TAMPA CITY COUNCIL
THURSDAY, AUGUST 31, 2023
5:01 P.M.
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.
5:10:12PM [ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
5:10:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GOOD AFTERNOON, EVERYONE.
5:10:14PM I'D LIKE TO CALL THIS TAMPA CITY COUNCIL MEETING TO ORDER.
5:10:20PM AT THIS TIME, MAY I HAVE ROLL CALL, PLEASE?
5:10:25PM >>THE CLERK: CARLSON?
5:10:26PM >>BILL CARLSON: HERE.
5:10:28PM >>LYNN HURTAK: HERE.
5:10:30PM >> CLENDENIN?
5:10:30PM HENDERSON?
5:10:33PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: PRESENT.
5:10:34PM >>LUIS VIERA: HERE.
5:10:35PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HERE.
5:10:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
5:10:38PM >>THE CLERK: WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
5:10:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:10:40PM AT THIS TIME, JUST A COUPLE OF ANNOUNCEMENTS.
5:10:43PM FIRST, I WOULD LIKE TO LET EVERYONE KNOW THAT OUR ATTORNEY
5:10:46PM MARTIN SHELBY WILL BE VIRTUAL.
5:10:49PM UNTIL THEN, MS. ANDREA ZELMAN, CITY ATTORNEY, WILL BE
5:10:54PM SITTING IN AND HE WILL BE LOGGING IN.
5:10:56PM ALSO RECOGNIZE MOLLY BIEBEL AND THE MAYOR'S YOUTH CORPS.
5:10:59PM THEY ARE SITTING IN THE BACK.
5:11:01PM IF YOU WOULD STAND UP AND WE'LL ACKNOWLEDGE YOU.
5:11:03PM GREAT GROUP OF STUDENTS FROM THROUGHOUT TAMPA THAT SERVE AND
5:11:09PM TAKE PART IN THE MAYOR'S YOUTH CORPS.
5:11:11PM I'VE HAD THE PLEASURE OF SPEAKING TO THEIR GROUP AND SEEING
5:11:13PM THE CHANGES OVER MANY YEARS, AND THEY ARE LEARNING HOW THE
5:11:16PM CITY WORKS.
5:11:17PM CITY GOVERNMENT, AND ALL ASPECTS OF OUR CITY.
5:11:20PM SO THANKS FOR JOINING US.
5:11:22PM STAY AS LONG AS YOU LIKE.
5:11:23PM IT WILL BE AN EXCITING MEETING.
5:11:24PM AND YOU'LL GET TO SEE US AT WORK.
5:11:27PM ALL RIGHT.
5:11:27PM AT THIS TIME, MAY I HAVE A MOTION TO OPEN ALL HEARINGS.
5:11:31PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO OPEN ALL PUBLIC HEARINGS FROM COUNCILMAN
5:11:33PM MIRANDA, SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
5:11:35PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:11:35PM AYE.
5:11:37PM ALL RIGHT.
5:11:38PM THERE ARE A COUPLE OF ITEMS GOING OVER THIS AGENDA.
5:11:41PM MAY I HAVE A MOTION TO MOVE ITEM NUMBER 12 TO ITEM NUMBER 1?
5:11:45PM IT IS VERY QUICK.
5:11:47PM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN WITH THE MOTION.
5:11:48PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
5:11:50PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:11:50PM AYE.
5:11:51PM WE HAVE A MEMO REQUESTING ITEM NUMBER 3 TO BE CONTINUED TO
5:11:57PM FEBRUARY 22, 2024.
5:12:00PM >> SO MOVED.
5:12:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WAIT.
5:12:01PM MR. COLLINS.
5:12:02PM YES, SIR.
5:12:03PM >> GOOD EVENING, DANNY COLLINS WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION
5:12:06PM STAFF.
5:12:07PM JUST A FEW HOUSEKEEPING THINGS.
5:12:09PM ITEM NUMBER 3, TA/CPA 22-23 IS REQUESTING A CONTINUANCE TO
5:12:15PM THE FEBRUARY 22nd CITY COUNCIL HEARING DATE.
5:12:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:12:19PM DO WE HAVE ANYBODY WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON THE CONTINUANCE
5:12:26PM ONLY FOR ITEM NUMBER 3?
5:12:27PM I SEE NO ONE.
5:12:29PM MAY I HAVE A MOTION TO CONTINUE?
5:12:32PM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA WITH THE MOTION TO CONTINUE ITEM NUMBER
5:12:36PM 3 TO FEBRUARY 22nd, 2024.
5:12:39PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:12:40PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:12:41PM AYE.
5:12:41PM ITEM NUMBER 6.
5:12:47PM >> ITEM 6, TA/CPA 23-10, THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING A
5:12:51PM CONTINUANCE OF TONIGHT'S TRANSMITTAL HEARING TO OCTOBER 26
5:12:54PM AND CONTINUANCE FROM THE ADOPTION HEARING FROM OCTOBER 26 TO
5:12:58PM FEBRUARY 22.
5:13:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE ANYBODY WHO WISHES TO SPEAK
5:13:05PM ON THE CONTINUANCE ONLY FOR ITEM NUMBER 6?
5:13:07PM WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA, SECOND FROM
5:13:12PM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:13:12PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:13:13PM AYE.
5:13:14PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:13:15PM ANYTHING ELSE, SIR?
5:13:17PM WE HAVE A REQUEST THAT WE TAKE ITEM NUMBER 9, 10, 11 AFTER
5:13:23PM NUMBER 2.
5:13:24PM WHY?
5:13:24PM BECAUSE THEY ARE ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE HEARINGS AND WE KNOW
5:13:27PM THAT WE ARE GOING TO HAVE QUITE A BIT OF PUBLIC COMMENT ON
5:13:32PM THE OTHERS.
5:13:33PM JUST TO KEEP IT GOING, MAY I HAVE A MOTION TO HEAR 9, 10, 11
5:13:38PM AFTER 2?
5:13:38PM MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:13:40PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
5:13:41PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:13:42PM AYE.
5:13:46PM ALL RIGHT.
5:13:48PM AT THIS TIME, WE'LL SWEAR EVERYBODY IN ONCE WE START WITH
5:13:55PM ITEM NUMBER 9.
5:13:56PM EVERYTHING ELSE IS NON-QUASI-JUDICIAL.
5:13:58PM AT THIS TIME, MS. JOHNSON VELEZ.
5:14:05PM MOTION TO APPROVE THE AGENDA FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
5:14:09PM SECOND MIRANDA.
5:14:10PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:14:10PM AYE.
5:14:12PM >>SUSAN JOHNSON-VELEZ: SUSAN JOHNSON VELEZ, LEGAL
5:14:16PM DEPARTMENT.
5:14:16PM ITEM 12 IS A RESOLUTION I PREPARED FOR COUNCIL BASED ON
5:14:22PM DIRECTION AFTER MY SUMMARY AND REPORT ON THE EPC PROPOSED
5:14:25PM RULE CHANGES.
5:14:26PM THIS IS A RESOLUTION OBJECTING TO THE INCLUSION OF MAPS 1
5:14:29PM AND 2, AND THAT WE WILL SUBMIT IT TO THE EPC IF IT'S
5:14:33PM COUNCIL'S PLEASURE TO APPROVE THIS THIS EVENING.
5:14:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM COUNCIL?
5:14:36PM DO WE NEED PUBLIC COMMENT ON THIS OR NO?
5:14:40PM NO.
5:14:41PM OKAY.
5:14:42PM MAY I HAVE A MOTION TO MOVE THE RESOLUTION.
5:14:44PM MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:14:45PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:14:47PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:14:47PM ANY OPPOSED? THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:14:51PM >>SUSAN JOHNSON-VELEZ: THANK YOU.
5:14:53PM SEE, THAT WAS EASY.
5:14:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: 8:30, HERE WE COME.
5:14:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YEAH, RIGHT.
5:14:57PM [ LAUGHTER ]
5:14:57PM KNOCK ON THE WOOD.
5:15:02PM [ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
5:15:03PM ITEM NUMBER 1, MR. COTTON.
5:15:05PM >>ERIC COTTON: I WILL DO MY BEST TO BE AS FAST AS POSSIBLE.
5:15:10PM THIS IS THE ADOPTION HEARING FOR THE JANUARY CYCLE.
5:15:12PM THIS IS THE FIRST READING.
5:15:14PM JUST A QUICK SUMMARY OF WHAT WAS COVERED, WE DID THE PUBLIC
5:15:19PM MEETINGS IN MARCH, MARCH 20, 21, 23.
5:15:26PM MARCH 20, 21, 22.
5:15:30PM QUICK SUMMARY.
5:15:31PM I HAVE A FULL-BLOWN PRESENTATION.
5:15:32PM IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS, I CAN GO OVER SOME OF THOSE.
5:15:35PM GENERALLY SPEAKING, AS WE JUST SAW ON TUESDAY AND WEDNESDAY,
5:15:40PM THIS WAS A CODE CHANGE TO 27-149.
5:15:44PM FIRST THING, EVENT OF A PUBLIC -- LOCAL STATE OF EMERGENCY
5:15:48PM DECLARED BY THE MAYOR, THAT IF YOU HAD TO CANCEL YOUR
5:15:53PM MEETING, YOU DO NOT HAVE TO SHOW UP TO MAKE A MOTION.
5:15:57PM MOVED TO THE NEXT AGENDA.
5:15:59PM 27-149, THE SECOND PART OF THAT IS THE MOTION, IS THE
5:16:06PM AMENDMENT TO REQUIRE -- NOT CURRENTLY IN THE CODE.
5:16:10PM PUT THE NUMBER OF THE APPLICATION ON BOTH THE LETTER AND THE
5:16:12PM SIGN.
5:16:13PM EVEN WITH THE NEW SIGNS THAT WE SHOWED YOU A COUPLE OF WEEKS
5:16:17PM AGO, THE RECORD NUMBER WILL STILL BE ON THERE.
5:16:20PM THE NEXT ONE, WHICH IS THE DEVELOPMENT STANDARD FOR SEMINOLE
5:16:24PM HEIGHTS WAS JUST A SCRIVENER ERROR TO CHANGE FROM STORIES TO
5:16:28PM FEET.
5:16:29PM 55 STORIES TO 55 FEET.
5:16:32PM THE NEXT ONE WAS FOR THE HEIGHT IN A RESIDENTIAL ZONING
5:16:36PM DISTRICT.
5:16:37PM FOR FENCING, RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY NEXT TO A COMMERCIAL
5:16:42PM PROPERTY, THEY CAN GO TO 8 FEET BY RIGHT VERSUS HAVING TO
5:16:46PM SEEK A DESIGN EXCEPTION TO GET THE TWO EXTRA FEET.
5:16:49PM THE COMMERCIAL SIDE ALREADY HAS THE ABILITY TO GO BY RIGHT
5:16:51PM GO TO THE 8 FEET.
5:16:53PM ADAPTIVE REUSE, WHICH IS ALLOWED IN YBOR, IN THE
5:16:58PM NONRESIDENTIAL ZONING DISTRICTS, ADAPTIVE REUSE IS ALLOWED
5:17:03PM FOR PROPERTIES THAT ARE EITHER IN A LOCAL OR NATIONAL
5:17:05PM HISTORIC DISTRICT OR A LOCAL OR NATIONAL LANDMARK THAT
5:17:08PM ALLOWS SOMEBODY WHO IS CURRENTLY ZONED COMMERCIAL GENERAL
5:17:12PM AND LET'S SAY IS IN HYDE PARK TO GO THROUGH AN ADAPTIVE
5:17:17PM REUSE WHICH ALLOWS THEM NOT TO HAVE TO COMPLY WITH ALL THE
5:17:20PM DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS IN THE CODE AS A TYPICAL PROPERTY
5:17:23PM WOULD HAVE TO.
5:17:24PM FOR EXAMPLE, EXISTING HOME THAT'S BEING CONVERTED TO A
5:17:26PM COMMERCIAL USE CAN'T ALWAYS MEET PARKING.
5:17:30PM PARKING WOULD BE BASED ON MOBILITY STANDARDS.
5:17:34PM 3.3 PER THOUSAND, FOR INSTANCE, IT MAY BE ABLE TO BE REDUCED
5:17:37PM IF THERE'S ON-STREET PARKING IN FRONT OF THE PROPERTY AND
5:17:40PM SUCH.
5:17:40PM THE NEXT ONE WAS THE DEFINITION OF COURTYARD, WHICH, IF YOU
5:17:48PM RECALL, WE HAD A COUPLE OF DISCUSSIONS ABOUT THE COURTYARD
5:17:50PM ISSUE WHICH HAD TO DO WITH WHAT IS A COURTYARD.
5:17:53PM RIGHT NOW UNDER CHAPTER 27, IT'S NOT DEFINED.
5:17:56PM NOW IT'S GOING TO BE DEFINED.
5:17:58PM SO ASKS WHAT A COURTYARD IS AND WHAT A COURTYARD IS NOT.
5:18:02PM NEXT ONE IS SOLID WASTE STANDARDS, REQUIRING THE INSIDE OF
5:18:06PM THE SOLID WASTE DUMPSTER CONTAINER TO BE A FOOT LARGER.
5:18:14PM REQUEST BY THE SOLID WASTE DEPARTMENT.
5:18:15PM MAKE IT EASIER FOR THEM TO GET THEIR EQUIPMENT IN AND OUT OF
5:18:18PM THAT LOCATION.
5:18:19PM ONE WAS FOR THE WESTSHORE OVERLAY DISTRICT, WHICH THE
5:18:21PM BIGGEST ONE IS GREENSPACE AND REDUCTION IN PARKING, MAKE THE
5:18:25PM PARKING -- WESTSHORE IS ONE OF THE AREAS OF THE CITY THAT IS
5:18:28PM ACTUALLY MORE URBAN IN NATURE, SO, THE DOWNTOWN AND THE CITY
5:18:34PM ZONING DISTRICTS AND SOME OTHER ZONING REQUIREMENTS.
5:18:36PM THE LAST ONE WAS THE ELECTRONIC -- ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING
5:18:44PM STATIONS.
5:18:45PM TO SAY THAT EV CAPABLE AND EV READY, CAPABLE MEANS YOU
5:18:53PM BASICALLY HAVE THE RACEWAY FOR THE ELECTRIC ALREADY THERE.
5:18:57PM EV MEANS YOU'RE PUTTING IN THE INFRASTRUCTURE, INCLUDING THE
5:19:00PM CHARGER PORTS THAT ACTUALLY CHARGE THE VEHICLE.
5:19:04PM DOES COUNCIL HAVE SPECIFIC QUESTIONS ON THOSE?
5:19:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I HAVE A QUESTION ON THE ELECTRIC
5:19:08PM VEHICLE CHARGING.
5:19:09PM THAT MEANS ANY NEW DEVELOPMENT THERE WILL BE A REQUIREMENT
5:19:11PM TO PROVIDE ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING?
5:19:14PM >>ERIC COTTON: REQUIREMENTS THAT REQUIRE MORE THAN 50
5:19:16PM PARKING SPACES.
5:19:17PM IF YOU ARE DOING A SMALL OFFICE, ONLY REQUIRES SIX SPACES --
5:19:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: BUT IF IT'S AN APARTMENT COMPLEX, LARGE
5:19:23PM OFFICE SPACE.
5:19:23PM >>ERIC COTTON: CORRECT.
5:19:24PM NOW, IN THAT ONE, I THINK WHAT DANA IS GETTING UP TO SAY,
5:19:29PM BUILT 250, BECAUSE OF THE LAST SERIES OF STORMS, THAT
5:19:36PM REQUIREMENT IS GOING TO BE PUSHED OUT TO OCTOBER 2024.
5:19:41PM IT MIGHT BE CONSIDERED MORE BURDENSOME.
5:19:43PM SO INSTEAD OF RUNNING AFOUL OF STATE REGULATIONS, PUSHING
5:19:47PM THAT ENFORCEMENT OUT.
5:19:51PM THE ENFORCEMENT WILL TAKE PLACE IN OCTOBER OF 2024 WHEN THE
5:19:55PM FLORIDA STATUTE EXPIRES.
5:19:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:19:57PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN.
5:20:00PM ALONG THE SAME CONVERSATION THE CHAIRMAN BROUGHT UP, ON
5:20:02PM THESE STATIONS FOR ELECTRICAL CHARGE STATIONS FOR ELECTRICAL
5:20:06PM CARS, ARE THERE ANY REGULATIONS THERE?
5:20:07PM HOW LONG THEY CAN BE THERE?
5:20:09PM SOME I'VE SEEN IN PARKING GARAGES.
5:20:12PM >>ERIC COTTON: HOW LONG SIT TO CHARGE?
5:20:14PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: STAY THERE FOREVER.
5:20:16PM >>ERIC COTTON: NO, IT DOESN'T HAVE THAT.
5:20:18PM WE WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO ENFORCE THAT.
5:20:20PM THAT WOULD BE UP TO THE PRIVATE PERSON.
5:20:23PM I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU SAY, FORT BROOKE, THE SAME VEHICLES
5:20:27PM ARE ALWAYS THERE CHARGING.
5:20:29PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I SEE SOME PEOPLE THAT HOG THE THING AND
5:20:31PM NOBODY ELSE CAN CHARGE.
5:20:32PM I'M NOT TALKING ABOUT MYSELF.
5:20:33PM I'M TALKING ABOUT, THERE ARE FAST CHARGERS ANYWAY, AND YOU
5:20:37PM CAN DO IT IN AN HOUR OR TWO HOURS BUT THEY ARE THERE SEVEN
5:20:40PM OR EIGHT HOURS.
5:20:41PM >>ERIC COTTON: THIS IS PRIVATE PROPERTY, NOT CITY PARKING
5:20:43PM GARAGES.
5:20:44PM I DON'T KNOW IF CODE ENFORCEMENT WOULD BE ABLE TO CITE THEM.
5:20:47PM I WOULD HAVE TO HAVE PARKING DISCUSS THAT WITH YOU.
5:20:52PM >>LYNN HURTAK: CAN YOU PULL UP THE SLIDE YOU HAVE FOR
5:20:54PM DEFINITION OF A COURTYARD?
5:20:56PM >>ERIC COTTON: YES, MA'AM.
5:20:57PM NOT QUICKLY, BUT I CAN PULL IT UP.
5:21:01PM THIS IS THE PROPOSED LANGUAGE.
5:21:10PM YOU WANT ME TO READ IT INTO THE RECORD OR ARE YOU ALL GOOD?
5:21:17PM >>LYNN HURTAK: DESIGNED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USE BY PEDESTRIANS.
5:21:21PM THANK YOU.
5:21:23PM >>ERIC COTTON: THAT WAS A CONCERN OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION
5:21:25PM ALSO.
5:21:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:21:26PM ANYBODY ELSE?
5:21:26PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM?
5:21:29PM ITEM NUMBER 1? MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
5:21:36PM CLENDENIN, SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:21:37PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:21:38PM AYE.
5:21:39PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:21:39PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA, WOULD YOU MIND READING ITEM NUMBER 1.
5:21:42PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: ITEM NUMBER 1, FILE 2023-8, CHAPTER 27.
5:21:50PM ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING, ORDINANCE IN
5:21:52PM THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, RELATING TO AMENDMENTS OF THE
5:21:55PM LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, MAKING REVISIONS TO THE CITY OF TAMPA
5:21:57PM CODE OF ORDINANCES, CHAPTER 27 (ZONING AND LAND
5:22:00PM DEVELOPMENT); AMENDING SECTION 27-43, DEFINITIONS; AMENDING
5:22:05PM SECTION 27-149, PUBLIC NOTICE REQUIREMENTS FOR LAND
5:22:08PM DEVELOPMENT DECISIONS AND TEXT AMENDMENTS TO THE LAND
5:22:12PM DEVELOPMENT CODE; AMENDING SECTION 27-156, OFFICIAL SCHEDULE
5:22:16PM OF DISTRICT REGULATIONS; AMENDING SECTION 27-211.6,
5:22:21PM DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR COMMERCIAL, MIXED-USE OR OTHER
5:22:24PM NONRESIDENTIAL (SH-CG AND SH-CI) DEVELOPMENT; AMENDING
5:22:30PM SECTION 27-211.8, SCHEDULE OF PERMITTED USES BY DISTRICT;
5:22:35PM AMENDING SECTION 27-238, WESTSHORE OVERLAY DISTRICT
5:22:40PM DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS; AMENDING SECTION 27-283.12,
5:22:44PM OFF-STREET PARKING SPACE STANDARDS; AMENDING SECTION 27-288,
5:22:49PM SOLID WASTE; AMENDING SECTION 27-290.1, FENCE AND WALL
5:22:55PM REGULATIONS; REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES OR PARTS OF ORDINANCES
5:22:58PM IN CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING AN
5:23:01PM EFFECTIVE DATE.
5:23:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
5:23:04PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
5:23:05PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
5:23:09PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
5:23:11PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
5:23:13PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
5:23:15PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
5:23:17PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
5:23:19PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
5:23:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
5:23:21PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
5:23:26PM SECOND PUBLIC HEARING IS SCHEDULED FOR SEPTEMBER 21st,
5:23:30PM 2023, AT 10:30 A.M. AT THE OLD CITY HALL BUILDING LOCATED AT
5:23:35PM 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA.
5:23:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:23:40PM YES, SIR.
5:23:42PM >>ERIC COTTON: ERIC COTTON, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:23:45PM ITEM NUMBER 2 IS SPECIFICALLY TO THE EAST TAMPA OVERLAY
5:23:48PM DISTRICT.
5:23:49PM IT'S A CHANGE TO SECTION 27-156.
5:23:52PM ADUs, SPECIAL USE ONE.
5:23:56PM THIS IS TO AMEND THAT SECTION TO SPECIFICALLY STATE THEY ARE
5:23:58PM ALLOWED IN THE EAST TAMPA OVERLAY DISTRICT.
5:24:01PM THAT WAS A NEIGHBORHOOD-INITIATED REQUEST.
5:24:05PM ANY QUESTIONS?
5:24:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO YOU HAVE A PRESENTATION?
5:24:08PM >>ERIC COTTON: NO, SIR.
5:24:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN?
5:24:10PM DO WE HAVE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM
5:24:14PM NUMBER 2?
5:24:14PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:24:20PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:24:21PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:24:22PM AYE.
5:24:22PM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
5:24:23PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES, SIR.
5:24:24PM I MOVE AN ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING
5:24:28PM CONSIDERATION.
5:24:28PM AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, RELATING TO EAST
5:24:30PM TAMPA OVERLAY DISTRICT, MAKING REVISIONS TO CITY OF TAMPA
5:24:33PM CODE OF ORDINANCES, CHAPTER 27 (ZONING AND LAND
5:24:36PM DEVELOPMENT); AMENDING SECTION 27-156, OFFICIAL SCHEDULE OF
5:24:41PM DISTRICT REGULATIONS; REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES OR PARTS OF
5:24:45PM ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT THEREWITH; PROVIDING FOR
5:24:48PM SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
5:24:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
5:24:53PM VIERA.
5:24:53PM SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
5:24:55PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
5:24:57PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
5:24:58PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
5:25:00PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
5:25:02PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
5:25:03PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
5:25:05PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
5:25:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
5:25:07PM >>THE CLERK: THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
5:25:09PM SECOND PUBLIC HEARING IS SCHEDULED FOR SEPTEMBER 21st,
5:25:14PM 2023, AT 10:30 A.M. LOCATED AT THE OLD CITY HALL BUILDING,
5:25:19PM 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA.
5:25:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:25:24PM JUST FOR THE RECORD, MR. SHELBY IS ONLINE.
5:25:27PM I SEE HIM, SO WE HAVE AN ATTORNEY VIRTUALLY PRESENT.
5:25:30PM AT THIS TIME, WE'LL TAKE ITEMS 9, 10, AND 11.
5:25:33PM IF YOU ARE GOING TO SPEAK ON 9, 10, OR 11, PLEASE STAND UP,
5:25:37PM RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND WE WILL SWEAR YOU IN BECAUSE THESE
5:25:40PM ARE NOW QUASI-JUDICIAL
5:25:54PM [OATH ADMINISTERED BY CLERK]
5:25:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: LET'S PROCEED.
5:25:59PM ITEM NUMBER 9.
5:26:03PM >>ERIC COTTON: ERIC COTTON, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:26:05PM THIS REQUEST IS AB-23-12 FOR PROPERTY AT 101 NORTH FRANKLIN
5:26:11PM STREET.
5:26:11PM THE APPLICANT IS ROBERT RIVERA.
5:26:13PM THIS IS A REVISED STAFF REPORT.
5:26:15PM THE ORIGINAL STAFF REPORT I BELIEVE RECEIVED, HAD A WRONG
5:26:20PM FIRST NAME ON THE APPLICANT.
5:26:22PM AND THE AERIAL THAT YOU RECEIVED IS WRONG.
5:26:24PM THIS IS AT 101 FRANKLIN STREET, THE YELLOW DOT AT WASHINGTON
5:26:28PM AND FRANKLIN.
5:26:29PM THE APPLICANT -- THE PROPERTY IS CURRENTLY WET.
5:26:34PM RIGHT NOW IT HAS A TWO COP, BASICALLY FOR BEER AND WINE.
5:26:38PM THE APPLICANT IS SEEKING TO ADD REGULAR LIQUOR TO THE
5:26:42PM PROPERTY, WHICH IS FOR CONSUMPTION ON PREMISES ONLY.
5:26:46PM THE SIZE OF THE PROPERTY HAS NOT CHANGED.
5:26:48PM IT'S 1236 SQUARE FEET INDOORS AND 815 SQUARE FEET OUTDOORS.
5:26:52PM PARKING IS NOT REQUIRED.
5:26:55PM IN THE CBD.
5:26:57PM WET ZONE SURVEY.
5:27:01PM YOU CAN SEE THE PROPERTY OUTLINED IN YELLOW.
5:27:03PM AGAIN, THIS IS CURRENTLY BEING OPERATED.
5:27:10PM SALES HOURS ARE TO BE CONSISTENT WITH CHAPTER 14.
5:27:13PM APPLICANT IS NOT REQUESTING ANY WAIVERS.
5:27:18PM THERE ARE SOME CORRECTIONS THAT NEED TO BE DONE TO THE SITE
5:27:20PM PLAN BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
5:27:22PM AS NOTED IN THE STAFF REPORT, ON THE SITE DATA TABLE, REMOVE
5:27:28PM THE TERM 4 COP, NOT A TERM WE UTILIZE ANYMORE.
5:27:33PM ADD FOR AB CLASSIFICATION AS A SMALL VENUE.
5:27:37PM THIS IS THE OUTDOOR AREA.
5:27:40PM THIS IS ON PRIVATE PROPERTY.
5:27:41PM HE DOES NOT HAVE A SIDEWALK CAFE PERMIT.
5:27:44PM THIS IS ON PRIVATE PROPERTY.
5:27:45PM AND THIS IS RIGHT ACROSS THE STREET, THE PNC BUILDING, THE
5:27:55PM HYATT HOTEL.
5:27:57PM DOES COUNCIL HAVE ANY QUESTIONS?
5:27:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE'RE IN THE NOTICE AREA.
5:28:01PM >>ERIC COTTON: CORRECT, CORRECT.
5:28:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: TECHNICALLY.
5:28:03PM ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN?
5:28:05PM NO.
5:28:06PM ALL RIGHT.
5:28:06PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:28:07PM DO WE HAVE AN APPLICANT FOR ITEM NUMBER 9?
5:28:10PM >>ERIC COTTON: YES, SIR.
5:28:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO COME UP.
5:28:13PM YES, SIR.
5:28:16PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL MEMBERS.
5:28:17PM ROBERT RIVERA.
5:28:19PM ANY QUESTIONS FOR ME?
5:28:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS THIS THE SANTOS LOCATION?
5:28:24PM >> YES, IT IS.
5:28:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN?
5:28:26PM DO WE HAVE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM
5:28:29PM NUMBER 9?
5:28:29PM I SEE NO ONE, AND THERE'S NO ONE REGISTERED.
5:28:33PM MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:28:34PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:28:35PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:28:36PM AYE.
5:28:37PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:28:37PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON, WOULD YOU MIND READING ITEM NUMBER
5:28:42PM 9?
5:28:42PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I MOVE FILE AB 2-23-12, ORDINANCE BEING
5:28:49PM READ FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION.
5:28:51PM AN ORDINANCE APPROVING A SPECIAL USE PERMIT (S-2) FOR
5:28:55PM ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES SALES, SMALL VENUE, CONSUMPTION ON
5:28:59PM PREMISES ONLY, AND MAKING LAWFUL THE SALE OF BEVERAGES
5:29:04PM REGARDLESS OF ALCOHOLIC CONTENT, BEER, WINE AND LIQUOR, ON
5:29:10PM THAT CERTAIN LOT, PLOT OR TRACT OF LAND LOCATED AT 101 NORTH
5:29:13PM FRANKLIN STREET, TAMPA, FLORIDA, AS MORE PARTICULARLY
5:29:16PM DESCRIBED IN SECTION 3, PROVIDING THAT ALL ORDINANCES OR
5:29:19PM PARTS OF ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT ARE REPEALED; REPEALING
5:29:22PM ORDINANCE NUMBER 97-57; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
5:29:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN
5:29:28PM HENDERSON.
