TAMPA CITY COUNCIL
THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 14, 2023
5:01 P.M.
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.
5:05:25PM [ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
5:05:27PM >> THE BROADCAST IS NOW STARTING.
5:05:29PM ALL ATTENDEES ARE IN LISTEN-ONLY MODE.
5:05:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GOOD AFTERNOON, EVERYONE.
5:05:34PM WELCOME TO TAMPA CITY COUNCIL.
5:05:35PM THIS IS THE EVENING SESSION.
5:05:37PM AT THIS TIME MAY I HAVE -- I'M SORRY.
5:05:42PM LET'S DO ROLL CALL.
5:05:43PM GO AHEAD.
5:05:44PM >>THE CLERK: CARLSON?
5:05:45PM HURTAK?
5:05:47PM >>LYNN HURTAK: HERE.
5:05:48PM >> CLENDENIN?
5:05:49PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HERE.
5:05:50PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: PRESENT.
5:05:53PM >> VIERA?
5:05:54PM MIRANDA?
5:05:54PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HERE.
5:05:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
5:05:57PM >>THE CLERK: WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
5:05:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MAY I HAVE A MOTION TO OPEN ALL PUBLIC
5:06:00PM HEARINGS?
5:06:01PM WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
5:06:03PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
5:06:04PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:06:04PM AYE.
5:06:05PM ALL RIGHT.
5:06:06PM YES, MA'AM, MS. DOCK, IF WE CAN GO THROUGH THE AGENDA.
5:06:10PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES, SIR.
5:06:11PM GOOD EVENING, CHAIRMAN AND COUNCIL.
5:06:12PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:06:14PM AND ON THIS EVENING'S AGENDA, ITEM NUMBER 3, THERE IS A
5:06:18PM REQUEST FOR A CONTINUANCE.
5:06:19PM THIS IS ITEM NUMBER, FILE TA/CPA 22-28.
5:06:26PM THE REQUEST IS TO CONTINUE THIS ITEM TO NOVEMBER 9, 2023, AT
5:06:31PM 5:01.
5:06:32PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SO MOVED, MR. CHAIRMAN.
5:06:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS THERE ANYBODY THAT IS HERE WHO WISHES
5:06:37PM TO SPEAK ON THE CONTINUANCE OF ITEM NUMBER 3?
5:06:39PM I SEE NO ONE, AND WE DON'T HAVE ANYBODY REGISTERED AT THIS
5:06:46PM POINT.
5:06:46PM MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA TO CONTINUE THIS ITEM TO
5:06:49PM NOVEMBER 9, 2023.
5:06:51PM SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK, AT 315 EAST KENNEDY
5:06:54PM BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, OLD CITY HALL, 33602, TAMPA,
5:07:01PM FLORIDA.
5:07:02PM MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
5:07:04PM SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
5:07:04PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:07:05PM AYE.
5:07:06PM YES, MA'AM.
5:07:07PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, CHAIRMAN.
5:07:09PM AND THE NEXT ITEM IS ITEM NUMBER 4.
5:07:11PM REZ-22-103.
5:07:16PM THE REQUEST IS TO CONTINUE TO OCTOBER 12, 2023, AT 5:01 P.M.
5:07:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE ANYBODY WHO WISHES TO SPEAK
5:07:22PM ON THIS CONTINUANCE ONLY?
5:07:23PM YES, MR. SHELBY.
5:07:27PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: LOOKING AT THE AGENDA, THIS IS THE SECOND
5:07:29PM CONTINUANCE ON THIS ITEM.
5:07:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
5:07:32PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES, THAT IS CORRECT.
5:07:33PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: IS THE PETITIONER PRESENT, IF YOU KNOW?
5:07:36PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES, THE APPLICANT IS PRESENT.
5:07:38PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THEY ARE AWARE THIS IS THE SECOND
5:07:40PM CONTINUANCE, UNLESS YOU WANT TO SPEAK.
5:07:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION TO CONTINUE THIS ITEM
5:07:44PM FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA, SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN
5:07:47PM HENDERSON.
5:07:47PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:07:48PM AYE.
5:07:48PM THIS WILL BE TO OCTOBER 12, 2023, 5:01 P.M., 315 EAST
5:07:53PM KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, OLD CITY HALL, TAMPA,
5:07:56PM FLORIDA.
5:07:59PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL AND CHAIRMAN.
5:08:03PM ITEM 12, REZ-22-44, THAT NEEDS TO BE REMOVED FROM THE
5:08:08PM AGENDA.
5:08:09PM THIS IS A MISNOTICE.
5:08:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION TO REMOVE ITEM 12 FROM
5:08:13PM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:08:14PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
5:08:15PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:08:15PM AYE.
5:08:16PM THE FINAL REQUEST I BELIEVE IS TO MOVE ITEM NUMBER 6 TO COME
5:08:21PM DIRECTLY AFTER ITEM NUMBER 1, AND THE REASON IS BECAUSE WE
5:08:25PM HAVE A TRANSLATOR PRESENT THAT IS HERE ON BEHALF OF THE
5:08:32PM CITY, I BELIEVE.
5:08:33PM WE'LL TAKE ITEM NUMBER 6 RIGHT AFTER ITEM NUMBER 1 AND THEN
5:08:36PM START WITH ITEM NUMBER 2.
5:08:38PM EVERYBODY OKAY?
5:08:39PM MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:08:41PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:08:43PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:08:44PM AYE.
5:08:44PM THAT WILL BE THE SUBSTITUTE WHEN WE READ THAT.
5:08:53PM AT THIS TIME, THAT CONCLUDES THE AGENDA.
5:09:00PM ALL RIGHT, AT THIS TIME, I'LL PASS THE GAVEL TO COUNCILMAN
5:09:05PM CLENDENIN.
5:09:05PM I HAVE A COMMENDATION TO PRESENT.
5:09:15PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE CHAIR RECOGNIZES CHAIRMAN MANISCALCO.
5:09:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: TODAY IS A SPECIAL DAY BECAUSE WE HAVE A
5:09:25PM VERY SPECIAL GUEST, A FRIEND TO ALMOST EVERYONE IN THIS
5:09:29PM ROOM.
5:09:30PM I DON'T THINK HE IS A STRANGER TO ANYONE.
5:09:32PM THIS IS THE HONORABLE MAYOR DICK GRECO.
5:09:35PM TODAY IS HIS 90th BIRTHDAY.
5:09:37PM SO, MAYOR GRECO, FIRST WAS ELECTED TO THE TAMPA CITY COUNCIL
5:09:42PM IN 1963 AND AFTER SERVING ONE TERM WAS ELECTED AS MAYOR.
5:09:49PM THE LAST TIME AN INCUMBENT MAYOR LOST, I BELIEVE.
5:09:52PM THIS WAS IN 1967, AND HE SERVED AS MAYOR TWO TERMS.
5:09:57PM WENT INTO THE PRIVATE SECTOR AND CAME BACK IN 1995 AND
5:10:00PM SERVED TWO TERMS AGAIN UNTIL 2003.
5:10:03PM BEFORE I BRING THE MAYOR UP, IF WE CAN GET THIS OVERHEAD
5:10:08PM PROJECTOR ACTIVE, I HAVE SOME PHOTOS.
5:10:14PM IF WE CAN GET THIS PROJECTOR UP.
5:10:20PM ALL RIGHT.
5:10:23PM IF YOU CAN SEE IT.
5:10:24PM THIS MAY NOT WORK.
5:10:26PM NO, IT'S NOT GOING TO WORK.
5:10:29PM ANYWAYS, PICTURES OF THE MAYOR AS A CITY COUNCIL MEMBER AND
5:10:32PM AS A MAYOR, BUT AT THIS TIME, MAYOR, IF YOU WANT TO COME ON
5:10:37PM UP.
5:10:42PM SO WE WROTE THIS FOR YOU.
5:10:47PM THESE ARE THE NEW COMMENDATIONS, YOU ARE THE FIRST TO GET
5:10:50PM IT.
5:10:50PM IT IS OUR DISTINCT PLEASURE TO PRESENT THIS COMMENDATION TO
5:10:53PM ONE OF OUR MOST BELOVED MAYORS ON HIS 90th BIRTHDAY.
5:10:56PM BORN SEPTEMBER 14, 1933, AT THE YOUNG AGE OF 30, OR 29,
5:11:01PM RIGHT BEFORE YOUR BIRTHDAY, YOU STARTED YOUR LONG POLITICAL
5:11:05PM CAREER AS A MEMBER OF THE TAMPA CITY COUNCIL.
5:11:06PM IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWED BY BEING ELECTED AS THE CITY'S 50th
5:11:09PM MAYOR.
5:11:09PM UNDER YOUR LEADERSHIP, TAMPA SAW A SUBSTANTIAL REDUCTION IN
5:11:12PM THE CRIME RATE AND AN INCREASE IN THE POLICE DEPARTMENT
5:11:14PM PERSONNEL.
5:11:15PM YOU EXPANDED THE CENTRAL LIBRARY SYSTEM AND YOU WERE
5:11:19PM INSTRUMENTAL IN INCREASING THE SEATING CAPACITY OF THE TAMPA
5:11:22PM STADIUM IN PREPARATION FOR THE ARRIVAL OF THE TAMPA BAY
5:11:24PM BUCCANEERS.
5:11:25PM YOU WERE MAYOR UNTIL 1974 WHEN YOU MOVED INTO THE PRIVATE
5:11:30PM SECTOR AND ACCEPTED THE ROLE OF VICE PRESIDENT OF THE EDWARD
5:11:33PM DeBARTOLO COMPANY.
5:11:35PM AFTER SPENDING MORE THAN 20 YEARS IN THE PRIVATE SECTOR, YOU
5:11:38PM WERE ONCE AGAIN ELECTED AS CITY'S 56th MAYOR IN 1995 AND
5:11:42PM SERVED UNTIL 2003.
5:11:44PM DURING YOUR TENURE, YOU FOCUSED ON CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS SUCH
5:11:47PM AS THE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT OF YBOR CITY, INCLUDING
5:11:50PM CENTRAL YBOR, BRINGING LIFE BACK TO YBOR CITY AND ALSO THE
5:11:53PM CHANNELSIDE DISTRICT.
5:11:54PM AND YOU WERE INSTRUMENTAL IN THE CONSTRUCTION OF RAYMOND
5:11:59PM JAMES STADIUM.
5:12:00PM WE ARE IN AWE OF YOUR ACCOMPLISHMENTS.
5:12:01PM THIS 14th DAY OF SEPTEMBER, YOUR BIRTHDAY, 2023, WE JUST
5:12:05PM WANT TO PRESENT YOU WITH THIS COMMENDATION FROM THE TAMPA
5:12:07PM CITY COUNCIL.
5:12:09PM >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:12:10PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:12:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I BELIEVE WE HAVE OUR CITY CLERK,
5:12:17PM SHIRLEY FOXX-KNOWLES, THAT WANTS TO COME UP AND YOU GO AHEAD
5:12:20PM AND SPEAK.
5:12:26PM >>SHIRLEY FOXX-KNOWLES: I WANTED TO PRESENT THIS.
5:12:28PM YOU DID AN INTERVIEW WITH ME BACK ON THIS DATE EIGHT YEARS
5:12:34PM AGO.
5:12:35PM AND IT IS FULL OF SO MUCH WISDOM AND I WANTED TO GIVE IT TO
5:12:40PM YOU AND YOUR FAMILY.
5:12:42PM YOU WILL LOVE IT.
5:12:43PM I JUST FINISHED WATCHING IT.
5:12:44PM IT'S GREAT.
5:12:45PM IT'S ON A JUMP DRIVE.
5:12:50PM AND I WANTED TO GIVE YOU THIS PAPERWEIGHT OF THE CITY OF
5:12:56PM TAMPA.
5:12:59PM AND HAPPY BIRTHDAY.
5:13:05PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MAYOR, WOULD YOU LIKE TO SAY A FEW WORDS?
5:13:10PM >> I WANT TO THANK ALL OF YOU FOR ACKNOWLEDGING US TODAY.
5:13:14PM I WAS SITTING HERE THINKING, SAT UP THERE 60 YEARS AGO, A
5:13:20PM LITTLE OVER 60 YEARS AGO.
5:13:21PM HARD TO BELIEVE THAT THIS MUCH TIME HAS GONE BY AND THE CITY
5:13:26PM IS GETTING BIGGER EVERY DAY AS WE LIVE.
5:13:29PM CHARLIE WAS AROUND.
5:13:31PM HE'D BEEN AROUND FOR ALMOST A HUNDRED YEARS.
5:13:35PM I REMEMBER CHARLIE FIRST GETTING ON THE WATER BOARD.
5:13:40PM WE COULDN'T TALK TO EACH OTHER ABOUT ANYTHING, SO I SAID YOU
5:13:44PM GET ON THE BOARD AND THEN LET ME KNOW WHAT IS WHAT AND I CAN
5:13:47PM CALL THE REST OF THE PEOPLE.
5:13:48PM THINGS LIKE THAT WERE DIFFERENT IN THOSE DAYS.
5:13:50PM WE GOT A LOT OF THINGS DONE.
5:13:50PM CLEANED UP THE BAY AND A BUNCH OF STUFF OVER THE YEARS.
5:13:54PM I WANTED TO THANK ALL OF YOU FOR CHOOSING TO DO THIS IN THE
5:14:01PM CITY WHERE I WAS BORN AND THAT I LOVE MORE THAN ANYTHING IN
5:14:04PM THE WORLD.
5:14:06PM IT'S NOT EASY, BUT YOU'RE GIVING SOMETHING BACK TO A
5:14:10PM WONDERFUL PLACE, AND I APPRECIATE IT AND MANY PEOPLE
5:14:14PM APPRECIATE IT.
5:14:17PM AND NOTHING IS SIMPLE AND NOTHING IS 100%.
5:14:21PM EVERYBODY BUYS.
5:14:26PM I REMEMBER ONE TIME SAYING YOU COULD PAVE THE STREETS IN
5:14:29PM GOLD FOR FREE AND SOMEBODY COULD COMPLAIN ABOUT THE GLARE.
5:14:31PM THAT'S JUST THE WAY IT IS.
5:14:35PM AGAIN, I WANT TO THANK EACH AND EVERY ONE OF YOU FOR TAKING
5:14:38PM THE TIME AND EFFORT TO PUT IN A CITY I LOVE AND THAT IS
5:14:42PM GROWING EVERY DAY IN A WONDERFUL WAY.
5:14:45PM THANK YOU FOR THIS ACKNOWLEDGMENT.
5:14:49PM TAKE A FEW MORE YEARS.
5:14:51PM GOD BLESS ALL OF YOU AND THE CITY OF TAMPA.
5:14:54PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:14:57PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I THINK SOME OF THE MEMBERS OF COUNCIL --
5:14:59PM MAYOR, I THINK SOME OF THE MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL WOULD LIKE
5:15:01PM TO ADDRESS YOU.
5:15:02PM WE'LL START WITH AGE BEFORE BEAUTY SO CHARLIE WILL BE FIRST
5:15:05PM AND I WILL BE LAST.
5:15:07PM [ LAUGHTER ]
5:15:07PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
5:15:12PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: MAYOR, LET ME SAY THANK YOU.
5:15:15PM IN FACT, YOU'RE MAKING HISTORY.
5:15:16PM THAT COMMENDATION YOU HAVE, IT IS THE FIRST ONE THAT'S
5:15:20PM WRITTEN AND STACKED THE WAY IT IS WITH THE CHAIRMAN ON TOP
5:15:23PM AND THE SIX COUNCIL MEMBERS.
5:15:25PM IT WAS ALWAYS DIFFERENT.
5:15:26PM THAT IS THE FIRST ONE THAT HAS A SIGNATURE OF ALL THE
5:15:29PM COUNCIL MEMBERS BECAUSE I GOT TIRED OF LOOKING AT SIGNATURES
5:15:32PM THAT LOOKED LIKE MINE SCRIBBLED.
5:15:35PM WHY ARE WE GIVING AWAY TO SOMEBODY WHO DOESN'T EVEN KNOW WHO
5:15:39PM SIGNED THE THINGS.
5:15:40PM WE HAD THE AIDE GET US TO SIGN, PRINTED IT UP THAT WAY.
5:15:45PM YOU HAVE THE FIRST ONE IN HISTORY THAT CAME UNDER THE NEW
5:15:47PM ONE.
5:15:48PM SO THANK YOU FOR WHAT YOU'VE DONE.
5:15:49PM GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR FAMILY AND YOUR WIFE FOR LETTING YOU
5:15:54PM DO WHAT YOU'VE DONE SO MANY YEARS.
5:15:56PM THE MOST ENJOYABLE CONVERSATION I HAD WITH AN AUDIENCE, WHEN
5:16:00PM YOU AND I WERE INVITED TO SPEAK AT THE CITY OF CLEARWATER
5:16:02PM ABOUT EIGHT YEARS AGO, AND THE CROWD NEVER FORGOT THAT.
5:16:06PM WE TALKED ABOUT YBOR CITY AND HOW IT CAME ABOUT AND HOW YOU
5:16:09PM DID THE THINGS, THE MARRIOTT HOTEL WOULDN'T BE HERE IF IT
5:16:13PM WASN'T FOR YOU.
5:16:14PM THE AIRPORT WOULDN'T BE WHAT IT IS.
5:16:15PM YOU STARTED THAT.
5:16:16PM SO MANY THINGS.
5:16:17PM YBOR CITY REVITALIZATION WAS ALL THROUGH YOU.
5:16:21PM EVERYBODY IS HAVING GOOD TIME ON NORTH BOULEVARD, THAT AREA
5:16:24PM THERE, TAMPA HEIGHTS.
5:16:26PM DON'T KNOW THAT YOU BOUGHT ALL THAT LAND FOR THAT, MOST OF
5:16:28PM THE LAND WHERE THE RIVERWALK IS AT CAME UNDER YOUR
5:16:33PM ADMINISTRATION.
5:16:33PM YOU DID IT UNDER THE --
5:16:38PM I'LL NEVER FORGET ALL THOSE CONVERSATIONS.
5:16:40PM GOD BLESS YOU.
5:16:42PM YOU DID A FANTASTIC JOB.
5:16:45PM YOU WERE DIFFERENT THAN MOST BECAUSE YOU TALKED AND YOU USED
5:16:47PM TO TELL EVERY COUNCIL MEMBER THIS: NO MATTER WHO IS IN MY
5:16:51PM OFFICE, IF YOU NEED TO SEE ME, YOU ASK THE LADY UP FRONT AND
5:16:55PM I WILL COME UP AND TALK TO YOU NO MATTER WHO IS IN THERE,
5:16:59PM INCLUDING THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.
5:17:02PM I NEVER FORGET THOSE THINGS.
5:17:03PM THANK YOU, GOD BLESS YOU FOR BRINGING TO THE CITY OF TAMPA
5:17:05PM WHAT IT IS TODAY.
5:17:06PM >> COUNCILMAN VIERA.
5:17:11PM >>LUIS VIERA: I WANTED TO THANK COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO FOR
5:17:13PM BRINGING MAYOR GRECO HERE.
5:17:15PM I KNOW THAT YOU HAVE PARTICULAR LOVE IN YOUR HEART FOR
5:17:18PM FORMER MAYOR GRECO AND YOU HAVE A FEW THINGS IN COMMON,
5:17:22PM INCLUDING YOU WERE ELECTED TO CITY COUNCIL WHEN YOU WERE
5:17:24PM ABOUT 11.
5:17:25PM YOU'LL HAVE A WONDERFUL LONG CAREER IN POLITICS, LIKE MAYOR
5:17:28PM GRECO.
5:17:29PM MAYOR, WHEN I THINK ABOUT YOU, YOU'RE ONE OF THOSE GUYS IN
5:17:32PM POLITICS THAT YOU DON'T STRIKE PEOPLE AS A REPUBLICAN OR A
5:17:36PM DEMOCRAT.
5:17:36PM YOU ARE A TAMPA-CRAT, WHICH IS YOU PUT TAMPA FIRST.
5:17:40PM AND THE TAMPA-CRAT PARTY IS REALLY SMALL.
5:17:44PM RICHARD GONZMART FOR ME IS PART OF THE TAMPA-CRAT PARTY, AND
5:17:48PM YOU ARE CERTAINLY ONE OF THE LEADERS OF IT.
5:17:50PM WE WERE TALKING THERE IN THE AUDIENCE, AND I REMEMBER
5:17:52PM READING ABOUT WHEN YOU MOVED OUT TO TAMPA PALMS, WHEN NEW
5:17:56PM TAMPA WAS ANNEXED, AND YOU WERE OUT THERE FOR SOME TIME, AND
5:17:59PM YOU WERE LIKE, YOU KNOW WHAT, THIS IS TOO FAR, MAN.
5:18:02PM YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN.
5:18:04PM YOU OBVIOUSLY SPEARHEADED IT AND HEARING ABOUT FROM PEOPLE
5:18:08PM LIKE COUNCILMAN MIRANDA WHO HAVE SUCH A GOOD VIEW INTO THE
5:18:11PM KIND OF MAYOR YOU WERE, ET CETERA, HOW YOU WORK WITH COUNCIL
5:18:14PM IN TERMS OF REACHING OUT TO COUNCIL MEMBERS, WORKING WITH
5:18:17PM COUNCIL MEMBERS, ET CETERA, ET CETERA, THAT YOU WERE ALWAYS
5:18:19PM ACCESSIBLE.
5:18:20PM YOU WERE ALWAYS HUMBLE.
5:18:21PM YOU WERE JUST A FELLOW PUBLIC SERVANT LIKE I THINK SO MANY
5:18:26PM OF OUR MAYORS, INCLUDING I THINK MAYOR CASTOR AND OTHERS
5:18:29PM STRIVE TO DO THAT, BUT YOU DID IT SO VERY WELL.
5:18:33PM HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU, SIR, AND GOD BLESS YOU.
5:18:36PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
5:18:38PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THANK YOU.
5:18:39PM IF I WERE IN THE CLASSROOM TODAY, I WOULD CALL YOUR NAME AND
5:18:41PM IT WOULD BE ON THE ROSTER AS SAYING RICHARD GRECO, YOU KNOW.
5:18:45PM SO YOU ARE HERE AND PRESENT.
5:18:47PM I WANT TO SAY GO HILLSBOROUGH TERRIERS.
5:18:50PM GO UNIVERSITY OF TAMPA SPARTANS BECAUSE YOU REPRESENT THEM
5:18:54PM AS WELL, SO I WANT THE PUBLIC TO HEAR THAT AND REMIND THEM
5:18:57PM OF YOUR ROOTS.
5:18:59PM AS THE 16th COUNCILWOMAN, I HAD THE PLEASURE OF MEETING
5:19:02PM YOU AT TIGER BAY RIGHT AFTER I WON THE ELECTION AND YOU KNEW
5:19:06PM WHO I WAS AND I WAS GRATEFUL FOR THAT.
5:19:08PM A STORY, I WAS DRIVING DOWNTOWN BY THE STRAZ CENTER AND I
5:19:12PM WAS SPEEDING AND THERE WAS A MAN WALKING ACROSS THE STREET
5:19:14PM AND IT WAS THE MAYOR GRECO.
5:19:16PM I DECIDED FROM THAT POINT ON, LET ME SLOW DOWN BECAUSE I
5:19:20PM ALMOST HIT THE MAYOR.
5:19:21PM [ LAUGHTER ]
5:19:22PM SO I APOLOGIZE.
5:19:23PM EVERY TIME I PASS BY THE STRAZ, I ALWAYS THINK OF YOU, EVERY
5:19:28PM SINGLE TIME AND I SLOW DOWN.
5:19:29PM YOU TAUGHT ME A LESSON WITHOUT EVEN KNOWING IT.
5:19:32PM CONGRATULATIONS.
5:19:33PM HAPPY BIRTHDAY.
5:19:34PM YOU'RE 90 YEARS OLD.
5:19:36PM MY MOTHER IS 92.
5:19:37PM YOU ARE A PART OF THAT, I DON'T KNOW IF IT IS THE SILENT
5:19:39PM GENERATION, IS THAT WHAT IT'S CALLED?
5:19:43PM BUT YOUR FAMILY IS SO BLESSED TO STILL HAVE YOU AND THE FACT
5:19:46PM THAT YOU'RE ABLE TO STAND THERE ON YOUR OWN IS AMAZING.
5:19:50PM HAPPY BIRTHDAY.
5:19:52PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
5:19:52PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU AND HAPPY BIRTHDAY.
5:19:54PM IT IS WONDERFUL TO SEE YOU HERE TODAY AND TO JUST REMIND
5:20:00PM PEOPLE ALL THE GOOD THAT YOU'VE DONE FOR THE CITY OF TAMPA.
5:20:05PM I THINK CHAIRMAN MANISCALCO TALKED ABOUT ALL THE DIFFERENT
5:20:08PM THINGS YOU BROUGHT TO THE CITY.
5:20:11PM WE JUST WANT TO SAY THANK YOU.
5:20:13PM WE OWE YOU AN ABSOLUTE UNPAYABLE DEBT OF GRATITUDE FOR HOW
5:20:18PM YOU'VE MADE THIS CITY WHAT IT IS TODAY.
5:20:22PM THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR EVERYTHING.
5:20:24PM I'LL ECHO WHAT COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON SAID, YOUR FAMILY IS
5:20:28PM SO LUCKY TO HAVE YOU.
5:20:29PM WE'RE SO LUCKY TO HAVE YOU.
5:20:32PM I HOPE THAT WE ALL GET A COPY OF THAT VIDEO OR AT LEAST PUT
5:20:36PM IT UP ON SOMEWHERE -- YEAH, THAT WOULD BE FABULOUS.
5:20:40PM I WOULD LOVE FOR EVERYONE TO LEARN FROM THE WISDOM OF THAT
5:20:45PM INTERVIEW.
5:20:45PM SO THANK YOU AGAIN AND HAVE A WONDERFUL BIRTHDAY.
5:20:48PM I HOPE YOU HAVE SOME WONDERFUL DINNER PLANS AFTER THIS.
5:20:52PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
5:20:54PM >>BILL CARLSON: HAPPY BIRTHDAY.
5:20:55PM I DIDN'T EVEN KNOW YOU WOULD BE HERE TONIGHT.
5:20:57PM GREAT SURPRISE.
5:20:58PM I WAS DROPPING OFF MY KIDS.
5:21:00PM SORRY TO BE LATE.
5:21:01PM GREAT TO SEE YOU.
5:21:02PM THANK YOU FOR ALL YOU'VE DONE OVER THE YEARS.
5:21:04PM YOU'VE BEEN A GREAT INSPIRATION TO MANY OF US, MANY
5:21:07PM GENERATIONS, IT MAKES ME FEEL LIKE A KIDDING ABOUT HERE
5:21:10PM AGAIN.
5:21:10PM I REMEMBER MY 20s WHEN YOU WERE MAYOR.
5:21:14PM ONE OF THE HEYDAYS OF TAMPA.
5:21:17PM YOU INSPIRED THE PEOPLE OF THE CITY AND SHOWED US THAT WE
5:21:20PM COULD MOVE FORWARD IN A VERY POSITIVE WAY.
5:21:22PM AS COUNCILMAN MIRANDA SAID, ALL THE CITY COUNCILS I KNEW AT
5:21:25PM THE TIME SAID YOU ALWAYS TOOK THEIR CALLS, YOU ALWAYS MET
5:21:27PM WITH THEM.
5:21:28PM ALWAYS NEGOTIATED AND WORKED WITH THEM WELL.
5:21:30PM APPRECIATE THAT.
5:21:31PM MOST IMPORTANTLY, YOU INSPIRED OUR FRIEND, CHAIR MANISCALCO,
5:21:36PM AND I WOULD SUGGEST SOMETIME THAT YOU ALL HAVE A FUND-RAISER
5:21:41PM WHERE YOU DO TRIVIA NIGHT AND YOU SAY THAT FOR EVERY TRIVIA
5:21:46PM QUESTION ABOUT YOU THAT HE GETS RIGHT THAT WE'LL DONATE $10
5:21:49PM TO CHARITY OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT BECAUSE I THINK HE KNOWS
5:21:51PM EVERYTHING ABOUT YOU.
5:21:52PM HOPEFULLY HE'LL WRITE YOUR BIOGRAPHY SOMEDAY.
5:21:58PM ALSO, AS AN ASIDE, I JUST HAD DINNER WITH YOUR SON A COUPLE
5:22:01PM OF WEEKS AGO.
5:22:02PM WE HAD A GREAT TIME.
5:22:03PM I'LL MEET HIM AGAIN SOON AND TRY TO GET SOME STORIES OUT OF
5:22:06PM HIM SO I CAN COME BACK AND TALK TO YOU ABOUT THEM.
5:22:09PM LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING YOU AGAIN.
5:22:11PM THANK YOU SO MUCH.
5:22:11PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: NOW IT IS TIME FOR THE BEAUTY.
5:22:13PM FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON'S STORY ABOUT NEARLY HITTING YOU
5:22:18PM IN THE CAR, FOR THE SHORT PERIOD OF TIME I'VE BEEN IN
5:22:22PM ELECTED OFFICE, I THINK YOU'RE GLAD IT WAS COUNCILWOMAN
5:22:24PM HENDERSON AND NOT ANOTHER POLITICIAN YOU WOULD HAVE RUN
5:22:27PM ACROSS BECAUSE THERE ARE A FEW OUT THERE THAT WOULD HAVE
5:22:29PM SPED UP, AS I KNOW THERE ARE A FEW THAT WOULD NOW SPEED UP
5:22:32PM AT ME.
5:22:33PM I'VE ONLY BEEN HERE SINCE MAY 1st AND YOU WERE THERE FOR
5:22:36PM AN AWFUL LONG TIME.
5:22:38PM YOU ARE REALLY A CASE THAT I STUDY ABOUT WHAT ONE PERSON CAN
5:22:46PM DO FOR A COMMUNITY.
5:22:47PM SO OFTEN WHILE THE CITY OF TAMPA HAS GOTTEN SO MUCH BIGGER,
5:22:52PM THE SAME TYPE OF MODEL THAT YOU DEMONSTRATED, THE
5:22:54PM COOPERATIVE AGREEMENT BETWEEN GOVERNMENT AND PRIVATE
5:22:57PM INTERESTS, TO BE ABLE TO, YOU KNOW, CREATE INCUBATOR
5:23:01PM PROJECTS AND REALLY HAVE A LONGER TERM VISION, THE SEEDS
5:23:04PM THAT YOU SOWED IN THE GROUND OF TAMPA, SOME OF THE TREES
5:23:09PM AREN'T FULLY MATURED YET.
5:23:11PM THEY ARE STILL GOING TO HAVE FRUIT ON THEM FOR YEARS AND
5:23:13PM YEARS TO COME.
5:23:15PM I'LL END BY SAYING, YOU KNOW, DON'T CHALLENGE ME BECAUSE
5:23:21PM WHEN I WALKED IN THIS ROOM THAT I WAS CHALLENGED THAT I
5:23:23PM WOULDN'T SING A HAPPY BIRTHDAY SONG.
5:23:26PM I INVITE EVERYBODY IN THE AUDIENCE AND ALL THE STAFF TO JOIN
5:23:29PM ME IN SINGING HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO MAYOR GRECO.
5:23:35PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I'LL DO IT WITH YOU.
5:23:36PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WANT EVERYBODY TO SING.
5:23:38PM HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU
5:23:40PM HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU
5:23:42PM HAPPY BIRTHDAY, MAYOR GRECO
5:23:46PM HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU
5:23:50PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:23:57PM >> THANK YOU ALL SO VERY MUCH.
5:23:59PM AGAIN, THANK YOU FOR WHAT YOU'RE DOING AND WHAT YOU'RE
5:24:02PM CONTINUING TO DO IN OUR CITY.
5:24:07PM 28 YEARS AGO, I GOT VERY FORTUNATE AND I WALKED INTO A PARTY
5:24:13PM AND MET THIS BEAUTIFUL BLOND GIRL BEHIND ME.
5:24:15PM 28 YEARS WE'VE BEEN MARRIED.
5:24:20PM AT THAT TIME SHE WAS AN INTENSIVE CARE PEDIATRICIAN.
5:24:22PM I FIGURED SHE MIGHT CHANGE MY DIAPER ONE DAY.
5:24:25PM I HOPE THAT NEVER HAPPENS.
5:24:27PM MY WIFE LINDA CAME WITH ME TODAY.
5:24:31PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:24:31PM THANK YOU ALL SO VERY MUCH.
5:24:37PM IF I CAN EVER BE OF HELP IN ANY WAY, I'M AVAILABLE.
5:24:41PM THANKS AGAIN.
5:24:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: BEFORE I MET MAYOR GRECO, I WOULD ANSWER
5:24:44PM THE PHONE WHEN I WAS AT MY GRANDMOTHER'S HOUSE AND HIS
5:24:47PM MOTHER WOULD CALL FOR MY GRANDMOTHER, EVELYN.
5:24:51PM I REMEMBER WHEN HE GOT MARRIED, I DIDN'T GO TO THE WEDDING,
5:24:54PM BUT I THINK EVERYBODY ELSE IN TAMPA DID.
5:24:56PM GOT A THOUSAND PEOPLE THERE.
5:24:58PM I WOULD HEAR ABOUT MAYOR GRECO.
5:24:59PM ONE DAY I'M IN YBOR CITY AND I MET HIM OVER IN CENTENNIAL
5:25:03PM PARK, AND THAT'S WHEN I GOT THIS INSPIRATION TO RUN FOR
5:25:07PM OFFICE BECAUSE I HEAR ABOUT THIS CHARISMATIC DICK GRECO,
5:25:10PM MAYOR GRECO WHO WAS MAYOR AT THE TIME.
5:25:13PM FAST-FORWARD, I GET INVOLVED IN POLITICS.
5:25:15PM FAST-FORWARD, I GET LUCKY ENOUGH TO WIN.
5:25:17PM INTERESTING FACT, I GOT MARRIED ALMOST TWO YEARS AGO RIGHT
5:25:21PM OUTSIDE OF CITY HALL HERE IN THE COURTYARD AND MAYOR GRECO
5:25:24PM OFFICIATED.
5:25:25PM OH, YOU SPEND A LOT OF TIME AT CITY HALL, IT'S LIKE, I GOT
5:25:29PM MARRIED AT CITY HALL, I PROPOSED OUTSIDE CITY HALL.
5:25:31PM I SPEND LOTS OF TIME AT CITY HALL AND THEN I GET MAYOR GRECO
5:25:35PM TO DO THE HONORS AND OFFICIATE THE WEDDING FOR MY WIFE AND
5:25:39PM I.
5:25:40PM YOU ARE A VERY SPECIAL PART OF MY WIFE.
5:25:43PM HAPPY BIRTHDAY, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:25:44PM >> THANK YOU ALL VERY MUCH.
5:25:46PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MAYOR.
5:25:47PM APPRECIATE IT.
5:25:48PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:25:52PM >> LISTEN TO A COUPLE OF ISSUES WHILE WE'RE HERE.
5:25:55PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHILE WE'RE WAITING FOR THE CHAIRMAN TO
5:25:57PM GET BACK TO THE DAIS, ARE WE GOING TO MOVE ON WITHOUT YOU OR
5:26:00PM TAKE A PICTURE?
5:26:01PM WE CAN TAKE A FIVE-MINUTE BREAK TO TAKE SOME PHOTOGRAPHS.
5:26:10PM I WOULD JUST LIKE TO SAY REFERENCE BEING AT CITY HALL THAT
5:26:13PM MUCH, I PRETTY MUCH DETERMINED I'LL FILE HOMESTEAD EXEMPTION
5:26:17PM ON CITY HALL BECAUSE I SPEND SO MUCH TIME HERE, I'M SURE I
5:26:20PM QUALIFY.
5:26:21PM [BREAK]
5:34:32PM [ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
5:34:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:34:37PM CITY COUNCIL IS BACK IN SESSION.
5:34:39PM LET'S DO ROLL CALL.
5:34:40PM >> CARLSON?
5:34:41PM HURTAK?
5:34:43PM >>LYNN HURTAK: HERE.
5:34:45PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HERE.
5:34:47PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: PRESENT.
5:34:50PM >>THE CLERK: VIERA?
5:34:51PM MIRANDA?
5:34:51PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HERE.
5:34:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
5:34:54PM >>THE CLERK: WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
5:34:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:34:57PM I'LL PASS THE GAVEL TO THE VICE-CHAIRMAN.
5:35:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CHAIRMAN MANISCALCO, YOU ARE RECOGNIZED.
5:35:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:35:05PM I WANT TO MAKE A MOTION TO ADD TO THE SEPTEMBER 21st,
5:35:08PM 2023, AGENDA A CLOSED SESSION TO BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER
5:35:12PM 21st, 2023, AT 11 A.M. ON THE 8th FLOOR -- IN THE 8th
5:35:19PM FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM OF OLD CITY HALL, 315 EAST KENNEDY
5:35:23PM BOULEVARD NORTH, TO DISCUSS SETTLEMENT NEGOTIATIONS IN THE
5:35:24PM CASE OF BURGER VERSUS THE CITY OF TAMPA WITH THE FOLLOWING
5:35:28PM PERSONS IN ATTENDANCE AT THE CLOSED SESSION:
5:35:29PM MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL, CITY COUNCIL ATTORNEY MARTIN
5:35:32PM SHELBY, CITY ATTORNEY ANDREA ZELMAN, ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY
5:35:35PM REBECCA JOHNS, HUMAN RESOURCES AND TALENT DIRECTOR KELLY
5:35:39PM AUSTIN, AND A CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER.
5:35:42PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WE HAVE A MOTION, DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
5:35:44PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
5:35:45PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: DO WE NEED A ROLL CALL?
5:35:47PM ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY AYE.
5:35:49PM OPPOSED?
5:35:50PM THE MOTION CARRIES.
5:35:51PM GAVEL BACK TO THE CHAIR.
5:35:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:35:54PM AT THIS TIME, IF YOU ARE GOING TO SPEAK ON ANY ITEM ON THE
5:35:57PM AGENDA, PLEASE STAND AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND WE WILL
5:36:00PM SWEAR YOU IN.
5:36:01PM THIS IS ANYTHING ON THE AGENDA THIS EVENING.
5:36:07PM [OATH ADMINISTERED]
5:36:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
5:36:17PM ITEM NUMBER 6.
5:36:20PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:36:23PM ITEM 6 IS REZ-23-36, THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2003 NORTH
5:36:29PM 60th STREET.
5:36:30PM THE APPLICANT IS REPRESENTED BY MUELLER LAW FIRM AND THE
5:36:34PM REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY FROM RS 50, RESIDENTIAL
5:36:38PM SINGLE-FAMILY, TO IG, INDUSTRIAL GENERAL.
5:36:40PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO DAVID TO GIVE HIS REPORT AND I'LL COME
5:36:43PM BACK AND GIVE MY REPORT.
5:36:44PM THANK YOU.
5:36:46PM >> GOOD AFTERNOON, COUNCIL MEMBERS.
5:36:48PM DAVID HEY WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
5:36:50PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
5:36:51PM THIS FIRST CASE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING
5:36:56PM DISTRICT AND ALSO WITHIN THE EAST SIDE COMMERCIAL
5:36:59PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:37:01PM THE CLOSEST TRANSIT IS LOCATED OUT ON EAST BROADWAY AVENUE.
5:37:05PM THAT'S THE HART ROUTE 8.
5:37:07PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: MAY I INTERRUPT FOR JUST A MINUTE, PLEASE?
5:37:09PM IS THIS A CASE WHERE THERE NEEDS TO BE SOME SORT OF
5:37:14PM INTERPRETATION FOR WHAT'S HAPPENING IN THE CASE?
5:37:16PM WHO IS THE INTERPRETER IN THIS MATTER?
5:37:17PM COULD YOU PLEASE COME FORWARD?
5:37:26PM >> [INAUDIBLE]
5:37:27PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YES, PLEASE.
5:37:28PM SORRY, MR. HEY.
5:37:31PM MY APOLOGIES.
5:37:32PM IF YOU COULD STATE YOUR NAME ON THE RECORD, INTERPRETER,
5:37:39PM PLEASE.
5:37:42PM >> SPANISH COURT INTERPRETER.
5:37:43PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YOU ARE GOING TO BE TRANSLATING FROM
5:37:45PM ENGLISH INTO SPANISH AND SPANISH INTO ENGLISH?
5:37:48PM >> THAT IS CORRECT.
5:37:49PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: COULD WE HAVE THE INTERPRETER SWORN IN,
5:37:51PM PLEASE?
5:37:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SHE WAS SWORN IN.
5:37:53PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: BUT WERE YOU SWORN IN AS AN INTERPRETER TO
5:37:57PM ACCURATELY TRANSLATE FROM ENGLISH TO SPANISH AND SPANISH
5:37:59PM INTO ENGLISH, WAS THAT THE SWEARING IN THAT YOU HAD?
5:38:03PM >> NO.
5:38:04PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: COULD YOU PLEASE DO THAT.
5:38:07PM >>THE CLERK: DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT THE TESTIMONY YOU
5:38:08PM ARE ABOUT TO GIVE IS THE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH.
5:38:11PM >> I WILL.
5:38:12PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YOU ARE TRANSLATING ON BEHALF OF THESE
5:38:16PM PEOPLE SPEAKING OR PRESENT TO YOUR LEFT.
5:38:20PM COULD YOU IDENTIFY THEM FOR THE RECORD?
5:38:25PM >> MALDONADO.
5:38:28PM AND AMERICA SOLIS.
5:38:31PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: A NOTE TO THOSE PEOPLE WHO WILL BE SPEAKING
5:38:33PM TONIGHT, PLEASE MAKE A NOTE OF THE FACT THAT THERE IS A
5:38:36PM TRANSLATOR PRESENT.
5:38:37PM PLEASE REMAIN MINDFUL THAT EVERYTHING FOR THE BENEFIT OF
5:38:43PM THESE WITNESSES, I BELIEVE WILL BE TESTIFYING, THAT YOU
5:38:48PM ALLOW THEM TO BE ABLE TO HAVE THE ITEMS TRANSLATED AND, OF
5:38:51PM COURSE, WHEN IT IS THEIR TURN TO COME, YOU WILL STEP FORWARD
5:38:54PM AND THEN WE WILL GO THROUGH THE PROCESS OF HAVING YOU
5:38:57PM TRANSLATE AND BACK AND FORTH.
5:38:58PM MR. HEY, IF YOU COULD START THE PRESENTATION AGAIN FOR THE
5:39:01PM PURPOSES OF THE RECORD.
5:39:02PM YOU COULD HAVE YOUR SEAT WHERE IT IS BEST FOR YOU, IF YOU
5:39:05PM WANT TO TAKE THEM WHEREVER YOU WERE SEATED.
5:39:07PM THE THING IS, YOU HAVE TO BE ABLE TO PLEASE ACCURATELY
5:39:11PM TRANSLATE.
5:39:11PM IF THERE IS AN ISSUE WITH WHAT IS BEING SAID, DON'T HAVE THE
5:39:15PM ABILITY, RAISE YOUR HAND AND WE'LL ADDRESS YOUR CONCERNS.
5:39:18PM YOU ARE WELCOME TO DO THAT.
5:39:23PM >>DAVID HEY: GOOD AFTERNOON AGAIN.
5:39:24PM DAVID HEY WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
5:39:26PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
5:39:27PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE CENTRAL TAMPA
5:39:30PM PLANNING DISTRICT AND MORE SPECIFICALLY THE EAST SIDE
5:39:33PM COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:39:34PM THE CLOSEST TRANSIT STOP IS LOCATED OUT ON EAST BROADWAY
5:39:39PM AVENUE, AND THAT EAST BROADWAY IS SERVED BY ROUTE 8.
5:39:44PM OAK PARK IS THE CLOSEST PUBLIC RECREATIONAL FACILITY, AND
5:39:51PM THAT'S LOCATED ABOUT A HALF MILE NORTHWEST OF THE SUBJECT
5:39:54PM SITE.
5:39:55PM AND THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED IN THE COASTAL PLANNING
5:39:59PM AREA, SPECIFICALLY EVACUATION ZONE D.
5:40:01PM HERE WE HAVE AN AERIAL OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
5:40:07PM IT'S LOCATED WITHIN THE CENTER OF THE MAP.
5:40:13PM AS YOU CAN SEE, THERE'S PREDOMINANTLY INDUSTRIAL USES SOUTH
5:40:16PM OF 10th.
5:40:18PM YOU ALSO HAVE THE RAIL YARD, THE CSX RAIL YARD TO THE SOUTH.
5:40:22PM NORTH OF 10th THERE IS A MIXTURE OF LIGHT INDUSTRIAL AND
5:40:29PM RESIDENTIAL USES SCATTERED THROUGHOUT.
5:40:32PM AND THEN NORTH OF COLUMBUS IS PREDOMINANTLY INDUSTRIAL.
5:40:37PM HERE WE HAVE THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
5:40:45PM THE SALMON COLOR WITH THE SUBJECT SITE AND PROPERTIES TO THE
5:40:48PM NORTH, EAST, AND WEST ARE ALL IN THAT TRANSITIONAL USE 24
5:40:53PM FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY.
5:40:54PM DIRECTLY TO THE SOUTH, SOUTH OF EAST 10th AVENUE IS LIGHT
5:40:58PM INDUSTRIAL, AND THEN DOWN IN THE RAIL YARD IT GOES TO THE
5:41:02PM HEAVY INDUSTRIAL.
5:41:03PM THAT TRANSITIONAL USE 24 YOU ARE AWARE, IT IS A VERY UNIQUE
5:41:10PM CATEGORY.
5:41:11PM THERE ARE SPECIFIC POLICY DIRECTIONS AS NOT TO BE EXPANDED.
5:41:15PM IT ALLOWS PROBABLY THE BROADEST USES ALLOWED WITHIN THAT
5:41:21PM DISTRICT.
5:41:21PM RANGING FROM RESIDENTIAL TO INDUSTRIAL.
5:41:25PM TO MINIMIZE ANY OFF-SITE IMPACTS ON ADJACENT USES, REZONINGS
5:41:35PM WITHIN THAT TU 24 SHALL RECOGNIZE THE SURROUNDING
5:41:37PM DEVELOPMENT DURING THE REZONING PROCESS.
5:41:39PM SO IT SHOULD BE SENSITIVE TO ANY ADJACENT RESIDENTIAL USES
5:41:43PM TO THE NORTH.
5:41:44PM THE PLAN DOES SUPPORT OPPORTUNITIES FOR INDUSTRIAL
5:41:47PM DEVELOPMENT TO ACCOMMODATE EMPLOYMENT FOR THE CITY'S GROWING
5:41:53PM POPULATION.
5:41:53PM THROUGH THE REZONING PROCESS, THE PLAN ALSO DISCOURAGES
5:41:57PM RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT NEAR INDUSTRIAL ZONED AREAS.
5:42:00PM GIVEN THE PRESENCE OF PARCELS CURRENTLY ZONED FOR INDUSTRIAL
5:42:04PM GENERAL AND INDUSTRIAL HEAVY TO THE SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT
5:42:06PM SITE, THE PROPOSED INDUSTRIAL GENERAL IG ZONING SUPPORTS
5:42:11PM THIS POLICY DIRECTION BY DISCOURAGING THE POTENTIAL OF
5:42:15PM RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT ON THAT SUBJECT SITE.
5:42:18PM SO BASED ON THAT, YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF RECOMMENDS
5:42:21PM TO YOU THIS EVENING THAT THIS PROPOSED REZONING BE FOUND
5:42:25PM CONSISTENT WITH THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
5:42:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:42:29PM DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. HEY AT THIS TIME?
5:42:31PM ALL RIGHT.
5:42:33PM YES, MA'AM.
5:42:38PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU AGAIN COUNCIL.
5:42:39PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:42:41PM IN THIS REZONING REQUEST FROM RS 50 TO IG, INDUSTRIAL
5:42:47PM GENERAL, IS A EUCLIDEAN REQUEST, SO THERE IS NO SITE PLAN
5:42:51PM ASSOCIATED WITH THIS REQUEST.
5:42:55PM THIS LOT CONTAINS .38 ACRES, AND I HAVE PICTURES TO SHOW YOU
5:43:02PM OF THE SITE AND OF THE AREA.
5:43:05PM I WOULD LIKE TO START WITH THE ZONING ATLAS TO SHOW YOU THE
5:43:09PM ZONING MAP OF THE AREA.
5:43:11PM SO THIS IS THE SITE THAT'S LOCATED HERE IN RED.
5:43:17PM AND YOU CAN SEE THAT THERE IS THE RS 50 ZONING THAT EXISTS
5:43:22PM NORTH OF THE SITE AND THEN AS YOU ARE SOUTH OF THE SITE, YOU
5:43:26PM HAVE THAT TRANSITION OF THE INDUSTRIAL GENERAL, THAT IG
5:43:29PM ZONING, AND YOU HAVE CI ZONING THAT'S LOCATED HERE A LITTLE
5:43:34PM BIT FARTHER SOUTH.
5:43:35PM THE REST IS INDUSTRIAL, INDUSTRIAL HEAVY, AND THEN FURTHER
5:43:39PM RIGHT IS RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY WITH RM 24.
5:43:43PM THIS AREA OF THE CITY HAS SEEN -- I MEAN, YOU HAVE
5:43:46PM PROPERTIES THAT ARE ZONED RESIDENTIAL.
5:43:48PM THEY MAY HAVE A COMMERCIAL OR AN INDUSTRIAL USE ON THE
5:43:51PM PROPERTY, AND THEN YOU HAVE PROPERTIES THAT HAVE INDUSTRIAL
5:43:54PM ZONING THAT MAY HAVE THE RESIDENTIAL USES ON IT.
5:44:00PM YOU'VE SEEN A COUPLE OF REZONINGS COME THROUGH RECENTLY IN
5:44:03PM THE AREA WHERE THERE IS THIS TRANSITION FROM THE RESIDENTIAL
5:44:08PM TO INDUSTRIAL ZONING.
5:44:10PM I LIKE TO SHOW YOU PICTURES OF THE AREA.
5:44:14PM SO THIS IS THE SITE.
5:44:18PM LOOKING ON 60th STREET.
5:44:20PM THIS IS THE SITE.
5:44:24PM THIS IS NORTH OF THE SITE.
5:44:29PM THIS IS WEST OF THE SITE.
5:44:33PM THIS IS THE VIEW TO THE WEST.
5:44:37PM THIS IS SOUTHWEST OF THE SITE, SO THIS IS AT THE CORNER OF
5:44:41PM 10th.
5:44:45PM THIS IS WEST OF THE SITE.
5:44:48PM AND THIS IS NORTHWEST OF THE SITE.
5:44:52PM THE DRC STAFF REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FINDS THE REQUEST
5:44:58PM CONSISTENT AND THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
5:45:04PM I'M AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
5:45:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR MS. DOCK?
5:45:08PM I SEE NONE.
5:45:10PM ALL RIGHT.
5:45:12PM IS THE APPLICANT HERE FOR THIS PROJECT?
5:45:14PM >> COUNCIL MEMBERS, GOOD EVENING.
5:45:15PM JORGE MARTIN REPRESENTING THE APPLICANT.
5:45:17PM MY APPLICANT IS SANCHEZ TRUCKING INC.
5:45:22PM RUIZ AND HER SON DANIEL SANCHEZ.
5:45:28PM THEY OPERATE A TRANSPORT TRUCKING OPERATION AND THEY
5:45:36PM PURCHASED THIS PARCEL IN ORDER TO ALLOW THEM TO HAVE
5:45:40PM OVERNIGHT STORAGE AND PARKING OF THEIR VEHICLES.
5:45:44PM THEY ARE CURRENTLY PAYING RENT AND THAT IS GOING UP TO
5:45:51PM ASTRONOMICAL RATE AND THEY FIGURED THAT IF THEY COULD HAVE
5:45:54PM THEIR OWN PLACE WHERE THEY COULD STORE VEHICLES OVERNIGHT,
5:45:58PM THAT WOULD ALLOW THEM TO HAVE A BETTER BUSINESS MODEL AND BE
5:46:04PM ABLE TO GROW THEIR BUSINESS.
5:46:06PM THIS IS A SMALL BUSINESS, MINORITY BUSINESS IN TAMPA, AND
5:46:12PM THEY LOOKED AT MANY LOTS, AND THE ONLY ONES THAT THEY FOUND
5:46:17PM THAT MET THE REQUIREMENTS FOR SPACE, EXITS, AND ACCESS TO
5:46:25PM HIGHWAYS WAS THIS ONE.
5:46:28PM SO THEY NEED THIS LOT REZONED TO OPERATE THEIR BUSINESS.
5:46:37PM AS THE PLANNING COMMISSION STATES, THIS IS IN THE
5:46:39PM TRANSITIONAL AREA, AND THE CITY COUNCIL HAS RULED ON AT
5:46:43PM LEAST FOUR OCCASIONS WHERE I HAVE LOOKED AT THE DIFFERENT
5:46:46PM HEARINGS, IGs HAVE BEEN GRANTED FROM RESIDENTIAL AS A
5:46:52PM PREFERRED METHOD WITHIN THIS TRANSITIONAL AREA.
5:46:55PM THE CITY STAFF HAS REVIEWED ALL ASPECTS OF THIS REZONING AND
5:47:05PM UNANIMOUSLY THE RECOMMENDATION IS APPROVAL.
5:47:07PM SO WITH THAT SAID, IF COUNCIL HAS ANY QUESTIONS, EITHER FOR
5:47:14PM ME OR MY CLIENT, FEEL FREE.
5:47:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE
5:47:18PM GENTLEMAN?
5:47:19PM >> I WOULD LIKE TO RESERVE ANY BALANCE I HAVE FOR ANY
5:47:21PM REBUTTAL.
5:47:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:47:22PM ALL RIGHT.
5:47:23PM AT THIS TIME, IF WE HAVE ANYBODY HERE THAT WISHES TO SPEAK
5:47:30PM -- YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD, SIR, MR. MARTIN.
5:47:33PM HE SAID JORGE MARTIN.
5:47:38PM >> YES, I THOUGHT I INTRODUCED MYSELF EARLIER.
5:47:41PM JORGE MARTIN.
5:47:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:47:46PM AT THIS TIME WE'LL TAKE PUBLIC COMMENT, IF ANYBODY WISHES TO
5:47:49PM SPEAK ON THIS CASE, THIS IS ITEM NUMBER 6.
5:47:51PM IF WE HAVE ANYBODY THAT WISHES TO SPEAK AT THIS TIME, NOW IS
5:47:55PM THE OPPORTUNITY.
5:47:56PM I DON'T SEE ANYONE REGISTERED.
5:48:00PM ANYBODY IN PERSON?
5:48:00PM PLEASE COME UP TO THE LECTERN AND STATE YOUR NAME.
5:48:09PM >> ANGEL MALDONADO.
5:48:14PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: IF I CAN, THE NAME, THE INTERPRETER.
5:48:16PM >> LISSY VIGOA-CARDET. L-I-S-S-Y V-I-G-O-A HYPHEN
5:48:16PM C-A-R-D-E-T.
5:48:25PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: ANGEL MALDONADO HAS TWO NAMES ON THIS
5:48:29PM SPEAKER WAIVER FORM.
5:48:33PM >> MALDONADO MORALES.
5:48:37PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THERE ARE TWO NAMES ON THIS LIST.
5:48:42PM WHAT THAT MEANS IS THOSE PEOPLE WILL GIVE UP THEIR TIME TO
5:48:46PM GIVE YOU AN EXTRA MINUTE TO TESTIFY.
5:48:48PM SO THEY CAN TAKE THREE MINUTES BY THEMSELVES IF THEY DON'T
5:48:53PM WANT TO BE ON THIS LIST OR YOU CAN SPEAK FOR THEM.
5:48:57PM BUT BY YOU SPEAKING, YOU GET AN EXTRA MINUTE AND THE OTHERS
5:49:00PM GIVE UP THEIR THREE.
5:49:01PM SO YOU WOULD HAVE A TOTAL OF THREE MINUTES PLUS TWO MINUTES,
5:49:06PM FIVE MINUTES TO SPEAK.
5:49:07PM DO YOU WISH ME TO SEE IF THOSE PEOPLE ARE PRESENT AND WAIVE
5:49:13PM THEIR TIME OR LET THEM SPEAK?
5:49:18PM >> WE'RE GOING TO TALK.
5:49:20PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YOU'LL TALK ON THEIR BEHALF OR EVERYBODY
5:49:23PM WILL TALK?
5:49:35PM >> I AM GOING TO USE MY MINUTES AND THEIR MINUTES.
5:49:39PM THIS IS THE INTERPRETER SPEAKING.
5:49:40PM THE WIFE ALSO IS GOING TO SPEAK.
5:49:44PM AND I THINK SOMEBODY IN HER PARTY ALSO DONATED MINUTES TO
5:49:47PM HER.
5:49:47PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: LET ME ASK WHOSE NAME IS ON THE LIST.
5:49:50PM COULD YOU PLEASE RAISE YOUR HAND TO LET ME KNOW YOU ARE
5:49:52PM HERE.
5:49:53PM ALEX MALDONADO.
5:49:55PM THAT'S ONE PERSON.
5:49:57PM JENNIFER RAMIREZ.
5:49:59PM THAT'S ONE PERSON.
5:50:00PM SO THEN A TOTAL OF FIVE MINUTES TO MR. MALDONADO MORALES AND
5:50:06PM THEN THE OTHER PEOPLE CAN SPEAK INDIVIDUALLY WHEN HIS TIME
5:50:10PM IS UP.
5:50:12PM THANK YOU.
5:50:15PM YOU CAN CONTINUE.
5:50:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD, SIR.
5:50:31PM >> I'M NOT AGREEING TO THE TRUCKING COMPANY BE THERE AND
5:50:39PM PARKING THEIR TRUCKS THERE BECAUSE I HAVE A YOUNG CHILD THAT
5:50:42PM HAS CANCER AND IT'S A VERY SHORT DISTANCE FROM THE FENCE AND
5:50:46PM TO THAT PROPERTY.
5:50:47PM SHE'S AT THE HOSPITAL BUT THEY SEND HER HOME IN JUST ONE
5:51:00PM WEEK TO REST, BUT I CANNOT HAVE HER RESTING WHILE THEY HAVE
5:51:06PM THAT NOISE THERE FROM THE TRUCKS.
5:51:08PM AND I CANNOT HAVE HER OR THE CHILDREN GOING OUT TO THE
5:51:18PM STREET AND PLAYING OUTSIDE BECAUSE IF THERE ARE GOING TO BE
5:51:21PM TRUCKS COMING IN AND OUT.
5:51:23PM AND IF THERE ARE GOING TO BE TRUCKS, THERE ARE GOING TO BE
5:51:38PM MECHANICS, NOISE THERE ALL THE TIME.
5:51:40PM AND ALL THE HOUSES AROUND ARE HOUSES, ONLY THAT SPACE, AND
5:51:47PM IN THE BACK IS THE LOT.
5:51:50PM IT'S NOT AN INDUSTRIAL AREA.
5:51:52PM IT IS A RESIDENTIAL AREA.
5:51:54PM THAT'S WHY I'M NOT AGREEING WITH THIS.
5:52:02PM MAYBE ANOTHER TYPE OF BUSINESS, BUT NOT A TRUCKING BUSINESS.
5:52:10PM AND THE ROAD, THE STREET IS ALREADY FULL OF POTHOLES AND IF
5:52:25PM THERE ARE GOING TO BE TRUCKS COMING IN AND OUT AND THERE
5:52:28PM WILL BE MORE HOLES.
5:52:29PM AND WE BROUGHT PICTURES OF CHILDREN WAITING OUTSIDE ON THE
5:52:45PM SIDE OF THE ROAD TO BE PICKED UP FOR SCHOOL AND THEN TRUCKS
5:52:49PM FLYING BY, SPEEDING ON THAT ROAD, SO IMAGINE WITH EVEN MORE
5:52:54PM TRUCKS.
5:52:57PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: DID HE HAVE INTENTION OF SHOWING PICTURES
5:52:59PM OR NO?
5:52:59PM ANOTHER SPEAKER WILL SHOW THE PICTURES OR NOW?
5:53:08PM >> SHE'S GOING TO SHOW THEM.
5:53:15PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: IF YOU JUST SET IT DOWN THERE.
5:53:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: LET'S BRING IT UP ON THE BIG SCREEN.
5:53:35PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: AND IF THEY COULD ZOOM OUT.
5:53:37PM THAT'S IT.
5:53:37PM THANK YOU.
5:53:38PM ANY OTHER PICTURES, PLEASE?
5:53:45PM >> YOU SEE THIS PICTURE SHOWS A LADY THAT IS OUT WALKING
5:53:59PM WITH THEIR CHILD TO THE BUS STOP AND THERE ARE TRUCKS GOING
5:54:04PM BY.
5:54:05PM THIS IS ONE THAT I GOT FROM BEHIND AND FROM A DISTANCE.
5:54:17PM AND THIS ONE DOESN'T SHOW VERY WELL, BUT BEHIND THAT FENCE
5:54:28PM IS OUR HOUSE.
5:54:30PM AND WHEN THEY WANT TO CHANGE THE ZONING, IT'S RIGHT NEXT TO
5:54:37PM IT HERE.
5:54:37PM I DON'T KNOW IF YOU GET TO SEE IT, BUT THIS WHITE AREA THAT
5:54:46PM I'M POINTING WITH MY FINGER HERE IS THE ENTRANCE TO THEIR
5:54:51PM LOT.
5:54:51PM AND THIS IS OUR FENCE.
5:55:00PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: ANYTHING FURTHER?
5:55:01PM ARE YOU DONE, MR. MORALES.
5:55:19PM WE CAN STOP THE TIMER AND GO THREE MINUTES FOR THE NEXT
5:55:22PM SPEAKER.
5:55:23PM HER NAME WAS NOT ON THE LIST.
5:55:25PM SHE GETS THREE MINUTES.
5:55:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE START WITH HER NAME.
5:55:36PM >> AMERICA SOLIS PONCE.
5:55:41PM AND HE IS MY HUSBAND AND I AM AGREEING TO WHAT HE SAID
5:56:00PM BECAUSE IT IS THE SAME CASE FOR MY DAUGHTER.
5:56:04PM AND I WANT TO MAKE A REQUEST TO THE OWNER.
5:56:18PM I KNOW THAT THIS IS THEIR BUSINESS, BUT I WANT HIM TO FIND
5:56:21PM ANOTHER PLACE BECAUSE THEY ARE GOING TO STEAL OUR
5:56:26PM PEACEFULNESS.
5:56:28PM IT'S A DANGER FOR THE CHILDREN AND FOR THE NEIGHBORS BECAUSE
5:56:41PM OF THE TRUCKS GOING IN AND OUT CONSTANTLY.
