TAMPA CITY COUNCIL
THURSDAY, APRIL 11, 2024, 5:01 P.M.
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.
5:04:02PM [ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
5:04:05PM >> THE BROADCAST IS NOW STARTING.
5:04:06PM ALL ATTENDEES ARE IN LISTEN-ONLY MODE.
5:04:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GOOD AFTERNOON, EVERYONE.
5:04:10PM WELCOME TO THE TAMPA CITY COUNCIL EVENING MEETING.
5:04:12PM AT THIS TIME, MAY WE HAVE ROLL CALL, PLEASE?
5:04:15PM >>BILL CARLSON: HERE.
5:04:16PM >>LYNN HURTAK: HERE.
5:04:18PM >> CLENDENIN?
5:04:18PM HENDERSON?
5:04:20PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: PRESENT.
5:04:21PM >> VIERA?
5:04:22PM MIRANDA?
5:04:23PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HERE.
5:04:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
5:04:25PM >>THE CLERK: WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
5:04:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:04:27PM YES, SIR.
5:04:28PM LET'S DO SOME HOUSEKEEPING.
5:04:31PM >> [INAUDIBLE] THE FIRST IS A REQUEST FROM AN APPLICANT FOR
5:04:36PM ITEM 3 TO BE HEARD BEFORE ITEM 2, IF THAT IS THE PLEASURE OF
5:04:39PM COUNCIL TO GRANT THAT REQUEST.
5:04:41PM >> SO MOVED.
5:04:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
5:04:43PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:04:44PM AYE.
5:04:45PM YOU SAID 3 BEFORE 2.
5:04:47PM >> YES, SIR.
5:04:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: AND THEN?
5:04:49PM >> NEXT WE HAVE AGENDA ITEM 10, THE APPLICANT'S
5:04:53PM REPRESENTATIVE REQUESTED THIS ITEM TO BE WITHDRAWN.
5:04:56PM PLEASE REMOVE IT FROM THE AGENDA.
5:04:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO WITHDRAW ITEM NUMBER 10,
5:05:01PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
5:05:03PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:05:03PM AYE.
5:05:04PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:05:05PM YES, SIR.
5:05:06PM WHAT'S NEXT.
5:05:07PM >> LASTLY IS ITEM 13.
5:05:08PM IT IS A MISNOTICE AND CANNOT BE HEARD.
5:05:10PM PLEASE REMOVE IT FROM THE AGENDA.
5:05:12PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:05:13PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
5:05:15PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:05:15PM AYE.
5:05:16PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:05:16PM ANYTHING ELSE, SIR?
5:05:18PM >> NO, SIR.
5:05:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE'LL HAVE ITEM NUMBER 1 WITH COUNCIL
5:05:21PM MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:05:33PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HONORABLE CHAIRMAN AND HONORABLE MEMBERS
5:05:35PM OF TAMPA CITY COUNCIL, MY PLEASURE THIS AFTERNOON TO
5:05:40PM INTRODUCE SOME YOUNG PEOPLE AND SOME THAT ARE NOT SO YOUNG
5:05:44PM THAT ONCE A YEAR THEY DO SOMETHING THAT'S REALLY, REALLY
5:05:48PM GREAT FOR THIS COUNTRY.
5:05:50PM THE PURPOSE IS THAT WE HAVE TWO FROM THE AMERICAN LEGION
5:05:57PM HIGH SCHOOL ORATORICAL CONTEST AND TWO FROM THE AMERICAN
5:06:01PM HERITAGE GIRLS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THE CITIZENSHIP AND
5:06:05PM GOVERNMENT BADGE.
5:06:06PM BOTH OF THESE THINGS ARE FUNDAMENTALLY WHAT THIS COUNTRY IS
5:06:08PM ABOUT, HONOR AND DOING THE RIGHT THING.
5:06:10PM THE INTRODUCTION OF THE GENTLEMAN WHO HAS TAKEN OVER POST 5
5:06:17PM IS A VERY WELL-KNOWN INDIVIDUAL IN THIS AREA.
5:06:20PM NOT ONLY HERE, BUT HE IS A VETERAN OF THE UNITED STATES
5:06:24PM NAVY, RETIRED POLICE OFFICER AND CHRISTOPHER MAN-SONG-HING
5:06:31PM IS THE USF TAMPA POST 5 COMMANDER AND THE TWO HERITAGE GIRLS
5:06:40PM ARE CHARLOTTE LURIA AND ABBY KOVALSKY WHO COMPETED IN THE
5:06:45PM AMERICAN HERITAGE GIRLS CITIZENSHIP BADGE.
5:06:48PM I BELIEVE THE COMMANDER AND HIS WIFE WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A
5:06:51PM PRESENTATION.
5:06:56PM LOVELY WIFE AND THE COMMANDER.
5:07:07PM >> GOOD EVENING.
5:07:08PM THE AMERICAN HERITAGE GIRLS IS A FAITH-BASED ORGANIZATION
5:07:12PM WHOSE PURPOSE IS TO DEVELOP THESE GIRLS INTO RESPONSIBLE
5:07:17PM WOMEN.
5:07:17PM CITIZENSHIP AND GOVERNMENT BADGE IS A TEN-STATION BADGE
5:07:23PM ENCOMPASSING VARIOUS ASPECTS OF OUR GOVERNMENT.
5:07:29PM IT IS CONDUCTED ON MY POST, POST 5.
5:07:33PM INCLUDED INTERVIEWS, PUBLIC OFFICIAL.
5:07:36PM THIS YEAR IT WAS THE HONORABLE HELEN DANIEL FROM THE FLORIDA
5:07:40PM 13th JUDICIAL COURT.
5:07:41PM I WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT THESE CERTIFICATES.
5:07:49PM BEFORE THAT, I'LL HAVE MY WIFE READ THE CERTIFICATES.
5:07:53PM >> THANK YOU.
5:07:54PM GOOD EVENING, HONORABLE CITY COUNCIL, MEMBERS AND CITY
5:07:59PM STAFF.
5:07:59PM I WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT TO YOU TO MY LEFT IS ABBY KOVALSKY,
5:08:07PM CONGRATULATIONS.
5:08:07PM I WILL BE READING THE CERTIFICATE OF APPRECIATION FOR ABBY
5:08:12PM KOVALSKY AMERICAN HERITAGE GIRL TROOP FLORIDA 1231 WESTSHORE
5:08:18PM BAPTIST CHURCH, TAMPA, FLORIDA, AND CHARLOTTE LURIA,
5:08:21PM AMERICAN HERITAGE GIRL TROOP FLORIDA 0147 ST. PAUL'S
5:08:27PM CATHOLIC CHURCH, TAMPA, FLORIDA.
5:08:29PM IN RECOGNITION AND SINCERE APPRECIATION FOR YOUR OUTSTANDING
5:08:35PM ACHIEVEMENT OF COMPLETING THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE CITIZEN IN
5:08:42PM GOVERNMENT BADGE AWARDED BY THE AMERICAN HERITAGE GIRLS,
5:08:44PM YOUR EFFORTS GREATLY HEIGHTEN YOUR KNOWLEDGE OF THE
5:08:50PM FORMULATION OF PUBLIC POLICY BY LAWMAKERS, DEMONSTRATED YOUR
5:08:58PM COMMITMENT TO THE AMERICAN DEMOCRACY AND FURTHER FOSTERED
5:09:03PM YOUR DEVELOPMENT INTO BECOMING AN INFORMED CITIZEN.
5:09:05PM YOUR ACCOMPLISHMENT IS ADVANCEMENT OF THE AMERICAN LEGION
5:09:10PM YOUTH AND COMMUNITY ACTIVITY PROGRAMS DEDICATED TO GOD AND
5:09:15PM COUNTRY.
5:09:18PM THIS IS PRESENTED TO YOU TODAY BY COMMANDER CHRISTOPHER
5:09:21PM MAN-SONG-HING PRESENTED BY THE USF TAMPA POST 5, DEPARTMENT
5:09:30PM OF FLORIDA, THIS 11th DAY OF APRIL, 2024.
5:09:39PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:09:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO SAY A FEW
5:09:49PM WORDS.
5:09:51PM >> THANK YOU.
5:09:52PM [ LAUGHTER ]
5:09:56PM >> VERY GOOD.
5:09:57PM THANK YOU.
5:09:58PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:10:02PM >> WE DO NOT HAVE CHARLOTTE WITH US TODAY, BUT WE WILL BE
5:10:05PM SURE SHE GETS HER CERTIFICATE.
5:10:07PM THANK YOU.
5:10:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:10:08PM CONGRATULATIONS.
5:10:23PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: ABBY, IF I MAY CALL YOU ABBY.
5:10:27PM IT IS MY PLEASURE TO PRESENT TO ABBY KOVALSKY THE AMERICAN
5:10:31PM HERITAGE GIRLS TROOP 1231 FROM THE WESTSHORE BAPTIST CHURCH
5:10:34PM OF TAMPA, FLORIDA.
5:10:35PM IT IS WITH GREAT PLEASURE THAT THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY
5:10:37PM OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, PRESENTS TO YOU THIS COMMENDATION FOR
5:10:41PM SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETING THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE AMERICAN
5:10:43PM HERITAGE GIRLS CITIZENSHIP IN GOVERNMENT BADGE ON JANUARY
5:10:48PM 13, 2024, HOSTED BY THE AMERICAN LEGION USF POST NUMBER 5 IN
5:10:53PM TAMPA, FLORIDA.
5:10:54PM BY EARNING THIS BADGE, YOU DEMONSTRATED THE VALUE THAT YOU
5:10:56PM PLACE ON YOUR RESPONSIBILITY AS AN AMERICAN CITIZEN.
5:11:00PM YOU GAINED AN UNDERSTANDING OF THE MECHANICS OF THE NATIONAL
5:11:03PM ISSUES, INCLUDING THE NATIONAL DEBT.
5:11:07PM THAT MEANS A LOT OF MONEY.
5:11:09PM THE IMMIGRATION, THE CITIZENSHIP PROCESS, FEDERAL AND LOCAL
5:11:14PM TAXES, VOTING RIGHTS, VERY IMPORTANT, THE TOPIC OF
5:11:18PM GOVERNMENT AROUND THE WORLD, THE RIGHTS AND RESPONSIBILITIES
5:11:20PM OF CITIZENS, POLITICAL PARTIES, CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED
5:11:25PM STATES AND THE DISCUSSION OF MORAL, POLITICAL ISSUES OF THE
5:11:30PM DAY.
5:11:31PM YOU ARE CONGRATULATED BY THE TAMPA CITY COUNCIL ON ALL THE
5:11:34PM THINGS THAT VALUE AMERICA ON A DAY-TO-DAY LIFE.
5:11:37PM AND CONGRATULATIONS FOR BEING WHO YOU ARE AND HOW WELL YOU
5:11:40PM REPRESENTED YOURSELF.
5:11:41PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:11:42PM WANT TO SAY A FEW WORDS?
5:11:53PM >> THANK YOU.
5:11:53PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I LEARNED THAT.
5:11:55PM EXPERIENCE.
5:11:55PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:11:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:12:07PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: A CONGRATULATORY WORDS ON WHAT'S COMING
5:12:10PM UP IS ONE THAT IS VERY DEAR TO ALL THE HEARTS.
5:12:13PM IT'S VERY DIFFICULT TO PLACE FIRST IN ANY ORATORICAL CONTEST
5:12:19PM AND NOT ONLY THAT THIS PERSON PLACED FIRST IN THE ORATORICAL
5:12:25PM CONTEST, SHE FINISHED SECOND IN THE STATE.
5:12:27PM ALONG WITH HER, WITH ANOTHER YOUNG LADY THAT DID FANTASTIC
5:12:33PM AND THAT PERSON THAT DID THAT IS LILLIAN HUND.
5:12:41PM EMILY PEAKE I THINK IS THE ONE I SPOKE ABOUT EARLIER.
5:12:44PM I BELIEVE THAT NOW WE HAVE GLENN JUMAN.
5:12:52PM COME RIGHT UP.
5:12:56PM >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:12:57PM GOOD AFTERNOON, COUNCIL.
5:13:00PM MY NAME IS GLENN JUMAN, THE DISTRICT 15 ORATORICAL CHAIRMAN.
5:13:06PM JUST REALLY QUICK TELL YOU A LITTLE BIT ABOUT IT.
5:13:09PM SOME KNOW, SOME DON'T.
5:13:10PM IT ENCOMPASSES HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY, A PORTION OF PASCO AND
5:13:15PM HERNANDO COUNTY.
5:13:16PM SO WE'RE ALL OVER THE PLACE.
5:13:18PM I'M ALL OVER THE PLACE TRYING TO WORK WITH THE PEOPLE AND
5:13:22PM BRING THIS PROGRAM TOGETHER.
5:13:24PM THE ORATORICAL IS A SCHOLARSHIP OPPORTUNITY FOR HIGH SCHOOL
5:13:28PM STUDENTS.
5:13:29PM SINCE 1938, ALMOST 80 YEARS THIS HAS BEEN GOING ON.
5:13:34PM PROVIDED HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS WITH THE LEADERSHIP,
5:13:36PM COMMUNICATION, PUBLIC PRESENTATION, AND SPEAKING SKILLS
5:13:39PM DEVELOPMENTS BESIDES HAVING SOMETHING GREAT ON THEIR RESUM
5:13:43PM FOR THE FUTURE PLUS MAKING MONEY AT IT.
5:13:46PM WHILE DEVELOPING, WHILE THEY ARE DOING THIS THEY ARE
5:13:49PM DEVELOPING A DEEPER KNOWLEDGE AND APPRECIATION FOR THE U.S.
5:13:52PM CONSTITUTION AMONG HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS.
5:13:56PM YOUNG ORATORS EARN SOME OF THE MOST GENEROUS SCHOLARSHIP
5:14:01PM MONEY FOR COLLEGE, AVAILABLE TO HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS.
5:14:05PM APPROXIMATELY $203,000.
5:14:09PM NATIONAL LEVEL, IT'S 25,000.
5:14:12PM SECOND PLACE IS 20,000.
5:14:15PM THIRD PLACE 20,000.
5:14:17PM SO IT'S SERIOUS MONEY FOR PEOPLE WHO WANT TO ACHIEVE AND
5:14:21PM PEOPLE WHO WANT TO REALLY WORK HARD AT DEVELOPING THEIR
5:14:25PM LEADERSHIP IN ALL THESE SKILLS.
5:14:26PM THE PROGRAM FEATURED NUMEROUS POLITICIANS, BY THE WAY, SO
5:14:30PM IT'S NOT JUST A SMALL PROGRAM.
5:14:32PM IT'S NATIONAL LEVEL.
5:14:34PM THE CONTESTANTS OVER THE YEARS HAVE BEEN FORMER PRESIDENTIAL
5:14:38PM CANDIDATE ALAN KEYS, NATIONAL TELEVISION COMMENTATOR LOU
5:14:43PM DOBBS.
5:14:43PM YOU ALL KNOW HIM AND, OF COURSE, FORMER VICE PRESIDENT MIKE
5:14:49PM PENCE.
5:14:51PM HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS UNDER THE AGE OF 20 ARE ELIGIBLE AND
5:14:56PM COMPETITION, IT'S A FIVE-TIER PROCESS.
5:14:59PM YOU START AT THE POST LEVEL.
5:15:02PM THAT'S WHAT THE COMMANDER WAS TALKING ABOUT, AND THEN YOU
5:15:04PM START AT THE DISTRICT LEVEL, THAT'S ME.
5:15:06PM AND YOU START AT THE AREA LEVEL AND NATIONAL LEVEL.
5:15:09PM AND THESE YOUNG LADIES HAVE MADE IT MOVING UP THE LADDER
5:15:15PM WITH THAT.
5:15:15PM THE ONLY ONE POST THAT PARTICIPATE, ONE WINNER, THEY MOVE UP
5:15:19PM AND THEY COMPETE, AND THE CONTESTANTS DELIVER A PREPARED
5:15:24PM SPEECH EIGHT TO TEN MINUTES ON THE CONSTITUTION ON A TOPIC
5:15:27PM OF THEIR OWN CHOOSING WITHOUT NOTES OR AMPLIFICATION.
5:15:34PM THEY HAVE TO MEMORIZE IT AND THEY ARE COMPETING AGAINST
5:15:36PM PEERS NATIONWIDE, IN FLORIDA STATEWIDE AND DOWN TO YOUR
5:15:40PM DISTRICTS, ALL YOUR DISTRICTS ARE REPRESENTED HERE.
5:15:43PM AT THE POST 5, WHICH IS THE COMMANDER'S POST, THE CONTESTANT
5:15:52PM WINNER WAS EMILY PEAKE, YOUNG LADY HERE.
5:15:57PM WHO RECEIVED A PIN, CERTIFICATE, GOLD MEDAL, $400.
5:16:01PM IT WAS DONATED BY THE LAW FIRM OF WINTERS AND YONKERS.
5:16:05PM EMILY WENT ON TO SECOND PLACE AT THE DEPARTMENT OF FLORIDA
5:16:08PM CONTEST HELD IN ORLANDO ON MARCH 30th.
5:16:12PM SO MOVING ALONG, THE SECOND PLACE WINNER WAS LILLIAN HUND,
5:16:19PM WHO ALSO RECEIVED A PIN, CERTIFICATE, SILVER MEDAL FOR $200
5:16:23PM DONATED BY RON BUSH FROM THE LAW FIRM OF BUSH, GRAZIANO,
5:16:28PM RICE AND HEARING.
5:16:30PM LILLIAN, THERE YOU GO.
5:16:33PM THESE ARE SUPERSTARS.
5:16:35PM AGAIN, I WOULD LIKE TO SAY THIS IS A FANTASTIC PROGRAM, LAST
5:16:44PM BUT NOT LEAST.
5:16:45PM THIS IS A FANTASTIC PROGRAM, AND IT'S SOMETHING WE ALL
5:16:51PM SHOULD PUSH FOR TO GET OUR STUDENTS GREAT DEVELOPING
5:16:56PM LEADERSHIP AND LET'S GET INVOLVED.
5:16:57PM THE COUNCIL WILL GIVE THE AWARDS.
5:17:04PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I WOULD BE REMISS IF I DIDN'T SAY OUR
5:17:10PM GOOD FRIEND, THE COLONEL, THAT'S WHAT HE IS, DEDICATED
5:17:15PM INDIVIDUAL, U.S. ARMY OFFICER VETERAN OF COMBAT SERVICES IN
5:17:21PM AFGHANISTAN, IRAQ, BOSNIA, ASSIGNED TO CENTCOM, REGIONS OF
5:17:30PM THE MILITARY OFFICE AND RUSSIAN FOREIGN AREA OFFICER.
5:17:34PM GLENN JUMAN IS THE 15th DISTRICT ORACLE CHAIRMAN AND THE
5:17:40PM SECOND ORATORICAL CHAIRMAN THAT HE DOES WHAT IS NECESSARY TO
5:17:44PM DO TO BRING THIS AREA HERE OF HILLSBOROUGH, PASCO, AND
5:17:48PM HERNANDO COUNTY UP TO THE STANDARDS.
5:17:51PM AND HE'S DONE AN EXCELLENT JOB.
5:17:53PM I HAVE THE COMMANDER WITH ME, AND THEY ARE GOING TO HELP US
5:17:58PM MAKE THE PRESENTATION TO THE SECOND-PLACE WINNER.
5:18:01PM THERE ARE NO LOSERS.
5:18:02PM LILLIAN HUND.
5:18:05PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:18:16PM >> I WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE AMERICAN LEGION FOR GIVING ME
5:18:19PM THIS OPPORTUNITY AND MY COACH, MS. COLLINS, FOR HER
5:18:23PM COMMITMENT TO OUR TEAM.
5:18:25PM THANK YOU.
5:18:27PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:18:31PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THE WINNER OF THE AREA FIRST PLACE WINNER
5:18:34PM AND SECOND IN THE STATE OF FLORIDA IS EMILY PEAKE.
5:18:36PM EMILY.
5:18:37PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:18:38PM SAY A FEW WORDS.
5:18:47PM >> HI.
5:18:47PM GOOD AFTERNOON.
5:18:48PM I WOULD LIKE TO SAY THANK YOU, FIRST, TO THE AMERICAN LEGION
5:18:51PM FOR PROVIDING THE OPPORTUNITY IN THIS PROGRAM AS I KNOW
5:18:55PM PERSONALLY IT SERVED ME VERY, VERY WELL.
5:18:56PM I'VE LEARNED SO MUCH.
5:18:58PM THANK YOU TO POST 5 AND DISTRICT 15 FOR SPONSORING.
5:19:01PM LASTLY, THANK YOU TO CITY COUNCIL FOR THIS RECOGNITION AND
5:19:05PM HONOR.
5:19:06PM I AM VERY TOUCHED AND HONORED.
5:19:07PM THANK YOU SO MUCH.
5:19:08PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:19:13PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: IN CLOSING, LET ME SAY THIS, I CAN'T
5:19:16PM SPEAK FOR YOU OTHER SIX COUNCIL MEMBERS, BUT THIS COUNCIL
5:19:19PM MEMBER COULDN'T HOLD A CANDLE TO THESE TWO YOUNG LADIES.
5:19:22PM THEY REALLY ARE SHARP.
5:19:23PM THEY ARE REALLY INTELLIGENT, AND THEY GOT A FANTASTIC
5:19:26PM OUTLOOK FOR THE FUTURE.
5:19:29PM THANK YOU FOR DOING WHAT YOU ALL DO.
5:19:31PM ALL OF YOU.
5:19:32PM IT IS A PLEASURE TO HAVE YOU HERE.
5:19:34PM I'M SURE YOU'LL DO MUCH BETTER THAN A LOT OF PEOPLE THINK
5:19:37PM BECAUSE I KNOW YOU GUYS, THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A WINNER AND
5:19:41PM A LOSER, A WINNER DOESN'T LIKE TO LOSE.
5:19:45PM TAKE CARE OF YOURSELF.
5:19:46PM GOD BLESS YOU.
5:19:48PM [ APPLAUSE ]
5:19:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:19:59PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND CONGRATULATIONS AGAIN.
5:20:00PM AT THIS TIME, I WOULD LIKE TO ASK FOR A MOTION TO OPEN ALL
5:20:14PM THE PUBLIC HEARINGS.
5:20:14PM WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:20:16PM DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
5:20:17PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
5:20:19PM ALL IN FAVOR, AYE.
5:20:21PM IF ANYBODY WOULD BE SPEAKING ON ANY OF THE ITEMS TONIGHT
5:20:26PM BECAUSE WE'RE STARTING WITH NUMBER 3 FIRST, PLEASE STAND AND
5:20:28PM RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND.
5:20:30PM SPEAKING TONIGHT, RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND, STAND AND WE WILL
5:20:33PM SWEAR YOU IN.
5:20:37PM >>THE CLERK: DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT THE TESTIMONY YOU
5:20:39PM ARE ABOUT TO GIVE IS THE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH?
5:20:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:20:45PM YES, SIR, GO AHEAD WITH ITEM NUMBER 3.
5:20:52PM >>SAMUEL THOMAS: SAM THOMAS, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:20:55PM AGENDA ITEM 3, IS REZ-23-88, A REQUEST TO REZONE 203 SOUTH
5:21:00PM MOODY AVENUE FROM RESIDENTIAL OFFICE 1 TO PLANNED
5:21:00PM DEVELOPMENT FOR RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY TOWNHOMES.
5:21:03PM THIS ITEM WAS CONTINUED FROM THE JANUARY 18th PUBLIC
5:21:06PM HEARING.
5:21:07PM SOME SLIGHT MODIFICATIONS HAVE BEEN MADE TO THE SITE PLAN BY
5:21:10PM ADDING SOME ADDITIONAL GREEN AREA.
5:21:12PM HOWEVER, THOSE AREAS DO NOT ADD OR COUNT TOWARDS GREENSPACE.
5:21:16PM NATURAL RESOURCES STILL DOES HAVE SOME CONCERNS WITH THE
5:21:20PM SITE PLAN AND THOSE WILL BE ADDRESSED LATER ON IN THE
5:21:23PM PRESENTATION.
5:21:23PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO DANNY WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
5:21:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:21:26PM YES, SIR.
5:21:36PM >>DANNY COLLINS: GOOD EVENING.
5:21:37PM DANNY COLLINS WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
5:21:39PM I WAS SWORN IN.
5:21:40PM OUR FIRST CASE IS IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT
5:21:43PM SPECIFICALLY IN THE SOUTH HOWARD NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:21:46PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN EVACUATION ZONE C.
5:21:49PM HERE IS AN AERIAL MAP OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND THE
5:21:52PM SURROUNDING PROPERTIES.
5:21:53PM YOU'LL SEE THE SUBJECT SITE OUTLINED IN THIS PURPLE COLOR IS
5:21:57PM SOUTH OF THE WEST CLEVELAND AND MOODY -- SOUTH MOODY AVENUE
5:22:02PM INTERSECTION.
5:22:04PM THERE ARE SOME SURROUNDING RESIDENTIAL USES TO THE SUBJECT
5:22:08PM SITE AS WELL AS SOME NONRESIDENTIAL USES ONE BLOCK EAST OF
5:22:12PM THE SITE ALONG HOWARD AVENUE.
5:22:15PM HERE IS AN AERIAL MAP OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND THE
5:22:25PM SURROUNDING PROPERTIES.
5:22:26PM YOU'LL SEE THE SUBJECT SITE, IT IS RECOGNIZED UNDER THE
5:22:28PM RESIDENTIAL 35 DESIGNATION.
5:22:30PM THAT CATEGORY IS TO THE NORTH, EAST, AND SOUTH OF THE SITE.
5:22:34PM DIRECTLY TO THE WEST IS THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35, WHICH IS
5:22:38PM A MIXED USE LAND USE CATEGORY.
5:22:41PM THAT CATEGORY IS PREDOMINANTLY ALONG ARMENIA AVENUE AND
5:22:45PM SOUTH HOWARD AVENUE WHICH IS ONE BLOCK TO THE EAST OF THE
5:22:47PM SITE.
5:22:48PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REVIEWED THE SURROUNDING AREA
5:22:50PM AND FOUND THE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT
5:22:52PM PATTERN ON THIS PORTION OF SOUTH MOODY AVENUE.
5:22:55PM THE REQUEST IS CONSISTENT WITH THE DENSITY PLANNED FOR UNDER
5:22:57PM THE R-35 AND IS CONSISTENT WITH POLICIES THAT SUPPORT INFILL
5:23:00PM DEVELOPMENT ON VACANT AND UNDERUTILIZED LANDS.
5:23:03PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDS THE REQUEST WILL ALLOW FOR
5:23:06PM COMPATIBLE INFILL DEVELOPMENT IN AN AREA PLANNED FOR 35
5:23:09PM DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE.
5:23:09PM THE ENTRANCES TO UNITS ONE AND TWO ARE ORIENTED TO AND
5:23:13PM CONNECTED TO THE SIDEWALK ADJACENT TO SOUTH MOODY AVENUE.
5:23:16PM PATHWAYS FROM THE ENTRANCES TO THE REAR UNITS, THOSE ARE
5:23:19PM UNITS THREE AND FOUR CONNECT TO THE SIDEWALK ON SOUTH MOODY
5:23:22PM AVENUE MEETING THE INTENT OF LAND USE POLICY 9.2.6.
5:23:25PM THE PD PROPOSES A SIDEWALK ADJACENT TO THE SITE IN AN AREA
5:23:30PM WHERE SIDEWALKS ARE PRESENTLY LACKING CONSISTENT WITH
5:23:33PM SEVERAL MOBILITY POLICIES.
5:23:34PM FINALLY, THE REQUEST IS CONSISTENT WITH THE PLAN'S HOUSING
5:23:39PM POLICY, SPECIFICALLY THOSE POLICIES THAT SPEAK TO ENSURING
5:23:42PM HOUSING IS AVAILABLE TO MEET TAMPA'S POPULATION DEMANDS.
5:23:46PM THE REQUEST WILL PROVIDE ADDITIONAL HOUSING CHOICES WITHIN
5:23:49PM PROXIMITY TO TRANSIT ALONG WEST CLEVELAND AVENUE AS WELL AS
5:23:53PM HOWARD AVENUE AND ARMENIA CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE
5:23:56PM PLAN.
5:23:56PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
5:23:59PM PLANS FINDS THE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH THE TAMPA
5:24:03PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
5:24:04PM I'M AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
5:24:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
5:24:06PM NO.
5:24:06PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:24:07PM YES, SIR.
5:24:10PM >>SAMUEL THOMAS: SAM THOMAS, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:24:11PM WE'LL START OUT WITH AN AERIAL VIEW OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
5:24:17PM AS DANNY MENTIONED, YOU HAVE A MIXTURE OF RESIDENTIAL USES
5:24:21PM AND OFFICE USES ALONG SOUTH MOODY AVENUE.
5:24:24PM YOU CAN SEE THE SUBJECT SITE RIGHT HERE.
5:24:26PM YOU DO HAVE A FEW PLANNED DEVELOPMENTS HERE WHERE YOU HAVE
5:24:29PM AN OFFICE ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE SUBJECT SITE, FARTHER
5:24:32PM SOUTH ALONG PLATT STREET, PUBLIX AND SOUTH HOWARD CORRIDOR
5:24:36PM RIGHT HERE WITH COMMERCIAL GENERAL ZONING.
5:24:39PM MOVE TO THE NORTH ALONG KENNEDY BOULEVARD ALSO COMMERCIAL
5:24:41PM GENERAL ZONING.
5:24:42PM YOU CAN SEE LARGER MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENTS DOWN HERE TO THE
5:24:44PM SOUTH AS WELL.
5:24:45PM MOVE ON TO THE SITE PLAN.
5:24:48PM HERE IS A SITE PLAN PROVIDED BY THE APPLICANT.
5:24:53PM AS DANNY MENTIONED, YOU HAVE TWO FRONT DOORS ORIENTED TOWARD
5:24:58PM THE NORTHERN PROPERTY LINE, PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIONS PROVIDED
5:25:01PM VIA THE SIDEWALK AND THE SAME TO THE SOUTH. THE MAX
5:25:06PM BUILDING HEIGHT IS PROPOSED TO BE AT 45 FEET.
5:25:08PM NINE PARKING SPACES ARE REQUIRED.
5:25:10PM THE APPLICANT HAS AGREED TO PROVIDE 10 PARKING SPACES.
5:25:14PM APPLICANT IS ALSO PROVIDING A PVC SIX-FOOT SENSE ALONG THE
5:25:19PM NORTH AND SOUTHERN PROPERTY LINES.
5:25:21PM HERE ARE THE ELEVATIONS PROVIDED BY THE APPLICANT.
5:25:25PM THIS WOULD BE THE ELEVATION FACING THE ALLEY AND FACING
5:25:28PM SOUTH MOODY.
5:25:30PM AND THIS WOULD BE THE SIDE ELEVATIONS.
5:25:32PM YOU CAN SEE THE FRONT DOORS ALONG THE SIDE.
5:25:34PM I'LL SHOW YOU SOME PICTURES FROM THE SITE NOW.
5:25:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IF YOU COULD ZOOM OUT A LITTLE BIT.
5:25:43PM >>SAMUEL THOMAS: YES, SIR.
5:25:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANKS.
5:25:45PM >>SAMUEL THOMAS: THIS IS LOOKING WEST DIRECTLY AT THE SITE.
5:25:48PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTHWEST AWAY, SO THIS IS THE SITE HERE.
5:25:54PM YOU CAN SEE A PARKING LOT HERE THAT SERVES THE MONTESSORI
5:25:57PM SCHOOL.
5:25:57PM THIS IS MOVING FURTHER WEST OR FURTHER SOUTH AWAY FROM THE
5:26:03PM SITE.
5:26:03PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTH.
5:26:04PM YOU CAN SEE THE PARKING LOT THERE AGAIN AND SOME OF THOSE
5:26:07PM SINGLE-FAMILY SEMI DETACHED USES.
5:26:10PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTHEAST ON MOODY.
5:26:13PM SO YOU HAVE SINGLE-FAMILY, SEMI DETACHED HERE AND HERE AND
5:26:15PM THEN A MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT THERE.
5:26:17PM MORE OF THE OLDER HISTORIC DEVELOPMENT MULTIFAMILY THERE.
5:26:20PM THIS IS LOOKING EAST ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE SUBJECT
5:26:25PM SITE.
5:26:26PM THIS IS THE OFFICE BUILDING THAT WAS ORGANIZED UNDER THE
5:26:28PM PLANNED DEVELOPMENT THAT I MENTIONED EARLIER.
5:26:30PM AND THIS IS A LITTLE BIT FARTHER NORTH AT THE INTERSECTION
5:26:33PM OF CLEVELAND AND MOODY LOOKING NORTHWEST.
5:26:35PM HERE IS THE SITE PLAN AGAIN.
5:26:46PM DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION AND COMPLIANCE STAFF REVIEWED THE
5:26:53PM APPLICATION AND FIND THE REQUEST INCONSISTENT WITH THE LAND
5:26:56PM DEVELOPMENT CODE.
5:26:57PM PLEASE SEE THE FINDINGS FROM NATURAL RESOURCES RELATED TO
5:27:02PM THE WAIVERS REQUESTED FOR LANDSCAPE BUFFER REDUCTION AND
5:27:05PM GREENSPACE NOTWITHSTANDING STAFF'S FINDING OF INCONSISTENCY,
5:27:07PM IF COUNCIL APPROVED THE APPLICATION, MODIFICATIONS TO THE
5:27:10PM SITE PLAN AS SHOWN ON THE SUBMITTED REVISION SHEET MUST BE
5:27:13PM COMPLETED BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
5:27:15PM REVISIONS WILL NOT RESOLVE STAFF'S FINDING OF INCONSISTENCY.
5:27:19PM AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS.
5:27:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE INCONSISTENCY IS BECAUSE OF THE
5:27:22PM TREES ON THE SITE.
5:27:23PM >>SAMUEL THOMAS: IT'S RELATED TO BUFFERS AND GREENSPACE.
5:27:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: OKAY.
5:27:26PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:27:27PM ANY QUESTIONS?
5:27:28PM YES, SIR.
5:27:31PM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
5:27:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE SITE.
5:27:33PM WHAT I'M LOOKING AT, WHAT IS THE REQUIRED GREENSPACE, THE
5:27:37PM PERCENTAGE FOR THIS SPACE?
5:27:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM, GO AHEAD.
5:27:50PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHAT I'M LOOKING AT IS THE BUILDING IS
5:27:53PM BASICALLY BUILT LOT LINE TO LOT LINE.
5:27:56PM >> ERIN MAEHR, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:27:58PM THE SITE REQUIRES 350 SQUARE FEET PER UNIT.
5:28:01PM THERE ARE FOUR UNITS ON THE SITE.
5:28:02PM THAT'S 1400 SQUARE FEET REQUIRED.
5:28:05PM THE APPLICANT HAS PROVIDING 719 SQUARE FEET WITH THE
5:28:10PM PROPOSED IN FRONT OF YOU.
5:28:12PM I X'D OUT THE RIBBON STRIPS.
5:28:15PM VUA.
5:28:16PM DOESN'T COUNT TOWARD GREENSPACE.
5:28:19PM THEN WE HAD REQUESTED, USE-TO-USE BUFFER WAIVER FROM 15 TO
5:28:24PM 0.
5:28:24PM AND WE HAD REQUESTED THEY SWAP THE BUFFER WITH THE SIDEWALK
5:28:27PM TO PROVIDE MORE -- LESS IMPACT TO SOME OF THESE OFF-SITE
5:28:33PM TREES.
5:28:34PM THE RED Xs, EXEMPT SPECIES ON THE NEIGHBORING PROPERTY TO
5:28:38PM THE SOUTH AND THOSE TREES HAVE BEEN REMOVED BY THE NEIGHBOR.
5:28:43PM THE OTHER ISSUE WE HAD WITH THIS IS ALL OF THESE STRIPS YOU
5:28:47PM SEE IN FRONT OF YOU ARE TWO AND A HALF FEET WIDE, THREE FEET
5:28:51PM WIDE.
5:28:52PM THEY CAN'T ACCOMMODATE ANY OF THE REQUIRED TREES.
5:28:54PM THAT WAS OUR CONCERN.
5:28:57PM HOWEVER, THE APPLICANT HAS BEEN WORKING WITH US IN THE LAST
5:29:01PM COUPLE OF DAYS.
5:29:06PM OKAY.
5:29:07PM THAT'S WHY WE'RE INCONSISTENT.
5:29:09PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: GOTCHA.
5:29:10PM THANK YOU SO MUCH.
5:29:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:29:11PM YES, SIR.
5:29:12PM ANYTHING ELSE?
5:29:15PM >> LET ME JUST SAY, THE WAIVER IS DOWN.
5:29:19PM RIGHT NOW, THE WAIVER WITH THE SITE PLAN IN FRONT OF YOU WAS
5:29:21PM TO 107 SQUARE FEET PER UNIT FROM 350.
5:29:24PM SO THE TOTAL GREENSPACE WAS 719.
5:29:35PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: -- ALONG THE PERIMETER, CORRECT?
5:29:43PM >>SAMUEL THOMAS: ASKING IF IT IS THE GREEN STRIPS.
5:29:46PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE NUMBER YOU GAVE US IS JUST THE TWO
5:29:49PM FOOT STRIPS?
5:29:50PM >> AND THE ONES BETWEEN THE GARAGES.
5:29:52PM THAT'S FINE BECAUSE THEY DON'T PARK OVER THEM.
5:29:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:29:57PM ANYTHING ELSE?
5:29:57PM WE'LL GO TO THE APPLICANT.
5:30:00PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:30:05PM >> STEVE MICHELINI.
5:30:07PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
5:30:09PM THIS PETITION IS REQUESTING A TOWN HOUSE PROJECT THAT'S
5:30:15PM BASICALLY SURROUNDED BY OFFICE, MULTIFAMILY.
5:30:19PM I THINK THE STAFF WENT THROUGH AND SHOWED YOU.
5:30:23PM THESE ARE TOWN HOUSES ACROSS THE STREET.
5:30:27PM THIS IS AN OFFICE DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET.
5:30:30PM THESE ARE TOWN HOUSES TO THE SOUTH AND THEY ARE SEPARATED BY
5:30:36PM A PARKING LOT BEFORE YOU GET TO THE OTHER TOWN HOUSES.
5:30:40PM THIS IS THE OFFICE TO THE NORTH, AND THIS IS THE PARKING LOT
5:30:46PM TO THE SOUTH.
5:30:49PM THESE ARE THE OTHER TOWN HOUSES THAT ARE LOOKING SOUTH ALONG
5:30:53PM THE ALLEY THAT ACCESS THE ALLEY, AND THIS IS THE PARKING
5:30:59PM THAT'S ADJACENT TO IT.
5:31:02PM WE'VE BEEN TALKING TO THE STAFF ABOUT THE ADJACENT AND
5:31:09PM REQUIRING BUFFERS.
5:31:10PM I THINK YOU SAW THE SITE PLAN.
5:31:15PM THEY ARE REQUIRING A BUFFER BETWEEN A RESIDENTIAL UNIT AND A
5:31:17PM COMMERCIAL UNIT HERE, AND THEN ALSO BETWEEN THE BACK HERE,
5:31:23PM AND THERE'S ALSO CG ZONING AND MULTIFAMILY TO THIS SIDE.
5:31:29PM THIS HAS BEEN AN ONGOING DISCUSSION ABOUT WHY ARE WE
5:31:31PM BUFFERING RESIDENTIAL FROM COMMERCIAL AND OTHER OFFICE USES.
5:31:36PM BUT THAT IS YET TO BE RESOLVED.
5:31:39PM WE'RE IN THE MIDDLE OF THOSE DISCUSSIONS.
5:31:46PM THIS IS THE SITE, AND YOU CAN SEE THE PARKING LOT HERE, THE
5:31:52PM ALLEY HERE.
5:31:54PM THIS IS AN OFFICE.
5:31:56PM THESE ARE ALL MULTIFAMILY HERE AND ACROSS THE STREET IS
5:31:58PM OFFICE AND MULTIFAMILY.
5:32:01PM THIS IS JUST A COLOR VERSION OF WHAT I JUST SHOWED YOU.
5:32:10PM WE'VE APPROACHED NEIGHBORS REGARDING THIS PROJECT, AND WE
5:32:17PM HAVE LETTERS OF SUPPORT FROM THE SURROUNDING PROPERTY OWNERS
5:32:21PM THAT ARE MARKED IN RED.
5:32:29PM WHEN WE WENT THROUGH THIS PROJECT, WE TRIED TO MAXIMIZE THE
5:32:34PM AMOUNT OF GREENSPACE.
5:32:36PM AS ERIN POINTED OUT WE'RE AT 107 SQUARE FEET IS WHAT WE'RE
5:32:42PM ASKING THE WAIVER FOR.
5:32:43PM TYPICALLY ON SOME OF THE OTHER PROJECTS YOU'VE ALLOWED, NOT
5:32:50PM IN THIS DISTRICT, BUT IN THE HISTORIC DISTRICT, THEY WANT
5:32:52PM YOU TO USE RIBBON DRIVEWAYS, WHICH IS WHY WE SHOWED IT ON
5:32:56PM THERE IN THE HOPES THAT THEY WOULD CONSIDER THAT AS
5:32:59PM ADDITIONAL GREENSPACE.
5:33:01PM WE DIDN'T REMOVE THESE OTHER TREES THAT ARE OFF-SITE THAT
5:33:05PM ARE NOT ON OUR PROPERTY.
5:33:06PM THE ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNER DID.
5:33:09PM SO WE HAD ASKED FOR PERMISSION FROM THEM.
5:33:14PM IT WAS MENTIONED IN THE FIRST STAFF REPORT ABOUT THOSE
5:33:17PM TREES.
5:33:17PM THEY SIT KIND OF ON THE PROPERTY LINE AND WHETHER OR NOT WE
5:33:21PM COULD COUNT THEM TOWARD THE TREE REQUIREMENT.
5:33:24PM AND WE CAN'T COUNT THEM OBVIOUSLY NOW BECAUSE THEY HAVE BEEN
5:33:27PM REMOVED.
5:33:28PM THE LAND USE CLASSIFICATION IS RES 35, WHICH IS 35 UNITS TO
5:33:34PM THE ACRE, WHICH IS A HIGHER DENSITY THAN YOU NORMALLY WOULD
5:33:38PM HAVE.
5:33:39PM SOME OF THESE WOULD BE RESIDENTIAL 20, BUT THIS ONE IS RES
5:33:43PM 35.
5:33:44PM THE PARKING THAT WE'RE PROPOSING MEETS AND EXCEEDS THE CODE
5:33:51PM REQUIREMENT.
5:33:51PM THE SIDEWALK PATHWAYS ARE CONSISTENT WITH WHAT THE FIRE
5:33:55PM MARSHAL WOULD LIKE TO SEE REGARDING ACCESS FOR EMERGENCIES
5:34:00PM AND IDENTIFICATION OF THOSE PROPERTIES.
5:34:02PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION, AS YOU'VE HEARD, FOUND THAT WE WERE
5:34:08PM CONSISTENT, AND THAT WE HAVE A NUMBER OF POLICIES THAT IT'S
5:34:15PM CONSISTENT WITH, AND I JUST ASK THAT THEY BE RECEIVED AND
5:34:19PM MADE PART OF THE RECORD.
5:34:20PM BASICALLY THEY PROMOTE THE EFFICIENT AND SUSTAINABLE USE OF
5:34:26PM LAND AND INFRASTRUCTURE, PROMOTES ENCOURAGEMENT OF
5:34:29PM DEVELOPMENT WHERE APPROPRIATE IN LOCATION, CHARACTER AND
5:34:32PM COMPATIBILITY, PROMOTES MORE DESIRABLE LIVING AND WORKING
5:34:35PM ENVIRONMENTS AND CONDITIONS.
5:34:36PM PROMOTES ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES.
5:34:38PM I THINK YOU NOTED ON THERE THAT WE PROVIDED PER THE DESIGN
5:34:44PM GUIDELINES THAT STEVE BENSON PRESENTED TO YOU WITH MORE
5:34:47PM WINDOWS AND BALCONIES IN THE FRONT, SO THAT THEY ARE MORE
5:34:50PM VISIBLE AND YOU HAVE ARCHITECTURAL FENESTRATION.
5:34:55PM PROMOTE THE RETENTION AND REUSE OF EXISTING BUILDING STOCK.
5:34:59PM THIS IS PROBABLY ONE OF THE LAST LOTS LEFT THAT HAS NOT
5:35:03PM ALREADY BEEN DEVELOPED AS A TOWN HOUSE OR AS AN OFFICE.
5:35:08PM THE DESIGN AND THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENTS ARE UNIQUE AND
5:35:11PM THEREFORE NEED THE WAIVERS PROPOSED.
5:35:13PM THESE UNITS ARE ABOUT 20 FEET, 22 FEET WIDE.
5:35:17PM SO THEY ARE SMALLER IN SIZE.
5:35:20PM AND EACH UNIT IS ABOUT 2,000 SQUARE FEET.
5:35:22PM SO WE DID PROVIDE ENOUGH SPACE IN THERE FOR THE WIDTH AS WE
5:35:27PM ALSO HAD THAT DISCUSSION PREVIOUSLY ABOUT THE WIDTH BEING AT
5:35:30PM LEAST 22 FEET TO ACCOMMODATE THE CARS AND BEING ABLE TO OPEN
5:35:33PM THE CAR DOORS.
5:35:34PM SO YOU CAN SEE THE DIMENSIONS ARE 22 FEET INSIDE DIMENSION.
5:35:39PM THE WAIVER IF ALLOWED WOULD NOT SUBSTANTIALLY INTERFERE WITH
5:35:42PM THE RIGHTS OF OTHERS.
5:35:43PM AS I SAID, THIS IS PROBABLY ONE OF THE LAST LOTS THERE IS IN
5:35:46PM BETWEEN ALL OF THESE OTHER COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENTS,
5:35:50PM COMMERCIAL AND MULTIFAMILY.
5:35:51PM THE WAIVERS IN HARMONY AND SERVES THE GENERAL INTENT AND
5:35:55PM PURPOSE OF THE CHAPTER.
5:35:56PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION INDICATE THAT THEY FOUND IT TO BE
5:36:00PM CONSISTENT WITH THE CHAPTER IN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
5:36:03PM ALLOWING THE WAIVER WILL RESULT IN SUBSTANTIAL JUSTICE BEING
5:36:05PM DONE CONSIDERING THE PUBLIC BENEFITS.
5:36:07PM AS I SAID, YOU HAVE A DEMAND FOR HOUSING.
5:36:11PM THESE ARE NOT HUGE UNITS.
5:36:13PM THEY ARE SMALLER UNITS, AND THEY WILL HELP TO MEET THE
5:36:17PM DEMAND FOR HOUSING.
5:36:18PM AND IT IS SECURED BY THE CHAPTER AS THE PLANNING COMMISSION
5:36:23PM STAFF ALREADY POINTED OUT TO YOU, IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
5:36:27PM NUMBER OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN POLICIES AND OBJECTIVES.
5:36:32PM WE ARE ADJACENT, AS I SAID, WE ARE ADJACENT TO A PARKING LOT
5:36:37PM ON THE SOUTH SIDE AND YET WE'RE STILL BEING REQUIRED TO MEET
5:36:40PM A BUFFER.
5:36:41PM THE BUFFERS TECHNICALLY SHOULD BE APPLIED TO THE OTHER
5:36:46PM PROPERTIES BUFFERING THE RESIDENTIAL, NOT THE RESIDENTIAL
5:36:50PM BUFFERING FROM ANOTHER COMMERCIAL OFFICE WHICH IS ON THE
5:36:53PM NORTH SIDE OR THE PARKING LOT TO THE SOUTH.
5:36:57PM SO I THINK THAT THERE IS SOME FLEXIBILITY OR SHOULD BE SOME
5:37:01PM FLEXIBILITY IN CONSIDERATION REGARDING THAT CODE
5:37:04PM REQUIREMENT.
5:37:05PM WE DID AGREE TO FLIP THE SIDEWALKS AROUND TO INCREASE THE
5:37:09PM GREENSPACE.
5:37:12PM IF WE'RE SUCCESSFUL IN BEING APPROVED THIS EVENING, WE'LL
5:37:15PM MAKE THAT CHANGE, WHICH WILL INCREASE THE AMOUNT OF
5:37:18PM GREENSPACE.
5:37:18PM AS THE STAFF HAS POINTED OUT, IT IS IN THE CENTRAL PLANNING
5:37:25PM DISTRICT AND THE SITE IS RESIDENTIAL 35 AND IT ALLOWS MORE
5:37:29PM UNITS.
5:37:31PM YOU COULDN'T PUT -- FOUR UNITS IS APPROPRIATE SIZE AND
5:37:35PM LOCATION FOR THIS PROPERTY.
5:37:36PM IT IS CONSISTENT WITH GOALS AND OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OF
5:37:42PM THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, LAND USE OBJECTIVE 1.2.3.36,
5:37:51PM 2.1, 2.12, OBJECTIVE 8.15 FOR LAND USE DEVELOPMENT
5:37:56PM REGULATIONS GOALS AND OBJECTIVES.
5:37:58PM 8.151, WHICH IS DEVELOPMENT OF DENSITIES AND DENSITIES.
5:38:04PM COMPATIBLE WITH THAT.
5:38:05PM LAND USE POLICIES 8.15.2 WHICH IS THE CATEGORY OF UNIQUE SET
5:38:11PM OF ZONING DISTRICTS THAT MAY BE PERMITTED FOR THE LAND USE
5:38:13PM CATEGORY AND ADOPTED, WHICH THIS IS AN APPROPRIATE LOCATION
5:38:17PM FOR THIS DEVELOPMENT.
5:38:18PM EACH LAND USE CATEGORY SHALL HAVE A UNIQUE SET OF ZONING
5:38:22PM DISTRICTS AND MAY BE PERMITTED WITHIN THE LAND USE PLAN
5:38:26PM CATEGORY AS ADOPTED BY THE ZONING CODE.
5:38:28PM WE BELIEVE THAT WE HAVE MET THE INTENT OF THE CODE WITH
5:38:33PM RESPECT TO THE SIZE OF THE UNITS.
5:38:37PM WE'VE REDUCED THEM AND AGREED TO FLIP SOME OF THE SIDEWALKS
5:38:40PM AROUND TO INCREASE GREENSPACE.
5:38:42PM ENCOURAGE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED AND MULTIFAMILY
5:38:46PM DEVELOPMENTS TO BE DESIGNATED INCLUDING THE ORIENTATION.
5:38:49PM WE MET THE INTENT OF THAT CODE WITH THE SIDEWALKS.
5:38:51PM AS I SAID, THE CONNECTIONS AND IT'S TYPICAL FOR DEVELOPMENTS
5:38:57PM OF THIS TYPE TO MEET THE CODE IN THAT MANNER.
5:39:01PM INFRASTRUCTURE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES, WE MEET OBJECTIVE 11,
5:39:05PM 1118, SITE CONSIDERATIONS AND HOUSING, 1.13, 1.3.4.
5:39:13PM LOW AND MEDIUM DENSITY FAMILY AREAS 9.7, 9.71, 9.72, 9.73.
5:39:19PM HURRICANE EVACUATIONS, WE'RE NOT UNDER AN EVACUATION ZONE.
5:39:25PM SO WE PROVIDE MULTIMODAL OPTIONS.
5:39:28PM THIS IS NEAR A TRANSIT WAY.
5:39:30PM WE ARE ALSO PROVIDING ACCESS AND OPTIONS REGARDING ARMENIA
5:39:34PM AND HOWARD, WHICH IS VERY CLOSE BY.
5:39:37PM THE STAFF ANALYSIS PORTION IS BETWEEN WEST CLEVELAND AND
5:39:41PM WEST PLATT WITH A MIX OF SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED AND DETACHED
5:39:44PM DEVELOPMENT ON THE AVERAGE OF 16.33 UNITS PER ACRE.
5:39:47PM AND THIS IS BASED ON 19 SAMPLE SITES MEET THE GOAL AND
5:39:58PM OBJECTIVE, SIGNIFICANTLY LESS THAN THE 35.
5:40:02PM DESIGNATED WITH AREAS ALREADY DEVELOPED IN A SIMILAR AND
5:40:04PM LIKE MANNER.
5:40:05PM AS I'VE POINTED OUT TO YOU, THIS PROPERTY IS SURROUNDED BY
5:40:09PM MULTIFAMILY AND OFFICE USES.
5:40:12PM THE REQUEST SUPPORTS THE POLICIES OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN,
5:40:17PM RELATES TO THE HOUSING POPULATION.
5:40:18PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ENCOURAGES NEW HOUSING IN VACANT,
5:40:21PM UNDERUTILIZED PROPERTIES.
5:40:23PM THIS TAKES AN EXISTING OFFICE THAT IS CURRENTLY ZONED RO 1
5:40:28PM AND IT CONVERTS IT TO HOUSING.
5:40:29PM THE SUBJECT SITE, AS I SAID, IS NOT IN AN EVACUATION ZONE.
5:40:36PM CONCLUSION AND COMPARISON THEY FOUND THE PLANNING COMMISSION
5:40:39PM FOUND IT CONSISTENT.
5:40:41PM WE WOULD LIKE THE OPPORTUNITY TO CONTINUE WORKING WITH STAFF
5:40:43PM BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING TO TWEAK THIS PLAN AND TO
5:40:48PM COME BACK WITH RELOCATING THE SIDEWALKS AND MEETING THE
5:40:54PM CODE.
5:40:54PM THIS IS A BETTER PICTURE OF WHAT'S ACROSS THE STREET.
5:41:00PM AND I WOULD LIKE TO HAVE THE LETTERS OF SUPPORT BE RECEIVED
5:41:05PM AND FILED.
5:41:07PM AND WE HAVE A LIST OF THEM FOR YOU.
5:41:11PM I THINK THAT I'VE COVERED EVERYTHING.
5:41:26PM AS I SHOWED YOU, ON THIS MAP, THIS IS THE LOCATION OF THE
5:41:32PM LETTERS OF SUPPORT SURROUNDING THE SUBJECT PROPERTY WHICH IS
5:41:36PM BEING REQUESTED FOR THE REZONING.
5:41:40PM AGAIN, PARKING LOT HERE, OFFICE USE HERE, MULTIFAMILY HERE
5:41:45PM AND MULTIFAMILY ACROSS THE STREET AND THEN THE OTHER AREA
5:41:50PM ALL AROUND.
5:41:53PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
5:42:03PM I WOULD BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
5:42:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
5:42:06PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN YOU PUT THE AERIAL BACK UP SHOWING THE
5:42:09PM NEIGHBORHOOD?
5:42:09PM CAN YOU GO THROUGH AGAIN, PULL IT DOWN A LITTLE BIT.
5:42:16PM THERE YOU GO.
5:42:16PM CAN YOU GO THROUGH AND HIGHLIGHT THE USAGE OF HOW THIS IS
5:42:20PM CURRENTLY BUILT OUT, THESE PROPERTIES?
5:42:23PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THIS IS THE SUBJECT PROPERTY.
5:42:25PM THIS IS A PARKING LOT.
5:42:27PM THIS IS AN OFFICE.
5:42:28PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IF YOU GET THE HOUSING, TELL US
5:42:31PM APPROXIMATELY HOW MANY UNITS, IS IT MULTIPLE, MULTIPLE
5:42:36PM UNITS?
5:42:37PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THIS PROJECT IS MULTIPLE UNITS HERE.
5:42:40PM I DON'T KNOW EXACTLY HOW MANY.
5:42:41PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MORE THAN TWO?
5:42:43PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: YES.
5:42:43PM THE ONES ACROSS THE STREET -- DO I NEED TO ZOOM OUT SOME
5:42:49PM MORE?
5:42:50PM THIS IS AN OFFICE COMPLEX HERE.
5:42:55PM THIS IS AN OFFICE HERE.
5:42:58PM THESE ARE TWO UNITS FACING, I THINK THEY ARE TWO UNITS.
5:43:01PM IT COULD BE -- I'M PRETTY SURE THOSE ARE TWO UNITS FACING
5:43:04PM MOODY HERE, HERE AND HERE.
5:43:06PM BUT THESE ARE ALL SINGLE PROPERTIES THAT ARE FAIRLY NARROW.
5:43:11PM THESE ARE NOT AS WIDE AS THE SUBJECT PROPERTY HERE.
5:43:16PM ALL THE REST OF THESE ARE MULTIFAMILY, AND --
5:43:20PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHAT ABOUT THE OTHER STUFF OVER HERE.
5:43:22PM THAT'S ALL COMMERCIAL?
5:43:23PM TOWARDS THE LEFT -- LOOKING MY LEFT -- WHAT ARE THOSE AND
5:43:32PM WHAT ARE THE THINGS ON THE END OF THE BLOCK OF MOODY?
5:43:34PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: TOWN HOUSES.
5:43:36PM MONTESSORI SCHOOL.
5:43:37PM AND THEIR ACCESS DRIVE YOU SEE IS HERE.
5:43:40PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE LOTS CUT UP, WHAT ARE THOSE?
5:43:43PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: MULTIFAMILY TOWN HOUSES.
5:43:45PM THAT'S WHY I SAID IN THIS AREA, THIS IS THE LAST LOT THAT'S
5:43:51PM NOT DEVELOPED AS TOWN HOUSES.
5:43:53PM EVERYTHING ELSE IS EITHER THE PARKING LOT OR MULTIFAMILY ALL
5:43:57PM AROUND OR OFFICES.
5:43:58PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU.
5:43:59PM THAT'S ALL I'VE GOT.
5:44:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:44:00PM IS THERE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS
5:44:04PM ITEM, ITEM NUMBER 3?
5:44:06PM I DON'T HAVE ANYBODY REGISTERED.
5:44:09PM YES, SIR.
5:44:12PM COME ON UP, SIR, IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK.
5:44:15PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME, SIR.
5:44:28PM >> MY NAME IS TED GILLETTE.
5:44:32PM I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF THE MONTESSORI CHILDREN'S HOUSE OF
5:44:36PM HYDE PARK, THE SUBJECT SCHOOL THAT'S BEEN MENTIONED.
5:44:39PM I WOULD LIKE TO PERHAPS PREFACE HEARING THE UPDATED
5:44:45PM PRESENTATIONS, WE AS A NEIGHBOR TO THE PROPERTY, WE'RE
5:44:49PM COMPLETELY OKAY WITH SEEING MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT.
5:44:52PM WE UNDERSTAND THE NEED FOR DENSITY AND SO ON.
5:44:55PM BUT WE DO HAVE SEVERAL SPECIFIC CONCERNS THAT I WOULD LIKE
5:44:58PM TO BRING TO THE COUNCIL'S ATTENTION.
5:45:02PM FIRST, A POINT OF JUST CLARIFICATION THAT WAS PRESENTED
5:45:06PM PRIOR.
5:45:08PM REFER TO THE TREES, THOSE ARE OUR TREES.
5:45:10PM THEY HAVE NOT BEEN REMOVED.
5:45:11PM WE LIKE OUR TREES.
5:45:13PM ONE OF THEM IS AN OAK TREE THAT WOULD BE PROTECTED, STILL
5:45:18PM THERE.
5:45:20PM ANYWAY, TO SUMMARIZE THE POINTS I'D LIKE TO SPEAK TO WOULD
5:45:23PM BE ON THE GREENSPACE ELEMENT OF BOTH THE SETBACK AND THE
5:45:28PM PROTECTION OF OUR TREES.
5:45:31PM SECONDLY IS THE OVERALL GREENSPACE.
5:45:34PM BUT THIRD, THERE IS AN ELEMENT THAT HASN'T BEEN BROUGHT UP
5:45:38PM THAT IS A SPECIFIC CHILDREN SAFETY ISSUE.
5:45:41PM I'LL BRING THAT UP AT THE END.
5:45:43PM FIRST, IF I MAY, OAK TREE IS STILL THERE.
5:45:55PM THAT IS THE ONE SUBJECT TREE.
5:45:56PM AND THEN THERE IS A BEAUTIFUL CHERRY LAUREL BEHIND THAT.
5:45:59PM RESPECTFULLY, ALL WE'RE ASKING IS THAT THE RECOMMENDED
5:46:06PM 10-FOOT RADIUS FOR A TREE IS RESPECTED BECAUSE WE'RE BEING
5:46:11PM TOLD THE TREE PROBABLY WON'T SURVIVE OVER TIME WITH THAT.
5:46:14PM OTHER PICTURES TO SHOW YOU THE TREE.
5:46:23PM BUT THEN, IF I MAY SPEAK TO THEN JUST THE SEEKING APPROVAL
5:46:33PM TO REDUCE THE AMOUNT OF GREENSPACE AND UNDERSTAND THE NEED
5:46:37PM TO DO THAT TO ACHIEVE SOME OF THE DENSITY EFFORTS.
5:46:41PM BUT WE RESPECTFULLY ASK THAT THAT BE CONSIDERED IN LIGHT OF
5:46:45PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD, THAT YOU WOULD NOTICE A LOT OF PHOTOS
5:46:48PM BEING SHOWN BEFORE, BUT THIS WOULD -- SO THIS IS A PHOTO
5:47:01PM STANDING IN FRONT OF THEIR PROPERTY ON MOODY LOOKING ACROSS
5:47:05PM OUR PARKING LOT.
5:47:07PM BUT YOU CAN SEE THE AMOUNT OF GREENSPACE, AND THESE ARE ALL
5:47:11PM MULTIFAMILY, AS I POINTED OUT.
5:47:13PM THE AMOUNT OF GREENSPACE AND LANDSCAPING THAT THEY HAVE PUT
5:47:16PM IN, THE CURRENT PROPOSED PLAN WOULD APPEAR TO BE SIMPLY
5:47:21PM CONCRETE WITH A COUPLE OF THIN STRIPS OF GRASS.
5:47:30PM SO I THINK JUST ON BEHALF OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD, AND I DIDN'T,
5:47:34PM AT LEAST ON THAT ONE CHART, IF I UNDERSTOOD THE ONES THAT
5:47:39PM WERE APPROVING IT, I DIDN'T SEE ANY OF THESE HOMES DOING
5:47:42PM THAT.
