TAMPA CITY COUNCIL
THURSDAY, MAY 9, 2024, 5:01 P.M.
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.
5:04:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WELCOME TO OUR CITY COUNCIL EVENING
5:04:34PM MEETING.
5:04:35PM IF WE COULD HAVE ROLL CALL, PLEASE.
5:04:40PM >> CARLSON?
5:04:40PM HURTAK?
5:04:41PM >>LYNN HURTAK: HERE.
5:04:44PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HERE.
5:04:46PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: PRESENT.
5:04:48PM >> VIERA?
5:04:48PM MIRANDA?
5:04:50PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HERE.
5:04:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
5:04:52PM >>THE CLERK: WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
5:04:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:04:55PM I HAVE A MEMO FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON'S OFFICE.
5:04:58PM HE WILL NOT BE ABLE TO ATTEND THIS EVENING'S MEETING.
5:05:01PM WANT TO PUT THAT IN THE RECORD.
5:05:03PM MS. DOCK, WE HAVE A VERY, VERY HEAVY AGENDA, IF YOU WANT TO
5:05:06PM KICK IT OFF.
5:05:06PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: GOOD EVENING, CHAIRMAN AND COUNCIL.
5:05:09PM YES, WE DO.
5:05:10PM I HAVE ONE ITEM TO CLEAR ON THIS EVENING'S AGENDA.
5:05:13PM THAT IS ITEM NUMBER 5, IF THAT COULD BE REMOVED FROM THE
5:05:15PM AGENDA.
5:05:16PM THIS IS A MISNOTICE.
5:05:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION TO REMOVE ITEM NUMBER 5
5:05:19PM BY COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN AND A SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
5:05:21PM MIRANDA.
5:05:21PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:05:22PM >> AYE.
5:05:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: AYE.
5:05:24PM OKAY.
5:05:24PM MAY I GET A MOTION TO APPROVE THE AGENDA?
5:05:28PM >> SO MOVED.
5:05:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:05:30PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:05:31PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:05:32PM AYE.
5:05:32PM IF I CAN GET A MOTION TO OPEN ALL THE PUBLIC HEARINGS, 1
5:05:37PM THROUGH 4.
5:05:38PM MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:05:39PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:05:41PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:05:41PM AYE.
5:05:42PM THESE ARE ALL QUASI-JUDICIAL.
5:05:45PM I SEE WE HAVE AT LEAST ONE PERSON REGISTERED ONLINE.
5:05:47PM BUT IF YOU ARE GOING TO SPEAK ON ANY OF THE ITEMS TONIGHT,
5:05:50PM 1, 2, 3, OR 4, PLEASE STAND, RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND WE'LL
5:05:54PM SWEAR YOU IN.
5:05:55PM IF YOU'RE GOING TO SPEAK ON ANYTHING.
5:06:00PM >> DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT THE TESTIMONY THAT YOU ARE
5:06:02PM ABOUT TO GIVE IS THE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH?
5:06:04PM >> I DO.
5:06:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
5:06:05PM LET'S START OFF WITH ITEM NUMBER 1.
5:06:07PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU SO MUCH, COUNCIL.
5:06:09PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:06:10PM ITEM NUMBER 1 IS SU2-23-09 FOR THE PROPERTY AT 16001 TAMPA
5:06:17PM PALMS BOULEVARD.
5:06:18PM THIS IS A SPECIAL USE REQUEST.
5:06:21PM THE REQUEST IS FOR A RESTAURANT WITH DRIVE-IN WINDOW.
5:06:24PM THE PROPERTY IS CURRENTLY ZONED CU, WHICH IS COMMUNITY UNIT.
5:06:30PM THIS IS A COUNTY DESIGNATION THAT IS A REMAINDER AFTER
5:06:36PM ANNEXATION.
5:06:37PM SOME OF THE PROPERTIES THAT HAD THIS DESIGNATION OF CU WERE
5:06:41PM NOT REZONED TO A CITY DESIGNATION.
5:06:45PM WHETHER IT'S A COMMERCIAL DESIGNATION OR A PD SITE PLAN
5:06:49PM CONTROL DESIGNATION.
5:06:50PM SO THIS CU IS THE EQUIVALENT OF CG OR COMMERCIAL GENERAL
5:06:55PM USE.
5:06:55PM AND WHILE THE RESTAURANT USE IS AN ALLOWABLE USE, THE
5:06:59PM DRIVE-IN WINDOW IS THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE SPECIAL USE, AND
5:07:02PM THAT'S WHAT IS BEFORE YOU TODAY.
5:07:03PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO PLANNING COMMISSION TO GIVE THEIR
5:07:06PM REPORT AND I'LL COME BACK AND GIVE MY REPORT.
5:07:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:07:08PM YES, SIR.
5:07:12PM >> GOOD AFTERNOON, COUNCIL MEMBERS.
5:07:13PM DAVID HEY WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
5:07:15PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
5:07:16PM WE START IN THE NEW TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT FOR THIS FIRST
5:07:21PM CASE.
5:07:22PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS SITUATED WITHIN AN EXISTING SHOPPING
5:07:26PM PLAZA.
5:07:28PM HERE IS AN AERIAL OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
5:07:30PM THIS IS BRUCE B. DOWNS.
5:07:32PM THEN YOU'VE GOT TAMPA PALMS BOULEVARD RUNNING ON THE WEST
5:07:36PM SIDE.
5:07:37PM AGAIN, IT'S AN EXISTING SHOPPING PLAZA.
5:07:40PM IT IS NOT WITHIN AN EVACUATION ZONE.
5:07:44PM HERE WE HAVE THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
5:07:51PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS SUBURBAN MIX USE 6.
5:07:56PM THIS DESIGNATION ALLOWS FOR THE CONSIDERATION OF A VARIETY
5:07:59PM OF USES, INCLUDING GENERAL COMMERCIAL.
5:08:01PM THE PORTION OF BRUCE B. DOWNS AND TAMPA BAY PALMS BOULEVARD
5:08:05PM ARE CHARACTERIZED BY A MIXTURE OF COMMERCIAL USES AND
5:08:08PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED NEIGHBORHOODS.
5:08:10PM THE APPLICANT IS ASKING FOR A DRIVE-THROUGH.
5:08:14PM THE DRIVE-THROUGH IS ORIENTED TOWARDS THE PUBLIC
5:08:19PM RIGHTS-OF-WAY, AND THERE IS SOME BUFFERING AND SCREENING
5:08:22PM PRESENT ALONG BRUCE B. DOWNS THAT HELPS ENHANCE THE
5:08:27PM STREETSCAPE, WHICH IS HELPING IT MEET LAND USE POLICY 4.3.4.
5:08:31PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
5:08:34PM FINDS THE PROPOSED SPECIAL USE REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH THE
5:08:37PM PROVISIONS OF THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
5:08:39PM THANK YOU.
5:08:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:08:40PM ANY QUESTIONS?
5:08:40PM NO.
5:08:41PM YES, MA'AM.
5:08:43PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU AGAIN, COUNCIL.
5:08:44PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:08:46PM AND THIS PROPERTY REQUEST, AS MENTIONED EARLIER, IS FOR THE
5:08:50PM SPECIAL USE FOR THE DRIVE-IN WINDOW FOR THE RESTAURANT USE.
5:08:54PM SO THIS DEVELOPMENT WOULD CONTAIN 664 SQUARE FEET.
5:08:59PM THIS IS A SCOOTER'S COFFEE.
5:09:01PM I DON'T KNOW IF YOU'VE SEEN ONE OF THOSE, BUT IT'S JUST THE
5:09:04PM STRUCTURE ITSELF.
5:09:04PM THE ONLY CUSTOMERS THAT ENTER -- THERE NO CUSTOMERS THAT
5:09:09PM ENTER THE INSIDE OF THE BUILDING.
5:09:11PM ONLY EMPLOYEES.
5:09:11PM THIS IS A DRIVE-THROUGH SERVICE ONLY THAT IS PROVIDED.
5:09:15PM SO ON THIS LOT, THIS IS AN OUTPARCEL OF THE OVERALL, AND
5:09:19PM I'LL JUST SHOW YOU THE AERIAL MAP, THE ZONING MAP.
5:09:21PM THIS WILL BE AN EASIER DESCRIPTION FOR YOU.
5:09:23PM EASIER TO SEE AND VISUAL.
5:09:26PM SO THIS IS THE SITE WHICH IS OUTLINED IN RED.
5:09:29PM THIS IS BRUCE B. DOWNS, AND THIS IS TAMPA PALMS.
5:09:33PM SO THIS IS THE PUBLIX SHOPPING CENTER, THE STRIP CENTER WITH
5:09:37PM THE COMMERCIAL USES LOCATED.
5:09:38PM THIS IS THE BANK ON THE CORNER.
5:09:40PM SO THIS, THE REQUEST BEFORE YOU IS FOR THIS AREA LOCATED
5:09:43PM HERE APPROXIMATELY.
5:09:44PM THIS WOULD BECOME AN OUTPARCEL.
5:09:48PM THIS IS AN OUTPARCEL OF THE OVERALL PROPERTY.
5:09:50PM YOU CAN SEE THE USES, THE ZONINGS SURROUNDING PROPERTY.
5:09:54PM YOU HAVE THE CU DESIGNATION FURTHER WEST.
5:09:56PM YOU HAVE YOUR PD WITH YOUR RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT THAT'S TO
5:09:59PM THE NORTH AND NORTHEAST.
5:10:01PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY DEVELOPMENT FURTHER NORTHEAST AND
5:10:06PM YOUR CU TO THE EAST ON THE EAST SIDE ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF
5:10:09PM BRUCE B. DOWNS.
5:10:10PM AND THEN YOU HAVE YOUR PD DEVELOPMENT TO THE WEST BECAUSE
5:10:14PM THIS IS THE LOCATION OF THE SITE.
5:10:17PM AND THAT ALLOWS FOR COMMERCIAL PLACE OF RELIGIOUS ASSEMBLY
5:10:22PM USES ON THE SITE.
5:10:23PM VISUALLY, WHEN YOU'RE OUT ON SITE AND YOU LOOK ACROSS TAMPA
5:10:28PM PALMS, YOU SEE THE WATERFALL AND YOU'D HAVE TO REALLY COME
5:10:32PM ON AMBERLY TO SEE THIS USE HERE.
5:10:38PM AND THIS IS THE SITE PLAN SUBMITTED.
5:10:41PM THIS IS THE SITE WITH THE GRAY OUTLINE.
5:10:46PM THIS IS BRUCE B. DOWNS, WHICH IS LOCATED HERE.
5:10:50PM SO VEHICULAR ACCESS TO THE SITE IS NOT FROM BRUCE B. DOWNS.
5:10:54PM YOU CANNOT ACCESS THIS PARCEL AT ALL FROM BRUCE B. DOWNS.
5:10:59PM THIS IS THE VEHICULAR ENTRANCE TO THE SITE.
5:11:01PM HERE IS THE BANK PARCEL THAT'S LOCATED HERE.
5:11:04PM HERE IS THE SUBJECT PROPERTY THAT'S OUTLINED HERE.
5:11:08PM THIS IS THE BUILDING, AND THE TRAFFIC FLOW, THE TRAFFIC
5:11:12PM WOULD COME IN, ENTER THE SITE, CIRCLE THE DRIVE-THROUGH, AND
5:11:15PM THEN THEY CAN EXIT THE SITE.
5:11:18PM SO EXISTING RIGHT NOW ON SITE, I HAVE PHOTOS FOR YOU IS
5:11:22PM PARKING, SURFACE PARKING.
5:11:24PM SO THE SITE OVERALL IS OVER-PARKED.
5:11:27PM THIS USE, BECAUSE IT DOES NOT HAVE INSIDE CUSTOMER SEATING
5:11:31PM REQUIRES TWO PARKING SPACES AND TWO PARKING SPACES ARE
5:11:34PM PROVIDED AND THE ADDITIONAL SPACES THERE ARE OVERAGE FOR THE
5:11:38PM OVERALL DEVELOPMENT.
5:11:39PM I HAVE THE ELEVATIONS OF THE SITE.
5:11:45PM SO THE TOP, THIS IS THE SOUTH ELEVATION AND THIS IS THE WEST
5:11:51PM ELEVATION.
5:11:56PM AND THE TOP VIEW, THAT IS THE EAST ELEVATION, AND THEN THIS
5:12:00PM IS THE NORTH ELEVATION.
5:12:01PM AND THEN I HAVE A FEW PICTURES OF THE SITE.
5:12:08PM THIS WOULD BE THE LOCATION, THE APPROXIMATE LOCATION OF THE
5:12:11PM OUTPARCEL.
5:12:13PM THIS IS BRUCE B. DOWNS.
5:12:18PM LET ME ZOOM OUT A LITTLE BIT.
5:12:20PM THIS IS ALSO A VIEW OF THE SITE.
5:12:26PM THIS IS FROM THE VIEWPOINT OF WHERE THE SHOPPING CENTER IS
5:12:32PM LOCATED AND YOU'RE LOOKING AT THE SITE.
5:12:34PM THE SUBJECT SITE WOULD BE SOMEWHERE ALONG IN THIS AREA.
5:12:36PM THIS IS A VIEW OF THE SHOPPING CENTER.
5:12:41PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW.
5:12:44PM THIS IS NEAR THE ENTRY POINT WHERE VEHICLES WOULD ENTER.
5:12:50PM ANOTHER VIEW.
5:12:52PM THIS IS THE BANK, WHICH IS LOCATED AT THE CORNER.
5:12:56PM THIS IS AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF BRUCE B. DOWNS.
5:12:59PM AND THIS IS A VIEW, THE SITE IS OFF TO THE DISTANCE.
5:13:05PM THIS IS BRUCE B. DOWNS.
5:13:06PM THIS IS THAT PD WITH THE WATERFALL THAT'S LOCATED THERE, THE
5:13:14PM WEST OF THE SITE.
5:13:15PM AND THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE.
5:13:16PM THAT IS THE OTHER CORNER AT TAMPA PALMS.
5:13:20PM STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FINDS THE REQUEST
5:13:23PM CONSISTENT.
5:13:26PM THERE ARE SITE PLAN MODIFICATIONS TO BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST
5:13:28PM AND SECOND READING.
5:13:29PM WITH THAT, THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
5:13:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
5:13:34PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I JUST HAD A QUESTION.
5:13:36PM I NOTICED HOW WOODED THE PARKING LOT IS, WHICH IS VERY NICE.
5:13:41PM WILL THE MAJORITY OF THOSE TREES IN THAT AREA BE STAYING OR
5:13:45PM WILL THEY HAVE TO TAKE DOWN TREES TO BUILD THE STRUCTURE?
5:13:49PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THE MAJORITY OF THE TREES ARE STAYING.
5:13:53PM IT'S ENCOMPASSING A VERY SMALL AREA.
5:13:55PM I'M TRYING TO FIND A VIEW OF THE SITE GOING TO A VIEW THAT
5:14:00PM LOOKS DIRECTLY TO THE OUTPARCEL.
5:14:03PM DO YOU WANT TO TALK TO IT?
5:14:08PM >> ERIN MAEHR, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:14:11PM THEY ARE REMOVING FIVE OF THE OAKS I BELIEVE ON THE SITE.
5:14:15PM I EVEN ASKED THEM TO REMOVE A COUPLE OF ADDITIONAL SMALLER
5:14:18PM TREES THAT WERE NOT IN THE BEST CONDITION.
5:14:20PM THEY ARE GOING TO BE REPLACING THEM.
5:14:22PM THEY ARE ALSO REPLACING WITH I THINK IT'S 22 TREES.
5:14:26PM SO THEY ARE PUTTING A LOT OF TREES BACK, ADDITIONAL TREES.
5:14:30PM AND THEY ARE JUST REMOVING FIVE.
5:14:32PM THEY ARE GOING TO BE USING A LOT OF THE EXISTING ASPHALT.
5:14:35PM THEY ARE GOING TO REDO THE ASPHALT BUT A LOT OF THESE ARE IN
5:14:39PM ISLANDS AND THEY ARE GOING TO PROTECT THEM.
5:14:40PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OKAY.
5:14:41PM THANK YOU.
5:14:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:14:42PM ALL RIGHT.
5:14:43PM DO WE HAVE AN APPLICANT FOR ITEM NUMBER 1?
5:14:45PM IS THERE AN APPLICANT?
5:14:48PM YES, MA'AM, COME ON UP.
5:14:50PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:14:55PM >> GOOD AFTERNOON.
5:14:56PM MY NAME IS BET WITH THOMAS ENGINEERING.
5:15:01PM THANK YOU ALL FOR HAVING US TODAY AND REVIEWING OUR PROPOSAL
5:15:04PM FOR THE DRIVE-THROUGH ONLY COFFEE SHOP.
5:15:07PM I'M HERE TO REPRESENT THE DEVELOPMENT TEAM AS WELL AS THE
5:15:11PM APPLICANT.
5:15:12PM AS STAFF PRESENTED TODAY, WE WILL BE PROPOSING A 664 SQUARE
5:15:18PM FOOT BUILDING ON A .55-ACRE LEASE AREA WITHIN A CITY PLAZA
5:15:25PM SHOPPING CENTER.
5:15:25PM IT'S LOCATED AT BRUCE B. DOWNS AND TAMPA PALMS BOULEVARD
5:15:30PM INTERSECTION.
5:15:30PM WE'RE HERE TO RESPECTFULLY REQUEST FOR APPROVAL AND ANSWER
5:15:35PM ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE.
5:15:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE
5:15:37PM APPLICANT?
5:15:38PM DO WE HAVE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON
5:15:40PM ITEM NUMBER 1?
5:15:42PM >> MOVE TO CLOSE.
5:15:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL
5:15:44PM MEMBER CLENDENIN WITH A SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:15:46PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:15:47PM AYE.
5:15:48PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:15:48PM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA, WOULD YOU MIND READING NUMBER ONE?
5:15:51PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: NOT AT ALL, MR. CHAIRMAN.
5:15:54PM THANK YOU.
5:15:54PM ITEM NUMBER 1, FILE SU2-23-09, ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR
5:16:01PM FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE APPROVING A
5:16:04PM SPECIAL USE PERMIT SU-2, APPROVING A RESTAURANT WITH
5:16:06PM DRIVE-IN WINDOW IN A CU, COMMUNITY UNIT, ZONING DISTRICT IN
5:16:11PM THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 16001 TAMPA PALMS BOULEVARD, IN THE
5:16:19PM CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN
5:16:22PM SECTION 1 HEREOF, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
5:16:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
5:16:26PM MIRANDA.
5:16:27PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA.
5:16:28PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:16:28PM AYE.
5:16:30PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:16:30PM WOULD YOU PREFER A ROLL CALL?
5:16:38PM NO.
5:16:39PM IT'S FIRST READING.
5:16:43PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: LET ME JUST ADD THAT THE APPLICANT HAS
5:16:46PM MET THE PROPOSED REQUEST WITH THE EXISTING SHOPPING CENTER
5:16:49PM AND CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERNS, POLICY 1.2.3
5:16:53PM AND 1.2.8 AND 15.2.1.
5:16:57PM ALSO THE USE OF THE LOCATION OF CU DISTRICT DOES NOT REQUEST
5:17:00PM ANY WAIVERS AND MEETS THE GENERAL STANDARDS OF SECTION
5:17:03PM 27-129, USE IS COMPATIBLE WITH MIXED NEIGHBORHOOD SERVING
5:17:07PM COMMERCIAL USES LOCATED ADJACENT TO THE SITE AND WILL NOT
5:17:10PM ESTABLISH A PRECEDENT AND ENCOURAGE INCOMPATIBLE USES IN THE
5:17:15PM SURROUNDING AREA.
5:17:16PM >>THE CLERK: SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON
5:17:19PM JUNE 6, 2024, AT 9:30 A.M. LOCATED AT OLD CITY HALL, 315
5:17:23PM EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
5:17:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:17:29PM ITEM NUMBER 2.
5:17:32PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
5:17:33PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:17:35PM ITEM 2 IS REZ-23-84.
