:49PM OBJECTIVE 2.1 REGULATES LEVEL OF BUILDING INTENSITY AND THE
8:45:57PM STANDARDS OF LAND USE TO MEET THE PROJECTED POPULATION
8:46:01PM INCREASE OF 150,000 BY 2024 OR 2040.
8:46:06PM LIMITING LAND USE RESOURCES, THIS IS AN UNDERUTILIZED PARCEL
8:46:10PM OF LAND, QUITE HONESTLY, THIS AREA, AND I WOULD SUSPECT THE
8:46:17PM DUPLEXES ADJACENT TO IT ON THE EAST SIDE WILL BE
8:46:22PM REDEVELOPED, PROBABLY PURCHASED, DEMOLISHED AND THEN
8:46:26PM REDEVELOPED IN SIMILAR STYLE DEVELOPMENTS LIKE THIS.
8:46:29PM THE TRANSFORMATION OF MAJOR CORRIDORS INCLUDING A BROADER
8:46:33PM MIX OF USES ON THE HORIZON OF HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL,
8:46:37PM OPPORTUNITIES OF MEDIUM AND HIGH DENSITY WHILE ADDRESSING
8:46:40PM THE NEED FOR HOUSING CITYWIDE.
8:46:42PM AS I SAID TO YOU EARLIER, THIS IS ADJACENT TO JUST NORTH OF
8:46:50PM THE INTERSTATE.
8:46:53PM SO THERE'S A WHOLE SERIES OF HOMES IN HERE.
8:46:56PM YOU CAN SEE DOWN HERE THESE ARE THOSE DUPLEXES AND QUADS
8:47:11PM THAT I WAS TELLING YOU ABOUT APARTMENT BUILDING IN HERE.
8:47:16PM THIS AERIAL WAS TAKEN BEFORE THE REDEVELOPMENT OCCURRED IN
8:47:20PM HERE.
8:47:20PM SO YOU'RE NOT SEEING THOSE NEW HOUSES THAT I JUST TOLD YOU
8:47:25PM ABOUT, THE DUPLEXES THAT WERE BEING BUILT.
8:47:27PM SO IT IS AN AREA THAT'S ATTRACTING SOME ACTIVITY, AND SOME
8:47:32PM OF THE MODERATE PRICED HOUSING PRODUCTS ARE COMING OUT OF
8:47:38PM THERE.
8:47:38PM ENCOURAGE THE REDEVELOPMENT PROCESS AND RESIDENTIAL MIXED
8:47:42PM USE AND RETAIL AND COMMERCIAL SERVICES.
8:47:45PM THIS IS ADJACENT, AS SAID, MAJOR STREETS, PLUS THE
8:47:51PM INTERSTATE.
8:47:52PM SO IT WILL ATTRACT SOME ACTIVITY.
8:47:54PM WE DIDN'T RECEIVE ANY CALLS, NO E-MAILS OR ANY COMMUNICATION
8:47:58PM INDICATING ANY KIND OF CONCERNS REGARDING THIS PROJECT.
8:48:02PM I DID COMMIT TO THE STAFF THAT WE WOULD CORRECT THE SITE
8:48:04PM PLAN REGARDING THE SIDEWALKS AND THE CONNECTIVITY, INCLUDING
8:48:08PM THE SIDEWALKS REQUIRED ON THE FRONT OF THE PROPERTY.
8:48:11PM WITH A REVISED SITE PLAN.
8:48:15PM BASICALLY, I THINK THAT THIS IS THE TYPE OF PROJECT THAT YOU
8:48:22PM WOULD ENCOURAGE TO HAPPEN AS AN INFILL, PARTICULARLY IN THE
8:48:25PM EAST TAMPA DISTRICT, WHERE YOU'RE BRINGING THAT -- THOSE
8:48:31PM PROPERTIES UP IN VALUE, AND YOU'RE ALSO TRYING TO PROVIDE
8:48:34PM MORE AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
8:48:35PM THE LAND COSTS ARE LESS HERE THAN THEY ARE ANYWHERE ELSE.
8:48:40PM THE CONSTRUCTION COSTS REMAIN THE SAME, BUT AT LEAST YOU
8:48:43PM HAVE A PRODUCT IN AN AREA WHERE YOU CAN HAVE A POSITIVE
8:48:48PM IMPACT ON THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
8:48:49PM DEVELOPMENT SHALL NOT EXCEED THE DENSITIES.
8:48:54PM THIS ONE IS AT OR BELOW THE DENSITY THAT'S ALLOWED.
8:48:57PM EACH LAND USE CATEGORY SHALL HAVE UNIQUE SET OF ZONING
8:48:59PM DISTRICTS PERMITTED FOR THE LAND USE CATEGORY AND ADOPTED,
8:49:03PM WHICH MAY EXIST FOR THE USE OF THIS LAND AND THIS IS A
8:49:06PM PERMITTED USE.
8:49:07PM ENSURE THAT THE ADEQUATE AMOUNT OF LAND PLANNED IN
8:49:10PM RESIDENTIAL PURPOSES TO ACCOMMODATE THE PROJECTED POPULATION
8:49:13PM INCREASE.
8:49:15PM AGAIN, THIS IS AN IDEAL LOCATION FOR INFILL HOUSING, AND
8:49:19PM IT'S IN AN AREA THAT DOESN'T HAVE A LOT OF INFILL
8:49:23PM DEVELOPMENT GOING ON.
8:49:24PM ENCOURAGE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED AND MULTIFAMILY DESIGNATED
8:49:28PM TO INCLUDE ORIENTATION OF THE FRONT DOORS.
8:49:32PM ONE OF THE UNITS FACES COLUMBUS DRIVE.
8:49:34PM THE OTHER TWO FACE THE SIDE, AND THE CONNECTIVITY BETWEEN
8:49:37PM THE SIDEWALKS AND THE SIDEWALK REQUIRED IN THE FRONT WILL BE
8:49:41PM MADE.
8:49:41PM DIVERSITY, IMPROVE SUSTAINABILITY OF MULTIFAMILY IN THE
8:49:48PM AREA.
8:49:49PM THIS HAS ALREADY BEEN, I WOULD GUESS THAT THOSE DUPLEXES ON
8:49:53PM THE CORNER LOOK LIKE THEY ARE 1960s ERA DUPLEXES, SO IT'S
8:50:01PM ALREADY BEEN A REDEVELOPMENT AREA.
8:50:04PM AND THIS APARTMENT BUILDING, WHICH IS AT THE OTHER CORNER,
8:50:08PM PROBABLY FROM THE '30s OR '40s, AND IT'S TYPICAL FOR
8:50:14PM THAT PART OF THE TOWN.
8:50:15PM THESE ARE ACROSS THE STREET.
8:50:21PM THOSE ARE RELATIVELY NEW, AND THOSE ARE TRIPLEXES.
8:50:25PM SO WE HAVE A PATTERN OF DEVELOPMENT THAT IS ENCOURAGING
8:50:32PM MULTIFAMILY IN THE AREA.
8:50:34PM AND I SAID WE'LL MAKE THE CORRECTIONS IN THE EVENT THAT
8:50:38PM COUNCIL APPROVES THIS, WE'LL MAKE THE CORRECTIONS REGARDING
8:50:41PM THE SITE PLAN BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
8:50:44PM I THINK, AGAIN, THIS IS AN IDEAL AREA FOR REDEVELOPMENT.
8:50:49PM I'LL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
8:50:53PM WE'D LIKE TO HAVE THIS, THE DOCUMENTS AND THE COMMENTS MADE
8:50:56PM BY STAFF TO BE RECEIVED AND FILED AND MADE PART OF THE
8:50:59PM RECORD.
8:50:59PM I THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME, AND THAT CONCLUDES MY
8:51:05PM PRESENTATION.
8:51:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
8:51:09PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I HAVE A QUESTION FOR STAFF.
8:51:11PM CAN YOU PLEASE PUT UP A PICTURE OF THE SITE PLAN?
8:51:33PM >> CAN YOU SEE IT?
8:51:35PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YOU NEED TO ZOOM OUT.
8:51:37PM IT NEEDS TO BE UP FOR EVERYONE ELSE TO SEE, TOO, PLEASE.
8:51:40PM THANKS.
8:51:41PM SO WHILE I UNDERSTAND THE APPLICANT SAYS THAT HE CAN PUT
8:51:46PM SIDEWALKS IN, WE ALREADY HAVE WAIVERS FOR SIDE, AND THE
8:51:52PM DRIVE AISLE IS 20 FEET, WHICH IS ALREADY A REDUCTION IN THE
8:51:56PM DRIVE AISLE.
8:51:57PM HOW CAN WE SHOEHORN A SIDEWALK IN THERE?
8:52:00PM >>ZAIN HUSAIN: I'LL HAVE TO HAVE JONATHAN SCOTT IS FROM
8:52:03PM TRANSPORTATION COME UP AND SPEAK ON THIS ONE.
8:52:06PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OKAY.
8:52:09PM >> JONATHAN SCOTT, TRANSPORTATION.
8:52:11PM YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT THE SIDEWALK ALONG THE ROADWAY THERE.
8:52:14PM >>LYNN HURTAK: NO, NO.
8:52:15PM THEY NEED TO HAVE SIDEWALK CONNECTIVITY FROM THE BUILDING TO
8:52:20PM COLUMBUS DRIVE.
8:52:23PM THERE'S NO SPACE TO ADD A SIDEWALK, SO HE SAYS HE'S GOING TO
8:52:28PM MAKE THOSE CHANGES BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING, BUT I
8:52:31PM AM ASKING STAFF IF THAT'S EVEN POSSIBLE.
8:52:35PM >> JONATHAN SCOTT: WELL, HE CAN HAVE LIKE A PEDESTRIAN
8:52:38PM CONNECTION FROM THE SIDEWALK FROM COLUMBUS DOWN AND THEN IT
8:52:44PM WOULD -- I CAN POINT --
8:52:46PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YEAH, PLEASE SHOW.
8:52:48PM BECAUSE ON ALL THESE OTHERS, THEY HAVE SHOWN HOW THERE IS AN
8:52:51PM EXTRA SIDEWALK.
8:52:55PM >>JONATHAN SCOTT: YEAH, IN THIS CASE, TO DO THAT, HE COULD
8:52:58PM SHOW PEDESTRIAN CONNECTION OVER THIS UNIT TO RIGHT HERE.
8:53:02PM BUT THESE OVER HERE, IT'S GOING TO BASICALLY HAVE TO CONNECT
8:53:07PM TO THE ENTRANCES.
8:53:08PM IT WOULD, LIKE, OVERLAP THE DRIVE AISLE.
8:53:12PM NOW, HE CAN DO LIKE SOME MARKINGS TO MAKE IT SAFER TO
8:53:19PM DESIGNATE THAT WALKWAY.
8:53:21PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OKAY.
8:53:22PM BUT YOU COULD NOT REALLY ADD A SIDEWALK.
8:53:24PM >>JONATHAN SCOTT: NOT REALLY.
8:53:26PM MORE LIKE A WALKWAY, PEDESTRIAN CONNECTION.
8:53:27PM WHAT WE DO A LOT OF TIMES IS HAVE THEM MARK IT.
8:53:31PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OKAY.
8:53:31PM THANK YOU.
8:53:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?
8:53:34PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES, MR. MICHELINI, CAN YOU EXPLAIN WHAT
8:53:36PM YOU MEANT WHEN YOU SAID THAT THE DEVELOPER IS TAKING A LEAP
8:53:41PM BUILDING INTO THIS COMMUNITY?
8:53:42PM HIS FIRST TIME THERE?
8:53:47PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: JUST BECAUSE IT'S JUST STARTING TO
8:53:49PM REDEVELOP, AND SOME OF THE HOUSES IN THERE ALREADY WERE
8:53:53PM PROBABLY BUILT, THE LAST TIME THEY SAW ANY NEW DEVELOPMENT
8:53:58PM WAS PROBABLY IN THE '60s, SOMEWHERE IN ALONG THERE.
8:54:00PM IT WOULD BE A WELCOME ADDITION TO COME IN AND START
8:54:03PM REDEVELOPING SOME OF THESE SITES.
8:54:05PM THE PICTURE I SHOWED YOU OF THE DUPLEXES ON THE CORNER AND
8:54:10PM THE QUADPLEXES, THOSE ARE SIMILAR TO THE ONES THAT WERE
8:54:18PM AROUND BY THE UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH FLORIDA WHEN IT WAS FIRST
8:54:22PM BUILT IN THE '60s, DESIGNED FOR STUDENT HOUSING.
8:54:25PM I'M SURE THAT'S -- THIS WASN'T BUILT FOR STUDENT HOUSING,
8:54:28PM BUT IT WAS BUILT FOR WORKER HOUSING THAT WAS LESS EXPENSIVE.
8:54:32PM AND IT REALLY HASN'T SEEN A LOT OF ATTENTION FROM NEW
8:54:36PM DEVELOPMENT.
8:54:38PM SO THAT WAS MY POINT WAS THAT I DON'T THINK THESE UNITS
8:54:43PM HERE, THESE ARE AT THE CORNER AND THE PROPERTY THAT WE'RE
8:54:46PM TALKING ABOUT IS IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO IT GOING TO THE
8:54:50PM EAST.
8:54:52PM MY GUESS IS THAT IN THE FUTURE, THESE WILL BE COMING DOWN
8:54:57PM AND MORE NEWER DEVELOPMENTS WILL BE GOING IN THERE.
8:55:00PM BUT THESE ARE BASICALLY BLUE-COLLAR WORKING HOUSES.
8:55:05PM THESE ARE NOT HIGH-END, UPSCALE HOUSES.
8:55:08PM AND I'M SURE THAT IT'S JUST WHATEVER PEOPLE CAN AFFORD TO
8:55:12PM LIVE IN.
8:55:13PM AS THIS GENTRIFIES AND COMES BACK ON THE MARKET AND
8:55:20PM REDEVELOPS, IT WILL PROVIDE OTHER OPPORTUNITIES FOR HOUSING
8:55:23PM THAT CURRENTLY DON'T EXIST.
8:55:26PM AND BEING ADJACENT TO THE INTERSTATE, YOU KNOW, IT'S A
8:55:33PM DIFFICULT SELL.
8:55:35PM IF IT WERE MORE INTERIOR, FURTHER AWAY FROM THE INTERSTATE,
8:55:38PM IT MIGHT BE A LITTLE BIT EASIER TO DEVELOP, BUT THESE ARE
8:55:41PM DIFFICULT LOTS TO REDEVELOP.
8:55:44PM >>BILL CARLSON: COULD YOU SHOW US -- AS I REMEMBER, ONE OF
8:55:50PM THE WAIVERS IS MOVING THE DOORS.
8:55:53PM COULD YOU JUST SHOW US THE ELEVATIONS AGAIN SO WE CAN SEE
8:55:59PM WHAT THE FRONT LOOKS LIKE AND WHERE THE DOORS ARE?
8:56:04PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: DO YOU HAVE THE ELEVATIONS?
8:56:05PM THEY ARE RECESSED DOORWAYS.
8:56:28PM >>BILL CARLSON: COULD YOU SHOW US WHICH ONE IS THE FRONT
8:56:31PM FROM THE ROAD, WHERE THE DOOR IS SUPPOSED TO BE?
8:56:34PM IS IT THE TOP LEFT?
8:56:37PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THIS ONE IS THE FRONT ONE.
8:56:41PM FRONTS ON COLUMBUS DRIVE.
8:56:43PM >>BILL CARLSON: OKAY, THANK YOU.
8:56:44PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THESE ARE THE INTERIOR ONES.
8:56:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?
8:56:49PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WISH TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, ITEM
8:56:54PM NUMBER 6?
8:56:55PM ANYBODY FROM THE PUBLIC?
8:56:57PM NOBODY ONLINE.
8:56:58PM MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON, SECOND FROM
8:57:02PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
8:57:03PM ALL IN FAVOR?
8:57:04PM AYE.
8:57:04PM ANY OPPOSED?
8:57:04PM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
8:57:07PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THIS IS ANOTHER ONE OF THOSE PROJECTS
8:57:11PM WE'RE TRYING TO PUT THE OLD ADAGE OF 12-FOOT INTO A SIZE 8
8:57:22PM SHOE.
8:57:22PM IT'S -- THE BUILDINGS ARE WHAT THEY ARE, BUT IT'S TOO MUCH
8:57:26PM FOR THIS PIECE OF PROPERTY.
8:57:28PM THE SETBACKS REDUCED SO MUCH FOR THIS PIECE OF PROPERTY.
8:57:31PM I MEAN, AND THE ALLEY IS REDUCED, ALL THE WAIVERS THAT ARE
8:57:35PM REQUESTED, WHY THEY FOUND IT NONCOMPLIANT.
8:57:39PM THE ORIENTATION OF THIS BUILDING IS TOTALLY NOT IN SCALE
8:57:43PM WITH THE REST.
8:57:44PM YOU SHOWED THERE IS THIS NEW DEVELOPMENT WITH ALL THE
8:57:48PM DUPLEXES BUT FORWARD FACING, FACING COLUMBUS, THE DOOR WHERE
8:57:52PM IT SHOULD BE, AND NONE OF THIS ALLEY ACCESS, AISLE ACCESS
8:57:57PM STUFF THAT YOU'VE GOT GOING ON.
8:57:59PM IT'S TOO MUCH.
8:58:02PM AND THIS IS DEFINITELY A RESIDENTIAL AREA, AT LEAST IT
8:58:07PM APPEARS TO BE MOSTLY RESIDENTIAL.
8:58:11PM AS YOU SAID, WORKING FOLK PEOPLE.
8:58:16PM I THINK THIS PROPERTY YOU COULD FAIRLY WELL DEVELOP WITH
8:58:19PM EUCLIDEAN ZONING WITHOUT THE CRAZY WAIVERS, WITHOUT A PD,
8:58:22PM COME BACK WITH A GREAT PROJECT THAT FITS ON THIS PIECE OF
8:58:27PM PROPERTY AND THIS PIECE OF LAND THAT THE DEVELOPER COULD
8:58:29PM MAKE MONEY ON.
8:58:31PM I THINK COUNCIL WOULD BE GLAD TO APPROVE IT, BRING BACK GOOD
8:58:34PM PROJECTS ON APPROPRIATE SIZE UNIT ON THE APPROPRIATE SIZE
8:58:39PM LOT.
8:58:39PM WE'RE ALL IN.
8:58:40PM WE WANT TO BUILD AND HOUSE PEOPLE, TOO, BUT THIS IS TOO MUCH
8:58:44PM FOR THIS SIZE PIECES OF PROPERTY.
8:58:46PM IT'S TOO MUCH.
8:58:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
8:58:56PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: MR. MICHELINI, THIS ONE DOESN'T WORK FOR
8:58:59PM ME.
8:58:59PM WELL, IT DOESN'T MATTER WHAT MY OPINION IS ABOUT IT.