5:56:45PM AND THEY GO AT HIGH SPEEDS, TOO.
5:56:51PM AND AS MY HUSBAND SAID, THE LOT IS NEXT DOOR AND WE HAVE OUR
5:57:09PM DAUGHTER WITH THE SITUATION AND SHE'S NOT GOING TO BE ABLE
5:57:11PM TO REST.
5:57:12PM AND MY HUSBAND WORKS AND MY CHILDREN GO TO SCHOOL, THEY HAVE
5:57:28PM TO BE ABLE TO REST TO GO FRESH TO SCHOOL NEXT DAY.
5:57:31PM AND IF WE HAVE THAT CONSTANT NOISE, WE WILL NOT BE ABLE TO
5:57:42PM DO IT.
5:57:43PM AND I ASKED THE OWNER OF THE LOT TO PLEASE REACH OUT TO HIS
5:58:01PM HEART AND PLACE HIMSELF IN OUR SHOES.
5:58:04PM AND THINK MOST OF ALL OF THE CHILDREN, MY CHILD INCLUDED
5:58:13PM THAT NEEDS TO HAVE PEACE.
5:58:16PM AND TO PLEASE NOT TO STEAL THAT PEACEFULNESS TO THE
5:58:24PM CHILDREN.
5:58:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:58:34PM IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE THAT WISHES TO SPEAK DURING PUBLIC
5:58:37PM COMMENT?
5:58:37PM PLEASE COME UP AND STATE YOUR NAME.
5:58:39PM YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES TO SPEAK.
5:58:41PM ARE YOU ALL GOING TO BE SPEAKING TOGETHER OR THREE SEPARATE?
5:58:45PM >> SEPARATE.
5:58:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: OKAY.
5:58:46PM WE'LL GIVE THREE MINUTES TO EACH PERSON, AS LONG AS EACH
5:58:49PM PERSON SPEAKS ON THEIR OWN.
5:58:50PM GO AHEAD.
5:58:50PM >> HI.
5:58:50PM MY NAME IS JOLENE CLAUVIL SPEAKING ON THE BEHALF OF OUR
5:58:56PM HOUSEHOLD.
5:58:57PM SO THE POTHOLES ON 60th STREET IS THE SIZE OF MOON
5:59:01PM CRATERS.
5:59:01PM THE GOVERNMENT FIXED THE PREVIOUS POTHOLES IN THE PAST THAT
5:59:04PM WERE CREATED BY TRUCKS.
5:59:05PM HOWEVER, DUE TO MULTIPLE TRUCKS CONSTANTLY GOING UP AND DOWN
5:59:09PM 60th AND 59th STREET, THE POTHOLES ARE BACK AND WORSE.
5:59:13PM OUR STREET IS VERY NARROW, AND TWO SUVs GOING DOWN THE
5:59:19PM STREET ALREADY HAVE DIFFICULTY GOING DOWN OUR STREET WITH
5:59:21PM THE SUVs SIDE BY SIDE.
5:59:23PM WE ALSO HAVE COMMERCIAL TRUCKING COMPANIES TRYING TO DEVELOP
5:59:27PM THEMSELVES IN OUR SMALL NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:59:29PM THIS IS NOW CAUSING US TO CONSTANTLY WORRY ABOUT OUR
5:59:32PM CHILDREN ON THE WAY TO SCHOOL, GOING UP TO THE STREET TO
5:59:35PM THEIR BUS STOP.
5:59:38PM WE ALSO HAVE NEAR-CAR COLLISIONS BECAUSE OF THE POTHOLES AT
5:59:42PM THE BEGINNING OF OUR STREET AND ON THE 10th STREET.
5:59:45PM WE PETITION AS A COMMUNITY THAT THE NEW TRUCKING BUSINESS,
5:59:49PM ESPECIALLY THE ONES TRYING TO LOCATE THEMSELVES AT 2003
5:59:53PM RELOCATE THEMSELVES TO AN INDUSTRIAL AREA INSTEAD.
5:59:56PM THAT'S ALL FOR ME.
5:59:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:00:00PM >> THANK YOU.
6:00:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NEXT SPEAKER.
6:00:01PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:00:02PM YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
6:00:04PM >> HELLO.
6:00:05PM MY NAME IS JOHANNA CLAUVIL, AND I AM SPEAKING TODAY AS
6:00:11PM SOMEONE WHO LIVES AT THE HOUSE OF 2002.
6:00:17PM IN ALL NATURAL REALITY TO PARK A 55, WHETHER IT'S 55 INCHES
6:00:22PM OR NOT OR LESS, BUT LET'S JUST SAY A TRUCK TO BE PARKED IN
6:00:28PM THE PARKING LOT, IT WOULD REQUIRE NOT ONLY FOR THEM TO COVER
6:00:35PM OR INSERT THE TRUCK INTO AN ACTUAL RESIDENCE TO PARK IN
6:00:42PM THEIR ESTABLISHMENT BECAUSE THERE'S ALREADY NO ROOM ON OUR
6:00:44PM STREET, BUT THEY WOULD HAVE TO LITERALLY TURN IN ONTO THAT
6:00:48PM DRIVE PAVEMENT OF ANOTHER HOME DIRECTLY IN FRONT OF THEIR
6:00:53PM INSTITUTION.
6:00:54PM SO THERE IS NO SPACE FOR THEM TO TURN THEIR PROPERTY EN
6:01:01PM MASSE INTO THEIR OWN LOT.
6:01:03PM SO WITH THAT BEING SAID, THIS IS ALREADY A BIG DEAL FOR THE
6:01:08PM HOME THAT'S THERE IN FRONT OF IT BECAUSE OUR PARKING PATHWAY
6:01:13PM IS A PARKING PATHWAY THAT HAD TO BE REBUILT TWICE.
6:01:18PM THE CITY CAME IN, PUT SANDBAGS AND HAD IT LIKE REMADE FROM
6:01:24PM SCRATCH BECAUSE IT HAD BROKE ONCE MORE.
6:01:28PM WHEN THE OWNERS CAME IN TO LIVE AT THIS PROPERTY FROM THE
6:01:32PM BEGINNING, THERE WAS A SMALL PLANK, WOOD PLANK FOR THEM TO
6:01:38PM DRIVE INTO THEIR OWN PARKING LOT.
6:01:40PM SO NOW THAT IT HAD TO BE REMADE, THE CITY CAME IN, REMADE
6:01:43PM THAT PATHWAY.
6:01:45PM THEY HAD TO REMAKE IT WITH SANDBAGS AND HENCE IT'S ALREADY
6:01:52PM FALLING, BECAUSE IT'S, AGAIN, DIRT.
6:01:55PM THE PATHWAY IS MADE OF DIRT.
6:01:57PM SO FOR A BIG COMMERCIAL TRUCK TO PARK INTO THEIR OWN LOT, IT
6:02:03PM WOULD REQUIRE THEM TO BACK UP ON THAT PATHWAY.
6:02:07PM THAT WOULD HAVE TO BE REDONE AGAIN BY THE CITY BECAUSE IT'S
6:02:10PM NOT MADE OF CEMENT.
6:02:11PM IN ALL HONESTY, IT'S UNREALISTIC.
6:02:14PM IT'S NOT REAL TO DO THAT, SO THEY WOULD DEFINITELY NEED TO
6:02:18PM REZONE BECAUSE, AGAIN, THIS IS A RESIDENTIAL PLACE.
6:02:21PM THIS IS A RESIDENTIAL COMMUNITY.
6:02:23PM THERE'S NO --
6:02:37PM [ENCODER DROP]
6:02:50PM -- IS IN JEOPARDY.
6:03:01PM I DEAL WITH DANGEROUS DEEP POTHOLES EVERY DAY COMING HOME
6:03:04PM FROM WORK SINCE I AM A PERSON WHO WORKS NIGHT SHIFTS.
6:03:07PM SO IMAGINE POTHOLES DEEP AND IT'S DARK.
6:03:12PM WE DON'T REALLY HAVE MUCH LIGHT IN OUR ALLEYWAY.
6:03:15PM SO MY CAR DO SUFFER A LOT WITH TRYING TO MANEUVER AROUND
6:03:20PM THESE POTHOLES, AND WE HAVE HAD OUR ROAD FIXED BEFORE, BUT
6:03:26PM NOW THESE POTHOLES ARE BIGGER, THEY ARE MORE DANGEROUS.
6:03:30PM MY FATHER'S BIGGEST CONCERN IS HIS YOUNGER DAUGHTER WALKING
6:03:35PM DOWN THE STREET TO THE BUS STOP OR WALKING DOWN TO WALK OUR
6:03:40PM DOG.
6:03:41PM THERE ARE BIG COMMERCIAL TRUCKS JUST RUNNING DOWN THE STREET
6:03:45PM EVERY DAY.
6:03:47PM TWO MORNINGS AGO, MY MOM WITNESSED A TRUCK GETTING STUCK IN
6:03:50PM A POTHOLE.
6:03:51PM IT TOOK NEARLY 20 MINUTES TO GET THE TRUCK UNSTUCK.
6:03:54PM I MYSELF WITNESSED A BIG SEMITRUCK IN THE PATH BEFORE
6:03:58PM GETTING STUCK DUE TO THE ROADS BEING SO NARROW.
6:04:03PM LIKE, IT WAS I GUESS ATTEMPTING TO MAKE A TURN, AND IT WAS
6:04:07PM JUST TOO LARGE TO MAKE THAT TURN, AND IT GOT STUCK IN ONE OF
6:04:11PM THE POTHOLE DITCH AREAS.
6:04:14PM THIS NEW COMPANY WILL ONLY CAUSE MORE DAMAGE TO THE ROADS.
6:04:18PM MAJORITY OF MY HOUSEHOLD WORK NIGHT SHIFT.
6:04:21PM LIKE I SAID BEFORE, AND WE STRUGGLE WITH TRUCK NOISE
6:04:23PM CURRENTLY DUE TO THE LOUD NOISES.
6:04:26PM I DO HAVE PICTURES OF HOW THE ROADS LOOK AND HOW BIG AND
6:04:29PM MASSIVE THESE POTHOLES ARE.
6:04:33PM I ALSO HAVE A PICTURE OF THE AS WELL.
6:04:44PM THIS IS A PICTURE OF ONE OF MY SIBLINGS STANDING IN THE
6:04:48PM POTHOLE.
6:04:49PM YOU CAN SEE HER SMALL FEET COMPARED TO THE HUGE POTHOLE.
6:04:52PM ANOTHER PICTURE OF THE POTHOLE.
6:04:57PM I'LL ZOOM IN HERE.
6:04:58PM THIS IS HOW DAMAGED THE ROADS ARE FROM THE SIDE.
6:05:03PM THIS IS MY SISTER STANDING IN THE DAMAGED ROAD.
6:05:11PM MASSIVE, VERY BIG.
6:05:13PM YOU CAN SEE ALL THE DAMAGE RIGHT HERE.
6:05:18PM SO THIS IS A VIDEO OF HER STANDING IN THERE.
6:05:29PM [ENCODER DROP]
6:05:53PM --
6:06:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SPEAK AT THIS TIME, PUBLIC COMMENT,
6:06:05PM PLEASE COME UP, STATE YOUR NAME, YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
6:06:08PM YES, MA'AM, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:06:12PM >> GOOD EVENING, STEPHANIE POYNOR.
6:06:14PM I WOULD LOVE TO HAVE THEM AT 7400 INTERBAY BOULEVARD.
6:06:18PM WE WOULD LOVE TO CONTINUE TO HAVE A TRUCKING COMPANY THERE.
6:06:21PM WE WOULD LOVE TO HAVE LIGHT INDUSTRIAL NEXT DOOR TO US.
6:06:24PM PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE, 7400 INTERBAY BOULEVARD.
6:06:28PM THE TRUCKING COMPANY THAT'S THERE WANTS TO SELL OUT.
6:06:31PM THESE FOLKS OBVIOUSLY ARE NOT EXCITED ABOUT IT.
6:06:33PM AND I HAVE TO SUPPORT THEM, OF COURSE, AND THOSE ROADS ARE
6:06:36PM ATROCIOUS.
6:06:38PM THOSE FOLKS LIVE NOT IN A THIRD WORLD, BUT IN A HUGE CITY.
6:06:46PM WE GOT $140 MILLION HANNA STREET, BUT THESE FOLKS LIVE ON A
6:06:49PM STREET THAT LOOKS LIKE THAT.
6:06:51PM IT'S EMBARRASSING.
6:06:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:06:53PM IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE THAT WISHES TO SPEAK?
6:06:56PM YES, MA'AM.
6:06:57PM COME ON UP.
6:06:58PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:07:01PM >> MY NAME IS GUYRLENE CLAUVIL, HERE TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF
6:07:08PM MY HUSBAND BECAUSE HE IS NOT IN THE COUNTRY.
6:07:11PM HE IS A TRUCK DRIVER AS WELL THAT LIVES 2002 NORTH 60th
6:07:17PM STREET.
6:07:18PM HE'S BEEN HELPING A LOT OF DRIVERS WHEN THEY ARE STUCK IN
6:07:22PM THE DITCH BECAUSE THEY ARE TRYING TO TURN AND THEY KEEP
6:07:25PM FALLING IN THE DITCH.
6:07:26PM SO WE ALREADY HAVE A PROBLEM WITH THE STREET.
6:07:29PM AND NOW NOT ONLY THE POTHOLES, THE OTHER LADY SHOWS THAT THE
6:07:33PM FRONT OF THE STREET, WE STARTING ON 10th STREET TOO, WE'RE
6:07:37PM HAVING HOLES IN THE MIDDLE OF THE STREET.
6:07:39PM NOW, TO COME HOME FROM WORK, I HAVE TO TURN ON 59th STREET
6:07:44PM BECAUSE TWO CARS CANNOT TURN ON 60th STREET.
6:07:49PM SO IT'S LIKE A MESS.
6:07:51PM RIGHT NOW, WHEN IT RAINS, IT GETS DEEPER AND DEEPER.
6:07:55PM SO I WITNESSED A TRUCK STUCK LIKE SHE WAS SHOWING YOU THE
6:07:59PM OTHER MORNING, THEY ARE STUCK THERE AND I HAD TO STAY THERE
6:08:02PM AND THEN WAIT UNTIL TRAFFIC CLEARED TO TURN TO 59th STREET
6:08:05PM TO GET HOME.
6:08:06PM SO IT'S REALLY A BAD IDEA TO HAVE A COMPANY COME IN FRONT OF
6:08:15PM THE HOUSE WHEN WE CAN'T BACK INTO THE DRIVEWAY.
6:08:17PM IT'S DANGEROUS ALREADY WITH ALL THE TRUCKS GOING BACK AND
6:08:20PM FORTH.
6:08:20PM NOW IF WE HAVE A TRUCKING BUSINESS IN FRONT OF OUR YARD,
6:08:23PM THERE'S NO WAY WE CAN LIVE WITH IT.
6:08:25PM PLUS, MOST OF US WORK NIGHT SHIFT.
6:08:28PM WE WON'T BE ABLE TO SLEEP DURING THE DAY AS WELL.
6:08:31PM THANK YOU.
6:08:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:08:33PM ANYBODY ELSE WISHING TO SPEAK?
6:08:35PM YES, MA'AM.
6:08:38PM >> GOOD EVENING.
6:08:39PM KELLA McCASKILL.
6:08:41PM INITIALLY I WAS GOING TO SAY, WELL, THEY MAY NOT HAVE A
6:08:43PM WHOLE LOT OF -- WHAT YOU ALL WOULD BE LOOKING FOR IN TERMS
6:08:47PM OF COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE, BUT THEN SHE SHOWED
6:08:51PM PICTURES AND I KNOW THAT STILL MAY NOT MEET THE MERIT OF
6:08:55PM WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING FOR, BUT WHICH ONE OF YOU WOULD WANT TO
6:08:58PM LIVE IN THAT TYPE OF NEIGHBORHOOD?
6:08:59PM I'M NOT SURE WHAT YOU COULD DO ABOUT IT.
6:09:02PM IT'S TOUGH BECAUSE ONE GROUP PURSUED A BUSINESS AND FOUND AN
6:09:05PM IDEAL LOCATION TO PUT IT.
6:09:06PM THE OTHER GROUP PURSUIT OF THE AMERICAN DREAM WHICH WE
6:09:10PM ASSOCIATE TO HOME OWNERSHIP.
6:09:14PM NOW YOU HAVE THIS SITUATION.
6:09:15PM WHAT CHILD, WHO WANTS THEIR CHILDREN TO WALK DOWN THE STREET
6:09:18PM POTENTIALLY DURING THE DAY, HEAD TO SCHOOL, COMING FROM
6:09:21PM SCHOOL, PARK, WHATEVER.
6:09:22PM MOST PEOPLE ARE OUTSIDE IN THEIR FRONT YARD.
6:09:24PM UNFORTUNATELY, THIS FAMILY WON'T BE ABLE TO DO THAT.
6:09:28PM IDEALLY IT IS A TOUGH CALL, BUT WHICH ONE OF YOU LOOKING AT
6:09:31PM THE PROCESS, AGAIN, NOT A WHOLE LOT OF COMPETENT AND
6:09:35PM SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE BUT I DON'T KNOW ANYBODY THAT WANT TO
6:09:37PM LIVE IN THOSE CONDITIONS.
6:09:38PM WHEN I WAS LOOKING AT SUPPORTING HEAVILY ALL FOR
6:09:41PM TRANSPORTATION, I SAW HOW MANY DEATHS WERE ON THE EAST SIDE
6:09:44PM OF THE AREA.
6:09:45PM THE PEDESTRIAN DEATHS, AS A MATTER OF FACT.
6:09:47PM AND ON BICYCLES.
6:09:49PM WHEN I THINK ABOUT IT, IF WE SAY YES TO SOMETHING LIKE THIS,
6:09:52PM ALTHOUGH IT'S VERY UNFORTUNATE FOR THE GROUP THAT'S PURSUING
6:09:55PM BUSINESS, I LOVE TO SEE PEOPLE GO AND START A BUSINESS,
6:09:57PM ACQUIRE, LOT ACQUISITIONS AND DEVELOP SOMETHING TO EXPAND
6:10:00PM THAT BUSINESS.
6:10:01PM BUT IN THIS SITUATION, CONSIDERING THE DEATHS, CONSIDERING
6:10:05PM IT IS A NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:10:08PM BEFORE IT WAS TO ADD ANOTHER TRUCKING COMPANY OR ALLOW THEM
6:10:10PM TO EXPAND, MAKES IT EVEN WORSE AND IT TAKES AWAY THE BENEFIT
6:10:14PM OF BEING IN A NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:10:15PM I'M ASKING THAT YOU CONSIDER THAT.
6:10:17PM I THINK SHE SAID SHE ASKED THEM TO REACH INTO THEIR HEART
6:10:20PM AND REALIZE, AND I KNOW THAT DOESN'T ALWAYS MAKE THE
6:10:21PM DECISION.
6:10:22PM BUT HERE YOU GET AN OPPORTUNITY TO SEE WHAT YOU CAN DO TO
6:10:25PM MAYBE RESEARCH THE IMPACT IN TERMS OF TRANSPORTATION AND HOW
6:10:28PM IT IMPACTS -- HOW IT COULD IMPACT PEDESTRIANS AS THEY
6:10:33PM NAVIGATE THROUGH THAT AREA.
6:10:34PM AGAIN, WHICH ONE OF YOU WANT TO LIVE ACROSS FROM A TRUCKING
6:10:38PM COMPANY DOWN THE STREET WITH THOSE POTHOLES.
6:10:41PM COMING FROM SOUTH TAMPA TO EAST TAMPA ON A REGULAR.
6:10:46PM THAT I THINK YOU NEED EVERY TWO DAYS.
6:10:48PM AWFUL TO COME DOWN AT NIGHT, DURING THE DAY, ANYTIME,
6:10:51PM HORRIBLE.
6:10:52PM I KNOW THEY DIDN'T HAVE A WHOLE LOT OF COMPETENT AND
6:10:55PM SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE BUT YOU'VE SEEN ENOUGH TO RULE
6:10:59PM WHICHEVER WAY YOU CAN.
6:11:02PM THANK YOU.
6:11:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:11:04PM ANYBODY ELSE WISH TO SPEAK?
6:11:05PM IF NOT -- GO AHEAD, SIR.
6:11:10PM DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FROM COUNCIL MEMBERS FOR THE
6:11:12PM APPLICANT AT THIS TIME BEFORE HE BEGINS HIS REBUTTAL?
6:11:19PM >> COUNCIL MEMBERS, JORGE MARTIN AGAIN.
6:11:22PM WE HAVE A SITUATION AS STATED BY THE PREVIOUS SPEAKER, IT IS
6:11:30PM ENDEMIC IN THIS AREA.
6:11:32PM WE ARE IN A TRANSITIONAL AREA.
6:11:34PM THE COMPLAINTS THAT HAVE BEEN LEVELED BUT THE TRUCK TRAFFIC,
6:11:39PM YOU KNOW, THE POTHOLES AND WHATEVER, THEY ARE THERE.
6:11:42PM EVERY TIME I'VE BEEN AT THIS PROPERTY FROM THE RAIL YARD,
6:11:48PM YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE SEMIS, NOT THEIR TRUCKS.
6:11:51PM THEIR TRUCKS ARE FAIRLY SMALL.
6:11:53PM THEY ARE DUMP TRUCKS.
6:11:55PM AND LET'S FOCUS ON WHAT WE HAVE TODAY.
6:11:58PM THIS IS A EUCLIDEAN REZONING.
6:12:01PM WHAT OPERATION WILL BE THERE IS GOING TO BE HASHED OUT
6:12:05PM THROUGHOUT THE PERMITTING PROCESS, BUT THEY CAN'T GET TO
6:12:08PM THAT WITHOUT A REZONING.
6:12:12PM NOW, NOBODY WANTS A SITUATION LIKE THIS IN THEIR BACKYARD.
6:12:17PM THIS IS A SMALL MINORITY BUSINESS AND THEY FIND NO PLACE TO
6:12:22PM GO.
6:12:22PM WHERE ARE THEY GOING TO GO?
6:12:23PM SOUTH TAMPA?
6:12:24PM EVEN SOUTH OF GANDY USED TO BE A POSSIBILITY, NOT ANYMORE.
6:12:31PM NEW TAMPA?
6:12:32PM FORGET IT.
6:12:34PM CITY OF TAMPA NEEDS SMALL BUSINESSES.
6:12:38PM THEY NEED IT FOR THE TAX BASE.
6:12:41PM THEY NEED IT BECAUSE THESE ARE SERVICE INDUSTRIES THAT NEED
6:12:44PM TO BE HERE.
6:12:45PM IF WE DON'T MAKE SPACES AVAILABLE FOR THEM, WHERE ARE THEY
6:12:49PM GOING TO GO?
6:12:49PM I CAN GUARANTEE YOU THAT IN TRANSITIONAL AREA, IT'S GOING TO
6:12:55PM BE MUCH BETTER THAN ELSEWHERE, AND THAT'S WHY IT IS A
6:12:59PM TRANSITIONAL AREA AND WHY THE PLANNING COMMISSION WANTS TO
6:13:02PM DISCOURAGE ADDITIONAL RESIDENTIAL USE.
6:13:06PM NOW, A LOT OF THE THINGS THAT HAVE BEEN CONJECTURED HERE
6:13:11PM ABOUT NOISE AND WHATEVER, NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.
6:13:15PM THIS OPERATION WORKS DURING THE DAY, THE WHOLE DAY.
6:13:20PM THEY HAVE DUMP TRUCKS.
6:13:21PM THEY TAKE FILL, ROCK, WHATEVER, AND THEY ARE GONE ALL DAY.
6:13:25PM THERE ARE NO REPAIRS.
6:13:26PM THEY HAVE THEIR OWN REPAIR FACILITIES WITH OTHER PEOPLE.
6:13:31PM THE SOLE USE OF THIS YARD IS GOING TO BE AS A DEPOT, TO
6:13:35PM STORE THE VEHICLES OVERNIGHT.
6:13:37PM THEY ARE NOT GOING TO INCREASE THE TRAFFIC AND, IN FACT, IN
6:13:42PM THE PERMITTING PROCESS, WHAT THEY PROPOSE TO DO IS TO HAVE
6:13:46PM THE DRIVEWAY BUILT, STRENGTHENED THROUGH TENT, NOT WHERE IT
6:13:52PM IS PRESENTLY AT SO TRAFFIC DOESN'T IMPACT 60th OR 59th.
6:13:58PM BUT THE TRAFFIC IS THERE.
6:14:00PM THE TRUCKS ARE THERE.
6:14:03PM MUCH BIGGER AND MUCH, YOU KNOW, MORE DANGEROUS OR INVASIVE
6:14:11PM THAN ANYTHING THAT THEY PROPOSE TO DO.
6:14:13PM BUT, AGAIN, THIS IS A TRANSITIONAL AREA.
6:14:17PM THIS IS A EUCLIDEAN REZONING, AND WE ASK YOU TO GIVE THE
6:14:23PM EUCLIDEAN REZONING APPROVAL AND I CAN GUARANTEE YOU THAT THE
6:14:30PM NEIGHBORHOOD WILL IMPROVE.
6:14:33PM THE NEIGHBORS TO THE NORTH.
6:14:36PM IN THE PAST, THE PROPERTY THERE HAD NUMEROUS CODE
6:14:40PM VIOLATIONS.
6:14:42PM IT WAS ESSENTIALLY A JUNKYARD.
6:14:45PM THE FENCE IS DISGRACEFUL.
6:14:49PM AS PART OF THIS BUSINESS, THEY WILL PUT UP A METAL FENCE,
6:14:54PM HIGH UP, NOT TO CAUSE A DISTURBANCE TO THEM OR TO THE OTHER
6:15:01PM NEIGHBORS.
6:15:01PM THEY WILL MOVE THEIR YARD.
6:15:03PM THERE WILL BE BUFFERING AND THERE WILL BE IMPROVEMENTS.
6:15:06PM AND I CAN GUARANTEE YOU THAT WHAT EXISTED THERE BEFORE IS
6:15:11PM MUCH WORSE THAN WHAT IS THERE NOW.
6:15:13PM THEY HAVE CLEANED UP THIS LOT AND MADE IT -- YOU SAW THE
6:15:18PM PICTURES.
6:15:18PM IT IS A CLEAN LOT.
6:15:19PM BEFORE IT WAS A JUNKYARD.
6:15:21PM YOU WOULDN'T WANT TO HAVE YOUR CHILD NEXT TO A JUNKYARD.
6:15:28PM AND WE SYMPATHIZE WITH THAT SITUATION, BUT I CAN GUARANTEE
6:15:33PM YOU THAT THE OPERATION THAT MY CLIENTS WILL RUN THERE IS
6:15:37PM GOING TO BE A LOT BETTER AND IT'S GOING TO BE A LOT SAFER
6:15:40PM FOR THE COMMUNITY.
6:15:41PM THANK YOU.
6:15:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:15:43PM YES, MA'AM, COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
6:15:47PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THANK YOU.
6:15:48PM MY COMMENT IS THIS.
6:15:52PM THE AREA IS RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY.
6:15:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SHE CAN SPEAK WHILE WE'RE OPEN.
6:16:01PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: AS LONG AS THERE'S NO OTHER QUESTIONS, YOU
6:16:04PM CAN CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING.
6:16:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I DON'T WANT TO CLOSE THE PUBLIC
6:16:08PM HEARING.
6:16:09PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: OKAY.
6:16:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE CONTINUE, MA'AM.
6:16:14PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I JUST WANT TO BE CLEAR THAT MAYBE YOU WANT
6:16:17PM TO HAVE -- IF YOU'RE GOING TO TAKE ADDITIONAL TESTIMONY, YOU
6:16:20PM MAY WANT TO GET MORE INFORMATION BEFORE YOU MAKE YOUR
6:16:22PM COMMENTS OR YOU CAN MAKE YOUR COMMENTS NOW IF THERE ARE NO
6:16:26PM QUESTIONS.
6:16:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD.
6:16:29PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YEAH, I JUST THINK, I APPRECIATE THE
6:16:32PM TESTIMONY OF THE RESIDENTS.
6:16:36PM CURRENTLY, EVEN THOUGH IT IS MOVING TOWARD RESIDENTIAL,
6:16:41PM CLEARLY, THIS PORTION OF THIS COMMUNITY IS RESIDENTIAL AND
6:16:44PM NOT LIGHT INDUSTRIAL OR NOT INDUSTRIAL, AND THEY ARE
6:16:47PM FIGHTING FOR TO KEEP IT THAT WAY, RESIDENTIAL.
6:16:52PM AND I JUST SEE THAT AS A REASONABLE REQUEST ON BEHALF OF THE
6:16:58PM PEOPLE FIGHTING FOR THIS PARTICULAR SPACE BECAUSE THE
6:17:04PM PICTURES SHOWN BY OUR PLANNING COMMISSION CLEARLY SHOWS
6:17:08PM RESIDENTIAL AROUND IT.
6:17:10PM RESIDENTIAL ON THREE SIDES.
6:17:16PM IF IT IS A VOTE OF WHAT IS RESIDENTIAL AND WHAT'S
6:17:21PM INDUSTRIAL, CLEARLY IT IS MORE RESIDENTIAL IN THIS
6:17:23PM PARTICULAR AREA THAN IT IS INDUSTRIAL.
6:17:24PM I JUST WANTED TO MAKE THAT COMMENT, WHICH WOULD LEAD ME TO A
6:17:31PM DENIAL.
6:17:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:17:33PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I HAVE A QUESTION FOR STAFF, AND IF THEY
6:17:38PM CAN PUT UP THE AERIAL PICTURE, AND WE CAN LOOK THROUGH THAT
6:17:42PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:17:46PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:17:47PM THIS IS THE AERIAL OF THE PROPERTY.
6:17:52PM LET ME ZOOM IN A LITTLE CLOSER.
6:17:57PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I THINK WE'LL HAVE TO ZOOM IN AND OUT AS
6:18:00PM WE CONTINUE THE CONVERSATION.
6:18:00PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THIS IS THE PROPERTY IN RED OUTLINED.
6:18:03PM THE DOTTED RED.
6:18:06PM SO ALL OF THIS NORTH IS RS 50.
6:18:10PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: BUT ITS ACTUAL USE?
6:18:13PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: SOME OF THE STRUCTURES, YOU HAVE HOMES THAT
6:18:18PM ARE HERE.
6:18:19PM SOME STREETS HAVE MORE COMMERCIAL OR INDUSTRIAL USES -- HAVE
6:18:22PM RESIDENTIAL USES ON THE STREET.
6:18:24PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN YOU HIGHLIGHT, SO IF WE'RE ON 60th
6:18:28PM STREET, I MEAN, OBVIOUSLY, THE DWELLING, BECAUSE WE HAD
6:18:31PM TESTIMONY FROM THE PEOPLE NEXT DOOR IT'S RESIDENTIAL.
6:18:35PM HOUSE ACROSS THE STREET ON 60th IS OBVIOUSLY RESIDENTIAL.
6:18:38PM I'M ASSUMING THE THREE STRUCTURES OR FOUR STRUCTURES ARE
6:18:41PM RESIDENTIAL.
6:18:42PM THE ONE RIGHT NORTH TO IT DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE RESIDENTIAL.
6:18:46PM LOOKS LIKE WHITE BLOCKY LOOKING THING.
6:18:50PM I DON'T KNOW WHAT IT IS.
6:18:51PM FURTHER NORTH.
6:18:56PM [ENCODER DROP]
6:19:15PM -- ZOOM IT OUT.
6:19:18PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: ON THE SOUTH IS MORE OF THE COMMERCIAL USE
6:19:21PM OR YOU HAVE THE LARGER PARCELS THAT ARE HERE.
6:19:27PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHAT ABOUT THESE PARKING LOTS ON THE EAST
6:19:29PM SIDE?
6:19:31PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THIS IS VACANT INDUSTRIAL.
6:19:32PM ALL THIS, WHERE THIS YELLOW LINE IS ZONED -- GENERAL.
6:19:36PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ON THE NORTH SIDE OF THE YELLOW LINE, THE
6:19:39PM PROPERTIES THAT WE'RE SEEING FURTHER TO THE EAST, WHAT'S ALL
6:19:42PM THAT OVER THERE?
6:19:44PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: OVER HERE IS MORE OF YOUR OPEN STORAGE AREA.
6:19:49PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ITS ACTUAL USE IS SIMILAR TO WHAT THE
6:19:52PM APPLICANT IS LOOKING FOR.
6:19:54PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: AND RS 50.
6:19:55PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: RS 50 BUT NOT BEING USED AS RS 50.
6:19:59PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CORRECT.
6:20:00PM AND MOSTLY WHERE YOU SEE THE ZONING LINE FOR THE IG IS
6:20:07PM MOSTLY WHERE YOU SEE THE CHANGE WITH THE COMMERCIAL AND
6:20:10PM INDUSTRIAL AND OPEN STORAGE USES.
6:20:13PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HOW MANY RESIDENTIAL UNITS ARE WE TALKING
6:20:15PM ABOUT?
6:20:15PM GIVE ME A PERSPECTIVE OF LIKE WITHIN THIS AREA, HOW MANY
6:20:20PM RESIDENTIAL UNITS ARE WE TALKING ABOUT?
6:20:24PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: AT LEAST MAYBE 10.
6:20:31PM ABOUT 8.
6:20:35PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: 8 RESIDENTIAL UNITS IN AN AREA -- BECAUSE
6:20:40PM IT LOOKS TO BE QUITE LARGE.
6:20:41PM IT'S DEFINITELY THE MINORITY OF THE AREA.
6:20:45PM THE GEOGRAPHICAL AREA.
6:20:48PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: IF YOU GO, INDUSTRIAL, AS YOU HEAD NORTH,
6:20:52PM YOU GET BACK TO YOUR INDUSTRIAL AND YOUR COMMERCIAL.
6:20:56PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: EAST APPEARS TO BE SOMETHING LIKE THAT
6:20:59PM TOO.
6:21:00PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: AND THEN THE EAST, YOU'VE GOT MORE OF THE
6:21:02PM OPEN STORAGE HERE.
6:21:03PM YOU'VE GOT OPEN STORAGE THAT'S LOCATED HERE.
6:21:07PM AS YOU HEAD FURTHER WEST, YOU GO TWO BLOCKS WEST, THIS IS
6:21:11PM ALL OPEN STORAGE, THIS IS OPEN STORAGE AND COMMERCIAL.
6:21:15PM SO IT'S A MIX BETWEEN THE COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL AND THEN
6:21:18PM YOU HAVE THE RESIDENTIAL IN THE MIDDLE.
6:21:20PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OKAY.
6:21:21PM THANK YOU.
6:21:21PM I APPRECIATE IT.
6:21:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK, DID YOU HAVE YOUR
6:21:23PM HAND UP?
6:21:24PM NO.
6:21:25PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: IS OPEN STORAGE ALLOWED IN RS 50?
6:21:28PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: NO, IT IS NOT.
6:21:30PM NO.
6:21:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DOES ANYBODY ELSE HAVE QUESTIONS OR
6:21:33PM COMMENTS?
6:21:33PM DO WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE?
6:21:37PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SO MOVED.
6:21:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILWOMAN
6:21:39PM HENDERSON.
6:21:40PM SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
6:21:41PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:21:41PM AYE.
6:21:42PM WHAT IS THE PLEASURE OF COUNCIL?
6:21:45PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
6:21:47PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES, I'M GOING TO MOVE TO DENY REZ 36 FOR
6:21:55PM THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2003 NORTH 60th STREET DUE TO THE
6:22:00PM FAILURE OF THE APPLICANT MEET THE BURDEN OF PROOF TO PROVIDE
6:22:03PM COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE IN THE RECORD THAT THE
6:22:05PM REZONING IS CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND THE
6:22:10PM CITY CODE.
6:22:14PM FIRST OF ALL, COMPLIANCE WITH THE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND
6:22:16PM POLICIES OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IS WHAT I'M GOING TO USE
6:22:20PM FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF NOTES.
6:22:22PM I ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DISCOURAGES
6:22:26PM RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT NEAR INDUSTRIAL ZONED AREAS, BUT
6:22:30PM THIS IS DIFFERENT.
6:22:31PM THE REQUEST BEFORE US IS TO ALLOW AN INDUSTRIAL USE ADJACENT
6:22:36PM TO SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES, NOT ONE, TWO, THREE, THERE ARE MORE
6:22:42PM THAN ONE.
6:22:43PM THERE ARE SEVERAL HOMES IN THIS AREA.
6:22:46PM AS STAFF NOTED, THE SITE IS SURROUNDED BY THE SINGLE-FAMILY
6:22:49PM HOMES ON THE NORTH, ON THE EAST, AND ON THE WEST.
6:22:52PM FOR THIS REASON, I FIND THE REZONING IS NOT CONSISTENT WITH
6:22:55PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AS IT WOULD ALLOW AN INDUSTRIAL USE
6:23:00PM IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO EXISTING SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES.
6:23:04PM AND ALTHOUGH THE AREA SURROUNDING THE SITE HAS BEEN -- HAS
6:23:10PM SEEN RECENT REZONING ACTIVITY WITH A TRANSITION FROM
6:23:12PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ZONING TO INDUSTRIAL GENERAL
6:23:16PM ZONING, THIS SITE IS DIFFERENT.
6:23:20PM AS I ALREADY STATED, THIS SITE IS SURROUNDED BY
6:23:23PM SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES TO THE NORTH, EAST, AND WEST.
6:23:25PM THE REQUESTED IG ZONING IS NOT CONSISTENT WITH THE
6:23:30PM DEVELOPMENT PATTERN IN THE AREA.
6:23:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
6:23:33PM SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
6:23:37PM DO WE HAVE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS?
6:23:38PM IF NOT, WE'LL GO TO A VOTE.
6:23:41PM GO AHEAD, COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN AND COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
6:23:44PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YEAH, THIS IS A REALLY TOUGH ONE.
6:23:46PM A LOT OF THESE THINGS COME UP BEFORE ME SEEM QUITE OBVIOUS
6:23:51PM BECAUSE OF ESTABLISHED NEIGHBORHOODS AND STRESS ON
6:23:54PM ESTABLISHED NEIGHBORHOODS, BUT THIS ONE IS DIFFERENT.
6:23:56PM THIS NEIGHBORHOOD IS SHIFTING AND I THINK EVERYBODY UP HERE
6:24:01PM AND EVERYBODY KNOWS WHICH DIRECTION THIS NEIGHBORHOOD IS
6:24:03PM SHIFTING TOWARDS, AND I THINK THAT IS REFLECTED BY THE
6:24:07PM REPORTS THAT WE RECEIVED FROM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF AND
6:24:10PM CITY COUNCIL STAFF, WHICH FOUND THIS IN COMPLIANCE AND IN
6:24:17PM LINE WITH OUR LONG-TERM OBJECTIVES AS THE COMMUNITY
6:24:22PM DEVELOPMENT AND CREATING WORK SPACES.
6:24:24PM AND ENCOURAGING THIS TYPE OF ACTIVITY IN CERTAIN AREAS OF
6:24:29PM OUR CITY.
6:24:29PM BUT I AM HUMAN, AND I HEAR THE STORIES, AND IT BREAKS MY
6:24:36PM HEART.
6:24:36PM AND I'M VERY EMPATHETIC WITH THOSE CAUSES, BUT THE PROBLEM
6:24:41PM IS, IT DOESN'T FIT THE EXISTING, BECAUSE THE EXISTING
6:24:47PM CONDITION, BY TESTIMONY FROM PEOPLE WHO CAME IN OPPOSITION
6:24:50PM TO THIS, THE TRUCK TRAFFIC ALREADY EXISTED.
6:24:53PM SO IT'S A CURRENT EXISTING CONDITION.
6:24:56PM THE TRUCKS ARE ALREADY THERE.
6:24:58PM IT'S INEXCUSABLE THAT OUR ROADS ARE IN THIS SHAPE.
6:25:01PM I'D LOVE TO TELL YOU THAT 60th IS THE ONLY ONE, BUT IT IS
6:25:04PM ALL AROUND OUR CITY.
6:25:05PM OUR ROADS ARE IN HORRIBLE SHAPE.
6:25:07PM THE TRUCK NOISE.
6:25:12PM THE INDUSTRIAL ELEMENT IS ALREADY -- ALREADY EXISTS IN THIS
6:25:15PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:25:16PM IT IS NOT NEW.
6:25:17PM I WOULD HAVE LOVED TO HAVE SEEN A DEVELOPER COME IN AND
6:25:21PM OCCUPY ALL OF THESE HOUSES AND REZONE IT AS A BLOCK, BUT
6:25:25PM THAT'S NOT WHAT IS BEFORE US TODAY.
6:25:26PM AS HEARTFELT AS I FEEL FOR THE PEOPLE WHO ARE IN OPPOSITION
6:25:31PM TO THIS, I DON'T SEE THE COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
6:25:35PM TO DENY THE EUCLIDEAN REZONING REQUEST.
6:25:40PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: HAS THE HEARING BEEN CLOSED?
6:25:42PM BECAUSE I STEPPED OUTSIDE.
6:25:46PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WE ALREADY HAVE A MOTION TO DENY.
6:25:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA AND THEN HURTAK.
6:25:54PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN.
6:25:55PM IN REVIEWING THIS, I CERTAINLY HAVE A FEELING FOR THE
6:25:59PM NEIGHBOR AND ESPECIALLY FOR THE PROBLEMS THAT THEY HAVE WITH
6:26:01PM HEALTH PROBLEMS, BUT THAT'S NOT WHAT IS BEFORE ME, EVEN
6:26:04PM THOUGH IT'S COMPLICATED, PEOPLE SAY IT IS A DIFFICULT
6:26:08PM DECISION.
6:26:08PM WHEN YOU LOOK AT THIS, IT GIVES ME A FEELING OF SOMEWHAT OF
6:26:14PM DREW PARK WHERE YOU HAVE BOTH RESIDENTIAL AND HEAVY TRUCKS
6:26:18PM AT THE SAME TIME, NOT TO THAT EXTENT BUT REMINDER OF WHAT'S
6:26:23PM HAPPENING IN DREW PARK.
6:26:24PM THE APPLICANT I BELIEVE SAID THAT THEY WERE NOT GOING TO USE
6:26:28PM THAT ENTRANCE WAY, IF I RECALL WHAT HE SAID.
6:26:31PM AM I CORRECT OR NOT?
6:26:32PM I DON'T KNOW WHAT HE SAID.
6:26:36PM >>LYNN HURTAK: DO YOU WANT TO REOPEN?
6:26:38PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: IF THAT EVIDENCE IS RELEVANT TO YOUR
6:26:42PM DECISION --
6:26:42PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: WE DON'T HAVE TO REOPEN.
6:26:44PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION VOTED FOR IT, IF I RECALL,
6:26:52PM CONSISTENT, IF I RECALL.
6:26:53PM CITY VOTED AFTER REVIEWED ALL THE STATISTICS OF IT
6:26:59PM CONSISTENT, AM I CORRECT OR NOT?
6:27:00PM I'M LOOKING FOR A WAY TO SAY WHICH WAY, AND IT'S A VERY
6:27:06PM TOUGH DECISION FOR THE FIRST ONE, BUT THEY HAVE MET THE
6:27:10PM BURDEN OF PROOF, IN MY OPINION ANYWAY, REGARDING THE
6:27:15PM REZONING REQUEST.
6:27:16PM THAT'S ALL I'M GOING TO SAY NOW.
6:27:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:27:19PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
6:27:20PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
6:27:21PM I HEAR WHAT THE TWO COUNCIL MEMBERS IN FRONT OF ME HAVE SAID
6:27:25PM BUT I COMPLETELY DISAGREE BECAUSE IT'S NOT TRUE.
6:27:27PM IT'S BASICALLY LIKE IF SOMEBODY WAS NEXT TO YOUR HOUSE -- I
6:27:31PM MEAN, I LIVED ONE BLOCK FROM A HIGH COMMERCIAL CORRIDOR.
6:27:36PM ARE YOU SAYING THAT SOMEBODY COULD TAKE MY NEIGHBOR'S HOUSE
6:27:39PM DOWN AND BUILD -- OR ALLOW THIS KIND OF ZONING?
6:27:43PM I DISAGREE.
6:27:44PM THE RESIDENTS WERE HERE FIRST, AND IT IS ACTUAL COMPETENT
6:27:49PM AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE THAT THESE ARE RESIDENTIAL
6:27:52PM PROPERTIES SURROUNDING IT.
6:27:53PM NOT ONLY ARE THEY RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES, THEY ARE OWNER
6:27:56PM OCCUPIED RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES.
6:27:58PM AND THAT COMMUNITY CAME OUT IN FORCE TO SAY WE WANT TO KEEP
6:28:04PM OUR COMMUNITY, A COMMUNITY OF HOUSING.
6:28:10PM THEY HAVE DEVELOPMENT AROUND IT, BUT IT DOESN'T MEAN THAT
6:28:14PM THIS POCKET HAS TO BE INDUSTRIAL.
6:28:16PM THERE ARE OTHER PLACES TO PARK A TRUCK.
6:28:20PM SO TO ME, THE COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE WAS NOT.
6:28:24PM THEY JUST SAID WE WANT THIS.
6:28:27PM THERE WAS NO ACTUAL EVIDENCE.
6:28:29PM SO TO ME, THE EVIDENCE CAME FROM THE PEOPLE WHO SAID WE
6:28:33PM DON'T WANT THIS BECAUSE IT WILL IMPACT OUR QUALITY OF LIFE.
6:28:36PM TRAFFIC IS ONE THING, BUT IT'S NOT THE TRAFFIC THAT IS THE
6:28:40PM COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE HERE.
6:28:41PM IT IS THE USE OF THE PROPERTY WHICH IS TO HAVE DUMP TRUCKS
6:28:45PM ON IT.
6:28:46PM DUMP TRUCKS ARE VERY HEAVY AND LOUD.
6:28:51PM SO THAT TO ME IS THE BIGGER ISSUE.
6:28:54PM IT'S NOT THE TRAFFIC.
6:28:56PM ANY TRUCK CAN GO DOWN ANY ROAD.
6:28:59PM IT IS THE ABSENCE OF COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE FOR
6:29:03PM CHANGING THE ZONING OF THIS PARCEL.
6:29:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:29:07PM ANYBODY ELSE?
6:29:07PM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA?
6:29:10PM >>LUIS VIERA: THANK YOU.
6:29:13PM WITH REGARD TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION, WHAT WAS THE VOTE?
6:29:18PM DO YOU KNOW?
6:29:21PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: WHY DON'T YOU OPEN IT --
6:29:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO REOPEN.
6:29:24PM >>LUIS VIERA: I'LL REOPEN.
6:29:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:29:26PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
6:29:29PM ALL IN FAVOR, AYE.
6:29:30PM WE ARE REOPEN.
6:29:31PM MR. HEY.
6:29:31PM >>DAVID HEY: DAVID HEY, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
6:29:34PM AS YOU WELL KNOW, FOR ZONINGS, IT IS THE PLANNING COMMISSION
6:29:39PM STAFF THAT INTERPRETS.
6:29:41PM >>LUIS VIERA: OKAY.
6:29:42PM THANK YOU.
6:29:43PM >>DAVID HEY: THE STAFF FOUND IT CONSISTENT.
6:29:45PM >>LUIS VIERA: AFTER SEVEN YEARS, I SHOULD KNOW THAT.
6:29:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS BEFORE WE CLOSE?
6:29:52PM >> HAVING OPENED THIS, I THINK I HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
6:29:54PM RESPOND.
6:29:55PM IT'S OPEN.
6:30:00PM >>THE CLERK: WHEN WE FIRST STARTED, 13 MINUTES, 19 SECONDS.
6:30:04PM THEN WENT TO REBUTTAL.
6:30:06PM WITH REBUTTAL, TWO MINUTES AND 12 SECONDS.
6:30:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHAT IS THE PLEASURE OF THE BOARD.
6:30:12PM HE STILL HAS TIME FOR REBUTTAL.
6:30:26PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: HOW MUCH TIME?
6:30:27PM >>LUIS VIERA: BETTER TO ERR WITH CAUTION IF THERE'S
6:30:31PM SOMETHING ADVERSE.
6:30:32PM THAT'S MY OPINION.
6:30:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
6:30:34PM VIERA.
6:30:34PM DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
6:30:35PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:30:37PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:30:37PM AYE.
6:30:38PM ANY OPPOSED?
6:30:41PM >> NAY.
6:30:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE AYES HAVE IT TO FINISH YOUR
6:30:44PM REBUTTAL.
6:30:45PM TWO MINUTES AND CHANGE THERE.
6:30:46PM >> FIRST OF ALL, THE IDEA THAT THERE IS NO COMPETENT
6:30:51PM SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE DISCOUNTS THE TESTIMONY OF THE PLANNING
6:30:53PM COMMISSION AND CITY STAFF.
6:30:57PM THAT IS COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE AND BOTH,
6:31:02PM UNANIMOUSLY ON THE PART OF CITY STAFF, COMPLETE ON THE PART
6:31:05PM OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION FAVORS APPROVAL OF THIS EUCLIDEAN
6:31:10PM REZONING.
6:31:11PM I GO BACK TO EUCLIDEAN REZONING.
6:31:16PM AT THIS POINT, ALL OF THE DETAILS OF WHAT WILL HAPPEN HERE
6:31:19PM ARE HASHED OUT IN PERMITTING.
6:31:21PM IF WE DON'T GET PAST EUCLIDEAN REZONING, MY CLIENT IS OUT OF
6:31:27PM BUSINESS.
6:31:28PM THEY CANNOT OPERATE.
6:31:28PM ALL THESE OTHER FACTORS CAN HAPPEN.
6:31:33PM THE COMMUNITY HAS NOT TURNED OUT.
6:31:36PM TWO RESIDENTS, ONE TO THE NORTH AND ONE ACROSS THE STREET.
6:31:39PM THEY ARE THE SAME HOUSEHOLD.
6:31:41PM THEY HAVE THE SAME LAST NAME.
6:31:43PM THEY ARE ALL FAMILY MEMBERS.
6:31:44PM THE REST OF THE COMMUNITY HASN'T SHOWN UP.
6:31:49PM THERE ARE NO OBJECTIONS THAT WE RECEIVED IN THE MAIL.
6:31:52PM THERE'S NOBODY WHO SIGNED UP ON THIS.
6:31:54PM SO YOU HAVE TWO RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY OWNERS AND, YES, THEY
6:31:59PM ARE IN A DIFFICULT SITUATION.
6:32:02PM THE CITY HAS TO LOOK AT THE BROADER PICTURE ON BALANCE.
6:32:05PM ARE WE GOING TO DRIVE OUT SMALL BUSINESS?
6:32:08PM BECAUSE NOT IN MY NEIGHBORHOOD IS A WONDERFUL THING, BUT
6:32:12PM YOU'RE DRIVING OUT BUSINESSES BECAUSE THE CITY OF TAMPA HAS
6:32:15PM BORDERS, AND THOSE BORDERS DON'T FIT THIS KIND OF USE,
6:32:19PM EXCEPT IN VERY LIMITED PLACES.
6:32:22PM AGAIN, I REMIND YOU, SOUTH TAMPA, SOUTH OF GANDY, NO.
6:32:27PM NEW TAMPA, NO.
6:32:28PM WEST TAMPA, NO.
6:32:30PM SO THESE ARE THE ONLY VIABLE PLACES.
6:32:36PM THANK YOU.
6:32:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:32:37PM MS. WELLS.
6:32:41PM >>CATE WELLS: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
6:32:44PM CATE WELLS, LEGAL DEPARTMENT.
6:32:45PM THE REASON I STOOD UP TO SPEAK IS THIS IS A QUASI-JUDICIAL
6:32:48PM DECISION, AS YOU KNOW.
6:32:49PM COUNCIL IS TO MAKE A DECISION BASED ON WHETHER OR NOT THE
6:32:53PM APPLICATION COMPLIES OR IS CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE
6:32:56PM PLAN OR THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
6:32:57PM THIS IS NOT A LEGISLATIVE DECISION AS TO WHERE THIS USE
6:33:00PM SHOULD GO OR WHERE ELSE IT COULD GO OR WHAT THE VISION IS
6:33:03PM FOR THE CITY, AND THERE WAS SOME DISCUSSION OF THAT TONIGHT
6:33:06PM AND I JUST WANTED TO CLARIFY FOR THE RECORD THAT THIS IS
6:33:10PM QUASI-JUDICIAL.
6:33:11PM IT'S AN APPLICATION OF STANDARDS AND WHETHER OR NOT THERE'S
6:33:13PM COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THE REQUEST.
6:33:16PM THANK YOU.
6:33:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:33:18PM ANY OTHER QUESTIONS BEFORE WE CLOSE THE HEARING?
6:33:20PM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA HAS A MOTION TO CLOSE.
6:33:25PM IS THERE A SECOND?
6:33:25PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:33:27PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:33:27PM AYE.
6:33:28PM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON HAS A MOTION ON THE FLOOR.
6:33:32PM IT WAS SECONDED BY COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
6:33:33PM YES, MA'AM.
6:33:35PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I JUST WANTED TO, HIS CLOSING REMARKS REALLY
6:33:39PM MADE ME THINK, TOO.
6:33:40PM I HAD FORGOTTEN THIS POINT, WHICH IS WHY I SHOULD HAVE
6:33:43PM WRITTEN IT DOWN.
6:33:44PM I THINK THE FACT -- I MEAN, STAFF FAVORING SOMETHING DOES
6:33:48PM NOT MEAN WE HAVE TO FOLLOW IT, OTHERWISE WE WOULDN'T BE
6:33:51PM HERE.
6:33:52PM WHY WOULD WE EXIST?
6:33:53PM BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY, I THINK THE ISSUE IS I DON'T KNOW WHY
6:33:56PM THE PERSON BOUGHT THE PROPERTY NOT KNOWING WHAT THE ZONING
6:33:59PM WAS.
6:34:00PM LIKE, IF YOU BUY A PROPERTY THAT IS RESIDENTIALLY ZONED AND
6:34:04PM THEN YOU THREATEN THAT WE'RE GOING TO SHUT A BUSINESS DOWN,
6:34:08PM THAT WASN'T OUR DETERMINATION.
6:34:10PM THAT WASN'T OUR DECISION FOR THEM TO BUY A RESIDENTIAL
6:34:13PM PROPERTY AND NOW WANT TO MAKE IT A BUSINESS PROPERTY.
6:34:17PM I THINK THAT'S THE ISSUE FOR ME.
6:34:19PM IT'S NOT THAT THEY THOUGHT ABOUT IT AND WERE LIKE, WELL,
6:34:23PM MAYBE WE COULD BUY IT.
6:34:25PM LET'S SEE IF WE CAN GET REZONED FIRST.
6:34:27PM THEY BOUGHT A RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY AND THEN SAID, OH, OUR
6:34:30PM BUSINESS IS GOING TO FAIL IF WE DON'T MAKE THIS INDUSTRIAL
6:34:33PM GENERAL.
6:34:37PM THAT IS THE FAULT OF THE BUYER, NOT THE NEIGHBORS.
6:34:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
6:34:41PM WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
6:34:43PM SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
6:34:44PM LET'S TAKE A ROLL CALL VOTE.
6:34:47PM >>THE CLERK: CLENDENIN?
6:34:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE MOTION IS TO DENY.
6:34:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: NO.
6:34:57PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
6:35:02PM >>LUIS VIERA: IT'S A MOTION TO DENY, I'LL SAY -- AND LET ME
6:35:05PM SPEAK --
6:35:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE TURN YOUR MICROPHONE ON.
6:35:10PM >>LUIS VIERA: MOTION TO DENY, YES.
6:35:15PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: NO.
6:35:17PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
6:35:19PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
6:35:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
6:35:24PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION TO DENY CARRIED WITH CLENDENIN, MIRANDA
6:35:30PM VOTING NO.
6:35:33PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:35:33PM ALL RIGHT.
6:35:34PM WE'LL GO TO ITEM NUMBER 2.
6:35:40PM MR. BENSON.
6:35:55PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
6:36:02PM STEPHEN BENSON CITY PLANNING.
6:36:06PM THIS IS ITEM NUMBER 2, FILE E 2023-8, CHAPTER 27.
6:36:11PM THIS IS A PRIVATELY INITIATED TEXT AMENDMENT TO THE CITY OF
6:36:14PM TAMPA LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
6:36:17PM THE TAMPA HEIGHTS OVERLAY DISTRICT, AND THIS IS THE FIRST
6:36:20PM READING.
6:36:20PM THE APPLICANT FOR THIS AMENDMENT IS BRIAN ZEAL.
6:36:27PM THIS AMENDMENT WAS SUBMITTED IN JANUARY OF 2022, AND THE
6:36:29PM PURPOSE OF THIS AMENDMENT PACKAGE IS TO CREATE AN OVERLAY
6:36:33PM DISTRICT FOR THE TAMPA HEIGHTS NEIGHBORHOOD TO ENHANCE THE
6:36:36PM USE, DESIGN, AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS OF THE UNDERLYING
6:36:39PM ZONING AND TO GUIDE FUTURE DEVELOPMENT.
6:36:41PM THE INTENT OF THESE STANDARDS IS TO FACILITATE REDEVELOPMENT
6:36:45PM THAT IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE VISION FOR THE NEIGHBORHOOD, TO
6:36:50PM PROMOTE THE UNIQUE CHARACTER OF THE AREA, TO SUPPORT
6:36:53PM WALKABILITY, ENCOURAGE TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT, AND
6:36:56PM PROMOTE HOUSING OPTIONS.
6:36:57PM THIS IS THE MAP OF THE OVERLAY DISTRICT.
6:37:02PM I'M GOING TO ZOOM IN A LITTLE BIT SO YOU CAN SEE IT.
6:37:04PM THE BOUNDARY IS ALONG THE EAST SIDE AND THE SOUTH SIDE ARE
6:37:09PM GOING TO HUG I-275 --
6:37:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: JUST A MOMENT, MR. BENSON.
6:37:13PM WE DON'T HAVE THE CLOSED CAPTIONING UP.
6:37:15PM CTTV --
6:37:27PM ALL RIGHT.
6:37:27PM CAPTIONING IS UP.
6:37:28PM GO AHEAD, SIR.
6:37:29PM I APOLOGIZE.
6:37:31PM >>STEPHEN BENSON: THE BOUNDARIES OF THE OVERLAY DISTRICT
6:37:33PM FROM THE INTERSECTION OF MARTIN LUTHER KING BOULEVARD AND
6:37:36PM I-275 RUN ALONG THE WESTERN RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF I-275 DOWN
6:37:41PM AND TO THE WEST TO TAMPA STREET ON THE SOUTH.
6:37:44PM THEN IT RUNS NORTH ALONG TAMPA STREET TO PALM AVENUE, WEST
6:37:48PM ALONG PALM AVENUE TO OLA AVENUE, NORTH ALONG OLA AVENUE,
6:37:53PM WEST TO ALONG ROSS AVENUE, NORTH ALONG NORTH BOULEVARD, AND
6:37:58PM THEN TO MARTIN LUTHER KING BOULEVARD AND EAST BACK TO I-275.
6:38:02PM AND THEN ON THE MAP, JUST FOR ILLUSTRATIVE PURPOSES, IS THE
6:38:06PM EXISTING TAMPA HEIGHTS HISTORIC DISTRICT, WHICH DOES FALL
6:38:10PM WITHIN A PORTION OF WHICH FALLS WITHIN THE BOUNDARIES OF
6:38:12PM THIS OVERLAY.
6:38:13PM THERE ARE TWO SECTIONS OF THE CODE BEING AMENDED WITH THE
6:38:19PM PACKAGE.
6:38:19PM THE FIRST IS THE GENERAL CODE, SECTION 27-156.
6:38:23PM THIS IS TO ALLOW ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS WITHIN THE
6:38:27PM BOUNDARIES OF THE OVERLAY AS A SPECIAL USE ONE WITH
6:38:30PM CONDITIONS.
6:38:30PM THOSE CONDITIONS ARE THE SAME AS THE GENERAL CODE, EXCEPT
6:38:33PM FOR THESE TWO DIFFERENCES.
6:38:36PM ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS WITHIN THE TAMPA HEIGHTS OVERLAY
6:38:39PM WILL ONLY BE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE PARKING ON-SITE.
6:38:42PM IF THE ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT IS GREATER THAN 600 SQUARE
6:38:45PM FEET IN SIZE.
6:38:46PM THE GENERAL CODE REQUIRES PARKING FOR ALL ADUs REGARDLESS
6:38:50PM OF SIZE.
6:38:50PM AND THEN THE SECOND CRITERIA IS THAT THE MINIMUM OCCUPANCY
6:38:54PM FOR AN ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT IN THE TAMPA HEIGHTS OVERLAY
6:38:57PM SHALL BE NO MORE THAN TWO UNRELATED OCCUPANTS.
6:39:01PM THE GENERAL CODE LIMITS OCCUPANCY TO NO MORE THAN TWO
6:39:04PM OCCUPANTS EITHER RELATED OR UNRELATED.
6:39:07PM THE SECOND SECTION TO BE AMENDED IS A NEW SECTION.
6:39:12PM THIS IS -- THIS WILL BE SECTION 27-244.
6:39:16PM THIS IS THE CREATION OF THE 8th OVERLAY DISTRICT IN THE
6:39:19PM CITY OF TAMPA CODE.
6:39:20PM THE AMENDMENT ESTABLISHES THE DISTRICT'S BOUNDARIES,
6:39:23PM PURPOSE, AND INTENT, AND IS COMPRISED OF THREE COMPONENTS:
6:39:26PM RESIDENTIAL, COMMERCIAL, AND MIXED USE.
6:39:28PM AND THEN SPECIFIC TO THE NORTH FRANKLIN STREET DISTRICT,
6:39:33PM ALSO KNOWN AS YELLOW BRICK ROW.
6:39:35PM FOR RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT, LOTS OF RECORD SHALL BE MADE
6:39:39PM CONFORMING AS OF THE DATE OF THE OVERLAY DISTRICT ADOPTION.
6:39:42PM THE OVERLAY DISTRICT PROVIDES INCENTIVES TO ORIENT NEW
6:39:46PM GARAGES ON ATTACHED UNITS AWAY FROM THE STREET.
6:39:48PM IT DISCOURAGES DRIVER PROLIFERATION -- DRIVEWAY
6:39:53PM PROLIFERATION AND ENCOURAGES USE OF ALLEYS.
6:39:56PM ALLOWS MANEUVERING IN THE RIGHT-OF-WAY IN ALLEYS WITHOUT
6:40:00PM DESIGN EXCEPTION.