5:47:43PM THAT WOULD BE MY RECOMMENDATION IS THAT THE --
5:47:46PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
5:47:47PM GO AHEAD, SIR.
5:47:51PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE TREE IS ON YOUR PROPERTY, THE OAK
5:47:53PM TREE?
5:47:54PM >> YES.
5:47:55PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HOW FAR IS IT FROM THE PROPERTY LINE?
5:47:57PM DO YOU KNOW?
5:48:00PM >> I DON'T HAVE EXACT.
5:48:01PM IT'S LESS THAN FIVE FEET FROM THE PROPERTY LINE.
5:48:03PM IT IS PROBABLY CLOSER TO THREE FEET TO THE ACTUAL PROPERTY
5:48:08PM LINE.
5:48:08PM ONLY ONE OF THE TREES, SIR, IS AN OAK TREE.
5:48:12PM THE OTHER ONE IS A CHERRY LAUREL WHICH WE'RE TOLD IS NOT
5:48:16PM PROTECTED.
5:48:16PM OF COURSE, WE LIKE TO SEE IT SURVIVE.
5:48:19PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: VERY GOOD.
5:48:20PM THANK YOU.
5:48:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
5:48:21PM ANYBODY ELSE THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, ITEM NUMBER
5:48:23PM 3?
5:48:24PM IF NOT, WE WILL GO TO REBUTTAL.
5:48:28PM >> MAY I SPEAK ON MY THIRD POINT OR --
5:48:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO, WE ONLY HAVE THREE MINUTES PER
5:48:35PM PERSON.
5:48:36PM >> THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT, SAFETY OF CHILDREN POINT.
5:48:41PM OKAY.
5:48:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GIVE ANOTHER 30 SECONDS.
5:48:47PM THERE ARE NO OTHER SPEAKERS.
5:48:48PM GO AHEAD.
5:48:49PM 30 SECONDS.
5:48:50PM >> LET ME GO STRAIGHT TO THE DRAWING.
5:48:55PM IF YOU LOOK THERE, THE YELLOW, THE NARROW ONE IS THE ALLEY,
5:49:00PM THE WIDER ONE IS MOODY.
5:49:06PM WHAT I'M SHOWING YOU THAT HAS NOT BEEN TAKEN INTO THOUGHTFUL
5:49:10PM CONSIDERATION IS THAT THE CARS THAT WOULD BE HAVING TO BACK
5:49:17PM INTO THE ALLEY ARE BACKING DIRECTLY INTO CAR LINE.
5:49:21PM 110 CHILDREN AGE 3 THROUGH 12 EVERY DAY GET IN AND OUT OF
5:49:26PM CARS RIGHT WHERE YOU SEE THE PINK VEHICLES.
5:49:29PM IT'S BEEN THAT WAY FOR 20 YEARS.
5:49:31PM WE NEVER HAD AN INCIDENT.
5:49:33PM AND IN THIS CASE, WHAT I HAVE DRAWN FOR YOU IN THE ORANGE
5:49:38PM FIRST IS AVERAGE CAR, 15 FEET, BUT I ALSO DREW TODAY YOU
5:49:43PM HAVE CARS THAT ARE 20 PLUS FEET.
5:49:45PM THEY WON'T EVEN FIT IN THE DRIVEWAY.
5:49:48PM SO YOU COULD BE TOUCHING THEIR GARAGE AND YOU WOULD BE
5:49:51PM STICKING OUT INTO THE ALLEY.
5:49:54PM SECONDLY, THE ALLEY IS ONLY 14 FEET WIDE.
5:49:57PM SO IT WOULD TAKE, IF SOMEBODY HAS A BACKUP CAMERA, THEY ARE
5:50:02PM A GREAT DRIVER, MAYBE IT'S OKAY.
5:50:05PM IF THEY ARE NOT A GOOD DRIVER, NO BACKUP CAMERA.
5:50:08PM ACCIDENTALLY HIT THE ACCELERATOR, IT IS A DISASTER WAITING
5:50:13PM TO HAPPEN WITH CHILDREN.
5:50:14PM AND THIS IS A VIEW OF WHAT YOU WOULD SEE FROM THE BACKUP
5:50:17PM CAMERA OF A CAR BACKING UP OUT OF THEIR DRIVEWAY.
5:50:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
5:50:22PM >> THANK YOU.
5:50:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. MICHELINI, YOU HAVE REBUTTAL.
5:50:35PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THAT'S THE TREE THAT THEY CUT DOWN.
5:50:38PM THAT'S A FRESH CUT.
5:50:39PM WE DIDN'T DO THAT.
5:50:40PM I THINK WHEN THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT THE BACKUP ALLEY, THEY
5:50:51PM HAVE -- ON THEIR PROPERTY THEY HAVE A WIDE DROP-OFF AND
5:50:58PM PICKUP LANE THAT'S NOT EVEN ON THE PROPERTY.
5:51:02PM YOU CAN SEE IT IN THIS AERIAL.
5:51:05PM SO WHEN THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT BACKING UP, THE WIDTH OF THE
5:51:07PM ALLEY IS UNOBSTRUCTED.
5:51:10PM THEY HAVE STANCHIONS ALL ALONG THIS PICKUP AND DROP-OFF
5:51:15PM POINT.
5:51:15PM AND THAT DROP-OFF IS ALL ON THEIR PROPERTY AND IT COMES BACK
5:51:19PM OUT DOWN HERE, AND IT COMPLETELY -- IT GOES AROUND OUR
5:51:29PM PROPERTY.
5:51:30PM THIS IS THE MONTESSORI PICKUP LINE AND PARKING LOT HERE, AND
5:51:41PM THEN IT COMES DOWN HERE.
5:51:43PM IT GOES OFF OF THE ALLEY AND THEN DOWN THE STREET.
5:51:51PM THIS IS THEIR PARKING LOT AND THIS IS WHERE THEY GO ONTO
5:52:00PM THEIR DRIVE AISLE.
5:52:02PM EVERYONE ELSE ON THAT ALLEY ACCESSES IT FOR THEIR PARKING
5:52:05PM AND FOR THEIR DRIVE AISLE.
5:52:08PM HERE IS A PICTURE OF THE ALLEY, WHICH YOU SEE IS GRAY.
5:52:15PM HERE IS THEIR DROP-OFF AND PICKUP LINE OVER HERE.
5:52:17PM WE'RE NOT BACKING INTO THEIR PICKUP AND DROP-OFF AREA.
5:52:23PM THE ONLY PLACE THAT YOU'RE BACKING UP INTO IS THE ALLEY
5:52:28PM ITSELF.
5:52:29PM AND HERE IS ANOTHER PICTURE SHOWING THE GRAY AREA IS THE
5:52:34PM CITY ALLEY.
5:52:35PM THIS IS PAVED AND THAT'S THE MONTESSORI PICKUP AND DROP-OFF
5:52:39PM LINE.
5:52:40PM IT'S NOT EVEN ON THE CITY ACCESS.
5:52:44PM HERE ARE THE BARRICADES THAT THEY HAVE.
5:52:53PM WE WANT TO PROTECT CHILDREN.
5:52:59PM WE'RE NOT GOING TO TRY TO ENDANGER ANYONE.
5:53:02PM IT IS A RESIDENTIAL USE.
5:53:03PM NOT A COMMERCIAL USE.
5:53:04PM CONVERTING FROM COMMERCIAL TO RESIDENTIAL.
5:53:06PM AND THAT'S WHY WE'RE REQUESTING YOUR ASSISTANCE.
5:53:10PM YOU ASKED A MINUTE AGO ABOUT THE ACCESS TO THE ALLEY.
5:53:17PM HERE IS A PICTURE OF THE UNITS -- THIS IS JUST ADJACENT TO
5:53:26PM THIS PROPERTY.
5:53:28PM UNITS THAT ARE ACCESSING THE ALLEY.
5:53:30PM THIS IS A COMMERCIAL USE THAT'S ACCESSING THE ALLEY.
5:53:33PM THIS IS MORE RESIDENTIAL THAT'S ACCESSING THE ALLEY.
5:53:40PM ANYWAY, THERE ARE A NUMBER OF PROPERTIES.
5:53:44PM THIS IS NEXT DOOR, ACCESSING THE ALLEY.
5:53:49PM THAT'S TWO MORE UNITS.
5:53:50PM THIS IS 209 MOODY, 207 MOODY, THEY ARE ALL GOING ON THE
5:53:56PM ALLEY.
5:53:56PM AGAIN, WE DON'T WANT TO ENDANGER ANYBODY.
5:53:58PM BUT THEY DO HAVE THEIR OWN -- ON THEIR OWN PROPERTY THEY
5:54:02PM HAVE A COMPLETE ACCESS, PICKUP AND DROP-OFF LINE BECAUSE I'M
5:54:06PM SURE THEY RECOGNIZE THAT THEY SHOULDN'T BE USING THE ALLEY
5:54:10PM TO STOP, WHICH WOULD HAVE BEEN A VIOLATION OF CITY CODE.
5:54:13PM THEY CAN STOP ON THEIR PROPERTY.
5:54:16PM THEY DO.
5:54:16PM THE PICKUP LINE FUNCTIONS JUST LIKE THAT.
5:54:19PM I'VE DRIVEN BY IT SEVERAL TIMES.
5:54:21PM I KNOW THAT THEY DO THAT AND THEN THE CARS, THEN THEY
5:54:25PM TRANSITION ONTO THE ALLEY FOR THEIR EXITING.
5:54:28PM I WOULD JUST REQUEST THAT THE COUNCIL CONSIDER THAT WE'VE
5:54:33PM TAKEN A NUMBER OF MEASURES TO TRY TO MITIGATE ANY IMPACT
5:54:37PM THAT WE MIGHT HAVE.
5:54:38PM IT WAS FOUND CONSISTENT FOR THE LAND USE PLAN.
5:54:43PM WE ARE TRYING TO MEET THE INTENT OF THE CODE AND I THINK WE
5:54:47PM HAVE DEMONSTRATED THAT WE HAVE DONE THAT.
5:54:49PM THIS IS ANOTHER PICTURE OF THE TREE, AND YOU CAN SEE THE
5:54:55PM STUMPS HERE OF THE TREES THAT THEY HAVE REMOVED.
5:55:00PM THEY PAVED RIGHT UP TO THE BASE OF THE TREE.
5:55:02PM WHEN THEY COME DOWN AND SAY THEY WANT THE PROTECTIVE TEN
5:55:05PM FOOT RADIUS, THEY HAVE LESS THAN SIX INCHES OF RADIUS
5:55:09PM PROTECTION FOR THE TREE.
5:55:10PM THIS IS THE TREE THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT.
5:55:12PM WE WILL HAVE ALTERNATE MEANS OF CONSTRUCTION INCLUDING
5:55:16PM PERVIOUS PAVERS TO PROTECT THE RADIUS OF THE TREE AND TO
5:55:20PM ENSURE IT IS PROTECTED AND WILL BE MAINTAINED.
5:55:24PM I DON'T KNOW WHAT ELSE I CAN TELL YOU.
5:55:29PM I WOULD GREATLY APPRECIATE.
5:55:31PM THE OWNER IS HERE, AND SHE CAN TELL YOU ABOUT HER HARDSHIP
5:55:37PM AND TRYING TO GET THIS RENOVATED, BUT WE GREATLY APPRECIATE
5:55:41PM YOUR SUPPORT.
5:55:42PM >>LYNN HURTAK: MOTION TO CLOSE.
5:55:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM -- YES,
5:55:46PM SIR.
5:55:49PM >>SAMUEL THOMAS: SAM THOMAS, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:55:51PM BASED ON WHAT THE APPLICANT HAS AGREED TO ON THE RECORD I
5:55:53PM HAVE A REVISED REVISION SHEET TO PROVIDE FOR THE RECORD.
5:55:56PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I HAVE A QUESTION ABOUT THAT.
5:55:58PM WILL IT BE ABLE TO BE DONE WITHIN THE NORMAL TIME FOR --
5:56:02PM >>SAMUEL THOMAS: YES.
5:56:03PM CHANGES WILL BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
5:56:07PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: FOR STAFF, I DO RECOGNIZE WHAT THE
5:56:11PM APPLICANT HAS SAID IN THE PRESENTATION ABOUT THE
5:56:16PM ACCOMMODATION AND STUFF.
5:56:17PM I'M TRYING TO GET PAST THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND COMPATIBILITY
5:56:19PM WITH THE IMPACTED NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:56:21PM CAN YOU IDENTIFY IN THESE PICTURES, ANY OTHER QUADS BUILT ON
5:56:26PM THIS TYPE OF PIECE OF PROPERTY?
5:56:27PM IS THIS COMPATIBLE CONSTRUCTION WITH EXISTING CONSTRUCTION
5:56:30PM THAT'S THERE?
5:56:31PM >>SAMUEL THOMAS: I CAN'T SAY FOR SURE WHETHER THERE ARE
5:56:33PM OTHER QUADS ON THE BLOCK.
5:56:34PM BUT SOUTH OF KENNEDY AND IN THE HYDE PARK, SOUTH HOWARD
5:56:38PM GENERAL AREA, DOUBLE LOADED OFF THE ALLEY FROM WHAT MY
5:56:41PM EXPERIENCE IS BEING IN THAT AREA IS NOT UNCOMMON.
5:56:44PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHAT IS THE RULE ABOUT FRONT DOORS?
5:56:48PM >>SAMUEL THOMAS: THE FRONT DOORS, SO THE CODE DOESN'T WANT
5:56:51PM YOU TO HAVE IT FACING THE -- FACING RIGHT-OF-WAY THAT
5:56:54PM DOESN'T INCLUDE AN ALLEY.
5:56:56PM TYPICALLY, STAFF HAS RECOGNIZED THAT AS LONG AS YOU CAN
5:56:59PM PROVIDE A PEDESTRIAN CONNECTION TO THE SIDEWALK, THEN YOU'RE
5:57:04PM TRYING TO AT LEAST MEET THE INTENT OF THE POLICY.
5:57:07PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IS THE INTENT OF THE POLICY TO BE FORWARD
5:57:10PM FACING TOWARD THE STREET?
5:57:13PM >>SAMUEL THOMAS: YES, THAT IS THE INTENT OF THE POLICY.
5:57:16PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU.
5:57:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:57:18PM ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS BEFORE I ASK FOR THE MOTION
5:57:20PM TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK?
5:57:23PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: IF I COULD ELABORATE ON THAT FOR JUST A
5:57:26PM SECOND.
5:57:26PM WHEN THE DISCUSSIONS CAME UP ABOUT WIDENING THE GARAGES, IT
5:57:30PM ELIMINATED THE POSSIBILITY OF PUTTING A DOORWAY THERE IF YOU
5:57:33PM HAVE A WIDER GARAGE.
5:57:36PM SO WE ARE COMPATIBLE WITH WHAT THE FIRE MARSHAL HAS
5:57:39PM REQUESTED AND WHAT THE STAFF HAS RECOGNIZED AS A REASONABLE
5:57:42PM ALTERNATIVE, WHICH WAS THE WALKWAYS ALONG THE SIDE, AS LONG
5:57:45PM AS THEY WERE CLEARLY IDENTIFIED.
5:57:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:57:48PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THANK YOU.
5:57:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM
5:57:52PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
5:57:52PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
5:57:54PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:57:54PM AYE.
5:57:55PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:57:55PM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:58:00PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
5:58:01PM THIS IS JUST -- I FORGET WHOSE SAYING IT IS.
5:58:07PM I THINK YOURS.
5:58:08PM TEN FOOT SUGAR IN A FIVE POUND BAG.
5:58:12PM IT'S JUST TOO MUCH.
5:58:13PM EVEN IF WE EXPANDED THE DRIVEWAY OR THE GARAGES FROM 20 FEET
5:58:17PM TO 22 FEET, NO FRONT DOOR IS TWO FEET.
5:58:20PM IT JUST ISN'T.
5:58:21PM I MOVE TO DENY REZ 23-88 FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 203
5:58:28PM SOUTH MOODY AVENUE DUE TO THE FAILURE OF THE APPLICANT ITS
5:58:33PM BURDEN OF PROOF TO PROVIDE COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL
5:58:35PM EVIDENCE THAT THE DEVELOPMENT AS CONDITIONED AND ZONED ON
5:58:37PM THE SITE PLAN IS CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND
5:58:39PM CITY CODE AND THE APPLICANT'S FAILURE TO MEET ITS BURDEN OF
5:58:42PM PROOF WITH RESPECT TO THE REQUESTED WAIVERS.
5:58:45PM I ALSO ADOPT THE FINDINGS AND REASONINGS OF THE CITY STAFF
5:58:50PM REPORT.
5:58:51PM I FIND THAT ALSO THAT IT FAILS TO COMPLY WITH LAND
5:58:54PM DEVELOPMENT CODE SECTION 27-136, ALTHOUGH THE PROPOSED USE
5:58:59PM IS AN APPROPRIATE TRANSITIONAL USE WITHIN THE NEIGHBORHOOD,
5:59:02PM THE PROPOSED DESIGN AS SHOWN ON THE SITE PLAN DOES NOT
5:59:05PM PROMOTE OR ENCOURAGE DEVELOPMENT THAT IS APPROPRIATE IN
5:59:08PM LOCATION, CHARACTER, AND COMPATIBILITY WITH THE SURROUNDING
5:59:10PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:59:13PM FOR EXAMPLE, NONE OF THE UNITS PROVIDE A FRONT DOOR
5:59:16PM ORIENTATION TOWARD THE FRONT.
5:59:18PM AND THE REQUESTED REDUCTION IN THE USE-TO-USE LAND BUFFER
5:59:22PM WILL NOT ACCOMMODATE ANY TREES NOR PROVIDE THE APPROPRIATE
5:59:26PM BUFFER TO BETTER PROTECT THE OFF-SITE TREES.
5:59:29PM THE WAIVERS NEEDED ARE JUST TOO TREMENDOUS TO OVERLOOK IN
5:59:33PM THIS CASE.
5:59:34PM THE -- NONE OF THE FRONT DOORS FACE THE FRONT.
5:59:37PM THEY FACE THE SIDE, WHICH WE AS A COUNCIL HAVE AGREED THAT
5:59:43PM WE'RE NOT TAKING THAT OFF THAT WE WANT FRONT DOORS TO FACE
5:59:45PM THE FRONT.
5:59:46PM THE LANDSCAPE BUFFER FROM 15 FEET TO 0 FEET, THE NEIGHBORS
5:59:49PM HAVE SAID THAT THEY WANT THAT BUFFER THERE.
5:59:51PM BUT TO ME THE MOST EGREGIOUS IS THE GREENSPACE.
5:59:56PM WE'RE GOING FROM 350 FEET PER UNIT REQUIRED GREENSPACE TO
6:00:00PM 107.
6:00:01PM THAT'S LESS THAN 5,000 SQUARE FOOT -- FEET ON A 6,667 SQUARE
6:00:08PM FOOT LOT.
6:00:09PM THAT IS ONE-THIRTEENTH OF THE LOT SPACE.
6:00:12PM THE INCREASE OF IMPERVIOUS AREA IS 2,000 FEET, ACCORDING TO
6:00:16PM THE SITE PLAN, AND THAT'S JUST UNACCEPTABLE.
6:00:19PM SO THAT IS MY MOTION.
6:00:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
6:00:23PM HENDERSON.
6:00:23PM ANY DISCUSSION?
6:00:26PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I'LL EXPLAIN MY VOTE.
6:00:27PM I'M GOING TO SUPPORT THE MOTION.
6:00:29PM I REALLY DID TRY TO GET -- IT WAS A GOOD PRESENTATION.
6:00:33PM I THINK YOU MADE A LOT OF GOOD POINTS.
6:00:36PM I APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT YOU BROUGHT A PLAN THAT HAD MORE
6:00:39PM ARCHITECTURAL DETAIL, FACING OF THE FACADES.
6:00:42PM I APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT YOU WIDENED THOSE GARAGES TO
6:00:46PM ACCOMMODATE PAST REQUESTS.
6:00:47PM I DIDN'T LOOK AT THE ALLEY SITUATION AS PROBLEMATIC BECAUSE
6:00:50PM WE WANT TO ENGAGE ALLEYS.
6:00:51PM YOU ADEQUATELY DEMONSTRATED THAT ADJACENT SCHOOL HAD A DRIVE
6:00:55PM AREA, SO IT ISN'T BURIED INTO MY THOUGHTS.
6:00:59PM THE OTHER POINTS COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK MAKE I THINK ARE WELL
6:01:02PM MADE.
6:01:03PM IT IS AN AWFUL LOT ON A SMALL PIECE OF PROPERTY.
6:01:06PM I THINK SOME OF THE COMPELLING THINGS THE NEIGHBOR SHOWED
6:01:08PM SOME OF THE OTHER SPACES THAT SHOWED FRONT YARDS WITH TREES.
6:01:11PM AS FAR AS COMPATIBILITY WITH THE ADJACENT STRUCTURES AND
6:01:14PM ADJACENT, HOW THINGS ARE BUILT OUT, THAT IS WHAT THAT
6:01:17PM NEIGHBORHOOD NEEDS AND LOOKS LIKE.
6:01:20PM SO I'M GOING TO SUPPORT THE MOTION.
6:01:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
6:01:23PM ROLL CALL.
6:01:27PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
6:01:29PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
6:01:31PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
6:01:33PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
6:01:34PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
6:01:36PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
6:01:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO.
6:01:39PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:01:42PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION.
6:01:43PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION TO DENY CARRIED WITH MANISCALCO VOTING
6:01:47PM NO.
6:01:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
6:01:51PM NEXT IS ITEM IS NUMBER 2 FOLLOWED BY 4 AND 5.
6:02:19PM >> GOOD EVENING.
6:02:20PM DANNY COLLINS, AGAIN WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
6:02:23PM THIS IS TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT 22-28.
6:02:29PM IT'S A MAP AMENDMENT FOR THE TAMPA UNION WHARF AREA.
6:02:34PM CONTAINS MULTIPLE ADDRESSES IN THE VICINITY OF YBOR CHANNEL.
6:02:37PM JUST A QUICK BACKGROUND, PRIVATELY INITIATED AMENDMENT.
6:02:41PM SMALL SCALE IN SIZE.
6:02:43PM SUBJECT SITE IS APPROXIMATELY 14.51 ACRES.
6:02:46PM THE REQUEST IS TO CHANGE THE LAND FROM HEAVY INDUSTRIAL,
6:02:49PM LIGHT INDUSTRIAL AND GENERAL MIXED USE 24 TO URBAN MIXED USE
6:02:53PM 60 AND COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35.
6:02:55PM HERE IS THE GENERAL LOCATION OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:03:02PM IT'S WITHIN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT AND PORTIONS
6:03:04PM OF THE SITE ARE WITHIN THE HISTORIC YBOR NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:03:07PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS ALSO WITHIN THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD
6:03:10PM AREA.
6:03:11PM IT'S KIND OF HARD TO SEE BUT SHOWN HERE ON THE MAP JUST EAST
6:03:15PM OF CHANNELSIDE.
6:03:16PM HERE IS AN AERIAL MAP OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND THE
6:03:22PM SURROUNDING PROPERTIES.
6:03:23PM YOU CAN SEE THERE ARE SEVERAL PARCELS SCATTERED AROUND THE
6:03:27PM YBOR CHANNEL.
6:03:30PM SHOWN IN THE YELLOW COLOR.
6:03:34PM GENERALLY THE PARCEL SOUTH OF ADAMO DRIVE, OVER HERE, AND
6:03:39PM THEN YOU HAVE PARCELS JUST TO THE NORTH OF ADAMO DRIVE AND
6:03:42PM THEN JUST TO THE NORTH OF EAST 2nd AVENUE.
6:03:45PM THERE ARE SOME HEAVY INDUSTRIAL TO THE SOUTH OF THE SITES
6:03:49PM ADJACENT TO 19th STREET.
6:03:52PM UP ALONG ADAMO DRIVE WE HAVE SOME NONRESIDENTIAL USES AS
6:03:55PM WELL AS NORTH OF EAST 2nd AVENUE.
6:04:00PM HERE IS AN IMAGE LOOKING SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:04:06PM ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF NORTH 19th STREET.
6:04:11PM THIS IS LOOKING WEST.
6:04:12PM SUBJECT SITE IS TO THE RIGHT ON PENNY STREET.
6:04:16PM THIS IS LOOKING NORTHEAST, SUBJECT SITE IS ON BOTH SIDES OF
6:04:20PM PENNY STREET.
6:04:20PM THIS IS STILL SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE LOOKING NORTH ALONG
6:04:26PM PENNY STREET.
6:04:27PM THIS IS LOOKING NORTH.
6:04:31PM SUBJECT SITE IS ON THE LEFT.
6:04:35PM THIS IS LOOKING WEST, SUBJECT SITE IS ON BOTH SIDES OF EAST
6:04:38PM 2nd AVENUE.
6:04:40PM THIS IS LOOKING EAST, SUBJECT SITE IS ON THE RIGHT SIDE.
6:04:44PM THIS IS EAST 3rd AVENUE.
6:04:46PM ANOTHER IMAGE LOOKING SOUTH ON BOTH SIDES FROM NORTH 16th
6:04:53PM STREET.
6:04:54PM HERE IS THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
6:04:58PM AS YOU COULD SEE, THE PARCEL SOUTH OF ADAMO DRIVE ARE
6:05:01PM RECOGNIZED UNDER THE HEAVY INDUSTRIAL FUTURE LAND USE
6:05:04PM DESIGNATION.
6:05:06PM THAT'S REPRESENTED BY THE DARK GRAY COLOR.
6:05:09PM TO THE WEST WE HAVE URBAN MIXED USE 60.
6:05:12PM THERE IS SOME HEAVY INDUSTRIAL TO THE EAST OF THE SUBJECT
6:05:14PM SITE.
6:05:16PM FURTHER WEST OF THE CHANNEL IS THE CHANNEL DISTRICT, WHICH
6:05:22PM SOME RMU 100.
6:05:24PM AS WE MOVE NORTH, NORTH OF ADAMO, WE HAVE LANDS RECOGNIZED
6:05:28PM UNDER THE LIGHT INDUSTRIAL DESIGNATION WHICH IS SHOWN IN
6:05:31PM THIS GRAY COLOR.
6:05:33PM AS WE MOVE NORTH OF EAST 2nd AVENUE, THESE PARCELS HERE
6:05:36PM ARE RECOGNIZED UNDER THE GENERAL MIXED USE 24 DESIGNATION.
6:05:39PM THE GENERAL MIXED USE 24 DESIGNATION ALLOWS FOR A RANGE OF
6:05:43PM USES.
6:05:44PM ANYTHING FROM RESIDENTIAL TO COMMERCIAL ALL THE WAY UP TO
6:05:49PM LIGHT INDUSTRIAL USES.
6:05:51PM THE LIGHT INDUSTRIAL ALLOWS FOR LIGHT MANUFACTURING, LIGHT
6:05:56PM INDUSTRIAL TYPE USES AND HEAVY INDUSTRIAL IS MORE OF THE
6:06:00PM MORE INTENSIVE, HEAVY INDUSTRIAL USES.
6:06:03PM HERE IS THE PROPOSED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
6:06:10PM THE PARCELS SOUTH OF ADAMO DRIVE ARE REQUESTING THE URBAN
6:06:16PM MIXED USE 60 AS WELL AS THE PARCELS ON THE NORTH SIDE OF
6:06:18PM ADAMO DRIVE.
6:06:20PM AS WE MOVE NORTH TOWARDS THE YBOR LOCAL DISTRICT, THE
6:06:25PM PARCELS NORTH OF EAST 2nd AVENUE ARE PROPOSED TO GO UNDER
6:06:30PM THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35 DESIGNATION.
6:06:32PM THE URBAN MIXED USE 60 DESIGNATION ALLOWS A MIXED USE
6:06:38PM DEVELOPMENT PATTERN UP TO 3.25 F.A.R.
6:06:42PM URBAN MIXED USE 60 IS FOUND PREDOMINANTLY ALONG KENNEDY
6:06:45PM BOULEVARD.
6:06:46PM IT'S FOUND ALONG GANDY.
6:06:50PM CMU 35 IS ALSO ENCOURAGE THE MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN
6:06:54PM UP TO 35 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE UP TO 2.0 F.A.R.
6:06:59PM HERE IS A SLIDE SHOWING THE PROPOSED IMPACTS OF THE PROPOSED
6:07:04PM CHANGE.
6:07:05PM CURRENTLY UNDER THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USES, SUBJECT SITE
6:07:08PM CAN BE CONSIDERED FOR A HUNDRED DWELLING UNITS OR JUST OVER
6:07:12PM 1.2 MILLION SQUARE FEET OF NONRESIDENTIAL USES.
6:07:17PM AS PROPOSED UNDER THE CMU 35 AND URBAN MIXED USE 60
6:07:22PM DESIGNATIONS, THE SUBJECT SITE CAN BE CONSIDERED FOR 812
6:07:26PM DWELLING UNITS OR JUST UNDER 2 MILLION SQUARE FEET OF
6:07:30PM NONRESIDENTIAL OR RESIDENTIAL USES.
6:07:33PM THE REQUEST WILL INTRODUCE THE CONSIDERATION OF MULTIFAMILY
6:07:35PM USES ON THE PORTIONS OF THE SITE CURRENTLY DESIGNATED AS
6:07:40PM LIGHT INDUSTRIAL OR HEAVY INDUSTRIAL.
6:07:41PM THERE WAS AN OBJECTION FROM CITY OF TAMPA STAFF.
6:07:47PM THAT IS IN YOUR REPORT.
6:07:49PM THIS WENT TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
6:07:57PM THEY FOUND THE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH THE TAMPA
6:08:01PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:08:02PM THEY FOUND IT SPECIFICALLY CONSISTENT WITH LAND USE POLICY
6:08:04PM 2.1.1 WHICH ENCOURAGES COMPACT HIGHER DENSITY DEVELOPMENT
6:08:08PM THAT IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE SURROUNDING CHARACTER.
6:08:12PM OUR STAFF REPORT, WE FOUND IT INCONSISTENT, SO YOU'LL NOTICE
6:08:16PM THAT OUR STAFF REPORT IS AN INCONSISTENCY FINDING WHEREAS
6:08:20PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION BOARD VOTED TO FIND IT CONSISTENT.
6:08:22PM BASED ON THAT POLICY, THE PLANNING COMMISSION BOARD
6:08:28PM RECOMMENDED THAT THE PROPOSED MAP AMENDMENT BE FOUND
6:08:31PM CONSISTENT WITH THE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OF THE
6:08:33PM TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:08:34PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
6:08:37PM AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
6:08:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
6:08:41PM >>DANNY COLLINS: I BELIEVE THE CITY HAS SOME COMMENTS ON
6:08:43PM THIS.
6:08:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE'LL TAKE THE CITY FIRST AND THEN GO TO
6:08:46PM THE APPLICANT.
6:08:47PM YES, SIR.
6:08:49PM >> EVAN JOHNSON, CITY PLANNING DEPARTMENT.
6:08:52PM I HAVE WITH ME RON VILA FROM THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION.
6:08:55PM I REALLY JUST WANTED TO TAKE A SECOND TO REITERATE A LOT OF
6:09:00PM WHAT DANNY SAID REGARDING THE CITY'S OBJECTION.
6:09:03PM WE AGREE WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REGARDING THE
6:09:06PM INCREASE OF DENSITY AND INTENSITY IN THE CHHA.
6:09:09PM ALSO WANTED TO POINT OUT THAT ALTHOUGH DANNY DID SAY IT, YOU
6:09:13PM COULD DO A RESIDENTIAL ONLY USING F.A.R. WITH THIS
6:09:17PM PARTICULAR SITE IN THESE LAND USES.
6:09:20PM POTENTIALLY THAT YIELDS RESIDENTIAL UNITS EVEN HIGHER THAN
6:09:23PM THE 802 UNITS I BELIEVE THAT WE SHOWED ON THE PRESENTATION.
6:09:26PM I JUST WANTED TO REITERATE THOSE FOR THE RECORD.
6:09:29PM MR. VILA.
6:09:31PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
6:09:32PM RON VILA.
6:09:33PM STAFF WITH HISTORIC PRESERVATION.
6:09:35PM FROM THE BARRIO'S POSITION, I WOULD LIKE TO PROVIDE YOU WITH
6:09:38PM SOME ADDITIONAL INFORMATION.
6:09:39PM I THINK THIS ILLUSTRATION WAS ALREADY SHOWN BUT TO KIND OF
6:09:45PM STRENGTHEN THE POSITION, THIS IS ADAMO HERE.
6:09:48PM EVERYTHING TO THE SOUTH OF ADAMO IS OUTSIDE OF THE LOCAL
6:09:51PM HISTORIC DISTRICT OF YBOR CITY.
6:09:53PM EVERYTHING TO THE NORTH IS WITHIN.
6:09:55PM YOU SEE THE CONCENTRATION OF THE FABRIC.
6:10:00PM THIS IS THE YBOR CITY LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT.
6:10:04PM EVERYTHING WITHIN THE RED.
6:10:05PM THIS IS THE SOUTHERN PORTION OF THE SUBJECT SITE THAT WAS
6:10:11PM WITHIN AND THE BARRIO HAD JURISDICTION OVER AND REVIEWED AN
6:10:14PM APPLICATION.
6:10:15PM THE DUTIES AND POWER OF THE BARRIO LATINO COMMISSION UNDER
6:10:19PM CHAPTER 2795 IS AS FOLLOWS: WITH REGARDS TO THE APPLICATION
6:10:23PM FOR REZONING, CHANGES TO THE LAND USE CLASSIFICATION, OR
6:10:27PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT TO REVIEW AND RECOMMEND
6:10:30PM REASONABLE LAND USE CHANGES TO THE EXTENT NECESSARY TO
6:10:33PM PRESERVE THE HISTORIC INTEGRITY.
6:10:37PM THE BARRIO LATINO REVIEWED THE CHANGE TO THE COMP PLAN FROM
6:10:43PM GMU 24 TO CMU 35 AND UMU 60.
6:10:49PM AT THE PUBLIC HEARING ON MARCH 28, 2023, AND THEY FOUND IT
6:10:55PM CONSISTENT WITH RECOMMENDATION TO APPROVE TO THIS GOVERNING
6:10:59PM BODY.
6:10:59PM THAT WAS A MOTION OF 5-0 IN APPROVAL.
6:11:03PM THE BARRIO UNDERSTANDS THAT THEY'LL GET ANOTHER SHOT AT
6:11:06PM THIS.
6:11:07PM THIS IS THE UNDERLYING CLASSIFICATION.
6:11:09PM AS IT COMES FORWARD, IF A REZONING IS NEEDED, THE BARRIO
6:11:12PM WILL LOOK AT THAT REZONING.
6:11:14PM AND THEN ULTIMATELY WITH THE CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS,
6:11:17PM THE BARRIO WILL LOOK AT IT AGAIN.
6:11:19PM WITH ALL THAT THAT I PUT INTO THE RECORD, GAVE A FAVORABLE
6:11:23PM RECOMMENDATION MOVING FORWARD.
6:11:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:11:25PM ALL RIGHT.
6:11:27PM WE'LL GO TO THE APPLICANT.
6:11:31PM YES.
6:11:31PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:11:33PM >> TYLER HUDSON.
6:11:35PM 400 NORTH ASHLEY DRIVE.
6:11:37PM WE'VE GOT A LOT OF GROUND TO COVER IN THIS APPLICATION, SO
6:11:44PM I'LL GO AHEAD AND GET STARTED WITH THE PowerPoint.
6:11:46PM IT'S A LOT MORE DIGESTIBLE IF WE LOOK AT THE SET OF PARCELS
6:11:56PM IN THREE DIFFERENT GROUPS.
6:11:57PM GROUP ONE IS WHAT'S ON 2nd AVENUE.
6:12:00PM GROUP TWO IS ON ADAMO AND GROUP 3 IS SOUTH OF ADAMO.
6:12:04PM ALL THREE OF THESE GROUPS, EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THESE PARCELS
6:12:08PM HAS ONE THING IN COMMON WITH THIS APPLICATION, AND THAT'S
6:12:11PM WE'RE TRYING TO PULL THE LAND USE DESIGNATION ON THE WESTERN
6:12:14PM BORDER EASTWARD.
6:12:15PM WE ALL HAVE THAT IN COMMON.
6:12:17PM NOT INTRODUCING ANY WILD NEW SHADES OF PURPLE OR RED IN THIS
6:12:21PM APPLICATION.
6:12:21PM GROUPS TWO AND THREE HAVE THIS IN COMMON.
6:12:25PM RIGHT NOW PEOPLE CAN'T LIVE THERE.
6:12:29PM LAND USE CATEGORIES TODAY PROHIBIT RESIDENTIAL USE OF ANY
6:12:32PM KIND.
6:12:33PM GROUP 3 IS THE SUBJECT -- IT IS THE ONLY GROUP THAT'S ON
6:12:40PM SCREEN THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF A REZONING REQUEST LATER THIS
6:12:43PM EVENING.
6:12:43PM THAT'S THE LAST I'M GOING TO SPEAK OF IT, BUT JUST FOR
6:12:46PM CONTEXT AND SO EVERYONE IS AWARE, IF WE ARE FORTUNATE ENOUGH
6:12:49PM TO GET COUNCIL'S RECOMMENDATION -- SORRY, APPROVAL OF THIS
6:12:53PM ITEM, WE WILL BE TALKING ABOUT ONLY GROUP 3 LATER ON.
6:12:57PM THERE ARE NO PENDING ZONING APPLICATIONS FOR GROUP 1 OR
6:13:00PM GROUP 2.
6:13:01PM LET'S GET STARTED.
6:13:03PM GROUP ONE I THINK IS PROBABLY THE MOST STRAIGHTFORWARD,
6:13:06PM SEEKING A REQUEST TO GO FROM GENERAL MIXED USE 24 TO CMU 35
6:13:12PM IN THE BLACK DASHED OUTLINE THERE FRONTING 2nd AVENUE.
6:13:15PM CMU 35 IS THE LIGHTER PINK COLOR.
6:13:17PM ALREADY PRESENT TO THE WEST.
6:13:19PM ALSO PRESENT TO THE NORTH AND TO THE EAST.
6:13:21PM TRYING TO PULL THAT OVER TO THE SITES WE CONTROL.
6:13:24PM WE DON'T CONTROL THE PIECE THAT WE'RE SKIPPING IN THE
6:13:26PM MIDDLE.
6:13:26PM THAT'S NOT INTENTIONAL.
6:13:28PM IT'S JUST THE CIRCUMSTANCES.
6:13:30PM THERE IS AMPLE PRECEDENT FOR THIS GOING BACK ALL THE WAY TO
6:13:34PM 2006 WHEN AS YOU CAN SEE SOME OF THE ENTIRE BLOCKS IN THIS
6:13:37PM AREA TRANSITIONED OVER FROM GMU 24 TO CMU 35.
6:13:42PM SORT OF AN ODD CATEGORY.
6:13:44PM GMU 24, ONE OF TWO CATEGORIES IN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN THAT
6:13:47PM REALLY THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN GIVES A SHELF LIFE TO, A SORT
6:13:51PM OF EXPIRATION DATE ALONG WITH TRANSITIONAL USE 24 WHICH IS
6:13:55PM SOMEWHAT PRESENT IN THE INTERBAY AREA.
6:13:58PM IT'S TWO CATEGORIES THAT THE PLAN SPECIFICALLY SAYS HAVE NO
6:14:01PM DISCERNIBLE DEVELOPMENT DIRECTION.
6:14:06PM WOULDN'T CALL IT A CATCHALL, THAT MIGHT BE INSULTING TO THE
6:14:08PM CATEGORY BUT IT DOES SOUND A LITTLE BIT LIKE A CATCHALL.
6:14:12PM THE COMP PLAN MENTIONS TWO PARTS OF THE CITY WHERE GMU 24 IS
6:14:17PM PRESENT AND LIKELY NOT TO STAY FOR LONG.
6:14:19PM ONE OF THE PLACES THEY REFERENCE IS QUOTE SOUTH YBOR CITY.
6:14:22PM BACK IN 2016 IT WASN'T AN AREA THAT HAD MUCH OF A
6:14:25PM RECOGNIZABLE DEVELOPMENT TREND.
6:14:27PM I THINK THAT CHANGED TWO YEARS AGO WITH THIS COUNCIL'S
6:14:29PM APPROVAL OF THE GASWORX PDA JUST TO THE WEST.
6:14:32PM WE BELIEVE THERE IS NOW A FAIRLY CONSISTENT DIRECTION OF
6:14:35PM MODERATE, LOW, HIGH DENSITY MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT IN THIS
6:14:39PM AREA.
6:14:39PM AGAIN, THIS IS NOT ADAMO.
6:14:41PM WE ARE PROPOSING CMU 35 HERE.
6:14:44PM WE THINK IT IS AN APPROPRIATE CHANGE.
6:14:47PM RELATIVELY MINOR.
6:14:48PM IT DOES INCREASE THE F.A.R. TO 2.0 BECAUSE IT IS IN THE YBOR
6:14:52PM CITY HISTORIC DISTRICT.
6:14:54PM 1.0 IS THE BASE LINE EVERYWHERE ELSE IN THE CITY.
6:14:57PM WHOLE RANGE OF RESIDENTIAL, COMMERCIAL AND OFFICE USES ARE
6:15:00PM STILL ALLOWED.
6:15:01PM THE REASON WE'RE DOING THIS IS WHEN AND IF IT IS DEVELOPED
6:15:04PM AS PART OF MASTER PLAN, THERE ARE FEWER COLORS ON THE MAP,
6:15:07PM THERE IS A MORE CONSISTENT LAND USE THAT ZONING WOULD THEN
6:15:10PM IMPLEMENT.
6:15:11PM GROUP 2.
6:15:12PM THIS IS CURRENTLY A DORMANT STRIP CLUB AND A VERY LIVE
6:15:18PM PICKLEBALL CLUB ON ADAMO DRIVE AND 17th STREET.
6:15:21PM I THINK COUNCILMAN CARLSON REFERRED TO IT AS THE QUONSET
6:15:25PM HUTS EARLIER TODAY.
6:15:26PM RIGHT NOW LIGHT INDUSTRIAL.
6:15:27PM PROPOSING URBAN MIXED USE 60.
6:15:29PM URBAN MIXED USE 60 IS WHAT WAS APPROVED BY THIS COUNCIL AS A
6:15:33PM PRELUDE TO THE GASWORX DEVELOPMENT.
6:15:35PM ALREADY PRESENT JUST TO THE WEST.
6:15:37PM WE'RE SEEKING TO PULL THAT TO THE EAST TO CREATE A SORT OF
6:15:40PM CLEAR LINE THERE.
6:15:41PM A LOT OF PRECEDENT FOR THIS EXACT TYPE OF APPLICATION GOING
6:15:45PM BACK ALL THE WAY TO 2005 AS THE AREA EVOLVED AND MORE PEOPLE
6:15:51PM WANTED TO LIVE IN YBOR CITY.
6:15:52PM BEFORE THIS INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT PATTERN WAS AS PERSISTENT
6:15:57PM AS IT WAS, THESE WERE NEIGHBORHOODS, WHERE PEOPLE LIVED.
6:16:00PM WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO DO IS GO BACK TO THAT TO MAKE THIS A
6:16:03PM PLACE FOR PEOPLE TO LIVE AND ALSO PROTECT AN ENORMOUS RANGE
6:16:06PM OF INDUSTRIAL USES THAT YOU'RE NOT LOSING.
6:16:08PM I'LL TALK MORE ABOUT THAT LATER ON.
6:16:10PM ADAMO DRIVE IS A TRANSIT EMPHASIS CORRIDOR.
6:16:13PM I THINK THIS COUNCIL HAS HAD SOMEWHAT DISCERNIBLE PATTERN OF
6:16:17PM BEING MORE OPEN TO INTENSIFICATION AND DEVELOPMENT ALONG
6:16:20PM CORRIDORS.
6:16:21PM IT DOES RELIEVE PRESSURE FROM GOING DEEPLY INTO
6:16:24PM NEIGHBORHOODS.
6:16:25PM ADAMO DRIVE IS A TRANSIT EMPHASIS CORRIDOR.
6:16:28PM YOUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IDENTIFIES SEVERAL OF THESE AND SAYS
6:16:31PM THESE ARE IDEALLY SUITED FOR REDEVELOPMENT, INTENSIFICATION.
6:16:34PM THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT WE'RE SEEKING.
6:16:36PM SO COMPARISONS, THIS IS AN INCREASE IN DENSITY.
6:16:41PM AS DANNY ALLUDED TO.
6:16:43PM RESIDENTIAL NO ONE CAN LIVE HERE RIGHT NOW.
6:16:45PM NO ONE CAN LIVE HERE, IN AN AREA ADJACENT TO 5
6:16:49PM MILLION-SQUARE-FOOT DEVELOPMENT THAT THIS COUNCIL APPROVED
6:16:52PM TWO YEARS AGO.
6:16:53PM CAN YOU DO COMMERCIAL INTENSIVE USES?
6:16:54PM YOU CAN NOW AND YOU CAN DO THAT IF YOU APPROVE THIS.
6:16:57PM LIGHT MANUFACTURING STILL ALLOWED.
6:17:00PM IT'S ALLOWED TODAY.
6:17:01PM IT WOULD BE ALLOWED IN UMU 60.
6:17:04PM HEAVY MANUFACTURING, NOT EVEN LOSING THAT.
6:17:06PM HEAVY MANUFACTURING ISN'T ALLOWED IN THE LIGHT INDUSTRIAL
6:17:09PM ZONING CATEGORY.
6:17:10PM SO WE THINK THIS IS REALLY IDEAL BALANCE WITH VERY FEW
6:17:14PM DRAWBACKS, NOT A CHOICE THAT COUNCIL GETS OFTEN WHERE YOU
6:17:17PM ARE BRINGING PEOPLE INTO A NEIGHBORHOOD THAT PEOPLE WANT TO
6:17:19PM LIVE IN WHILE ALSO PRESERVING ALL OF THE NONRESIDENTIAL USES
6:17:23PM THAT ARE ALLOWED TODAY.
6:17:24PM GROUP 3, AS YOU NOTICE HERE, I WANT TO MAKE A COUPLE OF
6:17:29PM POINTS HERE.
6:17:30PM THIS IS NOT ON THE WATER.
6:17:31PM THIS LAND IS NOT ON THE WATER.
6:17:33PM IT DOES NOT HAVE DEEPWATER ACCESS.
6:17:35PM AS YOU CAN SEE AROUND, RMU 100 AND UMU 60 WHICH MIGHT BE A
6:17:39PM LITTLE SURPRISING.
6:17:40PM THAT'S BEEN LIKE THAT SINCE 2008.
6:17:42PM BACK IN 2008, THE ENTIRE NORTHERN TERMINUS OF THE YBOR
6:17:47PM CHANNEL, LAND USE WAS CHANGED ZONING CHANGED FROM RMU 100 ON
6:17:51PM THE WESTERN AND NORTHERN PORTIONS OF THE CHANNEL, UMU 60 ON
6:17:54PM THE EAST.
6:17:55PM THERE HAS NOT BEEN DEVELOPMENT SINCE THEN AS THIS COUNCIL
6:17:58PM PROBABLY OBSERVED.
6:17:59PM THE PORTION WE'RE TRYING TO CHANGE WASN'T INCLUDED IN THAT
6:18:02PM ORIGINAL MASTER PLAN.
6:18:03PM JUST THE WAY THE OWNERSHIP CIRCUMSTANCES WORKED OUT, IT JUST
6:18:06PM SIMPLY WASN'T INCLUDED.
6:18:07PM WE'RE SEEKING TO PULL THE UMU 60 THAT IS ALREADY THERE ON
6:18:11PM THE BORDER EASTERLY TO CREATE I THINK A MUCH CLEANER
6:18:15PM DIVISION, LINE OF DEMARCATION BETWEEN INDUSTRIAL AND MIXED
6:18:19PM USES AT 19th STREET.
6:18:21PM AS I MENTIONED, THE SURROUNDING CHANNEL PROPERTIES WERE
6:18:26PM ALREADY CHANGED TO MIXED USE BACK IN 2007.
6:18:31PM WE KNOW WHAT HAPPENED AFTER 2007, 2008 AND 2009, SORT OF WHY
6:18:36PM A PROLONGED PERIOD OF DORMANCY ON THIS PROJECT.
6:18:39PM ALSO MORE RECENTLY THIS COUNCIL HAS APPROVED SOME HEAVY
6:18:43PM INDUSTRIAL RMU 100 CHANGES ON THE WEST SIDE OF CHANNELSIDE
6:18:46PM DRIVE WHICH HAVE ALL BEEN APPROVED SINCE THEN WITH PDs FOR
6:18:50PM MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT.
6:18:51PM THERE'S ACTUALLY A SPECIFIC OBJECTIVE, NOT AS VAGUE AS A
6:18:56PM GOAL, BUT AN OBJECTIVE IN YOUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN TO PROMOTE
6:18:59PM THE REDEVELOPMENT OF THE CHANNEL DISTRICT.
6:19:01PM I THINK THERE'S BEEN PLENTY OF THAT WORKED ON IN THE YBOR
6:19:04PM CHANNEL AREA.
6:19:05PM THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT THIS COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT HAS
6:19:07PM BEEN FILED IN SERVICE OF.
6:19:10PM THIS VERY CLEAR OBJECTIVE TO PROMOTE REDEVELOPMENT OF THE
6:19:13PM YBOR CHANNEL AREA.
6:19:14PM THERE ARE MULTIPLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN POLICIES THAT THIS
6:19:18PM PROJECT EMBRACES, SUPPORTS.
6:19:20PM THAT IS WHY THE PLANNING COMMISSION, AFTER A VERY ROBUST
6:19:23PM DEBATE, WHICH WE MIGHT HAVE SHORTLY, FOUND THAT WHEN YOU
6:19:26PM BALANCE ALL THE FACTORS, HAVING RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT HERE
6:19:30PM THAT'S COMPATIBLE WITH THE MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN
6:19:32PM THAT'S BEEN EMERGING SINCE 2007, OUTWEIGHS OTHER CONCERNS
6:19:37PM THAT MIGHT BE PRESENT.
6:19:39PM AS I ALLUDED TO THIS EARLIER, IT'S A BIT OF A RAGGEDY LINE
6:19:45PM RIGHT NOW.
6:19:45PM I THINK APPROVING THIS CREATES A FAIRLY CLEAR BOUNDARY OF
6:19:48PM 19th STREET AS A BOUNDARY AS OPPOSED TO HAVING UMU 60 AND
6:19:52PM HEAVY INDUSTRIAL WHICH CAN ACCOMMODATE LAND FILLS AND ALL
6:19:54PM KINDS OF USES LITERALLY RIGHT NEXT TO EACH OTHER.
6:19:57PM THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT SLIDE THAT I'M GOING TO SHOW YOU
6:20:00PM AND I'M GOING TO NOT RUSH IT.
6:20:02PM THE ZONING CODE DIVIDES THE CITY INTO 23 ZONING DISTRICTS.
6:20:07PM THAT'S BEFORE WE GET TO SEMINOLE HEIGHTS AND YBOR, THE
6:20:09PM AIRPORT, THE PLACES THAT HAVE THEIR OWN SPECIAL DISTRICTS.
6:20:12PM ZONING CODE CHAPTER 27 DIVIDES THE WORLD IN THE CITY TO 23
6:20:17PM DISTRICTS.
6:20:17PM 147 USES.
6:20:20PM SOME OF THEM ARE VERY SPECIFIC.
6:20:21PM CREMATORIUM, BAKERY.
6:20:23PM THERE IS NOT A SINGLE USE IN THAT TABLE CALLED INDUSTRIAL.
6:20:27PM WHEN YOU CLOSE YOUR EYES AND YOU THINK ABOUT WHAT DOES
6:20:30PM INDUSTRIAL LOOKS LIKE, PROBABLY LOOKS LIKE SOME OF THE USES
6:20:33PM BOLDED AND UNDERLINED.
6:20:35PM LIGHT MANUFACTURING, WAREHOUSE, STORAGE, MAJOR VEHICLE
6:20:38PM REPAIR, MINOR VEHICLE REPAIR.
6:20:40PM ALL OF THOSE USES ARE ALLOWED IN THE URBAN MIXED USE 60
6:20:45PM CATEGORY.
6:20:46PM THE USES THAT -- THE REASON FOR THAT IS BECAUSE THEY ARE
6:20:49PM ALLOWED IN THE CI ZONING DISTRICT.
6:20:51PM ANY PROJECT THAT HAS UMU 60 LAND USE WHEN IT COMES TIME TO
6:20:56PM REZONING YOU SHOULD ASK, WHAT USES ARE YOU ALLOWING AND NOT
6:20:59PM ALLOWING.
6:21:01PM IN A ZONING SO I'M NOT GOING TO ADDRESS THAT NOW.
6:21:04PM THE USES YOU ARE LOSING THAT WOULD BE PROHIBITED IF THIS
6:21:06PM DOES GET APPROVED ARE IN RED.
6:21:11PM THOSE USES WE BELIEVE ARE EITHER NOT APPROPRIATE TO BE
6:21:15PM LOCATED NEXT TO A MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT OR THEY ARE NOT
6:21:18PM ECONOMICALLY FEASIBLE DUE TO THE AMOUNT OF LAND THAT THEY
6:21:22PM REQUIRE AND THE COST OF LAND IN THIS AREA AS A RESULT OF ALL
6:21:25PM THE MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT AROUND IT.
6:21:27PM I THINK THIS SLIDE SORT OF PAINTS THE CHOICE FAIRLY CLEARLY
6:21:34PM FOR YOU IN THAT YOU LOSE WHAT IS IN RED.
6:21:37PM YOU KEEP -- AND THAT'S NOT AN EXHAUSTIVE LIST, BY THE WAY,
6:21:40PM WHAT'S IN BLACK.
6:21:41PM THERE ARE A TON OF OTHER USES TOO.
6:21:44PM ALL THE USES THAT ARE ON-SITE NOW, THEY ARE STILL ALLOWED.
6:21:47PM EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM IS STILL ALLOWED, AND YOU GET THE
6:21:50PM OPPORTUNITY FOR PEOPLE TO CALL THIS AREA HOME.
6:21:53PM WANT TO TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE CHHA.
6:21:58PM THIS SITE IS AT THE VERY NORTHERN EDGE OF THE COASTAL HIGH
6:22:01PM HAZARD AREA.
6:22:02PM WITH ME HERE I HAVE KEITH GREMINGER WITH STANTEC, RANDY COEN
6:22:06PM WITH COEN AND COMPANY WHO CAN GO INTO AS MUCH DETAIL AS
6:22:11PM COUNCIL WOULD LIKE WITH ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING EVACUATION
6:22:12PM TIME, SHELTERS, FLORIDA BUILDING CODE, RESILIENCY, THINGS
6:22:16PM LIKE THAT.
6:22:16PM I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO TAKE A STEP BACK, WHY DO WE TALK
6:22:19PM ABOUT THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA AT ALL.
6:22:22PM BECAUSE IN 2012, FLORIDA LAW CHANGED AND REQUIRED COASTAL
6:22:25PM JURISDICTIONS TO ADOPT A COASTAL MANAGEMENT ELEMENT IN THEIR
6:22:29PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:22:30PM AND TO HAVE A COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA MAP.
6:22:34PM IF YOU READ THE STATUTE, THE REASON FOR THAT IS BECAUSE THEY
6:22:36PM WANTED TO MAKE SURE IF YOU PUT RESIDENTIAL USE IN A COASTAL
6:22:40PM HIGH HAZARD AREA THAT YOU HAD SUFFICIENT SHELTER SPACE.
6:22:44PM STATUTE REQUIRES THAT PROJECTS THAT DO PUT PEOPLE IN A
6:22:47PM COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA, WHICH, BY THE WAY, IT IS THE SAME
6:22:51PM THING AS THE EVACUATION ZONE A.
6:22:54PM FOLKS WHO HAVE TO EVACUATE WHEN THERE IS A CATEGORY ONE
6:22:56PM STORM, THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA IS.
6:23:00PM IT IS NOT A DIFFERENT THING.
6:23:01PM THAT'S WHAT IT IS.
6:23:02PM THE STATUTES REQUIRE THAT YOU MITIGATE YOUR SHELTER IMPACTS.
6:23:07PM AND YOUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN SAYS THAT, TOO, THAT IF YOU DO
6:23:10PM PUT RESIDENTIAL GROWTH IN THE COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA, THAT
6:23:13PM YOU HAVE TO MITIGATE YOUR SHELTER IMPACTS.
6:23:17PM WE CAN'T PUT CONDITIONS ON COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENTS.
6:23:19PM THERE'S NO SITE PLAN, NOTHING FOR US TO ATTACH TO.
6:23:23PM BUT YOUR CODE DOES ADDRESS THIS.
6:23:25PM YOUR CODE REQUIRES THAT REZONING REQUESTS IN A COASTAL
6:23:30PM PLANNING AREA REQUIRES, ISN'T OPTIONAL, ADHERES TO THE
6:23:34PM MITIGATION FORMULA THAT IS IN THE CODE.
6:23:37PM THAT IS THE MITIGATION THAT'S REQUIRED UNDER YOUR
6:23:40PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:23:41PM THAT'S THE MITIGATION THAT'S REQUIRED UNDER FLORIDA
6:23:43PM STATUTES, MORE IMPORTANTLY.
6:23:45PM AND THAT IS SOMETHING THAT IS NOT A -- CAN VOLUNTEER.
6:23:51PM INEVITABLE OBLIGATION THAT ANY PROJECT IN THE COASTAL HIGH
6:23:54PM HAZARD AREA WOULD HAVE.
6:23:55PM I WOULD NOTE THAT THE SITE IS IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING
6:23:57PM DISTRICT.
6:23:58PM I WOULD NOTE THAT THE SITE IS WITHIN THREE MILES OF THREE
6:24:01PM SHELTERS.
6:24:01PM TO THE EXTENT THAT COUNCIL IS LOOKING FOR A LIMITING
6:24:04PM PRINCIPLE TO COMPARE AN APPROVAL OF SOMETHING LIKE THIS WITH
6:24:08PM PROJECTS THAT ARE PERHAPS MORE CONTROVERSIAL IN THE COASTAL
6:24:11PM HIGH HAZARD AREA, I WOULD LOOK AT THINGS LIKE THAT.
6:24:14PM ALSO NOTEWORTHY THAT AS YOUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN EVOLVES,
6:24:19PM THERE IS ATTENTION TO HOW TO HANDLE THIS COASTAL MANAGEMENT
6:24:24PM ELEMENT BECAUSE THIS HAS COME UP ON MULTIPLE PROJECTS.
6:24:27PM WE THINK THAT THIS ONE BASED ON JUST THE LANGUAGE OF CHAPTER
6:24:30PM 27 IS AN APPROPRIATE PLACE TO PUT PEOPLE.
6:24:32PM IT'S ALREADY APPROVED FOR MIXED USE.
6:24:34PM WITH THAT, I'M GOING TO END EARLY.
6:24:36PM I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MIGHT HAVE ALONG WITH
6:24:39PM OUR EXPERTS.
6:24:40PM THANK YOU.
6:24:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
6:24:46PM >>BILL CARLSON: CAN YOU GO BACK TWO OR THREE SLIDES, PLEASE?
6:24:48PM THAT ONE.
6:24:49PM YOU KNOW MY CONCERN IS ENCROACHMENT IN THE MARITIME
6:24:54PM INDUSTRY.
6:24:55PM YOU HAVE EXPERIENCE IN THE MARITIME INDUSTRY.
6:24:57PM I KNOW YOU CARE ABOUT THAT AS WELL.
6:24:59PM THE PRIOR ZONING WAS APPROVED IN 2007 TO THE WEST AND NOW
6:25:05PM YOU JUST MADE THE ARGUMENT THAT NONE OF THESE THINGS TO THE
6:25:08PM RIGHT SHOULD BE NEXT TO THE HOUSING.
6:25:10PM BUT SEVERAL OF THESE THINGS ARE SOUTH OF THIS PROPERTY.
6:25:14PM NOW, YOU ALL ARE GOING FURTHER EAST AND YOU'RE GETTING CLOSE
6:25:22PM TO -- I FORGOT EXACTLY WHERE THE GATE IS DOWN THERE.
6:25:26PM THE PORT IS OUT OF LAND AND THE PORT IS A STRATEGIC ECONOMIC
6:25:30PM ENGINE.
6:25:31PM STRATEGIC IN THAT IT IS BRINGING IN PETROLEUM.
6:25:34PM THERE'S SOME MANUFACTURING THAT GOES ON THERE.
6:25:36PM MATERIAL RECOVERY.
6:25:37PM THERE'S RECYCLING.
6:25:38PM ALL OF THAT IS ESSENTIAL TO GET GOODS OUT OF HERE IF WE DO
6:25:41PM RECYCLING, CAN'T TAKE THE GOODS OUT OF HERE, THEN WE HAVE A
6:25:44PM PROBLEM OR IF WE HAVE TO PAY TO SHIP THEM TO MIAMI TO SHIP
6:25:48PM THEM OUT OF HERE IS WHAT USED TO HAPPEN.
6:25:50PM PEOPLE IN THE MARITIME INDUSTRY WANT TO PROTECT THE CRUISE
6:25:55PM TERMINALS EVEN THOUGH SOME FOLKS WANT TO GET RID OF THEM.
6:26:02PM THIS IS ONLY ONE OF THREE DEPORTER -- DEEPWATER CHANNELS.
6:26:05PM IF WE GET RID OF THE CRUISE TERMINALS, NEED TO REPLACE IT
6:26:09PM WITH SOMETHING ELSE.
6:26:10PM WE'RE NOT GOING TO GET ANY MORE LAND OR DEEPWATER CHANNELS.
6:26:14PM PEOPLE IN THE MARITIME WOULD LIKE TO REUSE THE BANANA DOCK.
6:26:18PM ALL OF THAT IS TO THE WEST.