8:59:03PM I'LL JUST GO AHEAD ON AND MOVE TO DENY REZ-23-57 FOR THE
8:59:08PM PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2917 EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE DUE TO THE
8:59:14PM FAILURE OF THE APPLICANT TO MEET THE BURDEN OF PROOF TO
8:59:17PM PROVIDE COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE THAT THE
8:59:20PM DEVELOPMENT AS CONDITIONED AND SHOWN ON THE SITE PLAN IS
8:59:23PM CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND CITY CODE AND THE
8:59:26PM APPLICANT'S FAILURE TO MEET ITS BURDEN OF PROOF WITH RESPECT
8:59:29PM TO THE REQUESTED WAIVERS.
8:59:31PM SOME OF THE REASONS, FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH APPLICABLE
8:59:35PM GOALS, COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, SUCH AS, WHILE THE ZONING -- DO I
8:59:40PM HAVE TO READ ALL OF THAT?
8:59:42PM WHILE THE PROPOSED REZONING MAY BE ALLOWED FOR CONSIDERATION
8:59:49PM UNDER COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35 DESIGNATION, THE PROPOSED SITE
8:59:52PM PLAN DOES NOT ENGAGE THE PUBLIC REALM OR PROVIDE A SAFE
8:59:57PM PEDESTRIAN CONNECTION FROM THE THREE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED
9:00:00PM UNITS TO THE SIDEWALK ALONG EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE IN VIOLATION
9:00:03PM OF LAND USE POLICIES 4.3.2 AND 4.3.6.
9:00:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION --
9:00:10PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: QUESTION.
9:00:11PM I'M SORRY.
9:00:11PM DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING WITH REGARD TO ANY OTHER SITE --
9:00:15PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I WAS GOING TO ADD AN AMENDMENT.
9:00:17PM I'LL SECOND IT AND THEN CAN I ADD A FRIENDLY AMENDMENT?
9:00:22PM I SAY IT ALSO FAILS TO COMPLY WITH LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE
9:00:26PM SECTION 27-136.
9:00:29PM THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT AS SHOWN ON THE SITE PLAN DOES NOT
9:00:32PM PROMOTE DEVELOPMENT THAT IS APPROPRIATE IN LOCATION OR
9:00:34PM CHARACTER BY FAILING TO COMPLY WITH THE EAST TAMPA OVERLAY
9:00:37PM DISTRICT DESIGN STANDARDS AND PROPOSING A REDUCTION IN DRIVE
9:00:40PM AISLE WIDTH, NOT ONLY IS THE WIDTH BEING REDUCED BUT THE
9:00:43PM DRIVE AISLE IS THE ONLY MEANS OF INGRESS, EGRESS FOR
9:00:47PM PEDESTRIANS.
9:00:47PM ADDITIONALLY, THERE ARE FIVE WAIVERS THAT JUST, THE SIDE AND
9:00:55PM REAR YARD SETBACKS, THE WAIVER FOR PARKING, THE FRONT DOOR
9:00:59PM PARKING, THE REDUCED BUFFER, BUT FOR ME, IT'S THE REDUCTION
9:01:02PM IN THE DRIVE AISLE FROM 24 FEET TO 20 FEET THAT'S ALSO BEING
9:01:07PM USED AS A SIDEWALK IS MY MOST PRESSING ISSUE.
9:01:12PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: COUNCILWOMAN, WOULD YOU PLEASE CITE TO THE
9:01:15PM SECTION OF THE CODE REGARDING WAIVERS?
9:01:16PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WAIVERS 27-139 SUBSET 4.
9:01:19PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THANK YOU.
9:01:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
9:01:23PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I ACCEPT THE AMENDMENTS.
9:01:26PM YEAH, THE DEVELOPER, HIS LEAP IS JUST TOO BIG.
9:01:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND SECOND.
9:01:30PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
9:01:32PM >>THE CLERK: VIERA?
9:01:36PM >>LUIS VIERA: I'M GOING TO EXPLAIN MY VOTE REALLY FAST, IF I
9:01:38PM MAY.
9:01:39PM I'M GOING TO VOTE NO ON THIS MOTION.
9:01:42PM HERE'S WHY.
9:01:42PM I AGREE THERE ARE A NUMBER OF WAIVERS THAT GO OUT A LITTLE
9:01:47PM FAR.
9:01:47PM THIS IS AN AREA, THOUGH, LARGER ISSUE THAT THIS WOULD HELP
9:01:53PM TREMENDOUSLY.
9:01:54PM I'M -- MY RATIONALE, I THINK IT'S GOING TO PASS BUT I'LL
9:01:58PM VOTE NO.
9:01:59PM THANK YOU.
9:02:00PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
9:02:02PM >>BILL CARLSON: I AGREE WITH VIERA, NO.
9:02:09PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
9:02:12PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
9:02:13PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
9:02:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO.
9:02:18PM AND I AGREE WITH WHAT COUNCILMAN VIERA SAID.
9:02:21PM I THINK IT'S A GOOD DEVELOPMENT.
9:02:26PM IN THE AREA.
9:02:26PM I KNOW EXACTLY WHERE IT'S AT.
9:02:28PM I'M GLAD THAT YOU HAVE A DEVELOPER THAT'S LOOKING AT
9:02:31PM BUILDING NEW HOUSING.
9:02:33PM SO I WILL VOTE NO TO THE MOTION.
9:02:36PM >>THE CLERK: THE MOTION TO DENY CARRIED WITH VIERA, CARLSON,
9:02:42PM MANISCALCO VOTING NO.
9:02:45PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
9:02:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER 7.
9:03:01PM >>ZAIN HUSAIN: ZAIN HUSAIN DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
9:03:03PM CASE REZ 23-62.
9:03:07PM REQUEST TO REZONE THE PROPERTY AT 3204 WEST CYPRESS STREET.
9:03:11PM PROPOSED REZONING FROM RS-50 TO CG.
9:03:15PM PASS IT ALONG TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
9:03:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
9:03:18PM >>EMILY PHELAN: EMILY PHELAN, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
9:03:28PM THE SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING
9:03:31PM DISTRICT IN THE OAKFORD PARK NEIGHBORHOOD.
9:03:33PM THE SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE COASTAL PLANNING AREA AND
9:03:37PM EVACUATION ZONE E.
9:03:38PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED HERE OUTLINED IN PURPLE.
9:03:42PM AND THE SUBJECT SITE IS A MIX OF USES WITH COMMERCIAL USES
9:03:46PM ALONG WEST CYPRESS STREET AND IT TRANSITIONS TO RESIDENTIAL
9:03:50PM USES TO THE SOUTH AND EAST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
9:03:52PM THIS IS THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP OF THE SUBJECT SITE, WHICH
9:04:00PM IS, AGAIN HE, HERE.
9:04:01PM IT IS OUTLINED AND REPRESENTED BY THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35
9:04:06PM DESIGNATION, WHICH IS PRESENT ALONG WEST CYPRESS STREET TO
9:04:09PM THE EAST AND IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO THE SOUTH IS THE
9:04:13PM RESIDENTIAL 20 DESIGNATION.
9:04:15PM AS YOU MOVE FURTHER SOUTH AND FURTHER NORTH AWAY FROM WEST
9:04:18PM CYPRESS STREET, IT TRANSITIONS TO THE RESIDENTIAL 10 FUTURE
9:04:22PM LAND USE DESIGNATION.
9:04:23PM THE COMMERCIAL GENERAL ZONING CAN BE CONSIDERED IN THE
9:04:26PM COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35 DESIGNATION, AND WOULD BE APPROPRIATE
9:04:30PM FOR THIS SITE PROVIDED THAT ANY POTENTIAL NONRESIDENTIAL
9:04:33PM DEVELOPMENT IS SENSITIVE TO THE EXISTING RESIDENTIAL USES
9:04:36PM ABUTTING THE SUBJECT SITE.
9:04:38PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PROMOTES PEDESTRIAN SAFETY AND
9:04:41PM ENCOURAGES COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT THAT ENHANCES THE CITY OF
9:04:43PM TAMPA'S CHARACTER AND AMBIENCE.
9:04:47PM IN DOING SO, THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN REQUIRES NEW COMMERCIAL
9:04:49PM DEVELOPMENT TO CONNECT BUILDING ENTRANCES TO PUBLIC
9:04:52PM RIGHTS-OF-WAY AND PROVIDE SIDEWALKS IN AREA WHERE IT IS
9:04:54PM PRACTICAL AND FEASIBLE FOR PEDESTRIAN ORIENTED ACTIVITIES.
9:04:57PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN A MIXED USE CORRIDOR AND A
9:05:01PM TRANSIT EMPHASIS CORRIDOR AND THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN HAS
9:05:04PM SPECIFIC DIRECTION THAT PROMOTES A PEDESTRIAN ORIENTED MIXED
9:05:07PM USE DEVELOPMENT WITH ACCESS TO TRANSIT, BUILDINGS ORIENTED
9:05:11PM TO THE STREET WITH PARKING IN THE REAR THAT IS SCREENED FROM
9:05:14PM ADJACENT RESIDENTIAL USES.
9:05:16PM PROVIDING STREET TREES ARE ALSO ENCOURAGED ALONG THE
9:05:20PM CORRIDORS WHICH SUPPORTED BY THE MIXED USE CORRIDOR POLICIES
9:05:22PM WITHIN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
9:05:24PM THE PROPOSED REZONING WOULD ALLOW FOR DEVELOPMENT THAT IS
9:05:27PM COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH THE CHARACTER OF THE
9:05:30PM SURROUNDING USES AND IS CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT
9:05:32PM PATTERN ANTICIPATED UNDER THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35
9:05:35PM DESIGNATION.
9:05:36PM THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
9:05:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
9:05:39PM ANY QUESTIONS?
9:05:39PM YES, SIR.
9:05:47PM >>ZAIN HUSAIN: ZAIN HUSAIN, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
9:05:49PM I'LL FIRST GO AHEAD AND SHOW THE AERIAL VIEW OF THE
9:05:51PM PROPERTY.
9:05:51PM AS YOU SEE THE PROPERTY RIGHT HERE OUTLINED IN RED.
9:06:03PM THIS IS ALONG WEST CYPRESS STREET TO THE NORTH.
9:06:06PM TO THE EAST, YOU HAVE NORTH MATANZAS AVENUE.
9:06:12PM IF YOU GO TO THE SOUTH, YOU HAVE WEST LEMON STREET RUNNING
9:06:14PM EAST TO WEST, AND IF YOU GO NORTH, YOU HAVE WEST GRAY STREET
9:06:18PM AND ALSO WEST CYPRESS STREET DIRECTLY NORTH.
9:06:24PM TO THE PROPERTY TO THE WEST AND ALSO TO THE NORTH IS
9:06:27PM PROFESSIONAL OFFICE USE.
9:06:29PM TO THE SOUTH -- SORRY, THOSE TWO ARE ZONED PD.
9:06:34PM TO THE SOUTH AND TO THE EAST ARE ZONED RS 50 AND THEY ARE
9:06:39PM OCCUPIED BY RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY.
9:06:42PM THE CURRENT LOT IS OCCUPIED BY A CLUBHOUSE.
9:06:49PM THE LOT SQUARE FOOTAGE OR LOT ACREAGE IS .33 ACRES.
9:06:54PM AND THE MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT IS 45 FEET IN HEIGHT.
9:06:59PM AS YOU SEE, WHERE THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED, SOUTHWEST
9:07:02PM INTERSECTION OF WEST CYPRESS AND NORTH MATANZAS.
9:07:08PM AS I WENT OUT TO THE SITE AND TOOK PICTURES, I WILL SHOW YOU
9:07:12PM WHAT I SAW.
9:07:13PM THE FIRST PICTURE IS OF THE SITE ITSELF, AS YOU SEE THE
9:07:24PM CLUBHOUSE.
9:07:31PM THAT IS FROM WEST CYPRESS STREET.
9:07:33PM ANOTHER PICTURE OF THE SITE ITSELF THAT IS FROM NORTH
9:07:36PM MATANZAS STREET.
9:07:38PM TO THE NORTHWEST OF THE SITE, YOU'LL HAVE RESIDENTIAL AS
9:07:46PM WELL AS BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL OFFICE RUNNING EAST TO WEST.
9:07:52PM ALONG WEST CYPRESS.
9:07:55PM TO THE NORTH, YOU WILL HAVE THE PD ZONED BUSINESS
9:08:06PM PROFESSIONAL OFFICE ON WEST CYPRESS.
9:08:09PM AND TO THE SOUTHEAST YOU'LL HAVE THOSE RESIDENTIAL
9:08:18PM SINGLE-FAMILY USES.
9:08:19PM THE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW AND COMPLIANCE STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE
9:08:26PM APPLICATION AND FINDS THE OVERALL REQUEST TO BE CONSISTENT
9:08:28PM WITH THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
9:08:30PM I'M HERE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
9:08:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
9:08:32PM ALL RIGHT.
9:08:33PM THE APPLICANT IS ONLINE, MR. BRICKLEMYER.
9:08:39PM IF YOU COULD TURN ON YOUR CAMERA, RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND
9:08:42PM WE'LL SWEAR YOU IN.
9:08:43PM UNMUTE YOURSELF, PLEASE.
9:08:50PM >>THE CLERK: DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THE TESTIMONY YOU'RE
9:08:53PM ABOUT TO RECEIVE IS THE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH?
9:08:58PM >> I DO.
9:09:00PM >>THE CLERK: THANK YOU.
9:09:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD, SIR.
9:09:02PM >> JOSEPH BRICKLEMYER, 26736 HIGHWAY 27, LEESBURG, FLORIDA,
9:09:08PM 34787.
9:09:10PM I WANTED TO POINT OUT TO THE COUNCIL AND MAKE SOME COMMENTS.
9:09:16PM ON PAGE 20 OF THE STAFF REPORT, WITHIN THE CHARACTER OF THE
9:09:21PM SURROUNDING AREA AND CONSISTENT WITH LONG-RANGE DEVELOPMENT
9:09:23PM PATTERN ENCOURAGE COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35 FUTURE LAND USE
9:09:26PM CATEGORY.
9:09:27PM THAT SAID, I WAS CONTACTED BY TWO FOLKS AFTER OUR MAILING
9:09:31PM AND PUBLIC OUTREACH, JOHN DEORIO OF THE OAKFORD PARK
9:09:37PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND DOMINIC GOOD BOTH CONTACTED ME.
9:09:41PM MR. DEORIO AND I DISCUSSED THE FACT WE STILL HAVE TO GO
9:09:44PM THROUGH A CHANGE OF USE.
9:09:46PM THAT BUILDING HAS BEEN A CLUBHOUSE SINCE AT LEAST 1995.
9:09:52PM WE'LL HAVE TO GO THROUGH THE CHANGE OF USE PROCESS AS WELL
9:09:55PM WHICH WILL REQUIRE SITE PLAN -- [AUDIO BREAKING UP] -- AND
9:10:03PM MY CLIENT PLANS CURRENTLY ON AND HAS -- NOT CERTIFIED UNTIL
9:10:10PM WE GET THROUGH THE SITE PLANNING REVIEW.
9:10:14PM DIFFERENT PEOPLE OF THE PLANNING STAFF TO GIVE US INPUT ON
9:10:17PM THAT AS WE'VE BEEN BUILDING OUT TOWARD THE PROCESS.
9:10:19PM WITH THAT, I'M SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS FROM THE COUNCIL.
9:10:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
9:10:23PM ANY QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME?
9:10:24PM NO QUESTIONS.
9:10:27PM DO WE HAVE ANYBODY FROM THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON
9:10:29PM ITEM NUMBER 7?
9:10:30PM I SEE NO ONE AND THERE'S NO ONE ELSE REGISTERED.
9:10:33PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
9:10:35PM SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
9:10:38PM ALL IN FAVOR?
9:10:38PM AYE.
9:10:39PM ANY OPPOSED?
9:10:39PM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN, YOU'RE UP.
9:10:48PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I MOVE FILE NUMBER REZ-23-62, AN ORDINANCE
9:10:52PM REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 3204 WEST
9:10:55PM CYPRESS STREET IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA AND MORE
9:10:59PM PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1, FROM ZONING DISTRICT
9:11:02PM CLASSIFICATION RS-50 (RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY) TO CG
9:11:07PM (COMMERCIAL GENERAL); PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
9:11:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
9:11:11PM CLENDENIN.
9:11:11PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
9:11:13PM ROLL CALL.
9:11:16PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
9:11:18PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
9:11:20PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
9:11:22PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
9:11:23PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
9:11:27PM >>THE CLERK: VIERA?
9:11:27PM MANISCALCO?
9:11:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
9:11:31PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION CARRIED WITH VIERA BEING ABSENT AT VOTE.
9:11:38PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER 7th,
9:11:43PM 2023, AT 9:30 A.M. AT 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, TAMPA,
9:11:49PM FLORIDA.
9:11:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM, ITEM NUMBER 8.
9:11:55PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
9:11:58PM ITEM NUMBER 8 IS REZ-23-64.
9:12:01PM PROPERTY LOCATED AT 5232 SOUTH MacDILL AVENUE.
9:12:04PM THE APPLICANT IS REPRESENTED BY MARK BENTLEY, AND THE
9:12:08PM REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY FROM CG COMMERCIAL GENERAL
9:12:12PM TO PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT.
9:12:14PM AND IT IS FOR THE USE OF A RESTAURANT.
9:12:16PM SO I'LL HAVE EMILY COME UP AND GIVE A REPORT.
9:12:18PM THANK YOU.
9:12:30PM >>EMILY PHELAN: EMILY PHELAN, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
9:12:32PM THE SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT
9:12:35PM AND THE BALLAST POINT NEIGHBORHOOD AND IT'S LOCATED WITHIN
9:12:38PM THE COASTAL PLANNING AREA, SPECIFICALLY EVACUATION ZONE B.
9:12:41PM THIS IS AN AERIAL OF THE SUBJECT SITE, WHICH IS LOCATED
9:12:45PM HERE, IT'S AT THE INTERSECTION OF SOUTH MacDILL AND --
9:12:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE DON'T HAVE THIS ON OUR SCREEN, IF WE
9:12:56PM COULD HAVE IT PULLED UP, PLEASE.
9:12:58PM THANK YOU.
9:12:58PM YES, MA'AM, SORRY ABOUT THAT.
9:12:59PM >>EMILY PHELAN: NO, IT'S OKAY.
9:13:01PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE RIGHT HERE.
9:13:02PM SOUTH MacDILL COMES DOWN HERE AND THIS IS SOUTH PURITAN
9:13:09PM AVENUE, WHICH COMES THIS WAY.
9:13:09PM THE AREA IS A MIXTURE OF USES WITH SOME RESIDENTIAL,
9:13:15PM MULTIFAMILY, AS WELL AS COMMERCIAL USES ALONG SOUTH
9:13:17PM MacDILL AVENUE.