6:40:01PM ON STREET PARKING COUNTED TOWARDS THE ON-SITE REQUIREMENT.
6:40:04PM THAT IS THE ON STREET PARKING DIRECTLY IN FRONT OF THE
6:40:07PM DEVELOPMENT.
6:40:07PM THE OVERLAY ALLOWS FOR TWO STORY GARAGE APARTMENTS TO BE
6:40:12PM PLACED ON SITES WITH AN EXISTING HOME WITHOUT A DESIGN
6:40:15PM EXCEPTION OR WAIVER.
6:40:16PM AND PORCHES MAY ENCROACH UP TO TEN FEET IN THE FRONT
6:40:20PM SETBACK.
6:40:20PM THE GENERAL CODE ONLY ALLOWS FOR EIGHT FEET OF AN
6:40:24PM ENCROACHMENT.
6:40:25PM THIS IS AN ADDITIONAL TWO FEET.
6:40:27PM FOR COMMERCIAL AND MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT, AGAIN, LOTS OF
6:40:30PM RECORD SHOW CONFORMING.
6:40:33PM OVERLAY ENCOURAGES NEW PARKING TO BE PLACED IN THE REAR OR
6:40:35PM THE SIDE OF NEW DEVELOPMENT, NOT IN FRONT.
6:40:38PM THERE ARE SOME SIGNIFICANT PARKING REDUCTIONS PROVIDED FOR
6:40:42PM MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT.
6:40:43PM PARKING FOR VERY SMALL COMMERCIAL BUILDINGS IS WAIVED TO
6:40:48PM ZERO.
6:40:48PM THAT'S VERY SMALL AS IN 1500 SQUARE FEET OR LESS.
6:40:52PM AND THEN BICYCLE PARKING OFFSETS SIMILAR TO WHAT EXISTS IN
6:40:56PM SEMINOLE HEIGHTS.
6:40:58PM ARE INCORPORATED IN THE OVERLAY UP TO 10% OF WHAT IS
6:41:01PM REQUIRED.
6:41:02PM AND THEN FOR THE NORTH FRANKLIN STREET DISTRICT, THIS WAIVES
6:41:10PM ON-SITE PARKING REQUIREMENTS FOR SMALLER PROJECTS THAT FRONT
6:41:12PM NORTH FRANKLIN STREET.
6:41:14PM AND BY SMALLER WE MEAN ROUGHLY ONE-THIRD OF THE BLOCK.
6:41:17PM THERE IS A SPECIFIC NUMBER BUT ROUGHLY ONE-THIRD OF A
6:41:20PM TYPICAL BLOCK IN THAT AREA, AND, AGAIN, THEY HAVE TO FRONT
6:41:23PM NORTH FRANKLIN.
6:41:24PM THE GENERAL CODE, HOWEVER, WILL STILL CONTROL HEIGHT, MASS,
6:41:28PM AND SCALE, AND THAT'S A 10-FOOT FRONT SETBACK, 45 FEET
6:41:32PM HEIGHT AND THEN ZERO SIDE SETBACK.
6:41:34PM THE TIMELINE THAT THIS AMENDMENT HAS GONE THROUGH, IT WAS
6:41:39PM INITIATED IN JULY OF 2021.
6:41:43PM REVIEW AND REVISIONS WERE MADE IN THE SPRING OF 2022, IN THE
6:41:47PM SUMMER OF 2022, THIS WAS WORKSHOPPED WITH CITY COUNCIL AND
6:41:50PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION WAS BRIEFED.
6:41:52PM VIRTUAL PUBLIC INFORMATION MEETING WAS HELD IN OCTOBER OF
6:41:55PM 2022, AND THE PLANNING COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING OCCURRED ON
6:41:59PM AUGUST 14, 2023.
6:42:01PM THIS IS STAFF ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATION.
6:42:07PM OVERLAY INCLUDES NEW GUIDELINES TO PROMOTE THE DESIRED
6:42:09PM DEVELOPMENT PATTERN WITHIN THE AREA AND PROVIDES RELIEF FROM
6:42:12PM GENERAL CODE REQUIREMENTS IN EXCHANGE FOR MEETING CERTAIN
6:42:15PM STANDARDS.
6:42:15PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOUND THIS AMENDMENT CONSISTENT WITH
6:42:17PM THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:42:18PM STAFF HAS ANALYZED THE ASSOCIATED PROVISIONS AND DETERMINED
6:42:22PM THAT THESE PROVISIONS ARE NOT UNDULY RESTRICTIVE OR
6:42:25PM BURDENSOME AND RECOMMEND ADOPTION.
6:42:26PM NOW I'M GOING TO HAND IT OVER TO THE APPLICANT WHO WILL
6:42:30PM PROVIDE THEIR PRESENTATION.
6:42:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR. BENSON.
6:42:34PM MR. SEAL, I BELIEVE.
6:42:35PM GO AHEAD.
6:42:39PM >> GOOD EVENING, MEMBERS OF THE TAMPA CITY COUNCIL.
6:43:02PM IT'S AN HONOR TO BE BEFORE YOU TONIGHT.
6:43:04PM MY NAME IS BRIAN SEAL.
6:43:05PM I AM A BOARD MEMBER OF THE TAMPA HEIGHTS CIVIC ASSOCIATION
6:43:08PM AND FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE ORGANIZATION.
6:43:10PM I'LL REFER TO IT AS THCA FOR SHORTHAND TONIGHT.
6:43:15PM I'M PROUD TO REPRESENT THEM AND ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT IN THE
6:43:18PM CREATION OF THE TAMPA HEIGHTS OVERLAY DISTRICT.
6:43:21PM THE MAIN PURPOSE OF THE INITIATIVE IS TO ENCOURAGE
6:43:24PM AFFORDABLE, WALKABLE, AND TRANSIT SUPPORTIVE URBAN DESIGN.
6:43:28PM THE OVERLAY WILL DO THIS THROUGH TARGETED INCENTIVES TO
6:43:31PM PRESERVE GREENSPACE, RETAIN ON-STREET PARKING, PROMOTE
6:43:35PM VEHICLE ACCESS VIA ALLEYS, ALLOW ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS
6:43:38PM AND REDUCE COMMERCIAL PARKING MINIMUMS.
6:43:40PM THE PROPOSAL BEFORE YOU TONIGHT IS A -- HAS A LONG HISTORY.
6:43:47PM WHEN TAMPA HEIGHTS LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT WAS CREATED IN
6:43:49PM 2000, IT ONLY INCLUDED ABOUT ONE-THIRD OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD
6:43:52PM DUE TO THE CONCENTRATIONS OF CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC
6:43:55PM PROPERTIES.
6:43:56PM HOWEVER, THE REMAINDER OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD STILL HAS THE
6:43:58PM SAME URBAN LAYOUT, JUST NOT THE CONCENTRATION OF REMAINING
6:44:01PM HISTORIC STRUCTURES.
6:44:02PM TAMPA HEIGHTS WAS PROMISED BY PAST ADMINISTRATIONS TO BE
6:44:05PM NEXT IN LINE FOLLOWING THE CREATION OF SEMINOLE HEIGHTS FORM
6:44:09PM BASED CODE OVERLAY.
6:44:10PM DUE TO CITY RESOURCES, THAT PROCESS WAS CONTINUALLY DELAYED
6:44:13PM FOR YEARS.
6:44:14PM IN 2019, THCA BOARD MEMBERS MET WITH THE CITY AND PLANNING
6:44:18PM COMMISSION STAFF ABOUT THIS TOPIC.
6:44:20PM WE WERE TOLD THE ONLY WAY FOR IT TO BE ACCOMPLISHED WAS BY
6:44:23PM PRIVATELY INITIATED TEXT AMENDMENT AND WE ACCEPTED THAT
6:44:26PM CHALLENGE.
6:44:26PM OUR LAND USE COMMITTEE REVIEWED EXISTING OVERLAYS IN THE
6:44:31PM CITY OF TAMPA AND HELD FOCUS GROUPS TO WRITE THE FIRST DRAFT
6:44:34PM WHICH WAS SUBMITTED IN JULY OF 2021.
6:44:36PM THIS INITIATIVE AND THE CODE AMENDMENT ITSELF HAVE BEEN WELL
6:44:41PM VETTED AMONG THE PUBLIC.
6:44:42PM STARTING IN JULY 2021, THE EFFORT HAS BEEN POSTED ON THE
6:44:45PM TAMPA HEIGHTS WEBSITE, DISCUSSED IN EVERY MONTHLY MEETING.
6:44:49PM IT INCLUDED EVERY THCA E-MAIL COMMUNICATION TO OVER 800
6:44:52PM MEMBERS.
6:44:53PM IN JANUARY AND MARCH 2022, HART HOSTED TWO TRANSIT ORIENTED
6:44:58PM DESIGN CHARRETTES AT THE TAMPA HEIGHTS COMMUNITY CENTER.
6:45:01PM THEIR CONSULTANT'S RECOMMENDATIONS FOR COMMERCIAL PARKING
6:45:03PM REDUCTIONS FROM THE EFFORT WERE DIRECTLY INCORPORATED INTO
6:45:06PM THIS PROPOSED OVERLAY.
6:45:07PM ALSO IN JUNE AND SEPTEMBER OF 2022, THCA PRESENTED THIS
6:45:14PM PUBLICLY NOTICED CITY OF TAMPA MEETINGS.
6:45:16PM IN OCTOBER 2022, THCA HOSTED A PUBLIC FORUM DEDICATED TO
6:45:25PM THIS PROPOSED OVERLAY.
6:45:26PM OUR BOARD MEMBERS CANVASSED THE NEIGHBORHOOD PLACING THIS
6:45:29PM DOOR HANGER AT EVERY RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL PROPERTY.
6:45:32PM IT INCLUDED MEETING DETAILS AND WEBSITE LINKS TO ALL THE
6:45:37PM OVERLAY INFORMATION.
6:45:37PM THE FORM WAS SIMULCAST VIA ZOOM, RECORDED AND UPLOADED TO
6:45:42PM YouTube THE FOLLOWING DAY.
6:45:43PM DURING THE STAGES OF PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT, VALUABLE COMMUNITY
6:45:46PM FEEDBACK INFORMED THE EVOLUTION OF THIS PROPOSAL.
6:45:49PM BECAUSE OF OUR TRANSPARENCY AND COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
6:45:53PM EFFORTS, WE RECEIVED STRONG SUPPORT.
6:45:55PM OUR ONLINE PETITION HAS BEEN SIGNED BY 267 PEOPLE, 90% OF
6:46:00PM WHOM LIVE, WORK, OR OWN PROPERTY IN TAMPA HEIGHTS.
6:46:03PM THE TAMPA DOWNTOWN PARTNERSHIP, WHOSE SPECIAL SERVICES
6:46:06PM DISTRICT COVERS PORTIONS OF TAMPA HEIGHTS, HAS GIVEN THEIR
6:46:10PM OFFICIAL SUPPORT TO CREATION OF THE OVERLAY.
6:46:12PM WALK BIKE TAMPA, NON-PRIVATE ADVOCACY GROUP INSTRUMENTAL IN
6:46:15PM THE CREATION OF THE CITY'S VISION ZERO PLAN RECOGNIZES THE
6:46:18PM PROVISIONS OF THIS OVERLAY CAN HELP CREATE A SAFER CITY FOR
6:46:22PM WALKING AND BIKING.
6:46:23PM THEY HAVE ENDORSED THIS PROPOSAL.
6:46:24PM THE CENTER FOR ARCHITECTURE AND DESIGN TAMPA BAY, WHICH IS
6:46:27PM THE ADVOCACY ARM OF THE AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS,
6:46:30PM OFFICIALLY SUPPORTS THIS OVERLAY.
6:46:32PM SO WHY DOES TAMPA HEIGHTS NEED AN OVERLAY?
6:46:37PM IT'S ONE OF THE ONLY CENTRAL CITY NEIGHBORHOODS NOT
6:46:40PM PROTECTED BY A COMPREHENSIVE OVERLAY, AS YOU CAN SEE ON THIS
6:46:43PM MAP.
6:46:43PM OUR NEIGHBORS IN SEMINOLE HEIGHTS, WEST TAMPA, YBOR CITY,
6:46:46PM EAST TAMPA, HYDE PARK, AND DOWNTOWN ALL HAVE SPECIAL
6:46:48PM PROVISIONS TO PROTECT THEIR UNIQUE URBAN FABRIC.
6:46:51PM RECENT DEVELOPMENTS HAVE BEEN DESIGNED IN UNSUSTAINABLE
6:46:56PM WAYS.
6:46:56PM SMART GROWTH ORIENTED GUIDELINES ARE NEEDED TO ACHIEVE TAMPA
6:46:59PM HEIGHTS FULL POTENTIAL AS IT GOES THROUGH A RAPID PHASE OF
6:47:02PM REDEVELOPMENT.
6:47:03PM IN FURTHER CONTEXT, TAMPA HAS BEEN UNDER TREMENDOUS PRESSURE
6:47:09PM FROM RISING HOUSING COSTS.
6:47:11PM NOT ONLY SHORT SUPPLY OF HOUSING AFFECT ITS COST, BUT CAR
6:47:15PM DEPENDENT DEVELOPMENT PATTERN CREATES A FURTHER BURDEN ON
6:47:17PM RESIDENTS.
6:47:18PM YOU CAN SEE HERE THAT IN 2019, BEFORE THE POST-COVID
6:47:21PM POPULATION BOOM, HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY RENTERS ALREADY SPENT
6:47:24PM MORE THAN 50% OF THEIR GROSS INCOME ON HOUSING.
6:47:27PM THE EXPENSE OF LIVING IN CALIFORNIA -- IN FLORIDA IS
6:47:31PM COMPARABLE TO CALIFORNIA AND NEW YORK WHICH ARE TYPICAL
6:47:33PM PUNCH OF BAGS FOR COST-OF-LIVING ISSUES.
6:47:35PM SINCE 2000, OUR RENTAL INFLATION HAS LED THE SOUTHEAST AND
6:47:39PM IN SOME REPORTS THE NATION.
6:47:40PM SIMILARLY, THE COST OF HOME OWNERSHIP HAS SKYROCKETED IN
6:47:47PM PAST YEARS, OUTPACING MUCH OF THE REST OF THE COUNTRY.
6:47:50PM TAMPA HEIGHTS HAS BEEN AMONG THE NEIGHBORHOODS EXPERIENCING
6:47:51PM THE HIGHEST LEVEL OF HOME APPRECIATION.
6:47:54PM IT'S BECOME INCREDIBLY UNAFFORDABLE TO LIVE IN THIS
6:47:57PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:47:57PM IMPROVING PEDESTRIAN SAFETY IS ANOTHER KEY GOAL OF THIS
6:48:03PM OVERLAY.
6:48:04PM THE CAR DEPENDENCY OF TAMPA BAY HAS MADE IT ONE OF THE MOST
6:48:08PM DANGEROUS PLACES FOR PEDESTRIANS.
6:48:09PM NOT ONLY IS WALKING MORE DANGEROUS REGIONALLY, IT'S SADLY
6:48:17PM LESS CONVENIENT IN A DOWNTOWN ADJACENT NEIGHBORHOOD LIKE
6:48:19PM TAMPA HEIGHTS.
6:48:20PM WE'RE FAR BEHIND SIMILAR NEIGHBORHOODS IN OUR PEER CITIES
6:48:23PM AND COMPARABLE NEIGHBORHOODS WALK SCORE RATES TAMPA AS 63
6:48:26PM WHILE ST. PETE IS A 77 AND MIAMI IS A STELLAR 91.
6:48:30PM WE CANNOT WAIT FOR LOCAL MASS TRANSIT FUNDING TO START
6:48:34PM CREATING MORE WALKABLE PLACES.
6:48:35PM WE NEED A ZONING CODE IN PLACE TO BRING THEM INTO EXISTENCE
6:48:38PM ON A PROPERTY-BY-PROPERTY BASIS.
6:48:41PM WE NEED TO TAKE INTRANEIGHBORHOOD TRIPS OFF THE ROAD AND PUT
6:48:44PM THEM ONTO SIDEWALKS AND BIKE LANES.
6:48:46PM WE NEED -- IF WE CAN BUILD TO THIS PATTERN, THEN BY THE TIME
6:48:50PM WE CAN GET OUR ACT TOGETHER FOR MASS TRANSIT, WE'LL HAVE A
6:48:53PM FIRST MILE/LAST MILE EQUATION SOLVED TO SUPPORT A TRANSIT
6:48:57PM SYSTEM FOR REAL RIDERSHIP.
6:48:59PM AS A COMMUNITY, WE'RE TAKING OWNERSHIP AND LEADERSHIP OF
6:49:06PM THESE SOLUTIONS.
6:49:07PM SOMETHING NEEDS TO CHANGE.
6:49:09PM SO WHY ADUs?
6:49:15PM ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS CAN BE A QUICKER AND EASIER
6:49:18PM SOLUTION TO INCREASING THE HOUSING SUPPLY WHERE IT'S NEEDED.
6:49:21PM WE NEED MORE SMALL AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS.
6:49:23PM THIS IS WHY MUNICIPALITIES AROUND THE COUNTRY, INCLUDING
6:49:25PM TAMPA, HAVE BEEN WORKING TO REMOVE BARRIERS TO THEIR
6:49:28PM CREATION.
6:49:28PM ADUs ARE COMPATIBLE IN TAMPA HEIGHTS.
6:49:34PM TAMPA HEIGHTS HAS A LONG HISTORY BOTH INSIDE AND OUTSIDE OUR
6:49:37PM HISTORIC DISTRICT OF ADUs.
6:49:39PM GARAGE APARTMENTS AND BACKYARD UNITS ARE COMMON BUILT FOR.
6:49:43PM THIS OVERLAY WOULD MAKE IT EASIER TO BUILD MORE OF THEM.
6:49:46PM TRADITIONAL NEIGHBORHOOD DESIGN OR TND IS RECOGNIZED FOR
6:49:54PM PROVIDING EXCELLENT WALKABILITY AND SAFETY, YET MOST OF
6:49:56PM TAMPA HEIGHTS IS COVERED BY THE CITY'S OUTDATED SUBURBAN
6:49:59PM BASED ZONING CODE.
6:50:00PM EVEN U.S. D.O.T. AND FEDERAL HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION TOUT THE
6:50:04PM BENEFITS OF TND PRACTICES.
6:50:06PM RECOMMEND TRAFFIC CALMING AND FRONT FACING DRIVEWAYS
6:50:09PM INHERENTLY UNSAFE.
6:50:11PM WE WANT TO INCENTIVIZE THE USAGE OF OUR EXTENSIVE ALLEY
6:50:14PM NETWORK FOR THIS REASON.
6:50:15PM THE KEY THERE IS INCENTIVIZE, NOT FORCE.
6:50:19PM HERE YOU SEE EXAMPLES OF RESIDENCES, BOTH OLD AND NEW, BOTH
6:50:25PM SINGLE-FAMILY AND MULTIFAMILY THAT WERE VOLUNTARILY DESIGNED
6:50:28PM WITH TRADITIONAL STREET ENGAGEMENT.
6:50:31PM NOTE THE AMOUNT OF GREENSPACE, SHADE TREES, ACCESS TO
6:50:34PM SIDEWALK AND AMOUNT OF AVAILABLE ON-STREET PARKING IN FRONT
6:50:36PM OF THESE PROPERTIES.
6:50:37PM IN CONTRAST, LOOK AT THESE RECENT PROJECTS THAT DID NOT
6:50:42PM VALUE WALKABILITY AND STREET ENGAGEMENT IN THE SAME WAY.
6:50:45PM THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT OR INCENTIVE FOR THEM TO ASSESS
6:50:48PM THEIR RELATIONSHIP WITH THE SURROUNDING URBAN FABRIC.
6:50:50PM VALUABLE GREENSPACE AND ON-STREET PARKING IS LOST FOR THE
6:50:53PM DECADES-LONG LIFE OF THE BUILDING.
6:50:55PM ANOTHER GOAL OF THIS OVERLAY IS TO SPUR REUSE IN
6:51:04PM REDEVELOPMENT ALONG OUR COMMERCIAL CORRIDORS, SUCH AS
6:51:06PM FRANKLIN STREET, FLORIDA AVENUE AND COLUMBUS DRIVE.
6:51:09PM SMALL TO MID SIZE PROPERTIES SIT VACANT YET SIMILARLY SIZED
6:51:12PM PROPERTIES DOWNTOWN TO OUR SOUTH AND SEMINOLE HEIGHTS TO THE
6:51:15PM NORTH HAVE BEEN ACTIVATED THANKS IN PART TO PARKING REFORMS.
6:51:18PM IT IS A HUGE BARRIER TO REDEVELOPMENT, YET THE ONLY WAY TO
6:51:21PM MEET EXCESSIVE PARKING MINIMUMS IS THROUGH EXPENSIVE
6:51:24PM STRUCTURED GARAGES OR SURFACE LOTS.
6:51:29PM ON THE SLIDE, YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING IN RED IS VACANT LOT OR
6:51:33PM SURFACE PARKING ON THESE KEY COMMERCIAL CORRIDORS.
6:51:36PM DESPITE ALL THE REDEVELOPMENT HAPPENING AROUND US, NOTHING
6:51:38PM HAS HAPPENED YET TO THESE PROPERTIES.
6:51:40PM PROPERTY OWNERS SHOULD BE ABLE TO USE THE ABUNDANT ON-STREET
6:51:49PM PARKING AND PROVIDE OFF-STREET SPACES THEY THINK THEY NEED
6:51:52PM FOR THEIR BUSINESSES.
6:51:53PM LEE'S GROCERY IS A PERFECT EXAMPLE THAT WE WANT TO
6:51:56PM REPLICATE.
6:51:57PM IT'S A VALUED GATHERING POINT FOR THE COMMUNITY, BUT THERE
6:51:59PM ARE FEW PLACES LIKE IT.
6:52:02PM THEY THRIVE WITHOUT A SINGLE OFF-STREET PARKING SPACE.
6:52:11PM LET'S MAKE IT EASIER FOR PLACES LIKE LEE'S TO EXIST.
6:52:11PM THIS EFFORT DIDN'T COME OUT OF LEFT FIELD.
6:52:14PM THE VALUES WE'RE ATTEMPTING TO CODIFY WERE IDENTIFIED BACK
6:52:15PM IN THE 2003 TAMPA HEIGHTS NEIGHBORHOOD PLAN.
6:52:18PM SOME EXCERPTS YOU'LL SEE HERE, WHICH CITY COUNCIL OFFICIALLY
6:52:21PM ADOPTED.
6:52:21PM IT WAS JUST NEVER GIVEN A STICK OR CARROTS TO BE PUT INTO
6:52:26PM CODE.
6:52:27PM FURTHERMORE, THERE WERE A VARIETY OF POLICIES IN THE CITY'S
6:52:31PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN THAT ENCOURAGE THE TRADITIONAL FORM OF
6:52:33PM OUR TAMPA HEIGHTS URBAN VILLAGE.
6:52:35PM THESE POLICIES HAVEN'T BEEN ENSHRINED IN TAMPA'S LAND
6:52:38PM DEVELOPMENT CODE.
6:52:39PM THE CODES PROPOSED FOR THE OVERLAY DO NOT EXIST IN A VACUUM.
6:52:49PM MIRROR SUCCESSFUL EFFORTS IN OTHER NEIGHBORHOODS, INCLUDING
6:52:51PM THE CHANGES TO EAST TAMPA'S OVERLAY, WHICH THE PLANNING
6:52:54PM COMMISSION AND CITY COUNCIL APPROVED EARLIER THIS YEAR.
6:52:57PM IT'S TIME WE CODIFY THE VALUES WE ESPOUSE IN TAMPA HEIGHTS,
6:53:03PM WALKABILITY, SAFETY AND AFFORDABILITY.
6:53:04PM THIS PROPOSAL DOES SO IN A PRODEVELOPMENT INCENTIVIZED
6:53:07PM MANNER.
6:53:08PM WE'VE BEEN PROUD TO WORK WITH STAFF ON IT.
6:53:10PM IT'S BEEN INSTRUMENTAL TO GETTING US TO THIS POINT.
6:53:13PM WE HUMBLY ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
6:53:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:53:17PM I'LL START BY SAYING THAT WAS A VERY IMPRESSIVE
6:53:21PM PRESENTATION.
6:53:21PM I THINK TAMPA HEIGHTS IS ONE OF THE CITY'S MOST BEAUTIFUL
6:53:27PM NEIGHBORHOODS.
6:53:28PM I RARELY GET EXCITED OVER PROJECTS, AND THIS, BECAUSE I'M IN
6:53:32PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD ALMOST EVERY DAY.
6:53:39PM WHOEVER PUT THIS TOGETHER, YOU AND YOUR TEAM, VERY
6:53:42PM IMPRESSIVE.
6:53:42PM >> THANK YOU.
6:53:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: AGAIN, I'M NOT BASING MY DECISION
6:53:45PM BECAUSE WE HAVE TO HEAR FROM THE PUBLIC, BUT ONE THING THAT
6:53:47PM MAY COME UP THIS EVENING IS REGARDING SOME FLOODING IN A
6:53:50PM SPECIFIC AREA.
6:53:52PM I WAS GOING OVER SOME E-MAILS THIS MORNING AND MY OFFICE, I
6:53:57PM KNOW THIS IS OFF TOPIC, BUT IT'S IN TAMPA HEIGHTS AND THERE
6:54:00PM ARE ISSUES WITH FLOODING.
6:54:01PM MY OFFICE IS WORKING ON THAT TO GET THAT BECAUSE IT'S BEEN A
6:54:04PM LONG TIME COMING, SO WE'RE WORKING ON IT.
6:54:07PM WE'VE HEARD FROM FOLKS.
6:54:08PM BUT I WANT TO BRING THAT UP IN CASE IT COMES UP IN PUBLIC
6:54:12PM COMMENT.
6:54:12PM I KNOW WE'RE SPECIFICALLY TALKING ABOUT THIS, BUT I SAW THAT
6:54:15PM IN E-MAILS.
6:54:16PM JUST WANT TO BRING THAT UP.
6:54:17PM THANK YOU, SIR.
6:54:18PM ANY QUESTIONS FROM COUNCIL MEMBERS BEFORE WE GO TO PUBLIC
6:54:20PM COMMENT?
6:54:21PM YES, SIR.
6:54:25PM >>BILL CARLSON: BRIAN, COULD YOU TELL US YOUR PROFESSIONAL
6:54:28PM CREDENTIALS AND EXPERIENCE?
6:54:29PM >> SURE.
6:54:29PM I HAVE A MASTER'S DEGREE IN BUILDING CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT
6:54:34PM AS WELL AS, I DON'T KNOW, ABOUT 15 YEARS AT THIS POINT IN
6:54:38PM CONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT AROUND THE COUNTRY.
6:54:41PM I'VE SERVED OFF AND ON FOR THE TAMPA HEIGHTS CIVIC
6:54:46PM ASSOCIATION FOR TEN YEARS, HEAD UP OUR LAND USE COMMITTEE.
6:54:49PM THANK YOU.
6:54:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:54:51PM DO WE HAVE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK FOR
6:54:54PM PUBLIC COMMENT?
6:54:55PM PLEASE COME UP.
6:54:56PM YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
6:54:57PM MS. SANCHEZ, WE'LL START WITH YOU.
6:55:02PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:55:04PM >> GOOD EVENING, CITY COUNCIL.
6:55:05PM MY NAME IS SANDRA DIDIEGO SANCHEZ.
6:55:08PM I LIVE IN ARMORY GARDENS COMMUNITY, THE HOME OF THE VILA
6:55:11PM BROTHERS PARK.
6:55:13PM PART OF OUR COMMUNITY IS WITHIN THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY.
6:55:18PM I WANT TO ASK YOU TO PLEASE MOVE THIS FORWARD.
6:55:23PM THE WEST -- THE OVERLAYS ARE WHAT PUTS MORE OF A CHANCE WHEN
6:55:28PM WE FIGHT SOME OF THE AGGRESSIVE DEVELOPERS.
6:55:32PM THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO BE A PRIORITY OVER CITY ORDINANCES.
6:55:35PM SO I WOULD ASK YOU IF YOU WOULD PLEASE MOVE THIS FORWARD SO
6:55:38PM IT CAN EVENTUALLY BE ACCEPTED.
6:55:40PM THANK YOU.
6:55:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:55:41PM NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:55:59PM ZOOM OUT A LITTLE BIT.
6:56:02PM THE OTHER WAY.
6:56:03PM ALL RIGHT.
6:56:10PM VERY GOOD, SIR.
6:56:16PM >> GOOD EVENING.
6:56:17PM I'M ROGER GRUNKE, BUILDING ARCHITECT CONTRACTOR AND URBAN
6:56:21PM THEORIST.
6:56:22PM I'M THE PROPERTY OWNER OF 2708 NORTH ELMORE AVENUE IN TAMPA
6:56:27PM HEIGHTS.
6:56:28PM THE SIZE OF MY PROPERTY IS 60 BY 198.
6:56:32PM UNDER THE CURRENT RS 50 ZONING, THAT CAN HANDLE TWO UNITS.
6:56:36PM QUITE A FEW PROPERTIES IN THE OLD ROBLES FARM AREA OF TAMPA
6:56:44PM HEIGHTS ARE 200 FEET IN DEPTH AND A NUMBER OF THEM ALREADY
6:56:49PM HAVE HISTORIC CARRIAGE HOUSES IN ADDITION TO THE MAIN HOUSE.
6:56:54PM I WORK WITH NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATIONS, AND I KNOW MANY
6:56:57PM PEOPLE FEAR DENSITY.
6:57:00PM MANY OF YOUR CONSTITUENTS ALSO FEAR AND OPPOSE DENSITY.
6:57:04PM BUT LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT THE ECONOMICS OF DENSITY.
6:57:09PM HERE IS A SIMPLE SCALED SKETCH COMPARING A QUADRUPLEX TO
6:57:15PM FOUR FREE-STANDING DETACHED HOMES.
6:57:18PM ALL FIVE PROPERTIES ARE THE SAME SIZE AND ALL FIVE HOUSING
6:57:23PM UNITS ARE THE SAME SIZE.
6:57:26PM HOWEVER, CONSIDERING THE REQUIRED INFRASTRUCTURE, THAT IS
6:57:32PM GAS LINES, WATER LINES, SEWER LINES, ELECTRIC, AND
6:57:35PM COMMUNICATION LINES, IT IS CLEAR THAT THE FOUR DETACHED
6:57:40PM UNITS REQUIRE FOUR TIMES THE LINEAR FEET OF GAS, WATER,
6:57:46PM SEWER, ELECTRIC, AND COMMUNICATION INFRASTRUCTURE.
6:57:49PM THAT'S FOUR TIMES.
6:57:53PM IMMEDIATELY WE SEE THE ECONOMIC ADVANTAGE OF DENSITY.
6:57:58PM MAYOR CASTOR'S ADMINISTRATION IS CONSTANTLY WARNING US OF
6:58:02PM OUR CITY'S ROAD MAINTENANCE FUNDING SHORTFALL.
6:58:05PM THE REDUCED QUANTITY OF PAVEMENT PER CAPITA IN A DENSELY
6:58:11PM POPULATED DISTRICT IS AN INDISPUTABLE ECONOMIC ADVANTAGE.
6:58:17PM WE HERE IN HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY SHOULD NOT BE BUILDING NEW
6:58:21PM ROADS WITHOUT INCORPORATING DENSITY IN THE DESIGN.
6:58:28PM DENSITY ALSO ENCOURAGES LOCAL SHOPPING, NEIGHBORHOOD
6:58:32PM RESTAURANTS, AND NEIGHBORHOOD BEVERAGE VENUES.
6:58:38PM DENSITY ENABLES A REALISTIC AND ACCEPTABLE PER CAPITA COST
6:58:44PM FOR PUBLIC TRANSIT.
6:58:46PM WITHOUT DENSITY, PUBLIC TRANSIT IS NOT POSSIBLE.
6:58:50PM WE IN TAMPA HEIGHTS ARE NOT ADVOCATING PUSHING DENSITY ON
6:58:55PM EVERY PART OF THE CITY, BUT WE KNOW IT IS OUR NEIGHBORHOOD
6:59:00PM -- OUR NEIGHBORHOOD DESERVES IT.
6:59:01PM IT BELONGS IN TAMPA HEIGHTS.
6:59:03PM PLEASE SUPPORT OUR OVERLAY REQUEST.
6:59:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
6:59:06PM NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:59:12PM >> MY NAME IS ARI FITZGERALD, AND I LIVE NEXT DOOR.
6:59:16PM I'M THE NEXT-DOOR NEIGHBOR TO TAMPA HEIGHTS.
6:59:18PM I LIVE IN RIVERSIDE HEIGHTS.
06:59:27PM BRIAN IS A HARD ACT TO FOLLOW.
06:59:29PM I SUPPORT THIS.
06:59:30PM I ACTUALLY AM A LITTLE JEALOUS OF IT.
06:59:33PM I WISH WE WOULD GET IT IN RIVERSIDE HEIGHTS.
06:59:37PM I WISH WE WOULD CARRY IT OVER TO THE RIVER.
06:59:39PM BECAUSE I AM SEEING SOME NOT-SO-GREAT DEVELOPMENT, AND YOU
06:59:43PM CAN'T USUALLY FIX DEVELOPMENT MISTAKES ONCE BRIAN POINTED
06:59:47PM OUT ONCE THEY ARE MADE.
06:59:49PM THEY LAST FOR GENERATIONS.
06:59:51PM SO I REALLY SUPPORT WHAT THEY ARE ADVOCATING FOR HERE.
06:59:54PM ONE THING I REALLY LIKE ABOUT IT IS THAT IT WILL REDUCE THE
06:59:58PM GARAGE PROMINENCE IN NEW DEVELOPMENT.
07:00:01PM GARAGE PROMINENCE, I JUST DON'T THINK IS AS ATTRACTIVE.
07:00:06PM CERTAINLY DOESN'T FOSTER A SENSE OF COMMUNITY.
07:00:09PM AND I REALLY SUPPORT THAT.
07:00:11PM ONE ASPECT OF MANY THAT I SUPPORT.
07:00:14PM I LIKE THAT IT PROMOTES WALKABILITY.
07:00:19PM IT IS A WIN-WIN-WIN.
07:00:21PM THE PEOPLE WANT IT.
07:00:22PM PLEASE SUPPORT IT.
07:00:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:00:26PM YES, MA'AM.
07:00:26PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:00:28PM >> GOOD EVENING.
07:00:31PM MY NAME IS LENA YOUNG-GREEN.
07:00:33PM I WANT TO FIRST THANK YOU ALL FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO COME UP
07:00:36PM HERE AND SHARE INFORMATION AND EXPRESS HOW -- HOW MUCH WE
07:00:43PM APPRECIATE OUR NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:00:44PM ALSO, I WANT TO THANK EACH OF YOU WHO ARE SITTING UP THERE WHO
07:00:48PM SUPPORTED US IN THE PAST SO MANY YEARS.
07:00:49PM I HAVE BEEN A LONG-TIME RESIDENT OF TAMPA HEIGHTS.
07:00:54PM BROUGHT MY CHILDREN THERE WHEN THEY WERE VERY YOUNG.
07:00:59PM HAD OUR LAST CHILD WHO WAS BORN THERE.
07:01:03PM WE SELECTED TAMPA HEIGHTS BECAUSE OF THE CHARACTER OF THE
07:01:06PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:01:06PM WE CAME IN AND WE STARTED TO WORK.
07:01:08PM ONE OF THE THINGS THAT IS ATTRACTIVE ABOUT TAMPA HEIGHTS IS
07:01:11PM THAT EVER SINCE IT WAS CREATED IN 1880s, IT WAS A DIVERSE
07:01:19PM NEIGHBORHOOD, UNLIKE MANY OTHER PARTS OF THIS AREA.
07:01:21PM AND THAT IS ONE OF THE ATTRACTIVE THINGS FOR US.
07:01:24PM TODAY, AS WE LOOK AT THE -- THE DIFFERENCE IN OUR
07:01:28PM NEIGHBORHOODS, IT IS NOT AS DIVERSE AS IT WAS BEFORE.
07:01:31PM MANY PEOPLE WITH NOT AFFORD TO LIVE IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD AS
07:01:35PM SOME OF THE INFORMATION THAT YOU HEARD BEFORE.
07:01:36PM NOW, IF WE ARE ABLE TO HAVE OUR ADUs INSIDE OF OUR
07:01:41PM PROPERTIES AND BE ABLE TO ACTUALLY HAVE SOME -- GENERATE
07:01:46PM SOME REVENUE FOR LOWER INCOME RESIDENTS, WE WILL BE ABLE TO
07:01:50PM MAINTAIN SOME OF THAT -- DIVERSITY.
07:01:57PM THAT IS VERY, VERY IMPORTANT.
07:01:59PM NOT ONLY TO ME BUT TO MANY OF OUR RESIDENTS INCLUDING EVERY
07:02:02PM MEMBER OF THE BOARD -- OF OUR BOARD OF DIRECTORS FOR THE
07:02:06PM ORGANIZATION.
07:02:07PM WE ALSO WANT TO ENCOURAGE THE SAFETY OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD BY
07:02:12PM REDUCING THE -- ADDING MORE PARKING TO THE STREETS.
07:02:17PM CARS HAVE TO SLOW DOWN SO OUR CHILDREN CAN PLAY MORE SAFELY.
07:02:21PM THAT IS IMPORTANT TO US.
07:02:24PM AND ALSO, TAMPA HEIGHTS, WE HAVE ALWAYS BEEN ADVOCATING FOR
07:02:28PM TAMPA HEIGHTS TO BE A WALKABLE, BIKABLE COMMUNITY.
07:02:32PM NOT ONLY THAT A QUALITY OF LIFE, BUT IT IS A HEALTH ISSUE.
07:02:36PM AND THE MORE THAT WE CAN MAKE DECISIONS THAT HELP US TO BE
07:02:41PM MORE -- TO BE MORE SAFE IN OUR NEIGHBORHOODS, THESE ARE
07:02:45PM THINGS THAT WE WANT TO ASK YOU TO SUPPORT.
07:02:47PM SO TONIGHT, KINDLY SUPPORT OUR REQUEST.
07:02:50PM AND WE APPRECIATE YOUR TIME -- YOU FOR ALLOWING US TO COME
07:02:56PM AND TALK.
07:02:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:02:58PM YES, SIR.
07:03:00PM NEXT SPEAKER.
07:03:03PM >> GOOD EVENING, EVERYBODY.
07:03:05PM PAUL RABBO, 202 NORTH MASSACHUSETTS IN TAMPA HEIGHTS.
07:03:08PM I AM ALSO A BOARD MEMBER OF THE THCA, AND I AM AN AVID BIKER.
07:03:15PM I PUT IN 20-PLUS MILES ON TAMPA STREETS EVERY DAY.
07:03:18PM I BIKE MY DAUGHTER TO SCHOOL THIS MORNING.
07:03:20PM MY WIFE PICKED HER IS UP BY BIKE.
07:03:23PM I BIKED HERE.
07:03:24PM I BIKED TO WORK.
07:03:25PM I WILL BIKE HOME, I GUESS.
07:03:27PM THE WAY PEOPLE MOVE THROUGH A NEIGHBORHOOD IS VERY IMPORTANT
07:03:31PM TO ME.
07:03:31PM IF WE JUST DRIVE IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD, WE DON'T MEET OUR
07:03:35PM NEIGHBORS.
07:03:35PM YOU DON'T SAY HI WHEN YOU ARE WALKING AROUND.
07:03:38PM AND ALSO -- THIS OVERLAY WILL START TO IMPROVE SAFETY.
07:03:41PM I HAVE TWO YOUNG KIDS.
07:03:43PM IF YOU BIKE WITH YOUNG KIDS IN TAMPA STREETS, I AM SURE YOU
07:03:48PM KNOW WHAT I AM TALKING ABOUT.
07:03:49PM THE MORE WE CAN TO DO IMPROVE SAFETY, WALKABILITY AND
07:03:53PM IMPROVE SMALL BUSINESS SO THERE IS SOMETHING TO WALK TO,
07:03:56PM THOSE ARE ALL THINGS THAT I AM VERY STRONGLY IN FAVOR OF.
07:03:58PM I HOPE THAT YOU SUPPORT THIS MEASURE.
07:04:00PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR TIME.
07:04:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
07:04:04PM YES, SIR, NEXT SPEAKER.
07:04:06PM >> GOOD EVENING, COMMISSIONERS.
07:04:08PM MY NAME IS JERRY KORSCH, A TAMPA HEIGHTS RESIDENT, 208 EAST
07:04:13PM PARK AVENUE.
07:04:14PM I AM SPEAKING IN FAVOR OF THE TAMPA HEIGHTS OVERLAY
07:04:17PM DISTRICT.
07:04:17PM OUR HOUSE HAS AN ADU.
07:04:20PM IT WAS CONSTRUCTED VIA A VARIANCE IN 2005 AND ONE OF THE
07:04:25PM REASONS WE PURCHASED OUR HOUSE.
07:04:27PM IN THE TIME WE HAVE OWNED OUR HOME, WE RENTED OUT THAT ADUS
07:04:31PM AS AFFORDABLE HOUSING BENEFITING BOTH OUR TENANT, LOCAL
07:04:35PM COMMUNITY AND US BECAUSE WE WERE ABLE TO GENERATE SOME
07:04:38PM INCOME FROM THAT TENANCY TO MAINTAIN OUR 100-YEAR-OLD HOUSE.
07:04:43PM I WOULD LIKE MY NEIGHBORS TO CONSTRUCT ADUs AND NOT HAVE TO
07:04:52PM JUMP THROUGH SO MANY HOOPS AS OUR PREDECESSOR.
07:04:55PM I AM A DOG OWNER, AND I WALK THE NEIGHBORHOOD EVERY DAY.
07:04:57PM THIS NEIGHBORHOOD OVERLAY WILL HELP AND ENCOURAGE OUR
07:05:01PM NEIGHBORHOOD GREEN SPACE AND PROMOTE AND PRESERVE OUR TREE
07:05:04PM CANOPY, WHICH, AS ANYONE WITH A GOD KNOWS, IS A GODSEND
07:05:09PM DURING OUR HOT SEASON.
07:05:10PM IT WILL ALSO PROMOTE DEVELOPMENT THAT WOULDN'T FORCE GEORGE
07:05:13PM AND I OFF THE SIDEWALKS AND INTO THE STREETS AS WE HAVE TO
07:05:16PM DO IN FRONT OF THE NEW CONSTRUCTION IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD
07:05:19PM WHERE WE HAVE TO STEP INTO THE STREETS TO DODGE CARS THAT
07:05:22PM ARE OVERLAPPING THE SIDEWALK AND THE DRIVEWAYS IN FRONT.
07:05:25PM IN OVERLAY WILL HELP PRESERVE THE AFFORDABILITY, CHARACTER
07:05:30PM AND SAFETY OF OUR NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:05:31PM AND I WOULD RESPECTFULLY REQUEST THAT YOU SUPPORT IT.
07:05:33PM THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
07:05:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:05:36PM YES, MA'AM.
07:05:38PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:05:39PM >> HI, MY NAME IS CARROLL ANN BENNETT.
07:05:42PM I AM THE VICE PRESIDENT OF T.H.A.N.
07:05:43PM T.H.A.N. TOOK A VOTE OF THEIR MEMBERSHIP SEVERAL MONTHS AGO
07:05:47PM AND UNANIMOUS TO SUPPORT THIS EFFORT WITH TAMPA HEIGHT, CITY
07:05:51PM STAFF, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF AND PLANNING COMMISSION
07:05:55PM FINDS THIS CONSISTENT AND WE ASK FOR TO YOU SUPPORT IT.
07:06:00PM A STAGGERING AMOUNT OF WORK BY THE TAMPA HEIGHTS
07:06:04PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND THEY HAVE DONE A GREAT JOB.
07:06:06PM I DON'T LIVE IN TAMPA HEIGHTS, WELL ADVERTISED AND OPEN TO
07:06:09PM THE PUBLIC.
07:06:10PM I ATTENDED A YEAR AND A HALF AGO.
07:06:12PM AS A NEIGHBORHOOD ADVOCATE, I INTERACT WITH RESIDENTS AROUND
07:06:16PM THE CITY AND WOULD LIKE TO DO SOMETHING LIKE THIS.
07:06:18PM I WISH I HAD THE SKILL TO CREATE SOMETHING OF THIS HIGH
07:06:22PM CALIBER IN MY OWN NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:06:24PM IN MY COMMENTS WITH THE CITY, I SEE HOW RESIDENTS CHERISH
07:06:27PM THE IDENTITIES OF THEIR NEIGHBORS.
07:06:29PM VERY EYE OPENING TO SEE THE DIFFERENCES OF WHAT IS CHERISHED
07:06:35PM BY EACH NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:06:36PM THEY ARE NOT ALL THE SAME.
07:06:37PM THEY HAVE ONE THING IN COMMON, THEY WANT TO ARDENTLY SUPPORT
07:06:42PM THE CHARACTER OF THEIR NEIGHBORHOOD AND CAN CHANGE
07:06:45PM DRASTICALLY FROM ONE NEIGHBORHOOD TO THE NEXT.
07:06:47PM THE LOVE OF THEIR PARTICULAR AND UNIQUE CHARACTER OF THEIR
07:06:51PM OWN NEIGHBORHOOD IS UNIVERSAL.
07:06:52PM I TRULY BELIEVE THAT DEVELOPERS AND DEVELOPERS ARE THEIR OWN
07:06:56PM WORST ENEMIES.
07:06:57PM OVER AND OVER AGAIN RESIDENTS TELL ME THEY WOULDN'T MIND THE
07:07:00PM NEW BUILDINGS AND DEVELOPMENT NEARLY SO MUCH IF IT JUST FITS
07:07:04PM IN THE CHARACTER OF THEIR NEIGHBORHOODS.
07:07:05PM BUILDING UNATTRACTIVE, BORING PROJECTS, BUILDERS SHOOT
07:07:10PM THEMSELVES IN THE FOOT.
07:07:11PM THEY ARE TONE DEAF WHAT ATTRACTED PEOPLE TO A PARTICULAR
07:07:14PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND WHY THE RESIDENTS LOVE IT TO MUCH.
07:07:16PM I'M GREEN WITH JEALOUSY OF WHAT TAMPA HEIGHTS HAVE
07:07:20PM ACCOMPLISHED.
07:07:20PM PLEASE ADOPT THIS AMENDMENT.
07:07:22PM THANK YOU.
07:07:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:07:24PM YES, SIR.
07:07:24PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:07:25PM >> GOOD EVENING, CITY COUNCIL, MR. SHELBY, MADAM CLERK, CITY
07:07:29PM STAFF, CAMILLO SOTO, AN ATTORNEY AND URBAN PLANNER, AND I'M
07:07:36PM HERE AS YOUR FRIENDLY NEIGHBORHOOD CITIZEN AND AS HALLOWEEN
07:07:39PM IS COMING UP, MAYBE A WANNABE SPIDERMAN, I DON'T KNOW.
07:07:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I AM GOING TO BE THE RIDDLER.
07:07:45PM I AM.
07:07:46PM MY WIFE WILL BE CATWOMAN.
07:07:47PM YOU MAY SEE US AROUND.
07:07:49PM WE ALREADY HAVE THE COSTUMES.
07:07:52PM GO AHEAD, SIR.
07:07:53PM >> I I'M HERE BECAUSE I WANT TO SPEAK ON THIS AND SUPPORT
07:07:57PM IT.
07:07:57PM I HAVE A PHRASE THAT I ABSOLUTELY LOVE.
07:07:59PM BE WHO YOU SAY YOU ARE.
07:08:00PM NEW FOOTBALL COACH FOR USF, ALEX GOLISH.
07:08:05PM THAT IS HIS CATCHPHRASE.
07:08:06PM THE REASON I AM SHARING THIS IS THREEFOLD.
07:08:09PM ONE, USF AND ALABAMA PLAY ON SATURDAY.
07:08:12PM A HUGE GAME.
07:08:13PM IF YOU HAVEN'T GOTTEN YOUR TICKETS, GET THEM.
07:08:16PM IF NOT -- I THINK THEY ARE PROBABLY SOLD OUT.
07:08:20PM I AM A SHAMELESS SHILL FOR USF ATHLETICS.
07:08:26PM BUT THIRD, AN APPROPRIATE PHRASE FOR WHAT IS GOING ON WITH
07:08:30PM THE CITY OF TAMPA.
07:08:31PM VISION ZERO.
07:08:32PM TRAFFIC AND ENGINEERING.
07:08:34PM THE TRAFFIC DEPARTMENT IS WORKING ON THAT.
07:08:37PM ENCOURAGING TRANSIT DEVELOPMENT.
07:08:39PM AND HERE WE ARE TAMPA HEIGHTS CITIZENRY, WE HAD TO DRAFT OUR
07:08:44PM OWN OVERLAY.
07:08:45PM I WAS THE ONE THAT INITIATED THE VERY FIRST DRAFT OF THIS
07:08:48PM OVERLAY.
07:08:49PM IT HAS CHANGED SIGNIFICANTLY SINCE I FIRST DRAFTED IT, AND I
07:08:54PM AM SO PROUD OF WHAT WE HAVE DONE AS A COMMUNITY TO FOSTER
07:08:58PM AND ENCOURAGE THIS OVERLAY -- THE ADOPTION OF THIS OVERLAY.
07:09:02PM THE CITIZENS HERE ARE BEING WHO THEY SAY THEY ARE.
07:09:05PM AND I HOPE THE CITY ALSO DOES THE SAME.
07:09:09PM THIS IS AN INCENTIVE-BASED OVERLAY DISTRICT.
07:09:16PM IT IS CARROT, NOT STICK.
07:09:21PM MY KIDDO AND I -- HE IS ABOUT TO TURN SIX.
07:09:25PM IF YOU ARE WATCHING, HAPPY EARLY BIRTHDAY.
07:09:27PM BUT SOMETIMES I LIKE TO JOKE THAT HE IS SIX GOING ON EIGHT
07:09:31PM BECAUSE WE LOVE TO WALK AROUND THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND PICK UP
07:09:34PM TRASH.
07:09:34PM HE USING HIS GRABBER TO PICK UP TRASH.
07:09:38PM IF THIS OVERLAY IS ADOPTED AND INCENTIVIZES A DEVELOPER,
07:09:43PM JUST ONE, TO USE THE ALLEYWAY AND FOSTER MORE WALKABILITY,
07:09:47PM THAT IS ONE LESS CAR THAT SANTIAGO AND I WILL HAVE TO DODGE
07:09:51PM AS WE PICK TRASH UP AROUND THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:09:53PM THOSE THAT OPPOSE THIS, POTENTIALLY OPPOSE IT FOR A
07:09:59PM MULTITUDE OF REASONS.
07:10:00PM AS YOU HEARD EARLIER ON IN THE RECORD, IT WAS WELL
07:10:03PM ADVERTISED.
07:10:03PM THE CITIZENRY GOT VERY INVOLVED WITH ALL STAKEHOLDERS
07:10:08PM INCLUDING DEVELOPERS THAT WANTED TO CHIME IN.
07:10:09PM THAT IS WHY THE DRAFT HAS GONE THROUGH NUMEROUS ITERATIONS.
07:10:13PM AT THIS POINT I THINK THEY CHOSE NOT TO BE INVOLVED.
07:10:16PM THEY ARE LAZY.
07:10:17PM THEY ARE POSSIBLY UNINVENTED AND POSSIBLY UNINSPIRED.
07:10:22PM YOU CAN'T MAKE MONEY IN TAMPA HEIGHTS, BUILDING IN TAMPA
07:10:25PM HEIGHTS, I DON'T KNOW WHAT TO TELL YOU.
07:10:27PM THIS PROVIDES THE CITIZENS OF TAMPA ONE MORE TOOL TO BE WHO
07:10:32PM WE SAY WE ARE.
07:10:34PM I DO WANT A FEW MORE SECONDS IF I MAY TO JUST FINISH MY
07:10:38PM THOUGHTS.
07:10:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHAT IS THE PLEASURE OF THE BOARD.
07:10:42PM 30 MORE SECONDS, SIR.
07:10:44PM >> THANK YOU, CHAIRMAN.
07:10:46PM THIS GIVES US ONE MORE TOOL TO DO WHAT WE SAY WE ARE.
07:10:50PM I AM GLAD YOU BROUGHT THIS UP, CHAIRMAN.
07:10:52PM WE LOOK STORMWATER INFRASTRUCTURE.
07:10:54PM WE CAN'T AFFORD TO WAIT ON FDOT TO DO WORK TO TAMPA AND
07:10:59PM FLORIDA AVENUE.
07:11:00PM WE NEED ALL THE TOOLS WE CAN GET.
07:11:02PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON, I URGE TO YOU LOOK AT THE CAPITAL
07:11:05PM IMPROVEMENT PROJECT LIST, NOT ONE STORMWATER INFRASTRUCTURE
07:11:08PM ON THAT LIST IN TAMPA HEIGHTS.
07:11:10PM WE ARE A NEIGHBORHOOD IN NEED OF TENDER LOVING CARE, TLC,
07:11:15PM OKAY.
07:11:15PM PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE, SEE THAT THERE IS COMPETENT
07:11:20PM SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE IN THE RECORD FOR THE ADOPTION OF THIS
07:11:23PM OVERLAY AND PLEASE GIVE US TOMORROW TLC.
07:11:26PM AND BE WHO YOU SAY YOU ARE.
07:11:28PM THANK YOU.
07:11:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
07:11:30PM NEXT SPEAKER.
07:11:31PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:11:32PM >> HELLO, EVERYBODY.
07:11:33PM MATTEN CASIN, AND I CAN'T FOLLOW UP WITH CAMILLO.
07:11:39PM HE IS ACTUALLY MY NEIGHBOR.
07:11:40PM I WANT TO SAY I AM FOR THE OVERLAY BECAUSE WALKABILITY IS
07:11:44PM VERY IMPORTANT.
07:11:45PM I DIDN'T REALIZE HOW IMPORTANT IT IS -- UNTIL I MOVED TO
07:11:48PM TAMPA HEIGHTS.
07:11:49PM I HAVE A WIFE.
07:11:50PM MY DAUGHTER IS 17 MONTHS OLD.
07:11:52PM AND TO BE HONEST WITH YOU, WE LIVE A STRESSFUL LIFE, THE
07:11:57PM HUSTLE AND BUSTLE, BUT WALKING AND RIDING OUR BIKES IN THE
07:12:01PM NEIGHBORHOOD IS SOMETHING THAT IS REALLY GREAT.
07:12:02PM AND HOPEFULLY OTHER FAMILIES CAN EXPERIENCE THAT TYPE OF
07:12:05PM STUFF.
07:12:06PM I AM FOR THAT REASON.
07:12:07PM AND I WILL BE VERY SHORT.
07:12:09PM I JUST WANT TO SAY I AM FOR IT.
07:12:10PM BUT THE FLOOD ISSUE AS WELL.
07:12:13PM I KNOW YOU BROUGHT THAT UP.
07:12:15PM WE HAVE -- WE HAVE A LOT OF FLOODING GOING ON IN OUR EV AS
07:12:20PM WELL.
07:12:20PM IT DOESN'T TAKE MUCH RAIN FOR US TO GET FLOODED AND POOR
07:12:25PM CAMILO'S HOUSE IS BELOW OURS AND HE GETS FLOODED.
07:12:29PM KEEP AN EYE ON THAT FOR US.
07:12:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
07:12:32PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:12:32PM NEXT SPEAKER.
07:12:34PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:12:35PM >> GOOD EVENING, JORDAN STARR, REPRESENTING ELLISON
07:12:40PM DEVELOPMENT.
07:12:40PM WE ARE WORKING WITH THE CENTRAL CITY YMCA ON REZONING AND
07:12:45PM MASTER PLAN IN TAMPA HEIGHTS AND WE ARE WORKING AS HARD TO
07:12:48PM MAKE IT AS WALKABLE WORKING WITH THE CIVIC HOLDERS OF THE
07:12:54PM TAMPA HEIGHTS ASSOCIATION AND WANTED TO SUPPORT THE OVERLAY.
07:12:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:12:58PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:12:59PM >> VINCENT SCOTT.
07:13:01PM I HAVE BEEN A RESIDENT OF TAMPA HEIGHTS SINCE ABOUT 28
07:13:05PM YEARS.
07:13:05PM I SEE A LOT OF MY NEIGHBORS AND PEOPLE YOU SEE THROUGH THE
07:13:09PM NEIGHBORHOOD THROUGHOUT THE YEARS.
07:13:11PM IF YOU DON'T LIVE IN TAMPA HEIGHTS, YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU
07:13:14PM ARE MISSING.
07:13:15PM IT IS A GREAT PLACE.
07:13:16PM SOME PEOPLE -- YOU KNOW, I GREW UP IN SPRINGFIELD, MASS.
07:13:20PM BUT BORN HERE AND GREW UP IN -- IT REMINDS YOU OF A SMALL
07:13:24PM NEW ENGLAND COMMUNITY, IT REALLY DOES.
07:13:26PM IT IS UNIQUE.
07:13:27PM WHAT -- WHEN I DISCOVERED TAMPA HEIGHTS, I WAS DOING A PAPER
07:13:32PM AT USF.
07:13:35PM DISCOVERED SANDY FREEMAN CHALLENGE FUND PROGRAM WHICH SHE
07:13:39PM DESCRIBED -- IF HER SLOGAN WAS, IF YOU ARE DOING CRACK, YOU
07:13:43PM BETTER PACK.
07:13:44PM SHE WAS BULLDOZING DOWN ALL THE HISTORIC HOMES AND SOMEBODY
07:13:48PM SAID, WAIT, WAIT, LET'S PRESERVE THIS NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:13:50PM IT IS UNIQUE.
07:13:52PM AND IT TRULY IS.
07:13:53PM ONE OF THE THINGS I WANT TO ELABORATE ON IS THAT I AM FOR
07:13:57PM THE OVERLAY PROJECT.
07:13:58PM ALSO, THE ALLEYWAY -- THE ALLEYWAYS.
07:14:02PM IF WE CAN GET THOSE ALLEYWAYS PAVED AGAIN BECAUSE THAT WOULD
07:14:08PM ENCOURAGE PEOPLE TO BUILD HOUSING ON THE BACK AND HAVE ENTRY
07:14:11PM WAYS -- SO LAST THING WE NEED IS MORE CARS.
07:14:13PM YOU DON'T EVEN NEED A CAR IN TAMPA HEIGHTS.
07:14:17PM I RODE MY BIKE DOWN HERE.
07:14:20PM I RIDE MY BIKE TO SPROUTS OR PUBLIX OR JUMP ON THE STREETCAR
07:14:25PM OR PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION.
07:14:27PM SO WITH EVERYTHING -- SINCE I'M THE LAST ONE UP.
07:14:31PM IT IS ALL TRUE.
07:14:32PM OKAY.
07:14:32PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:14:33PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
07:14:35PM THANK YOU, SIR.
07:14:46PM >> GOOD EVENING, MY NAME IS STEPHANIE POYNOR.
07:14:50PM I AM PRESIDENT OF T.H.A.N.
07:14:51PM I'M HERE TONIGHT BECAUSE WE SUPPORTED IT.
07:14:53PM WE DON'T VOTE VERY OFTEN TO SUPPORT AND DENY THINGS, BUT I
07:14:58PM WANT TO YOU KNOW THAT THE WHOLE T.H.A.N. COMMUNITY WAS IN
07:15:01PM SUPPORT OF THIS.
07:15:01PM I WENT TO ONE OF THE CHARRETTES.
07:15:04PM MY FIRST CONCEPT.
07:15:05PM I THOUGHT JESUS WOULD COME BACK BEFORE THIS THING GOT IN
07:15:09PM FRONT OF YOU GUYS.
07:15:09PM BECAUSE IT HAS BEEN GOING ON FOREVER.
07:15:11PM I DON'T KNOW WHY, BUT IT HAS.
07:15:15PM THE NEIGHBORS, I DON'T CARE WHAT ANYBODY SAYS, IF THEY COME
07:15:19PM UP BEHIND ME, I WANT TO LET EVERYBODY KNOW THAT THE
07:15:22PM NEIGHBORHOODS SHOULD MAKE THE DECISIONS ABOUT WHAT THEY WANT
07:15:24PM IN THEIR NEIGHBORHOODS.
07:15:25PM I DON'T LIVE -- I DON'T LIVE IN TAMPA HEIGHTS.
07:15:28PM AND UP COULDN'T POSSIBLY SAY WHAT THEY NEED IN THEIR
07:15:33PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:15:33PM AND I DON'T CARE WHO COMES SHOPPING UP HERE TO TELL YOU THAT
07:15:38PM THEY NEED TO DO THIS AND THEY NEED TO DO THAT.
07:15:41PM THE ONLY PEOPLE WHO SHOULD BE MAKING DECISIONS FOR THE
07:15:45PM NEIGHBORHOODS ARE THE NEIGHBORHOODS.
07:15:46PM THEY DON'T COME TO MY NEIGHBORHOOD AND TELL ME WHAT TO DO
07:15:49PM IN S.O.G.
07:15:50PM SO I DON'T GO THERE.
07:15:52PM I WANT THEM TO BE SUPPORTED.
07:15:53PM WE LEARNED THAT VERY QUICKLY.
07:15:55PM THAT WAS ONE OF THE FIRST THINGS THAT CARROLL ANN AND I
07:16:00PM LEARNED.
07:16:01PM WE ASKED COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
07:16:02PM WHAT IS YOUR DENSITY.
07:16:03PM WHAT HAVE THEY BEEN APPROVING?
07:16:07PM SHE WAS LIKE, WHAT?
07:16:10PM S.O.G. IS THE ONLY PLACE TO KEEP THE DENSITY DOWN.
07:16:12PM TOTALLY DIFFERENT WORLD.
07:16:14PM THEY WANTED DENSITY, WE DIDN'T.
07:16:16PM THE NEIGHBORHOODS ARE THE MOST IMPORTANT PART OF THE CITY.
07:16:18PM AND WHAT BRIAN AND WHAT ALL THESE OTHER FOLKS HAVE WORKED
07:16:23PM THEIR BUTTS OFF TO MAKE HAPPEN, THE CITY -- IT WOULD HAVE
07:16:29PM COST THEM THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS, PROBABLY HUNDREDS OF
07:16:31PM THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS.
07:16:32PM THEY HAD SIGNS -- I DON'T LEAVE MY NEIGHBORHOOD VERY OFTEN.
07:16:36PM I VERY RARELY COME NORTH OF KENNEDY AND THEY HAD SIGNS UP.