5:29:29PM A SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
5:29:31PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
5:29:32PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
5:29:34PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
5:29:35PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
5:29:37PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
5:29:39PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
5:29:40PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
5:29:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
5:29:43PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
5:29:47PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER 21st
5:29:52PM AT 9:30 A.M. AT 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR,
5:29:58PM TAMPA, FLORIDA.
5:30:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:30:01PM >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:30:01PM APPRECIATE IT.
5:30:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER 10.
5:30:03PM YES, SIR.
5:30:06PM >>ERIC COTTON: ERIC COTTON, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:30:09PM THIS IS FOR AB 23-20 FOR THE PROPERTY AT 709 SOUTH OREGON
5:30:14PM AVENUE.
5:30:15PM THE APPLICANT IS COOPER ROSARIO.
5:30:18PM THIS IS WITHIN THE HYDE PARK PD FOR HYDE PARK VILLAGE.
5:30:24PM THERE'S CURRENTLY -- THIS IS THE LOCATION SHOWN IN RED.
5:30:27PM THERE'S CURRENTLY AN ALCOHOL PERMIT ON THE PROPERTY BUT NOT
5:30:31PM FOR THIS LOCATION.
5:30:33PM THE ADJACENT PROPERTY IS A SPECIAL RESTAURANT WHICH IS FOR
5:30:37PM BEER AND WINE AND LIQUOR.
5:30:39PM I'LL SHOW YOU -- SO THIS IS THE AREA THAT'S PROPOSED FOR THE
5:30:43PM ALCOHOL, THE NEW ALCOHOL PERMIT.
5:30:45PM AND THE EXISTING ALCOHOL WRAPS AROUND IT LIKE THAT.
5:30:50PM THAT'S FOR A DIFFERENT RESTAURANT, DIFFERENT ESTABLISHMENT.
5:30:52PM THIS APPLICANT IS ASKING FOR ROUGHLY 1921 SQUARE FEET FOR A
5:30:58PM SMALL VENUE, BEER AND WINE CONSUMPTION ON PREMISES ONLY.
5:31:01PM HE'S IN THE HYDE PARK VILLAGE.
5:31:04PM THEY HAVE 1,026 PARKING SPACES AVAILABLE.
5:31:07PM AND HE REQUIRES TO HAVE 20.
5:31:09PM SO LOOKING AT THE NUMBERS FOR HYDE PARK, THEY HAVE ADEQUATE
5:31:13PM PARKING.
5:31:13PM HE WAS ASKING FOR A WAIVER.
5:31:16PM THERE IS A REQUIREMENT THAT DISTANCE SEPARATION FROM ANOTHER
5:31:20PM AB ESTABLISHMENT IS 250 FEET.
5:31:22PM HE'S DIRECTLY ADJACENT TO ONE.
5:31:24PM HE'S ASKING FROM 250 DOWN TO 0.
5:31:26PM THE ADJACENT PROPERTY, AGAIN, IT HAS -- A SPECIAL RESTAURANT
5:31:33PM FOR BEER, WINE, LIQUOR.
5:31:34PM THIS IS BEER, WINE, LIQUOR AS A SPECIAL RESTAURANT.
5:31:39PM THIS IS GOING TO BE BEER AND WINE FOR A SMALL VENUE.
5:31:42PM THERE ARE SOME CHANGES THAT NEED TO BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST
5:31:45PM AND SECOND READING TO THE SITE PLAN.
5:31:47PM PRIMARILY THEY NEED TO LIST THE WAIVERS ON THE SITE PLAN
5:31:51PM THAT I JUST MENTIONED.
5:31:52PM AND THEY NEED TO REMOVE -- THEY NEED TO ADD NOTES TO THE
5:31:56PM SITE PLAN, BASICALLY SALES AREA SHALL NOT BE LOCATED IN A
5:32:00PM PARKING LOT OR LOADING SPACE AND ALL PERMITS AFTER APRIL 1,
5:32:03PM 2011, SHALL POST A PLACARD PROVIDED BY THE CITY ON THE
5:32:09PM PROPERTY STATING WHAT THEY WERE APPROVED FOR.
5:32:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS THIS PARCEL THE ONE THAT HAS A
5:32:16PM PARKING GARAGE ON TOP?
5:32:18PM >>ERIC COTTON: CORRECT.
5:32:19PM THIS IS THE SITE.
5:32:23PM IT'S CURRENTLY NOT OPEN.
5:32:24PM IT'S UNDER CONSTRUCTION.
5:32:25PM THAT'S THE PARKING GARAGE.
5:32:28PM WHEN LACHONE WENT OUT THIS MORNING, NOT REALLY MUCH TO SEE
5:32:33PM AT THIS POINT BECAUSE HE'S NOT READY TO OPEN YET, BUT SHOULD
5:32:37PM -- I'M SURE HE'S TRYING TO GET OPEN IN TIME FOR THE HOLIDAY
5:32:40PM SEASON.
5:32:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THOSE WERE APARTMENTS BACK IN THE DAY.
5:32:45PM >>ERIC COTTON: YES, SIR.
5:32:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:32:46PM ANY QUESTIONS?
5:32:46PM APPLICANT?
5:32:48PM THIS IS FOR ITEM NUMBER 10.
5:32:56PM >> GOOD EVENING.
5:32:57PM STEVE GIANFILIPPO, IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
5:33:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN?
5:33:04PM THIS IS GOING TO BE A SMALL RESTAURANT?
5:33:08PM >> IT'S ACTUALLY -- WE HAVE ANOTHER CONCEPT IN HYDE PARK
5:33:12PM VILLAGE CALLED HOT HOUSE, SHARED OFFICE SPACE.
5:33:19PM IT'S ABOUT 30,000 SQUARE FEET, COMMUNITY FOCUSED CONCEPT,
5:33:26PM OFFICE, PHOTO STUDIO, AUDITORIUM, TEST KITCHEN.
5:33:31PM IT'S KIND OF THE MODERN DAY OFFICE.
5:33:33PM THIS WILL BE AN EXTENSION OF THAT CONCEPT TO PROVIDE OFFICE
5:33:38PM TENANTS AND MEMBERS WITH AN EXPERIENCE MORE CONDUCIVE TO
5:33:44PM BUSINESS.
5:33:44PM SOMEWHERE THEY COULD ACTUALLY GO AND ORDER BEER AND WINE AND
5:33:49PM ACTUALLY HOLD A MEETING.
5:33:50PM WE HAVE CONFERENCE ROOMS THERE AVAILABLE AS WELL.
5:33:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
5:33:54PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WISHING TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 10?
5:33:57PM ITEM NUMBER 10?
5:33:58PM WE HAVE NOBODY REGISTERED.
5:34:00PM MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:34:02PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:34:04PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:34:04PM AYE.
5:34:05PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:34:05PM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:34:07PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: AN ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST
5:34:10PM READING CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE APPROVING A SPECIAL USE
5:34:13PM PERMIT (S-2) FOR ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES SALES, SMALL VENUE
5:34:19PM (CONSUMPTION ON PREMISES ONLY) AND MAKING LAWFUL THE SALE OF
5:34:22PM BEER AND WINE AT OR FROM THAT CERTAIN LOT, PLOT OR TRACT OF
5:34:26PM LAND LOCATED AT 709 SOUTH OREGON AVENUE, TAMPA, FLORIDA, AND
5:34:30PM MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 2; PROVIDING THAT ALL
5:34:33PM ORDINANCES OR PARTS OF ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT ARE REPEALED;
5:34:35PM PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
5:34:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
5:34:38PM CLENDENIN.
5:34:39PM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA WITH THE SECOND.
5:34:41PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
5:34:43PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
5:34:45PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
5:34:47PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
5:34:48PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
5:34:50PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
5:34:51PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
5:34:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
5:34:53PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
5:34:58PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER 21st
5:35:02PM AT 9:30 A.M. AT 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR,
5:35:08PM TAMPA, FLORIDA.
5:35:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:35:12PM >> THANK YOU.
5:35:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:35:16PM ITEM NUMBER 11.
5:35:19PM >>ERIC COTTON: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
5:35:21PM ERIC COTTON, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:35:25PM THIS IS AB 2-23-23 FOR PROPERTY AT 5232 SOUTH MacDILL
5:35:31PM AVENUE.
5:35:31PM THE APPLICANT IS MARK BENTLEY.
5:35:34PM COUNCIL JUST SAW THIS A MONTH AGO FOR A REZONING FROM THE CG
5:35:39PM TO A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT.
5:35:40PM THE APPLICANT IS SEEKING -- THERE IS A CORRECTION IN THE
5:35:43PM STAFF REPORT.
5:35:44PM THE APPLICANT IS SEEKING A RESTAURANT CONSUMPTION ON
5:35:48PM PREMISES OF BEER, WINE AND LIQUOR.
5:35:50PM THE PREVIOUS APPROVAL THAT THE PROPERTY HAD WAS AB-1.
5:35:55PM 14-55, ADDING LIQUOR.
5:35:57PM IT WAS PREVIOUSLY JUST FOR BEER AND WINE.
5:35:59PM REQUESTED HOURS ARE CONSISTENT WITH CHAPTER 14, REQUIRED TO
5:36:01PM HAVE 13 SPACES OR PROVIDING 13 PARKING SPACES.
5:36:04PM THE CORRECT TOTAL, PROVIDING 2,062.8 SQUARE FEET INDOORS AND
5:36:10PM 889.86 SQUARE FEET OUTDOORS FOR A TOTAL OF 2,952.66 SQUARE
5:36:17PM FEET.
5:36:17PM LITTLE UNDER 3,000 SQUARE FEET FOR THE AB ESTABLISHMENT.
5:36:21PM THEY ARE ASKING FOR TWO WAIVERS.
5:36:24PM ONE IS THE DISTANCE SEPARATION FROM RESIDENTIAL USES THAT
5:36:28PM REQUIRE, FROM THE REQUIRED 250 FEET DOWN TO 3.8 FEET.
5:36:31PM THE RESIDENTIAL IS DIRECTLY BEHIND THIS PROPERTY TO THE
5:36:35PM EAST.
5:36:36PM AND FROM OTHER SALES, OTHER AB SALES ESTABLISHMENTS FROM 250
5:36:42PM FEET TO 125 FEET.
5:36:44PM OTHER SALES ESTABLISHMENTS ARE, FOOD MART.
5:36:49PM PROBABLY HAS A 2 APS.
5:36:51PM THAT'S FURTHER SOUTH ON MacDILL.
5:36:53PM COUPLE OF CHANGES THAT NEED TO BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST AND
5:36:57PM SECOND READING.
5:36:58PM REMOVE THE AB -- BASICALLY ON THE SITE DATA TABLE, REMOVE AB
5:37:05PM FOR INDOOR AND TOTAL AB SALES SQUARE FEET.
5:37:08PM ADD THE CORRECT SQUARE FEET AS FOLLOWS.
5:37:10PM I THINK THAT'S STILL THE SAME MISTAKE THAT WAS ON THE STAFF
5:37:13PM REPORT.
5:37:14PM THE CALCULATIONS ON OUR SIDE WERE INCORRECT.
5:37:18PM DOES COUNCIL HAVE ANY QUESTIONS?
5:37:19PM THIS USED TO BE A KOREAN RESTAURANT.
5:37:22PM THAT'S WHAT WAS THERE PREVIOUSLY.
5:37:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR COUNCIL?
5:37:27PM YES, SIR.
5:37:30PM COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
5:37:32PM >>BILL CARLSON: I FORGOT WHERE WE ENDED UP ON OUTDOOR
5:37:36PM AMPLIFIED SOUND.
5:37:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DID WE HAVE THIS THE OTHER DAY WITH MR.
5:37:42PM MANASSE?
5:37:44PM >>ERIC COTTON: YES, RYAN IS PROBABLY BETTER TO ADDRESS THAT.
5:37:47PM I WILL STEP TO THE SIDE FOR NOW.
5:37:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. MANASSE.
5:37:50PM >> GOOD EVENING.
5:37:50PM RYAN MANASSE, JOHNSON POPE, EAST JACKSON STREET.
5:37:54PM THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME.
5:37:55PM THANK YOU TO STAFF.
5:37:56PM I'LL TRY NOT TO BE REDUNDANT WITH THE INFORMATION.
5:37:58PM IF YOU LIKE, I'LL ADDRESS THAT FIRST COMMENT.
5:38:01PM JUST SO YOU KNOW, WE ARE PROPOSING TO ADDRESS OUTDOOR
5:38:06PM AMPLIFIED SOUND THAT WAS BROUGHT UP DURING THE REZONING A
5:38:09PM COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO.
5:38:10PM IT'S MORE IN LINES WITH TYPICAL AB 1 OPERATING HOURS.
5:38:14PM SO IF COUNCIL IS INCLINED TO APPROVE OUR APPLICATIONS, WE
5:38:18PM CAN ADD THIS BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
5:38:20PM BUT I'LL JUST STATE IT FOR THE RECORD.
5:38:21PM IT STATES OUTDOOR AMPLIFIED SOUND WILL BE LIMITED TO 11 P.M.
5:38:28PM SUNDAY THROUGH WEDNESDAY AND 12 A.M. THURSDAY THROUGH
5:38:32PM SATURDAY.
5:38:35PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I'M STILL TRYING TO REMEMBER WHERE THE
5:38:37PM PROPERTY IS.
5:38:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SOUTH OF GANDY, CORRECT?
5:38:41PM >> IT IS SOUTH OF GANDY.
5:38:42PM ERIC, YOU MIGHT HAVE A PHOTO.
5:38:45PM BUT THIS IS THE SITE.
5:38:46PM IT'S THAT DIAMOND-SHAPED LOT.
5:38:50PM AGAIN, INDOOR/OUTDOOR.
5:38:52PM THAT'S SITE CONFIGURATION THAT WAS EXISTING.
5:38:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IT WAS THE ITALIAN RESTAURANT?
5:38:57PM >> NOW IT'S ITALIAN, YES, CORRECT.
5:38:59PM WE'RE PROPOSING THIS.
5:39:03PM I'M GOING OUT OF ORDER IN MY PRESENTATION.
5:39:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE SAW IT THE OTHER DAY, YES.
5:39:08PM ALL RIGHT.
5:39:10PM ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?
5:39:11PM DO WE HAVE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON
5:39:14PM ITEM NUMBER 11?
5:39:15PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE -- THERE WAS NOBODY REGISTERED.
5:39:21PM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN WITH THE MOTION TO CLOSE.
5:39:23PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
5:39:24PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:39:24PM AYE.
5:39:25PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
5:39:28PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
5:39:29PM FILE NUMBER AB2-23-23, ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST
5:39:34PM READING CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE APPROVING A SPECIAL USE
5:39:38PM PERMIT (S-2) FOR ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES SALES, RESTAURANT
5:39:42PM (CONSUMPTION ON PREMISES ONLY) AND MAKING LAWFUL THE SALE OF
5:39:46PM BEVERAGES REGARDLESS OF ALCOHOLIC CONTENT, BEER, WINE AND
5:39:49PM LIQUOR, ON THAT CERTAIN LOT, PLOT, OR TRACT OF LAND LOCATED
5:39:53PM AT 5232 SOUTH MacDILL AVENUE, TAMPA, FLORIDA, AS MORE
5:39:56PM PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 3; PROVIDING THAT ALL
5:39:59PM ORDINANCES OR PARTS OF ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT ARE REPEALED;
5:40:03PM REPEALING AB 1-14-55; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
5:40:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
5:40:10PM HURTAK.
5:40:11PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:40:13PM SORRY, MR. MANASSE.
5:40:19PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: MR. CHAIRMAN.
5:40:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MR. SHELBY.
5:40:21PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: ALSO, AS PART OF THE MOTION, TO MAKE SURE
5:40:23PM THAT THE HOURS OF OPERATION ARE PLACED ON THE SITE PLAN.
5:40:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, I BELIEVE THEY ARE.
5:40:27PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I'LL ADD THAT TO MINE TO MAKE SURE THAT HOURS
5:40:30PM OF OPERATION ARE ADDED TO THE SITE PLAN.
5:40:32PM >> THAT WAS OUTDOOR AMPLIFIED SOUND HOURS.
5:40:34PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OUTDOOR AMPLIFIED SOUND HOURS WILL BE ADDED
5:40:37PM TO THE SITE PLAN.
5:40:39PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THANK YOU FOR THAT.
5:40:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
5:40:44PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
5:40:46PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
5:40:48PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
5:40:49PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
5:40:51PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
5:40:52PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
5:40:54PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
5:40:55PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
5:40:56PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
5:40:59PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER 21st
5:41:04PM AT 9:30 A.M. AT 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR,
5:41:09PM TAMPA, FLORIDA.
5:41:12PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:41:13PM ITEM NUMBER 4.
5:41:31PM THESE ARE NON-QUASI-JUDICIAL FOR THE REST OF THE AGENDA, SO
5:41:49PM YOU DO NOT HAVE TO BE SWORN IN.
5:41:50PM WE'RE ALL GOOD TO GO.
5:41:51PM MR. COLLINS, GO AHEAD, SIR.
5:41:56PM >> GOOD EVENING.
5:41:56PM THIS IS DANNY COLLINS WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
5:42:02PM TA/CPA 23-03, MAP AMENDMENT FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT 7400
5:42:06PM INTERBAY BOULEVARD.
5:42:07PM JUST A QUICK BACKGROUND, THIS IS A PRIVATELY INITIATED
5:42:12PM AMENDMENT.
5:42:12PM SMALL SCALE IN SIZE.
5:42:13PM SUBJECT SITE UNTIL 18.32 ACRES.
5:42:15PM THE REQUEST IS TO CHANGE THE FUTURE LAND USE FROM LIGHT
5:42:19PM INDUSTRIAL TO COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35.
5:42:21PM HERE IS THE GENERAL LOCATION MAP.
5:42:30PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN THE SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING
5:42:33PM DISTRICT.
5:42:33PM IT'S WITHIN THE GANDY SUN BAY SOUTH NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:42:36PM PORTIONS OF THE SITE ARE WITHIN THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA
5:42:39PM AND WITHIN THE MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE CLEAR ZONE, AND IT IS
5:42:42PM LOCATED HERE ON OUR LOCATION MAP.
5:42:45PM HERE IS AN AERIAL MAP OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND THE
5:42:49PM SURROUNDING PROPERTIES.
5:42:49PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS HIGHLIGHTED IN YELLOW.
5:42:51PM IT'S JUST SOUTH OF THE INTERSECTION OF SOUTH LOIS AVENUE,
5:42:55PM INTERBAY BOULEVARD.
5:42:57PM THIS IS THE NORTHERN BOUNDARY OF MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE TO
5:42:59PM THE SOUTH.
5:43:02PM THERE ARE SOME SINGLE-FAMILY USES TO THE WEST OF THE SITE AS
5:43:09PM WELL AS NORTH OF INTERBAY YOU HAVE SOME SINGLE-FAMILY AS
5:43:12PM WELL.
5:43:13PM THERE IS A STORAGE FACILITY JUST TO THE WEST ON INTERBAY
5:43:16PM BOULEVARD.
5:43:19PM THIS IS SOUTH MANHATTAN AVENUE JUST A COUPLE OF BLOCKS TO
5:43:22PM THE EAST OF THE SITE.
5:43:25PM HERE IS AN IMAGE LOOKING NORTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE TOWARD
5:43:28PM INTERBAY BOULEVARD.
5:43:29PM HERE IS AN IMAGE LOOKING SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE FROM
5:43:32PM INTERBAY BOULEVARD.
5:43:33PM THIS IS LOOKING EAST ALONG INTERBAY BOULEVARD.
5:43:37PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS OUT OF FRAME TO THE RIGHT.
5:43:39PM THIS IS LOOKING WEST ON INTERBAY BOULEVARD.
5:43:43PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS ON THE LEFT.
5:43:45PM HERE IS THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
5:43:50PM AS YOU COULD SEE, THE SUBJECT SITE IS CURRENTLY RECOGNIZED
5:43:54PM UNDER THE LIGHT INDUSTRIAL FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
5:43:57PM THAT'S REPRESENTED BY THIS GRAY COLOR.
5:44:00PM DIRECTLY TO THE WEST OF THE SITE IS LAND RECOGNIZED UNDER
5:44:03PM THE RESIDENTIAL 10 DESIGNATION.
5:44:05PM TO THE NORTHWEST OF THE SITE IS LAND RECOGNIZED UNDER THE TU
5:44:09PM 24 DESIGNATION, DIRECTLY TO THE NORTH IS LAND RECOGNIZED
5:44:12PM UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL 35 DESIGNATION.
5:44:15PM WE HAVE CMU 35 JUST TO THE EAST OF THE SITE AND TO THE SOUTH
5:44:19PM OF THE SITE IS LAND RECOGNIZED UNDER THE PUBLIC/SEMI-PUBLIC
5:44:23PM DESIGNATION.
5:44:24PM AGAIN, THIS IS THE MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE TO THE BASE.
5:44:27PM THE GREEN LINES DENOTE THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA.
5:44:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: CAN YOU EXPLAIN TO ME TRANSITIONAL USE,
5:44:34PM THAT BIG RED AREA?
5:44:37PM >>DANNY COLLINS: SURE.
5:44:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHAT DOES THAT MEAN, THAT IT CAN
5:44:40PM TRANSITION INTO RESIDENTIAL, COMMERCIAL, NOT ONE WE
5:44:45PM TYPICALLY --
5:44:46PM >>DANNY COLLINS: TRANSITIONAL USE 24 DESIGNATION ALLOWS A
5:44:49PM BROAD RANGE OF USES.
5:44:50PM ANYTHING FROM MULTIFAMILY, SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL, LIKE
5:44:58PM COMMERCIAL, ALL THE WAY UP TO LIGHT INDUSTRIAL.
5:45:00PM IT'S ONE OF THE GOALS OF THE COMP PLAN TO PHASE THAT
5:45:06PM CATEGORY OUT.
5:45:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PHASE IT OUT.
5:45:08PM OKAY.
5:45:09PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:45:10PM >>DANNY COLLINS: HERE IS THE PROPOSED FUTURE LAND USE MAP
5:45:13PM SHOWING THE SUBJECT SITE UNDER THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35
5:45:16PM FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
5:45:18PM THE CMU 35 DESIGNATION ALLOWS DEVELOPMENT UP TO A 2.0 F.A.R.
5:45:23PM OR UP TO 35 DWELLING UNITS AN ACRE.
5:45:28PM ALLOWS ANYTHING FROM SINGLE-FAMILY TOWNHOMES AS WELL AS
5:45:35PM COMMERCIAL GENERAL USES AND MULTIFAMILY.
5:45:37PM HERE IS A SLIDE SHOWING THE POTENTIAL IMPACTS OF THE
5:45:43PM PROPOSED CHANGE.
5:45:44PM CURRENTLY UNDER THE LIGHT INDUSTRIAL DESIGNATION,
5:45:47PM RESIDENTIAL USES ARE NOT PERMITTED.
5:45:50PM UNDER THE LIGHT INDUSTRIAL DESIGNATION, JUST UNDER 1.2
5:45:54PM MILLION SQUARE FEET OF NONRESIDENTIAL USES CAN BE CONSIDERED
5:45:57PM ON THE SITE.
5:45:57PM SO ANYTHING FROM THE INDUSTRIAL USES OR COMMERCIAL USES.
5:46:02PM AS PROPOSED UNDER THE CMU 35, A MAXIMUM OF 641 DWELLING
5:46:08PM UNITS COULD BE CONSIDERED ON THE SITE OR JUST UNDER 1.6
5:46:12PM MILLION SQUARE FEET OF NONRESIDENTIAL OR RESIDENTIAL USES
5:46:16PM THROUGH A MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT COULD BE CONSIDERED UNDER
5:46:18PM THE CMU 35 DESIGNATION.
5:46:21PM SO THIS REQUEST WOULD INCREASE THE NONRESIDENTIAL INTENSITY
5:46:23PM ON THE SUBJECT SITE FROM A 1.5 F.A.R. TO 2.0 F.A.R.
5:46:28PM IT WOULD REMOVE CONSIDERATION OF INDUSTRIAL USES FROM THE
5:46:31PM SUBJECT SITE.
5:46:32PM AND IT WOULD ALSO INTRODUCE THE CONSIDERATION OF RESIDENTIAL
5:46:34PM USES ON THE SITE.
5:46:36PM THOUGH ON THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FOUND THE REQUEST
5:46:44PM CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, THIS WENT TO THE
5:46:47PM PLANNING COMMISSION A COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO ON AUGUST 14.
5:46:51PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOUND THE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH
5:46:55PM THE FOLLOWING POLICIES.
5:46:58PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOUND THE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH
5:46:59PM POLICIES THAT SEEK TO ENCOURAGE COMPATIBLE, COMPACT HIGHER
5:47:04PM DENSITY DEVELOPMENT.
5:47:05PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOUND THE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH
5:47:07PM LAND USE POLICY 2.1.2 THAT ENCOURAGES INFILL DEVELOPMENT ON
5:47:11PM VACANT AND UNDERUTILIZED SITES.
5:47:14PM FINALLY, THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOUND THE REQUEST
5:47:15PM CONSISTENT WITH HOUSING POLICY 1.3.1, WHICH SEEKS TO
5:47:19PM DESIGNATE SUFFICIENT LAND FOR RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT.
5:47:22PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION
5:47:29PM RECOMMENDS THE PROPOSED MAP AMENDMENT BE FOUND CONSISTENT
5:47:31PM WITH THE GOALS, OBJECTIVES, AND POLICIES OF THE TAMPA
5:47:34PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
5:47:35PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
5:47:36PM I'M AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
5:47:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THERE IS NO CITY PRESENTATION.
5:47:41PM STRICTLY PLANNING COMMISSION, CORRECT?
5:47:43PM >>DANNY COLLINS: NOT THAT I'M AWARE OF.
5:47:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:47:45PM ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN?
5:47:48PM >> JENNIFER MALONE, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
5:47:51PM I BELIEVE DANNY MISSPOKE.
5:47:54PM STAFF FOUND IT INCONSISTENT, BUT THE PLANNING COMMISSION
5:47:54PM VOTED CONSISTENCY.
5:47:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE BOARD VOTED CONSISTENT.
5:47:58PM THE STAFF SAID INCONSISTENT.
5:47:59PM >> YES.
5:48:04PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHAT DID THE STAFF FIND INCONSISTENT ABOUT
5:48:06PM THIS APPLICATION?
5:48:09PM >>DANNY COLLINS: WE FOUND IT INCONSISTENT WITH POLICIES THAT
5:48:12PM SEEK TO -- PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF, FOUND IT INCONSISTENT
5:48:15PM WITH THE INDUSTRIAL PROTECTION PRESERVATION POLICIES AS WELL
5:48:19PM AS POLICIES, SPEAK TO DEVELOPMENT IN THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD
5:48:22PM AREA.
5:48:23PM THIS WOULD INTRODUCE A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF RESIDENTIAL
5:48:26PM USES OR RESIDENTIAL SQUARE FOOTAGE OR UNITS WITHIN THE
5:48:30PM COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA.
5:48:33PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IN THE PROCESS OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION,
5:48:35PM HOW DID THE PLANNING COMMISSION COME TO ITS CONCLUSION WITH
5:48:37PM THE STAFF RECOMMENDATION, BUT CLEARLY, THIS ISN'T AN
5:48:43PM INDUSTRIAL AREA AND WITHIN THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA, HOW
5:48:46PM DID THOSE TWO MARRY EACH OTHER?
5:48:49PM >>DANNY COLLINS: IT WAS A PRETTY CLOSE VOTE.
5:48:52PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOUND THAT THE POLICIES THAT KIND OF
5:48:57PM SPEAK TO LIKE THE HOUSING POLICY COMPATIBLE INFILL
5:49:01PM DEVELOPMENT OUTWEIGHED SOME OF THE POLICIES THAT STAFF FOUND
5:49:05PM INCONSISTENT.
5:49:05PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OKAY.
5:49:06PM THANK YOU.
5:49:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:49:07PM YES, SIR.
5:49:11PM >> EVAN JOHNSON WITH CITY PLANNING STAFF.
5:49:14PM I DID WANT TO, ALSO FOLLOWING UP WITH THE PLANNING
5:49:18PM COMMISSION AS WELL, MENTIONED THAT WE DID HAVE STAFF
5:49:21PM OBJECTIONS TO THIS PARTICULAR AMENDMENT RELATED TO THE SAME
5:49:24PM ITEM THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF BROUGHT UP REGARDING
5:49:26PM INCREASE IN DENSITY IN THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA.
5:49:30PM AS WELL AS THE LOSS OF INDUSTRIAL LAND.
5:49:33PM I WANT TO MAKE SURE TO PUT THAT ON THE RECORD WITH YOU AS
5:49:36PM WELL SINCE I SAID WE DIDN'T HAVE A STAFF PRESENTATION.
5:49:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE AN APPLICANT FOR THIS ITEM,
5:49:41PM ITEM NUMBER 4?
5:49:42PM YES, MA'AM.
5:49:44PM >> GOOD EVENING.
5:49:45PM MY NAME IS ANGELA RAUBER.
5:49:47PM I'M WITH HILL WARD HENDERSON.
5:49:49PM 101 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD.
5:49:51PM I REPRESENT THE APPLICANT.