9:13:18PM AND THERE ARE SOME ALSO LOCATED TO THE NORTH AND WEST OF THE
9:13:23PM SUBJECT SITE.
9:13:25PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE HERE REPRESENTED BY THE COMMUNITY
9:13:30PM MIXED USE 35 DESIGNATION.
9:13:32PM AS YOU CAN SEE FROM THE MAP, ALONG SOUTH MacDILL IS THE
9:13:36PM CMU 35 DESIGNATION.
9:13:38PM AS YOU MOVE AWAY FROM SOUTH MACDILL, BOTH TO THE WEST AND
9:13:42PM THE EAST IS RESIDENTIAL 10 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
9:13:45PM LAND USE POLICY 6.1.9 PROMOTES DEVELOPMENT PATTERN THAT
9:13:50PM ENCOURAGES WALKING AND TRANSIT THROUGH BUILDING DESIGN AND
9:13:54PM PEDESTRIAN AMENITIES.
9:13:54PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ALSO PROMOTES PEDESTRIAN SAFETY AND
9:13:57PM ENCOURAGES COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT THAT ENHANCES THE CITY AND
9:14:01PM TAMPA'S CHARACTER.
9:14:03PM THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT PROPOSES TO RETAIN SIDEWALKS
9:14:05PM ADJACENT TO THE SITE ALONG SOUTH MacDILL AVENUE AND
9:14:09PM SOUTH PURITAN AVENUE.
9:14:14PM IT ALSO PROPOSES A PEDESTRIAN CONNECTION TO CONNECT THE
9:14:14PM BUILDING'S ENTRANCE TO THE SIDEWALK ON SOUTH MacDILL.
9:14:16PM TWO ADDITIONAL ENTRYWAYS WITH A SIDEWALK ARE PROPOSED ALONG
9:14:19PM THE SOUTH-FACING WALL OF THE STRUCTURE PROVIDING SAFE
9:14:23PM PEDESTRIAN ACCESS FROM THE PARKING AREA.
9:14:25PM FINALLY, THE PATIO IS PROPOSED ADJACENT TO THE SIDEWALK
9:14:28PM ALONG SOUTH MacDILL AVENUE, WHICH ENGAGES AND IMPROVES
9:14:32PM THE PUBLIC REALM.
9:14:33PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE APPLICATION AND
9:14:36PM FOUND NO ADVERSE IMPACTS TO THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD.
9:14:38PM THE REQUEST WILL NOT ALTER THE CHARACTER OF THE SURROUNDING
9:14:41PM AREA AND IS COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH THIS PORTION OF
9:14:43PM THE BALLAST POINT NEIGHBORHOOD.
9:14:44PM THE PROPOSED PLANNED DEVELOPMENT IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
9:14:47PM DEVELOPMENT PATTERN ENCOURAGED UNDER THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE
9:14:50PM 35 DESIGNATION.
9:14:51PM AND THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
9:14:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
9:14:54PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
9:14:55PM YES, MA'AM.
9:14:57PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU AGAIN, COUNCIL.
9:14:59PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
9:15:01PM IN THIS PD REQUEST, AS MENTIONED EARLIER, FOR THE USE OF A
9:15:06PM RESTAURANT.
9:15:06PM SO A RESTAURANT USE WAS ALREADY ESTABLISHED AT THIS
9:15:09PM LOCATION.
9:15:09PM THE SITE CONTAINS 12,684 SQUARE FEET.
9:15:14PM THE SETBACKS PROPOSED ARE TO THE NORTH 4 FEET, TO THE SOUTH
9:15:17PM 46 FEET, TO THE WEST 29 FEET, AND TO THE EAST 4 FEET.
9:15:22PM SO THE EXISTING STRUCTURE, WHICH IS ON-SITE, WHICH I'LL SHOW
9:15:25PM YOU PICTURES OF SHORTLY, THAT WILL REMAIN.
9:15:28PM THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING TO ADD AN ADDITIONAL 510 SQUARE
9:15:31PM FEET OF OUTDOOR AREA TO THE WEST.
9:15:33PM AND THEN I'LL SHOW YOU THE ZONING ATLAS IN THE IMMEDIATE
9:15:38PM AREA.
9:15:38PM YOU HAVE ALONG MacDILL COMMERCIAL USES, BUT THERE'S ALSO
9:15:43PM TO THE NORTH AN APPROVAL THAT'S THROUGH A SPECIAL USE FOR
9:15:46PM RESIDENTIAL USE THAT'S JUST TO THE NORTH, AND THEN YOU'VE
9:15:49PM GOT RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY THAT'S FURTHER EAST, AND THEN
9:15:52PM COMMERCIAL SOUTH AND WEST.
9:15:54PM SO I'LL SHOW THOSE TO YOU MOMENTARILY ON THE ZONING MAP.
9:15:57PM THIS IS THE SITE PLAN THAT WAS SUBMITTED.
9:16:00PM THIS IS SOUTH MacDILL AVENUE THAT'S BORDERING, AND THIS
9:16:04PM IS PURITAN AVENUE.
9:16:08PM THE SITE PROPOSES, YOU CAN HAVE INGRESS AND EGRESS ON
9:16:11PM PURITAN, AND THEN EGRESS ONLY IS ON SOUTH MacDILL.
9:16:16PM THIS IS THE STRUCTURE WHICH IS EXISTING AND THIS IS THE
9:16:20PM OUTDOOR PATIO AREA THAT'S PROPOSED AT THIS SITE.
9:16:24PM YOU CAN SEE THE SURFACE PARKING THAT'S LOCATED ON-SITE ALONG
9:16:28PM WITH THE WALKWAY CONNECTIONS TO THE OUTDOOR AREA AND TO THE
9:16:33PM STRUCTURE FOR THE INDOOR SEATING AND THEN A CONNECTION TO
9:16:35PM THE SIDEWALK, WHICH IS LOCATED ALONG BOTH AVENUES
9:16:40PM SURROUNDING THE SITE.
9:16:41PM SO THIS IS AN ELEVATION OF THE STRUCTURE.
9:16:47PM SO THIS IS THE NORTH ELEVATION, AND THEN THIS IS THE EAST
9:16:52PM ELEVATION.
9:16:53PM THIS SHOWS YOU THE SOUTH, THE LAST TWO ARE THE SOUTH
9:16:58PM ELEVATION AND THEN THIS IS THE WEST ELEVATION.
9:17:00PM AND THEN THE ZONING ATLAS.
9:17:05PM THIS IS THE ZONING MAP OF THE SITE.
9:17:07PM SO THIS IS THE SITE WHICH IS LOCATED IN RED.
9:17:10PM AND THIS IS SOUTH MacDILL AVENUE.
9:17:14PM THIS IS PURITAN AVENUE.
9:17:15PM SO YOU CAN SEE THAT THIS IS THE RESIDENTIAL, WHICH IS
9:17:21PM IMMEDIATELY NORTH THAT WAS APPROVED UNDER A SPECIAL USE.
9:17:24PM YOU'VE GOT A PD THAT'S LOCATED FURTHER NORTH AND TO THE
9:17:28PM WEST, RESIDENTIAL USES.
9:17:29PM AND THEN YOU HAVE YOUR CG ZONING THAT'S LOCATED HERE ALL ON
9:17:33PM MacDILL AND THEN AS YOU HEAD FURTHER EAST, YOU HAVE
9:17:37PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ZONE WITH RS 60 TO THE EAST AND
9:17:40PM THEN TO THE SOUTHEAST IS RS 50.
9:17:43PM AND THEN HERE ARE PICTURES OF THE SITE.
9:17:46PM SO THIS IS THE SOUTH END OF THE SITE.
9:17:53PM THIS IS ON PURITAN.
9:17:54PM YOU CAN SEE THE STRUCTURE THAT'S THERE.
9:17:59PM THIS IS THE WEST END OF THE SITE ON MacDILL.
9:18:03PM THIS IS WEST OF THE SITE.
9:18:08PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW WEST OF THE SITE, RESIDENTIAL.
9:18:11PM SO THIS IS THE VIEW IF YOU'RE ON MacDILL AND YOU'RE
9:18:16PM LOOKING NORTH.
9:18:17PM THE SITE IS TO THE RIGHT ON THIS PICTURE.
9:18:21PM MY RIGHT.
9:18:24PM THIS IS NORTH OF THE SITE.
9:18:26PM THAT IS THE RESIDENTIAL USE THAT'S LOCATED THERE CLOSE TO
9:18:29PM THE SPECIAL USE.
9:18:31PM THIS IS EAST OF THE SITE.
9:18:32PM SO THIS IS ON PURITAN, THE SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL.
9:18:35PM AND THEN THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE, THE COMMERCIAL THAT
9:18:39PM EXISTS THERE.
9:18:40PM THE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW STAFF REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FINDS
9:18:43PM THE REQUEST INCONSISTENT.
9:18:45PM IT IS DUE TO THE WAIVER AND INCONSISTENT IS FROM
9:18:49PM TRANSPORTATION AND THAT'S FOR THE PARKING WAIVER REQUESTED.
9:18:51PM ALSO, WITHIN THE STAFF REPORT, I DID NOT INCLUDE THE
9:18:54PM REVISION SHEET SO I HAVE THE REVISION SHEET HERE TO SUBMIT
9:18:57PM INTO THE RECORD.
9:18:59PM AND THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION, IF YOU HAVE ANY
9:19:01PM QUESTIONS, I'M AVAILABLE.
9:19:04PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THEY WANT TO GO FROM 26 TO 13 PARKING
9:19:07PM SPACES, AM I CORRECT ABOUT THAT?
9:19:10PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES.
9:19:10PM SO THERE ARE 26 SPACES REQUIRED AND 13 ARE BEING PROVIDED.
9:19:15PM THIS IS INCLUSIVE OF THE OCCUPANCY WITH THE IN AND OUTDOOR
9:19:20PM AREA.
9:19:21PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SO HOW MANY DO THEY HAVE RIGHT NOW?
9:19:25PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: RIGHT NOW ON-SITE I BELIEVE THERE WOULD BE
9:19:27PM 13 SPACES BECAUSE I DON'T THINK THEY ARE ADDING ANY MORE.
9:19:31PM IT'S PERMITTED CURRENTLY FOR 13.
9:19:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
9:19:38PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SO BACK TO THE PDs, WHICH I DECIDED IN
9:19:43PM JUST THE FEW MONTHS I'VE BEEN HERE, SEEMS TO BE THE CRACK OR
9:19:47PM THE FENTANYL OF CITY COUNCIL FOR ZONING.
9:19:53PM IT'S JUST CRAZY.
9:19:54PM WHAT IS IT ON THE SITE PLAN THAT I'M MISSING?
9:20:01PM WHAT IS IT THAT I'M MISSING?
9:20:03PM THEY ARE ASKING FOR THE WAIVER FOR THE PARKING.
9:20:07PM WHAT DO THEY NEED THAT COULDN'T BE ACCOMPLISHED WITH
9:20:10PM EUCLIDEAN ZONING THAT THEY ARE ASKING US FOR A PD?
9:20:14PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: KEEP IN MIND ON THE SITE, IF YOU HAVE
9:20:16PM EUCLIDEAN ZONING, YOU CANNOT REQUEST THE WAIVERS, SO YOUR
9:20:19PM WAIVERS ARE GOING TO BE ONE THING THAT WILL TRIP YOU --
9:20:23PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THEY HAVE TO GO THROUGH THE PROCESS TO GET
9:20:25PM THE WAIVERS.
9:20:29PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: DEPENDING ON THE WAIVER REQUESTED.
9:20:30PM IN THIS CASE, THEY HAVE THE WAIVER TO REDUCE THE REQUIRED
9:20:33PM PARKING.
9:20:33PM THEY HAVE A WAIVER REQUEST TO REDUCE THE USE TO USE BUFFER.
9:20:37PM ON THE EAST, THEY ARE GOING TO FOUR FEET WITH THE SIX FOOT
9:20:40PM PVC FENCE.
9:20:41PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HOW IS THAT, BECAUSE IT'S AN EXISTING
9:20:45PM BUILDING, RIGHT?
9:20:45PM EXISTING ENCROACHMENT THEY ARE TRYING TO MAKE LEGAL?
9:20:48PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CORRECT.
9:20:49PM IT IS AN EXISTING BUILDING AND NOW THEY ARE COMING IN TO ADD
9:20:52PM THE ADDITION, THEN YOU HAVE THAT CONDITION.
9:20:55PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IS THAT AN ADDITION?
9:20:57PM BECAUSE THE ADDITION IS JUST THE PATIO, CORRECT.
9:20:59PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: JUST THE PATIO.
9:21:00PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: BUT THAT CORNER WHERE WE'RE GOING TO FOUR
9:21:03PM FEET, THAT'S JUST AN EXISTING ENCROACHMENT THAT WE'RE TRYING
9:21:06PM TO --
9:21:07PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES.
9:21:07PM THAT WAS TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATION WHEN STAFF DID ITS
9:21:12PM FINDING.
9:21:12PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: RETRO ACTIVELY APPROVING A PREVIOUS SIN.
9:21:17PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THEY WERE USING THE BUILDING THERE.
9:21:19PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WE'RE TALKING THE PARKING WAIVER AND WHAT
9:21:22PM WAS THE OTHER?
9:21:23PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: PARKING WAIVER, USE-TO-USE BUFFER WAIVER ON
9:21:26PM THE EAST AND THEN ON THE NORTH, THERE IS A BUFFER WAIVER TO
9:21:31PM TWO FEET WITH A SIX-FOOT PVC FENCE.
9:21:34PM AND THIS IS ALSO EXISTING.
9:21:38PM THIS BUILDING, THIS IS THE STRUCTURE, AND THEN THAT IS THE
9:21:42PM OUTDOOR PATIO.
9:21:45PM SAME SETBACK AS THE STRUCTURE THAT EXISTS.
9:21:47PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: DOES THE APPLICANT INTEND TO LEASE PARKING
9:21:51PM SOMEWHERE ELSE SO THEY DON'T BURDEN THE NEIGHBORHOOD?
9:21:53PM I'M JUST CURIOUS.
9:21:57PM IT'S GETTING LATE.
9:21:59PM I'M TIRED, TOO.
9:22:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
9:22:09PM >> GOOD EVENING, CITY COUNCIL.
9:22:10PM RYAN MANASSE WITH JOHNSON POPE, 401 EAST JACKSON STREET,
9:22:13PM SUITE 3100.
9:22:15PM HERE TONIGHT REPRESENTING THE PROPERTY OWNER AND OUR CLIENT.
9:22:20PM I'LL TRY TO NOT BE REDUNDANT WITH INFORMATION THAT WAS
9:22:24PM PROVIDED BY STAFF AND ANSWER ANY ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS THAT
9:22:26PM YOU MAY HAVE.
9:22:27PM THE GIST OF THIS WHOLE PROJECT AS KIND OF ALLUDED TO BY
9:22:31PM LaCHONE IS THE EXISTING STRUCTURE WAS HISTORICALLY A
9:22:35PM RESTAURANT.
9:22:36PM THE SITE CONFIGURATION WAS PERMITTED IN THAT CONFIGURATION
9:22:41PM WHICH I'LL SHOW IN ANOTHER SLIDE.
9:22:42PM THE CATALYST BEHIND THIS PLANNED DEVELOPMENT IS THE ADDITION
9:22:45PM OF THIS PATIO AREA, WHICH IS ACTUALLY NOT INCLUDED AS F.A.R.
9:22:49PM OR FLOOR AREA RATIO EITHER.
9:22:51PM THE POINT I'D LIKE TO MAKE, IT IS CG.
9:22:54PM GET UNDER THE CMU 5 CATEGORY, UP TO 1.0 STANDARD
9:22:58PM DEVELOPMENT.
9:22:59PM WE'RE USING .16.
9:23:00PM WE'RE WELL BELOW THE INTENSITY.
9:23:03PM THIS DEVELOPMENT IS MARKETED TO BE A NEIGHBORHOOD
9:23:05PM RESTAURANT.
9:23:06PM IT'S NOT GOING TO BE, OBVIOUSLY, YOU DON'T SEE A
9:23:09PM DRIVE-THROUGH OR A LOT OF SQUARE FOOTAGE FOR THE RESTAURANT
9:23:12PM ITSELF.
9:23:13PM IT'S GENERALLY A LITTLE OVER 1900 SQUARE FEET OF INDOOR AREA
9:23:17PM AND 500 SQUARE FEET OF OUTDOOR AREA.
9:23:19PM THIS ROOM PROBABLY HOLDS 70 SOME PEOPLE.
9:23:22PM LOOKING AT A VERY SMALL NEIGHBORHOOD-SERVING RESTAURANT.
9:23:27PM BRIEFLY HIT ON THE WAIVERS AND MAYBE THAT WILL HELP WITH
9:23:29PM SOME OF THE CLARITY, TOO.
9:23:31PM WAIVER NUMBER ONE IS THE REDUCTION IN PARKING AS
9:23:34PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON POINTED OUT.
9:23:37PM REDUCTION FROM 26 TO 13.
9:23:38PM THE WAY THAT'S CALCULATED IS THEY HAVE TO -- WE HAVE TO
9:23:41PM PROVIDE A SITE PLAN AND FLOOR PLAN WHICH GIVES US THE
9:23:45PM RESTAURANT OCCUPANCY AND THEN PROVIDE THAT TO STAFF.
9:23:47PM THEY MULTIPLY THAT BY THEIR TABLES AND WE GET THE OVERALL
9:23:50PM REQUIRED PARKING.
9:23:51PM SO THE EXISTING RESTAURANT AND PERMITTED, IT SHOULD BE AT
9:23:56PM THE 66 OCCUPANTS ON THE INSIDE.
9:24:00PM THE OUTDOOR PORTION ROUGHLY ACCOUNTS FOR 36 SEATS.
9:24:04PM REALLY THAT'S WHERE THE CULMINATION OF THE WAIVER COMES FROM
9:24:07PM IS THE ADDITION OF THE 510 OR 20 SQUARE FEET TRIGGERED OUR
9:24:11PM PARKING REQUIREMENT TO GO UP FROM WHAT WAS PERMITTED.
9:24:14PM THE SECOND WAIVER WHICH REFERS TO THE USE-TO-USE BUFFERS,
9:24:18PM THAT'S STRICTLY TO BRING INTO CONFORMANCE THE
9:24:22PM NONCONFORMITIES OF THE BUILDING.
9:24:24PM AGAIN, THIS IS AN EXISTING BUILDING.
9:24:26PM WE'RE NOT ASKING TO EXPAND ANY NONCONFORMITY TO THE NORTH OR
9:24:29PM THE SOUTH.
9:24:30PM AGAIN, THE PATIO IS ORIENTATED TOWARD SOUTH MacDILL,
9:24:35PM OBVIOUSLY THE MORE COMMERCIAL CORRIDOR, MORE TRAFFIC AND
9:24:38PM EVERYTHING LIKE THAT.