07:16:41PM I SAW THEM.
07:16:42PM IF ANYONE DIDN'T WANT TO COME AND PARTICIPATE AND THEY SHOW
07:16:45PM UP TONIGHT AND W HINE AND COMPLAIN, OH, THE NEIGHBORHOODS
07:16:49PM DIDN'T IT TELL US.
07:16:50PM NO.
07:16:51PM THAT IS BECAUSE OF THEIR OWN IGNORANCE BECAUSE THEY CHOSE
07:16:54PM NOT TO PARTICIPATE UNTIL NOW.
07:16:55PM THANK YOU.
07:16:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
07:16:57PM ANYBODY ELSE IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK?
07:17:00PM BECAUSE I SEE ONE REGISTERED SPEAKER BRIAN TURNBILL.
07:17:06PM >>CLERK: HE IS NOT ON.
07:17:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FROM COUNCILMEMBERS BEFORE
07:17:11PM WE GO TO REBUTTAL.
07:17:12PM >>LUIS VIERA: I WANTED TO WAIT TO SPEAK UNTIL AFTER PUBLIC
07:17:14PM COMMENT.
07:17:15PM JUST SAYING I APPRECIATE HOW MUCH COMING OUT.
07:17:17PM MR. SEEL, OBVIOUSLY AN AMAZING FIRST-CLASS NEIGHBORHOOD
07:17:21PM LEADER AND EVERYBODY RESPECTS YOU FOR THAT AND SO MUCH MORE.
07:17:25PM EVERYBODY WHO IS HERE.
07:17:25PM I LOOK FORWARD TO SUPPORTS THIS AND VOTING ON THIS.
07:17:28PM I LOVE TAMPA HEIGHTS.
07:17:30PM HYPE LATE GREAT GRANDFATHER JUAN CIVILIO USED TO LIVE ON
07:17:37PM ROSS, GOSH, 80 YEARS AGO.
07:17:38PM HE USED TO RUN HIS MEDICINE PRACTICE -- HE WAS A DOCTOR AND
07:17:42PM PRACTICE MEDICINE THERE.
07:17:43PM HE WAS A DOCTOR AT CENTRO ESTU RANO HOSPITAL.
07:17:50PM HE WAS BORN IN CUBA AND CAME FROM CUBA, BUT HE PRACTICED
07:17:56PM MEDICINE ON ROSS, AND I CHECKED OUT THE HOME NOT LONG AGO AND
07:18:00PM RECENTLY SOLD FOR $1 MILLION.
07:18:01PM MISS YOUNG, YOU TALKING ABOUT THE NEIGHBORHOOD CHANGING.
07:18:05PM TIMES, THEY ARE ACHANGING.
07:18:08PM I LOVE DEEPLY TAMPA HEIGHTS.
07:18:10PM MY GREAT GRANDMOTHER WITH WHOM I GREW UP WITH, SHE WAS IN
07:18:14PM TAMPA HEIGHTS FOR A NUMBER OF YEAR, ROMANA CIVILIO.
07:18:19PM IT IS DEEP IN MY HEART.
07:18:20PM THIS IS A VERY HEARTFELT YES.
07:18:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE.
07:18:24PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK AND COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
07:18:27PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
07:18:27PM I WANT TO SAY HOW HAPPY I AM FOR THE RESIDENTS OF TAMPA
07:18:31PM HEIGHTS TO FINALLY GET HERE.
07:18:32PM I REMEMBER HEARING ABOUT THIS BEFORE I EVEN JOINED COUNCIL
07:18:36PM WHEN I WAS WORKING WITH MY NEIGHBORHOOD OF SEMINOLE HEIGHTS.
07:18:38PM AND I AM SO -- AND EVERY TIME WE WOULD TALK, I HEARD SO MANY
07:18:42PM RESIDENTS SAY, WE WANT WHAT SEMINOLE HEIGHTS HAS.
07:18:46PM AND YOU WENT AHEAD AND BUILT IT FOR YOURSELF.
07:18:49PM YOU SHOULD BE INCREDIBLY PROUD OF IT.
07:18:51PM IT IS VERY WONDERFUL, AND I HOPE THAT OTHER NEIGHBORHOODS USE
07:18:55PM THIS AS A MODEL FOR AN OVERLAY THAT THEY WOULD, THEMSELVES,
07:19:00PM WOULD WANT.
07:19:00PM THANK YOU.
07:19:02PM AND OF COURSE WE WILL BE WHOLEHEARTEDLY SUPPORTING.
07:19:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CARLSON AND THEN MIRANDA.
07:19:08PM >>BILL CARLSON: THANK YOU TO THE COMMUNITY FOR ORGANIZING
07:19:11PM THIS.
07:19:11PM BRIAN, DID YOU LEAD THE WHOLE PROCESS?
07:19:15PM >> I DID.
07:19:15PM >>BILL CARLSON: FANTASTIC.
07:19:16PM THANK YOU FOR YOUR LEADERSHIP.
07:19:17PM YOU ALWAYS SHOW THE LEADERSHIP.
07:19:20PM THANK YOU FOR LEADING THAT OUTSTANDING PRESENTATION.
07:19:22PM VERY THOROUGH.
07:19:23PM IF EVERY CITY PROJECT HAD THIS KIND OF PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT AND
07:19:28PM POLICY DETAIL, THEY WOULD GO THROUGH VERY SMOOTHLY.
07:19:32PM SO APPRECIATE IT.
07:19:33PM LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING WHAT YOU ARE GOING TO DO NEXT.
07:19:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
07:19:37PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THANK YOU ALL FOR BEING HERE.
07:19:39PM VERY PROFESSIONALLY DONE.
07:19:41PM YOU CAN SEE WHEN YOU CAME TO SPEAK, THERE WAS A GLIMMER IN
07:19:44PM YOUR EYE.
07:19:44PM AND EVERYBODY WAS POSITIVE.
07:19:46PM SO THERE WAS THE SAME BOAT GOING THE SAME PLACE AND WAITING
07:19:50PM EVERYTHING DONE THE RIGHT WAY.
07:19:51PM SO I WANT TO SAY CONGRATULATIONS.
07:19:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
07:19:55PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THANK YOU SO MUCH.
07:19:57PM CONGRATULATIONS TO MY COMMUNITY.
07:19:59PM I CAN SEE ALL THE HARD WORK THAT YOU PUT INTO THIS.
07:20:03PM I AM SO PROUD.
07:20:05PM EVEN TO BE CHALLENGED BY IT AND QUESTIONED ABOUT IT WHEN I
07:20:08PM WAS ON THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL.
07:20:10PM IT ALLOWED ME TO DIVE INTO TO FIGURE OUT THE THINGS THAT
07:20:13PM HAVE BEEN GOING ON IN MY COMMUNITY WHILE I WAS BEEN BUSY
07:20:17PM TAKING CARE OF A MOTHER AND RAISING A CHILD.
07:20:20PM I BELIEVE IN TAMPA HEIGHTS A LONG, LONG TIME AGO WHEN PEOPLE
07:20:24PM THOUGHT I WAS CRAZY.
07:20:25PM IT WAS TOUGH IN THE VERY BEGINNING.
07:20:28PM AND NOW IT IS JUST SUCH A BEAUTIFUL PLACE.
07:20:31PM IT IS EXTREMELY DIVERSE.
07:20:33PM AND YOU ALL CREATED A PLAN THAT SHOWS HOW INCLUSIVE WE ARE.
07:20:38PM AND YOU DID IT ON YOUR OWN WITH THE SUPPORT OF, YOU KNOW,
07:20:43PM OUR -- OUR FOLKS HERE ON STAFF AND YOU CAN HEAR EVERYONE UP
07:20:46PM HERE ON THE DAIS IS PROUD OF YOU.
07:20:49PM I HAVE ASKED THE CHAIR IF I COULD MOVE THE MOTION.
07:20:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WAIT.
07:20:53PM WE WILL GET REBUTTAL AND THEN GO RIGHT TO YOU.
07:20:56PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: OKAY, GO RIGHT AHEAD.
07:20:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. SEEL, I THINK YOU HAVE THE VOTES.
07:21:02PM BUT DO YOU HAVE REBUTTAL.
07:21:04PM >> I DON'T BELIEVE THERE IS ANYTHING TO REBUT.
07:21:07PM THANK YOU ALL VERY MUCH FOR YOUR SUPPORT OF THIS.
07:21:09PM WE TALKED TO MANY OF YOU THROUGHOUT THIS PROCESS.
07:21:12PM AND WE ARE PROUD TO HAVE THIS BE A COMMUNITY-LED EFFORT.
07:21:17PM AND WE ARE -- WE ARE JUST GRATEFUL FOR ALL THAT AS WELL AS
07:21:22PM ALL THE STAFF SUPPORT ALONG THE WAY FROM LACHONE AND STEVEN
07:21:26PM AND THROUGHOUT.
07:21:27PM THANK YOU.
07:21:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
07:21:30PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WANT TO SAY AGAIN, CONGRATULATIONS.
07:21:33PM I TALKED TO MR. SEEL OUT IN THE HALL AND A TREMENDOUS JOB OF
07:21:37PM WHAT YOU HAVE DONE IN THIS.
07:21:38PM I WANT TO POINT OUT HOW AMAZING THIS NEIGHBORHOOD IS GOING
07:21:41PM TO LOOK LIKE WITH THE STREETCAR RUNNING UP FLORIDA AND BACK
07:21:44PM DOWN TAMPA THANK YOU SO MUCH.
07:21:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT, A MOTION TO CLOSE.
07:21:48PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SO MOVED.
07:21:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA AND
07:21:53PM SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN .
07:21:54PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON, DO THE HONORS.
07:21:56PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR, FOR THE OPPORTUNITY
07:22:00PM MOVE THIS MOTION --
07:22:01PM >> IF I MAY.
07:22:02PM SORRY.
07:22:02PM I KNOW.
07:22:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THERE IS A SUBSTITUTE.
07:22:07PM >>DANA CROSBY COLLIER: DANA CROSBY COLLIER WITH THE
07:22:08PM ATTORNEY'S OFFICE.
07:22:09PM YES, SIR, WE HAVE SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT IF YOU CAN MOVE THAT.
07:22:14PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I HAVE IT RIGHT HERE.
07:22:16PM THANK YOU.
07:22:17PM WITH GREAT PLEASURE, I MOVE FILE NUMBER E 2023-8 CHAPTER 27,
07:22:33PM FIRST PUBLIC HEARING OF THE ORDINANCE OF CITY COMPANY MAKING
07:22:36PM REVISIONS TO THE CITY OF TAMPA CODE OF ORDINANCES CHAPTER
07:22:40PM 27, ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT, AMENDING SECTION 27-156,
07:22:44PM OFFICIAL SCHEDULE OF DISTRICT REGULATIONS CREATING SECTION
07:22:47PM 27-244, TAMPA HEIGHTS OVERLAY DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT
07:22:51PM STANDARDS, REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES OR PARTS OF ORDINANCES
07:22:55PM IN CONFLICT THEREWITH, PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING
07:23:01PM AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
07:23:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON AND
07:23:06PM A SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
07:23:07PM MAY WE HAVE A ROLL CALL VOTE.
07:23:10PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
07:23:13PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
07:23:14PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
07:23:16PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
07:23:18PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
07:23:19PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
07:23:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
07:23:22PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
07:23:24PM SECOND PUBLIC HEARING IS SCHEDULED FOR OCTOBER 5, 2023 AT
07:23:29PM 10:30 A.M. AT OLD CITY HALL, 315 E. KENNEDY BOULEVARD,
07:23:36PM THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
07:23:39PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: MAY I ASK A QUESTION?
07:23:44PM [APPLAUSE]
07:23:55PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: COUNCIL, ITEM NUMBER 5 IS REZ-23-35 --
07:24:06PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WAIT A MINUTE FOR THE NOISE -- WAIT FOR
07:24:09PM THEM TO STEP OUT.
07:24:10PM OKAY, HERE WE GO.
07:24:32PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
07:24:35PM THIS IS REZ-23-35, ITEM NUMBER 5.
07:24:39PM PROPERTY AT 2204 EAST 15th AVENUE.
07:24:43PM THE APPLICANT IS REPRESENTED BY STEVE MICHELINI.
07:24:46PM THE REQUEST FROM RM-24 RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY TO PD,
07:24:51PM PLANNED DEVELOPMENT FOR THE USE OF RESIDENTIAL-SINGLE-FAMILY
07:24:55PM ATTACHED AND TURN IT OVER TO DAVID TO GIVE HIS REPORT.
07:24:59PM >>DAVID HEY: GOOD EVENING, COUNCILMEMBERS, DAVID HEY
07:25:05PM WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
07:25:07PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
07:25:07PM NEXT REZONING CASE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE CENTRAL TAMPA
07:25:11PM PLANNING DISTRICT AND MORE SPECIFICALLY THE NORTH YBOR
07:25:14PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:25:14PM THE CLOSEST PUBLIC RECREATION FACILITY IS AL BARNES PARK AND
07:25:21PM CASCADIAN PARK.
07:25:23PM THEY ARE APPROXIMATELY ONE MILE FROM THE SUBJECT SITE.
07:25:26PM THERE IS TRANSIT LOCATED JUST TO THE NORTH OF THE SUBJECT
07:25:29PM SITE ALONG EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE AND NORTH 22nd STREET.
07:25:32PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN THE COASTAL PLANS AREA,
07:25:36PM SPECIFICALLY EVACUATION ZONE E.
07:25:39PM WE HAVE AN AERIAL OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
07:25:48PM YOU CAN SEE THE SUBJECT SITE RIGHT IN THE CENTER.
07:25:52PM OF COURSE INTERSTATE 4 IS DIRECTLY TO THE SOUTH.
07:25:56PM NORTH 22ND STREET IS TO THE WEST.
07:26:03PM THE SURROUNDING AREA CHARACTERIZED BY MIXTURE OF RESIDENTIAL
07:26:08PM USES.
07:26:09PM RESIDENTIAL USES TO THE EAST ALONG 15th AVENUE.
07:26:12PM COMMERCE USES TO THE WEST OF THE SITE ALONG NORTH 22nd
07:26:16PM STREET AND INTERSTATE 4 IS TO THE SOUTH.
07:26:18PM HERE WE HAVE THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP THE SUBJECT SITE AND
07:26:26PM PROPERTIES TO THE EAST AND NORTH ARE IN THE DARK BROWN
07:26:29PM COLOR, THE RESIDENTIAL-35 LAND USE CATEGORY.
07:26:34PM IMMEDIATELY TO THE WEST IS THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35
07:26:38PM CATEGORY.
07:26:38PM AND ON THE OTHER SIDE AS YOU CONTINUE TO MOVE WESTWARD, THIS
07:26:45PM IS RESIDENTIAL-20.
07:26:46PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS AGAIN WITHIN THAT RESIDENTIAL-35 --
07:26:56PM >> ARE WE GOING TO HAVE MORE COUNCILMEMBERS COME BACK.
07:26:59PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THEY WILL.
07:27:00PM WE HAVE A QUORUM.
07:27:04PM >> ARE THEY MONITORING THIS?
07:27:07PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WE HAVE THE MONITORS ON BACK.
07:27:08PM >> SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED RESIDENTIAL USES CAN BE CONSIDERED
07:27:12PM IN THIS PLAN CATEGORY UP TO 35 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE --
07:27:17PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: EXCUSE ME FOR ONE SECOND.
07:27:21PM CAN YOU PLEASE REMAIN SILENT AND TAKE YOUR CONVERSATIONS
07:27:25PM OUTSIDE IF YOU NEED TO SPEAK.
07:27:26PM PLEASE CONTINUE.
07:27:29PM >>DAVID HEY: THE DENSITY ON EAST 14th STREET BETWEEN NORTH
07:27:32PM 22nd STREET AND NORTH 24th STREET IS 8.86 UNITS PER ACRE
07:27:38PM BASED ON SEVEN SAMPLE SITES.
07:27:40PM IF APPROVED, WILL DEVELOP AT A DENSITY OF 17 UNITS PER ACRE,
07:27:45PM WHICH IS CONSISTENT WITH THE DENSITY ANTICIPATED UNDER THAT
07:27:48PM RESIDENTIAL-35 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
07:27:50PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF DID REVIEW THE SITE PLAN.
07:27:57PM THE SITE PLAN MEETS POLICY DIRECTION INVOLVING THE
07:28:02PM ORIENTATION OF THE FRONT OF THE BUILDING AND THE DOORS TO
07:28:04PM THE STREET.
07:28:05PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PROMOTES A RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
07:28:08PM PATTERN COMPACT TO THE CITY FORM AND INCREASED OF HOUSING
07:28:14PM AND DENSITY THAT PROMOTE WALKING AND INTRINSIC USE AND
07:28:19PM EMPLOYMENT CONCENTRATIONS AND AMENITIES.
07:28:21PM THE REQUEST SUPPORTS THIS POLICY DIRECTION BECAUSE THE SITE
07:28:25PM IS WITHIN PROXIMITY OF TRANSIT AND AMENITIES OF EAST
07:28:29PM COLUMBUS DRIVE.
07:28:30PM THE REZONING IS ALSO CONSISTENT WITH INFILL POLICIES WITHIN
07:28:36PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN THAT DIRECTS THE GREATEST SHARE OF GROWTH
07:28:40PM TO THE CITY'S URBAN VILLAGES.
07:28:43PM IN CONCLUSION, THE D HAS A DEVELOPMENT THAT IS COMPARABLE
07:28:46PM AND COMPATIBLE WHERE THE SURROUNDING DEVELOPMENT PATTERN AND
07:28:49PM CONSISTENT WITH THE DENSITY UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-35 FUTURE
07:28:52PM LAND USE DESIGNATION.
07:28:54PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
07:28:57PM FINDS THE PROPOSED PLANNED DEVELOPMENT CONSISTENT WITH THE
07:28:59PM PROVISIONS OF THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
07:29:02PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:29:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN?
07:29:05PM YES, MA'AM, GO AHEAD.
07:29:06PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, CHAIRMAN AND COUNCIL, LaCHONE
07:29:12PM DOCK WITH LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
07:29:14PM THIS REZONINGS REQUEST FOR A PD WOULD ALLOW FOR THE
07:29:18PM SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED USES ON-SITE.
07:29:20PM A TOTAL OF FOUR UNITS ARE REQUESTED.
07:29:22PM THE PROPERTY CONTAINS 9970 SQUARE FEET.
07:29:26PM THEY -- THE MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT IS PROPOSED AT 40 FEET
07:29:30PM FOR THREE STORIES.
07:29:31PM THE SETBACKS ARE LISTED AS THE NORTH AT NINE FEET.
07:29:36PM TO THE SOUTH IS 21 FEET.
07:29:38PM TO THE WEST IS 5 FEET AND TO THE EAST IS 29 FEET.
07:29:41PM NINE PARKING SPACES ARE REQUIRED AND PROVIDED ON-SITE.
07:29:45PM AND I WOULD LIKE TO SHOW THIS SITE PLAN OF THE PROPERTY.
07:29:51PM THIS PROPERTY IS LOCATED IN THE EAST TAMPA OVERLAY SO IT
07:29:55PM MUST MEET THE STANDARDS OF THE EAST TAMPA OVERLAY CODE AT
07:29:58PM THE TIME OF PERMITTING.
07:30:00PM ONE WAIVER TO THE EAST TAMPA OVERLAY THAT IS REQUESTED TO
07:30:03PM THE REAR YARD.
07:30:04PM AND THEN -- LET ME ZOOM IN A LITTLE BIT ON THE SITE.
07:30:08PM THIS IS THE SITE THAT IS LOCATED -- THIS IS 15th AVENUE.
07:30:12PM THIS DOTTED LINE IS THE PROPERTY LIFE.
07:30:15PM THE PROPERTY BOUNDARY.
07:30:16PM THIS IS THE STRUCTURE.
07:30:18PM AND THERE ARE A TOTAL OF FOUR UNITS LOCATED WITHIN IT.
07:30:21PM SO THEY ARE SIDED AS UNIT 1, 2, 3 AND 4.
07:30:26PM EACH UNIT HAS AN ENCLOSED TWO-CAR GARAGE.
07:30:30PM VEHICULAR ACCESS TO THE SITE IS ON THE SOUTH FROM 15th
07:30:34PM AVENUE.
07:30:34PM THERE IS ONE VISITOR SPACE THAT IS LOCATED HERE.
07:30:39PM UNITS 1, 2, AND 4, THE FRONT DOOR ENTRY FACES THE SIDE YARD.
07:30:44PM FOR UNIT 1, THE FRONT DOOR ENTRY FACES THE RIGHT-OF-WAY
07:30:49PM ALONG EAST 15th AVENUE.
07:30:50PM THERE ARE A TOTAL OF TWO REQUESTED WAIVERS.
07:30:54PM I DID MENTION ONE TO THE EAST TAMPA OVERLAY, AND THAT IS FOR
07:30:58PM THE REAR YARD.
07:30:58PM AND THE OTHER WAIVER IS TO ALLOW THE FRONT DOORS TO FACE THE
07:31:03PM FRONT YARDS AND THAT IS FOR UNITS 2 THROUGH 4 ON-SITE.
07:31:10PM AND I HAVE ELEVATION IS OF THE PROPERTY.
07:31:12PM SO AT THE TOP LEFT, THIS IS THE EAST ELEVATION, INTERNAL TO
07:31:19PM THE SITE VIEW.
07:31:21PM THIS IS THE WEST ELEVATION.
07:31:25PM THIS IS THE SOUTH ELEVATION WHICH IS FROM THE ACTUAL STREET
07:31:28PM FRONTAGE AND THIS IS THE NORTH ELEVATION.
07:31:30PM AND IF I CAN SHOW YOU THE ZONING MAP OF THE PROPERTY.
07:31:37PM SO THIS IS THE PROPERTY THAT IS IDENTIFIED HERE IN RED.
07:31:40PM THIS IS 15th AVENUE.
07:31:42PM AND JUST FOR ORIENTATION, THIS IS EAST COLUMBUS.
07:31:45PM THIS IS THE INTERSTATE WHERE IT IS LOCATED.
07:31:48PM AND THIS IS NORTH 22nd STREET.
07:31:51PM YOU CAN SEE THIS PROPERTY IS SURROUNDED WITH THE RM-24
07:31:55PM ZONING DISTRICT, THAT DESIGNATION AND THERE IS A CN,
07:31:59PM COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD, A COUPLE OF THOSE, NORTH AND
07:32:01PM NORTHEAST OF THE SITE AS YOU RUN ALONG 22nd STREET, YOU HAVE
07:32:05PM MORE OF THE COMMERCIAL ZONING AND FURTHER WEST, YOU GET BACK
07:32:09PM INTO YOUR RESIDENTIAL ZONING DISTRICTS.
07:32:14PM THIS PROPERTY IS IN THE BOUNDARY OF THE YBOR CITY SPECIAL
07:32:17PM DISTRICT BECAUSE YOU CAN SEE THE ZONING OF THE YC-2 WHICH IS
07:32:20PM FURTHER WEST AND THIS LINE HERE IS ACTUALLY THE BOUNDARY
07:32:24PM RIGHT AT THE PROPERTY AND THIS IS YC-5, YBOR CITY, THE
07:32:29PM COMMERCIAL DISTRICT.
07:32:30PM AND THEN HERE ARE PICTURES OF THE SITE.
07:32:34PM THIS IS THE SITE.
07:32:35PM LOOKING DIRECTLY AT THE SITE.
07:32:37PM HERE IS ANOTHER VIEW OF THE SITE.
07:32:39PM THIS IS THE RESIDENTIAL, WHICH IS LOCATED TO THE EAST.
07:32:47PM THIS IS A VIEW TO THE EAST.
07:32:49PM SO THIS IS LOOKING EAST ON 15th AVENUE.
07:32:52PM THE SITE IS BEHIND US ON THE LEFT IN THIS PICTURE.
07:32:56PM THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE.
07:33:00PM THE INTERSTATE, ANOTHER VIEW TO THE SOUTH.
07:33:05PM THIS IS DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE SITE.
07:33:07PM THAT IS A VIEW IF YOU WERE LOOKING THE OTHER WAY LOOKING
07:33:10PM WEST ON 15th.
07:33:11PM THE SITE IS OFF OF THIS PICTURE TO THE RIGHT.
07:33:13PM AND THIS IS DIRECTLY WEST OF THE SITE.
07:33:16PM IT THE DRC STAFF HAS REVIEWED THIS REQUEST AND FINDS THE
07:33:25PM REQUEST CONSISTENT.
07:33:25PM THERE ARE SITE PLAN MODIFICATIONS TO BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST
07:33:29PM AND SECOND READING OF THE ORDINANCE IF COUNCIL CHOOSES TO
07:33:32PM APPROVE.
07:33:33PM I AM AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
07:33:35PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
07:33:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
07:33:39PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: PUT THE OVERHEAD PLEASE.
07:33:42PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THE AERIAL MAP?
07:33:44PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE AERIAL MAP, YES, PLEASE.
07:33:47PM ANY OTHER MULTIFAMILY HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS IN THE AREA.
07:33:51PM OR ARE THEY ALL SINGLE-FAMILY?
07:33:55PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: WELL, I CAN'T SAY -- I CAN'T SAY BLOCKS AWAY
07:33:58PM WHAT WILL BE MULTIFAMILY.
07:34:00PM THERE WERE SINGLE-FAMILY WITHIN THE VIEW ON THIS BLOCK,
07:34:04PM ALTHOUGH IT IS ZONED MULTIFAMILY ON THIS SAME SIDE OF THE
07:34:08PM STREET, BUT I CAN'T TESTIFY TO --
07:34:10PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THIS PARTICULAR LOT IS RM-24, RIGHT?
07:34:14PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CORRECT.
07:34:16PM IT IS RM-24 BUT THEY ARE ASKING A PD ZONING.
07:34:20PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OKAY, THANK YOU.
07:34:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
07:34:25PM IF ALL RIGHT, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:34:28PM IF NOT, GO TO THE APPLICANT.
07:34:29PM MR. MICHELINI, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:34:31PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
07:34:36PM STEVE MICHELINI, REPRESENTING THE PETITIONER.
07:34:38PM JUST -- LET ME -- LET ME START BY SHOWING YOU A LITTLE BIT
07:34:48PM CLOSER VIEW OF WHAT IS GOING ON IN THE AREA.
07:34:51PM IS THAT VISIBLE?
07:34:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
07:34:53PM >> THAT'S -- THIS IS -- THIS IS A MULTIFAMILY -- YOU ASKED
07:34:57PM WHAT IS GOING ON IN THE AREA.
07:34:58PM THIS IS THE -- THIS IS THE AERIAL VIEW.
07:35:07PM AND THIS -- THIS GREEN AREA HERE IS OWNED BY D.O.T.
07:35:14PM AND SO ALL OF THESE PROJECTS, ALL OF THESE LITTLE HOUSES
07:35:17PM HERE AND APARTMENTS AND COMMERCIAL BUILDINGS HERE, THEY ALL
07:35:21PM FACE -- THEY FACE THE INTERSTATE.
07:35:24PM SO THEY ARE -- THIS IS AN IDEAL LOCATION FOR INFILL.
07:35:31PM THERE IS NOT MUCH ELSE HAPPENING HERE EXCEPT FOR THAT OTHER
07:35:35PM PROJECT THAT I SHOWED YOU THAT IS IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO
07:35:38PM THIS.
07:35:38PM BOTH THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND CITY STAFF FOUND IT TO BE
07:35:45PM CONSISTENT.
07:35:47PM THERE ARE SIDEWALK CONNECTIONS.
07:35:49PM AND THIS IS -- THIS DESIGN IS BASICALLY CONSIDERED TO BE
07:35:52PM WHAT IS CALLED A "GARDEN STYLE" WHICH HAS AMPLE GREEN SPACE.
07:35:57PM 1400 SQUARE FEET PROVIDED AND WE ARE PROVIDING 1400
07:36:05PM SQUARE FEET.
07:36:05PM NINE PARKING SPACES ARE REQUIRED AND WE ARE PROVIDING NINE
07:36:09PM PARKING SPACES.
07:36:10PM THE GARAGES ARE ENCLOSED.
07:36:12PM AND ACCORDING THE VARIANCE CRITERIA ESTABLISHED BY THE CITY,
07:36:16PM WE HAVE TO MEET THE CRITERIA REGARDING THE USE OF A PLANNED
07:36:21PM DEVELOPMENT.
07:36:21PM AND I WILL GO THROUGH THOSE VERY QUICKLY FOR YOU.
07:36:24PM PROMOTE THE EFFICIENT AND SUSTAINABLE USE OF LAND AND
07:36:28PM INFRASTRUCTURE.
07:36:28PM THIS PROPERTY ITSELF IS ELEVATED APPROXIMATELY TWO AND A
07:36:33PM HALF FEET OR THREE FEET ABOVE THE CROWN OF THE ROAD ON THE
07:36:36PM SOUTH SIDE.
07:36:37PM AND I THINK YOU CAN -- YOU CAN SEE THAT PROBABLY BETTER WITH
07:36:44PM -- WITH LACHONE'S PHOTO THAN MINE THERE IS A SIDEWALK, AND
07:36:56PM THEN A WALL AND EACH OF THESE UNITS WILL CONNECT WITH A
07:36:59PM COMMON SIDEWALK IS GOING DOWN TO THE RIGHT-OF-WAY PROMOTE
07:37:12PM THE USE OF LAND AND STORMWATER.
07:37:14PM WE HAVE SEWER AVAILABLE AND UTILIZING THAT FOR THE
07:37:20PM CONNECTION OF THIS PROJECT.
07:37:21PM ENCOURAGE FLEXIBLE LAND DEVELOPMENT.
07:37:23PM THIS AREA HAS A NUMBER OF VACANT LOTS.
07:37:26PM AS WE ARE TRYING TO PROVIDE MORE AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND
07:37:29PM HOUSING OPTIONS IN THE EAST TAMPA DISTRICT, THIS COMPLIES
07:37:33PM WITH THAT OBJECTIVE.
07:37:36PM PROMOTE AND ENCOURAGE DEVELOPMENT WHERE APPROPRIATE IN
07:37:40PM LOCATION OF CHARACTER AND COMPATIBILITY.
07:37:42PM THE PROJECT SOMEBODY COMPATIBLE AND DOES PROMOTE APPROPRIATE
07:37:48PM LAND USES AND DEVELOPMENT WITHIN AN AREA THAT IS BADLY
07:37:51PM NEEDING OF NEW HOUSING AND INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS.
07:37:53PM SO ANYTHING THAT WE CAN'T -- THAT -- THE INFRASTRUCTURE, IF
07:37:58PM IT HAS TO BE IMPROVED, THE DEVELOPER HAS TO PAY FOR THAT AND
07:38:02PM MAKE SURE THAT THOSE LINES ARE ALL INCLUDED IN THE
07:38:05PM DEVELOPMENT COST.
07:38:06PM SO IN AN OLDER AREA LIKE THIS, WE TYPICALLY RUN INTO THE
07:38:10PM FACT THAT THE WATER LINES ARE GENERALLY ARE TWO-INCH LINES.
07:38:15PM IF THAT IS NOT SUFFICIENT TO SUSTAIN THIS PROJECT, THE
07:38:18PM DEVELOPER WILL HAVE TO PAY AND INSTALL NEW WATER LINES FROM
07:38:21PM THE MAIN.
07:38:22PM NOT JUST ADJACENT TO THE PROPERTY.
07:38:24PM PROMOTE MORE DESIRABLE LIVING AND WORKING CONDITIONS AND
07:38:29PM ENVIRONMENT.
07:38:29PM THIS AREA HAS EXPERIENCED A LOT OF TRANSIENT POPULATIONS.
07:38:35PM AND THIS WILL HELP TO STABILIZE THAT.
07:38:39PM PROMOTE ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES AND THAT SURROUND THE AREA.
07:38:45PM THIS IS UNDERGOING DEVELOPMENT AND YOU SEE THE ELEVATIONS
07:38:48PM THAT ARE COMPATIBLE WITH THE AREA.
07:38:50PM PROMOTE THE RETENTION AND REUSE OF BUILDING OF STRUCTURES.
07:38:53PM THE STRUCTURE THAT WAS THERE WAS FALLING DOWN AND HAD TO BE
07:38:56PM REMOVED.
07:38:56PM IT COULD NOT BE SALVAGED.
07:39:03PM THIS STRUCTURE WILL PROVIDE FOUR NEW STRUCTURES.
07:39:07PM SIX COULD BE BUILT ON THE SITE IF YOU CAN MAKE THEM WORK ON
07:39:10PM THE SITE.
07:39:11PM TO WILL BE FROM OUR OPINION, THE OVERBUILDING OF THAT SITE.
07:39:15PM IT SIMPLY COULDN'T HOLD THE CAPACITY AND MEET THE OTHER
07:39:18PM REQUIREMENTS THAT ARE ESTABLISHED BY THE CITY CODE.
07:39:20PM THIS IS R-35.
07:39:23PM SO THE -- THE ANTICIPATION IS FOR THE LAND USE SIDE, THE
07:39:29PM ANTICIPATION IS FOR A HIGHER DENSITY USE AND THE CURRENT
07:39:32PM ZONING IS RM-24.
07:39:33PM SO WE ARE PLANNING TO -- TO MAKE THIS -- YOU KNOW, A NICE
07:39:40PM DEVELOPMENT.
07:39:40PM AND, AGAIN, IT TAKES AN UNDERUTILIZED PIECE OF PROPERTY,
07:39:45PM CONVERTS IT TO A BETTER AND HIGHER USE, AND ALSO PROVIDES
07:39:49PM HOUSE WHERE PREVIOUSLY IT WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN PROVIDED.
07:39:52PM I GO BACK TO THE AERIAL.
07:39:59PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
07:40:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: BRING IT UP ON THE -- FLORIDA WE GO.
07:40:04PM >> THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
07:40:05PM THIS ROADWAY, I WILL TELL YOU, ONLY HANDLES THE TRAFFIC FOR
07:40:09PM THOSE RESIDENTIAL UNITS FRONTING ON THE INTERSTATE.
07:40:12PM THIS PROPERTY IS OWNED BY D.O.T.
07:40:15PM IT WILL NEVER BE DEVELOPED.
07:40:17PM AND THE PROPERTY IS ELEVATED.
07:40:19PM SO I THINK THAT THIS MEETS THE CRITERIA OF THE STAFF AND THE
07:40:27PM PLANNING COMMISSION AND THE CITY STAFF AGREE.
07:40:28PM AND THIS IS A BETTER SHOT SHOWING YOU THE PROXIMITY OF THE
07:40:34PM INTERSTATE TO THIS PROPERTY.
07:40:35PM IT IS ONLY -- YOU KNOW, THE ONLY CONNECTION WITH A ONE-WAY
07:40:41PM STREET GOING NORTH AND YOU CONNECT WHICH FACES THE
07:40:44PM INTERSTATE THIS IS EAST TAMPA.
07:40:52PM IN DIRE STRAITS RECORDING NEW DEVELOPMENT AND THIS PROJECT
07:40:55PM DOES A LONG WAY OF MEETING GOALS AND OBJECTIVES.
07:40:57PM WE GREATLY APPRECIATE YOUR CONSIDERATION AND WILL BE HAPPY
07:41:01PM TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
07:41:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS?
07:41:05PM YES, MA'AM, COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
07:41:06PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
07:41:07PM YOU MENTIONED THIS IS RM-24 ZONING.
07:41:11PM >> YES.
07:41:12PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WHY CAN'T YOU BUILD WITHIN THAT ZONING THAT
07:41:15PM IS ALREADY MULTIFAMILY?
07:41:21PM THAT IS MY QUESTION.
07:41:23PM >> OTHER CRITERIA TO MEET WITH RM-24 ZONING INCLUDING THE
07:41:28PM SETBACKS AND ORIENTATION.
07:41:29PM AND IT IS DIFFICULT.
07:41:30PM AND ONE -- I HAD THIS DISCUSSION WITH OTHER COUNCILMEMBERS
07:41:35PM BEFORE.
07:41:35PM WHEN THEY ESTABLISHED THE TRADITIONAL ZONING
07:41:40PM CLASSIFICATIONS, THEY PUT IN CERTAIN CRITERIA.
07:41:43PM AND ON TOP OF THAT AFTERWARDS, THEY INCLUDED OTHER THINGS
07:41:46PM LIKE 350 SQUARE FEET OF GREEN SPACE PER UNIT.
07:41:50PM THEY INCLUDED SOME OTHER CRITERIA, THE PARKING AND SIZE OF
07:41:54PM THAT AND HOW YOU ACCESS OTHER PORTIONS.
07:41:56PM OTHER CRITERIA AS WELL THAT SIMPLY CAN'T MEET UNDER THE
07:42:02PM STANDARD ZONING CRITERIA.
07:42:06PM I KNOW WE BRING A LOT OF PDs TO YOU FOR CONSIDERATION, BUT I
07:42:11PM KNOW THAT YOU -- YOU ALSO KNOW THE STAFF IS WORKING ON
07:42:14PM REWRITING ALL THOSE ZONING CLASSIFICATIONS BECAUSE WE HAVE
07:42:18PM LAYERS UPON LAYERS UPON LAYERS OF ADDITIONAL CRITERIA THAT
07:42:23PM WEREN'T IN THE ORIGINAL ZONING.
07:42:25PM A LOT OF THESE DISTRICTS ARE DESIGNED FOR SUBURBAN STANDARDS
07:42:28PM -- TO SUBURBAN STANDARDS AND NOT URBAN INFILL STANDARDS.
07:42:34PM WHEN YOU NEED RELIEF FROM THAT, YOU WILL HAVE TO USE
07:42:39PM THE RM-24 AND ASK FOR VARIANCES.
07:42:42PM GO YOU GO TO A PD, YOU CAN DEAL WITH ALL YOU HAVE THOSE
07:42:46PM ISSUES ALL AT ONE TIME.
07:42:47PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
07:42:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE.
07:42:49PM DO WE HAVE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS
07:42:53PM ITEM?
07:42:54PM ITEM NUMBER 5.
07:42:55PM YES, MA'AM, YOU CAN COME UP AND STATE YOUR NAME.
07:42:57PM YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
07:42:58PM >> MY NAME IS DELORES JACKSON.
07:43:01PM I LIVE ON THE BLOCK IN QUESTION WHERE THIS NEW STRUCTURE IS
07:43:04PM PROPOSED.
07:43:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO.
07:43:06PM THEY ARE GOING TO START YOUR CLOCK FROM THREE MINUTES.
07:43:09PM >> YES.
07:43:10PM MY NAME IS DELORES JACKSON.
07:43:13PM I HAPPEN TO LIVE ON THE BLOCK WHERE THIS NEW STRUCTURE IS
07:43:17PM PROPOSED.
07:43:18PM I AM JUST HERE -- WELL, FIRST OF ALL, I APPLAUD THE FACT
07:43:25PM THAT THERE IS NEW DEVELOPMENT COMING TO THE BLOCK.
07:43:27PM THE AREA IS SEEING A WONDERFUL UPGRADE OF NEW HOUSES, NEW --
07:43:36PM NEW HOMEOWNERS COMING IN.
07:43:38PM MY FAMILY HAVE LIVED IN THE HOUSE THAT I NOW OCCUPY SINCE
07:43:42PM THE 1950s.
07:43:43PM SO WE ARE FAR FROM TRANSIENT IN THAT AREA THAT I THINK THE
07:43:47PM GENTLEMAN JUST SAID.
07:43:48PM THERE ARE HEREDITARY HOMES -- HOMEOWNERS THERE, PEOPLE WHO
07:43:54PM GREW UP IN THESE HOUSES IN THE 1950s.
07:43:56PM THE AREA DID HAVE A -- WENT -- SUFFERED DURING THE '80s.
07:44:03PM AND IT IS NOW COMING BACK.
07:44:06PM AND I AM VERY HAPPY TO SAY THAT I WOULD HOPE TO PASS MY
07:44:10PM HOUSE DOWN TO THE FIFTH GENERATION SOME TIME IN THE NEAR
07:44:13PM FUTURE.
07:44:13PM I HAVE ONE OBJECTION.
07:44:15PM I THINK THE GENTLEMAN PROPOSED A CONSTRUCTION THAT WOULD
07:44:19PM HAVE FOUR UNITS.
07:44:20PM IT IS A VERY CONGESTED AREA TRAFFIC-WISE.
07:44:24PM IT'S ONE BLOCK NORTH OF I-4 HAD AT THE INTERSECTION OF 22nd
07:44:30PM STREET AND I-4.
07:44:31PM A GREAT DEAL OF TRAFFIC.
07:44:32PM I THINK FOUR UNITS IS A LOT FOR THAT PARTICULAR SPOT AND THE
07:44:39PM SIZE OF THE LOTS.
07:44:40PM THREE UNITS MIGHT BE MORE REASONABLE.
07:44:44PM AND ALSO, I HOPE THE CITY WILL DEVOTE SOME ATTENTION TO
07:44:48PM INSTALLING TRAFFIC LIGHTS THERE, BECAUSE IT IS KNOWN FOR
07:44:51PM ACCIDENTS AND WITH SO MANY -- FOUR NEW UNITS ON A VERY, VERY
07:44:58PM BUSY SPOT JUST NORTH OF YBOR CITY, IT'S JUST ACCIDENTS
07:45:04PM WAITING TO HAPPEN.
07:45:04PM SO I DO APPLAUD THE -- I AM HAPPY TO SEE THIS NEW
07:45:09PM CONSTRUCTION COMING IN, BUT I THINK OTHER CONSIDERATIONS
07:45:13PM SUCH AS THE NUMBER.
07:45:14PM UNITS AND MANAGING TRAFFIC.
07:45:17PM MAYBE A TRAFFIC LIGHT AT THAT CORNER WOULD BENEFIT THE
07:45:20PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:45:20PM AND THAT'S ALL I WANTED TO SAY.
07:45:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:45:24PM ANYBODY ELSE FROM THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM
07:45:27PM NUMBER 5?
07:45:28PM WE DON'T HAVE ANYBODY REGISTERED.
07:45:30PM MR. MICHELINI, DO YOU HAVE REBUTTAL, SIR?
07:45:33PM OR ANY QUESTIONS BEFORE WE GO TO REBUTTAL?
07:45:37PM NO?
07:45:37PM MR. MICHELINI, GO AHEAD.
07:45:39PM >> THE RM-24 ALLOWS YOU TO BUILD FOUR UNITS BY RIGHT.
07:45:42PM SO WE ARE NOT OVERBUILDING WHAT THE CURRENT ZONING IS.
07:45:46PM AS I SAID, IF IT WEREN'T FOR THE FACT THAT YOU HAVE LAYER
07:45:49PM UPON LAYER OF ADDITIONAL NEW CRITERIA THAT WERE NOT
07:45:54PM CONSIDERED ORIGINALLY IN THE RM-24 ZONING, WE WOULDN'T BE
07:45:59PM HERE ASKING FOR RELIEF.
07:46:00PM IT IS -- IT IS A BADLY NEEDED NEW DEVELOPMENT IN THE AREA.
07:46:04PM AND AS -- AS THE LADY SAID, WHEN I SAY TRANSITORY, RESIDENTS
07:46:11PM -- NOT THE PERSONAL DENT RESIDENTS THAT ARE THERE, THE OTHER
07:46:15PM -- THE HOUSES THAT ARE IN NEED OF REDEVELOPMENT AS WELL.
07:46:21PM WE MET THE CRITERIA, I HAVE GONE THROUGH THAT AND A
07:46:24PM CONSISTENCY FINDING FROM PLANNING COMMISSION AND THE CITY
07:46:27PM STAFF.
07:46:27PM WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL AND HAPPY TO ANSWER
07:46:31PM ANY QUESTIONS.
07:46:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
07:46:36PM IF NOT A MOTION TO CLOSE.
07:46:37PM >>LUIS VIERA: SO MOVED.
07:46:38PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SECOND.
07:46:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
07:46:40PM OPPOSED.
07:46:41PM COUNCILMEMBER, WOULD YOU MIND READING NUMBER 5?
07:46:46PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I WILL, MR. CHAIRMAN.
07:46:47PM ITEM NUMBER 5, REZ-23-35.
07:46:51PM ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION.
07:46:53PM ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 2204
07:46:58PM EAST 15th AVENUE IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, MORE
07:47:02PM PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1 FROM ZONING
07:47:07PM DISTRICT RM-24 RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY TO PD PLANNED
07:47:11PM DEVELOPMENT RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY PROVIDING EFFECTIVE
07:47:14PM DATE AND REVISION SHEET.
07:47:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
07:47:17PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
07:47:18PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
07:47:19PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I WILL NOT BE SUPPORTING THIS FOR THAT
07:47:23PM REASON.
07:47:23PM WHILE FOUR IS BY RIGHT, THREE WOULD BE MORE APPROPRIATE.
07:47:28PM THE DENSITY -- WHEN I LOOK AT THE BLOCK, THEY ARE ALL
07:47:31PM SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES.
07:47:33PM AND I JUST -- IT IS JUST NOT THE RIGHT SPACE.
07:47:37PM ADDITIONALLY, THE AISLE DRIVE THING.
07:47:40PM NARROW DOORS THAT FACE THE STREET.
07:47:43PM THERE IS NO -- NO OTHER DEVELOPMENT ON THE BLOCK WHERE THE
07:47:46PM FRONT DOORS DON'T FACE THE STREET.
07:47:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
07:47:50PM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
07:47:52PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THIS IS ANOTHER ONE OF THOSE.
07:47:54PM BECAUSE THE APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATION KNOW HOW I FEEL
07:47:59PM ABOUT PDs.
07:48:01PM UP FEEL WE SHOULD BE BUILDING -- YOU HAVE RULES AND YOU FIT
07:48:03PM WITHIN THE RULES.
07:48:04PM BUT THERE IS SOMETHING THAT IS PULLING ME BACK FROM THIS
07:48:07PM ONE, BECAUSE IT IS ABUTTING THE I-4 CORRIDOR.
07:48:12PM AND -- BUT -- 22nd STREET BEING THAT MIXED USE WITH
07:48:18PM COMMERCIAL AND RESIDENTIAL AND MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT AROUND
07:48:22PM THIS AREA.
07:48:23PM I AM NOT A BIG FAN OF THAT DEVELOPMENT EITHER AND THE FACT
07:48:26PM THAT THREE OF THESE UNITS ARE NOT FRONT DOOR FACING.
07:48:30PM BUT AS THE ONE PERSON WE HEARD IN PUBLIC TESTIMONY ATTESTED
07:48:35PM THEY REALLY WANT TO SEE NEW CONSTRUCTION IN AREA AND
07:48:39PM REVITALIZATION WHICH I THINK, YOU KNOW, WILL SPUR OTHER
07:48:45PM REVITALIZATION.
07:48:46PM I THINK I WILL SIDE ON THIS -- AS MUCH AS IT PAINS ME, SIDE
07:48:52PM ON THE PD ON THIS ONE.
07:48:54PM I DON'T WANT TO ENCOURAGE PEOPLE TO BRING PDs IN FRONT OF
07:48:59PM COUNCIL, BUT BARELY MEETS THE CRITERIA FOR ME.
07:49:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
07:49:03PM A ROLL CALL VOTE.
07:49:04PM MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
07:49:05PM AND SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN CAN VIERA.
07:49:07PM ROLL CALL.
07:49:08PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
07:49:11PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
07:49:13PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
07:49:14PM >>LYNN HURTAK: NO.
07:49:17PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
07:49:19PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: NO.
07:49:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
07:49:22PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED WITH HURTAK, HENDERSON VOTING NO.
07:49:28PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON OCTOBER 5, 2023
07:49:33PM AT 9:30 A.M. AT OLD CITY HALL, 315 E. KENNEDY BOULEVARD,
07:49:40PM THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
07:49:43PM >> THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
07:49:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU, SIR
07:49:46PM ITEM NUMBER 7.
07:49:48PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES, CHAIRMAN AND COUNCIL, ITEM NUMBER 7 IS
07:49:56PM FILE NUMBER REZ-23-38.
07:49:59PM LaCHONE DOCK.
07:50:00PM 2107 AND 2109 WEST SPRUCE STREET.
07:50:05PM THE APPLICANT A JUAN QUINONES.
07:50:11PM FOR SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED USE ON THE SITE.
07:50:14PM SOIL TURN IT OVER TO DAVID TO GIVE HIS REPORT AND THEN I
07:50:17PM WILL COME BACK AND GIVE MY REPORT.
07:50:19PM THANK YOU.
07:50:19PM >>DAVID HEY: GOOD EVENING, COUNCILMEMBERS, DAVID HEY WITH
07:50:24PM YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
07:50:24PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
07:50:26PM WE CONTINUE OUR STRING OF CASES WITHIN THE CENTRAL TAMPA
07:50:29PM PLANNING DISTRICT.
07:50:29PM THIS SITE IS ALSO LOCATED WITHIN THE OLD WEST TAMPA
07:50:33PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND THE WEST TAMPA NATIONAL HISTORIC DISTRICT.
07:50:36PM ALSO LOCATED WITHIN THE WEST TAMPA URBAN VILLAGE.
07:50:39PM THE CLOSEST PUBLIC RECREATION FACILITY IS ONE-THIRD OF A
07:50:44PM MILE NORTHWEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
07:50:45PM THERE IS TRANSIT TWO BLOCKS TO -- AT THE INTERSECTION OF
07:50:50PM WEST WALNUT STREET AND.
07:50:56PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE COASTAL PLANNING
07:50:59PM AREA, SPECIFICALLY EVACUATION ZONE C.
07:51:02PM HERE WE HAVE AN AERIAL OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
07:51:07PM THIS IS SPRUCE ON THE SOUTH.
07:51:10PM THIS IS ALBANY NORTH.
07:51:13PM YOU CAN SEE THAT THE SURROUNDING AREA IS PREDOMINANTLY
07:51:16PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED.
07:51:17PM THERE ARE LIGHT COMMERCIAL USES PEN FROM THE ONE BLOCK WEST
07:51:20PM OF THE SITE ALONG NORTH HOWARD AVENUE.
07:51:22PM A PLACE OF RELIGIOUS CAN US WILL ASSEMBLY EAST OF WEST
07:51:29PM BRIDGE AND NORTH ALBANY AVENUE.
07:51:32PM >> CAN YOU LEAVE THAT UP THERE FOR A SECOND.
07:51:34PM >>DAVID HEY: I CAN ZOOM IN.
07:51:38PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THAT WILL BE GREAT.
07:51:39PM THANK YOU.
07:51:48PM >>DAVID HEY: ON TO THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
07:51:57PM THE SUBJECT SITE AND PROPERTIES TO THE EAST, WEST AND NORTH
07:52:02PM ARE ALL IN THAT RESIDENTIAL-35, DIRECTLY ON THE SOUTH SIDE
07:52:07PM OF SPRUCE STREET IS RESIDENTIAL-20.
07:52:09PM TO THE WEST IN THAT RED COLOR, THAT IS THAT COMMUNITY
07:52:13PM COMMERCIAL 35, THAT ALLOWS UP TO CI ZONING.
07:52:16PM THAT ALSO CONTINUES DOWN TOWARD -- NEAR THE INTERSTATE.
07:52:21PM YOU ALSO GET SOME NEIGHBORHOOD MIXED USE ON THE -- ON THE
07:52:26PM EAST SIDE OF NORTH ROME AVENUE.
07:52:28PM THIS IS A LIGHT INDUSTRIAL USE.
07:52:30PM THE GRAY THAT IS SCATTERED THROUGHOUT.
07:52:33PM THOSE ARE LIGHT INDUSTRIALS.
07:52:34PM TYPICALLY IN THIS AREA, THOSE ARE CIGAR FACTORIES OR WERE.
07:52:39PM KNOW HISTORICALLY WEST SPRUCE BETWEEN NORTH AVENUE AND
07:52:49PM ALBANY AVENUE IS DEVELOPED WITH SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED USES.
07:52:52PM THE RESIDENTIAL-35 DESIGNATION SUPPORTS A RANGE SINGLE
07:52:59PM FAMILY ATTACHED, DETACH AND MULTIFAMILY USES.
07:53:02PM THE MAJORITY PORTION OF WEST SPRUCE STREET IS RECOGNIZED
07:53:06PM UNDER A RESIDENTIAL-35 DESIGNATION.
07:53:09PM MANY OF THE PARCELS SITUATED ON THE SOUTH PORTION OF WEST
07:53:13PM SPRUCE STREET IS RECOGNIZED UNDER THAT RES-20.
07:53:17PM WITHIN THAT COMMUNITY COMMERCIAL 35.
07:53:20PM THE AVERAGE EXISTING DENSITY OF PARCELS RECOGNIZED UNDER
07:53:25PM THAT RESIDENTIAL-35 DESIGNATION ALONG THE SEGMENT EXCLUDING
07:53:30PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS 14.74 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE.
07:53:35PM IF APPROVED, THE SUBJECT SITE WILL BE DEVELOPED AT A DENSITY
07:53:38PM OF 28.57 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE WHICH IS CONSISTENT TO THAT
07:53:44PM RESIDENTIAL-35 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
07:53:47PM WITH RESPECT TO THE PRESENCE OF RESIDENTIAL-35 AND
07:53:50PM RESIDENTIAL-20 DESIGNATED PARCEL ALONG THE SEGMENT AND CC-35
07:53:56PM DESIGNATED PARCELS ONE BLOCK WEST ON NORTH HOWARD AVENUE,
07:54:00PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDS THE REQUEST WILL NOT ALTER
07:54:02PM THE CHARACTER OF THIS -- OF THE SURROUNDING AREA.
07:54:05PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ALSO SPEAKS TO THE DESIGN OF ATTACHED
07:54:09PM SINGLE-FAMILY UNITS.
07:54:10PM LU POLICY 9.2.6 ENCOURAGES SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED
07:54:16PM DEVELOPMENTS TO CLOUDY THE ORIENTATION OF THE FRONT DOOR TO
07:54:20PM A NEIGHBORHOOD SIDEWALK AND STREET.
07:54:21PM THE ENTRANCES TO THE THREE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED UNITS ARE
07:54:25PM ORIENTED TOWARD WEST SPRUCE STREET WITH THE CLEAR PEDESTRIAN
07:54:29PM CONNECTION TO THE SIDEWALK, MEANING THE INTENT OF LAND USE
07:54:31PM POLICY 9.2.6.
07:54:33PM THIS DESIGN IS CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND
07:54:36PM MEETS THAT INTENT OF THAT POLICY.
07:54:37PM ADDITIONALLY, THE DESIGN IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
07:54:40PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND WILL PROMOTE A PEDESTRIAN FRIENDLY
07:54:43PM ENVIRONMENT WITH DOORS THAT CONNECT THE NEIGHBORHOOD
07:54:46PM SIDEWALKS AND STREETS.
07:54:46PM THE REQUEST ALSO IS SUPPORTIVE OF RESIDENTIAL INFILL
07:54:51PM POLICIES.
07:54:51PM WHICH ENCOURAGE THAT HOUSING IS AVAILABLE WITHIN FIREWORKS
07:54:56PM INCIDENT TO TRANSIT AND UNEMPLOYMENT AREAS SUCH AS THIS
07:54:59PM AREA.
07:55:00PM BASED ON THE ABOVE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION
07:55:03PM STAFF DOES FIND THE PROPOSED -- THE PROPOSED PLAN
07:55:07PM DEVELOPMENT CONSISTENT WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE TAMPA
07:55:10PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
07:55:10PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:55:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. HEY?
07:55:15PM NO?
07:55:16PM YES, MA'AM, GO AHEAD.
07:55:17PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
07:55:18PM LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
07:55:21PM IN THIS PD REQUEST FOR THE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED WILL ALLOW
07:55:24PM FOR THREE UNITS ON-SITE.
07:55:27PM THE SETBACKS PROPOSED TO THE NORTH, 20 FEET.
07:55:30PM TO THE SOUTH, 10 FEET.
07:55:31PM TO THE WEST, 7 FEET.
07:55:32PM AND TO THE EAST 4 FEET.
07:55:34PM SEVEN PARKING SPACES ARE REQUIRED ON-SITE AND NINE SPACES
07:55:39PM ARE PROVIDED.
07:55:40PM THIS SITE IS LOCATED IN THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY AND MUST
07:55:44PM COMPLY WITH THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY AT TIME OF PERMITTING
07:55:48PM UNLESS THERE ARE STANDARDS THAT ARE WAIVED THROUGHOUT THIS
07:55:50PM REQUEST.
07:55:50PM AND THERE IS ONE WAIVER THAT IS RELATED TO THE OVERLAY,
07:55:55PM WHICH IS LISTED.
07:55:56PM AND I WILL REVIEW THE OTHER WAIVERS.
07:55:58PM BUT THIS PARTICULAR WAIVER TO THE OVERLAY IS RELATED TO THE
07:56:02PM SETBACK.
07:56:02PM AND THAT IS THE FRONT YARD SETBACK AND THEN THE SIDE YARD
07:56:06PM SETBACK.
07:56:06PM THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY, THE IT IS DETERMINED BASED ON A
07:56:12PM BLOCK AVERAGE.
07:56:12PM FROM THAT BLOCK AVERAGE, WHEREVER THE ACTUAL STRUCTURE IS
07:56:16PM PLACED, IF A WAIVER IS NEEDED AND REQUESTED.
07:56:18PM SO IN THIS CASE, THAT WAIVER IS REQUESTED.
07:56:21PM SO ON THE SITE PLAN, THIS IS THE SITE THAT IS LOCATED ON
07:56:27PM SPRUCE -- I FEEL LIKE I NEED TO ZOOM IT OUT JUST A LITTLE
07:56:30PM BIT TO SEE THE STREET.
07:56:31PM SO THIS IS SPRUCE.
07:56:35PM SOME THIS DOTTED LINE IS THE PROPERTY.
07:56:37PM THIS IS THE STRUCTURE, WHICH IS LOCATED HERE ON-SITE.
07:56:41PM THE UNITS ARE IDENTIFIED BY LETTERS.
07:56:45PM SO THIS IS UNIT A, UNIT B, AND UNIT C.
07:56:49PM YOU CAN SEE THE FRONT DOOR ORIENTATION TO SPRUCE.
07:56:54PM THE WALKWAY CONNECTION TO THE SIDEWALK PROVIDED ON SPRUCE.
07:56:58PM EACH UNIT HAS THE ENCLOSED TWO-CAR GARAGE WITH SPACE OF ONE
07:57:03PM CAR BEYOND THE GARAGES.
07:57:04PM SO YOU WILL NOTICE THE DESIGN WITHIN THE SITE PLAN, WHAT IS
07:57:10PM HIGHLIGHTED IS THE MATERIALS WHICH WILL BE UTILIZED DURING
07:57:13PM CONSTRUCTION.
07:57:13PM AND EFFORTS TO PRESERVE AND MAINTAIN THIS 30-INCH LAUREL OAK
07:57:19PM THAT EXISTS.
07:57:20PM THIS IS A SHARED TREE ON THE SITE.
07:57:23PM IT IS ACTUALLY PARTIALLY ON EACH PROPERTY LINE.
07:57:26PM BUT THE DESIGN HAS BEEN INCORPORATED TO ALLOW THIS.
07:57:29PM SO FROM THE ONSET, THIS DESIGN HAS CHANGED.
07:57:35PM THE APPLICANT WORKED -- I BELIEVE IT MAY HAVE STARTED WITH
07:57:38PM FIVE UNITS, AND THEN WENT DOWN TO WHAT WE HAVE HERE, WHICH
07:57:42PM IS THREE UNITS.
07:57:42PM THEY WORKED TO TRY TO MEET THE OVERLAY STANDARDS.
07:57:46PM AND THEY STARTED INITIALLY WITH THE PARKING IN THE FRONT,
07:57:50PM ACCESSING FROM SPRUCE.
07:57:50PM AND THEY ENDED UP AT THE REAR FROM THE ALLEY.
07:57:53PM WITH THE DESIGN YOU HAVE BEFORE YOU NOW.
07:57:57PM BUT THIS IS THE ELEVATION.
07:57:58PM SO THIS IS THE SOUTH ELEVATION WHICH IS UP TOP.
07:58:01PM THE BOTTOM PICTURE IS THE WEST ELEVATION.
07:58:06PM AND THEN THE TOP PICTURE IS THE NORTH ELEVATION.
07:58:12PM YOU CAN SEE THE GARAGES FROM THAT ELEVATION AND THEN THE
07:58:16PM BOTTOM PICTURE ASK THE EAST ELEVATION.
07:58:24PM AND AGAIN I HAVE THE ZONING MAP OF THE PROPERTY.
07:58:27PM THIS IS THE PROPERTY IDENTIFIED AS LOCATED HERE IN RED.
07:58:33PM AND YOU CAN SEE ON THIS SITE AND I INCLUDED IT IN MY REPORT,
07:58:37PM THAT THERE ARE A LOT OF PDs IN THE AREA.
07:58:40PM SO THIS AREA WAS ACTUALLY A PART OF AN INFILL PROJECT IN
07:58:45PM TOWN.
07:58:46PM THIS WAS A TWO PHASED PROJECT.
07:58:47PM ONE PHASE IN 2005.
07:58:49PM THEN IT CAME BACK IN 2007.
07:58:51PM SO THAT IS ALL OF THE PDs IN THE AREA EITHER FROM '03, OR
07:59:00PM '05 OR '07, I AM SORRY.
07:59:02PM ASIDE FROM THAT THE RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY FURTHER EAST
07:59:05PM AS YOU ARE HEADED EAST ON SPRUCE, AND THEN YOU HAVE YOUR
07:59:08PM COMMERCIAL ALONG HOWARD AND THEN ON ALBANY ALSO.
07:59:11PM THEN I HAVE PICTURES OF THE SITE.
07:59:17PM SO THIS IS THE SITE.
07:59:24PM YOU CAN SEE THIS SITE IS VACANT.
07:59:28PM THIS IS DIRECTLY EAST OF THE SITE.
07:59:30PM THEN THIS IS THE VIEW IF YOU ARE LOOKING EAST ON SPRUCE, ON
07:59:39PM THIS PICTURE, THE SITE IS OFF TO THE LEFT IN THIS PICTURE.
07:59:43PM THIS IS DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET.
07:59:49PM SOUTH OF THE SITE.
07:59:51PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW SOUTH SHOWING THE HOMES THAT EXIST
07:59:54PM THERE.
07:59:55PM AND THEN THIS IS WEST OF THE SITE, CIRCLING BACK AROUND.
08:00:01PM HAND THIS IS A VIEW JUST SHOWING YOU JUST A VIEW OF THE
08:00:05PM STREET.