5:17:38PM THIS IS FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 5006 EAST 97th AVENUE.
5:17:43PM THIS ALSO CONTAINS FIVE ADDITIONAL FOLIOS, A TOTAL OF SIX
5:17:49PM PARCELS.
5:17:49PM IT'S JUST EASIER TO SHOW YOU ON THIS MAP THE LOCATION.
5:17:52PM THIS IS THE ADDRESS OF THE 5006 EAST 97th AVENUE.
5:17:59PM THIS IS 97th AVENUE AND THESE ARE THE ADDITIONAL FOLIOS
5:18:02PM WHICH ARE LISTED, WHICH ARE BEHIND THIS PARCEL.
5:18:06PM SO THE REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY FROM RS 60,
5:18:10PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY, TO RM 24, RESIDENTIAL
5:18:12PM MULTIFAMILY.
5:18:13PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO PLANNING COMMISSION TO GIVE THEIR
5:18:15PM REPORT AND I'LL COME BACK AND GIVE MY REPORT.
5:18:23PM >>DAVID HEY: DAVID HEY AGAIN WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION
5:18:25PM STAFF.
5:18:26PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE UNIVERSITY PLANNING
5:18:32PM AREA, SPECIFICALLY IN THE TERRACE PARK NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:18:37PM THE CLOSEST PUBLIC RECREATION FACILITY IS ABOUT ONE-FOURTH
5:18:40PM OF A MILE NORTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
5:18:42PM THE CLOSEST TRANSIT STOP IS WITHIN A HALF MILE SOUTH OF THE
5:18:46PM SUBJECT SITE AT THE CORNER OF EAST BUSCH BOULEVARD AND NORTH
5:18:49PM 50th STREET.
5:18:50PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS NOT WITHIN THE COASTAL PLANNING AREA OR
5:18:53PM AN EVACUATION ZONE.
5:18:55PM ON TO THE AERIAL, THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
5:19:00PM YOU'VE GOT 97th STREET ON THE SOUTH SIDE.
5:19:04PM IT'S PREDOMINANTLY SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED.
5:19:07PM AS YOU MOVE TO THE EAST, THOUGH, THERE ARE SOME TOWNHOMES
5:19:12PM AND MULTIFAMILY SCATTERED THROUGHOUT THIS AREA.
5:19:16PM THEN YOU ACTUALLY GO INTO TEMPLE TERRACE, I BELIEVE, OFF OF
5:19:20PM 52nd STREET.
5:19:21PM HERE WE HAVE THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
5:19:27PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS HARD TO SEE.
5:19:29PM IT'S RESIDENTIAL 35.
5:19:30PM THE TAN COLOR AROUND IT IS ALL THE RESIDENTIAL 10.
5:19:34PM TO THE EAST AND NORTH AND FURTHER TO THE SOUTH IN THIS LIGHT
5:19:39PM BROWN COLOR, THAT IS THE RESIDENTIAL 20.
5:19:41PM YOU GET OTHER RESIDENTIAL 35 AREAS TO THE SOUTH AND FURTHER
5:19:45PM TO THE EAST.
5:19:46PM AND THEN THERE IS A REC OPEN SPACE.
5:19:49PM THAT IS THE PARK TO THE NORTH.
5:19:50PM AND THEN THIS IS COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35 TO THE SOUTH.
5:19:54PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS RECOGNIZED UNDER THAT RESIDENTIAL 35
5:19:59PM DESIGNATION.
5:20:00PM THE DESIGNATION IS INTENDED FOR MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL
5:20:04PM USES, INCLUDING SMALL LOT SINGLE-FAMILY UNITS, DUPLEXES,
5:20:08PM CONDOMINIUMS, AND TOWNHOMES AND MULTIFAMILY DWELLINGS.
5:20:11PM THE PROPOSED RM 24 ZONING DISTRICT CAN BE CONSIDERED WITHIN
5:20:14PM THE R-35 FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY, ACCORDING TO THE
5:20:19PM CONSISTENCY MATRIX PROVIDED IN SECTION 27-21 OF THE LAND
5:20:22PM DEVELOPMENT CODE.
5:20:24PM PART OF THE CITY'S PLANNING AND HOUSING STRATEGIES ARE TO
5:20:26PM ACCOMMODATE CURRENT AND FUTURE POPULATION DEMANDS BY USING
5:20:32PM LAND RESOURCES MORE EFFICIENTLY AND ENCOURAGING INFILL
5:20:34PM DEVELOPMENT ON VACANT AND UNDERUTILIZED SITES.
5:20:37PM THE REQUEST SUPPORTS THESE STRATEGIES BECAUSE IT WILL
5:20:39PM ENCOURAGE HIGHER DENSITY ON A VACANT AND UNDERUTILIZED SITE
5:20:42PM THAT IS PLANNED FOR UP TO 35 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE.
5:20:45PM THE PROPOSED RM 24 ZONING DISTRICT WILL HELP PROVIDE
5:20:49PM ADDITIONAL HOUSING IN THE TERRACE PARK NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:20:51PM IN SUMMARY, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDS THE PROPOSED
5:20:53PM REZONING CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN ANTICIPATED
5:20:56PM UNDER THAT RESIDENTIAL 35 LAND USE DESIGNATION.
5:21:01PM AND THE REZONING REQUEST DOES SUPPORT THE OVERALL POLICY
5:21:05PM DIRECTION OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
5:21:06PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
5:21:09PM FINDS THE PROPOSED REZONING CONSISTENT WITH THE PROVISIONS
5:21:12PM OF THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
5:21:14PM THANK YOU.
5:21:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:21:15PM ANY QUESTIONS?
5:21:16PM NO.
5:21:17PM YES, MA'AM.
5:21:20PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:21:23PM THIS REZONING REQUEST, AS MENTIONED EARLIER, IS THE REQUEST
5:21:27PM TO REZONE TO RM-24.
5:21:29PM I'D LIKE TO POINT OUT ON THE STAFF REPORT ON PAGE 2 OF THE
5:21:32PM REPORT, THE ACREAGE IS LISTED INCORRECTLY.
5:21:34PM I HAVE IT AT 1.45, BUT IT IS 1.1 ACRES.
5:21:38PM THAT IS THE TOTAL ACREAGE FOR THIS REQUEST.
5:21:41PM THAT WOULD ALLOW FOR A MAXIMUM OF 33 UNITS ON-SITE.
5:21:45PM IN THE RM 24 ZONING CATEGORY, IN ADDITION TO THE LOT
5:21:49PM REQUIREMENT BEING A MINIMUM LOT FRONTAGE WIDTH OF 50 FEET, A
5:21:53PM MINIMUM LOT AREA OF 5,000 SQUARE FEET, IT ALSO ALLOWS FOR A
5:21:57PM MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT OF 60 FEET.
5:22:00PM NOW, THIS IS IN THE STAFF REPORT ON THE TOP OF PAGE 2, YOU
5:22:04PM CAN SEE THAT THERE IS AN ASTERISK THERE.
5:22:07PM FOR EACH FOOT ABOVE 35 FEET, YOU ARE REQUIRED TO STEP -- TO
5:22:14PM ADD AN ADDITIONAL FOOT TO YOUR SETBACK.
5:22:17PM SO I'M GOING TO SHOW YOU THE SITE HERE, THE SURVEY THAT WAS
5:22:23PM SUBMITTED.
5:22:24PM SO WHEN WE LOOK AT THE SITE, WHAT IT -- WOULD IT GET TO A
5:22:29PM HEIGHT OF 60 FEET GIVEN THAT YOU HAVE TO INCREASE YOUR
5:22:31PM SETBACK BY A FOOT, IT MAY NOT, BUT IT MAY REACH -- IT MAY BE
5:22:36PM ABLE TO BE DEVELOPED AND REACH A HEIGHT HIGHER THAN 35 FEET.
5:22:40PM THE ANALYSIS IS PROVIDED WITHIN THE STAFF REPORT, AND IT
5:22:42PM TALKS ABOUT THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT, WHAT IS SURROUNDING THE
5:22:46PM SITE AND THE SCALE.
5:22:47PM I'LL GET TO THAT IN JUST A MOMENT.
5:22:49PM BUT THIS IS THE SURVEY OF THE PROPERTY.
5:22:52PM THIS IS 97th AVENUE.
5:22:53PM THIS IS THE FRONTAGE OF THE PROPERTY, AND THEN HERE ARE THE
5:22:57PM LOTS, WHICH ARE CURRENTLY UNDER THIS REQUEST.
5:23:00PM SO WITHOUT THESE LOTS HERE THIS WOULD BECOME ONE ZONING LOT
5:23:05PM UPON APPROVAL TO BE DEVELOPED WITH RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY.
5:23:10PM WITHOUT THIS ACCESS OR FRONTAGE, THESE LOTS WOULD NOT BE
5:23:13PM ABLE TO BE DEVELOPED.
5:23:14PM THEY DON'T HAVE THE FRONTAGE.
5:23:16PM BUT I'LL SHOW YOU WHAT IS SURROUNDING THE SITE AND WHAT'S
5:23:19PM HERE TO THE EAST AND TO THE WEST OF THE SITE, THE SUBJECT
5:23:22PM SITE.
5:23:22PM AND REVIEW PART OF THE ANALYSIS PROVIDED.
5:23:27PM THIS IS THE ZONING MAP.
5:23:30PM THIS IS THE PARCEL WHICH IS IDENTIFIED AGAIN IN RED.
5:23:33PM I SHOWED THE MAP EARLIER.
5:23:34PM THIS IS 97th AVENUE.
5:23:36PM SO WHEN YOU'RE DRIVING ON THIS ROADWAY, THIS IS TEMPLE
5:23:41PM HEIGHTS ROAD.
5:23:43PM A VEHICLE CAN TRAVEL UP THE ROAD TO 97th.
5:23:46PM YOU MUST CURVE AROUND, AND THEN HEAD EAST.
5:23:49PM THE ROAD DOES NOT CONTINUE NORTH.
5:23:53PM THIS IS LIKE A DEAD END HERE.
5:23:55PM SO YOU HAVE YOUR USES HERE.
5:23:57PM YOU CAN SEE THAT THIS SITE IS SURROUNDED WITH RS 60 ZONING.
5:24:01PM YOU HAVE A POCKET OF RS 50 THAT'S LOCATED HERE.
5:24:05PM FURTHER NORTH, NORTH OF LINEBAUGH, YOU HAVE YOUR MULTIFAMILY
5:24:09PM ZONINGS AND USES.
5:24:11PM AND THEN FURTHER EAST ALONG MYRTLE, YOU HAVE YOUR
5:24:15PM RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY USES.
5:24:18PM RO.
5:24:18PM THE RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY IS HERE.
5:24:20PM BUT IT'S ALONG THE BOUNDARY ALONG THE EAST AND SOUTH AT
5:24:25PM TEMPLE HEIGHTS.
5:24:26PM AND THEN THIS IS 52nd STREET.
5:24:28PM THIS PD, WHICH IS SOUTH OF THE SITE, A BLOCK SOUTH, IS
5:24:31PM APPROVED FOR TOWNHOME DEVELOPMENT.
5:24:34PM SO THIS IS SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED USES THAT ARE LOCATED
5:24:37PM HERE.
5:24:38PM BUT THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN HAS BEEN WITH THE MULTIFAMILY
5:24:41PM ALONG THE EAST AND THE SOUTH.
5:24:42PM THIS WOULD ALLOW THIS RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY IN THE CENTER
5:24:47PM OF THIS BLOCK.
5:24:48PM SO THE USE IS, I'M GOING TO SHOW YOU PHOTOS.
5:24:53PM VISUALLY -- IF YOU LOOK AT THIS PARCEL THIS APPEARS TO BE
5:24:57PM MULTIFAMILY.
5:24:58PM THESE ARE SEPARATE LOTS.
5:24:59PM SO THESE ARE TWO FAMILY HOMES.
5:25:01PM THIS IS WHAT WOULD BE THE DUPLEX USE.
5:25:04PM BUT IT IS IN OUR CODE A TWO-FAMILY.
5:25:07PM SINGLE-FAMILY.
5:25:08PM THIS IS SINGLE-FAMILY.
5:25:08PM THAT'S TO THE SOUTH.
5:25:09PM AND THEN TO THE NORTH IS THE SAME USE.
5:25:12PM SO I'LL SHOW YOU.
5:25:14PM WHAT MY REPORT TALKS ABOUT IS THAT DEVELOPMENT PATTERN THAT
5:25:17PM EXISTS AND THE INTENSITY THAT'S ALLOWED WITH THIS RM 24.
5:25:21PM AND THAT IS THE REASON FOR THE FINDING OF INCONSISTENT ON
5:25:26PM THE SITE.
5:25:27PM THE OTHER THING IS JUST TO TALK ABOUT THE FUTURE LAND USE
5:25:29PM FOR A MOMENT.
5:25:30PM SO THE FUTURE LAND USE IS R 35 AND IT SUPPORTS THE
5:25:34PM RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY ZONE.
5:25:36PM SO ANY APPLICANT THAT COMES BEFORE COUNCIL FOR A FUTURE LAND
5:25:39PM USE MAP AMENDMENT, IT IS WITH THE INTENT LATER TO COME BACK
5:25:43PM FOR ADDITIONAL ENTITLEMENTS, DO A REZONING WHERE THERE IS A
5:25:46PM PD OR EUCLIDEAN REZONING.
5:25:48PM THE QUESTION IS, IS THAT THE TIME FOR THAT REZONING?
5:25:51PM BECAUSE THAT FUTURE LAND USE IS ON THE PROPERTY, IS THAT THE
5:25:54PM TIME TO DEVELOP?
5:25:55PM I JUST ASK JUST CONSIDER, AND I'LL PRESENT TO YOU AND SHOW
5:26:00PM YOU THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN THAT'S IN THIS AREA TO DETERMINE
5:26:04PM IF THAT IS THE RIGHT ZONING FOR THE PROPERTY.
5:26:08PM SO THE RM-24 IS ALLOWED WITHIN THE R 35.
5:26:12PM BUT ALSO WHAT IS ALLOWED IN MULTIFAMILY EUCLIDEAN IS RM 18.
5:26:16PM RM 18 ALLOWS FOR A 35-FOOT MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT.
5:26:21PM AND THAT IS IN LINE WITH THE RESIDENTIAL THAT IS IMMEDIATELY
5:26:25PM ADJACENT THAT IS THE MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT ALLOWED AT 35
5:26:29PM FEET.
5:26:29PM SO HERE ARE PICTURES OF THE SITE.
5:26:34PM THIS IS ON 97th AVENUE.
5:26:36PM THIS IS A VIEW IF LOOKING EAST ON 97th.
5:26:42PM THIS IS THE SITE OFF TO THE PICTURE ON THE LEFT.
5:26:44PM THESE ARE SOME OF THE TWO UNITS THAT ARE THERE.
5:26:46PM THESE ARE ACTUALLY LAND LINES THAT ARE HERE BETWEEN THESE
5:26:49PM BUILDINGS, BUT THESE ARE YOUR DUPLEXES THAT EXIST THERE
5:26:54PM IMMEDIATELY EAST.
5:26:54PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW.
5:26:56PM THIS IS FURTHER EAST, HEADING FURTHER EAST.
5:27:02PM THIS IS IF YOU'RE LOOKING WEST ON 97th.
5:27:11PM SO THE SITE IS ACTUALLY OFF ON THE RIGHT ON THE PICTURE.
5:27:15PM SO THIS IS WHERE I SAID THAT ROAD KIND OF DEAD ENDS.
5:27:19PM IT HAS TO CURVE AROUND.
5:27:20PM THIS IS WEST OF THE SITE, SO THE SUBJECT SITE IS TO THE
5:27:25PM RIGHT IN THIS PICTURE TWO LOTS OVER.
5:27:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOVE IT UP.
5:27:30PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: I'M SORRY.
5:27:31PM YOU'RE MISSING HALF THE PHOTO.
5:27:34PM I DIDN'T ZOOM BACK OUT AGAIN.
5:27:35PM THANK YOU.
5:27:35PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW ON THAT SIDE.
5:27:41PM THIS IS WEST OF THE SITE.
5:27:43PM THIS IS AT THE END OF THE BLOCK, SO THE SUBJECT SITE IS TWO
5:27:47PM PARCELS OVER.
5:27:47PM THIS IS THE HOUSE THAT'S AT THE END OF THE STREET AND THEN
5:27:50PM THESE ARE HOMES THAT ARE ON THE WEST AND THAT RESIDENTIAL
5:27:53PM SINGLE-FAMILY SUBDIVISION THAT DEVELOPMENT THAT'S THERE ON
5:27:56PM THE WEST.
5:27:57PM THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE, SO THIS IS ACROSS THE STREET.
5:28:02PM THIS IS THE RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY.
5:28:03PM SO THERE ARE SOME PRETTY LARGE LOTS THAT EXIST OUT THERE
5:28:07PM TODAY.
5:28:07PM AND WITH THAT, THAT CONCLUDES THE PRESENTATION.
5:28:13PM STAFF REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FOUND THE REQUEST
5:28:16PM INCONSISTENT.
5:28:17PM AND I'M AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
5:28:19PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
5:28:20PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:28:23PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: OKAY.
5:28:25PM THANK YOU.
5:28:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
5:28:29PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:28:33PM >> MR. CHAIRMAN AND COUNCIL MEMBERS, TODD PRESSMAN,
5:28:35PM 200 2nd AVENUE SOUTH NUMBER 451 IN ST. PETERSBURG.
5:28:41PM IF WE COULD GO TO THE PowerPoint, PLEASE.
5:28:43PM THIS IS REZ 23-84.
5:28:47PM SEEKING RS 60 TO RM 24.
5:28:50PM APPRECIATE MR. HEY'S REPORT, LaCHONE'S REPORT, TWO
5:28:54PM DIFFERENT OPINIONS.
5:28:55PM WE'RE HERE FOR ONE REASON AND ONE REASON ONLY, THAT LAST
5:28:59PM YEAR, THIS BODY VOTED TO APPROVE THE LAND USE AMENDMENT AND
5:29:04PM APPROVE THE DENSITY THAT'S BEFORE YOU TODAY.
5:29:06PM SO, OF COURSE, THE EDICT IS TO COME IN AND APPLY FOR
5:29:12PM COMPANION ZONING, WHICH IS WHY WE'RE HERE TODAY.
5:29:14PM WE'RE IN THE UNIVERSITY PLANNING AREA.
5:29:17PM WE'RE IN THE AREA BETWEEN BUSCH BOULEVARD AND NORTH 56th.
5:29:20PM THIS IS THE SITE WHICH IS AN ASSEMBLAGE AS I THINK THE STAFF
5:29:24PM MEMBERS HAVE MADE YOU WELL AWARE.
5:29:25PM AGAIN, THIS WAS -- SORRY, IT WAS APPROVED IN FEBRUARY OF
5:29:29PM '24.
5:29:30PM I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT AS LaCHONE INDICATED, THAT ANY
5:29:34PM HEIGHT OVER 35 FEET WOULD HAVE TO BE BIRTHDAY CAKE IN TERMS
5:29:38PM OF LAYERED UP AND PUSHED BACK FOR THE SETBACK.
5:29:41PM PLANNING COMMISSION NOTES THE REZONING IS CONSISTENT WITH
5:29:46PM THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN AND SUPPORTS THE OVERALL POLICY AND
5:29:48PM DIRECTION OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
5:29:50PM NOTES ACCOMMODATE CURRENT AND FUTURE POPULATION BY USING
5:29:53PM LAND RESOURCES MORE EFFICIENTLY, ENCOURAGING INFILL
5:29:56PM DEVELOPMENT ON VACANT AND UNDERUTILIZED SITES.
5:30:00PM THE PROPOSED 24 ZONING DISTRICT WHICH WILL HELP PROVIDE
5:30:05PM ADDITIONAL HOUSING IN THE TERRACE PARK NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:30:07PM LaCHONE BROUGHT FORWARD A LOT OF POLICIES FOR YOU AND SO
5:30:10PM DID MR. HEY, BUT I THINK THERE ARE OTHER POLICIES LIKE THIS
5:30:13PM THAT DIRECT YOU FOR SPECIFICALLY WHAT WE'RE PROPOSING HERE,
5:30:16PM AND THESE ARE TWO OF THEM.