6:26:19PM THE POINT IS, NOW SINCE ONE ZONING WAS DOWN, THE
6:26:23PM JUSTIFICATION, NOW THAT WE HAVE PEOPLE LIVING THERE, THEN WE
6:26:25PM SHOULD TAKE THESE THINGS OUT OF HERE.
6:26:27PM THE NEXT ARGUMENT IS GOING TO BE, WELL, WE SHOULD KEEP GOING
6:26:30PM FURTHER SOUTH ON THE PENINSULA AND GET RID OF -- AND THEN
6:26:33PM SUDDENLY WE SEVERELY WOUNDED OUR PORT.
6:26:35PM WHAT ASSURANCES CAN YOU GIVE THE MARITIME INDUSTRY OR OUR
6:26:41PM COMMUNITY IN GENERAL THAT THIS IS NOT GOING TO BE THE
6:26:43PM BEGINNING OF GETTING RID OF EVERYTHING ON THAT PENINSULA?
6:26:46PM SECOND, MAYBE THIS IS A ZONING THING, BUT PEOPLE MOVE NEXT
6:26:51PM TO AIRPORT AND THEN COMPLAIN ABOUT AIRPLANES.
6:26:54PM THEY MOVE IN CHANNEL DISTRICT, HARBOUR ISLAND, THEY COMPLAIN
6:26:56PM ABOUT THE UGLY NOISY STUFF ACROSS THE -- THAT IS ESSENTIAL
6:27:00PM TO OUR INDUSTRY HERE.
6:27:02PM WHAT DO WE DO TO MAKE SURE THAT AS MORE PEOPLE ARE MOVING IN
6:27:06PM HERE THAT THEY ARE NOT GOING TO COMPLAIN AND TRY TO FORCE TO
6:27:09PM US GET RID OF THAT IMPORTANT INDUSTRY THAT'S PAYING
6:27:12PM HIGH-PAYING BLUE COLLAR JOBS?
6:27:15PM >> THE PORT IS A CRITICAL ECONOMIC ENGINE FOR THIS ENTIRE
6:27:19PM REGION, NOT JUST THE CITY.
6:27:20PM THE ENTIRE REGION.
6:27:22PM WE'RE FOCUSING ON THE SEVEN ACRE PARCEL RIGHT HERE.
6:27:26PM CAN ANYONE COME IN AND ASK TO MOVE IT EAST AFTER THIS?
6:27:30PM MOVE IT SOUTH?
6:27:31PM TO THE SOUTH YOU HAVE PETROLEUM TRANSMISSION AND STORAGE
6:27:36PM EQUIPMENT THAT IS NEARLY IMPOSSIBLE TO IMAGINE THAT EVER
6:27:39PM MOVING DUE TO THE COST.
6:27:40PM I THINK 19th STREET RIGHT-OF-WAY ESTABLISHES MORE LOGICAL
6:27:44PM BOUNDARIES THAN TO HAVE AN INTERNALLY INCONSISTENT RAGGEDY
6:27:48PM SITE.
6:27:49PM I'M NOT SAYING THAT ANYONE, THAT NOBODY WOULD BE PROHIBITED
6:27:52PM FROM EVER COMING AND TRY TO SEEK THAT.
6:27:55PM I THINK IT WOULD BE AN EXCEPTIONALLY DIFFICULT ARGUMENT TO
6:27:58PM MAKE BECAUSE WHAT IS THIS FUTURE?
6:28:00PM IT IS RIGHT NEXT TO URBAN MIXED USE 60.
6:28:04PM IT'S ALREADY THERE.
6:28:05PM IT'S NOT ADJACENT.
6:28:06PM TO THE SOUTH -- FIRST OF ALL, I'D ALSO NOTE THAT THERE ARE
6:28:09PM OPPORTUNITIES THAT THIS COUNCIL HAS IN ITS LEGISLATIVE
6:28:12PM CAPACITY TO LOOK INTO MARITIME INDUSTRIAL CATEGORIES THAT
6:28:15PM COULD ADD FURTHER PROTECTION.
6:28:16PM BUT HERE, ALL WE'RE DOING IS GOING UP AGAINST THE
6:28:19PM RIGHT-OF-WAY, AND THIS HAS BEEN ON THE BOOKS FOR QUITE SOME
6:28:21PM TIME.
6:28:22PM WE TALKED TO THE PORT FOR A VERY LONG TIME.
6:28:25PM TALKED TO CHARLES PFLUG 90 MINUTES AGO.
6:28:28PM TALKED TO THE PORT BEFORE WE EVEN FILED THE APPLICATION.
6:28:31PM THEY ARE AWARE OF IT.
6:28:33PM FROM WHAT I UNDERSTAND, THEY ARE NOT OBJECTING.
6:28:35PM THEY ARE NOT TAKING A POSITION.
6:28:37PM THEY ARE CERTAINLY NOT HERE.
6:28:38PM IT'S OUR VIEW THAT ON THE BALANCE THE ABILITY TO ACCOMMODATE
6:28:43PM PEOPLE ON A SITE LIKE THIS IN A CITY THAT HAS A MATERIAL
6:28:48PM HOUSING SHORTAGE AND HAS A SIGNIFICANT SHORTAGE OF
6:28:51PM NEIGHBORHOODS THAT WANT TO EMBRACE SIGNIFICANT DENSIFICATION
6:28:54PM THAT ARE ON TRANSIT CORRIDORS THAT ARE NEXT TO A STREETCAR
6:28:59PM AND ARE NEXT TO MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT, THOSE OPPORTUNITIES
6:29:02PM ARE VERY, VERY FEW.
6:29:03PM I'M NOT SAYING THAT THE APPROVAL OF THIS IS WITHOUT ANY
6:29:07PM COST.
6:29:07PM IT'S OUR POSITION THAT IT IS WORTH THE COST BECAUSE THESE
6:29:10PM USES IN RED, CORRECTIONAL FACILITY, I DON'T BELIEVE ANYONE
6:29:13PM WANTS.
6:29:13PM MOTION PICTURE STUDIO, IF THAT BECAME AN OPPORTUNITY, THEN
6:29:16PM WE WOULD COME BACK HERE AND PROBABLY CHANGE THAT.
6:29:19PM BUT THOSE ARE VERY HORIZONTALLY INTENSIVE ENTERPRISES.
6:29:24PM THEY TAKE UP ENORMOUS BREADTH OF LAND AS DOES MANUFACTURING,
6:29:27PM MATERIAL RECOVERY, RECYCLING.
6:29:30PM DUE TO -- NOT DUE TO THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE COUNCIL BUT
6:29:33PM DUE TO CIRCUMSTANCES OF DEVELOPMENT AND HOW THE LAND USE HAS
6:29:37PM CHANGED, THE LAND IS TOO EXPENSIVE.
6:29:39PM >>BILL CARLSON: THE PORT IS IN A DIFFICULT SITUATION BECAUSE
6:29:43PM WHOEVER IS MAYOR IS ON THE PORT AUTHORITY BOARD.
6:29:45PM MANY OF US WORK TOGETHER TEN OR SO YEARS AGO TO GET MORE
6:29:48PM MARITIME PEOPLE ON THE BOARD.
6:29:49PM BUT AT LEAST THE LAST TWO MAYORS HAVE BEEN IN FAVOR OF
6:29:52PM GETTING RID OF THE PORT AND PUTTING CONDOS THERE.
6:29:56PM SO IF YOU'RE THE PORT DIRECTOR OR THE PORT, IT'S HARD UNLESS
6:30:00PM YOUR BOARD VOTES TO SPECIFICALLY SUPPORT SOMETHING.
6:30:03PM THE OTHER THING AS YOU KNOW THE PORT IS A LANDLORD PORT.
6:30:09PM ITS TENANTS RUN THE BUSINESSES FOR THE MOST PART.
6:30:12PM I DON'T KNOW IF ANY OF THEM CAME TONIGHT, BUT I THINK THERE
6:30:16PM ARE TENSIONS THERE BECAUSE OF POLITICS, NOT BECAUSE OF THIS
6:30:19PM PROJECT, BUT OTHERS.
6:30:21PM THE OTHER THING, YOU TALKED ABOUT THE PETROLEUM TO THE
6:30:24PM SOUTH, GOING BACK TO THAT SLIDE YOU JUST SHOWED, IS SOMEBODY
6:30:29PM GOING TO MAKE THE ARGUMENT THAT, WELL, WE EITHER SHOULDN'T
6:30:33PM BUILD WHAT YOU'RE PLANNING TO BUILD HERE BECAUSE OF THE
6:30:35PM PETROLEUM TO THE SOUTH OR IS SOMEBODY GOING TO MOVE INTO THE
6:30:37PM CONDO AND SAY, WELL, THAT'S UGLY AND DANGEROUS.
6:30:40PM WHAT HAPPENS IF A TERRORIST -- ALL THOSE ARGUMENTS, ARE WE
6:30:44PM GOING TO HAVE TO PAY A LOT OF MONEY TO GET RID OF IT BECAUSE
6:30:47PM PEOPLE ARE LIVING IN CONDOS NEXT TO IT?
6:30:50PM >> A COUPLE OF POINTS ON THAT.
6:30:51PM FIRST, I THINK HOW ANY LAND, ANY DEVELOPMENT ADDRESSES WHAT
6:30:55PM IS TO THE SOUTH IS THE SUBJECT OF THE ZONING AND I CAN'T
6:30:58PM SPEAK TO THAT.
6:30:59PM IF THIS GOES FORWARD, I PROMISE THAT WILL BE ADDRESSED.
6:31:02PM ON THE ISSUE ABOUT -- I DON'T REMEMBER A TON ABOUT TORTS IN
6:31:06PM LAW SCHOOL, BUT DEFINITELY -- I'M NOT A CONDO LITIGATOR, BUT
6:31:12PM I THINK SOMEONE WOULD HAVE AN EXCEEDINGLY DIFFICULT CASE
6:31:15PM ATTEMPTING TO SAY THAT BY MOVING TO A PLACE THAT OBVIOUSLY
6:31:17PM IS FULL OF MARINE INFRASTRUCTURE, WHICH A LOT OF PEOPLE
6:31:20PM LIKE, A LOT OF PEOPLE THINK THAT IS ATTRACTIVE, THAT FOR
6:31:23PM SOME REASON THAT WOULD MAKE THE PETROLEUM INTERESTS GO AWAY.
6:31:27PM I DON'T THINK THAT WOULD BE A GOOD ARGUMENT OR A WINNING
6:31:30PM ARGUMENT OR A REASON TO MAKE ANY DECISION TODAY BASED ON
6:31:33PM THIS SEVEN-ACRE PARCEL THAT'S BEFORE YOU.
6:31:35PM GO BACK TO THE DOCK CAM, I'D NOTE THAT THERE IS A
6:31:40PM SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF HEAVY INDUSTRIAL LAND USE LEFT.
6:31:45PM I WATCHED MULTIPLE TIMES MR. PFLUG'S APPEARANCE ON OCTOBER
6:31:51PM 23rd OF LAST YEAR.
6:31:52PM NO DOUBT THAT THERE ARE CONCERNS ABOUT LOSS OF INDUSTRIAL
6:31:55PM LAND.
6:31:55PM THIS IS A DEBATE WE SHOULD BE HAVING.
6:31:57PM THE REAL FOCUS WAS ON LOSS OF LAND THAT IS ON THE WATER.
6:32:01PM THAT IS VERY HARD TO REPRODUCE.
6:32:04PM THAT IS VERY BINARY EITHER-OR.
6:32:07PM WE'RE NOT PROPOSING TO CHANGE THE LAND USE OF ANYTHING THAT
6:32:11PM IS ON THE WATER.
6:32:12PM WE ARE PROPOSING TO ALLOW PEOPLE TO LIVE HERE IN THE CITY
6:32:21PM WITH A DIRE HOUSING SHORTAGE AND MORE THAN A DIRE HOUSING
6:32:24PM SHORTAGE, WE HAVE AN EVEN MORE DIRE SHORTAGE OF HOUSING
6:32:29PM THAT'S WALKABLE, THAT'S NEAR WHERE PEOPLE WANT TO LIVE OR
6:32:32PM PEOPLE LIVED IN AN OLD WAY PRIOR TO AUTOMOBILES WHERE YOU
6:32:35PM COULD WALK TO GET THINGS.
6:32:37PM IMAGINE THAT.
6:32:38PM THAT'S THE FAVORITE PART OF MOST PEOPLE'S VACATION, BEING AT
6:32:42PM A PLACE YOU CAN WALK TO THINGS.
6:32:43PM MOST WALKABLE AREAS IN THE CITY ARE OUT OF REACH FINANCIALLY
6:32:48PM FOR ALL BUT THE VERY FEW.
6:32:50PM BY CHANGING THE LAND USE TO ALLOW PEOPLE TO LIVE ON ADAMO
6:32:53PM DRIVE, A CORRIDOR THAT YOUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN FOR DECADES
6:32:56PM HAS TALKED ABOUT BEING A FOCUS OF REDEVELOPMENT, I BELIEVE
6:32:59PM THAT'S AN OPPORTUNITY THAT THIS COUNCIL SHOULD TAKE.
6:33:02PM I'M NOT SAYING IT'S NOT WITHOUT ANY COSTS.
6:33:05PM I'M NOT SAYING IT'S ABOUT ANY LOSS.
6:33:09PM THE LOSS ONLY OF THESE USES THAT YOU SEE ON YOUR SCREEN IN
6:33:13PM RED, I THINK IT'S JUSTIFIED.
6:33:16PM I THINK A LOT MORE QUESTIONS WOULD BE ANSWERED WHEN AND IF
6:33:18PM ANYONE GOES TO DEVELOP THIS PROPERTY THROUGH A ZONING, BUT
6:33:24PM THERE HAS BEEN A PATTERN GOING BACK 16 YEARS OF THIS AREA OF
6:33:28PM THE CHANNEL CHANGING, NOT ON THE EAST SIDE FURTHER SOUTH.
6:33:32PM THIS NORTHERN TERMINUS.
6:33:34PM BEFORE IT WAS THE YBOR CHANNEL, IT WAS YBOR ESTUARY.
6:33:37PM BEFORE YBOR ESTUARY, IT WAS JUST THE ESTUARY.
6:33:39PM MR. YBOR WAS STILL IN KEY WEST.
6:33:41PM THIS LAND HAS BEEN CHANGING FOR HUNDREDS OF YEARS.
6:33:44PM YOU'RE LOOKING AT A LITTLE PIECE OF THAT RIGHT NOW TONIGHT.
6:33:47PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION HAD THE SAME DEBATE.
6:33:53PM SAME BALANCE.
6:33:55PM YOU ARE IN AN UNENVIABLE POSITION UP THERE.
6:34:00PM IT IS OUR BELIEF, THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S BELIEF AND
6:34:02PM BELIEVE THE COMMUNITY'S BELIEF BASED ON OUR UNDERSTANDING
6:34:05PM THAT IT IS WORTH IT.
6:34:06PM IT IS A FAIR TRADE-OFF TO LET PEOPLE LIVE HERE, KEEP AN
6:34:10PM ENTIRE RANGE OF COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL USES, THESE ARE
6:34:13PM INDUSTRIAL USES, AT THE LOSS OF THE RED USES ON SCREEN.
6:34:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:34:23PM ANYBODY ELSE?
6:34:23PM WE'LL GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT.
6:34:25PM I HAVE ONE REGISTERED PUBLIC COMMENT SPEAKER.
6:34:27PM JIN.
6:34:27PM J-I-N.
6:34:36PM WE DON'T HAVE A JIN ONLINE.
6:34:39PM WE'LL GO TO IN-PERSON PUBLIC COMMENT.
6:34:42PM COME ON UP AND STATE YOUR NAME.
6:34:44PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME, SIR.
6:34:48PM YOU'LL HAVE THREE MINUTES.
6:34:49PM >> MY NAME IS TIM SCHUSTER.
6:34:51PM 777 NORTH ASHLEY DRIVE, UNIT 812.
6:34:55PM DOWNTOWN HERE.
6:34:56PM I MOVED TO TAMPA IN 1980, BEGAN PRACTICING LAW HERE IN 1984.
6:35:02PM ADMIRALTY ATTORNEY, MARITIME LAW ATTORNEY.
6:35:06PM SPENT MY ENTIRE CAREER PROMOTING COMMERCE AND BUSINESS IN
6:35:08PM THE PORT OF TAMPA.
6:35:10PM I THINK THERE IS A VERY SIMPLE WAY TO LOOK AT THIS.
6:35:12PM THE AREA YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT, NOTWITHSTANDING THE FACT THAT
6:35:16PM SOME OF THE ZONING WAS CHANGED BACK IN 2007, IS WITHIN
6:35:20PM WHAT'S KNOWN AS THE PORT ACTIVITY DISTRICT.
6:35:24PM AND AS COMMISSIONER CARLSON NOTED, IT'S ALSO ON A DEEPWATER
6:35:30PM CHANNEL.
6:35:31PM I THINK QUIBBLING SAY THIS PIECE OVER HERE DOESN'T COME UP
6:35:35PM TO THE WATER.
6:35:37PM IF YOU ALLOW RESIDENTIAL USES DOWN THERE THAT GO AROUND THE
6:35:42PM CORNER, UP TO THE PETROLEUM TERMINALS, I THINK THAT'S A
6:35:45PM PROBLEM.
6:35:46PM AND I THINK WHAT PEOPLE FORGET ABOUT IS TO KEEP OUR
6:35:50PM INDUSTRIAL AREAS, WE SHOULD HAVE BUFFER ZONES BETWEEN THE
6:35:54PM RESIDENTIAL AREAS OR SOME OF THESE OTHER USES AND THE
6:35:58PM INDUSTRIAL AREA.
6:35:59PM SO WE SHOULD KEEP THIS AREA AS PORT ACTIVITY, MARITIME
6:36:04PM ACTIVITY AREA.
6:36:06PM AND THE CROSSTOWN EXPRESSWAY PROVIDES A NATURAL BARRIER, A
6:36:11PM NATURAL BUFFER ZONE.
6:36:12PM WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THE AREA ON THE NORTH SIDE OF ADAMO
6:36:16PM DRIVE I THINK IS PERFECTLY ACCEPTABLE FOR WHAT -- FOR
6:36:20PM REDEVELOPMENT.
6:36:21PM THIS AREA AROUND THE END OF THE CHANNEL I THINK SHOULD BE
6:36:25PM KEPT AS PORT ACTIVITY AREA BECAUSE WE HAVE SEEN TIME AND
6:36:30PM TIME AGAIN THAT ONCE YOU MOVE RESIDENTIAL INTO THE
6:36:33PM INDUSTRIAL AREA, THERE ARE COMPLAINTS.
6:36:37PM EARLY IN MY CAREER I SPENT A LOT OF TIME DEFENDING MARITIME
6:36:41PM COMPANIES ALONG THE CHANNEL ACROSS FROM DAVIS ISLAND AND
6:36:45PM THEN HARBOUR ISLAND, COMPLAINING ABOUT INDUSTRIAL USES
6:36:49PM ACROSS THE WAY.
6:36:50PM NOISE FROM THE SHIPYARD.
6:36:53PM SMELLS FROM THE SHIPYARD.
6:36:54PM PAINT SPRAY FROM THE SHIPYARD, THINGS LIKE THAT.
6:36:58PM SO I THINK THERE IS AN EASY WAY TO LOOK AT IT.
6:37:02PM PRESERVE OUR PORT AREA.
6:37:03PM LOOK AT THE HIGHEST AND BEST USE OF OUR DEEPWATER CHANNELS
6:37:08PM AND REMEMBER THAT YOU NEED A BUFFER ZONE AND THIS IS A
6:37:11PM NATURAL BUFFER ZONE FROM THE DEVELOPMENT THAT IS NATURALLY
6:37:15PM GOING TO TAKE PLACE ON THE OTHER SIDE OF ADAMO DRIVE.
6:37:18PM THANK YOU.
6:37:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
6:37:20PM ANYBODY ELSE THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM?
6:37:22PM YES, SIR.
6:37:23PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:37:32PM >> KEN STOLTENBERG.
6:37:33PM GOOD EVENING, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN.
6:37:34PM TWICE IN ONE DAY.
6:37:35PM DOESN'T HAPPEN OFTEN.
6:37:36PM I WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THIS PROJECT.
6:37:41PM I AM VERY UNDERSTANDING OF EVERYTHING THAT EVERYBODY JUST
6:37:44PM SAID AS FAR AS PROTECTING THE PORT.
6:37:46PM LET ME PROVIDE YOU SOME INTERESTING PERSPECTIVE.
6:37:48PM I LIVED IN THE CHANNEL DISTRICT IN 2007.
6:37:51PM AND I LIVED ON CHANNELSIDE DRIVE AT 1000 CHANNELSIDE DRIVE.
6:37:56PM I WITNESSED EVERYTHING GOING ON THE PORT 24 HOURS A DAY.
6:38:01PM WHAT I FOUND WAS EVERYTHING GOING ON TO THE EAST WAS NOT IN
6:38:06PM ANY WAY OFFENSIVE TO A RESIDENT.
6:38:10PM I WAS A RESIDENT.
6:38:11PM I CAN TELL YOU THE FLOUR MILL MADE A LOT MORE NOISE AND
6:38:15PM CAUSED A LOT MORE PROBLEMS THAN ANYTHING GOING ON AT THE
6:38:17PM PORT, AND I HAVE LIVED IN THE CHANNEL DISTRICT FOR SEVEN
6:38:21PM YEARS.
6:38:21PM I THINK THAT THE NEED FOR HOUSING IN OUR COMMUNITY OUTWEIGHS
6:38:27PM ANY OF THE ARGUMENTS THAT ARE LEGITIMATE AND COULD BE MADE
6:38:32PM FOR AN INFRINGEMENT UPON THE PORT AND OUR MARITIME
6:38:37PM BUSINESSES.
6:38:37PM I LOVE THE PORT.
6:38:38PM I WANT THE CRUISE SHIPS TO ALWAYS BE THERE FOR AS LONG AS
6:38:41PM THEY WANT TO BE THERE.
6:38:42PM THE FACT THAT THE CHANNEL DISTRICT HAS BECOME WHAT IT'S
6:38:46PM BECOME, IT MIXES INDUSTRY.
6:38:47PM IT MIXES THE CRUISE SHIPS AND IT MIXES NOW A NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:38:51PM IF YOU LOOK AT ROTTERDAM, YOU SEE THE SAME THING.
6:38:54PM THERE WAS NO ROTTERDAM IN 1946 BECAUSE THE NAZIS DESTROYED
6:38:59PM IT.
6:38:59PM I HAVE BEEN BACK THERE.
6:39:02PM YOU SEE A CITY WHERE HEAVY INDUSTRIAL USES WITH ONE OF THE
6:39:07PM LARGEST PORTS IN EUROPE WORKED VERY WELL WITH A VIBRANT,
6:39:13PM VERY DENSE URBAN RESIDENTIAL AREA.
6:39:16PM I THINK THAT THE ARGUMENT THAT THESE TWO USES CAN'T COEXIST
6:39:21PM IS A FALSE NARRATIVE.
6:39:23PM IF WE LOOK AT THE AREAS IN THE CITY WHERE YOU CAN HAVE URBAN
6:39:30PM DENSITY AND WALKABILITY, THIS CHECKS ALL THE BOXES.
6:39:34PM AND IF WE CAN'T OR WE CHOOSE NOT TO MAKE TRADEOFFS TO HAVE
6:39:40PM THAT HAPPEN, WE WON'T HAVE GOOD PROBLEMS.
6:39:46PM WE'LL HAVE BAD PROBLEMS.
6:39:47PM I WOULD MUCH RATHER DEAL WITH GOOD PROBLEMS.
6:39:49PM I THINK THIS IS ONE OF THOSE THINGS.
6:39:51PM WHILE I UNDERSTAND PERHAPS THE HESITANCY OF SOME OF YOU TO
6:39:56PM DO THIS, MOST OF THE PROPERTY WAS REZONED IN 2007.
6:40:00PM I WAS HERE WHEN GIBRALTAR CAME IN.
6:40:03PM THEIR TIMING WAS TERRIBLE.
6:40:05PM BUT I DON'T THINK THAT BY CHANGING THE USE HERE IT'S GOING
6:40:09PM TO IMPACT THE PORT IN A VERY DETRIMENTAL WAY.
6:40:12PM I DON'T THINK ANYBODY WANTS TO SEE THAT.
6:40:14PM WE LOVE LIVING IN THE CHANNEL DISTRICT.
6:40:16PM I'VE BEEN DOING IT FOR YEARS AND WE LOVE THE PORT BEING WHAT
6:40:19PM IT IS.
6:40:19PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:40:20PM HAVE A GOOD EVENING.
6:40:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
6:40:22PM ANYBODY ELSE?
6:40:22PM SIR, COME ON UP.
6:40:24PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:40:25PM ANYBODY ELSE THAT WISHES TO SPEAK, JUST LINE UP AGAINST THE
6:40:30PM WALL.
6:40:30PM IF NOT, SIR, YOU'LL BE THE LAST PERSON.
6:40:33PM GO AHEAD.
6:40:34PM >> GOOD EVENING.
6:40:34PM MY NAME IS CAPTAIN JOHN TIMMEL.
6:40:37PM ADDRESS IS 3013 WEST HAWTHORNE ROAD.
6:40:39PM I'M HERE AS A PORT -- FORMER PORT COMMUNITY MEMBER.
6:40:47PM I JUST RECENTLY RETIRED A YEAR AND A HALF, TWO YEARS AGO
6:40:50PM AFTER 32 YEARS AS A TAMPA BAY HARBOR PILOT.
6:40:54PM THE LAST FIVE YEARS AS SENIOR PILOT.
6:40:57PM I'VE BEEN VERY ACTIVE IN THE PORT COMMUNITY.
6:40:59PM I WAS THE FOUNDER OF THE AMERICAN VICTORY SHIP.
6:41:03PM STARTED A MARITIME SCHOOL, GULF COAST MARITIME ACADEMY.
6:41:07PM I PUT ON THE STONE CRAB FEST EVERY YEAR IF ANY OF YOU ARE
6:41:11PM FAMILIAR WITH THAT.
6:41:12PM I TELL YOU THESE THINGS BECAUSE I AM WITHIN THE COMMUNITY,
6:41:17PM AND I HAVE TWO TONS THAT ARE NOW PRESENTLY WORKING AS HARBOR
6:41:21PM PILOTS AS WELL.
6:41:23PM I'M HERE TO SUPPORT THE PROJECT AND ALSO IN ADDITION, THE
6:41:30PM YBOR HARBOR PROJECT.
6:41:33PM THE REASON WHY IS THAT IF WE LOOK AT ANY MAJOR PORT, CITY OF
6:41:38PM TAMPA I DON'T THINK I HAVE TO TELL ANYBODY IS A PORT CITY.
6:41:42PM IT WAS BORN AS A PORT CITY AND IT'S GROWN, AND WE'VE HAD
6:41:45PM ENVIABLE GROWTH BOTH WITHIN THE CITY AND ALSO WITHIN THE
6:41:51PM PORT.
6:41:52PM THEY PARALLELLED AND SORT OF HOPSCOTCHED.
6:41:55PM BOTH COMMUNITIES ARE SWELLING, AND THEY ARE BUMPING INTO
6:41:59PM EACH OTHER.
6:41:59PM I THINK THIS USE MAKES A LOT OF SENSE.
6:42:03PM LOOK AT MANHATTAN ISLAND.
6:42:05PM IN THE '40s YOU HAD BERTHS ALL THE WAY AROUND IT.
6:42:09PM SAME THING IN SAN FRANCISCO, BALTIMORE HARBOR, AND NOW TAMPA
6:42:14PM AS WELL.
6:42:14PM WHERE THE CONVENTION CENTER SITS, USED TO BE DOCKS.
6:42:20PM ALL OF HARBOUR ISLAND USED TO BE SEDDON ISLAND, WAS ALL
6:42:26PM PHOSPHATE TERMINALS.
6:42:27PM THIS IS A NORMAL PROGRESSION.
6:42:28PM IT'S NOT BAD.
6:42:29PM IT'S NOT A TERRIBLE THING, AND THERE ARE A COUPLE OF OTHER
6:42:35PM THINGS THAT YOU HAVE TO UNDERSTAND, I THINK, ONE IS THAT IT
6:42:38PM IS INEVITABLE.
6:42:39PM THE CITY IS GOING TO GROW, AND WE ARE IN A GOOD SPOT BECAUSE
6:42:43PM THERE ARE SOME ALTERNATIVE PLACES.
6:42:45PM THE SHIPYARD -- THERE ARE TWO OTHER SHIPYARDS.
6:42:49PM THE SHIPYARD AT THE NORTH END OF YBOR CHANNEL CAN BE
6:42:53PM ABSORBED BY THE OTHER TWO SHIPYARDS AND ALSO DISCUSSION OF
6:42:58PM PUTTING IT IN ANOTHER PLACE.
6:43:00PM THIRDLY, I THINK WE HAVE TO LOOK AT THE GROUP THAT'S
6:43:07PM MANAGING THESE PROJECTS.
6:43:10PM AND THE FACT THAT DARRYL SHAW IS THE LOCAL INDIVIDUAL WHO
6:43:17PM HAS A GREAT PASSION AND LOVE FOR TAMPA, IT'S HIS HOME, AND
6:43:21PM HE UNDERSTANDS ITS HISTORY AND TRADITION.
6:43:25PM WE'VE MET WITH ALL OF THE PORT -- ALL OF THE TERMINAL
6:43:30PM OPERATORS AND OWNERS ON YBOR CHANNEL, AND EVERY ONE OF THEM
6:43:35PM HAS BEEN SUPPORTIVE OF AT LEAST THE YBOR HARBOR PROJECT.
6:43:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
6:43:41PM >> I THINK IT IS A GOOD OPPORTUNITY FOR THE CITY.
6:43:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD, SIR.
6:43:45PM >>BILL CARLSON: I WANT TO ASK YOU A QUESTION.
6:43:47PM I KNOW YOU ARE LIKE THE GODFATHER OF THE PILOTS LIKE YOU
6:43:51PM SAID.
6:43:53PM IN YOUR PROFESSIONAL OPINION WITH ALL YOUR EXPERIENCE, ARE
6:43:57PM YOU SAYING THAT THIS PROJECT OR THIS APPROVAL WOULD NOT
6:44:01PM IMPACT NAVIGATION OF THAT DEEP WATER CHANNEL?
6:44:05PM >> I WOULD SAY IT WOULD ABSOLUTELY NOT IMPACT THE
6:44:07PM NAVIGABILITY CAPACITY OF THAT CHANNEL.
6:44:10PM AND THE NICE THING IS, YES, YOU HAVE SOME TERMINALS DOWN THE
6:44:14PM EAST SIDE OF YBOR CHANNEL, BUT THE SHIPYARD IS AT THE END OF
6:44:20PM IT.
6:44:21PM SO IT WILL HAVE CRUISE SHIPS ON ONE SIDE AND THEN THERE IS A
6:44:25PM BIT OF A BUFFER AND THEN AN OIL TERMINAL. IN TERMS OF
6:44:33PM BRINGING SHIPS UP AND DOWN THE CHANNEL IT WILL HAVE NO
6:44:35PM IMPACT WHATSOEVER.
6:44:37PM >>BILL CARLSON: THANK YOU, SIR.
6:44:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:44:38PM NEXT SPEAKER.
6:44:39PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:44:41PM >> JOE ROBINSON.
6:44:44PM I WASN'T GOING TO GET UP ON THIS ONE.
6:44:46PM BUT WHEN I HEAR ABOUT HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES, AND I REMEMBER
6:44:51PM WHEN HENRY B. PLANT CAME IN IN THE 1800s, RIGHT, CHARLIE?
6:44:56PM ALL OF HILLSBOROUGH RIVER WAS INDUSTRIAL WITH SHIPPING FOR
6:45:03PM LUMBER AND RAIL ALL UP AND DOWN. YOU WOULDN'T HAVE CURTIS
6:45:10PM HIXON CONVENTION CENTER.
6:45:11PM IT WAS ALL HEAVY INDUSTRIAL BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT THE TIMES
6:45:15PM WERE.
6:45:17PM THINGS CHANGE.
6:45:19PM NEW YOUNG PEOPLE, EVER BEEN TO BALTIMORE HARBOR, THEY LIKE
6:45:24PM THAT STUFF.
6:45:25PM THEY LIKE TO HEAR THE SHIP, UNNNNN ..., THEY LIKE TO HEAR
6:45:32PM THAT ... UNNNN, SOME PEOPLE DOWNTOWN COMPLAINING ABOUT THE
6:45:36PM TRAIN RUNNING DOWN THERE.
6:45:38PM THE CITY HAD TO PAY A LOT OF MONEY TO GET THE RIGHT-OF-WAY
6:45:40PM ABOVE THE MUSEUM OF ART.
6:45:41PM SO THINGS CHANGE.
6:45:44PM WHAT IMPRESSED ME WITH THIS WAS THIS MATERIAL HOUSING
6:45:48PM SHORTAGE.
6:45:48PM NOW THAT IS A GOOD ONE.
6:45:50PM MATERIAL HOUSING SHORTAGE.
6:45:52PM PRECEDENT BEEN MADE.
6:45:59PM PROBABLY HEAR THAT LATER ON TONIGHT ON TWO OTHER ITEMS.
6:46:01PM BARRIO LATINO, THEY AIN'T GOT NO PROBLEM WITH IT.
6:46:06PM I DON'T SEE NOBODY DOWN HERE FROM THE PORT AUTHORITY TALKING
6:46:08PM ABOUT THEY DON'T WANT IT.
6:46:11PM PORT AUTHORITY TALKING ABOUT THEY WANT TO DO $2.3 BILLION
6:46:14PM DEVELOPMENT DOWN THERE THEMSELVES.
6:46:16PM SO THEY ARE LIKING THIS.
6:46:17PM THEY JUST WANT SOMEBODY ELSE TO SPEND THE MONEY TO MAKE IT
6:46:20PM START.
6:46:20PM TRANSIT EMPHASIS CORRIDOR.
6:46:25PM COME ON, MAN.
6:46:26PM THESE GUYS ARE TRYING TO DO THE HOOKUP THE RIGHT WAY.
6:46:30PM THE LAST TIME YBOR CHANNEL, THAT'S WHEN USED TO HAVE TWO
6:46:35PM INVASIONS, YBOR PIRATES INVASION AND GASPARILLA INVASION.
6:46:39PM HAVE TWO OF THEM.
6:46:40PM LISTEN, THINGS ARE CHANGING.
6:46:44PM HEAVY INDUSTRIAL IS MOVING FURTHER SOUTH, ALMOST TO RUSKIN
6:46:48PM SOMEWHERE. HOWARD CURREN, THE WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT,
6:46:54PM PLENTY OF LAND OVER THERE.
6:46:56PM BUT THIS IS NOT CHANGING EVERY USE THAT'S ALREADY BEING
6:47:01PM ALLOWED.
6:47:01PM THE MAN GOT -- ABOUT WHAT WON'T BE ALLOWED.
6:47:06PM IDENTIFYING THINGS THAT CAN STILL BE DONE.
6:47:10PM TO ME IT IS A SITUATION AND HE SAID IF WE GO FORWARD WITH
6:47:14PM THE OTHER ITEMS, COASTAL HIGH HAZARD AREA, BASICALLY ZONE A,
6:47:20PM HAVE TO HAVE SHELTERS.
6:47:22PM THAT'S ALL GOING TO BE TAKEN CARE OF.
6:47:25PM IT TO ME IS LIKE A NO-BRAINER.
6:47:27PM IF WE'RE GOING TO BE THE NEXT CITY GOING FORWARD AND WE'RE
6:47:31PM TALKING ABOUT THIS SO-CALLED MATERIAL HOUSING SHORTAGE,
6:47:36PM HEARD MATERIAL HOUSING SHORTAGE, THIS OPPORTUNITY PUTS
6:47:39PM HOUSING OUT THERE FOR SOME YOUNG FOLKS TO COME DOWN HERE FOR
6:47:43PM US TO GET SOME OF THE YOUNG PEOPLE TO WORK IN THE MARITIME
6:47:46PM INDUSTRY, I'M ALL FOR IT.
6:47:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. LEON, ARE YOU THE LAST SPEAKER?
6:47:50PM GO AHEAD, SIR.
6:47:54PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:47:55PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL, CHRISTIAN LEON.
6:47:58PM 2010 EAST PALM AVENUE.
6:48:00PM I JUST WANT TO SPEAK IN FAVOR OF THIS.
6:48:03PM I KNOW THE UPCOMING ITEM ALSO, YBOR HARBOR, BUT I DO THINK
6:48:08PM IT'S IMPORTANT TO KEEP IN MIND OTHER PLACES IN THE WORLD
6:48:13PM WHERE WE DO SEE RESIDENTIAL IN THIS TYPE OF INDUSTRIAL PORT
6:48:17PM ACTIVITY OCCUR SUCCESSFULLY.
6:48:20PM I KNOW ONE OF MY FAVORITE CITIES IN THE WORLD IS VANCOUVER,
6:48:24PM CANADA.
6:48:25PM I DON'T KNOW IF ANYONE HAS BEEN.
6:48:27PM I HIGHLY -- IT'S JUST BEAUTIFUL.
6:48:29PM BUT THERE'S SO MUCH BEAUTIFUL USE OF THE WATERWAY.
6:48:33PM I THINK THAT THIS PROJECT AND THE YBOR HARBOR PROJECT BOTH
6:48:37PM BRING MORE PEOPLE AND MORE ATTENTION DOWN TO THE RIVERWALK,
6:48:42PM EXTENSION OF THE RIVERWALK, AND I THINK THAT THE VISION OF
6:48:46PM HAVING DOWNTOWN CHANNELSIDE, GASWORX, YBOR, ALL CONNECTED
6:48:51PM AND HAVING PEOPLE FLOAT AROUND THAT IS SO IMPORTANT FOR OUR
6:48:55PM CITY MOVING FORWARD.
6:48:56PM WE DO, UNFORTUNATELY, HAVE A LACK OF PUBLIC SPACE, AND I
6:48:59PM THINK THAT BEFORE THE CITY WAS PLANNED IN A WAY,
6:49:05PM UNFORTUNATELY, THAT KEPT PEOPLE OR MADE AREAS THAT SHOULD BE
6:49:09PM PUBLIC SPACE PRIVATE, AND I THINK THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO
6:49:12PM BRING MORE PEOPLE AND GIVE MORE PEOPLE A REASON TO COME DOWN
6:49:16PM AND ENJOY THIS PART OF OUR CITY.
6:49:18PM I WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN FAVOR.
6:49:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
6:49:22PM ALL RIGHT.
6:49:23PM REBUTTAL.
6:49:31PM >> TYLER HUDSON.
6:49:33PM 400 NORTH ASHLEY DRIVE, FOR THE RECORD.
6:49:35PM I THINK IT'S ALL BEEN SAID.
6:49:36PM I WANT TO BE RESPECTFUL TO MY FELLOW TRAVELERS ON TONIGHT'S
6:49:42PM AGENDA.
6:49:42PM YOU HAVE A FRONT ROW SEAT TO WHAT IS PROBABLY ONE OF THE
6:49:44PM MOST EXCITING TIMES IN THE HISTORY OF THE CITY.
6:49:48PM YOU ARE FORCED EVERY TIME UP THERE TO MAKE TRADEOFFS.
6:49:51PM SOME ARE DIFFICULT.
6:49:52PM SOME ARE EASIER.
6:49:53PM SOMETIMES A SEVEN ACRE PIECE OF LAND CAN BRING UP BIG
6:49:57PM DISCUSSIONS.
6:49:58PM FOCUS ON THIS ONE PIECE OF LAND HERE.
6:50:00PM IN OUR VIEW AND THE TESTIMONY YOU'VE HEARD, TESTIMONY IN THE
6:50:03PM REPORTS BEFORE YOU, IT IS WORTH IT TO MAKE THIS CHANGE TO
6:50:06PM ALLOW IT TO BE A HOME FOR SOME PEOPLE GIVEN WHAT IT'S GOING
6:50:10PM TO PRESERVE FOR NONRESIDENTIAL USE, IT IS WORTH IT.
6:50:14PM I BELIEVE THERE'S AMPLE COMMUNITY SUPPORT FOR IT AND WE ASK
6:50:17PM THAT YOU APPROVE THIS ITEM.
6:50:18PM I THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND YOUR PATIENCE.
6:50:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:50:22PM ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS?
6:50:23PM IF NOT, I'LL ASK FOR A MOTION TO CLOSE.
6:50:26PM MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
6:50:27PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
6:50:29PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:50:30PM AYE.
6:50:31PM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA, WOULD YOU MIND READING ITEM NUMBER
6:50:33PM 2?
6:50:33PM WAIT.
6:50:35PM YOU WANT TO DISCUSS IT.
6:50:36PM GO AHEAD.
6:50:37PM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN AND COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK AND COUNCIL
6:50:40PM MEMBER CARLSON.
6:50:41PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ONE, EXCELLENT PRESENTATION.
6:50:44PM I THINK THIS IS REALLY IMPORTANT TO EMPHASIZE WHAT THE
6:50:48PM APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE JUST SAID.
6:50:50PM THIS IS AN EXCITING TIME FOR THE CITY OF TAMPA.
6:50:53PM I THINK MORE SO THAN EVER BEFORE WE'RE ON THE NEXUS OF SOME
6:50:58PM REALLY GREAT THINGS HAPPENING IN THIS CITY.
6:51:00PM THE TRANSFORMATION IS, I THINK PEOPLE WILL BE IN AWE OF SOME
6:51:06PM OF THE CHANGES.
6:51:07PM WHAT I'M LOOKING AT HERE, WE HAVE THE LAND USE ISSUE BEFORE
6:51:12PM US TODAY AND OTHER THINGS COMING UP NEXT.
6:51:16PM THIS IS THE FIRST STEP IN PART OF THAT BECAUSE THE CITY IS
6:51:20PM EVOLVING AND WE HAVE TO MAKE SMART DECISIONS ABOUT WHAT THE
6:51:23PM CITY WILL LOOK LIKE.
6:51:24PM ACCOMMODATE GROWTH AND REALLY MAKE THIS INTO THIS
6:51:28PM WORLD-CLASS CITY THAT I THINK WE'RE ALL KIND OF ENVISIONED.
6:51:32PM AS PEOPLE LOOK AT TAMPA, THERE WAS A TIME THAT PEOPLE LOOKED
6:51:34PM AT TAMPA AND THEY DIDN'T CONSIDER US IN THAT TIER OF CITIES.
6:51:37PM BUT WE ALL KNOW THAT WE'RE LIVING IN A JEWEL, AND I THINK
6:51:41PM WHEN WE LOOK BACK 15, 20 YEARS FROM NOW AND THIS IS ALL
6:51:45PM BUILT OUT, THIS IS GOING TO BE ONE OF THE AREAS PEOPLE LOOK
6:51:48PM AT WITH PRIDE AND THINK THAT THIS IS THE BEGINNING OF SOME
6:51:53PM GREAT THINGS AND IT'S GOING TO CONNECT WHAT'S HAPPENING IN
6:51:56PM CHANNELSIDE AND GASWORX AND HISTORIC YBOR.
6:52:02PM THINGS ARE STARTING TO COME TOGETHER.
6:52:03PM AND THAT'S WHAT WE'RE SEEING HERE.
6:52:05PM YOU SAW THAT IN THE LAND USE.
6:52:06PM THESE LAND USE CHANGES BLENDING SO THAT WE HAVE WHAT LOOKS
6:52:11PM LIKE A COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:52:14PM LOOKS LIKE A PLAN OF HOW YOU WOULD DEVELOP AN AREA.
6:52:17PM I THINK THAT'S PART OF WHAT HAS BEEN MISSING IN OUR
6:52:20PM HODGEPODGE OF OTHER THINGS.
6:52:22PM I'M EXCITED ABOUT IT.
6:52:23PM I'M GOING TO SUPPORT IT, OF COURSE.
6:52:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK AND CARLSON.
6:52:26PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I THINK IT'S INTERESTING AS YOU CALL IT THE
6:52:30PM BEGINNING OF WHAT'S COMING.
6:52:31PM I DEBATED THIS FOR A REALLY LONG TIME BUT THE GENTLEMAN WHO
6:52:36PM SPOKE REALLY CLARIFIED IT FOR ME.
6:52:38PM I ACTUALLY THINK IT IS THE OPPOSITE.
6:52:39PM I THINK IT IS THE BEGINNING OF THE END OF THE PORT.
6:52:42PM I THINK THIS WILL NOT BE THE STOP OF IT.
6:52:44PM I THINK THERE IS A NATURAL BUFFER OF SELMON.
6:52:47PM THERE IS A NATURAL BUFFER OF CHANNELSIDE DRIVE.
6:52:51PM WE HAVE THE INDUSTRIAL USE OF THAT SHIPYARD WHICH IS
6:52:55PM PROBABLY ONE OF MY FAVORITE THINGS IN THE CITY OF TAMPA
6:52:57PM DRIVING BY THAT SHIPYARD.
6:52:59PM I HAVE A DEEP AFFINITY FOR CONTAINER SHIPS, ANYBODY WHO
6:53:04PM KNOWS ME, BEEN NEAR ME AT THE PORT.
6:53:07PM BUT WE HAVE THREE DEEPWATER CHANNELS AND WE'RE TAKING HALF
6:53:10PM OF A DEEPWATER CHANNEL AWAY AND WE'RE GOING TO PUT LIKE
6:53:13PM SAILBOATS OR SOMETHING?
6:53:15PM I REALLY RESPECT WHAT THE DEVELOPER AND HIS COLLEAGUES DO.
6:53:27PM I JUST DON'T THINK THIS IS THE RIGHT PART, THE RIGHT SPACE
6:53:31PM FOR IT.
6:53:31PM I ALSO HAVE MAJOR SAFETY CONCERNS WITH THE GASOLINE TANKS
6:53:36PM THAT ARE RIGHT THERE.
6:53:37PM I THINK THAT'S VERY DANGEROUS.
6:53:40PM I DON'T WANT TO BE THE PERSON THAT'S RESPONSIBLE FOR THAT
6:53:43PM GOING FORWARD.
6:53:44PM I DON'T WANT TO HAVE THAT RESPONSIBILITY ON ME AS SOMEONE
6:53:46PM WHO SAID IT'S OKAY TO PUT HOUSING NEXT TO NOT JUST
6:53:50PM INDUSTRIAL USE, BUT THE LITERAL HIGHEST INDUSTRIAL USE YOU
6:53:55PM CAN COME UP WITH.
6:53:56PM AS MUCH AS I RESPECT WHAT THEY ARE TRYING TO DO, I JUST
6:54:01PM DON'T THINK THIS IS THE RIGHT PLACE FOR IT SO I WILL NOT BE
6:54:04PM SUPPORTING THIS.
6:54:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON.
6:54:07PM >>BILL CARLSON: IN TALKING ABOUT IT IS THE BEGINNING OF
6:54:11PM SOMETHING, I HOPE IT IS THE END.
6:54:16PM UNFORTUNATELY, THIS WAS REZONED IN 2007 AS AN -- I WASN'T
6:54:21PM PAYING ATTENTION, I DON'T KNOW ABOUT THE REST OF THE
6:54:23PM MARITIME INDUSTRY.
6:54:25PM MAYBE THEY FOUGHT AND LOST.
6:54:26PM ONCE THE ZONING WAS CHANGED, IT WAS TOO LATE TO GO BACK.
6:54:32PM IF SOME FOLKS, INCLUDING SOME CURRENT FORMER ELECTED
6:54:37PM OFFICIALS THINK THIS IS THE BEGINNING, WE NEED TO GET RID OF
6:54:39PM THE DEEPWATER CHANNEL, THERE IS NO MORE LAND.
6:54:41PM THE LAND THAT IS STILL AVAILABLE, YOU SAW THE PRESENTATION
6:54:44PM BY THE PORT AND THERE ARE OTHERS, THE LAND THAT'S STILL
6:54:47PM AVAILABLE HAS ALREADY BEEN PLANNED.
6:54:48PM IT'S ALREADY -- UNLESS WE GET RID OF THE CONDOS AND HOUSES
6:54:55PM DOWN BY APOLLO BEACH, THERE'S NO MORE LAND TO MOVE TO.
6:54:58PM A HUNDRED YEARS FROM NOW WE'LL STILL NEED TO BRING THINGS IN
6:55:02PM UNLESS WE HAVE A STAR TREK-STYLE TRANSPORTER, BRING
6:55:06PM EVERYTHING IN BY HOT AIR BALLOONS OR SOMETHING, BUT WE'LL
6:55:09PM HAVE TO BRING EVERYTHING INTO OUR COMMUNITY.
6:55:11PM ALSO, THERE ARE THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS OF JOBS THERE.
6:55:14PM THEY ARE HIGH-PAYING BLUE-COLLAR JOBS.
6:55:17PM THE UNDERLYING ISSUE WE HAVE ABOUT HOUSING IS THAT THE JOB
6:55:20PM PRICES, THE JOB WAGES HAVE NOT GONE UP TO MATCH THE
6:55:24PM INFLATION IN THE HOUSING.
6:55:25PM WE DEFINITELY NEED MORE HOUSING, BUT THERE'S PLENTY OF LAND
6:55:28PM UP BY USF, BUT HARDLY ANYBODY IS PROPOSING BUILDING HOUSING
6:55:32PM UP THERE COMPARED TO OTHER PARTS.
6:55:34PM EVERYBODY WANTS TO LIVE ON THE WATER.
6:55:37PM WE NEED TO BUILD HOUSING BUT BUILD IT ALSO IN OTHER PLACES.
6:55:40PM WE ALSO NEED TO GET RID OF THE EDIFICE COMPLEX WHERE ALL OF
6:55:43PM OUR SUCCESS IS MEASURED BY BUILDINGS.
6:55:46PM WE HAVE A PORT THAT IS VERY SUCCESSFUL AT BULK.
6:55:50PM IT'S BECOMING MORE AND MORE SUCCESSFUL AT CONTAINERS.
6:55:53PM IT'S CATCHING UP WITH THE REST OF THE STATE.
6:55:55PM WE'RE ALL STILL WAY BEHIND OTHER PORTS BUT WE'RE CATCHING
6:55:58PM UP.
6:55:59PM IT IS AN INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT STRATEGIC ASSET.
6:56:02PM WHEN CUBA OPENS UP, IT IS GOING TO BE THE MAIN PORT IN
6:56:06PM FLORIDA BECAUSE WE ARE THE CLOSEST MAJOR PORT.
6:56:09PM IF YOU LOOK AT OTHER CITIES LIKE BALTIMORE, SOME OF THE
6:56:12PM THINGS THEY DID, CITIES THAT GET RID OF THEIR PORTS, THEY
6:56:15PM REGRET IT AFTERWARDS BECAUSE AT MANY TIMES THINGS LIKE
6:56:19PM BALTIMORE HARBOR DON'T WORK.
6:56:21PM LOOK AT CHANNEL -- SHOPS AT CHANNELSIDE AND WHAT HAPPENED
6:56:26PM ORIGINALLY OR THE SHOPS ON HARBOUR ISLAND.
6:56:28PM I THINK THIS IS A DIFFERENT PROPOSAL, THOUGH.
6:56:31PM IT'S NOT ONE OF THESE SHORT-TERM PROJECTS.
6:56:34PM AND THE DECISION WAS MADE IN 2007.
6:56:36PM IT WASN'T OUR DECISION.
6:56:39PM SINCE THAT DECISION WAS MADE IN 2007, WE CAN'T GO BACK FROM
6:56:42PM THERE.
6:56:44PM ALSO, WHAT WAS NOT SAID IS THAT THE PATRIARCH OF THE
6:56:47PM SHIPYARD PASSED AWAY.
6:56:49PM SO THAT SHIPYARD IN ITS CURRENT FORM AND ALSO PROBLEMS WITH
6:56:53PM SOMETHING SANK.
6:56:55PM IN ITS CURRENT FORM IT'S NOT GOING TO EXIST IN THE FUTURE.
6:56:58PM SO WE MOST LIKELY COULDN'T KEEP IT THERE ANYWAY.
6:57:01PM BUT THE LAND IS TOO VALUABLE.
6:57:03PM PORT CAN'T AFFORD TO BUY IT BACK.
6:57:05PM MARITIME INDUSTRY CAN'T AFFORD TO BUY IT BACK.
6:57:07PM WHAT THIS IS SUGGESTING DOING IS TAKING A LITTLE PIECE TO
6:57:10PM THE EAST AND ADDING IT IN.
6:57:11PM I HAVE GREAT CONCERNS ABOUT THAT BECAUSE IT IS AT THE
6:57:14PM ENTRANCE TO THE PORT.
6:57:15PM MY OPPOSITION IS ABOUT THE FUTURE AND NOT THIS PROJECT.
6:57:19PM I'M VERY, VERY FEARFUL FOR THE FUTURE OF OUR PORT.
6:57:23PM IF SOMEBODY SELLS IT OUT FOR A CONDO AND GETS RID OF THOSE
6:57:27PM IMPORTANT JOBS.
6:57:28PM BUT FOR THIS PARTICULAR PROJECT, THE DECISION WAS MADE IN
6:57:31PM 2007 AND THIS LITTLE PIECE ADDS VALUE TO THE OVERALL
6:57:36PM PROJECT.
6:57:37PM I'M CONCERNED ABOUT ITS PROXIMITY TO THE WORKING PORT, BUT I
6:57:42PM HOPE THAT THIS DEVELOPER AND HIS ATTORNEYS AND OTHERS WILL
6:57:44PM HELP US DEFEND THE REST OF THE WORKING PORT SO THAT NOBODY
6:57:48PM ELSE WILL COME IN AND PROPOSE TRYING TO CHANGE IT IN THE
6:57:53PM FUTURE.
6:57:53PM I AM GOING TO VOTE YES BECAUSE THE DECISION WAS MADE A LONG
6:57:59PM TIME AGO.
6:57:59PM IF IT WAS 2007, I WOULD VOTE NO.
6:58:01PM BUT MOST OF THE DECISIONS HAVE BEEN MADE ALREADY.
6:58:03PM THANK YOU.
6:58:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN VIERA.
6:58:05PM >>LUIS VIERA: JUST BRIEFLY, I'M GOING TO VOTE YES ON THIS.
6:58:09PM I THINK THIS DOES A GOOD ADEQUATE BALANCE BETWEEN PROTECTING
6:58:12PM THE PORT AND HAVING THAT NEXT STEP WHEN IT COMES TO
6:58:15PM CONTINUING TO PUSH FOR HOUSING HERE IN THE TAMPA AREA.
6:58:18PM THIS IS SOMETHING WHERE LAND USE MEETS A DYNAMIC FUTURE HERE
6:58:22PM FOR TAMPA, AND THIS IS SOMETHING WHERE THROUGH THE LAND USE
6:58:25PM PROCESS WE'RE CREATING SOMETHING REALLY DYNAMIC, SOMETHING
6:58:28PM REALLY EXCITING FOR TAMPA WHILE PROTECTING OUR INDUSTRY I
6:58:33PM BELIEVE HERE THROUGH THIS PROJECT.
6:58:34PM I'LL BE GLAD TO SUPPORT THIS.
6:58:36PM AGAIN, THIS IS PART OF SOMETHING REALLY, REALLY DYNAMIC IN
6:58:38PM THIS AREA WHERE I THINK THAT BALANCE CAN BE REACHED FROM
6:58:41PM EVERYTHING THAT I'VE HEARD AND SEEN AND LOOKED AT ON MY OWN.
6:58:44PM THANK YOU.
6:58:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
6:58:45PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN.
6:58:48PM IF THIS WAS A CONCERN OF THE PORT, YOU WON'T HAVE 50 PEOPLE
6:58:55PM HERE.
6:58:55PM YOU'D HAVE 500.
6:58:56PM I'M NOT SAYING THAT THE BARRIO LATINO, YOU GET SOMETHING
6:59:05PM PAST THEM, YOU NEED A MEDAL.
6:59:08PM AND I DON'T MEAN ANYTHING BUT A HEROES MEDAL.
6:59:12PM THAT'S TOUGH.
6:59:14PM YOU LOOK BACK, AND THIS PORT IS GOING TO BE VIABLE FOR A
6:59:22PM LONG, LONG TIME.
6:59:24PM THIS PORT HAS DONE FANTASTIC.
6:59:30PM MAYBE I'M ONE OF THE FEW THAT CAN REMEMBER WHAT THE
6:59:33PM GENTLEMAN SAID ABOUT HARBOUR ISLAND OR STATEN ISLAND.
6:59:36PM THAT WAS NOTHING BUT A DUMP WITH AN OLD RAILROAD TRACK GOING
6:59:40PM THERE THAT HAD THREE OR FOUR BIG SILOS.
6:59:43PM WHEN THE WIND BLEW FROM EAST TO WEST, THEY THOUGHT IT WOULD
6:59:48PM BE ALL WHITE NO MATTER WHAT COLOR HOUSE OR CAR.
6:59:52PM CITRUS NITRATE WHERE THE AQUARIUM WAS AT AND THE PHOSPHATE
6:59:56PM THERE, YOU HAD MORE PROBLEMS IN BREATHING THAT WE NEVER
7:00:00PM TALKED ABOUT BECAUSE AT THAT TIME NOBODY -- DON'T KNOW WHAT
7:00:04PM WE KNOW NOW.
7:00:04PM THINGS HAVE IMPROVED A LOT.
7:00:09PM I DON'T THINK THAT THIS IS GOING TO START SOMETHING OF AN
7:00:13PM EFFECT -- DOMINO EFFECT WHERE THEY TAKE OVER ALL THE LAND.
7:00:17PM THEY ARE NOT GOING TO TAKE OVER ANYTHING.
7:00:18PM THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WAS DONE IN 2007 AND I'M NOT VOTING
7:00:23PM FOR IT JUST BECAUSE IT WAS DONE IN 2007.
7:00:27PM IN FACT, MAYBE I WAS HERE IN 2007.
7:00:30PM WHAT I'M SAYING IS THAT IT'S A NEED, A NECESSITY WITH VERY,
7:00:37PM VERY LIMITED, AND I CAN'T EVER SAY THERE IS NO RISK.
7:00:42PM THERE'S RISK IN EVERYTHING WE DO.
7:00:44PM NO MATTER HOW SMALL IT IS, THERE IS A RISK.
7:00:47PM BUT SO MINUSCULE THAT I DON'T THINK IT WILL COME UP TO
7:00:52PM CHANGE THE FUTURE GROWTH OF THE PORT.
7:00:54PM THIS PORT, THE PEOPLE WHO SIT ON THAT PORT, THE PEOPLE WHO
7:00:59PM WORK OUT OF THAT PORT ARE FANTASTIC INDIVIDUALS.
7:01:03PM THEY HAVE MADE THAT PORT ONE OF THE FINEST PORTS IN THE
7:01:06PM COUNTRY.
7:01:06PM I HOPE THEY CONTINUE TO DO THAT BECAUSE THEY KNOW WHAT THEY
7:01:10PM ARE DOING; I DON'T.
7:01:11PM I CAN ONLY SAY I DON'T BELIEVE THIS IS GOING TO BE OF ANY
7:01:14PM DAMAGE TO THE PORT IN THE MANY HUNDREDS OF YEARS TO COME.
7:01:19PM THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN.
7:01:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
7:01:21PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THANK YOU, CHAIR.
7:01:23PM I'LL BE BRIEF.
7:01:23PM I REALLY APPRECIATE THE PRESENTATION AND THE DETAILED
7:01:26PM OUTLINE OF HOW YOU PRESENTED IT TO US, MR. HUDSON.
7:01:30PM I KNOW THAT WE HAVE OPPORTUNITIES IN OTHER AREAS.
7:01:34PM I JUST HAPPENED TO LIKE WHAT I'M HEARING TODAY AS IT
7:01:39PM CONNECTS TO WHAT'S ALREADY HAPPENING IN THIS AREA.
7:01:41PM I JUST BELIEVE THAT THIS IS JUST ANOTHER OPPORTUNITY TO
7:01:45PM CREATE MORE HOUSING IN THIS AREA THAT WILL SERVE A DIVERSE
7:01:50PM POPULATION OF PEOPLE.
7:01:51PM I KNOW THAT THE PORT IS IMPORTANT BUSINESS OPPORTUNITY FOR
7:02:01PM US.
7:02:02PM BUT WHAT'S INTERESTING IS THAT NO ONE FROM THE PORT IS
7:02:05PM COMING TODAY TO SPEAK AGAINST THIS.
7:02:06PM SO I THINK THEIR SILENCE MAY BE AN INDICATION THAT THEY ARE
7:02:10PM OKAY.
7:02:11PM THAT'S ALL I HAVE TO SAY.
7:02:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:02:14PM I'M GOING TO SUPPORT IT.
7:02:17PM YOU KNOW, WE HAVE OUR SISTER CITY IN NORTHERN FRANCE IN
7:02:22PM NORMANDY, LE HAVRE.
7:02:26PM THEY HAVE A VERY ACTIVE PORT.
7:02:28PM I DON'T WANT TO SAY COMPARABLE TO WHAT WE HAVE HERE, BUT YOU
7:02:30PM HAVE THE ACTIVE PORT.
7:02:31PM YOU HAVE HOTELS ON THE WATER.
7:02:33PM YOU HAVE TOURS.
7:02:34PM YOU HAVE RESIDENTIAL.
7:02:35PM YOU HAVE SO MANY THINGS WHERE EVERYTHING COMINGLES AND IT IS
7:02:38PM A GOOD BALANCE AND HISTORICAL PORT JUST LIKE WE HAVE A
7:02:41PM HISTORICAL PORT.
7:02:42PM I THINK THIS IS A VERY EXCITING PROJECT.
7:02:45PM I DON'T KNOW WHAT'S COMING NEXT.
7:02:47PM STILL HAVE A REZONING.
7:02:49PM BUT THIS IS TRANSFORMATIVE IN A POSITIVE WAY AND I DON'T
7:02:52PM THINK IT'S GOING TO REDUCE THE STRENGTH OF OUR PORT.