5:49:53PM THE FIRST THING I'D LIKE TO SAY IS JUST TO CLARIFY, PLANNING
5:49:58PM COMMISSION STAFF FOUND THE APPLICATION CONSISTENT WITH THE
5:50:03PM SAME LAND USE AND HOUSING GOALS THAT WERE CITED BY PLANNING
5:50:07PM COMMISSION IN MAKING ITS DECISION.
5:50:09PM SO THAT'S I THINK A PRETTY IMPORTANT POINT OF CLARIFICATION.
5:50:12PM GOING TO PUT THAT UP THERE.
5:50:15PM I'M HERE THIS EVENING WITH REPRESENTATIVES FROM THE
5:50:21PM DEVELOPER, WHICH IS MILL CREEK RESIDENTIAL.
5:50:24PM AND WE ALSO HAVE SOME CONSULTANTS FROM JR EVANS TO SPEAK TO
5:50:28PM THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD COASTAL MANAGEMENT EMERGENCY
5:50:32PM PREPAREDNESS KIND OF TOPICS.
5:50:33PM WE ALSO HAVE MICHAEL YATES TO TALK ABOUT TRANSPORTATION
5:50:39PM PLANNING.
5:50:40PM AT THIS POINT, I'M GOING TO TURN IT OVER TO MR. DAMON KOLB
5:50:40PM WITH THE DEVELOPER TO SPEAK TO THE DETAILS OF WHAT HE'S
5:50:46PM PROPOSING.
5:50:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR, GO AHEAD.
5:50:49PM >> DAMON KOLB WITH MILL CREEK RESIDENTIAL, 225 EAST
5:50:52PM ROBINSON, ORLANDO, FLORIDA.
5:50:53PM I'M HERE AS A LOCAL REPRESENTATIVE FOR MILL CREEK, THE
5:50:58PM PROPOSED DEVELOPER OF THE COMMUNITY.
5:50:59PM THE SUBJECT SITE REPRESENTS OUR FOURTH INVESTMENT IN CITY --
5:51:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: JUST A MOMENT.
5:51:04PM YES, MA'AM.
5:51:04PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I THOUGHT THIS WAS SIMPLY A COMPREHENSIVE
5:51:07PM PLAN CHANGE.
5:51:08PM WE SHOULDN'T BE HEARING ABOUT THE ACTUAL PLAN.
5:51:12PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. SHELBY.
5:51:13PM >>LYNN HURTAK: FOR THIS DEVELOPMENT.
5:51:15PM AM I CORRECT, MR. SHELBY?
5:51:18PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YES.
5:51:19PM THIS IS NOT A REZONING.
5:51:20PM THIS IS NOT QUASI-JUDICIAL.
5:51:22PM THIS IS A LEGISLATIVE MATTER.
5:51:23PM IT IS A POLICY DECISION BASED ON THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
5:51:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SO THE APPLICANT CANNOT DISCUSS FUTURE
5:51:29PM PLANS FOR THIS SITE, CORRECT?
5:51:31PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: WELL, LET ME SAY THIS, WHAT'S BEFORE YOU IS
5:51:37PM NOTHING RELATED TO THAT PARTICULAR PROJECT, AND IT IS NOT
5:51:39PM RELEVANT TO YOUR DECISION IN THE FACT THAT THEY ARE NOT --
5:51:45PM AGAIN, WHAT YOU SHOULD LOOK FOR IN A COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
5:51:47PM CHANGE IS THE MAXIMUM DEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL FOR THAT
5:51:50PM PROPERTY BECAUSE THERE IS NO OBLIGATION AS YOU SIT HERE
5:51:54PM TODAY FOR THE DEVELOPER TO MOVE FORWARD ON THAT.
5:51:57PM YOU'RE LOOKING SOLELY AS AMENDING THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
5:52:01PM AND THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP TO ALLOW WHATEVER DEVELOPMENT IS
5:52:05PM ALLOWED UNDER THAT CATEGORY.
5:52:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HE SHOULD REFRAIN FROM SHOWING ANY
5:52:12PM RENDERINGS OF WHAT A FUTURE REZONING WOULD HAVE OR ANYTHING
5:52:14PM LIKE THAT, CORRECT?
5:52:15PM OR HE SHOULD SPEAK IN GENERALITIES?
5:52:19PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: WELL, I GUESS HE COULD MAKE WHATEVER
5:52:22PM PRESENTATION HE WILL, BUT WHAT I WOULD BRING TO YOUR
5:52:24PM ATTENTION AT THE END OF THAT IS THAT IS REALLY NOT RELEVANT
5:52:27PM ULTIMATELY TO YOUR DECISION.
5:52:28PM YOU CAN LOOK AT IT IN THE ABSTRACT AS TO HOW IT FITS IN THE
5:52:34PM PARTICULAR CATEGORY.
5:52:35PM AGAIN, THE CHARACTERISTICS OF WHETHER YOU WANT TO CHANGE THE
5:52:39PM FUTURE LAND USE MAP OR TO -- TO WHAT IS BEING ASKED FOR,
5:52:46PM WHAT IS REQUESTED, AS OPPOSED TO WHAT IS PRESENTLY THERE
5:52:48PM TODAY.
5:52:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE SHOULD FOCUS ON THE FUTURE LAND USE
5:52:52PM CHANGE AND WHAT WAS DISCUSSED PERHAPS AT THE PLANNING
5:52:54PM COMMISSION OR WHAT WAS FOUND CONSISTENT OR INCONSISTENT, AND
5:52:57PM NOT FOCUS ON FUTURE PROJECTS ON THE SITE.
5:53:02PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THAT WOULD BE MY RECOMMENDATION.
5:53:04PM OF COURSE, THE APPLICANT MAY MAKE WHATEVER PRESENTATION THE
5:53:07PM APPLICANT CHOOSES TO.
5:53:08PM BUT IN TERMS OF YOUR DECISION, IT IS A POLICY DECISION OF
5:53:14PM THE CITY COUNCIL WITH REGARD TO THE FUTURE LAND USE OF THAT
5:53:17PM PROPERTY.
5:53:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: VERY GOOD.
5:53:18PM SORRY, SIR, GO AHEAD.
5:53:21PM >> I'M HERE TO PROVIDE SOME CONTEXT.
5:53:23PM THAT'S WHAT I'M HERE.
5:53:26PM NOT TO TALK DETAILS.
5:53:28PM FOURTH INVESTMENT IN THE CITY OF TAMPA AND SIXTH IN THE
5:53:30PM TAMPA BAY REGION.
5:53:31PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF OUR ONGOING
5:53:34PM DEVELOPMENT OF NEW HOMES IN DESIRABLE LOCATIONS THROUGHOUT
5:53:36PM THIS REGION.
5:53:37PM FURTHER CONTEXT ON WHY WE'RE HERE REQUESTING THE LAND USE
5:53:43PM CHANGE.
5:53:43PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS -- BECAME AVAILABLE FOR REDEVELOPMENT.
5:53:47PM AS THE SITE WAS ORIGINALLY UTILIZED AS A WAIT POINT FOR
5:53:51PM DRYWALL DELIVERIES FROM THE PORT OF TAMPA BAY.
5:53:53PM HOWEVER, THE MAJORITY OF THOSE FACILITIES HAVE SINCE
5:53:55PM RELOCATED TO THE APOLLO BEACH AND GIBSONTON AREA.
5:53:59PM THE SITE IS CURRENTLY UTILIZED FOR TRUCK STORAGE AND A RELAY
5:54:02PM POINT FOR DELIVERIES.
5:54:03PM WHEN WE BEGAN WORKING WITH THE LANDOWNER OVER A YEAR AGO,
5:54:07PM THE OWNER ADMITTED THE CURRENT USE WAS NO LONGER COMPATIBLE
5:54:10PM WITH THE ADJACENT RESIDENTIAL USES AND EXPANSION OF THE
5:54:13PM TRUCKING FACILITY WAS NOT A LONG-TERM SOLUTION AND THAT HE
5:54:16PM WAS SEEKING OTHER SITES OUTSIDE OF THIS AREA.
5:54:20PM TONIGHT, WE'RE HERE REGARDING THE CHANGE IN LAND USE.
5:54:22PM THE FIRST STEP IN THE APPROVAL PROCESS.
5:54:25PM IN CONJUNCTION WITH OUR INITIAL SUBMITTAL, WE MET WITH SOG
5:54:29PM LEADERSHIP AND HELD A COMMUNITY MEETING IN SOUTH OF GANDY.
5:54:32PM WE MODIFIED OUR LAND USE APPLICATION THAT'S BEFORE YOU
5:54:36PM TONIGHT BASED ON CONSTRUCTIVE FEEDBACK FROM SOG.
5:54:41PM SPECIFICALLY SOG REQUESTED RETAIL USES IN THE INCLUSION OF
5:54:44PM UNIT TYPES FOR FAMILIES DUE TO THE ONGOING HOUSING NEEDS AT
5:54:47PM MacDILL.
5:54:48PM WE ADDRESSED BOTH OF THE ITEMS IN THE COMPANION PD PLAN THAT
5:54:52PM WILL COME AT A LATER DATE.
5:54:54PM THAT WAS SUBMITTED TO THE CITY THIS WEEK.
5:54:56PM SPECIFICALLY, WE INCLUDED COMMUNITY SERVING RETAIL AND
5:54:58PM INCORPORATED THREE-BEDROOM TOWNHOMES INTO OUR DESIGN.
5:55:02PM A TOTAL OF 30% OF OUR PROPOSED UNITS ARE THREE BEDROOMS,
5:55:06PM WHICH IS SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER PERCENTAGE THAN THE ADJACENT
5:55:09PM COMMUNITIES.
5:55:10PM THE LAND USE DOESN'T REQUIRE THIS.
5:55:11PM THE ZONING CODE DOESN'T REQUIRE THIS.
5:55:13PM BUT WE'RE PROVIDING A MIX OF HOUSING OPTIONS AND
5:55:16PM NEIGHBORHOOD SERVING RETAIL IN OUR COMMUNITY ADJACENT TO ONE
5:55:19PM OF TAMPA'S LARGEST SINGLE-SITE EMPLOYERS.
5:55:22PM AND WE VIEW THIS AS A WIN-WIN.
5:55:24PM WITH THAT, I'LL TURN IT BACK TO ANGELA TO TAKE YOU THROUGH
5:55:27PM THE COMPATIBILITY.
5:55:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
5:55:28PM YES, MA'AM.
5:55:34PM >> SO WE'VE TALKED A LITTLE BIT ALREADY ABOUT WHERE THIS IS
5:55:41PM LOCATED.
5:55:42PM TO REITERATE, IT IS SOUTH OF GANDY AND IN A PREDOMINANTLY
5:55:45PM MIXED USE NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:55:46PM IT IS SURROUNDED ON THREE SIDES BY EXISTING RESIDENTIAL
5:55:51PM SITES.
5:55:51PM AGAIN, WE'RE ASKING FOR THAT COMMUNITY MIXED USE DESIGNATION
5:55:57PM WHICH IS CONSISTENT WITH THE TRANSITIONAL USES AND THE
5:56:00PM EXISTING USES THAT ARE IN THE AREA.
5:56:03PM LOOKING AT THIS, YOU CAN SEE THAT THERE'S RESIDENTIAL LAND
5:56:05PM USE CATEGORIES OR CATEGORIES THAT ALLOW RESIDENTIAL, SUCH AS
5:56:09PM THE TRANSITIONAL USES ON THREE SIDES OF THIS PROPERTY.
5:56:13PM MAKING SURE IT'S LINED UP HERE.
5:56:19PM THE SITE WAS FOUND TO BE COMPATIBLE WITH THE SURROUNDING
5:56:32PM NEIGHBORHOOD BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION, AND IN SUPPORT OF
5:56:35PM THAT, THEY REFERENCED SPECIFIC HOUSING AND LAND USE GOALS IN
5:56:43PM MAKING THAT DETERMINATION.
5:56:45PM THEY ARE MULTIFAMILY APARTMENTS TO THE NORTH.
5:56:47PM THERE ARE MULTIFAMILY APARTMENTS TO THE EAST OF THE SITE.
5:56:51PM ALSO TO THE WEST, THERE ARE EXISTING TOWNHOME UNITS, AND
5:56:55PM THEN MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE TO THE SOUTH.
5:56:56PM WE BELIEVE, AS PLANNING COMMISSION FOUND, THIS IS CONSISTENT
5:57:05PM WITH THE EXISTING MIXED USE NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:57:07PM I WON'T GO INTO TOO MUCH DETAIL ABOUT THE EXISTING PD, BUT
5:57:12PM THERE HAS BEEN A COMPANION PD ZONING SUBMITTED.
5:57:16PM AGAIN, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF CITED SEVERAL LAND USE
5:57:25PM GOALS IN SUPPORT OF ITS CONSISTENCY FINDINGS FOR LAND USE
5:57:28PM AND HOUSING.
5:57:30PM ULTIMATELY, THEY WEIGHED IN FAVOR OF THE PRESERVATION OF
5:57:33PM INDUSTRIAL AND THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA, BUT THEY CITED
5:57:40PM NUMEROUS LAND USE AND HOUSING STRATEGIES IN SUPPORT OF
5:57:45PM FINDING OF CONSISTENCY.
5:57:51PM THE EXISTING DEVELOPMENT IS A TRUCKING TERMINAL CURRENTLY,
5:57:54PM WHICH IS UTILIZING ONLY A FRACTION OF ITS AVAILABLE
5:57:59PM INTENSITY ON THAT INDUSTRIAL ZONED SITE.
5:58:02PM ONE IMPORTANT POINT IS THAT THE SUBJECT SITE IS ZONED LIGHT
5:58:07PM INDUSTRIAL.
5:58:07PM SO EVEN WITHOUT A FUTURE LAND USE AMENDMENT, LIVE LOCAL
5:58:11PM WOULD ALLOW RESIDENTIAL USES IN THIS -- ON THIS PROPERTY.
5:58:15PM THE PROPOSED SITE -- THE PROPOSAL, WE BELIEVE, IS A MORE
5:58:26PM SUITABLE DEVELOPMENT THAN WHAT COULD BE ALLOWED UNDER THE
5:58:30PM EXISTING FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY.
5:58:34PM AND AS FOR TRANSPORTATION -- I'M SORRY.
5:58:38PM AS FOR INDUSTRIAL USES, THIS SITE IS -- IT'S KIND OF
5:58:44PM INCOMPATIBLE AS AN INDUSTRIAL USE WITH WHAT'S GROWN UP
5:58:48PM AROUND IT.
5:58:48PM OVER TIME, THIS AREA HAS TRANSITIONED FROM ITS INDUSTRIAL
5:58:51PM CHARACTER TO A MIXED USE RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL
5:58:55PM NEIGHBORHOOD, AND AS FOR COASTAL MANAGEMENT POLICIES, THERE
5:59:01PM IS NOTHING IN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN THAT PROHIBITS
5:59:05PM INCREASED DENSITY WITHIN THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA, BUT
5:59:09PM IT DOES REQUIRE THE EVALUATION OF EVACUATION TIMES, ROUTES,
5:59:14PM AND SHELTER -- AVAILABLE SHELTER CAPACITY.
5:59:18PM I WOULD SAY THAT DURING CITY STAFF REVIEW, THERE WERE NO
5:59:21PM OBJECTIONS FROM EITHER TRANSPORTATION OR EMERGENCY
5:59:25PM MANAGEMENT.
5:59:26PM AND TO SPEAK MORE ABOUT THE COASTAL MANAGEMENT POLICIES, I'M
5:59:30PM GOING TO TURN IT OVER TO OUR REPRESENTATIVES FROM JR EVANS.
5:59:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:59:36PM YES, SIR.
5:59:43PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL MEMBERS.
5:59:44PM MY NAME IS JIM VONRINTELN.
5:59:47PM I'M WITH JR EVANS ENGINEERING.
5:59:50PM I'M A CERTIFIED EMERGENCY MANAGER NATIONALLY AND IN FLORIDA,
5:59:52PM AS WELL AS A CERTIFIED FLOODPLAIN MANAGER FOR THE LAST 25
5:59:55PM YEARS.
5:59:55PM ALSO, 15 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE AS AN EMERGENCY MANAGER DOWN IN
5:59:59PM COLLIER COUNTY, WHERE I OVERSAW 17 EVACUATIONS AND
6:00:03PM SHELTERING OPERATIONS, MOST OF THEM MAJOR.
6:00:07PM I WAS ASKED TO TAKE A LOOK AT THIS PROJECT AND ANALYZE THE
6:00:10PM IMPACT ON EVACUATION AND SHELTERING, AND MY DETAILED
6:00:15PM ANALYSIS IS IN YOUR REPORT.
6:00:17PM ESSENTIALLY, I FOUND NO SIGNIFICANT IMPACT HERE, EVACUATION
6:00:23PM OR SHELTERING, CONSISTENT WITH YOUR EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT
6:00:27PM STAFF FINDING.
6:00:28PM IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, HAPPY TO ANSWER THEM.
6:00:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
6:00:31PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
6:00:33PM WHO IS NEXT?
6:00:41PM >> WE WOULD ALSO ASK MR. YATES TO COME UP AND PRESENT SOME
6:00:45PM INFORMATION REGARDING THE TRANSPORTATION ANALYSIS.
6:00:50PM >> GOOD EVENING.
6:00:51PM MICHAEL YATES WITH PALM TRAFFIC.
6:00:53PM WE DID A TRIP GENERATION COMPARISON.
6:01:06PM FOR THE EXISTING GENERAL LIGHT INDUSTRIAL THAT COULD BE
6:01:08PM DEVELOPED ON THE SITE, WHICH WAS REFERENCED IN THE
6:01:10PM PRESENTATION, YOU CAN SEE FROM THIS, THAT WOULD GENERATE
6:01:14PM 5800 DAILY TRIPS.
6:01:16PM 800 A.M. PEAK HOUR TRIPS AND ALMOST 800 P.M. PEAK HOUR
6:01:21PM TRIPS.
6:01:22PM WE ALSO LOOKED AT THE LIVE LOCAL ACT WHICH COULD ALLOW FOR
6:01:26PM UP TO 1800 RESIDENTIAL DWELLING UNITS.
6:01:28PM THAT HAD VERY SIMILAR NUMBERS.
6:01:31PM 8,000 DAILY TRIPS.
6:01:34PM 666 A.M. PEAK HOUR TRIPS AND 702 P.M. PEAK HOUR TRIPS.
6:01:39PM AND THEN WE ALSO LOOKED AT WHAT IS PROPOSED UNDER THE ZONING
6:01:42PM THAT WOULD BE COMING AFTER THIS.
6:01:47PM SIGNIFICANTLY LESS TRIPS.
6:01:48PM 2766, 151 A.M. PEAK HOUR, AND 235 P.M. PEAK HOUR TRIPS.
6:01:55PM HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU HAVE.
6:02:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
6:02:01PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
6:02:03PM >> THAT ENDS OUR PRESENTATION.
6:02:05PM ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU MAY HAVE, WE WOULD WELCOME THEM.
6:02:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME?
6:02:08PM IF NOT, WE'LL GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT.
6:02:10PM ALL RIGHT.
6:02:11PM I HAVE ONE PERSON ONLINE.
6:02:13PM IS THAT CORRECT, FOR THIS ITEM, JEAN STROHMEYER?
6:02:15PM KALI OR BENJAMIN.
6:02:19PM WE HAVE JEAN AND BENJAMIN.
6:02:22PM IF YOU COULD TURN ON YOUR CAMERAS, RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND
6:02:25PM WE'LL SWEAR YOU IN.
6:02:26PM SO WE HAVE ALL THREE.
6:02:28PM OH, I'M SORRY.
6:02:30PM YEAH, WE GOT RID OF THOSE.
6:02:33PM IF YOU HAVE ANY SPEAKER WAIVER FORMS, MY LEGISLATIVE AIDE
6:02:38PM LISA WILL TAKE THEM.
6:02:39PM LISA, DO YOU WANT TO READ THE NAMES OUT OR DO YOU WANT ME TO
6:02:42PM READ THE NAMES?
6:02:43PM >> I'LL READ THE NAMES.
6:02:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE'LL GO TO THE THREE REGISTERED
6:02:46PM SPEAKERS.
6:02:46PM FIRST UP IS JEAN STROHMEYER.
6:02:48PM PLEASE TURN ON YOUR CAMERA, UNMUTE YOURSELF, AND YOU HAVE
6:02:52PM THREE MINUTES.
6:02:57PM >> HELLO.
6:02:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
6:03:00PM CAN YOU TURN YOUR CAMERA ON?
6:03:03PM >> CAN YOU HEAR ME?
6:03:04PM BECAUSE I HAVEN'T DONE THIS IN A WHILE.
6:03:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, WE CAN HEAR YOU.
6:03:09PM >> FRANKLY, I THOUGHT THIS WAS GOING TO BE
6:03:10PM NON-QUASI-JUDICIAL.
6:03:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IT IS.
6:03:12PM IT'S NON-QUASI-JUDICIAL.
6:03:14PM IT WAS MY MISTAKE.
6:03:14PM THAT'S BENJAMIN.
6:03:21PM WE NEED TO GET JEAN ON.
6:03:23PM JEAN, IS YOUR CAMERA ON?
6:03:24PM >> IT'S ON.
6:03:25PM CAN YOU HEAR ME?
6:03:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE CAN HEAR YOU, JUST CAN'T SEE YOU.
6:03:30PM >> OH, SHARE WEB CAM.
6:03:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE CAN SEE YOU AND HEAR YOU.
6:03:37PM >> BEEN A VERY LONG TIME.
6:03:39PM WELCOME ALL THE NEWBIES THAT I'VE NEVER SEEN BEFORE.
6:03:45PM I VOTED FOR SOME OF YOU, AND I HOPE YOU DO WHAT IS RIGHT.
6:03:50PM READY?
6:03:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
6:03:51PM GO AHEAD.
6:03:52PM YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
6:03:53PM WE'LL START THE CLOCK.
6:03:54PM >> THANK YOU.
6:03:54PM MY NAME IS JEAN STROHMEYER.
6:03:58PM I LIVE SOUTH OF GANDY FOR 32 YEARS.
6:04:01PM I PURCHASED MY AFFORDABLE HOME AT THE TENDER AGE OF 23.
6:04:05PM MY DAUGHTER, WHO JUST TURNED 24, UNFORTUNATELY FELT SHE HAD
6:04:10PM TO LEAVE TAMPA BECAUSE IT WAS INACCESSIBLE TO HER
6:04:13PM COLLEGE-EDUCATED SELF THAT I PAID FOR AND MOVED TO NEW
6:04:16PM JERSEY SO SHE COULD AFFORD TO LIVE SOMEWHERE.
6:04:19PM ISN'T THAT A JOKE?
6:04:21PM BUT IT'S TRUE.
6:04:22PM THIS PROPERTY INTERBAY 7400 IS LIGHT INDUSTRIAL.
6:04:25PM IT'S NOT RESIDENTIAL.
6:04:26PM THEY DON'T DESERVE RESIDENTIAL.
6:04:28PM WE DON'T NEED RESIDENTIAL.
6:04:29PM IF YOU ALL REMEMBER, THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD IS SUPPOSED TO
6:04:32PM BE NO RESIDENTIAL, NO-BUILD UP OF RESIDENTIAL SOUTH OF GANDY
6:04:37PM OR NEW TAMPA.
6:04:39PM RIGHT, MR. VIERA.
6:04:40PM THANK YOU SO MUCH.
6:04:40PM WE'VE BEEN ROBBED, ALL OF OUR NONRESIDENTIAL LAND OVER THE
6:04:44PM PAST FEW YEARS.
6:04:44PM I BELIEVE IT WAS DONE BY DESIGN WITH THE HELP OF SOME
6:04:47PM DISHONEST AND EVEN CORRUPT, I'M SORRY TO SAY, PLAYERS IN THE
6:04:51PM CITY OF TAMPA.
6:04:51PM I'VE SEEN SOME FOLKS, BOUGHT AND PAID FOR WITH OUR OWN TAX
6:04:55PM DOLLARS YET OUR ADMINISTRATION IS TRYING TO SQUEEZE SOME
6:04:57PM MORE OUT OF US.
6:04:59PM BUMMER.
6:05:00PM SHE DIDN'T LIE WHEN SHE SAID SHE WOULD FUNDAMENTALLY CHANGE
6:05:04PM AND OUR CITY WOULD BE UNRECOGNIZABLE.
6:05:06PM THAT WAS THE TRUTH.
6:05:07PM THE ONLY ONE I KNOW.
6:05:09PM BACK TO THE ISSUE, MY NEIGHBORHOOD, MY HOME FOR SO MANY
6:05:12PM YEARS IS UNRECOGNIZABLE.
6:05:13PM IT'S THAT WAY BECAUSE OF OUR NONRESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES ARE
6:05:18PM LOST DUE TO THE RECKLESS DISREGARD FOR OUR SAFETY AND
6:05:21PM QUALITY OF LIFE, WHICH IS IN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:05:24PM OUR QUALITY OF LIFE COUNTS.
6:05:26PM SO WITH THAT SAID, 6 -- 205 NEW UNITS, 7701 INTERBAY, 216.
6:05:34PM 5340, 500.
6:05:36PM 5105, TYSON, 325, 7210 INTERBAY, 350.
6:05:41PM 5301 TYSON, 325.
6:05:44PM 5411 TYSON, 799.
6:05:48PM ANOTHER 76, 256.
6:05:50PM ALL OF WESTSHORE YACHT CLUB PROPERTY, INCLUDING THE TOWER
6:05:54PM NOT YET BUILT, APPROVED TOTALING 8 -- 79 UNITS.
6:06:01PM DOUBLE THAT BY THE PEOPLE, TWO PEOPLE PER UNIT, THAT'S
6:06:04PM 17,000 EXTRA PEOPLE.
6:06:05PM YOU WANT TO TALK ABOUT TRIPS.
6:06:07PM IT DOESN'T MATTER IF THEY HAVE A TRIP TO WORK.
6:06:09PM IT'S ABOUT GETTING OUT OF HERE.
6:06:11PM WE TOOK 30 MINUTES TO GO FROM INTERBAY TO GANDY JUST TWO
6:06:15PM DAYS AGO WHEN WE WERE STUCK HERE.
6:06:18PM YOU ALL DON'T LISTEN TO THIS.
6:06:19PM DON'T LET THEM LIE TO YOU.
6:06:21PM OH, BY THE WAY, WE'RE NOT SUPPOSED TO HAVE BUILDING DOWN
6:06:25PM HERE AT ALL.
6:06:26PM THAT IS A BULL.
6:06:27PM IF YOU PAY FOR SOME EXPERT TO TELL YOU THAT IT'S OKAY TO
6:06:30PM HAVE ANOTHER 17,000 PEOPLE DOWN HERE, THEY ARE LYING.
6:06:33PM BECAUSE THEY ARE PAID FOR.
6:06:35PM THIS IS ZONED LIGHT INDUSTRIAL.
6:06:36PM IT'S OCCUPIED BY TRUCKING COMPANY.
6:06:38PM IT'S USED DAILY.
6:06:39PM BUT THEY DON'T EVACUATE FROM THEIR JOB.
6:06:41PM THEY EVACUATE FROM APARTMENT.
6:06:44PM WE'RE TALKING, AGAIN, 17,000 NEW PEOPLE.
6:06:48PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:06:48PM VOTE NO.
6:06:49PM OH, THAT'S NOT RIGHT.
6:06:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU'RE DONE.
6:06:54PM [ LAUGHTER ]
6:06:54PM BENJAMIN WARD.
6:06:55PM BENJAMIN WARD, YOU'RE UP.
6:06:59PM YOU'RE MUTED, SIR.
6:07:05PM PLEASE UNMUTE YOURSELF.
6:07:08PM >> CAN YOU HEAR ME?
6:07:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR, GO AHEAD.
6:07:10PM >> I HAD A HARD TIME FINDING THAT MUTE BUTTON.
6:07:13PM I'M ASKING THAT YOU DENY THIS TA/CPA 23-03.
6:07:18PM I THINK IT'S INCONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:07:20PM THERE WASN'T ENOUGH TIME NOTIFIED FOR US TO DO THIS AND THE
6:07:25PM PROPERTY IS IN THE EVACUATION ZONE A, AND THAT'S ALWAYS A
6:07:27PM BIG ISSUE.
6:07:28PM LIVING SOUTH OF TAMPA, WE JUST HAD TO DEAL WITH THE
6:07:31PM EVACUATION THIS PAST WEEK, AND IT'S ALWAYS A PROBLEM.
6:07:34PM IT'S A PROBLEM WHEN WE'RE NOT BEING FORCED TO EVACUATE.
6:07:38PM THIS ADDS MORE TO THE ISSUE.
6:07:39PM I THINK IT WOULD NOT BE A GOOD IDEA TO HAVE THIS.
6:07:42PM THAT'S ALL I HAVE TO SAY.
6:07:43PM THANK YOU.
6:07:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
6:07:47PM KALI, YOU'RE NEXT.
6:07:50PM >> HI.
6:07:51PM MY NAME IS KALI DENAULT.
6:07:53PM PORT TAMPA CIVIC ASSOCIATION PRESIDENT.
6:07:55PM I ASK YOU PLEASE TO DENY THIS REQUEST.