9:24:39PM SO WE'RE KEEPING ALL IMPACTS TO THIS PATIO OBVIOUSLY TO THE
9:24:42PM FRONT.
9:24:43PM ALSO WHAT THAT DOES IS MAINTAIN THE EXISTING GREENSPACE VUA
9:24:47PM THAT HAS BEEN PREVIOUSLY HAD THERE AND PERMITTED AND SUCH.
9:24:50PM THE THIRD WAIVER IS THE REDUCTION OF THE 8-FOOT LANDSCAPE
9:24:55PM BUFFER THAT'S -- OR VUA BUFFER THAT'S REQUIRED AROUND THE
9:24:58PM PARKING AREA.
9:24:59PM WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO POINT OUT WITH THAT WAIVER SPECIFICALLY
9:25:01PM IS WE HAVE TO TAKE THE SHORTEST DISTANCE.
9:25:04PM FOR INSTANCE, ON THE WAIVER, WE GO FROM 8-FOOT TO 3-FOOT 2
9:25:08PM INCHES ON MacDILL.
9:25:09PM AND THEN 8-FOOT TO 4 FEET 5 INCHES ON PURITAN.
9:25:14PM SO THOSE ARE THE SHORTEST POINTS.
9:25:17PM BUT AS YOU CAN SEE, THE SITE, ONE, THE SHAPE IS OBVIOUSLY
9:25:20PM VERY INTERESTING TO WORK WITH.
9:25:21PM IT'S LIKE A DIAMOND SHAPE.
9:25:22PM THIS IS A PLATTED LOT.
9:25:24PM THIS HAPPENS NOT A REMNANT OF SOME TYPE OF DEVELOPMENT
9:25:26PM THAT'S BEEN CHOPPED UP OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT.
9:25:28PM BUT THE VUA BUFFER VARIES.
9:25:31PM WE MAY ONLY BE GIVING THE 3.2 OR 3-FOOT 2 INCHES HERE.
9:25:35PM HOWEVER, YOU CAN SEE IT'S VERY SUBSTANTIAL HERE.
9:25:38PM AGAIN, THE WAIVER HAS TO ACCOUNT FOR THE SHORTEST DISTANCE
9:25:41PM AND THAT'S WHY WE'RE REQUESTING THAT WAIVER.
9:25:43PM ELEVATIONS.
9:25:50PM I KNOW LaCHONE SHOWED YOU THIS.
9:25:52PM ONE THING TO POINT OUT, ON THE EAST ELEVATION, YOU CAN SEE
9:25:55PM THERE ARE NO WINDOWS, NO PATIOS, NO FURTHER IMPACT TO THE
9:25:58PM NEIGHBORHOOD THAT IS IMMEDIATELY TO THE EAST.
9:26:02PM THIS IS JUST FROM THE PROPERTY APPRAISER.
9:26:06PM I JUST WANTED TO POINT OUT THAT THE BUILDING WAS BUILT
9:26:09PM ORIGINALLY IN 1959.
9:26:10PM OUR CLIENT ORIGINALLY STARTED REMODELING THIS BUILDING AND
9:26:14PM IT'S IN PERMITTING.
9:26:15PM I'LL SHOW YOU THE PERMIT NUMBER HERE IN A SECOND.
9:26:18PM AGAIN, THE REASON FOR THE PD IS BECAUSE AS SOON AS WE ADDED
9:26:22PM ADDITIONAL OCCUPANCY AND NOT EVEN FLOOR AREA RATIO WHICH
9:26:27PM ACCOUNTS FOR MOSTLY ENCLOSED BUILDINGS, WHEN WE ADDED
9:26:29PM OUTDOOR PATIO IT TRIGGERED FULL SITE COMPLIANCE.
9:26:33PM THAT IS THE REASON WE'RE HERE FOR THAT.
9:26:35PM ULTIMATELY, THERE ARE DIFFERENT PROCESSES THE CITY HAS FOR
9:26:37PM REQUESTING VARIANCES AND SUCH, BUT TWO THINGS TO POINT OUT,
9:26:41PM WHEN YOU HAVE THIS KIND OF UNIQUE SITE WITH AN EXISTING
9:26:44PM BUILDING THAT WE'RE TRYING TO ADAPT TO THE CURRENT CODE AND
9:26:46PM TRY TO MAKE A SMALL IMPROVEMENT TO THE PROPERTY, IT'S
9:26:50PM ALMOST, NOT JUST EASIER, BUT MORE CLEAR TO EVERYBODY ON A
9:26:53PM PLANNED DEVELOPMENT WHY WE'RE REQUESTING IT THIS WAY.
9:26:56PM ADDITIONALLY, WHAT THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT DOES IT RESTRICTS
9:26:58PM THE USE AND THAT'S SOMETHING I WOULD LIKE TO POINT OUT.
9:27:01PM TAKING IT OUT OF CG AND ONLY SAYING YOU'RE A RESTAURANT.
9:27:04PM THAT'S IT.
9:27:05PM DOWN THE LINE ANYBODY WHO WANTS TO DO ANYTHING ELSE, THEY'LL
9:27:07PM HAVE TO COME BACK IN AND REZONE.
9:27:09PM A RESTAURANT IS HISTORICALLY WHAT I BELIEVE THIS
9:27:11PM NEIGHBORHOOD IS USED TO.
9:27:13PM THESE ARE GOOGLE PHOTOS I TRIED TO GRAB.
9:27:20PM 2007, IT'S LIKE A PAVEMENT FROM TREE TO EDGE TO SIDEWALK,
9:27:23PM EVERYWHERE, RIGHT?
9:27:24PM I THINK THIS WAS AN OLD -- I COULDN'T READ THE SIGN, BUT IT
9:27:28PM WAS SOME TYPE OF CAFE.
9:27:32PM BUT YOU'LL SEE ITS EVOLUTION OVER TIME.
9:27:33PM 2011 IT LOOKED LIKE IT WAS SOME TYPE OF GERMAN RESTAURANT.
9:27:35PM BUT YOU CAN SEE THIS MASSIVE ASPHALTED AREA.
9:27:37PM WHEN YOU START SEEING THE DIFFERENCE OVER TIME IS WHEN AIR
9:27:37PM RING CAME THERE AND THAT WAS 2013-2014 TIME FRAME.
9:27:45PM AND THIS WAS A PERMITTED PLAN FOR THAT SITE CONFIGURATION
9:27:49PM THAT'S SIMILAR TO WHAT YOU'RE SEEING HERE TONIGHT.
9:27:50PM SEE THIS X HERE ACTUALLY -- IT DOESN'T SHOW UP TOO WELL, BUT
9:27:57PM I'LL POINT TO IT -- IT INDICATES THE OUTDOOR GARDEN AREA
9:27:59PM THAT WAS ORIGINALLY INTENDED FOR THIS RESTAURANT BACK IN
9:28:01PM 2013.
9:28:02PM BUT YOU'LL NOTICE A SIMILAR CONFIGURATION OF THE SITE.
9:28:04PM AND I SAY SIMILAR BECAUSE AIR RING WAS THERE LIKE THIS IN
9:28:11PM THIS CAPACITY, AND YOU CAN SEE THIS OUTDOOR, WHAT THEY CALL
9:28:15PM GARDEN AREA, BUT THAT WOULD BE THE AREA WE'RE PROPOSING FOR
9:28:18PM THE 510 SQUARE FOOT EXPANSION FOR OUTDOOR PATIO WITH NO
9:28:23PM STRUCTURES.
9:28:24PM AGAIN IN 2021, SO THIS WOULD BE PROBABLY THE LAST PICTURE
9:28:27PM YOU WOULD SEE BEFORE IT WAS COMPLETELY REMODELED AND SOME OF
9:28:30PM THE PICTURES LaCHONE SHOWED.
9:28:32PM I'M POINTING THIS OUT FOR A REASON.
9:28:34PM YOU CAN SEE HOW IT'S ASPHALT TO ASPHALT FROM BASICALLY
9:28:37PM PROPERTY LINE, AND YOU CAN SEE IT OVER HERE AS WELL.
9:28:40PM I THOUGHT THIS WAS A GOOD VISUAL FOR YOU TO SEE.
9:28:45PM I OUTLINED GENERALLY THE PROPERTY BOUNDARY IN YELLOW.
9:28:48PM AGAIN, YOU CAN SEE THIS IS POST THE PERMIT IN 2013-2014
9:28:52PM WHERE THEY HAD THIS OUTDOOR GARDEN AREA AND THEN THE
9:28:55PM CONFIGURATION THAT'S VERY SIMILAR TO WHAT WE'RE PROPOSING
9:28:59PM TONIGHT.
9:28:59PM THE REASON AGAIN I SAY SIMILAR IS BECAUSE IN 2022, OUR
9:29:03PM CLIENT WENT THROUGH AND IS GETTING APPROVED FOR PERMITTING.
9:29:06PM THAT'S WHY YOU SEE IN THOSE PICTURES THE NEW CONSTRUCTION OF
9:29:09PM THE BUILDING WITHOUT THIS BEING OCCUPIABLE AREA AS FAR AS
9:29:15PM OUTDOOR PATIO.
9:29:16PM THE SITE, IT WAS ACTUALLY PERMITTED WITH THAT LARGE
9:29:19PM ASPHALTED AREA TO REMAIN IN THE CURRENT CONFIGURATION. SO
9:29:26PM THROUGH THIS REZONING, WHAT IT DOES, IT ACTUALLY PROVIDES
9:29:29PM OUR INGRESS AND EGRESS POINTS TO CITY STANDARDS.
9:29:32PM IT PROVIDES PROPER FLAIRS ALONG PURITAN AND REDUCES THAT
9:29:36PM LARGE OPEN AREA THAT MIGHT CAUSE TRAFFIC ISSUES, AND THAT'S
9:29:40PM AT THE RECOMMENDATION OF OBVIOUSLY THE REVIEW FROM
9:29:42PM TRANSPORTATION STAFF AND MEETING THE TECHNICAL REQUIREMENTS
9:29:44PM AND SUCH.
9:29:45PM WE HAVE TO -- WE ARE PROVIDING SIDEWALKS.
9:29:49PM THEY ARE EXISTING BUT MAY HAVE TO MOVE THIS ONE UP.
9:29:52PM ALSO PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIONS THERE.
9:29:53PM AGAIN, HIGHLIGHTED IN YELLOW IS BASICALLY THE CATALYST FOR
9:29:58PM THIS REZONING TONIGHT.
9:29:59PM WHAT WE'RE DOING HERE IS WE'RE TRYING TO TAKE, AGAIN, AN
9:30:02PM EXISTING STRUCTURE WITH NONCONFORMITIES THAT'S EXISTED AS A
9:30:06PM RESTAURANT AND ADD A VERY SMALL PATIO TO ALLOW THE PATRONS
9:30:09PM THE CAPACITY TO GO OUTDOOR.
9:30:12PM I KNOW PLANNING COMMISSION AND STAFF DISCUSSED IT, SNIPPETS
9:30:20PM FROM THE MAP.
9:30:22PM CMU 35.
9:30:24PM YOU CAN SEE IT RUNNING ALONG SOUTH MacDILL, OBVIOUSLY,
9:30:26PM INCLUSIVE OF OUR PROPERTY AND R-10, RESIDENTIAL
9:30:29PM NEIGHBORHOODS, AS WELL AS THE ZONING MAP.
9:30:31PM IT IS POINTED OUT THAT THE PROPERTY NORTH IS ZONED CG.
9:30:35PM LaCHONE DID POINT OUT IT IS A SPECIAL USE ONE THAT WAS
9:30:38PM RELATIVELY RECENTLY DONE FOR THIS -- I THINK IT WAS A
9:30:41PM DUPLEX, IF I RECALL CORRECTLY.
9:30:43PM ALL INTENTS AND PURPOSES THE ZONING DISTRICT ALONG
9:30:46PM MacDILL HAS BEEN CG.
9:30:47PM THESE TWO PDs ARE THE LARGE MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENTS.
9:30:54PM THIS IS TO GIVE YOU AN IDEA DOWN PURITAN, SOUTH MacDILL,
9:30:58PM COMMERCIAL HERE, EXISTING RESTAURANT HERE.
9:30:59PM THERE IS THE LARGE MULTIFAMILY.
9:31:01PM GAS STATION, FURTHER COMMERCIAL GOING DOWN SOUTH.
9:31:06PM LOOKING NORTH, GAS STATION, MULTIFAMILY.
9:31:09PM THIS WOULD BE THE EXISTING RESTAURANT AND BEING REMODELED.
9:31:12PM AND THEN THE PATIO AREA WOULD BE OUT HERE AND FURTHER NORTH
9:31:15PM ON SOUTH MacDILL.
9:31:17PM LOOKING SOUTH ON SOUTH MacDILL, AGAIN, I TRIED TO KEEP
9:31:22PM SOME OF THE PICTURE IN THERE FOR DIRECTIONAL PURPOSES, BUT
9:31:25PM YOU CAN SEE IT'S ALL COMMERCIAL GOING DOWN.
9:31:27PM THESE ARE JUST SOME RENDERINGS THE ARCHITECT PROVIDED TO US
9:31:32PM THROUGH THIS.
9:31:32PM OUR CLIENT, HE PLANS TO OPEN A SMALL ITALIAN RESTAURANT.
9:31:37PM THIS IS WHAT IT HOPEFULLY WILL LOOK LIKE IF APPROVED WITH
9:31:40PM OUTDOOR PATIO AREA.
9:31:42PM AGAIN, THEY CAN'T OPERATE, BUILDING PERMITTING FOR THE
9:31:49PM ENCLOSED BUILDING PORTION RIGHT NOW.
9:31:52PM NO SELECTION ON THE CARS IN CASE ANYBODY WAS WONDERING.
9:31:58PM I LEAVE THAT TO THE ARCHITECT.
9:31:59PM THESE ARE RENDERINGS FROM THE INSIDE.
9:32:02PM THIS IS NOT A LARGE STRUCTURE.
9:32:03PM 1900 SOME SQUARE FEET OF STRUCTURE.
9:32:05PM IT'S NOT A LOT OF RESTAURANT.
9:32:09PM THIS KIND OF REMINDS ME OF A RESTAURANT ALMOST LIKE THE SOMI
9:32:15PM ON HOWARD.
9:32:17PM SMALL, ALMOST NEIGHBORHOOD RESTAURANT.
9:32:19PM IT'S NOT INTENDED FOR A LARGE CROWD AND SUCH.
9:32:23PM AS POINTED OUT BY STAFF, TRANSPORTATION IS INCONSISTENT AND
9:32:26PM THAT'S DUE TO TRANSPORTATION, US REQUESTING THE WAIVER.
9:32:29PM AS YOU CAN SEE, THE REMAINING REVIEW AGENCY DEPARTMENTS HAVE
9:32:33PM FOUND US CONSISTENT WITH APPLICABLE CODES FROM THE LAND
9:32:36PM DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS.
9:32:38PM MOST NOTABLY THE WAIVERS FROM NATURAL RESOURCES ARE STILL
9:32:42PM FOUND CONSISTENT AND LaCHONE POINTED THAT OUT, AGAIN,
9:32:45PM EXISTING STRUCTURE AND WE'RE TRYING TO ACCOMMODATE SOME OF
9:32:48PM THOSE NONCONFORMITIES FROM THAT STRUCTURE.
9:32:51PM OBVIOUSLY, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STATED THAT THEY WERE
9:32:53PM CONSISTENT.
9:32:55PM WITH THAT, I WILL -- I KNOW STEPHANIE TOOK MY THUNDER AWAY,
9:32:59PM BUT I DID ORIGINALLY BEFORE WE EVEN APPLIED FOR THIS
9:33:03PM APPLICATION, WE SENT OUT A PROPOSED SITE PLAN AS WELL AS
9:33:06PM FLOOR PLAN TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATIONS THAT WERE FOUND
9:33:08PM ON THE CITY'S WEBSITE.
9:33:10PM WE DID NOT RECEIVE ANY OPPOSITION.
9:33:12PM I FOLLOWED UP WITH STEPHANIE AGAIN TONIGHT AND SHE WAS NICE
9:33:15PM ENOUGH TO PROVIDE ME A LETTER THAT I'LL TURN INTO THE CLERK
9:33:18PM FOR THE RECORD IN SUPPORT OF THIS REZONING, AS WELL AS I'LL
9:33:21PM TURN IN THE BACKUP DOCUMENT FOR MY PRESENTATION.
9:33:24PM WITH THAT BEING SAID, I'M AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
9:33:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA AND COUNCILMAN
9:33:34PM CARLSON.
9:33:37PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: OUTDOOR MUSIC?
9:33:39PM >> I DID TALK TO THE PROPERTY OWNER.
9:33:40PM I DON'T THINK HE INTENDS TO HAVE IT, BUT IF THERE ARE
9:33:43PM CONCERNS ABOUT IT, WE CAN ADDRESS THOSE.
9:33:45PM JUST FOR FULL DISCLOSURE, THERE IS AN ALCOHOL PETITION
9:33:47PM COMING TO YOU IN TWO WEEKS.
9:33:49PM IT WILL BE FOR A RESTAURANT USE, BEER, WINE, LIQUOR, NOT
9:33:53PM TRYING TO GET OFF TOPIC, BUT HAPPY TO ADDRESS THAT ON THAT
9:33:56PM AS WELL, IF THAT SEEMS EASIER.
9:33:58PM I KNOW HISTORICALLY IT USUALLY --
9:34:03PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: [INAUDIBLE] YOU DON'T NEED ANY PARKING.
9:34:11PM >> CORRECT.
9:34:11PM [ LAUGHTER ]
9:34:20PM >>BILL CARLSON: DO YOU KNOW SOMETHING --
9:34:23PM >> WE DO INTEND FOR THIS TO BE A VERY PEDESTRIAN FRIENDLY
9:34:26PM ENVIRONMENT.
9:34:26PM OBVIOUSLY I SHOWED YOU ON THE SITE PLAN, I THINK STAFF
9:34:29PM INDICATED THERE'S PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIONS.
9:34:31PM THERE'S SIDEWALKS, THERE ARE BIKE RACKS.
9:34:33PM AGAIN, SUPPOSED TO BE FOR THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
9:34:35PM I THINK MS. POYNOR'S E-MAIL OR HANDWRITTEN LETTER STATES
9:34:39PM THAT THEY LIKE OR THEY ARE IN SUPPORT OF THIS DEVELOPMENT.
9:34:44PM >>BILL CARLSON: WHEN I USED TO GO TO CAFE PEPE, I HAD TO
9:34:47PM PARK WAY DOWN THE STREET.
9:34:48PM JUST KIDDING.
9:34:52PM THE SOUND ISSUE IS THE SAME ONE I HAVE.
9:34:56PM IF WE PASS THIS AND THEN THERE'S LOUD MUSIC OUTSIDE AND THE
9:35:02PM LAWYERS CAN CUT ME OFF IF I'M NOT SUPPOSED TO TALK ABOUT IT,
9:35:06PM BUT IF SUDDENLY IT'S LOUD OUTSIDE, WE'LL GET ALL KINDS OF
9:35:13PM COMPLAINTS.