7:02:58PM I THINK THIS IS TASTEFULLY AND INTELLIGENTLY DONE, SO I'M
7:03:03PM GOING TO BE SUPPORTING IT.
7:03:05PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA, WOULD YOU MIND READING IT?
7:03:07PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN.
7:03:08PM ITEM NUMBER 2, FILE NUMBER TA/CPA 22-28.
7:03:15PM MOVE AN ORDINANCE FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, AN
7:03:18PM ORDINANCE AMENDING THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN FUTURE LAND
7:03:21PM USE ELEMENT, FUTURE LAND USE MAP FOR THE PROPERTIES LOCATED
7:03:26PM AT FOLIO NUMBERS 189779.0000, 189778.0000, 189777.0100,
7:03:40PM 189777.0000, 189774.0000, 189775.0000, 189776.0000,
7:03:57PM 189780.0000, 189864.0000, 189863.0100, 189863.0000,
7:04:15PM 189862.0000, 189864.0100, 189865.0000, 189866.0000,
7:04:31PM 189870.0100, 189872.0100, 189872.0000, 189871.0000,
7:04:51PM 190093.0000, 190087.0100, 189598.0000, AND 189577.0020 FROM
7:05:24PM GENERAL MIXED USE 24 -- DO YOU WANT ME TO READ IT AGAIN?
7:05:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO, NO, NO.
7:05:34PM [ LAUGHTER ]
7:05:36PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: WAIT UNTIL THIS MEETING IS OVER.
7:05:39PM GENERAL MIXED USE 24 (GMU-24), LIGHT INDUSTRIAL (LI) AND
7:05:52PM HEAVY INDUSTRIAL (HI) TO COMMUNITY MIXED USE-35 (CMU-35) AND
7:05:58PM URBAN MIXED USE-60; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCE IN
7:06:08PM CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
7:06:11PM DATE (CONTINUED FROM JULY 20, 2023, NOVEMBER 9, 2023, AND
7:06:17PM JANUARY 18, 2024, MARCH 21, 2024.)
7:06:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
7:06:25PM >>SUSAN JOHNSON-VELEZ: SUSAN JOHNSON-VELEZ, LEGAL
7:06:28PM DEPARTMENT.
7:06:29PM IF I COULD GET YOU TO READ AGAINST THE LAST FOLIO NUMBER.
7:06:33PM JUST TO MAKE SURE --
7:06:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: 189577.
7:06:39PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: 189577.0020.
7:06:44PM >>SUSAN JOHNSON-VELEZ: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
7:06:45PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: CORRECTION.
7:06:46PM JUST IN CASE I MISTAKE, I APOLOGIZE.
7:06:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN VIERA WITH A SECOND.
7:06:50PM CAN I GET A ROLL CALL VOTE, PLEASE?
7:06:52PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
7:06:53PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
7:06:55PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
7:06:57PM >>LYNN HURTAK: NO.
7:06:59PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
7:07:01PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
7:07:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
7:07:05PM >>THE CLERK: THE MOTION CARRIED WITH HURTAK VOTING NO.
7:07:10PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MAY 2nd, 2024,
7:07:14PM AT 9:30 A.M., LOCATED AT OLD CITY HALL, 315 EAST KENNEDY
7:07:18PM BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
7:07:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE'RE GOING TO TAKE A FIVE-MINUTE RECESS
7:07:26PM AND WE'LL BE RIGHT BACK.
7:07:27PM [ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
7:07:28PM [RECESS]
07:20:52PM [GAVEL SOUNDING]
07:20:55PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WELCOME BACK TO TAMPA CITY COUNCIL.
07:20:59PM IF WE CAN GET ROLL CALL.
07:21:01PM >>LYNN HURTAK: HERE.
07:21:05PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HERE.
07:21:07PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: PRESENT.
07:21:11PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HERE.
07:21:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
07:21:14PM >>CLERK: WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
07:21:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER 4, MISS DOCK.
07:21:19PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CHAIRMAN, COUNCIL, LaCHONE DOCK, LAND
07:21:25PM DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
07:21:25PM ITEM NUMBER 4 IS A REZONING REQUEST.
07:21:27PM I WANT TO SHOW YOU ON THE AERIAL MAP THE AREA OF THE REQUEST
07:21:31PM BECAUSE MULTIPLE PARCELS INVOLVED.
07:21:40PM BOUNDED WITH CHANNELSIDE ON THE WEST.
07:21:43PM 19th STREET ON THE EAST AND THE EXPRESSWAY THAT IS RUNNING
07:21:46PM ALONG THE NORTH.
07:21:47PM THE ADDRESSES ARE 610 HARBOR STREET, 1705 EAST ADAMO.
07:21:53PM 1616 AND 1620 PENNY STREET, 1019th STREET, 1821 SHAMAN DRIVE
07:22:03PM AND FOLIO 190039-2106.
07:22:09PM THE ADDRESS ON THE STAFF REPORT THAT IS NOT LISTED.
07:22:13PM I LEFT IT OFF BY MISTAKE BUT IT WAS NOTICED PROPERLY.
07:22:17PM THE REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY.
07:22:18PM CURRENTLY THREE ZONINGS ON THE PROPERTY.
07:22:22PM PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT APPROVED IN '07 AND CD-2, CHANNEL
07:22:27PM DISTRICT AND IH, INDUSTRIAL HEAVY.
07:22:30PM THE REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PD-A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT
07:22:34PM ALTERNATIVE AND CHANNEL DISTRICT TO ALLOW RESIDENTIAL
07:22:37PM MULTIFAMILY AND ALL CI USES ON-SITE.
07:22:39PM I WILL TURN IT OVER TO DANNY TO GIVE HIS REPORT AND I WILL
07:22:42PM COME BACK AND GIVE MY REPORT.
07:22:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
07:22:45PM >>DANNY COLLINS: DANNY COLLINS WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION
07:22:48PM STAFF.
07:22:48PM I WAS SWORN IN.
07:22:50PM OUR NEXT CASE IS IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT,
07:22:54PM SPECIFICALLY THE CHANNEL DISTRICT URBAN VILLAGE AND PORTIONS
07:22:58PM IN THE PORT TAMPA NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:22:59PM HERE IS AN AERIAL MAP OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND SURROUNDING
07:23:03PM PROPERTIES.
07:23:03PM WE KIND OF WENT OVER THIS IN THE LAST ITEM, BUT PRIMARILY
07:23:08PM HEAVY INDUSTRIAL USES SOUTH OF THE SITE.
07:23:11PM THERE ARE SOME NONRESIDENTIAL USES UP ALONG ADAMO DRIVE.
07:23:16PM OVER HERE TO THE WEST IS THE CHANNEL DISTRICT.
07:23:18PM HERE IS THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
07:23:24PM AGAIN, THIS WILL CHANGE.
07:23:27PM THIS REZONING IS CONTINGENT ON APPROVAL OF THE LAST
07:23:31PM AMENDMENT THAT WE HEARD.
07:23:32PM 22-28.
07:23:36PM THE WESTERN PORTION OF THE SITE IS CURRENTLY RECOGNIZED
07:23:40PM UNDER THE RMU-100 DESIGNATION.
07:23:43PM THIS AREA HERE JUST ON THE WEST SIDE OF THE CHANNEL IS
07:23:46PM RECOGNIZED UNDER THE UMU-60.
07:23:48PM TA-CPA 20 IS APPROVED IT WILL BE RECOGNIZED UNDER THE URBAN
07:23:55PM MIXED USE.
07:23:55PM HEAVY INDUSTRIAL TO THE SOUTHEAST AND JUST TO THE NORTH OF
07:23:58PM THE SITE.
07:23:59PM WE HAVE UMU-60 UP ALONG ADAMO DRIVE AND RMU-100 TO THE
07:24:08PM NORTH, NORTHWEST AND TO THE WEST OF THE CHANNEL, EXISTING
07:24:11PM HEAVY INDUSTRIAL ALSO TO THE WEST.
07:24:13PM THE PROPOSED -- AH, THE PROPOSED PD-A SUPPORTS MANY OF THE
07:24:19PM COMPREHENSIVE POLICIES RELATED TO MIXED USE AND DENSITY THAT
07:24:22PM SUPPORT TRANSIT ALONG THE TECO STREETCAR LINE CONSISTENT
07:24:26PM WITH THE EXACT CITY FORM STRATEGY, DESIGN BOOK, MANY URBAN
07:24:31PM STYLE DEVELOPMENT COST CONCEPTS.
07:24:33PM WITH BUILDINGS PLACED CLOSE TO THE PUBLIC SIDEWALK, INTERNAL
07:24:38PM PEDESTRIANS AND ACTIVATED GROUND FLOOR USES.
07:24:40PM ADDITIONALLY THE PROPOSED 4750 RESIDENTIAL UNITS WILL ALSO
07:24:44PM PROVIDE ADDITIONAL HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES FOR TAMPA'S GROWING
07:24:47PM POPULATION.
07:24:48PM THE APPLICANT IS UTILIZING LAND USE POLICY 5.1.6 TO WAIVE
07:24:53PM THE FLOOR AREA RATIO THROUGHOUT THE SITE AND PERIPHERY BONUS
07:24:58PM TO I A LOW ADDITIONAL INTENSITY RESULTING IN AN
07:25:02PM OVERALL F.A.R. OF 4719.
07:25:04PM ADDITIONALLY, THE RMU-100 AND UMU PROMOTE A MIXED USE
07:25:11PM PATTERN OF FLOOR AREA RATIO TO DETERMINE THE FLOOR AREA
07:25:17PM RATIO FOR RESIDENTIAL USES.
07:25:18PM AND ENCOURAGED BY THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IN THE
07:25:22PM DISTRICT WHICH IS THE PRIMARY URBAN EMPLOYMENT CENTER WHERE
07:25:25PM MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT TO FOSTER A VIBRANT URBAN LIFESTYLE.
07:25:30PM THE PROPOSED DESIGN BOOK INCLUDES LANGUAGE INVOLVING THE
07:25:33PM INTENT OF THE YBOR HARBOR AS A WATERFRONT DISTRICT.
07:25:36PM DESIGN BOOK PROPOSES BOAT SLIPS, FLOATING DOCKS, AND PARKS
07:25:42PM TO ENSURE THAT THE NATURAL RESOURCES ARE AVAILABLE TO ALL
07:25:49PM RESIDENTS AND PUBLIC ACCESS IN OPEN SPACE ALONG THE
07:25:52PM WATERFRONT IS ENCOURAGED BY THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
07:25:54PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
07:25:57PM FINDS THE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE
07:25:59PM PLAN AND THAT CONCLUDES PRY PRESENTATION AND AVAILABLE FOR
07:26:04PM ANY QUESTIONS.
07:26:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
07:26:06PM YES, MA'AM.
07:26:06PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
07:26:09PM THIS REQUEST BEFORE YOU FOR A PD-A, A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT
07:26:14PM ALTERNATIVE.
07:26:15PM WE DON'T HAVE TOO MANY PD-AS THAT COME BEFORE COUNCIL AND I
07:26:20PM WANT TO TAKE A SECOND TO EXPLAIN THE PD-A.
07:26:23PM WITH THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT ALTERNATIVE, IN THE CODE, THIS
07:26:26PM IS ALLOWED FOR PARCELS 20 ACRES OR MORE.
07:26:30PM IN THIS CASE, THE SITE IS APPROXIMATELY 3 ACRES.
07:26:34PM SLIGHTLY OVER 3 ACRES AND COMING IN AS IN PDA --
07:26:37PM WITH THE PD-A, YOU ARE PROVIDED A SITE PLAN WITH A PROJECT
07:26:42PM BOUNDARY.
07:26:42PM WITHIN THE PROJECT BOUNDARY, THERE IS A SET OF ENTITLEMENTS
07:26:47PM WHICH ARE ALLOWED.
07:26:49PM THIS IS PHASED DEVELOPMENT AS EACH PHASE IS SUBMITTED, THE
07:26:52PM DEVELOP WILL SUBMIT FOR INCREMENTAL SITE PLAN REVIEW.
07:26:55PM THAT IS AN ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW.
07:26:57PM THOSE CONDITIONS ARE REVIEWED AGAINST THE APPROVED PD-A AND
07:27:02PM A SET OF ENTITLEMENT IN AN ENTITLEMENT CHART IS USED TO SHOW
07:27:06PM THE DRAWDOWN AND IN TURN WILL SHOW THE REMAINING
07:27:09PM ENTITLEMENTS LEFT IN EACH CATEGORY.
07:27:12PM I WILL REVIEW A LITTLE BIT WITH YOU THIS EVENING ON THOSE
07:27:16PM TERMS.
07:27:16PM BUT THE PD-A IS WHAT WILL GOVERN IT.
07:27:20PM THE APPLICANT SUBMITTED WITH THE PD-A SITE PLAN A DESIGN
07:27:24PM BOOK, BONUS AGREEMENT AND DEVELOPER'S AGREEMENT, ALL
07:27:29PM DETERMINE THE ENTITLEMENT AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS WITHIN
07:27:31PM THE PROJECT.
07:27:32PM SO ON PAGE 2 OF THE STAFF REPORT, WHAT IS PROVIDED FOR YOU
07:27:35PM ARE SOME OF THE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT ENTITLEMENTS GENERAL
07:27:40PM OFFICE, 500,000 SQUARE FEET.
07:27:41PM RETAIL SALES 156,000 SQUARE FEET.
07:27:44PM HOTEL OR MOTEL USE OF 800 ROOMS.
07:27:47PM THERE ARE 4750 RESIDENTIAL UNITS PROPOSED.
07:27:51PM THE APPLICANT IS ENTERED INTO A BONUS AGREEMENT.
07:27:54PM THE TERMS OF THAT BONUS AGREEMENT WOULD ALLOW THE APPLICANT
07:27:58PM TO PROVIDE OR THE APPLICANT HAS COMMITTED TO PROVIDE 10% OF
07:28:02PM THE UNITS AS AFFORDABLE UNITS.
07:28:03PM SO THAT WILL GIVE 475 AFFORDABLE UNITS WITHIN THIS PROJECT.
07:28:10PM SOME WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO DO IS SHOW THE AERIAL MAP AGAIN,
07:28:13PM THE ZONING MAP ON THE SITE.
07:28:17PM SO AS MENTIONED BEFORE, THE SUBJECT SITE HAS THE THREE
07:28:21PM ZONING DISTRICTS CURRENTLY.
07:28:23PM JUST TO ORIENT YOU FROM THIS IS THE EXPRESSWAY.
07:28:26PM THIS IS CHANNELSIDE DRIVE WHICH IS THE WESTERN BOUNDARY.
07:28:29PM THIS IS 19th STREET.
07:28:31PM AND THEN YOU CAN SEE THIS IS THE SITE WHICH IS OUTLINED IN
07:28:35PM RID.
07:28:35PM SO THE CURRENT PD ON THE PROPERTY ENCOMPASSES A LITTLE BIT
07:28:42PM OVER 2 ACRES.
07:28:44PM SO THESE PARCELS WHICH ARE LOCATED IN THE NORTHEAST WILL THE
07:28:48PM PARCELS THAT ARE NOT CURRENTLY UNDER THE PD.
07:28:51PM ALL THE OTHER PARCELS ARE.
07:28:53PM THE SITE YOU ARE GOING TO SEE -- THE SUBJECT SITE HAS ON THE
07:28:57PM WESTERN BOUNDARY, IT IS IN THE CHANNEL DISTRICT IN THAT
07:29:01PM SPECIAL DISTRICT.
07:29:02PM IT IS WITHIN THE CRA ON THE EASTERN BOUNDARY.
07:29:05PM YOU HAVE YOUR PD ZONING THAT EXISTS ON THE SITE.
07:29:09PM YOU HAVE IH ZONING, INDUSTRIAL HEAVY THAT EXISTS TO THE EAST
07:29:14PM AND THE SOUTH.
07:29:15PM NORTH OF THE EXPRESSWAY, YOU HAVE THE YBOR CITY, THE YC
07:29:21PM DISTRICT, THE SPECIAL DISTRICT AND MIXTURE OF COMMERCIAL AND
07:29:24PM RESIDENTIAL USES THERE.
07:29:25PM NORTHWEST OF THE SITE OR JUST NORTH OF THE SITE ACTUALLY
07:29:29PM BECAUSE THE SITE RUNS TO CHANNELSIDE IS THE GASWORX PROJECT
07:29:34PM THAT WAS MENTIONED EARLIER.
07:29:35PM A PD-A.
07:29:36PM THIS MAP IS NOT UPDATED WITH THAT PD-A AND WE WILL UPDATE
07:29:41PM THAT.
07:29:41PM ALSO ON THE WEST I NEED OF NUCCIO, THAT DEVELOPMENT HAS
07:29:45PM STARTED, THE WESTERN LEG OF THE GASWORX DEVELOPMENT.
07:29:48PM AND THEN ON THE WEST SIDE OF THE SITE, WEST OF THE SITE ON
07:29:53PM THE WEST SIDE OF CHANNELSIDE, YOU SEE THE CD- AND THE PD.
07:29:57PM THE SITE PLAN CONTROL DISTRICTS WHICH ARE APPROVED FOR
07:30:01PM RESIDENTIAL HIGH-RISE DEVELOPMENT WITH COMMERCIAL ALSO ON
07:30:05PM THE GROUND FLOOR.
07:30:06PM AND THOSE DEVELOPMENTS.
07:30:07PM SO I WOULD LIKE TO SHOW YOU THE SITE PLAN THAT WAS SUBMITTED
07:30:12PM THAT IS ON RECORD.
07:30:13PM SO THERE ARE A COUPLE OF THINGS HERE.
07:30:15PM ONE, THIS IS THE BOUNDARY WHICH IS IDENTIFIED ON THE SITE
07:30:18PM PLAN.
07:30:19PM YOU WILL NOTICE THE BUILDING FOOTPRINTS ARE NOT SHOWN.
07:30:22PM THEY ARE PROVIDED AT THE TIME OF INCREMENTAL BY A DUE WITH
07:30:27PM EACH PHASE AS SUBMITTED FOR PERMIT.
07:30:28PM SO THE SITE PLAN IS BROKEN INTO THREE SECTIONS.
07:30:31PM YOU HAVE THE WESTERN HALF AND YOUR WESTERN BLOCK IS
07:30:34PM IDENTIFIED, W 1-6.
07:30:37PM YOU HAVE TWO CENTRAL BLOCKS, C-1 AND C-2.
07:30:40PM AND THE EASTERN BLOCKS ON THE EAST.
07:30:42PM WHAT IS IDENTIFIED HERE IN ORANGE IS AN AREA WHICH WILL BE
07:30:46PM REMOVED FROM THE SITE PLAN BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
07:30:48PM THIS IS IDENTIFIED ON THE SITE PLAN AS A WATER PARCEL.
07:30:52PM AND YOU CAN NOT INCLUDE THE WATER IN THE REZONING.
07:30:55PM SO THAT WILL BE REMOVED FROM THE SITE PLAN BETWEEN FIRST AND
07:30:59PM SECOND READING.
07:31:00PM AND THAT IS ALSO NOTATED IN THE STAFF REPORT PROVIDED.
07:31:04PM I WANTED TO SHOW YOU THE DEVELOPMENT ENTITLEMENT CHART.
07:31:11PM SO THIS IS WHAT IS INCLUDED IN THE SITE PLAN.
07:31:13PM THIS IS ALSO INCLUDED IN THE DESIGN BOOK.
07:31:15PM AND THIS GIVES AN OVERALL -- THIS IS WHAT WOULD BE SUBMITTED
07:31:20PM AT THE TIME OF INCREMENTAL ALSO TO SHOW THE DRAWDOWN.
07:31:23PM SO IT IS BROKEN OUT BY THE BLOCKS.
07:31:26PM YOU HAVE YOUR WEST CENTER AND EASTERN BLOCKS.
07:31:29PM AND THEN ALSO, USES WHICH ARE ALLOWED AND THEN FOR YOUR
07:31:32PM RESIDENTIAL, YOUR GENERAL OFFICE.
07:31:35PM THE RETAIL, HOTEL ROOMS, ALL OF THOSE WHICH I MENTIONED
07:31:40PM EARLIER ARE INCLUDED WITHIN THAT CHART.
07:31:42PM ON THE MAXIMUMS.
07:31:46PM AND WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO DO IS GO BACK TO THE SITE PLAN AND
07:31:49PM JUST SHOW YOU -- I HAVE PICTURES OF THE SITE.
07:31:52PM WE WILL START ON THE WESTERN BOUNDARY OF THE SITE.
07:31:55PM LOOK AT THE ADJACENT USES TO THE WEST.
07:31:58PM AND THEN LOOK NORTH.
07:32:00PM THE NORTH BOUNDARY OF THE SITE ON PENNY AND THEN COME AROUND
07:32:03PM TO THE EAST.
07:32:04PM AND END AT THE SOUTH -- SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY.
07:32:08PM SO THIS IS THE SITE.
07:32:15PM THIS WOULD BE ONE OF THE WESTERN BLOCKS, APPROXIMATELY
07:32:23PM BLOCK W-1.
07:32:24PM THIS IS ON THE WEST BOUNDARY, ON CHANNELSIDE.
07:32:26PM WE WILL JUST HEAD SOUTH ON CHANNELSIDE.
07:32:32PM THEN BACK TO THE WEST.
07:32:33PM ANOTHER VIEW.
07:32:37PM THIS IS WEST OF THE SITE.
07:32:38PM SO THIS IS -- THIS IS SOME OF THE DEVELOPMENTS THAT WERE
07:32:43PM MENTIONED WITHIN THE STAFF REPORT WHICH IS SURROUNDING THE
07:32:45PM SITE.
07:32:45PM THE HIGH-RISE DEVELOPMENT TO THE WEST.
07:32:47PM AND THEN SOME OF THESE PARCELS WEST OF THE SITE JUST HAVE
07:32:51PM INTO THE BEEN DEVELOPED YET, BUT THEY ARE APPROVED THROUGH A
07:32:53PM REZONINGS.
07:32:54PM STREETCAR WHICH IS WEST.
07:32:57PM THIS IS NORTH OF THE SITE.
07:32:58PM SO THIS IS ON THE NORTHERN BOUNDARY.
07:33:01PM THIS IS ON PENNY STREET.
07:33:02PM THIS IS IF YOU ARE LOOKING WEST.
07:33:04PM SO THE SUBJECT SITE IS ON THE LEFT IN THIS PICTURE.
07:33:07PM THIS IS MORE IF YOU ARE INTERNAL TO THE NORTHERN BOUNDARY
07:33:14PM LOOKING NORTH.
07:33:14PM SO THIS IS IF YOU ARE LOOKING EAST ON PENNY HEADED TOWARD
07:33:22PM 19.
07:33:22PM OOPS.
07:33:23PM SO THIS IS ON PENNY.
07:33:26PM THIS IS LOOKING EAST.
07:33:27PM ANOTHER VIEW.
07:33:28PM 17th AND PENNY, THIS IS IF YOU ARE LOOKING WEST.
07:33:37PM AND THIS IS A VIEW IF YOU ARE -- THIS IS THE EASTERN
07:33:41PM BOUNDARY OF THE SITE.
07:33:43PM AND THEN THAT IS LOOKING SOUTH.
07:33:45PM ANOTHER VIEW ON 19th STREET LOOKING SOUTH.
07:33:51PM AND THEN THIS IS -- THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE.
07:33:54PM THE TRC STAFF REVIEWED THE REQUEST FINDS THE REQUEST
07:34:01PM CONSISTENT.
07:34:01PM SITE PLAN MODIFICATIONS MADE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
07:34:05PM READING.
07:34:05PM THERE IS A REVISION SHEET, WHICH HAS OPINION PROVIDED TO YOU
07:34:09PM THAT HAS ADDITIONAL REVISIONS REQUIRED.
07:34:12PM AND THERE IS ONE ADDITIONAL REVISION TO ADD THAT I WILL
07:34:19PM SUBMIT INTO HAD THE RECORD WHICH IS THE TREE STANDARDS.
07:34:22PM FOUR-INCH CALIPER AND THREE-INCH CALIPER TREES ON THE SITE
07:34:29PM PLAN AND DESIGN BOOK.
07:34:30PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
07:34:31PM I AM AVAILABLE IF ENOUGH ANY QUESTIONS.
07:34:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
07:34:37PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:34:38PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
07:34:39PM TYLER HUDSON, MY ADDRESS IS 400 NORTH ASHLEY DRIVE.
07:34:43PM I WOULD LIKE TO INTRODUCE THE PROJECT TEAM BEHIND THIS
07:35:01PM PROJECT.
07:35:01PM A PROJECT IMAGINED AND PLANNED BY AND WILL BE EXECUTED BY
07:35:04PM DARRYL SHAW.
07:35:05PM DARYL WILL SPEAK TOWARD THE END OF OUR PRESENTATION.
07:35:08PM OUR CIVIL ENGINEER FOR THE PROJECT IS STAN TECH.
07:35:12PM RANDY COEN WITH COEN AND COMPANY.
07:35:16PM DARK MOSS IS OUR ARBORIST.
07:35:19PM RICKY PETERIKA WILL BE HERE AND SPEAK BRIEFLY.
07:35:23PM ENORMOUS AMOUNT OF ASSISTANCE.
07:35:27PM THIS JEN REGAN IS HERE.
07:35:29PM AND EAST AND MAIN, THEY COULD NOT BE HERE.
07:35:34PM LACHONE GAVE THE EARLIER PRESENTATION.
07:35:37PM I THINK AT THIS POINT EVERYBODY WAS AWARE THAT THIS REZONED
07:35:41PM BACK IN 2007 AND WE COVERED THAT IN DETAIL IN THE
07:35:45PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT WHAT IS NEW AND APPROVED WITH
07:35:53PM MIXED AUTO US DEVELOPMENT.
07:35:54PM THE AREA IN GREEN IS MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT.
07:35:57PM WHAT WE ARE PROPOSING TO ADD IS THE AREA IN YELLOW.
07:36:00PM I DON'T THINK IT WILL BE VERY HELPFUL TO GO INTO DETAIL OF
07:36:03PM APPROVALS IN PLACE NOW.
07:36:05PM THEY WERE APPROVED UNDER ATTEMPT ZONING CODE IN ANTICIPATION
07:36:09PM OF A DEVELOPMENT REGIONAL IMPACT THAT DON'T EXIST ANY.
07:36:13PM MORE BUT A PRETTY DENSE MIXED-USE DEVELOPMENT.
07:36:16PM AS LACHONE WENT THROUGH, WHAT WE ARE PROPOSING AND THE SITE
07:36:19PM PLAN SHOWS A CREATION OF 20 BLOCKS AND A GRID -- A GRID
07:36:23PM PATTERN, IMPOSITION OF A GRID ON WHAT IS NOW SORT OF SOME
07:36:27PM LARGE AREAS OF LAND.
07:36:28PM COUPLE OF IMPORTANT FEATURE BETWEEN W-1 AND W-4, 14th
07:36:34PM STREET.
07:36:34PM A CRITICAL GOAL OF THE PORT FOR SOME TIME BRINGING 14th
07:36:38PM STREET DOWN SOUTH OF ADAMO DRIVE.
07:36:41PM THIS PROJECT WILL DO THAT PRESSING 16th AND 17th STREET
07:36:45PM WHICH IS BETWEEN E-4 AND E-5 AND E-6 RESPECTIVELY AND
07:36:51PM BRINGING 16th STREET ADAMO DRIVE BETWEEN C-1 AND C-2.
07:36:57PM PD-ARRANGES, AND WE MET BEEN FILING WITH FDOT.
07:37:03PM NOT ONLY OPPORTUNITY FOR COOPERATION.
07:37:05PM THIS PROJECT ONLY WORKS WITH COOPERATION WITH THE WHOLE
07:37:07PM ALPHABET SOUP OF GROUPS AND HAPPY TO SAY THE INITIAL
07:37:11PM MEETINGS WERE VERY POSITIVE OF THINKING THROUGH
07:37:13PM HOW DO WE DO ADAMO DRIVE TO TAKE LESS OF A SLINGSHOT.
07:37:19PM AND A STREET THAT IS LITTLE LESS INTIMIDATING.
07:37:25PM STREETCAR.
07:37:26PM WE HAVE A COMMITMENT ON THE PLAN TO WORK WITH HART PRIOR TO
07:37:30PM THE RIGHT OF OUR FIRST BUILDING PERMIT OF WHERE A POTENTIAL
07:37:33PM STREETCAR STOP WILL GO.
07:37:35PM THERE IS A STOP ON TWIGGS.
07:37:36PM NOT CLEAR IF HART IS GOING TO WANT A SECOND STOP GIVEN THE
07:37:42PM GASWORX STATION COMMITTED TO ON THE OTHER SIDE OF ADAMO.
07:37:45PM IF THEY NEED IT, WE ARE WILLING TO COMMIT TO IT AND WILL BE
07:37:49PM PRIOR TO THE FIRST BUILDING PERMIT.
07:37:51PM THE CURVY GREEN ARROW IS THE SELMON GREENWAY.
07:37:57PM A LOT OF OPPORTUNITY WITH THIS DEVELOPMENT TO WIDEN --
07:38:00PM BASICALLY A SIDEWALK NOW, BUT TO WIDEN THAT TO MAKE IT A
07:38:04PM MUCH MORE ATTRACTIVE MULTIUSE TRAIL ALONG THE NORTHERN EDGE
07:38:08PM OF THE PROPERTY.
07:38:09PM I THINK LACHONE COVERED THIS, BUT A QUICK REFRESHER ON
07:38:15PM A PD-A.
07:38:15PM WE DON'T HAVE A TON OF THEM AND YOU PROBABLY WON'T SEE A
07:38:18PM LOT.
07:38:18PM WHAT IS APPROVED AT THIS STAGE IS A CONCEPTUAL SITE PLAN.
07:38:21PM CALLED A BUBBLE PLAN AND A SET OF DESIGN.
07:38:24PM ALEX WILL COVER THE DESIGN GUIDELINES IN JUST A SECOND.
07:38:27PM THAT IS WHAT IS APPROVED.
07:38:28PM THROUGH THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS WE GET THE DETAILED SITE
07:38:32PM PLANS.
07:38:32PM THAT IS WHAT YOU TYPICALLY SEE THE PD.
07:38:34PM WHERE IS THE STORMWATER?
07:38:36PM THINGS LIKE THAT.
07:38:36PM PROCESS WORKS WELL.
07:38:38PM THIRD OR FOURTH INCREMENTAL REVIEW FOR GASWORX.
07:38:41PM IT WORKS.
07:38:42PM THIS ALLOWS COUNCIL TO GET A GOOD LOOK AT THE MAXIMUMS,
07:38:47PM CEILINGS, COMMITMENTS ON OPEN SPACE, PARKING WITHOUT GETTING
07:38:50PM INTO THE GRANULAR DETAIL THAT CANDIDLY WE ARE NOT IN A
07:38:53PM POSITION TO EVEN KNOW THAT COMES WITH THINGS WITH
07:38:57PM STORMWATER.
07:38:58PM I WILL HAVE MY COLLEAGUE ALEX WALK YOU THROUGH FEATURES OF
07:39:01PM THE DESIGN GUIDELINES THAT YOU TYPICALLY SEE ON PDs.
07:39:05PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL, ALEX SCHALER, 400 EAST ASHLEY
07:39:14PM DRIVE.
07:39:14PM AS TYLER MENTIONED, THESE ARE KEPT IN THE BOOK.
07:39:16PM DETAILS YOU WILL SEE ON A PD SITE PLAN.
07:39:19PM AND THESE ARE BINDING REGULATIONS ON THE DEVELOPMENT.
07:39:21PM SO I WANT TO GO THROUGH AND NOTE SOME OF THOSE DIMENSIONAL
07:39:25PM REGULATIONS AND HIT SOME OF THE HIGHLIGHTS.
07:39:26PM THERE ARE A LOT OF INFORMATION IN THAT BOOK.
07:39:29PM THE FIRST IS THE STREET HIERARCHY AND THE ROADWAY GRID.
07:39:32PM AND TYLER SET THIS UP A BIT.
07:39:35PM I WILL GO INTO A BIT MORE GRANULAR DETAIL ON THE STREET
07:39:39PM SECTIONS AND WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE ON THE GROUND PLAIN.
07:39:42PM ZOOMING OUT FROM THE AERIAL BIRD'S-EYE VIEW, THE MAGENTA
07:39:48PM COLOR THAT IS CROSSHATCHED.
07:39:49PM YBOR HARBOR WAY.
07:39:50PM AND THAT IS -- WHAT WE WOULD CALL THE SIGNATURE PROMENADE OF
07:39:54PM THE PROJECT.
07:39:55PM AS YOU CAN SEE IT WRAPS AROUND THE WATER AND ENGAGES THE
07:39:59PM WATER FRONT.
07:40:00PM THE MOST PEDESTRIAN-FRIENDLY STREET.
07:40:04PM BUT YOU CAN SEE THEY ARE ALL PEDESTRIAN-FRIENDLY.
07:40:08PM SECOND IS THE TYPE A STREETS.
07:40:10PM THE PLAIN PINK COLOR.
07:40:11PM EAST-WEST CONNECTORS.
07:40:13PM BRINGING IN TRAFFIC FROM CHANNELSIDE DRIVE TO THE CENTER OF
07:40:16PM THE DEVELOPMENT AS WELL AS FROM 19th STREET TO THE CENTER OF
07:40:20PM THE DEVELOPMENT AS WELL.
07:40:21PM TYPE B STREETS ARE THE STREETS HIGHLIGHTED IN YELLOW AS
07:40:25PM TYLER ALLUDED TO THESE EARLIER BUT DRAWING TRAFFIC SOUTH
07:40:28PM OF ADAMO DRIVE.
07:40:30PM TRAFFIC SOUTH OF YBOR CITY TO THE DEVELOPMENT.
07:40:33PM AND TYPE C STREETS, ONES COLORED IN A BLUEISH-PURPLE COLOR.
07:40:39PM AND THEY ARE MAINLY STRUCTURED IN THE SOUTH EAST CORNER OF
07:40:43PM THE DEVELOPMENT ALONG THE NORTHERN BOUNDARY.
07:40:44PM EXTERNAL PERIPHERIES OF THE LAND ABUTTING THE -- AND GETTING
07:40:49PM INTO A LITTLE BIT MORE DETAIL HERE ON THE STREET SECTIONS.
07:40:52PM STARTING WITH THE SPECIALTY A STREET, WHEN YOU THINK
07:40:55PM SPECIALTY, YOU THINK WATER.
07:40:57PM SO A 26-WIDE BOARDWALK THAT WRAPS AROUND HERE.
07:41:01PM YOU CAN SEE YOU HAVE WITH EXTENDED CAFE SEATING.
07:41:05PM ALL OF THIS IS FUNCTIONING A SENSE OF PLACEMAKING AND A
07:41:10PM SENSE OF FOCUS HIGHLIGHTING THE PROCESS.
07:41:13PM SIGNALING THE VIEWS OF THE WATER.
07:41:17PM TYPE A STREETS ARE INTERNAL CORRIDORS, BUT AS MENTIONED THE
07:41:22PM MOST PEDESTRIAN-ACTIVATED STREETS IN THE PROJECT.
07:41:24PM AS YOU CAN SEE QUITE WIDE -- FOR A STREET SECTION IT IS
07:41:28PM ALMOST 80 FEET.
07:41:29PM TWO TRAVEL LANES, ON-STREET PARKING ON BOTH SIDES.
07:41:32PM A 15-FOOT PUBLIC WAY.
07:41:34PM THAT IS EXTENSIVE FOR A PUBLIC REALM.
07:41:37PM THE CHANNEL DISTRICT HAS AMPLE OF FIVE-FOOT SIDEWALKS.
07:41:42PM SO 15 HERE IS -- LIKE I SAID IT IS EXTENSIVE.
07:41:45PM AS YOU CAN SEE AND THE TYPE B EXCEPTIONS, RELATIVELY THE
07:41:50PM SAME SIMILAR TO TYPE A.
07:41:52PM CAFE SEATING ON THE ENDS IS A THREE-FOOT SETBACK OR FLEX
07:41:57PM SPACE THERE ON THE END.
07:41:59PM TYPE C RELATIVELY SIMILAR TO TYPE B.
07:42:03PM A PATTERN, MAINTAINING 15-FOOT PUBLIC REALM FROM SPECIALTY A
07:42:09PM ALL THE WAY TO THE TYPE C STREET SECTIONS.
07:42:11PM WITH THE TYPE C USUALLY WHAT WE SEE WITH UNLOADING AND
07:42:16PM LOADING SERVICE AND YBOR HARBOR WHERE WE ARE, AGAIN,
07:42:18PM INCREASING THE PUBLIC REALM WITH, AND ALSO THEY ARE
07:42:23PM PEDESTRIAN-FRIENDLY STREETS.
07:42:24PM SECOND SET OF REGULATIONS I WOULD LIKE TO NOTE IS WITH
07:42:27PM REGARD TO PARKING.
07:42:29PM THIS TABLE IS VERY FAMILIAR TO YOU.
07:42:30PM REPLICAS OF THE CURRENTLY ADOPTED PARKING CODE FOR THE
07:42:35PM CHANNEL DISTRICT IN THE CDB.
07:42:38PM AS YOU ALL KNOW, BACK IN 2022, THAT WAS ADDED TO THE LAND
07:42:43PM DEVELOPMENT CODE SO YBOR HARBOR WILL BE COMPLYING WITH THE
07:42:46PM CITY CODE STANDARDS FOR BIKE PARKING.
07:42:48PM LACHONE MENTIONED THIS AS WELL.
07:42:51PM THE SAME TABLE FROM THE SITE PLAN AND CONDENSED A BIT AND
07:42:55PM THE COLORS ARE CHANGED.
07:42:56PM I WOULD LIKE TO NOTE AS YOU SEE ON THIS CHART, WE HAVE THE
07:42:59PM AREAS DIVIDED GEOGRAPHICALLY, WEST, CENTER AND EAST.
07:43:03PM HOWEVER, AS YOU ALL HAVE SEEN ON THIS BUBBLE PLAN, BLOCK
07:43:06PM PLAN OR SITE PLAN, MULTIPLE BLOCKS WITHIN EACH ONE OF THESE
07:43:10PM GEOGRAPHIC AREAS.
07:43:11PM THIS PROJECT IS LIKELY GOING TO COME ONLINE ON EITHER A
07:43:15PM BLOCK BY BLOCK BASIS OR A MULTIBLOCK BASIS.
07:43:18PM ROME WAS NOT BUILT IN A DAY.
07:43:21PM YBOR HARBOR WILL NOT BE BUILT OVERNIGHT EITHER.
07:43:23PM THE HEIGHT IS REGULATED FROM FAA.
07:43:28PM YOU NOTICE ON THE DESIGN GUIDELINES, WE DO NOT SPECIFY A
07:43:32PM CERTAIN NUMBER VALUE FOR HEIGHT THAT WILL BE STRICTLY
07:43:34PM REGULATED BY THOSE AGENCIES.
07:43:36PM AND WE ARE PROUD TO HAVE A PRISTINE STAFF REPORT ON A
07:43:39PM PROJECT OF THIS SIZE AND COMPLEXITY FOR A PD-A.
07:43:42PM ALL THE CITY'S REVIEWING DEPARTMENTS FOUND THIS APPLICATION
07:43:46PM CONSISTENT AS WELL AS OUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
07:43:47PM AND WITH THAT, I AM GOING TO BRING UP RICKY PETERIKA AND OUR
07:43:52PM PROJECT ARBORIST SPEAK A BIT TO THOUGHTFUL COMMITMENTS THAT
07:43:55PM WE ARE MAKING ON OPEN SPACE.
07:43:56PM >> THANK YOU, ALEX.
07:44:00PM GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
07:44:01PM RICKY PETERIKA, DARK MOSS, 3028 EAST 7th AVENUE.
07:44:07PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
07:44:08PM ERIN MAHER AND I TOOK WHAT WE LEARNED IN GASWORX AND DID
07:44:16PM CREATIVE IMPROVEMENTS.
07:44:17PM DIVIDED SPECIFICALLY PUBLIC AND PRIVATE, AND THEN TOOK CUES
07:44:22PM FROM CHANNEL DISTRICT THAT HAS PARK SPACE REQUIREMENTS.
07:44:25PM WE NOW -- AS YOU SEE IN THE BOTTOM RIGHT OF THE SLIDE, WE
07:44:28PM NOW HAVE WATERFRONT AND POCKET PARK REQUIREMENT THAT WILL GO
07:44:32PM IN THE PUBLIC SPACE -- PUBLIC SPACES AND TO HAPPEN
07:44:36PM BEFORE 50% OF THE INCREMENTAL DEVELOPMENT CAN OCCUR.
07:44:39PM SOMETHING WE HAVEN'T HAD BEFORE.
07:44:41PM ADDITIONALLY, WE HAVE PROVIDED MINIMUM LANDSCAPE AREA WHICH
07:44:45PM IS NOT SOMETHING THAT HAPPENS IN THESE URBAN DISTRICTS,
07:44:48PM MEANING PERMEABLE GREEN SPACE.
07:44:50PM AND WE HAVE PROVIDED NOT ONLY WHAT WOULD TYPICALLY BE
07:44:53PM REQUIRED, BUT AN ADDITIONAL BUMP, EQUIVALENT TO THE GREEN
07:44:57PM SPACE OR THE AREA OF ALL THE CANOPY GRAND TREES ON-SITE.
07:45:02PM NOW TRANSLATED BOTH TO TREE MITIGATION BUT ALSO NOW TO GREEN
07:45:07PM SPACE MITIGATION AS WELL.
07:45:08PM WE FINE-TUNE THE STREET SECTIONS TO PROMOTE ADDITIONAL
07:45:15PM ROOTING AREA AND PROVIDE CANOPY CLEARANCE.
07:45:18PM NATURAL RESOURCES AND I -- AND THEN THE DESIGN TEAM --
07:45:22PM PROVIDED MINIMUM SEPARATION REQUIREMENT FOR SUCCESSFUL TREE
07:45:26PM AND MINIMUM SOIL AREA REQUIREMENTS.
07:45:28PM WE HAVEN'T COMPLETED A FULL LANDSCAPE PLAN YET AT THIS
07:45:31PM STAGE, BUT BASED ON THE DESIGN GUIDELINES COMMITMENTS, WE
07:45:35PM WILL RESULT IN ROUGHLY 57 TO 750 NEW STREET TREES.
07:45:39PM ONLY IN THE PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY, NOT ANY PRIVATE TREES OR
07:45:43PM PARK TREES.
07:45:44PM WE HAVE TWO NATURAL RESOURCES WAIVERS.
07:45:47PM GRAND TREE REMOVAL AND MINIMUM TREE RETENTION COMMON ON
07:45:51PM SITES LIKE THIS.
07:45:51PM BUT IN 2010, THE MAJORITY OF THE SITE, THE AREA THAT WAS --
07:45:57PM RE-- THE COMP PLAN CHANGE IN 26, THE MAJORITY WAS DESIGNATED
07:46:06PM A BROWN FIELD REHABILITATION BY THE 2010 CITY COUNCIL.
07:46:09PM GRAND TREE REMOVAL AND BY FUNCTIONAL EXTENSION, MINIMUM TREE
07:46:18PM RETENTION CAN BE ADMINISTRATIVELY APPROVED THROUGH DESIGN
07:46:21PM EXCEPTION.
07:46:22PM IF IT IS A BROWN FIELD SITE SUBJECT TO REMEDIATION WHICH WE
07:46:26PM ARE.
07:46:26PM WE ARE ONLY REQUESTING THE WAIVER NOW FOR CLARITY TO MAKE
07:46:30PM SURE THAT ANSWERS THAT QUESTION IS ADDRESSED NOW AND NOT
07:46:34PM THROUGH STEPS OF INCREMENTAL.
07:46:36PM SO I CAN CERTAINLY SPEAK TO MORE.
07:46:38PM DEFINITELY THE TREES ON THE SITE AND TYPICAL LANDSCAPE
07:46:41PM QUESTIONS.
07:46:42PM AND I WOULD LIKE -- NOW WOULD LIKE TO HAND IT OFF TO MR.
07:46:46PM DEARLY SHAW TO MAKE SOME CLOSING REMARKS.
07:46:48PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
07:46:56PM DARRYL SHAW WITH YBOR HARBOR.
07:46:59PM WHAT I ENVISIONED -- WHEN WE VISIONED A THRIVING URBAN CORE,
07:47:07PM WE VISIONED MULTIPLE INTERCONNECTED NEIGHBORHOODS.
07:47:10PM AND I EMPHASIZE "INTERCONNECTED."
07:47:13PM I TYPICALLY WALK THE RIVERWALK AT LEAST TWICE A WEEK.
07:47:17PM I WILL START ON 7th AVENUE IN YBOR CITY.
07:47:20PM I WILL HEAD DOWN 7th AVENUE OVER TO ARMATURE WORKS.
07:47:23PM I WILL FOLLOW THE RIVERWALK PAST CURTIS HIXON PARK, PAST THE
07:47:29PM CONVENTION CENTER, PAST WATER STREET.
07:47:31PM I WILL TURN THE CORNER OUT BY THE AQUARIUM, AND THAT WALK
07:47:35PM THROUGH TO THE AQUARIUM IS A DREAM.
07:47:38PM IT IS AN UNBELIEVABLE EXPERIENCE THAT IS PUTTING TAMPA ON
07:47:44PM THE MAP WORLDWIDE.
07:47:45PM THE STRIP FROM THE AQUARIUM THROUGH TO 7th AVENUE IS A VERY
07:47:54PM DEAD STRIP RIGHT NOW.
07:47:55PM THE GASWORX PROJECT INTENDS TO ADDRESS THE SEGMENT THAT
07:48:02PM EXISTS NORTH OF ADAMO DRIVE, BUT VISIONING THIS
07:48:10PM INTERCONNECTIVENESS OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD REQUIRES ENVISIONING
07:48:13PM THE REMAINDER OF THAT DEAD AREA.
07:48:15PM YBOR HARBOR DOES THAT IN A VERY THOUGHTFUL MATERIAL WAY.
07:48:20PM NOT WITHOUT ITS NUANCES AND INTRICACIES, IT IS TRULY
07:48:30PM THREADING THE NEEDLE.
07:48:31PM THREADING THE NEEDLE BECAUSE THE MARITIME COMMUNITY IS VERY
07:48:35PM SIGNIFICANT AND ACTIVE.
07:48:40PM THE POPULATION THAT IS MOVING TO TAMPA THAT EXISTS IN TAMPA
07:48:45PM IS WANTING TO EXPERIENCE THE WATERFRONT.
07:48:48PM THEY ARE WANTING TO EXPERIENCE WALKABILITY.
07:48:50PM THEY WANT TO EXPERIENCE TRANSIT-ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT.
07:48:55PM THEY WOULD LIKE TO HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO NOT UTILIZE THEIR
07:48:58PM CAR.
07:48:58PM AND THOSE VERY PEOPLE THAT ARE LOOKING FOR THAT WATERFRONT
07:49:05PM EXPERIENCE IN THE URBAN CORE ARE DEMANDING OR NEEDING GOODS
07:49:09PM THAT COME IN THROUGH THE PORT.
07:49:13PM AS OUR POPULATION GROWS, THE DEMAND FOR THE GOODS THROUGH
07:49:17PM THE PORT GROWS, AND IT GETS EVEN BUSIER.
07:49:21PM THOSE TWO WORLDS INTERSECT AND IN SOME WAY COLLIDE THAT YBOR
07:49:27PM CHANNEL.
07:49:27PM AND SO I HAVE SPENT A VERY SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF TIME
07:49:32PM GETTING TO KNOW THE MARITIME COMMUNITY.
07:49:36PM I AM A MEMBER OF THE PROPELLER CLUB.
07:49:41PM I HAVE MULTIPLE MEETINGS WITH THE MARITIME ALLIANCE.
07:49:46PM I MET WITH EVERY BUSINESS ON YBOR CHANNEL.
07:49:48PM I SPENT SIGNIFICANT TIME SPEAKING WITH THE PORT AND THEIR
07:49:54PM DESIRE TO SEE THE CRUISE INDUSTRY GROW.
07:49:57PM AND WE BELIEVE THAT THROUGH THIS DEVELOPMENT IN A THOUGHTFUL
07:50:01PM WAY, WE CAN WEAVE A TAPESTRY THAT CONNECTS ALL OF THOSE USES
07:50:07PM IN A MIXED USE URBAN TRANSIT-ORIENTED COMMUNITY WITH
07:50:12PM AFFORDABLE HOUSING, WITH ACCESS TO TROLLEY, TO FERRY, TO
07:50:18PM WATER TAXI.
07:50:19PM IF WE ARE INTENTIONAL AND THOUGHTFUL, WE WILL BE SUCCESSFUL.
07:50:23PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:50:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
07:50:25PM ALL RIGHT, ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM COUNCIL BEFORE I
07:50:29PM GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT?
07:50:30PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
07:50:31PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
07:50:32PM I HAVE A FEW QUESTIONS MAYBE FOR MR. HUDSON.
07:50:34PM THE PARKING RATIO.
07:50:42PM THE PARKING INFORMATION ISN'T REALLY CLEAR.
07:50:46PM BUT MISS SCHALER DID SPEAK OF USING CENTRAL BUSINESS
07:50:52PM DISTRICT.
07:50:53PM SO WE ARE TALKING 4700 UNITS.
07:50:58PM WHAT KIND OF PARKING WE TALKING ABOUT?
07:51:02PM >> LET ME TULLE PULL IT UP.
07:51:04PM TYLER HUDSON FOR THE RECORD.
07:51:07PM IT MIGHT BE LITERALLY UNCLEAR BECAUSE TINY FONT.
07:51:10PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES, SO THAT'S -- I AM KIND -- I AM LOOKING
07:51:13PM AT THE -- AT THE NUMBERS.
07:51:14PM THIS.
07:51:15PM BUT WHAT ARE WE REALLY LOOKING AT?
07:51:18PM >> SURE, SO -- IF EVERY SINGLE -- IF WE DIDN'T TAKE
07:51:22PM ADVANTAGE OF THE SHARED PARKING OPTIONS THAT ARE IN THE CODE
07:51:25PM AND WE WOULD ADDRESS EACH INCREMENTAL STAGE, IF IT WAS JUST
07:51:29PM PURELY -- IF WE HIT CLICK AND 4750 UNITS WERE THERE, IT
07:51:33PM WOULD BE .75 SPACES PER UNIT.
07:51:38PM BUT IT IS OUR BELIEF THAT THIS PROJECT WILL HAVE A LOT OF
07:51:41PM OPPORTUNITY FOR SHARED PARKING AND USES THAT OFF-SET ON A
07:51:45PM TIME BASIS.
07:51:46PM AND A CHALLENGE OF THE PD-A.
07:51:48PM WE ARE GRANTED A LOT OF LEEWAY ON BEING CONCEPTUAL ON SOME
07:51:54PM THINGS, BUT NOT ON PARKING.
07:51:55PM I WOULD BE SURPRISE BY THE TIME THE LAST BUILDING OPENS, WE
07:52:00PM HAVEN'T CHANGED THE PARKING RULES.
07:52:01PM THROUGH THE CODE ALREADY, THERE IS AN ALLOWANCE FOR AN
07:52:04PM APPLICANT TO DEMONSTRATE ADMINISTRATIVELY THAT SHARED
07:52:07PM PARKING IS APPROPRIATE BECAUSE WHEN FOLKS ARE AT THE OFFICE,
07:52:09PM THEY ARE NOT HOME.
07:52:11PM THAT IS A BAD EXAMPLE DUE TO THE TIMES WE LIVE IN.
07:52:14PM BUT MAY NOT BE THE CASE IN FOUR YEARS.
07:52:16PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THAT WAS SORT OF MY QUESTION.
07:52:18PM I WANTED TO MAKE SURE YOU AREN'T LOCKED IN TO PARKING,
07:52:21PM BECAUSE I BELIEVE THE LONGER WE GO, THE LESS PARKING WE ARE
07:52:25PM REALLY GOING TO NEED.
07:52:25PM SO I DON'T WANT TO OVERPARK THIS.
07:52:28PM MY OTHER -- I HAVE A QUESTION ALSO.
07:52:31PM WHAT IS W-6?
07:52:33PM THAT IS TEENY, TINY.
07:52:35PM WHAT DO YOU ENVISION THERE?
07:52:36PM BECAUSE I DON'T -- I DON'T SEE A BUILDING, BUT I NOTICE THAT
07:52:40PM IT IS PART OF IT.
07:52:41PM SO WHAT DO YOU EXPECT W-6 TO BE?
07:52:45PM >> THAT IS A FUNNY LITTLE GUY.
07:52:46PM W-6 IS RIGHT -- RIGHT THERE.
07:52:53PM IT IS BASICALLY UNDERNEATH THE EXPRESSWAY WHICH LIMITS THE
07:52:58PM DEVELOPMENT PRETTY SIGNIFICANTLY.
07:52:59PM I THINK THAT IS PROBABLY A PARCEL THAT I COULD SEE US
07:53:02PM ENTERING INTO AN AGREEMENT TO GIVE TO THEM AND A LITTLE MORE
07:53:09PM ROOM FOR A TRAIL.
07:53:10PM IT IS NOT A PARCEL THAT -- IT DOES CUT DOWN -- IT IS NOT
07:53:14PM JUST THAT.
07:53:15PM IT GOES DOWN A LITTLE BIT HERE SO SOME POSSIBLE ACCESS
07:53:19PM POTENTIAL FOR PEDESTRIANS.
07:53:21PM IT IS JUST REALLY A RELIC OF -- OF THE CURRENT --
07:53:27PM MR. LORTON'S LAND ACQUISITIONS OVER THE YEARS BUT NOT A
07:53:29PM PARCEL WE SEE PARTICULARLY DEVELOPABLE.
07:53:32PM MY COPY -- PARDON SCRATCHES.
07:53:36PM PORT OWNS THAT LAND.
07:53:37PM CITY OWN AS PIECE OF LAND RIGHT HERE AND PARCEL A RIGHT
07:53:41PM THERE.
07:53:41PM CITY OWNS THAT.
07:53:43PM RIGHT-OF-WAY.
07:53:44PM COUPLE OF PARCELS AS THIS PROJECT EVOLVES AND INCREMENTAL
07:53:51PM PLATS PRIOR TO EACH, IT COMES TO LIGHT EVEN MORE.
07:53:54PM GOOD QUESTION.
07:53:55PM IT IS A WEIRD ONE.
07:53:56PM >>LYNN HURTAK: ABOUT HOW MANY UNITS ARE IN GASWORX?
07:54:02PM >> GASWORX AT MAXIMUM BUILD IT IS ABOUT 4250.
07:54:06PM THERE WERE 3250 UNITS THAT WERE -- ARE BUILDABLE IN AN AREA
07:54:12PM WITH BONUS DENSITY AND 325 AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNIT CAME FROM
07:54:17PM THAT PROJECT.
07:54:17PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WE ARE LOOKING AT BASICALLY 9,000 NEW UNITS.
07:54:23PM >> AT MAXIMUM BUILD-OUT, CORRECT.
07:54:25PM >>LYNN HURTAK: PLUS HOTEL ROOMS.
07:54:28PM I WANT SOMEWHERE FOR A FIRE STATION TO GO.
07:54:34PM AND -- WE COULDN'T TALK ABOUT THIS BEFORE, BUT WE ARE
07:54:41PM TALKING ABOUT 9,000 MORE UNITS AND -- AND -- DIDN'T EVEN
07:54:46PM OCCUR TO ME UNTIL YOU BROUGHT UP THE SHEET WHERE YOU GOT
07:54:48PM CHECKED OFF BY -- BY FIRE RESCUE.
07:54:50PM AND I THOUGHT, WE -- WE HAVE TO HAVE SOMETHING IN THIS AREA.
07:54:57PM WE HAVE BEEN -- WE AS A COUNCIL HAS BEEN TRYING TO FIND
07:55:00PM SPACE TO PUT A FIRE STATION.
07:55:03PM AND QUITE HONESTLY, YOUR DEVELOPMENT IS THE REASON WE NEED
07:55:11PM ONE.
07:55:11PM >> UNDERSTOOD.
07:55:13PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WHAT CAN -- I KNOW THIS IS NOT A TIME FOR ME
07:55:15PM TO BE -- AS MR. SHELBY WOULD SAY, THIS ISN'T THE TIME FOR
07:55:21PM NEGOTIATION, BUT I REALLY DO THINK THAT SINCE THERE IS NO
07:55:25PM OTHER TIME FOR US TO BRING THIS UP, I AM JUST CONCERNED
07:55:29PM ABOUT THE STRAIN ON PUBLIC RESOURCES.
07:55:31PM >> SURE.
07:55:32PM TOTALLY FAIR QUESTION TO ASK.
07:55:34PM SO WITHIN THE THREE QUARTER -- WITHIN THE THREE-QUARTER-MILE
07:55:38PM RADIUS, THERE ARE THREE STATIONS ALREADY.
07:55:40PM THIS PROJECT IS ALMOST AT THE LITERAL INTERSECTION POINT OF
07:55:44PM THE THREE STATIONS THAT ARE THERE.
07:55:45PM THAT IS STATION 6 RIGHT THERE DOWN ON 22nd STREET.
07:55:48PM PALMETTO BEACH.
07:55:50PM IT IS A MILE AWAY.
07:55:51PM FROM THE PROJECT.
07:55:53PM AND I -- FROM THE CIP PERSPECTIVE, THERE IS ALREADY -- A FAIRLY
07:55:58PM SIGNIFICANT FUNDING TO BOTH EXPAND -- WELL, TO EXPAND BY
07:56:02PM PROPERTY ACQUISITION AND PHYSICAL PLANT IMPROVEMENTS TO THAT
07:56:06PM FIRE STATION.
07:56:07PM SO I THINK THAT -- I DON'T KNOW IF THAT IS A COMPLETE ANSWER
07:56:09PM TO THE QUESTION, BUT IT IS -- IT IS THE CLOSEST FIRE
07:56:13PM STATION, ONE OF THREE, IT IS ALREADY BUDGETED TO GET BY THIS
07:56:17PM COUNCIL VERY SIGNIFICANT BUDGETARY IMPROVEMENTS, I MEAN TO
07:56:21PM THE TUNE OF -- TO '26, '27.
07:56:30PM >>LYNN HURTAK: INCREDIBLY SMALL PIECE OF LAND AND WE NEED
07:56:33PM FIVE APPARATUS AND RIGHT NOW WE CAN'T FIT ONE.
07:56:36PM THAT IS NOT A REALLY GOOD COMP FOR THAT.
07:56:39PM I AM JUST SAYING, THIS IS SOMETHING THAT -- YOU ARE BRINGING
07:56:45PM A LOT TO THE COMMUNITY, BUT THAT IS SOMETHING THAT WE ARE
07:56:47PM NOT GOING TO BE ABLE TO -- I MEAN, WE JUST CAN'T -- WE -- WE
07:56:53PM CAN'T FIND THE LAND AROUND HERE TO DO SOMETHING LIKE THAT.
07:56:55PM AND, I MEAN, THAT'S WHY -- I INQUIRED ABOUT W-6, YOU KNOW,
07:57:02PM SOMETHING WORKING WITH THEA, MAYBE USING THE LAND UNDER THE
07:57:06PM INTERSTATE.
07:57:06PM BUT I AM JUST -- I -- WE KEEP BRINGING THESE GIANT
07:57:11PM DEVELOPMENTS.
07:57:12PM BUT WE DON'T BRING AND HAVE SPACE FOR THE INFRASTRUCTURE
07:57:14PM THAT THIS CITY KEEPS ASKING FOR AND KEEPS NEEDING.
07:57:17PM SO THIS -- THAT IS PROBABLY MY BIGGEST CONCERN WITH THIS.
07:57:21PM IS THAT NOW WE ARE BRINGING 9,000 UNITS AND WE ARE NOT --
07:57:25PM THERE IS -- THERE IS NOTHING THAT YOUR DEVELOPMENT IS DOING
07:57:28PM TO HELP US WITH THOSE NEEDS AND I WOULD ARGUE THAT WE ARE
07:57:34PM WORKING ON A PUBLIC SAFETY IMPACT FEE, BUT THAT IS NOT GOING
07:57:37PM TO BE IN THE BOOKS FOR A COUPLE OF YEARS, SO WHAT CAN WE DO
07:57:42PM IN THE MEANTIME TO GET SOME RELIEF IN THAT WAY.
07:57:46PM THANK YOU.
07:57:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
07:57:50PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: ALONG THOSE SAME LINES.
07:57:52PM I AM NOT GOING TO DISAGREE.
07:57:54PM A FIRE STATION WITHIN A MILE AND A HALF, BUT HOW MANY
07:57:57PM RESIDENTS ARE THERE?
07:57:59PM IN OTHER WORDS, ARE WE GOING FROM X PLUS Y PLUS Z EQUALS
07:58:07PM DANGER.
07:58:07PM AT THE X, THEN WHEN YOUR DEVELOPMENT, THE Y, BECAUSE IT WILL
07:58:12PM PUT A STRESS ON THAT FIRE STATION.
07:58:14PM IT HAS GOT TO BE MOVED, SO SMALL, THEY COULDN'T PUT OUT A
07:58:20PM BRUSH FIRE.
07:58:20PM THE CITY IS OLDER THAN ME.
07:58:22PM AND IT IS -- IT WOULD BE A FEATHER IN YOUR HAT TO -- TO JUST
07:58:27PM CONSIDER SOMETHING LIKE THAT.
07:58:28PM AND MAYBE WE WILL CALL IT THE DARRYL SHAW FIRE STATION.
07:58:33PM I AM ONLY SAYING THAT AS A JOKE, BUT I MEAN, IT'S SOMETHING
07:58:39PM THAT -- SOMETHING THAT IS NEEDED.
07:58:42PM AND NOT ONLY THERE BUT AT LEAST TWO OR THREE MORE NEEDED
07:58:49PM BECAUSE OF A GROWTH POPULATION-WISE.