5:30:17PM WHEN YOU LOOK THROUGHOUT THE SITE, THERE IS SIGNIFICANT
5:30:21PM MULTIFAMILY ON THE BLOCK AND IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO THE
5:30:25PM BLOCK.
5:30:25PM LaCHONE SHOWED YOU SOME OF THOSE.
5:30:27PM THIS IS ONE HERE, AND YOU HAVE THESE, AND YOU HAVE THESE.
5:30:31PM AND THIS, WHICH IS ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE BLOCK TO THE
5:30:34PM NORTH.
5:30:34PM THIS IS A MEDIAN HOUSEHOLD INCOME OF $35,000.
5:30:40PM MIXED INCOME RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOODS, THE EFFORT IS TO
5:30:43PM ATTRACT RESIDENTS TO LIVE IN TAMPA, MUST INCLUDE PROMOTION
5:30:46PM OF MIXED INCOME RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT, AND THAT IS
5:30:50PM SPECIFIC TO PROMOTING MIXED INCOME RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
5:30:53PM IN THE UNIVERSITY PLANNING DISTRICT WHICH IS SPECIFICALLY
5:30:55PM AND EXACTLY WHERE WE ARE AT.
5:30:57PM THAT IS A VERY SPECIFIC POLICIES THAT IS DIRECTED.
5:31:00PM OBJECTIVE 9.6 IS INCREASE DIVERSITY AND IMPROVE THE
5:31:04PM SUSTAINABILITY OF MULTIFAMILY RESIDENTIAL AREAS, WHICH THIS
5:31:07PM DOES.
5:31:07PM 9.6.1 IS ENCOURAGE THE DEVELOPMENT AND RETENTION OF THE
5:31:11PM DIVERSITY OF MULTIFAMILY HOMES TO MEET THE NEEDS OF TAMPA'S
5:31:14PM PRESENT AND FUTURE POPULATIONS.
5:31:15PM AND OBJECTIVE 9.7, PROVIDE OPPORTUNITIES FOR INFILL IN AREAS
5:31:21PM ALREADY CHARACTERIZED BY LOW TO LOW-MEDIUM DENSITY
5:31:24PM RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT.
5:31:26PM WHICH I'VE SHOWN THAT YOU THIS AREA SPECIFICALLY IS.
5:31:29PM UNIVERSITY AREA COMMUNITY PLAN DOES HAVE A POINT ABOUT
5:31:33PM PROVIDING GREATER FLEXIBILITY IN LAND USE AND DENSITY FOR
5:31:36PM FUTURE DEVELOPMENT WHILE ENSURING THAT NEIGHBORHOOD BUFFERS
5:31:39PM AND URBAN AMENITIES ARE ENHANCED.
5:31:41PM POLICY 9.8 SOMEWHAT ECHOS THAT, STANDARDS FOR MODERATE
5:31:46PM DENSITY FAMILY ZONE PROVIDE SCALE, DEVELOPMENT BUILDING
5:31:48PM TYPES THAT DIFFER FROM THOSE OF SINGLE-FAMILY AND
5:31:50PM LOW-DENSITY MULTIFAMILY AREAS.
5:31:53PM THERE'S PLENTY OF TRANSPORTATION ROUTES IN AND OUT OF THE
5:31:56PM SITE.
5:31:56PM YOU CAN GO NORTH, SOUTH, EAST, OR WEST.
5:32:00PM LaCHONE SHOWS YOU A COUPLE OF PICTURES HOW THE SITE SITS.
5:32:03PM IN SUMMARY, MR. CHAIRMAN, WE'RE HERE PRIMARILY AND SOLELY
5:32:06PM FOR ZONING CONSISTENCY AS REQUIRED FROM THE APPROVAL OF
5:32:10PM TAMPA CITY COUNCIL ON THE LAND USE AMENDMENT, SUPPORTED BY
5:32:13PM MANY, MANY COMPREHENSIVE POLICIES.
5:32:15PM THE NET INCREASE OF UNITS REALLY IS LOW.
5:32:17PM IT'S NOT A LARGE SITE.
5:32:20PM PROVIDES HOUSING OPTIONS AND TRANSPORTATION IS VERY SAFE.
5:32:23PM SO WITH THAT, HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE.
5:32:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN AND COUNCIL
5:32:28PM MEMBER HURTAK.
5:32:29PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ONE, THE PICTURES YOU SHOWED WITHOUT
5:32:31PM CONTEXT OF WHERE THEY ARE GEOGRAPHICALLY REALLY IS NOT
5:32:35PM RELEVANT TO ME.
5:32:35PM THEY COULD BE ANYWHERE.
5:32:37PM I'M MORE CONCERNED ABOUT THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN IN
5:32:40PM PROXIMITY TO THE PARCEL THAT YOU'RE ASKING FOR REZONING.
5:32:43PM THE NEXT THING IS NONE OF THEM SHOWED 60-FOOT UNITS WHICH
5:32:47PM THE ZONING THAT YOU'VE ASKED FOR WOULD PERMIT BEING
5:32:49PM CONSTRUCTED WITH SETBACKS, OF COURSE, WHICH -- AT LEAST IN
5:32:55PM THE ONE PORTION, NOT REALLY USABLE.
5:32:57PM SO MY QUESTION WOULD BE, WHY YOU WOULDN'T COME, IF THE PLAN
5:33:01PM ISN'T TO BUILD TO 60, WHY WOULD YOU COME WITH A
5:33:04PM CLASSIFICATION THAT WAS MORE COMPATIBLE WITH THE SURROUNDING
5:33:07PM NEIGHBORHOODS.
5:33:09PM >> WE DO FEEL THE CATEGORY CHOSEN IS COMPATIBLE BECAUSE IT
5:33:12PM IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE LAND USE CATEGORY.
5:33:14PM WE ALSO SENT OUT 60 NOTICES AND, OF COURSE -- I DON'T KNOW
5:33:20PM IF THERE IS ANYONE HERE TO SPEAK AGAINST IT, BUT WE SENT OUT
5:33:24PM QUITE A LARGE NUMBER OF NOTICES AND I WAS NOT MADE AWARE
5:33:28PM THERE WAS ANY IN OPPOSITION.
5:33:29PM THE PUSH OF ALL THE PLANNING POLICIES IS TO PROVIDE A MIX OF
5:33:33PM HOUSING AND TO PROVIDE MULTIFAMILY.
5:33:37PM THERE IS MULTIFAMILY ON THE BLOCK, AS I SHOWED THE ONE
5:33:41PM SLIDE.
5:33:41PM I CONCENTRATED ON THE BLOCK.
5:33:43PM NOT DIRECTLY NEXT DOOR BUT ON THE BLOCK IN THE GENERAL
5:33:46PM VICINITY.
5:33:48PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: AGAIN, IF YOU ARE NOT PLANNING TO BUILD TO
5:33:50PM 60, CLEARLY THERE IS EUCLIDEAN ZONING IN A LESSER CATEGORY
5:33:54PM THAT WOULD ALLOW YOU TO BUILD THE DENSITY WITHOUT THE
5:33:56PM HEIGHT, CORRECT?
5:33:57PM >> WELL, THE APPLICANT HAS NOT MOVED FORWARD FOR A SPECIFIC
5:34:02PM PLAN.
5:34:02PM THE INTEREST, OF COURSE, IS IN MAXIMIZING THE UNITS, AND
5:34:07PM THAT'S WHAT THIS CATEGORY DOES.
5:34:10PM AGAIN, I DON'T KNOW IF THERE'S ANYONE HERE IN OPPOSITION.
5:34:12PM THERE WERE A COUPLE OF PEOPLE AT THE LAND USE COMPREHENSIVE
5:34:18PM REVIEW, BUT WE'VE HAD NO PUSH-BACK ON IT.
5:34:22PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: AS I'M LOOKING AT THESE REQUESTS, I MEAN,
5:34:27PM EVEN IF THEY ARE NOT HERE, I FEEL LIKE IT IS MY JOB TO
5:34:30PM PROTECT THEM BECAUSE FOR PEOPLE THIS IS THEIR HOME.
5:34:33PM THIS IS THEIR SECURITY.
5:34:34PM AS WE APPROVE DEVELOPMENT CHANGES, I WANT TO MAKE SURE IT
5:34:37PM DOESN'T NEGATIVELY IMPACT THESE FOLKS EVEN IF THEY ARE
5:34:39PM UNWITTINGLY -- YOU KNOW, DON'T KNOW ABOUT IT.
5:34:43PM SEEMS LIKE THERE ARE A LOT OF SINGLE-FAMILY, SINGLE STORY,
5:34:46PM OR EVEN MAYBE A FEW TWO-STORY HOUSES BUT NOTHING BIGGER THAN
5:34:50PM THAT IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF THE PROPERTY.
5:34:52PM I'LL LET IT GO AT THAT.
5:34:54PM >> THE SITE CLEARLY IS NOT A HUGE SITE AND WOULD NOT LEND
5:34:58PM ITSELF TO A LOT OF HEIGHT.
5:34:59PM WHAT THE HEIGHT WOULD BE, I CAN'T ANSWER THAT AT THE MOMENT.
5:35:02PM >>LYNN HURTAK: MY QUESTION WAS GOING TO BE ABOUT PUBLIC
5:35:04PM OUTREACH.
5:35:07PM YOU SAID YOU WERE NOT -- YOU DIDN'T ACTUALLY SPEAK TO
5:35:10PM ANYONE.
5:35:11PM >> WE HAD A SERIES OF NOTICES FOR THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
5:35:15PM AMENDMENT.
5:35:16PM AND WE HAD TWO NOTICES TO 60 RESIDENTS IN THE AREA PLUS, OF
5:35:20PM COURSE, SIGNS OUT THERE FOR I THINK ABOUT A MONTH, MONTH AND
5:35:23PM A HALF.
5:35:24PM THAT WAS THE COMMUNICATION THAT WAS MADE TO THE
5:35:28PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:35:29PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OKAY.
5:35:29PM THANK YOU.
5:35:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
5:35:30PM IS THERE ANYBODY THAT WISHES TO SPEAK?
5:35:35PM PLEASE COME ON UP AND STATE YOUR NAME.
5:35:42PM >> HI.
5:35:44PM I'M DELGADO.
5:35:45PM I AM THE OWNER TO ONE OF THE ADJACENT LOTS.
5:35:48PM I'M THE ONE THAT YOU HAVE THE PICTURE, THE ONE THAT LOOKS
5:35:50PM LIKE THE L.
5:35:51PM MY QUESTION IS, HOW IS IT GOING TO AFFECT ME AND THE FOUR
5:35:56PM SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES THAT SIT, THREE TO MY LEFT, EAST,
5:36:00PM HALF-ACRE LOTS.
5:36:02PM MINE IS THREE-QUARTERS OF AN ACRE.
5:36:03PM THAT LOT IN QUESTION THAT'S EMPTY IS ABOUT AN ACRE.
5:36:07PM HOW ARE YOU GOING TO FIT 33 UNITS WHEN THE OTHER LOTS ONLY
5:36:11PM HAVE SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES?
5:36:12PM AND I HAVE THE BIGGEST HOUSE ON THE BLOCK, WHICH IS TWO
5:36:16PM STORY, STILL ONLY ONE FAMILY.
5:36:19PM HOW IS IT GOING TO AFFECT US AND THE NEIGHBORS ALONG
5:36:22PM LINEBAUGH AVENUE.
5:36:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE'LL HAVE THE APPLICANT RESPOND WITH
5:36:28PM THE ANSWER.
5:36:29PM IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE HERE TO SPEAK?
5:36:37PM BRING IT ON UP, SIR.
5:36:47PM >> ARE YOU TALKING TO ME, SIR?
5:36:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YEAH.
5:36:52PM >> I WAS ASKING THE YOUNG LADY WHERE SHE IS.
5:36:55PM SHE'S LOCATED RIGHT HERE.
5:36:57PM IS THAT CORRECT, MA'AM?
5:36:58PM >> YES.
5:37:00PM >> SHE'S ANSWERING YES.
5:37:01PM >> THE L-SHAPED LOT.
5:37:04PM >> WOULD YOU POINT?
5:37:08PM >> THIS ONE RIGHT HERE.
5:37:09PM THIS IS THE DRIVEWAY.
5:37:10PM THIS IS MY DRIVEWAY AND THIS IS MY HOME.
5:37:14PM >> OKAY.
5:37:15PM GOT IT.
5:37:15PM IN ANSWER, WHAT WAS PROPOSED WOULD BE A MULTIFAMILY
5:37:23PM DEVELOPMENT.
5:37:25PM HEIGHT WOULD ONLY BE DETERMINED ONCE PENCIL IS PUT TO PAPER.
5:37:29PM BUT AGAIN, IT WILL BE LIKE A BIRTHDAY CAKE REQUIRING A
5:37:34PM BIGGER SETBACK FOR OVER 35 FEET.
5:37:37PM IT WOULD BE THE REAR OF HER LOT, WHICH YOU CAN SEE THERE'S
5:37:45PM SUBSTANTIAL BUFFERING AND SCREENING NATURALLY AT THE SITE.
5:37:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHAT IS THE MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE HEIGHT FOR
5:37:49PM RM-24?
5:37:50PM RM-18 IS 35 FEET.
5:37:53PM MS. DOCK.
5:37:59PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CORRECT.
5:38:00PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:38:02PM THE MAXIMUM HEIGHT ALLOWED IN RM 24 IS 60 FEET.
5:38:06PM BUT AS YOUR HEIGHT INCREASES OVER 35 FEET, YOU MUST STEP
5:38:10PM BACK YOUR SETBACK.
5:38:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THIS BUILDING IS LIKE A LAYERED CAKE.
5:38:15PM ONCE YOU GO PAST THE THIRD FLOOR.
5:38:17PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THE BUILDING ITSELF WOULD -- YES.
5:38:20PM THE SETBACK WOULD HAVE TO INCREASE, WHICH IS WHY GIVEN THIS
5:38:23PM LOT SIZE -- I CAN PUT UP THE SURVEY, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO
5:38:31PM DEVELOP 60 FEET?
5:38:32PM I DON'T KNOW.
5:38:33PM AS YOU GO UP IN HEIGHT, THE SETBACK OF THAT BUILDING IS
5:38:36PM GOING TO STEP BACK ANOTHER FOOT, ANOTHER FOOT.
5:38:38PM YOU STILL HAVE TO PROVIDE PARKING PLUS THE OTHER CODE
5:38:42PM REQUIREMENTS.
5:38:42PM BUT THE CONCERN IS YOU CAN GET A STRUCTURE ON THIS SITE THAT
5:38:47PM IS OVER 35 FEET.
5:38:48PM IT MAY NOT BE 60, BUT IT COULD GO OVER 35 FEET.
5:38:55PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: AGAIN, JUST FOR THE RECORD, RM 18 IS 35
5:38:59PM FEET, CORRECT?
5:39:00PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CORRECT.
5:39:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: 60 FEET, IF THEY REACH AT 60-FOOT, AS
5:39:04PM YOU SAID, THE SETBACKS, HOW MANY STORIES DO YOU FIT IN 60
5:39:07PM FEET?
5:39:07PM IS IT FIVE, FOUR?
5:39:10PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: AT LEAST THE FIVE STORIES, BUT IT JUST
5:39:14PM DEPENDS ON THE DEVELOPMENT.
5:39:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: BECAUSE OF THE SHAPE OF THE LOT, IT
5:39:19PM WOULD OBVIOUSLY BE, AS YOU SAID, IT WOULD BE SET BACK THE
5:39:22PM HIGHER THEY GO.
5:39:23PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CORRECT.
5:39:24PM AND THIS WOULD JUST BE -- WHATEVER THE STRUCTURE IS AND THAT
5:39:30PM HEIGHT AND THE PLACEMENT, I'M ASSUMING STRUCTURES WOULD HAVE
5:39:34PM TO BE PLACED BACK HERE ON THIS LOT, ON THIS PROPERTY.
5:39:37PM SO THIS IS THE BACKYARD.
5:39:40PM THIS IS THE BACKYARDS OF THE HOMES TO THE EAST OF THE
5:39:43PM SUBJECT SITE.
5:39:45PM AND THEN THIS IS HER YARD UP HERE, THE LADY THAT IS HERE
5:39:49PM NOW.
5:39:49PM SO THIS IS HER BACKYARD, THIS IS HER HEIGHT.
5:39:53PM THIS WOULD BE THE HEIGHT OF THE STRUCTURE AND THE REAR YARDS
5:39:56PM OF THESE.
5:39:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: AND IS THERE -- WHAT I SAW FROM THE
5:39:59PM OVERHEAD, IS THERE A LANDSCAPE BUFFER?
5:40:01PM ARE THERE EXISTING TREES THERE?
5:40:04PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THERE ARE EXISTING TREES.
5:40:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO YOU HAVE AN IMAGE OF WHAT THOSE TREES
5:40:08PM LOOK LIKE?
5:40:09PM IT'S NOT A COUPLE OF PALM TREES.
5:40:11PM IT'S TREE TREES.
5:40:12PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: I DON'T HAVE AN IMAGE OF THE TREES DIRECTLY
5:40:15PM ON-SITE BECAUSE WHEN I DROVE OUT ON-SITE, LIKE WHEN YOU'RE
5:40:18PM ON MISSION HILLS FOR HER PROPERTY, IT'S HARD BECAUSE THIS
5:40:24PM HOME IS SET BACK SO FAR, IT'S HARD TO SEE.
5:40:27PM THESE ARE PRETTY DEEP LOTS.
5:40:29PM LIKE THIS LOT IS PRETTY LARGE.
5:40:30PM THESE ARE PRETTY LARGE PARCELS THAT ARE JUST KIND OF
5:40:33PM REMAINING, BUT THEY ARE THE SINGLE-FAMILY.
5:40:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
5:40:36PM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN AND THEN HURTAK.
5:40:39PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN YOU ZOOM OUT A LITTLE BIT?
5:40:41PM IS THERE ANYTHING IN PROXIMITY -- ANYTHING IN PROXIMITY TO
5:40:46PM THIS SITE THAT EXCEEDS ZONING THAT WOULD ALLOW ABOVE 35
5:40:52PM FEET, ANYWHERE IN THIS AREA?
5:40:54PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: MAYBE ON -- EVEN LOOKING AT THE MULTIFAMILY
5:40:58PM THAT EXISTS ON THE EAST, WHEN YOU GET -- ONCE YOU APPROACH
5:41:02PM MYRTLE STREET.
5:41:05PM SO THESE, EVEN THESE ARE KIND OF WITHIN THAT HEIGHT.
5:41:11PM I DIDN'T SEE ANYTHING THAT WAS REALLY TALLER THAN THAT.
5:41:14PM IT'S POSSIBLE TOWARDS 52nd.
5:41:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
5:41:20PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I'M GOING TO ASK THE MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC IF
5:41:24PM YOU COULD COME UP.
5:41:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:41:30PM >> NOIENYA DELGADO.
5:41:33PM >>LYNN HURTAK: DID YOU GET YOUR QUESTIONS ANSWERED?
5:41:36PM >> NO.
5:41:36PM I WANT TO KNOW HOW THESE 35 FAMILIES ARE GOING TO LIVE IN MY
5:41:39PM BACKYARD.
5:41:40PM THAT'S THE THING.
5:41:43PM TO GIVE YOU A LITTLE BIT MORE DETAILS, THERE ARE ON
5:41:47PM LINEBAUGH AVENUE AND MISSION HILLS, TWO SENIOR CITIZEN
5:41:49PM CENTERS.
5:41:50PM THOSE ARE MULTILEVEL, BUT THEY HAVE PLENTY OF SPACE.
5:41:55PM I DON'T KNOW HOW YOU'RE GOING TO GET 35 UNITS INTO A
5:41:58PM LANDLOCKED LOT.
5:41:59PM WHERE IS YOUR EASEMENT?
5:42:01PM WHERE IS THE TRAFFIC?