08:00:06PM THIS IS WEST OF THE SITE.
08:00:07PM AND YOU CAN SEE THE HOMES THERE.
08:00:09PM AND THE DRC STAFF REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FINDS THE REQUEST
08:00:22PM INCONSISTENT DUE TO THE WAIVER FOR THE REDUCTION IN THE
08:00:25PM DRIVE AISLE FOR TRANSPORTATION.
08:00:26PM AND THEN THERE IS AN INCONSISTENT TO SOLID WASTE DUE TO THE
08:00:31PM SOLID WASTE CAN STORAGE ON-SITE.
08:00:33PM ONCE THAT IS PROVIDED BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING, THE
08:00:37PM SOLID WASTE WOULD -- KIND ALSO, CONSISTENT, THE
08:00:41PM TRANSPORTATION REMAINS.
08:00:42PM INCONSISTENT.
08:00:43PM HAND THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
08:00:46PM I AM AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
08:00:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM
08:00:50PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I HAVE A QUESTION.
08:00:51PM THE -- THE LAUREL OAK THAT IS SITTING RIGHT CLOSE BY THE
08:00:57PM WHITE HOUSE, THAT IS THE ONE THAT WILL BE SAVED IN THIS
08:01:00PM PROJECT?
08:01:00PM I JUST WANT --
08:01:03PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: OH, SO IT IS -- IT IS THIS ONE WHICH IS ON
08:01:06PM THE WEST.
08:01:07PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YEAH, OKAY.
08:01:09PM IT IS REALLY BIG, RIGHT?
08:01:13PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES.
08:01:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU SEE THE RADIUS.
08:01:16PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: I WAS LOOKING FOR A SEPARATE PICTURE OF IT.
08:01:20PM BECAUSE THIS DOESN'T REALLY SHOW IT.
08:01:22PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES, OKAY.
08:01:25PM THAT TREE.
08:01:26PM >> I HAVE PICTURES.
08:01:30PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YOU HAVE BETTER?
08:01:32PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: NOT THE ONE RIGHT NEXT TO THAT WHITE
08:01:34PM HOUSE.
08:01:34PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: NO, THIS ONE HERE?
08:01:37PM NO, IT IS OVER HERE.
08:01:38PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THE ONE RIGHT ABOVE -- OH, THAT ONE.
08:01:42PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THIS ONE.
08:01:43PM >> YOU CAN MOVE IT UP.
08:01:45PM WE CAN'T SEE THE BOTTOM.
08:01:47PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THAT WHITE ONE, THE VERY BIG ONE, THAT
08:01:49PM ONE WILL COME DOWN?
08:01:53PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES.
08:01:54PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: IF THE PROJECT -- YEAH, THAT ONE CAN'T BE
08:01:57PM SAVED?
08:01:58PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THE HEALTH OF IT.
08:01:59PM THE CONDITION.
08:02:00PM >> IN DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
08:02:06PM THIS IS A GRAND LAUREL OAK.
08:02:08PM AND IT IS RATED A C-9.
08:02:11PM SOME OF THE STRUCTURE LOOKS LIKE THE TREE WAS PRUNED
08:02:16PM PROPERLY IN THE PAST.
08:02:17PM AND LOOKS LIKE IF THE ATTACHMENTS ARE WEAKLY ATTACHED THERE.
08:02:20PM THE TREE IS IN THE ENTER OF THE SITE.
08:02:23PM I DON'T KNOW HOW YOU COULD REALLY DEVELOP THIS PROJECT AND
08:02:26PM KEEP THAT TREE.
08:02:27PM THAT TREE WOULD REQUIRE A 20-FOOT PROTECTIVE RADIUS ON ALL
08:02:31PM SIDES.
08:02:31PM SO THEY DIDN'T NEED A WAIVER TO REMOVE IT DUE TO THE TREE'S
08:02:39PM RATING OF BEING HAZARDOUS.
08:02:41PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SAY THAT AGAIN.
08:02:42PM >> THEY DIDN'T NEED A WAIVER TO REMOVE THE GRAND TREE
08:02:45PM BECAUSE IT WAS DEEMED HAZARDOUS.
08:02:47PM THIS IS ANOTHER PICTURE OF IT.
08:02:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?
08:02:51PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THANK YOU.
08:02:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: BEFORE WE GO TO THE APPLICANT?
08:02:53PM OKAY, APPLICANT.
08:02:54PM >> GOOD EVENING, HOW ARE YOU?
08:03:11PM MY NAME IS JUAN QUINONES, AND I AM REPRESENTING THE
08:03:15PM APPLICANT.
08:03:16PM THE STAFF DID A PRETTY GOOD JOB PRESENTING THE PROJECT TO
08:03:20PM YOU GUYS.
08:03:21PM WE ARE REQUESTING THREE UNITS ON THIS PROPERTY.
08:03:24PM WE ARE GOING THROUGH A PD PROCESS.
08:03:26PM THE ONLY REASON WE ARE DOING THAT BECAUSE OF THE SETBACKS
08:03:29PM AND REQUIREMENTS THAT WE HAVE TO MEET.
08:03:30PM THE PROJECT TO SAVE THE TREE, AND ONE ON THE EAST SIDE -- ON
08:03:38PM THE WEST SIDE OF THE PROPERTY.
08:03:39PM AND THEN WE ALSO ACTUALLY -- ACTUALLY VEHICULAR ACCESS IS
08:03:47PM FROM THE REAR.
08:03:48PM WE ARE UTILIZING THE ALLEYWAY TO ENTER INTO OUR PROPERTY.
08:03:51PM SO WE HAVE OUR FRONT DOORS FACING THE STREETS AND VEHICLES
08:04:00PM VEHICLE ACCESS TO THE BACK.
08:04:01PM WE PROVIDED THREE PARKING SPOTS PER UNIT.
08:04:03PM WE PROVIDED -- THE ALLOWABLE GREEN SPACE THAT WAS NEEDED FOR
08:04:09PM THE THREE UNITS.
08:04:11PM SO IF YOU GUYS HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS, WE ARE HERE
08:04:14PM TO ANSWER ANY.
08:04:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE APPLICANT?
08:04:20PM I HEAR NONE.
08:04:21PM THANK YOU.
08:04:21PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC TO WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 7?
08:04:25PM ITEM NUMBER 7?
08:04:27PM YES, MA'AM.
08:04:27PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
08:04:28PM YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
08:04:29PM WHAT IS IT?
08:04:46PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: A SPEAKER WAIVER FORM WITH AT LEAST FIVE
08:04:49PM NAMES ON TAMPA ACKNOWLEDGE YOUR PRESENCE.
08:04:52PM ADRIAN LARAMIE, CARROLL ANN BENNETT.
08:04:56PM THANK YOU.
08:04:57PM MISS POYNOR.
08:05:00PM THANK YOU.
08:05:01PM KELLA McCASKILL, THANK YOU.
08:05:06PM I BELIEVE THAT IS ONLY FOUR NAMES, SO A TOTAL OF SEVEN
08:05:09PM MINUTES.
08:05:09PM WHO IS DJ?
08:05:13PM WHO?
08:05:15PM >> EXCUSE ME?
08:05:16PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: EXCUSE ME?
08:05:19PM I COUNT -- I COUNT ADRIAN LARAMIE, CARROLL ANN BENNETT.
08:05:26PM >> HE LEFT.
08:05:35PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: OKAY.
08:05:36PM SEVEN MINUTES.
08:05:37PM >> GOOD EVENING, CITY COUNCIL.
08:05:41PM ANY NAME IS SANDRA DEDIEGO SANCHEZ AND 725 WEST FIG STREET.
08:05:50PM I AM A MEMBER OF THE WEST TAMPA CAC AND HERE AS A PRIVATE
08:05:54PM CITIZEN.
08:05:54PM MOST OF YOU KNOW ONE OF THE MANY GOALS OF THE WEST TAMPA CAC
08:05:58PM IS TO PRESERVE THE AMBIENCE OF THE HISTORY AND RETAIN THE
08:06:04PM ARCHITECTURE AND PRESERVE THIS NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:06:07PM WITH GUIDELINES OF THE CRA BOARD HAVE ADMINISTERED GRANTS
08:06:11PM FOR FACADE IMPROVEMENTS AND GENERAL RESIDENTIAL MAINTENANCE.
08:06:14PM THIS PARTICULAR BLOCK HAS DONE A BEAUTIFUL JOB OF STICKING
08:06:18PM TO THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY.
08:06:20PM THIS PROJECT DOES NOT.
08:06:22PM THE PROPERTY IS RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NATIONAL HISTORIC
08:06:28PM DISTRICT OF WEST TAMPA.
08:06:29PM SEE PAGE 1 OF YOUR HANDOUT.
08:06:31PM YOU WILL NOTICE ITS LOCATION AND THE PLAN DESIGN AND
08:06:35PM HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE OF THE EXISTING RESIDENCES ON THE
08:06:39PM STREET.
08:06:39PM ON PAGE 2, YOU WILL PRETTY MUCH SEE THE PICTURE THAT CITY
08:06:43PM STAFF SHOWED YOU BUT A LITTLE MORE DETAILED ON THE
08:06:46PM ARCHITECTURE.
08:06:47PM ON PAGE THREE, IT SHOWS THE REPORT THAT WAS SUBMITTED IN
08:06:55PM APRIL AND RESUBMITTED AUGUST 17 THAT SHOWED THE POSITION IN
08:06:59PM APRIL DID NOT CHANGE.
08:07:00PM IT WAS INCONSISTENT.
08:07:01PM INCONSISTENT BECAUSE THE TURNING RADIUS INTO THE ALLEY MAKES
08:07:06PM IT ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE TO MAKE A 90-DEGREE TURN INTO THE
08:07:09PM GARAGE.
08:07:10PM IT SHOW IS THE PARKING ISSUES ON THE STREET.
08:07:13PM YOU WILL ALSO NOTICE THE TWO CARS SIZES OF GARAGE ARE 18 OR
08:07:21PM 19 FEET.
08:07:21PM TWO CARS MAY SQUEEZE IN THE GARAGE BUT THEY CAN NOT OPEN
08:07:24PM THEIR DOORS.
08:07:25PM THERE SHOULD BE A TRAFFIC REPORT INTO THIS FILE, BUT THERE
08:07:28PM IS NOT ONE.
08:07:29PM YOU WILL SEE ON THIS FILE -- THOSE WERE TAKEN THIS MORNING
08:07:34PM WITH THE TRAFFIC THAT IS PARKING ON THAT STREET.
08:07:36PM OF COURSE, MY FAVORITE SUBJECT, TRASH CANS.
08:07:41PM ALL 20 SQUARE FEET.
08:07:42PM THREE TO SIX OF THEM.
08:07:44PM WHERE ARE THEY POSITIONED ON THE PROPOSED SITE PLAN?
08:07:48PM NO NOTATION ON THIS PLAN.
08:07:51PM THIS BLOCK ALREADY HAS 22 HOUSES FACING THE STREET.
08:07:56PM WITH PICK-UP TRASH OPTIONS ARE ON THE STREET.
08:08:00PM THE DEVELOPER WANT TO BE ADD THREE MORE RESIDENCES.
08:08:03PM PLEASE GO TO PAGE 5.
08:08:05PM THESE ARE SOME OF THE HIGHLIGHT REPORTS THAT CAME FROM SOME
08:08:11PM OF THE OLDER STAFF REPORTS.
08:08:12PM THE SPECIFIC ONE THAT MISS LACHONE SPOKE OF IS INCONSISTENT
08:08:18PM --
08:08:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO PAGE 5.
08:08:21PM IT GOES 4 TO 6.
08:08:23PM >> CAN SOMEBODY SHARE PAGE 5 WITH MR. --
08:08:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WILL LEAN OVER.
08:08:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU, GO AHEAD.
08:08:36PM STORY.
08:08:37PM >> THE MAIN THING TO DIRECT TO YOU PAGE 6.
08:08:40PM THESE ARE DIRECT QUOTES FROM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN THAT WAS
08:08:43PM NOT USED BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF ON THIS REPORT.
08:08:46PM WHY?
08:08:47PM THESE LAND USE OBJECTIONS HAVE EVERYTHING TO DO WITH
08:08:50PM HISTORIC DISTRICTS.
08:08:51PM WHY DIDN'T STAFF REMIND YOU OF THE LAND USE OBJECTIVES.
08:08:56PM ALLOW ME TO DO SO.
08:08:58PM HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLANNING, LAND USE OBJECTION 16.1,
08:09:02PM PRESERVE TAMPA'S HISTORIC RESOURCES.
08:09:04PM LAND USE POLICY 16.1.1, DEVELOP AND DESIGN STANDARDS FOR
08:09:10PM LOCAL HISTORICALLY DESIGNATED BUILDING, SITES, STRUCTURES,
08:09:14PM OBJECTS, DISTRICT IN A HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOOD PRESERVATION.
08:09:17PM LAND USE POLICY 16.1.2, SUPPORT HISTORIC PRESERVATION IN THE
08:09:23PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:09:23PM 16.1.3, RESOURCE AND DEVELOPMENTS OF THE PLANS OF THE
08:09:30PM CANOPY.
08:09:31PM 16.1.4, FOR VALUE AND TAKE STEPS FOR SIGNIFICANCE.
08:09:39PM THESE VALUES MAY BE HISTORICAL ASSOCIATIONS OF A HISTORICAL
08:09:44PM EVENT AND RECOGNITION OF TRADITIONAL ETHNIC NEIGHBORS.
08:09:47PM ENCOURAGE, 16.1.6, ENCOURAGE RESIDENTS AND HOMEOWNERS TO
08:09:54PM WORK WITH HISTORIC PRESERVATION TO MAINTAIN OLDER STOCK AND
08:09:58PM STRUCTURES.
08:09:59PM PLEASE CONSIDER THESE LAND USE OBJECTIVES WHEN YOU CONSIDER
08:10:04PM YOUR DECISION TO MAKE ON THIS.
08:10:05PM PAGE 8 ARE THE TWO STRUCTURES THAT HAVE FLAT ROOFS.
08:10:09PM THEY WERE PART OF THAT -- ONE IS 2004.
08:10:12PM THE OTHER BUILT IN 2009.
08:10:20PM YOU GO INTO ACELA, NO CONSIDERING THAT THEY CONSIDERED THE
08:10:24PM WEST TAMPA OVERLAY.
08:10:26PM CITY PERMITTING WENT AHEAD AND APPROVED THEM.
08:10:29PM AND THEY WERE BUILT.
08:10:30PM THIS PROJECT DOES NOT MEET THE NEEDS OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND
08:10:33PM DOES NOT ADD ANYTHING POSSIBLE TO THIS NEIGHBORHOOD. AND
08:10:36PM PUTS THE NEIGHBORHOOD IN DANGER.
08:10:37PM AND ALSO, REMEMBER, THIS IS NOT AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
08:10:41PM IT IS UNAFFORDABLE HOUSING.
08:10:43PM WE HAVE PLENTY OF COMMUNITY AFFORDABLE HOUSING COMING WITH
08:10:48PM ROME YARD AND WITH WEST RIVER.
08:10:50PM SO I ASK YOU TO PLEASE CONSIDER THE OVERLAY SHOULD BE A
08:10:56PM PRIORITY.
08:10:56PM AND THIS IS A HISTORICAL DISTRICT.
08:10:58PM HAND THIS DESIGN NOWHERE COMPLEMENTS THE SURROUNDING AREA.
08:11:03PM I ASK YOU TO DENY THIS REQUEST.
08:11:05PM THANK YOU.
08:11:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: BLESS YOU.
08:11:08PM YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:11:10PM ANYBODY ELSE HERE FOR PUBLIC COMMENT?
08:11:14PM ALL RIGHT.
08:11:14PM ANY QUESTIONS FOR COMMENTS BEFORE WE GO TO REBUTTAL?
08:11:18PM SIR?
08:11:19PM YOU HAVE REBUTTAL?
08:11:22PM >> SURE.
08:11:22PM SO SUBMITTED THE PD AND ELEVATION FOR THIS FACILITY.
08:11:33PM OR THIS UNIT.
08:11:35PM WE ARE WILLING TO DO HISTORIC DESIGN FOR THIS PROPERTY.
08:11:41PM THOSE WERE PRELIMINARY.
08:11:43PM THEY WERE NOT ACTUAL FOR THIS PARTICULAR PROJECT.
08:11:46PM BUT THE STAFF ASKED FOR ELEVATIONS SO WE PROVIDED THEM.
08:11:50PM AS FAR AS THE TRASH CANS GOES, WE ARE -- OUR -- THE TRASH
08:11:55PM CANS WILL, LOCATED WITHIN THE GARAGE.
08:11:58PM THE GARAGE IS 20 -- ACTUALLY 19 X 22 DEEP.
08:12:03PM SO THE GARAGE WILL BE -- CANS WILL BE STORED IN THE GARAGE.
08:12:08PM HISTORIC -- NATIONAL HISTORIC DISTRICT.
08:12:13PM I BELIEVE WE ARE WITHIN IT.
08:12:19PM STAFF, CORRECT ME IF I AM WRONG.
08:12:22PM ARE WE WITHIN THE HISTORIC DISTRICT, NATIONAL DISTRICT?
08:12:26PM ANYWAY, YEAH, WE ARE WILLING TO UPDATE THE EXTERIOR
08:12:32PM ELEVATIONS.
08:12:33PM THAT IS NOT A PROBLEM.
08:12:34PM WHAT WE WOULD LIKE TO DO IS ACTUALLY BUILD THE THREE UNITS
08:12:37PM WITHIN THIS PROPERTY.
08:12:39PM SO IF YOU GUYS ALLOW US TO DO THAT, WE WILL GREATLY
08:12:43PM APPRECIATE IT.
08:12:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
08:12:47PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:12:48PM ANYTHING?
08:12:51PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I HAVE A QUESTION FOR STAFF.
08:12:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
08:12:53PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THE GENTLEMAN SAID THAT HE WOULD CHANGE THE
08:12:57PM ELEVATION.
08:12:58PM IS THAT SOMETHING THEY CAN DO BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READ
08:13:03PM SOMETHING IN.
08:13:03PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES.
08:13:04PM LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
08:13:06PM IF THE DESIRE IS TO CHANGE THE ELEVATION, IT WOULD GO BACK
08:13:10PM TO FIRST READING, AND THIS COULD CONTINUE TO ANOTHER HEARING
08:13:14PM CATEGORY, AND THEN THEY WOULD HAVE ANOTHER FIRST READING.
08:13:18PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THE ANSWER IS NO, THEY --
08:13:20PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: NO, THEY CAN'T.
08:13:22PM IT WOULD REQUIRE MORE.
08:13:23PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YOU CAN'T CHANGE THE ELEVATION BETWEEN FIRST
08:13:25PM AND SECOND READING
08:13:26PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CORRECT.
08:13:28PM >>LYNN HURTAK: TRADITIONALLY, THE OTHER REASON.
08:13:31PM THE REASON YOU MADE MENTION OF THE GARBAGE CAN -- CAN
08:13:35PM PUTTING THEM INSIDE A GARAGE BE AN OPTION?
08:13:40PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES, YOU CAN STORE THEM INSIDE THE GARAGE
08:13:44PM AND SHOW THE DIMENSIONS.
08:13:45PM AND WHAT HAPPENED WHEN IT WAS RESUBMITTED WILL -- I CAN
08:13:49PM SMELL AN IMAGE OF THE SITE PLAN.
08:13:51PM WHEN IT WAS SUBMITTED, THE DIMENSIONS WERE NO NOT INCLUDED
08:13:56PM AND SOLID WASTE COULD NOT CONFIRM THE DISTANCE, THE
08:14:00PM MEASUREMENT.
08:14:00PM I DON'T AS LONG AS ITS BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING THE
08:14:05PM DEPTH THAT THEY CAN STORE WITHIN THE GARAGE.
08:14:08PM >>LYNN HURTAK: AND I HAVE ONE ADDITIONAL QUESTION, BECAUSE
08:14:10PM THIS KEEPS COMING UP.
08:14:12PM SPECIFICALLY IN THIS DISTRICT.
08:14:13PM THE SIZE OF A GARAGE.
08:14:16PM ARE THERE -- DO WE HAVE PARAMETERS FOR THE SIZE OF A GARAGE?
08:14:28PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: I WILL LET JONATHAN SPEAK OF THAT.
08:14:30PM >>JONATHAN SCOTT: JONATHAN SCOTT, MOBILITY.
08:14:33PM WE REALLY DON'T HAVE A STANDARD FOR THAT, BUT MORE OF A
08:14:37PM BUILDING CODE THING.
08:14:38PM YOU KNOW, YOUR GARAGE IS -- YOU KNOW PARKING SPACE WOULD
08:14:44PM BE 9 X 18.
08:14:46PM IF YOUR GARAGE IS 18 FEET WIDE, YOU WON'T BE OPEN YOUR DOOR.
08:14:51PM TALKING TO ARCHITECTS.
08:14:53PM I AM ALWAYS ASKING QUESTIONS LIKE THAT.
08:14:55PM I AM INTERESTED.
08:14:56PM YOU TYPICALLY WANT TO MAKE A GARAGE FOR ONE CAR 12 FOOT
08:15:00PM WIDE.
08:15:00PM SO THAT'S KIND OF WHERE THE -- WHERE THEY TRY TO PUT IT.
08:15:04PM BUT IF THAT ANSWERS YOUR QUESTION.
08:15:06PM >>LYNN HURTAK: SO THIS -- THIS GARAGE IS 18 FEET WIDE.
08:15:10PM WHAT YOU ARE SAYING THEY COULD NOT FIT TWO CARS.
08:15:13PM >> HE SAID IT WAS 19 X 22.
08:15:18PM I THINK THE APPLICANT TOLD ME IT WAS 19 FEET WIDE BY 22 FEET
08:15:27PM DEEP.
08:15:27PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
08:15:30PM THE GARAGE IS 19 X 22.
08:15:34PM TYPICALLY WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IS IF THEY PROVIDE AT LEAST 22
08:15:38PM FEET OF DEPTH, THAT ALLOWS ADEQUATE ROOM FOR STORAGE OF THE
08:15:43PM SOLID WASTE.
08:15:44PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I APPRECIATE THAT.
08:15:45PM BUT 22 IS THE LENGTH OF IT.
08:15:48PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CORRECT.
08:15:50PM >>LYNN HURTAK: MY QUESTION WIDTH, THANK YOU FOR SHOWING
08:15:57PM THAT.
08:15:58PM THE WIDTH YOU ARE SAYING AT 18 WILL BE DIFFICULT TO GET TWO
08:16:01PM CARS IN AND OPEN THE DOORS.
08:16:03PM >> YOU WOULDN'T HAVE TO OPEN THE DOORS.
08:16:07PM WOULD YOU HAVE TO JUMP OUT THE WINDOW.
08:16:08PM >>LYNN HURTAK: BUT THIS IS MY QUESTION.
08:16:12PM DO WE HAVE -- DO WE HAVE -- I AM SORRY IT HAS BEEN A VERY
08:16:21PM LONG DAY.
08:16:21PM DO WE HAVE STANDARDS FOR SIZES OF GARAGES DUE TO THE OPEN
08:16:25PM DOOR -- OPENING OF DOORS ISSUE?
08:16:27PM OR IS THAT NOT SOMETHING THE CITY HAS?
08:16:30PM >> IT DOESN'T, BUT IT IS MORE OF AN ARCHITECTURAL BUILDING
08:16:35PM STANDARD, BUT IT IS NOT CODIFIED ANY WAY OF WHAT WE LOOK AT
08:16:41PM FOR THIS YEAR.
08:16:41PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WE NEED TO LOOK INTO THAT.
08:16:43PM THIS KEEPS COMING UP AND KEEPS COMING UP AND KEEPS COMING
08:16:47PM UP.
08:16:48PM STANDARDS FOR -- I AM JUST GOING TO WRITE THIS DOWN OR ELSE
08:16:52PM I WILL FORGET.
08:16:53PM THANK YOU SO MUCH.
08:16:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMEMBER CLENDENIN.
08:16:58PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: TWO OBSERVATIONS.
08:16:59PM THE SITE PLAN I AM LOOKING FOR ON SIRE SHOWS THE DEPTH OF
08:17:04PM THIS GARAGE IS 20 FEET, 1 INCH.
08:17:08PM WHAT AM I LOOKING AT THAT IS WRONG?
08:17:11PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES, LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT
08:17:13PM COORDINATION.
08:17:13PM THE APPLICANT BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING IS PROVIDING
08:17:17PM 22.
08:17:19PM >> IT IS ON THE REVISION SHEET?
08:17:21PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: IT IS, YES.
08:17:23PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I LIVE -- MY GARAGE IS 19 X 22, AND I
08:17:28PM CAN'T STORE GARBAGE CANS.
08:17:30PM I CAN BARELY GET OUT OF MY CAR.
08:17:33PM AND I CAN'T STORE GARBAGE CANS.
08:17:37PM >> WE CAN MAKE THE GARAGE A LITTLE DEEPER IF NEED TO BE.
08:17:49PM WE CAN GO UP TO 24 FEET, IF THAT WORKS.
08:17:52PM SO WE WORK -- WE WILL BE WORKING WITH STAFF TO MAKE THAT
08:17:58PM HAPPEN, WHATEVER THAT DIMENSION IS, WE WILL MAKE THAT
08:18:02PM HAPPEN.
08:18:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS, COUNCILWOMAN
08:18:08PM HURTAK?
08:18:09PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
08:18:10PM MISS DOCK, DOES THIS COMPLY WITH THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY?
08:18:14PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES.
08:18:15PM LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
08:18:19PM WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THE WAIVERS THAT ARE REQUESTED, THEY
08:18:23PM ARE WAIVING THE FRONT-YARD SETBACK.
08:18:25PM AND THEY ARE REDUCING IT FROM 19 FEET TO TEN FEET.
08:18:29PM AND ON THE EAST SIDE YARD, THE SIDE YARD FROM FIVE FEET TO
08:18:35PM FOUR FEET.
08:18:36PM IN THE OVERLAY YOU HAVE REDUCED SIDE YARDS SO THE SIDE YARD
08:18:40PM IS FIVE FEET.
08:18:41PM ASKING FOR AN ADDITIONAL FOOT.
08:18:43PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THE ANSWER IS NO.
08:18:44PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: NO, THEY ARE NOT MEETING ALL THE STANDARDS.
08:18:48PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WAS GOING TO SAY THE ANSWER TO THAT
08:18:50PM QUESTION IS NO.
08:18:51PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CORRECT.
08:18:52PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE SHORT ANSWER.
08:18:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO CLOSE.
08:18:56PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MOTION TO CLOSE.
08:18:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILMAN
08:19:00PM CLENDENIN --
08:19:01PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: QUESTION.
08:19:02PM BECAUSE I BELIEVE -- AND WE SHOULD ASK THE PETITIONER IF HE
08:19:07PM WANTS TO HAVE A FINAL WORD BASED ON THE TESTIMONY YOU HAVE
08:19:10PM TAKEN UP AT THIS POINT.
08:19:11PM BUT IT ALSO SOUNDS THAT WHAT HE IS SUGGESTING TO BE DONE
08:19:15PM CANNOT BE DONE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
08:19:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THAT'S CORRECT.
08:19:19PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: MY QUESTION TO STAFF -- FIRST OF ALL, HEAR
08:19:22PM FROM THE PETITIONER AND THEN DECIDE HOW TO PROCEED.
08:19:24PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
08:19:27PM WE WOULD WANT CLARIFICATION OF COUNCIL'S DIRECTION OF WHAT
08:19:31PM CHANGES THE APPLICANT SHOULD MAKE BETWEEN THIS READING AND
08:19:34PM WHETHER IT IS VOTED UPON AND MOVED TO SECOND READING.
08:19:37PM IT DEPENDS WHAT IS REQUESTED WITH THE CHANGE.
08:19:42PM THE APPLICANT IS ALREADY PROVIDING THE DIVISIONS IN THE
08:19:45PM INTERIOR MEASUREMENT IN THE GARAGE AT 22 FEET IN LENGTH TO
08:19:49PM ACCOMMODATE THE SOLID WASTE.
08:19:50PM SO ANYTHING ASIDE FROM THAT OR THE DESIRE TO CHANGE THE ROOF
08:19:57PM PITCH, IT NEEDS TO GO BACK FOR ANOTHER FIRST READING.
08:19:59PM THE APPLICANT HAS TO AGREE, AND THEN WE WILL HAVE TO DECIDE.
08:20:03PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: COUNCILMEMBERS, ALSO I WILL JUST ASK YOU TO
08:20:06PM CONSIDER YOU HAVE IN FRONT OF YOU, CERTAINLY, THE LAND
08:20:10PM DEVELOPMENT 27-136 AS WELL AS THE WAIVER CRITERIA, 27-139.
08:20:16PM THE QUESTION THEN IS, IF THAT IS COUNCIL'S PLEASURE TO DO
08:20:21PM THAT, TO ENSURE THAT AT LEAST THEN WHAT THOSE CHANGES THEN
08:20:24PM DO WOULD BE TO BE ADDRESS YOUR CONCERNS AS IT WILL APPLY TO
08:20:31PM THE PURPOSE OF THE PD AND THE WAIVER CRITERIA.
08:20:35PM THE QUESTION WHETHER COLONEL IS WILLING TO CONSIDER THE
08:20:37PM WAIVERS AND HOW IT WILL RESULT WITH THE CHANGES THAT MIGHT
08:20:40PM SHALL OF THE PETITION IF YOU FOLLOW WHAT I AM SAYING.
08:20:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
08:20:44PM SIR ANYTHING ELSE TO ADD?
08:20:48PM >> I'M HERE JUST IN CASE YOU NEED IT.
08:20:50PM BUT I AGREE WITH WHAT STAFF WAS SAYING AND WHATEVER YOU GUYS
08:20:55PM WANT US TO DO TO MAKE THIS WORK.
08:20:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MR. SHELBY.
08:21:07PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: IF COUNCIL IS PREPARED TO GO FORWARD.
08:21:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MY QUESTIONS HAVE BEEN --
08:21:13PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: COUNCIL'S PLEASURE.
08:21:14PM THE THING IS, AGAIN, STAFF HAS SAID THEY WOULD NEED SOME
08:21:19PM DIRECTION FROM COUNCIL.
08:21:19PM IF COUNCIL WISHES TO CLOSE THE HEARING, THAT IS YOUR
08:21:24PM PREROGATIVE.
08:21:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN MADE A MOTION TO
08:21:28PM CLOSE.
08:21:29PM SECOND BY COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
08:21:31PM COUNCILMAN VIERA FOR ITEM NUMBER 7.
08:21:34PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON, 2002 LIKE TO READ ITEM NUMBER 7?
08:21:40PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: WELL --
08:21:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU CAN PASS OR VOTE TO APPROVE IT.
08:21:45PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: JUST FOR ROBERTS RULES OF ORDER NOT THAT I
08:21:49PM AM MAKING ANY JUDGMENTS, BUT BE REMINDED THE MAKER OF THE
08:21:55PM MOTION HAVE TO VOTE IN THE AFFIRMATIVE.
08:21:58PM SECONDER CAN VOTE EITHER WAY.
08:22:00PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I JUST HAPPEN TO -- LET ME JUST SAY, I AM
08:22:11PM VERY FAMILIAR WITH THE STREET.
08:22:12PM AND THE -- THE PLANS YOU PRESENTED JUST DO NOT FIT INTO THE
08:22:19PM HISTORIC NATURE OF THIS PARTICULAR BLOCK OF WEST TAMPA.
08:22:23PM AND SO I -- AND YOU NEED THREE WAIVERS.
08:22:30PM SO -- I WILL PASS.
08:22:35PM I MEAN -- I COULD, BUT I ALREADY DONE THAT ONCE TONIGHT.
08:22:44PM I DON'T WANT TO -- YOU KNOW.
08:22:47PM YEAH, I KNOW YOU LIKE DOING IT.
08:22:49PM IMP.
08:22:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN --
08:23:00PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: COUNCIL, AGAIN, IF YOU -- WHATEVER YOUR
08:23:03PM MOTION IS, PLEASE DO STATE THE EXCEPTION OF THE CODES UPON
08:23:08PM WHICH YOU ARE BASING YOUR DECISION.
08:23:09PM AND THE SPECIFIC CRITERIA AND APPLY THE FACTS THAT YOU KNOW
08:23:15PM IT TO BE TO THAT CRITERIA ON MAKING YOUR DECISION ON
08:23:19PM COMPETENT, SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE IN THE RECORD.
08:23:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANKS, COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
08:23:24PM CAN WE GET "JEOPARDY" MUSIC.
08:23:40PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WANT TO GET IT RIGHT.
08:23:41PM I MOVE TO DENY REZ-23-38 FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2107
08:23:57PM AND 210 9 WEST SPRUCE STREET DUE TO THE FAILURE OF THE
08:24:03PM APPLICANT TO MEET BURDEN OF PROOF TO MEET COMPETENT AND
08:24:06PM SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE THAT THE DEVELOPMENT AS CONDITIONED AND
08:24:09PM SHOWN ON THE SITE PLAN IS CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE
08:24:11PM PLAN AND CITY CODE AND THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY DISTRICT.
08:24:15PM AND THE APPLICANT'S FAILURE TO MEET ITS BURDEN OF PROOF WITH
08:24:19PM THE REQUESTED WAIVERS.
08:24:20PM I ALSO ADOPT THE FINDINGS AND REASONS OF THE CITY STAFF
08:24:25PM REPORT; HOWEVER, I FEEL THAT THE APPLICANT HAS FAILED TO
08:24:29PM COMPLY WITH APPLICABLE GOALS, POLICIES AND OBJECTIVES IN THE
08:24:33PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
08:24:33PM WHILE THE PROPOSED REZONING MAY FOLLOW -- BE ALLOWED FOR
08:24:37PM CONSIDERATION UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL R-35 DESIGNATION.
08:24:42PM THIS SEGMENT OF WEST SPRUCE STREET BETWEEN NORTH HOWARD AND
08:24:47PM ALBANY AVENUE HAVE BEEN DEVELOPED WITH SINGLE-FAMILY
08:24:51PM ATTACHED USES.
08:24:52PM FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH 27-136, PURPOSE OF SITE PLAN
08:24:56PM CONTROLLED DISTRICT ALTHOUGH THE PROPOSED AUTO US IS
08:25:00PM COMPATIBLE WITH THE SURROUNDING ENVIRONMENT, THE PROPOSED
08:25:02PM DEVELOPMENT AS SHOWN ON THE SITE PLAN DOES NOT PROMOTE
08:25:05PM DEVELOPMENT THAT IS APPROPRIATE IN ITS LOCATION AND OR
08:25:08PM CHARACTER BY FAILING TO APPLY FROM IT THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY
08:25:12PM DISTRICT DESIGN STANDARDS.
08:25:14PM THE WAIVERS THAT ARE REQUESTED ARE FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH
08:25:18PM 27-139-4, SUCH AS THE DESIRE AND NEED FOR WAIVERS
08:25:23PM NECESSARILY TO SUPPORT THE FACT THAT THE PROPOSED
08:25:27PM DEVELOPMENT IS NOT APPROPRIATE FOR THE SITE AND DOES NOT
08:25:30PM COMPLY WITH LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
08:25:31PM THE APPLICANT DID NOT PROVIDE EVIDENCE THAT THE PROPOSED
08:25:35PM DESIGN IS UNIQUE IN ORDER TO JUSTIFY THE WAIVERS.
08:25:38PM THE APPLICANT DID NOT PROVIDE EVIDENCE THAT THE REQUESTED
08:25:41PM WAIVERS WILL NOT SUBSTANTIALLY INTERFERE OR INJURY THE
08:25:44PM RIGHTS OF OTHERS WHOSE PROPERTY WILL BE AFFECTED BY THE
08:25:47PM WAIVERS.
08:25:47PM AND ADDITIONALLY IN 27-136, TO IT BE GRANTED A PD, SHOW
08:25:57PM SUBSTANTIAL COMPETENT EVIDENCE AND APPLICANT FAILED TO SHOW
08:26:01PM THAT AND DID NOT ENCOURAGE THE DEVELOPMENT WITH THE
08:26:04PM COMPATIBILITY WITH THE SURROUNDING IMPACTED NEIGHBORHOODS
08:26:08PM AND ENVIRONMENTS AND EXISTING GEOGRAPHY AND FAILED TO SHOW
08:26:13PM THAT THE ARCHITECTURE FEATURES AND ELEMENTS OF THE
08:26:15PM SURROUNDING COMMUNITY ENHANCE THE OVERALL QUALITY OF THE
08:26:18PM DEVELOPMENT.
08:26:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN MAKES THE MOTION.
08:26:22PM SECOND BY COUNCILMAN VIERA.
08:26:25PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
08:26:26PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
08:26:30PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
08:26:32PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
08:26:33PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
08:26:36PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
08:26:38PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
08:26:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
08:26:40PM >>CLERK: MOTION TO DENY CARRIED.
08:26:43PM UNANIMOUSLY.
08:26:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:26:49PM NEXT UP, ITEM NUMBER 8.
08:26:52PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
08:26:53PM LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT BOARD NATION.
08:26:57PM ITEM NUMBER 8 IS REZ-23-43.
08:27:02PM THIS IS FOR THE PROPERTY -- DOESN'T HAVE AN ADDRESS BUT
08:27:07PM 169180.0005 FOLIO.
08:27:11PM EAST OF NORTH ARMENIA STREET INTERSECTION.
08:27:15PM THE APPLICANT IS BEING REPRESENTED BY STEVE MICHELINI.
08:27:18PM THE REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY FROM PD PLANNED
08:27:22PM DEVELOPMENT WHICH CURRENTLY ALLOWS RO USES, RESIDENTIAL
08:27:27PM OFFICE USES TO PD TO RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY, SINGLE
08:27:32PM DETACHED USE ON-SITE.
08:27:34PM I WILL TURN IT OVER TO DAVID TO GIVE HIS REPORT.
08:27:36PM >>DAVID HEY: THANK YOU, DAVID HEY WITH YOUR PLANNING
08:27:40PM COMMISSION STAFF.
08:27:40PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
08:27:41PM WE REMAIN IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT.
08:27:44PM NEXT CASE MORE SPECIFICALLY LOCATED WITHIN THE WEST TAMPA
08:27:48PM URBAN VILLAGE AND THE NORTH HYDE PARK NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:27:51PM THE CLOSEST RECREATION FACILITY POINT 17 NORTHWEST OF THE
08:27:57PM SUBJECT SITE.
08:27:58PM VILA BROTHERS PARK.
08:28:00PM TRANSIT 285 FEET SOUTHWEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE AT NORTH
08:28:05PM ARMENIA AVENUE, WHICH IS A DESIGNATED TRANSIT EMPHASIS
08:28:10PM CORRIDOR AND THAT STREET IS SERVED WHICH HART ROUTE 14.
08:28:14PM THE SUBJECT SITE IN THE COASTAL HAZARD AREA PARTICULARLY
08:28:20PM ZONING PLAN C.
08:28:23PM ON TO THE AERIAL.
08:28:24PM WE HAVE THE SUBJECT SITE.
08:28:25PM THIS IS ARMENIA JUST TO THE WEST.
08:28:27PM THEN WE HAVE NORTH B LOCATED ALONG THE NORTH OF THE PARCEL.
08:28:32PM THE SURROUNDING AREA CONTAINS A MIX OF COMMERCIAL AND
08:28:39PM RESIDENTIAL USES.
08:28:40PM COMMERCIAL USES ARE SOUTH AND WEST OF THE SITE A NORTH
08:28:44PM ARMENIA AVENUE AND NORTH A STREETS.
08:28:49PM SINGLE-FAMILY TO THE NORTH AND EAST AND MULTIFAMILY USES ARE
08:28:53PM TO THE SOUTH OF THE SITE.
08:28:54PM HERE WE HAVE THE FUTURE ADOPTED LAND USE MAP.
08:29:01PM SUBJECT SITE AND PROPERTY LOCATED TO THE NORTH, EAST AND
08:29:06PM WEST AND WITHIN THAT RESIDENTIAL-20 LAND USE CATEGORY, THE
08:29:09PM BROWN.
08:29:09PM IMMEDIATELY TO THE SOUTH IN THE PINK COLOR, THE COMMUNITY
08:29:14PM MIXED USE 35.
08:29:15PM ALONG KENNEDY BOULEVARD WHICH IS FURTHER TO SOUTH, THE URBAN
08:29:20PM MIXED USE-60, FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY.
08:29:22PM THESE TAN COLORS FURTHER TO THE EAST AND TO THE WEST OF
08:29:27PM HABANA, THAT IS THE RESIDENTIAL-10.
08:29:30PM AND THERE ARE SOME POCKETS OF RESIDENTIAL-35 IN THE DARKER
08:29:34PM BROWN.
08:29:34PM AND THEN YOU ACTUALLY HAVE IN THE RED, THE COMMUNITY
08:29:38PM COMMERCIAL 35, WHICH ALLOWS UP TO A CI ZONING DISTRICT.
08:29:42PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REVIEWED THE EXISTING DENSITY OF
08:29:50PM RESIDENTIALLY DEVELOPED PROPERTY OF B STREET BETWEEN ARMENIA
08:29:55PM AVENUE AND NORTH HOWARD AVENUE.
08:29:57PM THIS SEGMENT IS DEVELOPED AT 10.7 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE
08:30:01PM BASED ON 17 SAMPLE SITES WHICH IS APPROXIMATELY 50% OF THE
08:30:05PM DENSITY ANTICIPATED IN THIS AREA OF THE CITY.
08:30:11PM THE PD 19.2 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE WHICH IS CONSISTENT WITH
08:30:15PM THE DENSITY PLANNED FOR UNDER THAT RESIDENTIAL-20
08:30:18PM DESIGNATION.
08:30:19PM BECAUSE THE PD EXCEEDS THE BY-RIGHT DENSITY OF 18 DWELLING
08:30:25PM UNITS PER ACRE UNDER THAT RESIDENTIAL-20, THE APPLICANT HAS
08:30:28PM ENTERED INTO A BONUS PROVISION AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY.
08:30:32PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDS THE REQUEST IS COMPARABLE
08:30:35PM AND COMPATIBLE WITH THIS PORTION OF WEST NORTH B STREET.
08:30:39PM FURTHERMORE, THE ASK WILL PROVIDE INFILL DEVELOPMENT ON A
08:30:43PM SITE THAT IS PRESENTLY UNDERUTILIZED WHICH IS ENCOURAGED BY
08:30:47PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
08:30:48PM THE REQUEST IS ALSO CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY'S COMPACT CITY
08:30:53PM FORM STRATEGY THAT SEEKS DENSITY OF WALKING AND TRANSIT NEAR
08:30:57PM EMPLOYMENT CONCENTRATIONS, RESIDENTIAL SERVICES AND
08:31:01PM AMENITIES.
08:31:01PM THE -- THE REZONING ALSO MEETS THE INTENT OF THE LAND USE
08:31:08PM POLICY 4.3.2, 4.3.6, AND 9.2.6, DEALING WITH THE ORIENTATION
08:31:16PM OF THE BUILDING AND CONSISTENT WITH POLICY DIRECTION
08:31:18PM REGARDING PROVIDING HOUSING CHOICES FOR THE CITIZENS OF
08:31:21PM TAMPA.
08:31:22PM AND BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION
08:31:26PM STAFF FINDS THE PROPOSED PLANNED DEVELOPMENT CONSISTENT WITH
08:31:29PM THE PROVISIONS OF THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
08:31:34PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT
08:31:46PM COORDINATION.
08:31:46PM THE REQUEST FOR A PD FOR TWO UNITS ON-SITE.
08:31:49PM I WILL JUST PUT THE AERIAL -- THE ZONING AERIAL UP TO SEE
08:31:53PM VISUALLY A LITTLE BIT BETTER WHAT WE ARE LOOKING AT HERE ON
08:31:56PM THE SITE.
08:31:56PM SO THIS IS THE SITE WHICH IS OUTLINED IN RED.
08:32:03PM THIS IS ARMENIA AVENUE.
08:32:05PM THIS IS NORTH B.
08:32:06PM SO THIS -- CURRENTLY THIS SITE IS A PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT.
08:32:11PM AND THIS ALLOWS FOR ALL RO-1 USE.
08:32:15PM WHAT IS BEFORE YOU TO TAKE THIS PORTION OF THE SITE AND
08:32:18PM CREATE THE PD TO ALLOW FOR THESE USES ON-SITE.
08:32:21PM SO THERE ARE TWO UNITS THAT ARE REQUESTED.
08:32:24PM THE SETBACKS THAT ARE PROVIDED ARE TO THE NORTH, 17 FEET.
08:32:29PM TO THE SOUTH, 18 FEET.
08:32:31PM TO THE WEST AND EAST ARE 5 FOOT SETBACKS.
08:32:34PM FOUR PARKING SPACES ARE REQUIRED.
08:32:36PM AND SIX PARKING SPACES ARE PROVIDED.
08:32:44PM THE REQUEST IS IN THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY AND MUST MEET THE
08:32:47PM WEST TAMPA OVERLAY STANDARDS AT THE TIME OF PERMITTING.
08:32:51PM THIS SITE AS DAVID MENTIONED IS IN A FUTURE LAND USE.
08:32:57PM 18 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE.
08:33:02PM AND WITH THE BONUS AGREEMENT UP TO 20 UNITS PER ACRE.
08:33:05PM THE APPLICANT AS DAVID MENTIONED HAS ENTERED INTO A BONUS
08:33:08PM AGREEMENT TO ALLOW FOR ONE ADDITIONAL UNIT TO PROVIDE THE
08:33:11PM TWO UNITS ON-SITE.
08:33:12PM AND THAT BONUS PAYMENT WILL BE IN THE AMOUNT OF 32,050 FOR
08:33:24PM THE NEWS.
08:33:25PM WHAT I HAVE DONE IS PUT A SITE PLAN FOR YOU.
08:33:27PM ON THE SITE PLAN, THIS IS WEST NORTH B STREET.
08:33:31PM THIS IS THE PROPERTY BOUNDARY THAT IS LOCATED HERE.
08:33:33PM SO THE STRUCTURE ON-SITE, YOU CAN SEE THERE IDENTIFIED AS
08:33:43PM UNIT 1 AND UNIT TWO.
08:33:45PM YOU CAN SEE THE STEPS AND THE PEDESTRIAN PAST TO THE
08:33:48PM SIDEWALK AND YOU HAVE VEHICULAR ACCESS FROM THE ALLEY.
08:33:50PM UNIT TWO HAS A TWO-CAR GARAGE ENCLOSED.
08:33:54PM UNIT ONE HAS A ONE-CAR GARAGE.
08:33:57PM ON THIS ONE, YOU WILL NOTICE THE ACTUAL DESIGN OF UNIT ONE
08:34:04PM HAS BEEN DESIGNED IN A WAY TO ACCOMMODATE AND SAVE THE
08:34:07PM EXISTING TREE, WHICH IS A LIVE OAK, WHICH IS LOCATED EAST OF
08:34:13PM THIS SITE.
08:34:13PM SO THE APPLICANT MODIFIED THE DESIGN.
08:34:16PM HAS PROVIDED IN UNIT ONE, A ONE-CAR GARAGE.
08:34:22PM AND THAT ALLOWS THE APPLICANT TO KEEP THAT 20-FOOT
08:34:26PM PROTECTIVE RADIUS WHICH IS REQUIRED AND PRESERVATION OF THAT
08:34:30PM TREE.
08:34:31PM THERE IS A REVISION SHEET THAT IS INCLUDED.
08:34:33PM AND IT WOULD INCLUDE A LIST OF CHANGES TO BE MADE BETWEEN
08:34:37PM FIRST AND SECOND READING.
08:34:38PM ONE OF THE CHANGES THAT THE APPLICANT WILL MAKE IS PUT THE
08:34:46PM ACTUAL PARKING SPACE THAT IS HERE TO MAKE A PAD HERE TO THE
08:34:48PM RIGHT SO IT AVOID A WAIVER THAT WILL BE REQUIRED FROM
08:34:52PM TRANSPORTATION.
08:34:53PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: A WAIVER?
08:34:58PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THERE IS NO WAIVER.
08:34:59PM IT WOULD AVOID IT.
08:35:01PM RIGHT NOW IT WOULD SHOW A WAIVER OF TRANSPORTATION WOULD BE
08:35:04PM REQUIRED.
08:35:04PM WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO DO -- THAT THE SITE PLAN ITSELF, SO I
08:35:08PM WILL SHOW YOU THE ELEVATIONS.
08:35:10PM ON THE SITE.
08:35:11PM THE TOP LIFT, THE NORTH ELEVATION.
08:35:22PM THE SOUTH ELEVATION ON THE RIGHT.
08:35:24PM AND BOTTOM IMAGES.
08:35:26PM TO THE WEST.
08:35:30PM AND THE EAST ELEVATION IS LOCATED THERE.
08:35:33PM THE ZONING MAP AGAIN, JUST TO SHOW YOU THE ZONING IN THE
08:35:37PM AREA, ON ARMENIA, YOU HAVE, OF COURSE, THE PD THAT IS HERE.
08:35:42PM A COUPLE OF CN AND COMMERCIAL ZONING DESIGNATION.
08:35:45PM AS YOU HEAD FURTHER WEST ON THE WEST SIDE OF ARMENIA, YOU
08:35:50PM HAVE YOUR RESIDENTIAL RM-16 ZONING DESIGNATION AND ALSO
08:35:54PM NORTH AND NORTHEAST OF THE SITE.
08:35:55PM AS YOU HEAD FURTHER SOUTH FROM THIS PROPERTY TOWARD KENNEDY
08:35:59PM IS WHERE YOU HAVE YOUR COMMERCIAL ZONING AND USES IN THAT
08:36:03PM AREA.
08:36:04PM AND SO I HAVE PICTURES OF THE SITE.
08:36:09PM THIS IS THE SIDE OF THE SITE
08:36:14PM BUT THIS IS SHOWING YOU EAST OF THE SITE.
08:36:16PM THIS IS IT ANOTHER VIEW, ANOTHER ANGLE SHOWING YOU THE SITE
08:36:19PM THAT IS LOCATED THERE.
08:36:21PM THIS IS THE VIEW IF YOU ARE LOOKING WEST ON NORTH B AND THE
08:36:26PM SITE IS OFF TO THE LEFT -- TO MY LEFT IN THE PICTURE.
08:36:30PM THIS IS THE WEST SIDE OF THIS PD, THE CURRENT PD.
08:36:38PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW OF THE WEST SIDE.
08:36:42PM THIS IS ON ARMENIA.
08:36:44PM THIS IS ON THE NORTHWEST CORNER.
08:36:47PM AND THEN THIS IS EAST OF THE SITE.
08:36:50PM WHICH IS CURRENTLY VACANT.
08:36:54PM THE DRC STAFF REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FOUND THE REQUEST
08:37:00PM INCONSISTENT.
08:37:00PM ONE OF THE FINDINGS OF INCONSISTENT IS REALLY THE ONLY ONE
08:37:04PM WHICH IS THROUGH STONE TO STORMWATER OF MODIFICATION OF THE
08:37:10PM SITE PLAN TO SHOW THE RETENTION ON THE PLAN.
08:37:12PM THAT WAS NOT INCLUDED ON THIS VERSION.
08:37:14PM ONCE THEY MAKE THE CHANGE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING,
08:37:17PM STORMWATER WILL BE CONSISTENT.
08:37:18PM I HAVE PROVIDED -- I HAVE A REVISED REVISION SHEET, WHICH I
08:37:23PM WILL PROVIDE TO COUNCIL.
08:37:25PM HAND THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
08:37:27PM I AM AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
08:37:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME?
08:37:35PM NO?
08:37:36PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:37:36PM APPLICANT, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
08:37:38PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
08:37:40PM STEVE MICHELINI.
08:37:41PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
08:37:42PM AND I AM REPRESENTING THE PETITIONER ON THIS PROJECT.
08:37:44PM AS LACHONE POINTED OUT TO YOU, THIS PROPERTY IS CURRENTLY --
08:37:49PM CAN I LEAVE SOME OF THAT STUFF HERE.
08:37:51PM THIS PROPERTY IS CURRENTLY ZONED RO-1 WHICH IS CURRENTLY
08:37:58PM RESIDENTIAL OFFICE.
08:37:59PM WE ARE CONVERTING THE RESIDENTIAL OFFICE PORTION TO
08:38:01PM RESIDENTIAL, WHICH IS ESSENTIALLY A DOWNZONING.
08:38:05PM IT IS A VACANT PARCEL.
08:38:07PM AND IT -- IT IS CONSISTENT WITH THE LAND USE CODES RELATED
08:38:14PM TO THIS PROPERTY.
08:38:15PM IT IS SURROUNDED BY COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES TO THE WEST AND TO
08:38:20PM THE SOUTH OF THIS AND ALSO TO THE NORTH.
08:38:22PM AND IT IS IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO AN OFFICE WHICH IS ABOUT
08:38:27PM -- WHICH FRONTS ON ARMENIA.
08:38:29PM SO WE ARE ALSO ON A TRANSIT CORRIDOR.
08:38:33PM AND AS -- AS THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF POINTED OUT IT
08:38:38PM IS R-20 AND CMU YOU-35 IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO THIS.
08:38:42PM AND THIS IS -- THIS IS AN IDEAL LOCATION FOR INFILL.
08:38:46PM AS STAFF ALSO POINTED OUT, THIS DOESN'T HAVE AN OFFICIAL
08:38:51PM ADDRESS.
08:38:51PM IT IS ANOTHER ONE OF THOSE ODD LOT INFILL PROJECTS THAT I
08:39:00PM PRESENTED TO YOU A FEW WEEKS AGO.
08:39:02PM THE MISSING NOTE FROM STORMWATER, IF IT HAD BEEN THERE, WE
08:39:07PM WOULDN'T HAVE AN AREA OF INCONSISTENCY BUT WILL MAKE THE
08:39:11PM CHANGES BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING IF IT IS THE
08:39:14PM PLEASURE OF COUNCIL TO APPROVE THIS.
08:39:15PM IT IS A TWO-UNIT PROJECT.
08:39:17PM IT IS A DUPLEX.
08:39:18PM IT HAS ALLEY ACCESS FOR BOTH PROPERTIES.
08:39:22PM BOTH PROPOSED UNITS.
08:39:23PM AND IT ALSO HAVE -- THE FRONT DOORS ARE FACING NORTH B
08:39:27PM STREET.
08:39:28PM AND I THINK LACHONE POINTED THAT OUT TO YOU.
08:39:33PM THE FRONT DOOR FACING NORTH B STREET.
08:39:42PM WE HAVE ALLEY ACCESS THAT WILL BE REQUIRED ALSO TO PAVE AND
08:39:45PM IMPROVE THAT ALLEY FOR THAT ACCESS.
08:39:47PM AND -- AND JUST SORT OF ANTICIPATING A QUESTION THAT MIGHT
08:39:51PM COME UP REGARDING THE GARAGES.
08:39:53PM THEY ARE 20 FEET WIDE, WHICH IS ADEQUATE FOR TWO CARS.
08:40:00PM AND THE SINGLE GARAGE IS 11 FEET, WHICH IS ALSO ADEQUATE FOR
08:40:06PM A SINGLE CAR.
08:40:06PM WE SHIFTED THE BUILDING TO ACCOMMODATE AN OFF-SITE LIVE OAK
08:40:13PM TREE.
08:40:13PM SO YOU SEE THAT CUT OUT THERE AND TRYING TO BE SENSITIVE TO
08:40:17PM THE SITE CONDITIONS, WHICH ARE REALLY DICTATING HOW
08:40:24PM DEVELOPS.
08:40:25PM THE STAFF POINTED OUT TO YOU IN THE EVENT WE GET TO A SECOND
08:40:32PM READING, THIS PARKING SPACE WILL BE SHIFTED TO ELIMINATE ALL
08:40:35PM OF THE WAIVERS.
08:40:38PM SO WE DO -- WE STILL HAVE TO COMPLY WITH THE WEST TAMPA
08:40:42PM OVERLAY.
08:40:43PM AND WE ARE STILL GOING TO DO THAT.
08:40:45PM SO WE WILL BE -- IN DURING CONSTRUCTION PHASES, WE WILL HAVE
08:40:50PM TO COMPLY WITH ALL OF THOSE CODES.
08:40:52PM THE BONUS PROVISION IS TO ALLOW THE SECOND UNIT.
08:40:56PM YOU CAN BUILD ONE BY RIGHT, BUT WE ARE AT 18 UNITS UNDER THE
08:41:01PM REQUEST FOR TWO UNITS.
08:41:04PM A TYPICAL DUPLEX.
08:41:05PM THIS IS NOT A LARGE SCALE PROJECT.
08:41:07PM THIS IS A SMALL INFILL-STYLE PROJECT.
08:41:10PM WE -- WE ARE REQUIRED TO HAVE FOUR PARKING SPACES.
08:41:17PM WE ARE PROVIDE SOMETHING SIX.
08:41:18PM WE AGAIN, WE ARE MOVING THE BUILDING OVER TO ACCOMMODATE THE
08:41:27PM OFF-SITE TREE.
08:41:28PM I HAVE A LETTER HERE FROM AN ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNER
08:41:32PM INDICATING THAT THEY HAVE NO OBJECTION TO -- TO THIS
08:41:36PM PROJECT.
08:41:36PM AND THEY FEEL LIKE THE SETBACKS THAT WE ARE PROPOSING ARE
08:41:41PM COMPATIBLE AND ACCEPTABLE TO THEM.
08:41:42PM I WILL BE HAPPY TO GIVE THIS TO -- JUST WITH RESPECT TO THE
08:42:01PM PROXIMITY, WE ARE 50 FEET OFF OF ARMENIA IN THIS LOT HERE.
08:42:06PM AND AS YOU CAN SEE, WE HAVE COMMERCIAL HERE.
08:42:08PM WE HAVE COMMERCIAL AND TOWN HOUSE-STYLE PROJECTS HERE.
08:42:13PM AND I THINK THOSE OF HOW ARE FAMILIAR WITH THE AREA THOUGH
08:42:16PM IN A FAIRLY INTENSIVELY DEVELOPED AREA AND, AGAIN, ARMENIA
08:42:22PM IS PART OF A TRANSIT CORRIDOR.
08:42:25PM WE HAVE ENDEAVORED TO MEET THE REQUIREMENTS THAT ARE
08:42:28PM ESTABLISHED BY THE CODE.
08:42:29PM AND, AGAIN, LET ME JUST READ THROUGH THEM REAL QUICK.
08:42:34PM THE PURPOSE IS FOR INFILL IN DEVELOPMENTS TO ENCOURAGE
08:42:39PM OPTIMAL USE OF PUBLIC FACILITIES.
08:42:41PM AND THIS DOES THAT.
08:42:42PM THE GROUND FLOOR ENTRANCES FACING NORTH B STREET.
08:42:51PM THE STANDARD IS MET.
08:42:52PM WE ARE PROVIDING ALL THE PARKING THAT IS REQUIRED.
08:42:55PM PROMOTE THE EFFICIENT, SUSTAINABLE USE OF LAND.
08:42:57PM AGAIN THIS IS AN ODD LOT THAT IS AN INFILL AND ZONING FROM
08:43:02PM RESIDENTIAL OFFICE TO RESIDENTIAL.
08:43:04PM ENCOURAGE THE FLEXIBLE AND LAND DEVELOPMENT.
08:43:07PM THIS ALSO ACCOMPLISHES THAT.
08:43:11PM PROMOTE AND ENCOURAGE DEVELOPMENT WHERE APPROPRIATE IN
08:43:15PM LOCATION.
08:43:17PM BUT FOR THE FACT THAT THIS IS AN ODD LOT THAT IS ASSOCIATED
08:43:22PM OR CLOSE -- IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO THE COMMERCIAL PROPERTY,
08:43:25PM IT BOO NEVER HAPPEN.
08:43:27PM SO OPTIMALLY USING THE VACANT LOT THAT NORMALLY WOULD NOT BE
08:43:31PM DEVELOPED.
08:43:32PM PROMOTE DESIRABLE LIVING CONDITIONS.
08:43:34PM THE REQUESTED UNITS, AGAIN, ONE CAN BE BUILT BY RIGHT.
08:43:38PM AND TWO WITH A BONUS PROVISION.
08:43:41PM BUT WE ARE MEETING THE -- THE INTENT OF THE CODE REGARDING
08:43:46PM BOTH THE LAND USE CODE AND THE CITY INTENT FOR PROVIDING
08:43:49PM MORE HOUSING AND IT IS IN THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY DISTRICT
08:43:55PM AND WE HAVE TO MEET ALL THAT CRITERIA.
08:43:57PM I WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE.
08:44:00PM AND WE ARE RESPECTFULLY REQUESTING YOUR APPROVAL.
08:44:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN?
08:44:05PM DO WE HAVE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS
08:44:07PM ITEM?
08:44:08PM THIS IS ITEM NUMBER 8?
08:44:10PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM?
08:44:14PM WE HAVE NOBODY REGISTERED.
08:44:15PM DO YOU NEED ANY REBUTTAL, SIR?
08:44:20PM >> NO, SIR, UNLESS -- REBUT MYSELF.
08:44:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO YOU DISAGREE WITH WHAT YOU SAID?
08:44:25PM >> NO, NO, I DIDN'T.
08:44:27PM I AGREE WHOLEHEARTEDLY AND WE ALSO AGREE TO MAKE THE
08:44:31PM REVISIONS AS LACHONE HAS PASSED OUT BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
08:44:36PM READING.
08:44:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: VERY GOOD.
08:44:38PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I HAVE A COMMENT.
08:44:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILMAN
08:44:43PM CLENDENIN.
08:44:43PM SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
08:44:45PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
08:44:46PM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN, A COMMENT FROM YOU?
08:44:49PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I DO.
08:44:49PM I WANT TO SAY, ONE, IT IS SO REFRESHING THAT -- BECAUSE I AM
08:44:55PM SO USED TO SEEING THESE TYPE OF PDs AND TRYING TO PUT FOUR
08:44:59PM UNITS ON THE PIECE OF PROPERTY THAT YOU ARE PRESENTING FOR
08:45:01PM US TODAY.
08:45:02PM SO THIS IS A REFRESHING CHANGE.
08:45:04PM AND THE FACT THAT YOU MADE THE DESIGN CHANGES TO ACCOMMODATE
08:45:07PM SAVING -- AND ACCOMMODATING THE TREE.
08:45:11PM YOU KNOW THE GARAGES WHILE THEY ARE NOT SPACIOUS CAN
08:45:14PM ACCOMMODATE WHAT NEEDS TO BE ACCOMMODATED IN A GARAGE.