6:07:57PM AFTER THIS STORM --
6:08:05PM [INDISCERNIBLE]
6:08:05PM -- THE APARTMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN BUILT UP CAUSE SO MUCH
6:08:10PM FLOODING ON PROPERTIES THAT --
6:08:14PM [INDISCERNIBLE]
6:08:14PM LIVED HERE FOR YEARS AND YEARS.
6:08:21PM [INDISCERNIBLE]
6:08:21PM I ASK THAT YOU DENY IT AND DON'T ALLOW DOUBLE WHAT IS
6:08:29PM CURRENTLY BEING BUILT ON INTERBAY.
6:08:33PM THE INFRASTRUCTURE DOWN HERE JUST CAN'T TAKE IT.
6:08:35PM THE SEWER SYSTEM CAN'T TAKE IT.
6:08:37PM I KNOW THEY BUILD BIGGER SEWERS WHEN THE APARTMENTS GO UP,
6:08:40PM BUT THE EXISTING INFRASTRUCTURE CAN'T HANDLE ALL OF IT.
6:08:43PM I ASK YOU ON BEHALF OF THE PORT TAMPA CIVIC ASSOCIATION TO
6:08:45PM DENY THIS.
6:08:46PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:08:47PM THAT CONCLUDES OUR VIRTUAL SPEAKERS.
6:08:51PM WE NOW GO TO THE IN-PERSON PUBLIC COMMENT.
6:08:54PM IF WE HAVE ANY SPEAKER WAIVER FORMS, MS. EDWARDS IS GOING TO
6:08:58PM CALL YOUR NAME.
6:08:59PM IF YOU ARE HERE, PLEASE RAISE YOUR HAND.
6:09:02PM YES, MA'AM.
6:09:06PM >> [NOT SPEAKING INTO A MICROPHONE]
6:09:26PM [ENCODER DROP]
6:09:44PM >> HELLO.
6:09:45PM I AM JAISHEKIA KOWALWSKI.
6:09:48PM THIS IS PENELOPE KOWALWSKI, PENNY.
6:09:53PM WE LIVE IN SOUTH TOWN PARK IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD ADJACENT TO
6:09:57PM THE TRUCKING COMPANY WHERE I ALSO HAPPEN TO BE THE HOA
6:10:02PM PRESIDENT.
6:10:02PM AND I'M ASKING YOU THIS EVENING TO PLEASE VOTE NO.
6:10:09PM I'VE LOST MY TRAIN OF THOUGHT BEING THAT I HAVE THE BABY
6:10:11PM RIGHT NOW, BUT JUST SOME OF THE MAIN POINTS THAT COME TO
6:10:14PM MIND, WE DON'T NEED ADDITIONAL APARTMENTS.
6:10:18PM WE NEED RETAIL.
6:10:19PM WE NEED THINGS THAT ARE GOING TO BRING JOBS INTO THE
6:10:23PM COMMUNITY.
6:10:23PM THE ADDITIONAL PERSONNEL COMING INTO SOUTH TAMPA NOT ONLY
6:10:29PM POSES A HAZARD FROM AN EVACUATION STANDPOINT AND CONGESTING
6:10:34PM ROADS AND THINGS LIKE THAT, BUT SOME OF THE OTHER EFFECTS
6:10:37PM THAT DON'T SEEM TO BE MEASURED IN THIS FORUM IS HOW IT
6:10:41PM CAUSES CONTENTION AND DIVISION WITHIN A COMMUNITY, BECAUSE
6:10:46PM WHAT YOU DON'T SEE IS THAT THERE IS A LOT OF DIVISION WITH
6:10:50PM THE OLD TIME SOGERS VERSUS THE NEW-TIME FOLKS.
6:10:54PM WHEN YOU CONSTANTLY ALLOW THIS CONSTANT BUILDING, YOU'RE
6:10:57PM CAUSING AN UNINTENTIONAL CONSEQUENCE OF DIVISION IN THE
6:11:00PM COMMUNITY.
6:11:01PM SORRY ABOUT THAT.
6:11:05PM ADDITIONALLY, AGAIN, BACK TO RETAIL, NO ONE IS DRIVING
6:11:12PM THROUGH SOUTH OF GANDY AND SAYING, GEE, YOU KNOW WHAT THESE
6:11:16PM PEOPLE NEED, ADDITIONAL APARTMENTS, LIKE THEY REALLY NEED
6:11:18PM MORE.
6:11:18PM NO, THEY ARE SAYING THAT WE NEED BUSINESSES.
6:11:20PM WE NEED STUFF TO ACTUALLY SUSTAIN THE PEOPLE THAT WE
6:11:24PM CONSTANTLY BRING INTO THE COMMUNITY.
6:11:26PM THAT'S ALL I HAVE.
6:11:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:11:28PM NEXT SPEAKER.
6:11:33PM CARROLL ANN, DO YOU HAVE VIDEOS?
6:11:37PM >> I DO.
6:11:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO YOU WANT THE VIDEOS FIRST?
6:11:39PM >> NO, I'LL TELL THEM WHEN I WANT THEM TO PLAY THEM.
6:11:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: CUE THE VIDEOS.
6:11:47PM YOU HAVE NINE MINUTES.
6:11:56PM >> HI.
6:11:57PM MY NAME IS CARROLL ANN BENNETT.
6:11:58PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION BOARD HAD TO VOTE ON THIS TWICE
6:12:02PM BECAUSE THE FIRST VOTE WAS A TIE.
6:12:04PM FOR SOME REASON, THE BOARD MEMBERS KEPT ASKING ABOUT THE
6:12:06PM EVACUATION TIME FOR JUST THIS SPECIFIC NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:12:10PM THEY COULDN'T GET THAT ANSWER BECAUSE EVACUATION TIMES WERE
6:12:13PM EVALUATED BY ZONE, A, B, C, ET CETERA.
6:12:17PM THIS REALLY SEEMED TO CONFUSE THEM AND I BELIEVE SOME OF
6:12:20PM THEM VOTED FOR THIS AS CONSISTENT BECAUSE OF THAT CONFUSION.
6:12:23PM BOTH THE CITY STAFF AND PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FOUND THIS
6:12:26PM AMENDMENT INCONSISTENT AND ONE OF THE THINGS THEY CITED WAS
6:12:29PM THE FACT THAT WE ARE ALREADY FAILING THE CURRENT EVACUATION
6:12:33PM LEVEL OF SERVICE REQUIRED BY THE STATE.
6:12:35PM UNFORTUNATELY, THE BOARD MISSED THAT FACT.
6:12:38PM AT LEAST ONE MEMBER ADMITTED THEY HADN'T READ THE STAFF
6:12:42PM REPORTS.
6:12:42PM I REITERATE BOTH CITY STAFF AND PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
6:12:45PM FOUND THIS AMENDMENT INCONSISTENT.
6:12:46PM I ASK THAT YOU ALSO RECOGNIZE THAT THERE IS A VERY, VERY BAD
6:12:50PM IDEA.
6:12:50PM I WANT TO REMIND YOU THAT THIS IS A LEGISLATIVE NOT
6:12:53PM QUASI-JUDICIAL AND THE BAR FOR LEGISLATION IS MUCH LOWER.
6:12:57PM YOU DO NOT HAVE TO RISE TO THE LEVEL OF COMPETENT AND
6:13:00PM SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE AND THE APPLICANT DOES NOT HAVE THE
6:13:02PM SAME LEGAL TOOLS OF RETALIATION.
6:13:04PM NO MATTER HOW MANY UNITS THEY SAY THEY WILL BUILD, THIS
6:13:07PM CHANGE WILL ALLOW 641 DWELLING UNITS AND THAT RIGHT TRAVELS
6:13:10PM WITH THE LAND.
6:13:11PM IF THEY CHANGE THEIR MIND, IF IT IS SOLD, THEY CAN BUILD 641
6:13:15PM UNITS.
6:13:16PM THAT'S 641 UNITS IN EVACUATION ZONE A, THE COASTAL HIGH
6:13:20PM HAZARD AREA, SPECIAL FLOOD ZONE AE, THE 100-YEAR FLOODPLAIN
6:13:25PM AND SFHA, SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA.
6:13:28PM IT VIOLATES COMP PLAN OBJECTIVE 1.1 WHICH CALLS FOR NO NET
6:13:33PM INCREASE IN RESIDENTIAL DENSITY IN CHHA, THE CHHA RECOGNIZED
6:13:38PM BY THE COMP PLAN.
6:13:39PM IT WOULD ELIMINATE THE POTENTIAL FOR INDUSTRIAL AND
6:13:41PM COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT.
6:13:42PM MANY MUNICIPALITIES BELATEDLY REALIZING THE SHORTSIGHTEDNESS
6:13:47PM OF ALLOWING THE LOSS OF THEIR INDUSTRIAL LAND.
6:13:49PM THE SOUTH TAMPA COMMUNITY WANTS THIS PROPERTY TO REMAIN
6:13:52PM INDUSTRIAL BECAUSE IT PROVIDES JOBS AND IT DOES NOT HARM
6:13:54PM EVACUATION TIMES.
6:13:55PM PEOPLE EVACUATE FROM THEIR HOMES, NOT THEIR WORKPLACES, SO
6:13:59PM KEEPING THIS NONRESIDENTIAL IS A WIN-WIN FOR SOUTH TAMPA.
6:14:02PM THE STAFF ANALYSES SAID THIS REQUEST CONFLICTS WITH THE COMP
6:14:08PM PLAN'S INDUSTRIAL PROTECTION AND PRESERVATION POLICIES.
6:14:11PM THE REQUEST IS INCONSISTENT WITH THE POLICY WHICH SEEKS THE
6:14:14PM PRESERVATION OF INDUSTRIAL LANDS.
6:14:16PM THE PLAN RECOGNIZES INDUSTRIAL LANDS AS KEY ECONOMIC ENGINES
6:14:21PM AND SEEKS TO STRENGTHEN TAMPA'S ROLE AS A REGIONAL
6:14:24PM EMPLOYMENT CENTER.
6:14:25PM THE PROXIMITY TO OLD PORT TAMPA AND RELATED INDUSTRIAL USES
6:14:28PM MAKES THE SUBJECT SITE STILL VIABLE FOR PORT RELATED
6:14:32PM INDUSTRIAL USES.
6:14:33PM THIS REQUEST WILL REMOVE 18.32 ACRES OF LIGHT INDUSTRIAL
6:14:38PM LAND.
6:14:38PM STAFF CITED -- CITY STAFF CITED INCONSISTENCIES WITH LU
6:14:43PM POLICIES 8.9.1, POINT TWO AND POINT THREE.
6:14:47PM IT IS INCONSISTENT WITH POLICIES TO MAINTAIN INDUSTRIAL
6:14:49PM AREAS AND ENCOURAGE THE CONTINUED EXISTENCE OF INDUSTRIAL
6:14:52PM WAREHOUSING AND DISTRIBUTION ACTIVITIES TO PROVIDE A RANGE
6:14:55PM OF EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES.
6:14:56PM STAFF SAID, THE PRESERVATION OF INDUSTRIAL LANDS AND PUBLIC
6:14:59PM SAFETY OUTWEIGH THE BENEFITS OF A MEDIUM DENSITY MIXED USE
6:15:04PM DEVELOPMENT ON THIS SITE THAT IS NOT LOCATED IN URBAN
6:15:07PM VILLAGE OR EMPLOYMENT CENTER.
6:15:08PM STAFF STATED MAINTAINING AND IMPROVING EVACUATION TIMES IS
6:15:13PM CRITICAL CONSIDERING THE COUNTY IS NOT MEETING ITS
6:15:15PM EVACUATION LEVEL OF SERVICE, CM POLICIES 1.1.2 AND POINT 6.
6:15:21PM ON SEPTEMBER 30, 2021, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF AND THE
6:15:24PM CITY'S PLANNING DEPARTMENT MADE A PRESENTATION TO CITY
6:15:27PM COUNCIL.
6:15:27PM PLEASE PLAY THE FIRST VIDEO.
6:15:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD AND PLAY THE VIDEO.
6:15:38PM >> THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ESTABLISHES UNIQUE VISIONS FOR THE
6:15:41PM NEW TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT AND SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING
6:15:43PM DISTRICT.
6:15:44PM THOSE EXCERPTS ARE SHOWN ON YOUR SCREEN.
6:15:46PM AND THESE ARE BASED UPON, WITH THE PLANNER, LIMITED GROWTH
6:15:50PM OPPORTUNITIES IN THESE AREAS.
6:15:51PM AND THE RESEARCH THAT WE PERFORMED, YOU CAN SEE THIS SLIDE
6:15:55PM DISPLAYS THE RESIDENTIAL GROWTH THAT HAS OCCURRED IN THE
6:15:58PM CITY OVER THE PAST TEN YEARS.
6:16:00PM THE MOST RECENT TEN YEARS OF GROWTH IS BROKEN INTO FIVE-YEAR
6:16:04PM INCREMENTS.
6:16:05PM THE 2010 RESIDENTIAL UNITS ARE SHOWN IN GRAY AND THE GROWTH
6:16:09PM THAT OCCURS FROM 2010 TO 2015, THAT INCREASE IS SHOWN IN
6:16:14PM DARK BLUE AND THE GROWTH THAT OCCURRED FROM 2015 TO 2020 IS
6:16:19PM SHOWN IN RED.
6:16:20PM THE TWO DISTRICTS THAT HAVE SEEN THE HIGHEST RESIDENTIAL
6:16:23PM GROWTH IN THAT PERIOD ARE THE NEW TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT
6:16:26PM AND THE SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT.
6:16:29PM THIS TREND IS NOT IN LINE WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN'S
6:16:32PM VISION FOR GROWTH, WHICH IS SUPPOSED TO BE LIMITED IN THESE
6:16:36PM TWO DISTRICTS.
6:16:36PM LOOKING AT THE NEW TAMPA TREND, IT APPEARS THAT THE RATE OF
6:16:39PM GROWTH, RESIDENTIAL GROWTH IS DECREASING SINCE THE GROWTH
6:16:43PM FROM 2010 TO 2015 WAS SIGNIFICANTLY MORE THAN THE GROWTH
6:16:46PM FROM 2015 TO 2020.
6:16:48PM SO THE RED IS SMALLER THAN THE BLUE.
6:16:52PM SEE THE GROWTH IS ACTUALLY DECREASING.
6:16:55PM WHEREAS IN THE SOUTH TAMPA DISTRICT THE OPPOSITE IS TRUE.
6:16:58PM THE RED, GROWTH IN LAST FIVE YEARS IS MORE THAN THE GROWTH
6:17:01PM THAT OCCURRED IN THE FIVE YEARS PRIOR.
6:17:06PM >> THE NEXT VIDEO IS DAVID HEY FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSION
6:17:09PM STAFF.
6:17:09PM PLEASE PLAY THE SECOND VIDEO.
6:17:18PM >> BASED ON THE DISTRICT CHARACTERISTICS, THE COMPREHENSIVE
6:17:23PM PLAN HAVE VIEWED THESE TWO DISTRICTS AS PROVIDING, QUOTE,
6:17:27PM LIMITED GROWTH OPPORTUNITIES, UNQUOTE.
6:17:30PM ALSO REFERENCES IN THE COMP PLAN CALLING THESE TWO AREAS,
6:17:34PM QUOTE, AREAS OF STABILITY, UNQUOTE.
6:17:37PM THE COMP PLAN REALLY ENVISIONS THE THREE CORE DISTRICTS,
6:17:41PM CENTRAL, WESTSHORE, AND UNIVERSITY, AS HAVING THE MOST
6:17:45PM GROWTH OPPORTUNITIES WITHIN THE CITY OF TAMPA.
6:17:48PM THE MAJORITY OF TRANSIT AND EMPLOYMENT IN THE CITY OF TAMPA
6:17:51PM ARE FOUND WITHIN THE CENTRAL, WESTSHORE, AND UNIVERSITY
6:17:55PM PLANNING DISTRICTS.
6:18:00PM >> YOU HEARD THEM.
6:18:01PM THE DEVELOPMENT IN SOUTH TAMPA IS NOT IN LINE WITH THE COMP
6:18:03PM PLAN.
6:18:04PM THE MAJORITY OF TRANSIT AND EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES ARE
6:18:06PM FOUND IN THE WESTSHORE, CENTRAL, AND UNIVERSITY DISTRICTS.
6:18:08PM THEREFORE GROWTH SHOULD BE HIGHEST IN THOSE DISTRICTS AND
6:18:11PM LOWEST IN THE SOUTH TAMPA.
6:18:13PM UNFORTUNATELY, THE EXACT OPPOSITE HAS HAPPENED.
6:18:16PM IF YOU LOOK AT THIS GRAPHIC AGAIN, YOU WILL SEE THAT NEW
6:18:20PM TAMPA'S GROWTH GOT SMALLER AS THOSE BIG NEW HOUSING
6:18:25PM DEVELOPMENTS WERE FINISHED, WHERE THE EXACT OPPOSITE WAS
6:18:28PM TRUE OF SOUTH TAMPA.
6:18:29PM THE RED IS BIGGER THAN THE BLUE BECAUSE OUR RATE OF
6:18:31PM RESIDENTIAL GROWTH IS ACTUALLY INCREASING.
6:18:33PM WE HAVE A FASTEST GROWING, WHEN WE SHOULD BE THE LOWEST
6:18:37PM GROWING.
6:18:38PM THIS IS THE OPPOSITE OF THE COMP PLAN'S VISION FOR GROWTH.
6:18:41PM THE UNIVERSITY DISTRICT SHOULD HAVE THE HIGHEST GROWTH IN
6:18:45PM POPULATION EMPLOYMENT, BUT INSTEAD IT HAD THE LOWEST GROWTH.
6:18:48PM 1%.
6:18:49PM THAT'S 1% GROWTH IN TEN YEARS.
6:18:51PM I WANT YOU TO LOOK AT THIS MAP.
6:18:54PM THIS IS THE UNIVERSITY DISTRICT.
6:18:58PM THIS IS THE CENTRAL DISTRICT.
6:19:00PM THIS IS PART OF THE OTHER DISTRICT.
6:19:02PM I WANT YOU TO NOTICE THAT THEY DON'T NEED TO EVACUATE.
6:19:06PM YOU NEED TO THINK ABOUT HOW IMPORTANT THAT IS.
6:19:08PM THINK ABOUT HOW MUCH IT COSTS A PERSON TO EVACUATE FOR DAYS.
6:19:12PM THINK ABOUT HOW MUCH DAMAGE IS DONE TO THEIR CARS AND THEIR
6:19:15PM HOMES.
6:19:15PM THINK ABOUT HOW HARD IT HAS BEEN FOR HURRICANE IAN'S VICTIMS
6:19:19PM IN FORT MYERS TO GET INSURANCE COMPANIES TO PAY OUT AND HOW
6:19:22PM HIGH THEIR DEDUCTIBLES ARE.
6:19:24PM THINK ABOUT THE PICTURES OF FLOODING FROM IDALIA.
6:19:26PM THINK ABOUT HOW IDALIA DIDN'T EVEN COME CLOSE TO US YET THE
6:19:30PM DAMAGE FROM FLOODING IS GOING TO BE VERY, VERY EXPENSIVE.
6:19:33PM URBAN TAMPA BAY SAID IT BEST.
6:19:35PM IT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE TO ALLOW NEW DEVELOPMENT IN LOCATIONS
6:19:40PM WHICH ARE AT HIGH RISK OF INUNDATION FLOODING DURING FLOOD
6:19:44PM EVENTS.
6:19:44PM EACH PROPERTY DEVELOPED IN SUCH LOCATIONS IS ANOTHER
6:19:47PM PROPERTY THE REST OF US WILL BE SUBSIDIZING IN PERPETUITY
6:19:51PM WITH OUR INSURANCE AND DISASTER RELIEF PAYMENTS.
6:19:55PM BOTH STAFF SAID THIS IS INCONSISTENT AND IT IS THE OPPOSITE
6:19:58PM OF WHAT THE CITY NEEDS.
6:19:59PM PLEASE VOTE NO.
6:20:01PM THANK YOU.
6:20:01PM OH, ONE OTHER THING.
6:20:03PM IF YOU ALL SAW THIS, I PUT IT IN YOUR PACKETS.
6:20:06PM THIS WAS PRESENTED BY JEAN DUNCAN ON FEBRUARY 6 TO CITY
6:20:09PM COUNCIL.
6:20:09PM AGAIN, SHE EMPHASIZED FROM A TRANSPORTATION POINT OF VIEW
6:20:14PM WHERE THE GROWTH IS.
6:20:15PM I DON'T SEE A CIRCLE DOWN HERE.
6:20:19PM THANK YOU.
6:20:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:20:22PM YES, MA'AM.
6:20:23PM STEPHANIE POYNOR.
6:20:28PM DOES SHE HAVE A SPEAKER WAIVER FORM?
6:20:32PM >> [NOT SPEAKING INTO A MICROPHONE] SHE HAS A TOTAL OF SIX
6:20:37PM MINUTES.
6:20:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
6:20:39PM GO AHEAD.
6:20:39PM >> STEPHANIE POYNOR.
6:20:40PM I WANT TO POINT OUT FOR THE RECORD, BECAUSE WHEN WE WERE AT
6:20:42PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION, PEOPLE CHANGED THE RECORD AND
6:20:45PM CHANGED THE CHHA.
6:20:48PM THAT'S WHY I SIGNIFICANTLY HAVE ISSUES WITH IT.
6:20:54PM THIS IS THE CHHA LINE FOR OUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:21:00PM THIS GENTLEMAN BACK HERE BEHIND ME THREW ONE UP THERE THAT
6:21:03PM ONLY SHOWED THE VE AND THE FEMA FLOOD ZONES.
6:21:07PM NO WONDER THE PLANNING COMMISSION DECIDED THAT IT WAS OKAY
6:21:11PM BECAUSE THIS IS MY NEIGHBORHOOD AND ALL OF YOU HAVE BEEN TO
6:21:14PM MY NEIGHBORHOOD AT ONE TIME OR ANOTHER.
6:21:16PM AND THIS PROPERTY IS IN THE CHHA.
6:21:20PM AGAIN, HERE IS MY HOUSE, THIS ORANGE.
6:21:23PM THIS IS THE PROPERTY.
6:21:25PM THERE'S 350 APARTMENTS GOING IN HERE.
6:21:27PM THERE'S 216 GOING HERE.
6:21:29PM THERE'S 205 THERE.
6:21:31PM AND AS JEAN POINTED OUT TO YOU, ALL OF THESE STOLE PLACES TO
6:21:37PM WORK FROM OUR COMMUNITY.
6:21:39PM PEOPLE DON'T EVACUATE FROM THEIR WORK.
6:21:41PM WHEN THEY TAKE THIS TRUCKING COMPANY, THAT WORKS.
6:21:46PM I GUARANTEE YOU THEY WORK BECAUSE I SEE THE TRUCKS GOING IN
6:21:49PM AND OUT OF THERE EVERY DAY.
6:21:52PM ANOTHER LITTLE ISSUE, THIS IS ONE OF THE FEW WAYS OUT OF
6:21:54PM ROBINSON HIGH SCHOOL AND ALREADY A DEATH TRAP TRYING TO GET
6:21:57PM OUT OF THERE.
6:21:57PM I WOULD LIKE TO REMIND THAT YOU WE'VE GOT ALL OF THESE
6:22:01PM APARTMENTS COMING, 6300 AND SOME.
6:22:04PM AND THE YELLOW ONES AREN'T FINISHED YET.
6:22:07PM THIS IS MY FABULOUS LITTLE MAP.
6:22:09PM THIS GUY MADE IT FOR THE GHS.
6:22:12PM AND PLEASE, IF THIS GENTLEMAN GETS UP HERE AND SHOWS A
6:22:14PM PowerPoint, PLEASE LET US COME BACK UP BECAUSE I HAVE MORE
6:22:17PM ISSUES WITH WHAT THEY SAID AND I HAVE PROOF.
6:22:20PM OKAY.
6:22:20PM IF YOU LOOK RIGHT DOWN HERE, THE NUMBER OF UNITS IN SOG HAS
6:22:29PM DOUBLED SINCE THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN WAS WRITTEN IN 2016.
6:22:31PM DOUBLED.
6:22:32PM WE WENT FROM 10,000 UNITS TO ALMOST 20.
6:22:35PM I MEAN, REALLY?
6:22:38PM WE SAW THIS MORNING, YOU GUYS SAW IN THE NEWS YESTERDAY,
6:22:42PM JUST LIKE EVERYBODY ELSE DID, ALL THE FLOODING THAT WENT ON
6:22:44PM THERE.
6:22:45PM AND ONE OF THEM, PEOPLE SAID, OH, THAT'S THE TIDE.
6:22:48PM NO, IT'S NOT THE TIDE.
6:22:50PM THE LEGION WASN'T FLOODED.
6:22:52PM ALL THE HOUSES BEHIND THE LEGION, THEY ARE ALL FLOODED.
6:22:57PM ACROSS FROM 485 UNITS.
6:22:59PM GO FIGURE.
6:22:59PM LET ME MAKE SURE I GOT EVERYTHING.
6:23:04PM BUT I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE UNDERSTAND, FIRST OF ALL,
6:23:08PM THIS ISN'T GOING TO BE LIVE LOCAL.
6:23:10PM WE ASKED THIS GENTLEMAN RIGHT HERE FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
6:23:13PM THAT GUY RIGHT THERE AND HIS BUDDY BACK THERE.
6:23:16PM WE ASKED THEM FOR AFFORDABLE.
6:23:18PM THEY SAID NOBODY WANTS AFFORDABLE NEXT TO THEM.
6:23:20PM ARE YOU KIDDING ME?
6:23:21PM I'M LIKE, YOU HAVE NEVER MET WITH US THEN, HAVE YOU?
6:23:24PM AND THEY SAID, NO.
6:23:26PM IN ORDER FOR IT TO BE LIVE LOCAL, DON'T LET THIS CHICK SELL
6:23:30PM YOU A BILL OF GOODS BECAUSE IN ORDER FOR IT TO BE
6:23:33PM AFFORDABLE, IT HAS TO BE AFFORDABLE AT LEAST 40% IN ORDER
6:23:36PM FOR IT TO BE LIVE LOCAL.
6:23:38PM SO IT CAN'T BE LIVE LOCAL, SO LET'S STOP TELLING A STORY.
6:23:42PM THE OTHER THING IS, TRANSPORTATION, WE HAVE ALL THESE OTHER
6:23:45PM ISSUES ALREADY IN OUR COMMUNITY.
6:23:47PM LOOK AT THE WATER THAT'S STILL ON THE ROAD TODAY.
6:23:50PM I GOT PICTURES.
6:23:51PM I'M SORRY.
6:23:53PM I DID NOT BRING MY MAPS.
6:23:54PM I FORGOT MY PowerPoint WHEN I CAME BACK.
6:23:57PM THESE FOLKS HERE, THIS GUY RIGHT THERE AND HIS COMPADRE BACK
6:24:01PM THERE, SAID THERE ARE TEN SHELTERS WITHIN TEN MILES OF US.
6:24:04PM NOW, FIVE OF THOSE ARE IN SOUTH COUNTY.
6:24:06PM APOLLO BEACH, RIVERVIEW.
6:24:09PM I'M LIKE, UM, EXCUSE ME, ARE WE SUPPOSED TO DO SWIM ACROSS
6:24:13PM THE BAY?
6:24:13PM HOW ARE WE SUPPOSED TO DO GET THERE?
6:24:15PM BUT LISTEN, THIS PROPERTY IS RIGHT FLAT IN THE MIDDLE OF THE
6:24:21PM COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA.
6:24:23PM HERE IT IS.
6:24:23PM I HAVE NOT SPENT MY TIME DIGGING INTO THIS, BUT I WANT TO
6:24:29PM REMIND YOU OF ONE THING, YOU HAVE ABSOLUTELY NO OBLIGATION
6:24:33PM WHATSOEVER TO APPROVE THIS.
6:24:34PM THIS IS NOT A REZONING.
6:24:36PM THIS IS A PLAN AMENDMENT.
6:24:37PM THESE PEOPLE THINK THEY KNOW BETTER ABOUT WHAT WE NEED IN
6:24:42PM OUR CITY THAN WHAT OUR FUTURE LAND USE SAYS.
6:24:45PM I THINK WE ALL KNOW BETTER.
6:24:49PM THE BOTTOM LINE IS, THESE FOLKS JUST CAN'T COME TO OUR CITY.
6:24:55PM THEY ARE NOT FROM HERE.
6:24:56PM THEY ARE FROM ORLANDO.
6:24:56PM THEY CAN'T JUST COME TO OUR CITY AND MAKE CHANGES.
6:24:59PM NOBODY WANTS THESE.
6:25:00PM YOU HAVE THE E-MAILS.
6:25:01PM YOU HAVE THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE REACHED OUT TO YOU.
6:25:03PM YOU KNOW WHAT?
6:25:04PM THERE WERE A BUNCH OF THEM WHO WERE SUPPOSED TO BE HERE WITH
6:25:07PM US TONIGHT.
6:25:07PM YOU KNOW WHERE THEY ARE AT?
6:25:08PM THEY ARE AT HOME.