5:42:01PM HOW ARE YOU GOING TO GET -- BECAUSE MY NEXT CONCERN IS, WHEN
5:42:05PM YOU APPROVE THIS, OH, CAN WE BORROW YOUR DRIVEWAY?
5:42:09PM I DO HAVE AN EASEMENT FOR THEM TO GET TO THEIR LANDLOCKED
5:42:12PM LOT FOR 35 FAMILIES.
5:42:18PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
5:42:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
5:42:19PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I WANT IT CLEAR IN MY MIND.
5:42:22PM THE LOT THAT YOU OWN WHERE YOU BUILT YOUR HOME, WAS THAT
5:42:25PM LAND LOCKED AT ONE TIME?
5:42:27PM >> NO.
5:42:28PM MINE SITS ON LINEBAUGH AVENUE.
5:42:30PM THE LOT THAT IS IN QUESTION IS LANDLOCKED BY MY LOT AND THE
5:42:35PM DUPLEX LOT ON 97th.
5:42:37PM IT SITS IN THE MIDDLE --
5:42:40PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: L SHAPE THAT COMES BACK?
5:42:42PM >> NO, MINE IS L BUT THAT'S -- YEAH.
5:42:44PM THIS IS MINE.
5:42:46PM MINE WAS NEVER LANDLOCKED.
5:42:48PM THIS IS MINE.
5:42:50PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THAT'S YOURS, RIGHT?
5:42:51PM >> YEAH.
5:42:52PM AND THERE IS A HOUSE.
5:42:54PM RIGHT HERE, THIS IS A HOME AND THIS DRIVEWAY, THAT'S MY
5:42:57PM EASEMENT FROM THE STREET AND THIS IS MY HOME.
5:43:00PM AND THIS IS THE SITE THAT THEY ARE PROPOSING.
5:43:05PM THERE ARE PLENTY OF TREES THERE IN BETWEEN MY YARD AND THE
5:43:09PM PROPOSED SITE, BUT THEN THESE -- OVER HERE, THESE ARE
5:43:14PM ALREADY BUILT.
5:43:16PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: IT LOOKS LIKE YOU HAVE ABOUT A 45-FOOT
5:43:19PM WIDE LOT AREA TO GET BACK INTO YOUR HOUSE OR 50-FOOT.
5:43:22PM I DON'T KNOW THE WIDTH OF IT COMING DOWN.
5:43:25PM >> I HAVE A DECENT SIZE YARD.
5:43:30PM BUT IT'S ONLY ONE FAMILY.
5:43:31PM IT'S ONLY FOUR PEOPLE LIVING THERE.
5:43:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: CAN YOU PULL UP THE SCREEN A LITTLE BIT?
5:43:35PM I WANT TO SEE YOUR PARCEL IN QUESTION.
5:43:38PM THERE IS A ROAD THERE -- YOU HAVE ACCESS TO THIS SITE,
5:43:45PM CORRECT?
5:43:46PM >> I WANT TO CLARIFY THAT THE ONLY ACCESS TO THE SITE IS ON
5:43:49PM 97th, WHICH IS HERE.
5:43:50PM THE ACCESS TO THE SITE WOULD BE HERE.
5:43:52PM THERE'S NO ACCESS TO THE REAR.
5:43:54PM TO THE LADY'S PROPERTY.
5:43:58PM IT'S JUST ONLY TO 97th HERE.
5:44:00PM THE ASSEMBLAGE.
5:44:04PM THIS IS THE ASSEMBLAGE, AND THIS WOULD BE THE ACCESS POINT
5:44:06PM HERE.
5:44:07PM THE LADY IS HERE.
5:44:08PM THERE'S NO ACCESS TO THE REAR.
5:44:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
5:44:10PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:44:12PM DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING ELSE TO ADD, SIR?
5:44:14PM CLOSING COMMENTS?
5:44:16PM >> AGAIN THAT WE CONTACT THE 60 RESIDENTS IN THE AREA AND WE
5:44:19PM JUST HAD ONE, WITH GREAT RESPECT, WE HAVE ONE WOMAN HERE,
5:44:22PM THANK YOU, THAT APPEARS TO HAVE A WIDE BUFFER AND VERY
5:44:26PM INTENSIVE SCREENING.
5:44:27PM THANK YOU.
5:44:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL
5:44:29PM MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:44:29PM DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
5:44:30PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
5:44:32PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:44:33PM AYE.
5:44:33PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:44:34PM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA, WOULD YOU LIKE TO READ ITEM NUMBER 2.
5:44:37PM >>LUIS VIERA: SO I'M VERY CONFLICTED ON THIS ONE.
5:44:42PM WE OBVIOUSLY NEED HOUSING IN THE CITY OF TAMPA.
5:44:47PM WE IDENTIFY CERTAIN AREAS, REALLY ALL THE CITY OF TAMPA IS
5:44:51PM OBVIOUSLY RIPE FOR HOUSING.
5:44:54PM IT'S NOT RELEVANT TO THE HEARING.
5:44:58PM YOU KNOW, I'M GOING BACK AND FORTH ON THIS ONE, TO BE
5:45:03PM HONEST.
5:45:03PM I AM.
5:45:06PM I THINK THAT WE CAN READ IT ON FIRST READING, PASS IT
5:45:09PM FORWARD, AND THEN MAYBE HAVE THE APPLICANT CONTINUE TO REACH
5:45:13PM OUT TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND THEN SEE WHERE IT GOES ON THE
5:45:15PM SECOND ROUND.
5:45:16PM TURNING AWAY A LEVEL OF HOUSING, IT'S A -- LET ME DO THIS.
5:45:23PM I'LL READ IT, SEE WHERE IT GOES.
5:45:25PM LET'S SEE WHERE IT GOES.
5:45:26PM READ AN ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING
5:45:28PM CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL
5:45:30PM VICINITY OF 5006 EAST 97th AVENUE AND FOLIO NUMBER
5:45:34PM 142834-0025, 142830-5075, 142830-5050, 142830-5025 AND
5:45:50PM 142830-5000, IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA MORE PARTICULARLY
5:45:55PM DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1 FROM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION
5:45:58PM RS-60, RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY, TO RM-24, RESIDENTIAL
5:46:02PM MULTIFAMILY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
5:46:04PM I FIND THAT THE APPLICANT HAS MET ITS BURDEN OF PROOF TO
5:46:11PM PROVIDE COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE THAT THE REZONING
5:46:13PM IS CONSISTENT WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION REPORT AND I
5:46:18PM ADOPT THE FINDINGS AND REASONING OF THE SAID REPORT.
5:46:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
5:46:26PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I'LL SECOND.
5:46:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
5:46:29PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:46:29PM AYE.
5:46:34PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:46:35PM >> NO.
5:46:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: FOR CLARIFICATION -- YEAH, LET'S DO A
5:46:39PM ROLL CALL.
5:46:40PM SOUNDED LIKE 3-3.
5:46:41PM GO AHEAD.
5:46:43PM >>THE CLERK: CARLSON?
5:46:43PM HURTAK?
5:46:44PM >>LYNN HURTAK: NO.
5:46:46PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: NO.
5:46:48PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: NO.
5:46:50PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
5:46:51PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
5:46:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
5:47:00PM >>THE CLERK: HURTAK, CLENDENIN, HENDERSON VOTING NO.
5:47:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IT'S A TIE VOTE.
5:47:09PM IT WILL COME BACK AT THE NEXT REGULAR MEETING WHEN WE HAVE A
5:47:12PM FULL COUNCIL, AND THEN WE WOULD TAKE IT UP THERE.
5:47:16PM >>LUIS VIERA: I HAVE A QUESTION FOR MR. SHELBY.
5:47:18PM IT'S CLOSE, SO I DON'T WANT TO SPEAK TO THE APPLICANT,
5:47:23PM RIGHT?
5:47:23PM BUT DURING THIS TIME MR. PRESSMAN CAN MEET WITH THE
5:47:27PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND MAYBE LOOK AT POTENTIAL REFORMS IN HIS
5:47:32PM DISCRETION, IF HE WISHES IN THE PROJECT, AM I CORRECT?
5:47:34PM I'M GETTING A NO.
5:47:36PM STRIKE THE SECOND QUESTION.
5:47:38PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: WELL, THE ANSWER TO YOUR QUESTION IS WHAT
5:47:42PM NORMALLY HAPPENS AT A SITUATION SUCH AS THIS IS THE HEARING
5:47:46PM IS AUTOMATICALLY REOPENED.
5:47:47PM SO LET THE RECORD REFLECT THAT THE HEARING IS REOPENED,
5:47:50PM WHICH MEANS THAT THE MOTION HAS TO COME BACK.
5:47:55PM IT FAILS.
5:47:55PM SO A NEW MOTION HAS TO BE MADE.
5:47:57PM THE COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON WOULD HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
5:47:59PM HAVE REVIEWED THE RECORD AND BE PREPARED TO VOTE.
5:48:02PM CUSTOMARILY, IF HE HAS NO QUESTIONS AND IS PREPARED TO VOTE,
5:48:07PM THE HEARING WILL THEN BE CLOSED.
5:48:09PM A NEW MOTION IS MADE AND A VOTE IS THEN TAKEN ON THAT
5:48:12PM MOTION.
5:48:13PM >>LUIS VIERA: NO.
5:48:14PM MY POINT IS -- WELL, YOU KNOW WHAT, I THINK MY POINT -- I'M
5:48:18PM NOT GOING TO SAY ANYTHING.
5:48:20PM DISREGARD.
5:48:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
5:48:21PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
5:48:24PM NEXT REGULAR MEETING, WOULD THAT BE NEXT THURSDAY?
5:48:27PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YES.
5:48:28PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THAT'S NOT GOING TO BE POSSIBLE BECAUSE I'M
5:48:33PM GOING TO BE OUT.
5:48:33PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HOW ABOUT JUNE 6?
5:48:38PM >> I'M OUT OF TOWN ON JUNE 6.
5:48:47PM >> CAN THE APPLICANT CHANGE HIS REQUEST BETWEEN THIS MEETING
5:48:50PM AND THE NEXT MEETING?
5:48:51PM I'M DOING IT VERY GENERALLY.
5:48:55PM I KNOW YOU WERE GOING TO GET INTO SPECIFICS.
5:48:58PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I GUESS THAT IS A QUESTION --
5:49:01PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IT WOULD BE THE 20th.
5:49:04PM >> CATE WELLS, LEGAL DEPARTMENT, WITH REGARD TO THAT
5:49:06PM QUESTION, THE APPLICANT CAN ALWAYS REQUEST A ZONING DISTRICT
5:49:10PM THAT IS LESS INTENSE.
5:49:12PM SO I THINK WHAT WAS DISCUSSED THIS EVENING, THE NEXT LOWEST
5:49:14PM ONE IS RM 18.
5:49:18PM THEY CAN ALWAYS GO LESS DENSE.
5:49:18PM THEY CAN'T GO HIGHER OR EXPAND THE SCOPE OF THE ZONING AREA.
5:49:23PM AND WITH REGARD TO THE ONE COMMENT ABOUT MEETING WITH THE
5:49:26PM PUBLIC AND MAYBE YOU CAN MAKE SOME REFORMS, THIS ISN'T SITE
5:49:29PM PLAN CONTROLLED.
5:49:31PM IT IS EUCLIDEAN.
5:49:32PM SO I THINK THE ONLY REFORM POTENTIALLY WOULD BE CONSIDERING
5:49:37PM A LESS DENSE ZONING DISTRICT THAT WOULD STILL ALLOW FOR THE
5:49:41PM MULTIFAMILY TYPE DEVELOPMENT.
5:49:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
5:49:44PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I'M ACTUALLY JUST GOING TO MAKE A PLEA.
5:49:53PM CAN WE DO ANOTHER VOTE OR ARE WE DONE?
5:50:01PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: LET ME TAKE A LOOK.
5:50:04PM >>LYNN HURTAK: CATE IS NODDING.
5:50:06PM SHE SAID YES.
5:50:06PM I WANT TO MAKE A BIT OF AN ARGUMENT THAT TECHNICALLY YOU
5:50:11PM CAN'T GO UP, BUT YOU'RE GONNA BE ABLE TO GO UP.
5:50:14PM IT'S GONNA BE MORE THAN THREE STORIES.
5:50:16PM AND I THINK THAT LOOKING AT THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE
5:50:21PM NEIGHBORHOOD NOW, THAT THAT'S NOT APPROPRIATE.
5:50:24PM IT DOESN'T MATTER.
5:50:25PM FOUR STORIES IS WAY TOO MUCH.
5:50:28PM THREE STORIES IS GOING TO BE HIGHER THAN ANYTHING ALREADY.
5:50:31PM I THINK THREE STORIES IS A MAX THAT THE NEIGHBORHOOD CAN
5:50:37PM HANDLE WHEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT CONSISTENCY WITH WHAT'S
5:50:40PM SURROUNDING IT.
5:50:41PM SO I'M GOING TO ARGUE THAT WE SHOULD TRY FOR A DENIAL.
5:50:49PM I DON'T KNOW IF ANYBODY WOULD BE WILLING FOR THAT.
5:50:51PM BUT STAIR STEPPING ISN'T GOING TO SAVE THE NEIGHBORS FROM A
5:50:55PM FOUR TO FIVE FOOT BUILDING -- I'M SORRY, FOUR TO FIVE STORY
5:50:59PM BUILDING.
5:51:01PM >>LUIS VIERA: FOR ME, I'M TRYING BALANCE A NUMBER OF THINGS,
5:51:04PM INCLUDING HOUSING IN THIS AREA, ET CETERA.
5:51:07PM YOUR SENTIMENTS I'M VERY, VERY SYMPATHETIC TO AND I'LL LEAVE
5:51:11PM IT AT THAT FOR THE RECORD.
5:51:12PM BUT, YEAH, I'LL --
5:51:14PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: SORRY, I DON'T WANT TO INTERPRET.
5:51:18PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I HAVE A QUESTION, AND MAYBE THIS IS BACK
5:51:21PM TO STAFF.
5:51:21PM MAYBE THE GOOD THING FOR THE APPLICANT OF US HANDLING THIS
5:51:26PM THE WAY WE DID THIS EVENING IS IT GIVES THEM AN OPPORTUNITY
5:51:28PM TO MAYBE RETHINK AND MAYBE GO IN A DIRECTION THAT WAY.
5:51:32PM BUT IF WE DID IT THIS WAY, IT'S DONE, RIGHT?
5:51:35PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THERE IS ANOTHER OPTION.
5:51:37PM THERE IS A THIRD OPTION.
5:51:38PM AND THIS IS, AGAIN, SO THE COUNCIL IS CLEAR FOR THE RECORD
5:51:42PM AND SO IS THE APPLICANT, WE ARE REFERRING TO -- I WANT TO
5:51:49PM RECITE CHAPTER AND VERSE.
5:51:50PM RELYING ON RULE 6 UNDER QUASI-JUDICIAL HEARING.
5:51:54PM RULE H, IF A MOTION IN A QUASI-JUDICIAL MATTER FAILS TO
5:51:57PM RECEIVE AT LEAST FOUR VOTES, THE MOTION FAILS.
5:52:01PM IF ANOTHER MOTION IN ORDER IS NOT MADE, THE PUBLIC HEARING
5:52:04PM SHALL BE AUTOMATICALLY REOPENED AND CONTINUED TO A TIME
5:52:07PM CERTAIN AT THE NEXT REGULARLY SCHEDULED COUNCIL MEETING,
5:52:10PM AGAIN, SUBJECT TO YOUR SCHEDULE.
5:52:12PM SO THE OTHER THING IS THAT IF COUNCIL WISHES TO REOPEN THIS
5:52:16PM PUBLIC HEARING AT THIS TIME, THEY CAN INQUIRE OF THE
5:52:19PM APPLICANT IF HE WISHES TO ASK FOR A CONTINUANCE OR TO BE
5:52:23PM ABLE TO ADDRESS THE REZONING.
5:52:26PM OTHERWISE IT WOULD MOVE FORWARD AS PLANNED TO AN AVAILABLE
5:52:31PM DATE, SUBJECT TO EVERYONE'S AVAILABILITY.
5:52:36PM >> YES, WE --
5:52:38PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: REOPEN, PLEASE.
5:52:40PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I WOULD STILL LIKE THE CHANCE TO MAKE THE
5:52:42PM OTHER MOTION FIRST.
5:52:43PM I DON'T WANT TO HEAR FROM -- I WANT TO GO AHEAD AND MAKE THE
5:52:47PM MOTION TO DENY AND SEE WHERE IT GOES.
5:52:49PM THAT'S THE OPTION, CORRECT?
5:52:51PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: YOU HAVE THAT RIGHT.
5:52:52PM IF THAT IS SECONDED, THAT'S ON THE FLOOR.
5:52:54PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OKAY.
5:52:55PM I'LL GO AHEAD AND MAKE A MOTION TO DENY REZ 23-84 FOR THE
5:53:01PM PROPERTY LOCATED AT 5006 EAST 97th AVENUE, FOLIO NUMBER
5:53:07PM 142,834.0025, 142,830.5075, 142,830.5050, 142,830.5025 AND
5:53:24PM 142,830.5000 FROM RS-60 TO RM-24.
5:53:32PM DUE TO THE FAILURE OF THE APPLICANT TO MEET ITS BURDEN OF
5:53:35PM PROOF TO PROVIDE COMPETENT AND SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE IN THE
5:53:37PM RECORD THAT THE REZONING IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
5:53:39PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND THE CITY CODE.
5:53:42PM ALSO ADOPT THE FINDINGS AND REASONINGS OF THE CITY STAFF.
5:53:45PM BUT MAINLY THAT THE PROPOSED REZONING DOES NOT MEET THE
5:53:49PM DEFINITION OF COMPATIBILITY AS ADOPTED IN THE COMPREHENSIVE
5:53:52PM PLAN, ALTHOUGH THE REQUESTED ZONING DISTRICT MAY BE
5:53:55PM CONSIDERED IN THE RS 30 DESIGNATION, THE MAXIMUM DEVELOPMENT
5:53:59PM POTENTIAL IS OF A HEIGHT, SCALE, MASS, AND BULK THAT IS NOT
5:54:03PM COMPATIBLE WITH THE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED USES LOCATED NEAR
5:54:06PM OR ADJACENT TO THE PROPERTY.
5:54:08PM AND ALTHOUGH COMPATIBILITY DOES NOT MEAN THE SAME AS, IT
5:54:12PM REQUIRES A SENSITIVITY OF DEVELOPMENT IN ORDER TO MAINTAIN
5:54:15PM THE CHARACTER OF EXISTING DEVELOPMENTS.
5:54:17PM THE PROPOSED REZONING WHICH ALLOWS CONSIDERATION OF UP TO 34
5:54:22PM DWELLING UNITS AT MAX I AM HEIGHT OF 60 FEET OR POSSIBLY SIX
5:54:26PM STORIES IS INCONSISTENT WITH THE SURROUNDING SINGLE-FAMILY
5:54:29PM DETACHED AND ATTACHED USES. THIS ALLOWABLE HEIGHT IS OUT OF
5:54:33PM CHARACTER WITH THE SURROUNDING BUILT ENVIRONMENT AND ALLOWS
5:54:35PM FOR A SCALE THAT IS NOT COMPATIBLE WITH THE EXISTING
5:54:38PM DEVELOPMENT PATTERN NOR APPROPRIATE IN THE CENTER OF AN
5:54:40PM ESTABLISHED RESIDENTIAL SINGLE AND MULTIFAMILY BLOCK.
5:54:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
5:54:48PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SECOND.
5:54:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
5:54:50PM HENDERSON.
5:54:50PM ANY DISCUSSION?
5:54:51PM IF NOT, I'LL ASK FOR A ROLL CALL VOTE.
5:54:55PM >>THE CLERK: VIERA?
5:54:56PM >>LUIS VIERA: NO.
5:54:58PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: NO.
5:55:01PM >> CARLSON?
5:55:01PM HURTAK?
5:55:02PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
5:55:04PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
5:55:06PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
5:55:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO.