08:45:19PM AREA YOU ARE DEVELOPING, THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT WE ARE DOING
08:45:23PM AS YOU HIGHLIGHT THE TRANSIT CORRIDOR, BUILDING DENSITY.
08:45:26PM AN INTENSELY DEVELOPED AREA.
08:45:29PM THIS STRIKES, HONESTLY, EVERY ONE OF THE CORES AS FAR AS
08:45:32PM FUTURE LAND USE AND DEVELOPMENT IN THE CITY OF TAMPA.
08:45:35PM AND THIS IS THE KIND OF PROJECT THAT WAS BROUGHT BEFORE US
08:45:38PM EVERY DAY, I THINK WE WOULD BE SMOOTH SAILING AND WOULDN'T
08:45:41PM HAVE TO DENY THAT MANY PROJECTS.
08:45:43PM BUT THIS IS A GOOD ONE.
08:45:44PM GOOD JOB.
08:45:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:45:46PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON, WOULD YOU LIKE TO READ ITEM NUMBER
08:45:51PM 8?
08:45:52PM SORRY, COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
08:45:53PM >>LYNN HURTAK: JUST QUICKLY I WANT TO ECHO WHAT COUNCILMAN
08:45:56PM CLENDENIN SAID.
08:45:57PM IT IS A PROJECT THAT REALLY LOOK AT THE SPACE.
08:46:07PM PROTECTS THE TREE.
08:46:08PM FRONT YARD -- FRONT DOOR ACCESS WITH THE ALLEY FOR THE CARS.
08:46:12PM AND A DECENT WIDTH FOR THE GARAGES AND I WANT TO SAY THIS IS
08:46:18PM EXACTLY WHAT WE NEED IN THE CITY OF TAMPA.
08:46:20PM SO THANK YOU.
08:46:24PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I MOVE FILE NUMBER REZ-23-43, ORDINANCE
08:46:28PM BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION.
08:46:34PM ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF FOLIO
08:46:39PM NUMBER 169180-00 05 IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, AND MORE
08:46:46PM PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1, FROM ZONING DISTRICT
08:46:49PM CLASSIFICATIONS PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT TO PD, PLANNED
08:46:53PM DEVELOPMENT, RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY, SEMI DETACHED,
08:46:56PM PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
08:46:58PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: WITH THE REVISION SHEET.
08:47:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WITH THE REVISION SHEET.
08:47:02PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: WITH THE REVISION.
08:47:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: RESOLUTION GETS MOVED AFTER SECOND
08:47:09PM READING.
08:47:11PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: WITH THE REVISION SHEET.
08:47:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
08:47:14PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
08:47:16PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
08:47:17PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
08:47:20PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
08:47:21PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
08:47:22PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
08:47:25PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
08:47:26PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
08:47:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
08:47:28PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
08:47:31PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON OCTOBER 15,
08:47:36PM 2023, AT 9:30 A.M. AT OLD CITY HALL LOCATED AT 315 E.
08:47:43PM KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
08:47:47PM THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
08:47:49PM I WANT TO MAKE ONE FINAL COMMENT.
08:47:51PM WE TRY VERY HARD TO MEET THE CRITERIA AND WE LISTEN TO YOUR
08:47:55PM COMMENTS AND TAKE THEM BACK AND TRY OUR BEST TO FACILITATE
08:48:00PM THAT.
08:48:00PM THANK YOU FOR RECOGNIZING THE EFFORT.
08:48:03PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES, THANK YOU, MR. MICHELINI AND SAVING
08:48:07PM THE GRAND OAK.
08:48:09PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: IF I CAN, MADAM CLERK.
08:48:11PM REPEAT THE DATE AGAIN FOR PURPOSES OF THE RECORD.
08:48:14PM >>CLERK: SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE OCTOBER 5, 2023
08:48:18PM AT 9:30 A.M.
08:48:20PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: REMINDER, COUNCIL.
08:48:22PM THIS TRAVELS WITH A BONUS PROVISION AGREEMENT THAT WILL BE
08:48:25PM ON THE AGENDA FOR THAT DATE FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION.
08:48:31PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: MY BIRTHDAY, BY THE WAY.
08:48:33PM OCTOBER 5.
08:48:35PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: REMINDER, TWO MEMBERS OF COUNCIL WILL NOT
08:48:38PM BE PRESENT ON THAT DATE.
08:48:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NEITHER ONE OF US WILL.
08:48:43PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I AM GOING TO MISS YOUR BIRTHDAY.
08:48:46PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
08:48:48PM GO AHEAD.
08:48:49PM ITEM NUMBER 9.
08:48:52PM >>LUIS VIERA: BEFORE, IF I MAY, MR. SHELBY, I WANTED TO --
08:48:55PM FOR THIS ONE, I DISCUSSED THIS WITH MR. SHELBY AND I WISH TO
08:49:00PM ABSTAIN ON THIS QUASI JUDICIAL MATTER OUT OF AN ABUNDANCE OF
08:49:04PM CAUTION TO AVOID AN APPEARANCE OF A CONFLICT OF INTEREST AND
08:49:08PM A FAIR PROCEEDING.
08:49:11PM DOESN'T APPEAR TO BE A VERY CONTESTED ONE.
08:49:14PM LONG STORY SHORT, AN INDIVIDUAL WHO APPEARS TO BE CONTESTING
08:49:19PM -- HE AND I ARE VIRTUALLY LIKE FAMILY.
08:49:21PM AND THAT'S IT.
08:49:22PM THAT -- JUST OUT OF AN ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION.
08:49:25PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: HAVE YOU SUBMITTED THE APPROPRIATE FORM.
08:49:30PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
08:49:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE THE
08:49:34PM MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
08:49:35PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
08:49:37PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
08:49:38PM AYE.
08:49:40PM YOU MAY STEP OUT.
08:49:41PM YES, MA'AM.
08:49:42PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
08:49:44PM ITEM NUMBER 9 IS REZ-23-55, FOR THE PROPERTY 5210 BAYSHORE
08:49:55PM BOULEVARD.
08:49:55PM THE APPLICANT IS REPRESENTED BY DAVID MECHANIK FROM RS-60
08:50:01PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY TO PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT
08:50:04PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED.
08:50:06PM AND TURN TO IT OVER TO DAVID TO GIVE HIS REPORT.
08:50:10PM >>DAVID HEY: DAVID HEY, WITH PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
08:50:14PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
08:50:15PM SOUTH TOUCHDOWN -- TAMPA DISTRICT, THE BALLAST POINT
08:50:22PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:50:22PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN THE MacDILL AIR FORCE BASE FLIGHT
08:50:28PM PATH AND THE CLOSEST PUBLIC RECREATION FACILITY IS BALLAST
08:50:33PM POINT PARK WHICH IS A LITTLE UNDER HALF A MILE EAST OF THE
08:50:36PM SITE.
08:50:37PM NO TRANSIT WITHIN THE PROXIMITY OF THE SITE.
08:50:39PM AND THIS SITE IS WITHIN THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA AND
08:50:43PM EVACUATION ZONE A.
08:50:45PM HERE WE HAVE THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND ALL THE
08:50:54PM PROPERTY IS UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-20 FUTURE LAND USE
08:50:59PM PROPERTY.
08:50:59PM IF YOU GO WEST OF RUSSELL STREET, IT WILL GO DOWN TO THE
08:51:04PM RESIDENTIAL-10.
08:51:04PM THERE IS SOME RESIDENTIAL-35 AND RESIDENTIAL 50 TO THE
08:51:07PM NORTH.
08:51:13PM RESIDENTIAL 83 UNDER THAT DARK BROWN COLOR AND COMMUNITY USE
08:51:19PM 35 NEAR GANDY.
08:51:20PM BLUE IS QUASI PUBLIC AND GREEN IS BALLAST POINT PARK FOR
08:51:24PM RECREATION/OPEN SPACE.
08:51:25PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS ON THE INTERIOR OF THE BALLAST POINT
08:51:37PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND SURROUND BY A COLLECTOR ROADWAY AND
08:51:40PM SURROUNDED BY RESIDENTIAL-20.
08:51:41PM THE SURROUNDING AREA IS PREDOMINANTLY RESIDENTIAL IN
08:51:44PM CHARACTER WITH A MIX OF SINGLE FAMILY DETACHED AND
08:51:48PM MULTIFAMILY USES, SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED USES ARE PRESENT ON
08:51:51PM THE WEST PORTION OF BAYSHORE BOULEVARD BETWEEN WEST BALLAST
08:51:55PM POINT BOULEVARD AND WEST TYSON AVENUE.
08:51:57PM SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED AND MULTIFAMILY USES ARE PRESENT ON
08:52:00PM THE WEST PORTION OF THE SEGMENT OF BAYSHORE BOULEVARD.
08:52:07PM GIVEN THE PRESENCE OF SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED TO THE WEST AND
08:52:11PM COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT TO THE SOUTHWEST OF THE SITE, PLANNING
08:52:13PM COMMISSION STAFF HAS DETERMINED THAT THE SITE IS APPROPRIATE
08:52:16PM FOR DETACHED SINGLE-FAMILY USES.
08:52:18PM THE REQUEST WILL EXPAND OPPORTUNITIES FOR HOUSING CHOICES IN
08:52:22PM THE BALLAST POINT NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:52:24PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REVIEWED THE EXISTING DENSITIES OF
08:52:26PM THE SURROUNDING AREA.
08:52:27PM ALL SAMPLES ARE WITHIN THE MacDILL AIR FORCE BASE FLIGHT
08:52:32PM PATH, EVEN THOUGH IT IS RESIDENTIAL-20, THERE IS A CAP
08:52:35PM WITHIN THAT FLIGHT PATH THAT YOU CAN NOT EXCEED 10 DWELLING
08:52:41PM UNITS PER ACRE.
08:52:42PM THE SEGMENT ON BAYSHORE BETWEEN WEST BALANCE LAST POINT AND
08:52:46PM WEST TYSON EXCLUDING THE SUBJECT SITE IS DEVELOPED AT 8.19
08:52:51PM DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE.
08:52:53PM ADDITIONALLY, THE PORTION OF SOUTH JULES VERNE COURT IS
08:52:58PM DEVELOPED 7.2 DWELLING UNITS.
08:53:03PM 10 DWELLING UNITS PER ACHOR IS ANTICIPATED WITH THE DENSITY
08:53:07PM UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-20.
08:53:08PM THE SITE PLAN ALSO DOES MEET -- IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
08:53:13PM POLICY REGARDING THE ORIENTATION OF THE BUILDINGS TO THE
08:53:16PM LOCAL, THE ADJACENT PUBLIC RIGHTS-OF-WAY.
08:53:26PM THE APPLICANT NEEDS TO WORK WITH THE CITY OF TAMPA AND OTHER
08:53:29PM AGENCIES TO MAKE SURE THAT ANY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
08:53:32PM MITIGATES IMPACT ON SHELTER PLACE.
08:53:33PM IN CONCLUSION, THE REQUEST IS CONSISTENT WITH THE DENSITY
08:53:37PM UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-20 AND WITHIN THE MacDILL AIR FORCE
08:53:45PM BASE FLIGHT PATH AND REQUEST IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE
08:53:47PM SURROUNDING AREA AND WILL PROVIDE THE HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES
08:53:50PM IN SOUTH TAMPA.
08:53:51PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
08:53:54PM FINDS THE PROPOSED PLANNED DEVELOPMENT CONSISTENT WITH THE
08:53:57PM PROPOSED COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
08:53:58PM THANK YOU.
08:53:59PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
08:54:03PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
08:54:05PM THIS REQUEST BEFORE YOU FOR THIS PD WOULD ALLOW FOR A TOTAL
08:54:09PM OF SIX RESIDENTIAL UNITS ON-SITE.
08:54:11PM SO THERE ARE TWO RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED UNITS
08:54:16PM AND A TOTAL OF FOUR RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED
08:54:19PM UNITS.
08:54:19PM SO JUST TO SHOW YOU A LITTLE BIT BETTER, I WILL JUST PUT THE
08:54:24PM SITE PLAN UP.
08:54:25PM SO THIS IS BAYSHORE BOULEVARD.
08:54:28PM THIS LOT RUNS FROM STREET TO STREET.
08:54:31PM STREET FRONTAGE.
08:54:32PM ON THE WEST SIDE OF THE PROPERTY IS WHERE YOU WILL FIND
08:54:37PM UNITS LOCATED WHICH ARE ATTACHED.
08:54:38PM AND THEY ARE IDENTIFIED ON THE SITE PLAN UNIT 1, 2, 3, AND
08:54:43PM UNIT 4.
08:54:44PM FRONT DOOR ENTRIES ARE ACTUALLY ORIENTED TOWARD BAYSHORE
08:54:50PM WITH EACH UNIT WITH THE FRONT DOORS LOCATED HERE AND HERE.
08:54:53PM AND HERE AND HERE.
08:54:54PM EACH UNIT PROVIDES A TWO-CAR ENCLOSED GARAGE.
08:54:58PM AND THEN SURFACE PARKING THAT IS LOCATED HERE ON-SITE.
08:55:01PM VEHICULAR ACCESS TO THE SITE IS FROM BAYSHORE ON THESE UNITS
08:55:06PM AND PARK HERE ON THE SURFACE PARKING LOCATED HERE.
08:55:09PM LOOK AT EAST SIDE OF THE SITE, THE TWO DETACHED FAMILY
08:55:16PM UNITS.
08:55:17PM TWO-CAR GARAGES ARE PROVIDED AND EACH UNIT HAS A PORCH AND I
08:55:22PM HAVE ELEVATIONS TO SHOW YOU WITH THE -- WITH THE SITE.
08:55:28PM SO THE PARKING SPACES REQUIRED ARE 13 SPACES.
08:55:33PM AND THIS IS FOR THE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACH THE STRUCTURES AND
08:55:39PM 20 SPACES ARE PROVIDED FOR THE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED AND
08:55:43PM AIR ATTACHED TOGETHER.
08:55:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. SHELBY, CAN YOU TAKE THE
08:55:50PM CONVERSATION OUTSIDE.
08:55:51PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I APOLOGIZE.
08:55:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD.
08:55:55PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THEN WE HAVE THE ELEVATIONS.
08:56:00PM THESE ARE THE ELEVATIONS OF THE UNITS ON THE WEST.
08:56:02PM ON THE WEST IS THE SINGLE FAMILY ATTACHED AND THESE ARE THE
08:56:07PM ELEVATIONS.
08:56:08PM SO YOU CAN SEE THIS IS THE FRONT ELEVATION.
08:56:10PM THIS IS ALONG BAYSHORE.
08:56:12PM THIS IS THE -- THE LEFT SIDE OF THE ELEVATION, THE BOTTOM.
08:56:17PM PICTURE.
08:56:19PM AND THIS IS THE REAR ELEVATION AND THE BOTTOM PICTURE IS THE
08:56:29PM RIGHT SIDE ELEVATION FOR THOSE UNITS.
08:56:32PM AND THEN WE HAVE THE ELEVATIONS THAT I WILL SHOW YOU WITH I
08:56:35PM IS THE SAME FOR EACH SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED UNIT.
08:56:38PM AND I WILL SHOW YOU ONE ELEVATION.
08:56:39PM OPPOSITE SIDES.
08:56:41PM THE GARAGES.
08:56:42PM THIS IS THE FRONT ELEVATION.
08:56:45PM AND WE HAVE THE LEFT SIDE, YOU CAN SEE THE GARAGES LOCATED
08:56:50PM THERE.
08:56:50PM AND THIS IS THE REAR AND THEN ON THE RIGHT SIDE -- OR THE
08:56:57PM NORTH.
08:56:57PM AND I HAVE THE ZONING MAP OF THE AREA.
08:57:00PM SO THIS IS THE PROPERTY WHICH IS IDENTIFIED HERE IN THE RED
08:57:06PM DOTTED LINE.
08:57:07PM THIS IS BAYSHORE.
08:57:08PM SO YOU CAN SEE THE RS-60 ZONING WHICH IS HERE.
08:57:12PM AND YOU HAVE THE PD DEVELOPMENT WHICH IS RESIDENTIAL
08:57:16PM MULTIFAMILY, RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED USES.
08:57:19PM FURTHER NORTHWEST AND TO THE WEST AND FURTHER EAST YOU HAVE
08:57:23PM YOUR RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY WHICH IS YOUR RS-60, RS-50
08:57:28PM DESIGNATIONS.
08:57:29PM THEN I HAVE PICTURES OF THE SITE.
08:57:32PM I WILL START WITH THE WEST SIDE OF THE SITE WHICH IS WHERE
08:57:35PM THE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED UNITS ARE PROPOSED.
08:57:38PM SO THIS IS THE VIEW.
08:57:40PM THIS IS ON BAYSHORE.
08:57:42PM HAND THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW OF THE SITE.
08:57:48PM THIS IS A VERY BRIGHT DAY, SO I APOLOGIZE, THE SUN IS
08:57:53PM SHINING THROUGH.
08:57:53PM THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE ON THE -- ALL OF THESE ARE
08:57:57PM PICTURES ALONG THE WEST SIDE OF THE DEVELOPMENT SO THIS IS
08:58:02PM SOUTH OF THE SITE ON BAYSHORE.
08:58:04PM WEST OF THE SITE.
08:58:06PM AND THEN TO THE -- TO THE NORTH, IF I CAN GRAB THE PAGE.
08:58:16PM THIS IS THE VIEW IF YOU WERE LOOKING NORTH ON BAYSHORE.
08:58:20PM SO THE SITE IS OFF TO THE LEFT.
08:58:22PM THIS IS NORTH OF THE SITE.
08:58:25PM AND THEN NOW WE ARE ON THE EAST SIDE OF THE PROPERTY.
08:58:29PM SO THIS IS THE EAST SIDE WHERE THE DEVELOPMENT WOULD OCCUR.
08:58:32PM THIS IS WHERE YOU WILL HAVE IS THE TWO SINGLE-FAMILY
08:58:34PM DETACHED UNITS.
08:58:35PM THIS IS SOUTH OF THAT.
08:58:37PM THIS IS THE VIEW, IF YOU WERE LOOKING SOUTH.
08:58:41PM THIS IS ACROSS THE -- THE -- ACROSS FROM THE SITE, ACROSS
08:58:49PM THE STREET.
08:58:49PM THIS IS TO THE EAST.
08:58:50PM AND THIS IS DIRECTLY NORTH OF THE SITE.
08:58:52PM SO IS THE DRC STAFF REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FINDS THE
08:58:58PM REQUEST CONSISTENT.
08:58:59PM THERE ARE NO WAIVERS ASSOCIATED WITH THIS REQUEST.
08:59:01PM AND THERE ARE TWO SMALL CHANGES TO BE MADE.
08:59:04PM THEY ARE VERY MINOR TO BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
08:59:08PM READING.
08:59:08PM OTHER THAN THAT, SO WE DON'T HAVE A -- A VERY LENGTHY
08:59:12PM REVISION SHEET.
08:59:13PM BUT I AM AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
08:59:16PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
08:59:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME?
08:59:22PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU.
08:59:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:59:25PM >>LUIS VIERA: MAY I, MR. CHAIR.
08:59:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
08:50:30PM >>LUIS VIERA: FOR MR. MECHANIK'S BENEFIT.
08:59:33PM I SPOKE TO MR. SHELBY.
08:59:35PM IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH MY TEXT.
08:59:37PM YOU KNOW ME VERY WELL.
08:59:38PM CHARACTER AND INTEGRITY -- I WISH TO READ THE TEXT.
08:59:43PM BEFORE SAYING THAT, THE REASON I SOUGHT TO DO A CONFLICT ON
08:59:46PM THIS IS BECAUSE OF MY DEEPLY VERY PERSONAL RELATIONSHIP WITH
08:59:50PM COLONEL REYES.
08:59:51PM AND I DIDN'T WANT TO GIVE ANYONE THE WRONG IMPRESSION.
08:59:54PM I THOUGHT TO DO THAT OUT OF THE ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION.
08:59:58PM IN MIRE SEVEN YEARS I NEVER DONE THAT AND I CONSULTED WITH
09:00:01PM MY COUNSEL.
09:00:02PM SINCE THE TEXTS WERE BROUGHT UP.
09:00:03PM 1:57 TODAY SENT BY COLONEL REYES.
09:00:07PM HOPE THIS CELL PHONE.
09:00:09PM I WILL BE AT 5 P.M. FOR A REZONING HEARING.
09:00:12PM WE GET THESE KIND OF TEXTS AND SAID.
09:00:15PM SOME DEVELOPER BOUGHT THE LAND NEXT TO THE HOUSE AND PLAN ON
09:00:20PM MULTIFAMILY UNIT.
09:00:21PM ME.
09:00:21PM OKAY.
09:00:22PM I NEED TO SEND THIS TEXT TO THE QUASI JUDICIAL AND ALL GOOD.
09:00:26PM THANK YOU AND I WILL SEE YOU TONIGHT, MY FRIEND.
09:00:28PM HIM, MAN, I CAN'T WIN HERE, LOL.
09:00:31PM ME, I CAN'T COMMUNICATE SUBSTANTIVELY ON QUASI-JUDICIAL
09:00:36PM CASES.
09:00:36PM I ADD A SMILEY CASE.
09:00:38PM HE SAID I ASSUMED I WAS GOING BEFORE ANOTHER CITY ZONING
09:00:42PM BOARD.
09:00:42PM NOT CITY COUNCIL.
09:00:43PM THAT WAS 2:01 P.M. AND WAS SENT THE FOLLOWING TEXT TO ANY
09:00:48PM ASSISTANCE ON MY CITY CELL AND GOES, WE HAVE TO FIND OUT
09:00:53PM WHAT CASE THIS IS.
09:00:53PM I SAID FROM ME TO AND FROM COLONEL DJ REYES.
09:00:58PM THOSE WERE THE TEXTS.
09:01:00PM NOTHING TRYING TO HIDE FOR THE RECORD AND FOR THE ADVICE OF
09:01:04PM COUNSEL, I STAND BY WHAT I DID.
09:01:06PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I AM SUBMITTING THAT TEXT INTO THE RECORD.
09:01:08PM AND IT -- IT RAISES THE QUESTION AND OF COURSE WE CAN HEAR
09:01:11PM FROM MR. MECHANIK, AND MY UNDERSTAND WHEN YOU READ UNDER THE
09:01:18PM RECORD WHEN YOU ABSTAINED.
09:01:20PM PERMITTED FROM FLORIDA STATUTE I ABSTAIN FROM VOTING IN
09:01:24PM QUASI-JUDICIAL MATTER TO AVOID THE APPEARANCE OF A CONFLICT
09:01:29PM OF INTEREST AND TO ASSURE A FAIR PROCEEDING AWAY FROM BIAS
09:01:33PM AND PREJUDICE.
09:01:34PM >>LUIS VIERA: ONE THING.
09:01:35PM I DON'T KNOW COLONEL REYES' POSITION ON THIS.
09:01:39PM AS SOON AS I SAW HIM, YOU WERE RIGHT THERE WITH HIM AND I
09:01:42PM TOLD YOU WOULD BE GETTING TEXTS ON THIS, ETC.
09:01:44PM THAT'S IT.
09:01:45PM THAT'S IT.
09:01:46PM SO THAT -- AGAIN, I DO THIS IN GOOD FAITH AND OUT OF
09:01:50PM CONSCIOUS AND WHAT I FEEL IS AN ETHICAL TO OBLIGATION.
09:01:54PM THAT'S IT.
09:01:54PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: MR. MECHANIK.
09:01:57PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL, MR. CHAIRMAN, COUNCILMEMBERS.
09:02:01PM MY NAME IS DAVID MECHANIK.
09:02:03PM I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF THE APPLICANT.
09:02:07PM I HAVE WITH ME THIS EVENING MR. JEFF KRAFT IS
09:02:14PM MY CLIENT AND HIS CIVIL ENGINEER, ELI PAYNE.
09:02:18PM THE QUESTION I RAISED IS WHETHER SOMEONE SENT AN E-MAIL OR
09:02:28PM IS A FRIEND OF MR. VIERA IS NOT BY ITSELF SUFFICIENT FOR A
09:02:33PM COUNCILMEMBER TO RECUSE HIMSELF.
09:02:36PM AND IT CARRIES THE IMPLICATION THAT THIS PERSON WAS
09:02:41PM OBJECTING.
09:02:41PM THIS PERSON ACTUALLY LEFT THE ROOM AFTER TALKING WITH MY
09:02:45PM CLIENT, SO HE MUST HAVE DECIDED HE IS NOT OBJECTING THIS
09:02:50PM EVENING.
09:02:51PM SO I WOULD JUST RESPECTFULLY REQUEST MR. VIERA TO RECONSIDER
09:02:58PM AND PARTICIPATE IN THE HEARING BECAUSE I AM DEPRIVED OF ONE
09:03:02PM OF THE VOTES THAT I MIGHT WIN TONIGHT IF I PRESENT A
09:03:09PM RESPECTABLE CASE TO THIS COUNCIL.
09:03:12PM THAT'S ALL I AM SAYING.
09:03:14PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THANK YOU, MR. MECHANIK.
09:03:16PM AND THAT WAS CONTEMPLATED WHETHER HE WAS IN FAVOR OF IT OR
09:03:20PM OPPOSED TO IT.
09:03:21PM THE FACT IS IF ONE COULD STATE THAT UNDER THE CIRCUMSTANCES,
09:03:26PM THAT TO AVOID AN APPEARANCE OF A POTENTIAL CONFLICT OF
09:03:31PM INTEREST OR BIAS OR IMPROPRIETY WITH REGARD TO THE
09:03:36PM RELATIONSHIP, WHATEVER IT IS BETWEEN THE -- BETWEEN THE
09:03:40PM POTENTIAL WITNESS WHO WAS HERE AND THEN LEFT FOR THE
09:03:43PM PURPOSES OF THE RECORD.
09:03:44PM THAT PERSON WAS HERE, PRESENT IN CHAMBERS.
09:03:46PM THE QUESTION IS, WHETHER HE IS IN FAVOR OF IT OR NOT, IF
09:03:50PM THERE IS AN IMPLICATION OR AN INFERENCE THAT HE WOULD BE
09:03:54PM BASING HIS DECISION ON THE RELATIONSHIP, THAT MIGHT
09:03:57PM INFLUENCE HIS DECISION WHETHER THE POTENTIAL WITNESS WAS IN
09:04:00PM FAVOR OF IT OR OPPOSED TO IT.
09:04:01PM AND, THEREFORE, OUT OF AN ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION, I BELIEVE
09:04:05PM MR. VIERA MADE THE DECISION, BASED ON THE CRITERIA THAT IS
09:04:09PM ALLOWABLE UNDER FLORIDA STATUTES TO ABSTAIN, TO TAKE THE
09:04:16PM OPPORTUNITY TO ABSTAIN FROM THIS IN ORDER TO ENSURE THAT THE
09:04:20PM PROCEEDING FREE OF POTENTIAL BIAS AND PREJUDICE.
09:04:24PM I UNDERSTAND.
09:04:25PM YOUR OBJECTION IS NOTED FOR THE RECORD.
09:04:27PM >> THANK YOU, AND I WILL NOT PURSUE THE QUESTION ANY
09:04:31PM FURTHER, ESPECIALLY I WOULD LIKE TO NOTE THAT MR. REYES
09:04:35PM TALKED TO MY CLIENT.
09:04:36PM MY CLIENT ANSWERED SEVERAL QUESTIONS.
09:04:38PM AND HE DECIDED TO LEAVE.
09:04:40PM AND THE ONLY INFERENCE I COULD OFFER YOU IS THAT HE DECIDED
09:04:45PM HE DIDN'T NEED TO OBJECT THIS EVENING.
09:04:47PM I AM NOT GOING TO SAY HE IS IN FAVOR OF IT.
09:04:50PM BUT HE DECIDED HE DIDN'T NEED TO OBJECT THIS EVENING.
09:04:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
09:04:58PM >>BILL CARLSON: MR. MECHANIK, AS YOU PROBABLY -- WE KNOW
09:05:03PM LOTS OF PEOPLE IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:05:04PM I HAVEN'T HAD ANY CONVERSATIONS WITH ANYBODY ABOUT THIS
09:05:08PM PROJECT.
09:05:08PM IT IS THE FIRST TIME I AM LOOKING AT THE RENDERINGS.
09:05:12PM BUT THE -- AS YOU KNOW, ONE OF MY COLLEAGUES FROM WORK LIVES
09:05:16PM ABOUT THREE BLOCKS AWAY.
09:05:18PM DOESN'T LOOK TO ME IT IS WITHIN THE 250-FEET RANGE.
09:05:22PM BUT I THINK WHICH ONE -- YOU KNOW MY COLLEAGUE THAT IS
09:05:25PM THERE.
09:05:25PM I HAVEN'T HAD ANY CONVERSATION ABOUT IT.
09:05:27PM HE HAVEN'T SAID ANYTHING TO ME ABOUT IT.
09:05:30PM BUT IF YOU FEEL IT IS A CONFLICT, I WILL BE HAPPY TO RECUSE
09:05:35PM MYSELF.
09:05:35PM >> I DO NOT.
09:05:37PM >>BILL CARLSON: I DON'T THINK IT IS A CONFLICT.
09:05:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. SHELBY.
09:05:41PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: MY QUESTION TO YOU FOR THE PURPOSES OF THE
09:05:43PM RECORD, BASE YOUR DECISION ON THE COMPETENT SUBSTANTIAL
09:05:47PM EVIDENCE AT THE HEARING AND MAKE A DECISION FREE OF BIAS AND
09:05:50PM PREJUDICE?
09:05:53PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
09:05:54PM >> I AM HAPPY TO PROCEED AT THIS POINT.
09:05:57PM THANK YOU.
09:05:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD, SIR.
09:05:59PM >> I AM GOING TO BE VERY BRIEF.
09:06:01PM I WILL NOTE FOR THE RECORD AS LACHONE DID, THAT -- WE HAVE
09:06:07PM ASKED FOR NO WAIVERS WHATSOEVER.
09:06:08PM WE HAVE ALL FINDINGS OF CONSISTENT FROM ALL OF THE
09:06:13PM APPLICABLE DEPARTMENTS FROM THE CITY.
09:06:16PM WE HAVE A FINDING OF CONSISTENT FROM THE PLANNING
09:06:22PM COMMISSION.
09:06:22PM AND I WOULD POINT OUT THAT EVEN THOUGH THE PROPERTY IS
09:06:27PM WITHIN A COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA, IT IS ENTIRELY
09:06:32PM PERMISSIBLE FOR CITY COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE ZONING, BECAUSE
09:06:35PM WE ARE NOT SEEKING AN INCREASE IN DEN DENSITY.
09:06:41PM WE ARE WITHIN THE APPLICABLE DENSITY WHICH IS LOWER IN THE
09:06:45PM ZONE THAT IS AFFECTED BY MacDILL AIR FORCE BASE.
09:06:51PM WE ARE ABIDING BY THAT -- BY THAT DENSITY RESTRICTION.
09:06:55PM SO AT THIS POINT, I WOULD LIKE MY CLIENT, MR. KRAFT TO COME
09:07:00PM UP AND DESCRIBE THE PROJECT, GIVE YOU A LITTLE IDEA OF WHAT
09:07:05PM IT IS GOING TO LOOK LIKE AND SO FORTH.
09:07:07PM SO THANK YOU.
09:07:08PM GOOD EVENING.
09:07:14PM I AM JEFF KRAFT.
09:07:17PM HOW ARE YOU?
09:07:19PM SO MY CONVERSATION WITH COLONEL REYES.
09:07:21PM HE JUST HAD A COUPLE OF COMMENTS ON THE GRAND OAK TREE WHICH
09:07:25PM IS ON HIS PROPERTY.
09:07:26PM AND WE CHATTED.
09:07:27PM DAVID RILEY IS OUR ARBORIST.
09:07:30PM OBVIOUSLY HE WORKED WITH THE CITY FOR, YOU KNOW, PROBABLY 15
09:07:34PM YEARS.
09:07:34PM I HAD COLONEL REYES' CARD.
09:07:38PM WE ARE GOING TO TALK TOMORROW OR EARLY NEXT WEEK.
09:07:41PM HE JUST WANTS TO CHAT WITH HIS WIFE TO MAKE SURE THAT THE
09:07:44PM GRAND TREE IS GOING TO REMAIN PROTECTED, WHICH IT IS.
09:07:47PM AND THAT WAS THE NATURE OF THE CONVERSATION.
09:07:49PM HE SAID RUNNING LATE.
09:07:53PM I GOT TO GO.
09:07:54PM I SAID I WILL TALK TO YOU SOON.
09:07:55PM I MEAN, THAT WAS THE DIALOGUE THAT HE AND I JUST HAD.
09:07:59PM SO I WILL BE BRIEF WITH -- WITH EVERYTHING.
09:08:05PM SEE IF I CAN USE THIS PROPERLY.
09:08:09PM A POINT 6 ACRE SITE.
09:08:23PM 90%-PLUS IMPERVIOUS.
09:08:29PM 7,000 SQUARE FOOT, EVENT BUILDING, ASSEMBLY HALL AND OFFICE
09:08:35PM SPACE THAT WAS USED PRIOR.
09:08:36PM AND THEN THERE HAS BEEN -- OBVIOUSLY SOME OF THESE PHOTOS.
09:08:44PM THIS IS FROM -- THE EAST ELEVATION FROM BAYSHORE.
09:08:48PM NO TREES ON-SITE BECAUSE IT IS A PARKING LOT.
09:08:52PM IT IS SURROUNDED BY A CHAIN-LINK FENCE.
09:08:55PM THIS IS THE VIEW FROM JULES VERNE COURT.
09:09:03PM OBVIOUSLY THE SAME.
09:09:04PM THE CURRENT ACCESS POINT OFF JULES VERNE AND ANOTHER ACCESS
09:09:08PM POINT ON BAYSHORE.
09:09:09PM THAT IS WHAT WE HAVE NOW.
09:09:11PM SO I HAVE A GRAPHIC RENDERING OF OUR SITE.
09:09:18PM JUST, AGAIN.
09:09:20PM I WILL BE BRIEF.
09:09:21PM SO WE HAVE BAYSHORE BOULEVARD.
09:09:24PM WE HAVE FOUR SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED UNITS.
09:09:29PM AND THEN -- SO THAT'S -- THAT IS CONSISTENT WITH WHAT
09:09:32PM CURRENTLY EXISTS ON BAYSHORE.
09:09:35PM AND THEN ON THE JULES VERNE COURTSIDE, IT IS ALL
09:09:39PM SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES AND JUST CONTINUING THAT TREND.
09:09:42PM REGARDING THE IMPERVIOUS VERSUS PERVIOUS.
09:09:47PM WE ARE LOOKING NOW, AGAIN, AT 90-PLUS PERCENT IMPERVIOUS
09:09:54PM SPACE, ESSENTIALLY A PARKING LOT.
09:09:56PM ONCE THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT MOVES FORWARD, IT WILL BE 50%
09:10:06PM SAN FRANCISCO GRASS, GREEN SPACE.
09:10:07PM AND AN IMPROVEMENT TO THE AREA.
09:10:13PM RENDERING ON JULES VERNE COURT.
09:10:17PM SINGLE-FAMILY HOME A FRENCH ARCHITECTURE THAT I THINK LOOKS
09:10:23PM PRETTY SHARP.
09:10:24PM ON THE FLOOR, SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED FACING BAYSHORE.
09:10:30PM HERE IS A RENDERING.
09:10:32PM AND GO -- SORT OF GO BACK TO THE -- TO THE GRAPHIC SITE
09:10:40PM PLAN.
09:10:41PM JUST SEE WHAT ELSE I HAVE HERE.
09:10:43PM TALKED ABOUT THE GREEN SPACE THAT IS GOING TO BE ADDED.
09:10:52PM WE ALSO PLAN ON USING -- THIS IS NOT COMPLICATED WITH THE
09:10:58PM GREEN SPACE, BUT WE USE A PERVIOUS PAVER WHICH IS NOT -- IT
09:11:03PM IS -- IT IS MORE PERVIOUS THAN AN IMPERVIOUS PAVER IF THAT
09:11:08PM MAKES ANY SENSE.
09:11:09PM HELPS WITH STORMWATER FLOW AND DRAINAGE ON THE SITE.
09:11:12PM CURRENT -- YOU KNOW, LAND USE ZONING COULD BE 12 UNITS.
09:11:16PM WE ARE AT 6.
09:11:17PM MacDILL FLIGHT PATH LIMITS IT AT 10.
09:11:21PM SO -- SO WE ARE UNDER THAT AS WELL.
09:11:23PM AGAIN, THE, THE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED AND SINGLE-FAMILY
09:11:29PM BUILDINGS ARE VERY CONSISTENT WITH WHAT IS UP AND DOWN
09:11:33PM BAYSHORE AND UP AND DOWN JULES VERNE COURT.
09:11:36PM WE HAD A TRANSPORTATION STUDY DONE BY JANE CALDERA.
09:11:42PM SO BASED ON THE TRAFFIC GENERATED BY THE EXISTING USE, YOU
09:11:47PM KNOW, CONVERTED -- AS IT TRANSITION TO THIS WILL HAVE A 40%
09:11:51PM NET TRAFFIC REDUCTION ON THIS DEVELOPMENT BASED ON FROM
09:11:56PM WHAT'S -- OBVIOUSLY WE KNOW THAT BAYSHORE IS CROWDED.
09:12:00PM GOOD NEWS IS THAT FOLKS WHO LIVE HERE WILL GO NORTH TO
09:12:03PM DOWNTOWN TO WORK.
09:12:04PM THE TRAFFIC PATTERN IS ALSO GOING -- OBVIOUSLY MacDILL SOUTH
09:12:09PM ON BAYSHORE OF THE BACK DATE.
09:12:13PM BOTH MY PARENTS ARE IN THE MILITARY.
09:12:14PM SO GOING BACK TO COLONEL REYES.
09:12:18PM WE HAVE -- THERE IS -- THIS IS A PARKING LOT.
09:12:22PM SO WE HAVE VERY, VERY, VERY FEW TREES.
09:12:25PM WE HAVE TWO AREAS -- GUILT TO THIS.
09:12:29PM SO ALL GRAND TREES ARE PROTECTED.
09:12:38PM WE WORK WITH STAFF.
09:12:39PM SO THERE IS ONE HERE.
09:12:41PM THEY ALWAYS HUG THE PROPERTY LINE.
09:12:43PM SO WE FULLY PROTECTED THIS TREE.
09:12:46PM MAINTAIN OUR RADIUS SETBACK, AND I EVEN NOTCHED THE BUILDING
09:12:50PM OUT TO PROTECT THE TREE.
09:12:52PM AND THEN ON COLONEL REYES, THE LOCATION HERE.
09:12:56PM AGAIN, WE -- THEY HAD -- WE HAD THE DRIVEWAY ON THIS SIDE.
09:13:03PM THEY WANTED THE DRIVEWAY ON THE OPPOSITE SIDE.
09:13:06PM THE APPROACH, THE PIER AND LENTIL SYSTEM SLATS UP SO THE
09:13:13PM ROOTS CAN GROW ACCORDINGLY.
09:13:14PM DURING CONSTRUCTION, IT IS JUST -- DOING WHAT WE NEEDED
09:13:25PM TO AERATE THE ROOTS, OF WHAT WE CAN ACCOMMODATE WITH DAVE
09:13:31PM RILEY AND OUR ARBORIST REPORT.
09:13:33PM BY SPOKE WITH ROUGHLY A DOZEN NEIGHBORS AND EVERYBODY
09:13:43PM EXPRESSED SUPPORT.
09:13:44PM THERE HAVE BEEN A FEW QUESTIONS.
09:13:46PM CLARIFICATIONS.
09:13:47PM WE DIDN'T GET ANY NOTICES OF -- NO OBJECTION LETTERS OR
09:13:51PM WHATEVER ELSE.
09:13:52PM SO SOMEONE ASKED OF ACCESS POINT FROM BAYSHORE TO JULES
09:14:02PM VERNE.
09:14:02PM ASKED WILL IT BE FENCED.
09:14:03PM I SAID, OF COURSE.
09:14:05PM ANOTHER NEIGHBOR ON JULES VERNE SAID, HEY, A TIGHT SITE --
09:14:09PM THIS IS A TIGHT STREET AND A LOT OF CARS PARKED AND WHATNOT.
09:14:14PM GOOD NEWS, WE HAVE TWO GARAGE SPACE AND PLENTY OF ROOM FOR
09:14:17PM ANOTHER FOUR GUEST CARS.
09:14:19PM THAT IS SIX PARKING SPACES PER STRUCTURE.
09:14:22PM ALSO, YOU KNOW -- I AM A GENERAL CONTRACTOR AND OWNER OF THE
09:14:26PM BUILDING.
09:14:26PM SO FROM A CONSTRUCTION METHODOLOGY STANDPOINT.
09:14:33PM WHEN THESE UNITS ARE CONSTRUCTED.
09:14:34PM PROPOSED TO BE CONSTRUCTED.
09:14:37PM HEAVY LIFTING CONCRETE STUFF.
09:14:46PM AND WON'T HAVE CRANES AND OTHER NONSENSE ON A TIGHT STREET.
09:14:49PM THAT WORKS VERY WELL.
09:14:51PM HAND THIS WILL BE DEVELOPED AND BACK INTO THAT.
09:14:53PM SO IT WILL GO FROM EAST TO WEST THAT'S GOOD?
09:15:08PM OKAY.
09:15:08PM THANK YOU.
09:15:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:15:16PM >> ONE QUICK CLARIFICATION.
09:15:17PM WHAT HE WAS REFERRING TO THE PIER AND LENTIL SYSTEM.
09:15:22PM IT MEANS THAT THE CORNER OF THE BUILDING WILL BE ELEVATED
09:15:24PM AND NOT TOUCH THE GROUND AT THE POINT WHERE THE ROOT
09:15:32PM STRUCTURE OF THE TREE NEEDS TO BE PROTECTED.
09:15:34PM NO STRUCTURE INTERFERING WITH THAT ROOT STRUCTURE.
09:15:37PM AND WITH THAT WE WILL CONCLUDE OUR PRESENTATION AND BE HAPPY
09:15:44PM TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE.
09:15:45PM WE WOULD LIKE AN OPPORTUNITY FOR ANY REBUTTAL IF WE NEED TO.
09:15:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN?
09:15:54PM NO?
09:15:55PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WISH TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 9?
09:15:58PM YES, MA'AM.
09:15:58PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
09:16:00PM >> MY NAME IS ROSEANNE CLEMENTE.
09:16:03PM 5203 BAYSHORE BOULEVARD.
09:16:06PM I AM ONE OF 40 UNITS CALLED COLONY OAKS.
09:16:09PM IT IS 5207 BAYSHORE IS DIRECTLY OPPOSITE THE PROPOSED UNITS,
09:16:17PM MULTIFAMILY UNITS.
09:16:18PM I HAVE NO OBJECTION TO DEVELOPMENT.
09:16:21PM I WORK IN DEVELOPMENT.
09:16:22PM I HAVE OBJECTION TO IT THE FACT THAT THEY DON'T HAVE TO DO
09:16:26PM STORMWATER DETENTION ON THIS PROPERTY.
09:16:29PM WITH REDEVELOPMENT, IT IS A SUBDIVISION AND IN MOST PLACES
09:16:34PM IN THIS STATE, WHEN YOU REDEVELOP 100% PAVEMENT, YOU HAVE TO
09:16:38PM INCLUDE STORMWATER TREATMENT AND STORAGE.
09:16:41PM I DON'T CARE ABOUT STORMWATER TREATMENT IN SOUTH TAMPA,
09:16:44PM BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE ANY.
09:16:46PM BUT I DO CARE ABOUT DETENTION.
09:16:49PM AND WE HAVE -- ON AUGUST 31 -- I DON'T KNOW HOW THIS THING
09:16:56PM OPERATES.
09:16:56PM IF SOMEBODY COULD -- YOU WILL SEE THIS IS THE STORMWATER
09:17:00PM POND BEHIND MY HOME.
09:17:01PM IT IS TOTALLY SEAWALLED AND THE WATER WAS WITHIN EIGHT
09:17:07PM INCHES OF GOING OVER THE CAP.
09:17:08PM OKAY.
09:17:08PM THAT -- THIS IS A PICTURE A WHILE AGO -- I WASN'T PREPARED
09:17:14PM THAT I WOULD BE SHARING PICTURES OF THE POND, BUT THE NORMAL
09:17:17PM WATER LEVEL IS WAY DOWN HERE.
09:17:20PM SO YOU CAN SEE HOW MUCH WATER WENT UP IN 45 MINUTES IN OUR
09:17:23PM STORMWATER POND.
09:17:26PM WE STARTED TO CALLING EVERYBODY IN THE CITY BECAUSE WE WERE
09:17:28PM AFRAID WE WOULD TAKE WATER IN OUR GARAGES AGAIN.
09:17:32PM WE HAD WATER IN OUR GARAGES IN 2018.
09:17:35PM LET THEM REDEVELOP.
09:17:37PM I DON'T CARE.
09:17:38PM BUT SOMEBODY NEEDS TO START LOOKING AT RETROFITTING
09:17:42PM STORMWATER TO STOP THE FLOODING IN SOUTH TAMPA.
09:17:45PM YOU CAN'T KEEP PUTTING ALL THESE ROOFTOPS THE LAST 40 YEARS
09:17:49PM IN SOUTH TAMPA, AND NOT EXPECT US TO HAVE FLOODING.
09:17:52PM WE FLOOD.
09:17:53PM THE WORD PRONE IS LIKELY.
09:17:59PM BUT NOT LIKELY.
09:18:02PM WE FLOOD.
09:18:02PM HOPE YOU DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS IN THE CONSTRUCTION PHASE.
09:18:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:18:09PM ANYONE ELSE FROM THE PUBLIC WISH TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM?
09:18:13PM SEE IF WE HAVE ANYBODY REGISTERED?
09:18:15PM >> I WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK.
09:18:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR, PLEASE TURN ON YOUR CAMERA SO
09:18:19PM WE CAN SEE YOU AND WE HAVE TO SWEAR YOU IN AND RAISE YOUR
09:18:22PM RIGHT HAND.
09:18:23PM >> ARE YOU SEEING IT NOW?
09:18:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: CAN WE BRING UP THE SCREEN?
09:18:36PM >> AM I ON, NO, MAYBE?
09:18:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NOT YET.
09:18:39PM WE ARE BRINGING UP THE SCREEN.
09:18:41PM >> THERE WE GO.
09:18:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND.
09:18:43PM >> DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT THE TESTIMONY YOU ARE ABOUT
09:18:46PM TO GIVE IS THE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH?
09:18:49PM >> IT IS.
09:18:49PM >>CLERK: THANK YOU.
09:18:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD, SIR.
09:18:55PM >> HANG ON ONE SECOND.
09:18:58PM I HAVE SOME SLIDES SO I NEED TO ADJUST -- AS THEY JUST
09:19:03PM GRANTED ME PERMISSIONS.
09:19:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: OKAY.
09:19:06PM YOU WILL SHARE YOUR SCREEN.
09:19:07PM WHAT IS YOUR NAME, SIR.
09:19:09PM >> CHRISTOPHER KIZINISHI.
09:19:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
09:19:15PM >> LET'S TRY THIS AND SEE IF THIS WORKS.
09:19:26PM ALL RIGHT.
09:19:31PM I AM SORRY.
09:19:43PM I APOLOGIZE.
09:19:44PM NO INSTRUCTIONS HOW TO MAKE THIS WORK INITIALLY.
09:19:49PM SO HOPING -- DO YOU SEE THAT?
09:19:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
09:19:54PM >> EXCELLENT.
09:19:55PM I OWN THE HOUSE TWO HOMES AWAY FROM THE PROPOSED SITE.
09:19:59PM I AM IN OPPOSITION OF THE REZONING OF THIS SITE TO PD.
09:20:02PM THE BAYSHORE BOULEVARD BALLAST POINT NEIGHBORHOOD BETWEEN
09:20:06PM GANDY BOULEVARD AND INTERBAY IS BUILT WITH MULTIUNIT DENSITY
09:20:10PM HOUSING SUCH AS THE PROPOSAL HERE TODAY.
09:20:12PM APPROVING THIS REZONING CONTINUES THIS CREEP TOWARD ZERO
09:20:15PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED HOMES IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD WHICH
09:20:18PM SIGNIFICANTLY TRANSFORMS THE DISTINCTIVE NATURAL, HISTORIC
09:20:23PM CHARACTERISTICS OF THE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED NEIGHBORHOOD
09:20:26PM WITH THE FUTURE LAND USE ZONING OF RS-20.
09:20:30PM THIS IS THE MEADE ROAD EXCEPTION PROFIT POSED SITE DEPICTED
09:20:35PM HERE IN YELLOW ON BAYSHORE BOULEVARD.
09:20:38PM ATTACHED ARE THE BUILDINGS ATTACHED OR MID DENSITY
09:20:44PM STRUCTURES.
09:20:45PM IN GREEN ARE THE FEW REMAINING SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES.
09:20:48PM THENUMBERS, 32 ATTACHED OR MID DENSITY VERSUS THE SADLY
09:20:54PM OUTWEIGHTED NINE.
09:20:55PM THIS DOESN'T REFLECT WHAT THE NEIGHBORHOOD HAS HISTORICALLY
09:20:58PM AND CULTURALLY LOOKED LIKE .
09:21:01PM THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IMAGINE 2040 SHOWS HOUSING
09:21:06PM OPPORTUNITIES THAT ARE SERVED BY TRANSIT IN THE SOUTH TAMPA
09:21:09PM DISTRICT.
09:21:09PM NO TRANSIT IMPROVEMENTS ARE BEING PROVIDED TO THE AREA OF
09:21:12PM THE CITY WHICH INCREASES VEHICLES USING THIS ROAD.
09:21:15PM THIS SECTION FROM GANDY BOULEVARD SOUTHWARD A TWO-LANE LOW
09:21:19PM DENSITY, LOW RESIDENTIAL STREET.
09:21:21PM HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY COUNTS 12,500 CARS PER DAY USE THIS ROAD
09:21:26PM AND IN CONTRAST, OUR PARALLEL SISTER STREET MacDILL MEASURE
09:21:31PM 14,200 OR ONE-THIRD OF THE PROPERTY.
09:21:33PM DALE MABRY A FOUR-LANE HEAVY THOROUGHFARE MEASURED 22,000
09:21:38PM VEHICLES.
09:21:38PM THIS SECTION OF BAYSHORE SHOULD BE SEEING CLOSER TOWARD
09:21:41PM MacDILL AND NOT TRENDING AT DALE MABRY.
09:21:45PM IN PROPOSAL FOR DENSE HOUSING HAVE AN A DENSE TRAFFIC ISSUE
09:21:50PM FOR OUR COMMUNITY.
09:21:50PM CREATE INSPIRED URBAN DESIGN BY RESPECTING TAMPA'S URBAN,
09:21:56PM AESTHETICS, NATURAL ENVIRONMENT AND COMMON SENSE OF
09:21:59PM COMMUNITY IDENTITY AS THE CITY CHANGES AND EVOLVES.
09:22:02PM THIS PROPOSED PLAN WITH A ZONING CHANGE FOUR-UNIT
09:22:07PM 38-AND-A-HALF-FOOT-TALL STRUCTURE.
09:22:10PM FOUR UNITS AT 38-AND-A-HALF-FEET TALL.
09:22:15PM NOT HUMAN SCALE.
09:22:16PM NOT EVEN TREE SCALE.
09:22:17PM THE HOUSES IN THIS AREA TOP OUT 25 FEET.
09:22:20PM TREES AROUND 30 FEET.
09:22:22PM THE ONLY WAY TO GET SIX UNITS ON THIS SITE IS TO SHOEHORN IN
09:22:28PM A VERTICAL DIRECTION.
09:22:29PM ANYTHING IN THIS RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD WILL HAVE THE VIEW
09:22:31PM OF THIS STRUCTURE TOWERING OVER THE TREE LINE.
09:22:34PM NOTHING LIKE THAT SOUNDS LIKE RESPECT TO THE HISTORY,
09:22:37PM AESTHETICS OR SENSE OF IDENTITY FOR OUR NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:22:40PM ENSURE THAT REDEVELOPMENT DESIGN AND NEIGHBORHOODS ENHANCES
09:22:46PM DISTINCTIVE HISTORIC AND CULTURAL CHARACTERISTICS.
09:22:50PM BUILT IN 1995 A VISUAL AESTHETIC THAT IS LEAVING OUR CITY.
09:22:57PM WHY ISN'T THE CITY STAFF ASKING TO RENOVATE THE BUILDING ON
09:23:00PM THE SITE.
09:23:01PM HAVE THEY PROPOSED TO THE SOLICITOR TO PRESERVE THIS
09:23:04PM BUILDING?
09:23:05PM WE SHOULD BE PRESERVING OUR PAST WHERE WE CAN.
09:23:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
09:23:10PM THANK YOU.
09:23:10PM DO WE HAVE ANYBODY ELSE IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK?
09:23:14PM ANY QUESTIONS FROM COUNCILMEMBERS BEFORE WE ASK FOR A
09:23:18PM REBUTTAL?
09:23:19PM YES, SIR, COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
09:23:20PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: FOR STAFF.
09:23:21PM CAN WE GO BACK IN AND LOOK AT HOW THIS AREA HAS BEEN -- IS
09:23:26PM CURRENTLY DEVELOPED?
09:23:29PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES, LaCHONE DOCK.
09:23:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SOUNDS LIKE A LIFETIME AGO SINCE YOU WERE
09:23:35PM UP HERE.
09:23:35PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: WELL, LET'S SEE.
09:23:39PM LET ME START ON THE -- PICTURES OF THE SITE.
09:23:44PM YOU WANT THE PICTURES CAN SURROUNDING --
09:23:47PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
09:23:49PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: JUST TO KIND OF SEE.
09:23:50PM WHEN YOU ARE ON BAYSHORE, THIS IS WEST OF THE SITE.
09:23:53PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHAT AM I LOOKING AT, WHAT IS THAT?
09:23:58PM TURN HOUSES?
09:24:00PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THEY ARE TOWN HOMES.
09:24:01PM ATTACHED UNITS.
09:24:02PM >> ON THE OPPOSITE SIDE OF THE STREET.
09:24:06PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OKAY.
09:24:06PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THIS IS SOUTH.
09:24:08PM AND THIS IS A SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL -- OR IS IT TWO?
09:24:15PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OTHER WAY.
09:24:15PM IT HAS TWO ADDRESSES.
09:24:18PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: SO THAT'S SOUTH.
09:24:26PM YOU CAN SEE THE HEIGHT IS TWO STORIES.
09:24:29PM THIS IS SOUTH.
09:24:32PM THIS IS ALSO ON BAYSHORE THAT IS THE SITE AND THAT IS
09:24:42PM ANOTHER PICTURE OF THE SITE ITSELF.
09:24:44PM AND THEN -- LET'S GO TO JULES VERNE ON THE EAST END OF THE
09:24:50PM SITE.
09:24:50PM WELL, THIS IS ON BAYSHORE WEST, NORTH OF THE SITE, NORTH.
09:24:59PM WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE THE AERIAL ALSO.
09:25:03PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: KIND OF HELPFUL.
09:25:04PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: TO ORIENT AGAIN.
09:25:06PM THIS IS THE AERIAL.
09:25:07PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
09:25:09PM WHAT I HAVE SHOWN IS THE DEVELOPMENT THAT IS ACROSS NORTH
09:25:11PM AND SOUTH.
09:25:12PM SO NEXT WE HAVE JULES VERNE.
09:25:16PM AND THEN I WILL SHOW YOU THE DEVELOPMENT THAT IS AROUND
09:25:20PM THERE.
09:25:20PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I AM ASSUMING THAT COLONY IS RM-12.
09:25:26PM THE SPEAKER SPOKE ABOUT, MULTIFAMILY ACROSS THE STREET.
09:25:29PM DOWN THERE.
09:25:30PM IS THAT --
09:25:31PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY.
09:25:34PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IS THAT THE COLONY?
09:25:36PM OKAY.
09:25:36PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THIS IS A VIEW ALSO ON BAYSHORE, IF YOU WERE
09:25:43PM LOOKING DOWN BAYSHORE.
09:25:45PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: LOVELY.
09:25:46PM LOOK AT THE CONDITION OF THAT ROAD.
09:25:48PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES, I KNOW THE ROAD.
09:25:49PM NOW WE ARE ON THE EAST SIDE OF THE SITE.
09:25:52PM JULES VERNE.
09:25:53PM THIS IS EAST OF THE SITE.
09:25:57PM THIS IS ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE SITE.
09:26:00PM THIS IS IF YOU ARE LOOKING SOUTH.
09:26:07PM SOUTH OF THE SITE.
09:26:09PM HAND THIS IS DIRECTLY SOUTH OF THE SITE.
09:26:16PM AND THOSE ARE ALL THE PICTURES I HAVE SURROUNDING THE SITE.
09:26:25PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU, I APPRECIATE THAT.
09:26:27PM THANK YOU SO MUCH.
09:26:28PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: OH, I DO HAVE A ANOTHER.
09:26:30PM JUST A SECOND.
09:26:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD, MA'AM.
09:26:33PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THAT IS NORTH.
09:26:36PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: COULD YOU --
09:26:42PM >>BILL CARLSON: COULD STAFF TELL US WHAT THE RESPONSE IS TO
09:26:44PM THE NEIGHBOR'S COMMENT ON STORMWATER?
09:26:49PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES, THE STORMWATER WILL HAVE TO BE MET AT
09:26:53PM THE TIME OF PERMITTING.
09:26:54PM SOMETIMES WHAT WOULD HAPPEN -- WELL, IN ALL INSTANCES WHEN
09:26:58PM YOU HAVE NEW DEVELOPMENT, THEY MUST PROVIDE THE RETENTION
09:27:05PM AND MEET STORMWATER REQUIREMENTS.
09:27:07PM SOMETIMES THERE IS A CONCERN BECAUSE OF FLOODING, BUT
09:27:09PM SOMETIMES THAT CONDITION IMPROVES ONCE THE SITE HAS
09:27:12PM IMPROVED.
09:27:13PM BUT THE APPLICANT CAN CERTAINLY ADDRESS HOW THEY ARE GOING
09:27:17PM TO ADDRESS IT AT PERMITTING BUT THEY MUST -- EACH TIME A NEW
09:27:21PM DEVELOPMENT COMES IN MUST PROVIDE THE STORMWATER
09:27:25PM REQUIREMENTS.
09:27:25PM THEY CANNOT WAIVE IT.
09:27:27PM >>BILL CARLSON: IF NOT ON THE SITE PLAN NOW.
09:27:29PM WILL IT BE ADDED BEFORE SECOND READING?
09:27:32PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: IT IS ON THE SITE PLAN ACTUALLY TO MEET THE
09:27:35PM REQUIREMENT MUCH CODE.
09:27:36PM THERE IS A CONDITION ON THE SITE PLAN.
09:27:38PM ONE OF THE GENERAL NOTES FOR THEM TO MEET STORMWATER
09:27:43PM REQUIREMENTS.
09:27:43PM AT THE TIME OF PERMITTING, THEY CAN NOT GET A PERMIT WITHOUT
09:27:47PM MEETING THOSE REQUIREMENTS.
09:27:48PM >>BILL CARLSON: CAN I ASK A QUESTION OF THE APPLICANT OR DO
09:27:53PM YOU WANT ME TO WAIT?
09:27:55PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THERE WAS TIME ON THE REBUTTAL.
09:27:56PM MR. MECHANIK.
09:27:58PM >>BILL CARLSON: I WANT TO ASK THE DEVELOPER, MAYBE.
09:28:02PM OR MR. MECHANIK.
09:28:03PM I ALMOST BOUGHT A HOUSE ON JULES VERNE 20 YEARS AGO, AND I AM
09:28:07PM NOT ALLOWED TO PROVIDE TESTIMONY SO I WILL ASK IS THE
09:28:12PM QUESTIONS.
09:28:12PM DO YOU KNOW WHAT PERCENTAGE OF THE HOUSES WITHIN 250 FEET
09:28:16PM ARE NEW IN THE LAST 20 YEARS?
09:28:23PM I MEAN IT -- DID IT GO THROUGH MAJOR GENTRIFICATION, THE
09:28:28PM NEIGHBORHOOD OR A LOT OF HISTORIC HOMES THERE?
09:28:41PM >> ARE YOU ASKING ME?
09:28:43PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
09:28:43PM >> I AM SORRY, MR. CARLSON.
09:28:45PM I DON'T KNOW.
09:28:46PM DO YOU -- THAT IS -- THAT IS SOMETHING WE NORMALLY ANALYZE,
09:28:51PM BUT FOR -- FOR PRESENTING A ZONING CASE WHETHER THE HOMES
09:28:54PM ARE NEW OR NOT.
09:28:57PM I MEAN -- I SHOULD TRY TO POINT OUT FROM A DRAINAGE
09:29:05PM PERSPECTIVE, WE ACKNOWLEDGE THERE ARE EXISTING PROBLEMS.
09:29:08PM WHAT MISS CLEMENTE IS TALKING ABOUT.
09:29:11PM WE DON'T DENY THAT, BUT AN APPLICANT FOR DEVELOPMENT ISN'T
09:29:16PM RESPONSIBLE FOR IMPROVING EXISTING STORMWATER PROBLEMS AT
09:29:23PM THIS PARTICULAR LOCATION.
09:29:24PM NOW WHAT WE HAVE TESTIFIED TOO AND I WILL ASK THE ENGINEER
09:29:30PM TO GET UP AND SPEAK TO THIS, BUT WE ARE INCREASING THE
09:29:34PM PERVIOUS AREA OF THE SITE BY ABOUT 30%.
09:29:41PM W WE WILL BE IMPROVING THE DRAINAGE SITUATION COMING OFF OF
09:29:46PM THIS PROPERTY SO THIS IS A POSITIVE CHANGE.
09:29:51PM IF YOU WERE NOT TO REDEVELOP THIS SITE VIRTUALLY THE ENTIRE
09:29:56PM SITE IS A PARKING LOT AND THE BUILDING THAT IS NOT THE IDEA
09:30:03PM SITUATION.
09:30:05PM >> CAN I ASK A QUESTION OF YOU AND THE OWNER BEFORE YOU
09:30:09PM BRING UP THE ENGINEER IF MY COLLEAGUES WANT THAT.
09:30:12PM IT -- MY RECOGNITION THAT THIS SITE HAS BEEN VACANT FOR A
09:30:19PM LONG TIME.
09:30:19PM IS THAT RIGHT?