6:25:09PM THEY ARE CLEANING OUT THEIR HOUSES BECAUSE LIKE KALI WAS
6:25:13PM SAYING, I DON'T KNOW IF YOU UNDERSTOOD THAT OR NOT, KALI
6:25:15PM LOST FOUR MORE AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS, FOUR DUPLEXES OVER
6:25:19PM THERE BY THE LEGION BECAUSE OF THE FLOODING, JUST LIKE WE
6:25:24PM DID WITH ETTA THAT NEVER HAPPENED FOR THE 15 YEARS BEFORE
6:25:27PM THOSE 485 UNITS WERE BUILT.
6:25:30PM WHEN DO WE STOP PUTTING FOLKS' LIVES IN DANGER?
6:25:34PM WHEN I TALKED TO THE CITY THIS TIME, WE HAVE TWO AFFORDABLE
6:25:37PM HOUSING COMPLEXES ALREADY.
6:25:39PM THE CITY SAID, WE WILL SEND VANS DOWN TO GET THOSE PEOPLE.
6:25:44PM DO YOU KNOW WE HAD FOUR APARTMENT COMPLEXES THAT TURNED OFF
6:25:47PM THE ELECTRICITY AND TURNED OFF THE WATER TO THOSE APARTMENT
6:25:52PM COMPLEXES BECAUSE THEY SAID, OH, YOU HAVE TO EVACUATE.
6:25:55PM SO THE PEOPLE WHO DID WHAT THEY WERE STUDIO AND EVACUATE,
6:26:00PM THEY CAME HOME TO REFRIGERATORS OF RUINED STUFF.
6:26:03PM THESE WERE AFFORDABLE, PEOPLE WHO WERE HOMELESS IN THE LAST
6:26:06PM SIX MONTHS OR SO.
6:26:07PM WE HAVE GOT TO STOP.
6:26:12PM SOUTH TAMPA IS FULL.
6:26:13PM SOG IS EVEN MORE FULL.
6:26:15PM THEY ARE NOT BUILDING WHAT MacDILL NEEDS.
6:26:17PM I DON'T CARE IF THEY BUILT 30% IN THEIR LITTLE WORLD.
6:26:19PM IF THEY WANTED TO BUILD 100%, THAT WOULD BE A DIFFERENT
6:26:24PM CONVERSATION BECAUSE THAT MIGHT BE WHAT WE NEED.
6:26:26PM WE'VE GOT ALL THESE ADDITIONAL UNITS THAT I SHOWED YOU,
6:26:29PM 7,000 OF THEM, AND 94% OF THEM ARE ONE AND TWO BEDROOM,
6:26:33PM WHICH NOBODY AT MacDILL WANTS TO LIVE IN.
6:26:36PM I WISH THAT BEN HAD A MINUTE TO TELL YOU THAT.
6:26:38PM I WISH YOU WOULD GO BACK AND LISTEN TO THE PLANNING
6:26:41PM COMMISSION MEETING.
6:26:42PM I WISH I COULD SHOW THAT WHOLE VIDEO TO YOU WHERE TONY
6:26:45PM RODRIGUEZ SAID WE DON'T NEED ONE AND TWO BEDROOMS.
6:26:47PM PLEASE DENY THIS.
6:26:49PM THERE IS NOTHING TO STOP YOU FROM DENYING IT BECAUSE ALL IT
6:26:52PM IS IS A COMP PLAN CHANGE.
6:26:54PM IT'S NOT A REZONING.
6:26:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:26:56PM ANYBODY ELSE WISHING TO SPEAK?
6:26:59PM ALL RIGHT.
6:27:05PM FIVE-MINUTE REBUTTAL, CORRECT?
6:27:07PM MARTY, BEING THAT THIS IS A FUTURE LAND USE, WE HAVE A
6:27:15PM FIVE-MINUTE REBUTTAL, JUST LIKE WE TREAT EVERYBODY ELSE?
6:27:18PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YES, THAT'S BEEN CONSISTENT.
6:27:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: APPLICANT, YOU HAVE FIVE MINUTES TO
6:27:23PM REBUT.
6:27:24PM YES, MA'AM, GO AHEAD.
6:27:32PM YOU HAVE FIVE MINUTES.
6:27:33PM >> I'M GOING TO START JUST BY POINTING OUT THAT LAND USE
6:27:36PM POLICY 1.1.8, WHICH SUPPORTS DIVERSE HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES
6:27:41PM IN THE SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT, WHERE TRANSIT SERVICES
6:27:45PM AND MIXED USE ARE WITHIN THIS AREA.
6:27:47PM AND THAT WAS ONE OF THE CITED LAND USE POLICIES IN SUPPORT
6:27:52PM OF PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF'S APPROVAL, WHICH WAS PART OF
6:27:55PM THEIR PLANNING REPORT.
6:27:56PM I'M ALSO GOING TO TURN IT BACK OVER TO MR. VONRINTELN.
6:28:06PM >> FOR THE RECORD, JIM VONRINTELN WITH JR EVANS ENGINEERING.
6:28:13PM THE ONLY MAP I SPOKE TO IS THIS ONE.
6:28:18PM THE NOAA COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA.
6:28:21PM THIS IS THE ONE APPLICABLE TO THE COMP PLAN.
6:28:23PM IT ESSENTIALLY MODELS A WORST-CASE SURGE PREDICTION FOR EACH
6:28:27PM CATEGORY OF STORM.
6:28:29PM SO WORST-CASE SITUATION.
6:28:31PM NOT ABSOLUTE.
6:28:32PM IT IS A PLANNING TOOL THAT EMERGENCY MANAGERS USE TO TRY TO
6:28:36PM GAUGE THE WORST POSSIBLE STORM SURGE PER STORM.
6:28:39PM SO THAT'S THE ONE I REFERRED TO.
6:28:42PM IT MAY HAVE BEEN SOME CONFUSION BECAUSE IN OUR PRESENTATION,
6:28:47PM THE FEMA COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA WAS ALSO REFERENCED, AND
6:28:51PM THAT'S THIS.
6:28:52PM SO FEDERAL AGENCIES HAVE A BAD HABIT OF USING THE SAME
6:28:55PM ACRONYM, SAME TITLES FOR TWO DIFFERENT THINGS.
6:28:58PM IN THIS CASE, FEMA USES THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA TO TALK
6:29:02PM ABOUT THEIR MAPS AND FLOOD ZONES AND SPECIFICALLY TALKS
6:29:06PM ABOUT V ZONES AND COASTAL A ZONES, WHICH IS WHERE THE WAVE
6:29:11PM ACTION ARE AND THAT REQUIRES CERTAIN CONSTRUCTION STANDARDS.
6:29:16PM THERE ARE THE TWO DIFFERENCES.
6:29:17PM IF WE CONFUSED ANYBODY, I APOLOGIZE.
6:29:20PM ONLY THING I WAS REFERRING TO WITH REGARD TO EVACUATION AND
6:29:24PM SHELTERING WAS THE NOAA COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA, WHICH HAS
6:29:28PM TO DO WITH SURGE MODELING.
6:29:30PM THIS IS WHAT EMERGENCY MANAGERS USE.
6:29:33PM WITH REGARD TO ANY CONFUSION AND ANY RISK THAT YOU SHOULD BE
6:29:39PM CONSIDERING, I WOULD REFER YOU TO YOUR STAFF EMERGENCY
6:29:42PM MANAGERS WHO HAVE THE SAME ANALYSIS I DO WITH THIS
6:29:47PM PARTICULAR PROJECT AND THEY DON'T SEE ANY SPECIFIC INCREASE
6:29:50PM TO THE EVACUATION OR SHELTERING.
6:29:52PM HOPE THAT ANSWERS THE QUESTION.
6:29:55PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MS. MALONE, I SEE YOU STANDING.
6:29:59PM >> JENNIFER MALONE WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
6:30:02PM I WAS GOING TO ASK SHAWN COLLEGE FROM THE PLANNING
6:30:03PM COMMISSION IS HERE, AND HE'S OUR RESIDENT EXPERT ON
6:30:06PM EVERYTHING COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA.
6:30:09PM HE ACTUALLY WAS THE ONE TO CLARIFY THIS TO THE PLANNING
6:30:12PM COMMISSIONERS AT THE HEARING.
6:30:13PM I WAS JUST GOING TO INVITE HIM UP TO CLARIFY THE DIFFERENCE
6:30:18PM IN THESE MAPS BECAUSE I THINK THERE IS A FAIR AMOUNT OF
6:30:21PM CONFUSION TONIGHT.
6:30:22PM THANK YOU.
6:30:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: OKAY.
6:30:25PM >> SHAWN COLLEGE, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
6:30:27PM WHAT WAS JUST SAID WAS ACCURATE.
6:30:32PM THE FEMA COASTAL HIGH HAZARD ZONE IS NOT THE ZONE THAT IS
6:30:36PM APPLICABLE TO YOUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:30:37PM YOUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IS DEALING WITH FLORIDA STATUTE
6:30:41PM WHICH IS COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AS DEFINED BY FLORIDA STATUTE
6:30:46PM AND AS APPLICABLE TO YOUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:30:49PM IT IS THIS MAP AND THIS PROPERTY IS IN THE COASTAL HIGH
6:30:54PM HAZARD AREA RELEVANT TO YOUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:30:56PM AND IT IS ALSO ACCURATE THAT WE DO NOT, CITY OF TAMPA OR
6:31:00PM HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY, DO NOT CURRENTLY MEET THE STANDARD FOR
6:31:03PM EVACUATION LEVEL OF SERVICE FOR THE COUNTY.
6:31:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:31:10PM APPLICANT, YOU STILL HAVE TIME ON YOUR REBUTTAL.
6:31:13PM >> I DO WANT TO SAY THAT THE REASON THAT THE FEMA MODELED
6:31:19PM CHHA WAS PRESENTED IN REBUTTAL.
6:31:24PM THE EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS SLIDE THAT WE PRESENTED IS
6:31:28PM APPLICABLE BECAUSE WHEN A PLAN AMENDMENT PROPOSES HIGHER
6:31:34PM DENSITIES, ACCORDING TO YOUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, YOU ARE
6:31:36PM SUPPOSED TO TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION WHETHER THERE IS
6:31:39PM SUFFICIENT EVACUATION TIMES AND SHELTERS, AND THAT IS WHAT
6:31:43PM WE PRESENTED TONIGHT.
6:31:45PM I DON'T BELIEVE WE HAVE ANYTHING ELSE AT THIS TIME.
6:31:48PM BUT WOULD ASK THAT YOU APPROVE OUR APPLICATION.
6:31:53PM AGAIN, WE ARE AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS.
6:31:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:31:55PM IF THERE ARE NO OTHER QUESTIONS, MAY I HAVE A MOTION TO
6:31:58PM CLOSE?
6:31:58PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
6:32:01PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
6:32:03PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:32:03PM AYE.
6:32:04PM YES, WHAT IS THE PLEASURE OF COUNCIL?
6:32:08PM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN AND COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON AND
6:32:11PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON AND VIERA.
6:32:14PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I APPRECIATE THE APPLICANT'S REQUEST TO
6:32:17PM CHANGE THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:32:19PM I HAVE NO DOUBT THAT WHAT YOU'RE ASKING FOR IS A GOOD
6:32:23PM DEVELOPMENT.
6:32:23PM I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOU TO LOOK ELSEWHERE IN THE CITY.
6:32:26PM WE HAVE MANY AREAS AND OPPORTUNITIES IN THE CITY FOR
6:32:30PM DEVELOPMENT AND INCREASE IN DENSITY.
6:32:33PM I MEAN LOTS.
6:32:34PM I THINK THERE'S LOTS OF OPPORTUNITIES IN THE CITY.
6:32:36PM WE'RE GOING TO CREATE A CITY THAT IS WORTHY OF THE PEOPLE
6:32:39PM THAT LIVE HERE AND ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITIES FOR DEVELOPERS AND
6:32:42PM FOLKS THAT CAN MAKE MONEY.
6:32:43PM THERE'S PLENTY OF MONEY TO BE MADE AND THERE IS THE MONEY
6:32:45PM LEFT ON THE TABLE IN SO MANY AREAS OF THE CITY OF TAMPA.
6:32:48PM THIS IS NOT ONE OF THOSE.
6:32:50PM IF I COULD GO BACK AND RE-CREATE PRIOR DECISIONS ON SOME OF
6:32:54PM THOSE OTHER PROPERTIES, YOU KNOW, I WOULD.
6:32:57PM BUT I CAN'T.
6:32:58PM SOMETIMES YOU JUST HAVE TO SAY ENOUGH IS ENOUGH AND THIS IS
6:33:01PM WHERE WE DRAW THE LINE.
6:33:02PM IT'S BEYOND MY COMPREHENSION THAT WE CONTINUE TO APPROVE
6:33:08PM PROJECTS IN THESE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREAS AND BEYOND THAT
6:33:13PM AND TAKING SOME OF THE VALUABLE INDUSTRIAL LAND NEXT TO AN
6:33:18PM AIR FORCE BASE.
6:33:18PM WISER PEOPLE THAN I THAT INITIALLY CREATED THESE INDUSTRIAL
6:33:22PM ZONES AS A BUFFER BETWEEN THE AIR FORCE BASE AND OTHER
6:33:25PM RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES.
6:33:26PM SO IT MAKES COMMON SENSE TO ME.
6:33:29PM ONE DAY THERE MAY BE FIGHTERS THERE AGAIN AND SOUND LIKE
6:33:33PM VIETNAM AND SOUTH PART OF TAMPA.
6:33:35PM BUT, YOU KNOW, AGAIN, I LOOK FORWARD TO YOU DOING BUSINESS
6:33:38PM IN THE CITY OF TAMPA AND MAKING LOTS OF MONEY IN THE CITY OF
6:33:41PM TAMPA.
6:33:41PM SOUTH TAMPA IS FULL.
6:33:45PM WE NEED TO LOOK ELSEWHERE AND LOOK FOR ECONOMIC
6:33:48PM OPPORTUNITIES AND FOR ANYBODY ELSE THAT'S LISTENING THAT
6:33:51PM WANTS TO APPLY FOR THIS TYPE OF DEVELOPMENT IN SOUTH TAMPA,
6:33:54PM LOOK ELSEWHERE.
6:33:55PM WE HAVE AREAS OF SULPHUR SPRINGS, UNIVERSITY AREA, WESTSHORE
6:34:03PM AREA, DREW PARK, TONS OF AREAS THAT ARE WONDERFUL
6:34:05PM OPPORTUNITIES FOR PEOPLE TO MAKE MONEY IN THE CITY OF TAMPA.
6:34:07PM THIS IS NOT ONE OF THEM.
6:34:08PM THANK YOU.
6:34:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
6:34:11PM COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
6:34:11PM >>BILL CARLSON: I WAS JUST GOING TO SAY I'M HAPPY TO MAKE A
6:34:14PM MOTION TO DENY.
6:34:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: LET ME GO TO THE OTHER COUNCIL MEMBERS.
6:34:19PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON AND COUNCILMAN VIERA.
6:34:21PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
6:34:22PM I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT I AGREE WITH THE STAFF REPORT AND
6:34:25PM FINDING THIS INCONSISTENT.
6:34:26PM THERE ARE OTHER OPPORTUNITIES FOR YOUR ORGANIZATION TO GO
6:34:30PM ELSEWHERE.
6:34:31PM EAST TAMPA IS WILLING AND WAITING FOR YOU.
6:34:34PM BUT SOUTH TAMPA IS FULL.
6:34:36PM BECAUSE IT'S A HIGH COASTAL AREA THAT TENDS TO EVEN ADD MORE
6:34:42PM OF A NO FOR ME AS I CONTINUE TO LEARN IN THIS.
6:34:45PM AND ALSO THE FACT THAT, YOU KNOW, THERE SHOULD BE
6:34:48PM OPPORTUNITIES FOR THOSE AREAS TO REMAIN AS REGIONAL
6:34:52PM EMPLOYERS.
6:34:53PM I JUST CAN'T SUPPORT YOU AT THIS TIME.
6:34:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN VIERA.
6:34:57PM >>LUIS VIERA: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR. CHAIR.
6:34:58PM I WANT TO GIVE MY THOUGHTS.
6:35:00PM ON CONTROVERSIAL THINGS, WHETHER I VOTE YEA OR NAY, A LOT OF
6:35:03PM TIMES ON SOME OF THESE I'LL ALWAYS POINT TO THE STAFF
6:35:06PM REPORTS AND GO, WE HAVE A POSITIVE STAFF REPORT, NO WAIVERS,
6:35:11PM BLAH, BLAH, BLAH, OUR HANDS ARE TIED, ET CETERA.
6:35:14PM THIS IS THE OPPOSITE WHERE I THINK OUR HANDS ARE TIED 100%
6:35:17PM AGAINST THIS.
6:35:17PM YOU READ THE STAFF REPORT AND JUST GOING OVER THE PLANNING
6:35:19PM COMMISSION'S FINDINGS SAYS, QUOTE, THE POTENTIAL
6:35:23PM INTRODUCTION TO POTENTIALLY INTRODUCE 641 DWELLING UNITS OF
6:35:29PM RESIDENTIAL USES ON THE SITE CONFLICTS WITH POLICY DIRECTION
6:35:32PM OF THE PLAN THAT DIRECTS -- STRIKE THAT, POPULATION
6:35:34PM INCREASES AWAY FROM THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREAS.
6:35:38PM IT ALSO SAYS PROPOSED PLAN AMENDMENTS THAT WOULD INCREASE
6:35:41PM DENSITIES WITHIN THE COASTAL PLANNING AREA SHALL DEMONSTRATE
6:35:44PM NO NEGATIVE IMPACTS ON HURRICANE EVACUATION TIME, ROUTES AND
6:35:47PM SHELTER DEMANDS.
6:35:48PM THIS APPLICANT DOES NOT ADDRESS OR DEMONSTRATE IF THE
6:35:51PM AMENDMENT WILL HAVE NO NEGATIVE IMPACTS ON HURRICANE
6:35:53PM EVACUATION TIMES AND ROUTES, MAINTAINING AND IMPROVING
6:35:56PM EVACUATION TIMES IS CRITICAL CONSIDERING THE COUNTY IS NOT
6:35:59PM MEETING ITS EVACUATION LEVEL OF SERVICE.
6:36:01PM THOSE THINGS, AND WE'RE OBVIOUSLY DEALING WITH THIS HEARING
6:36:06PM JUST A COUPLE OF DAYS AFTER A VERY SCARY EVENT FOR TAMPA
6:36:08PM WHICH MAKES IT VERY, VERY EMOTIONAL.
6:36:11PM FOR ALL OF US, I THINK THESE FINDINGS TAKE AWAY THE EMOTION,
6:36:14PM WHICH IS VERY REASONABLE, VERY NORMAL, OBVIOUSLY, AND I
6:36:17PM THINK GIVE US A VERY CLEAR DIRECTION OF WHERE WE NEED TO GO
6:36:22PM ON THIS IN OPPOSING THIS.
6:36:23PM OBVIOUSLY WE WANT MORE HOUSING IN THE CITY OF TAMPA.
6:36:25PM THAT'S SOMETHING WE SHOULD ALL SUPPORT.
6:36:27PM BUT I THINK PUTTING IT HERE IS VERY UNREASONABLE.
6:36:29PM AND WITH THIS REPORT AND THE LANGUAGE HERE, I THINK
6:36:32PM APPROVING THIS WOULD BE A MOVE THAT -- AN OPINION THAT'S
6:36:36PM DAMNING.
6:36:37PM THANK YOU.
6:36:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS BY
6:36:41PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON AND COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN WHEN
6:36:44PM THEY SAY SOUTH TAMPA IS FULL AND THERE ARE OTHER PARTS OF
6:36:46PM THE CITY.
6:36:47PM I ALWAYS TALK ABOUT EAST TAMPA.
6:36:48PM PARTS OF THE CITY THAT ARE NEGLECTED THAT WE NEED THE
6:36:50PM HOUSING, THAT WE WELCOME THE HOUSING, AND THERE ARE A LOT OF
6:36:53PM OPPORTUNITIES.
6:36:53PM WE SAW THIS HURRICANE THE OTHER DAY.
6:36:55PM I'VE BEEN HERE MY WHOLE LIFE.
6:36:57PM I'VE SEEN MANY NEAR MISSES.
6:36:59PM AND I SEE HOW NARROW THE STREETS ARE, A LOT OF TWO-LANE
6:37:03PM STREETS.
6:37:04PM EVACUATION, WE SEE THE FLOODING.
6:37:06PM FLOODING FROM WHAT WAS A MINOR EVENT COMPARED TO THE
6:37:10PM CATASTROPHE THAT WE COULD HAVE FACED WITH A DIRECT HIT.
6:37:13PM WE'VE BEEN LUCKY FOR 102 YEARS.
6:37:17PM SOONER OR LATER, SOMETHING IS GOING TO HAPPEN AND WE'RE
6:37:20PM GOING TO SEE THE TRUE NEGATIVE IMPACT OF OVERBUILDING IN
6:37:23PM THESE AREAS AND THE ISSUES WITH THE EVACUATION AND ALL THE
6:37:27PM HAZARDS THAT GO WITH THEM.
6:37:29PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
6:37:30PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
6:37:31PM I'M GOING TO ECHO WHAT MY FELLOW COUNCIL MEMBER SAID ABOUT
6:37:37PM FLOODING.
6:37:38PM THE THING ABOUT THAT MAP, WE CAN ARGUE ABOUT THAT MAP, BUT
6:37:41PM THAT MAP IS ONLY GOING TO GET REDDER.
6:37:43PM IT'S NOT EVER GOING TO BACK UP AND BECOME ORANGE.
6:37:46PM IT'S GOING TO ONLY GET REDDER.
6:37:48PM AS I LOOKED AT THAT PENINSULA, I WAS JUST THINKING TO
6:37:51PM MYSELF, WHEN DOES THE ENTIRE PENINSULA BECOME RED?
6:37:54PM IT WILL HAPPEN IN MY LIFETIME.
6:37:57PM AND I'M MIDDLE AGED.
6:37:59PM [ LAUGHTER ]
6:38:00PM YOU KNOW WHAT WOULD BE GREAT ON THAT SITE IS THE RETAIL THAT
6:38:14PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD IS BEGGING FOR.
6:38:18PM A LARGE GROCER.
6:38:21PM ANYTHING THAT SURROUNDS THAT, THEY ARE DESPERATELY IN NEED
6:38:27PM OF.
6:38:28PM AND WHAT I TRULY DID NOT APPRECIATE WAS THREATENING, WHAT I
6:38:33PM FELT LIKE WAS A THREAT TO COUNCIL AND CITIZENS ABOUT LIVE
6:38:38PM LOCAL.
6:38:38PM YOU CAN USE LIVE LOCAL, BUT DON'T COME TO US AND SAY, WELL,
6:38:42PM IF YOU DON'T APPROVE THIS, WE'RE GOING TO GO AHEAD AND DO
6:38:45PM THAT.
6:38:45PM THAT IS NOT A WAY TO GET ON OUR GOOD SIDE.
6:38:49PM YES, YOU ARE ALLOWED TO DO THAT, BUT COMING AND BASICALLY
6:38:53PM THREATENING US IS NOT A SUCCESSFUL STRATEGY.
6:38:56PM AND I WOULD RECOMMEND NO ONE COME TO US AND TRY TO TELL US
6:39:01PM THAT THEY ARE JUST GOING TO GO AROUND US AND DO LIVE LOCAL.
6:39:05PM BECAUSE IF YOU DID LIVE LOCAL, YOU'D HAVE TO PUT 40%
6:39:08PM AFFORDABLE HOUSING, AND THAT'S NOT AFFORDABLE.
6:39:10PM I KNOW HOW MUCH THAT LAND COSTS.
6:39:12PM IT'S NOT CHEAP.
6:39:13PM SO PLEASE DON'T COME AND THREATEN US AGAIN.
6:39:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
6:39:24PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I GUESS WHERE I COME FROM, I'M NEVER
6:39:27PM THREATENED.
6:39:27PM I JUST LISTEN AND DO THE BEST I CAN WITH WHATEVER ABILITY I
6:39:31PM HAVE.
6:39:32PM I'M A LITTLE DIFFERENT THAT WAY.
6:39:33PM I JUST FLUFF THEM OFF AND KEEP GOING.
6:39:36PM IT'S LIKE PICKING A BALL GAME.
6:39:38PM YOU CAN'T WIN THEM ALL.
6:39:39PM IF YOU COULD, LIFE WOULD BE MISERABLE BECAUSE WHEN WILL I
6:39:43PM HAVE UPSCALE TO DO SOMETHING BETTER THAN NOW AND I CAN'T.
6:39:47PM I'M NOT TRYING TO MAKE THIS A FUNNY THING REGARDING LAND
6:39:51PM ZONING AND BASEBALL.
6:39:53PM THAT'S OUT OF TEXT.
6:39:54PM BUT LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION.
6:39:56PM YOU HEARD THAT FROM MANY DEVELOPERS AND THOSE THAT DEAL IN
6:39:58PM THIS KIND OF BUSINESS DAY IN AND DAY OUT THAT DO THE BEST TO
6:40:02PM REPRESENT THEIR CLIENT AND THAT'S WHAT IS HAPPENING HERE.
6:40:04PM LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION.
6:40:08PM I MEAN, THERE ARE OTHER AREAS OF THE CITY THAT THIS COULD GO
6:40:14PM INTO.
6:40:15PM I'M NOT TELLING YOU WHERE TO GO.
6:40:16PM I DON'T HAVE THAT RIGHT.
6:40:19PM BUT IT'S YOUR DEAL.
6:40:23PM YOUR FINDING OF FACT.
6:40:25PM TIED FROM THE BEGINNING, DIDN'T SHOW MUCH POSITIVE AT ALL.
6:40:28PM AND READING THE REPORTS AND READING OTHER THINGS LIKE THE
6:40:30PM REST OF US HAVE, IT SHOWED IT WAS A TOUGH SELL.
6:40:34PM I THINK THE DEVELOPER KNEW THIS.
6:40:36PM I COULD TELL YOU BY LOOKING AT YOU YOU KNEW THIS.
6:40:40PM I DIDN'T GET BALD AND OLD FOR A REASON.
6:40:43PM I JUST LISTENED TO A LOT OF PEOPLE AND I SEE YOU SMILING.
6:40:46PM I BELIEVE THAT I'M RIGHT.
6:40:48PM NOT TELLING YOU WHAT TO DO OR NOT TO DO.
6:40:50PM BUT IN THIS CASE, I THINK THAT YOU AND FROM THE BEGINNING,
6:40:53PM THERE WAS A LITTLE HESITANCY TO GO FORWARD AND YOUR TONE OF
6:40:56PM VOICE.
6:40:57PM I LISTEN TO WHAT PEOPLE SAY.
6:40:59PM I REMEMBER MOST WHAT THEY DON'T SAY, AND THEN I SEE WHAT
6:41:04PM THEY SAY.
6:41:04PM THE NEXT THING I DO, I STUDY THE BODY LANGUAGE.
6:41:07PM BODY LANGUAGE TELLS ME MORE THAN WORDS.
6:41:09PM BUT IN THIS CASE, I'M SORRY.
6:41:11PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:41:12PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CARLSON, DID YOU WANT TO MAKE
6:41:14PM A MOTION?
6:41:15PM >>BILL CARLSON: YEAH.
6:41:17PM MARTY, CAN I MAKE THE MOTION -- IS MARTY STILL THERE?
6:41:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, HE IS.
6:41:23PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I'M HERE.
6:41:25PM >>BILL CARLSON: DO YOU WANT ME TO CITE ANYTHING OR JUST MAKE
6:41:27PM THE MOTION TO DENY?
6:41:28PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: WELL, YOU'VE HEARD THE DISCUSSION.
6:41:31PM THAT'S PART OF THE RECORD.
6:41:32PM BUT CERTAINLY I THINK AS PART OF YOUR MOTION, THE MORE
6:41:36PM DETAILED YOU ARE, CITING SPECIFIC PROVISIONS, CITING
6:41:40PM SPECIFIC FACTS AS YOU FIND THEM TO BE WOULD BE HELPFUL TO
6:41:43PM THE RECORD.
6:41:44PM >>BILL CARLSON: I'D LIKE TO MOVE TO DENY ITEM NUMBER 4, FILE
6:41:47PM NUMBER TA/CPA 23-03 FOR THE REASONS DISCUSSED BY MY
6:41:54PM COLLEAGUES, ALSO JUST READING FROM THE STAFF REPORT, THE
6:41:56PM SUBJECT SITE DOES NOT MEET THE GENERAL CHARACTER AND
6:41:59PM DESCRIPTION OF A TRADITIONAL NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:42:01PM LAND USE POLICY 9.3.8 IS THE INTENT OF THE CITY THAT NEW
6:42:06PM RESIDENTIAL REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS SHALL BE MINIMALLY
6:42:09PM DISRUPTIVE TO ADJACENT AREAS TO ACHIEVE THIS THE CITY SHALL
6:42:13PM ASSESS THE POTENTIAL POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE ASPECTS OF
6:42:16PM RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT POLICIES.
6:42:18PM ALSO, THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT WOULD ALLOW 641 ADDITIONAL
6:42:24PM RESIDENTIAL UNITS WITHIN THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA.