5:55:16PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: WHAT HAPPENS NOW IS THAT IF THERE IS A
5:55:20PM MOTION THAT IS MADE TO CONTINUE IT TO A DATE AND TIME
5:55:23PM CERTAIN, THE HEARING IS AUTOMATICALLY REOPENED.
5:55:25PM IF THERE IS A DESIRE OF CITY COUNCIL TO DISCUSS THIS
5:55:27PM FURTHER, THERE COULD BE A MOTION TO REOPEN THE PUBLIC
5:55:29PM HEARING NOW.
5:55:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA, SECOND
5:55:32PM FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:55:34PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:55:34PM THE HEARING IS REOPENED.
5:55:38PM >>LUIS VIERA: COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK'S MOTION, THERE IS
5:55:42PM SYMPATHY I HAVE WITH THAT, I DO.
5:55:44PM I BELIEVE IN TRYING TO KEEP THIS ALIVE TO GET THE GOOD OUT
5:55:48PM OF WHAT WE CAN FOR THE HOUSING.
5:55:49PM I THINK THAT'S VERY, VERY IMPORTANT HERE.
5:55:51PM BUT, AGAIN, I AM VERY SYMPATHETIC ON THE ISSUE OF SCALE AND
5:55:55PM MASSING, ET CETERA.
5:55:56PM SO THAT'S JUST -- YEAH, THAT'S IT.
5:56:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HOW IS JUNE 20th?
5:56:04PM >> I THINK THAT WILL BE FINE.
5:56:06PM BEAR WITH ME ONE SECOND, PLEASE.
5:56:13PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN THE APPLICANT --
5:56:15PM >> YEAH, JUNE 20 WORKS.
5:56:16PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN THE APPLICANT TODAY AT THIS HEARING
5:56:20PM AMEND HIS REQUEST FOR A LOWER EUCLIDEAN REZONING REQUEST?
5:56:26PM >> MAY I RESPOND TO THAT?
5:56:28PM I DO WANT TO CONSIDER IT BUT I DON'T KNOW ALL THE CHANGES.
5:56:31PM I DON'T WANT TO JUMP -- DEFINITELY WANT TO CONSIDER IT AND
5:56:35PM WE WILL CONSIDER IT.
5:56:36PM I NEED TO UNDERSTAND IT.
5:56:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
5:56:38PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:56:40PM ALSO WHAT CAN HAPPEN IS AFTER THIS HEARING, IF THE APPLICANT
5:56:44PM DESIRES TO LOWER HIS REQUEST AND REQUEST TO AMEND IT FOR RM
5:56:50PM 18, HE CAN DO SO.
5:56:52PM WE CAN CERTAINLY GO BACK TO ANOTHER FIRST READING, IF HE
5:56:56PM DOES IT BETWEEN NOW AND THE NEXT READING, AND THEN YOU WOULD
5:56:59PM HEAR THE CASE AND THEN VOTE AGAIN.
5:57:04PM THAT HAPPENS SOMETIMES.
5:57:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA AND COUNCILMAN --
5:57:07PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN.
5:57:08PM IN FACT, WHAT I WAS HOPEFUL IS THAT THE APPLICANT AND THE
5:57:11PM NEIGHBORHOOD OR THE NEIGHBORS GET TOGETHER AND SEE WHAT CAN
5:57:14PM BE DONE.
5:57:15PM HOUSING IS NEEDED HERE SO BADLY.
5:57:16PM I'M NOT HERE TO PUSH ANYTHING ON ANYBODY.
5:57:18PM IT'S VERY DIFFICULT.
5:57:19PM I DON'T DISAGREE OR AGREE WITH ANYTHING THAT MY COUNCIL
5:57:23PM MEMBERS HAVE SAID, BUT THERE IS A NEED AND THERE IS A
5:57:27PM COMPROMISE THAT COULD BE WORKED OUT.
5:57:29PM WHEN YOU LOOK AT FEET, FIVE FEET, FROM HOME TO FIRST IS 90
5:57:36PM FEET, HOME TO SECOND 120 FEET, HOME TO PITCHER MOUND, 160
5:57:41PM FEET.
5:57:42PM THAT GIVES YOU THE SCALE.
5:57:43PM MAYBE WITHIN THAT 60 FEET THERE COULD BE A CHANGE AND THAT'S
5:57:47PM ALL I'M SAYING.
5:57:48PM I CAN'T SPEAK FOR EITHER ONE FOR THE HOMEOWNER WHO I
5:57:50PM UNDERSTAND WHAT SHE'S SAYING AND FOR THE DEVELOPER,
5:57:53PM UNDERSTAND WHAT THEY ARE SAYING.
5:57:54PM JUST THROWING THAT OUT TO SEE WHAT WOULD HAPPEN.
5:57:57PM THANK YOU.
5:58:01PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THE ONLY THING I WOULD RECOMMEND IS THAT YOU
5:58:03PM GET CONTACT INFO FOR THE NEIGHBORS SO THAT MAYBE THERE COULD
5:58:06PM BE MORE COMMUNICATION BETWEEN HER AND THEN MAYBE SOME OTHER
5:58:10PM NEIGHBORS AS WELL.
5:58:11PM YES, BUT I THINK A CHANGE OF ZONING TO SOMETHING A LITTLE
5:58:18PM LESS HIGH WOULD PROBABLY -- MIGHT GET A DIFFERENT VOTE.
5:58:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. SHELBY.
5:58:25PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: JUST A REMINDER, COUNCIL.
5:58:28PM THIS IS SOMEWHAT DIFFERENT THAN YOUR USUAL 3-3 TIE.
5:58:33PM MY RECOMMENDATION NOW THAT THE HEARING IS OPEN, COULD BE A
5:58:36PM REQUEST FROM MR. PRESSMAN FOR A DATE -- A CONTINUANCE.
5:58:41PM OF COURSE, I WILL ASK COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON TO HAVE
5:58:44PM REVIEWED THE RECORD SO YOU DON'T HAVE TO GO THROUGH A WHOLE
5:58:47PM FULL HEARING BUT YOU COULD BEGIN BY HEARING FROM THE
5:58:49PM APPLICANT, NOT JUST CLOSING THE HEARING RIGHT OFF THE BAT
5:58:52PM AND BE ABLE TO HAVE TO VOTE.
5:58:54PM MY RECOMMENDATION WOULD BE TO SEE WHAT'S ACCEPTABLE TO THE
5:58:57PM CLERK AND TO COUNCIL AND CERTAINLY TO MR. PRESSMAN FOR A
5:59:00PM DATE FOR CONTINUANCE.
5:59:02PM >> JUNE 20 WOULD WORK.
5:59:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA, SECOND
5:59:08PM FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:59:10PM JUNE 20, 2024, HERE, 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD
5:59:13PM FLOOR.
5:59:14PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:59:16PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: DID WE SAY A TIME?
5:59:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: 1:00, 10:30?
5:59:28PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: 10:30 FOR A FIRST READING?
5:59:31PM IT WILL CHANGE BY THEN, PERHAPS.
5:59:36PM DON'T LEAVE UNTIL WE HAVE A DATE.
5:59:40PM WHERE IS THE PUBLIC?
5:59:42PM SHE IS OUT.
5:59:43PM COULD WE CALL THEM BACK, PLEASE?
5:59:45PM I WANT THEM TO HEAR THIS.
5:59:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A 1:30 REVIEW HEARINGS.
5:59:51PM 1 WILL BE 1:30 BY THEN.
5:59:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS 1:30 GOOD?
6:00:00PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: 1:30 IN THE AFTERNOON THAT DAY?
6:00:02PM >> OF THE 20th?
6:00:04PM >> FOR MYSELF, YES.
6:00:06PM >> YEAH, I'LL MAKE IT HAPPEN.
6:00:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
6:00:08PM WE'LL SEE YOU THEN.
6:00:10PM >> THANK YOU.
6:00:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:00:11PM ITEM NUMBER 3.
6:00:13PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, CHAIRMAN AND COUNCIL.
6:00:15PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:00:17PM ITEM 3 IS REZ 24-28 FOR THE PROPERTY AT 1102 WEST OHIO
6:00:21PM AVENUE.
6:00:22PM THIS REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY FROM RS 60 TO RS 50.
6:00:26PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO DAVID TO GIVE HIS REPORT AND I'LL COME
6:00:29PM BACK AND GIVE MY REPORT.
6:00:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:00:39PM >>DAVID HEY: GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL MEMBERS.
6:00:41PM DAVID HEY WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
6:00:43PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
6:00:44PM WE MOVE DOWN TO THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT FOR THIS
6:00:47PM NEXT CASE.
6:00:49PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE RIVERSIDE HEIGHTS
6:00:54PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:00:55PM PLYMOUTH PARK TO THE SOUTHEAST AND FREEDOM PARK TO THE
6:00:58PM NORTHEAST ARE THE CLOSEST PUBLIC RECREATION FACILITIES.
6:01:01PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN THE COASTAL PLANNING AREA AND
6:01:05PM MORE SPECIFICALLY LOCATED IN EVACUATION ZONE C.
6:01:09PM HERE WE HAVE AN AERIAL.
6:01:12PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS RIGHT THERE IN THE CENTER.
6:01:14PM THE SUBJECT SITE AND ALL THE TAN COLOR IS THAT RESIDENTIAL
6:01:19PM 10.
6:01:20PM YOU ONLY GET ADDITIONAL INTENSITY AND DENSITY UP ALONG DR.
6:01:25PM MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. BOULEVARD WITH THE PINK.
6:01:28PM THAT'S ALL THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35.
6:01:33PM AND THEN THESE ARE THE PARKS IN GREEN WITH THE REC OPEN
6:01:37PM SPACE CATEGORY.
6:01:39PM I SHOULD HAVE SHOWN THE AERIAL.
6:01:41PM BUT THE AERIAL YOU CAN SEE THAT IT'S MOSTLY ALL
6:01:44PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED.
6:01:45PM THE SUBJECT SITE AGAIN IS WITHIN THAT RESIDENTIAL 10.
6:01:53PM THE SURROUNDING AREA IS PREDOMINANTLY RESIDENTIAL IN
6:01:56PM CHARACTER.
6:01:56PM THIS PORTION OF WEST OHIO AVENUE BETWEEN NORTH RIDGE AVENUE
6:01:59PM AND NORTH OAKDALE AVENUE, EXCLUDING THE SUBJECT SITE, HAS AN
6:02:04PM EXISTING DENSITY OF 5.56 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE.
6:02:07PM THAT IS BASED ON TEN SAMPLE SITES WITHIN THAT BLOCK.
6:02:11PM THE EXISTING DENSITY ON THIS PORTION OF WEST OHIO AVENUE IS
6:02:15PM APPROXIMATELY 55% OF THE DENSITY ANTICIPATED UNDER THAT
6:02:19PM RESIDENTIAL 10 DESIGNATION.
6:02:21PM THE PROPOSED REZONING WILL ALLOW CONSIDERATION OF TWO
6:02:23PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED ZONING LOTS AT A DENSITY OF 6.45
6:02:28PM UNITS PER ACRE ON THE SUBJECT SITE IN AN AREA PLANNED FOR UP
6:02:33PM TO 10 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE.
6:02:35PM DUE TO THE PRESENCE OF SINGLE-FAMILY USES IN THE SURROUNDING
6:02:37PM AREA AND THE PROPOSED DENSITY, PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
6:02:40PM FINDS THAT THE REQUEST WILL NOT ALTER THE CHARACTER OF THE
6:02:42PM SURROUNDING AREA AND IS COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH THIS
6:02:46PM PORTION OF WEST OHIO AVENUE.
6:02:48PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN RECOGNIZES THE IMPORTANCE OF
6:02:51PM SINGLE-FAMILY NEIGHBORHOODS SEEKING TO PROMOTE COMPATIBLE
6:02:54PM DEVELOPMENT OF NEIGHBORHOODS TO ENSURE ECONOMIC HEALTH AND
6:02:57PM THAT AN ADEQUATE AMOUNT OF LAND IS PLANNED FOR THE CITY'S
6:03:01PM GROWING POPULATION.
6:03:02PM BY APPROVAL OF THE REZONING, THE SUBJECT SITE HAS THE
6:03:05PM POTENTIAL TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL INFILL HOUSING ON AN
6:03:11PM UNDERUTILIZED PARCEL WITHIN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING
6:03:14PM DISTRICT.
6:03:14PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF
6:03:18PM DOES FIND THE PROPOSED REZONING CONSISTENT WITH THE
6:03:21PM PROVISIONS OF THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:03:23PM I'M AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
6:03:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
6:03:26PM >>LUIS VIERA: I DON'T HAVE A QUESTION.
6:03:27PM I'M JUST GOING TO SAY, DAVID, IT'S GOOD TO SEE YOU AT CITY
6:03:30PM COUNCIL.
6:03:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I SECOND.
6:03:32PM >>LUIS VIERA: I MEAN THAT.
6:03:34PM >>DAVID HEY: THEY BRING ME OUT EVERY ONCE IN A WHILE.
6:03:37PM >>LUIS VIERA: YOU ARE A GENTLEMAN.
6:03:39PM >>DAVID HEY: THANKS.
6:03:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
6:03:41PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU AGAIN, COUNCIL.
6:03:42PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:03:45PM SO THIS REQUEST FOR THE RS 50 ZONING IS FOR A PROPERTY WITH
6:03:51PM A LOT AREA OF 13,650 SQUARE FEET.
6:03:55PM THE LOT FRONTAGE IS 105 FEET AND THEN THE DEPTH IS 130 FEET.
6:04:02PM IN THIS ZONING DISTRICT, MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT OF 35 FEET
6:04:07PM IS PERMITTED.
6:04:08PM THIS IS THE SURVEY SUBMITTED.
6:04:13PM THIS IS OHIO AVENUE.
6:04:14PM THIS PROPERTY IS LOCATED ON THE CORNER.
6:04:16PM IT IS A CORNER SITE.
6:04:18PM THIS IS KINYON AVENUE THAT'S LOCATED HERE.
6:04:21PM THIS IS THE 105 FEET OF WIDTH AND THIS IS THE DEPTH OF THE
6:04:24PM LOT.
6:04:25PM IT HAS THE EXISTING ONE-STORY HOME ON THE SITE.
6:04:28PM THIS IS A PART OF NORTH RIVERSIDE SUBDIVISION.
6:04:31PM BLOCK 23, LOT 1 IN THE EAST 45 FEET OF LOT 2.
6:04:36PM THE RS 50 ZONING DISTRICT REQUIRES A MINIMUM LOT AREA OF
6:04:40PM 5,000 SQUARE FEET SO THIS WOULD MEET THE STANDARD.
6:04:44PM IF IT WERE DIVIDED IT WOULD MEET THE MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS
6:04:47PM FOR THE RS 50.
6:04:48PM I WANT TO SHOW YOU THE ZONING MAP AND THEN I'LL SHOW THE
6:04:56PM CONFORMING MAP AND DISCUSS IT.
6:04:58PM SO THIS IS THE PROPERTY THAT'S LOCATED HERE IN RED.
6:05:01PM THIS IS KINYON AVENUE.
6:05:04PM THIS IS OHIO.
6:05:05PM THIS IS RIDGE AVENUE.
6:05:06PM THIS IS OAKDALE, JUST AS A POINT OF REFERENCE.
6:05:11PM BUT THIS SITE YOU CAN SEE HAS THE ZONING SURROUNDING IT OF
6:05:16PM RS 60.
6:05:18PM YOU DO HAVE A COUPLE OF PD REZONINGS THAT ARE NORTH OF THE
6:05:22PM SITE.
6:05:22PM SO THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:05:24PM WITHIN ONE BLOCK IS THE PD.
6:05:26PM THIS WAS A PD THAT WAS APPROVED IN 06.
6:05:30PM THIS ALSO WAS A SPLIT THAT WAS APPROVED.
6:05:34PM THESE TWO PDs THAT ARE LOCATED HERE IS THE SAME.
6:05:38PM I'LL SHOW YOU ON THE CONFORMING MAP AND YOU CAN SEE THE
6:05:42PM WIDTH OF THE DRIVE AISLE FROM THE ROADWAY TO SEE THAT THESE
6:05:45PM WERE SPLIT.
6:05:47PM ALSO AND APPROVED.
6:05:49PM BUT THE REMAINDER OF THE ZONING IS THE RS 60.
6:05:53PM AS YOU CROSS THE RIVER, YOU HAVE THE RS 50 ZONING FURTHER
6:05:57PM NORTHWEST.
6:05:57PM SO THIS IS THE CONFORMING MAP.
6:06:03PM SO THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:06:09PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE THAT'S HATCHED HERE.
6:06:13PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT BLOCK, OF COURSE.
6:06:17PM SO YOU CAN SEE THAT THIS BLOCK IS UNIQUE.
6:06:20PM IT IS AT THE END OF THE ROAD.
6:06:23PM OHIO AND RIDGE AVENUE IS HERE.
6:06:26PM ADJACENT TO THE PROPERTY ON THE WEST IS A VACANT LOT.
6:06:29PM SO THIS IS A BIT UNIQUE COMPARED TO THE BLOCK PATTERN OF THE
6:06:33PM REMAINDER OF THE ANALYSIS AREA.
6:06:36PM WHICH HAS COMPLETE BLOCKS ON IT.
6:06:39PM I'LL READ THE ANALYSIS THAT WAS PROVIDED FOR THIS BLOCK,
6:06:44PM THIS ONE AND THEN THIS BLOCK ALSO TO THE SOUTH.
6:06:46PM IN THE STAFF REPORT, STARTING ON PAGE 3 OF THE STAFF REPORT
6:06:51PM CONTAINS THE ANALYSIS.
6:06:52PM SO THE AREA OF ANALYSIS AND IF THAT MAP COULD REMAIN,
6:06:57PM PLEASE.
6:06:57PM THE AREA OF ANALYSIS INCLUDES 234 TOTAL ZONING LOTS.
6:07:02PM 233 LOTS ARE 95% HAVE BEEN DEVELOPED WITH A WIDTH OF 60 FEET
6:07:07PM OR GREATER AND 11 LOTS OR 5% HAVE BEEN DEVELOPED WITH A
6:07:10PM WIDTH OF 59.99 FEET OR LESS.
6:07:13PM THE SUBJECT BLOCK IS THE SMALLEST BLOCK IN THE STUDY AREA.
6:07:17PM PURSUANT TO A REVIEW OF THE EXISTING DEVELOPMENT PATTERN,
6:07:20PM THE SUBJECT BLOCK ON WEST OHIO AVENUE, THIS IS FROM NORTH
6:07:23PM KINYON TO NORTH RIDGE AVENUE CONTAINS SEVEN TOTAL ZONING
6:07:28PM LOTS, INCLUDING THE SUBJECT SITE WITH ONE OR 14 PERCENT OF
6:07:31PM THE LOTS DEVELOPED WITH A WIDTH LESS THAN 59.99 FEET.
6:07:34PM AND SIX OR 86% OF THOSE LOTS BEING DEVELOPED WITH A WIDTH OF
6:07:39PM 60 FEET OR GREATER.
6:07:40PM ONE BLOCK SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE ON WEST WOODLAWN AVENUE,
6:07:46PM THIS IS BETWEEN NORTH KINYON AND NORTH RIDGE AVENUE,
6:07:49PM CONTAINS 8 TOTAL ZONING LOTS WITH ONE LOT BEING DEVELOPED AT
6:07:53PM 59.99 FEET OF WIDTH OR LESS.
6:07:56PM AND SEVEN LOTS DEVELOPED AT 60 FEET OR GREATER.
6:08:00PM ONE BLOCK EAST OF THE SUBJECT SITE, WHICH IS LOCATED HERE,
6:08:07PM ON WEST OHIO AVENUE, THIS IS FROM NORTH KINYON AVENUE TO
6:08:11PM NORTH OAKDALE AVENUE, CONTAINS TEN TOTAL ZONING LOTS WITH
6:08:15PM 100% OF THE LOTS DEVELOPED AT A WIDTH OF 60 FEET OR GREATER.