09:30:20PM WHAT IS -- WHAT IS THERE.
09:30:22PM IS THAT --
09:30:24PM >> MY UNDERSTANDING IT IS USED BY -- IT IS A PRIVATE CLUB.
09:30:28PM AND USED INFREQUENTLY.
09:30:29PM IT IS NOT AN ABANDONED PIECE OF PROPERTY.
09:30:32PM >>BILL CARLSON: ALL RIGHT, THANK YOU.
09:30:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
09:30:41PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: DO YOU WANT -- I DON'T BELIEVE YOU HAD
09:30:45PM REBUTTAL YET.
09:30:46PM >> NO, I HAVEN'T HAD ANY REBUTTAL.
09:30:49PM I JUST HAVE BEEN ANSWERING QUESTIONS.
09:30:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU WANT TO BRING UP THE OTHER
09:30:55PM GENTLEMAN?
09:30:55PM >> YES.
09:30:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD.
09:30:58PM >> I WOULD LIKE TO COMMENT BRIEFLY ON THE VIRTUAL SPEAKER AS
09:31:02PM WELL.
09:31:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: STATE YOUR NAME.
09:31:05PM >> ELI PAYNE, BAYSIDE ENGINEERING.
09:31:08PM ENGINEER FOR THE PROJECT.
09:31:09PM JUST A QUICK CLEANUP ITEMS.
09:31:12PM STORMWATER ON REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS IN THE CITY UNDER
09:31:16PM 10,000 SQUARE FEET OF NEW IMPERVIOUS, YOU ARE NOT REQUIRED
09:31:19PM TO DO WATER ATTENUATION.
09:31:21PM UNDER 3,000 SQUARE FEET, YOU ARE NOT REQUIRED TO DO WATER
09:31:24PM QUALITY.
09:31:25PM WE WILL BE -- AS THEY STATED A NET REDUCTION IN IMPERVIOUS
09:31:29PM AREA.
09:31:29PM SO OVERALL NET IMPROVEMENT TO THE STORMWATER SYSTEM IN THE
09:31:33PM AREA.
09:31:33PM REAL QUICK ON PARKING.
09:31:38PM REQUIRED PARKING FOR THE SINGLE-FAMILY IS JUST TWO PER UNIT
09:31:41PM WHICH WE HAVE.
09:31:41PM SO WE WILL HAVE FOUR UNITS AND A COUPLE EXTRA PARKING SPOTS
09:31:46PM THERE.
09:31:46PM TRAFFIC AS OUR CLIENT AID IS A NET REDUCTION FROM WHAT IS
09:31:52PM CURRENTLY THE SITE IS.
09:31:53PM AND ON THE HEIGHT OF THE TOWNHOUSE BUILDING, THE MAXIMUM
09:31:59PM HEIGHT IN A SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD IS 35
09:32:02PM FEET AT THE EAVE AT THE TOWN HOUSE WAS 31 FEET, 4 INCHES.
09:32:08PM 38 BUT AT THE EAVE, THE PROPERTY LINE, AT THE SETBACKS, 31
09:32:13PM FEET, 4 INCHES.
09:32:16PM >> BRIEFLY, JUST TO RESPOND TO THE GENTLEMAN WHO HAD
09:32:21PM PARTICIPATED VIRTUALLY.
09:32:22PM THE PREDOMINANT HOUSING TYPE ALONG BAYSHORE.
09:32:29PM I MEAN WE HAVE TWO STREET FRONTAGES HERE.
09:32:32PM WE HAVE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED ALONG JULES VERNE AND
09:32:39PM SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED ALONG BAYSHORE.
09:32:41PM ATTACHED HOUSING, WHICH SOME PEOPLE REFER TO AS TOWN HOMES,
09:32:47PM IS PROBABLY THE PREVAILING LAND USE TYPE ALONG BAYSHORE
09:32:53PM BOULEVARD OTHER THAN THE FACT THERE ARE COMMERCIAL USES ALSO
09:32:57PM ALONG BAYSHORE.
09:32:59PM SO OUR PROPOSED ATTACHED HOUSING IS NOT AT ALL OUT OF
09:33:03PM CHARACTER WITH THE DEVELOPMENT ALONG BAYSHORE BOULEVARD.
09:33:07PM THE COMMENT OF IT BEING OVERBUILT DOWN THERE.
09:33:13PM WE ARE IN THE DENSITY.
09:33:15PM THIS IS WHAT YOUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IS STILL ENCOURAGING
09:33:18PM HOUSING DEVELOPMENT TO OCCUR IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:33:21PM AND THE POLICIES IN YOUR STAFF REPORT REFLECT THAT.
09:33:26PM THAT THESE POLICIES ARE ENCOURAGING THIS TYPE OF DEVELOPMENT
09:33:30PM TO OCCUR AT THIS LOCATION.
09:33:32PM SO I WOULD JUST RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL.
09:33:37PM THERE ARE -- THESE COMMENTS ARE -- IF YOU WILL, EMOTIONAL,
09:33:43PM AND MAY DRAW YOUR ATTENTION, BUT THEY ARE NOT REALLY A BASIS
09:33:48PM FOR DENIAL OF A REZONING APPLICATION.
09:33:51PM ONE FINAL COMMENT I WOULD JUST LIKE TO MAKE.
09:33:54PM I WAS NOT SUGGESTING IN ANY WAY ANY DISRESPECT TO COUNCILMAN
09:34:02PM VIERA, IN FACT QUITE THE CONTRARY, I ALWAYS BELIEVED AND
09:34:06PM CONTINUED TO BELIEVE THAT HE WOULD HAVE RENDERED A FAIR AND
09:34:10PM HONEST DECISION REGARDLESS OF HIS FRIENDSHIP WITH THIS
09:34:14PM PARTICULAR NEIGHBOR.
09:34:17PM IN FACT I WAS NOT EVEN AWARE OF THAT AT THE TIME I RAISED
09:34:20PM THE QUESTION.
09:34:20PM BUT I MEANT NO DISRESPECT WHATSOEVER FOR COUNCILMAN VIERA.
09:34:27PM WITH THAT WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL.
09:34:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
09:34:33PM >>BILL CARLSON: THAT NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION IS VERY
09:34:36PM ACTIVE.
09:34:37PM DID THEY WEIGH IN AT ALL.
09:34:38PM >> MY CLIENT CONTACTED -- HOW MANY --
09:34:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE COME UP, SIR, AND SPEAK IN
09:34:47PM THE MIC.
09:34:47PM >> JEFF KRAFT.
09:34:50PM I SPOKE TO A DOZEN NEIGHBORS.
09:34:52PM AT A RESTAURANT.
09:34:53PM MET ON-SITE AND EVERYBODY SUPPORTED THE PROJECT.
09:34:58PM >>BILL CARLSON: OKAY, THANK YOU.
09:35:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR, GO AHEAD.
09:35:05PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MR. MECHANIK, WITHOUT A PD, COULD YOU
09:35:09PM DEVELOP -- YOU HAVE SIX SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL UNITS.
09:35:12PM FOUR ATTACHED, TWO ATTACHED.
09:35:14PM WITHOUT A PD, DEVELOP SIX SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES ON THIS
09:35:19PM PROPERTY?
09:35:20PM >> I THINK THAT THE -- I DIDN'T GO THROUGH THIS ANALYSIS.
09:35:23PM MR. PAYNE AND MR. KRAFT DID, BUT I THINK THERE WOULD BE AN
09:35:30PM ISSUE WITH THE SETBACKS, OTHERWISE I THINK IT WOULD SATISFY
09:35:34PM THE APPLICABLE CODE REQUIREMENTS.
09:35:36PM I MEAN THE PROPERTY -- THE PROPERTY IS ZONED RS-60.
09:35:40PM SO THAT IS A SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED CATEGORY.
09:35:43PM I DON'T -- I DON'T THINK WE COULD HAVE EVEN CONCEIVED
09:35:49PM OF THIS DEVELOPMENT IN THAT ZONING DISTRICT.
09:35:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU ORDINANCE MANISCALCO THANK YOU
09:35:56PM VERY MUCH.
09:35:56PM ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS BEFORE I ASK FOR A MOTION TO
09:35:59PM CLOSE.
09:36:00PM >>BILL CARLSON: ONE MORE QUESTION.
09:36:03PM MR. MECHANIK WHY DIDN'T YOU -- THIS IS NOT A JUDGMENT, I AM
09:36:07PM JUST ASKING A QUESTION CONSIDERING HOW MANY UNITS YOU PUT
09:36:09PM THERE.
09:36:10PM WHY DIDN'T YOU GO FOR MORE DENSITY?
09:36:13PM WHY -- IT IS -- WHAT, SIX UNITS INSTEAD OF -- A LOT OF
09:36:17PM PROPOSALS IN THAT AREA ARE PUSHING FOR 20 OR 30 UNITS.
09:36:22PM >> BILL KRAFT.
09:36:27PM THE MacDILL FLIGHT PATH WITHIN TEN.
09:36:32PM LAND USE DESIGNATION WE CAN DO 12.
09:36:35PM MY INTENT IS TO KEEP THE CHARACTER OF JULES VERNE COURT AS
09:36:40PM SINGLE-FAMILY AND, YOU KNOW, STAY CONSISTENT WITH HAVING THE
09:36:43PM MULTIFAMILY OPTION ON BAYSHORE.
09:36:45PM SO I THINK SIX UNITS VERSUS TEN UNITS IS MUCH BETTER.
09:36:49PM I UNDERSTAND THE STORMWATER, THE GREEN SPACE.
09:36:52PM IT JUST WORKS FOR US.
09:36:53PM >>BILL CARLSON: MY POINT IS THAT THIS IS PRETTY LOW DENSITY
09:36:57PM COMPARED TO WHAT WE --
09:36:58PM >> CORRECT.
09:36:59PM >>BILL CARLSON: I AM JUDGING WHETHER IT IS BETTER OR WORSE,
09:37:01PM BUT WE SEE SO MANY DEVELOPERS THAT COME IN AND WANT 20 OR 30
09:37:06PM UNITS ON A SPACE LIKE THIS.
09:37:07PM THAT IS THE KIND OF THING THAT IS REALLY CROWDING OUT SOUTH
09:37:10PM TAMPA AND THIS IS -- THIS IS A VERY LOW NUMBER COMPARED TO
09:37:15PM THAT.
09:37:15PM >> YES, I PROBABLY SHOULD HAVE EMPHASIZED THAT.
09:37:18PM THANK YOU.
09:37:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE BEFORE I ASK FOR A MOTION
09:37:21PM TO CLOSE.
09:37:21PM MOTION TO CLOSE BY COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
09:37:24PM SECONDED BY COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
09:37:26PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
09:37:28PM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN, IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO READ IT.
09:37:31PM ITEM NUMBER 9?
09:37:40PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I MOVE AN ORDINANCE REZ-23-55, ORDINANCE
09:37:48PM BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION.
09:37:51PM ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 5210
09:37:55PM BAYSHORE BOULEVARD IN CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, MORE
09:37:59PM PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1, ZONING
09:38:04PM CLASSIFICATIONS RS-60 RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY, TO PD,
09:38:10PM PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED AND
09:38:13PM ATTACHED.
09:38:13PM PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
09:38:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
09:38:16PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
09:38:18PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: MAY I ADD A COUPLE OF THINGS HERE.
09:38:22PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WAS GOING TO, BUT YOU DO.
09:38:25PM I WOULD RATHER YOU DO IT.
09:38:33PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I WOULD RATHER YOU DO IT.
09:38:35PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: AGE BEFORE BEAUTY.
09:38:39PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THE POLICY AND THE SURROUNDING AREA IS
09:38:43PM PREDOMINANTLY RESIDENTIAL IN CHARACTER WITH A MIX OF
09:38:46PM SINGLE-FAMILY, ATTACHED AND DETACHED AND MULTIFAMILY USES.
09:38:50PM GIVEN THE PRESENCE OF SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED TO THE WEST AND
09:38:54PM MULTIFAMILY TO THE SOUTHWEST.
09:38:55PM THIS SITE IS APPROPRIATE FOR ATTACHED SINGLE-FAMILY USED AND
09:39:00PM EXPAND FOR HOUSING CHOICES IN THE BALLAST POINT
09:39:04PM NEIGHBORHOODS WHILE AT THE SAME TIME, MAINTAIN A DENSITY
09:39:06PM CONSISTENT WITH THE MacDILL AIR FORCE BASE FLIGHT PATH.
09:39:10PM I FIND IT CONSISTENT WITH LAND USE 9.35, 9.51, 9.52, 9.53,
09:39:19PM AND 9.54.
09:39:20PM COMPLIANCE OF LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE 27-136, PROPOSED
09:39:25PM DEVELOPMENT IS SHOWN AT THE SITE FOR MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT
09:39:29PM THAT IS COMPATIBLE AND CHARACTER WITH THE SURROUNDING
09:39:33PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:39:33PM SHE'S SHELBY THE REVISION SHEET ON --
09:39:39PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THE REVISION SHEET ON THAT.
09:39:41PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES, WITH THE REVISION SHEETS.
09:39:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN HAS A SECOND.
09:39:47PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA WITH THE SECOND.
09:39:50PM COUNCILMAN CARLSON HE HAS HIS HAND UP.
09:39:55PM >>BILL CARLSON: BECAUSE THIS IS MY DISTRICT, I WANT TO
09:39:58PM EXPLAIN MY VOTE.
09:39:59PM THIS AREA USED TO BE MOSTLY RANCH-STYLE HOMES UNTIL 15 OR 20
09:40:04PM YEARS AGO AND ALL CONVERTED TO LARGER HOMES.
09:40:08PM AND -- IT IS NOT LIKE THE MIDDLE OF HYDE PARK.
09:40:12PM AS WAS PRESENTED, IT IS MOSTLY MULTIFAMILY IN THIS AREA.
09:40:16PM SOUTH TAMPA CANNOT STAND HEAVY DENSITY, BUT -- BUT THIS IS A
09:40:23PM VERY SMALL AMOUNT OF DENSITY COMPARED TO WHAT COULD HAVE
09:40:27PM BEEN PROPOSED ON THE -- ON THE STREET ADJACENT TO MY
09:40:30PM NEIGHBORHOOD, THERE WAS A PROPOSAL FOR FOUR-STORY CONDOS IN
09:40:34PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD FOUGHT AGAINST IT AND NOW THEY HAVE A CAR
09:40:36PM WASH BEHIND THEM AND NOW THEY WISH THEY HAD FOUR-STORY
09:40:39PM CONDOS.
09:40:40PM AND SO, MY VOTE -- SOMEBODY WILL CRITICIZE IN THE FUTURE.
09:40:45PM BUT MY VOTE WILL BE YES, BECAUSE I THINK THIS FILLS A HOLE
09:40:48PM IN THE -- IN THE LOOK AND FEEL OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:40:51PM PROVIDES SINGLE-FAMILY ON ONE SIDE AND LOW DENSITY ON THE
09:40:54PM OTHER.
09:40:54PM AND TO THE POINT THAT THE PERSON THAT SPOKE ABOUT WITH
09:41:01PM STORMWATER.
09:41:01PM I AM HAPPY TO TALK -- PUT YOU IN TOUCH WITH THE RIGHT PERSON
09:41:06PM OR TALK TO YOU ABOUT THE STORMWATER PLAN THAT IS GOING ON
09:41:09PM FOR SOUTH TAMPA, ESPECIALLY IN THAT NEIGHBORHOOD, MASSIVE
09:41:13PM INFRASTRUCTURE PROGRAMS GOING ON THAT THE CITY STARTED A FEW
09:41:16PM YEARS AGO.
09:41:16PM I AM HAPPY -- IT WON'T FIX ALL THE PROBLEMS BUT WILL FIX
09:41:20PM MANY.
09:41:20PM I AM HAPPY TO TALK TO YOU.
09:41:22PM I GET A LOT OF CALLS OF FLOODING IN THE AREA.
09:41:24PM CONSIDERING THE ALTERNATIVES, I AM GOING TO SUPPORT THIS
09:41:31PM BECAUSE I THINK IT IS MUCH, MUCH BETTER.
09:41:33PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WANT TO SAY ONE THING TOO.
09:41:35PM SIMILAR AND DITTO WHAT COUNCILMAN CARLSON JUST SAID.
09:41:41PM BECAUSE ALSO I AM A SOUTH TAMPA PERSON AS WELL AND I GET THE
09:41:46PM SAME FEEDBACK AND STRESSES FROM FOLKS.
09:41:48PM I AGREE WITH EVERYTHING THAT YOU JUST SAID.
09:41:50PM THE PUBLIC COMMENT THAT WAS COMMUNICATED ELECTRONICALLY WITH
09:41:54PM THIS.
09:41:54PM ONE OF THE THINGS YOU PRESENTED IS THE DISPARITY BETWEEN
09:41:58PM DETACHED AND ATTACHED UNITS.
09:42:00PM THE IRONY OF THAT TESTIMONY IS, IT REALLY JUSTIFIED THIS
09:42:06PM TYPE OF DEVELOPMENT BECAUSE YOU SEE THAT THIS AREA -- THAT
09:42:11PM THE THIS AREA HAS DEVELOPED HAS ENCOURAGED DIFFERENT TYPES
09:42:15PM OF DEVELOPMENT VERSUS SINGLE-FAMILY.
09:42:16PM BECAUSE IT IS A MIXED TYPE OF NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:42:18PM AND I JUST WANT TO HIGHLIGHT THAT.
09:42:20PM WE HEARD WHAT YOU HAVE TO SAY, BUT COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL
09:42:24PM EVIDENCE.
09:42:24PM AND THAT'S WHY I THINK WE ARE GOING TO MOVE IN A DIFFERENT
09:42:27PM DIRECTION THAN YOU WOULD HAVE WISHED.
09:42:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: OKAY.
09:42:30PM WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
09:42:32PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
09:42:33PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
09:42:37PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
09:42:39PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
09:42:41PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
09:42:43PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
09:42:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
09:42:50PM >>CLERK: AND VIERA IS ABSTAINING.
09:42:52PM MOTION CARRIED WITH VIERA ABSTAINING.
09:42:55PM >> I NEED TO ADDRESS THE SECOND READING.
09:42:58PM >>CLERK: SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON OCTOBER
09:43:02PM 5, 2023 AT 9:30 A.M. AT 3315 E. KENNEDY BOULEVARD, TAMPA.
09:43:10PM FLORIDA, THIRD FLOOR, 33602.
09:43:13PM >> MR. CHAIRMAN, I APOLOGIZE, BUT I AM GOING TO BE OUT OF
09:43:17PM TOWN ON OCTOBER 5, AND I WOULD LIKE TO REQUEST THAT WE PUSH
09:43:20PM OFF SECOND READING FOR A WEEK OR WHATEVER IS THE APPROPRIATE
09:43:25PM TIMING.
09:43:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. SHELBY, IS THAT POSSIBLE TO DO.
09:43:32PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YES.
09:43:33PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THE 19th.
09:43:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: OCTOBER 19 IS THE NEXT CITY COUNCIL
09:43:40PM MEETING.
09:43:41PM MADAM CLERK, CAN YOU READ WHAT YOU READ BUT CHANGE THE DATE
09:43:44PM TO OCTOBER 19.
09:43:45PM >>CLERK: SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON OCTOBER
09:43:49PM 19, 2023 AT 9:30 A.M. AT THE OLD CITY HALL BUILDING LOCATED
09:43:54PM AT 315 E. KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA,
09:43:59PM 33602.
09:44:02PM >> THANK YOU.
09:44:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:44:11PM ITEM NUMBER 10.
09:44:13PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
09:44:14PM LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:44:17PM ITEM NUMBER 10, REZ-23-60, 1305 SOUTH 22nd STREET, 2015 AND
09:44:28PM 2017 MAPLE AVENUE AND 2020 OAKWOOD AVENUE.
09:44:34PM APPLICANT IS TYLER HUDSON.
09:44:36PM TO REQUEST FROM PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT TO PD PLANNED
09:44:42PM DEVELOPMENT FOR STOREFRONT AND OFFICE USES.
09:44:45PM TURN IT OVER TO DAVID.
09:44:47PM >>DAVID HEY: DAVID HEY WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
09:44:51PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
09:44:53PM BACK TO THE TAMPA PLANS DISTRICT FOR THE NEXT CASE.
09:44:58PM THE PALMETTO BEACH NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:45:01PM PARK IS THE LATEST RECREATION FACILITY.
09:45:05PM HALF A MILE NORTHEAST OF THE TRANSIT SITE.
09:45:10PM TRANSIT IS NOT LOCATED WITHIN THE AREA AND THE SUBJECT SITE
09:45:13PM IS WITHIN THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA AND COASTAL PLANNING
09:45:17PM AREA.
09:45:18PM SPECIFICALLY EVACUATION ZONE A.
09:45:25PM WE HAVE THE AERIAL OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
09:45:27PM YOU CAN SEE -- HERE IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
09:45:29PM THIS IS 22nd STREET.
09:45:31PM THIS IS WHERE IT CURVES DOWN INTO THE ENTRANCE TO THE PORT.
09:45:34PM THIS IS McKAY BAY.
09:45:37PM YOU HAVE GOT CAUSEWAY BOULEVARD AND 20th STREET TO THE WEST
09:45:41PM AND THEN THIS IS ALL MOSTLY HEAVY INDUSTRIAL USES RELATED TO
09:45:49PM THE PORT ON THE WEST SIDE OF 20.
09:45:51PM THIS PARTICULAR -- ESPECIALLY -- THIS PARTICULAR POCKET, A
09:45:58PM MIXTURE OF RESIDENTIAL AND NONRESIDENTIAL USES.
09:46:01PM THE RESIDENTIAL DETACH AND DUPLEXES ARE LOCATED MORE TO THE
09:46:06PM NORTHEAST.
09:46:12PM HERE WE HAVE THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND THE ENTIRE
09:46:18PM SITE IS THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35.
09:46:20PM IMMEDIATELY TO THE NORTH AND WEST AND SOUTH IN THE SALMON
09:46:25PM COLOR, THAT IS THE TRANSITIONAL USE-24.
09:46:27PM THIS PINK, OF COURSE, IS THAT COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35.
09:46:32PM SOME RESIDENTIAL-20 ALONG BERMUDA BOULEVARD.
09:46:36PM AND THEN THE RESIDENTIAL-10 AREA IS LOCATED FURTHER TO THE
09:46:40PM NORTHEAST.
09:46:40PM THE LIGHT GRAY IS LIGHT INDUSTRIAL.
09:46:43PM THE DARK GRAY IS THE HEAVY INDUSTRIAL RELATED TO THE PORT.
09:46:47PM THE -- THE REQUEST IS TO ALLOW A TOTAL OF 82 DWELLING UNITS
09:46:59PM AND 972 SQUARE FEET OF STOREFRONT RESIDENTIAL USES.
09:47:03PM THE APPLICANT IS ELIGIBLE FOR THE 1.5 FLOOR AREA RATIO BY
09:47:08PM RIGHT DUE TO THE PD BEING A VERTICALLY MIXED USE PROJECT AND
09:47:12PM THE SITE IS LOCATED ON AN ARTERIAL ROADWAY.
09:47:15PM TO ENSURE THAT THAT AUTO SECOND USE IS NOT ONLY AN AMENITY
09:47:21PM FOR THE RESIDENTS AND A NOTE INCLUDED ON THE REVISION SHEET
09:47:25PM THAT WOULD REQUIRE THAT TO BE NONAFFILIATED WITH THE -- WITH
09:47:29PM THE MAIN USE.
09:47:29PM AND OPEN TO THE PUBLIC.
09:47:31PM THE SITE PLAN DOES -- THE SITE PLAN AND THE DENSITY DOES
09:47:37PM PROMOTE WALKING AND TRANSIT USES.
09:47:40PM SO HOPEFULLY ONE DAY HART WILL BE ABLE TO EXTEND TRANSIT
09:47:46PM FURTHER DOWN THIS STREET.
09:47:50PM THE REQUEST SUPPORTS MANY OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLANS RELATED
09:47:55PM TO PROVIDING HOUSING CHOICES FOR THE CITIZENS OF TAMPA.
09:47:59PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN THAT COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA AND
09:48:05PM EVACUATION ZONE A.
09:48:08PM EVACUATIONS THAT WILL EFFECT THE UNITS WILL HAVE TO MITIGATE
09:48:13PM IMPACT ON SHELTER SPACE DEMAND.
09:48:16PM AND THEY WILL HAVE TO COORDINATE WITH HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY
09:48:18PM AND THE CITY OF TAMPA AT THE TIME OF PERMITTING.
09:48:20PM WE HAVE TALKED ABOUT THE NOTE BEING ADDED FOR THAT SECOND
09:48:24PM USE.
09:48:25PM SO BASED ON -- ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS AND POLICIES PROVIDED
09:48:31PM IN THE REPORT, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDS THE
09:48:33PM PROPOSED PLAN DEVELOPMENT CONSISTENT WITH THE PLANNED
09:48:36PM PROVISIONS OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
09:48:37PM THANK YOU.
09:48:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:48:40PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
09:48:43PM LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:48:47PM IN THE PD REQUEST FOR THE STOREFRONT, RESIDENTIAL AND
09:48:51PM COMMERCIAL OFFICE USE WOULD CONTAIN 972 SQUARE FEET OF
09:48:55PM COMMERCIAL USE AND 78 RESIDENTIAL UNITS ARE PROPOSED.
09:48:58PM THE LOT SIZES, 44,003 SQUARE FEET.
09:49:05PM MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT 57 FEET FOR FIVE STORIES.
09:49:08PM SO THE DEVELOPMENT REQUIRES A TOTAL OF 82 SPACES AND 92
09:49:14PM PARKING SPACES ARE PROVIDED .THIS IS PROVIDING THE
09:49:18PM DEVELOPMENT AT A 1.66 F.A.R.
09:49:23PM THIS IS THE SITE PLAN ASSOCIATED WITH THE REQUEST.
09:49:25PM THIS IS MAPLE AVENUE.
09:49:29PM THIS IS SOUTH 22nd STREET.
09:49:31PM AND THIS IS OAKWOOD AVENUE THAT IS BORDERING TO THE SOUTH.
09:49:36PM YOU CAN SEE VEHICULAR ACCESS TO THE SITE THAT IS LOCATED ON
09:49:40PM MAPLE AVENUE.
09:49:41PM YOU HAVE ON-STREET PARKING SPACES THAT ARE PROPOSED BUT OF
09:49:46PM COURSE THEY DO NOT COUNT TOED PARKING BUT PROPOSED WITHIN
09:49:48PM THE DEVELOPMENT.
09:49:50PM THIS IS THE STRUCTURE, WHICH WILL, PROVIDED.
09:49:52PM AND WOULD YOU HAVE THE SURFACE PARKING SPACES THAT ARE
09:50:00PM LOCATED HERE.
09:50:01PM A DOG PARK IS LOCATED HERE IN THIS AREA.
09:50:03PM AND I WILL SHOW YOU THE ELEVATIONS OF THE SITE.
09:50:06PM >>LYNN HURTAK: BEFORE YOU GO ANY FURTHER, CAN YOU SHOW ME
09:50:14PM WHERE THE 972 SQUARE FEET OF RETAIL OFFICE SPACE ARE
09:50:21PM SUPPOSED TO BE?
09:50:22PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: SO THE OFFICE SPACE WILL BE ADDED AND
09:50:24PM IDENTIFIED ON THE SITE PLAN BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
09:50:27PM READING, BUT WHICH CORNER WILL BE IT LOCATED.
09:50:30PM >> JUST TO THE RIGHT.
09:50:32PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IF THEY WANT TO EXPLAIN IT LATER, THAT IS
09:50:35PM FINE.
09:50:35PM I JUST COULDN'T SEE IT.
09:50:36PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: IT WAS NOT IDENTIFIED ON THE SITE PLAN AND
09:50:39PM ONE OF THE REVISION IS TO IDENTIFY THEM.
09:50:41PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
09:50:45PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: AND THE ELEVATIONS TO THE SITE.
09:50:49PM SO THIS IS THE WEST ELEVATION.
09:50:51PM THEN THIS IS THE EAST ELEVATION.
09:50:55PM THEN HERE ARE ELEVATIONS OF THE NORTH.
09:51:05PM THEN THIS IS THE SOUTH.
09:51:10PM AND HERE IS THE AERIAL OF THE AREA.
09:51:18PM THIS IS THE ZONING MAP.
09:51:20PM SO THIS IS THE PROPERTY WHICH IS IDENTIFIED HERE IN RED.
09:51:23PM THIS IS MAPLE AVENUE.
09:51:25PM THIS IS OAKWOOD AVENUE.
09:51:27PM AND THIS IS SOUTH 22nd STREET.
09:51:29PM THIS IS 20th SLIGHTLY LOCATED HERE FOR ORIENTATION.
09:51:37PM THE RM-16 ZONING IS PREDOMINANT TO THE WEST.
09:51:42PM COUPLE OF PDs.
09:51:44PM LOCATED NORTH OF THE SITE IS OLDER PDs AND A ONE FOR 99 THAT
09:51:50PM IS FOR COMMERCIAL OFFICE USE.
09:51:51PM THIS IS FOR COMMERCIAL AND RESIDENTIAL HAND THIS IS AN
09:51:56PM 07 PD.
09:51:57PM THIS YOU SEE THE CG ZONING WHICH IS LOCATED SOUTHEAST OF THE
09:52:01PM SITE.
09:52:02PM THEN WE HAVE PICTURES OF THE SITE.
09:52:05PM TO PROVIDE PRIDE.
09:52:10PM WE WILL TAKE YOU AND THE SITE ITSELF.
09:52:13PM WE WILL SHOW YOU WHAT WE HAVE ON THIS.
09:52:15PM SO THIS IS ON MAPLE.
09:52:17PM LOOKING AT THE SITE.
09:52:22PM SO THIS IS ON MAPLE.
09:52:24PM THIS IS IF YOU ARE NEAR 22nd STREET.
09:52:26PM THIS IS LOOKING AT THE SITE.
09:52:28PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW OF THE SITE AT MAPLE AND 22nd STREET.
09:52:36PM THIS IS THE NORTHEAST.
09:52:37PM SO THIS IS IF YOU ARE FACING WEST.
09:52:41PM IF YOU ARE LOOKING WEST ON MAPLE STREET ACTUALLY.
09:52:47PM THIS IS NORTH OF THE SITE.
09:52:50PM OF MAPLE, COMMERCIAL.
09:52:55PM THIS IS EAST OF THE SITE.
09:52:57PM THIS IS AT 22nd.
09:52:58PM THIS IS NORTHEAST OF THE SITE.
09:53:04PM SO THE SITE IS OVER HERE ON THE LEFT IN THE PICTURE.
09:53:08PM THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE.
09:53:14PM SO THIS IS ACROSS OAKWOOD.
09:53:18PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW OF THE SITE.
09:53:23PM THIS IS IF YOU ARE IN OAKWOOD AND LOOKING AT THE SITE.
09:53:27PM YOU ARE LOOKING NORTH.
09:53:29PM THIS IS AT OAKWOOD AND 22nd THAT IS LOOKING TO THE EAST.
09:53:33PM SO MUCH DRC STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE REQUEST.
09:53:40PM THERE IS A FINDING OF INCONSISTENT RELATED TO NATURAL
09:53:42PM RESOURCES AND THE WAIVERS REQUESTED.
09:53:45PM A TOTAL OF THREE WAIVERS REQUESTED.
09:53:48PM ONE OF THE FAVORS THAT WERE LISTED WILL BE REMOVED.
09:53:51PM IT IS NOT NECESSARY, BUT WHAT I AM GOING TO DO IT TURN IT
09:53:55PM OVER TO ERIN SO SHE CAN REVIEW HER NATURAL RESOURCES
09:53:59PM COMMENTS AND FINDINGS, BUT ALSO THERE IS A REVISION SHEET
09:54:02PM THAT HAS BEEN REVISED THAT I WILL PROVIDE TO YOU THIS
09:54:05PM EVENING.
09:54:06PM SO THERE ARE REVISIONS TO BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
09:54:09PM READING.
09:54:09PM AND I AM ALSO AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ONCE ERIN
09:54:13PM SPEAKS.
09:54:13PM THANK YOU.
09:54:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:54:17PM YES, MA'AM.
09:54:18PM >>ERIN MAHER: ERIN MAHER, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:54:29PM WANT TO SPEAK TO THE REASON NATURAL RESOURCES FOUND THE
09:54:32PM APPLICATION INCONSISTENT.
09:54:33PM HERE, THE MAIN REASON IS -- THE WAIVER, THE FIRST WAIVER
09:54:38PM BEING TO REDUCE THE 15-FOOT REQUIRED LANDSCAPE BUFFER AND A
09:54:44PM SIX-FOOT-TALL MASONRY.
09:54:49PM AND A OPAQUE FENCE.
09:54:51PM RIGHT HERE IS THE LOCATION WHERE THE WEST SIDE OF THE
09:54:54PM PROPERTY LINE.
09:54:54PM YOU ARE LOOKING NORTH.
09:54:55PM HAND THIS IS WHAT EXISTS.
09:54:57PM SO THERE IS A SINGLE-FAMILY HOME RIGHT THERE.
09:55:00PM THERE IS TREES THAT ARE CURRENTLY THE BUFFER.
09:55:06PM I AM GOING TO SHOW YOU WHAT THE PROPOSED LANDSCAPE PLAN
09:55:10PM LOOKS LIKE.
09:55:10PM LET'S SEE.
09:55:13PM SO RIGHT HERE, YOU CAN SEE IS WHERE THE 15-FOOT LANDSCAPE
09:55:23PM BUFFER WILL BE.
09:55:24PM THIS IS A STOREFRONT RESIDENTIAL HAND THIS IS WHERE 15
09:55:29PM FEET WILL BE.
09:55:30PM RIGHT NOW THE APPLICANT -- IT SHOWS TEN FEET BUT THEY ARE
09:55:35PM REQUESTING A FIVE-FOOT USE-TO-USE LANDSCAPE BUFFER.
09:55:40PM THE CODE REQUIRES A TYPE 1 OR TYPE 2 TREES, YOUR LARGER
09:55:45PM TREES, TALLER TREES LIKE LIVE OAKS OR CYPRESS AND OTHER
09:55:49PM TREES LIKE THAT.
09:55:51PM HOWEVER, WITH A FIVE-FOOT LANDSCAPE BUFFER, THE ONLY THING
09:55:55PM TO FIT IS PALMS AND TYPE 3 TREES.
09:55:58PM OVERALL, THERE ARE IS ABOUT 200 FEET LONG, I BELIEVE, NORTH
09:56:02PM TO SOUTH.
09:56:02PM AND TEN EITHER TYPE 1 OR TYPE 2 TREES COULD HAVE BEEN PLACED
09:56:09PM IN THIS BUFFER IF THE FULL 15 FEET WAS PROVIDED.
09:56:12PM SO THAT IS ONE OF THE REASONS WE ARE INCONSISTENT.
09:56:15PM JUST THE TOTAL TREES THAT WE COULD HAVE HAD BEEN PROVIDED
09:56:19PM ON-SITE.
09:56:19PM IN ADDITION TO THAT, THE USES ARE JUST INCOMPATIBLE BETWEEN
09:56:24PM THE FIVE-STORY MULTIFAMILY HOUSING COMPLEX ABUTTING THE
09:56:30PM SINGLE-FAMILY HOME HAVING A FIVE-FOOT LANDSCAPE BUFFER.
09:56:33PM SO NATURAL RESOURCES WOULD HAVE LIKED TO HAVE SEEN THE 15
09:56:38PM FEET LAND BUFFER.
09:56:43PM SECOND WAIVER IS TREE RETENTION.
09:56:45PM SO TO REQUEST THE REQUIRED 50% TREE RETENTION ON A NONWOODED
09:56:50PM LOT OVER A ONE ACRE TO ZERO PERCENT.
09:56:56PM NOT A LOT OF TREES ON THE SITE.
09:56:59PM 16 TOTAL.
09:57:00PM SEVEN OF THOSE ARE ACTUALLY EXEMPT SPECIES SO THEY DON'T
09:57:04PM EVEN COUNT.
09:57:05PM HOWEVER THREE LAUREL OAKS ON THE SITE INCLUDING A
09:57:09PM NONHAZARDOUS GRAND LAUREL OAK HERE.
09:57:11PM SO THIS IS LOOKING TO THE EAST TOWARD THE BAY.
09:57:17PM HAND THIS IS THE GRAND LAUREL OAK RIGHT HERE THAT WILL NEED
09:57:20PM A WAIVER.
09:57:21PM NATURAL RESOURCES ISN'T OPPOSED TO THE REMOVAL OF THE TREE
09:57:26PM DUE TO THE PRIOR APPROVAL, THE FINAL PD TO REMOVE THE
09:57:31PM REMOVAL OF THIS GRAND TREE.
09:57:32PM THIS IS TALLER IN CONSTRUCTION.
09:57:35PM IT IS NATURE AGE.
09:57:37PM ITS TRUNK AND BRANCHING STRUCTURE.
09:57:40PM WE ARE NOT OPPOSED TO THE REMOVAL OF THAT TREE.
09:57:43PM BUT WITH REGARD TO TREE PLANTING, THE SITE TREE COMPOSITION
09:57:47PM WILL BENEFIT FROM A BETTER MIX OF SPECIES OF TREE SPECIES OF
09:57:54PM REPLACING THE MATURE LAUREL OAKS WITH LIVE OAKS ON THE SITE.
09:57:58PM THE APPLICANT IS PLANNING TO PLANT FOUR-INCH CALIBER TREES
09:58:05PM TO REACH MITIGATION REQUIREMENTS.
09:58:06PM THE PROJECT DOES MEET MITIGATION REQUIREMENTS.
09:58:09PM I WANT TO POINT OUT HERE THAT THERE ARE NINE TYPE 1 TREES
09:58:13PM THAT CAN BE ACCOMMODATED ON THE SITE.
09:58:15PM THESE TREES ARE THE TYPE 1 TREES PROPOSED; HOWEVER, THREE OF
09:58:21PM THEM ARE ON THE RIGHT-OF-WAY BECAUSE THERE IS JUST LIMITED
09:58:24PM SPACE, YOU KNOW, ON-SITE, TO ACCOMMODATE ALL THESE -- ALL
09:58:28PM THE TREES THAT -- THAT COULD HAVE BEEN PLANTED.
09:58:32PM SO, THAT IS REALLY ALL I HAVE FOR THIS.
09:58:36PM THERE ARE TWO TREES HERE THAT CAN'T BE ACCOMMODATED IN THIS
09:58:41PM -- THIS TREE IS CENTERED FOUR FEET FROM THE BUILDING
09:58:45PM STRUCTURE.
09:58:45PM AND THERE ARE TWO PROPOSED LIVE OAKS WHICH I SAID THIS
09:58:49PM SPACING WAS NOT SUITABLE FOR THOSE TREES.
09:58:53PM I HAVE CROSSED THEM OUT.
09:58:54PM THAT'S IT.
09:58:55PM AND THERE IS AN ANALYSIS OF PAGE 3 AND 4 OF THE STAFF REPORT
09:59:00PM FOR NATURAL RESOURCES AND I'M HERE IF YOU HAVE ANY
09:59:04PM QUESTIONS.
09:59:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME?
09:59:07PM HEARING NONE.
09:59:07PM NEXT UP, YES, SIR YES, MA'AM.
10:00:00PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: AS A COMPUTER TEACHER, THOSE ARE A LOT OF
10:00:05PM FILES UP THERE.
10:00:06PM PUT THEM IN A FOLDER.
10:00:07PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ARE YOU VOLUNTEERING TO CLEAN UP HER
10:00:13PM DESKTOP FOR HER.
10:00:14PM >> CAN YOU GUYS SEE MY SCREEN?
10:00:16PM OKAY.
10:00:17PM IT IS NOT COMING UP ON THIS SIDE.
10:00:18PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: NOW IT IS ON TV.
10:00:24PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: TAKE A LOOK UP AT THE TOP BECAUSE I THINK
10:00:27PM THE MONITOR AT THE LECTERN IS NOT WORKING.
10:00:31PM >> I HAVE THE POWERPOINT PULLED UP OVER HERE AND IT DOESN'T
10:00:35PM LOOK LIKE IT IS SHOWING UP OVER HERE.
10:00:36PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THERE IT IS.
10:00:39PM >> ALEX SCHALER, 200 NORTH ASHLEY DRIVE.
10:00:46PM I WILL MAKE IT BRIEF BUT NOT OF WAY OF SPEED TALKING.
10:00:51PM I WON'T REPEAT ALL THE LOCATION INFORMATION.
10:00:55PM DAVID DID A GOOD JOB SETTING UP WHERE THIS IS.
10:00:58PM THIS PORTION OF 22nd STREET IS AN ARTERIAL ROADWAY BECAUSE
10:01:03PM 20th STREET IS A D.O.T.
10:01:06PM THIS IS OWNED BY THE CITY AND GOING INTO A BIT OF THE ZONING
10:01:11PM HISTORY ON THE SITE, A RELATIVELY RECENT PD, 20-19 THAT
10:01:18PM ZONED THE SITE FOR SIMILAR TO WHAT WE ARE PROPOSING TODAY.
10:01:21PM MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT THAT INCLUDED APARTMENTS, RESTAURANTS
10:01:26PM AND STRIP SHOPPING WHICH CAN ACCOMMODATE ALL CG USES.
10:01:29PM AS I MENTIONED WE ARE PROPOSING SOMETHING SIMILAR TO THIS
10:01:34PM AND YOU WILL SEE IT ON THE SITE PLAN.
10:01:36PM ZONING HISTORY LEADING INTO COMP PLAN HISTORY.
10:01:39PM THIS TU-24 IS NOT ONE WE SEE VERY OFTEN.
10:01:45PM WE AMENDED THAT IN APRIL OF 2022 TO MAKE THE SITE
10:01:49PM CONSISTENTLY CMU-35.
10:01:52PM THE FLU DESIGNATION ACROSS THE ENTIRETY OF THE SITE.
10:01:57PM WHAT WE ARE PROPOSING -- I WILL RUN THROUGH THE SITE PLAN.
10:02:01PM MAIN ACCESS POINT OF MAPLE AVE AND THIS WILL COME UP A
10:02:04PM LITTLE BIT LATER, AGAIN, TRYING TO KEEP THE TRAFFIC
10:02:07PM CIRCULATION OFF OF THE HIGH VOLUME ROADWAY WHICH IS
10:02:10PM SOMETHING WE SEE VERY OFTEN.
10:02:11PM AND THE MAIN ENTRANCE LOCATED AT THE CORN EVERY OF MAPLE AND
10:02:16PM SOUTH 22nd STREET.
10:02:17PM WE ARE PROPOSING AN ACTIVATED STREETSCAPE THAT YOU WILL SEE
10:02:22PM ON THE RENDERINGS IN THE BIT ON THE LANDSCAPE PLAN THAT WE
10:02:27PM ARE RAIN SHOWED AS WELL.
10:02:28PM MOVING TO THE SOUTHERN SIDE, OAKWOOD AND MAPLE ARE PROPOSED
10:02:32PM TO HAVE SOME OF THE CONCEPTUAL ON-STREET PARKING THAT
10:02:36PM DOESN'T COUNT TOWARD OUR ZONING REQUIREMENT BUT SOMETHING
10:02:39PM THAT THE NEIGHBORHOOD DEEMED WOULD BE USEFUL.
10:02:42PM SOLID WASTE POINT OUT OF OAKWOOD.
10:02:45PM THE DOG PARK WHICH IS LAW FOR MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENTS IN
10:02:50PM TAMPA.
10:02:50PM AND WHAT IS BIT INTERESTING AND WILL PLAY INTO OUR BUFFER
10:02:54PM JUSTIFICATION LATER, A TEN-FOOT-WIDE STRIP OF LAND THAT WE
10:02:59PM HAVE DEDICATED BACK TO THE CITY ALONG THE PERSON PORTION OF
10:03:01PM THE PROPERTY.
10:03:03PM DURING THE INITIAL ZONING BACK IN 2019, AN ASSOCIATED ALLEY
10:03:08PM VACATING .A T-SHAPED ALLEY.
10:03:14PM A T-SHAPED ALLEY.
10:03:17PM THE CONDITION OF THE REZONING WAS TO PROVIDE THE
10:03:21PM TEN-FOOT-WIDE STRIP FOR EGRESS AND INGRESS FOR THE PORTION
10:03:24PM OF THE ALLEY REMAINS INTACT TO THE WEST.
10:03:27PM SOMETHING WE DON'T SEE ANYMORE.
10:03:29PM USUALLY VACATE THE ENTIRELY OF THE ALLEY DONE BACK IN 2019
10:03:34PM AND WE ARE DEDICATING AND HAVE DEDICATED THAT STRIP OF LAND
10:03:37PM BACK TO THE CITY.
10:03:38PM A RENDERING OF WHAT WE ARE PROPOSING THE SITE TO LOOK LIKE.
10:03:41PM AGAIN THIS IS VERY CONCEPTUAL, BUT GIVES YOU A GOOD IDEA OF
10:03:45PM SOME OF THE MASSING AND THE SCALING AND HOW WE REALLY TRIED
10:03:49PM TO PUSH THIS DEVELOPMENT CLOSE TO 22nd STREET.
10:03:51PM PROPOSING MULTIFAMILY AND OFFICE AS LACHONE MENTIONED, 78
10:03:58PM UNITS AND 1,000 FEET OF BP-O AND AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC FOR
10:04:03PM LEASING.
10:04:04PM NOT SPECIFIC TO THE APARTMENT COMPLEX.
10:04:07PM WE ARE PROUD TO HAVE MOST OF THE SUPPORT, DEVELOPMENT,
10:04:12PM TRANSPORTATION COORDINATION.
10:04:13PM AND SOME OF THE DEPARTMENTS THAT LACHONE AND ERIN ALLUDED TO
10:04:19PM WE HAVE NATURAL RESOURCE WAIVERS AND WANTED TO TOUCH ON
10:04:22PM THOSE WITH SOME OF OUR JUSTIFICATION.
10:04:24PM ERIN SHOWED THIS PLAN AND I WON'T BELABOR THIS POINT.
10:04:27PM MOST OF THE EXISTING ON-SITE FREES.
10:04:31PM VERY FEW.
10:04:32PM AS ERIN MENTIONED 16 TREES.
10:04:34PM A LARGE MAJORITY ARE PALMS, AGAIN, CLUSTERED IN THE
10:04:41PM SOUTHWEST PORTION.
10:04:42PM WE FEEL THAT THE TREES THAT WE ARE REPLANTING IS A BETTER
10:04:45PM PATTERN.
10:04:45PM HIGHER QUALITY.
10:04:46PM PLACEMENT AROUND THE SITE.
10:04:47PM ACCOMMODATING THE DEVELOPMENT WITH NEWER TREES AS WELL.
10:04:51PM THE NEXT ONE IS A REMOVAL OF THE TREE THAT ERIN ALSO
10:04:56PM HIGHLIGHTED TO YOU AND MENTIONED THIS AS WELL.
10:04:58PM AND THIS WAIVER WAS APPROVED IN THE 2019 REZONING FOR THIS
10:05:01PM SPECIFIC TREE.
10:05:02PM WHILE IT DOESN'T SAY THAT IT WILL BE APPROVED AGAIN, BUT
10:05:07PM DECENT PRECEDENT THAT THE SITE IS FUNCTIONS FOR RELATIVELY
10:05:10PM THE SAME USE AND WE SUBMITTED TWO REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION
10:05:15PM ALTERNATIVES INTO THE RECORD WITH THE REVISED PLAN SUBMITTAL
10:05:19PM AND SHOWING THAT UNFORTUNATELY THE KEEPING OF THE TREE WILL
10:05:22PM REND THEY ARE DEVELOPMENT INFEASIBLE.
10:05:26PM TOUCHING ON THE BUFFER WAIVER AS MENTIONED, TEN-FOOT-WIDE
10:05:32PM LAND DEDICATION TO THE CITY.
10:05:33PM NOT BUFFERED, IT IS WIDTH.
10:05:36PM THE EDGE OF OUR SITE WILL BE THIS TEN FEET PLUS OUR
10:05:40PM FIVE-FOOT BUFFER ADJACENT TO THE SINGLE-FAMILY HOME AND WE
10:05:43PM HAVEN'T HAD ANY COMPLAINTS FROM THEM IN TERMS OF THIS
10:05:46PM APPLICATION.
10:05:46PM AND TO THE SOUTH, THIS WILL REMAIN AS TEN FEET.
10:05:49PM WE HAD TO WHY THE WAIVER REDUCTION GOING DOWN TO FIVE
10:05:53PM BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT IT IS IN THE NORTHERN PORTION OF THE
10:05:55PM WESTERN BUF FER BUT FULLY COMMITTED OF DEVELOPING THIS AS
10:05:59PM SHOWN ON THE SITE PLAN BUT TEN FEET OF THE SITE.
10:06:07PM AND THE PROPERTY OWNER IS IN SUPPORT OF THE PROJECT.
10:06:11PM IN BOARD NATION WITH HIM.
10:06:13PM HE IS CO-APPLICANT IN THE EASEMENT FOR THE ALLEY VACATION.
10:06:18PM THEY HAVE BEEN WORKING WELL WITH US.
10:06:20PM WE ARE VERY PROUD TO HAVE THE COMMUNITY SUPPORT OF THE
10:06:23PM PALMETTO BEACH COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION.
10:06:25PM OUR DEVELOPER -- THE PROPERTY OWNER HAS BEEN WORKING WITH
10:06:29PM THEM FOR QUITE SOME TIME TO MAKE SURE THIS IS A PROJECT THAT
10:06:35PM THEY CAN GET BEHIND.
10:06:35PM THE PRESIDENT SUBMITTED A LETTER.
10:06:37PM E-MAILED YOU ALL AND WAS IN THE RECORD AND A VERY, VERY NICE
10:06:42PM LETTER OF THIS PROBABLY BECAUSE THIS IS PRECEDENTED
10:06:46PM DEVELOPMENT IN PALMETTO BEACH AND WE WANT TO DO IT RIGHT AND
10:06:51PM IN A WAY THAT NEIGHBORS WILL BE PROUD OF.
10:06:53PM WITH THAT I WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER QUESTIONS AND RICKY
10:06:56PM PETERIKA IS ONLINE IF YOU HAVE SPECIFIC TECHNICAL QUESTIONS.
10:07:00PM YES, MA'AM, COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK AND THEN COUNCILWOMAN
10:07:04PM HENDERSON.
10:07:04PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
10:07:05PM 972 SQUARE FEET OF OFFICE.
10:07:09PM THAT IS MY HUSBAND'S ADU OFFICE SPACE.
10:07:12PM THAT IS NOT VERY MUCH OFFICE SPACE.
10:07:14PM I AM CONCERNED THAT IF THIS IS REALLY SUPPOSED TO BE
10:07:27PM MULTIUSE, YOU ARE KIND OF REALLY TIGHTLY SQUEEZING IN THERE.
10:07:31PM CAN YOU TALK ABOUT WHY THERE IS NOT MORE -- MORE SQUARE
10:07:35PM FOOTAGE FOR AN ACTUAL MULTIUSE DEVELOPMENT.
10:07:41PM >> RIGHT, I THINK THIS WILL -- I CAN'T SPEAK TO THE ACTUAL
10:07:44PM TECHNICALITIES OF THIS.
10:07:47PM THE SITE IS A LITTLE BIT UNIQUE, THE OFFICE IS ON THE FIRST
10:07:51PM FLOOR OF THE BUILDING AND THE GROUND FLOOR IS ALL PARKING.
10:07:54PM GIVEN THE FEMA, WE NEED TO BUILD THE SITE UP X NUMBER OF
10:07:58PM SQUARE FEET.
10:07:59PM IF THIS WAS ABLE TO BE BUILT ON THE GROUND FLOOR.
10:08:04PM BUT I FEEL THAT THE MARKET FOR THE FIRST FLOOR OFFICE IN A
10:08:07PM PRECEDENT DEVELOPMENT, WE DON'T KNOW YET HOW WELL THAT WILL
10:08:11PM DO.
10:08:12PM BUT AS MENTIONED, THIS SPACE IS AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC.
10:08:16PM NOT JUST FOR THE TENANTS.
10:08:17PM ANYONE FROM PALMETTO BEACH CAN SIGN A LEASE FOR THAT SPACE.
10:08:22PM >>LYNN HURTAK: SO I GUESS THIS BEGS A QUESTION WHY THIS
10:08:27PM ISN'T JUST AN APARTMENT COMPLEX?
10:08:29PM >> IN TERMS OF WHY WE HAD THE OFFICE INCLUDED?
10:08:32PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WHY ARE YOU DOING THAT IF IT DOESN'T -- IF
10:08:36PM YOU WERE NOT EVEN SURE IF PEOPLE --
10:08:39PM >> RIGHT, AGAIN.
10:08:40PM I THINK THERE WILL BE DEMAND FOR THAT AT SOME POINT.
10:08:43PM I DON'T THINK IT IS THERE RIGHT SECOND AND CAN PROBABLY
10:08:49PM SPEAK TO THAT BETTER THAN ME.
10:08:50PM BUT THIS IS A ET, QUOTE, VERTICAL MIXED USE OFFICE.
10:08:55PM AND THE COMPONENT THAT THE PLANNING COMMISSION RECOGNIZES AS
10:08:59PM MIXED USE.
10:08:59PM THAT IS WHY IT WAS INCLUDED.
10:09:01PM >>LYNN HURTAK: MY OTHER QUESTION IS ABOUT THE LANDSCAPE.
10:09:04PM THE LANDSCAPE BUFFER -- BUT REALLY THE TREES, THE TYPES OF
10:09:08PM TREES BECAUSE AS MISS MAHER MENTIONED THE TREES ON THE RIGHT
10:09:17PM SIDE, THEY CAN'T -- THE SITE JUST GOES ALL THE WAY TO THE
10:09:20PM EDGE, AND YOU REALLY CAN'T MAKE UP YOU CAN'T PUT TREES
10:09:28PM THERE.
10:09:28PM YOU JUST AREN'T GOING TO BE ABLE TO PUT THOSE TYPE OF TREES.
10:09:31PM AGAIN IN A LOT MORE DENSE NEIGHBORHOOD TRANSIT ORIENTED
10:09:36PM DEVELOPMENT, THIS INVESTMENTS TO FIT, BUT I AM JUST
10:09:38PM CONCERNED THAT WE ARE NOT, THAT THE NATURAL RESOURCE WAIVERS
10:09:43PM ARE VERY CONCERNING.
10:09:44PM SURE, YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT ALONG SOUTH 22nd STREET.
10:09:48PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES -- BUT MAINLY SOUTH 22 WHICH IS WHERE SHE
10:09:52PM SAID YOU WON'T BE ABLE TO PUT THE TYPE OF SHADE TREES WOULD
10:09:55PM NEED TO BE ON 22nd TO HELP WITH THE WALKABILITY AND THE
10:09:58PM COOLNESS THAT PEOPLE ARE REQUESTED NOW WITH THEIR WALKABLE
10:10:06PM DEVELOPMENTS.
10:10:06PM >> RICKY, CAN YOU -- I THINK HE IS ON VIRTUALLY.
10:10:11PM CAN YOU SPEAK TO THAT.
10:10:13PM DO YOU KNOW OF TREES THAT WE CAN SWITCH OUT THAT COULD FIT
10:10:16PM OR SOMETHING THAT CAN BE HOPEFULLY ADJUSTED DURING READINGS.
10:10:20PM >> MR. PETERIKA, WAS YOU SWORN IN?
10:10:39PM >>CLERK: DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT THE TESTIMONY YOU ARE
10:10:42PM ABOUT TO GIVE IS THE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH?
10:10:47PM >> YOU ARE STILL MUTED.
10:10:48PM >> HELLO, COUNCIL.
10:11:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
10:11:01PM >> SORRY ABOUT THAT, RICKY PETERIKA, DARK MOSS.
10:11:06PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN NOW.
10:11:07PM THE -- COUNCILWOMAN, CAN YOU REPEAT THE QUESTION.
10:11:10PM SORRY, I GOT DISTRACTED.
10:11:13PM >>LYNN HURTAK: NO PROBLEM.
10:11:13PM NO PROBLEM.
10:11:14PM THE TREES ON THE 22nd STREET SIDE, MISS MAHER SAID YOU WON'T
10:11:20PM BE ABLE TO PUT A TYPE ONE OR TWO CALIPER TREE BECAUSE OF
10:11:25PM NARROWNESS.
10:11:26PM OF ALL SPACES THAT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT BECAUSE 22nd STREET
10:11:30PM IS A CORRIDOR THAT PEOPLE WILL NEED TO WALK.
10:11:32PM THE OTHER SIDE STREETS ARE MORE RESIDENTIAL, BUT THIS IS
10:11:35PM OBVIOUSLY BECAUSE OF IT, IT IS USES THAT MORE PEOPLE WILL BE
10:11:43PM ON IT.
10:11:43PM >> YES, THERE ARE IS A LITTLE BIT OF DESIGN NEGOTIATION
10:11:49PM BETWEEN THE ARCHITECT AND I THAT DIDN'T HAPPEN WITH ERIN AT
10:11:54PM THE TIME, MISS MAHER, BUT CAN.
10:11:57PM THE BUILDING FOOTPRINT OF THE GROUND LEVEL FOR THE SITE PLAN
10:12:01PM DOES SUGGEST AND IMPLY THAT THE BUILDING GOES TO -- GOES
10:12:06PM VERY CLOSE.
10:12:09PM IF YOU LOOK AT THE SECOND STORY PLAN AND THE PERSPECTIVE
10:12:13PM THAT WAS SHOWN FROM 22nd STREET, IT IS REALLY A C-SHAPED
10:12:19PM WITH A COURTYARD IN THE CENTER.
10:12:21PM WE INITIALLY LOCATED PALMS AND PUT THE OAKS IN THE CORNER
10:12:29PM AND A LITTLE CANOPY, AND GET IT THERE AND STILL OPEN UP
10:12:34PM VIEWS TO McKAY BAY.
10:12:37PM BUT THERE IS CANOPY SPACE WHERE THAT SECOND STORY OR ABOVE
10:12:42PM GARAGE COURTYARD AREA IN BETWEEN THE C-SHAPED BUILDING WHERE
10:12:52PM WE ARE CURRENTLY SHOWING PROBLEMS ON THE LANDSCAPE.
10:12:55PM THIS IS SORT OF A FINESSE DESIGN DETAIL THAT STAYED WITH THE
10:13:00PM DESIGN TEAM INTENTIONALLY AND DIDN'T GET TO STAFF, BUT CAN
10:13:04PM EASILY BE RECTIFIED.
10:13:06PM WITH A REVISION TO ADJUST IT.
10:13:15PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:13:17PM THAT ANSWERS MY QUESTIONS.
10:13:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
10:13:20PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I HAVE NO QUESTION.
10:13:22PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HELLO THERE.
10:13:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD.
10:13:27PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I HAVE A QUESTION BECAUSE I DIDN'T FOLLOW
10:13:30PM Y'ALL'S LOGIC ON THE LANDSCAPE BUFFER WITH DEEDING BACK HALF
10:13:35PM AN ALLEY BACK TO THE CITY.
10:13:36PM WHY WOULD YOU DEED IT BACK?
10:13:41PM >> THEY NEED AN EXIT FOR THE WESTERN PORTION OF THE ALLEY
10:13:44PM THAT IS STILL INTACT TODAY.
10:13:46PM BEYOND OUR ASSEMBLAGE TO THE WEST, THAT ALLEY IS -- IT IS AN
10:13:51PM ESTABLISHED ALLEY.
10:13:51PM THEY NEED AN EXIT.
10:13:53PM I DON'T KNOW IF IT WILL BE APPROVED, BUT THERE IS -- THERE
10:13:55PM IS A WAY TO LEAVE THAT EXISTING ALLEY.
10:13:58PM WITHOUT CREATING A DEAD-END.
10:14:01PM >> WILL YOU STILL NEED A LANDSCAPE BUFFER IF YOU DID NOT
10:14:06PM DEED BACK THAT HALF OF THE ALLEY?
10:14:10PM >> OUR WAIVER REQUEST IS TO REDUCE ON THAT PORTION TO FIVE
10:14:13PM FEET.
10:14:14PM WHAT WE ARE ENTIRELY ON OUR PROPERTY.
10:14:16PM THE TEN-FOOT LAND DEDICATION TEN FEET WIDTH FROM THE
10:14:22PM LANDSCAPE BUFFER TO THIS PROPERTY.
10:14:25PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE EXISTING PD THAT THAT WAS APPROVED,
10:14:28PM WHAT WAS PERMITTED TO BUILD ON THAT PROPERTY.
10:14:31PM IF YOU WERE TO BUILD ON THAT PD, WHAT WOULD YOU BE BUILDING
10:14:36PM THERE.
10:14:36PM >> MULTIFAMILY, RESTAURANT OR COMMERCIAL.
10:14:41PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHAT SETBACKS?
10:14:45PM >> LET ME GET THAT FOR YOU.
10:14:47PM SO FIVE-FOOT SETBACK TO THE NORTH.
10:14:55PM SEVEN FOOT TO THE SOUTH.
10:14:57PM SEVEN FOOT TO THE EAST AND TEN FOOT TO THE WEST.
10:15:01PM BUILDING SETBACKS.
10:15:03PM NOT NECESSARILY BUFFERS.
10:15:05PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SO THE -- SO THOSE WERE SETBACKS FROM THE
10:15:09PM BUILDING, NOT NECESSARILY -- SOMEBODY EDUCATE ME ON THAT.
10:15:12PM STAFF CONSIDER CAN YOU EXPLAIN THE DIFFERENCE OF THAT FOR
10:15:19PM ME?
10:15:24PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL, LaCHONE DOCK, LAND
10:15:29PM DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:15:29PM THE SETBACKS ARE WHERE THE BUILDING IS PLACED.
10:15:32PM IF YOU ARE LOOKING AT A SITE AND YOU HAVE A PROPERTY
10:15:37PM BOUNDARY OF THE OLD PD INSTEAD OF THE CURRENT ONE.
10:15:42PM YOU ARE LOOKING AT THE PROPERTY AND THE PROPERTY BOUNDARY,
10:15:44PM YOUR SETBACK IS ESTABLISHED FROM THE PROPERTY LINE TO THE
10:15:46PM STRUCTURE.
10:15:47PM AND SO THAT'S WHETHER IT IS YOUR FRONT, YOUR SIDE, YOUR
10:15:51PM REAR.
10:15:51PM YOUR BUFFER IS WHAT IS REQUIRED TO BUFFER AGAINST USES.
10:15:55PM WHICH ARE ADJACENT TO THE PROPERTY.