07:58:51PM THOSE ARE NUMBERS THAT ARE -- YOU DON'T NEED -- THE LAND IN
07:58:56PM THE CITY OF TAMPA IS NOT EXPANDING BUT YOU DON'T NEED FIRE
07:58:59PM STATION FOR LAND, BECAUSE THE BASE WITHIN THAT LAND IS
07:59:03PM GROWING EXPEDITIOUSLY EVERY DAY.
07:59:05PM BETWEEN GOOD PEOPLE LIKE YOURSELF AND YOUR CLIENT, MR. SHAW,
07:59:10PM AND OTHERS WHO ARE DOING A FANTASTIC OPPORTUNITY FOR THEM
07:59:12PM AND FOR THE CITY, DON'T GET ME WRONG.
07:59:15PM SOMETHING THAT -- SOMETHING THAT YOU SHOULD CONSIDER.
07:59:18PM >> COUNCIL, WE ARE -- I NEED TO BE CAREFUL HOW TO CHOOSE MY
07:59:24PM WORDS HERE.
07:59:24PM WE ARE AWARE OF THE NEED AND HAD CONVERSATIONS WITH THE CITY
07:59:28PM ABOUT THE NEEDS.
07:59:29PM THIS PROJECT HAS A PRETTY LONG TIMELINE.
07:59:33PM THE EASTERN PORTION OF THIS FROM A CLOSING PERSPECTIVE IS
07:59:36PM SIGNIFICANTLY DELAYED BECAUSE OF THE RELOCATION NEEDS OF THE
07:59:39PM CURRENT OCCUPANT.
07:59:41PM I DON'T THINK A WEEK WILL GO BY WHERE WE ARE NOT HAVING
07:59:44PM SIGNIFICANT CONVERSATIONS WITH THE CITY ABOUT THE NEED.
07:59:46PM GRAND A PERMITTING PERSPECTIVE, IT -- YOU ARE NOT GOING TO
07:59:50PM BE ABLE TO GET PERMITS IF YOU ARE OUT OF FIRE CAPACITY.
07:59:53PM OUT OF SEWER CAPACITY.
07:59:55PM OUT OF ANY CAPACITY.
07:59:56PM WE ARE MINDFUL OF THE IMPACT THIS PROJECT WILL HAVE.
07:59:59PM WE ARE MINDFUL THE REAL ESTATE RESOURCES IN THE AREA.
08:00:03PM AND I -- I DON'T WANT THAT TO SOUND LIKE A BRUSH-OFF.
08:00:07PM I CAN'T POINT TO COMMIT WHERE A FACILITY WILL GO BUT WE ARE
08:00:11PM MINDFUL OF IT NOT BECAUSE IT IS THE RIGHT THING TO DO FOR
08:00:14PM THE CITY BUT THE DEVELOPMENT DOESN'T WORK IF THERE IS NOT
08:00:18PM ADEQUATE PUBLIC FACILITIES.
08:00:19PM NOT JUST OUR COMMITMENT BUT THE LAW.
08:00:21PM >> JUST GIVING A CLASSIC EXAMPLE, FIRE STATION NUMBER 1, I
08:00:27PM THINK THAT WAS BUILT IN 1977.
08:00:28PM I AM NOT SURE, BUT I THINK IT WAS.
08:00:30PM AND -- SO '77 TO 2000, THAT IS A -- THAT IS A LONG TIME.
08:00:41PM 50 YEAR.
08:00:44PM THE POPULATION WHEN THAT FIRE STATION WAS BUILT.
08:00:49PM NOTHING DOWNTOWN OTHER THAN HARBOR ISLAND WAS VACANT.
08:00:57PM CITRUS NITRATE EVERYWHERE.
08:00:59PM WE HAD A JAIL.
08:01:00PM THAT WAS ABOUT IT.
08:01:01PM BIG DIFFERENCES HAPPEN SINCE THEN.
08:01:09PM IN FACT I AM GOING BACK TO 2007 WHEN YOU BROUGHT IT UP, THAT
08:01:15PM COUNCIL THAT CHANGE IT.
08:01:16PM I DON'T THINK THAT WAS YOUR FIRM THAT HANDLED THAT CASE, IN
08:01:19PM MY MIND.
08:01:20PM I THINK IT WAS DAVE MECHANIK.
08:01:21PM BUT MY COMPUTER AIN'T WORKING TOO WELL TODAY.
08:01:25PM >> YOU ARE CORRECT, SIR.
08:01:27PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I AM TRYING TO THINK OUT LOUD.
08:01:30PM I THOUGHT IT WAS DAVE MECHANIK.
08:01:33PM >> IT WAS, SIR.
08:01:34PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THANK YOU.
08:01:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
08:01:36PM YES, SIR.
08:01:37PM >>BILL CARLSON: TYLER, I WANTED TO ASK YOU A QUESTION.
08:01:39PM LEGAL CAN SHUT ME DOWN OR HELP ME ANSWER IT.
08:01:42PM WE WERE TALKING ABOUT THE -- ABOUT THE MARITIME INDUSTRY
08:01:46PM I KNOW IN -- IN SOME CASES WHEN PEOPLE DEVELOP NEXT TO
08:01:52PM INDUSTRIAL AREAS LIKE AN AIRPORT, THERE ARE SOME RIDERS OR
08:01:55PM WHATEVER, REQUIREMENTS THAT PEOPLE MOVE INTO APARTMENTS OR
08:01:58PM SOMETHING, THEY HAVE TO SIGN THAT THEY UNDERSTAND IT IS A
08:02:02PM WORKING INDUSTRIAL AREA.
08:02:04PM IS THAT -- IS THAT POSSIBLE TO DO THAT?
08:02:06PM IS IT APPROPRIATE TO TALK ABOUT IT IN THIS QUORUM?
08:02:10PM MY CONCERN IS, I DON'T WANT PEOPLE TO MOVE INTO THE CONDOS
08:02:15PM NEXT TO THE WORKING PORT, AND THEN SAY, NOW YOU NEED TO GET
08:02:18PM RID OF THE WORKING PORT BECAUSE I DON'T LIKE THE WAY IT
08:02:21PM WORKS.
08:02:22PM >> I THINK IT IS APPROPRIATE.
08:02:23PM A FAIR QUESTION.
08:02:24PM I BELIEVE WATER STREET, PERHAPS, DID THAT -- WHAT YOU ARE
08:02:27PM ASKING ABOUT IS IN ANY RESIDENTIAL OWNERSHIP SITUATION LIKE
08:02:30PM A CONDOMINIUM, THAT YOU INCLUDE IN THAT DISCLAIMER, RELEASES
08:02:35PM ABOUT, YOU KNOW, THE NOISE, THE EMISSIONS, THE LIGHT
08:02:41PM VIBRATION THAT IS THERE AND THEY ACKNOWLEDGE IT IS THERE.
08:02:43PM I WOULD WANT TO TALK TO CATE AND WORK WHAT THAT WILL LOOK
08:02:49PM LIKE, BUT COULD BE PRIOR TO THE CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY FOR
08:02:53PM A RESIDENTIAL BUILDING, THAT THE APPLICANT WOULD DEMONSTRATE
08:02:56PM THAT EITHER -- THERE WAS A RECORDED DOCUMENT OR CONDO OR
08:03:01PM SOMETHING IN THE LEASE WITH -- WITH THAT TYPE OF DISCLAIMER
08:03:05PM LANGUAGE.
08:03:05PM THAT DOES HAPPEN.
08:03:06PM THAT IS NOT LIKE A WILD IDEA.
08:03:09PM >>BILL CARLSON: FOR ME LESS OF -- DISCLAIMER SOUNDS LIKE A
08:03:14PM LIABILITY DISCLOSURE.
08:03:15PM FOR ME IT IS MORE MAKING THE TENANT AWARE --
08:03:19PM >> MAKES OUR LIFE EASIER TOO.
08:03:20PM >>BILL CARLSON: IDEALLY STAYING YOU ARE MOVING NEXT TO AN
08:03:23PM INDUSTRIAL AREA.
08:03:24PM YOU CAN'T COMPLAIN ABOUT IT.
08:03:26PM OPINION FIRST AMENDMENT WOULDN'T ALLOW THAT.
08:03:29PM BUT ANY WAY TO WORK ON THAT --
08:03:30PM >> I THINK CATE AND I CAN COME UP WITH A NOTE BETWEEN FIRST
08:03:34PM AND SECOND READING.
08:03:36PM YEAH.
08:03:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN VIERA.
08:03:38PM THEN COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
08:03:39PM >>LUIS VIERA: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:03:41PM I APPRECIATE THE -- YOU KNOW, THE POLICY DISCUSSIONS ON
08:03:45PM TAMPA FIRE RESCUE.
08:03:46PM YOU KNOW, THAT'S WHY -- GOSH, MAYBE FOUR AND A HALF OR SO
08:03:51PM YEARS AGO WE FIRST STARTED TALKING OF A PUBLIC SAFETY MASTER
08:03:55PM PLAN AND GOES TO ISSUES LIKE THIS. THIS.
08:03:57PM THIS IS A POLICY ISSUE.
08:03:59PM FOR ME -- THAT IS A POLICY ISSUE VERSUS THIS BEING A LEGAL
08:04:03PM ISSUE THAT WE ARE HERE BEFORE US.
08:04:04PM AND I WANT TO MAKE SURE OBVIOUSLY -- NO OBJECTION FROM TAMPA
08:04:09PM FIRE RESCUE, PUBLIC SAFETY ON THIS, I WOULD SAY TSUNAMI.
08:04:12PM AND SO FOR ME, I HAVE BEEN VERY VOCAL ABOUT THIS FOR MANY
08:04:16PM YEARS.
08:04:17PM I THINK THAT LOCAL GOVERNMENTS, ESPECIALLY THE CITY OF
08:04:20PM TAMPA, A BIG FAILURE TO KEEP UP WITH GROWTH IN THE CITY OF
08:04:24PM TAMPA WITH THE PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE THAT WE NEED, RIGHT,
08:04:27PM ALL OVER THE CITY.
08:04:28PM BUT THAT IS A POLICY DISCUSSION.
08:04:30PM I WOULDN'T WANT TO CONFUSE THAT WITH THE LEGAL ISSUES AT
08:04:34PM HAND.
08:04:35PM FOR ME OBVIOUSLY, I STRONGLY SUPPORTED MORE FIRE STATION
08:04:38PM THROUGHOUT OUR CITY OF TAMPA, ETC., THAT I -- ON MY OWN END.
08:04:42PM I DON'T WANT TO CONFUSE THE LEGAL WITH THE POLICY, BUT,
08:04:46PM YEAH, BUT IT IS A GOOD POLICY DISCUSSION.
08:04:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
08:04:51PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I JUST WANTED TO SEE IF WE CAN RETROACTIVELY
08:04:55PM ADD SOMETHING ABOUT THE YBOR CHICKENS TO GASWORX.
08:04:58PM [LAUGHTER]
08:04:59PM JUST SAYING.
08:05:00PM I MEAN --
08:05:03PM >> THEY ARE STAYING.
08:05:07PM >>LYNN HURTAK: JUST WARNING PEOPLE BECAUSE WE GET COMPLAINTS.
08:05:10PM >> REALLY?
08:05:12PM >>LYNN HURTAK: PEOPLE MOVE INTO YBOR AND COMPLAIN ABOUT THE
08:05:15PM CHICKENS.
08:05:16PM >> THAT IS SHOCKING TO ME.
08:05:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: KEEP IT GOING.
08:05:19PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I THOUGHT YOU WERE GOING TO SUGGEST
08:05:21PM SENDING THEM TO KENTUCKY FRIED CHICKEN.
08:05:23PM I ACTUALLY HAVE SOMETHING TO SAY.
08:05:29PM SO -- COUNCIL, I WANTED -- I WANTED TO ECHO WHAT COUNCILMAN
08:05:36PM VIERA JUST SAID.
08:05:37PM I DON'T WANT TO BE SIDE RAILED ON THIS OTHER DISCUSSION
08:05:42PM BECAUSE THERE WAS A DIVIDE BETWEEN THE ISSUE TODAY THAT WE
08:05:45PM HAVE TO DISCUSS AND THE PUBLIC POLICY ISSUES ABOUT
08:05:47PM GOVERNMENT PROVIDED SERVICES.
08:05:48PM I THINK THAT -- THAT IS SOMETHING THAT WE OBVIOUSLY HAVE AN
08:05:51PM ACTIVE CONVERSATION ON COUNCIL ABOUT HOW WE ARE GOING TO
08:05:55PM FUND THESE PUBLIC SAFETY ENTITIES -- AMENITIES.
08:05:58PM AND -- BUT I DON'T NECESSARILY THINK THAT -- I WOULD CAUTION
08:06:02PM MY COLLEAGUES NOT TO TIE THESE THINGS TOGETHER.
08:06:05PM BECAUSE WHILE WE HAVE TO CONSIDER THAT AS WE HAVE THE
08:06:08PM DISCUSSION ON THE BUILDING FIRE STATIONS, ABOUT THE NEEDS
08:06:11PM FOR THOSE, I THINK THAT -- THAT IS -- SO THIS -- WHEN THIS
08:06:15PM -- HOPEFULLY THIS PROJECT MOVES FORWARD, WHEN WE COME BACK
08:06:18PM AND TALK ABOUT FIRE STATIONS, WE CAN TALK ABOUT WHY PETITION
08:06:21PM TO FUND THEM AND WHAT WE HAVE TO DO AND USE THIS AS
08:06:24PM JUSTIFICATION FOR THAT, BUT I DON'T NECESSARILY THINK THESE
08:06:28PM ARE TIED TOGETHER.
08:06:29PM >> IT WASN'T A QUESTION BUT IF I CAN MAKE A QUICK COMMENT.
08:06:32PM I WANT TO REITERATE HOW EARLY IT IS IN THE PROCESS.
08:06:35PM INFRASTRUCTURE AGREEMENTS THAT HAVE TO COME BEFORE YOU.
08:06:37PM DARYL, A GROUP IS A VERY SIGNIFICANT STAKEHOLDER IN THE
08:06:41PM SUCCESS OF THIS ENTIRE AREA.
08:06:43PM DARYL HAS BEEN AN ACTIVE PARTICIPANT IN THE CONVERSATIONS
08:06:46PM FOR A LONG TIME.
08:06:47PM I PROMISE YOU THAT WILL CONTINUE ON HIS BEHALF, AND MINE.
08:06:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY HERE FOR PUBLIC COMMENT, MR.
08:06:53PM ROBINSON, ARE YOU GOING TO COME UP?
08:06:56PM ANYBODY ELSE?
08:06:59PM IF YOU ARE GOING TO SPEAK, PLEASE LINE UP.
08:07:01PM IF NOT, GO AHEAD, SIR.
08:07:03PM >> JOE ROBINSON.
08:07:05PM ONCE AGAIN, LET'S JUST GO THROUGH THE THING HERE.
08:07:09PM FIRST OF ALL, MAN, I HAVEN'T SEEN A 15-FOOT SIDEWALK SINCE I
08:07:14PM WALKED DOWN CENTRAL AVENUE IN ST. PETERSBURG.
08:07:17PM TALKING OF 15-FOOT SIDEWALKS.
08:07:19PM WALKABILITY COMMUNITY, HOUSING.
08:07:24PM YOU KNOW THE CITY GOT A FIREBOAT THAT SHOOT WATER, SO COME
08:07:27PM UP YBOR HARBOR AND PUT FIRES OUT AT LEAST FROM THE POET WE
08:07:31PM GOT, RIGHT.
08:07:32PM THINK ABOUT THAT.
08:07:33PM MOVING RIGHT ALONG -- YOU CAN'T DO THAT ANYWHERE ELSE IN THE
08:07:38PM CITY.
08:07:38PM THEY HAVE A FIREBOAT.
08:07:39PM USE IT FOR GASPARILLA, AND GO AND SHOOT THE WATER FROM SOME
08:07:43PM OF THE BUILDINGS IF THEY DO CATCH ON.
08:07:45PM DESIGN GUIDELINES ARE VERY IMPORTANT AS AN ENGINEER.
08:07:47PM THESE PEOPLE GOT A BIBLE ON DESIGN GUIDELINES.
08:07:52PM WOW.
08:07:53PM AND THIS IS NOT GOING TO HAPPEN OVERNIGHT.
08:07:56PM THIS IS GOING TO BE PHASED OF PD-A, ALTERNATIVE.
08:08:01PM GOT TO COME IN HERE.
08:08:03PM GOT TO COME IN HERE.
08:08:04PM KEEP COMING IN HERE.
08:08:05PM KEEP COMING IN HERE.
08:08:06PM EVERY TIMING IS COME UP.
08:08:08PM PLANNING COMMISSION SAID IT LOOKED GOOD.
08:08:09PM DESIGN GUIDELINES LOOK GOOD.
08:08:11PM THEY WANT BONUS POINTS FOR 10% AFFORDABLE UNITS.
08:08:18PM 475, THEY ARE CLAIMING.
08:08:20PM COME ON, CITY OF TAMPA, THERE IS ANOTHER ITEM THAT IS CALLED
08:08:26PM A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT.
08:08:29PM NOW I HEAR ABOUT THIS FIRE STATION AND ALL OF THAT, BUT THE
08:08:33PM CITY GOT TO GIVE SOMETHING UP TO GET SOMETHING OF A
08:08:35PM DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT.
08:08:36PM TO GET A COMMUNITY BENEFIT AGREEMENT.
08:08:38PM WE HAVE AN ORDINANCE FOR THAT WHICH I WILL TALK ABOUT NEXT
08:08:41PM THING.
08:08:41PM BUT THIS IS WHAT SOMEONE ALREADY SAID.
08:08:44PM THIS IS TRANSFORMATION IN A POSITIVE WAY.
08:08:47PM OKAY.
08:08:48PM SO NOW WE GOT EVERYBODY BE ON BOARD.
08:08:53PM WE ARE TAKING AN AREA THAT -- COME ON, MAN.
08:08:56PM DID YOU SEE THEM PICTURES?
08:08:58PM IF THAT AIN'T SLUM AND BLIGHT, I DON'T KNOW WHAT IS.
08:09:01PM THAT DON'T LOOK GOOD.
08:09:03PM BACK IN THE DAY WHEN WE HAD BANANA AND COCA-COLA AND ALL OF
08:09:08PM THAT, MAN, USED TO WORK DOWN THERE BOXING FOR COCA-COLA --
08:09:12PM AND MY -- MY -- MY FATHER AND I STEVEDORS WORKED IN THE HULL
08:09:19PM OF ALL THOSE SHIPS.
08:09:20PM THAT WAS A GOOD JOB FOR A BROTHER BACK THEN.
08:09:23PM PERRY HARVEY AND ALL OF THAT, CHARLIE.
08:09:26PM I AM VERY FAMILIAR WITH MARITIME.
08:09:28PM IT HELPED PUT ME THROUGH ST. PETER CLAVER.
08:09:34PM OKAY.
08:09:34PM WHAT I AM SAYING I DON'T HAVE AN ISSUE FOR THIS.
08:09:37PM WHEN I CAME DOWN -- DOING THIS KIND OF MEGA DEVELOPMENT.
08:09:41PM YOU HAVE TO UNDERSTAND WHO IS DOING IT.
08:09:44PM ANYBODY JUST CAN'T DO IT.
08:09:45PM A LOT OF DEVELOPERS OUT THERE.
08:09:47PM THEY DON'T WANT WALKABILITY.
08:09:49PM THEY DON'T WANT CONNECTIVITY.
08:09:51PM THEY DON'T WANT ANYBODY BUT TO TRY TO MAKE A PROFIT.
08:09:54PM YOU HAVE SOMEBODY WHO COMES IN AND WANTS TO DO THE RIGHT
08:09:57PM THING AND SPEND THEIR MONEY, MAN, PLEASE, SO THEY CAN GO
08:10:00PM AHEAD ON THE TAX ROLL AND PAY SOME OTHER BILLS IN THE CITY.
08:10:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:10:05PM YES, MA'AM.
08:10:06PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
08:10:07PM >> HELLO, CITY COUNCIL.
08:10:10PM TATIANA MORALES.
08:10:14PM OUR CHAPTER WANTED TO COME IN SUPPORT OF THIS PROJECT,
08:10:18PM MOSTLY BECAUSE AS YOU KNOW WE HAVE 150 PEOPLE A DAY.
08:10:21PM WE HAVE A PRETTY MASSIVE HOUSING CRISIS AND ONLY 4% OF
08:10:24PM VACANT LAND IN THE CITY.
08:10:25PM SOMEONE WHO SAT AND LISTENED TO A LOT OF YOUR MEETINGS.
08:10:28PM A LOT OF PLACES THAT YOU DISAGREE WHERE THAT WILL GO.
08:10:33PM A LAND CONNECTING THE DOWNTOWN AND YBOR AREA WHICH IS
08:10:36PM ALREADY HAPPENING AND DARRYL SHAW IS ONE OF THE LARGEST
08:10:38PM PRIVATE DEVELOPER BRINGING IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
08:10:40PM GASWORX WAS THE PREVIOUS LARGEST CONTRIBUTION AND THIS WILL
08:10:45PM BE THE NEXT LARGEST CONTRIBUTION.
08:10:46PM TO GET AFFORDABLE HOUSING, HOW DO WE WORK WITH DEVELOPERS TO
08:10:51PM HAVE A CITY THAT WHERE WE LIVE.
08:10:54PM IT IS GROWING.
08:10:54PM PERSON WHO TRIED TO LIVE IN YBOR EVERY SINGLE YEAR, PEOPLE
08:10:58PM DO NOT MOVE.
08:10:59PM BECAUSE THEY LOVE YBOR.
08:11:00PM I LOVE YBOR.
08:11:01PM I LIVE 20 MINUTES AWAY AND I SPEND PRETTY MUCH EVERY DAY
08:11:04PM GOING TO YBOR TO GET SOME COFFEE OR SOMETHING.
08:11:07PM I THINK IT IS IMPORTANT THAT WE LOOK AT THE FUTURE OF THE
08:11:09PM CITY TO BE EXCITED OF THIS.
08:11:11PM I GREW UP IN MIAMI, I SAW A LOT OF NASTY PROJECTS THAT DID A
08:11:15PM LOT OF WEIRD THINGS OVER THE CITY THAT WEREN'T TAKEN ACCOUNT
08:11:18PM WITH CONVERSATION WITH FIRE, POLICE, WITH THE PORT.
08:11:20PM AND THIS IS ACTUALLY THREADING -- TYLER SAID IT BEST,
08:11:24PM THREADING A VERY CAREFUL NEEDLE OF CONNECTING OUR CITY.
08:11:27PM WE WON'T GET THAT SCALE OF PROJECT IN THE U;F AREA.
08:11:30PM THEY WILL NOT LAND FOR IT.
08:11:32PM NOT ANOTHER PLACE FOR THIS SCALE OF DEVELOPMENT AND SAYING
08:11:35PM WE WILL BE A STILL WHERE ALL THIS CONNECTS AND NOT A CITY
08:11:37PM WHERE I -- ON NUCCIO THIS THEY ARE LIKE WHERE IS THAT
08:11:42PM DOWNTOWN THING.
08:11:43PM IF WE LOOK AT THIS PROJECT -- A BEAUTIFUL PROJECT
08:11:45PM CONSIDERING THE AMOUNT OF PEOPLE THAT PUT THE WORK INTO IT.
08:11:48PM AND WILLING TO MAKE THE CHANGES.
08:11:51PM I WANT TO MAKE A COMMENT ON FIRE.
08:11:52PM I E-MAILED YOU A MONTH OR TWO OF SUGGESTIONS OF DIFFERENT
08:11:56PM DEVELOPMENTS.
08:11:56PM THIS CLEARWATER WHERE THEY INCORPORATED FIRE INTO THE
08:12:00PM DEVELOPMENT.
08:12:00PM BEAUTIFUL THING.
08:12:01PM TONS OF PUBLIC RESOURCES.
08:12:03PM AND ONCE AGAIN, I THINK MR. VIERA SAID IT BEST, SOMETIMES WE
08:12:06PM CONFUSE THESE POLICY DECISIONS WITH OTHER THINGS.
08:12:08PM SOMETIMES WE CONFUSE THE LACK OF FIRE ON AN INDIVIDUAL
08:12:11PM DEVELOPER.
08:12:12PM I THINK AS A CITY GROWS, WE HAVE TO GROW WITH IT.
08:12:15PM A CITY LIKE A TOWN.
08:12:16PM FOUR IN WE ARE A CITY AND I WANT TO BE CONFIDENT WE ARE A
08:12:19PM CITY AND BOTH CONVERSATIONS HAVE TO HAPPEN AT ONCE.
08:12:21PM BUDGET ANALYST.
08:12:22PM HOW DO WE GET MORE FIRE STATIONS.
08:12:25PM I KNOW YOU PROBABLY HAVE DONE THAT, TO BE HONEST.
08:12:28PM BUT HERE TO SUPPORT THE PROJECT.
08:12:30PM GET THESE UNITS ON THE GROUND AND MOVING THE CITY FORWARD.
08:12:32PM A COUPLE -- AREN'T GOING TO MOVE THE NEEDLE.
08:12:36PM THIS WILL MOVE THE NEEDLE, THANK YOU.
08:12:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
08:12:40PM IF NOT, I HAVE TWO REGISTERED SPEAKERS.
08:12:42PM ONE IS JEN.
08:12:45PM HOW ABOUT MIKE LAWSON.
08:12:47PM NO?
08:12:50PM >> I WILL HOLD MY COMMENT.
08:12:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: OKAY.
08:12:52PM ANY COUNCILMEMBERS HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS BEFORE I
08:12:55PM GO TO REBUTTAL?
08:12:57PM YES, SIR, DO YOU HAVE REBUTTAL, SIR?
08:13:01PM >> NO, COUNCIL.
08:13:02PM I APPRECIATE YOUR THOUGHTFUL CONVERSATION.
08:13:04PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MOTION TO CLOSE.
08:13:06PM >> SECOND.
08:13:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WAIT.
08:13:08PM MISS DOCK, YES, MA'AM.
08:13:09PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
08:13:12PM I WANT TO PUT ON THE RECORD ONE ADDITIONAL AMENDMENT TO BE
08:13:17PM MADE AND APPLICANT HAS AGREED TO WORK WITH THE LEGAL
08:13:20PM DEPARTMENT TO DEVELOPMENT A NOTE THAT WILL ADDRESS SOME SORT
08:13:23PM OF NOTICE PROVIDED TO RESIDENTS OR OWNERS OF RESIDENTIAL
08:13:28PM UNITS OF THE EXISTING INDUSTRIAL USES THAT SURROUND THE
08:13:32PM PROPERTY.
08:13:32PM SO THAT NOTE WILL BE AGREED UPON AND ADDED TO THE SITE PLAN
08:13:36PM BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
08:13:38PM IF YOU CAN ADD THAT.
08:13:39PM THAT WILL BE ON THE RECORD AS AN ADDITION TO THE REVISIONS
08:13:43PM REQUIRED TO BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
08:13:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
08:13:47PM >>BILL CARLSON: THANK YOU FOR REMEMBERING THAT.
08:13:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILMAN
08:13:51PM CLENDENIN.
08:13:51PM SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN VIERA.
08:13:53PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
08:13:54PM ANY OPPOSED.
08:13:55PM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
08:13:56PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES, SIR.
08:13:57PM GLAD TO DO THIS.
08:13:59PM AND, AGAIN, YOU KNOW, LIKE I SAID BEFORE, AND MOVING FOR
08:14:03PM THIS, YOU KNOW THE ISSUE ON FIRE STATIONS IS A GREAT POLICY
08:14:07PM DISCUSSION TO HAVE.
08:14:08PM AND I BELIEVE PROBABLY THIS BUDGET WE ARE GOING TO SEE A --
08:14:13PM SOME DISCUSSIONS ON POTENTIALLY SOMETHING CHANNELSIDE, WHO
08:14:18PM KNOWS, DOWNTOWN, WHATEVER.
08:14:19PM AND THOSE ARE -- THOSE ARE GREAT DISCUSSIONS TO HAVE.
08:14:22PM I DID ALSO WANT TO MENTION, IF I MAY HERE, THAT -- BECAUSE I
08:14:26PM HEARD SOME THINGS ABOUT THE UNIVERSITY SQUARE NORTH TAMPA
08:14:28PM AREA THAT IN -- IN JUNE, THE PLANNING COMMISSION IS COMING
08:14:33PM TO CITY COUNCIL.
08:14:33PM I MOTIONED FOR THEM TO COME TO TALK WITH THE CODE
08:14:36PM AMENDMENTS.
08:14:37PM IT WILL BE A GOOD DISCUSSION TO HAVE.
08:14:38PM BUT I WILL FINALLY READ THIS.
08:14:40PM I MOVE AN ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING
08:14:43PM CONSIDERATION.
08:14:44PM ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 610
08:14:48PM HARBOR STREET.
08:14:50PM 1705 EAST ADAMO, 60 AND 1026 NORTH 19th STREET, 1821
08:15:01PM EAST SALMAN DRIVE.
08:15:02PM 101 AND 102 AND FOLIO NUMBER 190093-2306 FROM PD PLANNED
08:15:11PM DEVELOPMENT, CD-2, CHANNEL DISTRICT TWO AND IH TO PD-A
08:15:21PM AND CD-2 AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
08:15:24PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
08:15:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SECOND AND COMMENTS.
08:15:28PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
08:15:30PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YOU HAVE TO STATE --
08:15:32PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THE REVISION SHEET.
08:15:33PM >>LUIS VIERA: WITH I APOLOGIZE, WITH THE REVISION SHEET.
08:15:36PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
08:15:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION AND A SECOND.
08:15:38PM ANY FINAL COMMENTS BEFORE WE ASK FOR A VOTE?
08:15:41PM COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
08:15:41PM >>BILL CARLSON: JUST ONE THING.
08:15:43PM THE FACT THAT NO OPPOSITION SHOWS UP IS TYPICALLY INDICATIVE
08:15:51PM OF THE EFFORT THAT THE APPLICANT MAKES TO TALK TO THE
08:15:54PM COMMUNITY AND YOU CAN SEE THE RESULT HERE TONIGHT.
08:15:56PM THANK YOU TO THE APPLICANT FOR DOING THEIR WORK SO WE DON'T
08:15:59PM HAVE TO DO OUR --
08:16:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR -- YES, MA'AM.
08:16:06PM >>LYNN HURTAK: AND I RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE WITH MY
08:16:09PM COLLEAGUES.
08:16:10PM I THINK THERE IS ALWAYS TIME FOR POLICY DISCUSSION.
08:16:13PM IF WE DON'T BRING IT UP NOW, WHEN CAN WE?
08:16:17PM WE ARE NOT ALLOWED TO TALK TO DEVELOPERS.
08:16:20PM IF THE DEVELOPER START HEARING THAT WE EXPECT TO SEE THEM IN
08:16:24PM THE LARGER PROJECTS, WE MIGHT START SEEING THEM.
08:16:26PM I DO BELIEVE THIS IS SOMETHING WE NEED TO SEE IN THESE TYPES
08:16:29PM OF PROJECTS.
08:16:29PM WE NEED TO SEE THOUGHT FOR WHAT THEY ARE CREATING.
08:16:33PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ROLL CALL VOTE.
08:16:37PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
08:16:40PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
08:16:41PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
08:16:44PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
08:16:45PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
08:16:48PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
08:16:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
08:16:50PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED -- MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
08:16:59PM SECOND READING ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MAY 2, 2024 AT 9:30
08:17:04PM A.M. LOCATED AT OLD CITY HALL 315 E. KENNEDY BOULEVARD,
08:17:08PM THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
08:17:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE RESOLUTION WILL NOT BE ADOPTED UNTIL
08:17:14PM AFTER THE SECOND PUBLIC HEARING.
08:17:17PM >>LUIS VIERA: MAY I, MR. CHAIR.
08:17:18PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK BROUGHT UP A VERY GOOD POINT.
08:17:21PM MY POINT ON POLICY LEGAL, I DIDN'T WANT TO USE A POLICY
08:17:24PM ISSUE AS A LEGAL JUSTIFICATION FOR DENYING IT.
08:17:27PM YOUR POINTS ARE VERY WELL TAKEN IN THE DISCUSSION.
08:17:29PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I ABSOLUTELY DIDN'T WANT TO DENY ANYTHING,
08:17:32PM BUT WE GOT TO -- IN FACT, I WAS ASKING TO ASK MISS JOHNS
08:17:36PM ABOUT THIS.
08:17:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
08:17:38PM >>BILL CARLSON: I DIDN'T WANT TO SAY ANYTHING DURING THAT
08:17:41PM CASE, BUT WE SHOULD HAVE THIS DISCUSSION ANOTHER TIME.
08:17:43PM BUT THE FIRST FLOOR OF THE PARKING GARAGE ACROSS FROM --
08:17:50PM FROM THE --
08:17:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE AQUARIUM?
08:17:55PM >>BILL CARLSON: DOWN FROM THE AQUARIUM.
08:17:56PM SPARKMAN WHARF.
08:17:59PM THAT IS -- THAT IS AVAILABLE.
08:18:00PM WE ASKED THE QUESTION.
08:18:01PM AND THE ADMINISTRATION SAID THEY WOULD CHECK WITH THE PORT
08:18:05PM AND THE PORT HAS A LEASE AND THEY ASKED US TO RECEIVE AND
08:18:08PM FILE.
08:18:08PM YOU KNEW THAT THE PORT ALREADY HAD A LEASE, BUT AT LEAST THE
08:18:11PM TENANT SAID THEY ARE FINE WITH US USING IT AS A FIRE
08:18:15PM STATION.
08:18:15PM IT IS NOT -- THERE HAS TO BE MORE INFORMATION AND THAT IS A
08:18:18PM SPACE THAT IS AVAILABLE.
08:18:20PM BUT WE HAVE TO HAVE MORE CONVERSATION ABOUT IT ANYWAY.
08:18:23PM THANK YOU.
08:18:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
08:18:25PM MISS JOHNS.
08:18:26PM >>REBECCA JOHNS: REBECCA JOHNS, LEGAL DEPARTMENT, ITEM 5,
08:18:33PM THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT REGARDING EAT ABOVE HARBOR
08:18:37PM PROJECT.
08:18:37PM AGREEMENT BETWEEN CITY OF TAMPA AND BANANA DOCK LCC.
08:18:46PM AND AT THE DEVELOPER'S SOLE COST AND EXPENSE.
08:18:49PM THOSE INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS ARE OUTLINED IN SECTION 7
08:18:53PM OF THIS AGREEMENT.
08:18:54PM THERE WILL BE SEPARATE INFRASTRUCTURE AGREEMENTS FOR EACH
08:18:57PM PHASE OF THE DEVELOPMENT WHICH WILL COME BEFORE YOU.
08:18:59PM THEY WILL ALSO BE CITY APPROVAL OF PL, THE INFRASTRUCTURE
08:19:06PM PLAN AND PLATS DONE FOR EACH PHASE.
08:19:08PM WE DO WANT TO ADD THAT THERE WILL BE THREE REVISIONS TO THIS
08:19:14PM AGREEMENT PRIOR TO THE SECOND READING.
08:19:16PM ONE IS TO ADD LANGUAGE THAT THE PLATS -- THE PLN AND THE
08:19:23PM INFRASTRUCTURE AGREEMENTS FOR EACH PHASE WILL BE APPROVED
08:19:27PM FOR THE CITY PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE OF THE FIRST BUILDING
08:19:30PM PERMIT OF EACH PHASE.
08:19:31PM WE WILL ALSO BE SUBSTITUTING THE SITE PLAN OUT WITH THE
08:19:35PM UPDATED SITE PLAN FROM THE REZONING.
08:19:36PM AND WE WILL ALSO BE ADDING THE LANGUAGE THAT THEY COME UP
08:19:40PM WITH REGARDING THE DISCLOSURE TO THE TENANTS PER COUNCILMAN
08:19:45PM CARLSON'S IDEA.
08:19:45PM PLEASE NOTE, THIS PROPERTY IS OWNED BY MULTIPLE PROPERTY
08:19:49PM OWNERS.
08:19:50PM THEY WILL ALL BE SIGNING JOINERS TO THE AGREEMENT.
08:19:54PM I REMIND THE CHAIR TO PLEASE ANNOUNCE THE DATE OF THE SECOND
08:19:58PM PUBLIC HEARING PRIOR TO CLOSING THIS PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE
08:20:02PM MAY 2 AT 9:30 A.M. AND THAT THE RESOLUTION WILL BE HELD
08:20:07PM UNTIL THE SECOND PUBLIC HEARING.
08:20:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
08:20:09PM >>REBECCA JOHNS: DEVELOPER IS HERE IF YOU HAVE ANY
08:20:13PM QUESTIONS.
08:20:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MISS JOHNS.
08:20:15PM ANYTHING FROM THE DEVELOPER?
08:20:17PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM.
08:20:19PM NOT MOVING THE RESOLUTION.
08:20:20PM THIS IS JUST THE FIRST PUBLIC HEARING.
08:20:23PM >> JOE ROBINSON.
08:20:25PM THAT IS WHAT I CAME HERE FOR.
08:20:27PM I AM FAMILIAR WITH DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENTS HAVING HAD ONE AT
08:20:31PM ROME YARD.
08:20:31PM I AM FAMILIAR WITH COMMUNITY BENEFIT AGREEMENT THAT THIS ONE
08:20:34PM DOESN'T TOUCH YET UNLESS THEY HAVE SOMETHING FROM THE CITY.
08:20:38PM UNLESS THEY WANT SOMETHING FROM THE CITY.
08:20:39PM CREDITS, TAX CREDITS, MONEY.
08:20:42PM THEY ARE IN A CRA ON THE WESTERN PORTION.
08:20:45PM IF THEY WANT SOMETHING, THEN WE CAN HIT THEM IN THE HEAD
08:20:48PM WITH THAT COMMUNITY BENEFIT AGREEMENT.
08:20:49PM AND THE CITY IS NOW IN THE PROCESS OF CODIFYING THE PROCESS
08:20:55PM OF DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENTS.
08:20:56PM THANKS TO MR. TAMPA HEIGHTS OVER THERE, ADAM HARDEN, ON THE
08:21:03PM PLANNING COMMISSION.
08:21:03PM THAT WILL BE TIMELY.
08:21:04PM SO, THEREFORE, THIS PARTICULAR D.A. HAS IN IT SOME REPORTING
08:21:13PM REQUIREMENTS.
08:21:14PM AND THEY ARE LISTED ON PAGE 12, THE LAST TIME I LOOKED ABOUT
08:21:17PM THE DEVELOPMENT AND THE REPORT, BLAH-BLAH-BLAH.
08:21:20PM SO IT IS ALREADY IN HERE.
08:21:21PM SO IF YOU DO GET TO THE COMMUNITY BENEFIT AND THEY GOT TO DO
08:21:25PM SOMETHING WITH EVO, OTHER REPORTING REQUIREMENTS IN THE
08:21:32PM DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT, THE LANGUAGE WILL BE THERE AND BEING
08:21:35PM CODIFIED.
08:21:36PM AND THE CITY ALREADY HAS FOR THE RECORD -- THEY ALREADY HAVE
08:21:40PM UNDER THE CODE OF ORDINANCES CHAPTER 2, ADMINISTRATION,
08:21:45PM SECTION 2850 COMMUNITY BENEFIT PROGRAM.
08:21:48PM IT IS ALREADY THE LAW.
08:21:49PM SO THIS SHOULD MOVE FORWARD.
08:21:51PM I'M HERE TO SUPPORT IT.
08:21:52PM I THINK THAT IT IS THE RIGHT THING TO DO.
08:21:55PM AND DOWN THE ROAD, YOU WILL BE REAL GLAD THAT YOU HAVE THIS
08:21:58PM AGREEMENT IN PLACE.
08:22:00PM AND SECOND READING, THERE MAY BE CHANGES BETWEEN NOW AND
08:22:04PM THEN.
08:22:04PM BUT RIGHT NOW, I WOULD SAY, LET'S GO FORWARD WITH IT.
08:22:07PM AND ONCE AGAIN, I STILL BELIEVE WHAT MISS HURTAK.
08:22:13PM I CAN'T BELIEVE -- PEOPLE COMING AROUND.
08:22:15PM ONE THING I LEARNED IN LIFE, RIGHT, CHARLIE, YOU ASK FOR IT,
08:22:19PM IT DOESN'T MEAN YOU WILL GET AN ANSWER, RIGHT.
08:22:21PM ALL THEY CAN SAY IS NO.
08:22:22PM BUT IF YOU DON'T ASK.
08:22:25PM IF YOU DON'T SAY SOMETHING.
08:22:26PM THEN THEY ARE GOING TO THINK IT AIN'T NECESSARILY GO GOING
08:22:30PM TO BE THOUGHT ABOUT.
08:22:31PM I GAVE YOU ONE BACK TONIGHT.
08:22:33PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:22:36PM ANYONE ELSE WISHING TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM?
08:22:39PM IF NOT, NO REBUTTAL.
08:22:41PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MOTION TO CLOSE.
08:22:42PM >>LUIS VIERA: SECOND.
08:22:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE ARE NOT READING ANYTHING YET.
08:22:47PM MAY 2 WILL BE THE SECOND PUBLIC HEARING AT 10:30 A.M., 315
08:22:55PM E. KENNEDY BOULEVARD, TAMPA, 3602.
08:22:59PM THIRD FLOOR.
08:23:00PM WE DON'T VOTE ON ANYTHING.
08:23:07PM ALL IN FAVOR TO CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING.
08:23:09PM AYE.
08:23:10PM EXACTLY WHAT I SAID.
08:23:11PM YES?
08:23:12PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I JUST WANT TO SAY THIS IS A MASSIVE
08:23:15PM PROJECT.
08:23:15PM IT IS VERY COMPLICATED AS YOU SAW SOME OF THE CONTINUATIONS
08:23:18PM ON -- THAT WE SPOKE ABOUT IN THE EARLIER ISSUES.
08:23:21PM I WANT TO THANK CITY STAFF FOR WORKING THROUGH THIS
08:23:24PM COMPLICATED PROCESS ALONG WITH THE DEVELOPER AND HAVING A
08:23:27PM COLLABORATIVE -- FOR THE DEVELOPER TO BE COLLABORATIVE AND
08:23:32PM WORKING WITH STAFF.
08:23:33PM I KNOW THIS HAS TAKEN A LOT OF TIME AND STAFF HAS GONE ABOVE
08:23:36PM AND BEYOND TO BRING FORTH A GREAT PROJECT.
08:23:38PM WORKING TOGETHER WITH -- AND IN THAT TYPE OF RELATIONSHIP
08:23:41PM THEY HAVE ESTABLISHED.
08:23:42PM THE GIVE AND THE TAKE.
08:23:43PM I THINK IT REALLY SHOWS IN THAT SOMETHING THAT IS THIS
08:23:47PM TRANSFORMATIONAL HAS MADE IT THROUGH COUNCIL EASY THAN
08:23:51PM SOMETHING WE HAVE DISCUSSED 5,000-SQUARE-FOOT LOTS THAT
08:23:55PM TAKEN LONGER THAN SOME OF THIS STUFF.
08:23:57PM CONGRATULATIONS TO THE STAFF AND THE DEVELOPER FOR BRINGING
08:24:00PM FORWARD A GOOD PROJECT TONIGHT.
08:24:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
08:24:02PM ITEM NUMBER 6.
08:24:21PM >>SAM THOMAS: SAM THOMAS, ITEM NUMBER 6 FROM PLANNED
08:24:25PM DEVELOPMENT TO STOREFRONT RESIDENTIAL AND ALL USES.
08:24:28PM I WILL TURN IT OVER TO DANNY WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
08:24:31PM >>DANNY COLLINS: DANNY COLLINS WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION
08:24:37PM STAFF.
08:24:37PM I WAS SWORN IN.
08:24:39PM OUR NEXT CASE IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT EAST
08:24:42PM SIDE COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:24:43PM THE SITE IS WITHIN AN EVACUATION ZONE E.
08:24:47PM AN AERIAL MAP OF THE SITE AND THE SURROUNDING PROPERTIES.
08:24:50PM SITUATED IN THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF COLUMBUS DRIVE AND NORTH
08:24:53PM 54th STREET.
08:24:54PM THE SURROUNDING AREA IS PREDOMINANTLY RESIDENTIAL IN
08:24:59PM CHARACTER AND NONRESIDENTIAL USE ALONG COLUMBUS DRIVE AS
08:25:02PM WELL AS NORTH 56th STREET.
08:25:03PM HERE IS THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
08:25:09PM SUBJECT SITE IS RECOGNIZED UNDER THE CMU-35 DESIGNATION TO
08:25:16PM IT THE NORTH AND EAST OF THE SITE.
08:25:17PM R-35 TO THE SOUTH OF THE SITE AND THE AREA OVER HERE IS
08:25:21PM RECOGNIZED UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL OPEN SPACE DESIGNATION.
08:25:24PM STOREFRONT RESIDENTIAL USES CAN BE CONSIDERED IN THE CMU-35,
08:25:30PM 27-21 OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
08:25:32PM PROPOSED VERTICAL MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT WILL BE DEVELOPED
08:25:35PM WITH A F.A.R. OF 1.5 WHICH IS OF THE DENSITY ON THE
08:25:42PM CATEGORY.
08:25:42PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FIND THAT THE APPLICANT
08:25:45PM ADEQUATELY ADDRESSES THE MIXED USE CENTERS AND CORRIDORS AS
08:25:49PM WELL AS POLICIES THAT APPLY CITY WIDE.
08:25:51PM PROPOSED SITE PLAN INCLUDE SIDEWALKS ADJACENT TO THE SITE
08:25:54PM ALONG EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE AND NORTH 54th STREET WITH
08:25:59PM CONSISTENT WITH MOBILITY POLICIES AND BUILDING IS CLOSE TO
08:26:02PM BOTH RIGHT-OF-WAYS.
08:26:05PM ADDITIONALLY, THE TEAM ENTRANCE FACES EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE
08:26:10PM AND AN ADDITIONAL ENTRANCE ON THE CORNER OF COLUMBUS DRIVE
08:26:14PM AND NORTH 54th STREET.
08:26:16PM BUILDING PLACEMENT AND ORIENTATION IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
08:26:19PM OVERALL POLICY DIRECTION OF THE COMP PLAN.
08:26:22PM LU POLICY 1.2.27 REQUIRES PARKING GARAGES -- SAYS THE
08:26:28PM PARKING GARAGES SHOULD BE ARCHITECTURALLY COMPATIBLE AND
08:26:33PM SCREENED.
08:26:33PM BASED ON THE ELEVATION UNSURE IF THE PORTION IS OPEN OR WALL
08:26:41PM BLOCKS THE VIEW OF THE GARAGE.
08:26:42PM REGARDLESS, PLANNING COMMISSION STRONGLY ENCOURAGES TO
08:26:46PM BETTER INTEGRATE THE GARAGE WITH THE SURROUNDING AREA AND
08:26:49PM PROVIDE DESIGN ASPECTS SUCH AS PROVIDING WINDOWS AND DOORS
08:26:52PM TO BETTER ENGAGE THE PUBLIC REALM ALONG EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE.
08:26:59PM A EMPHASIS CORRIDOR.
08:27:03PM USE IS COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH THE SURROUNDING AREA.
08:27:06PM IN CONCLUSION, THE PD WITH MIXED USE PROJECT AND MULTIFAMILY
08:27:13PM USES IN THE AREA IN THE CMU-35 WILL PROMOTE A MIXED USE
08:27:18PM DEVELOPMENT AND SUPPORT THE PLAN'S GUIDANCE OF INCREASING
08:27:21PM DENSITIES NEAR TRANSIT SERVICES.
08:27:22PM BASED ON ANOTHER CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION
08:27:25PM STAFF IS CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
08:27:27PM AND THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION AND WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR
08:27:30PM ANY QUESTIONS.
08:27:31PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ANY QUESTIONS?
08:27:33PM YES, SIR.
08:27:34PM >>SAM THOMAS: SAM THOMAS, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
08:27:37PM WE WILL START OFF WITH OUR AERIAL MAP.
08:27:40PM AND THE SITE OUTLINED IN RED.
08:27:51PM THE GENERAL PATTERN IS MIXTURE OF SEMI DETACHED AND SINGLE
08:27:56PM FAMILY DETACHED ALONG NORTH 51st STREET AND NORTH 56th
08:28:00PM STREET AND SOUTH OF THIS LINE HERE.
08:28:01PM NORTH OF THIS LINE RIGHT HERE IS RS-50.
08:28:04PM SOUTH YOU HAVE THE RM-16 ZONING DISTRICT.
08:28:08PM JUST RIGHT NEXT TO THIS SITE HERE, YOU HAVE A DUPLEX.
08:28:10PM YOU HAVE SOME MULTIFAMILY OVER HERE AND MORE ALONG 14th
08:28:14PM STREET DOWN HERE.
08:28:14PM YOU HAVE OAK PARK HERE.
08:28:16PM AS YOU MOVE TO THE EAST OF 56th STREET, YOU HAVE COMMERCIAL
08:28:21PM INTENSIVE USES AND INDUSTRIAL GENERAL USES.
08:28:23PM IN GENERAL, THIS IS PART OF THE CITY THAT HAVEN'T SEEN TOO
08:28:27PM MUCH REDEVELOPMENT YET.
08:28:28PM MOST RECENT PD IN THIS AREA IS SOUTH OF 14TH STREET RIGHT HERE
08:28:32PM THAT WAS APPROVED IN 2021 UNDER REZ-99 THAT WAS APPROVED FOR THE
08:28:40PM 10,400 OF STRIP RETAIL AND CI USES AND 104 MULTIFAMILY
08:28:45PM UNITS.
08:28:45PM WE WILL GO AHEAD AND MOVE ON TO THE SITE PLAN.
08:28:50PM HERE IS THE SITE PLAN THAT THE APPLICANT PROPOSED.
08:28:58PM THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING 4O MULTIFAMILY UNITS AND THE
08:29:04PM BUILDING IS ORIENTED TOWARD COLUMBUS DRIVE.
08:29:07PM AND YOU HAVE AN EXIT ON NORTH 54th STREET HERE.
08:29:13PM THE MULTIFAMILY IS RIGHT HERE.
08:29:19PM >> AND THE COMMERCIAL GENERAL USES ARE LOCATED RIGHT HERE
08:29:23PM WITH A FRONT DOOR FACING NORTH 54th STREET AND EAST COLUMBUS
08:29:27PM DRIVE.
08:29:28PM THE APPLICANT DID WORK WITH STAFF ON THIS.
08:29:30PM ORIGINALLY THE COMMERCIAL WAS LOCATED OVER HERE IN THIS
08:29:32PM CORNER AND STAFF SUGGESTED THAT IT BE MOVED OVER TO THIS
08:29:35PM CORNER TO ACTIVATE THIS AREA AND ALSO BE IN CLOSER
08:29:38PM RELATIONSHIP TO THAT PART TO THE SOUTH.
08:29:40PM THERE ARE SIX-FOOT SIDEWALKS EXISTING ON EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE
08:29:44PM RIGHT NOW AND THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING FIVE-FOOT SIDEWALKS
08:29:47PM ALONG NORTH 54th STREET.
08:29:50PM THE DUMPSTER WILL HAVE A SIX-FOOT SCREENING MINIMUM ALONG
08:29:55PM 54th STREET.
08:29:55PM THE PROPOSED MAXIMUM HEIGHT IS 45 FEET OR THREE STORIES
08:29:59PM ABOVE PARKING.
08:30:00PM SEE HERE.
08:30:01PM AND I THINK THAT COVERS ABOUT IT FOR THE SITE PLAN.
08:30:04PM WE WILL GO INTO THE ELEVATIONS NOW.
08:30:05PM AND THIS IS -- YOUR CELEBRATION ALONG COLUMBUS.
08:30:11PM THIS IS YOUR SOUTH ELEVATION, YOUR EAST, AND THEN YOUR WES
08:30:15PM ELEVATION.
08:30:16PM WE WILL GO THROUGH SOME PICTURES NOW.
08:30:21PM THIS IS LOOKING NORTH ON 54th STREET.
08:30:28PM YOU HAVE THE SUBJECT SITE HERE.
08:30:30PM COLUMBUS DRIVE IS UP HERE.
08:30:31PM YOU SEE IT AT THE END OF 54th STREET AND A SEMI DETACHED USE
08:30:38PM WITH TWO UNITS.
08:30:38PM THIS IS LOOKING WEST ON 54th STREET HERE, COLUMBUS DRIVE.
08:30:42PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
08:30:44PM THIS IS LOOKING EAST AT THE INTERSECTION OF 54th AND
08:30:49PM COLUMBUS.
08:30:49PM YOU HAVE THE CHURCH AND THE DUPLEX RIGHT THERE.
08:30:51PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
08:30:53PM THIS IS LOOKING WEST ALONG COLUMBUS DRIVE NEAR SUBJECT SITE.
08:31:00PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTH AT THE SUBJECT SITE.
08:31:03PM THIS IS COLUMBUS DRIVE.
08:31:06PM LOOKING SOUTHWEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND YOU CAN SEE THE
08:31:14PM SUBJECT PROPERTY RIGHT HERE NEXT TO IT.
08:31:16PM THIS IS LOOKING EAST ALONG COLUMBUS DRIVE.
08:31:19PM YOU CAN SEE THE CHURCH HERE ON THE SUBJECT SITE LOOKING
08:31:26PM NORTH THE SUBJECT SITE IS BEHIND ME LOOKING AT COLUMBUS
08:31:30PM DRIVE.
08:31:30PM THIS IS BACK ON 54th STREET.
08:31:32PM THIS THE IS SUBJECT SITE AND SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED HOME
08:31:36PM THAT IS BEHIND IT.
08:31:37PM A BIT FARTHER SOUTH ALONG 14th STREET WHERE THE PARK IS AND
08:31:46PM SOME OF THE MULTIFAMILY AND COLUMBUS DRIVE UP HERE.
08:31:49PM TWO PARCELS EAST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
08:31:51PM HERE IS THE SITE PLAN AGAIN.
08:32:02PM DEVELOPMENT REVIEW AND COMPLIANCE STAFF HAVE FOUND THE
08:32:08PM APPLICATION INCONSISTENT.
08:32:09PM SEE THE FINDINGS RELATED TO NATURAL RESOURCES RELATED TO
08:32:12PM WAIVERS.
08:32:12PM AND THE WATER DEPARTMENT REGARDING REQUIRED SPACE FOR THE
08:32:16PM WATER METER NOT WITHSTANDING STAFF'S FINDING OF
08:32:21PM INCONSISTENCY, IF CITY COUNCIL APPROVES MODIFICATIONS OF THE
08:32:25PM SITE PLAN ON THE REVISION SHEET WILL BE BETWEEN FIRST AND
08:32:28PM SECOND.
08:32:28PM AND THIS WILL NOT RESOLVE THE ISSUES OF NATURAL REFER
08:32:31PM SOURCES FINDING OF INCONSISTENCY.
08:32:34PM I AM AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
08:32:36PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ANY QUESTIONS?
08:32:37PM THANK YOU, SIR.
08:32:38PM IS THERE AN APPLICANT?
08:32:47PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL, STEVE MICHELINI REPRESENTING THE
08:32:50PM PETITIONER.
08:32:51PM THIS IS ONE OF THOSE PROJECTS THAT YOU ALL AS COUNCILMEMBERS
08:32:55PM HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT FOR SOME TIME.
08:32:57PM IT IS A REDEVELOPMENT IN AN AREA THAT NEEDS REDEVELOPMENT.
08:33:01PM IT IS PROPOSING TO HAVE 40 UNITS OF RESIDENTIAL.
08:33:09PM 75% OF WHICH WILL BE AFFORDABLE.
08:33:12PM TEN OF UNITS WILL BE OTHER.
08:33:16PM THAT IS A MINIMUM OF 75%.
08:33:19PM SO 30 OUT OF THE 40 UNITS PROPOSED TO BE AFFORDABLE.
08:33:22PM THEIR AVERAGE SIZE IS ABOUT 900 SQUARE FEET.
08:33:28PM SOME OF THEM ARE LARGER, AND SOME OF THEM ARE SMALLER.
08:33:30PM BUT THE AVERAGE SIZE IS 900 SQUARE FEET.
08:33:33PM THE -- THE COMMERCIAL -- THE RESIDENTIAL -- THE RESIDENTIAL
08:33:44PM STOREFRONT IS ABOUT 1700 SQUARE FEET SERVING THE RESIDENTS.
08:33:49PM AND IT IS ORIENTED TOWARD COLUMBUS DRIVE.
08:33:52PM AT THE CORNER OF THE BUILDING.
08:33:53PM I THINK STAFF POINTED THAT OUT TO YOU.
08:33:56PM 1680 SQUARE FEET, BUT IT IS AT THE CORNER OF COLUMBUS DRIVE
08:34:04PM AND 54th STREET.
08:34:06PM SO IT -- IT HAS THE ABILITY TO SERVICE THE RESIDENTS THERE.
08:34:12PM THE PARKING IS MET REGARDING THIS PROJECT.
08:34:18PM WE PROVIDED A REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION PLAN FOR THE CITY
08:34:24PM STAFF REGARDING THE NEED TO REMOVE THE TREES THAT ARE ON THE
08:34:29PM SITE, NOT ALL OF THEM, BUT TO REMOVE THE TREES THAT ARE
08:34:32PM SHOWN HERE AS XED OUT.
08:34:34PM WE ARE PROPOSING A PROJECT THAT IS LIMITED TO 45 SQUARE
08:34:38PM FEET.
08:34:39PM AND THAT INCLUDES A LOWER LEVEL OF PARKING.
08:34:41PM AND THEN THREE LEVELS OF RESIDENTIAL USE ABOVE THAT.
08:34:46PM WE HAVE -- THE OWNER HAS BEEN AROUND AND VISITED THE
08:34:52PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND HAS SOUGHT LETTERS OF SUPPORT.
08:34:58PM AND I HAVE A DIAGRAM HERE, AS WELL AS A LIST OF NEIGHBORS
08:35:04PM WHO ARE SUPPORTING IT.
08:35:05PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
08:35:12PM AND EACH OF THE NEIGHBORS IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO THE
08:35:15PM PROPERTY ARE SUPPORTING IT.
08:35:16PM AND I HAVE THEIR LIST WHICH I WILL GIVE TO MR. SHELBY
08:35:22PM SHORTLY.
08:35:22PM AS THE -- AS THE STAFF HAS POINTED OUT, WE ARE REQUIRED TO
08:35:34PM HAVE 47 PARKING SPACES.
08:35:35PM WE ARE PROVIDING 53.
08:35:37PM THE ISSUE REGARDING THE CITY WATER METER WILL REDUCE THAT TO
08:35:42PM 52 SPACES.
08:35:43PM WE WILL USE ONE OF THE PARKING SPACES FOR THE WATER METER.
08:35:46PM THE CALCULATIONS ARE HERE, BUT IN TERMS OF RESPECT FOR THE
08:35:54PM PROPERTY ITSELF AS I SAID, IT IS A STOREFRONT RESIDENTIAL,
08:35:58PM WHICH IS INCORPORATED INTO THIS PROJECT.
08:36:00PM AND IF THIS -- IF THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF POINTED OUT
08:36:09PM THAT THE ORIENTATION OF THESE ARE SUPPOSED TO BE TOWARD THE
08:36:12PM STREET, WHICH WE HAVE DONE.
08:36:14PM WE HAVE PUSHED A BUILDING UP TOWARD THE STREET TO CREATE
08:36:18PM WHAT THEY NORMALLY CALL AN URBAN EDGE WE HAVE SIX-FOOT
08:36:26PM SIDEWALKS.
08:36:26PM AND LET ME GET TO THE REST OF THIS.
08:36:29PM THE CRITERIA FOR REVIEW IS TO PROMOTE THE REVIEW OF LAND AND
08:36:37PM INFRASTRUCTURE.
08:36:37PM THE PROJECT PROMOTES TO USE THE EFFICIENT USE OF LAND AND
08:36:42PM INFRASTRUCTURE AS PROPOSED FOR MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT ON AN A
08:36:46PM TER YELL WHICH IS ANOTHER ISSUE THAT YOU ALL HAVE TALKED
08:36:49PM ABOUT.
08:36:49PM NOT INTERIOR TO A NEIGHBORHOOD SITE.
08:36:53PM IT IS ON AN ARTERIAL.
08:36:55PM THERE IS A BUS STOP SHORTLY WITHIN 2,000 -- 2,000 FEET.
08:37:01PM AND IT ALLOWS THE INTEGRATION OF DIFFERENT LAND USES.
08:37:07PM THE APPLICATION -- THE APPLICANT PROPOSES STOREFRONT
08:37:11PM RESIDENTIAL WITH CG USES THAT IS NOT ALLOWED IN RM-16 BUT
08:37:16PM ALLOWED UNDER THE PD THAT WE ARE REQUESTING.
08:37:19PM PROVIDE THE STOREFRONT RESIDENTIAL IN CG, AS IDENTIFIED ON
08:37:25PM THE SITE PLAN AND SUPPORTING THE RESIDENTIAL USES ABOVE.
08:37:28PM THE RETAIL SPACE IS ON THE FIRST LEVEL ADJACENT TO THE
08:37:32PM PARKING GARAGE.
08:37:33PM ENCOURAGE FLEXIBLE LAND DEVELOPMENT THAT REDUCES
08:37:39PM TRANSPORTATION NEED.
08:37:40PM SO WE ARE IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO TRANSIT NEEDS AS WELL AS --
08:37:46PM AS BEING ON COLUMBUS FOR THREE BLOCKS AWAY FROM 56th STREET
08:37:51PM WHERE THERE IS TREMENDOUS AMOUNTS AND NUMBERS OF TRANSIT.
08:37:56PM PROMOTE AND ENCOURAGE DEVELOPMENT WHERE APPROPRIATE IN THE
08:38:00PM LOCATION.