9:35:13PM DO WE HAVE TO WAIT UNTIL THE ALCOHOL LICENSE OR IS THERE
9:35:16PM SOMETHING THAT WE CAN DO NOW?
9:35:21PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I WAS GOING TO SUGGEST WAIT UNTIL THE
9:35:23PM ALCOHOL ISSUE COMES UP.
9:35:24PM >>CATE WELLS: IF I MAY, CATE WELLS, LEGAL DEPARTMENT.
9:35:28PM THOSE TYPE OF ISSUES AS THEY RELATE TO HOW THIS BUSINESS
9:35:31PM WILL BE OPERATED WOULD BE BETTER ADDRESSED THROUGH THE
9:35:34PM REQUEST FOR ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE PERMIT.
9:35:37PM TYPICALLY ON A REZONING, WE DO NOT TRY TO ADDRESS THE
9:35:40PM OPERATIONS OF THE ESTABLISHMENT.
9:35:42PM >>BILL CARLSON: SO THE SAME QUESTION TO BOTH OF YOU.
9:35:46PM HE'S CLASSIFYING IT AS A RESTAURANT.
9:35:50PM WHAT ASSURANCE DO WE HAVE THAT IT WON'T CONVERT TO A BAR?
9:35:55PM IS THERE SOME REGULAR CHECK-INS TO MAKE SURE --
9:36:03PM >>CATE WELLS: I THINK THAT WOULD BE ADDRESSED WHEN THEY MAKE
9:36:05PM THE REQUEST FOR ALCOHOL BEVERAGE APPROVAL.
9:36:07PM >>BILL CARLSON: RIGHT NOW THERE'S NO LICENSE AT ALL?
9:36:11PM >>CATE WELLS: RIGHT NOW, THIS IS JUST THE RESTAURANT THAT
9:36:14PM THEY ARE REQUESTING THROUGH THE REZONING.
9:36:16PM ANYTHING RELATED TO THE TYPE OF ESTABLISHMENT THAT WILL BE
9:36:20PM OPERATED THERE, THAT WOULD BE REGULATED THROUGH THE REQUEST
9:36:24PM FOR A AB PERMIT.
9:36:25PM >>BILL CARLSON: PART OF THE DESIGN ON THE INSIDE LOOKED LIKE
9:36:28PM A BAR.
9:36:30PM YOU'RE SHAKING YOUR --
9:36:33PM >> LIKE CATE ALLUDED TO, AB 2 THAT YOU'LL SEE IN TWO WEEKS
9:36:38PM WHICH DOES RESTRICT HOW ALCOHOL IS SOLD, WE'RE REQUESTING A
9:36:41PM RESTAURANT, WHICH IS A REPORTING RESTAURANT.
9:36:43PM NOT REQUESTING A SMALL VENUE OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT.
9:36:46PM >>BILL CARLSON: THE LAST THING, AND I THINK THIS ONE IS
9:36:48PM ALLOWED HOPEFULLY.
9:36:50PM YOU SAID IT'S PERMITTED RIGHT NOW FOR 13 SPACES, SO THE
9:36:53PM RESTAURANT HAS BEEN OPERATING FOR MORE THAN TEN YEARS WITH
9:36:56PM 13 SPACES?
9:36:59PM >> CORRECT.
9:37:00PM WHEN IT WENT THROUGH REMODEL, THEY ARE IN PERMITTING RIGHT
9:37:05PM NOW FOR THE ENCLOSED PROPERTY.
9:37:07PM >>BILL CARLSON: CAN YOU SAY HOW MANY SPACES AIR RING HAD?
9:37:11PM >> I THINK THEY HAD 14.
9:37:13PM AND THIS WAS PERMITTED WITH 13.
9:37:15PM >>BILL CARLSON: DID YOU HAPPEN TO LOOK AND SEE IF THERE WERE
9:37:18PM ANY COMPLAINTS ABOUT PARKING IN THE STREETS OR ANYTHING?
9:37:21PM >> I HAVEN'T RECEIVED ANY COMPLAINTS.
9:37:24PM AGAIN, LIKE I STATED, I REACHED OUT TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD
9:37:26PM ASSOCIATION BEFORE WE EVEN SUBMITTED TO FACILITATE
9:37:29PM CONVERSATION.
9:37:29PM >>BILL CARLSON: DO YOU HAVE ANY KIND OF EVIDENCE OR STUDY
9:37:32PM THAT YOU COULD CITE THAT SAYS THAT NEIGHBORHOOD RESTAURANTS
9:37:35PM NEED LESS PARKING THAN DESTINATION RESTAURANTS OR SOMETHING
9:37:39PM LIKE THAT?
9:37:40PM >> I DO NOT.
9:37:41PM BUT I CAN SAY, AGAIN, IT'S ON MacDILL AVENUE AND THERE
9:37:44PM ARE SIDEWALKS, SO PEDESTRIAN FRIENDLY.
9:37:46PM WE'RE PROVIDING THE ACCESS TO THE RESTAURANT FROM
9:37:48PM MacDILL.
9:37:50PM THERE ARE BUS STOPS.
9:37:51PM WE ARE PROVIDING BIKE RACKS AND OBVIOUSLY I'M SURE EVERYBODY
9:37:55PM HEARS THIS ALL THE TIME BUT UBER, LYFT, GENERALLY, IF YOU
9:37:59PM LIVE IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD, I IMAGINE WOULD YOU WALK THERE.
9:38:02PM LIKE SOME OF THE OTHER SMALLER RESTAURANTS YOU MAY SEE IN
9:38:04PM THE CITY.
9:38:05PM >>BILL CARLSON: THANK YOU.
9:38:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
9:38:11PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM?
9:38:14PM THIS IS ITEM NUMBER 8.
9:38:16PM I SEE NO ONE.
9:38:17PM WE HAVE NOBODY ONLINE.
9:38:18PM MOTION TO CLOSE?
9:38:18PM MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER --
9:38:21PM >> I'LL SUBMIT THIS FOR THE RECORD.
9:38:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN, SECOND FROM
9:38:25PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
9:38:25PM ALL IN FAVOR?
9:38:26PM AYE.
9:38:27PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
9:38:28PM >>LYNN HURTAK: FILE NUMBER REZ-23-64, ORDINANCE REZONING
9:38:36PM PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 5232 SOUTH MacDILL
9:38:39PM AVENUE IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA AND MORE PARTICULARLY
9:38:43PM DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1 FROM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION,
9:38:45PM CG, COMMERCIAL GENERAL, TO PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT,
9:38:48PM RESTAURANT, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND INCLUDING THE
9:38:51PM REVISION SHEET.
9:38:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
9:38:54PM CARLSON.
9:38:55PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
9:38:58PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
9:38:59PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
9:39:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: JUST TO EXPLAIN MY VOTE BECAUSE I COME OUT
9:39:05PM SO STRONGLY AGAINST PDs.
9:39:06PM THIS IS AN EXISTING STRUCTURE.
9:39:08PM THEY ARE MODIFYING, IT HAS HAD THE SAME USE AS RESTAURANT
9:39:12PM FOR YEARS.
9:39:14PM THIS IS ONE OF THOSE THINGS KIND OF MAKES SENSE TO RESOLVE A
9:39:17PM PAST SIN AND DO WHAT NEEDS TO BE DONE TO GET THIS PROPERTY
9:39:20PM GOING AND IN CONFORMANCE AND SERVICE TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND
9:39:23PM I'LL VOTE YES.
9:39:25PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YEAH, I'M GOING TO VOTE NO.
9:39:28PM THE PARKING IS A BIG CONCERN TO ME.
9:39:31PM IF IT IS A SUCCESSFUL RESTAURANT, I THINK THAT WOULD TURN
9:39:34PM INTO A PROBLEM FOR THE COMMUNITY.
9:39:36PM GOOD FOOD IS GOOD FOOD AND PEOPLE CAN COME FROM EVERYWHERE.
9:39:39PM I JUST DON'T SEE WHERE THE PATRONS WOULD END UP PARKING
9:39:43PM BECAUSE IT ACTUALLY DOES HOLD 80 PEOPLE CAPACITY, AND I JUST
9:39:49PM -- I'M JUST GOING TO VOTE NO FOR THAT REASON.
9:39:52PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
9:39:54PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THINKING ABOUT IT, YOU KNOW I HAVE TO
9:40:01PM VOTE NO BECAUSE OF PARKING.
9:40:03PM ANY RESTAURANT HAS ANY BUSINESS, YOU HAVE TO HAVE AT LEAST
9:40:06PM 50% OF THE OCCUPANCY.
9:40:07PM 50 INSIDE AND NEED 25 SPACES.
9:40:10PM PEOPLE COME IN AND OUT.
9:40:12PM 13 PARKING SPACES, I WISH THEM LUCK.
9:40:15PM I DON'T WANT THEM TO -- I WANT TO HAVE A LOT OF BUSINESS AND
9:40:19PM A LOT OF PARKING.
9:40:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
9:40:24PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION CARRIED WITH HENDERSON, MIRANDA VOTING
9:40:28PM NO.
9:40:29PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER 7th,
9:40:33PM 2023, AT 9:30 A.M. AT THE OLD CITY HALL, 315 EAST KENNEDY
9:40:38PM BOULEVARD, TAMPA, FLORIDA.
9:40:41PM >> THANK YOU, CITY COUNCIL.
9:40:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
9:40:44PM LEE'S GROCERY, THE SECOND BEST PIZZA PLACE IN TOWN.
9:41:05PM ITEM NUMBER 9.
9:41:09PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
9:41:13PM ITEM NUMBER 9 IS REZ 23-65.
9:41:17PM THIS IS FOR FOLIO 102910.0000.
9:41:24PM THE APPLICANT IS REPRESENTED BY STEVE MICHELINI.
9:41:27PM THE REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY FROM RS 50,
9:41:30PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY, TO PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, FOR
9:41:33PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED USE ON-SITE.
9:41:35PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO EMILY.
9:41:49PM >>EMILY PHELAN: EMILY PHELAN, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
9:41:51PM THE SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE UNIVERSITY PLANNING DISTRICT
9:41:54PM AND IS LOCATED WITHIN THE COASTAL PLANNING AREA,
9:41:57PM SPECIFICALLY EVACUATION ZONE D.
9:41:59PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED HERE.
9:42:03PM AND THERE ARE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED USES TO THE NORTH,
9:42:07PM SOUTH AND WEST OF THE SITE AND COMMERCIAL USES ARE LOCATED
9:42:11PM TO THE EAST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
9:42:20PM [ENCODER DROP]
9:42:22PM -- SOUTH IS CC 35 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
9:42:43PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REVIEWED THE APPLICATION AND FOUND
9:42:47PM MINIMAL IMPACTS ON THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD.
9:42:49PM SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN THE RESIDENTIAL 10 FUTURE LAND USE
9:42:51PM DESIGNATION WHICH ENCOURAGES SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL
9:42:55PM DEVELOPMENT UP TO 10 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE.
9:42:58PM THIS PORTION OF NORTH CHURCH STREET BETWEEN WEST POWHATAN
9:43:03PM AVENUE AND WEST COMANCHE AVENUE HAS AN EXISTING DENSITY OF
9:43:08PM 3.09 UNITS PER ACRE BASED ON 20 SAMPLE SITES.
9:43:12PM THIS PORTION OF NORTH CHURCH AVENUE HAS BEEN DEVELOPED AT
9:43:15PM APPROXIMATELY 30% OF THE DENSITY ANTICIPATED IN THIS AREA.
9:43:18PM THE SUBJECT SITE AND NORTH CHURCH AVENUE CAN CURRENTLY BE
9:43:22PM CONSIDERED UNDERUTILIZED AND AN INCREASE IN THE NUMBER OF
9:43:25PM DWELLING UNITS IS CONSISTENT WITH THE POLICY DIRECTION OF
9:43:27PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN THAT SEEKS TO ENSURE AN ADEQUATE
9:43:31PM SUPPLY OF HOUSING FOR TAMPA'S GROWING POPULATION, ESPECIALLY
9:43:34PM ON VACANT OR UNDERUTILIZED SITES.
9:43:37PM THE PROPOSED PD IS COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH THE
9:43:40PM DEVELOPMENT PATTERN AND IS CONSISTENT WITH THE LONG-RANGE
9:43:43PM DEVELOPMENT ENCOURAGED UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL 10 FUTURE LAND
9:43:46PM USE DESIGNATION.
9:43:47PM AND THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
9:43:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
9:43:50PM ANY QUESTIONS?
9:43:50PM SEEING NONE, YES, MA'AM.
9:43:54PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
9:43:57PM AND THIS PD REQUEST IS CONSISTING OF A PROPERTY THAT
9:44:02PM CONTAINS 6,538 SQUARE FEET.
9:44:05PM THE APPLICANT PROPOSES TO CONSTRUCT A SINGLE-FAMILY
9:44:08PM RESIDENTIAL DETACHED STRUCTURE ON-SITE.
9:44:11PM IT WILL CONTAIN TWO STORIES WITH A MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT
9:44:13PM OF 35 FEET.
9:44:15PM THE SETBACKS PROPOSED ARE TO THE NORTH 7 FEET, TO THE SOUTH
9:44:18PM 6 FEET, TO THE WEST 20 FEET, AND TO THE EAST 25 FEET.
9:44:22PM THIS PROPERTY HAS FRONTAGE OF 46 FEET AND IT HAS A DEPTH OF
9:44:31PM APPROXIMATELY 142 FEET.
9:44:33PM SO THIS IS THE SITE WHICH IS LOCATED ON CHURCH.
9:44:37PM THIS IS THE SITE PLAN WHICH WAS SUBMITTED, SO YOU CAN SEE
9:44:40PM THE WIDTH IDENTIFIED HERE AT 46 FEET.
9:44:44PM AND THEN THE STRUCTURE IS PROPOSED WITH TWO CAR ENCLOSED
9:44:49PM GARAGE AND THEN A CONNECTION TO THE SIDEWALK ALONG CHURCH
9:44:53PM AVENUE.
9:44:54PM AND THEN HERE ARE THE ELEVATIONS PROPOSED OF THE SITE.
9:45:01PM TOP TWO PHOTOS ARE THE EAST AND THE SOUTH ELEVATION.
9:45:07PM AND THEN THIS IS THE NORTH ELEVATION AND THE WEST ELEVATION.
9:45:10PM AND EMILY TALKED A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE AREA, SO I'LL JUST
9:45:20PM SHOW YOU THE AERIAL MAP.
9:45:23PM THIS IS THE SITE WHICH IS LOCATED -- I HAVE IT HIGHLIGHTED
9:45:27PM HERE.
9:45:27PM IT'S NOT THIS RED PARCEL.
9:45:28PM IT IS THE ONE JUST NORTH OF IT.
9:45:31PM THE SMALLER PIECE.
9:45:32PM AND THIS IS CHURCH AVENUE AND JUST TO ORIENT YOU ON THE MAP,
9:45:36PM THIS IS HILLSBOROUGH AVENUE AND THIS IS DALE MABRY.
9:45:38PM SO A LOT OF THE PARCELS ON THE EAST SIDE OF CHURCH AVENUE,
9:45:43PM THEY ARE COMMERCIAL OR INDUSTRIAL BECAUSE THEY ACTUALLY
9:45:45PM FRONT DALE MABRY, SOME OF THOSE USES.
9:45:48PM AND THEN THE SAME WHEN YOU HEAD SOUTH, TO THE SOUTH, THESE
9:45:53PM PARCELS FRONT HILLSBOROUGH.
9:45:54PM SO THEY ARE COMMERCIAL IN NATURE.
9:45:57PM THIS IS A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENT.
9:45:58PM WE HAVEN'T SEEN THIS IN A WHILE.
9:46:00PM THESE LOTS ARE UNPLATTED, SO THEY ARE NOT A PART OF A
9:46:03PM SUBDIVISION AND THAT'S WHY THERE'S NOT AN INSET OF A PLAT
9:46:06PM MAP LIKE WE USUALLY WILL SHOW YOU.
9:46:09PM THE BLOCK AND LOT NUMBER.
9:46:12PM SO WHAT I DID IS JUST RUN THE NUMBERS ON THE LOT WIDTH IN
9:46:17PM THE AREA.
9:46:18PM IT'S JUST IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT, ONE, THIS IS A DIFFERENT
9:46:21PM AREA JUST BECAUSE OF WHAT I MENTIONED, THE COMMERCIAL THAT'S
9:46:24PM ON DALE MABRY TO THE EAST AND THEN THE COMMERCIAL THAT
9:46:26PM EXISTS TO THE SOUTH ON HILLSBOROUGH.
9:46:27PM BUT ALSO THIS IS THE COUNTY LINE.
9:46:32PM THERE WERE ADDITIONAL PARCELS WHICH WOULD HAVE BEEN INCLUDED
9:46:35PM IN THE ANALYSIS BUT THEY ARE IN THE COUNTY.
9:46:37PM YOU CAN SEE THE LOT WIDTHS ARE SMALLER.
9:46:42PM ALSO AS YOU APPROACH NORTH OF THE COUNTY LINE.
9:46:45PM I JUST WANT TO READ QUICKLY THE ANALYSIS, THE RESULTS OF THE
9:46:50PM ANALYSIS, BUT I THINK YOU CAN SEE THE MAJORITY OF THE LOTS
9:46:52PM ARE LARGER JUST BECAUSE OF THE SHAPE OF THESE LOTS AND THE
9:46:56PM AREA ITSELF.
9:46:57PM BUT IN RELATION TO REVIEWING THE EXISTING DEVELOPMENT
9:47:00PM PATTERN, THE SUBJECT BLOCK, AND THIS IS FROM POWHATAN TO
9:47:06PM COMANCHE.
9:47:07PM IT CONTAINS FOUR LOTS, AND THIS DOES NOT INCLUDE THE SUBJECT
9:47:11PM PARCEL.
9:47:11PM ALL OF THE LOTS ARE DEVELOPED AT A WIDTH OF 65 FEET OR
9:47:15PM GREATER.
9:47:15PM AND THEN IN THE AREA, THREE LOTS OR 6% OF THE LOTS DEVELOPED
9:47:22PM WITH 55 FEET TO 59.99 FEET AND THEN TWO OR 4 PERCENT OF THE
9:47:25PM LOTS ARE DEVELOPED WITH THE WIDTH OF 60 TO 64.99 FEET.
9:47:30PM TWO OR 4 PERCENT OF THE LOTS ARE DEVELOPED AT A WIDTH OF 65
9:47:34PM FEET TO 69.99 FEET, AND ONE OR TWO PERCENT OF THE LOTS ARE
9:47:38PM DEVELOPED WITH A WIDTH OF 70 FEET TO 74.99 FEET, AND ONE LOT
9:47:44PM OR 2% OF THE LOTS ARE DEVELOPED AT A WIDTH OF 75 TO 79.99
9:47:49PM FEET.