10:16:00PM SO DEPENDING ON THE USE, THEN THAT IS WHAT DETERMINES WHAT
10:16:04PM THE BUFFER IS.
10:16:06PM IT IS AREA THAT IS BETWEEN THE BUILDING AND THE PROPERTY
10:16:09PM LINE.
10:16:10PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SO WHAT I AM HEARING --
10:16:12PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YOU CAN'T HAVE BUILDING IN IT.
10:16:14PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SO WHAT I AM HEARING IS THAT THE BUFFER
10:16:16PM COULD BE GREATER THAN THE SETBACK, BUT THE SETBACKS WILL
10:16:22PM NEVER BE GREATER THAN THE BUFFER.
10:16:24PM IS THAT WHAT I AM HEARING CORRECTLY?
10:16:27PM >> OPPOSITE.
10:16:28PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: BECAUSE IT IS LATE AND WE HAVE BEEN
10:16:31PM WORKING ALL DAY YESTERDAY AND TODAY.
10:16:33PM I UNDERSTAND THE CONCEPT, OKAY.
10:16:36PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CURRENTLY ON THE SITE.
10:16:37PM IT WAS REQUESTED -- THE CURRENT PD ALLOWS FOR AS ALEX
10:16:43PM MENTIONED THE RESTAURANT, STRIP SHOPPING CENTER, ALL CG
10:16:46PM USES.
10:16:47PM ALL 31 RESIDENTIAL USES AND 6500 SQUARE FEET OF COMMERCIAL.
10:16:51PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHAT WOULD YOU LOST IN SQUARE FOOTAGE AND
10:16:55PM CONSTRUCTION TO BUILD A UNIT HERE AND NOT REQUEST THESE
10:16:59PM LANDSCAPE WAIVERS SO YOU CAN ACCOMMODATE THE TYPE OF TREES
10:17:03PM THAT YOU ARE AT LEAST TO -- AND ONE MAJOR TREE THAT YOU ARE
10:17:07PM TAKING OUT.
10:17:07PM HOW MUCH WOULD YOU HAVE LOST IN CONSTRUCTION SIZE TO DO
10:17:12PM THAT?
10:17:17PM >> OUR ARCHITECT IS ON.
10:17:19PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HOW MANY UNITS WOULD UP HAVE LOST?
10:17:23PM >> I HAVE NO IDEA, BUT BRUCE NAY BE ABLE TO CONFIRM A BIT.
10:17:26PM >> HEY, THERE, BRUCE WERNER WITH OLD LINE DESIGN.
10:17:32PM YOU CAN SWEAR ME IN, IF NEEDED.
10:17:34PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HE HAS TO BE SWORN IN.
10:17:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND WE WILL
10:17:40PM CLEAR YOU IN.
10:17:42PM >>CLERK: DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT THE TESTIMONY YOU ARE
10:17:44PM ABOUT TO GIVE IS THE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH.
10:17:47PM >> I DO.
10:17:48PM >>CLERK: THANK YOU.
10:17:50PM >> OKAY, SO IF I CAN -- AM ABLE TO SHARE MY SCREEN HERE?
10:18:00PM A BUTTON THAT STAFF CAN ALLOW ME TO DO THAT.
10:18:03PM I AM NOT NECESSARILY SEEING THAT -- BUT WITHOUT SHARING --
10:18:14PM ARE YOU GUYS SEEING THE SCREEN.
10:18:16PM CAN YOU SEE MY SITE PLAN?
10:18:20PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WE CAN NOT.
10:18:20PM MAYBE YOU CAN JUST TALK US THROUGH IT.
10:18:22PM >> YES, I CAN TALK YOU THROUGH IT.
10:18:25PM IT IS NOT NECESSARILY A MATTER OF LOSING UNITS OR
10:18:29PM DEVELOPABLE AREA.
10:18:30PM MORE ABOUT A COMBINATION OF THINGS.
10:18:37PM WITH THE SITE BEING IN THE FLOOD ZONE, ONLY REQUIRED TO HAVE
10:18:41PM PARKING ON THE GROUND FLOOR.
10:18:42PM SO WE ARE NOT ABLE TO GET THE AMOUNT OF OFFICE SPACE AND ALL
10:18:46PM THAT WHICH IS NEEDED.
10:18:47PM BUT IN THE LANDSCAPE, IT IS ACTUALLY CONSTRICTED BY THE
10:18:50PM MINIMUM SIZES OF THE PARKING SPACES.
10:18:53PM SO IF YOU GUYS ARE ABLE TO LOOK AT THE SITE PLAN OF THE
10:18:58PM STAFF REPORT AND ANYTHING THAT IS AVAILABLE, YOU CAN SEE
10:19:01PM THAT THERE IS MINIMUM DRIVE AISLE.
10:19:07PM AND PARKING SPACE DEPTH.
10:19:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THEY WILL BRING IT UP HERE.
10:19:12PM HOLD ON A SECOND.
10:19:14PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OKAY, WE ARE LOOKING AT THE SITE PLAN NOW.
10:19:21PM >> OKAY, PERFECT.
10:19:23PM IF YOU LOOK AT THE SITE PLAN STARTING AT SOUTH 22nd STREET,
10:19:27PM YOU CAN SEE THERE ARE THREE DOUBLE-LOADED DRIVE AISLES,
10:19:31PM MEANING THAT THERE ARE PARKING SPACES ON EACH SIDE OF THE
10:19:36PM THREE DRIVE AISLES THAT ARE SHADED, AND THANK YOU FOR WHOEVER IS
10:19:40PM DOING THE GREAT JOB OF HAND MODELLING, YOU CAN SEE THAT
10:19:43PM BECAUSE OF THE MINIMUM DEPTH OF THE -- OF THE PARKING SPACES
10:19:47PM AND THE MINIMUM WIDTH OF THE DRIVE AISLES, THAT IS REALLY
10:19:52PM DICTATING THE LEFTOVER SPACE FOR LANDSCAPE.
10:19:54PM WHILE THERE ISN'T AS MUCH WIDTH FOR THE LANDSCAPE AND THE
10:19:59PM TYPE OF TREES THAT IS REQUESTED, IF YOU START TO LOOK AT
10:20:03PM MAYBE THE 3D IMAGE THAT WE SHOWED AND ANY OF THE LANDSCAPE
10:20:07PM PLANS.
10:20:07PM THE 3D IMAGE MIGHT BE BETTER IF YOU CAN BRING THAT UP.
10:20:11PM YOU CAN SEE THAT NOT ONLY WILL THE STREETSCAPE BE ACTIVATED
10:20:16PM AND FRIENDLY WITH SHADED TREES, BUT THE BUILDING ITSELF WILL
10:20:19PM ALSO PROVIDE SHADE, BECAUSE SOME OF THE CANOPIES OF THE
10:20:27PM BUILDING ACTUALLY EXTEND THERE.
10:20:29PM IF THE INTENT OF THE LANDSCAPE IS PROVIDING FRIENDLY
10:20:34PM PEDESTRIAN EXPERIENCE AND PROVIDE SHADE TO THE PEDESTRIANS,
10:20:37PM OUR DESIGN ACTUALLY ACCOMMODATES THAT PRETTY AS WELL.
10:20:47PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IF YOU LEAVE THE ELEVATIONS UP, ONE OF THE
10:20:50PM THINGS THAT DRIVES ME CRAZY BECAUSE DEPLOYING TREES THAT ARE
10:20:55PM LARGE SHADE TREES.
10:20:56PM AND THIS IS THE KIND OF STUFF THAT I HATE BECAUSE KIND OF A
10:21:00PM MISREPRESENTATION, BECAUSE IT IMPLIES THERE WILL BE A TREE
10:21:03PM THERE THAT IS NOT FEASIBLE.
10:21:05PM WITH THAT BEING SAID, THANK YOU.
10:21:08PM THAT ANSWERED MY QUESTIONS.
10:21:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS?
10:21:16PM THANK YOU.
10:21:16PM ANYBODY ELSE?
10:21:17PM READY FOR PUBLIC COMMENT?
10:21:19PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WISH TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, ITEM
10:21:22PM NUMBER 10?
10:21:23PM ALL RIGHT, I DON'T SEE ANYONE REGISTERED ONLINE OTHER THAN
10:21:28PM THE APPLICANTS THAT'S CORRECT?
10:21:34PM DO YOU NEED TO ADD ANYTHING ELSE OR WANT TO ADD ANYTHING
10:21:37PM ELSE?
10:21:38PM >> I DO WANT TO MENTION FOR COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
10:21:41PM PER RICKY'S COMMENT, WE CAN GET TO THE PLACE TO PROVIDE
10:21:46PM TREES ON 22nd BETWEEN READINGS.
10:21:50PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IF WE WERE BE ABLE TO APPROVE WITH A
10:21:53PM COUNCIL CONDITION, THAT WILL BE HELPFUL TO YOU.
10:21:57PM >> YES.
10:21:59PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I THINK WE NEED ADVICE.
10:22:00PM ERIN MAH ER, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:22:12PM I THINK HE SAID THEY COULD FINESSE AND FIT IN SHADE TREES
10:22:16PM ALONG 22nd, BUT I DON'T EVEN SEE HOW THAT IS EVEN POSSIBLE
10:22:21PM WITH WHAT -- RICKY, I DON'T KNOW IF YOU ARE STILL ON THERE.
10:22:25PM BUT THE BUILDING SEEMS TO GO -- IT'S FOUR FEET FROM THE
10:22:29PM CENTER OF THE TRUNK OF THE TREE IS WHAT I MEASURED IT.
10:22:33PM AND THIS IS A MATURE LIVE OAK THAT IS BEING PROPOSED TO BE
10:22:39PM PLANTED IN THAT LOCATION.
10:22:40PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: RICKY?
10:22:43PM >> YES, THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
10:22:45PM RICKY PETERIKA.
10:22:47PM TREE PRESERVATION SITUATIONS, MAYBE NOT AS TIGHT OF
10:22:52PM URBANNESS.
10:22:53PM WE PROPOSED SPECIAL DESIGN TECHNIQUES FOR THE PARKING GARAGE
10:22:59PM ITSELF.
10:22:59PM IT CERTAINLY IS TIME FOR US TO VISIT THAT.
10:23:02PM AND ALSO PREPARE A -- A -- A ROOF PLAN -- LANDSCAPE PLAN
10:23:12PM THAT SHOWS THE GROUND LEVEL AND THE UPPER STORIES TO WORK
10:23:16PM OUT THOSE DETAILS.
10:23:17PM I THINK WE CAN.
10:23:18PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I THINK WE CAN IS NOT A GREAT ANSWER.
10:23:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. SHELBY.
10:23:28PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I WOULD THINK THIS WOULD HAVE TO BE
10:23:30PM RESOLVED WITH DIRECTION OF COUNCIL BEFORE IT COMES BACK TO
10:23:35PM BE HANDLED FOR FIRST AND SECOND READING.
10:23:37PM I DON'T KNOW IF YOU ARE IN A POSITION TO DO THAT TONIGHT.
10:23:40PM >> UNLESS YOU BUMP THE ROAD OUT, I DON'T KNOW HOW --
10:23:51PM >> WELL, WE ARE -- THERE IS A MINIMUM HARD SCAPE SEPARATION
10:23:57PM THAT I PROVIDED FROM BOTH THE SIDEWALK AND THE BUILDING
10:24:00PM EDGE.
10:24:01PM IF WE PLAYED WITH THE SIDEWALK TREATMENT -- LET'S SAY REDUCE
10:24:07PM THAT HARD SCAPE SEPARATION, BASICALLY THE SIDEWALK EDGE TO
10:24:11PM THE TRUCK TO INCREASE THE BUILDING EDGE TO THE TRUCK, THOSE
10:24:17PM ARE THE KIND OF DETAILS THAT I GOT TO WORK WITH -- I CAN
10:24:20PM WORK WITH STAFF ON TO GET TREES THERE THAT CAN PROVIDE
10:24:24PM SHADE.
10:24:25PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU, RICKY.
10:24:26PM I HAVE A QUESTION FOR MARTY SHELBY.
10:24:28PM IS THIS SOMETHING THAT -- THAT I WOULDN'T BE COMFORTABLE
10:24:32PM UNTIL NATURAL RESOURCES WAS COMFORTABLE WITH THIS AND THESE
10:24:36PM NATURAL RESOURCE CONCERNS WERE RESOLVED.
10:24:38PM WHAT ARE OUR OPTIONS?
10:24:40PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YOUR OPTIONS ARE THAT YOU CAN SEE IF -- YOU
10:24:44PM CAN -- YOU CAN STATE WHAT -- WHAT YOUR CONCERNS ARE AND YOU
10:24:47PM CAN SEE IF IT CAN BE RESOLVED.
10:24:49PM IF IT REQUIRES A CONTINUANCE, CAN YOU ADDRESS THAT ISSUE.
10:24:53PM >> IF I CAN ANSWER THE QUESTION.
10:24:55PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: WHY DON'T YOU DIRECTLY DO THIS.
10:24:57PM >> I TALKED TO SOME OF YOU ABOUT THIS.
10:24:59PM A GAP IN THE CODE BECAUSE LANDSCAPE SOMETHING TYPICALLY
10:25:02PM HANDLED AT PERMITTING.
10:25:03PM PEOPLE ASK FOR ZONING TREE-RELATED WAIVERS NOW AND THERE IS
10:25:08PM THIS GAP.
10:25:08PM AND TRUST DOESN'T ALWAYS GET YOU THE WHOLE WAY.
10:25:11PM SO WHAT RICKY AND I OFTEN WORK ON WITH THESE TYPES OF PDs WE
10:25:17PM HAVE THE PRIVILEGE TO WORK ON TOGETHER IS A LANDSCAPE PLAN.
10:25:20PM THIS IS PART OF THE SITE PLAN.
10:25:22PM THIS IS PUTTING 30-FOOT SPACING, 18 FEET HIGH.
10:25:30PM THAT IS WHAT WE ARE DOING ON GASWORX ON NUCCIO.
10:25:35PM IF WE CAN'T DO THAT -- THIS IS A PART OF THE SITE PLAN, THE
10:25:39PM SHEET PLAN, IF WE CAN'T DO THAT, THEN THAT IS A PROBLEM.
10:25:42PM THIS IS NOT LIKE SOME HOCUS POCUS.
10:25:47PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THAT IS A SITE PLAN FOR A TYPE 1 TREE.
10:25:50PM >> YEAH, 11 TYPE 1 TREES .A NORTH OF SILVER CELLS THAT RICKY
10:25:56PM IS EXPLAIN IN MORE DETAILS.
10:25:58PM THESE ARE BOXES -- WHERE IS ERIN -- THOSE ARE A WAY TO MAKE
10:26:02PM LARGER TREES GROW IN A SMALLER AREA THAN JUST ORDINARY SOIL
10:26:06PM WILL ALLOW.
10:26:07PM LIKE A STRUCTURAL SOIL PRODUCT WE HAVE DONE ON OTHER
10:26:11PM PROJECTS.
10:26:11PM THESE ARE COMMITMENTS WE ARE MAKING.
10:26:14PM I WANT TO MAKE THAT VERY CLEAR.
10:26:16PM RENDERING WITH THE STREET ART.
10:26:19PM THAT IS NOT A COMMITMENT.
10:26:20PM THAT IS A RENDERING.
10:26:22PM THAT IS A COMMITMENT.
10:26:23PM THIS IS PART OF THE SITE PLAN THAT WE ARE ASKING FOR --
10:26:26PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: TWO PEOPLE -- I WILL GO TO MARTY AND THEN
10:26:30PM WHAT YOU WANTED TO SAY THERE.
10:26:31PM DID YOU HAVE SOMETHING TO SAY?
10:26:32PM MARTY?
10:26:34PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: COUNCIL, I AM JUST ASKING YOU AGAIN WITH
10:26:37PM YOUR CRITERIA.
10:26:39PM CERTAIN WAIVERS BEING REQUESTED.
10:26:41PM YOU HAVE WAIVER CRITERIA, IF YOU HAVE CONCERNED, CONCERNS
10:26:45PM THOSE, PLEASE BE IN MIND IT HAVEN'T COME UP FOR DISCUSSION A
10:26:48PM BONUS AGREEMENT THAT DOES TRAVEL WITH THIS AND WILL BE
10:26:52PM COMING BACK IF THIS IS ADOPTED AT FIRST READING.
10:26:55PM THAT BEING SAID, MY SUGGESTION IS FOR YOU TO LOOK AT THE
10:27:03PM CRITERIA AND WHAT YOU HEARD AND WHAT THE EVIDENCE AND THE
10:27:05PM ISSUES THAT NEED TO BE RESOLVED THEN YOU CAN MAKE A
10:27:08PM DETERMINATION AS TO IF CAN BE INVOLVED BETWEEN FIRST AND
10:27:14PM SECOND READING OR SOME OTHER COMMENDATION.
10:27:16PM DO YOU WANT TO ADD ANYTHING TO THIS?
10:27:19PM >> OUR POSITION THERE IS NOTHING TO RESOLVE.
10:27:22PM OUR POSITION -- I WILL BE VERY TRANSPARENT WITH ALL OF THIS.
10:27:26PM WE ARE MAKING COMMITMENTS WHAT TYPE OF NEW TREES WE ARE
10:27:30PM PUTTING IN.
10:27:31PM THE ARBORIST, THE ARCHITECT.
10:27:33PM THE TREES THAT ARE ON-SITE ARE VERY POOR QUALITY.
10:27:36PM WE ARE TAKING THEM OUT AND PUTTING THEM BACK WITH A NEW
10:27:40PM CONFIGURATION OF TREES WITH THIS COMMITMENT HERE.
10:27:43PM SOME TREPIDATION THESE ARE NOT FULLY ENGINEERED CROSS
10:27:49PM SECTION OF WHAT THE TREES LOOK LIKE.
10:27:52PM NOT THE STAGE OF THE PROCESS TO GET TO THAT LEVEL OF DETAIL,
10:27:56PM BUT IT IS THE APPROPRIATE STAGE TO GET TO THE TREE TYPES.
10:27:59PM THESE ARE COMMITMENTS THAT WE ARE MAKING.
10:28:01PM IF WE CAN'T MAKE THOSE, THAT IS A PROBLEM FOR US.
10:28:04PM NOT A PROBLEM FOR THE CITY TO RESOLVE FOR US.
10:28:07PM THAT IS OUR PROBLEM.
10:28:09PM WE MADE THESE AGREEMENTS BECAUSE WE HAVE THE CONFIDENCE THAT
10:28:14PM WE CAN MAKE THEM.
10:28:14PM RICKY DOES A GREAT JOB THINKING THOROUGHLY THROUGH THESE
10:28:18PM THINGS.
10:28:18PM WE THINK THEY ARE ACHIEVABLE.
10:28:30PM WE CAN PULL THEM BACK A LITTLE BIT TO ACCOMMODATE THE TREE
10:28:34PM IT IS WE HAVE TO.
10:28:35PM BUT STRESS FOR THE FOLKS -- ANYONE WATCHING AT HOME AT THIS
10:28:38PM HOUR, THESE ARE COMMITMENTS WE ARE MAKING IN TERMS OF TREE
10:28:42PM TYPES AND, AGAIN, THIS IS -- THIS IS A NEW TYPE OF PROJECT
10:28:46PM FOR PALMETTO BEACH.
10:28:47PM 18-FOOT-TALL TREES ON 22nd STREET TO MATCH WHAT THEY ARE
10:28:53PM DOING ON NUCCIO.
10:28:54PM THAT IS A PRETTY BIG COMMITMENT.
10:28:57PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I DON'T KNOW HOW MY FELLOW COUNCILMEN, IN
10:29:01PM THE COASTAL HIGH AREA, I AM WORRIED OF THE BONUS PROVISION.
10:29:06PM AND IN AREAS WHERE YOU SNEEZE ON IT, AND WATER IS THERE.
10:29:11PM >> YOU CAN.
10:29:12PM THE MAXIMUM DENSITY IS 2.0.
10:29:16PM PROPOSING 1.66 AND NOT THE ABSOLUTE MAXIMUM.
10:29:20PM THIS IS AN EXAMPLE OF FULL CIRCLE OF BONUS -- $94,000.
10:29:26PM HELP FIX THE SEAWALL OF BERMUDA BOULEVARD.
10:29:30PM ALL ABOUT TRADE-OFFS AND FIND THE OPPORTUNITY OF APPROXIMATE
10:29:39PM HOUSING OF JOB CENTERS TO NOT TRANSIT BUT FOR NOW MAJOR
10:29:43PM ROADS, ADAMO AND DO THAT WITH SUPPORT OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD, I
10:29:48PM WOULD RESPECTFULLY SUBMIT THOSE APPLICATIONS ARE RARE IN
10:29:51PM THIS DAY AND AGE AND WE THINK THIS PROJECT DOES -- IS NOT
10:29:55PM PERFECT.
10:29:56PM I NEVER HAD THE CHANCE TO REPRESENT ONE BUT BALANCES THE
10:30:01PM TRADE-OFFS IN A VERY APPROPRIATE WAY AND NOT GIVEN THE HOUR
10:30:05PM READ THE WAIVER JUSTIFICATION MEMO IN THE RECORD BUT A
10:30:09PM WAIVER JUSTIFICATION FOR EACH OF THESE IN THE RECORD THAT
10:30:13PM ARE DUE TO THIS CRITERIA.
10:30:15PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU.
10:30:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
10:30:17PM ALL RIGHT.
10:30:17PM YES, MA'AM.
10:30:18PM >>ERIN MAHER: ERIN MAHER, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:30:24PM RICKY WILL PROPOSE SOME SYSTEM TO INCREASE READING VOLUME.
10:30:30PM I THINK IF WE DO COME BACK BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING
10:30:34PM WITH A REALITY TYPE OF LANDSCAPE PLAN, THEN, YOU KNOW, WE
10:30:38PM CAN GET THERE TOO.
10:30:38PM ANYONE ELSE BEFORE WE ASK FOR -- YES, MA'AM.
10:30:49PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL, LaCHONE DOCK, LAND
10:30:53PM DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:30:54PM THE REVISION SHEET PROVIDED.
10:30:55PM REVISED REVISION SHEET.
10:30:57PM IN ADDITION TO THAT WILL PROVIDE A REVISED LANDSCAPE PLAN
10:31:01PM BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
10:31:02PM SO JUST TO STATE THAT ON THE RECORD AND THEN THE APPLICANT
10:31:05PM CAN STATE THEY AGREE TO THAT ON THE RECORD OR NOT.
10:31:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: REVISED REVISION SHEET.
10:31:13PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: PROVIDED TO YOU THIS EVENING OR THE
10:31:15PM LANDSCAPE PLAN.
10:31:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: AND YOU AS THE APPLICANT WILL STATE THAT
10:31:20PM ON THE RECORD?
10:31:21PM OKAY.
10:31:21PM ANYTHING ELSE.
10:31:23PM IF WE ASK FOR A MOTION TO CLOSE.
10:31:25PM MOTION BY COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:31:28PM SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:31:30PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK, WOULD YOU LIKE TO TAKE THIS?
10:31:34PM >>LYNN HURTAK: SURE.
10:31:35PM I DON'T KNOW WHERE I AM.
10:31:39PM I MOVE ITEM NUMBER 10, FILE NUMBER REZ-23-06, ORDINANCE
10:31:47PM BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING AND CONSIDERATION, AN
10:31:50PM ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 2015
10:31:54PM AND 2017 MAPLE AVENUE, 1305 SOUTH 22nd STREET, AND 2020
10:32:00PM OAKWOOD AVENUE IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, AND MORE
10:32:03PM PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1 FROM ZONING DISTRICT
10:32:08PM CLASSIFICATION, P BED, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT TO PD, PLANNED
10:32:13PM DEVELOPMENT, MULTIFAMILY AND STOREFRONT RESIDENTIAL AND
10:32:16PM OFFICE USES PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE, INCLUDING THE
10:32:19PM REVISED REVISION SHEET AND A LANDSCAPE PLAN.
10:32:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
10:32:25PM >>LYNN HURTAK: BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
10:32:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK WITH THE MOTION.
10:32:31PM SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:32:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
10:32:37PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: BECAUSE OF ASSOCIATION, I WILL DEFINITELY
10:32:42PM SAY YES.
10:32:43PM >>LUIS VIERA: SURE, YES.
10:32:44PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
10:32:46PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
10:32:47PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
10:32:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
10:32:51PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
10:32:53PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON OCTOBER 5, 2023
10:32:58PM AT 9:30 A.M. AT 315 E. KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR,
10:33:04PM TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
10:33:06PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: A TOUGH ROAD TO GET THERE BUT WE WILL SEE
10:33:12PM SOME NICE IMPROVEMENTS BETWEEN THE FIRST AND THE SECOND.
10:33:15PM LOOKING FORWARD TO IT OKAY, WE ARE MOVING ON -- MOVING ON TO
10:33:24PM 11.
10:33:24PM REZ-23-16.
10:33:28PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
10:33:31PM LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT.
10:33:35PM REZ-23-61.
10:33:38PM 2511 NORTH ALBANY AVENUE AND THE APPLICANT, ALEX RIOS,
10:33:46PM FROM RS-50 RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT
10:33:52PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY.
10:33:54PM >>DAVID HEY: GOOD EVENING, COUNCILMEMBERS.
10:33:58PM DAVID HEY WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
10:34:02PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
10:34:03PM WE END THE EVENING IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT
10:34:07PM MOST THE OLD TAMPA.
10:34:12PM PUBLIC RECREATION FACILITY ONE FOURTH MILE.
10:34:16PM THERE IS TRANSIT ALONG NORTH HOWARD AVENUE AND THE SUBJECT
10:34:19PM SITE IS WITHIN THE EVACUATION ZONE D.
10:34:22PM WE HAVE THE AERIAL OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
10:34:30PM YOU CAN SEE IT IS LOCATED RIGHT IN THE CENTER HERE.
10:34:34PM ST. CONRAD STREET RUNS EAST, WEST ON THE NORTH.
10:34:39PM AND THEN WE HAVE -- I THINK THAT IS ALBANY ON THE -- ON THE
10:34:44PM WEST SIDE RUNNING NORTH TO SOUTH.
10:34:46PM YOU CAN SEE -- YOU CAN SEE HILLSBOROUGH RIVER.
10:34:49PM THAT IS COLUMBUS DRIVE TO THE NORTH.
10:34:51PM THIS IS THE WEST RIVERFRONT DEVELOPMENT OFF TO THE -- TO --
10:34:57PM ABOUT TWO BLOCKS TO THE EAST.
10:35:00PM THIS AREA -- THIS SURROUNDING AN AREA CONTAINS A MIXTURE OF
10:35:07PM SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL AND NONRESIDENTIAL USES,
10:35:10PM SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL USES ARE PRESENT ON WEST ST.
10:35:13PM CONRAD STREET AND A MIX OF SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED LIGHT
10:35:17PM COMMERCIAL USES ARE PRESENT ALONG NORTH ALBANY AVENUE.
10:35:22PM ON TO THE -- THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
10:35:27PM THE SUBJECT SITE AND ALL THE PARCELS IN THE BROWN ARE
10:35:32PM THAT R-35.
10:35:33PM IT GETS MORE INTENSE AS YOU MOVE WESTWARD OVER TO -- OVER TO
10:35:37PM NORTH HOWARD AVENUE.
10:35:38PM THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35, COMMUNITY COMMERCIAL 35.
10:35:42PM GREEN IS REC OPEN SPACE.
10:35:44PM LIGHT INDUSTRIAL IN THE LIGHT GRAY.
10:35:46PM THE -- GIVEN THE PRESENCE OF LIGHT COMMERCIAL USES TO THE
10:35:54PM WEST OF THE SITE, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF HAD THE SITE
10:35:59PM APPROPRIATE FOR ATTACHED SINGLE-FAMILY USES AND EXPAND THE
10:36:02PM HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES.
10:36:03PM CONSISTENT WITH HOUSING CHOICE POLICIES WITHIN THE
10:36:06PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
10:36:07PM THE SITE PLAN IS ALSO NEEDING ORIENTATION -- MEETING
10:36:14PM ORIENTATION POLICIES RECORDING THE FRONT DOORS.
10:36:16PM IT IS WITHIN -- LOCATED WITHIN EVACUATION ZONE D SO WORK
10:36:23PM WITH THE CITY FOR MITIGATING SHELTER SPACE AND IN
10:36:26PM CONCLUSION, CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN UNDER
10:36:28PM THAT RES-35.
10:36:30PM THE REQUEST IS COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE AND WILL BE AN
10:36:34PM ASSET TO THE WEST TAMPA URBAN VILLAGE.
10:36:37PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS AND THE POLICIES WITHIN THE
10:36:40PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDS THE
10:36:43PM PLANNED DEVELOPMENT CONSISTENT WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE
10:36:46PM TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
10:36:47PM THANK YOU.
10:36:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
10:36:50PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:36:53PM THIS PD REQUEST WOULD ALLOW FOR THREE UNITS ON SITE.
10:36:57PM 6344 SQUARE FEET.
10:37:00PM 35 FEET IS THE MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT PROPOSED.
10:37:03PM THAT IS A TWO-STORY HEIGHT ON THE SITE.
10:37:06PM SO WHAT I HAVE DONE IS PROVIDED FOR YOU THE SITE PLAN FOR
10:37:09PM THIS LOCATION.
10:37:10PM THIS SITE IS ALSO LOCATED IN THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY AND MUST
10:37:16PM MEET THE CODE REQUIREMENTS AT THE TIME OF PERMITTING.
10:37:20PM THERE ARE -- THERE IS ONE WAIVER REQUESTED ON THE SITE BUT
10:37:24PM IT IS FOR A LANDSCAPE BUFFER.
10:37:26PM SO ON THE SITE PLAN ITSELF, THIS IS WEST CONRAD STREET.
10:37:32PM THIS IS NORTH ALBANY.
10:37:34PM THE SITE IS ON THE CORNER.
10:37:35PM THIS IS THE PROPERTY LINE THAT IS SHOWN, THE DOTTED LINE.
10:37:41PM THREE UNITS IDENTIFIED.
10:37:43PM UNIT 1, UNIT 2, AND UNIT 3, THE FRONT DOOR ENTRY FOR UNIT 2
10:37:49PM AND 3 ORIENT WEST.
10:37:52PM THE FRONT DOOR OF UNIT NUMBER 1, TO ALBANY.
10:37:57PM UNIT NUMBER 1, AN ADDITIONAL DOOR ADDED ON ST. CONRAD ALSO.
10:38:02PM THIS IS A SIDE DOOR.
10:38:04PM EACH OF THESE DOORS HAVE A FRONT PORCH THAT I WILL SHOW YOU
10:38:08PM ON THE ELEVATIONS, BUT ACCESS TO THE SITE, VEHICULAR ACCESS
10:38:12PM IS ON ST. CONRAD WITH THE SURFACE PARKING SPACES LOCATED
10:38:18PM EAST OF THE BUILDING.
10:38:18PM THE DESIGN OF THE BUILDING IS CREATED SO THAT YOUR ELEVATION
10:38:24PM FROM ST. CONRAD HAS THE SAME FRONT DOOR ENTRY OR DOOR ENTRY
10:38:30PM WITH A PORCH.
10:38:31PM SO THIS IS THE ELEVATION.
10:38:34PM SO ON THE LEFT IS THE EAST ELEVATION.
10:38:38PM THIS IS THE WEST ELEVATION.
10:38:40PM THIS IS IN THE UPPER RIGHT.
10:38:42PM SO THIS IS THE NORTH --
10:38:45PM >>LYNN HURTAK: CAN YOU ZOOM OUT A BIT MORE.
10:38:47PM THANK YOU.
10:38:50PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THERE WE GO.
10:38:52PM SO THIS IS THE NORTH ELEVATION.
10:38:55PM AND THIS IS WHERE YOU CAN SEE THE FRONT DOOR.
10:38:57PM FRONT DOOR.
10:38:58PM AND THEN THE SIDE DOOR ENTRY ON THE STRUCTURE.
10:39:02PM AND THEN THIS IS THE SOUTH ELEVATION.
10:39:04PM THEN WE HAVE THE ZONING ATLAS I WOULD LIKE TO PROVIDE.
10:39:10PM SO THIS IS THE SITE THAT IS LOCATED HERE IN RED.
10:39:15PM THIS IS ALBANY AVENUE.
10:39:17PM THIS IS ST. CONRAD.
10:39:19PM THIS IS BEACH STREET HERE.
10:39:22PM ROME AVENUE HERE.
10:39:23PM HOWARD AVENUE HERE FURTHER WEST.
10:39:26PM YOU CAN SEE THE SURROUNDING ZONING SURROUNDING THE PROPERTY
10:39:30PM IS RS-50.
10:39:32PM YOU HAVE THE COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD WHICH DAVID HAS
10:39:35PM MENTIONED, BUT YOU HAVE THAT COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD ZONING
10:39:38PM TO THE WEST.
10:39:39PM BUT OTHER THAN THAT, THE MAJORITY OF THE USES ARE EITHER
10:39:42PM RESIDENTIAL OR COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD IN NATURE, THE ZONING
10:39:48PM AND THE USE OF THE PROPERTY.
10:39:49PM SO THIS IS THE SITE ON ALBANY.
10:39:53PM WHICH IS VACANT.
10:39:57PM ANOTHER VIEW OF THE SITE.
10:39:58PM THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE.
10:40:00PM IMMEDIATELY TO THE SOUTH.
10:40:01PM THIS IS WEST OF THE SITE, WHICH IS THE COMMERCIAL.
10:40:06PM LOCATED TO THE WEST.
10:40:08PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW WEST.
10:40:11PM THIS IS A CONVENIENCE STORE.
10:40:17PM THIS IS NORTHWEST OF THE SITE, THE HOME THERE.
10:40:21PM THIS IS THE RESIDENCE.
10:40:22PM THIS IS AT THE NORTHEAST CORNER, ST. CONRAD.
10:40:26PM AND DIRECTLY NORTH OF THE SITE.
10:40:29PM SO THE DRC STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FINDS THE
10:40:34PM REQUEST CONSISTENT.
10:40:34PM THERE ARE SITE PLAN MODIFICATIONS TO BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST
10:40:38PM AND SECOND READING.
10:40:39PM THERE IS A REVISION SHEET PROVIDED.
10:40:41PM THERE IS AN ADDITION TO THIS REVISION SHEET WHICH WAS JUST
10:40:45PM DISCOVERED.
10:40:46PM THE APPLICANT BROUGHT IT TO MY ATTENTION.
10:40:50PM HE NEEDS TO CALL BACK THE SETBACKS IN THE SITE DATA TABLE
10:40:53PM FOR THE FRONT SETBACK, BECAUSE RIGHT NOW IT IS SHOWING
10:40:56PM THROUGH THE STRUCTURE ITSELF.
10:40:58PM I AM GOING TO ADD -- I HAVE WRITTEN THIS ON THE REVISION
10:41:02PM SHEET AND I HAVE IT STATED ON THE RECORD AND PROVIDE YOU,
10:41:06PM COUNCIL, WITH THE REVISED REVISION SHEET.
10:41:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:41:11PM >> THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
10:41:13PM I AM AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ORDINANCE
10:41:17PM MANISCALCO YES, SIR.
10:41:19PM >> I DO NEED TO BE SWORN IN?
10:41:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DID YOU GET SWORN IN BEFORE?
10:41:25PM >> NO.
10:41:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND -- [SWEARING
10:41:31PM IN]
10:41:32PM >> YES.
10:41:33PM >>CLERK: THANK YOU.
10:41:34PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
10:41:36PM MY NAME IS ALEX RIOS WITH RIOS ARCHITECTURE.
10:41:41PM FROM RS-50 TO PD.
10:41:44PM THE MAXIMUM DENSITY ACHIEVABLE BASED ON R-35 FUTURE LAND USE
10:41:51PM IS FOUR UNITS BUT WE ARE PURSUING THREE.
10:41:54PM ALSO WITHIN THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY AND ALLOWING FOR ONE
10:41:59PM PARKING SPACE PER UNIT.
10:42:00PM THE DESIGN IS CONSTRAINED DUE TO TWO LARGE OFFSITE GRAND
10:42:05PM TREES IN THE NORTH.
10:42:05PM THE 20-FOOT PROTECTIVE RADIUS GOT US TO THINK CREATIVELY OF
10:42:11PM ON THE TOWN HOMES OF THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY REQUIREMENTS OF
10:42:15PM PARKING AND GREEN SPACE.
10:42:16PM THE SITE PLAN LOOKS AT THE NORTH SETBACK AND ACCOMMODATE
10:42:22PM PARKING TO THE EAST WHICH IS TO PROTECT THESE GRAND TREES.
10:42:26PM EAST SETBACK IS IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE BUILD TO OF THE
10:42:31PM STREET PRESENCE ALONG ALBANY.
10:42:33PM EXTERIOR DESIGN EXHIBITS DESIGN FEATURES ROOF SLOPES,
10:42:40PM PORCHES AND DETAILS OF THE WEST TAMPA OVERLAY AND
10:42:44PM NEIGHBORING HOMES.
10:42:44PM HERE ARE A FEW RENDERING..
10:42:49PM THIS IS FACING CONRAD.
10:42:55PM THIS IS FACING ALBANY.
10:42:58PM AND THIS IS JUST THE CORNER VEHICLE.
10:43:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THIS IS CONRAD AND ALBANY?
10:43:09PM >> YES, THIS IS CONRAD.
10:43:11PM THIS IS ALBANY.
10:43:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THAT WAS CORNER.
10:43:16PM >> SO ALBANY AND CONRAD HERE.
10:43:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:43:22PM >> WITH THAT, WE ARE PLEASED WITH STAFF'S UNANIMOUS FINDING
10:43:33PM THAT THIS DESIGN IS CONSISTENT WITH CODE AND SURROUNDING
10:43:35PM AREA.
10:43:35PM WE NOW SEEK CITY COUNCIL APPROVAL.
10:43:38PM THANK YOU.
10:43:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM, COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
10:43:41PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I WANT TO SAY I APPRECIATE YOUR CREATIVITY
10:43:44PM WITH SAVING THE TREES, FINDING A WAY TO WORK WITH THE WEST
10:43:48PM TAMPA OVERLAY.
10:43:49PM THIS WAS 100% WHAT WE NEED TO SEE AND I WANT TO THANK YOU
10:43:53PM FOR THE TIME AND EFFORT YOU HAD YOU HAD TO DO TO MAKE IT
10:43:57PM RIGHT.
10:43:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
10:44:02PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SANDY SANCHEZ IS NOT HERE SO I KNEW YOU
10:44:06PM WOULD BE SAFE TONIGHT.
10:44:07PM IT IS A NICE PLAN.
10:44:09PM I LIKE IT.
10:44:09PM CAN I SAY STUFF LIKE THAT.
10:44:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I AM LOOKING AT MR. SHELBY.
10:44:17PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: OBVIOUSLY -- ONE OF THE THINGS I WANT T
10:44:19PM BRING TO COUNCIL'S ATTENTION BECAUSE WE HAVE TWO RELATIVELY
10:44:23PM RECENT ADDITIONS TO COUNCIL.
10:44:25PM BUT MY POINT IS THIS.
10:44:28PM YOUR DECISION, IRRESPECTIVE OF WHO IS HERE AND WHO IS NO NOT
10:44:33PM HAVE TO BE BASED ON COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE IN
10:44:37PM THE RECORD.
10:44:38PM THE FACT IS FOR WHATEVER REASON IF PEOPLE DON'T SHOW, THE
10:44:42PM PLAN HAS GOT TO STAND ON ITS OWN TO MEET CITY COUNCIL'S
10:44:46PM SCRUTINY.
10:44:46PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ALL THE CONVERSATIONS IN THE MIDDLE OF THE
10:44:58PM DAIS TONIGHT.
10:44:58PM I WANT TO SAY THAT -- AGAIN, KUDOS TO YOU.
10:45:03PM I LIKE -- I LIKE THE ELEVATIONS ARE NICE WITH THE WEST TAMPA
10:45:08PM OVERLAY DISTRICT.
10:45:09PM YOU HAVE FOUR FACING DOORS.
10:45:11PM YOU HAVE -- IT IS A GOOD -- I MEAN HONESTLY A COMPLETE SITE
10:45:15PM PLAN.
10:45:15PM WELL-DONE.
10:45:17PM I WISH THEY WERE ALL LIKE THIS.
10:45:19PM >> THANK YOU.
10:45:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:45:25PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: KEEP THE GARBAGE CANS THERE TOO.
10:45:28PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THEY ARE SO PRETTY.
10:45:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY PUBLIC COMMENT AT THIS TIME.
10:45:33PM A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
10:45:35PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:45:37PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:45:38PM OPPOSED?
10:45:39PM COUNCILMAN CARLSON, I BELIEVE IT IS YOU ITEM NUMBER 11.
10:45:44PM >>BILL CARLSON: MO OF FILE NUMBER REZ-23-61, ORDINANCE BEING
10:45:50PM PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING.
10:45:52PM ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY 2511 NORTH ALBANY AVENUE, CITY
10:45:58PM OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, RS-50, RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY TO PD
10:46:05PM AND PLUS THE REVISED REVISION SHEET.
10:46:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
10:46:10PM A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
10:46:12PM A SECOND FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
10:46:14PM SORRY, ROLL CALL VOTE.
10:46:17PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
10:46:19PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
10:46:20PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
10:46:22PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
10:46:24PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
10:46:26PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
10:46:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
10:46:29PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
10:46:31PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION ON OCTOBER 5, 2023, AT 9:30 A.M.
10:46:37PM AT 315 E. KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, IT, 234 FLORIDA,
10:46:46PM 33602.
10:46:48PM >>> NOW GO TO NEW BUSINESS.
10:46:49PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ARE YOU RECOGNIZED.
10:46:52PM THE CHAIR PRO TEM RECOGNIZES CHAIRMAN MANISCALCO.
10:46:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I WILL VIERA THIS.
10:46:58PM I HAVE A LOT OF MOTIONS.
10:47:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: AND A LOT OF COMMENDATIONS.
10:47:04PM WE WILL BE HERE UNTIL MIDNIGHT.
10:47:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SCHEDULE OF A PUBLIC HEARING FOR THE
10:47:11PM NOTICE ON OCTOBER 19, 2023 AT 1:30 P.M. IN CITY COUNCIL
10:47:17PM CHAMBERS 315 E. KENNEDY BOULEVARD IN CITY OF TAMPA,
10:47:22PM FLORIDA, TO REQUEST A NOTICE OF INTENT TO US SPEND THE SALE
10:47:28PM OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES PURSUANT TO LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE
10:47:35PM 27-318.
10:47:37PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IS THERE AN ADDRESS?
10:47:40PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: TURN THE PAGE, MR. CHAIRMAN, A FURTHER
10:47:45PM REQUEST AND THE ADDRESS.
10:47:46PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE ADDRESS FOR THIS HEARING FOR, FOR.
10:47:56PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: REQUEST FURTHER AS PART OF THE MOTION TO
10:47:59PM DIRECT THE OPTION OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK.
10:48:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SORRY, I AM NEW.
10:48:04PM TO NOTIFY THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY AND HOLDER OF THE
10:48:08PM ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE LICENSE FOR THE PROPERTY IN THE NOTICE
10:48:11PM ATTACHED TO BY CERTIFIED MAIL NOT LESS THAN 30 DAYS FROM
10:48:15PM OCTOBER 19, 2023.
10:48:17PM AGAIN IT IS YBOR FOOD MART, INC., TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33605.
10:48:24PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: A MOTION FROM CHAIRMAN MANISCALCO.
10:48:26PM SECOND BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:48:28PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE, SAY AYE.
10:48:29PM OPPOSED.
10:48:31PM THE AYES HAVE IT.
10:48:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:48:34PM MY NEXT MOTION, MAKE A MOTION TO GIVE THE GOVERNOR OF PUERTO
10:48:38PM RICO, PEDRO PERA LEWIS A COMMENDATION OFF-SITE.
10:48:48PM THE GOVERNOR'S FIRST VISIT.
10:48:52PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: A MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
10:48:53PM SECOND BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:48:56PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:48:57PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: AS LONG AS YOU PRONOUNCE THE NAME.
10:49:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I AM A STICKLER BECAUSE MY NAME HAS BEEN
10:49:06PM --
10:49:07PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: EVERYBODY PRONOUNCES MY NAME CORRECTLY.
10:49:11PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: CLENDENIN, I FINALLY GOT IT.
10:49:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION FOR BIG
10:49:18PM BROTHERS AND BIG SISTERS OF TAMPA BAY TO MAKE A PRESENTATION
10:49:22PM NEXT WEEK FOR THE WORK THEY DO IN THE COMMUNITY AND THE
10:49:24PM REASON FOR SUCH SHORT NOTICE IS SEPTEMBER IS BIG BROTHERS
10:49:30PM AND BIG SISTERS.
10:49:34PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: A MOTION BY CHAIRMAN MANISCALCO.
10:49:36PM SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:49:38PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:49:39PM OPPOSED.
10:49:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION FOR THE
10:49:43PM COMMENDATION FOR THE SONS OF ITALY, SONS OF ITALY LODGE TO
10:49:49PM COMMEMORATE THEIR 100-YEAR ANNIVERSARY.
10:49:52PM AND I BELIEVE COUNCILMEMBERS, YOU GOT THE INVITATION AND
10:49:56PM PERSONALLY PUT THEM IN THE MAILBOX.
10:49:58PM I BOUGHT MY TICKET.
10:50:01PM YOU ARE WELCOME TO GO.
10:50:03PM VERY TAMPA.
10:50:06PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IS THIS THE MASQUERADE THING.
10:50:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE CAN GO LIKE THIS.
10:50:10PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: A MOTION BY COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
10:50:13PM SECONDED BY MIRANDA.
10:50:15PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:50:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: LAST THING "JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR" AND
10:50:26PM THE PERSON WHO PLAYED IT WILL BE THERE TOO.
10:50:28PM ALWAYS A FUN TIME.
10:50:30PM >> TELL WHO HE USED TO DATE.
10:50:34PM >> WHO DID HE DATE?
10:50:36PM >> DALI'S WIFE.
10:50:39PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: IS THAT A MOTION OR A STATEMENT?
10:50:44PM >>BILL CARLSON: PROVIDE THE CLERK.
10:50:46PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WOULD YOU LIKE THE GAVEL BACK TO GAVEL US
10:50:50PM HOME.
10:50:50PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: NONE.
10:50:52PM >>LUIS VIERA: JUST -- I MOTION FOR A COMMENDATION TO BE
10:51:01PM GIVEN TO OUR FRIENDS RANDY AND HANS AT A GALA TO BE
10:51:10PM PRESENTED OFFSITE.
10:51:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA AND A
10:51:13PM SECOND BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:51:15PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:51:15PM A LETTER IN SUPPORT OF FUND RAISING FOR AN ALL ABILITIES
10:51:22PM PARK.
10:51:23PM WANTS THE DISABILITY CAUCUS TO HELP WITH THAT.
10:51:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:51:27PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN.
10:51:36PM >>LUIS VIERA: TOY BINS ARE ALL AROUND HERE AND GIVE WHAT YOU
10:51:40PM CAN.
10:51:40PM THANK YOU.
10:51:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: VERY GOOD.
10:51:43PM YES, MA'AM?
10:51:44PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I HAVE NOTHING.
10:51:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHY HE IS?
10:51:48PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: UP WOULD LIKE EVERYBODY CAN COMMENDATIONS
10:51:51PM TO DO THEM OFFSITE.
10:51:54PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I SAID THIS LAST NIGHT -- GOSH, IT WAS LAST
10:52:00PM NIGHT THAT I -- THAT I AM ASKING THAT THE MONTHLY FUND
10:52:04PM BALANCE REPORT BE SHARED WITH US EVERY MONTH FOR THE -- FOR
10:52:07PM EVERY FISCAL YEAR.
10:52:09PM SO I REQUESTED THE REVENUE AND FINANCE PROVIDE CITY COUNCIL
10:52:12PM WITH CITY COUNCIL FUND BALANCE REPORT THEY RUN MONTHLY
10:52:18PM STARTING AT THE BEGINNING OF FISCAL '24 WHICH IS OCTOBER 1,
10:52:22PM 2023.
10:52:23PM A MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
10:52:25PM SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:52:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:52:31PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: PRINTED OR DIGITAL.
10:52:34PM >>LYNN HURTAK: DIGITAL IS FINE WITH MINE.
10:52:36PM NOT ONLY GET DIGITAL -- BUT I WANT TO GET CLASSES TO LEARN
10:52:41PM HOW TO READ IT.
10:52:42PM GLASSES I HAVE ALREADY UNFORTUNATELY.
10:52:46PM BUT I -- I ALSO MOVE TO HAVE THE ADMINISTRATION IDENTIFY
10:52:49PM EACH DEPARTMENT SEPARATELY AND ANY BUDGET RESOLUTION TO
10:52:53PM APPROVE THE TRANSFER, REALLOCATION OR REAPPROPRIATION OF
10:52:57PM FUNDS.
10:52:57PM RIGHT NOW WE HAVE AN ISSUE WHERE SOMETIMES WE CO-MINGLE
10:53:01PM FUNDS TO TRANSFER.
10:53:02PM I WANT EACH THING INDIVIDUALLY SO WE CAN ALL FOLLOW THE
10:53:06PM BUDGET A LITTLE MORE CLOSELY.
10:53:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
10:53:10PM SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:53:11PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:53:12PM OPPOSED.
10:53:13PM >>LYNN HURTAK: MAKE A MOTION FOR STAFF BRING IDEAS FOR
10:53:17PM GARAGE SIZE STANDARDS SPECIFICALLY MAKING SURE THAT CARS
10:53:21PM HAVE SPACE TO OPEN THE DOORS WHEN THEY ARE INSIDE THE
10:53:25PM GARAGE, JANUARY 11, 2024.
10:53:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
10:53:29PM AND A SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
10:53:31PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:53:32PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OBVIOUSLY IF THEY NEED MORE TIME.
10:53:36PM AND THE BIG ONE, DUE TO THE LENGTH OF CITY COUNCIL AND CRA,
10:53:41PM I MOVE TO HAVE STAFF REPORT ON THE POSSIBILITY OF
10:53:44PM RESCHEDULING CRA BOARD AND WORKSHOP MEETINGS TO TUESDAY AND
10:53:49PM WEDNESDAY MORNINGS TO AVOID DAYS WITH MORNING AND EVENING
10:53:53PM MEETINGS ON THE SAME DAY.
10:53:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SORRY, I LOVE BEING OVERWORKED.
10:53:59PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I HAVE A JOB.
10:54:00PM I CAN'T DO THAT.
10:54:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I HAVE A HARD TIME DOING THAT.
10:54:03PM >>LYNN HURTAK: BUT THIS IS OUR JOB.
10:54:06PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I HAVE TWO JOBS.
10:54:08PM THIS IS A PART-TIME JOB.
10:54:11PM >>LUIS VIERA: JUST FOR CLARIFICATION, MA'AM --
10:54:16PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I WANT STAFF TO COME AND TALK OF THE
10:54:19PM VIABILITY OF IT.
10:54:21PM >>LUIS VIERA: YOU ARE TRYING TO GET THE VIABILITY, DAYS WE
10:54:24PM HAVE WORKSHOP AND CRA, HAVE THE WORKSHOP AND CRA ON A
10:54:28PM SEPARATE DAY THAN THE EVENING MEETINGS.
10:54:30PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
10:54:32PM >>LUIS VIERA: I AM OKAY TALKING ABOUT IT.
10:54:34PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: IN THE MORNINGS.
10:54:36PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: IF I UNDERSTAND -- EXCUSE ME MARTIN SHELBY,
10:54:40PM CITY COUNCIL ATTORNEY.
10:54:41PM IF I UNDERSTAND THE NATURE OF THE MOTION YOU DON'T WANT TO
10:54:44PM HAVE TWI-NIGHT DOUBLE HEADERS.
10:54:47PM >> WE LITERALLY HAVE THEM EVERY OTHER WEEK AND NO OPTION AND
10:54:51PM WE ARE NOT SERVING THE PUBLIC WELL BY THE END OF THE EVENING
10:54:55PM -- I AM NOT SERVING THE PUBLIC WELL.
10:54:59PM RIDICULOUS.
10:55:00PM I HAVE NO ABILITY TO DO ANYTHING THE NEXT DAY.
10:55:02PM I AM -- I AM -- WE HAVE -- DOING 14-HOUR DAY IS NOT
10:55:07PM SUSTAINABLE.
10:55:07PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I AGREE.
10:55:09PM IF WE DID LIKE AN AFTERNOON MEETING AT 1.
10:55:13PM WOULD THAT ACCOMMODATE --
10:55:16PM >> WORSE FOR ME.
10:55:17PM >>LUIS VIERA: IF I MAY.
10:55:18PM I DON'T MIND TALKING ABOUT IT, BUT IF ONE COUNCILMEMBER
10:55:22PM PRECLUDES THEIR PRIVATE SECTOR -- OR PUBLIC SECTOR TEACHERS
10:55:27PM I WOULDN'T SUPPORT IT, BUT I HAVE NO PROBLEM TALKING ABOUT
10:55:31PM IT.
10:55:31PM >>LYNN HURTAK: BEGS THE QUESTION, I MEAN, THIS CITY OF
10:55:36PM 400,000 PEOPLE WITH A $2 BILLION BUDGET.
10:55:39PM WE NEED TO -- WE NEED TO HAVE A SALARY SO THIS SHOULD BE A
10:55:43PM FULL-TIME JOB.
10:55:44PM AND WE SHOULD PAY IT AS SUCH.
10:55:47PM BECAUSE -- I MEAN, DOING 14-HOUR DAYS IS SIMPLY NOT
10:55:53PM SUSTAINABLE.
10:55:53PM >>BILL CARLSON: I THINK MOST OF US SCHEDULE MEETINGS WITH
10:55:58PM CONSTITUENTS ON THE OTHER DAYS ANYWAY.
10:56:02PM AS COUNCILMAN VIERA SAYS, I AM WILLING TO SUPPORT IT FOR
10:56:08PM DISCUSSION.
10:56:08PM BUT IT IS -- BUT IT -- WE WORK FULL TIME -- EVEN WHEN WE ARE
10:56:14PM NOT HERE, WE ARE WORKING ALL THE TIME.
10:56:17PM SO THE SCHEDULING OF THIS IS A FINITE THING.
10:56:21PM REST OF IT WE CAN MOVE TO ACCOMMODATE IT.
10:56:25PM I PROBABLY WILL NOT SUPPORT IT EVENTUALLY BUT WILL SUPPORT
10:56:29PM IT --
10:56:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ONE LAST COMMENT.
10:56:33PM NOT JUST US BUT A SUPPORT STAFF.
10:56:36PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WHY I AM ASKING STAFF.
10:56:37PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SUPPORT STAFF, LONG DAYS IS OVERLY
10:56:42PM BURDENSOME -- WE ARE ALL ELECTED TO THESE POSITIONS, THESE
10:56:46PM FOLKS ARE THEIR JOB AND ASKING THEM TO PUT IN MARATHON DAYS
10:56:50PM OR WORKING.
10:56:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: LISA LOVES IT THERE.
10:56:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE SOLE SURVIVOR.
10:56:57PM MARY IS -- SHE HAS A COT.
10:57:00PM I THINK --
10:57:02PM >>BILL CARLSON: WORSE TODAY BECAUSE WE WERE HERE LAST NIGHT.
10:57:06PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WE TALKED ABOUT IT THREE WEEKS IN A ROW THAT
10:57:09PM THIS IS NOT SUSTAINABLE.
10:57:11PM IF WE ARE LEAVING, THIS IS NOT SUSTAINABLE AND THAT IS WHY
10:57:15PM THE MOTION IS HERE.
10:57:16PM WE HAVE NOR CRA STUFF.
10:57:18PM THE WORKSHOPS ARE ALREADY FILLING UP.
10:57:22PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MAYBE WE CAN MOVE -- HAVE A DAY OF -- THAT
10:57:25PM WOULD BE AN OPTIONS FOR -- STAFF REPORTS AND THEY CAN GET
10:57:29PM WRITTEN COPIES AND COMMENDATIONS.
10:57:32PM DO THAT MAYBE TWICE A MONTH.
10:57:33PM >>BILL CARLSON: PUT IT ON THE AGENDA TO TALK ABOUT IT.
10:57:37PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: COUNCIL, I SHOULD POINT OUT AND YOU
10:57:39PM PROBABLY ARE AWARE OF THIS PRIOR TO YOUR TIME ON COUNCIL,
10:57:42PM THERE WAS A TIME THAT THEY DID HAVE A TRIAL DATE OF
10:57:47PM COMMENDATIONS ON A DIFFERENT DAY, ON A TUESDAY.
10:57:50PM >>LYNN HURTAK: PEOPLE MADE HERE ON A TUESDAY MORNING FOR
10:57:53PM THAT.
10:57:53PM >>LUIS VIERA: I WILL SECOND IT.
10:57:57PM FOR THE COMMENDATION, PEOPLE WOULD HAVE DONE COMMENDATIONS
10:58:02PM IN COUNCIL THAN I WOULDN'T OTHERWISE, I KNOW I DID.
10:58:06PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: NO, SHOCKING.
10:58:08PM THERE IS GAMBLING GOING ON IN THAT ESTABLISHMENT?
10:58:11PM >>BILL CARLSON: FOUR HOURS OF COMMENDATIONS THAT WE CAN DO.
10:58:15PM >>LUIS VIERA: EXACTLY.
10:58:16PM I WILL SECOND THAT FOR DISCUSSION.
10:58:18PM >>BILL CARLSON: CALL THE VOTE.
10:58:20PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I'M PREPARED FOR THIS TO BE MY LONG DAY.
10:58:22PM I WORKED THREE JOBS BEFORE AS A SINGLE MOM AND I HAD 14,
10:58:26PM 16-HOUR DAYS AS AN EDUCATOR.
10:58:28PM IF THIS IS WHAT WE SIGNED UP FOR, THIS IS WHAT I KNEW IT
10:58:32PM WOULD BE.
10:58:32PM I AM OKAY WITH IT.
10:58:34PM YOU KNOW, I REALLY AM OKAY WITH IT.
10:58:37PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THIS IS UNUSUAL.
10:58:39PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: DON'T INTERRUPT ME WHEN I AM TALKING.
10:58:42PM I WANT TO GO ON RECORD SAYING THAT.
10:58:44PM I ACTUALLY HAVE A FULL-TIME JOB.
10:58:46PM THIS WAS ADVERTISED AS A PART-TIME JOB, AND THE SALARY
10:58:50PM INDICATES THAT IT IS A PART-TIME JOB, ALTHOUGH IT IS
10:58:54PM FULL-TIME IN MANY REGARDS WITH THE HOURS WE PUT IN.
10:58:57PM I WANT TO BE ABLE TO ATTEND EVERYBODY.
10:58:59PM AND JUST BASED ON WHAT THE PUBLIC IS USED TO, THEY KNOW WE
10:59:03PM MEET ON THURSDAYS, MORNING AND AFTERNOON.
10:59:05PM AND I JUST WOULD LIKE KEEP IT THAT WAY SO I WILL NOT HAVE TO
10:59:10PM REPORT TO THE SUPERINTENDENT TO ASK HIM FOR SOMETHING THAT
10:59:12PM NO ONE ELSE HAS EVER BEEN GRANTED BEFORE.
10:59:15PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I RESPECT THAT, BUT THIS IS NOT A PART-TIME
10:59:19PM JOB.
10:59:19PM NOWHERE IN THE CHARTER DOES IT SAYS IT A PART-TIME JOB.
10:59:23PM IF YOU COULD HE IS TO MAKE IT A PART-TIME JOB, THAT IS UP
10:59:27PM TO YOU AS INDIVIDUALS.
10:59:28PM BUT WE ARE CHARGED TO THE CITY AND PEOPLE'S BUSINESS.
10:59:33PM IF I HAVE TO BE HERE EVERY DAY FOR EIGHT HOURS, I WILL DO
10:59:37PM THAT.
10:59:38PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SOME PLACE WRITTEN WHERE IT INDICATES
10:59:41PM THAT IT WAS FULL TIME.
10:59:43PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IT IS NOT INDICATED A FULL-TIME OR PART-TIME
10:59:47PM JOB.
10:59:48PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: DOESN'T SAY EITHER WAY.
10:59:50PM THAT IS A FAIR STATEMENT.
10:59:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
10:59:54PM I HAVE TO GO TO BED. SIR.
10:59:56PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: FORGIVE ME FOR JUST SAYING THIS.
11:00:00PM BUT I THINK IT IS IMPORTANT TO BE SAID.
11:00:01PM IRRESPECTIVE HOW LONG YOU WANT TO COMMIT TO DO THIS JOB, HOW
11:00:06PM MANY HOURS OF DAY YOU DO IT, YOU HAVE TO PROVIDE THE SAME
11:00:10PM COMPETENCY AT 12:00 MIDNIGHT THAT YOU DO AT 8:00 IN THE
11:00:15PM MORNING.
11:00:15PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I THINK WE ARE DOING A DISSERVICE TO THE
11:00:20PM PEOPLE.
11:00:21PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: IF THAT IS THE DETERMINATION, I WANT TO
11:00:24PM RAISE THAT AS A POINT OF CONCERN.
11:00:27PM I BELIEVE THAT THE END OF THE NIGHT -- THE PETITION AT THE
11:00:30PM END OF THE NIGHT SHOULD NOT BE TREATED DIFFERENTLY THAN A
11:00:33PM PETITION EARLIER THIS THE EVENING.
11:00:35PM >>BILL CARLSON: THE ONLY OPTION IS THE NUMBER.
11:00:37PM LET'S TALK --
11:00:38PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I AM BRINGING THIS NOVEMBER 2, 2023.
11:00:43PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: OR INDICATE THEY ARE DONE AT 9:00.
11:00:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION AND A SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN
11:00:50PM VIERA.
11:00:50PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
11:00:51PM OPPOSED.
11:00:53PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: NAY -- FOR --
11:00:57PM >>BILL CARLSON: MR. CHAIR, I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO
11:01:00PM RECEIVE AND FILE AN ETHICS FORM FROM MY PREVIOUS MEETING.
11:01:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
11:01:05PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
11:01:07PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
11:01:08PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?
11:01:10PM DISCUSSION?
11:01:14PM >> A CONFLICT.
11:01:15PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I SEE.
11:01:17PM OKAY.
11:01:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYTHING ELSE, SIR.
11:01:22PM A MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE.
11:01:23PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SO MOVED.
11:01:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
11:01:30PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
11:01:31PM AYE.
11:01:32PM WE ARE ADJOURNED.
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.