6:08:18PM SO BASED ON THE ANALYSIS, STAFF FOUND THE REQUEST
6:08:22PM INCONSISTENT, BUT AS WE DESCRIBE, AS I DESCRIBED EARLIER,
6:08:28PM THE UNIQUENESS OF THIS BLOCK IS UNDER CONSIDERATION, AND
6:08:32PM THEN IT IS NOT LIKE THE REMAINDER OF THE BLOCK THAT'S WITHIN
6:08:37PM THE STUDY AREA.
6:08:38PM I HAVE PHOTOS OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND SURROUNDING.
6:08:46PM THIS IS THE SITE.
6:08:47PM IT IS A PRETTY WIDE LOT CURRENTLY, SO I HAVE A COUPLE OF
6:08:50PM PICTURES.
6:08:52PM THIS IS THE NORTH SIDE OF THE SITE.
6:08:54PM THAT'S ANOTHER VIEW.
6:08:55PM YOU CAN SEE THE OTHER END OF THE SITE THAT'S LOCATED THERE.
6:08:59PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE, SO THIS IS THE EAST SIDE OF THE
6:09:06PM SITE.
6:09:07PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW OF THE EAST.
6:09:10PM SO THIS IS EAST OF THE SUBJECT SITE, SO THIS IS ACROSS THE
6:09:15PM STREET.
6:09:16PM THIS IS AT THE CORNER AT KINYON.
6:09:19PM THIS IS THE VIEW, THE SUBJECT SITE IS OFF TO THE RIGHT IN
6:09:22PM THIS PICTURE.
6:09:23PM THIS IS IF YOU'RE LOOKING EAST ON OHIO.
6:09:25PM THIS IS THE NORTHEAST CORNER.
6:09:29PM THIS IS NORTHEAST OF THE SITE.
6:09:31PM IT'S NOT THE NORTHEAST CORNER.
6:09:32PM IT'S NORTHEAST OF THE SITE BUT IT'S ACROSS THE STREET FROM
6:09:35PM THE SITE.
6:09:35PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS BEHIND IN THIS PICTURE.
6:09:38PM THIS IS NORTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:09:43PM AND THIS IS FURTHER NORTH, WE'RE APPROACHING RIDGE.
6:09:47PM AND THEN THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW JUST SHOWING YOU AN ANGLE OF
6:09:50PM THE SUBJECT SITE AND THAT IS THE VACANT AND NEXT TO IT IS
6:09:53PM THE VACANT PARCELS.
6:09:54PM AND THAT CONCLUDES STAFF'S PRESENTATION.
6:09:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
6:09:59PM NO.
6:10:01PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:10:02PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU.
6:10:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO WE HAVE AN APPLICANT FOR ITEM NUMBER
6:10:04PM 3?
6:10:27PM >> GOOD AFTERNOON, COUNCIL MEMBERS AND FRIENDS AND HAPPY
6:10:30PM MOTHER'S DAY TO YOU ALL AND ALL THE MOTHERS IN YOUR FAMILY,
6:10:33PM ESPECIALLY DIANA, MY WIFE THAT'S HERE WITH US.
6:10:36PM ANTHONY SCAGLIONE.
6:10:38PM THANK YOU FOR HEARING US TODAY FOR MY PROPERTY AT 1102 WEST
6:10:43PM OHIO AVENUE, TAMPA, FLORIDA.
6:10:44PM I'M HERE WITH MY WIFE AND FOUR NEIGHBOR FRIENDS THAT HAVE
6:10:48PM COME TO SPEAK ON OUR BEHALF.
6:10:50PM KNOWING HOW VALUABLE YOUR TIME IS AND MY FELLOW CITIZENS
6:10:55PM HERE TONIGHT, I PREPARED COMMENTS WITH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS
6:10:57PM TO HOPEFULLY DEMONSTRATE THE MERIT OF OUR REQUEST AND YOUR
6:11:01PM APPROVAL.
6:11:01PM OUR APPLICATION NUMBER IS REZ 24-28, REQUESTING TO BE
6:11:06PM REZONED FROM RESIDENTIAL 60 SINGLE-FAMILY TO RESIDENTIAL 50
6:11:11PM SINGLE-FAMILY.
6:11:11PM WE'RE REPRESENTING OURSELVES HAVING NO ATTORNEY OR
6:11:15PM CONSULTANT, AND THIS APPLICATION IS FOR OUR PERSONAL FAMILY
6:11:18PM USE.
6:11:19PM WE COME BEFORE YOU RESPECTFULLY REQUESTING YOUR
6:11:22PM CONSIDERATION FOR OUR REZONING REQUEST SO OUR FAMILY CAN
6:11:26PM HAVE EXPANDED HOUSING OPTIONS AT OUR PROPERTY, A
6:11:28PM TWO-BEDROOM, ONE BATH HOUSE ON DOUBLE SIZE CORNER LOT
6:11:32PM MEASURED 105 FEET IN THE FRONT, 130 FEET DEEP IN RIVERSIDE
6:11:39PM HEIGHTS.
6:11:39PM YOUR APPROVAL WOULD ALLOW ANOTHER DWELLING TO BE BUILT ON
6:11:42PM THE PROPERTY, WHICH WOULD GIVE OUR EXTENDED FAMILY BETTER
6:11:46PM HOUSING OPTIONS, PARTICULARLY FOR DIANA'S MOTHER, MY
6:11:50PM MOTHER-IN-LAW, CARMEN, WHO IS WIDOWED, PHYSICALLY DISABLED
6:11:55PM AND THAT WE ARE FINANCIALLY RESPONSIBLE FOR.
6:11:57PM A LITTLE BACKGROUND.
6:11:59PM MY FAMILY, THE SCAGLIONES IMMIGRATED LIKE MANY TAMPA
6:12:04PM FAMILIES FROM SICILY TO WORK IN YBOR CITY AND START A NEW
6:12:07PM LIFE.
6:12:07PM FIRST SMALL HOME AND BUSINESS WAS IN YBOR CITY.
6:12:10PM IN THE 1950s, ONCE THEY SAVED ENOUGH MONEY, THEY BOUGHT
6:12:13PM PROPERTY OUTSIDE OF YBOR CITY IN A NEIGHBORHOOD THEN CALLED
6:12:16PM BUFFALO HEIGHTS, NOW RIVERSIDE HEIGHTS.
6:12:18PM THEY BROUGHT IN TRUCKLOADS OF FILL DIRT, LEVELED THE GROUND
6:12:23PM BY HAND.
6:12:24PM RECYCLED BRICKS FROM A DESTROYED BAKERY AND BUILT THEIR HOME
6:12:26PM AT 2902 NORTH PERRY BRICK BY BRICK.
6:12:31PM DRILLED AN ARTESIAN WELL IN THE BACKYARD FOR DRINKING WATER.
6:12:35PM OUR FAMILY HAS CONTRIBUTED, CARED FOR AND LOVED THE
6:12:38PM NEIGHBORHOOD ALONG WITH TAMPA FOR OVER 70 YEARS.
6:12:41PM FROM THIS UNIQUE BACKGROUND, I KNOW THE NEIGHBORHOOD VERY
6:12:43PM WELL AND CONTINUE TO LOVE IT TODAY.
6:12:44PM COMMUNITY OUTREACH.
6:12:48PM BEFORE WE STARTED THE APPLICATION PROCESS, WE SPOKE TO OUR
6:12:51PM IMMEDIATE NEIGHBORS AND EXTENDED NEIGHBORS ABOUT THE REZONE
6:12:54PM IDEA AND RECEIVED AN OUTPOURING OF SUPPORT.
6:12:57PM WE SUBMITTED BY E-MAIL TODAY TO THE QUASI-E-MAIL BOX OUR
6:13:04PM SUPPORT LETTER SIGNED BY 45 NEIGHBORS AND TAMPA RESIDENTS.
6:13:08PM WE ALSO HAVE FOUR NEIGHBORS HERE TONIGHT TO SPEAK ON OUR
6:13:12PM BEHALF.
6:13:12PM I'LL TRY TO USE THIS.
6:13:14PM THIS IS A COPY THAT WE SUBMITTED OF THE SIGNED LETTER THAT I
6:13:19PM CAN GIVE TO THE CITY TONIGHT.
6:13:20PM WE BEGAN OUR OUTREACH OVER A YEAR AGO IN MARCH OF 2023
6:13:27PM BEFORE WE STARTED THE FORMAL PROCESS BY MAKING PHONE CALLS,
6:13:30PM HOUSE CALLS, KNOCKING ON DOORS AND VISITS AND THEN
6:13:34PM ULTIMATELY MAILING THE REQUIRED GOOD NEIGHBOR LETTER APRIL
6:13:37PM 3rd WITH MY PERSONAL CELL PHONE AND E-MAIL ADDRESS FOR
6:13:41PM DIRECT COMMUNICATION.
6:13:42PM I DID GET SOME CALLBACKS AND OUR NEIGHBOR, MR. GILL RAY,
6:13:48PM THEN MET WITH ME AND SIGNED OUR LETTER OF SUPPORT.
6:13:52PM WE RECEIVED NO CONCERNS OR OPPOSITION.
6:13:54PM ALL BEST EFFORTS HAVE BEEN MADE TO ENSURE OUR NEIGHBORS ARE
6:13:57PM SUPPORTIVE OF OUR REQUEST AND WE BELIEVE THROUGH THE PROCESS
6:14:01PM THEY ARE.
6:14:02PM WE'RE CONFIDENT THROUGH THE CONVERSATIONS WITH NEIGHBORS AND
6:14:04PM FOLLOWING SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS AT OUR -- THAT OUR REQUEST,
6:14:07PM IF GRANTED WOULD BE POSITIVE FOR THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND
6:14:09PM MAINTAIN OUR UNIQUE CHARACTER.
6:14:10PM SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS.
6:14:15PM LET THESE DOCUMENTS AND MAPS SHOW THAT WE'RE NOT ASKING FOR
6:14:21PM ZONING A PARCEL DIFFERENT THAN MANY OF WHAT OUR NEIGHBORS
6:14:24PM HAVE.
6:14:24PM IN THE STAFF REPORT, WHICH SHOWS A LOT OF GOOD INFORMATION,
6:14:30PM THE STAFF REPORT IS OVERALL VERY FAVORABLE AND POSITIVE FOR
6:14:35PM OUR REQUEST.
6:14:36PM ON THE MAP THAT MS. DOCK REFERRED TO EARLIER, THERE ARE SOME
6:14:45PM ELEMENTS THAT ARE HELPFUL ON THIS MAP.
6:14:50PM I THINK WHAT IT SHOWS REALLY THAT WE'VE GOT A MELTING POT IN
6:14:55PM THE VICINITY OF OUR PROPERTY OF DIFFERENT PROPERTY SIZES AND
6:14:59PM TYPES AND USES.
6:15:02PM THIS MAP IS A THREE-BLOCK BUFFER OR A 1300 FEET.
6:15:07PM THERE ARE 11 PROPERTIES THAT ARE THE SIZE LOT THAT WE'RE
6:15:12PM ASKING FOR OR SMALLER.
6:15:15PM INCLUDING MR. GILL RAY'S PROPERTY DIRECTLY SOUTH ON
6:15:20PM WOODLAWN, WHICH IS A 50-FOOT LOT.
6:15:22PM THESE GREEN DOTS ARE -- THOSE ARE THE NINE IMMEDIATE
6:15:28PM NEIGHBORS THAT WE WERE ABLE TO REACH DIRECTLY AND SIGN A
6:15:30PM LETTER OF SUPPORT.
6:15:31PM IN ADDITION TO MR. GILL RAY'S PROPERTY, THERE IS A SECOND
6:15:37PM PROPERTY ON RIDGE, AND THEN A THIRD PROPERTY ON PERRY THAT
6:15:44PM EACH HAVE A 55-FOOT LOT, WHICH IS THE SAME SIZE OR LESS THAN
6:15:49PM WHAT WE'RE ASKING FOR.
6:15:50PM STARTING TWO BLOCKS AWAY, YOU GET INTO RS 50.
6:15:59PM SOME OF THIS HAS BEEN MENTIONED ALREADY.
6:16:00PM THERE ARE SOME CONDOS NORTH ON KENTUCKY.
6:16:06PM AND THE UNIQUENESS OF HOW SMALL MY BLOCK IS.
6:16:10PM WHILE ALL THIS INFORMATION WE BELIEVE IS HELPFUL AND SHOWS
6:16:13PM THAT WHAT WE'RE ASKING FOR IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
6:16:15PM NEIGHBORHOOD, IN OUR CASE, THIS MAP IS NOT AN ACCURATE
6:16:21PM PORTRAYAL OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD MAKEUP FOR A VERY IMPORTANT
6:16:24PM REASON.
6:16:25PM RIVERSIDE HEIGHTS IS A VERY BIG NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:16:27PM IT MEASURES ABOUT ONE MILE NORTH TO SOUTH FROM MLK DOWN TO
6:16:31PM COLUMBUS DRIVE AND ABOUT A MILE EAST TO WEST IN THE WIDEST
6:16:35PM PART OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:16:36PM SO I WENT TO THE HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER'S
6:16:42PM CUSTOMER SERVICE, AND SUBMITTED TO THE RECORD FOLIO LIST OF
6:16:47PM 3,000-FOOT -- 3,000-FOOT BUFFER FROM OUR PROPERTY, AND USING
6:16:55PM A 3,000-FOOT BUFFER, THAT COVERS MOST OF RIVERSIDE HEIGHTS,
6:16:59PM NOT ALL, BUT MOST OF IT, AND YOU HAVE 420 HOMES WITH --
6:17:05PM EXCUSE ME, PROPERTIES WITH PARCEL SIZES OF WHAT WE'RE ASKING
6:17:09PM FOR THAT SIZE OR SMALLER.
6:17:11PM AND THEN IF YOU GO OUT A MILE, WHICH COMPLETELY COVERS
6:17:15PM RIVERSIDE HEIGHTS AND SOME OF THE OTHER AREAS, YOU GET OVER
6:17:20PM 2,300 HOMES WITH THE PARCEL SIZE THAT WE'RE ASKING FOR.
6:17:30PM WRAPPING UP HERE, SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS, SOME OF THIS HAS
6:17:34PM BEEN MENTIONED BY I BELIEVE THE PLANNING COMMISSION ALREADY.
6:17:38PM THE ZONING THAT WE'RE ASKING FOR IS -- MEETS THE STANDARD OR
6:17:45PM THE MATRIX --
6:17:46PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: TURN IT AROUND.
6:17:47PM >> SORRY.
6:17:48PM FIRST TIME USING THIS.
6:17:49PM MEETS THE STANDARD OF WHAT'S CALLED FOR IN THE CODE.
6:17:54PM AND THAT'S IT FOR SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS.
6:18:02PM IN SUMMARY, COMBINING OUR BROAD COMMUNITY SUPPORT AND
6:18:13PM SUPPORTING TECHNICAL DATA, WE ASK THAT YOU PLEASE GRANT OUR
6:18:18PM REQUEST SO OUR FAMILY CAN HAVE BETTER AND EXPANDED HOUSING
6:18:21PM OPTIONS WHILE WE CONTRIBUTE TO OUR WONDERFUL NEIGHBORHOOD
6:18:23PM AND BELOVED HOME IN THE CITY OF TAMPA.
6:18:25PM THANK YOU.
6:18:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:18:27PM ANY QUESTIONS?
6:18:28PM ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 3,
6:18:31PM PLEASE COME UP AND STATE YOUR NAME.
6:18:33PM YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
6:18:38PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
6:18:40PM GRAHAM.
6:18:41PM 908 WEST PLYMOUTH AVENUE, NEIGHBOR OF ANTHONY AND DIANA
6:18:45PM SCAGLIONE.
6:18:46PM SON IS WITH ME.
6:18:52PM HERE TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF THEIR PETITION TO BE ABLE TO
6:18:55PM BUILD ON THE LOT AND FOR THE REZONING FOR RS 50.
6:18:58PM DIANA AND ANTHONY HAVE SHARED THEIR REZONING IDEAS WITH US
6:19:02PM AND WE THINK IT'S BEEN -- NOT JUST FOR THEIR FAMILY AND THE
6:19:06PM LONG HERITAGE THEIR FAMILY HAS IN THE AREA AND CONTRIBUTE TO
6:19:10PM THE AREA BUT THE AREA IN GENERAL.
6:19:12PM THE CITY OF TAMPA AND MAYOR'S OFFICE HAS STATED SPECIFICALLY
6:19:16PM ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS ARE PART OF OUR FUTURE.
6:19:18PM IF WE DON'T TAKE REALLY GOOD EXAMPLES ON HOW TO DO THAT,
6:19:23PM YOU'RE GOING TO BE STUCK WITH A LOT OF BAD ONES.
6:19:26PM THIS IS A GOOD PLACE TO SHOW WHAT THAT POLICY WAS MADE FOR,
6:19:30PM I THINK.
6:19:30PM ANTHONY'S WORK GOES A LOT BEYOND WHAT HE'S SPOKEN ABOUT
6:19:36PM TODAY.
6:19:36PM HIS VOLUNTEER WORK WITH THE ROTARY CLUB, YBOR CITY, WHERE HE
6:19:39PM IS THE CHAIRMAN OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL COMMITTEE, REVITALIZING
6:19:42PM PARTS OF THE RIVER ALONG RIVERSIDE HEIGHTS SPEAKS TO HIS
6:19:45PM COMMITMENT TO THE AREA AS A LOCAL RESIDENT AND AS SOMEONE
6:19:48PM WHOSE FAMILY IS GOING TO USE THE PROPERTY THEMSELVES.
6:19:50PM I THINK THERE'S REALLY NO OTHER OPTION THAN FOR YOU ALL TO
6:19:54PM STRONGLY CONSIDER AND SUPPORT HIS REZONING FOR RS 50.
6:19:57PM I THINK IT'S BEYOND DOUBT THAT HE SHOWED THAT THERE ARE
6:20:00PM MULTIPLE OTHER PROPERTIES WITH SMALLER SIZES THAT ARE RS 50
6:20:04PM IN THAT AREA.
6:20:04PM AND THIS IS NOT INCONSISTENT AT ALL WITH HOW THE
6:20:07PM NEIGHBORHOOD LOOKS.
6:20:08PM I THINK ANYTHING HE DOES THERE WILL SET THE SAME HIGH
6:20:13PM STANDARDS THAT HE'S HELD HIMSELF AND HIS FAMILY TO.
6:20:15PM I REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR STRONG CONSIDERATION AND SUPPORT
6:20:19PM FOR THE CHANGE OF ZONE.
6:20:20PM THANK YOU.
6:20:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:20:21PM IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE THAT WISHES TO SPEAK?
6:20:23PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:20:28PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL MEMBERS.
6:20:30PM MY NAME IS MATT BAILEY.
6:20:33PM I'M A NEIGHBOR AND FRIEND OF ANTHONY AND DIANA.
6:20:37PM I'M HERE TONIGHT TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THEIR REZONING OF
6:20:40PM THE PROPERTY AS WELL.
6:20:42PM FOR OVER A YEAR, ANTHONY HAS BEEN SPEAKING TO ME ABOUT THE
6:20:45PM REZONING OF THE PROPERTY AND WORKING DILIGENT WITH THE
6:20:49PM APPLICATION PROCESS.
6:20:50PM I'VE SEEN HIM SPEAK TO ALL OF THE NEIGHBORS AND GO ABOVE AND
6:20:54PM BEYOND IN THE APPLICATION PROCESS, THE REQUIREMENTS, AND
6:20:57PM GETTING SUPPORT ALONG THE WAY.
6:20:59PM AS A REAL ESTATE BROKER, I'M FAMILIAR WITH OUR NEIGHBORHOOD
6:21:02PM AND THE MAKEUP OF THE PROPERTIES HERE.
6:21:05PM HIS DESIGN IDEAS MAINTAIN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD'S UNIQUENESS AND
6:21:08PM ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE PROPERTIES IN THE AREA, BOTH BY SIZE
6:21:12PM AND DENSITY.
6:21:13PM ANTHONY AND DIANA ARE ACTIVE IN OUR COMMUNITY.