9:47:50PM 7 OR 14% OF THE LOTS ARE DEVELOPED WITH A WIDTH OF 80 TO
9:47:54PM 99.99 FEET.
9:47:56PM AND 29 -- OR 59% OF THE LOTS ARE DEVELOPED AT A WIDTH OF 100
9:48:01PM FEET OR MORE.
9:48:02PM AND THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
9:48:10PM THIS IS IF YOU'RE LOOKING SOUTH ON CHURCH, SUBJECT SITE IS
9:48:21PM LOCATED HERE.
9:48:22PM THIS IS SOME OF THE COMMERCIAL THAT'S LOCATED HERE THAT
9:48:25PM ABUTS DALE MABRY.
9:48:27PM SO THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE.
9:48:33PM THIS IS ONE OF THE COMMERCIAL.
9:48:34PM THIS IS EAST OF THE SITE DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET.
9:48:37PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW FURTHER EAST OF THE SITE.
9:48:44PM THIS IS NORTH OF THE SITE, RESIDENTIAL.
9:48:47PM AND THEN THIS IS NORTH OF THE SITE.
9:48:50PM THIS IS ON POWHATAN.
9:48:51PM SO THE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND
9:48:56PM FINDS THE REQUEST INCONSISTENT BASED UPON THE ANALYSIS.
9:48:59PM BUT THAT CONCLUDES STAFF'S REPORT.
9:49:02PM I'M AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
9:49:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN AND COUNCILWOMAN
9:49:09PM HENDERSON.
9:49:09PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE OTHER TWO PARCELS, TOTAL OF FOUR THAT
9:49:13PM FACE CHURCH ON THE WEST SIDE, ARE THEY CURRENTLY DEVELOPED?
9:49:18PM I MIGHT HAVE MISSED IT BECAUSE IT'S GETTING LATE.
9:49:21PM THE ONES, LIKE SAW ON YOUR PLAT.
9:49:26PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THE ONES THAT ARE -- SO THIS ONE IN THE
9:49:29PM YELLOW, THIS IS 65 TO 69.
9:49:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IS THERE SOMETHING THERE?
9:49:34PM IS IT ALREADY DEVELOPED?
9:49:35PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES.
9:49:36PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE?
9:49:38PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: [INAUDIBLE]
9:49:39PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ONE NORTH IS SINGLE-FAMILY AS WELL.
9:49:42PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES.
9:49:43PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHAT'S ON THE BIG PIECE OF PROPERTY TO THE
9:49:47PM SOUTH.
9:49:47PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: SO THE SOUTH IS A RESIDENCE.
9:49:49PM JUST ORIENTED DIFFERENTLY.
9:49:54PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I ANSWERED MY OWN QUESTION.
9:49:55PM THANK YOU.
9:49:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
9:49:57PM APPLICANT?
9:50:13PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
9:50:16PM THIS IS A UNIQUE SITUATION REGARDING THIS LOT.
9:50:19PM IT DOESN'T HAVE THE FRONTAGE BUT HAS THE DEPTH.
9:50:26PM IT'S 142 FEET DEEP.
9:50:28PM THE PROPOSAL IS FOR SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL HOUSE THAT
9:50:32PM MEETS ALL OF THE SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SETBACKS.
9:50:36PM EXCEPT FOR ONE SIDE.
9:50:38PM ONE SIDE IS BEING REDUCED TO SIX FEET, BUT THAT'S PUSHING
9:50:41PM THE HOUSE BACK SO THAT WE DON'T INTERFERE WITH A GRAND TREE
9:50:46PM THAT'S AT THE CORNER OF THE LOT.
9:50:49PM MY GENERAL INTERPRETATION OF THIS IS THAT IF YOU DROVE BY
9:50:56PM AND YOU SAW A SINGLE-FAMILY HOUSE THAT MET THE SETBACKS,
9:51:00PM EXCEPT FOR WHERE THE TREE IS YOU WOULDN'T NOTICE ANY
9:51:06PM DISTINGUISHABLE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THAT AND THEN THE OTHER
9:51:09PM SINGLE-FAMILY HOUSE.
9:51:10PM AND AS LaCHONE POINTED OUT, IF YOU GO FURTHER NORTH, THERE
9:51:15PM ARE LOTS THAT ARE MUCH, MUCH SMALLER.
9:51:19PM I HAVE A COPY JUST IN CASE THE QUESTION CAME UP REGARDING
9:51:24PM DID SOMEBODY SPLIT THIS OFF OF SOME OTHER PARCEL TO CREATE
9:51:28PM THIS.
9:51:29PM AND THE RESEARCH THAT I CONDUCTED SHOWED THAT NEITHER THAT
9:51:34PM LOT NOR THAT LOT CREATED THIS LOT.
9:51:40PM IT HAS A FOLIO NUMBER.
9:51:42PM IT'S UNPLATTED, BUT IT'S A LOT OF RECORD.
9:51:45PM AND ORIGINALLY THE OWNER TRIED TO GET A PERMIT TO BUILD A
9:51:49PM SINGLE-FAMILY HOUSE AND WAS BASICALLY TOLD YOU DON'T MEET
9:51:52PM THE FRONTAGE.
9:51:53PM YOU MEET THE SQUARE FOOTAGE, BUT YOU DON'T MEET THE
9:51:56PM FRONTAGE.
9:51:56PM SO IF YOU ARE AT 6500 SQUARE FEET INSTEAD OF 5,000, WHICH IS
9:52:00PM REQUIRED UNDER RS 50, YOU'VE EXCEEDED THAT REQUIREMENT BY
9:52:05PM 1500 SQUARE FEET.
9:52:07PM AND YOU'RE MEETING THE SETBACKS.
9:52:09PM LaCHONE POINTED IT OUT, 17 ON ONE SIDE, 6 FEET ON THE
9:52:14PM OTHER, AND 20 ON THE FRONT AND REAR.
9:52:17PM BUT THE 6 FEET IS TO SAVE -- IT'S TO ACCOMMODATE THIS TREE.
9:52:26PM YOU CAN SEE THE RADIUS OF THAT TREE.
9:52:31PM CAN YOU SEE THAT OKAY?
9:52:32PM >> YES.
9:52:33PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: SO TO CREATE A PROTECTIVE RADIUS FOR THE
9:52:39PM TREE, SLID THE HOUSE DOWN TO 6 FEET.
9:52:42PM THE FRONT DOORS WILL FACE CHURCH STREET.
9:52:45PM THE DRIVEWAYS WILL OBVIOUSLY FACE THE STREET.
9:52:50PM SO THERE'S NOT AN ISSUE ABOUT THAT.
9:52:52PM IT WILL MEET ALL OF THE GREENSPACE REQUIREMENTS.
9:52:55PM THE OPEN SPACE AND ALL OF THAT.
9:52:57PM THERE ARE SMALLER LOTS IN THE AREA.
9:53:01PM I WILL SHOW YOU THE TAX DEED THAT INDICATES.
9:53:09PM IT WASN'T SPLIT OFF.
9:53:12PM IT WAS PURCHASED AS A SINGLE LOT.
9:53:16PM SO THEY DIDN'T CREATE THIS HARDSHIP.
9:53:19PM THE ONLY WAY THAT WE CAN ADDRESS THE HARDSHIP, THERE'S NO
9:53:23PM DESIGNATION THAT'S LIKE AN RS 45.
9:53:29PM WE HAVE TO ASK FOR A PD IN ORDER TO ADDRESS THAT ISSUE.
9:53:32PM THERE ARE SINGLE-FAMILY HOUSES IN THE AREA ALL AROUND THEM,
9:53:35PM ON THIS SIDE.
9:53:37PM AS YOU MOVE FURTHER AWAY FROM THAT AND IF YOU MOVE SOUTH,
9:53:44PM YOU'LL HAVE THE COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES THAT ARE DOWN NEAR
9:53:49PM HILLSBOROUGH AND YOU GO FURTHER WEST, YOU HAVE DALE MABRY.
9:53:56PM I THINK JUST IN GENERAL, YOU'RE GOING TO SEE MORE OF THE
9:53:59PM SMALLER LOTS COME IN FOR INFILL, AND I DON'T GENERALLY THINK
9:54:04PM THERE IS A PROBLEM AS LONG AS THEY ARE MEETING THE SETBACKS.
9:54:11PM BASICALLY, THESE REMAINDERS ARE AROUND THERE.
9:54:13PM I DON'T REALLY KNOW HOW IT GOT CREATED, BUT IT'S THERE.
9:54:17PM IT HAS A FOLIO NUMBER.
9:54:19PM WE DON'T HAVE AN ADDRESS YET BECAUSE DIDN'T WANT TO GO TO
9:54:22PM THE EXTENT OF FILING FOR AN ADDRESS IF YOU DEEMED THAT IT
9:54:26PM WAS NOT APPROPRIATE TO DEVELOP.
9:54:27PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION HAS FOUND THAT IT'S CONSISTENT AND
9:54:31PM COMPATIBLE.
9:54:32PM THE STAFF HAS ALREADY POINTED OUT IT'S 12 FEET DEEP BY 46
9:54:37PM FEET WIDE, WHICH IS 6,538 SQUARE FEET.
9:54:41PM THERE IS COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL ALL AROUND THERE.
9:54:47PM IT DOES SEEM LIKE IT'S APPROPRIATE FOR SINGLE-FAMILY
9:54:52PM RESIDENTIAL.
9:54:53PM WE'RE NOT ASKING FOR WAIVERS ON THAT.
9:54:57PM NOT ASKING FOR WAIVERS EXCEPT FOR THE ONES WE POINTED OUT,
9:55:00PM WHICH ARE BASICALLY THE SETBACKS ON ONE SIDE.
9:55:06PM IT IS ECONOMICALLY FEASIBLE TO BUILD A HOUSE THERE.
9:55:09PM IT WILL BE A SMALLER ONE THAT PROBABLY, AGAIN, IS LESS
9:55:14PM EXPENSIVE THAN SOME OF THE OTHER HOMES.
9:55:17PM IT'S IN AN AREA THAT NEEDS HOUSING.
9:55:20PM WE HAVEN'T RECEIVED ANY OBJECTIONS FROM ANYONE.
9:55:24PM WE NOTICED AND VISITED THE SITE.
9:55:28PM IT DOES HAVE A PARK IN THE AREA, WHICH IS AL LOPEZ.
9:55:31PM IT'S ALSO CLOSE TO ST. LAWRENCE SCHOOL.
9:55:37PM IT DOES MEET THE POLICIES AND OBJECTIVES AND THE PLANNING
9:55:40PM COMMISSION FOUND IT TO BE CONSISTENT TO REGULATE THE LEVELS
9:55:44PM OF BUILDING INTENSITY AND PROVIDING HOUSING.
9:55:49PM LAND USES THAT ARE MORE EFFICIENT USE OF PROPERTY AND,
9:55:52PM AGAIN, I THINK YOU'RE GOING TO SEE THAT IN THE FUTURE YOU'RE
9:55:55PM -- THERE'S GOING TO BE MORE OF THESE LITTLE INFILL LOTS.
9:55:59PM AGAIN, IF THEY MEET THE SETBACKS AND YOU'RE DRIVING BY THEM,
9:56:03PM YOU WOULD NOT NOTICE THAT IT WAS A SMALLER LOT NECESSARILY.
9:56:06PM THE GUIDELINES ARE IN THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S REPORT.
9:56:12PM I DON'T WANT TO GO THROUGH ALL OF THEM.
9:56:16PM IT'S GETTING KIND OF LATE.
9:56:17PM OBJECTIVE 9.2, 9.2.1, 9.3, 9.3.8.
9:56:23PM LAND USE OBJECTIVE AND SINGLE-FAMILY AREAS WHICH IS WHAT
9:56:25PM WE'RE PROPOSING, SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL STRUCTURE 9.5,
9:56:30PM 9.5.1, 9.53, NEIGHBORHOOD AND COMMUNITY PLANS, IT'S NOT
9:56:37PM GOING TO DISRUPT ANYTHING IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
9:56:39PM IT'S A SINGLE-FAMILY HOUSE.
9:56:40PM IF IT'S APPROVED, IT'S PLANNED TO BE A COMPATIBLE USE AND
9:56:51PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION HAS FOUND IT TO BE SO.
9:56:55PM WE'RE BELOW THE DENSITY.
9:56:56PM IT'S RESIDENTIAL 10, AND WITH THE SQUARE FOOTAGE PROVIDED IN
9:57:00PM THAT LOT AND THE AREA THAT'S IN NEED OF REDEVELOPMENT, I
9:57:05PM THINK IT QUALIFIES ON THOSE ACCOUNTS FOR COUNCIL'S
9:57:09PM CONSIDERATION TO BE FAVORABLY APPROVED.
9:57:11PM THERE ARE A NUMBER OF POLICIES, LAND USE POLICY 8.14.2.
9:57:19PM LAND USE POLICY 2.12.
9:57:21PM 9.21.
9:57:23PM HOUSING POLICY 1.34.
9:57:27PM LAND USE POLICY 93.8, 95.1, 95.3.
9:57:31PM ALL SUPPORT THIS BEING CONSIDERED.
9:57:36PM AS I SAID, WE'RE RESPECTFULLY REQUESTING YOUR APPROVAL.
9:57:41PM I THINK THAT IT DOES MEET THE INTENT OF THE CODE AND IT DOES
9:57:44PM NOT DISRUPT OR CAUSE ANY HARM TO ANY ADJACENT PROPERTY.
9:57:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE PETITIONER?
9:57:50PM YES, MA'AM.
9:57:51PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: NOT NECESSARILY FOR MR. MICHELINI BECAUSE
9:57:58PM 96% OF THE LOTS IN THIS AREA, 50% OR GREATER.
9:58:03PM SO THAT KIND OF BOTHERS ME, BUT IT IS ONE HOUSE IN THIS
9:58:09PM INSTANCE.
9:58:10PM I WANT TO ASK REALLY MORE SO STAFF THE QUESTION, BECAUSE --
9:58:15PM DO WE HAVE ANY REGULATIONS OR RULES ABOUT THE WIDTH OF A
9:58:18PM HOME ON LOTS THAT MAY NOT BE THE STANDARD, LIKE THIS ONE IS
9:58:26PM 50 FEET -- I MEAN, THE OTHER ONES ARE 50% OR GREATER.
9:58:30PM 96% OF THEM.
9:58:32PM SO IN THIS INSTANCE, IS THERE A WIDTH RESTRICTION?
9:58:35PM DOES IT HAVE TO BE A SMALLER HOUSE IN ORDER FOR IT TO BE ON
9:58:39PM THIS LOT SINCE IT IS A NARROW LOT?
9:58:42PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
9:58:44PM SO WE HAVE BUILDING CODES THAT REQUIRE BUILDING SEPARATION,
9:58:48PM BUT ASIDE FROM THAT, YOU'D HAVE YOUR SETBACKS.
9:58:51PM SO THERE'S NO MINIMUM, AND THIS IS A PD, SO IT DOESN'T HAVE
9:58:57PM -- DOESN'T HAVE SETBACKS ESTABLISHED THROUGH THE PD.
9:59:00PM HE CAN ESTABLISH SETBACKS THROUGH THIS PD.
9:59:04PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: IF I COULD ELABORATE A LITTLE BIT,
9:59:06PM BECAUSE IT IS A SMALLER LOT AND WE'RE AGREEING TO MEET
9:59:09PM BASICALLY THE RS 50 STANDARD SETBACKS, IT WILL BY DEFINITION
9:59:15PM BE A MUCH SMALLER HOME.
9:59:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
9:59:21PM >>BILL CARLSON: I WANT TO ASK STAFF, HE TESTIFIED THAT IT
9:59:27PM HAS A FOLIO NUMBER AND THAT IT APPEARS TO BE ORIGINALLY
9:59:30PM PLATTED THAT WAY.
9:59:32PM IS THERE ANY EVIDENCE FROM THE CITY'S SIDE --
9:59:40PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THIS IS FROM THE PROPERTY APPRAISER'S
9:59:42PM OFFICE THAT SHOWS THE FOLIO NUMBER ON THERE.
9:59:45PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THIS IS CURRENTLY UNPLATTED.
9:59:46PM IT HAS NOT BEEN PLATTED.
9:59:49PM >>BILL CARLSON: DOES A FOLIO NUMBER MEAN THAT WHEN THIS WAS
9:59:52PM ORIGINALLY, THIS NEIGHBORHOOD WAS ORIGINALLY SET UP THAT
9:59:56PM THERE WAS A LOT THAT WAS THAT SIZE?
10:00:02PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LIKELY ON THE FOLIO NUMBER WHEN THE LAST
10:00:05PM EXTENSIONS HAVE A NUMBER TO IT, THEN IT MAY HAVE BEEN
10:00:09PM CREATED LATER AT SOME POINT.
10:00:11PM AND I THINK WHAT STEVE IS REPRESENTING IS THAT IT DOES NOT.
10:00:16PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: I CAN'T FIND ANY EVIDENCE THAT IT WAS
10:00:18PM SPLIT OFF FROM EITHER THE ADJACENT PROPERTY.
10:00:22PM I KNOW FROM PREVIOUS CONVERSATIONS HERE IN FRONT OF COUNCIL
10:00:25PM YOU ALL HAVE BEEN CONCERNED THAT PERHAPS THIS PROPERTY OWNER
10:00:29PM SPLIT IT OFF AND DECIDED TO SELL IT OR THIS PROPERTY DECIDED
10:00:33PM TO SPLIT IT OFF OF HIS AND SELL IT.
10:00:36PM I CAN'T FIND ANY EVIDENCE OF THAT.
10:00:39PM I DO HAVE A TRACK RECORD HERE WITH A TAX DEED THAT SHOWS
10:00:42PM THAT FOR SOME REASON THEY DISCOVERED THAT TAXES WEREN'T
10:00:47PM BEING PAID ON THAT PARTICULAR PARCEL.
10:00:49PM AND THEN IT WAS SOLD TO ONE INDIVIDUAL, NOT TO TWO
10:00:55PM INDIVIDUALS AND THEN RECONVEYED.
10:00:57PM >>BILL CARLSON: NEIGHBORHOODS LIKE DOBYVILLE OR PARTS OF
10:01:00PM YBOR THAT HAD THESE SHOTGUN HOUSES.
10:01:02PM THAT'S WHY I ASKED.
10:01:05PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: I THINK THE CRITICAL ELEMENT HERE IS
10:01:06PM MEETING THE SETBACKS ON THE SIDE AND THE FRONT SO THAT THE
10:01:09PM APPEARANCE WHEN YOU'RE DRIVING BY IS THE SAME AS ANY OTHER
10:01:13PM LARGER LOT.
10:01:20PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: MOVE TO CLOSE.