6:42:26PM THE SITE -- STAFF OBJECTS FOR THE REASONS IN COASTAL
6:42:35PM MANAGEMENT OBJECTIVE 1.1 AND LAND USE POLICY 8.9.1,
6:42:40PM ACCOMMODATE A RANGE OF EMPLOYMENT ACTIVITY TO ENSURE
6:42:44PM EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES ARE AVAILABLE FOR THE CITY'S
6:42:46PM DIVERSE RESIDENTIAL POPULATION, INCLUDING MAINTAINING
6:42:49PM HEALTHY MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIAL AREAS, LAND USE POLICY
6:42:51PM 8.9.2, ENCOURAGE THE CONTINUED INTENSIFICATION AND EXISTENCE
6:42:55PM OF INDUSTRIAL WAREHOUSING AND DISTRIBUTION FACILITIES.
6:42:59PM LAND USE POLICY 8.9.3, MAINTAIN INDUSTRIAL AREAS THAT
6:43:04PM PROVIDE FOR THE MANUFACTURING OF GOODS, FLEX SPACE AND
6:43:08PM RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT THAT ARE ATTRACTIVE, COMPATIBLE AND
6:43:10PM ADJOINING NONINDUSTRIAL AREAS AND WELL MAINTAINED.
6:43:13PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SECOND.
6:43:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
6:43:16PM CARLSON.
6:43:17PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON AND COUNCILWOMAN
6:43:19PM HURTAK.
6:43:20PM YES, MA'AM.
6:43:21PM >>LYNN HURTAK: CAN I ADD A FRIENDLY AMENDMENT?
6:43:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD.
6:43:25PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THAT THIS DOES NOT FOLLOW CM OBJECTIVE 1.1,
6:43:29PM DIRECT FUTURE POPULATION CONCENTRATIONS AWAY FROM THE
6:43:32PM COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA, CHHA, SO AS NOT TO ACHIEVE -- SO
6:43:37PM AS TO ACHIEVE A NO NET INCREASE IN OVERALL RESIDENTIAL
6:43:40PM DENSITY WITHIN THE CHHA.
6:43:44PM >>BILL CARLSON: ACCEPT THE AMENDMENT AND WOULD LIKE TO ADD
6:43:46PM ONE MORE, LAND USE OBJECTIVE 8.9, RECOGNIZE INDUSTRIAL LANDS
6:43:49PM FOR THE SUPPORT TO KEY ECONOMIC ENGINES WITHIN THE CITY IN
6:43:52PM ORDER TO STRENGTHEN TAMPA'S ROLE AS REGIONAL EMPLOYMENT
6:43:57PM CENTER.
6:43:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
6:43:58PM CARLSON.
6:43:59PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
6:44:01PM FRIENDLY AMENDMENT FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK WHICH WAS
6:44:03PM ACCEPTED.
6:44:04PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
6:44:06PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
6:44:08PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
6:44:09PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
6:44:11PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
6:44:13PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
6:44:15PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
6:44:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
6:44:17PM >>THE CLERK: THE MOTION TO DENY CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
6:44:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:44:24PM THE NEXT IS ITEM NUMBER 5.
6:44:27PM MAYOR'S YOUTH CORPS, ARE YOU ENJOYING THE MEETING?
6:44:38PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IF THE ANSWER TO THAT IS YES, THEN YOU'RE
6:44:41PM NOT WELL.
6:44:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU KNOW WHAT, WE EXPECTED A MUCH BIGGER
6:44:44PM CROWD TONIGHT.
6:44:45PM LET'S TAKE A FEW MINUTES.
6:44:47PM IF THE MAYOR'S YOUTH CORPS COULD COME UP AND INTRODUCE
6:44:50PM YOURSELVES.
6:44:51PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: COME ON UP, EVERYBODY.
6:44:53PM EVERYBODY IN THOSE BLUE SHIRTS.
6:44:55PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I WANT TO KNOW WHAT SCHOOL YOU ATTEND.
6:45:03PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MAYOR'S YOUTH CORPS, LINE UP AND HIT THE
6:45:06PM MICROPHONES.
6:45:07PM IF YOU ARE FROM JEFFERSON, YOU HAVE TO GO TO THE END OF THE
6:45:14PM LINE.
6:45:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: STATE YOUR NAME AND WHAT SCHOOL.
6:45:23PM >> I GO TO BROOKS DeBARTOLO.
6:45:27PM >> HI.
6:45:29PM I GO TO HILLSBOROUGH HIGH SCHOOL.
6:45:33PM >> HI.
6:45:34PM I GO TO ROBINSON HIGH SCHOOL.
6:45:38PM >> HI.
6:45:39PM I'M REBECCA WALTERS, I GO TO BROOKS DeBARTOLO HIGH SCHOOL.
6:45:45PM >> HI.
6:45:46PM I GO TO FLORIDA VIRTUAL.
6:45:52PM >> HI.
6:45:53PM DIEGO, JESUIT HIGH SCHOOL.
6:45:57PM >> HI.
6:45:58PM MY NAME -- I GO TO ROBINSON HIGH SCHOOL.
6:46:10PM >> HELLO, COUNCIL MEMBERS.
6:46:11PM MY NAME IS TALADI.
6:46:13PM I GO TO STRAWBERRY CREST HIGH SCHOOL.
6:46:17PM >> HI.
6:46:17PM MY NAME IS BRADY KAISER.
6:46:19PM I GO TO JESUIT HIGH SCHOOL.
6:46:22PM >> HELLO.
6:46:23PM MY NAME IS ADDISON CHEZ.
6:46:25PM BROOKS DeBARTOLO COLLEGIATE HIGH SCHOOL.
6:46:29PM >> HELLO.
6:46:30PM MY NAME IS KAREN McINTOSH.
6:46:32PM I GO TO ROBINSON HIGH SCHOOL.
6:46:35PM >> HI.
6:46:36PM LOGAN HARDEN.
6:46:37PM JESUIT HIGH SCHOOL.
6:46:40PM >> HELLO.
6:46:42PM MY NAME IS DEVORE.
6:46:46PM I ATTEND ACADEMY.
6:46:49PM >> I GO TO PLANT HIGH SCHOOL.
6:46:52PM >> HI.
6:46:53PM MY NAME IS EMILY.
6:46:54PM I GO TO PLANT HIGH SCHOOL.
6:46:57PM >> HI.
6:46:58PM I GO TO TAMPA PREP HIGH SCHOOL.
6:47:02PM >> I GO TO BROOKS DeBARTOLO COLLEGIATE HIGH SCHOOL.
6:47:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANKS FOR COMING.
6:47:09PM >> THANK YOU SO MUCH.
6:47:10PM [ APPLAUSE ]
6:47:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: TRUETT GARDNER, PLANT HIGH SCHOOL.
6:47:37PM >> STEPHANIE POYNOR, GED.
6:47:42PM >> GOOD EVENING.
6:47:43PM KATRINA CORCORAN, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
6:47:47PM I'M HERE TONIGHT TO PRESENT THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
6:47:51PM UPDATE, TA/CPA 23-01.
6:47:54PM THIS IS FOR THE MOBILITY SECTION.
6:47:56PM STARTING OFF WITH A BRIEF INTRODUCTION ON MOBILITY SECTION,
6:48:02PM IT IS A PORTION OF THE OVERALL TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
6:48:05PM UPDATE.
6:48:05PM IT IMPLEMENTS KEY COMPONENTS OF THE ADOPTED VISION.
6:48:10PM THAT INCLUDES SIX KEY VISION THEMES, INCLUDING THE
6:48:14PM TRANSPORTATION IS SAFE, ACCESSIBLE, CONNECTED AND
6:48:16PM CONVENIENT.
6:48:17PM NEIGHBORHOODS ARE COMPLETE WITH A WALKABLE ENVIRONMENT.
6:48:20PM RESILIENCY ENABLES THE COMMUNITY TO RECOVER AND MITIGATE
6:48:24PM CLIMATE CHANGE, WEATHER AND OTHER HAZARDS AS WELL AS SEVERAL
6:48:27PM OTHER THEMES THROUGHOUT.
6:48:28PM WE HAD SIGNIFICANT PUBLIC AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT FOR
6:48:31PM THIS UPDATE AND IMPLEMENTATION WAS COORDINATED CLOSELY WITH
6:48:34PM CITY STAFF IN VARIOUS DEPARTMENTS.
6:48:36PM AS YOU CAN SEE HERE, WE HAVE A PROJECT PAGE FOR THIS
6:48:40PM SECTION.
6:48:40PM THE MOBILITY SECTION IS A PORTION CURRENTLY A PORTION OF THE
6:48:50PM PLACES SECTION IN THE CITY OF TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:48:53PM THE CURRENT GOALS INCLUDE LAND AND TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM
6:48:57PM COORDINATION, WALK/BIKE NETWORK, TRANSIT, NEIGHBORHOOD
6:49:00PM LIVEABILITY AND SAFE, CONVENIENT, AND EFFICIENT ROADWAY.
6:49:03PM THIS SECTION UPDATES AND MODERNIZES MOBILITY-RELATED
6:49:06PM LANGUAGE AND PROVIDES A FRAMEWORK FOR MOBILITY-RELATED
6:49:08PM INITIATIVES.
6:49:08PM THE PROPOSED NEW GOALS FOR THE MOBILITY SECTION INCLUDE
6:49:15PM MULTIMODAL OPTIONS, ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY, SUSTAINABILITY,
6:49:19PM RESILIENCE AND HEALTH, EQUITY AND SAFETY.
6:49:23PM THERE ARE SEVERAL PROPOSED TOPIC AREA UPDATES WITH NEW
6:49:29PM LANGUAGE PROPOSED TO MOST AREAS.
6:49:31PM NOTABLE TOPIC AREAS INCLUDE CONTEXT CLASSIFICATION.
6:49:36PM IT CONSIDERS THE USE OF THE LAND SURROUNDING A ROAD.
6:49:38PM FOR EXAMPLE, A ROAD SURROUNDED BY LARGE NATURAL AREAS MAY BE
6:49:41PM CONSIDERED RURAL FOR ITS CONTEXT SO C-1.
6:49:45PM IN CONTRAST, A ROAD IN DOWNTOWN TAMPA WOULD BE CONSIDERED
6:49:47PM URBAN OR C-6.
6:49:49PM WE ALSO HAVE LANGUAGE ON DEVELOPMENT IMPACTS ON THE
6:49:51PM TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM.
6:49:52PM SO MANY OF THE POLICIES DIRECT OR SUPPORT DEVELOPMENT TO
6:49:54PM INCLUDE MULTIMODAL IMPROVEMENTS WHEREVER POSSIBLE AND
6:49:58PM FEASIBLE, INCLUDING SIDEWALKS, BICYCLE FACILITIES,
6:50:01PM CONNECTING TO TRANSIT, ET CETERA.
6:50:03PM WE HAVE POLICIES ON PARKING AND CURB SPACE MANAGEMENT.
6:50:06PM SO THOSE DIRECT THE IMPLEMENTATION OF PARKING AND CURB SPACE
6:50:09PM STANDARDS THAT RESERVE CURB SPACE FOR THE HIGHEST AND BEST
6:50:11PM USE.
6:50:12PM THIS INCLUDES ADOPTING PARKING POLICIES WITH THE LDC,
6:50:16PM REDUCED PARKING BY TRANSIT AND PARKING THAT FACILITATES SAFE
6:50:20PM AND CONVENIENT WALKING TO BUILDINGS.
6:50:22PM WE HAVE LANGUAGE ON EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES.
6:50:24PM THESE POLICIES SUPPORT THE CITY REVIEWING NEW TECHNOLOGIES
6:50:27PM AND STRATEGIES SUCH AS AUTONOMOUS CONNECTED AND ELECTRIC
6:50:31PM VEHICLES, ENHANCED TRAFFIC SYSTEMS AND COORDINATION WITH
6:50:33PM COMPANIES SUCH AS UBER AND LYFT.
6:50:36PM WE HAVE POLICY LANGUAGE ON TRANSPORTATION INVESTMENTS THAT
6:50:39PM IMPROVE RESILIENCE AND HEALTH.
6:50:41PM THESE POLICIES ENCOURAGE EVALUATION OF ROADWAY IMPACTS TO
6:50:43PM THE ENVIRONMENT, NEIGHBORHOODS, AND COMMERCIAL AREAS, THE
6:50:46PM CAPABILITY OF EVACUATION AND A FOCUS ON THE HEALTH
6:50:49PM IMPROVEMENTS OF TRANSPORTATION PROJECTS.
6:50:51PM WE ALSO HAVE EQUITABLE TRANSPORTATION PROJECT DEVELOPMENT
6:50:54PM AND PRIORITIZATION.
6:50:55PM I REALIZE THAT IS A MOUTHFUL, WHAT THAT MEANS IS WE'RE
6:50:58PM FOCUSING ON THE COMPLETION OF CRITICAL WALK AND BIKE
6:51:01PM CONNECTIONS IN UNDERSERVED COMMUNITIES, CONSIDERING THE
6:51:03PM NEGATIVE IMPACTS OF CERTAIN TRANSPORTATION PROJECTS TO
6:51:05PM UNDERSERVED COMMUNITIES, AND REVIEWING SOCIODEMOGRAPHIC AND
6:51:09PM EQUITY FACTORS DURING THE PROJECT DEVELOPMENT AND DESIGN
6:51:12PM PROCESS.
6:51:12PM FINALLY, WE HAVE A FOCUS ON VISION ZERO AND A SAFE SYSTEMS
6:51:16PM APPROACH.
6:51:16PM SO THESE POLICIES COORDINATE WITH THE CITY'S VISION ZERO
6:51:19PM ACTION PLAN.
6:51:20PM VISION ZERO AIMS TO ELIMINATE ALL SEVERE INJURIES AND
6:51:23PM FATALITIES ON OUR ROADWAYS AND SAFE SYSTEMS APPROACH FOCUSES
6:51:26PM ON HOW BOTH HUMAN MISTAKES AND HUMAN VULNERABILITY AND
6:51:31PM DESIGNS A SYSTEM WITH MANY REDUNDANCIES IN PLACE TO PROTECT
6:51:35PM EVERYONE.
6:51:36PM OTHER UPDATES FOR THE SECTION INCLUDE THAT THE LANGUAGE
6:51:41PM BETTER SUITED TO OTHER SECTIONS HAS BEEN PROPOSED TO BE
6:51:44PM MOVED.
6:51:45PM WE REMOVED REGULATORY AND PROGRAMMATIC LANGUAGE AND
6:51:50PM STREAMLINING THE LANGUAGE AND REMOVING DUPLICATION.
6:51:52PM ALSO UPDATED MAPS AND DATA TO MEET CHAPTER 163 STATE STATUTE
6:51:57PM REQUIREMENTS FOR COMPREHENSIVE PLANS AND WE INCLUDED MINOR
6:51:59PM DEFINITION ADDITIONS AND CLARIFICATIONS.
6:52:01PM WE HAD EXTENSIVE STAKEHOLDER AND PUBLIC OUTREACH.
6:52:07PM MAY 2023, WE HAD FORMAL ANNOUNCEMENTS AS WELL AS PROJECT
6:52:11PM WEBSITE, AND OUR PUBLIC OUTREACH KICKOFF.
6:52:14PM THIS INCLUDED E-MAILS, SOCIAL MEDIA AND IN-PERSON OUTREACH
6:52:17PM CAMPAIGNS.
6:52:17PM WE CREATED REFERENCE DOCUMENTS TO ENABLE GREATER
6:52:21PM TRANSPARENCY AND STAKEHOLDER REVIEW, SPECIFICALLY, THIS IS
6:52:23PM WHAT WE CALL A CROSSWALK, SO IT SHOWS YOU THE ADOPTED
6:52:27PM LANGUAGE AND THEN WHAT WE'RE PROPOSING, WHETHER THAT IS A
6:52:29PM MINOR CHANGE, A SUBSTANTIAL CHANGE, A MOVEMENT OF A POLICY
6:52:31PM OR DELETION OF A POLICY.
6:52:33PM IN JUNE WE ALSO HAD TWO PUBLIC MEETINGS.
6:52:35PM ONE IN PERSON AND ONE VIRTUAL.
6:52:37PM THE VIRTUAL MEETING WAS RECORDED AND PLACED ON OUR PROJECT
6:52:41PM PAGE.
6:52:41PM WE DID HAVE PUBLIC COMMENT ON THE MOBILITY SECTION.
6:52:47PM THE OFFICIAL PUBLIC COMMENT INCLUDED COMMENTS ON ADA
6:52:50PM COMPLIANCE AND INCLUSIVE TERMINOLOGY.
6:52:52PM STAFF REVIEWED AND INCLUDED THAT WHERE APPROPRIATE.
6:52:54PM WE HEARD FROM THE SIERRA CLUB, INCLUDING COMMENTS ON
6:52:58PM WALKING, BIKING, PUBLIC TRANSIT, VISION ZERO AND ELECTRIC
6:53:01PM VEHICLES FOR THE CITY'S FLEET.
6:53:02PM HAPPY TO SAY THAT THE MOBILITY SECTION ADDRESSED ALL OF
6:53:05PM THOSE COMMENTS WITH THE NEW LANGUAGE.
6:53:07PM WE ALSO HAD A CITY OF TAMPA SOCIAL MEDIA POST WHERE WE
6:53:10PM RECEIVED HUNDREDS OF COMMENTS ON THAT POST.
6:53:12PM THE MAIN THEMES INCLUDED TRANSIT, INCLUDING LIGHT RAIL AND
6:53:16PM IMPROVED BUS SYSTEM.
6:53:18PM DEVELOPMENT IN TRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE TO SUPPORT IT,
6:53:20PM STORMWATER AND DRAINAGE AND PRESERVATION OF TREES.
6:53:24PM FOR AGENCY COMMENT, WE DID NOT RECEIVE ANY OBJECTIONS, AND I
6:53:32PM WOULD ALSO LIKE TO SAY THAT THE CITY OF TAMPA STAFF
6:53:35PM SUPPORTED THIS PROPOSED SECTION UPDATE.
6:53:38PM FOR OUR CONSISTENCY REVIEW, THIS WAS FOUND CONSISTENT WITH
6:53:45PM THE ADOPTED MOBILITY AND LAND USE SECTIONS IN THE LANGUAGE.
6:53:50PM HERE I LISTED REPRESENTATIVE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES
6:53:53PM FOR BOTH THE MOBILITY SECTION AND LAND USE SECTION.
6:53:56PM THAT INCLUDES MOBILITY GOAL ONE, OBJECTIVE 1.1 AND POLICY
6:54:00PM 1.1.2 AS WELL AS LAND USE GOAL 1, OBJECTIVE 1.2 AND POLICY
6:54:04PM 1.2.9.
6:54:07PM SO THESE POLICIES INCLUDE A MULTIMODAL TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM
6:54:10PM THAT'S IN LINE WITH THE CITY'S GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT.
6:54:13PM AGAIN, REFERENCING THOSE MOBILITY POLICIES AND OBJECTIVES.
6:54:16PM THE PROPOSED SECTION ALSO BRIDGES THE CONNECTION BETWEEN
6:54:19PM LAND USE AND MOBILITY BY SUPPORTING ESTABLISHED LAND USE
6:54:22PM GOALS OF WELL-DESIGNED URBAN ENVIRONMENTS AND MULTIMODAL
6:54:25PM COMPONENTS.
6:54:25PM AGAIN, REFERENCING LAND USE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES LISTED
6:54:28PM HERE.
6:54:29PM THE RECOMMENDATION, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FOUND
6:54:35PM TA/CPA 23-01 CONSISTENT WITH THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:54:39PM AND THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
6:54:41PM I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
6:54:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FROM COUNCIL MEMBERS?
6:54:44PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WISHING TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, SIR?
6:54:51PM WE HAVE A GENTLEMAN THAT'S GOING TO COME UP.
6:54:57PM >> MY NAME IS DAVE COLEMAN.
6:55:00PM CLASS OF '72.
6:55:02PM LONG ISLAND IN SUFFOLK COUNTY.
6:55:12PM THE POPULATION OF SUFFOLK COUNTY WAS 1.1 MILLION PEOPLE 50
6:55:14PM YEARS AGO, AND NOW IT'S 1.5 MILLION, 50 YEARS LATER, AND
6:55:19PM IT'S ONLY 50 MILES FROM NEW YORK CITY.
6:55:20PM SO UNBRIDLED GROWTH DOESN'T NECESSARILY HAVE TO BE A THING
6:55:25PM FOR SUCCESS.
6:55:25PM ANYWAY, I'M BURNING MY TIME.
6:55:32PM SO AGENDA NUMBER 5 SAYS TO UPDATE THE LANGUAGE OF THE FIVE
6:55:38PM MAIN GOALS IN THE FUTURE LAND USE.
6:55:40PM ONE OF THEM INCLUDES THE WORD "EQUITY."
6:55:42PM I RECENTLY ATTENDED A FUTURE LAND USE MEETING.
6:55:45PM IT WAS ON THE SAME DAY UNFORTUNATELY AS THE MAYOR'S BUDGET
6:55:48PM MEETING.
6:55:48PM THE MAIN TOPICS REPEATED IN THE FLU PRESENTATION WERE
6:55:51PM HOUSING AND TRANSPORTATION.
6:55:52PM SO I SPOKE TO THE INEQUITY ACROSS OUR CITY IN HOUSING
6:55:57PM PARTICULARLY OF LOW-INCOME SENIORS AND SOME FAILURES OF
6:56:00PM TRANSPORTATION.
6:56:01PM THE PRESENTER THERE TOLD ME THE FUTURE LAND USE WASN'T ABOUT
6:56:05PM EQUITY, AND THAT THERE WERE VARIOUS OTHER AVENUES WITHIN THE
6:56:07PM CITY TO ADDRESS THOSE ISSUES.
6:56:09PM I AM GLAD YOU DO HAVE THE WORD EQUITY IN YOUR LANGUAGE AND I
6:56:13PM WAS LISTENING TO WHAT WAS JUST SAID, BUT MORE SO I HOPE IT
6:56:17PM IS AN ABIDING PRINCIPLE.
6:56:19PM IF PEOPLE ARE CALLING FOR HOUSING AND TRANSPORTATION, SIMPLY
6:56:24PM MUST BE A PRIORITY GOING FORWARD.
6:56:25PM I ALSO ASKED ABOUT SULPHUR SPRINGS.
6:56:27PM IT'S NOT A CRA, AND I WAS TOLD IT WASN'T AN URBAN VILLAGE.
6:56:31PM SO WHAT IS IT?
6:56:32PM IT SEEMS IT'S A HISTORIC COMMUNITY MUCH IGNORED.
6:56:35PM A WHILE BACK I BROUGHT PICTURES OF THE VARIOUS SIDEWALK
6:56:38PM TREATMENTS, GRANTED BY VARIANCES OVER THE YEARS.
6:56:42PM WHAT THE CITY AND COUNTY HAVE ALLOWED IS ABYSMAL.
6:56:45PM IF NEBRASKA AVENUE IS SULPHUR SPRINGS MAIN STREET, IT IS ONE
6:56:48PM OF THE CRAPPIEST MAIN STREETS I'VE SEEN IN MY LIFE.
6:56:51PM CAN FUTURE LAND USE CLEAN UP SOME CITY CODES AND CREATE A
6:56:54PM REAL MAIN STREET, NO SHELTER, NO BENCH BUS STOPS HAVE TO GO.
6:56:58PM I WAS AT THE LAST TUESDAY MEETING WHERE A GRANDMOTHER SAID
6:57:02PM HER GRANDCHILD WAS TERRIFIED TO WALK EVEN WITH HER TO
6:57:06PM SCHOOL.
6:57:06PM OUR CHIEF SAID SOMEBODY WOULD BE THERE TO WALK THEM THE NEXT
6:57:09PM DAY.
6:57:10PM WHY IS IT LIKE THIS?
6:57:11PM THROUGH CODES AND ALLOWING ONLY GOOD VARIANCES CAN YOU CLEAN
6:57:14PM UP MAIN STREET, UNLIKE THE CITY'S INABILITY TO CLEAN UP THE
6:57:18PM HILLSBOROUGH RIVER, I WAS LISTENING INTENTLY THIS MORNING.
6:57:20PM OR GET A CLEAN ENERGY GOAL WORTH ANYTHING.
6:57:23PM EQUITY NEEDS TO BE IN THE FLU.
6:57:30PM PLEASE, IF YOU CAN'T ATTEND COMMUNITY MEETINGS IN THE
6:57:32PM FUTURE, SEND AN AIDE.
6:57:34PM HEAR THE VOICES OF STRUGGLING PEOPLE.
6:57:36PM SINCE THE MEETING IS ABOUT DINING AND DRINKING WHICH IT WAS
6:57:39PM EARLIER, REMINDER THAT SULPHUR SPRINGS HAS A RIVER JUST LIKE
6:57:42PM RIVERWALK.
6:57:43PM THANK YOU.
6:57:43PM CLEAN UP MAIN STREET.
6:57:45PM CREATE SIDEWALKS AND SAFE STREETS FOR KIDS.
6:57:47PM PROVIDE TRANSPORTATION OPTIONS.
6:57:48PM THE RESIDENTS DESERVE ALL THAT IN FUTURE LAND USE.
6:57:53PM THANK YOU FOR LISTENING TO ME.
6:57:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
6:57:55PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:57:55PM IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM
6:58:01PM NUMBER 5?
6:58:01PM WOULD YOU LIKE TIME FOR REBUTTAL MA'AM?
6:58:04PM >> JUST A CLARIFICATION.
6:58:05PM THE AGENDA SAYS THAT THIS INCLUDES AN AMENDMENT TO THE
6:58:09PM FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT.
6:58:11PM THE MOBILITY SECTION IS ITS OWN SECTION OUTSIDE OF THE
6:58:13PM FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT.
6:58:15PM I WANTED TO CLARIFY THAT FOR ANY MOTIONS AND WILL IS IN
6:58:19PM REGARDS TO THE GENTLEMAN'S COMMENTS.
6:58:21PM THANK YOU.
6:58:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:58:22PM THAT CONCLUDES PUBLIC COMMENT.
6:58:24PM THERE'S NOBODY REGISTERED.
6:58:26PM IS THERE A MOTION TO CLOSE?
6:58:27PM MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
6:58:29PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
6:58:30PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:58:30PM AYE.
6:58:32PM COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON -- COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA, LIKE TO
6:58:38PM MOVE TO TRANSMIT.
6:58:39PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: [MICROPHONE NOT ON]
6:58:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
6:58:44PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
6:58:46PM ROLL CALL VOTE, PLEASE.
6:58:50PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
6:58:51PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
6:58:53PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
6:58:54PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
6:58:55PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
6:58:57PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
6:58:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
6:58:58PM >>THE CLERK: THE MOTION CARRIED.
6:59:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:59:01PM NEXT IS ITEM NUMBER 7.
6:59:08PM WHO WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT ON ITEM NUMBER 7?
6:59:20PM >> I APOLOGIZE.
6:59:21PM IT'S BEEN A LONG NIGHT.
6:59:22PM GOOD EVENING, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN.
6:59:23PM DIEGO GUERRA, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
6:59:25PM THIS ITEM IS TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN 23-11.
6:59:29PM THE UPDATE TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL SECTION.
6:59:32PM THIS UPDATE WOULD REPLACE THE ENVIRONMENTAL SECTION WITH THE
6:59:36PM PROPOSED LANGUAGE IN YOUR PACKETS.
6:59:39PM AGAIN, THIS IS AN UPDATE.
6:59:42PM THE ENVIRONMENTAL SECTION IS A SEPARATE SECTION, APART FROM
6:59:45PM THE ENVIRONMENTAL -- APART FROM THE FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT
6:59:49PM OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:59:53PM THE ENVIRONMENTAL SECTION IS HOUSED WITHIN THE NATURAL
6:59:55PM SPACES OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:59:58PM CURRENTS CONTEXT INCLUDES LANGUAGE ON NATURAL RESOURCE
7:00:00PM MANAGEMENT, THE TAMPA BAY ESTUARY AND COASTAL HIGH HAZARD
7:00:03PM AREA.
7:00:03PM THERE'S MINIMAL LANGUAGE ON URBAN FORESTRY AND WILDLIFE
7:00:07PM CORRIDORS.
7:00:07PM AND WATER RESOURCE LANGUAGE THAT DID EXIST IN THE SECTION IS
7:00:12PM NOW INCORPORATED INTO THE ONE WATER CHAPTER, WHICH BECAME
7:00:15PM EFFECTIVE IN APRIL OF THIS YEAR.
7:00:18PM THE LANGUAGE WAS DEVELOPED COLLABORATIVELY WITH CITY STAFF
7:00:23PM AND EPC, AND IS CONSISTENT WITH THEIR PROGRAMS.
7:00:28PM IT ALSO INCORPORATES FEEDBACK FROM THE PUBLIC AND
7:00:31PM STAKEHOLDERS.
7:00:33PM AN UPDATE -- SO AN UPDATE TO THE PROPOSED LANGUAGE.
7:00:37PM WE RETAINED THE IMPORTANT COMPONENTS OF THE EXISTING PLAN,
7:00:42PM UPDATED AND MODERNIZED THESE COMPONENTS.
7:00:46PM 20% OF THE PROPOSED LANGUAGE IS NEW WITH THE REMAINING 80%
7:00:50PM OF THE PROPOSED LANGUAGE INCLUDES THE EXISTING LANGUAGE.