08:38:00PM THE PROPOSED USES ARE APPROPRIATE IN LOCATION AND PROVIDE
08:38:04PM ADDITIONAL HOUSING IN THE AREA THAT THE CITY HAS NOT SEEN
08:38:07PM SUBSTANTIAL REDEVELOPMENT IN THAT AREA AND PROXIMITY TO
08:38:11PM PUBLIC AMENITIES LIKE OAK PARK AND THE BUS STATION AND THE
08:38:14PM SCALE AND THE MAPS OF THE PROPOSAL ARE SIGNIFICANTLY LARGER
08:38:17PM THAN WHAT IS DEVELOPED IN THE SURROUNDING AREA.
08:38:20PM HOWEVER, IT DOES MEET THE NEEDS WITH RESPECT TO THE DEMANDS
08:38:23PM THAT ARE RECURRING IN THIS AREA.
08:38:25PM PROMOTE MORE DESIRABLE LIVING CONDITIONS.
08:38:28PM THE REQUEST IS STOREFRONT RESIDENTIAL WITH ALL OF COMMERCIAL
08:38:32PM GENERAL.
08:38:32PM NORMALLY CAN'T BE CONSIDERED WITHOUT -- WITHOUT THE PD.
08:38:36PM PROMOTE THE ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES.
08:38:39PM WE HAVE INCORPORATED THOSE FEATURES INTO THIS PROJECT.
08:38:41PM AND THE LOWER LEVEL OF THE GARAGE WILL BE SCREENED
08:38:45PM APPROPRIATELY SO IT DOES NOT CREATE A VISUAL EYESORE.
08:38:49PM PROMOTE THE RETENTION AND REUSE OF EXISTING BUILDING STOCK.
08:38:52PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS VACANT AND NEW CONSTRUCTION IS PROPOSED.
08:38:56PM THE DESIGN ON THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT IS UNIQUE AND,
08:39:01PM THEREFORE, NEEDS THE WAIVERS.
08:39:03PM AND GRANTING THOSE WAIVERS WOULD NOT CAUSE ANY DIFFICULTY
08:39:07PM RELATED TO OTHERS.
08:39:08PM THE WAIVERS ARE ALLOWED TO SUBSTANTIALLY INTERFERE WITH THE
08:39:12PM RIGHTS OF OTHERS.
08:39:13PM THE LOT IS VACANT.
08:39:15PM AND AS I SHOWED YOU, ALL OF THE ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERS
08:39:18PM IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO THIS PROJECT HAVE INDICATED BY A
08:39:21PM PETITION THAT THEY SUPPORT IT.
08:39:23PM THE WAIVER IS IN HARMONY AND SERVES THE GENERAL INTENT AND
08:39:28PM PURPOSE OF THIS CHAPTER AND THE CITY OF TAMPA CODE, THE CITY
08:39:33PM STAFF WENT THROUGH THAT, AS WELL AS THE PLANNING COMMISSION,
08:39:36PM INDICATING THAT THEY FOUND IT TO BE CONSISTENT.
08:39:38PM ALTHOUGH THE CITY DIDN'T, THE PLANNING COMMISSION DID.
08:39:40PM ALLOWING THE WAIVER WILL RESULT IT SUBSTANTIAL JUSTICE TO BE
08:39:44PM DONE CONSIDERING THE PUBLIC BENEFITS.
08:39:46PM THERE IS A DEMAND FOR HOUSING ESPECIALLY SMALLER UNITS THAT
08:39:49PM ARE AFFORDABLE.
08:39:50PM AND IN AN AREA THAT IS IN NEED OF HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT.
08:39:54PM WE ARE ASKING TO REDUCE THE LANDSCAPE BUFFER BECAUSE THE
08:40:02PM ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERS, FIRST OF ALL, IN ORDER TO MEET THE
08:40:05PM TECHNICAL STANDARDS FOR THE PARKING AND THE DRIVE AISLES AND
08:40:09PM SOLID WASTE, AND THE ACCESS FOR EMERGENCY VEHICLES REQUIRES
08:40:13PM THAT WE MEET THOSE TECHNICAL STANDARDS.
08:40:16PM YOU CAN'T WAIVE THEM.
08:40:18PM SO IN ORDER TO MEET ALL THE OTHER STANDARDS THAT WE HAVE TO
08:40:21PM MEET FOR PARKING AND THE -- AND THE BE CORPORATION OF THE
08:40:26PM STOREFRONT RESIDENTIAL, WE ARE REQUESTING THE WAIVERS ON THE
08:40:29PM GROUND LEVEL.
08:40:29PM THE RM-16, AS I SAID, DOESN'T ALLOW THAT.
08:40:36PM WE ARE -- WE ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
08:40:39PM AND I WILL GO THROUGH SOME OF THOSE.
08:40:43PM WE ARE ADJACENT TO RESIDENTIAL-35 IN TERMS OF LAND USE.
08:40:48PM THIS IS CMU-35, WHICH ALLOWS FOR THE CONSIDERATION OF A
08:40:52PM HIGHER DENSITY.
08:40:53PM BASED UPON THE LOCATION, THE ARTERIAL ROADWAY, THE VERTICAL
08:41:02PM MIXED USE OF THE PROJECT QUALIFIES WITH RESPECT TO
08:41:08PM THE UMU-35.
08:41:08PM THE SEGMENT OF EAST BETWEEN 52nd AND FOURTH STREET -- 54th
08:41:15PM STREET CONTAIN AS MIX OF RESIDENTIAL VACANT LAND.
08:41:19PM PLACES OF RELIGIOUS ASSEMBLY, RESIDENTIAL USES UNDER THIS
08:41:24PM CAN BE CONSIDERED.
08:41:25PM THE OAK PARK IS THE CLOSEST PARK, THE CLOSEST TRANSIT STOP,
08:41:34PM SITUATED AT 50th STREET AND EAST COLUMBUS.
08:41:37PM THE SITE IS IN THE COASTAL PLANNING AREA.
08:41:40PM MEETS ALL OF THE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES FOR CITY DESIGN, LAND
08:41:44PM USE OBJECTIVE 1.1, 1.1.3, 1.1.26.
08:41:50PM MIXED USE, GOALS AND OBJECTIVES, LAND USE 6.1, LAND USE
08:41:58PM 6.1.1.
08:41:58PM POLICY 6.1.2.
08:42:00PM POLICY 6.1.5.
08:42:04PM BUILDINGS ORIENTED TO THE STREET.
08:42:06PM TRANSIT SERVICE SAFE AND ACCESS FOR PEDESTRIANS SUPPORTING
08:42:09PM GREENWAYS.
08:42:10PM TRAIL MASTER PLANS AND ROADWAYS IT HE SIGNED FOR AUTOMOBILE
08:42:13PM AND EFFICIENT TRANSIT.
08:42:15PM LAND USE POLICY 6.19 IS ONE OF A KEY ELEMENT HERE THAT I WOULD
08:42:20PM LIKE TO FOCUS ON PUTTING BUILDINGS CLOSE TO THE SIDEWALK
08:42:23PM THAT WILL CREATE AND CONSIDER STREET WALK.
08:42:28PM AND ALLOW TO SEE THE SHOPS AND MAKE IT INTERESTING FOR
08:42:31PM PEOPLE TO WALK THROUGH THE CORRIDOR.
08:42:32PM INTRODUCE TALLER BUILDINGS CONSISTENT WITH THE UNDERLYING
08:42:36PM PLAN CATEGORIES WHICH WE HAVE DONE.
08:42:37PM CONSIDER PLACING PARKING IN THE REAR OF THE BUILDING.
08:42:40PM WE ARE PLACING IT UNDER THE BUILDING.
08:42:42PM DIRECT TRAFFIC BACK TO THE MAYOR ROADS.
08:42:46PM WE HAVE DONE THAT.
08:42:47PM CREATE AN ALTERNATIVE ATTRACTIVE FRONT AND REAR FACADE FOR
08:42:50PM ENTRY FOR PEDESTRIANS.
08:42:51PM WE ARE DOING THAT.
08:42:52PM AND PUTTING -- BY PUTTING THE STOREFRONT RESIDENTIAL AT THE
08:42:56PM CORNER.
08:42:58PM AND IT IS SET AT AN ANGLE.
08:43:00PM CREATE A PEDESTRIAN PATHWAY BETWEEN THE USE OF THE CORRIDOR
08:43:04PM AND THE NEIGHBORHOODS BEHIND.
08:43:05PM WE ARE PROVIDING THAT SIX-FOOT SIDEWALKS.
08:43:08PM AND CONNECTING TO THE EXISTING ONES.
08:43:11PM REDURING THE VISUAL CLUTTER OF SIGN THROUGH CONSISTENT SIGN
08:43:14PM PATTERN HELD WITH AND AT PERMITTING.
08:43:17PM REMOVE UTILITY POLLS AND PLACE UTILITIES UNDERGROUND.
08:43:22PM THE PLAN IS TO PUT ALL OF THE UTILITIES UNDERGROUND.
08:43:26PM PLANT STREET TREES AND STREET FURNITURE.
08:43:30PM PUSHING THE BUILDINGS UP.
08:43:32PM WE DON'T HAVE A LOT OF ROOM LEFT TO DO THAT BUT WE WILL MAKE
08:43:35PM IT AN ATTRACTIVE FACADE.
08:43:37PM POLICY 6.110, DENSITY AND MIXES OF TRANSPORTATION THAT
08:43:44PM SUPPORT WALKING AND USE OF PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION.
08:43:46PM 6.1.13, MIXED CORRIDORS DESIGNED SEGMENTS OF MIXED DOOR
08:43:54PM CORRIDOR, REPRESENTED BY MIXED USE PLANS AND WE ARE DOING
08:43:57PM THAT WITH THE STOREFRONT INTEGRATING THAT INTO THE BUILDING
08:44:00PM ITSELF.
08:44:01PM LAND USE DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS AND OBJECTIVE 8.15.
08:44:05PM EXISTING REGULATIONS SHOULD BE MADE CONSISTENT WITH THE
08:44:08PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
08:44:08PM WE HAVE BEEN FOUND TO BE CONSISTENT.
08:44:11PM 8.51, DEVELOPMENT SHOULD NOT EXCEED THE DENSITY.
08:44:15PM WE ARE AT OR BELOW THE DENSITIES INVOLVED.
08:44:17PM LAND USE POLICY 8.15-EACH LAND USE CATEGORY UNIQUE ZONING
08:44:25PM DISTRICT AND REQUESTING IT UNDER A , D.
08:44:27PM OVERALL RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT IN OBJECTIVE 9.3 TO HAVE
08:44:33PM SUSTAINABLE NEIGHBORHOODS IN THE TRANSIT CORRIDOR AND NOT AN
08:44:36PM INTERIOR NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:44:37PM ADJACENT TO WITHIN NEIGHBORHOODS THAT ARE PLANNED FOR
08:44:41PM NONRESIDENTIAL USES AND DEVELOPED, THIS IS ADJACENT TO
08:44:43PM COMMERCIAL CORRIDORS THAT ARE IN -- WITHIN THE BLOCK OR TWO.
08:44:48PM FURTHER TO EAST.
08:44:50PM OBJECTIVE 15. DEVELOP COMMERCIAL AREAS THAT ENHANCES CITY'S
08:44:58PM CHARACTER AND AMBIENCE.
08:44:59PM THIS IS INCORPORATED INTO THE BUILDING ITSELF SO THAT THE
08:45:02PM MINIMAL PORTIONS OF SUSTAINABLE RETAIL IS ON-SITE.
08:45:07PM REQUIRE COMMERCIAL USES TO BE BUFFERED INTO RESIDENTIAL
08:45:13PM DEVELOPMENT.
08:45:14PM INCORPORATED INTO THIS AND THE BUILDING.
08:45:16PM SITES TO ACCOMMODATE HOUSING NEEDS.
08:45:18PM AGAIN, WE HAVE BEEN TALKING OF THE NEED FOR HOUSING FOR
08:45:21PM QUITE SOME TIME.
08:45:22PM THE SIZE OF THESE UNITS IS SMALLER.
08:45:25PM SO THAT THEY CAN BE AFFORDABLE.
08:45:27PM AS I SAID, 75% OF THE UNITS WITH I IS 30 OUT OF THE 40 AS A
08:45:32PM MINIMUM ARE PROJECTED TO BE AFFORDABLE.
08:45:35PM ENSURE THAT THE ADEQUATE SUPPLY OF HOUSING IS ADEQUATE AND
08:45:42PM MEETS THE NEED.
08:45:42PM THIS IS NOT AN AREA THAT HAS A LOT OF DEVELOPMENT GOING ON.
08:45:47PM THIS IS AN ADVENTURE FOR THE PROPERTY OWNER GOING INTO THIS
08:45:50PM AND RECOGNIZING THE NEED FOR ADDITIONAL HOUSING.
08:45:52PM ENCOURAGE NEW HOUSING ON VACANT EN FILL AND UNDERUTILIZED
08:45:58PM LAND.
08:45:58PM THIS IS VACANT AND ON A TRANSIT CORRIDOR WHICH QUALIFIES FOR
08:46:02PM YOUR OBJECTIVES PROVIDING HOUSING.
08:46:06PM INVEST IN SAFE, CONVENIENT AND COMFORTABLE MOBILITY OPTIONS
08:46:10PM WHICH ARE ALL AVAILABLE ALONG COLUMBUS DRIVE.
08:46:13PM ENCOURAGE NEW DEVELOPMENT, REDEVELOPMENT OF SIDEWALKS ON
08:46:16PM BOTH SIDES.
08:46:17PM WE ARE DOING THAT.
08:46:17PM PRESERVE, STRENGTHEN AND EXPLORE OPPORTUNITIES FOR
08:46:20PM RECONNECTING THE GRID AND PROVIDING ACCESSES TO MODES OF
08:46:26PM TRANSPORTATION.
08:46:26PM DIRECT CONNECTIONS BETWEEN DESTINATIONS OF ADJACENT PARCELS.
08:46:31PM WE ARE DOING THAT.
08:46:32PM AND DEVELOPMENT REQUIREMENTS FOR IMPROVING SITE MULTIMODAL
08:46:39PM ACCESS.
08:46:39PM WE ARE DOING THAT.
08:46:40PM POLICY 8.8.1, CONSTRUCTION OF SIDEWALKS TO ADJACENCIES.
08:46:48PM IN FACT, THE STAFF HAS FOUND -- READING FROM THE PLANNING
08:46:52PM COMMISSION STAFF REPORT THAT THE MIXED USE CMU-35 MEETS WITH
08:46:55PM ALL THOSE CRITERIA AND FOUND IT TO BE CONSISTENT.
08:46:59PM THE SITE ISSUES THAT WE ARE DEALING WITH WE CAN ADDRESS THEM
08:47:05PM AS CAREFULLY AS POSSIBLE AND MEETING WITH STAFF WITH REGARD
08:47:09PM OF HOW TO DO THAT.
08:47:10PM AND POINT OUT TO YOU AGAIN IN THE LAND USE MATRIX, CMU-35.
08:47:15PM THIS IS RES-35.
08:47:17PM THE DENSITY HAS BEEN PROGRAMMED AND EXPECTED FOR THIS AREA
08:47:22PM AND PLANNED FOR THE FUTURE.
08:47:23PM WE ARE MEETING WITH THAT.
08:47:24PM I WILL BE HAPPY TO GIVE YOU A COPY OF THIS SUPPORT DOCUMENT
08:47:31PM WITH THE SIGNATURES OF THE PROPERTY OWNERS THAT ARE
08:47:35PM IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TOP IT.
08:47:36PM IF THERE WERE PROBLEMS WITH THE SETBACKS THAT WE ARE
08:47:39PM REQUESTING, THESE IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNER WOULD
08:47:43PM NOT HAVE SIGNED THIS.
08:47:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
08:47:47PM ANY QUESTIONS FROM COUNCILMEMBERS?
08:47:53PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
08:47:54PM I HAVE A QUESTION ON THE SITE PLAN.
08:47:57PM SO SORRY.
08:47:58PM ON THE SITE PLAN, IT -- IT SAY THAT A BIKE ROOM WILL BE
08:48:04PM PROVIDED WITHIN THE BUILDING.
08:48:06PM AND I DON'T SEE THAT ON THE SITE PLAN.
08:48:08PM >> IT'S IN -- IT WILL BE INCORPORATED INTO THE FIRST LEVEL
08:48:14PM OF THE BUILDING IN THE PARKING AREA.
08:48:16PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I WANT TO -- I WOULD LIKE BETWEEN FIRST AND
08:48:19PM SECOND READING FOR YOU TO DELINEATE EXACTLY WHERE THAT IS
08:48:22PM GOING TO BE ON THE INTERIOR.
08:48:24PM >> WILL BE HAPPY TO.
08:48:25PM >>LYNN HURTAK: BECAUSE -- IT JUST SAYS IT IS -- THAT WAY WE
08:48:29PM CAN KNOW WHERE IT IS GOING TO BE.
08:48:31PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:48:32PM >> AS I SAID, WE ARE GOING TO REMOVE ONE OF THE PARKING
08:48:36PM SPACES FOR THE WATER METER.
08:48:39PM AND SO THAT -- THAT AREA WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR ADDITIONAL
08:48:43PM PARKING OF BIKES AND THINGS LIKE THAT.
08:48:45PM SO WE WILL BE HAPPY TO DELINEATE IT.
08:48:48PM >>LYNN HURTAK: SAYS WITHIN THE BUILDING AND SOUNDED LIKE
08:48:50PM PROTECTED INDOOR BIKE SPACE, WHICH IS ALWAYS NICE.
08:48:54PM >> I AM GLAD YOU BROUGHT IT UP BECAUSE I FORGOT TO MENTION
08:48:58PM WE HAVE A BIKE ROOM.
08:48:59PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WELL, THANK YOU.
08:49:00PM VERY INNOVATIVE ESPECIALLY THIS FAR OUT OF THE URBAN AREA.
08:49:04PM >> WE TRY TO TOUCH BASES AND LISTEN TO COUNCIL AND THE
08:49:08PM COMMENTS THAT YOU ALL HAVE MADE OVER SEVERAL WEEKS AND
08:49:10PM MONTHS.
08:49:11PM WE TRIED TO INCORPORATE THOSE ELEMENTS INTO THIS PROPOSAL.
08:49:15PM AND THAT IS ONE OF THE REASONS WHY THE OWNER COMMITTED TO
08:49:21PM 75% OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING WHICH, AS YOU KNOW, IS AN EXTREME
08:49:25PM LEVEL.
08:49:25PM THAT IS USUALLY NOT HEARD OF HERE.
08:49:27PM IT IS USUALLY LESS THAN 10% ANYWAY.
08:49:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
08:49:36PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SO ON THE STAFF REPORT, IT SAYS DUE TO
08:49:39PM MINIMAL SETBACK AND MINIMAL SPACE, THE LOCATION OF THE WATER
08:49:44PM METER ON THE SITE PLAN.
08:49:46PM POTABLE WATER REQUIRE A TEN-FOOT MINIMUM SETBACK FROM ALL
08:49:51PM BUILDINGS, FOUNDATIONS AND TREES.
08:49:52PM HOW DOES THAT FIT -- YOU KNOW YOU ARE BUILDING LINE TO LINE
08:49:55PM WHEN YOU CAN'T FIT A WATER METER.
08:49:57PM I MEAN THIS THING -- YOU ARE SQUEEZING A BIG BUILDING ON A
08:50:00PM REALLY TINY PIECE OF PROPERTY.
08:50:02PM >> WE CAN SHOW THAT YOU PARKING SPACE WILL DISAPPEAR, AND --
08:50:09PM IT IS NOT JUST THE WATER METER BUT THE BACKFLOW.
08:50:13PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: EXACTLY.
08:50:14PM >> THAT SPACE IS 10 X 18 AND WILL GO AWAY AND REMOVE ONE OF
08:50:20PM THE PARKING SPACES.
08:50:21PM WE ALREADY EXCEED THE PARKING REQUIREMENTS AS IT IS.
08:50:23PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE OTHER THING IS ON THE LANDSCAPING AND
08:50:32PM THE INCONSISTENCIES THAT WERE FOUND .IT LIKE THE ONLY REASON
08:50:35PM YOU ARE UNDERGROUND BECAUSE YOU CAN'T FIT ANYTHING WITHOUT
08:50:39PM UNDERGROUNDING UTILITIES.
08:50:40PM YOU CAN'T PLANT ANYTHING ACCORDING TO THIS.
08:50:42PM THAT'S CORRECT?
08:50:44PM >> YES, HERE IS WHAT WE ARE DEALING WITH.
08:50:45PM WHEN YOU MEET THE TECHNICAL STANDARDS, FOR EXAMPLE, ON THE
08:50:50PM WIDTH OF THE ACCESS DRIVE AND THE INTERIOR DRIVE AISLE AT 24
08:50:55PM FEET.
08:50:56PM AND THE -- AND THE LOT -- THE DIMENSIONS FOR THE PARKING
08:51:00PM SPACES.
08:51:00PM WHEN YOU START ADDING ALL THOSE THINGS TOGETHER, IT IS VERY
08:51:03PM DIFFICULT TO GET EVERYTHING INTO ONE SPACE.
08:51:10PM WE DID THE CUT OUT ON THE BUILDING OVER HERE FOR SOLID WASTE
08:51:13PM AND WE CHANGED THIS AND PUT THAT -- PUT THAT FOR THE
08:51:17PM STOREFRONT COMMERCIAL ON -- ON A CORNER AND CUT THE CORNER
08:51:21PM SO THAT YOU WOULD -- THAT THE TRAFFIC DRIVING WOULD BE ABLE
08:51:25PM TO SEE THAT VETERAN INTEGRATED.
08:51:27PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I JUST -- I MEAN -- I LOOK AT THE -- AT
08:51:32PM THE SETBACK ON THE BACK BECAUSE -- WHAT, YOU ARE REQUIRED TO
08:51:37PM HAVE A 15-FOOT SETBACK WITH THE MASONRY WALL, BUT YOU REDUCE
08:51:43PM IT TO HOW FAR?
08:51:45PM ON THE BACK LINE?
08:51:47PM >> SIX FEET.
08:51:49PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: NO ROOM -- NO ROOM TO PLANT ANY TYPE OF
08:51:53PM CANOPY TYPE OF TREES.
08:51:56PM STAFF?
08:52:02PM >> ERIN MAHER, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
08:52:05PM THEY ARE PLANTING TYPE TWO TREES, THE TALL AND NARROW TREES
08:52:09PM IN THE BUFFER.
08:52:10PM BUT THE CANOPY TREES --
08:52:12PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ON RIGHT-OF-WAY?
08:52:14PM >> THE CANOPY TREES CAN ONLY GO ON THE RIGHT-OF-WAY.
08:52:16PM CORRECT.
08:52:17PM >> DIDN'T ASK FOR A WAIVER FOR CANOPY TREES ON THE
08:52:24PM RIGHT-OF-WAY.
08:52:24PM >> YOU ARE ALLOWED TO DO THAT.
08:52:25PM >> JUST TO NOTE -- AGAIN, I AM GLAD YOU ASKED THE QUESTION,
08:52:29PM BUT WE CAN PLANT CANOPY TREES IN THE RIGHT-OF-WAY.
08:52:33PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HE CALLED IT OUT BECAUSE YOU SAID
08:52:36PM UNDERGROUND UTILITIES BECAUSE YOU CAN'T PLANT A TREE UNLESS
08:52:40PM YOU UNDERGROUND THE UTILITIES.
08:52:41PM >> PART OF IT IS THE OBJECTIVE OF HARDENING UTILITIES.
08:52:45PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I AGREE.
08:52:46PM I APPRECIATE THAT.
08:52:47PM THAT THEY ARE UNDERGROUNDING AND I CALLED THAT OUT, I WISH
08:52:51PM THAT MORE DEVELOPER WOULD UNDERGROUND UTILITIES.
08:52:54PM HONEST HERE, SEEMS LIKE AN AWFULLY BIG BUILDING ON A SMALL
08:52:59PM PIECE OF PROPERTY.
08:52:59PM I AGREE -- I AGREE OF PUSHING THIS BUILDING UP COLUMBUS.
08:53:05PM I BUY INTO THAT STREET FRONTAGE, HAVING GO VERTICAL OFF OF
08:53:09PM COLUMBUS, THE OTHER SETBACKS IN THE SINGLE-FAMILY
08:53:13PM DEVELOPMENT OFF TO THE SIDE AND THE WAY THE AREA IS
08:53:15PM DEVELOPED.
08:53:15PM I DON'T KNOW, IT IS A DIFFICULT ONE.
08:53:17PM >> THAT'S WHY I PROVIDED YOU -- THE OWNER WENT AROUND TO
08:53:21PM PERSONALLY EACH OF THE SURROUNDING PROPERTY OWNERS.
08:53:23PM SHOWED THEM A SITE PLAN AND ASKED THEM IF THEY HAVE ANY
08:53:27PM OBJECTIONS.
08:53:28PM WE WENT TO THEM TO MAKE SURE THEY DIDN'T HAVE ANY CONCERNS
08:53:32PM REGARDING THE SETBACKS AND I PROVIDED YOU WITH THE LOCATION
08:53:35PM SO YOU EACH OF THOSE PEOPLE SIGNED AND LOCATION ON THAT MAP
08:53:39PM THAT I PROVIDED.
08:53:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT, ANYBODY ELSE.
08:53:42PM IF NOT, WE WILL GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT.
08:53:44PM YES, SIR?
08:53:47PM WAIT --
08:53:49PM >> SORRY, I JUST NEEDED TO PROVIDE SOME CLARIFICATION -- OR
08:53:53PM ASK FOR CLARIFICATON ON AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
08:53:56PM NO NOTE ON THE SITE PLAN REGARDING THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
08:53:59PM I WANT TO SEE IF THE APPLICANT IS WILLING --
08:54:02PM >> WE WILL BE PROVIDING THAT BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
08:54:04PM READING.
08:54:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GOOD.
08:54:05PM >> IF COUNCIL SO DOES CHOOSE TO APPROVE IT, IT IS WITH THE
08:54:09PM REVISION SHEET ALONG WITH A NOTE TO WORK WITH CITY LEGAL AND
08:54:13PM STAFF TO COME UP WITH A NOTE ON THE SITE PLAN ADDRESSING THE
08:54:16PM 75% AFFORDABLE HOUSING ALONG WITH THE BIKE ROOM AND THE SITE
08:54:20PM PLAN.
08:54:20PM THANK YOU.
08:54:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:54:23PM AT THIS TIME WE WILL GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT.
08:54:26PM IF ANYONE WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, COME UP AND STATE
08:54:30PM YOUR NAME.
08:54:30PM YES, MA'AM.
08:54:33PM >> MY NAME IS JOY.
08:54:34PM I LIVE IN THE AREA.
08:54:35PM AND HE -- HE MENTIONED --
08:54:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: LAST NAME.
08:54:38PM >> BLOCKER.
08:54:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
08:54:40PM GO AHEAD.
08:54:41PM >> HE MENTIONED OF HAVING PEOPLE SIGN AND SAYING THEY
08:54:43PM APPROVE IT, BUT THE PICTURE THAT HE SHOWED THAT THE
08:54:47PM SURROUNDINGS WERE DUPLEXES.
08:54:49PM SO THOSE ARE RENTAL PROPERTIES.
08:54:51PM YOU SAW THAT FOR YOURSELF.
08:54:53PM WE HAVE HOMEOWNERS HERE AND SIGNATURES OF PEOPLE THAT
08:54:56PM ACTUALLY OWN HOMES IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD THAT ARE SAYING THAT
08:54:59PM THERE IS NO WAY WE WANT THAT HUGE PIECE OF CRAP IN OUR
08:55:03PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:55:04PM WE ARE A SINGLE-FAMILY DWELLING.
08:55:06PM AND WE DON'T -- I MEAN, THERE IS NO WAY YOU CAN PUT
08:55:10PM SOMETHING UP IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD THAT -- THAT CAN BENEFIT US
08:55:14PM WITH SOMETHING LIKE THAT.
08:55:14PM WE JUST REFUSE TO HAVE SOMETHING LIKE THAT PUT UP.
08:55:19PM IT BRINGS NO VALUE TO OUR COMMUNITY.
08:55:22PM YES, WE DO NEED SOME DEVELOPMENT, BUT WE WANT SINGLE-FAMILY
08:55:26PM HOMES.
08:55:26PM THERE ARE ALREADY HOMES BEING BUILT IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD FOR
08:55:30PM SINGLE-FAMILY, NOT -- NOT A LOW-INCOME HOUSING.
08:55:33PM WE ALREADY DEAL WITH DIKO ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE FREEWAY
08:55:40PM AND A LOT OF PEOPLE WE ARE TRYING TO GET OUT OF OUR
08:55:43PM COMMUNITIES AND WE DON'T WANT TO BRING IN ANY MORE.
08:55:45PM THIS NOW THEY ALSO HAVE THE CODE BEHAVIORAL CENTER THAT IS
08:55:50PM ALSO IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:55:51PM AND THOSE PEOPLE HAVE NOWHERE TO GO.
08:55:53PM AND THEY ARE ON THE STREETS.
08:55:55PM SO WE ARE DEALING WITH ALL OF THOSE FACTORS AS WELL.
08:55:57PM SO WE DON'T NEED TO DEAL WITH ANOTHER 75% OF SOMEONE ELSE
08:56:01PM COMING IN WITH -- WITH -- WITH UNDESIRABLES THAT WE JUST
08:56:06PM DON'T NEED.
08:56:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MA'AM.
08:56:08PM WOULD YOU LIKE TO GIVE A -- THOSE SIGNATURES TO THE
08:56:14PM ATTORNEY.
08:56:14PM HE WILL PUT IT IN THE RECORD.
08:56:15PM >> WHO?
08:56:17PM OH, YOU?
08:56:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
08:56:23PM >> HELLO, KEVIN ANDERSON.
08:56:25PM 5201 EAST 20th.
08:56:27PM THIS IS -- FIRST POINT, IT IS A SINGLE HOME RESIDENTIAL
08:56:32PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:56:33PM TO HAVE A FOUR-STORY APARTMENT.
08:56:37PM NONE OF OUR BACKYARDS WILL HAVE ANY PRIVACY ANYMORE.
08:56:41PM WE LOSE EVERYTHING.
08:56:42PM SECOND, 50th AVENUE -- OR th STREET HAS CONVENIENCE STORES
08:56:50PM ALL WITHIN WALKING DISTANCE.
08:56:51PM TO PUT ONE RIGHT SMACK IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD, ALL THE ONES ON
08:56:55PM 50th HAVE TO HAVE SECURITY GUARD BECAUSE YOU WILL BE
08:56:58PM APPROACHED BY PEOPLE LOOKING FOR MONEY, DRUGS, BEER,
08:57:04PM WHATEVER.
08:57:04PM THAT WILL PUT THAT RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE OF OUR NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:57:07PM WHICH BRINGS MORE HOMELESS INTO THAT AREA, WHICH -- IF YOU
08:57:15PM -- DRIVE 4 OUT TO THE FAIRGROUND, THERE ARE THESE -- BEHIND
08:57:21PM THE -- IT IS LESS THAN A QUARTER MILE FROM WHERE THIS
08:57:25PM BUILDING SITE IS.
08:57:26PM TO BRING MORE HOMELESS.
08:57:27PM THERE ARE HOMELESS CAMPS.
08:57:29PM SOMEONE SAID OF THE SPOONBILLS FLYING IN THERE IN THE
08:57:32PM MORNING.
08:57:32PM I HEAR THE SHOPPING CARTS ROLLING IN.
08:57:35PM BUT RIGHT ON 4, YOU WILL SEE IT ON THE SOUTH SIDE BEFORE THE
08:57:44PM FAIRGROUNDS HOMELESS ENCAMPMENTS.
08:57:47PM THE CITY HAD TO SPEND TON OF MONEY CLEANING IT UP BEFORE.
08:57:52PM THIS WILL JUST BRING MORE IN.
08:57:55PM IT DESTROYS ALL OF OUR PRIVACY IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:58:03PM IT DOESN'T BRING ANY BENEFIT TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:58:06PM THANK YOU.
08:58:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU, SIR.
08:58:08PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
08:58:10PM >> GOOD EVENING, HENRY --
08:58:16PM AGAIN, SINGLE-FAMILY NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:58:18PM FOUR YEARS AGO, WE INVESTED OUR LIFE'S BLOOD -- NOT LIFE'S
08:58:23PM SAVING INTO IT.
08:58:24PM A LOT OF PEOPLE LIVED THERE THEIR WHOLE LIVES.
08:58:26PM WE BOUGHT A HOUSE FROM THE NEXT-DOOR NEIGHBOR WHO GREW UP IN
08:58:30PM THE HOUSE.
08:58:31PM WE APPRECIATE THAT AND WHAT WE LOOK FOR IN A NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:58:33PM WE UNDERSTAND ALL THE TALK FOR HOURS HAS BEEN ABOUT HOUSING.
08:58:36PM AND OBVIOUSLY TAMPA IS GROWING AND IT CAN'T GROW INTO THE
08:58:40PM GULF.
08:58:40PM IT HAS TO GROW EAST.
08:58:41PM WE ONLY HOPE THAT THE SAME RESPECT WILL BE SHOWN TO THE
08:58:46PM PEOPLE WHO LIVE THERE ALREADY TOWARD OUR PROPERTY AND OUR
08:58:51PM PROPERTY VALUES.
08:58:52PM WE REALLY FEEL THIS IS NOT A GOOD ADDITION TO OUR
08:58:54PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:58:54PM HE KEPT SHOWING PICTURES OF COLUMBUS AVENUE.
08:58:58PM ON THE OTHER SIDE OF COLUMBUS AVENUE WHERE HE DIDN'T COME
08:59:01PM AND ASK US IF WE WERE INTERESTED OR OBJECTED TO IT.
08:59:05PM ALL THE SIGNATURES RECEIVED WERE FROM THAT SIDE OF COLUMBUS
08:59:09PM AVENUE.
08:59:09PM A VERY SMALL NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:59:11PM THE ONLY ACCESS IS COLUMBUS AVENUE.
08:59:13PM AND I THINK THREE STREETS THAT CUT STARTING WITH 52nd, I
08:59:19PM THINK 54th WHERE THE CONVENIENCE STORE IS GOING TO BE AND
08:59:22PM 56th.
08:59:22PM THE TRAFFIC IS ALREADY HORRENDOUS THERE.
08:59:25PM BECAUSE IT IS CORRIDORS -- I BELIEVE THAT IS THE WORD YOU
08:59:30PM HAVE BEEN USING, CORRIDOR.
08:59:31PM VERY BUSY.
08:59:32PM WE JUST -- WE JUST DO NOT AGREE THIS IS GOING TO BE A VALUE
08:59:37PM ADDED TO OUR NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:59:38PM THANK YOU FOR LISTENING.
08:59:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:59:40PM YES, MA'AM, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
08:59:42PM >> [INAUDIBLE]
08:59:45PM I WAS SWORN IN.
08:59:46PM 5214 EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE.
08:59:49PM AND SO THERE IS A SAFETY CONCERN AND ALSO THIS WILL LOWER
08:59:54PM THE VALUE OF OUR COMMUNITY, OUR NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:59:58PM SO MY FAMILY HAS BEEN IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD SINCE 1950s.
09:00:05PM WE HAVE SEVERAL DIFFERENT PROPERTIES.
09:00:06PM WE ARE ALL AGAINST IT.
09:00:07PM NONE OF US WERE ASKED WHAT WE THOUGHT ABOUT THIS.
09:00:10PM MY HOUSE PERSONALLY IS GOING TO BE RIGHT IN FRONT OF THIS
09:00:15PM BUILDING.
09:00:15PM SO IT WASN'T PICTURED IN WHAT HE DISPLAYED, BUT MY HOUSE
09:00:21PM WILL -- IT IS GOING TO BE RIGHT IN FRONT OF IT, DIRECTLY IN
09:00:24PM FRONT BASICALLY.
09:00:24PM SO THE SAFETY CONCERN IS THERE IS HOMELESS.
09:00:28PM THERE ARE DRUG ADDICTS.
09:00:31PM ALL THIS DOWN THERE.
09:00:32PM THEY GO TO THE LITTLE CONVENIENCE STORES.
09:00:35PM THEY GO TO THE GAS STATIONS.
09:00:37PM WE DON'T WANT THEM COMING INTO OUR NEIGHBORHOOD TO THIS NEW
09:00:40PM AREA THAT IS GOING TO BE BUILT OR PROPOSED.
09:00:43PM BUT, ALSO, WE HAVE INPUTTING -- ALL OF NEWS THE AREA HAVE
09:00:52PM BEEN -- NOT A HOA, BUT WE PUT A LOT OF WORK INTO OUR HOUSE,
09:00:56PM OUR PROPERTY.
09:00:56PM IT IS ALL WELL-MAINTAINED.
09:00:59PM AND IT IS NICE LITTLE COMMUNITY NEIGHBORHOOD ON THIS SIDE.
09:01:07PM SO FOR THEM TO REZONE IT.
09:01:10PM AND THEN OUR PROPERTY VALUES ARE JUST GOING TO DROP
09:01:14PM COMPLETELY.
09:01:15PM AND ALL OUR INVESTMENTS THAT WE PUT IN, IT'S NOT -- IT
09:01:20PM DOESN'T BENEFIT THE AREA AT ALL.
09:01:22PM SO THAT'S IT.
09:01:23PM A LOT OF MY FAMILY THAT ARE STILL THERE ARE OLDER SO THEY
09:01:27PM ARE NOT ABLE TO ATTEND THIS.
09:01:28PM BUT THEY ALL FEEL THE SAME WAY.
09:01:33PM AND THERE IS OVER 60 SOMETHING SIGNATURES ON THAT PETITION.
09:01:37PM SO WE JUST DON'T WANT SOMETHING LIKE THIS COMING INTO THE
09:01:41PM AREA.
09:01:41PM SO THAT'S IT.
09:01:42PM THANK YOU.
09:01:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:01:44PM ANYBODY ELSE?
09:01:45PM YES, MA'AM.
09:01:46PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
09:01:48PM >> TATYANA MORALES, 101 SOUTH NEWPORT.
09:01:53PM THING THAT CALLED ME TO SPEAK AS SOMEONE THAT LIVES IN
09:01:57PM MULTIFAMILY HOUSING WHOLE LIFE FAMILY ONLY AFFORDING
09:02:01PM MULTIFAMILY.
09:02:02PM CALLING THOSE WHO LIVE IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNDESIRABLES.
09:02:08PM SICKENS ME TO ANY CORE.
09:02:11PM I AM NOT BLAMING THIS NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:02:12PM I AM NOT GOING TO BLAME ANY NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:02:15PM BUT THE VERY LONG DECADES OF SYSTEMIC RACISM AND
09:02:20PM DISCRIMINATION AND WHAT WE ARE TRYING TO UNDO WITH HOUSING.
09:02:23PM I WANT TO DISCUSS THE BUS LANES NEARBY.
09:02:25PM IF SOMETHING I DON'T KNOW ABOUT IS WATER.
09:02:27PM THAT IS NOT ME.
09:02:27PM BUT I KNOW ABOUT THE BUS LANES IN THE CITY.
09:02:29PM THE SIX RUNS NEARBY, 20-MINUTE WEEKDAY FREQUENT.
09:02:36PM 15 NEAR WITH 15-MINUTE.
09:02:39PM THE 8 WITH 60-MINUTE FREQUENCY.
09:02:43PM THERE IS A LOT OF TRANSIT BIG BUILDING, SMALL LOT.
09:02:47PM PEOPLE SAY THAT OF HEIGHT AND BUILDING, BUT WE ARE ALONG A
09:02:50PM MAJOR CORRIDOR ALONG COLUMBUS AND 56 -- AS IT TURNS INTO 58.
09:02:55PM WHERE SHOULD DEVELOPMENT GO, IN THESE CORRIDORS.
09:02:58PM I DON'T WANT TO PUT IT ON THE ACTUAL CENTER OF THEIR
09:03:01PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND END OF THE CORRIDOR.
09:03:04PM 75% AFFORDABLE HOUSING I AM SORRY PEOPLE DON'T LIKE
09:03:08PM AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN THEIR NEIGHBORHOOD BUT WE HAVE TO DO
09:03:10PM SOME WITH A GAP OF 26,000 UNIT.
09:03:12PM PEOPLE WHO LIVE IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING WHO LIVE IN CITY OF
09:03:16PM TAMPA ON A WAITING LIST FOR A VERY LONG TIME AND SENIORS ON
09:03:19PM OUR STREETS BECAUSE GETS PRICED OUT BY SOMEONE RICHER THAN
09:03:23PM THEM.
09:03:23PM I WANT TO CHALLENGE THE LEGITIMACY WHO GETS TO HAVE STAKE IN
09:03:26PM A NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:03:27PM WHEN YOU SAY HOMEOWNERS, IT IGNORES PEOPLE LIKE ME BECAUSE
09:03:32PM OF MY STUDENT ED, COMPLETE IRRELEVANT PROBLEM, I CAN'T BUY A
09:03:37PM HOME AND I WORK AT NONPROFITS AND I DON'T MAKE GOOD MONEY
09:03:40PM AND WHY PEOPLE LIKE ME WANT AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN THE CITY.
09:03:43PM I GET IT.
09:03:43PM A PROJECT NOT PERFECT AND NOT LIKE EVERYTHING.
09:03:47PM BUT IT HAS A BIKE ROOM.
09:03:48PM BRINGS 40 MORE UNITS.
09:03:49PM 75% AFFORDABLE AND I THINK THAT IS A MAJOR STEP FORWARD.
09:03:53PM A LOT OF TIME PEOPLE WORRY OF THEIR NEW NEIGHBORS.
09:03:55PM SOMEBODY WHO LIVED IN A LOT OF APARTMENTS WITH NEW
09:03:58PM NEIGHBORS.
09:03:59PM YOU DON'T MIND THEM.
09:04:00PM THEY HAVE A DOG.
09:04:00PM BUILD A DOG PARK.
09:04:02PM WE GROW REVENUE.
09:04:04PM AND GROW AS A CITY.
09:04:05PM I WANT TO EMPHASIZE WHEN WE LOOK FORWARD TO WHAT OUR
09:04:08PM COMMUNITY MEANS FOR EVERYONE THAT LIVES THERE, WE HAVE TO
09:04:10PM REALLY STOP DIVIDING THAT HOMEOWNERS HAVE THE VALUE AND THE
09:04:14PM SAY OF EVERYTHING AND RENTERS WHO LIVE HERE, WHO WORK HERE,
09:04:17PM WHO PAY TAXES HERE SHOULD HAVE A TAKE AND DO HAVE A PART OF
09:04:21PM THE HOME OWNERSHIP OF WHAT IT MEANS TO BE A RESIDENT IN
09:04:24PM TAMPA.
09:04:15PM THANK YOU.
09:04:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:04:26PM ANYBODY ELSE?
09:04:28PM THERE IS NOBODY ELSE.
09:04:29PM NO, ONLY ONE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK.
09:04:32PM YES, SIR, YOU HAVE REBUTTAL.
09:04:33PM IF THERE ARE NO QUESTIONS, YOU HAVE FIVE-MINUTE REBUTTAL.
09:04:37PM >> YOU KNOW, I HEAR WHAT THEY ARE SAYING.
09:04:40PM BUT IT IS -- IT IS PERPLEXING WHEN YOU -- WHEN YOU TRY TO
09:04:44PM COME FORWARD WITH WHAT THE CITY, THE CITY STAFF, THE CITY
09:04:49PM COUNCIL, AND THE CITY ADMINISTRATION HAS SAID WE NEED
09:04:51PM HOUSING.
09:04:52PM THERE IS A DEFINED AND DEFINITE NEED FOR HOUSING.
09:04:56PM AND WE TRY TO COME IN WITH A PROJECT THAT IS SENSITIVE WHERE
09:05:02PM THE COMMITMENT DIDN'T HAVE TO BE MADE THAT 75%, WHICH IS 30
09:05:06PM OUT OF THE 40 UNITS WERE COMMITTED TO AFFORDABLE.
09:05:10PM WE BROUGHT IT UP.
09:05:11PM WE DIDN'T HAVE TO DO THAT.
09:05:12PM OR THE SIZE OF THE UNITS.
09:05:14PM AND THAT DISCUSSION HAS HAPPENED AMONG COUNCILMEMBERS AS
09:05:19PM WELL.
09:05:19PM REDUCE THE SIZE OF THE UNITS, MAKE THEM LESS EXPENSIVE SO
09:05:22PM THAT PEOPLE CAN AFFORD TO GO IN THERE.
09:05:24PM I DON'T KNOW HOW YOU ATTRACT HOMELESS PEOPLE WHEN YOU ARE
09:05:28PM TRYING TO PROVIDE HOUSING THAT IS AFFORDABLE.
09:05:31PM I DON'T GET IT.
09:05:32PM IT DOESN'T EQUATE.
09:05:33PM AND UNDESIRABLES.
09:05:38PM IT IS JUST -- AS THE WOMAN JUST SAID, IT IS OFFENSIVE.
09:05:42PM WE ARE TRYING TO PROVIDE HOUSING.
09:05:44PM WE ARE TRYING TO PROVIDE AN ADEQUATE SOLUTION TO THE NEED.
09:05:51PM WE WENT AROUND.
09:05:52PM THE OWNER WENT AROUND TO ALL OF THE PROPERTY OWNERS --
09:05:57PM DIDN'T TELL ME EXACTLY WHERE THEY WERE IN RELATIONSHIP TO
09:06:00PM THIS PROPERTY, BUT ALL OF THE ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERS
09:06:03PM SIGNED THAT PETITION.
09:06:03PM THE ONE THAT WERE MOSTLY WOULD BE AFFECTED BY SETBACKS.
09:06:08PM WE DIDN'T GO ACROSS THE STREET ON COLUMBUS.
09:06:11PM WE DIDN'T GO ON THE OTHER SIDE.
09:06:13PM BUT WE WENT TO THE IMMEDIATE ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERS.
09:06:17PM TO TRY TO PROVIDE A LOWER COST ALTERNATIVE TO THE NEED FOR
09:06:22PM HOUSING.
09:06:22PM AGAIN, 30 OUT OF THE 40 UNITS ARE BEING PROPOSED TO BE
09:06:26PM AFFORDABLE.
09:06:27PM AND IT COULD BE MORE, BUT THAT CERTAINLY IS THE MINIMUM.
09:06:30PM SECURITY AND ISSUES.
09:06:34PM AS YOU GO AND TRY TO CLEAN UP AREAS AND INSERT NEW
09:06:40PM DEVELOPMENT, THE SECURITY AND THE -- AND THE ACTIVITY ON THE
09:06:44PM STREET LEVEL HELPS TO IMPROVE THAT CONDITION.
09:06:47PM IT HAS HAPPENED ALL OVER THE CITY.
09:06:49PM AS YOU BROUGHT IN NEW DEVELOPMENT IN AREAS THAT WERE CRIME
09:06:53PM RIDDEN.
09:06:54PM AREAS THAT YOU WOULDN'T HAVE BUILT IN BEFORE ARE NOW MORE
09:06:58PM VALUABLE THAN THEY EVER THOUGHT TO BE VALUABLE.
09:07:00PM NOT DIMINISHING THEIR INVESTMENT IN THEIR HOMES.
09:07:05PM IT ACTUALLY INCREASES AND IMPROVES IT.
09:07:08PM THAT STREET-LEVEL ACTIVITY -- AND THE POLICE WILL TELL YOU
09:07:12PM UNDER THEIR STANDARDS, THE ACTIVITY ON THE STREET IS CRIME
09:07:18PM PREVENTION THROUGH DESIGN.
09:07:19PM THEY WILL TELL YOU THAT THE ACTIVITY ON THE SCREEN WILL HELP
09:07:22PM TO REDUCE CRIME.
09:07:23PM I DON'T KNOW, THIS IS NOT -- THIS IS -- THIS IS
09:07:30PM RESIDENTIAL-35.
09:07:31PM AND CMU-35.
09:07:33PM IT WAS ANTICIPATED THAT HIGHER DENSITY WOULD COME.
09:07:37PM AND NOW IT IS BEING PRESENTED TO YOU FOR CONSIDERATION.
09:07:40PM THE DENSITY AND THE PROPOSAL IS HERE BEFORE YOU AND WE
09:07:45PM RESPECTFULLY REQUESTING YOUR APPROVAL.
09:07:47PM I WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
09:07:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
09:07:50PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I JUST WANT TO CLARIFYING OF AMI.
09:07:54PM WHAT RANGE OF AMI ARE YOU GOING TO BE PROPOSING AND I WOULD
09:07:58PM LIKE THAT ADDED -- WHAT IS THE AMI THAT YOU ARE LOOKING AT?
09:08:02PM >> I DIDN'T HAVE THE SPECIFIC NUMBER.
09:08:04PM WE WERE GOING TO WORK THAT OUT WITH STAFF TO DETERMINE WHAT
09:08:07PM THE CURRENT NUMBER IS.
09:08:08PM I MEAN THEY CAN -- THEY CAN TELL US WHAT THAT IS, AND I WILL
09:08:14PM BE HAPPY TO SAY AGREE TO IT.
09:08:15PM >> TYPICALLY IS 80 TO 100% AMI AND NOW ON THE RECORD 80 TO
09:08:24PM 120 AMI AND WORK WITH THE APPLICANT TO FIGURE OUT HOW MANY
09:08:28PM UNITS ARE GOING TO BE AT WHICH PERCENTAGE AND BRING THAT TO
09:08:31PM YOU BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND HURTAK THURSDAY THAT'S FINE.
09:08:34PM FOR THE GENERAL PUBLIC, AMI IS AREA MEDIAN INCOME.
09:08:38PM AND CURRENTLY THE AREA MEDIAN INCOME IS $71,540, I BELIEVE.
09:08:46PM AND SO 80% OF THAT IS GOING TO BE ABOUT $56,000.
09:08:52PM SO YOU WILL HAVE TO MAKE $56,000 TO BE ABLE TO AFFORD THE
09:08:56PM UNIT.
09:08:56PM >> JUST FOR THE RECORD, WE ARE COMMITTING TO THE 80% OF
09:09:02PM THE AMI.
09:09:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
09:09:04PM ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS?
09:09:06PM IS THERE A MOTION TO CLOSE?
09:09:09PM >>LUIS VIERA: SO MOVED.
09:09:10PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SECOND.
09:09:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
09:09:14PM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON, MIND READING ITEM NUMBER 6?
09:09:27PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I ACTUALLY AM GOING TO DENY RE -- I WILL
09:09:33PM MAKE A MOTION TO DENY IT, BECAUSE IT IS JUST TOO MUCH.
09:09:37PM SO I MOVE FILE REZ 23-39 FOR THE PROPERTY AT 53009 AND 5311
09:09:47PM EAST COLUMBUS DRIVE FAILURE OF THE APPLICANT OF COMPETENT
09:09:51PM AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE THAT THE DEVELOPMENT AS SHOWN ON
09:09:55PM THE SITE PLAN IS CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND
09:09:58PM THE CITY CODE AND TO MEET BURDEN OF PROOF WITH RESPECT TO
09:10:03PM THE REQUESTED WAIVERS.
09:10:04PM COMPETENT SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE FOUND IN THE STAFF REPORT AS
09:10:07PM WELL AS THE APPLICANT'S REPORT AND EVEN THE TESTIMONY OF OUR
09:10:09PM RESIDENTS SUPPORT THE DENIAL OF FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE
09:10:13PM LAND CODE SECTION 27-136.
09:10:16PM ALTHOUGH THE PROPOSED USE IS APPROPRIATE IN THE LOCATION,
09:10:19PM THE INTENSITY AND DESIGN AS DEPICTED IN THE SITE PLAN IS NOT
09:10:23PM CONSISTENT WITH THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
09:10:25PM FOR EXAMPLE, THE PROPOSED REDUCTION IN LANDSCAPE BUFFER ON
09:10:30PM THE SOUTH AND THE WEST AND THE REQUEST TO PLANT FOUR PALMS
09:10:34PM IN THE WESTERN BUFFERS IS NOT APPROPRIATE GIVEN THE ADJACENT
09:10:39PM SINGLE-FAMILY USE.
09:10:39PM IN ADDITION TO THE REQUEST AND THE MASSING IS
09:10:43PM SIGNIFICANTLY LARGER AND, THUS, IS NOT COMPATIBLE WITH THE
09:10:47PM SURROUNDING BUILT.
09:10:49PM IF THE WAIVERS ARE REQUESTED, FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH SECTION
09:10:52PM 27-139 SUCH AS THE DESIRED WAIVERS NECESSARILY SUPPORT THE
09:10:56PM FACT THAT THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT IS NOT APPROPRIATE FOR
09:10:58PM THIS SITE.
09:10:59PM THE APPLICANT DID NOT PROVIDE EVIDENCE THAT A PROPOSED IT HE
09:11:02PM SIGN IS UNIQUE IN ORDER TO JUSTIFY THE WAIVERS AND THE
09:11:05PM APPLICANT DID NOT PROVIDE EVIDENCE THAT THE REQUESTED
09:11:08PM WAIVERS WOULD NOT BE SUBSTANTIALLY BE INTERFERED WITH THE
09:11:13PM RIGHTS OF OTHERS WHOSE PROPERTY WILL BE AFFECTED BY THE
09:11:16PM ALLOWANCE OF THE WAIVERS.
09:11:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
09:11:20PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SECOND.
09:11:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
09:11:22PM ANY DISCUSSION?
09:11:23PM COUNCILMAN VIERA?
09:11:24PM >>LUIS VIERA: I WILL RESPECTFULLY VOTE NO ON THE DENIAL.
09:11:27PM THIS IS NOT A PERFECT PROJECT BY ANY MEANS.
09:11:30PM THIS DOES A LOT OF GOOD FOR THINGS THAT WE WANT TO DO GOOD
09:11:34PM IN THOSE AREAS.
09:11:36PM IT IS -- THIS IS SOMETHING WHERE THERE IS A LOT OF GRAY,
09:11:40PM RIGHT, WHICH IS THE -- THE PROJECT DOES A LOT OF GOOD.
09:11:44PM ARE THERE CHALLENGES WITH IT?
09:11:47PM YES, ABSOLUTELY.
09:11:47PM I TEND TO SAY AGREE WITH A LOT OF WHAT MISS MORALES SAID IN
09:11:51PM MY RATIONALE.
09:11:55PM I WON'T GET INTO IT, BUT I JUST DO.
09:11:57PM SOME OF THE COMMENTS THAT WERE MADE TROUBLE ME.
09:11:59PM AND I WILL NOT SUPPORT THAT.
09:12:00PM THANK YOU.
09:12:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
09:12:03PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I DON'T THINK THOSE COMMENTS ARE RELEVANT
09:12:06PM -- I AGREE -- I DON'T AGREE WITH SOME OF THE COMMENTS
09:12:08PM EITHER, BUT I DON'T THINK THEY ARE RELEVANT TO THE
09:12:10PM DISCUSSION ABOUT THIS LAND USE AND HOW THIS FITS INTO OUR
09:12:14PM CODE AND THE URBAN PLANNING FOR THE CITY OF TAMPA.
09:12:16PM I LOOKED AT THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT CODE CRITERIA AND I SEE
09:12:20PM IT DOESN'T MEET MANY OF THE ELEMENTS IN THERE.
09:12:22PM IT DOESN'T HAVE THE ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES AND ELEMENTS THAT
09:12:30PM COMPLIMENT THE SURROUNDING COMMUNITY AND DOESN'T ENCOURAGE
09:12:33PM CHARACTER AND COMPATIBILITY WITH THE IMPACTED NEIGHBORHOODS
09:12:36PM AND ENVIRONMENT AND GEOGRAPHY.
09:12:39PM YOU DOES NOT BELIEVE IT PROMOTES THE CAREFUL CONSIDERATION
09:12:42PM OF POTENTIAL ADVERSE IMPACTS OF ON-SITE NATURAL ELEMENTS AND
09:12:48PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND CULTURAL RESOURCES.
09:12:51PM WE ARE REMOVING TREES WITH NO LANDSCAPE BUFFER.
09:12:55PM A BIG BUILDING IN A SINGLE-FAMILY NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:12:57PM IF I LIVED IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD, I WOULD BE STOMPING UP AND
09:13:01PM DOWN IF SOMEBODY WANTED TO BUILD THIS NEXT TO MY HOUSE.
09:13:03PM JUST BECAUSE FOLKS DON'T LIVE IN SOUTH TAMPA, DOESN'T MEAN
09:13:07PM THEY ARE ENTITLED TO QUALITY OF LIFE WHEN THEY INVEST IN
09:13:10PM THEIR HOMES.
09:13:11PM AND THIS IS SOMETHING THAT I DON'T FEEL IS COMPATIBLE.
09:13:14PM THEY COULD HAVE BUILT MULTIFAMILY HERE IN A MORE REASONABLE
09:13:19PM TRANSITION WAY WITH THE OTHER NEIGHBORHOODS.
09:13:21PM ON THE SIZE OF THIS PIECE OF PROPERTY, YOU COULD DEVELOP
09:13:25PM THIS PROPERTY, BUILD SOME MULTIFAMILY, AND -- AND TO
09:13:30PM ACCOMMODATE FOLKS AND DO WHAT THEY ARE TRYING TO DO.
09:13:32PM BURR NOT BUILD UP TO THE PROPERTY LINE.
09:13:34PM NOT BUILD THIS HIGH.
09:13:36PM I MEAN, THIS HIGH RIGHT UP TO THE PROPERTY LINE.
09:13:38PM UP GET IT ALONG COLUMBUS.
09:13:41PM I DON'T GET IT ALONG THE OTHER TWO, SIDES OF THE BUILDING.
09:13:46PM I DON'T GET IT.
09:13:47PM I AM GOING TO VOTE IN SUPPORT OF DENYING THIS REQUEST.
09:13:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION TO DENY AND WE HAVE A SECOND.
09:13:52PM YES, COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK?
09:13:54PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
09:13:55PM THIS ONE IS PROBABLY THE HARDEST ONE OF ALL FOR ME TONIGHT,
09:14:01PM BECAUSE IT -- WE DESPERATELY NEED THE HOUSING.
09:14:04PM WE DESPERATELY NEEDED THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
09:14:07PM IT'S REALLY TALL.
09:14:09PM IT'S SQUEEZED IN.
09:14:11PM BUT I ALSO KNOW THAT I AM SOMEONE BE WHO LIVES DIRECTLY
09:14:17PM BEHIND A FOUR-STORY APARTMENT WHERE THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT
09:14:21PM HAPPENED.
09:14:21PM PEOPLE WERE VERY UPSET ABOUT IT, BUT BECAUSE OF THE ZONING,
09:14:25PM IT DIDN'T COME IN FRONT OF COUNCIL SO IT GOT BUILT ANYWAY.
09:14:29PM AND NOW WE LOVE OUR NEIGHBORS BECAUSE THEY ARE PHENOMENAL
09:14:31PM PEOPLE AND THEY WALK THEIR DOGS EVERYWHERE AND THEY -- THEY
09:14:34PM DRIVE DOWN OUR STREETS AND THEY PARK ON OUR STREETS WHICH
09:14:38PM MAKE PEOPLE SLOW DOWN.
09:14:39PM BUT IN LOOKING AT THE NEIGHBORHOOD, IT IS A SINGLE-FAMILY
09:14:44PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:14:45PM AND SO HOW DO WE CREATE THAT STAIR-STEP PATTERN DOWN.
09:14:52PM IT -- THIS ONE -- THIS ONE IS VERY HARD.
09:14:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
09:14:57PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
09:14:58PM THIS IS THE MOTION TO DENY.
09:15:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
09:15:06PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
09:15:08PM >>LUIS VIERA: NO.
09:15:10PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: NO.
09:15:15PM >>BILL CARLSON: NO.
09:15:16PM >>LYNN HURTAK: NO.
09:15:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
09:15:23PM >>CLERK: MOTION TO DENY FAILED WITH THREE VOTING YES AND
09:15:34PM FOUR VOTING NO.
09:15:34PM VIERA VOTED -- CLENDENIN VOTED YES, HENDERSON VOTED YES,
09:15:41PM VIERA VOTED NO, MIRANDA VOTED NO, CARLSON VOTED NO, HURTAK
09:15:48PM VOTED NO, AND MANISCALCO VOTED YES.
09:15:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT, A MOTION TO MOVE FORWARD WITH
09:15:52PM THIS IF ANYONE WOULD LIKE TO MAKE IT, SINCE THE MOTION TO
09:15:56PM DENY HAS FAILED.
09:15:57PM WOULD ANYBODY LIKE TO READ IT?
09:16:00PM THE ONLY OTHER CHOICE.
09:16:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HAS TO BE SOMEBODY --
09:16:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN VIERA, IF YOU WANT TO GO
09:16:10PM AHEAD AND READ IT.
09:16:11PM >>LUIS VIERA: MOVE AN ORDINANCE PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING
09:16:20PM CONSIDERATION, REZONING PROPERTY 5309 AND 5 \211 EAST COLUMBUS
09:16:25PM DRIVE IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, ZONING DISTRICT RM,
09:16:31PM RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY TO PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT
09:16:35PM STOREFRONT AND USES PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
09:16:39PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: WITH THE REVISIONS.
09:16:41PM >>LUIS VIERA: WITH THE REVISIONS.
09:16:42PM FIND THE APPLICANT HAS MET ITS BURDEN OF PROOF OF COMPETENT
09:16:46PM SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE SHOWN ON THIS SITE.
09:16:48PM THE PLAN IS CONSISTENT WITH THE -- REQUESTED WAIVERS DO NOT
09:16:53PM ADVERSELY AFFECT THE PUBLIC'S HEALTH, SAFETY AND WELFARE.
09:16:57PM MA MINNESOTA MANISCALCO A MOTION TO APPROVE.
09:17:00PM IS THERE A SECOND?
09:17:02PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
09:17:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
09:17:04PM CAN WE HAVE A ROLL CALL VOTE.
09:17:07PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: DISCUSSION SINCE THIS WAS SECONDED UP
09:17:10PM WANT TO SAY SOMETHING -- WHAT BOTHERING ME ABOUT THIS IS THE
09:17:14PM FACT THAT THE LOT IS EXTREMELY SMALL.