10:01:22PM >> FOR THE RECORD, THERE ARE NO WAIVERS REQUESTED BECAUSE I
10:01:26PM KNOW THAT WAS MENTIONED EARLIER AND ALSO THERE ARE NO SITE
10:01:29PM PLAN REVISIONS NEEDED.
10:01:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY PUBLIC COMMENT?
10:01:33PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WISH TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, ITEM
10:01:36PM NUMBER 9?
10:01:36PM SEEING NONE, NOBODY ONLINE.
10:01:38PM MAY I GET A MOTION TO CLOSE?
10:01:39PM MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA, SECOND FROM
10:01:43PM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
10:01:44PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:01:45PM AYE.
10:01:47PM >>BILL CARLSON: I MOVE FILE NUMBER REZ-23-65, ORDINANCE
10:01:54PM BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, ORDINANCE
10:01:58PM REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF FOLIO NUMBER
10:02:00PM 102910-0000 IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, MORE PARTICULARLY
10:02:07PM DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1 FROM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION
10:02:10PM RS 50 RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY TO PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT,
10:02:13PM RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
10:02:15PM DATE.
10:02:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
10:02:17PM CARLSON, SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
10:02:19PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
10:02:24PM >>THE CLERK: HURTAK?
10:02:25PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I WANT TO EXPLAIN MY VOTE.
10:02:27PM I THINK THIS IS -- I DID HAVE MY MIKE TURNED OFF.
10:02:32PM IT WANTS TO GO TO BED, TOO.
10:02:34PM THIS IS A WEIRD LOT AND I ASKED ALL THE SAME QUESTIONS, IF
10:02:39PM IT HAD BEEN SPLIT, AND IT'S 47 FEET.
10:02:42PM IT'S NOT SOMETHING WE WOULD APPROVE AT ANY POINT IN THE
10:02:46PM HISTORY OF THE CITY, SO THESE LITTLE LOTS, I AGREE WITH YOU,
10:02:50PM WILL BE COMING UP.
10:02:51PM AND TO DO THE BEST WE CAN WITH THEM, HOUSING IN A
10:02:55PM NEIGHBORHOOD IS BEST USE.
10:02:57PM I WILL SAY YES.
10:03:00PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I FEEL LIKE I HAVE TO EXPLAIN, TOO,
10:03:02PM BECAUSE IT IS A PD AND EVERYBODY KNOWS MY POSITION ON PDs
10:03:06PM AS PREVIOUSLY DESCRIBED, I THINK YOUR CLIENT DID A GREAT JOB
10:03:09PM OF ACCOMMODATING THE BEST USE OF THIS PROPERTY WITH A VERY
10:03:12PM MODEST SIZE BUILDING ON NICE SIZE LOT.
10:03:17PM THE LOT IS BIG.
10:03:20PM SAVING THE GRAND TREE, GIVING PLENTY OF ROOM WITH SLIGHT
10:03:22PM SETBACK REDUCTION FROM NORMAL, EUCLIDEAN KIND OF ZONING I
10:03:26PM THINK WAS ABOVE AND BEYOND.
10:03:27PM AGAIN, I THINK WE'RE GOING TO HAVE THESE, YOU'RE RIGHT.
10:03:32PM THERE ARE AREAS IN TOWN THAT HAVE THESE TYPES OF LOTS THAT
10:03:35PM WE'LL HAVE TO DEAL WITH.
10:03:37PM I'M GOING TO VOTE YES, EVEN THOUGH IT IS A PD, I'M GOING TO
10:03:41PM VOTE YES.
10:03:43PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
10:03:44PM I'M GOING TO VOTE YES AS WELL.
10:03:46PM I LIKE THE FACT THAT THERE'S JUST ONE HOUSE ON THIS LOT.
10:03:54PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES, WITHOUT ANY COMMENT.
10:03:56PM [ LAUGHTER ]
10:04:03PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
10:04:06PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
10:04:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
10:04:11PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
10:04:13PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER 7th,
10:04:17PM 2023, AT 9:30 A.M. AT THE OLD CITY HALL BUILDING LOCATED AT
10:04:22PM 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA.
10:04:27PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
10:04:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANKS.
10:04:29PM TWO MORE LEFT.
10:04:33PM LET'S DRAG THEM OUT.
10:04:40PM >>ZAIN HUSAIN: ZAIN HUSAIN, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:04:43PM ITEM 10, REZ-23-77, THIS IS A REQUEST TO REZONE THE LOCATION
10:04:48PM OF 3917 NORTH NEBRASKA AVENUE, PROPOSED REZONING FROM PD TO
10:04:54PM CG.
10:04:54PM I'LL NOW PASS ALONG TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
10:05:10PM >>EMILY PHELAN: THE SUBJECT SITE IS -- EMILY PHELAN,
10:05:13PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
10:05:14PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE CENTRAL TAMPA
10:05:17PM PLANNING DISTRICT.
10:05:18PM THE EAST TAMPA URBAN VILLAGE AND THE YBOR HEIGHTS
10:05:21PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
10:05:22PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE LOCATED HERE AT THE INTERSECTION OF
10:05:26PM EAST DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. BOULEVARD AND NORTH NEBRASKA
10:05:29PM AVENUE.
10:05:30PM THE SURROUNDING AREA HAS MOSTLY COMMERCIAL USES ALONG
10:05:34PM NEBRASKA AND MARTIN LUTHER KING WHICH WOULD BE THE NORTH,
10:05:40PM SOUTH AND WEST.
10:05:41PM TO THE EAST THERE ARE SINGLE-FAMILY USES AS WELL.
10:05:45PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS, AGAIN, HERE, IT HAS TWO FUTURE LAND
10:05:52PM USES ON THIS SITE.
10:05:54PM THE PINK IS THE CMU 35 AND THE RED IS THE COMMUNITY
10:05:59PM COMMERCIAL 35 DESIGNATION.
10:06:01PM THEY ARE THE PRIMARY DESIGNATIONS ALONG BOTH MARTIN LUTHER
10:06:04PM KING AND NEBRASKA AVENUE.
10:06:06PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PROMOTES PEDESTRIAN SAFETY AND
10:06:14PM ENCOURAGES COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT THAT ENHANCES THE CITY OF
10:06:15PM TAMPA'S CHARACTER AND AMBIENCE.
10:06:18PM IN DOING SO, LAND USE POLICY 15.2.6 REQUIRES NEW COMMERCIAL
10:06:22PM DEVELOPMENT TO CONNECT BUILDING ENTRANCES TO PUBLIC
10:06:24PM RIGHTS-OF-WAY AND TO PROVIDE SIDEWALKS IN AREAS WHERE IT IS
10:06:27PM PRACTICAL AND FEASIBLE FOR PEDESTRIAN-ORIENTED ACTIVITIES.
10:06:30PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS ALSO WITHIN A MIXED-USE CORRIDOR AT THE
10:06:34PM INTERSECTION OF TWO TRANSIT EMPHASIS CORRIDORS AND WITHIN
10:06:37PM THE EAST TAMPA URBAN VILLAGE AS DEFINED BY THE COMPREHENSIVE
10:06:40PM PLAN.
10:06:41PM ANY FUTURE DEVELOPMENT SHOULD BE CONSISTENT WITH THE POLICY
10:06:44PM DIRECTION FOR THE CITY OVERALL AS WELL AS THE SPECIFIC
10:06:46PM AREAS.
10:06:47PM DUE TO THE LOCATION OF THE SITE AT THE CORNER OF TWO
10:06:47PM ARTERIAL ROADWAYS, THE PROPOSED CG ZONING DISTRICT WOULD BE
10:06:56PM APPROPRIATE FOR THIS SITE, PROVIDED THAT ANY POTENTIAL
10:06:58PM NONRESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT IS SENSITIVE TO THE EXISTING
10:07:01PM RESIDENTS ABUTTING THE SUBJECT SITE.
10:07:04PM THE PROPOSED REZONING IS COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE AND
10:07:06PM CONSISTENT WITH THIS CMU 35 AND THE CT 35 FUTURE LAND USE
10:07:11PM DESIGNATIONS.
10:07:12PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
10:07:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
10:07:22PM >>ZAIN HUSAIN: I'LL FIRST SHOW THE AERIAL VIEW OF THE
10:07:25PM PROPERTY OR THE LOT.
10:07:28PM AS YOU SEE, THE PROPERTY RIGHT HERE OUTLINED IN RED
10:07:38PM CURRENTLY ZONED PD, TO THE NORTH, YOU HAVE LOT ZONED CHCG,
10:07:44PM THAT'S COMMERCIAL STORE WAREHOUSE AND A CHURCH THERE.
10:07:48PM TO THE SOUTH YOU HAVE PD AND THAT IS A BANK, AS I'LL SHOW
10:07:52PM YOU IN PICTURES TO COME.
10:07:53PM TO THE WEST, YOU HAVE A GAS STATION AND A SUPERMARKET ZONED
10:07:57PM CG AND PD, WHICH I'LL SHOW YOU IN PICTURES TO COME AND TO
10:08:01PM THE EAST YOU HAVE RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ZONED RS 50 AND
10:08:07PM CG.
10:08:08PM THE LOT IS 1.94 ACRES.
10:08:12PM THE MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT IS 45 FEET IN HEIGHT.
10:08:15PM THE EXISTING USE IS A VACANT STRUCTURE ON THE SITE AND WHEN
10:08:21PM I SHOW YOU THE PICTURE, YOU CAN GUESS WHERE IT IS, WHAT IT
10:08:25PM IS.
10:08:25PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED AT THE SOUTHEAST INTERSECTION OF
10:08:30PM NORTH NEBRASKA AND EAST DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING BOULEVARD.
10:08:35PM I'LL SHOW YOU THE PICTURE OF WHEN I WENT OUT THERE.
10:08:49PM PHARMACY.
10:09:02PM AND THE REAR OF THE STRUCTURE.
10:09:12PM TO THE SOUTH YOU HAVE THE BANK I SPOKE OF.
10:09:22PM TO THE WEST YOU HAVE A SUPERMARKET.
10:09:34PM I'M SURE BY THE COLORS YOU CAN GUESS WHICH ONE IT IS.
10:09:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I LIKE HOW YOU DON'T SAY THE NAMES OF
10:09:40PM THESE PLACES.
10:09:42PM >>ZAIN HUSAIN: WINN DIXIE.
10:09:44PM IT'S 10:09, ALL RIGHT.
10:09:50PM THE INTERSECTION OF EAST DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. AND
10:09:55PM NORTH NEBRASKA AND ACROSS THE STREET IS A BP GAS STATION.
10:10:01PM DEVELOPMENT REVIEW AND COMPLIANCE STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE
10:10:04PM APPLICATION AND FINDS THE OVERALL REQUEST TO BE CONSISTENT
10:10:07PM WITH THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
10:10:09PM I'M HERE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
10:10:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
10:10:11PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:10:14PM YES, MA'AM.
10:10:38PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
10:10:40PM ALEX SCHALER, 400 NORTH ASHLEY DRIVE.
10:10:42PM AS TRUETT MENTIONED EARLIER, WE GET THE VERY RARE
10:10:45PM OPPORTUNITY TO BRING EUCLIDEAN REZONINGS BEFORE YOU.
10:10:48PM WHEN WE DO WE ALWAYS GET EXCITED AND I PROMISE THIS WILL BE
10:10:51PM A BIT QUICKER THAN TRUETT'S.
10:10:53PM I'LL SKIP OVER THE LOCATION INFORMATION SINCE ZAIN ALREADY
10:10:56PM ORIENTED US ON WHERE THE SITE IS LOCATED.
10:11:00PM I WANT TO JUMP INTO THE ZONING HISTORY.
10:11:01PM THIS SITE IS CURRENTLY ZONED PD, BUT PRIOR TO 2000 IT WAS
10:11:04PM SPLIT ZONED CG AND RS 50.
10:11:07PM IN 2000 THE PD WAS BORN WITH THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE
10:11:09PM WALGREENS AND THEN OUR PROPOSAL BEFORE YOU TONIGHT IS CG.
10:11:12PM I NOTE THIS JUST TO TELL YOU THERE WAS PRECEDENT FOR
10:11:16PM EUCLIDEAN ZONED CG ON THIS SITE.
10:11:19PM THIS IS THE PRIOR SITE PLAN SHOWING THE WALGREENS BUILDING.
10:11:22PM WHILE OUR CLIENT INTENDS TO KEEP THIS AS COMMERCIAL
10:11:25PM DEVELOPMENT, WE WANT THE FLEXIBILITY TO PROVIDE A DIFFERENT
10:11:27PM RANGE OF USES IN THE COMMERCIAL ZONING DISTRICT AND DON'T
10:11:30PM NECESSARILY WANT TO BE LOCKED IN TO A SPECIFIC PHARMACY USE
10:11:33PM AS THIS PD PRESCRIBES.
10:11:35PM SO STAFF FULLY SUPPORTS THE APPLICATION AS ZAIN MENTIONED
10:11:39PM PREVIOUSLY AND I WANTED TO NOTE THAT OUR CLIENT DID MEET
10:11:42PM WITH THE YBOR HEIGHTS NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION.
10:11:46PM THEY OFFERED TO HELP IN ANY WAY THEY CAN.
10:11:48PM THEY ARE EAGER TO SEE THIS BEING REDEVELOPED AND THEY ARE
10:11:50PM PLANNING ON ORGANIZING THEIR QUARTERLY NEIGHBORHOOD
10:11:53PM RESIDENTS MEET AND GREET IN OUR PARKING LOT TO GET SOME MORE
10:11:57PM EYES ON THE PROPERTY TO HELP COME UP WITH A FUTURE VISION
10:12:00PM FOR SOME COMMERCIAL HERE.
10:12:01PM WITH THAT, I WILL CLOSE.
10:12:02PM I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MIGHT HAVE.
10:12:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I LIKE HOW THAT SITE PLAN SAID BUFFALO
10:12:07PM AVENUE AT THE TOP.
10:12:09PM YOU WEREN'T EVEN BORN PROBABLY.
10:12:10PM >> PROBABLY NOT.
10:12:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: USED TO BE BUFFALO AVENUE.
10:12:16PM ANY QUESTIONS?
10:12:17PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: JUST TO COMMENT, I'M EXCITED TO SEE WHAT
10:12:21PM WILL HAPPEN.
10:12:21PM WE WERE SAD WHEN WALGREENS DECIDED TO LEAVE THE COMMUNITY,
10:12:26PM BUT HOPEFULLY IT WILL BE SOMETHING BIGGER, BETTER AND
10:12:28PM GREATER THAT DEFINITELY BENEFITS THE COMMUNITY.
10:12:31PM SO LOOKING FORWARD TO IT.
10:12:33PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
10:12:34PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WISHING TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM?
10:12:37PM ITEM NUMBER 10?
10:12:38PM NO.
10:12:39PM ANYBODY ONLINE?
10:12:40PM NO.
10:12:41PM MOTION TO CLOSE?
10:12:42PM MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:12:44PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN HENDERSON.
10:12:47PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:12:48PM ANY OPPOSED?
10:12:48PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:12:50PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: NUMBER 10, REZ-23-77, ORDINANCE BEING
10:12:56PM PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE
10:12:58PM REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 3917 NORTH
10:13:01PM NEBRASKA AVENUE, IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA AND MORE
10:13:04PM PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1 FROM ZONING DISTRICT
10:13:06PM CLASSIFICATION PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT TO CG COMMERCIAL
10:13:09PM GENERAL, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
10:13:11PM EVERYTHING IS FINE.
10:13:25PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:13:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
10:13:27PM MIRANDA.
10:13:27PM A SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
10:13:32PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
10:13:33PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
10:13:33PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
10:13:34PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
10:13:37PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
10:13:38PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
10:13:40PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
10:13:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
10:13:42PM >>THE CLERK: THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
10:13:45PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER 7,
10:13:49PM 2023, AT 9:30 A.M. AT THE OLD CITY HALL BUILDING LOCATED AT
10:13:54PM 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA FLORIDA.
10:14:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD, SIR.
10:14:03PM >>ZAIN HUSAIN: ZAIN HUSAIN, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION, CASE
10:14:06PM REZ-23-79, AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 11.
10:14:09PM REQUEST TO REZONE AT THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 3119 WEST
10:14:14PM SAN PEDRO STREET.
10:14:15PM PROPOSED REZONING FROM RM 16 TO RM 18.
10:14:19PM I'LL PASS IT ALONG TO EMILY WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
10:14:32PM >>EMILY PHELAN: EMILY PHELAN, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
10:14:35PM SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING
10:14:37PM DISTRICT IN THE PALMA CEIA NEIGHBORHOOD.
10:14:41PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED HERE AND THE AREA SURROUNDING
10:14:46PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS PRIMARILY RESIDENTIAL IN NATURE.
10:14:51PM THERE ARE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED, TWO FAMILY AND MULTIFAMILY
10:14:55PM RESIDENTIAL USES.
10:14:58PM TWO BLOCKS SOUTH OF NORTH BAY TO BAY BOULEVARD.
10:15:04PM CORRIDOR WHICH CONTAINS LIGHT COMMERCIAL AND NONRESIDENTIAL
10:15:07PM USES.
10:15:08PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS HERE REPRESENTED BY THE RESIDENTIAL 20
10:15:14PM FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
10:15:16PM IT IS THE PRIMARY FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION IN THE AREA
10:15:19PM WITH POCKETS OF RESIDENTIAL 10.
10:15:22PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REVIEWED THE APPLICATION AND FOUND
10:15:25PM NO ADVERSE IMPACTS ON THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD AND THE
10:15:28PM REQUEST WILL ALLOW FOR COMPATIBLE INFILL DEVELOPMENT IN AN
10:15:32PM AREA PLANNED FOR 18 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE, AREA PLANNED
10:15:41PM FOR 20 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE CONSISTENT WITH LAND USE
10:15:44PM POLICIES 2.1.2 AND 8.14.1.
10:15:48PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REVIEWED LOT WIDTHS ALONG THIS
10:15:51PM SEGMENT OF WEST SAN PEDRO AVENUE.
10:15:54PM LOT WIDTHS VARIED FROM APPROXIMATELY 35 TO 90 FEET.
10:15:57PM THE LOT WIDTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE IS 150 FEET PER THE
10:16:00PM SUBMITTED SURVEY.
10:16:01PM TAKING INTO CONSIDERATION THE EXISTING BLOCK DENSITY AND
10:16:05PM RANGE OF LOT WIDTHS AMONG THIS SEGMENT OF WEST SAN PEDRO
10:16:09PM AVENUE, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDS THAT THE REQUEST
10:16:11PM WILL PROVIDE FOR RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT THAT WILL BE BUILT
10:16:14PM WITHIN THE EXISTING STREET BLOCK AND LOT CONFIGURATION OF
10:16:18PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
10:16:18PM THE PROPOSED REZONING SUPPORTS MANY POLICIES IN THE
10:16:21PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AS IT RELATES TO HOUSING THE CITY'S
10:16:24PM POPULATION.