7:00:56PM THE GOALS, OBJECTIVES, AND POLICIES.
7:00:58PM AGAIN, ALL WE DID WAS GO AHEAD AND MODERNIZE THESE
7:01:02PM COMPONENTS, STREAMLINED, REMOVED REGULATORY AND PROGRAMMATIC
7:01:09PM LANGUAGE.
7:01:10PM WE REDUCED THE SIZE OF THE SECTION FROM OVER 200 GOALS,
7:01:13PM OBJECTIVES, AND POLICIES TO 147 IN THE ENVIRONMENTAL
7:01:17PM SUSTAINABILITY SECTION THAT IS BEING PROPOSED.
7:01:19PM THE NEW SECTION UPDATES AND MODERNIZES THE LANGUAGE AND
7:01:22PM PROVIDES A FRAMEWORK FOR ENVIRONMENTALLY RELATED
7:01:27PM INITIATIVES.
7:01:29PM WHAT ARE THE PROPOSED CHANGES?
7:01:30PM THE PROPOSED CHANGES INCLUDE NEW LANGUAGE ON ALTERNATIVE
7:01:32PM ENERGY WHICH SUPPORTS THE CITY OF TAMPA'S RECENTLY RELEASED
7:01:37PM CLIMATE ACTION EQUITY PLAN.
7:01:38PM THERE'S NEW LANGUAGE ON WILDLIFE CORRIDORS.
7:01:41PM THERE'S NEW LANGUAGE THAT SUPPORTS THE URBAN FOREST
7:01:45PM MANAGEMENT PLAN, AND THE TAMPA BAY ESTUARY AND COASTAL
7:01:51PM RELATED LANGUAGE THAT CURRENTLY EXISTS IS BEING PROPOSED
7:01:55PM WITH THIS UPDATE TO BE MOVED TO THE COASTAL MANAGEMENT
7:01:58PM SECTION, WHICH IS MORE APPROPRIATE FOR THAT LANGUAGE.
7:02:02PM MOBILITY RELATED LANGUAGE WOULD BE MOVED TO THE MOBILITY
7:02:04PM SECTION AS PREVIOUSLY MENTIONED.
7:02:07PM AND THE LAND USE SPECIFIC LANGUAGE WOULD BE MOVED OVER TO
7:02:09PM THE LAND USE SECTION.
7:02:11PM THE PROPOSED GOALS, OBJECTIVES, AND POLICIES ARE DEPICTED ON
7:02:21PM THE SLIDE.
7:02:22PM THE FIRST GOAL IS SPECIFIC TO CLEAN ENERGY.
7:02:24PM THE SECOND GOAL IS THE PRESERVATION, CONSERVATION,
7:02:28PM RESTORATION MANAGEMENT OF OUR NATURAL RESOURCES.
7:02:30PM AND THE THIRD GOAL IS THE HILLSBOROUGH RIVER MASTER PLAN.
7:02:34PM IN TERMS OF STAKEHOLDER AND PUBLIC OUTREACH, WE ANNOUNCED A
7:02:44PM PUBLIC OUTREACH IN MAY/JUNE.
7:02:48PM WE LAUNCHED A WEBSITE TO ENSURE THAT THE PUBLIC WAS
7:02:51PM INFORMED.
7:02:52PM WE PUT REFERENCE DOCUMENTS ON THE WEBSITE TO ENABLE GREATER
7:02:56PM TRANSPARENCY AND STAKEHOLDER REVIEW.
7:03:00PM WE ALSO HAD TARGETED OUTREACH TO STATE ENVIRONMENTAL
7:03:04PM ORGANIZATIONS.
7:03:04PM THE FINAL VERSION THAT'S PRESENTED BEFORE YOU REFLECTS THIS
7:03:07PM OUTREACH AND INCORPORATES THEIR FEEDBACK AS WELL.
7:03:10PM IN TERMS OF AGENCY COMMENT, WE DID NOT HAVE ANY OBJECTIONS
7:03:15PM FROM REVIEWING AGENCIES; HOWEVER, WE DID RECEIVE COMMENTS
7:03:19PM FROM EPC, TPO AND THE SCHOOL BOARD.
7:03:22PM IN TERMS OF CONSISTENCY, THE SECTION UPDATE IS CONSISTENT
7:03:28PM WITH THE CURRENT GOALS, OBJECTIVES, AND POLICIES OF THE
7:03:31PM CURRENTLY ADOPTED ENVIRONMENTAL SECTION.
7:03:33PM IN ADDITION TO THE GOALS -- IN ADDITION TO THE OBJECTIVES
7:03:37PM AND POLICIES IN THE RECREATION OPEN SPACE SECTION AND THE
7:03:42PM GOVERNANCE OBJECTIVE AND SOLID WASTE POLICIES.
7:03:45PM NEXT UP, SHOULD YOU CHOOSE TO TRANSMIT, THIS UPDATE WOULD BE
7:03:54PM BROUGHT FORTH TO YOU AGAIN TENTATIVELY ON 26 OCTOBER FOR ITS
7:03:58PM FIRST ADOPTION HEARING.
7:04:01PM LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOUND TA/CPA
7:04:03PM 23-11 CONSISTENT WITH THE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OF
7:04:07PM THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND RECOMMENDS CITY -- THE CITY
7:04:09PM COUNCIL TRANSMIT FOR STATE AND REGIONAL REVIEW.
7:04:11PM THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
7:04:14PM I'M AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE.
7:04:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
7:04:17PM YES, MA'AM.
7:04:18PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
7:04:18PM YOU MENTIONED IT, SO I'M GOING TO ASK, AND YOU WERE HERE FOR
7:04:22PM THE CONVERSATION EARLIER.
7:04:23PM CAN YOU EXPLAIN A LITTLE BIT ABOUT WHAT ADDITIONS POSSIBLY
7:04:29PM WERE MADE ABOUT THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREAS?
7:04:32PM >> SO, CURRENTLY, WE ARE NOT UPDATING THE COASTAL MANAGEMENT
7:04:38PM SECTION AS OF RIGHT NOW.
7:04:39PM THAT IS BEING PROPOSED TO BE BROUGHT FORTH TO YOU SOMETIME
7:04:44PM IN SPRING/SUMMER OF NEXT YEAR.
7:04:46PM DURING THAT UPDATE OF THE COASTAL MANAGEMENT SECTION OF THE
7:04:50PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, THAT'S WHERE THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD
7:04:54PM LANGUAGE WILL EXIST.
7:04:55PM CURRENTLY, THE TAMPA BAY ESTUARY IN TERMS OF COASTAL
7:05:02PM WETLANDS, COASTAL FAUNA FLORA EXISTS IN THIS SECTION, THAT
7:05:06PM IS THAT LANGUAGE BEING PROPOSED TO BE MOVED TO THE COASTAL
7:05:09PM MANAGEMENT SECTION.
7:05:12PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
7:05:12PM THAT CLARIFIES IT.
7:05:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:05:14PM ANYBODY ELSE?
7:05:14PM NO.
7:05:15PM YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD.
7:05:17PM >> DIEGO GUERRA.
7:05:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DIEGO GUERRA.
7:05:24PM G-U-E-R-R-A?
7:05:26PM >> CORRECT.
7:05:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY WISHING TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER
7:05:29PM 7?
7:05:29PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN AND
7:05:33PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
7:05:34PM ALL IN FAVOR?
7:05:34PM AYE.
7:05:35PM >> MOVE TO TRANSIT.
7:05:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO TRANSMIT FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
7:05:39PM VIERA.
7:05:41PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
7:05:42PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
7:05:44PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
7:05:44PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
7:05:46PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
7:05:47PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
7:05:49PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
7:05:50PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
7:05:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
7:05:52PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
7:05:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
7:06:00PM NEXT UP IS ITEM NUMBER 8.
7:06:06PM MR. GARDNER, I THOUGHT YOU WOULD BE UP AROUND 11:00.
7:06:09PM YOU GOT LUCKY.
7:06:11PM YES, SIR.
7:06:47PM >> GOOD EVENING.
7:06:58PM DANNY COLLINS AGAIN WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
7:07:01PM THIS IS TA/CPA 23-15.
7:07:03PM IT'S A PRIVATELY INITIATED TEXT AMENDMENT TO THE
7:07:06PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN RELATED TO ENVIRONMENTAL SENSITIVE AREAS.
7:07:10PM JUST A QUICK BACKGROUND, PRIVATELY INITIATED AMENDMENT.
7:07:16PM SEEKS MORE FLEXIBILITY FOR DEVELOPMENT NEAR ESA LANDS WITHIN
7:07:19PM THE WESTSHORE PLANNING DISTRICT.
7:07:21PM CURRENTLY, UNDER THE ADOPTED PLAN, PROJECTS ARE ELIGIBLE FOR
7:07:34PM A DENSITY INTENSITY CREDIT IF ESA LANDS EXCEED 20% OF THE
7:07:40PM TOTAL PROJECT AREA.
7:07:40PM AS PROPOSED THROUGH THIS AMENDMENT, IF 50% OR MORE OF A SITE
7:07:42PM ARE DEEMED WETLANDS, THE APPLICANT WILL BE ALLOWED TO WAIVE
7:07:46PM THE DENSITY AND/OR INTENSITY THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE SITE
7:07:49PM THROUGH A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT ZONING DISTRICT.
7:07:51PM THIS AMENDMENT WOULD ONLY APPLY TO THE WESTSHORE PLANNING
7:07:53PM DISTRICT.
7:07:54PM SO IT WOULD NOT APPLY CITYWIDE.
7:07:56PM FOR THIS AMENDMENT -- FOR A DEVELOPER TO USE THIS AMENDMENT,
7:08:06PM THERE ARE SOME CONDITIONS THAT ARE PROVIDED IN THE LANGUAGE.
7:08:08PM ALL PORTIONS OF THE SITE MUST BE CONTIGUOUS.
7:08:12PM THE 25% ESA CREDIT THAT'S CURRENTLY ADOPTED BY THE PLAN
7:08:17PM CANNOT BE CLUSTERED FROM LAND OUTSIDE THE COASTAL HIGH
7:08:20PM HAZARD AREA TO LAND INSIDE THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA.
7:08:23PM THE CALCULATIONS OF DENSITY AND INTENSITY CAN ONLY BE
7:08:26PM APPLIED TO THE UPLAND ACREAGE OF THE SITE.
7:08:29PM AND THE COMBINED TOTAL NUMBER OF DWELLING UNITS AND/OR
7:08:32PM F.A.R. POSSIBLE UNDER ALL PLAN CATEGORIES WITHIN THE PROJECT
7:08:35PM WILL BE USED AS A CEILING.
7:08:38PM TO GET A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF WHERE THE ESA LANDS ARE
7:08:42PM WITHIN THE WESTSHORE PLANNING DISTRICT, HERE IS THE ADOPTED
7:08:46PM FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
7:08:49PM THE ESA LANDS ARE -- THEY MAKE UP LESS THAN I BELIEVE 1% OF
7:08:55PM ALL LAND WITHIN THE WESTSHORE PLANNING DISTRICT, SO IT IS A
7:08:57PM SMALL AREA WITHIN THE DISTRICT.
7:09:00PM THE ESA LANDS, I DON'T KNOW IF YOU CAN SEE IT ON YOUR MAPS,
7:09:04PM BUT THEY ARE GENERALLY NORTH OF 275 AND THEN SOUTH OF THE
7:09:13PM COURTNEY CAMPBELL CAUSEWAY UP AROUND ROCKY POINT.
7:09:15PM ESA LANDS ARE RECOGNIZED BY THIS TEAL COLOR THAT RUNS ALONG
7:09:18PM THE COASTLINE.
7:09:21PM THE AFFECTED AREAS WHERE THIS PROVISION WOULD APPLY WOULD BE
7:09:25PM LIKELY, THESE AREAS ADJACENT TO ESA LANDS, SO YOU HAVE JUST
7:09:30PM SOUTH OF COURTNEY CAMPBELL CAUSEWAY.
7:09:33PM YOU HAVE LAND THAT'S ADJACENT TO LIGHT INDUSTRIAL AND
7:09:36PM PUBLIC, SEMI-PUBLIC.
7:09:38PM THERE IS SOME ESA LANDS ADJACENT TO COMMUNITY COMMERCIAL 35
7:09:41PM DESIGNATED PARCELS.
7:09:43PM AS YOU MOVE UP ALONG ROCKY POINT, THERE IS LAND, ESA LANDS
7:09:47PM ADJACENT TO CMU-35, AND URBAN MIXED USE 60 UP ALONG ROCKY
7:09:51PM POINT.
7:09:52PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF SENT THIS OUT TO OUR REVIEWING
7:10:02PM AGENCIES.
7:10:03PM CITY LEGAL HAD MET -- OR HAD SOME COMMENTS FOR THE
7:10:09PM APPLICANT, AND THE APPLICANT HAS ADDRESSED THOSE COMMENTS.
7:10:12PM ALSO, THE APPLICANT HAS ADDRESSED EPC'S COMMENTS THAT ARE
7:10:17PM PROVIDED IN THE STAFF PACKET.
7:10:19PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FOUND IT
7:10:23PM CONSISTENT WITH SEVERAL POLICIES OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
7:10:28PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOUND IT CONSISTENT WITH POLICIES
7:10:30PM THAT SEEK TO PRESERVE AND PROTECT ESA LANDS IN THE CITY.
7:10:35PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOUND IT CONSISTENT WITH POLICIES
7:10:38PM THAT SEEK A NO NET INCREASE IN RESIDENTIAL DENSITY WITHIN
7:10:42PM THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA SO THIS WOULD NOT INCREASE
7:10:45PM DENSITY WITHIN THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA AND THAT'S
7:10:49PM BECAUSE YOU CANNOT MOVE THE DENSITY CREDIT FROM LAND OUTSIDE
7:10:52PM THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA AND USE IT WITHIN THE COASTAL
7:10:55PM HIGH HAZARD AREA.
7:10:56PM FINALLY, THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOUND IT CONSISTENT WITH
7:10:58PM LAND USE POLICIES 2.1.2 AND HOUSING POLICY 1.3.4, WHICH SEEK
7:11:02PM TO USE LIMITED LAND RESOURCES MORE EFFICIENTLY.
7:11:05PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION
7:11:10PM RECOMMENDS THAT THE PROPOSED TEXT AMENDMENT BE FOUND
7:11:13PM CONSISTENT WITH THE GOALS, OBJECTIVES, AND POLICIES OF THE
7:11:15PM TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
7:11:16PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
7:11:18PM I'M AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
7:11:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DID I SEE CORRECTLY ON THE MAP THAT THIS
7:11:21PM IS NORTH OF HOWARD FRANKLAND?
7:11:26PM >> YES.
7:11:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IT IS A VERY SMALL AREA.
7:11:29PM LIKE 1%.
7:11:31PM >> YES.
7:11:32PM IT'S KIND OF HARD TO TELL ON THE MAP.
7:11:33PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IT'S BETWEEN THE CAUSEWAY AND THE --
7:11:37PM >> AND THE COURTNEY CAMPBELL.
7:11:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
7:11:42PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: IN REVIEWING YOUR PLAN, THE TAMPA BAY ON
7:11:46PM ONE SIDE, WITH THE PLAN YOU SHOWED DEFINING THE AREA, IS ANY
7:11:50PM OF THIS LAND UNDERWATER THAT WE'RE REVIEWING?
7:11:53PM >>DANNY COLLINS: THIS IS ENVIRONMENTAL SENSITIVE AREA.
7:11:55PM ESA LANDS INCLUDE ANYTHING, ANY WETLANDS, CRITICAL HABITAT.
7:12:04PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: ON THE WATER YOU'RE NOT GOING TO BE ABLE
7:12:05PM TO BUILD SOMETHING?
7:12:07PM >>DANNY COLLINS: NO, ONLY APPLY TO ESA LANDS.
7:12:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU CAN'T DREDGE AND FILL AND CREATE.
7:12:14PM >>DANNY COLLINS: NO.
7:12:14PM IT WOULD REQUIRE -- THIS IS JUST THE PLAN AMENDMENT -- OR
7:12:19PM THE TEXT AMENDMENT TO THE PLAN THAT ANY EPC REVIEWS WOULD
7:12:24PM NEED TO BE DONE AT THE TIME OF PERMITTING OR THROUGH THE
7:12:26PM REZONING PHASE.
7:12:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
7:12:31PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SO THE ACTUAL DIRECT IMPACT OF THIS, SO
7:12:35PM YOU'VE GOT THIS UNBUILDABLE LAND THAT'S ENVIRONMENTALLY
7:12:39PM SENSITIVE, AND THEY WANT TO TRANSFER WHAT WOULD HAVE BEEN
7:12:44PM RIGHTS FOR THAT SQUARE FOOTAGE TO LAND TO THE DRY LAND AND
7:12:50PM INCREASE DENSITY IN THAT AREA?
7:12:52PM WHAT IS THE PRACTICAL INTENT HERE?
7:12:57PM >>DANNY COLLINS: THERE'S NO INCREASES IN DENSITY.
7:13:01PM ESSENTIALLY WHAT HAPPENS IS THERE IS ESA LANDS ON A SITE, SO
7:13:05PM IF YOU GET A PD THAT MIGHT HAVE ESA LANDS IN IT.
7:13:09PM AND IT OFTEN MAKES IT DIFFICULT TO DEVELOP SOME PARCELS.
7:13:13PM SO THIS WOULD ALLOW THEM TO ACTUALLY MOVE SOME DEVELOPMENT
7:13:17PM RIGHTS AWAY FROM THE ESA LANDS.
7:13:21PM IT WOULD ACTUALLY HELP TO -- IT WOULD ACTUALLY HELP PRESERVE
7:13:26PM SOME OF THE ESA LANDS BY NOT PUTTING BUILDINGS RIGHT UP
7:13:29PM AGAINST SOME OF THESE LANDS.
7:13:31PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU.
7:13:33PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
7:13:33PM APPLICANT, MR. GARDNER, YES, SIR.
7:13:41PM >> TRUETT GARDNER, 400 NORTH ASHLEY DRIVE.
7:13:43PM ACTUALLY, I THINK BY ANSWERING THOSE TWO QUESTIONS YOU
7:13:47PM ASKED, MIGHT GIVE THE WHOLE PRESENTATION.
7:13:49PM I HAVE ADDIE CLARK, WHO IS GOING TO WALK THROUGH THE
7:13:50PM MECHANICS, AND ABBEY NAYLOR WHO IS OUR ENVIRONMENTAL
7:13:54PM CONSULTANT.
7:13:54PM MR. MIRANDA, TO YOUR QUESTION, THIS DOES NOT INVOLVE
7:13:57PM SUBMERGED LANDS.
7:13:59PM ONLY ESA LANDS.
7:14:00PM MR. CLENDENIN, TO YOUR QUESTION, WHAT THIS DOES, IF YOU'VE
7:14:03PM GOT A SITE THAT HAS A HIGH DEGREE OF ESA ON IT, THEN THE
7:14:07PM REASON WHY WE THINK THIS IS A VERY GOOD POLICY, INSTEAD OF
7:14:10PM TRYING TO SHOEHORN A DEVELOPMENT IN THE REMAINDER, THEN THAT
7:14:14PM PORTION THAT IS THE REMAINDER, THAT DENSITY COULD TRAVEL
7:14:17PM DOWN TO AN ADJACENT SITE THROUGH A PD WHICH THEN WOULD
7:14:21PM PROVIDE THE ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM TO MAKE SURE THAT ESA SITE
7:14:25PM IS PROTECTED AND FULL.
7:14:26PM SO INSTEAD OF HAVING THE SITES THAT ARE, IN THIS CASE, 51%
7:14:31PM ENVIRONMENTAL, 49% UPLAND, INSTEAD OF TRYING TO MAKE A
7:14:36PM DEVELOPMENT WORK ON THE 49%, YOU CAN TAKE THAT 49% AND APPLY
7:14:40PM THAT TO AN ADJACENT SITE WITHIN A PD.
7:14:43PM THERE'S ACTUALLY, AND IT'S FUNNY, MS. NAILER WILL SPEAK TO
7:14:51PM THE PRESENTATION THAT WAS JUST DONE.
7:14:54PM THIS FURTHERS THAT.
7:14:55PM AS YOU MIGHT HAVE READ, THERE IS A RECENT UNITED STATES
7:14:57PM SUPREME COURT DECISION, SACKETT, WHICH BASICALLY IS LIMITING
7:15:02PM THE ABILITY TO PROTECT WETLANDS THAT ARE NOT CONTIGUOUS.
7:15:07PM SO THIS IS THAT INSTANCE WHERE IN A SITE YOU MIGHT HAVE A
7:15:12PM NONCONTIGUOUS WETLAND INSTEAD OF TRYING TO FORCE A
7:15:14PM DEVELOPMENT THERE, YOU CAN PRESERVE THAT SITE IN ITS
7:15:17PM ENTIRETY AND MOVE THAT DENSITY DOWN TO ANOTHER ADJACENT
7:15:21PM PROPERTY WITHIN THAT PD.
7:15:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD, SIR.
7:15:26PM >> WITH THAT, ADDIE CLARK AND THEN ABBEY NAYLOR.
7:15:33PM >> THANK YOU.
7:15:33PM GOOD EVENING.
7:15:34PM FOR THE RECORD, ADDIE CLARK, 400 NORTH ASHLEY DRIVE.
7:15:37PM AS TRUETT MENTIONED, THE PURPOSE OF THIS TEXT AMENDMENT IS
7:15:40PM TO ENCOURAGE DEVELOPERS TO MAKE A MORE THOUGHTFUL
7:15:43PM DEVELOPMENT THAT IS MORE APPROPRIATELY LOCATED AND HAS FEWER
7:15:46PM WETLAND IMPACTS.
7:15:48PM AND THIS SLIDE HERE I THOUGHT DANNY DID A GREAT JOB OF GOING
7:15:51PM THROUGH THE CRITERIA THAT MUST BE IN PLACE FOR THIS KIND OF
7:15:55PM CLUSTERING EFFECT TO BE ACTIVATED.
7:15:57PM BUT I DID WANT TO FOCUS AGAIN ON THAT.
7:16:00PM THE REQUIREMENT OF 50% OR MORE OF THE SITE BEING DEEMED
7:16:04PM WETLANDS BY THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION COMMISSION AND AS
7:16:08PM WELL, THE SITE MUST BE INCLUDED IN A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT OR
7:16:11PM A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT ALTERNATIVE APPROVED BY THIS COUNCIL.
7:16:14PM SO HERE I'M A VISUAL PERSON, SO I THINK THIS WILL HELP
7:16:20PM EXPLAIN BY THIS EXAMPLE HERE.
7:16:22PM YOU CAN SEE HERE THAT -- IN THIS EXAMPLE, THE DEVELOPER OWNS
7:16:27PM THESE TWO PARCELS, PARCEL ONE AND PARCEL TWO.
7:16:30PM AND THEY ARE CONTIGUOUS AND LOCATED IN THE WESTSHORE
7:16:33PM PLANNING DISTRICT.
7:16:34PM PARCEL ONE ON THE TOP JUST HAS A FEW SMALL AREAS OF UPLAND
7:16:38PM THAT ARE DESIGNATED UMU 60 IN PURPLE.
7:16:42PM AND THE REST OF PARCEL ONE YOU CAN SEE IN THE GREEN.
7:16:45PM IN THIS CASE HAS BEEN DEEMED ESA LAND OR WETLAND BY EPC.
7:16:51PM PARCEL TWO TO THE SOUTH IS ALL UPLAND AND DESIGNATED CMU 35.
7:16:55PM IF THE OWNER WANTED TO DEVELOP TODAY RIGHT NOW BASED ON WHAT
7:16:59PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN HAS WRITTEN, JUST BEYOND THAT FIRST
7:17:03PM ARROW, THE DEVELOPER COULD DEVELOP 10,000 SQUARE FEET ON THE
7:17:06PM UPLAND AREAS OF PARCEL ONE SHOWN IN PURPLE.
7:17:10PM AND 20,000 SQUARE FEET ON PARCEL TWO.
7:17:13PM SO TODAY, THE DENSITY THAT IS CURRENTLY ALLOWED ON PARCEL
7:17:17PM ONE CANNOT BE RELOCATED AWAY TO PARCEL TWO FROM THE WETLANDS
7:17:22PM IN PARCEL ONE.
7:17:24PM SINCE PARCEL TWO IS DESIGNATED CMU 35 AND NOT UMU 60.
7:17:29PM BASIC LAYMAN'S TERMS YOU CAN'T CLUSTER PURPLE ONTO PINK
7:17:32PM RIGHT NOW THE WAY THE COMP PLAN IS WRITTEN.
7:17:35PM THIS PROPOSED AMENDMENT INTENDS TO ALLOW US TO BETTER
7:17:38PM PROTECT THOSE WETLANDS AS TRUETT MENTIONED BY CLUSTERING THE
7:17:42PM 10,000 SQUARE FEET AND THE 20,000 SQUARE FEET OF
7:17:46PM ENTITLEMENTS ALL ON THAT SOUTHERN PARCEL AWAY FROM THE
7:17:48PM WETLANDS THAT EXIST ON PARCEL ONE.
7:17:51PM AGAIN, THIS IS PROPOSING TO CLUSTER THE DENSITY ALL WITHIN
7:17:54PM THE SITE PLAN CONTROLLED PLAN DEVELOPMENT OR PDA.
7:17:59PM THIS IS NOT PROPOSING TO INCREASE ANY ENTITLEMENTS BUT
7:18:02PM RATHER RELOCATE THEM AWAY FROM THAT SENSITIVE AREA.
7:18:04PM YOU CAN SEE HERE IN THAT FIRST SCENARIO, WHICH CAN EXIST
7:18:07PM TODAY, THE TOTAL ENTITLEMENTS OF 30,000 SQUARE FEET DO NOT
7:18:11PM DIFFER FROM THE PROPOSED 30,000 SQUARE FEET JUST LOCATED
7:18:14PM AWAY FROM THOSE WETLANDS.
7:18:16PM NOW HERE I WILL TURN OVER TO ABBEY NAYLOR.
7:18:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
7:18:21PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:18:24PM >> HI.
7:18:26PM ABBEY NAYLOR, 14706 TUDOR CHASE DRIVE.
7:18:30PM UP ON THE SCREEN, ADDIE HAD MENTIONED -- HAD CREATED THE
7:18:37PM SLIDE THAT SHOWS HOW WE'RE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE
7:18:40PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN WITH THIS PROPOSED POLICY.
7:18:42PM I'M GOING TO SPEAK MORE TO THE WETLANDS AND THE PROTECTION.
7:18:46PM SO CLUSTERING THE ENTITLEMENT UPLANDS TO AVOID THE WETLAND
7:18:50PM IMPACT HAS SIGNIFICANT BENEFITS IN ADDITION TO SUPPORTING
7:18:53PM THE ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
7:18:56PM WE BELIEVE THIS PROPOSED POLICY INCENTIVIZES RETAINING
7:19:00PM ESSENTIAL WETLANDS THAT BENEFIT OUR COMMUNITY.
7:19:03PM OBVIOUSLY, WE KNOW THE WETLANDS PROVIDE FLOOD PROTECTION AND
7:19:07PM STORAGE, WATER QUALITY, NUTRIENT REMOVAL, CARBON
7:19:10PM SEQUESTRATION, EROSION PREVENTION AND HABITAT FOR FISH AND
7:19:15PM WILDLIFE AND RECREATION.
7:19:16PM BY SHIFTING THIS DENSITY TO THE UPLANDS WITHOUT INCREASING
7:19:20PM ANY DENSITY, THE POLICY COULD MINIMIZE WETLAND IMPACT IN THE
7:19:24PM CITY WHERE MITIGATION IS OFTEN NOT SET INSIDE THE CITY
7:19:29PM LIMITS BECAUSE WE HAVE LIMITATIONS THERE.
7:19:31PM WE BELIEVE THIS POLICY COULD RESULT IN AN OVERALL RETENTION
7:19:34PM OF WETLANDS WITHIN THE CITY BY ALLOWING TO MOVE THAT DENSITY
7:19:39PM TO ONLY THOSE UPLAND AREAS AWAY FROM THE ESA.
7:19:43PM AS TRUETT MENTIONED, THIS PROPOSED POLICY WILL ALSO HELP
7:19:48PM SUPPORT THE PROPOSED TEXT AMENDMENT THAT WE JUST HEARD TO
7:19:51PM THE FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT AND
7:19:55PM SUSTAINABILITY SECTION.
7:19:56PM PARTICULARLY PROPOSED POLICY 2.8.5, WHICH READS, TO MINIMIZE
7:20:02PM IMPACTS ON OPEN SPACE, ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES, AND
7:20:06PM FLOODPLAINS THROUGH ADOPTED CRITERIA STANDARDS,
7:20:10PM METHODOLOGIES AND PROCEDURES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO,
7:20:13PM CLUSTERING AND THE TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS TO
7:20:16PM INCREASE CONTIGUOUS PERVIOUS SURFACES.
7:20:19PM SO WE THINK THIS IS A REAL BENEFIT TO THE WETLANDS THAT
7:20:22PM EXIST WITHIN THE CITY AND MAY, IN FACT, PRESERVE MORE
7:20:27PM WETLANDS AND ALLOW FOR RETENTION OF MORE WETLANDS WITHIN THE
7:20:32PM WESTSHORE DISTRICT.