09:17:16PM YES, WE DO NEED HOUSING.
09:17:18PM I THINK EVERYONE IN THE ROOM UNDERSTANDS THAT, BUT THIS IS A
09:17:21PM SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL AREA.
09:17:23PM WHILE I DO SUPPORT THE NEED FOR HOUSING, THE NUMBER THAT IS
09:17:27PM REQUESTED OUT THE GATE FOR A SINGLE-FAMILY PROPERTY AREA IS
09:17:32PM JUST TOO MUCH.
09:17:33PM AND THAT IN AND OF ITSELF, WHILE I DID TAKE IT INTO
09:17:38PM CONSIDERATION IF THERE WERE OTHER PROJECTS TO SHOW EXAMPLES
09:17:41PM THAT WERE MOVING IN THAT DIRECTION WHERE YOU CAN SUPPORT,
09:17:44PM YOU KNOW, THAT TPD OF DEVELOPMENT WHERE YOU ARE GOING TO
09:17:46PM INCREASE THE CAPACITY OF HOUSING ON SMALL LOTS.
09:17:50PM AND YOU STARTED OUT WITH EIGHT OR 12, BUT THE NUMBER THAT IS
09:17:54PM BEING REQUESTED ON THIS LOT IS JUST SIGNIFICANT.
09:17:57PM AND SO -- THIS -- DESPITE THE -- THE VERBIAGE THAT WAS USED,
09:18:03PM A THAT IS DISRESPECTFUL FOR RENTERS, IT IS NOT COMPETENT AND
09:18:07PM SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE AND I DO RESPECT THE VIEWPOINTS ON
09:18:10PM THAT.
09:18:10PM EVERYBODY DESERVES HOUSING AND REGARDLESS OF WHERE YOU LIVE
09:18:14PM OR HOW YOU LIVE IT SHOULD BE RESPECTED.
09:18:17PM IT IS A LOT AND THAT IS WHY I JUST CAN'T SUPPORT IT.
09:18:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE.
09:18:23PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
09:18:24PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: NO.
09:18:27PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
09:18:29PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
09:18:31PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
09:18:32PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
09:18:35PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: NO.
09:18:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO.
09:18:38PM >>CLERK: MOTION MOTION TO APPROVE CARRIED WITH HENDERSON,
09:18:46PM CLENDENIN AND MANISCALCO VOTING NO.
09:18:48PM >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH, COUNCIL.
09:18:50PM MANISCALCO JONATHAN THANK YOU VERY MUCH CLERK SECOND READING
09:18:54PM AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MAY 2, 2024 AT 9:30 A.M. A
09:18:58PM LOCATED OLD CITY HALL 315 E. KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD
09:19:05PM FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
09:19:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER 7.
09:19:08PM >>SAM THOMAS: SAM THOMAS, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:19:10PM AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 7 IS REZ-23-78.
09:19:15PM TO REZONE 4212 WEST NORTH B STREET FROM RS-50 TO PD
09:19:24PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY.
09:19:25PM >>DANNY COLLINS: DANNY COLLINS WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION
09:19:28PM STAFF.
09:19:29PM I WAS SWORN IN.
09:19:30PM OUR NEXT CASE IN THE WEST SHORE PLANNING DISTRICT.
09:19:33PM WEST SHORE PALMS NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:19:34PM THE SITE IS ON THE WEST SHORE BUSINESS CENTER.
09:19:37PM THE SITE WITHIN EVACUATION ZONE B.
09:19:40PM HERE IS THE SUBJECT SITE OUTLINED IN PURPLE.
09:19:42PM SUBJECT SITE IS ALONG WEST -- NORTH B STREET BETWEEN LOIS
09:19:48PM AVENUE AND NORTH HEBERT AVENUE.
09:19:51PM TWO BLOCKS NORTH OF WEST KENNEDY BOULEVARD.
09:19:55PM NONRESIDENTIAL ALONG KENNEDY BOULEVARD AND TRANSITION INTO
09:19:58PM RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD PAZ YOU MOVE NORTH.
09:20:00PM HERE IS THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
09:20:09PM SUBJECT SITE OF THE PARCELS TO THE EAST, WEST OF THE SITE IS
09:20:13PM RECOGNIZED UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-35 DESIGNATION.
09:20:15PM TO THE NORTH OF THE SITE IS RESIDENTIAL-35.
09:20:18PM AND THEN -- YOU KNOW, EAST OF -- EAST OF LOIS AVENUE IS
09:20:23PM THE R-10 AND KENNEDY IS UMU-60.
09:20:27PM THE SITE -- THE SITE FALLS WITHIN THE R-35 DESIGNATION.
09:20:32PM SINGLE-FAMILY SELL I DETACHED USES.
09:20:35PM PROPOSED PD OF 12.5 UNITS PER ACRE CONSISTENT WITH THE DENT
09:20:42PM TEE UNDER THE R-35 AND FOR 35 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE.
09:20:48PM PROPOSED DENSITY OF 12.5 IS BELOW THE EXISTING DENSITY ALONG
09:20:54PM THIS PORTION OF WEST NORTH B STREET AND LOWER THAN THE
09:21:01PM DENSITY OF THE 35 CATEGORY.
09:21:02PM SURROUNDING AREAS WERE HISTORICALLY DEVELOPED WITH
09:21:05PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED USES SURROUNDING AREAS IS
09:21:08PM TRANSITIONED TO INCLUDE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED USES
09:21:10PM INCLUDING TOWN HOMES AND SINGLE-FAMILY OR SINGLE-FAMILY SEMI
09:21:14PM DETACHED USES.
09:21:15PM ADDITIONALLY MULTIFAMILY USES ARE TO THE SOUTH OF THE SITE.
09:21:19PM GIVEN THE PROPOSED DENSITY IS LOWER THAN THE CURRENT DENSITY
09:21:22PM ALONG THE SEGMENT OF NORTH B STREET AND ONGOING TREND OF
09:21:28PM DEVELOPMENT WITHIN THE WEAPONS SHORE PALMS NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:21:30PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDS THE REQUEST TO BE
09:21:32PM COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH SURROUNDING AN AREA.
09:21:34PM BOTH PRIMARY ENTRANCES ARE ORIENTED TOWARD WEST NORTH B.
09:21:43PM EXISTING FIVE-FOOT SIDEWALK, CONSISTENT WITH THE MOBILITY
09:21:48PM POLICIES.
09:21:49PM IN SUMMARY, THE REQUEST IS COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH
09:21:52PM THE SURROUNDING A AREA AND CONSISTENT WITH LONG-RANGE
09:21:54PM DEVELOPMENT PATTERN IN THE R MACHINE 35 AND THAT CONCLUDES
09:22:00PM MY PRESENTATION.
09:22:01PM I AM AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
09:22:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
09:22:04PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:22:04PM YES, SIR.
09:22:05PM >> SAM THOMAS, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:22:10PM WE WILL START WITH OUR AERIAL MAP.
09:22:12PM AS DANNY MENTIONED WE HAVE A MIXTURE OF RESIDENTIAL USES IN
09:22:24PM THE AREA.
09:22:24PM YOU SEE THE SUBJECT SITE OUTLINED IN RED ON NORTH B STREET,
09:22:31PM MIX OF RESIDENTIAL 16, 18 AND 24.
09:22:33PM YOU SEE THE 24 THERE, 16 THERE.
09:22:36PM 18 THERE.
09:22:37PM QUITE A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF PD ZONING DISTRICTS THERE THAT
09:22:41PM COMPRISE OF SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED, SEMI-DETACHED.
09:22:44PM PD DON'T COMPRISE OF DETACHED, SEMI-DETACHED, DETACHED AND
09:22:51PM MULTIFAMILY.
09:22:52PM SOME SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND YOU CAN
09:22:55PM SEE RS-50/
09:22:57PM THE MOST PART, THIS NEIGHBORHOOD HAS BEEN DEVELOPED
09:23:00PM SIGNIFICANTLY WITH MULTIFAMILY AND SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED
09:23:04PM UNITS.
09:23:04PM ON THE EAST SIDE OF LOIS AVENUE, YOU CAN KIND OF SEE A
09:23:07PM TRANSITION HERE TOWARD WHERE IT IS MORE OF A SINGLE-FAMILY
09:23:10PM DETACHED NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:23:11PM AS YOU MOVE TO THE WEST, IT IS MORE MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT.
09:23:14PM AND THEN, OF COURSE, ALONG KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THE COMMERCIAL
09:23:18PM GENERAL USES.
09:23:19PM HERE IS THE APPLICANT -- THE SITE PLAN PROPOSED BY THE
09:23:26PM APPLICANT.
09:23:27PM THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING TWO UNITS THAT ARE ORIENTED
09:23:30PM TOWARD WEST NORTH B STREET.
09:23:32PM FIVE-FOOT SIDEWALK ALONG NORTH B STREET.
09:23:37PM THEY ARE PROPOSING REAR LOADING OFF THE ALLEY AND FOUR
09:23:43PM PARKING SPACES ARE REQUIRED AND FOUR SPACES HAVE BEEN
09:23:46PM PROVIDED.
09:23:46PM PROPOSED WHO IT IS 35 FEET FOR TWO STORIES AND ADDITIONALLY
09:23:50PM THE APPLICANT ENTERTAINING A 30-INCH TREE AT THE FRONT OF
09:23:55PM THE PROPERTY.
09:23:55PM HERE ARE THE ELEVATIONS.
09:24:01PM THE FRONT ON NORTHWEST B.
09:24:04PM THIS WILL BE YOUR BACK OFF THE ALLEY AND YOUR SIDE
09:24:08PM ELEVATIONS HERE.
09:24:08PM I WILL SHOW YOU SOME PICTURES FROM AROUND THE SITE.
09:24:12PM SO THIS IS LOOKING SOUTH DIRECTLY AT THE SUBJECT PROPERTY.
09:24:15PM YOU HAVE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED.
09:24:17PM YOU CAN SEE SOME OF THE -- A LITTLE BIT -- SOME OF THE
09:24:20PM ATTACHED AND SEMI DETACHED USES HERE AT THE CORNER.
09:24:24PM THIS IS LOOKING NORTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE, ACROSS THE
09:24:28PM STREET.
09:24:28PM SO YOU HAVE SOME DETACHED USES AND A PUBLIC PARK RIGHT HERE.
09:24:33PM THIS IS LOOKING EAST.
09:24:37PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE HERE.
09:24:39PM AND THIS IS LOOKING WEST.
09:24:43PM YOU CAN SEE SEMI-DETACHED USES HERE AND HERE.
09:24:46PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED RIGHT HERE.
09:24:48PM AND THIS IS THE PARK AGAIN.
09:24:49PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTH FEW PARCELS OVER OF THE SUBJECT SITE
09:24:56PM OF SEMI DETACHED USES.
09:24:58PM AND THIS IS MOVING LITTLE FARTHER WEST OF THE SITE.
09:25:03PM AND SOME OF THE SEMI DETACHED USES UNDER CONSTRUCTION.
09:25:08PM AND LASTLY, THIS A VIEW OF THE ALLEY IN THE BACK.
09:25:11PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS RIGHT HERE AND SOME OF THE PARKING OFF
09:25:14PM THE ALLEY TO THE MULTIFAMILY TO THE SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT
09:25:17PM SITE.
09:25:17PM HERE IS THE SITE PLAN AGAIN.
09:25:26PM DEVELOPMENT REVIEW AND STAFF FIND IT CONSISTENT WITH THE
09:25:36PM APPLICABLE CITY OF TAMPA LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS.
09:25:39PM SHOULD THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVE THE APPLICATION, FURTHER
09:25:42PM MODIFICATIONS OF THE SITE PLAN COMPLETED BETWEEN FIRST AND
09:25:46PM SECOND READING AS STATED IN THE REVISION SHEET.
09:25:48PM I AM AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
09:25:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
09:25:54PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I HAVE A QUESTION FOR MISS MAHER.
09:25:57PM I HAVEN'T SEEN IT ON A SITE PLAN.
09:26:00PM WHAT IN THE WORLD IS A PUNK TREE.
09:26:02PM >> REMEMBER RAIN MAHER.
09:26:05PM A PUMP TREE IS A COMMON NAME THEY CALL A MELALEUCA, AN
09:26:13PM EXEMPT SPECIES .
09:26:18PM >> ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?
09:26:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO.
09:26:20PM YES.
09:26:22PM YES, SIR.
09:26:23PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
09:26:24PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL, DAVID WRIGHT, CYPRESS BAY PARKWAY.
09:26:29PM I PREPARED A PRESENTATION, BUT BOTH DAN AND SAM -- DANNY AND
09:26:33PM SAM COVERED EVERYTHING I WAS GOING TO.
09:26:35PM IN THE INTEREST OF TIME, AVAILABLE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS
09:26:38PM AND REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL.
09:26:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE WANT TO GO AS LONG AS POSSIBLE.
09:26:41PM >> I KNOW YOU DO.
09:26:42PM SORRY TO DISAPPOINT.
09:26:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I MEAN, THAT WAS FANTASTIC.
09:26:46PM ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
09:26:47PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: TWO THUMBS UP.
09:26:48PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I ACTUALLY DO HAVE A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS FOR
09:26:51PM YOU.
09:26:51PM >> OKAY.
09:26:52PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I AM CONFUSED AS YOU HAVE PARKING IN THE
09:26:56PM BACK, BUT THEN YOU HAVE DRIVEWAYS.
09:26:57PM WHY?
09:27:00PM >> THESE ARE RIBBONS.
09:27:01PM THEY ARE FOR PARKING FOR GUEST PARKING.
09:27:03PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OKAY.
09:27:04PM AND SO -- ON THE SITE PLAN, ONE IS A RIBBON.
09:27:07PM AND THE OTHER ONE IS NOT A RIBBON.
09:27:10PM IS THAT -- IS THAT -- IS THAT A MISTAKE?
09:27:15PM HAVE YOU FIXED THEM TO BOTH BEING RIBBONS.
09:27:18PM I THINK THAT WAS THE WEIRD PART WAS -- ONE WAS A RIBBON AND
09:27:22PM ONE WAS JUST A NORMAL DRIVEWAY AND I THOUGHT THAT IS NOT
09:27:27PM CONSISTENT.
09:27:27PM >> FROM MY UNDERSTANDING IT WAS A MISTAKE ON THE REVISION
09:27:31PM SHEET AND BETWEEN THE FIRST AND SECOND READING CHANGE THAT
09:27:34PM ON THE SITE PLAN SO THEY ARE BOTH RIBBONS.
09:27:36PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I ALSO DON'T SEE ANY SIDEWALKS TO THE HOUSE
09:27:40PM OR TO THE DOORS OR PATHWAYS.
09:27:44PM >> THE RIBBONS ARE BEING USED --
09:27:48PM >> THE RIBBONS BASICALLY IN THIS SITUATION, THE RIBBONS WILL
09:27:51PM BE ACTING AS A SIDEWALKS CONNECTING TO THE SIDEWALKS.
09:27:53PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OKAY, THANK YOU.
09:27:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS SOMEBODY IN ANYONE
09:27:57PM FROM THE PUBLIC WISH TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, ITEM NUMBER 7.
09:28:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MOTION TO CLOSE.
09:28:03PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SECOND.
09:28:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
09:28:05PM COUNCILMEMBER CLENDENIN.
09:28:08PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ME.
09:28:12PM YAY.
09:28:14PM COMPATIBLE PROJECT.
09:28:15PM COMPATIBLE PROJECT.
09:28:17PM SORRY, WASTING MORE TIME.
09:28:21PM I HAD TO RELISH IN THE MOMENT.
09:28:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAD TO MAKE UP FOR IT.
09:28:26PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: REZ-23-78.
09:28:31PM WHAT WAS THE TITLE?
09:28:35PM AS THE APPLICANT HAS MET ITS BURDEN OF PROOF TO PROVIDE
09:28:39PM COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE AS THE DEVELOPMENT AS
09:28:42PM CONSISTENT AND SHOWN ON THE SITE PLAN CONSISTENT WITH THE
09:28:44PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND CITY CODE AND I FIND THAT THE
09:28:47PM REQUESTED WAIVER DOES NOTED A ADVERSELY IMPACT THE HEALTH,
09:28:51PM SAFETY AND WELFARE AND ADOPT THE REASONS OF THE PLANNING
09:28:55PM COMMISSION AND CITY STAFF REPORT THAT THE COMPLIANCE WITH
09:28:57PM THE APPLICABLE -- BASED ON COMPETE TENT AND SUBSTANTIAL
09:29:02PM EVIDENCE IN THIS APPLICANT'S REPORTS AND TESTIMONY THAT
09:29:06PM APPLIES WITH THE APPLICABLE GOALS, POLICIES IN THE
09:29:09PM COMPREHENSIVE.
09:29:10PM AND CONCLUDED IN THE STAFF -- IN THE PLANNING COMMISSION
09:29:13PM STAFF REPORT SUCH AS THE PROPOSED REZONING, WHICH IS
09:29:16PM CONSISTENT WITH THE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED DEVELOPMENT
09:29:18PM WITHIN THE WEST SHORE PALMS NEIGHBORHOOD IS CONSISTENT WITH
09:29:22PM LAND USE POLICIES 1.2.3, 1.2.6, 1.2.1, 9.7. AND 9.7.3.
09:29:35PM CONSISTENT WITH 1.3.4 WHICH ENCOURAGES NEW HOUSING ON VACANT
09:29:40PM AND UNDERUTILIZED LAND TO MEET THE NEEDS OF TAMPA'S PRESENT
09:29:44PM AND FUTURE POPULATION.
09:29:46PM IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE 27-136, PURPOSE
09:29:51PM OF THE SITE PLAN CONTROL DISTRICT SUCH AS DEVELOPMENT AS
09:29:54PM SHOWN ON THE SITE PLAN PROMOTES AND ENCOURAGES DEVELOPMENT
09:29:58PM THAT IS APPROPRIATE IN THE LOW CHASE, CHARACTER AND
09:30:00PM COMPATIBILITY WITH THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:30:02PM WHILE THE SUBJECT SITE IS FLANKED BY SINGLE-FAMILY UNITS, IT
09:30:07PM PROVIDES AN APPROPRIATE INFILL AND TRANSITION FROM THE
09:30:11PM MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT PATTERN LOCATED SOUTH OF THE ALLEY
09:30:13PM AND NORTH OF NORTH HEBERT AVENUE AND WAIVER IN COMPLIANCE
09:30:17PM WITH 27-139 FOR SUCH AS THE DESIGN OF THE PROPOSED
09:30:21PM DEVELOPMENT IS THOUGHTFUL AND TAKES ADVANTAGE OF THE ALLEY
09:30:24PM ACCESS AND THE REQUESTED WAIVER MUD IS NOT SUBSTANTIALLY
09:30:28PM INTERFERE THE RIGHTS OF THE OTHERS AND THE PROPERTY WILL BE
09:30:32PM AFFECTED BY THE WAIVERS AND MOTION INCLUDES THE D REVISION
09:30:35PM SHEETS.
09:30:35PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YOU ACTUALLY NEED TO READ THE ORDINANCE.
09:30:40PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THAT IS WHAT I WAS -- YOU WERE HURRYING ME
09:30:43PM ALONG.
09:30:44PM AND I WILL MOVE -- SEVEN.
09:30:48PM I MOVE AN APPLICATION OF DAVID WRIGHT TO REZONE -- SORRY,
09:30:52PM JESUS -- AN ORDINANCE REZONING THE PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL
09:30:56PM VICINITY OF 4212 WEST NORTH B STREET IN THE CITY OF TAMPA,
09:31:01PM FLORIDA, MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION ONE WITH
09:31:04PM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION, RS-50 RESIDENTIAL
09:31:08PM SINGLE-FAMILY TO PD -- RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY SINGLE
09:31:12PM DETACHED PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
09:31:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
09:31:16PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
09:31:17PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
09:31:20PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
09:31:22PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
09:31:24PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
09:31:26PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
09:31:27PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
09:31:29PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
09:31:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
09:31:31PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED -- MOTION TO APPROVED CARRIED
09:31:42PM UNANIMOUSLY.
09:31:42PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MAY 2, 2024 AT
09:31:49PM 9:30 A.M. LOCATED AT OLD CITY HALL, 315 E. KENNEDY
09:31:56PM BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, 33602.
09:32:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:32:02PM ITEM NUMBER 8.
09:32:03PM >>SAM THOMAS: SAM THOMAS, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:32:06PM AGENDA NUMBER 8, REZ-23-112.
09:32:11PM REQUEST TO REZONE 1324 WEST FIG STREET FROM RESIDENTIAL 50
09:32:17PM TO RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY 18.
09:32:20PM TURN IT OVER TO DANNY WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
09:32:23PM >>DANNY COLLINS: DANNY COLLINS WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION
09:32:26PM STAFF.
09:32:26PM OUR NEXT CASE IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT.
09:32:30PM WEST TAMPA URBAN VILLAGE.
09:32:32PM WITHIN EVACUATION ZONE B -- SORRY, C.
09:32:38PM KITE IS GENERALLY EAST OF WEST FIG STREET AND NORTH OREGON
09:32:43PM AVENUE.
09:32:43PM THE SURROUNDING AREA IS PREDOMINANTLY URBAN AND SOME
09:32:47PM RESIDENTIAL USES.
09:32:48PM YOU KNOW IN THE IMMEDIATE AREA.
09:32:49PM IT IS -- THE SITE IS ONE BLOCK WEST OF NORTH WILLOW AVENUE
09:32:59PM WHICH HAS NONRESIDENTIAL USES.
09:33:01PM HERE IS THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
09:33:04PM SUBJECT SITE UNDER THE R-20 DESIGNATION WITH I IS TO THE
09:33:09PM EAST, WEST AND THEN TO THE -- TO THE NORTH AND EAST OF THE
09:33:13PM SUBJECT SITE AND TO THE NORTH IS CMU-35 AS WELL AS TO THE --
09:33:17PM TO THE WEST AND SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
09:33:19PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REVIEWED THE APPLICATION AND FOUND
09:33:22PM NO ADVERSE IMPACTS TO THE SURROUND AREA.
09:33:25PM PROPOSED RM-18 ZONING DISTRICT TO BE CONSIDERED FOR THE
09:33:31PM MATRIX IN SECTION 27-21 OF THE LDC.
09:33:34PM THE REQUEST SUPPORTS MANY POLICIES OF THE COMPREHENSIVE
09:33:40PM PLAN.
09:33:40PM ENCOURAGE NEW HOUSING ON VACANT AND UNDERUTILIZED LAND TO
09:33:45PM MEET THE NEEDS OF TAMPA'S FUTURE AND PRESENT POPULATION.
09:33:49PM REQUEST WILL PROVIDE ADDITIONAL HOUSING IN THE NORTH HYDE
09:33:53PM PARK NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:33:53PM 9.2.6 SINGLE-FAMILY MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENTS TO DESIGN
09:33:59PM ORIENTATION TO THE FRONT DOOR TO A NEIGHBORHOOD SIDEWALK AND
09:34:02PM STREET.
09:34:02PM DEVELOPMENT OF THIS SITE FOR SINGLE-FAMILY DETACH AND
09:34:07PM MULTIFAMILY USES OF POLICY OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT.
09:34:11PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDS IT CONSISTENT WITH THE TAMPA
09:34:15PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION AND
09:34:16PM AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
09:34:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
09:34:20PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:34:21PM YES, MA'AM.
09:34:21PM >>SAM THOMAS: SAM THOMAS, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:34:24PM PER USUAL WE WILL START WITH THE AERIAL MAP SO THE SUBJECT
09:34:33PM SITE HERE OUTLINED IN RED ON WEST FIG STREET.
09:34:39PM MULTIFAMILY AND SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED WITH SOME COMMERCIAL
09:34:43PM AND INDUSTRIAL USES MIXED IN.
09:34:45PM SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED UNITS HERE.
09:34:49PM TO THE SOUTH A WAREHOUSE USE.
09:34:50PM ON BOTH SIDES, YOU HAVE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED.
09:34:53PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED HERE.
09:34:55PM AND THEN SEMI-DETACHED AS WELL.
09:34:57PM YOU HAVE SOME DETACHED USES HERE AND THESE LARGER
09:35:02PM MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENTS ON THE OTHER SIDE OF WILLOW, A FEW
09:35:05PM INDUSTRIAL GENERAL PROPERTIES AND SOME OTHER LARGE SCALE
09:35:07PM MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS.
09:35:09PM THIS IS THE WALMART ON KENNEDY UNDER THE IG ZONING DISTRICT
09:35:14PM AND THE NEW TGH PROPERTY CONSTRUCTED ALONG KENNEDY BOULEVARD
09:35:20PM RECOGNIZED UNDER THE PD ZONING DISTRICT AND THE UNIVERSITY
09:35:24PM OF TAMPA.
09:35:24PM CITIZENS THIS A EUCLIDIAN ZONING, THERE ARE NO SITE PLAN.
09:35:30PM I HAVE PICTURES TO SHOW YOU.
09:35:32PM SOUTH OF FIG STREET OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
09:35:35PM THE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED THAT I MENTIONED EARLIER.
09:35:39PM IN IS LOOKING AT SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED PROMPT IN THE LAST
09:35:42PM PICTURE HEAD ON LOOKING SOUTH FROM FIG.
09:35:45PM MOVING WEST DOWN FIG CLOSER TO ROME, THE NEXT SINGLE-FAMILY
09:35:51PM DETACHED HOUSE NEXT TO THE BLACK ONE.
09:35:52PM THIS WALL RIGHT HERE IS PART OF A SEMI DETACHED PROPERTY
09:35:57PM THAT YOU WILL SEE IN THE NEXT PICTURE THAT I MENTIONED WHEN
09:36:00PM I WAS GOING OVER THE MAP.
09:36:02PM SO THERE IS SEMI-DETACHED USES.
09:36:04PM THIS IS, LIKE, THREE PARCELS UNTIL YOU GET OVER TO THE NEXT
09:36:07PM BLOCK.
09:36:08PM THIS IS LOOKING NORTH ON FIG STREET AT THAT PD DEVELOPMENT
09:36:17PM THAT I MENTIONED WAS SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED.
09:36:20PM AND THIS IS LOOKING -- SORRY, TOO MANY PICTURES GOING
09:36:26PM DIFFERENT DIRECTIONS.
09:36:27PM LOOKING EAST ON FIG STREET TOWARD WILLOW AVENUE AND YOU SEE
09:36:32PM MORE OF THE 'ATTACHED USES.
09:36:34PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED PROPERTIES AND IN THE FOREGROUND ONE
09:36:38PM OF THE LARGER MULTIFAMILY PROJECTS THAT WAS UNDER
09:36:41PM CONSTRUCTION RECENTLY.
09:36:43PM LOOKING NORTH AT THE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED PROPERTY THAT
09:36:46PM YOU SAW IN THE DISTANCE A MINUTE AGO.
09:36:48PM COMPLIANCE STAFF REVIEWED THE APPLICATION AND FOUND THE
09:36:52PM REQUEST CONSISTENT.
09:36:52PM WHILE THE TWO PARCELS EAST AND WEST WERE DEVELOPED WITH
09:36:57PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED, THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN HAS
09:37:01PM TRANSITIONED TO SINGLE MULTIFAMILY.
09:37:05PM MAXIMUM OF TWO DWELLING UNITS CONSIDERED ON THE SUBJECT SITE
09:37:08PM IF ALL LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS ARE MET.
09:37:10PM IT IS CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN IN AT AREA AND
09:37:14PM I AM AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
09:37:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
09:37:16PM NO?
09:37:17PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:37:18PM NOW THE APPLICANT.
09:37:20PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
09:37:22PM STEVE MICHELINI REPRESENTING THE PETITIONER.
09:37:24PM AS THE STAFF HAS POINTED OUT, WE HAVE BEEN FOUND CONSISTENT
09:37:29PM WELL PLANNING COMMISSION AND THE CITY STAFF.
09:37:31PM A EUCLIDIAN ZONING, SO WE ARE NOT DEALING WITH ALL THE PD
09:37:36PM ISSUES WE HAVE BEEN DEALING WITH.
09:37:38PM IT IS URBAN DEVELOPMENT SITE.
09:37:41PM IT IS CHARACTERIZED BY A LOT OF MULTIFAMILY IN THE AREA.
09:37:45PM AND WILL SHOW YOU A LITTLE BIT CLOSE-UP AERIAL WITH THE
09:37:50PM SUBJECT SITE.
09:37:51PM AND OF WHAT IS AROUND IT.
09:37:54PM THIS -- THIS IS DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE PROPOSED
09:37:57PM REZONING.
09:37:58PM WE ARE REQUESTING YOUR APPROVAL.
09:38:02PM IT IS IN A TRANSITION AREA.
09:38:04PM IT DOES HAVE RES-20 LAND USE CLASSIFICATIONS.
09:38:09PM IF YOU WOULD LIKE ME TO GO THROUGH ALL THE LAND USE POLICIES
09:38:13PM IT COMPLIES WITH, I WILL BE HAPPY TO BUT OTHERWISE HAVE YOU
09:38:16PM RECEIVE AND FILE IT AND MAKE IT PART OF THE RECORD.
09:38:18PM I WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
09:38:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN?
09:38:23PM ANYBODY ELSE?
09:38:24PM NO?
09:38:25PM PUBLIC COMMENT.
09:38:25PM WE HAVE ONE REGISTERED SPEAKER, MR. BRIAN SMITH.
09:38:29PM IS BRIAN SMITH ONLINE.
09:38:31PM SIR, IF YOU RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND, WE NEED TO SWEAR YOU IN.
09:38:34PM PLEASE SWEAR HIM IN, MA'AM.
09:38:39PM >>CLERK: [SWEARING IN]
09:38:44PM >> I DO.
09:38:44PM >>CLERK: THANK YOU.
09:38:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD, SIR.
09:38:47PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
09:38:48PM >> HELLO.
09:38:49PM I LIVE IN THE TOWN HOMES DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET.
09:38:55PM I AM SITTING ABOUT 100 FEET AWAY FROM THAT PROPERTY.
09:38:58PM IT IS A VERY NARROW PIECE OF PROPERTY.
09:39:01PM TO GIVE YOU A GENERAL IDEA, THERE IS A HOUSE TO THE LEFT AND
09:39:04PM TO THE RIGHT OF IT, SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES AND YOU CAN PUT TWO
09:39:09PM AND A HALF CARS BUMPER-TO-BUMPER IN FRONT OF IT.
09:39:12PM IT IS VERY NARROW.
09:39:13PM I AM EXCITED TO SEE THAT PEOPLE WANT TO DEVELOPMENT IT.
09:39:17PM BUT SEEMS LIKE GREED, STICK TOO MANY PEOPLE IN TOO SMALL OF
09:39:21PM A PLACE AND RUN AWAY AND LEAVE US WITH NOT ENOUGH PARKING
09:39:25PM SPACES.
09:39:25PM I KNOW THEY WANT TO USE THE ALLEY.
09:39:27PM IF YOU HAVE BEEN DOWN THAT ALLEY NASTY, DARK AND WELCOMING.
09:39:31PM I WOULDN'T WALK DOWN IT WITH MY 87-POUND DOG ESPECIALLY AT
09:39:36PM NIGHT LATE FROM WORK.
09:39:37PM MOST OF THE PEOPLE I BELIEVE WILL END UP PARKING ON THE
09:39:40PM STREET.
09:39:40PM THAT PARTICULAR PROPERTY LOOKS AS IF IT WAS MEANT FOR A
09:39:44PM SINGLE-FAMILY WITH TWO CARS.
09:39:45PM MAY END UP WITH FOUR CARS, POSSIBLY SIX CARS USING THE
09:39:49PM STREETS.
09:39:49PM A LOT OF COLLEGE KIDS IN THERE UTILIZING THAT.
09:39:51PM AGAIN I WANT TO SEE THE PROPERTY DEVELOP.
09:39:53PM I DON'T WANT TO SEE IT DEVELOP AT THAT SIZE.
09:39:55PM SEEMS TO BE A THEME TONIGHT.
09:39:57PM STUFFING TOO MUCH IN TOO SMALL OF A PLACE.
09:40:00PM I THINK IT IS A TERRIBLE IDEA AND FAR TOO BIG AND NOT
09:40:05PM CONSIDERATE OF THE PEOPLE THAT LIVE IN THE AREA.
09:40:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD.
09:40:10PM >> BRIAN SMITH.
09:40:11PM I LIVE DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET.
09:40:13PM THAT PROPERTY IS 100 FEET BEHIND ME.
09:40:16PM I AM NOT REPRESENTING THE HOA BUT I AM THE HOA OF THE TOWN
09:40:20PM HOMES ACROSS THE STREET.
09:40:21PM I WANT TO POINT OUT THAT WE HAVE OUR OWN GARAGES SO WE
09:40:25PM REALLY DON'T HAVE TO PARK IN THE STREET.
09:40:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
09:40:28PM MA'AM?
09:40:29PM YES, MA'AM.
09:40:29PM STATE YOUR NAME.
09:40:30PM COME ON UP.
09:40:31PM >> CYNTHIA MALONEY, AND I AM ON THE BOARD OF THE NORTH HYDE
09:40:40PM PARK CIVIC ASSOCIATION AND WE WROTE A LETTER TO THE COUNCIL
09:40:43PM RECOMMENDING THAT YOU IT HE ANY THE REQUEST.
09:40:44PM LIKE MR. SMITH SAID, WE ARE CONCERNED OF THE DETAILS OF THE
09:40:49PM DEVELOPMENT.
09:40:49PM THERE ARE -- THE DEVELOPER DID NOT REACH OUT TO US AT ALL TO
09:40:55PM TALK TO US ABOUT WHAT HE WAS DOING.
09:40:57PM WE HAD NO CON TACK WITH HIM.
09:40:59PM THE TREES THAT ARE GROWING NOW ON THE BACK OF THE LOT ARE
09:41:06PM GORGEOUS.
09:41:06PM AND WE ARE CONCERNED THOSE ARE JUST TOAST BECAUSE OF THE --
09:41:10PM OF THE REQUIREMENT THAT, YOU KNOW, THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE TO
09:41:12PM BUILD TWO GARAGES ON THE BACK.
09:41:14PM FOR FOUR CARS, RIGHT.
09:41:17PM THAT WILL BE THE CODE.
09:41:19PM SO THOSE TREES ARE -- ARE GOING TO BE GONE.
09:41:24PM AND THAT IS A CONCERN IT WOULD SET A PRECEDENT FOR THE REST
09:41:33PM OF THE BLOCK WHICH IS ZONED SINGLE-FAMILY AS I KNOW AND THE
09:41:37PM HOUSES ON THE OTHER SIDE OF OREGON ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF FIG
09:41:44PM ARE ALL SINGLE-FAMILY.
09:41:45PM AND WE ARE TRYING TO, YOU KNOW, BUILD A NICE COMMUNITY THERE
09:41:49PM AND WE WOULD LIKE THE QUALITY OF THE DEVELOPMENT TO, YOU
09:41:52PM KNOW, BE SUFFICIENT TO, YOU KNOW, ENCOURAGE PEOPLE TO HAVE A
09:41:58PM HEALTHIER LIFE WITH LANDSCAPING AND TREES AND THINGS LIKE
09:42:04PM THAT.
09:42:04PM SO.
09:42:04PM THAT'S IT.
09:42:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:42:09PM ANYBODY ELSE?
09:42:10PM ANY -- ANYTHING FROM COUNCIL?
09:42:12PM YES, SIR, YOU HAVE REBUTTAL?
09:42:14PM YES, MA'AM, GO AHEAD.
09:42:16PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I JUST HAVE A QUESTION FOR STAFF.
09:42:26PM >> WHAT IS THE WIDTH OF THE PROPERTY.
09:42:29PM >> THE WIDTH IS 50 FEET.
09:42:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR, MR. MICHELINI, YOU HAVE
09:42:35PM REBUTTAL?
09:42:36PM >> WE ARE ASKING FOR EUCLIDIAN DISTRICT.
09:42:39PM SO THE ISSUES THAT THE SPEAKERS BROUGHT UP HAVE TO BE
09:42:42PM ADDRESSED AT PERMITTING AND WE HAVE TO MEET CODE CONCERNS OF
09:42:52PM LIVING IN A TOWNHOUSE THAT HAVE PARKING.
09:42:54PM WHATEVER DEVELOPMENT HAS TO HAVE PARKING AND HAS TO MEET THE
09:42:57PM CODE FOR ALL OF THAT.
09:42:58PM AS I POINTED OUT TO YOU, THIS IS THE LOT.
09:43:00PM THESE ARE THE TOWN HOUSES ACROSS THE STREET.
09:43:03PM AND -- I MEAN, IT IS A LITTLE HARD TO BELIEVE THAT SOMEONE
09:43:07PM IN A TOWN.
09:43:07PM HOUSE WILL GO TO OTHER POTENTIAL TOWN HOUSES ACROSS
09:43:13PM THE STREET.
09:43:14PM REGARDLESS, WE WILL MEET THE CODE.
09:43:16PM IT IS EUCLIDIAN AND FOUND CONSISTENT WITH THE PLANNING
09:43:19PM COMMISSION AND STAFF.
09:43:20PM RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL AND WILL BE GLAD TO
09:43:25PM ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
09:43:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
09:43:27PM YES?
09:43:27PM OH, NO.
09:43:28PM MOTION TO CLOSE.
09:43:29PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: NOTION CLOSE.
09:43:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILMAN
09:43:33PM CLENDENIN AND SECONDED FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
09:43:35PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK, WOULD YOU LIKE TO READ THIS?
09:43:42PM >>LYNN HURTAK: FILE NUMBER REZ-23-112, ORDINANCE BEING
09:43:47PM PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION.
09:43:49PM ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 1324
09:43:53PM WEST FIG STREET IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, MORE
09:43:55PM PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION ONE FROM ZONING
09:43:57PM CLASSIFICATION RS-50, RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY TO RM-18,
09:44:02PM RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
09:44:08PM >>LUIS VIERA: SECOND.
09:44:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK AND
09:44:11PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
09:44:13PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
09:44:17PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
09:44:18PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
09:44:21PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: NO.
09:44:23PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
09:44:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO.
09:44:26PM >>CLERK: MOTION TO APPROVE CARRIED WITH HENDERSON AND
09:44:37PM MANISCALCO VOTING NO.
09:44:37PM AND CARLSON VOTING NO.
09:44:42PM >> THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
09:44:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
09:44:46PM SECOND READING, MA'AM.
09:44:49PM >>CLERK: SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD MAY 2,
09:44:55PM 2024 AT 9:30 A.M. LOCATED OLD CITY HALL, 315 E. KENNEDY
09:45:00PM BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
09:45:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:45:07PM ITEM NUMBER 9.
09:45:08PM >>SAM THOMAS: SAM THOMAS, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:45:10PM 23-119 ALREADY REQUEST TO REZONE 213 SOUTH NEW JERSEY AVENUE
09:45:17PM FROM RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY 16 TO PD, RESIDENTIAL
09:45:24PM SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED.
09:45:25PM TURN IT OVER TO DANNY.
09:45:27PM >>DANNY COLLINS: DANNY COLLINS WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION
09:45:29PM STAFF.
09:45:29PM NEXT CASE IN THE CENTRAL PLANNING DISTRICT IN THE PALMA CEIA
09:45:36PM PINES NEIGHBORHOOD IN EVACUATION ZONE C.
09:45:39PM AN AERIAL MAP OF THE SURROUNDING PROPERTIES.
09:45:42PM IT IS APPROXIMATELY ONE BLOCK EAST OF MacDILL AVENUE.
09:45:47PM ADJACENT TO COMMERCIAL USES TO THE WEST.
09:45:50PM THERE ARE RESIDENTIAL USES TO THE NORTH, EAST AND SOUTH OF
09:45:54PM THE SITE.
09:45:54PM HERE IS THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
09:46:02PM SUBJECT SITE UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-20 DESIGNATION TO THE
09:46:05PM NORTH, EAST AND SOUTH OF THE SITE AND COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35
09:46:11PM TO THE WEST OF SOUTH MacDILL AVENUE.
09:46:13PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REVIEWED THE REQUEST, AND FOUND NO
09:46:17PM ADVERSE IMPACTS TO THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:46:19PM PREDOMINANTLY A SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED RESIDENCES LOCATED TO
09:46:24PM THE EAST AND NORTH OF THE SITE.
09:46:26PM A FEW -- A FEW SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED ARE HE IS DENTS ARE
09:46:31PM ALSO TO THE NORTH OF THE SITE.
09:46:32PM THE PROPOSED DENSITY OF 17.96 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE IS
09:46:38PM CONSISTENT WITH THE R-20 DESIGNATION.
09:46:42PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF IT COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH
09:46:45PM THE SURROUNDING AREA AS CONSISTENT WITH THE DENSITY
09:46:47PM ANTICIPATED UNDER THE R-20 DESIGNATION.
09:46:50PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ENCOURAGES SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED
09:46:53PM RESIDENTIAL USES TO BE DESIGNED TO INCLUDE THE ORIENTATION
09:46:56PM OF THE FRONT DOOR TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD SIDEWALK OR STREET.
09:46:58PM THE FRONT ENTRANCES ARE ORIENTED TOWARD AND CONNECTED TO THE
09:47:02PM SIDEWALK ON WEST PLATT STREET MEETING THE INTENT OF THIS
09:47:06PM POLICY.
09:47:06PM IN CONCLUSION, THE PROPOSED PLANNED DEVELOPMENT FURTHER
09:47:10PM SEVERAL -- SEVERAL COMPREHENSIVE PLAN POLICIES PROMOTING
09:47:15PM RESIDENTIAL INFILL UNTIL APPROPRIATE AREAS.
09:47:17PM ADDITIONALLY THE PROPOSED PD WILL PROVIDE ADDITIONAL HOUSING
09:47:22PM WITHIN -- COMPATIBLE TO THE R REASON 20 DESIGNATION.
09:47:26PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
09:47:30PM FINDS CAN CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND THAT
09:47:33PM CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION AND HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
09:47:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
09:47:37PM THANK YOU.
09:47:37PM YES, SIR.
09:47:38PM >>SAM THOMAS: SAM THOMAS, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:47:42PM HERE IS THE AERIAL MAP.
09:47:46PM AS DANNY MENTIONED THIS AREA IS DEVELOPED WITH SINGLE-FAMILY
09:47:49PM DETACHED OR MULTIFAMILY USES.
09:47:52PM REFLECTED IN THE RM-16 AND 18 ZONING DISTRICT WITH THE
09:47:58PM NUMBER OF PDs IN THE AREA.
09:48:00PM MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT AND THE INTERSECTION WHERE THE
09:48:03PM PROPERTY IS LOCATED ALL CORNERS ARE DEVELOPED WITH
09:48:07PM MULTIFAMILY ATTACHED.
09:48:09PM THIS IS MULTIFAMILY USE.
09:48:10PM THIS LOOKS VACANT BUT DEVELOPED WITH SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED
09:48:13PM AND SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED HERE AS WELL.
09:48:15PM COMMERCIAL GENERAL USES ALONG MacDILL AND ALONG KENNEDY
09:48:20PM BOULEVARD AS WELL.
09:48:20PM WE WILL GO ALONG TO THE SITE PLAN NOW.
09:48:22PM HERE IS THE SITE PLAN PROVIDED BY THE APPLICANT.
09:48:30PM THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING THREE UNITS TO WEST PLATT STREET
09:48:34PM WITH PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIONS VIA THE DRIVEWAY.
09:48:38PM EXISTING FIVE-FOOT SIDEWALK ALONG WEST PLATT STREET AND
09:48:42PM APPLICANT IS PROPOSING FIVE-FOOT SIDEWALK ALONG NEW JERSEY
09:48:45PM AVENUE.
09:48:46PM SEVEN PARKING SPACES ARE REQUIRED AND NINE ARE BEING
09:48:50PM PROVIDED.
09:48:50PM 35 FEET FOR THREE STORY.
09:48:53PM A SIX-FOOT PVC FENCE ON THE SIDES AND THE PERIMETER AND
09:48:58PM NORTH AND WEST OF THE PROPERTY.
09:48:59PM AND THE SUBJECT SITE SHOWS A 32-INCH LAUREL OAK TREE BEING
09:49:07PM REMOVED BUT THE APPLICANT IS RETAINING THAT LAUREL OAK.
09:49:11PM HERE ARE THE ELEVATION PROVIDED BY THE APPLICANT.
09:49:16PM SO THIS IS FACING PLAT STREET.
09:49:19PM THIS WILL BE TO THE PROPERTY LINE.
09:49:21PM THIS IS YOUR EAST ELEVATION ALONG JERSEY.
09:49:26PM AND THAT IS YOUR BEST ELEVATION.
09:49:28PM THIS IS LOOKING WEST DIRECTLY AT THE SUBJECT SITE FROM SOUTH
09:49:34PM NEW JERSEY AVENUE.
09:49:35PM THIS IS PLATT STREET HERE.
09:49:36PM THIS IS LOOKING NORTH FROM THE SUBJECT SITE.
09:49:40PM HERE IS SOME SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED USES.
09:49:43PM THIS IS THE MULTIFAMILY HERE.
09:49:44PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTH NEW JERSEY HERE, PLATT.
09:49:54PM THE SINGLE-FAMILY UNITS THAT WERE UNDER CONSTRUCTION
09:49:58PM TESTIMONY LOOKS LIKE VACANT ON THE AERIAL MAP.
09:50:00PM THIS IS LOOKING EAST.
09:50:02PM HERE IS THE SUBJECT SITE HERE.
09:50:04PM YOU CAN SEE SOME SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED IN THE DISTANCE
09:50:07PM THERE NEXT TO THE SUBJECT SITE.
09:50:10PM THIS IS LOOKING WEST WITH PLATT STREET.
09:50:13PM MacDILL AVENUE HERE ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THIS FENCE AND
09:50:17PM RIGHT HERE IS WHERE THE COMMERCIAL USES START.
09:50:20PM AND THEN THIS IS LOOKING EAST ON PLATT STREET.
09:50:22PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
09:50:24PM AND THERE IS THAT LAUREL OAK THAT WILL BE RETAINED.
09:50:29PM HERE IS A VIEW OF THE SITE PLAN AGAIN.
09:50:37PM DEVELOPMENT REVIEW AND COMPLIANCE STAFF HAVE REVIEWED THE
09:50:43PM APPLICATION AND FINDS THE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH THE
09:50:45PM APPLICABLE CITY OF TAMPA DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS.
09:50:47PM SHOULD IT BE THE PLEASURE OF COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE WAIVER
09:50:50PM AS IDENTIFIED ON THE STAFF REPORT AND APPROVE THE
09:50:53PM APPLICATION, FURTHER MODIFICATION BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
09:50:56PM READING AS STATED ON THE REVISION SHEET.
09:50:59PM I AM AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
09:51:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
09:51:03PM NO?
09:51:04PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:51:05PM YES, SIR.
09:51:05PM IS THIS YOUR LAST CASE TONIGHT?
09:51:09PM >> NO, SIR, I HAVE ONE MORE.
09:51:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT, GO AHEAD.
09:51:13PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
09:51:14PM >> YOU KNOW -- STEVE MICHELINI, AND I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
09:51:18PM YOU KNOW IF YOU HAD TO DRAW AN EQUATION ABOUT HOW MANY CASES
09:51:22PM YOU HAD IN ONE NIGHT, YOU WOULDN'T DRAW THIS.
09:51:24PM IT IS JUST -- I GUESS THE LUCK OF THE IRISH TONIGHT.
09:51:29PM BUT ANYWAY, CITY STAFF AND THE PLANNING COMMISSION BOTH
09:51:34PM FOUND THIS TO BE CONSISTENT.
09:51:35PM THE WAIVERS BEING REQUESTED IS BETWEEN THIS PROPERTY AND
09:51:39PM COMMERCIAL USE.
09:51:41PM AGAIN, WE TALKED ABOUT THIS.
09:51:43PM AND IT PROBABLY NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED BY A CODE CHANGE THAT
09:51:48PM YOU -- THE PROTECTED BUFFERS ARE REALLY FOR THE RESIDENTIAL
09:51:52PM PROPERTIES, NOT FOR COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES, BUT I -- THERE IS
09:51:59PM A WAY THE LANGUAGE IS WRITTEN THAT IS WHAT IS HAPPENING.
09:52:02PM RESIDENTIAL-20.
09:52:04PM WE ARE PROPOSING THREE UNITS.
09:52:07PM IT IS COMPATIBLE AND CONSISTENT WITH THE SURROUNDING AREA
09:52:11PM THE AREA IF YOU SEE HERE IS SURROUNDED BY MULTIFAMILY
09:52:17PM DEVELOPMENTS OF ALL DIFFERENT SHAPES AND SIZES.
09:52:19PM AGAIN, INSTEAD OF READING ALL THIS CRITERIA, I WILL ASK THAT
09:52:25PM THEY BE RECEIVED AND FILED AND PART OF THE RECORD.
09:52:30PM THE SUSTAINABLE USE OF THE LAND AND INTEGRATION OF DIFFERENT
09:52:34PM LAND USES AND PROVIDES FOR AND ACKNOWLEDGES THAT THERE ARE
09:52:37PM DEVELOPMENT PATTERNS THAT ARE CONSISTENT WITH THIS -- WITH
09:52:39PM THE AREA AND ENCOURAGES FLEXIBLE DEVELOPMENT AREAS FOR
09:52:43PM TRANSPORTATION NEEDS.
09:52:44PM PROMOTES, ENCOURAGES DEVELOPMENT OF LOCATION AND PROMOTES
09:52:50PM LIVING CONDITIONS AND ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES AND ALLOW THE
09:52:53PM DESIGN.
09:52:54PM PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT IS UNIQUE AND THEREFORE NEEDS THE
09:52:57PM WAIVERS AND THE ONLY WAIVER IN THERE WAS THE ONE THAT I
09:53:00PM MENTIONED.
09:53:00PM THE WAIVER ALLOWED SUBSTANTIALLY INTERFERE -- DOES NOT
09:53:05PM INTERFERE WITH THE RIGHTS OF OTHERS AND IN HARMONY WITH THE
09:53:07PM GENERAL INTENT OF THE CHAPTER AND THE CODE AND ALLOWS THE
09:53:10PM WAIVER WILL RESULT IN SUBSTANTIAL JUSTICE BEING DONE.
09:53:12PM I WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS, BUT, AGAIN, I WOULD
09:53:16PM PREFER THAT THE RECORD TO REFLECT THAT WE ASK THE ACCEPTANCE
09:53:22PM REGARDING CONSISTENCY.
09:53:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
09:53:26PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM?
09:53:29PM ITEM NUMBER 9?
09:53:30PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MOTION TO CLOSE.
09:53:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILMAN
09:53:35PM CLENDENIN.
09:53:35PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
09:53:37PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
09:53:38PM OPPOSED?
09:53:40PM COUNCILMAN CARLSON, ITEM NUMBER 9.
09:53:42PM >>BILL CARLSON: I WOULD LIKE TO MOVE REZ-23-119, ORDINANCE
09:53:48PM BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, IN THE
09:53:52PM AGAIN VALUE VICINITY 213 SOUTH NEW JERSEY AVENUE IN SECTION
09:53:57PM 1 FROM ZONING CLASSIFICATION RM-16 RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY
09:54:02PM TO PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED PROVIDING
09:54:06PM AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
09:54:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN CARLSON AND
09:54:10PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
09:54:11PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
09:54:14PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I BELIEVE THERE IS A REVISION SHEET.
09:54:16PM >>BILL CARLSON: A REVISION SHEET AND TO RECEIVE AND FILE THE
09:54:19PM -- THE -- THE CODE REFERENCES THAT THE APPLICANT REFERENCED.
09:54:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
09:54:27PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
09:54:28PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
09:54:31PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
09:54:33PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
09:54:34PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
09:54:36PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
09:54:37PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
09:54:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
09:54:39PM >> THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
09:54:41PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
09:54:45PM SECOND READ AND ADOPTION LOCATED OLD CITY HALL, 315 E.
09:54:54PM KENNEDY BOULEVARD, TAMPA, FLORIDA, THIRD FLOOR.
09:54:56PM 33602.
09:54:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER 11.
09:55:00PM >>SAM THOMAS: SAM THOMAS, ITEM NUMBER 11, REQUEST TO REZONE.
09:55:09PM 4314 WEST GRAY STREET FROM RS-50 TO PD.
09:55:17PM DANNY.
09:55:19PM >>DANNY COLLINS: DANNY COLLINS.
09:55:20PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
09:55:21PM NEXT CASE IN THE WEST SHORE PALMS NEIGHBORHOOD SUBJECT SITE
09:55:26PM -- SITE IS WITHIN OUR EVACUATION ZONE B.
09:55:29PM SUBJECT SITE IS SHOWN HERE.
09:55:31PM IT IS BETWEEN MANISCALCO AND NORTH HEBERT AVENUE.
09:55:37PM SURROUNDING RESIDENTIAL.
09:55:39PM SOME TOWN HOME DEVELOPMENTS TO THE NORTH OF THE SITE, AS
09:55:43PM WELL AS SOME SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED ALONG THIS SEGMENT.
09:55:46PM THERE ARE SOME MULTIFAMILY ALONG HERBERT AVENUE.
09:55:51PM HERE IS THE ADOPTED FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
09:55:56PM THE PARCEL AND THE SUBJECT SURROUNDING PARCELS ARE
09:55:59PM RECOGNIZED UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL-20 DESIGNATION.
09:56:03PM PROPOSED PD FOUR RESIDENTIAL ATTACHED UNITS WHICH IS
09:56:08PM CONSISTENT WITH THE DENSITY ANTICIPATED IN THE R-20
09:56:12PM CATEGORY.
09:56:12PM THE REZONING WILL PROVIDE COMPATIBLE DWELLING UNITS OF 20
09:56:17PM PER ACRE.
09:56:20PM THE EXISTING DENSITY UNDER THE R-20 BETWEEN
09:56:23PM NORTH MANHATTAN AND NORTH HUBERT AVENUE IS 3.9 DWELLING
09:56:28PM UNITS PER ACRE WHICH IS APPROXIMATELY 47% OF THE DENSITY
09:56:32PM PLANNED FOR THIS AREA IN THE CITY.
09:56:33PM THE PD A DENSITY OF 17 DWELLING UNITS PER ACHE THEIR WILL
09:56:37PM PROVIDE A BETTER UTILIZATION OF LAND UNDER THE R-20
09:56:42PM CATEGORY.
09:56:42PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDS THAT IT WILL NOT ALTER THE
09:56:45PM CHARACTER OF THE SURROUNDING AREA.
09:56:46PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ENCOURAGES SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED
09:56:51PM DEVELOPMENTS TO BE DESIGNED TO INCLUDE THE ORIENTATION OF
09:56:53PM THE FRONT DOOR TO A NEIGHBORHOOD SIDEWALK OR STREET.
09:56:56PM U PD PROPOSE AS FRONT DOOR OF WEST GRAY STREET AND UNITS
09:57:02PM ONE.
09:57:02PM UNITS TWO THROUGH FOUR FACING A SIDEWALK OF GRAY STREET.
09:57:08PM MEETING THE INTENT OF THIS POLICY.
09:57:10PM FINALLY, THE PD ALSO SUPPORTS THE PLAN'S HOUSING AND COMPACT
09:57:17PM CITY FORM STRATEGY AND REQUEST WILL REQUEST ADDITIONAL
09:57:21PM HOUSING OF TRANSIT OPPORTUNITIES.
09:57:22PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
09:57:26PM FINDS THE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY OF TAMPA
09:57:28PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
09:57:29PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
09:57:30PM AND I AM AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
09:57:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ANY QUESTIONS?
09:57:38PM YES, SIR?
09:57:39PM >>SAM THOMAS: SAM THOMAS, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:57:42PM WE ARE BACK IN THE SAME NEIGHBORHOOD AS ITEM NUMBER
09:57:47PM 7, REZ-23-78 ON WEST NORTH B STREET.
09:57:50PM IF THE PLEASURE OF COUNCIL, I CAN GO INTO GREAT DETAIL AGAIN
09:57:54PM OF THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN.
09:57:56PM IF NOT WE BELIEVE SKIP IT, MULTIFAMILY AND SINGLE-FAMILY
09:57:59PM DETACHED WITH A MIXTURE OF MULTIFAMILY AND PD ZONING
09:58:03PM DISTRICTS.
09:58:04PM HERE IS THE SITE PLAN PROVIDED BY THE APPLICANT.
09:58:06PM AS DANNY MENTIONED, THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING FOUR UNITS
09:58:12PM WITH UNIT ONE ORIENTED TOWARD WEST GRAY STREET AND THE OTHER
09:58:18PM UNIT ORIENTED INTERNALLY WITH A SIDE WALL PROVIDING
09:58:22PM CONNECTIONS TO WEST GRAY STREET.
09:58:24PM THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING NINE PARKING SPACES AND NINE
09:58:30PM PARKING SPACES ARE PROVIDED.
09:58:32PM PROPOSED WHO IT IS 40 FEET OR THREE STORIES AND ADDITIONALLY
09:58:36PM THE APPLICANT IS RETAIN TWO 20-INCH TREES AT THE REAR OF THE
09:58:40PM SITE AND ONE GUEST PARKING SPOT IS PROVIDED.
09:58:42PM WE WILL GO TO THE AERIALS NEXT.
09:58:45PM HERE ARE THE AERIALS.
09:58:50PM THE FRONT FACING GRAY STREET.
09:58:51PM THIS IS YOUR INTERNAL DRIVE AISLE FACING.
09:58:54PM YOUR SOUTH AND WEST ELEVATION.
09:58:56PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTH AT THE SUBJECT SITE HERE.
09:59:02PM SOUTHWEST OF SUBJECT SITE WITH THE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED.
09:59:11PM LOOKING SOUTHWEST OF THE SITE WITH SOME OF THE SINGLE-FAMILY
09:59:17PM ATTACHED BEING CONSTRUCTED.
09:59:18PM SOME SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED LOOKING NORTH FROM GRAY STREET
09:59:22PM WEST OF THE SITE EAST OF THE SITE AND LOOKING SOUTH.
09:59:28PM THE PARCEL NEXT TO THE SUBJECT SITE, SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED.
09:59:31PM ANOTHER SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF WEST
09:59:34PM GRAY STREET.
09:59:35PM AND THEN EAST OF THE SITE, LOOKING SOUTH ON GRAY STREET,
09:59:38PM HERE ARE SOME SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED UNDER CONSTRUCTION.
09:59:42PM LITTLE FARTHER EAST OF THE SITE, LOOKING WEST DOWN GRAY
09:59:47PM STREET, SOME MULTIFAMILY THAT HAS BEEN THERE FOR A LITTLE
09:59:50PM BIT NOW DEVELOPMENT AND REVIEW COMPLIANCE STAFF FINDS THE
09:59:58PM REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH THE APPLICABLE CITY OF TAMPA
10:00:02PM REGULATIONS.
10:00:03PM COUNCIL APPROVES THE WAIVERS IN THE STAFF REPORT, FURTHER
10:00:08PM MODIFICATION OF THE SITE PLAN MUST BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST AND
10:00:10PM SECOND READING AS STATED IN THE REVISION STREET.
10:00:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
10:00:17PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHAT IS THE SIZE OF THE FRONT DOORS AND
10:00:20PM THE GARAGES.
10:00:20PM WHAT ARE THAT FACING.
10:00:22PM DO YOU HAVE A PICTURE WHAT THAT IS FACING, THE DRIVEWAY.
10:00:26PM >> YOU ARE TALKING THE ELEVATIONS AS SOON AS.
10:00:29PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THE ACTUAL PICTURES OF THIS SITE.
10:00:31PM WHAT IS THAT PROPERTY FACING.
10:00:33PM >> THIS PROPERTY HERE.
10:00:34PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHERE THE DRIVEWAY IS.
10:00:36PM THE DRIVEWAYS ARE TO THE LEFT OF THE
10:00:39PM PICTURE AND A SINGLE-FAMILY HOUSE TO THE LEFT?
10:00:41PM >> YES, ON BOTH SIDE OF THE PROPERTY ARE SINGLE-FAMILY
10:00:44PM DETACHED HOUSES.
10:00:45PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ALL RIGHT, THANKS.
10:00:47PM >> ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?
10:00:55PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
10:00:57PM >> STEVE MICHELINI, REPRESENTING THE PETITIONER.
10:00:59PM AND, YES, I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
10:01:01PM WE PROVIDED ON THE SITE PLAN SO THAT THE BUFFER ON THIS SIDE
10:01:09PM INCLUDED THE DRIVE AISLE AS WELL AS GREEN SPACE.
10:01:11PM SO IT IS NOT DIRECTLY AGAINST IT.
10:01:13PM AND ON THIS SIDE, WE ARE MEETING THE BUFFER REQUIREMENT IN
10:01:18PM GREEN SPACE.
10:01:19PM SO WE ARE -- WE ARE HAPPY ABOUT ALL OF THE GREEN SPACE
10:01:22PM ISSUES.
10:01:23PM QUITE HONESTLY, BUT TRANSIT IS AVAILABLE.
10:01:27PM NINE PARKING SPACES REQUIRED.
10:01:29PM WE ARE PROVIDING NINE SPACES.
10:01:31PM AS STAFF HAS POINTED OUT, WE ARE SURROUNDED BY DEVELOPING
10:01:36PM AND REDEVELOP TOWN HOUSES.
10:01:41PM HERE IS THE AERIAL.
10:01:42PM HERE IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
10:01:44PM AND YOU CAN SEE WHAT IS GOING ON IN THE AREA.
10:01:47PM SO THIS IS -- THIS IS NOT AN INTRODUCTION OF A NEW CONCEPT.
10:01:51PM THIS IS THE STREET LOOKING FROM SUBJECT SITE, LOOKING DOWN
10:01:56PM THE STREET.
10:01:57PM SO -- SO THERE ARE PLENTY OF COMPATIBILITY INVOLVED HERE.