6:21:16PM OUR CHILDREN GO TO SCHOOL TOGETHER AT TRINITY.
6:21:19PM THEY GO ABOVE AND BEYOND TO VOLUNTEER THERE.
6:21:22PM THEY ALSO VOLUNTEER IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD AND HAVE HELPED GAIN
6:21:28PM SUPPORT AND SAFETY FOR OUR NEIGHBORHOOD PARK.
6:21:30PM I BELIEVE THAT IF YOU GRANT THE RS 50 APPROVAL, THAT THEY
6:21:34PM WILL FURTHER IMPROVE THEIR PROPERTY ALONG WITH THE
6:21:37PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:21:37PM I SUPPORT THEIR REQUEST AND ASK FOR YOUR APPROVAL, PLEASE.
6:21:40PM THANK YOU.
6:21:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:21:41PM IS THAT IT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT?
6:21:44PM YES, MA'AM, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:21:52PM >> ASHLEY TERRY.
6:21:53PM I AM A NEIGHBOR AND FRIEND ALSO.
6:21:55PM I LIVE AT 2906 NORTH PERRY AVENUE.
6:21:58PM MY HOME IS NEXT TO WHAT ANTHONY WAS SAYING IS HIS
6:22:04PM GREAT-GRANDPARENTS' ORIGINAL HOMESITE.
6:22:07PM I LIVE ON 52 WIDE LOT.
6:22:11PM IT'S VERY TYPICAL, LIKE HE MENTIONED, TO HAVE THE DIFFERENT
6:22:15PM SIZES GOING THROUGHOUT THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:22:16PM I DON'T THINK IT'S AGAINST ANYTHING.
6:22:19PM SO AS A NEIGHBOR AND LICENSED REAL ESTATE AGENT ALSO, I CAN
6:22:23PM TELL YOU THAT THE ONE NEXT TO ME, ACROSS THE STREET FROM ME,
6:22:29PM IN THE 50s TOO, NEXT TO SOMETHING BIGGER, TOTALLY MAKES
6:22:33PM SENSE.
6:22:33PM I ALSO HAVE RIGHT AROUND THE CORNER TOWNHOMES.
6:22:36PM SO IT FITS.
6:22:37PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD IS OVER A HUNDRED YEARS OLD.
6:22:38PM IT'S BEEN REZONED SO MANY TIMES.
6:22:41PM LIKE HE SAID, I THINK IT IS A MELTING POT AND IT'S ONLY
6:22:46PM GOING TO BENEFIT HIM AND THE NEIGHBORHOOD TO HAVE SOMETHING
6:22:48PM ELSE THERE AND TO HELP HIS FAMILY.
6:22:51PM IN SUPPORT OF THEM.
6:22:53PM I HOPE YOU FIND THAT AS WELL.
6:22:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:22:55PM SIR?
6:22:57PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I JUST WANT TO SAY, THE PROFESSIONALISM
6:22:59PM THAT ANTHONY SHOWED, I DON'T KNOW IF HE IS AN ATTORNEY OR
6:23:02PM NOT AN ATTORNEY, BUT THE PROFESSIONALISM, YOU SOUND LIKE YOU
6:23:05PM ARE A CPA OR SOMETHING BECAUSE EVERYTHING WAS SO METHODICAL
6:23:08PM AND DONE IN PERFECT ORDER.
6:23:10PM I WANT TO CONGRATULATE THE NEIGHBORHOOD, ALL OF YOU FOR
6:23:12PM BEING WHO YOU ARE AND HOW YOU HANDLED YOURSELVES.
6:23:15PM VERY RARELY HAVE WE SEEN THIS KIND OF UNITY AND SOMETHING
6:23:18PM EVEN IF YOU HAD A DISAGREEMENT SOMEWHERE, IT WAS NEVER SHOWN
6:23:21PM HERE.
6:23:22PM I WANT TO THANK THE NEIGHBORHOOD FOR BEING WHO YOU ARE AND
6:23:24PM WHERE YOU COME FROM, THE SCAGLIONE FAMILY, LIKE LOOKING AT
6:23:28PM THE JONESES AND SMITHS, THEY ARE EVERYWHERE.
6:23:31PM THERE ARE A LOT OF SCAGLIONES AND SOMETIMES THEY ARE RELATED
6:23:35PM AND MOST TIMES THEY ARE NOT.
6:23:36PM I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU TO THE WHOLE NEIGHBORHOOD FOR
6:23:38PM SHOWING UP.
6:23:42PM >>LUIS VIERA: I WAS JUST GOING TO AGREE.
6:23:44PM AND THIS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH MY VOTE OR ANYTHING OF THAT
6:23:47PM NATURE.
6:23:47PM MR. SCAGLIONE HAS ALWAYS BEEN A VERY NICE GUY AND A
6:23:51PM GENTLEMAN.
6:23:52PM WE HAVEN'T TALKED A LOT IN A WHILE.
6:23:54PM IT'S BEEN A WHILE.
6:23:55PM BUT THIS PRESENTATION IS NOT INCONSISTENT WITH WHAT I'VE
6:23:59PM SEEN IN THE PAST.
6:24:00PM AND THE SUPPORT OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:24:02PM IT'S NICE TO SEE BECAUSE WE DON'T OFTEN SEE THAT.
6:24:05PM THAT'S ALL I'M SAYING.
6:24:06PM THANK YOU.
6:24:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. MANISCALCO, WE'RE NOT RELATED.
6:24:12PM WE'RE NOT RELATED.
6:24:13PM >> I HAD THAT IN MY NOTES TO MENTION.
6:24:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THERE'S NO CONFLICT.
6:24:16PM NOT RELATED.
6:24:18PM >> JORDAN MANISCALCO.
6:24:19PM NO RELATION TO COUNCILMAN MANISCALCO.
6:24:22PM I'M A RESIDENT OF RIVERSIDE HEIGHTS AT 3211 NORTH PERRY.
6:24:27PM AND NEIGHBORHOOD FRIEND OF ANTHONY AND DIANA SCAGLIONE.
6:24:32PM I WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THE REZONING APPLICATION
6:24:35PM FOR THEIR PROPERTY.
6:24:36PM ANTHONY AND DIANA ARE ACTIVE IN SUPPORTING AND VOLUNTEERING
6:24:40PM IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:24:42PM LAST OCTOBER, ANTHONY ORGANIZED A FLAG-RAISING CEREMONY HERE
6:24:47PM ABOVE THE OLD CITY HALL IN CELEBRATION OF ITALIAN AMERICAN
6:24:54PM HERITAGE.
6:24:55PM THE EVENT WAS SUCCESSFULLY COORDINATED WITH THE CITY AND
6:24:57PM WELL ATTENDED BY THE PUBLIC.
6:24:58PM OUR NEIGHBORHOOD AT RIVERSIDE HEIGHTS IS MADE UP OF A
6:25:01PM THOUSAND HOMES AND MANY DIFFERENT PROPERTY SIZES.
6:25:04PM WE HAVE RESIDENTIAL, CONDOS, TOWNHOMES, CHURCHES,
6:25:08PM MULTIFAMILY.
6:25:09PM IT'S LIKE EVERYONE SAID, A VERY BIG MELTING POT.
6:25:13PM OVER HALF THE NEIGHBORHOOD HAS PARCEL SIZES LESS THAN WHAT
6:25:16PM ANTHONY AND DIANA ARE ASKING FOR IN THIS APPLICATION.
6:25:21PM PERSONALLY I'M IN THE CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY AND I SEE MANY
6:25:24PM TYPES OF NEIGHBORHOOD PROJECTS AND DESIGNS IN MY WORK.
6:25:27PM IT IS MY PERSONAL OPINION THAT ANTHONY AND DIANA'S REZONING
6:25:31PM REQUEST IS CONSISTENT AND MAINTAINS THE CHARACTER OF THE
6:25:35PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:25:35PM I ASK THAT YOU PLEASE GRANT THEM APPROVAL FOR THEIR
6:25:38PM APPLICATION.
6:25:39PM I WOULD LIKE TO THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME THIS EVENING.
6:25:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:25:43PM ANYBODY ELSE?
6:25:45PM IF NOT, NO QUESTIONS, ASK FOR A MOTION TO CLOSE.
6:25:47PM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:25:49PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THIS IS AN INTERESTING ONE BECAUSE I'LL BE
6:25:53PM HONEST WITH YOU, I CAME INTO THIS FULLY EXPECTING TO VOTE
6:25:56PM AGAINST THIS.
6:25:57PM I MEAN 100%.
6:25:59PM I DO A LOT OF THE RESEARCH AND READING, LOOK AT THE
6:26:01PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:26:02PM I WILL TAKE ISSUE ON WHAT YOU'RE ASKING FOR REALLY ISN'T,
6:26:06PM BECAUSE I AGREE WITH STAFF.
6:26:08PM THIS IS NOT CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN OF THIS
6:26:10PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:26:11PM CLEARLY, MOST OF THE LOTS, IF NOT ALL BUT A FEW OUTLINED
6:26:17PM EXCEPTIONS, ONE ODD SHAPED LOT, RIVER LOT AND THE ONE
6:26:20PM DIRECTLY BEHIND YOUR PROPERTY ARE ALL SUBSTANTIALLY LARGER
6:26:23PM WIDTHS.
6:26:24PM THE IMMEDIATE VICINITY.
6:26:25PM BUT THAT BEING SAID, I DO APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT IT IS A
6:26:29PM VERY ECLECTIC NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:26:30PM IT'S DEVELOPED IN A VERY ECLECTIC WAY WITH DIFFERENT STYLES
6:26:34PM OF HOUSING, DIFFERENT AGES OF HOUSING.
6:26:37PM RIVERFRONT PROPERTY, AGAIN, SWAYING THE TYPES -- THE WAY THE
6:26:42PM STREETS ARE LAID OUT IS SOMEWHAT DIFFERENT.
6:26:44PM I CONCUR WITH MY FELLOW COUNCILPERSONS.
6:26:48PM IT'S NICE TO SEE THE FOLKS THAT COME IN SUPPORTIVE OF THE
6:26:52PM ISSUE.
6:26:54PM OBVIOUSLY, I ALSO APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT YOU INCORPORATED
6:26:56PM YOUR NEIGHBORS INTO THE DISCUSSIONS AS YOU DEVELOPED THESE
6:27:01PM IDEAS.
6:27:02PM I THINK THAT WAS IMPORTANT.
6:27:05PM THE FACT THAT NOBODY, CLEARLY THIS WAS SIGNED PROPERLY AND
6:27:08PM PEOPLE DID NOT SHOW UP IN OPPOSITION I THINK IS A TESTAMENT
6:27:11PM TO YOUR OUTREACH AHEAD OF TIME AND BEING PROACTIVE.
6:27:15PM I THINK YOU SWAYED ME BECAUSE MINE WOULD HAVE BEEN A VOTE
6:27:18PM AGAINST.
6:27:18PM AGAIN, TAKING THIS IN A STERILE ENVIRONMENT, IT WOULD HAVE
6:27:21PM BEEN A VOTE AGAINST.
6:27:22PM I WOULD HAVE SUPPORTED OUR CITY STAFF'S OBJECTIONS.
6:27:25PM BUT I THINK TAKING THAT AND WEIGHING THAT WITH EVERYTHING
6:27:28PM ELSE THAT WE'RE HEARING TONIGHT, I THINK YOU CHANGED MY
6:27:30PM MIND.
6:27:31PM THANK YOU.
6:27:31PM I MOVE TO CLOSE.
6:27:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
6:27:34PM CLENDENIN.
6:27:34PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
6:27:35PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:27:36PM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
6:27:39PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I MOVE FILE REZ-24-28, AN ORDINANCE BEING
6:27:44PM PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE
6:27:46PM REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 1102 WEST OHIO
6:27:50PM AVENUE, IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, AND MORE PARTICULARLY
6:27:53PM DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1 FROM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION
6:27:56PM RS-60 (RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY) TO RS-50 (RESIDENTIAL,
6:28:00PM SINGLE-FAMILY); PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
6:28:03PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
6:28:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
6:28:05PM HENDERSON.
6:28:06PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
6:28:07PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:28:08PM AYE?
6:28:09PM ANY OPPOSED?
6:28:11PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I DON'T NEED TO GIVE REASONS?
6:28:18PM I FIND THE FINDINGS BASED ON COMPETENT SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
6:28:21PM FOUND IN THE STAFF REPORT, APPLICANT'S REPORT, AND TESTIMONY
6:28:24PM ESTABLISHES THAT THE REZONING WILL ALLOW FOR ENHANCED
6:28:27PM UTILIZATION OF THE LAND CONSISTENT WITH THE DENSITY
6:28:29PM ANTICIPATED UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL 10 DESIGNATION AND WILL
6:28:33PM PROVIDE ADDITIONAL INFILL HOUSING ON AND UNDERUTILIZED
6:28:37PM PARCEL IN ACCORDANCE WITH LAND USE POLICIES ONE -- 2.12,
6:28:42PM 9.2.1, AND HOUSING POLICY 1.3.4 AND COMPLIANCE WITH THE LAND
6:28:47PM DEVELOPMENT CODE.
6:28:49PM ALTHOUGH THE PROMINENT PATTERN OF THE DEVELOPMENT INCLUDES
6:28:53PM LOT THAT ARE 60 FEET OR WIDER, THE OVERALL LOT AREA OF THE
6:28:56PM RESULTING LOTS IS APPROPRIATE -- APPROXIMATELY 6,825 WHICH
6:29:02PM IS GREATER THAN THE MINIMUM LOT AREA FOR THE RS 60 ZONING
6:29:07PM DISTRICT.
6:29:07PM AND WITHIN A TWO-BLOCK RANGE TO THE NORTH THERE ARE EXISTING
6:29:12PM PD ZONINGS, REZ 06-67 WHICH ALLOWED A LOT SPLIT WHICH
6:29:19PM CREATED A 37-FOOT WIDE LOT AND REZ 06-36 WHICH ALLOWED FOR
6:29:25PM TWO HOMES IN THE REAR OF AN EXISTING LOT.
6:29:28PM THANK YOU, CHAIR.
6:29:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
6:29:30PM ALL RIGHT.
6:29:30PM LAST ITEM OF THE NIGHT.
6:29:33PM DID YOU DO A SECOND READING?
6:29:42PM >>THE CLERK: SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON
6:29:44PM JUNE 6, 2024, AT 9:30 A.M., LOCATED AT OLD CITY HALL, 315
6:29:49PM EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
6:29:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:29:58PM YES, MA'AM.
6:29:58PM LAST ITEM.
6:29:59PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
6:30:00PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:30:02PM THE LAST ITEM FOR THIS EVENING IS REZ 24-29.
6:30:06PM THIS IS FOR THE PROPERTY AT 1408 EAST 21st AVENUE.
6:30:10PM THE REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY FROM RS 50,
6:30:13PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY, TO RM 18, RESIDENTIAL
6:30:16PM MULTIFAMILY.
6:30:16PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO PLANNING COMMISSION AND COME BACK AND
6:30:21PM GIVE MY REPORT.
6:30:23PM >>DAVID HEY: GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL MEMBERS.
6:30:25PM DAVID HEY AGAIN WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
6:30:28PM WE END UP IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT FOR THIS
6:30:32PM LAST CASE, MORE SPECIFICALLY THE EAST TAMPA URBAN VILLAGE.
6:30:38PM THERE IS THE CLOSEST TRANSIT STOPS ARE APPROXIMATELY .3
6:30:41PM MILES FROM THE SUBJECT SITE AT THE NEAREST EAST 21st
6:30:47PM AVENUE INTERSECTION.
6:30:50PM CUSCADEN PARK IS THE CLOSEST PUBLIC RECREATIONAL FACILITY.
6:30:53PM AND THE SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN A LEVEL E EVACUATION ZONE.
6:30:57PM HERE WE HAVE AN AERIAL.
6:31:01PM THE SUBJECT SITE -- KIND OF HARD TO SEE HERE.
6:31:04PM THIS IS EAST 21st AVENUE.
6:31:05PM THIS IS THE PARK JUST TO THE SOUTH.
6:31:08PM YOU COULD SEE THE PREDOMINANT PATTERN IS MOSTLY
6:31:11PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED.
6:31:12PM THERE IS SOME MULTIFAMILY SCATTERED THROUGHOUT, ESPECIALLY
6:31:17PM TO THE WEST.
6:31:19PM AND THEN ALSO DOWN HERE IN THE SOUTH.
6:31:22PM HERE WE HAVE THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP.
6:31:28PM THIS KIND OF SHOWS THE ECLECTIC FUTURE LAND USE
6:31:31PM DESIGNATIONS.
6:31:32PM THE SUBJECT SITE AND PARCELS SURROUNDING IT AND DOWN TO THE
6:31:38PM SOUTHWEST AND ALSO ALONG 15th AVENUE.
6:31:42PM THAT'S ALL THE RESIDENTIAL 20 IN THAT BROWN.
6:31:45PM IT GETS MORE DENSE AS YOU GO SOUTH OF THE PARK.
6:31:47PM AGAIN, RESIDENTIAL 20 AND THIS IS THE COMMUNITY MIXED USE
6:31:51PM 35.
6:31:52PM FURTHER UP 15th, ON THAT RED, THAT IS THE COMMUNITY
6:31:57PM COMMERCIAL 35.
6:31:58PM UNDER THAT RESIDENTIAL 20 DESIGNATION, IT DOES HAVE AN
6:32:08PM EXISTING DENSITY -- WELL, WITHIN THAT BLOCK, BETWEEN NORTH
6:32:13PM AVENUE REPUBLIC DE CUBA AND NORTH 15th AVENUE, EXCLUDING
6:32:17PM THE SUBJECT SITE, ANY VACANT AND COMMERCIAL PARCELS, THE
6:32:21PM DENSITY THERE IS 12.15 UNITS PER ACRE.
6:32:23PM THAT IS UNDER THAT RESIDENTIAL 20.
6:32:26PM THE EXISTING DENSITY OF THIS PORTION OF EAST 21st AVENUE
6:32:30PM IS APPROXIMATELY 60% OF THE DENSITY PLANNED FOR UNDER THE
6:32:34PM RESIDENTIAL 20.
6:32:35PM THE SITE CAN BE CONSIDERED FOR TWO DWELLING UNITS BASED ON
6:32:38PM ITS SIZE UNDER THAT RES 20 DESIGNATION.
6:32:43PM PROPOSED ZONING IS CONSISTENT WITH THE UNDERLYING FUTURE
6:32:46PM LAND USE DESIGNATION AND PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF HAS
6:32:49PM DETERMINED IT WILL NOT ALTER THE CHARACTER OR DEVELOPMENT
6:32:51PM PATTERN OF THIS PORTION OF THE VM YBOR NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:32:54PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS WITHIN THE EAST TAMPA URBAN VILLAGE.
6:32:57PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN POLICY DIRECTION DOES SEEK TO DIRECT
6:33:02PM THE GREATEST SHARE OF GROWTH TO THOSE URBAN CENTERS AND
6:33:04PM VILLAGES.
6:33:05PM IT IS ALSO LOCATED WITHIN PROXIMITY TO TRANSIT WHERE THE
6:33:08PM PLAN DOES IDENTIFY IT'S APPROPRIATE FOR INFILL DEVELOPMENT.
6:33:12PM IN CONCLUSION, THROUGH THE ASSESSMENT OF THE CHARACTER OF
6:33:15PM THE AREA, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF HAS DETERMINED THE
6:33:18PM PROPOSED ZONING WILL ALLOW FOR DEVELOPMENT THAT IS IN
6:33:21PM CHARACTER WITH THE SURROUNDING AREA AND IS CONSISTENT WITH
6:33:23PM THAT LONG-RANGE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL
6:33:26PM 20.
6:33:27PM BASED ON THOSE CONSIDERATIONS, YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION
6:33:31PM STAFF DOES RECOMMEND TO YOU THIS EVENING THAT THE ZONING
6:33:32PM REQUEST BE FOUND CONSISTENT WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE TAMPA
6:33:38PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:33:39PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I WAS JUST THINKING I HAVE TO RECUSE
6:33:40PM MYSELF BECAUSE THIS IS WHERE I WAS RAISED.