7:20:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:20:35PM NEXT.
7:20:36PM ANYBODY?
7:20:37PM YES, SIR.
7:20:39PM >> THAT'S ALL WE HAVE UNLESS YOU HAVE QUESTIONS.
7:20:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
7:20:43PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SO TWO QUESTIONS.
7:20:47PM ONE, IF I'M HEARING YOU CORRECTLY, THE LAND ENTITLEMENTS
7:20:52PM FROM THE LAND THAT'S AROUND THE WETLAND AREA TRANSFERRED TO
7:20:55PM THE OTHER PARCEL WHERE YOU'RE GOING TO DEVELOP SO THAT MEANS
7:20:59PM NO FUTURE DEVELOPER WOULD BE ABLE TO EXERCISE ANY KIND OF
7:21:02PM RIGHT OF ENTITLEMENT IN THAT LAND.
7:21:04PM >> CORRECT.
7:21:04PM I KNOW YOU'RE NOT A FAN OF PDs, BUT I THINK THIS IS THE
7:21:08PM ONE WHERE A PD IS VERY BENEFICIAL BECAUSE THAT'S GOING TO BE
7:21:12PM THE DOCUMENT THAT ENSURES THAT THESE DENSITIES ARE LEAVING
7:21:17PM THAT ENVIRONMENTAL SITE OR THE UPLANDS ON THE ENVIRONMENTAL
7:21:20PM SITE AND BEING TRANSFERRED TO THE UPLANDS SITE AND THOSE
7:21:25PM ENTITLEMENTS WILL NEVER BE ABLE TO GO BACK TO THAT WETLAND
7:21:29PM SITE.
7:21:29PM SO IT WOULD PRESERVE THOSE IN PLACE.
7:21:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MY NEXT QUESTION IS, WHEN SOMEBODY COMES
7:21:35PM AND SAYS, BOY, HAVE I GOT A DEAL FOR YOU, I WONDER IF THIS
7:21:39PM IS GOOD FOR THE WESTSHORE AREA, WHY ISN'T IT GOOD FOR THE
7:21:43PM ENTIRE CITY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN?
7:21:45PM >> SO WE THINK IT ACTUALLY IS GOOD FOR THE ENTIRE CITY PLAN
7:21:49PM IN TALKING WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION, THIS WAS ALMOST
7:21:53PM LIKE LET'S START IT HERE, NOT TO COMPARE CITY OF TAMPA WITH
7:21:56PM HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY, BUT THE SPREADING OR CLUSTERING OF
7:22:00PM DENSITY IS ALLOWED COUNTYWIDE, IF I'M NOT MISTAKEN, MAYBE
7:22:09PM THERE ARE SOME RARE INSTANCES.
7:22:10PM THIS ONE LIMITS IT ONLY TO SITES THAT HAVE THIS HIGH LEVEL
7:22:13PM OF WETLANDS ON-SITE OR ESAs ON-SITE.
7:22:16PM AND THEN, TWO, JUST TO START IT, WAS DEEMED TO BE WESTSHORE
7:22:22PM AS A START.
7:22:22PM BUT I THINK IT'S A GOOD PILOT PROGRAM.
7:22:25PM AS ABBEY MENTIONED AND PLANNING COMMISSION BEFORE, IT'S
7:22:28PM SOMETHING THAT THE PLANNING COMMISSION WOULD LIKE TO SEE ON
7:22:30PM A BROADER SCALE.
7:22:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OKAY.
7:22:33PM 20% IS THE ACREAGE REQUIRED, CORRECT OF ESA LAND?
7:22:39PM >> 50%.
7:22:40PM YES.
7:22:42PM 20% IS THE CURRENT.
7:22:46PM THERE IS NO SPREADING.
7:22:47PM BUT 50% IS WHAT WOULD TRIGGER IT, THE ABILITY TO USE IT IN
7:22:52PM THIS INSTANCE.
7:22:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: GOT IT.
7:22:55PM I SEE IT NOW.
7:22:56PM MISREAD IT.
7:22:56PM THANK YOU.
7:22:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
7:22:59PM ANYBODY ELSE?
7:22:59PM DO WE HAVE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK?
7:23:03PM MR. COLEMAN, WOULD YOU LIKE TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM?
7:23:07PM NO.
7:23:08PM ANYBODY ELSE?
7:23:08PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
7:23:10PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
7:23:13PM ALL IN FAVOR?
7:23:13PM AYE.
7:23:15PM COUNCIL WOMAN HENDERSON, WOULD YOU LIKE TO DO THE HONORS?
7:23:21PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: MOVE TO TRANSMIT.
7:23:25PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
7:23:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON,
7:23:28PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
7:23:30PM ROLL CALL VOTE, PLEASE.
7:23:33PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
7:23:34PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
7:23:36PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
7:23:37PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
7:23:39PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IT PAINS ME TO VOTE FOR SOMETHING THAT'S
7:23:42PM GOING TO INSTITUTIONALIZE PDs.
7:23:45PM PAINS ME.
7:23:45PM PAINS ME.
7:23:46PM YOU OWE ME A MARTINI SOMETIME, SOMEPLACE.
7:23:49PM YES.
7:23:51PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
7:23:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
7:23:54PM >>THE CLERK: THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
7:23:56PM TO TRANSMIT.
7:23:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I TOLD MY WIFE WE WOULD BE HOME BY
7:24:01PM MIDNIGHT.
7:24:02PM LET'S KEEP IT GOING.
7:24:04PM I'LL GO TO NEW BUSINESS.
7:24:06PM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA, DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING?
7:24:07PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES, SIR.
7:24:08PM I HAVE A COUPLE HERE.
7:24:09PM MR. CHAIRMAN AND COUNCIL MEMBERS, ON AUGUST 24th, 2023, I
7:24:13PM MADE A MOTION TO MOVE TWO ITEMS FROM THE 8/31/2023 AGENDA TO
7:24:19PM BE HEARD AT THE DECEMBER WORKSHOP.
7:24:20PM UNFORTUNATELY, THERE IS NOT A WORKSHOP IN DECEMBER.
7:24:23PM I WOULD LIKE TO REINSTATE THE MOTION AND ASK THAT IT BE
7:24:25PM HEARD IN THE FEBRUARY 22 WORKSHOP.
7:24:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM --
7:24:30PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: LET ME READ WHAT THEY ARE.
7:24:31PM IN AN EFFORT TO REDUCE THE NUMBER OF ITEMS ON THE 8/31/2023
7:24:36PM CITY COUNCIL WORKSHOP AS WELL AS TO ASSIST ABBYE FEELEY FROM
7:24:40PM EXHAUSTIVE WORKLOAD IN THE DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC
7:24:42PM OPPORTUNITY, I WOULD LIKE TO SUGGEST THAT WE CONTINUE THE
7:24:45PM FOLLOWING TWO ITEMS TO THE 2024 WORKSHOP, CODE ENFORCEMENT,
7:24:48PM LAND DEVELOPMENT STAFF TO BRING FORTH A PLAN TO BRING
7:24:51PM ILLEGAL RESIDENTIAL UNITS INTO COMPLIANCE.
7:24:54PM AND CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT TO DISCUSS HOW THE CITY
7:24:57PM CAN FAIRLY AND SYSTEMATICALLY GO THROUGH NEIGHBORHOODS TO
7:25:00PM IDENTIFY STRUCTURES AND WORK WITH REALTORS AND REAL ESTATE
7:25:04PM COMMUNITY TO ADEQUATE INFORM BUYERS OF PROPERTIES ABOUT THE
7:25:07PM RIGHTS THAT PROPERTY OWNERS HAVE ON THEIR STRUCTURES.
7:25:10PM >> WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
7:25:13PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
7:25:14PM ALL IN FAVOR?
7:25:14PM AYE.
7:25:15PM ANY OPPOSED?
7:25:16PM ANYTHING ELSE, SIR?
7:25:17PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THAT'S IT.
7:25:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA HAS 102.
7:25:20PM >>LUIS VIERA: IT'S FUNNY.
7:25:23PM I WASN'T GOING TO DO ANY BUT I DO HAVE ONE.
7:25:26PM I DID SOME RESEARCH.
7:25:28PM WHEN I HEARD SOME DISCUSSION ON THE USF UNIVERSITY SQUARE
7:25:31PM AREA, AND I'M GOING TO MOTION -- I'LL PREFACE OR PREDICATE
7:25:36PM MY MOTION ABOUT 8, 10 YEARS AGO, WE HAD THE UNIVERSITY
7:25:40PM SQUARE AND TERRACE PARK STUDY THAT WAS DONE AT THE REQUEST
7:25:43PM OF THEN COUNCILWOMAN LISA MONTELIONE, HAD A LOT OF GOOD
7:25:48PM COMMUNITY INPUT AND HAS RECOMMENDATIONS ON GROWTH AND
7:25:50PM DENSITY FOR THE UNIVERSITY SQUARE AND TERRACE PARK AREA.
7:25:53PM I WANTED FOR STAFF, INCLUDING THE PLANNING COMMISSION, AND
7:25:56PM I'LL MAKE THIS FAR ENOUGH OUT WHERE IF THEY NEED MORE TIME I
7:26:00PM KNOW YOU ALL -- TO BRIEF COUNCIL ON THIS PRIOR STUDY AND ANY
7:26:05PM POTENTIAL UPDATE WITH A PLAN OF ACTION FOR COUNCIL TO
7:26:07PM INVESTIGATE OR TO CONSIDER, I SHOULD SAY.
7:26:10PM THIS PLAN ADDRESSES ISSUES SUCH AS TRAFFIC IN THE UNIVERSITY
7:26:13PM SQUARE AND TERRACE PARK AREA, HOUSING, DENSITY, AS WELL AS
7:26:17PM CRIME, CODE ENFORCEMENT, PEDESTRIAN SAFETY, ET CETERA.
7:26:21PM AND I WOULD LIKE FOR STAFF TO BRIEF US ON THIS STUDY THAT
7:26:26PM WAS DONE TEN YEARS AGO AND THEN FOR POTENTIAL CONSIDERATION.
7:26:30PM I'LL OBVIOUSLY TALK TO YOU BEFORE ABOUT IT.
7:26:33PM I HATE TO DO MOTIONS WHEN I THINK ABOUT IT ON THE SPOT, BUT
7:26:37PM THIS ONE I THOUGHT WAS JUST A GOOD IDEA GIVEN SOME OF THE
7:26:40PM ISSUES WE ENCOUNTERED HERE TONIGHT'S.
7:26:42PM AND, BY THE WAY, DENISE, I'LL SEND YOU -- I'LL E-MAIL A
7:26:46PM SHORTER VERSION BECAUSE I'M RAMBLING.
7:26:48PM THERE YOU GO.
7:26:49PM THANK YOU.
7:26:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA WITH A MOTION.
7:26:52PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
7:26:53PM ALL IN FAVOR?
7:26:54PM ANY OPPOSED?
7:26:55PM ANYTHING ELSE, SIR?
7:26:58PM >>LUIS VIERA: I WILL SAY THIS IS THE LAST THURSDAY BEFORE
7:27:00PM OUR BUDGET HEARING ON TUESDAY, ONE REQUEST I WOULD MAKE IS
7:27:07PM -- WHEN WE'RE -- I KNOW A LOT OF COUNCIL MEMBERS ARE LOOKING
7:27:11PM AT AREAS IN THE BUDGET WHERE WE COULD POTENTIALLY CUT FOR
7:27:15PM SAVINGS, ET CETERA, ET CETERA, IS TO JUST -- AND I GUESS WE
7:27:18PM CAN'T SHARE WITH ONE ANOTHER OUTSIDE OF THIS MEETING LIKE
7:27:22PM WHAT IT'S GOING TO BE, BUT JUST MY ONLY FEAR IS THAT WE
7:27:26PM BEGIN TO BRING UP BUDGET CUTS WITHOUT, WHERE IT'S SOMETHING
7:27:30PM I HEAR ABOUT ON SEPTEMBER 5th FOR THE FIRST TIME,
7:27:33PM ET CETERA.
7:27:33PM IN OTHER WORDS, JUST IF SOMEONE IS GOING TO COME WITH THOSE
7:27:36PM ISSUES TO HAVE AS MUCH BRIEFED AS POSSIBLE INCLUDING WITH
7:27:40PM THE ADMINISTRATION, WHATEVER DEPARTMENT DEALS WITH THAT
7:27:42PM PROGRAM SO THAT WE CAN CONSIDER IT WITH FULL KNOWLEDGE AND
7:27:46PM IMPACT, ET CETERA, ET CETERA.
7:27:47PM AND THAT'S IT.
7:27:48PM IT WILL BE FUN ON TUESDAY NIGHT.
7:27:51PM THERE YOU GO.
7:27:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I CAN'T WAIT.
7:27:53PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
7:28:01PM >>LUIS VIERA: I APOLOGIZE.
7:28:02PM I DIDN'T PUT A DATE ON THAT.
7:28:07PM ON THE UNIVERSITY SQUARE.
7:28:09PM MAY I HAVE IT TENTATIVELY ON THE FIRST WEEK IN NOVEMBER, IF
7:28:15PM I MAY.
7:28:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT NOVEMBER.
7:28:17PM >>LUIS VIERA: IT CAN BE WHENEVER.
7:28:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NOVEMBER 2nd.
7:28:22PM >>LUIS VIERA: THERE YOU GO.
7:28:24PM YES.
7:28:24PM THANK YOU.
7:28:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NOVEMBER 2nd AND HE'LL SEND YOU THE
7:28:27PM FULL MOTION.
7:28:28PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
7:28:30PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: BASED ON THE PUBLIC COMMENT TODAY, I MOVE
7:28:33PM THAT WE RECEIVE THE SEMI ANNUAL REPORTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE
7:28:37PM 2013 TAMPA HEIGHTS RIVERFRONT DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT FOR
7:28:39PM WOMEN AND MINORITY BUSINESS ENTERPRISES, EQUAL OPPORTUNITY
7:28:42PM AND AFFIRMATIVE ACTION ON NOVEMBER 2nd BY STAFF AND THE
7:28:47PM DEVELOPER.
7:28:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN
7:28:49PM HENDERSON.
7:28:50PM DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
7:28:51PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
7:28:53PM ALL IN FAVOR?
7:28:54PM ANY OPPOSED?
7:28:55PM YES, MA'AM.
7:28:57PM ANYTHING ELSE?
7:28:57PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: NO, THAT'S IT.
7:28:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
7:29:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE OBSERVATION THAT WE'LL GET OUT BY
7:29:03PM 8:30.
7:29:04PM THE COMMON DENOMINATOR IS MARTIN SHELBY IS NOT HERE.
7:29:08PM CLEARLY HE IS THE ANCHOR AROUND OUR NECK THAT KEEPS US HERE
7:29:12PM UNTIL MIDNIGHT IN THE NIGHT MEETINGS.
7:29:15PM THANKS, MARTY, FOR NOT BEING HERE.
7:29:18PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: MY PLEASURE.
7:29:21PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: 7:30.
7:29:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
7:29:22PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
7:29:23PM I ACTUALLY DON'T HAVE ANY MOTIONS, BUT I DID WANT TO BRING
7:29:26PM TO PEOPLE'S ATTENTION THAT COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON AND I AND
7:29:31PM MAYBE OTHERS, THAT WE'RE GOING TO THE CRA CONFERENCE.
7:29:35PM WE HAVE A LOT OF MONEY IN OUR CRA THIS YEAR.
7:29:38PM I KNOW THAT YOU LIKE TO SAY WE DON'T REALLY WANT TO COPY
7:29:42PM OTHER PEOPLE, BUT I JUST GOT BACK FROM A HOUSING CONFERENCE
7:29:45PM AND I REALIZE WE ARE NOT COPYING PEOPLE.
7:29:47PM WE ARE SO FAR BEHIND WHEN LITTLE TOWNS HAVE CREATED
7:29:51PM COMMUNITY LAND TRUSTS AND HAVE MILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN THEM,
7:29:55PM WE ALL OUGHT TO BE THERE.
7:29:56PM I JUST WANT TO SAY, IF YOU WANT TO GO TO THE CRA CONFERENCE,
7:29:59PM ERICA CAN GET YOU IN.
7:30:01PM I'M SURE.
7:30:03PM I DIDN'T CLEAR THIS WITH HER.
7:30:04PM BUT THIS OCTOBER WORKSHOP SESSION, WE CAN MOVE THESE.
7:30:09PM WE HAVE THE POSSIBILITY TO LEARN SO MUCH.
7:30:11PM I LEARNED SO MUCH IN THE LAST TWO DAYS ABOUT HOUSING.
7:30:14PM AND I WAS SO DISAPPOINTED.
7:30:17PM EVERYBODY HAS THEIR REASONS, BUT I WOULD REALLY ENCOURAGE
7:30:20PM PEOPLE TO GO TO EITHER A HOUSING OR A CRA CONFERENCE.
7:30:23PM AND WE JUST HAVE SO MUCH WE CAN LEARN FROM OTHER CITIES.
7:30:27PM I KNOW WE'RE LOOKING OUTWARD, BUT ALSO LOOKING AT WHAT OTHER
7:30:31PM PEOPLE ARE DOING IN THIS STATE WITH OUR CRAZY LAWS IS
7:30:34PM HELPFUL.
7:30:35PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HOW MANY DAYS IS THE CONFERENCE?
7:30:36PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IT'S THREE DAYS.
7:30:38PM IT'S LIKE TUESDAY, WEDNESDAY, THURSDAY, AND THAT'S THE
7:30:40PM REASON WE WON'T BE HERE FOR A WORKSHOP.
7:30:43PM BUT IT'S SUCH A GOOD -- I JUST LEARNED SO MUCH.
7:30:47PM I CAN'T WAIT TO DISCUSS IT WITH YOU ALL.
7:30:50PM >> DON'T WE HAVE A NIGHT SESSION?
7:30:51PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WE DO.
7:30:52PM BUT IT ENDS EARLY ON THURSDAY, SO YOU CAN GET BACK.
7:30:55PM IT'S ALCOHOL NIGHT, TOO.
7:30:56PM YOU'RE RIGHT.
7:31:01PM IT'S NOT ORLANDO.
7:31:02PM IT'S UP IN JACKSONVILLE.
7:31:03PM BUT I'M JUST SAYING, IT'S ONE OF THOSE THINGS THAT I JUST
7:31:06PM THINK THAT PEOPLE SHOULD CONSIDER.
7:31:09PM IF YOU HAVE ANY INTEREST, PLEASE SEE ERICA.
7:31:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:31:12PM COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON.
7:31:14PM >>BILL CARLSON: ARE YOU GOING TO SCHEDULE TO PRESENT TO THE
7:31:18PM HOUSING STUFF TO US AT SOME POINT?
7:31:20PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
7:31:21PM I WILL PRESENT -- AND MOST OF IT IS REALLY GOING TO BE
7:31:26PM COMMENTS IN DIFFERENT AREAS WITH HOUSING.
7:31:29PM I'LL SPEAK ABOUT IT QUITE A BIT ON TUESDAY, BUT THE BIG
7:31:33PM TAKEAWAY FOR ME IN THAT CONFERENCE IS WE ARE SO FAR BEHIND
7:31:38PM AT COMMUNITY LAND TRUST, I WAS KIND OF EMBARRASSED.
7:31:40PM I REALLY DIDN'T REALIZE IT.
7:31:42PM I DIDN'T EVEN KNOW IT WOULD BE A PART OF THE CONFERENCE.
7:31:45PM TURNED OUT EVERY SINGLE SESSION I WENT TO TALKED ABOUT
7:31:48PM COMMUNITY LAND TRUST.
7:31:48PM I ASKED A LOT OF GOOD QUESTIONS, AND I WAS REALLY IMPRESSED
7:31:52PM BY WHAT TEENY, TINY TOWNS ARE DOING.
7:31:55PM I WAS SHOCKED.
7:32:03PM I DID NOT EXPECT AS MUCH CONVERSATION AS I GOT.
7:32:07PM IT'S FORT WALTON BEACH -- NO, IT WASN'T THAT.
7:32:10PM JUST A TINY LITTLE TOWN HAD DONE MILLIONS OF DOLLARS AND
7:32:13PM THEY HAVE PEOPLE -- AND THEIR PER CAPITA OR SALE PRICES NOW
7:32:18PM ARE 600,000, AND THEY HAD COMMUNITY LAND TRUST HOUSES
7:32:22PM SELLING AND PEOPLE WERE ABLE TO BE IN THEM FOR LIKE 180.
7:32:26PM IT WAS DOWN NEAR FT. LAUDERDALE.
7:32:35PM SO IT WAS VERY EXPENSIVE AREA, BUT THEY HAD MANAGED TO
7:32:39PM REALLY HOLD ON TO SOME OF THEIR LAND AND TURN IT INTO REALLY
7:32:44PM PHENOMENAL MIXED USE DEVELOPMENTS.
7:32:47PM THESE WERE ALL BEACH COMMUNITIES.
7:32:51PM IT WAS A CITY THAT USED TO NOT HAVE THE WORD BEACH ON IT AND
7:32:57PM NOW DOES.
7:32:57PM THAT WAS THE WEIRDEST THING.
7:32:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HALLANDALE BEACH.
7:33:03PM >>LYNN HURTAK: ANYWAY, IT WAS A SMALL TOWN THAT HAD VERY FEW
7:33:06PM PEOPLE AND DONE A REALLY GOOD JOB.
7:33:07PM I THINK WE OWE IT TO OURSELVES TO MAYBE SPREAD OUT AND FIND
7:33:11PM OUT WHAT OTHER PEOPLE ARE DOING JUST TO KIND OF FIGURE OUT
7:33:15PM HOW WE CAN BE BETTER AT IT.
7:33:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:33:18PM GOOD IDEA.
7:33:19PM YES, SIR, COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON.
7:33:20PM >>BILL CARLSON: FOLKS THAT ARE ON OTHER BOARDS TELL ME THAT
7:33:27PM THEIR CFO OR BUDGET PERSON GIVES A MONTHLY OR QUARTERLY
7:33:32PM UPDATE ON THE BUDGET.
7:33:33PM THERE WAS AN ISSUE THAT WAS MENTIONED THIS MORNING ABOUT
7:33:35PM THAT 5.5 MILLION FOR HOUSING.
7:33:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHICH OTHER BOARDS DO YOU MEAN?
7:33:40PM >>BILL CARLSON: JUST OTHER PUBLIC BOARDS.
7:33:42PM I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO ASK THE CFO TO PRESENT AN
7:33:46PM UPDATED BUDGET TO COUNCIL ON A QUARTERLY BASIS AND TO
7:33:49PM HIGHLIGHT MAJOR CHANGES WITH THE FIRST PRESENTATION BEING ON
7:33:52PM JANUARY 11, 2024.
7:33:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
7:33:56PM CARLSON.
7:33:57PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
7:33:58PM MR. SHELBY, YOUR THINKING?
7:34:02PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: NO.
7:34:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR?
7:34:04PM AYE.
7:34:05PM ANY OPPOSED?
7:34:05PM YES, SIR.
7:34:06PM >>BILL CARLSON: APPARENTLY THE FIVE-YEAR TREE PLAN CANOPY
7:34:11PM REPORT WAS AN INITIATIVE OF COUNCIL YEARS AGO, MAYBE MR.
7:34:15PM MIRANDA REMEMBERS.
7:34:16PM BUT THE PUBLIC WANTS US TO HAVE IT PRESENTED HERE AT SOME
7:34:24PM POINT.
7:34:25PM I -- I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO ASK CITY STAFF TO
7:34:28PM PRESENT THE FIVE-YEAR TREE CANOPY REPORT TO COUNCIL ON
7:34:32PM NOVEMBER 30, WHICH IS THE WORKSHOP.
7:34:34PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I WAS READING THAT 21 TODAY.
7:34:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CARLSON WITH THE MOTION,
7:34:42PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
7:34:44PM ALL IN FAVOR?
7:34:45PM AYE.
7:34:46PM >>BILL CARLSON: AND THEN -- IT SEEMS LIKE THERE WAS INTEREST
7:34:52PM HAVING USF.
7:34:53PM BUSINESS SCHOOL HAS OFFERED FOR FREE TO DO THE DATA
7:34:57PM ANALYTICS.
7:34:58PM I WOULD JUST LIKE TO ASK THEM TO HELP US WITH AT LEAST THE
7:35:03PM POVERTY RATE AND HOME OWNERSHIP BASED ON THE FEEDBACK YOU
7:35:06PM ALL GAVE.
7:35:06PM I WOULD LIKE TO MOTION TO ASK THAT USF MUMA COLLEGE OF
7:35:13PM BUSINESS TO REVIEW THE INPUTS TO THE POVERTY RATE AND HOME
7:35:16PM OWNERSHIP RATE AND TO PRESENT RECOMMENDATIONS TO MAKE
7:35:19PM POSITIVE CHANGE USING PREDICTIVE ANALYTICS.
7:35:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHAT DAY.
7:35:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: TO BE DETERMINED?
7:35:25PM >>BILL CARLSON: CAN I --
7:35:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: LET'S DO IT AFTER THE NEW YEAR.
7:35:31PM >>BILL CARLSON: IS THERE A DAY IN JANUARY?
7:35:33PM DO YOU THINK THE JANUARY WORKSHOP?
7:35:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IT'S FAR ENOUGH AHEAD.
7:35:40PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WE DON'T HAVE A WORKSHOP IN JANUARY.
7:35:43PM >>BILL CARLSON: FEBRUARY 22.
7:35:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: FEBRUARY 22.
7:35:45PM WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON.
7:35:47PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN FOR THE FEBRUARY 22,
7:35:50PM 2024 WORKSHOP.
7:35:51PM ALL IN FAVOR?
7:35:52PM AYE.
7:35:53PM ANY OPPOSED?
7:35:53PM ANYTHING ELSE?
7:35:55PM >>BILL CARLSON: YEAH.
7:35:56PM THE LAST TWO QUICK THINGS, MS. JOHNSON VELEZ LEFT, I DON'T
7:36:01PM KNOW ABOUT YOU ALL, BUT I THOUGHT WE HAD PUT A CAP ON ANY
7:36:05PM NEW PRIVATELY INITIATED TEXT AMENDMENTS.
7:36:14PM WE HAD SEVERAL TODAY.
7:36:16PM WE PUT A LIMIT ON ONE BUT NOT THE OTHER.
7:36:20PM I TALKED TO MS. JOHNSON VELEZ.
7:36:22PM IT SEEMS LIKE STAFF IS OPEN TO OR EVEN LIKES THE IDEA OF
7:36:26PM PUTTING A LIMIT ON THE OTHERS.
7:36:28PM I DON'T HAVE THE MOTION TO MAKE TONIGHT.
7:36:29PM BUT IF YOU ALL HAVE ANY INTEREST, YOU COULD TALK TO HER.
7:36:33PM SHE MAY COME BACK TO US WITH IT.
7:36:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE CAN MAKE A MOTION NEXT THURSDAY AT
7:36:36PM THE REGULAR MEETING.
7:36:37PM WE CAN DISCUSS WITH HER.
7:36:38PM >>BILL CARLSON: SO IF ANYBODY HAS AN INTEREST IN THAT.
7:36:42PM THE PUBLIC KEEPS ASKING ARE THEY GRANDFATHERED IN, BECAUSE
7:36:45PM THEY ARE TWO DIFFERENT CATEGORIES.
7:36:46PM THE OTHER THING, REGARDING THE TAX, SINCE COUNCILMAN VIERA
7:36:50PM MENTIONED IT I THINK IT IS THE JOB OF THE STAFF TO FIND THE
7:36:53PM CUTS.
7:36:55PM I MENTIONED MULTIPLE TIMES EVEN BEFORE THEY MADE THE
7:36:57PM PROPOSAL I'M GOING TO VOTE AGAINST IT.
7:36:59PM I HOPE TO MAKE THE MEETING SIMPLE ON TUESDAY NIGHT YOU ALL
7:37:03PM VOTE AGAINST IT AND WE'LL ASK THE STAFF TO FIND THE 46
7:37:06PM MILLION.
7:37:08PM WE'VE ALL GOT RECOMMENDATIONS.
7:37:10PM WE CAN GIVE THEM PRIVATELY.
7:37:11PM THE SIMPLE THING WOULD BE TO CALL THE MEETING, VOTE AGAINST
7:37:14PM IT AND THEN LET STAFF --
7:37:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE TO TAKE PUBLIC COMMENT.
7:37:19PM >>BILL CARLSON: ANYWAY, I DON'T THINK WE HAVE TO GO THROUGH
7:37:22PM AND MICROMANAGE THE BUDGET.
7:37:24PM I WOULD BE SURPRISED BASED ON PUBLIC INPUT THAT WE DON'T
7:37:29PM HAVE THE VOTES TO VOTE IT DOWN.
7:37:30PM I THINK WE SHOULD TRY THAT FIRST AND THEN SEE WHAT HAPPENS.
7:37:33PM THANK YOU.
7:37:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
7:37:34PM MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE?
7:37:35PM MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
7:37:37PM SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
7:37:39PM ALL IN FAVOR?
7:37:40PM AYE.
7:37:40PM WE ARE ADJOURNED.
7:37:41PM [ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.