10:02:05PM AGAIN I WILL SAVE SOME TIME AND ASK THAT THE STAFF REPORT BE
10:02:08PM RECEIVED AND FILED AND MADE PART OF THE RECORD.
10:02:10PM IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, I WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER THEM.
10:02:13PM I AM RESPECTFULLY REQUESTING YOUR APPROVAL.
10:02:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
10:02:18PM ANYONE IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM, ITEM
10:02:21PM NUMBER 11?
10:02:23PM MAY I HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE.
10:02:25PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MOTION TO CLOSE.
10:02:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCILMAN
10:02:28PM CLENDENIN.
10:02:28PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:02:30PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:02:31PM COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
10:02:32PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
10:02:33PM I -- WHEN LOOKING AT THIS -- THIS DESIGN AND LOOKING AT THE
10:02:39PM -- THE DEVELOPMENTS AROUND IT, ALL OF THEM HAVE DRIVEWAYS
10:02:43PM THAT FACE THE STREET.
10:02:46PM AND ALL ARE ACTUAL FRONT-FACING UNITS.
10:02:49PM SO I DON'T BELIEVE THIS MATCHES.
10:02:51PM SO I AM GOING TO MOTION TO DENY.
10:02:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: OKAY.
10:03:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WANT --
10:03:03PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I MEAN -- NO, MY RATIONALE.
10:03:05PM THERE ARE MULTIPLE REASONS.
10:03:07PM ONE, WE SHOULDN'T BE -- WE SHOULDN'T BE APPROVING THESE TYPE
10:03:11PM OF AISLE-STYLE DEVELOPMENTS.
10:03:13PM BUT, TWO, EVEN IF WE DID, THE GARAGES ARE ONLY 21 FEET WIDE.
10:03:18PM SO WE CAN'T FIT TWO CARS IN THEM.
10:03:20PM AND B, OR C, OR 3 OR WHATEVER, WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE ACTUAL
10:03:27PM IMAGES OF WHAT IS SURROUNDING IT, YOU HAVE FACE ON UNITS.
10:03:32PM YOU DON'T HAVE THIS AISLE-STYLE DEVELOPMENT THROUGHOUT THE
10:03:35PM COMMUNITY.
10:03:36PM AND BECAUSE THERE ARE ---ER IN ALL -- THEY ARE SINGLE-FAMILY
10:03:41PM PROPERTIES ALL AROUND STILL, YOU WANT TO SORT OF MATCH WITH
10:03:47PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND IN WILL BRING IN SOMETHING THAT ISN'T
10:03:49PM WHAT -- WHAT THE REST OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD HAS.
10:03:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES?
10:03:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: INTERESTING, BECAUSE I THINK I WAS WITH
10:03:57PM YOU, BUT THEN WHEN I SOUGHT DEVELOPMENT PATTERN.
10:04:00PM IT IS A VERY ECLECTICALLY AREA.
10:04:07PM VERY ECLECTIC.
10:04:09PM >> BUT THEY ALL FACE THE FRONT.
10:04:12PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I GET THAT, BUT THE DIVERSITY OF THE TYPE
10:04:15PM OF HOUSING ALLOW IT IS.
10:04:16PM WHAT I LIKE THE FACT IT IS A 20-FOOT DRIVE.
10:04:18PM AND 21 -- I MEAN, I DO -- I HAVE A 19-FOOT DRIVE GARAGE AND
10:04:25PM I FIT TWO CARS IN IT BY THE WAY.
10:04:27PM I LIKE THE FACT THAT THERE IS A LOT OF GREEN SPACE.
10:04:29PM THERE IS A LOT OF WINDOWS.
10:04:31PM YOU KNOW, IT'S -- IT IS NOT A PLAIN, YOU KNOW -- IT IS -- I
10:04:37PM DON'T KNOW.
10:04:38PM I THINK IT JUST FITS WITH THE ECLECTIC DEVELOPMENT OF THE
10:04:42PM AREA.
10:04:42PM IF IT WAS IN A DIFFERENT AREA I WOULDN'T APPROVE IT.
10:04:44PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IF YOU WANT TO TRY --
10:04:48PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WILL APPROVE IT.
10:04:49PM WE LOOK AT THAT AS WHAT JUSTIFIES A PD IS IF IT IS
10:04:55PM COMPATIBLE WITH THE BUILT-OUT AREA, THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
10:04:58PM WHEN I LOOK AT THOSE PICTURES WHAT I SAW, A WEIRD ECLECTIC
10:05:03PM OF INTERESTING DEVELOPMENT.
10:05:04PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OKAY, WELL, ANYBODY ELSE THAT WANTS TO WEIGH
10:05:09PM IN AND TELL US WITH AWAY WE WANT TO GO.
10:05:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU WANT TO PUT A HOLD ON YOUR MOTION?
10:05:14PM >>LYNN HURTAK: SOUNDS LIKE IT IS ONE OF EACH OF US.
10:05:17PM WHAT IS THE PLEASURE.
10:05:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I AM GOING TO BE SUPPORTING IT.
10:05:20PM SO COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN, IF YOU WANT TO MAKE YOUR MOTION
10:05:23PM FIRST.
10:05:24PM ANYBODY ELSE WANT TO CHIME IN OR JUST --
10:05:26PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: IS THIS THE LAST PARCEL ON NORTH B
10:05:29PM STREET?
10:05:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS THIS THE WHAT?
10:05:33PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THE LAST PARCEL ON NORTH B STREET?
10:05:36PM >>LYNN HURTAK: SURROUNDED BY SINGLE-FAMILY.
10:05:38PM THAT IS WHAT IS SO INTERESTING -- THIS PART IS REALLY
10:05:41PM SURROUNDED BY SINGLE-FAMILY WHICH IS WHY THE FORWARD-FACE
10:05:44PM SOMETHING SO IMPORTANT IN THIS CASE.
10:05:45PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WE HAVEN'T CLOSED, RIGHT?
10:05:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE CLOSED.
10:05:50PM ON GRAY STREET, WHAT I SAW ON SOME OF THE PHOTOS.
10:05:54PM THIS IS CLOSER TO WEST SHORE MALL, CORRECT?
10:05:57PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MOTION TO OPEN.
10:05:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I KNOW THE ANSWER.
10:05:59PM I KNOW THE ANSWER.
10:06:00PM WE DON'T NEED TO REOPEN.
10:06:02PM I KNOW THE ANSWER BECAUSE THE PHOTOGRAPH SHOWED ANOTHER
10:06:05PM PARCEL AND I KNOW WHERE IT IS AT.
10:06:06PM UNLESS ANYONE ELSE WANT TO ADD ANYTHING ELSE TO REOPEN IT.
10:06:11PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I MOVE AN ORDINANCE FILE NUMBER REZ
10:06:20PM 24-11, AN APPLICATION REQUEST TO REZONE PROPERTY GENERALLY
10:06:24PM LOCATED 4314 WEST GRAY STREET FROM RS-50 TO PD, RESIDENTIAL
10:06:29PM SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED.
10:06:30PM AN ORDINANCE BEING CONSIDERED -- PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING
10:06:37PM CONSIDERATION, REZONING THE PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY
10:06:40PM -- I AM OFF -- 4314 WEST GRAY STREET IN THE CITY OF
10:06:46PM TAMPA, FLORIDA, MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION ONE
10:06:49PM ZONING CLASSIFICATION RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY TO PLANNED
10:06:53PM DEVELOPMENT, RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED PROVIDING AN
10:06:56PM EFFECTIVE DATE.
10:06:57PM I MOVE THAT -- I FIND THAT THE STATEMENT OF NATIONAL BASED
10:07:00PM ON COMPETENT SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE FOUND IN THE STAFF
10:07:04PM REPORTS, APPLICANT'S REPORTS AND TESTIMONY THAT ESTABLISHES
10:07:07PM AND COMPLIES WITH THE APPLICABLE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND
10:07:10PM POLICIES OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND SEE THE PLANNING
10:07:15PM COMMISSION REPORT, 17 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE WHICH IS
10:07:18PM CONSISTENT WITH THE DENSITY ANTICIPATED OF THE
10:07:20PM RESIDENTIAL-20 DESIGNATION AND WILL PROVIDE INFILL
10:07:23PM DEVELOPMENT ON A SITE THAT PRESENTLY UNDERUTILIZE WHICH IS
10:07:27PM ENCOURAGED BY LAND USE POLICY 8.15.1 AND 8.15.2.
10:07:33PM PROPOSED IS KIN WITH 1.3.4.
10:07:36PM AND LAND USE 2.1.2 AND 9.7.1 THAT ENCOURAGES NEW HOUSING ON
10:07:42PM VACANT AND TO ENSURE AN ADEQUATE SUPPLY OF HOUSING IS TO
10:07:47PM MEET THE NEED OF TAMPA'S PRESENT AND FUTURE POPULATIONS.
10:07:49PM THAT THE -- AND IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE LAND CODE SECTION
10:07:56PM 27-136 THAT THE DEVELOPMENT AS SHOWN ON THE SITE PLAN
10:07:59PM PROMOTES AND ENCOURAGES DEVELOPMENT THAT IS APPROPRIATE IN
10:08:02PM LOCATION AND CHARACTER AND COMPATIBILITY OF THE SURROUNDING
10:08:06PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND INFILL DEVELOPMENT IN AN AREA THAT IS
10:08:08PM LARGELY TRENDING TOWARD MULTIFAMILY AND SEMI-DETACHED UNITS.
10:08:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION AND A SECOND.
10:08:16PM A REVISION SHEET.
10:08:19PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WITH THE REVISION SHEET.
10:08:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IN ONE OF THE PHOTOS I SAW THERE WERE
10:08:23PM THE APARTMENTS.
10:08:23PM ADAGIO, I BELIEVE.
10:08:26PM SEEING HOW THAT PART OF GRAY STREET.
10:08:28PM YOU HAVE MORE TOWN HOMES AS IT GETS CLOSER TO WEST SHORE
10:08:35PM BOULEVARD BETWEEN LOW BUSINESS AND WEST SHORE.
10:08:38PM A MIX THERE.
10:08:38PM IT HAS BEEN CHANGING FOR THE LAST DECADE, I WOULD SAY.
10:08:42PM SO I AM GOING TO BE SUPPORTING IT.
10:08:44PM WE HAVE A MOTION WITH THE REVISION SHEET FROM COUNCILMAN
10:08:46PM CLENDENIN.
10:08:47PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:08:49PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
10:08:50PM >>LYNN HURTAK: NO.
10:08:52PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
10:08:54PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: NO.
10:08:56PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
10:08:58PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
10:09:00PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
10:09:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
10:09:02PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED WITH HURTAK AND HENDERSON VOTING NO.
10:09:11PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MAY 2, 2024 AT
10:09:16PM 9:30 A.M. LOCATED OLD CITY HALL, 315 E. KENNEDY BOULEVARD,
10:09:21PM THIRD FLORIDA, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
10:09:25PM >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH, COUNCIL.
10:09:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: LAST CASE OF THE NIGHT.
10:09:29PM WE DID IT.
10:09:31PM >>SAM THOMAS: IN THE HOME STRETCH.
10:09:32PM SAM THOMAS, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:09:34PM AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 12, REZ 24-19.
10:09:38PM REQUEST TO REZONE 803 AND 809 WEST LINEBAUGH FROM
10:09:43PM RESIDENTIAL 06 AND PLAN DEVELOPMENT TO PLAN DEVELOPMENT TO
10:09:47PM SEMI DETACHED.
10:09:48PM TURN IT OVER TO DANNY NOW.
10:09:50PM >>DANNY COLLINS: DANNY COLLINS WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION
10:09:55PM STAFF.
10:09:55PM OUR LAST CASE IS WITHIN THE UNIVERSITY PLANNING DISTRICT,
10:10:00PM SPECIFICALLY THE EAST FOREST HILLS NEIGHBORHOOD WITHIN
10:10:03PM EVACUATION ZONE E.
10:10:05PM SUBJECT SITE IS OUTLINED IN PURPLE HERE.
10:10:08PM IT IS JUST TO THE WEST OF NORTH OLA AVENUE AND WEST
10:10:12PM LINEBAUGH AVENUE.
10:10:13PM SURROUNDING AREAS IS PREDOMINANTLY RESIDENTIAL.
10:10:17PM MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT.
10:10:20PM TO THE WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE AS WELL AS TO THE SOUTHWEST
10:10:22PM OF THE SITE, AS WELL -- THERE IS SOME SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED
10:10:26PM IN THE AREA AS WELL.
10:10:27PM PROPOSED PD PROPOSES 18 DWELLING UNITS AS AN OVERALL 17.82
10:10:35PM DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE CONSISTENT WITH THE DENSITY
10:10:37PM ANTICIPATED UNDER THE R-20 DESIGNATION.
10:10:40PM REQUEST IS CONSISTENT WITH LU 2.12 OF COMPATIBLE INFILL
10:10:45PM DEVELOPMENT IN AN AREA 20 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE.
10:10:48PM THIS SEGMENT OF LINEBAUGH AVENUE CONTAIN AS MIX OF USES
10:10:52PM INCLUDING A PLACE OF RELIGIOUS ASSEMBLY, MULTIFAMILY,
10:10:57PM SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCES AND PARCELS ZONED.
10:11:01PM AND LOCATED JUST TO THE NORTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
10:11:05PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDS THE REQUEST COMPARABLE AND
10:11:08PM COMPATIBLE WITH THE SURROUNDING AREA.
10:11:09PM THE PLAN ENCOURAGES ATTACHED SINGLE-FAMILY USES TO ORIENT TO
10:11:14PM THE FRONT DOORS TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD SIDEWALK AND STREET.
10:11:17PM THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING A SIDEWALK ADJACENT TO NORTH OLA
10:11:21PM AVENUE AND RETAINING THE EXISTING SIDEWALKS ADJACENT OF THE
10:11:25PM SITE OF WEST LINEBAUGH OF MOBILITY POLICIES DUE TO THE
10:11:29PM EXISTING EIGHT-FOOT PUBLIC DRAINAGE EASEMENT ALONG THE WEST
10:11:34PM LINEBAUGH.
10:11:35PM AND APPLICANT UNDER THE PRIMARY ENTRANCES TO UNITS 6-9 ALONG
10:11:40PM LINEBAUGH AVENUE.
10:11:41PM APPLICANT HAS PROVIDED INTERNAL PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIONS THAT
10:11:46PM CONNECT THE ENTRANCES TO THE PUBLIC RIGHTS-OF-WAY.
10:11:50PM MEETS 9.2.6 BY CONNECTING THE UNIT ENTRANCES TO A
10:11:54PM NEIGHBORHOOD SIDEWALK AND STREET.
10:11:56PM AND IN CONCLUSION, THE PROPOSED REZONING SUPPORTS MAIN OF
10:12:00PM THE POLICIES IN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN OF HOUSING THE CITY'S
10:12:02PM POPULATION.
10:12:03PM THE REQUEST IS COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH THE
10:12:05PM SURROUNDING A AREA AND CONSISTENT WITH THE LONG-RANGE
10:12:09PM DEVELOPMENT PATTERN.
10:12:10PM BASE AND ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, ITS PLANNING COMMISSION
10:12:14PM STAFF FINDS IT CONSISTENT WITH THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
10:12:17PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
10:12:19PM AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
10:12:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
10:12:27PM >> SAM THOMAS, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:12:30PM I WON'T GO OVER THE AERIAL MAP TOO MUCH DETAIL.
10:12:33PM DANNY COVERED IT PERFECTLY.
10:12:35PM THE SUBJECT OUTLINED IN RED HERE.
10:12:37PM OVERALL THE SURROUNDING A AREA IS ZONED INVESTIGATION
10:12:41PM SINGLE-FAMILY 60.
10:12:41PM WE HAVE A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT JUST TO THE WEST OF THE
10:12:45PM SUBJECT SITE HERE AND HERE.
10:12:46PM THIS WAS APPROVED IN 2022 UNDER REZ-22-117 THAT ALLOW FOR A
10:12:53PM MEDICAL OFFICE AND MULTIFAMILY USES HERE.
10:12:56PM THE PD APPROVED ON THE SCHOOL IT TO THE WEST IS APPROVED
10:13:00PM 2021 IN REZ-21-78 OF SEMI-ATTACHED USES AND SEMI DETACHED.
10:13:08PM DETACHED AND SEMI-DETACHED USES.
10:13:11PM SEE HERE, AS YOU MOVE NORTH OF THE SITE A PUBLIC POOL, DANNY
10:13:16PM DEL RIO POOL AND ELEMENTARY AND MIDDLE SCHOOL FURTHER TO THE
10:13:20PM NORTH.
10:13:20PM A CHURCH USE.
10:13:21PM MULTIFAMILY AND ANOTHER CHURCH USE HERE.
10:13:23PM THIS PD WAS APPROVED ORIGINALLY FOR EIGHT UNITS.
10:13:28PM HERE IS THE SITE PLAN PROVIDED BY THE APPLICANT.
10:13:36PM LET'S SEE HERE.
10:13:39PM THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING 18 UNITS WITHIN NINE BUILDINGS.
10:13:44PM ALL THE UNITS ARE ORIENTED INTERNALLY AS DANNY MENTIONED DUE
10:13:50PM TO THIS DRAINAGE EASEMENT.
10:13:52PM AND SIDEWALKS RUN ALONG HERE AND HERE WITH CONNECTIONS
10:13:56PM COMING DOWN ALONG THERE AND A SIDEWALK ALONG LYNN TO COME
10:13:59PM DOWN TO WEST LINEBAUGH AVENUE.
10:14:01PM VEHICULAR ACCESS IS PROVIDED FROM LINEBAUGH AND NORTH LYNN
10:14:07PM AVENUE.
10:14:07PM 36 SPARKING SPACES ARE REQUIRED AND 41 SPACES ARE PROVIDED.
10:14:11PM GUEST PARKING HERE, HERE AND HERE.
10:14:13PM PROPOSED HEIGHT IS 35 FEET FOR THREE STORIES.
10:14:17PM I WILL SHOW YOU SOME PICTURES THE SUBJECT SITE NOW.
10:14:20PM THE SUBJECT SITE IN THE AREA AND ELEVATIONS.
10:14:23PM SO THIS THE ELEVATIONS FOR THE PORTION OF THE SUBJECT SITE
10:14:29PM THAT IS TO THE SOUTH CLOSEST TO LINEBAUGH.
10:14:32PM AND THESE ARE YOUR ELEVATIONS FOR THE NORTHERN HALF FARTHER
10:14:40PM AWAY FROM LINEBAUGH AVENUE AND THEY ARE A LITTLE DIFFICULT
10:14:43PM TO SEE, I AM SORRY.
10:14:44PM WE WILL GO INTO PICTURES.
10:14:52PM LOOKING WEST TO THE SITE.
10:14:55PM THIS IS ON LYNN AVENUE.
10:14:56PM THIS IS LOOKING NORTH ON LYNN AVENUE.
10:15:00PM THIS IS THE CHURCH HERE.
10:15:02PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE AS YOU MOVE FARTHER NORTH.
10:15:05PM YOU HAVE THE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED USES LOOK CAN EAST.
10:15:11PM WEST LYNN.
10:15:12PM CHURCH, WEST LINEBAUGH.
10:15:14PM THE SUBJECT SITE HERE.
10:15:15PM THIS IS LOOKING NORTH.
10:15:17PM THIS IS LINEBAUGH.
10:15:18PM SO HERE IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
10:15:21PM LYNN AVENUE RIGHT HERE LOOKING SOUTH ACROSS THE STREET FROM
10:15:27PM THE SUBJECT SITE.
10:15:28PM THIS IS LINEBAUGH.
10:15:29PM LOOKING EAST ALONG LINEBAUGH, THE CHURCH IN THE FOREGROUND.
10:15:36PM LOOKING WEST ON THE OPPOSITE SIGN OF LINEBAUGH AVENUE.
10:15:44PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE WHERE THE MULTIFAMILY WAS APPROVED
10:15:48PM NEXT TO IT.
10:15:48PM AND YOU CAN SEE -- YOU CAN SEE THAT MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT
10:15:51PM IN THE FOREGROUND THERE.
10:15:53PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTHWEST ALONG LINEBAUGH FOR A BETTER VIEW
10:15:57PM OF THE MULTI FAMILY DOWN THE STREET I WILL PUT THE SITE PLAN
10:16:07PM BACK UP REAL QUICK DEVELOPMENT REVIEW AND COMPLIANCE STAFF
10:16:19PM REVIEWED THE APPLICATION AND FIND IT CONSISTENT WITH THE
10:16:22PM APPLICABLE CITY OF TAMPA REGULATIONS.
10:16:24PM SHOULD IT BE FOR COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE REPORT, FURTHER
10:16:30PM MODIFICATION OF THE SITE PLAN MUST BE COMPLETED BETWEEN
10:16:32PM FIRST AND SECOND READING AS STATED IN THE REVISION SHEET.
10:16:35PM I AM AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
10:16:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
10:16:39PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:16:39PM MR. PRESSMAN.
10:16:40PM >> MR. CHAIRMAN, COUNCILMEMBERS, TODD PRESSMAN.
10:16:49PM ST. PETERSBURG.
10:16:51PM I'M HERE THIS EVENING WITH MICHAEL LEAKS AND CHARLIE THOMAS.
10:16:56PM THEY HAVE BEEN VERY BUSY AND A LOT OF A AREAS IN THE CITY OF
10:17:00PM TAMPA PROVIDING A VERY UNIQUE AND WONDERFUL HOUSING
10:17:05PM PROJECTS.
10:17:05PM THIS IS ONE OF THEM.
10:17:06PM WHICH REALLY IS A PORTION THAT IS REFERRED TO AS A MISSING
10:17:12PM MIDDLE IN WORKFORCE HOUSING WHICH IS WHAT THIS PROJECT WOULD
10:17:15PM BE.
10:17:15PM THIS PROJECT IS REALLY ABOUT EXPANDING PRIOR APPROVAL
10:17:18PM ALREADY.
10:17:19PM IF WE CAN GO TO A SHORT POWERPOINT PLEASE.
10:17:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, WE HAVE IT UP.
10:17:24PM THERE YOU GO.
10:17:25PM >> ISSUE FROM RS-50 TO PD.
10:17:29PM AND IT HAS BEEN APPROVED AND THEY ARE EXPANDING THE PROJECT
10:17:32PM TO THE EAST TO 18 SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED UNITS.
10:17:34PM JUST ABOUT ONE ACRE FOR NINE BUILDINGS, TWO UNITS IN EACH.
10:17:38PM IN THE UNIVERSITY PLANNING DISTRICT.
10:17:40PM EAST FOREST HILLS NEIGHBORHOOD.
10:17:41PM DRC, ZONING STAFF, PLANNING COMMISSION ALL SUPPORT IT.
10:17:46PM NO NEIGHBORHOOD OPPOSITION.
10:17:47PM WE NOTICED 30 PERSONS AND DOCUMENTED SUPPORT FOR YOU.
10:17:51PM AS STAFF HAS WELL POINTED OUT, THE AREA CONTAINS A LOT OF
10:17:56PM MULTIFAMILY INCLUDING NEXT DOOR APPROVAL.
10:17:59PM AND THE SITE THAT WILL MOVE EASTWARD ACROSS THE STREET ARE
10:18:03PM APARTMENTS AND TO THE REAR IS A -- IS A SCHOOL AND CITY
10:18:07PM POOL.
10:18:08PM ACROSS THE STREET ARE APARTMENTS ARE EXISTING AS YOU CAN SEE
10:18:12PM HERE.
10:18:12PM THIS IS A LETTER OF SUPPORT FROM THE CHURCH WHICH IS THE
10:18:15PM EAST I HAVE A JAY SENT OWNER ACROSS LYNN.
10:18:18PM AND THE SECOND LET FROM ANOTHER CITIZEN THAT CAME THROUGH AS
10:18:23PM WELL.
10:18:23PM THERE ARE A COUPLE OF WAIVERS THAT ARE CONNECTED TO THE
10:18:25PM EXPANSION OF THE ALREADY APPROVED SITE.
10:18:27PM THERE IS SOME GREEN AREA AND VEHICULAR USE AREA.
10:18:31PM GREEN OPEN SPACE THAT WILL BE PROVIDED ABOVE AND BEYOND WHAT
10:18:37PM THE CODE REQUIRES.
10:18:37PM YOU HAVE SEEN THE SITE PLAN THAT IS VERY STRAIGHTFORWARD AND
10:18:41PM VERY FUNCTIONAL.
10:18:41PM AND ALSO THE ELEVATION THAT HAS BEEN PROPOSED FOR THE SITE.
10:18:45PM SO WITH THAT, WE APPRECIATE YOUR CONSIDERATION.
10:18:48PM AND WE ARE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE.
10:18:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
10:18:53PM >> WE APPRECIATE YOU SAVING THE BEST REQUEST FOR LAST.
10:18:56PM [LAUGHTER]
10:18:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SIR, IT'S YOU.
10:18:58PM YOU KNOW.
10:18:59PM ANYONE IN THE PUBLIC WISH TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM?
10:19:02PM WE HAVE NOBODY REGISTERED.
10:19:03PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MOTION TO CLOSE.
10:19:07PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SECOND.
10:19:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION AND A SECOND.
10:19:09PM ALL IN FAVOR.
10:19:10PM COUNCILMAN CARLSON, DID YOU READ ONE OF THE LAST ONES.
10:19:14PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA, WOULD YOU MIND READING ONE.
10:19:18PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: ITEM NUMBER 12, FILE NUMBER REZ-24-19,
10:19:24PM CONSIDERATION REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF
10:19:27PM 80 3, 809 BEST LINEBAUGH AVENUE MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED
10:19:32PM IN SECTION 1 FROM ZONING DISTRICT RS-60 RESIDENTIAL
10:19:37PM SINGLE-FAMILY TO PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT TO PD PLANNED
10:19:41PM DEVELOPMENT SINGLE-FAMILY PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
10:19:44PM AND THIS -- THIS SECTION 27-136, DEVELOPMENT HAS SHOWN THAT
10:19:50PM THE SITES PROMOTES ENCOURAGE DEVELOPMENT THAT IS
10:19:53PM COMPATIBILITY WITH THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD AND PROVIDES
10:19:56PM AN APPROPRIATE TRANSITION FOR THE BLOCK OF WEST LINEBAUGH
10:20:00PM AND N. BOULEVARD AND NORTH LYNN AVENUE FROM OFFICE AND
10:20:03PM RESIDENTIAL IN ADDITION TO THE WESTERN PORTION OF THE SITE
10:20:05PM IS CURRENTLY APPROVED FOR RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED
10:20:09PM AND DETACHED USE.
10:20:10PM AND FOR WAIVERS, SECTION NUMBER 27-139-4, DESIGN AND PROPOSE
10:20:17PM DEVELOPMENT EXCEEDS MULTIFAMILY GREEN SPACE REQUIREMENTS
10:20:20PM THAT EXCEEDS THE -- VUA GREEN FACE AND PROVIDES REQUIRED 21
10:20:26PM TREES THAT IN THE MIND WILL HAVE NATURAL RESOURCE WAIVERS
10:20:31PM ARE MINIMAL AND APPROPRIATE.
10:20:32PM REQUESTED WAIVERS ARE SUBSTANTIALLY INTERFERED OR INJURY THE
10:20:36PM RIGHTS OF OTHERS WHOSE PROPERTY WILL BE AFFECTED BY THE
10:20:39PM WAIVERS.
10:20:40PM >>LUIS VIERA: SECOND -- I DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT WAS.
10:20:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA AND A
10:20:52PM MUFFLED SECOND BY COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:20:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
10:20:55PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
10:20:56PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
10:20:58PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
10:21:00PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
10:21:00PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
10:21:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
10:21:04PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
10:21:07PM SECOND READING AND IT ADOPTION MAY 2, 2024 AT 9:30 A.M.
10:21:12PM LOCATED AT OLD CITY MALL, 315 E. KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD
10:21:16PM FLORIDA, TAMPA, BOULEVARD, 33602.
10:21:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THAT CONCLUDES OUR AGENDA.
10:21:21PM GO TO NEW BUSINESS.
10:21:22PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YOU DON'T WANT TO HANG OUT WITH US?
10:21:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CHAIR PRO TEM RECOGNIZES CHAIR MANISCALCO.
10:21:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:21:38PM I WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT A MOTION TO HAVE AN COMMENDATION FOR
10:21:43PM DAVID YANOS WHO ASSISTED A DISTRAUGHT MOTHER FINDING HER
10:21:48PM LOST CHILD SHOWING HOW THE CITY OF TAMPA TEAM IS COMMITTED
10:21:53PM TO PUBLIC SERVICE.
10:21:53PM I WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT IN AT OUR REGULAR MEETING ON MAY 2.
10:21:57PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: A MOTION FROM CHAIR MANISCALCO AND A
10:21:59PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:22:00PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE, AYE.
10:22:02PM OPPOSED EYES HAVE IT.
10:22:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A HAPPY EARLY BIRTHDAY TO ANY DAD.
10:22:10PM HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU
10:22:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THAT'S IT.
10:22:15PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:22:17PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: FIRE RESCUE TIFFANY AND HER HARD-WORKING
10:22:21PM TEAM FOR SUPPORT OF FRONT LINE OF PUBLIC SAFETY PERSONNEL
10:22:25PM DURING THIS OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH NURSE WEEK AND POSSIBLY WHEN
10:22:28PM I GET THE NAMES OF ALL -- THE COMBINATION TO BE DELIVERED
10:22:31PM ON-SITE.
10:22:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE WE HAVE A MOTION FROM
10:22:35PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:22:36PM AND SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
10:22:38PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:22:39PM ANY OPPOSED?
10:22:40PM NO?
10:22:41PM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:22:42PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES, SIR, COUPLE VERY QUICK IF I MAY.
10:22:44PM I HAVE MENTION ON APRIL 18 TO LIGHTEN THE AGENDA MOVING THE
10:22:50PM PRESENTATION ON THE PUBLIC SAFETY MASTER PLAN.
10:22:53PM HAVE THE CONTENT OF TFR AND TPD.
10:22:58PM MOTIONED FOR MAY 16.
10:22:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:23:01PM A SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
10:23:03PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:23:03PM OPPOSED?
10:23:05PM >>LUIS VIERA: I ALSO MOTIONED -- REQUESTED BY CHIEF BERCAW
10:23:09PM TO MOVE ITEM NUMBER 4503 SET FOR THE APRIL 18 MEETING TO BE
10:23:14PM PULLED FROM THE PUBLIC SAFETY CONSENT AGENDA IT STAFF
10:23:20PM REPORTS AGREEMENTS OF COMMUNITY AND THE CHIEF WOULD LIKE A
10:23:29PM CHANCE TO DISCUSS THE AGREEMENT AND THE IMPACT ON THE
10:23:31PM COMMUNITY AND REFERENCE TOWARD GUN VIOLENCE FOR PREVENTION
10:23:35PM PARTICULARLY IN LIGHT OF RECENT EVENTS.
10:23:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:23:39PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:23:41PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:23:42PM OPPOSED?
10:23:44PM >>LUIS VIERA: MR. ERIC PONZI AS YOU KNOW A 30-YEAR TAMPA
10:23:49PM FIRE FIGHTER.
10:23:50PM HE IS RETIRING AND TODAY IS THE DAY HE DID 30 YEARS.
10:23:52PM 30 YEARS AGO TAMPA CITY COUNCIL COMMENDATION.
10:23:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:24:00PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:24:02PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:24:03PM OPPOSED.
10:24:04PM >>LUIS VIERA: A WORKSHOP ON SULPHUR SPRINGS IN JUNE OF 2024.
10:24:09PM THE AGENDA IS OKAY.
10:24:10PM IF WE NEED MORE TIME WE CAN MOVE TO JULY AND AUGUST.
10:24:15PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
10:24:16PM >>LYNN HURTAK: DATE?
10:24:19PM >>LUIS VIERA: JUNE WORKSHOP.
10:24:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: 27th OF JUNE.
10:24:26PM ALL RIGHT.
10:24:28PM WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
10:24:30PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:24:30PM OPPOSED?
10:24:33PM >>LUIS VIERA: HAPPY BIRTHDAY ETHEL KENNEDY.
10:24:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
10:24:39PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: RE, WHY I HAVE THREE THINGS.
10:24:42PM I MOVE THAT CITY STAFF COME BEFORE US ON MAY 23 TO REPORT ON
10:24:46PM TAMPA'S URBAN TREE CANOPY AND THE HEAT PROJECTS PLAN WITH
10:24:51PM EMPHASIS IN EAST TAMPA.
10:24:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
10:24:55PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:24:56PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:24:57PM OPPOSE?
10:24:58PM YES, MA'AM.
10:24:58PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THANK YOU, CHAIR.
10:25:00PM I ALSO MOVE THAT EVERY ORGANIZATION FUNDED WITH SOCIAL
10:25:05PM ACTION FUNDS BE PROVIDED WITH ADVANCED NOTIFICATION THAT
10:25:08PM FUNDING IS TO END ON AN ANNUAL BASIS AND PLACE THAT IN
10:25:13PM WRITING TO ALL OF THE PEOPLE WHO RECEIVE THOSE FUNDS BECAUSE
10:25:16PM THEY ARE SUBJECT TO APPROVAL BY CITY COUNCIL'S BUDGET
10:25:19PM ADOPTION ON AN ANNUAL BASIS.
10:25:20PM ALSO, I WANT FOR US TO -- FOR STAFF TO PROVIDE A
10:25:26PM COMPREHENSIVE REPORT TO OUR NEW BUDGET ANALYST WHO WAS HIRED
10:25:31PM RECENTLY AND OUTLINE WHO HAS AGREEMENTS, WHO DOESN'T HAVE
10:25:35PM AGREEMENTS, WHO IS IN COMPLIANCE WITH THOSE AGREEMENTS, AND
10:25:39PM THE NUMBER OF YEARS EACH ORGANIZATION HAS RECEIVED FUNDING
10:25:42PM FROM US.
10:25:44PM AND I WOULD LIKE THIS BY THE END OF MAY.
10:25:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THAT WOULD BE --
10:25:51PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: JUNE 1.
10:25:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: JUNE 6.
10:25:55PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THAT IS THE STAFF MEETING BUT I WANT OUR
10:25:57PM BUDGET ANALYST GET IT AND LET HER HAVE THE TIME TO DECIDE --
10:26:01PM >>LYNN HURTAK: SHE IS NOT START FOR ANOTHER THREE WEEKS.
10:26:03PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: RIGHT SO JUNE 1, THEY CAN HAVE IT DONE --
10:26:09PM STAFF HAS -- YES, STAFF HAS TO HAVE IT DONE FOR HER AND WE
10:26:12PM CAN DECIDE HOW LONG SHE WILL NEED AT A LATER DATE.
10:26:16PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN WE DIVIDE -- THE FIRST ONE NEEDS TO BE
10:26:20PM AGENDA.
10:26:20PM I DON'T THINK THAT IS AN ITEM WITHOUT PUBLIC COMMENT.
10:26:23PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: NOT TRUE, UP TO US BECAUSE THE BUDGET
10:26:26PM ACTUALLY -- EACH FISCAL YEAR, WE DECIDE -- WE APPROVE A
10:26:31PM BUDGET.
10:26:31PM AND THE SOCIAL ACTION FUNDS ARE ON AN ANNUAL BASIS.
10:26:35PM THAT BUDGET IS PROVIDED ON AN ANNUAL BASIS.
10:26:40PM JUST A LETTER TO THOSE FOLKS FROM CITY STAFF INDICATING --
10:26:44PM THEY NEED TO BE AWARE --
10:26:45PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: A RESTATEMENT OF POLICY.
10:26:48PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: RESTATEMENT OF POLICY.
10:26:49PM I GET THE IMPRESSION THAT ORGANIZATIONS JUST CONTINUE TO
10:26:54PM EXPECT TO RECEIVE THIS MONEY YEAR AFTER YEAR.
10:26:55PM AND, YOU KNOW, IT IS JUST BEEN STANDARD -- STANDARD ACTION.
10:27:00PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I UNDERSTAND STAND WHERE YOU ARE GOING.
10:27:02PM IF YOU ARE TRYING TO INTRODUCE SOMETHING DIFFERENT TAMPA.
10:27:06PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: NOT SOMETHING DIFFERENT AND GET
10:27:09PM NOTIFICATION BECAUSE I DON'T WANT ANYONE TO ASSUME TO GET
10:27:13PM MONEY.
10:27:13PM EVEN IF WE AFFORD THEM TO GET MONEY.
10:27:17PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WOULD STILL SUGGEST THAT WE DO TWO
10:27:21PM DIFFERENT THINGS.
10:27:22PM >>BILL CARLSON: I THINK THAT IS A GREAT IDEA.
10:27:23PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THANK YOU.
10:27:25PM >>BILL CARLSON: BECAUSE -- ANYWAY --
10:27:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. SHELBY.
10:27:29PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: A REQUEST OF THE ADMINISTRATION TO PROVIDE
10:27:31PM A WRITTEN REPORT, IS THAT WHAT YOU ARE ASKING?
10:27:34PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THE WRITTEN REPORT IS WILL BE FOR OUR
10:27:37PM BUDGET ANALYST TO SHARE WITH US.
10:27:39PM >>LYNN HURTAK: BUT I WANT TO SEE IT TOO.
10:27:41PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: TO SHARE WITH US.
10:27:42PM SHE IS NEW.
10:27:43PM SHE DOESN'T NEED TO STAND BEFORE THE PUBLIC FIRST.
10:27:46PM SHE CAN PROVIDE THAT INFORMATION TO US BECAUSE WE WILL BE
10:27:50PM TALKING TO HER AS A NEW BUDGET ANALYST FOR US.
10:27:53PM SO I DON'T THINK IT IS NECESSARY FOR HER TO BE PUBLIC
10:27:57PM RIGHT-OF-WAY WITH SOME OF THE TASKS THAT WE ASK HER TO DO.
10:27:59PM WE ARE LOOKING INTO THINGS.
10:28:00PM WE ARE DIVING INTO BUDGET THINGS.
10:28:03PM SO, YOU KNOW --
10:28:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE CAN BE BRIEFED.
10:28:06PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: WE CAN BE BRIEFED AND THEN DECIDE --
10:28:09PM EXACTLY --
10:28:11PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: A WRITTEN REPORT BY JUNE 1.
10:28:13PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: FROM STAFF TO HAVE IT COMPLETED.
10:28:16PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YES.
10:28:17PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: PROVIDE IT TO OUR BUDGET ANALYST.
10:28:19PM >>LYNN HURTAK: JUNE 6.
10:28:21PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: JUNE 6 IS FINE.
10:28:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: JUNE 1.
10:28:26PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THAT.
10:28:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
10:28:30PM SECOND BY COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
10:28:32PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:28:33PM OPPOSED.
10:28:34PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: NEXT ONE, WE INCREASE THE SALARY STAFF
10:28:38PM CITY COUNCIL TO $73,713 AND NOT BE SUBJECT TO ANY INCREASES
10:28:44PM OF THIS PARTICULAR BUDGET YEARS WHILE WE ARE ON COUNCIL BUT
10:28:47PM FOR THE NEXT ELECTION CYCLE EFFECTIVE MAY 2027.
10:28:52PM >>LUIS VIERA: MAY I ASK A QUESTION -- MAY I, MR. CHAIR.
10:28:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD, MR. CHAIR.
10:28:58PM >>LUIS VIERA: YOU ARE LOOKING TO INCREASE THE SALARY TO THE
10:29:00PM $75,000 RANGE NOT TO TAKE EFFECT UNTIL AFTER THE NEXT
10:29:04PM ELECTION.
10:29:05PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: CORRECT, SOMETHING -- FROM THE
10:29:07PM CONVERSATIONS WE HAD BEFORE BOARD MEMBER CARLSON MADE THAT
10:29:11PM MOTION I SECOND IT BEFORE.
10:29:12PM UNFORTUNATELY IT DID HAVE A -- WHAT YOU CALL THOSE THINGS --
10:29:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: AMENDMENT.
10:29:19PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SO IT FAILED.
10:29:21PM WHAT I WAS HEARING UP HERE, THERE ARE SEVERAL COUNCILMEMBERS
10:29:25PM ARE FOLLOWING DO IT FOR THE NEXT ELECTION CYCLE.
10:29:27PM THAT IS WHAT YOU ALL WERE COMMUNICATING SO I AM THE PERSON
10:29:30PM BOLD ENOUGH TO DO THAT BECAUSE I AM NOT THE POLITICIAN.
10:29:33PM I AM A TEACHER.
10:29:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION.
10:29:35PM DO WE HAVE A SECOND.
10:29:37PM >>LUIS VIERA: SECOND.
10:29:38PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THE DISCUSSION OF IT LAST TIME, I THINK
10:29:45PM THERE WAS SOME DEBATE WHAT THE MEAN AVERAGE WAS.
10:29:47PM AND THERE IS VARIATIONS, AND I AM NOT SPEAKING TO ANYONE
10:29:53PM CORRECTLY BUT $7,000.
10:29:55PM I HAD -- CAME OUT -- AND TAMPA BAY TIMES AND THEY SAID IT
10:30:00PM WAS -- THEY HAD A SCALE OF MAYBE 10 CITIES AND SO FORTH.
10:30:06PM I THINK IT WAS $68,700 AND SOMETHING.
10:30:10PM I AM NOT GOING TO VOTE FOR A RAISE THAT BIG.
10:30:13PM I DON'T THINK PRIVATE ENTERPRISE WILL GET A RAISE OF $40,000
10:30:16PM OR WHATEVER IT IS.
10:30:17PM FROM 56 OR WHATEVER IT IS NOW.
10:30:20PM 18 ,000 OR WHATEVER IT IS.
10:30:22PM I DON'T THINK WE GET ANY RAISE LIKE THAT IN ANY PRY HAVE A
10:30:28PM INDUSTRY --
10:30:29PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THIS IS NOT A RAISE, MR. MIRANDA.
10:30:31PM A NEW ELECTION CYCLE TO BRING IT IN LINE WITH A COMPARABLE
10:30:35PM WAGE FOR SOMEONE WHO TAKES ON THIS JOB WHO WE UNDERSTAND HOW
10:30:40PM MUCH TIME IT TAKES, YOU KNOW.
10:30:41PM WE DON'T NEED TO GET INTO THE DEBATE OF THAT AGAINST.
10:30:44PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I AM NOT DEBATING.
10:30:46PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I UNDERSTAND.
10:30:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK AND THEN CARLSON.
10:30:52PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I WILL SUPPORT IT IF IT INCLUDED A ROBUST --
10:30:56PM I MEAN, MAYBE I WILL JUST LEAVE IT TO COUNCILMAN CARLSON,
10:31:00PM BECAUSE THE IDEA OF KEEPING UP WITH COST OF LIVING INCREASE
10:31:05PM SO IT WILL NOT BE $75,000 BY THEN.
10:31:08PM SO I WOULDN'T APPROVE -- I WOULDN'T VOTE FOR IT UNLESS IT
10:31:12PM HAD THOSE THING ALREADY BELT IN.
10:31:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU MEAN COST OF LIVING ADJUSTMENT.
10:31:18PM >>LYNN HURTAK: COST OF LIVING, READJUSTING.
10:31:20PM I WOULDN'T VOTE FOR A NUMBER.
10:31:21PM I WOULD VOTE TO ADJUSTING TO VOTES FOR SOMETHING FOR THE
10:31:24PM NEXT COUNCIL THAT IS BASED ON A STUDY DONE AT THAT TIME TO
10:31:29PM LOOK AT OTHER MUNICIPALITIES, TO LOOK AT THE COST OF LIVING
10:31:32PM INCREASE, AND BUILD IT IN SO THAT WE DON'T -- SO THAT FUTURE
10:31:37PM COUNCILS DON'T HAVE TO ARGUE ABOUT THIS.
10:31:39PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: IG MAKE THAT ADJUSTMENT TO IT BECAUSE
10:31:43PM THERE ARE STUDIES DONE ON THAT.
10:31:45PM AND THAT NUMBER CAN BE DETERMINED BY A NEUTRAL PARTY AND
10:31:49PM PRESENTED WHATEVER IT IS.
10:31:50PM IT COULD FALL WITHIN A RANGE SIMILAR TO THIS.
10:31:53PM UP DON'T HAVE TO TIE IN NECESSARILY A FIGURE BUT BASED ON A
10:31:59PM STUDY THAT WAS PRESENTED BY THE CHIEF OF STAFF.
10:32:01PM YOU KNOW, WE CAN TAKE A LOOK AT THE STUDY AND WHAT IS TAKING
10:32:06PM INTO CONSIDERATION.
10:32:07PM YOU KNOW I AM DEFINITELY OPEN TO THAT.
10:32:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
10:32:11PM >>BILL CARLSON: I -- SIMILAR TO WHAT COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN
10:32:16PM SAID, I THINK THIS ONE IS SUFFICIENT ENOUGH THAT IT SHOULD
10:32:19PM BE SCHEDULED IN PUBLICLY NOTICED.
10:32:22PM WE HAD THE DISCUSSION BEFORE AND RAN OUT OF TIME.
10:32:25PM I THINK THE -- BIG THINGS -- TO US -- AND IN REALITY, IT IS
10:32:29PM NOT A BIG THING, BUT I -- JUST SO THE PUBLIC DOESN'T THINK
10:32:34PM WE ARE TRYING TO PULL A FAST ONE.
10:32:36PM I WOULD IN FAVOR OF SCHEDULING IT.
10:32:39PM IF THE VOTE IS TONIGHT, I WOULD HAVE TO VOTE NO.
10:32:41PM I DON'T THINK IT HAS TO BE A FORMULA.
10:32:44PM NO CITY COUNCIL IN THE FUTURE SHOULD HAVE TO VOTE ON THEIR
10:32:47PM SALARY.
10:32:47PM I SUGGESTED A PERCENTAGE OF WHAT THE MAY EARNS.
10:32:51PM SOUNDED LIKE YOU DIDN'T LIKE THAT.
10:32:53PM NO FURTHER CITY COUNCIL SHOULD VOTE ON A RAISE FOR
10:32:56PM THEMSELVES.
10:32:56PM COST OF LIVING MAY NOT BE ENOUGH IF INFLATION IS 10%.
10:33:00PM AND WHATEVER FORM -- AND MY BRAIN IS NOT WORKING -- COULD BE
10:33:05PM THAT THE FORMULAS DON'T MATCH UP.
10:33:07PM I THINK WE SHOULD ARGUE IN A PUBLICLY NOTICED DISCUSSION.
10:33:13PM THE NUMBER RIGHT NOW IS ARTIFICIALLY KNOW.
10:33:20PM I WON'T BE ON CITY COUNCIL FOR THREE YEARS.
10:33:23PM BUT -- BUT ANYWAY, IT -- I THINK THE PAY FOR CITY COUNCIL IS
10:33:31PM ARTIFICIALLY LOW.
10:33:32PM SO THERE IS A JUSTIFICATION FOR A ONE-TIME JUMP AND
10:33:36PM FROM THERE IT SHOULD BE BASED ON SOME KIND OF FORMULA.
10:33:39PM I HOPE THAT YOU CHANGE IT TO A SCHEDULED THING AND WE WILL
10:33:42PM DISCUSS IT AND APPROVE SOMETHING.
10:33:43PM NO CITY COUNCIL SHOULD HAVE TO VOTE ON ITSELF AGAIN.
10:33:47PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I APPRECIATE THOSE COMMENTS.
10:33:48PM I AM OPEN OF DOING THAT AND SOMEBODY HAS TO HAVE THE COURAGE
10:33:52PM TO ADDRESS IT.
10:33:54PM IT FAILED TWO WEEKS AGO AND WE CAN'T JUST LET IT DIE AND NOT
10:33:57PM DO ANYTHING ABOUT IT.
10:33:59PM SIMILAR TO REUSE 568.
10:34:02PM WE HAVE TO TACKLE THIS I THINK SO THAT ARE HARD AND THIS IS
10:34:04PM JUST ONE OF THEM AND FIND SOMETHING THAT WILL BE AMENABLE TO
10:34:08PM -- WHERE IT IS PASSABLE.
10:34:10PM YEAH, I CAN TAKE IT OFF THE TABLE.
10:34:12PM AT LEAST WE HAD THE DISCUSSION AGAIN TODAY.
10:34:14PM >>BILL CARLSON: CAN YOU SCHEDULE --
10:34:16PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I NEVER SCHEDULED THINGS LIKE THAT
10:34:18PM BEFORE.
10:34:18PM LET'S SEE --
10:34:20PM >>BILL CARLSON: SCHEDULE FOR THAT WORKSHOP.
10:34:22PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN I SPEAK BEFORE WE DO THIS.
10:34:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN AND --
10:34:27PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: LET ME SPEAK FIRST BEFORE YOU DO THAT.
10:34:32PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SURE.
10:34:33PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: A COUPLE OF THINGS TO NOTE.
10:34:35PM I AM GLAD YOU SAID COURAGE -- LOOKING MYSELF IN THE MIRROR,
10:34:41PM I AM LOOKING DISHEVELLED.
10:34:43PM THAT IS MY POINT.
10:34:46PM I SUPPORT THE SALARY INCREASE, BUT TO HAVE THE COURAGE
10:34:50PM SAYING WHAT IS THAT POSITION WORTH.
10:34:52PM AND IF IT IS WORTH THAT, WE SHOULD HAVE THE COURAGE TO STAND
10:34:56PM UP AND SAYS IT WORTH IT.
10:34:57PM KICK IT DOWN THE STREET IS IT KIND OF COWARDLY IS MY OWN
10:35:01PM PERSONAL OPINION.
10:35:02PM LIKE YOU SAID, WE HAVE TO HAVE THE COURAGE TO DO THE RIGHT
10:35:07PM THING.
10:35:07PM WHAT IS THE RIGHT THING?
10:35:08PM WE HAVE TO HAVE THE COURAGE TO DO THE RIGHT THING AND
10:35:12PM EVERYTHING DECISION.
10:35:13PM NOT ABOUT KICKING IT DOWN THE STREET.
10:35:15PM A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN POLICY AND POLITICS.
10:35:17PM BY THE WAY LOOK IN THE MIRROR, YOU ARE A POLITICIAN.
10:35:21PM THAT IS -- YOU ARE -- BY DEFINITION, YOU ARE A POLITICIAN.
10:35:25PM HOLD ON ONE SECOND.
10:35:27PM WE ALSO HAVE -- IF WE ARE GOING TO PURSUE THAT AGENDA.
10:35:29PM IF WE ARE NOT GOING TO HAVE THE COURAGE TO SAY THIS IS WHAT
10:35:33PM THE JOB DESCRIPTION IS, THIS IS THE TIME IT ENTAILS.
10:35:38PM THIS STATES COMPARATIVE SALARY AND WHAT IT IS WORTH TODAY.
10:35:41PM IF WE DON'T HAVE THE COURAGE TO DO THAT, WE HAVE THREE
10:35:44PM YEARS.
10:35:45PM LET'S DO IT RIGHT.
10:35:46PM GET AN ANALYSIS DONE.
10:35:48PM LET'S -- LET'S BANTER THIS ABOUT.
10:35:52PM I DON'T THINK THIS NEEDS TO BE RUSHED.
10:35:54PM THREE YEARS TO DO IT.
10:35:56PM TAKE OUR TIME AND DO IT RIGHT.
10:35:57PM WE DON'T HAVE TO RUSH THIS.
10:35:59PM MAKE HIRE THAT WE FOLLOW THE PROCESS THE WAY IT SHOULD BE
10:36:01PM DONE, THE WAY ANY PRIVATE BUSINESS WILL DO, THE QUAY ANY
10:36:06PM GOVERNMENT AGENCY WILL DO.
10:36:07PM WOULD YOU NOT JUST -- YOU KNOW -- YOU WOULD STUDY IT.
10:36:11PM YOU WOULD GET THOSE EXTRA I HAVE IT DATA AND BRING THAT
10:36:14PM FORWARD.
10:36:14PM AND YOU KNOW WHAT, THE FACTS WILL SPEAK FOR THEMSELVES.
10:36:17PM THE FACTS WILL SPEAK FOR THEMSELVES.
10:36:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:36:24PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I WAS JUST GOING TO SAY -- SEEMS LIKE ONLY
10:36:28PM FOUR OF US TO MAKE THE DECISION BECAUSE THREE PEOPLE MADE IT
10:36:32PM VERY CLEAR THEY DON'T WANT RAISES.
10:36:34PM IF THE FOUR OF US CAN CONTINUE TO WORK ON IT, WE WILL FIND
10:36:37PM SPACE.
10:36:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN VIERA.
10:36:39PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES -- YEAH, NO.
10:36:45PM I WAS GOING TO SAY, I WANT TO PUSH BACK ON SOMETHING WHICH
10:36:48PM IS A POLICY DISAGREEMENT IS NOT PLAYING POLITICS.
10:36:53PM IT IS NOT BEING COWARDLY, IT IS A DIFFERENCE OF OPINION.
10:36:57PM I AM OF THE OPINION AND I SAID THIS AND HAVE BEEN CONSISTENT
10:37:01PM WIN THIS CAME UP, IF WE VOTE ON A SALARY INCREASE IT
10:37:05PM SHOULDN'T TAKE PLACE UNTIL AFTER AN ELECTION.
10:37:07PM AND I DO SUPPORT THAT.
10:37:10PM I MOTIONED OF SOMETHING THAT COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON IS
10:37:13PM TRYING TWO WEEKS OR A WEEK AGO WHENEVER WE HAD THAT.
10:37:16PM AND I DO BELIEVE THAT THE CITY COUNCIL, THIS POSITION SHOULD
10:37:19PM GET PAID MORE, BUT I THINK WE SHOULD FIRST HAVE AN ELECTION
10:37:24PM BEFORE THIS TAKES PLACE.
10:37:25PM MY OPINION.
10:37:26PM AGAIN THAT IS A POLICY DISAGREEMENT, NOT ANYTHING ELSE.
10:37:30PM AGAIN, I WILL SUPPORT THAT IF IT COMES BACK IN THAT FORM,
10:37:34PM BUT SOMETHING ELSE AGAIN, I WON'T.
10:37:35PM BUT COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK, RIGHT, FOUR VOTES FOR THE OTHER
10:37:38PM ONE.
10:37:38PM GUESS WHAT THAT IS IT FINE.
10:37:40PM ALL YOU NEED IS FOUR VOTES.
10:37:42PM AS SOMEONE ONCE FAMOUSLY SAID.
10:37:46PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:37:48PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: IF YOU LOOK AT THE TAPES I SAID I WILL
10:37:53PM NOT GIVE A $20,000 RAISE.
10:37:54PM I AM NOT OPPOSED TO RAISES.
10:37:56PM I AM OPPOSED TOED AMOUNT OF THAT RAISE THAT WAS DISCUSSED
10:38:01PM AND I SAID 4% OF GENERAL EMPLOYEES IS FINE WITH ME.
10:38:06PM IT IS NOT ABOUT THE RAISE OF THAT.
10:38:08PM IT IS ABOUT WHAT THEY GAVE US IN THE BEGINNING, THEY HAD
10:38:12PM ORLANDO, THEY HAD MIAMI, THEY HAD FT. LAUDERDALE AND ST.
10:38:17PM PETERSBURG.
10:38:17PM IN THAT AREA THERE, THAT SALARY WAS NEVER OVER $620,000.
10:38:23PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HYPOTHETICALLY, IF THE DATA CAME BACK AND
10:38:26PM JUSTIFIED IT, WOULD YOU CHANGE THAT OPINION?
10:38:29PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: BUT IT IS NOT COMING BACK.
10:38:30PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HYPOTHETICALLY.
10:38:32PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I AM NOT OPPOSED SOMETHING THAT IS BASED
10:38:35PM ON THE -- ON THE SAME PEOPLE.
10:38:37PM DIFFERENT CITIES THAT ARE DOING THE SAME JOB.
10:38:40PM AND THAT IS WHAT IT IS ALL ABOUT.
10:38:42PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THAT'S WHY I AM ASKING STAFF.
10:38:45PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: IF YOU ARE A PILOT AND FLY FROM ONE
10:38:47PM AIRLINE AND ANOTHER, YOU MAY HAVE A DISPARITY BUT NOT THAT
10:38:51PM BIG.
10:38:51PM NOT OPPOSED TO ANYTHING LIKE THAT BUT OPPOSED TO MAKING A
10:38:55PM BIG RAISE.
10:38:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ST. PETE CITY COUNCIL IS $64,000 TO
10:39:00PM $65,000.
10:39:01PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I SUGGEST THAT YOU -- THAT YOU -- EITHER PUT
10:39:03PM IT ON THE WORKSHOP.
10:39:07PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: MAY 23.
10:39:09PM >>LYNN HURTAK: BETWEEN NOW AND THEN MAYBE SOLIDIFY WHAT WE
10:39:12PM ACTUALLY WANT TO TALK ABOUT AND THEN BRING IT BACK AS AN
10:39:16PM AMENDMENT WHEN YOU ARE READY, BUT LET'S SET THE DATE.
10:39:19PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I AGREE.
10:39:20PM LET'S SCHEDULE IT FOR MAY 23 WORKSHOP.
10:39:24PM >>CLERK: THE DEPUTY CITY CLERK RECOMMENDED JUNE 27 WORKSHOP
10:39:29PM DUE TO THE SCHEDULE FOR MAY 23.
10:39:30PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: IS SHE LISTENING?
10:39:38PM JUNE 23.
10:39:38PM SO YOU CAN -- 27th.
10:39:40PM OKAY.
10:39:41PM JUNE 27.
10:39:42PM SO WE STILL HAVE TO VOTE ON IT.
10:39:44PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SECOND.
10:39:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON FOR
10:39:47PM JUNE 27.
10:39:49PM >>BILL CARLSON: TELL US THE WORDS AGAIN ON THAT.
10:39:51PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: WE ARE GOING TO WORKSHOP.
10:39:55PM MOVE THAT I SET THE WORKSHOP TO DISCUSS THE SALARY INCREASE
10:40:03PM FOR THE JUNE -- JUNE 27 WORKSHOP.
10:40:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
10:40:12PM AND SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
10:40:14PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:40:15PM OPPOSED?
10:40:17PM THIS IS JUST TO PUT IT ON THE WORKSHOP.
10:40:19PM ANYTHING ELSE.
10:40:20PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: JUST THREE THINGS.
10:40:21PM THERE WAS -- OH -- I CAN'T REMEMBER WHAT IT WAS.
10:40:25PM I WANTED TO CONGRATULATE -- I WANTED TO CONGRATULATE -- I
10:40:30PM DON'T WANT TO BE HERE -- I WANT TO CONGRATULATE.
10:40:35PM MAYBE DAWN STALEY, I DON'T KNOW.
10:40:37PM I THINK IT WAS LOCAL.
10:40:38PM SOMETHING GREAT HAPPENED.
10:40:39PM BUT ANYWAY, HAPPY THURSDAY.
10:40:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HAPPY THURSDAY -- HAPPY -- GO AHEAD,
10:40:44PM SIR.
10:40:45PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I HAVE ONE.
10:40:46PM UP REQUEST BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION TO REMOVE TA-CPA 24-03
10:40:51PM FLORIDA MAY 3, 2024 ADOPTION HEARING.
10:40:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
10:40:58PM SECONDED FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:41:00PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:41:01PM OPPOSED?
10:41:02PM ANYTHING ELSE?
10:41:03PM YES, MA'AM, COUNCILWOMAN HURTAK.
10:41:05PM >>LYNN HURTAK: NO.
10:41:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CARLSON?
10:41:08PM >>BILL CARLSON: ONE QUICK -- REMEMBER STEPHANIE POYNOR WAS
10:41:12PM IN HERE THIS MORNING, A MULTIUNIT IS GOING NECK TO HER HOUSE
10:41:18PM AND SHE FOUND OUT ABOUT IT YESTERDAY.
10:41:19PM THE LAW -- THE LIVE LOCAL LAW IS WHAT IT IS, BUT WITHIN WHAT
10:41:25PM WE ARE ALLOWED TO DO IN THE LAW, I THINK WE AT LEAST SHOULD
10:41:28PM BE ABLE TO REQUIRE NOTICE, BUT I WOULD LIKE TO ASK STAFF THE
10:41:32PM QUESTION AND ALSO --
10:41:35PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I THOUGHT WE TALKED ABOUT THIS.
10:41:37PM WE TALKED ABOUT THE FACT THAT WHEN -- YOU HAVE TO NOW NOTICE
10:41:41PM TWICE.
10:41:41PM YOU NOTICE AT THE BEGINNING OF A PROJECT LIKE FOR ALL
10:41:44PM PROJECTS, AND WE BROUGHT LIVE LOCAL UP DURING THAT
10:41:47PM DISCUSSION.
10:41:48PM I AM ALMOST POSITIVE.
10:41:50PM >>BILL CARLSON: APPARENTLY DIDN'T HAPPEN IN THIS CASE.
10:41:53PM IF WE ARE OFFERING BONUS DENSITY AND CITY SUBSIDIES, I DON'T
10:41:58PM THINK IT SHOULD BE AUTOMATIC FOR LIVE LOCAL PROJECTS.
10:42:02PM SO I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO ASK STAFF TO ASK THEM IN
10:42:05PM TO REPORT ON JUNE 20 AS TO CREATING A NOTICE REQUIREMENT FOR
10:42:10PM LIVE LOCAL APPLICATIONS AND TOP LIMIT AND PROHIBIT LIVE
10:42:14PM LOCAL ACCESS TO BONUS DENSITY AND OR CITY SUBSIDIES.
10:42:19PM >>LYNN HURTAK: SECOND.
10:42:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MISS WE WILLS.
10:42:23PM >>CATE WELLS: I WILL WAIT UNTIL JUNE.
10:42:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:42:26PM OPPOSED?
10:42:27PM ANYTHING ELSE.
10:42:28PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE.
10:42:31PM >> YOU GUYS DON'T GET PAID ENOUGH FOR THIS.
10:42:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE.
10:42:36PM DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
10:42:37PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN CARLSON.
10:42:39PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:42:40PM WE ARE ADJOURNED.
10:42:41PM [GAVEL SOUNDING]
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.