6:33:43PM CUSCADEN PARK, THE PARK HE SAID, CUSCADEN PARK.
6:33:50PM TWO HALL OF FAMERS FROM THERE.
6:33:52PM AL LOPEZ AND TONY LaRUSSA.
6:34:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DAVIS ISLANDS AND THIS ONE.
6:34:10PM YES, MA'AM.
6:34:12PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:34:14PM SO THE PARCEL THAT IS UNDER THIS REQUEST FOR THE REZONING IS
6:34:21PM 5,000 SQUARE FEET.
6:34:22PM 50 FEET OF FRONTAGE.
6:34:24PM JUST HAPPENS TO HAVE A HUNDRED FEET IN DEPTH.
6:34:26PM SO IT MEETS THAT MINIMUM REQUIREMENT SIZE FOR THE LOT.
6:34:30PM IT IS CONTAINED ON EAST 21st AVENUE.
6:34:35PM LET ME SHOW THE ZONING MAP.
6:34:37PM SO THIS IS THE PROPERTY LOCATED HERE IN RED.
6:34:39PM THIS IS 21st AVENUE.
6:34:42PM IN EVALUATING THIS SITE, WE LOOKED AT THE USES THAT ARE
6:34:45PM ADJACENT TO THE SITE.
6:34:47PM THIS BLOCK ACTUALLY CONTAINS COMMERCIAL USE AT THE END,
6:34:52PM COMMERCIAL ZONING AND A VACANT COMMERCIAL USE.
6:34:55PM SO THIS IS CN, COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:34:57PM TO THE SOUTH IS THE PARK, TO THE SOUTHEAST IS A PD, WHICH IS
6:35:03PM AN OLDER PD.
6:35:04PM IT IS APPROVED FOR COMMERCIAL USES.
6:35:06PM AND TO THE NORTH OF THE SITE IS RO-1 ZONING, WHICH IS
6:35:11PM RESIDENTIAL OFFICE AND IT DOES HAVE AN OFFICE USE HERE.
6:35:14PM SO THERE IS A MIXTURE OF USES WITHIN THIS BLOCK.
6:35:17PM SO THIS REQUESTED ZONING OF RM-18 WOULD ALLOW FOR A MAXIMUM
6:35:21PM OF TWO UNITS, WHICH WOULD HAVE MINIMAL IMPACTS CONSIDERING
6:35:26PM THE COMMERCIAL NATURE OF THE BLOCK.
6:35:29PM YOU CAN SEE THAT THE ZONING TO THE WEST, YOU HAVE THE YC 8
6:35:33PM ZONING, WHICH IS THE RESIDENTIAL ZONING IN THE YBOR CITY
6:35:36PM DISTRICT.
6:35:36PM AND THEN NORTH OF 21st AVENUE, THE DISTRICTS CHANGE.
6:35:43PM THAT IS THE END OF THE YC DISTRICT AND YOU SEE YOUR PD
6:35:46PM DEVELOPMENT ALONG WITH YOUR RS 50 ZONING THAT'S FURTHER TO
6:35:49PM THE EAST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:35:51PM THIS IS A SURVEY OF THE SITE, WHICH SHOWS THE SITE ON 21st
6:35:57PM AVENUE.
6:35:57PM THIS IS THE FRONTAGE.
6:35:59PM IT IS CONTAINED WITHIN LOT 11, BLOCK 9, AND THIS IS THE
6:36:03PM PARCEL BOUNDARY.
6:36:05PM AND THEN I HAVE PICTURES OF THE SITE.
6:36:07PM SO THIS IS A VIEW OF THE SITE.
6:36:14PM THIS IS LOOKING DIRECTLY AT THE SITE.
6:36:15PM THIS IS EAST OF THE SITE.
6:36:22PM AND THIS IS THAT COMMERCIAL, THAT CN COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD
6:36:26PM ZONING, THE PROPERTY THAT'S ON THE CORNER.
6:36:28PM CUSCADEN PARK.
6:36:30PM LOCATED HERE.
6:36:32PM ANOTHER VIEW.
6:36:35PM SO THIS IS, OF COURSE, SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:36:39PM THIS IS WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:36:43PM AND THEN THIS IS WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE, WHICH IS A VACANT
6:36:49PM LOT.
6:36:49PM BUT YOU CAN SEE THAT RESIDENTIAL BUILDING.
6:36:51PM I HAVE ANOTHER VIEW OF IT.
6:36:53PM THROUGH THAT LOT.
6:36:56PM AND THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW OF THIS RESIDENTIAL BUILDING.
6:36:59PM SO THE SITE IN THIS PICTURE IS OVER IN THIS AREA.
6:37:02PM AND THEN THIS IS THE ALLEY AND THIS IS THE RESIDENTIAL, THAT
6:37:07PM RO-1 ZONING.
6:37:08PM IT'S NOT RESIDENTIAL USE.
6:37:10PM I'M SORRY.
6:37:11PM IT'S RESIDENTIAL OFFICE ZONE, BUT IT HAS AN OFFICE USE.
6:37:15PM AND THEN THIS IS WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:37:18PM SO STAFF REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FINDS IT CONSISTENT.
6:37:21PM I'M AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
6:37:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
6:37:24PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:37:25PM APPLICANT?
6:37:25PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:37:37PM >> MICHAEL GIANESKIS.
6:37:38PM I AM THE OWNER OF THE LOT.
6:37:40PM I'M PRETTY EXCITED ABOUT THE POTENTIAL OF YOU GUYS PASSING
6:37:45PM THIS AND DOING A DEVELOPMENT ON THE SITE.
6:37:47PM I PLAN ON LIVING THERE.
6:37:49PM I'VE SPOKEN TO THE OWNERS.
6:37:52PM THIS OWNER, I'VE SPOKEN TO THIS OWNER, THIS OWNER, THIS
6:37:55PM OWNER.
6:37:56PM THEY ARE ALL REALLY EXCITED ABOUT NEW DEVELOPMENT COMING IN.
6:38:01PM AND I'M REALLY EXCITED TOO BECAUSE YOU TALK ABOUT CUSCADEN
6:38:04PM PARK, I'LL BE ABLE TO WALK TO THE PICKLEBALL COURT, SO MY
6:38:11PM GAME WILL HOPEFULLY GET A LOT BETTER, TOO.
6:38:13PM I'M A REALLY BIG FAN OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND I KIND OF WANT
6:38:16PM TO DO MY PART TO HELP BUILD SOMETHING WITH A LOT OF
6:38:20PM CHARACTER.
6:38:21PM I APPRECIATE YOUR STRONG CONSIDERATION OF THIS.
6:38:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:38:25PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I'M NOT GOING TO HOLD THE PICKLEBALL
6:38:29PM AGAINST YOU.
6:38:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE'RE AN ANTI-PICKLEBALL COUNCIL.
6:38:33PM >> OH, SHOOT.
6:38:35PM >> MOTION TO DENY.
6:38:36PM [ LAUGHTER ]
6:38:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE ONLY DO TENNIS AND PING-PONG.
6:38:41PM >> OKAY.
6:38:41PM [ LAUGHTER ]
6:38:43PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I'M REALLY GLAD TO SEE SOME DEVELOPMENT IN
6:38:46PM THAT BLOCK IN PARTICULAR.
6:38:47PM I DRIVE BY THERE ALL THE TIME AND HOPEFULLY IT WILL INSPIRE
6:38:51PM SOME OTHER THINGS TO IMPROVE RIGHT IN THAT PARTICULAR
6:38:54PM SECTION.
6:38:55PM I'M GLAD TO HEAR THAT YOU ARE ALSO GOING TO LIVE AT THE
6:38:59PM PROPERTY.
6:39:00PM SO REALLY GOOD.
6:39:01PM >> THE NEIGHBORS TO THE EAST OF ME, THEY ARE REALLY EXCITED
6:39:06PM BECAUSE I THINK IT'S LIKE A FAMILY LIKE FOUR OR FIVE.
6:39:12PM IN ALL TRANSPARENCY, THE CODE ENFORCEMENT HAS BEEN ON ME --
6:39:15PM I'VE GOT TO GO BY THERE ONCE A WEEK BECAUSE THERE IS JUST A
6:39:19PM LOT OF LIKE HOMELESS PEOPLE THERE.
6:39:22PM I CLEANED UP -- I HAVE A PICTURE ON MY PHONE --
6:39:25PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SHOW IT TO US.
6:39:27PM >> YOU DO WANT TO SEE IT?
6:39:29PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: OF COURSE.
6:39:30PM THAT'S THE ONLY WAY WE KNOW.
6:39:38PM >> I HADN'T BEEN TO THE SITE IN A WHILE.
6:39:42PM SO THIS WAS -- I HAD TO GO TO THE DUMP, AND IT WAS LIKE OVER
6:39:48PM A THOUSAND POUNDS.
6:39:49PM WHAT'S WORSE, THERE'S LIKE OVER 150 NEEDLES.
6:39:52PM THE FAMILY TO THE EAST OF ME IS REALLY EXCITED THAT I'M
6:39:57PM GOING TO CLEAN UP THAT LOT AND THEY ARE NOT GOING TO HAVE TO
6:40:00PM DEAL WITH THAT ISSUE GOING FORWARD.
6:40:03PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: MOTION TO CLOSE.
6:40:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
6:40:06PM HENDERSON.
6:40:07PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
6:40:10PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ASK IF THERE'S ANYBODY IN THE AUDIENCE?
6:40:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY IN THE AUDIENCE THAT WISHES TO
6:40:15PM SPEAK.
6:40:16PM WE HAVE A MOTION AND SECOND TO CLOSE.
6:40:17PM ALL IN FAVOR.
6:40:19PM AYE.
6:40:19PM ANY OPPOSED?
6:40:20PM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:40:28PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: DESPITE OR IN SPITE OF THE PICKLEBALL
6:40:28PM COMMENTS -- [LAUGHTER] -- AN ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR
6:40:31PM FIRST READING, CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY
6:40:34PM IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 1408 EAST 21st AVENUE IN THE
6:40:38PM CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA AND MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN
6:40:41PM SECTION 1 FROM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION, RS 50,
6:40:45PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY, TO RM 18, RESIDENTIAL,
6:40:48PM MULTIFAMILY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
6:40:49PM I FIND THAT THE COMPLIANCE WITH THE APPLICABLE GOALS,
6:40:52PM OBJECTIVES, AND POLICIES IN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AS NOTED
6:40:55PM AND THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT THAT THE REZONING
6:40:58PM WILL NOT ALTER THE CHARACTER OR DEVELOPMENT PATTERN OF THIS
6:41:02PM PORTION OF VM YBOR NEIGHBORHOOD AND WILL ENCOURAGE
6:41:06PM RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT ON UNDERUTILIZED LOT AND PROVIDE
6:41:09PM ADDITIONAL HOUSING CHOICES IN THE EAST TAMPA URBAN VILLAGE
6:41:11PM IN ACCORDANCE WITH LAND USE POLICIES 5.1.48, POINT ONE --
6:41:15PM 15.2, 9.3.8, 9.7.1, 2.1.25.11, 9.6.1, 9.62, 9.64, AND
6:41:27PM HOUSING POLICIES 1.34.
6:41:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
6:41:34PM CLENDENIN.
6:41:35PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
6:41:36PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:41:36PM AYE.
6:41:37PM ANY OPPOSED?
6:41:40PM >> THANK YOU.
6:41:41PM APPRECIATE IT.
6:41:46PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: NOT DONE OFFICIALLY YET.
6:41:47PM >>THE CLERK: SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON
6:41:50PM JUNE 6, 2024, AT 9:30 A.M., LOCATED AT OLD CITY HALL, 315
6:41:54PM EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
6:41:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:42:00PM SEE YOU NEXT TIME.
6:42:01PM >> THANK YOU.
6:42:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NEW BUSINESS.
6:42:06PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CHAIR PRO TEM RECOGNIZES CHAIRMAN
6:42:08PM MANISCALCO.
6:42:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:42:09PM JUST A COUPLE OF QUICK THINGS.
6:42:10PM HAPPY MOTHER'S DAY TO ALL THE MOTHERS OUT THERE AND HAPPY
6:42:14PM MOTHER'S DAY.
6:42:15PM ALSO, MY FRIEND CHARLES, WHO I HAVE COFFEE WITH MANY
6:42:22PM MORNINGS IS GOING TO BE CELEBRATING A VERY SPECIAL BIRTHDAY
6:42:25PM THIS WEEKEND.
6:42:26PM HIS MOTHER IN SOUTH TAMPA ON MAY 12th WILL BE TURNING 108
6:42:32PM YEARS OLD.
6:42:33PM AND SHE IS IN GREAT SHAPE.
6:42:38PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: REMEMBER WHEN SHE WAS BORN, CHARLIE?
6:42:41PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I WAS THERE.
6:42:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WISH HER A VERY SPECIAL HAPPY BIRTHDAY.
6:42:44PM SHE MIGHT BE THE OLDEST LIVING TAMPA RESIDENT.
6:42:47PM I DON'T KNOW FOR SURE, BUT AT 108 YEARS OLD, IT'S EXCITING.
6:42:50PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA, ANY NEW BUSINESS?
6:42:51PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THE PASS OF SCAGLIONE, 99 YEARS OLD.
6:42:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SIX MONTHS SHY OF A HUNDRED.
6:42:59PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: VERY NICE GUY.
6:43:00PM THE WHOLE FAMILY VERY NICE.
6:43:02PM GOD BLESS THE WHOLE FAMILY.
6:43:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN VIERA.
6:43:04PM >>LUIS VIERA: A COUPLE OF QUICK ONES.
6:43:07PM JUDGE PERRY LITTLE IS GOING TO BE MARKING 55 YEARS AS BEING
6:43:11PM A MEMBER OF THE FLORIDA BAR.
6:43:12PM I WANTED TO GIVE HIM A COUNCIL COMMENDATION FOR THAT.
6:43:15PM IT WILL BE DONE OFF-SITE.
6:43:17PM I HAD TALKED TO HIM ACTUALLY ABOUT POTENTIAL BEING THE
6:43:20PM FACILITATOR FOR OUR COMMITTEE WHO WASN'T ABLE TO DO IT, BUT
6:43:25PM GOD BLESS HIM.
6:43:26PM GREAT GUY.
6:43:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA, SECOND
6:43:28PM FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
6:43:30PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:43:30PM OPPOSED?
6:43:31PM >>LUIS VIERA: I DID WANT TO REMIND COUNCIL MEMBERS THAT NEXT
6:43:34PM WEEK WE ARE GOING TO BE ADDRESSING THAT ISSUE.
6:43:36PM I HAVE SEEN SOME OF THE FOLKS BEING PUT ON, SO THAT'S GREAT.
6:43:43PM GOSH, I ONLY HAVE TWO.
6:43:48PM I MOTION FOR STAFF TO REPORT ON THE FEASIBILITY OF
6:43:51PM CONDUCTING A GPR SCAN AND/OR CONSULTING WITH AN
6:43:55PM ARCHAEOLOGIST AND/OR DIVE TEAM TO CONDUCT A SEARCH FOR THE
6:44:00PM ERASED OR FOR THE COLLEGE HILL CEMETERY ON THE CITY-OWNED
6:44:03PM PROPERTY IN AND AROUND THE RETENTION POND LOCATED AT THE
6:44:06PM CORNER OF 25th AVENUE AND 26th STREET ADJACENT TO THE
6:44:09PM ITALIAN CLUB AT THE SEPTEMBER 19th MEETING.
6:44:13PM THERE WERE SOME NOTES HERE.
6:44:15PM I THOUGHT THERE WAS ANOTHER VERSION OF THIS MOTION.
6:44:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
6:44:25PM VIERA.
6:44:25PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
6:44:26PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:44:27PM AYE.
6:44:27PM ANY OPPOSED?
6:44:28PM WE DID VOTE ON THE COMMENDATION, CORRECT?
6:44:36PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I MISSED IT.
6:44:37PM I DON'T HAVE ANYTHING, CHAIRMAN.
6:44:40PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THAT
6:44:42PM BACK AT THIS MEETING, COUNCILMAN VIERA, ON THE SCANNING.
6:44:45PM I APPRECIATE HAVING THE TIME TO DO A LITTLE BIT OF RESEARCH
6:44:50PM JUST TO MAKE SURE ALL THE DUCKS ARE IN A ROW.
6:44:53PM I THINK IT IS THE RIGHT THING TO DO.
6:44:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
6:44:56PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
6:44:57PM I'M GOING TO BE OUT NEXT WEEK.
6:44:59PM I KNOW YOU ALL ARE GOING TO BE TALKING ABOUT RESIDENCY
6:45:02PM REQUIREMENTS SOME MORE.
6:45:03PM I ACTUALLY HAVE A MOTION ABOUT THAT.
6:45:05PM I MOVE THAT THE LEGAL STAFF PROVIDE AN IN-PERSON REPORT ON
6:45:09PM JUNE 6, 2024, REGARDING THE RESIDENCY REQUIREMENTS IN
6:45:13PM CHARTER SECTION 6.01 SPECIFICALLY ANALYZING WHETHER AND HOW
6:45:17PM THE NUMBER OF INDIVIDUALS TO WHOM THE REQUIREMENT APPLY CAN
6:45:20PM BE REDUCED.
6:45:22PM >> SECOND.
6:45:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK WITH THE MOTION,
6:45:25PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
6:45:26PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:45:27PM AYE.
6:45:27PM ANY OPPOSED?
6:45:29PM >>LYNN HURTAK: AND THEN WE ARE SUPPOSED TO HAVE A SOLID
6:45:33PM WASTE RATE ADJUSTMENT STUDY OR DISCUSSION ON THURSDAY.
6:45:37PM AND SINCE I AM THE CHAIR OF THE PUBLIC WORKS, THEY HAVE
6:45:40PM ASKED TO MOVE THAT.
6:45:41PM THEY ALSO ASKED TO MAKE IT A TWO PART SINCE IT IS GOING TO
6:45:45PM BE TECHNICALLY MORE THAN $20 MILLION.
6:45:47PM ADMINISTRATION HAS ASKED THAT WE -- I CLEARED THIS WITH
6:45:53PM COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON WHO WILL NOT BE HERE FOR THE WORKSHOP
6:45:57PM SESSION, BUT I HAVE BEEN ASKED BY THE ADMINISTRATION TO MOVE
6:46:00PM THE SOLID WASTE RATE ADJUSTMENT STAFF REPORT FROM MAY
6:46:04PM 16th, 2024, TO THE MAY 23rd WORKSHOP, AND THEN THE RATE
6:46:09PM ADJUSTMENT VOTE WILL COME BACK TO COUNCIL ON JUNE 6, 2024.
6:46:14PM I'M MAKING TWO.
6:46:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
6:46:18PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
6:46:19PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:46:20PM AYE.
6:46:20PM MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE?
6:46:25PM >>LUIS VIERA: THERE WAS CONFUSION ON THIS OTHER MOTION.
6:46:29PM I THOUGHT I HAD ANOTHER VERSION OF IT.
6:46:31PM BUT WITH -- SORRY.
6:46:38PM WHERE DID IT GO?
6:46:38PM DARN IT.
6:46:39PM MOTION FOR TAMPA CITY COUNCIL LETTER IN SUPPORT OF HIVE
6:46:46PM INCLUSIVE COMMUNITY'S EFFORTS ON AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN TAMPA
6:46:51PM FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES.
6:46:53PM THEY ARE INQUIRING WITH THE COUNTY, AND THEY WANTED TO HAVE
6:46:55PM SUPPORT FROM THE CITY.
6:46:56PM THEY HAVE PRESENTED HERE BEFORE.
6:46:57PM REALLY GOOD FOLKS.
6:46:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION FROM COUNCILMAN VIERA.
6:47:00PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
6:47:02PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:47:02PM AYE.
6:47:02PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
6:47:04PM HENDERSON.
6:47:05PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
6:47:06PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:47:07PM AYE.
6:47:08PM WE ARE ADJOURNED.
6:47:09PM [ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.