10:16:24PM THE PLAN ENCOURAGES NEW HOUSING ON VACANT AND UNDERUTILIZED
10:16:28PM LAND TO ENSURE AN ADEQUATE SUPPLY OF HOUSING IS AVAILABLE TO
10:16:31PM MEET THE NEEDS OF TAMPA'S PRESENT AND FUTURE POPULATIONS.
10:16:34PM THE PROPOSED RM 18 ZONING WOULD ALLOW FOR DEVELOPMENT THAT
10:16:37PM IS COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH THE CHARACTER OF THE
10:16:41PM SURROUNDING USES AND IS CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT
10:16:44PM PATTERN ANTICIPATED UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL 20 FUTURE LAND USE
10:16:48PM DESIGNATION.
10:16:49PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
10:16:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
10:16:52PM NO.
10:16:53PM MR. HUSAIN.
10:16:55PM >>ZAIN HUSAIN: ZAIN HUSAIN, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:16:57PM I'LL SHOW THE AERIAL VIEW OF THE PROPERTY FIRST.
10:17:01PM AS YOU SEE, THE PROPERTY RIGHT HERE OUTLINED IN RED, TO THE
10:17:11PM NORTH IS ZONED RM 16 AND RS 50.
10:17:14PM THAT'S RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY, TO THE SOUTH RS 50,
10:17:18PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY.
10:17:19PM TO THE WEST, YOU'LL HAVE RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY AND TO THE
10:17:23PM EAST YOU'LL HAVE VACANT LAND AND ALSO YOU'LL HAVE THE
10:17:28PM INTERSTATE RUNNING NORTH AND SOUTH TO THE EAST.
10:17:31PM THE LOT AREA IS 15,000 SQUARE FEET.
10:17:37PM THE BUILDING HEIGHT IS AT MAXIMUM OF 35 FEET IN HEIGHT.
10:17:42PM THE EXISTING USE IS A RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY.
10:17:46PM THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT NORTHEAST INTERSECTION OF
10:17:50PM SOUTH ESPERANZA AVENUE AND WEST SAN PEDRO STREET.
10:17:59PM I WILL SHOW YOU WHAT I SAW WHEN I WENT ON-SITE.
10:18:02PM AS YOU SEE THE CURRENT SINGLE-FAMILY HOME ON THE SITE.
10:18:22PM ALSO ANOTHER VIEW OF THE SITE.
10:18:31PM TO THE WEST.
10:18:40PM ALSO DOWN TO THE WEST YOU HAVE RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY AND
10:18:43PM RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY.
10:18:47PM AND DIRECTLY TO THE SOUTH YOU HAVE RESIDENTIAL
10:18:50PM SINGLE-FAMILY.
10:18:51PM DEVELOPMENT REVIEW AND COMPLIANCE STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE
10:18:55PM APPLICATION AND FINDS THE REQUEST TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE
10:18:58PM LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
10:18:59PM I'M HERE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
10:19:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
10:19:02PM NO.
10:19:03PM MR. MICHELINI.
10:19:10PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: STEVE MICHELINI.
10:19:17PM I'VE BEEN SWORN.
10:19:18PM THIS IS A EUCLIDEAN ZONING, RM 16 TO RM 18.
10:19:22PM WE CANNOT ASK FOR WAIVERS UNDER THOSE EUCLIDEAN
10:19:27PM DESIGNATIONS.
10:19:28PM THERE'S MULTIFAMILY ALL AROUND.
10:19:29PM THE STAFF HAS ALREADY INDICATED AND I WOULD JUST HAVE THEIR
10:19:32PM REPORTS BE INCLUDED AS REFERENCE AS BEING CONSISTENT AND
10:19:38PM COMPATIBLE.
10:19:39PM I'LL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
10:19:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
10:19:42PM VERY GOOD.
10:19:43PM ANYBODY FROM THE PUBLIC?
10:19:44PM NO.
10:19:46PM MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
10:19:49PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:19:51PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:19:51PM AYE.
10:19:52PM ANY OPPOSED?
10:19:52PM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA, THIS IS THE LAST ONE.
10:20:05PM >>LUIS VIERA: AN ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING
10:20:09PM CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL
10:20:12PM VICINITY OF 3119 WEST SAN PEDRO STREET, IN THE CITY OF
10:20:16PM TAMPA, FLORIDA AND MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1
10:20:18PM FROM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION RM 16 RESIDENTIAL
10:20:20PM MULTIFAMILY, TO RM 18 RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY PROVIDING AN
10:20:23PM EFFECTIVE DATE.
10:20:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
10:20:25PM WE HAVE A SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
10:20:28PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
10:20:30PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
10:20:31PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
10:20:33PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
10:20:35PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
10:20:37PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
10:20:38PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
10:20:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
10:20:41PM >>THE CLERK: THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
10:20:44PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER 7,
10:20:49PM 2023, AT 9:30 A.M. LOCATED AT 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD,
10:20:56PM THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA.
10:20:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:20:59PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
10:21:00PM THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO SPEND THE EVENING WITH YOU.
10:21:02PM [ LAUGHTER ]
10:21:05PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: LET'S NOT DO THIS AGAIN REAL SOON.
10:21:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: OH, JUST WAIT.
10:21:09PM JUST WAIT.
10:21:09PM BEFORE WE GO TO NEW BUSINESS, JUST A PERSONAL REQUEST, IF
10:21:13PM YOU LOOK AT THE AUGUST 31st DATE, WE HAVE A CITY COUNCIL
10:21:20PM WORKSHOP SESSION AND WE ALSO HAVE A CITY COUNCIL EVENING
10:21:22PM SESSION, THEY ARE BOTH GOING TO BE VERY BUSY.
10:21:26PM SO THE WORKSHOP HAS A LOT OF ITEMS, AND I'M NOT ASKING YOU
10:21:30PM TO DO ANYTHING THIS EVENING, BUT ASKING COUNCIL MEMBERS TO
10:21:33PM LOOK AT WHAT'S GOING TO BE ON THE COUNCIL WORKSHOP AND IF
10:21:35PM THERE'S ANYTHING THAT YOU SEE THAT COULD BE CONTINUED THAT
10:21:39PM IS NOT ABSOLUTELY PRESSING, JUST FOR THE SAKE OF TIME,
10:21:43PM BECAUSE WE ARE GOING TO BE HERE DAY AND NIGHT.
10:21:46PM I KNOW THAT THAT EVENING IS GOING TO BE VERY, VERY BUSY ON
10:21:49PM TOP OF THE DAY.
10:21:50PM YOU SAW HOW TODAY WENT.
10:21:52PM NOT ASKING YOU TO DO ANYTHING TODAY, BUT BETWEEN NOW AND
10:21:55PM NEXT THURSDAY, WHICH IS A REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING, IF YOU
10:21:58PM WOULD TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION ANYTHING THAT IS NOT
10:22:01PM ABSOLUTELY PRESSING THAT WE COULD PERHAPS CONTINUE.
10:22:04PM THAT'S MY REQUEST.
10:22:06PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: DOES IT HELP IF I SAY PLEASE?
10:22:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU DON'T HAVE TO DO ANYTHING TONIGHT.
10:22:13PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IN THAT, MAYBE WE SHOULD DO WORKSHOPS ON
10:22:17PM DIFFERENT DAYS.
10:22:18PM I'LL JUST THROW IT OUT THERE.
10:22:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THAT COULD WORK BECAUSE NIGHT MEETING
10:22:21PM AND WORKSHOP, WE ARE EXHAUSTED AND WE HAVE TO STAY FOCUSED.
10:22:25PM >>LYNN HURTAK: AND THE CRA.
10:22:26PM WE MAY JUST HAVE TO DO SOMETHING BECAUSE WE CAN'T KEEP DOING
10:22:29PM THIS.
10:22:31PM IT'S ONLY 10:30.
10:22:32PM LIKE REALISTICALLY --
10:22:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: TODAY WAS A VERY TOUGH DAY.
10:22:36PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IF WE STARTED AT 5, IT WOULD BE 10:30, BUT
10:22:40PM NOW IT'S HORRIFIC.
10:22:42PM I AGREE WITH YOU.
10:22:43PM I WILL LOOK AT TRYING TO CHANGE THE DATES.
10:22:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE'LL TALK ABOUT IT NEXT THURSDAY IF WE
10:22:49PM HAVE ANY IDEAS OR ANY CONSIDERATION.
10:22:52PM COUNCILMAN CARLSON, DO YOU HAVE ANY NEW BUSINESS?
10:22:55PM >>BILL CARLSON: QUICKLY.
10:22:56PM I HAD A REQUEST FROM A LOT OF PEOPLE IN THE COMMUNITY TO ASK
10:22:58PM THE ADMINISTRATION FOR JUST A CHART THAT SHOWS WHAT THE TAX
10:23:02PM PROPOSALS ARE FOR OTHER CITIES, SO I'D LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION
10:23:05PM TO ASK STAFF TO CREATE JUST A CHART OF THE TAX PROPOSAL FOR
10:23:12PM SURROUNDING CITIES AND COUNTIES AND OUR PEER CITIES IN THE
10:23:16PM STATE TO -- GIVEN TO US AS A WRITTEN REPORT SOMETIME BEFORE
10:23:21PM SEPTEMBER 5th.
10:23:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SOMETIME BEFORE WHAT?
10:23:25PM SEPTEMBER 5th.
10:23:26PM >>LUIS VIERA: I'LL SECOND THAT.
10:23:28PM MAY I ADD A FRIENDLY AMENDMENT?
10:23:30PM I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO SEE -- AND NOT TO ADD TO YOUR MOTION,
10:23:34PM THOUGH, I GUESS I AM, WHAT THE HISTORY OF MILLAGE INCREASES
10:23:39PM IS PERCENTAGE-WISE OVER THE LAST 50 YEARS, JUST SO THAT WE
10:23:45PM KNOW THAT AS WELL.
10:23:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THIS WOULD BE THE THIRD PROPOSAL.
10:23:53PM >>LUIS VIERA: I MEAN IN TERMS OF JUST THE -- YOU KNOW WHAT,
10:23:56PM COUNCILMAN, FORGET IT.
10:23:57PM DISREGARD.
10:23:58PM IT'S LATE.
10:23:59PM NO, I CAN GET IT ON MY OWN.
10:24:02PM >>BILL CARLSON: WHAT I'M ASKING FOR SPECIFICALLY IS JUST TO
10:24:04PM LOOK AT WHETHER THEY ARE PROPOSING RAISING IT, REDUCING IT
10:24:07PM OR KEEPING THE MILLAGE THE SAME.
10:24:09PM AND ALSO PEER CITIES IN FLORIDA.
10:24:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MY KNOWLEDGE, PLANT CITY IS STAYING THE
10:24:19PM SAME.
10:24:20PM ST. PETE IS PROPOSING A MILLAGE DECREASE BUT THEY HAVE PENNY
10:24:22PM FOR PINELLAS.
10:24:24PM DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
10:24:27PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:24:29PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:24:29PM AYE.
10:24:30PM ANYTHING ELSE, SIR?
10:24:31PM YES, MA'AM, HURTAK.
10:24:33PM YES, SIR.
10:24:35PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I HAVE A LONGER LIST.
10:24:36PM ONE OF THEM IS MINE.
10:24:37PM I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION FOR STAFF TO RESEARCH
10:24:40PM ORLANDO'S PROHIBITION OF AISLE-STYLE DEVELOPMENTS AND DRAFT
10:24:44PM A PROPOSED ORDINANCE TO BE PRESENTED TO CITY COUNCIL ON
10:24:47PM DECEMBER 14th.
10:24:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: 2023.
10:24:51PM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA WITH THE SECOND.
10:24:52PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:24:57PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: LAND USE THAT EVENING.
10:24:59PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WE WOULD NEED TO DO THAT DURING REGULAR
10:25:02PM SESSION.
10:25:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DECEMBER 21st OR DECEMBER 7.
10:25:06PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: DECEMBER 7.
10:25:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DECEMBER 7.
10:25:08PM SECOND STILL GOOD?
10:25:09PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:25:09PM ANY OPPOSED?
10:25:11PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I HAVE ADMINISTRATIVE MOTIONS TO BE MADE.
10:25:14PM I MOVE TO REQUEST THE PLANNING COMMISSION, I MAKE THE MOTION
10:25:20PM TO SET A TRANSMITTAL HEARING FOR TA/CPA 2317 AND TA/CPA 2318
10:25:24PM ON NOVEMBER 30, 2023, AT 5:01 P.M. AND DIRECT THE LEGAL
10:25:29PM DEPARTMENT TO PROVIDE THE CITY CLERK WITH THE FORM OF NOTICE
10:25:33PM FOR ADVERTISING THE PUBLIC HEARINGS.
10:25:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
10:25:36PM CLENDENIN.
10:25:37PM SECOND BY COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
10:25:38PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:25:39PM AYE.
10:25:40PM ANY OPPOSED?
10:25:40PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I MAKE A MOTION TO SET AN ADOPTION HEARING
10:25:42PM FOR TA/CPA 2319 ON NOVEMBER 30th, 2023, AT 5:01 P.M. AND
10:25:48PM DIRECT THE LEGAL DEPARTMENT TO PROVIDE THE CITY CLERK WITH
10:25:50PM THE FORM OF NOTICE FOR ADVERTISING IN THE PUBLIC HEARINGS.
10:25:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN
10:25:55PM CLENDENIN, SECOND BY COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
10:25:57PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:25:57PM AYE.
10:25:58PM ANY OPPOSED?
10:25:59PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I MAKE A MOTION TO SET AN ADOPTION HEARING
10:26:01PM FOR TA/CPA 2317 AND TA/CPA 2318 ON FEBRUARY 22, 2024,
10:26:08PM 5:01 P.M. AND DIRECT THE LEGAL DEPARTMENT TO PROVIDE THE
10:26:11PM CITY CLERK WITH THE FORM OF NOTICE FOR ADVERTISING THE
10:26:13PM PUBLIC HEARING.
10:26:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION BY COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN, SECOND
10:26:16PM BY COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
10:26:18PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:26:19PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: LAST, I MAKE A MOTION FOR THE PLANNING
10:26:21PM COMMISSION TO APPEAR AND PRESENT BEFORE CITY COUNCIL WITH AN
10:26:23PM UPDATE ON THE FUTURE LAND USE ASSESSMENT FOR THE TAMPA
10:26:26PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DURING THE CITY COUNCIL WORKSHOP ON
10:26:29PM SEPTEMBER 28.
10:26:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
10:26:31PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
10:26:32PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:26:33PM AYE.
10:26:34PM ANY OPPOSED?
10:26:40PM >>BILL CARLSON: ONE SUGGESTION.
10:26:41PM YOU TALKED A LOT ABOUT PDs TODAY.
10:26:43PM CAN YOU TALK TO STAFF AND MAKE A MOTION SOME OTHER TIME
10:26:47PM ABOUT IT, PLEASE?
10:26:48PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SUPPOSEDLY IT'S COMING UP IN A WORKSHOP.
10:26:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I THINK IT IS THE SEPTEMBER WORKSHOP.
10:26:52PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: BECAUSE I MADE THAT MOTION A MONTH AGO OR
10:26:55PM SO.
10:26:56PM I'M DONE.
10:27:02PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: CHAIR, I HAVE NOTHING.
10:27:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THAT'S WONDERFUL.
10:27:04PM COUNCILMAN VIERA WILL FILL THAT IN.
10:27:06PM >>LUIS VIERA: A COUPLE OF REAL FAST, A LOT OF YOU ALL KNOW
10:27:11PM DISTRICT CHIEF KEN HUFF WITH TAMPA FIRE RESCUE, TONIGHT,
10:27:14PM 6:30 A.M., HE WILL BE ENDING HIS CAREER WITH TAMPA FIRE
10:27:18PM RESCUE.
10:27:18PM I WANTED TO GIVE HIM A COMMENDATION.
10:27:20PM I MAY DO IT LATER AT CITY COUNCIL OR NOT.
10:27:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION BY COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:27:24PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:27:26PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:27:27PM ANY OPPOSED?
10:27:28PM >>LUIS VIERA: SEPTEMBER 7 I WAS THE UPTOWN PRESENTATION.
10:27:31PM I WANT TO TAKE THAT OFF THE AGENDA AND I'LL BRING IT BACK
10:27:34PM ANOTHER TIME.
10:27:34PM THERE IS A CONFLICT.
10:27:35PM REMOVE THAT FROM THE AGENDA WHICH HELPS US ALL.
10:27:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SEPTEMBER 7.
10:27:40PM MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:27:41PM SECOND COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:27:43PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:27:44PM >>LUIS VIERA: THIRD, IF I MAY, WE HAVE FUNDED A JOB TRAINING
10:27:48PM AND APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAM FOR RETURNING CITIZENS WHICH I
10:27:51PM BELIEVE BETWEEN THE CITY AND THE COUNTY I'VE BEEN WORKING ON
10:27:53PM THIS WITH GWEN, COMMISSIONER GWEN MYERS IS GOING TO BE ABOUT
10:27:57PM HALF A MILLION DOLLARS FOR RETURNING CITIZENS TRAINING AND I
10:28:00PM WANT THAT TO COME BEFORE CITY COUNCIL FOR A PRESENTATION SO
10:28:03PM WE CAN LEARN ABOUT THIS PROGRAM ON NOVEMBER 2nd.
10:28:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GREAT.
10:28:07PM COUNCILMAN VIERA WITH THE MOTION, ASK HE HAD FROM COUNCIL
10:28:09PM MEMBER MIRANDA.
10:28:09PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:28:10PM ANY OPPOSED.
10:28:11PM >>LUIS VIERA: LASTLY, THE VETERANS TREATMENT COURT, MANY OF
10:28:14PM YOU ALL KNOW THEM, COLONEL DJ REYES, COLONEL JIM FLETCHER,
10:28:20PM AND COLONEL KEITH POYNOR, STEPHANIE'S HUSBAND.
10:28:25PM HE IS A SENIOR MENTOR THERE.
10:28:26PM THEY ARE CELEBRATING TEN YEARS OF THE VETERANS TREATMENT
10:28:26PM COURT IN THE 13TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT.
10:28:26PM I WANTED THEM TO COME TO TAMPA CITY COUNCIL.
10:28:27PM I FOUND TWO DAYS THAT COULD BE PARTICULAR.
10:28:30PM OCTOBER 19 OR SEPTEMBER 28, WHICH -- OCTOBER 19.
10:28:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:28:39PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:28:40PM ANY OPPOSED?
10:28:41PM >>LUIS VIERA: THAT'S IT.
10:28:43PM THANK YOU.
10:28:43PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I HAVE ONE.
10:28:44PM RECEIVE AND FILE.
10:28:46PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
10:28:53PM I'LL BRING IT UP LATER.
10:28:54PM IT'S NOT PRESSING.
10:28:55PM WE ARE ADJOURNED.
10:28:57PM [ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.