TAMPA CITY COUNCIL
THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 27, 2025, 5:01 P.M.
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.
5:04:55PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I CALL THIS TAMPA CITY COUNCIL MEETING
5:04:57PM TO ORDER.
5:04:58PM IF WE COULD HAVE ROLL CALL AT THIS TIME.
5:05:04PM >>BILL CARLSON: HERE.
5:05:05PM >>LYNN HURTAK: HERE.
5:05:06PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HERE.
5:05:07PM >> HENDERSON?
5:05:08PM VIERA?
5:05:10PM >>LUIS VIERA: HERE, VIRTUALLY.
5:05:12PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HERE.
5:05:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
5:05:14PM >>THE CLERK: WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
5:05:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN VIERA IS ON.
5:05:18PM HE DID SEND A MEMO SAYING THAT HE INTENDS TO BE VIRTUAL,
5:05:22PM WHICH HE IS, FOR TONIGHT'S EVENING SESSION BECAUSE OF A
5:05:26PM COMMITMENT THAT HE MUST ATTEND TO IN PERSON.
5:05:28PM SO HE WOULD REQUEST THAT THE CITY CLERK SHARE THE MEETING
5:05:31PM LOG-IN CREDENTIALS.
5:05:33PM HE'S ALREADY ALL SET.
5:05:35PM >>LUIS VIERA: IF I MAY, MR. CHAIR, FOR MY TIME, IF I MAY,
5:05:39PM THANK YOU, SIR, I WILL HAVE TO LEAVE AT ABOUT 5:50 TO GET TO
5:05:43PM MY SON'S HIGH SCHOOL.
5:05:44PM AND THEN I ANTICIPATE BEING BACK ONLINE HOPEFULLY BY 8 I
5:05:49PM HOPE.
5:05:49PM JUST FOR THE PUBLIC.
5:05:53PM IT'S A THING WITH MY SON.
5:05:54PM GOOD THING.
5:05:55PM NOT A BAD THING, BUT STILL SOMETHING I HAVE TO DO.
5:05:59PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: CITY COUNCIL ATTORNEY.
5:06:01PM IF WE COULD HAVE A MOTION TO PERMIT COUNCILMAN VIERA FROM
5:06:04PM PARTICIPATING.
5:06:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER
5:06:05PM CLENDENIN AND A SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA TO ALLOW
5:06:08PM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA TO ATTEND VIRTUALLY THIS EVENING AND
5:06:11PM PARTICIPATE.
5:06:12PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:06:13PM AYE.
5:06:13PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:06:14PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: JUST A REMINDER, COUNCILMAN VIERA, DURING
5:06:18PM THE TIME THAT YOU ARE ON CAMERA, YOU ARE COUNTED AS BEING AT
5:06:23PM THE MEETING.
5:06:24PM DURING THE TIME THAT COUNCILMAN VIERA IS PARTICIPATING, IT
5:06:27PM WILL HAVE TO BE A ROLL CALL VOTE.
5:06:29PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:06:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
5:06:32PM WE'RE GOING TO START THE MEETING.
5:06:34PM WE'LL GO THROUGH THE AGENDA WITH MS. DOCK.
5:06:39PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:06:41PM [MICROPHONE NOT ON]
5:07:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MAY I HAVE A MOTION TO REMOVE ITEM 10?
5:07:04PM MOTION FROM CLENDENIN, SECOND FROM MIRANDA.
5:07:08PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:07:08PM ANY OPPOSED?
5:07:10PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THAT'S IT.
5:07:10PM WITH THAT, WE ARE READY TO START.
5:07:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
5:07:13PM I'LL SWEAR EVERYBODY IN FIRST AND THEN KICK IT OFF.
5:07:21PM IF YOU ARE GOING TO SPEAK ON ANY OF THE ITEMS, 1 THROUGH 9,
5:07:24PM PLEASE STAND AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND WE'LL SWEAR YOU
5:07:27PM IN.
5:07:27PM IF YOU ARE GOING TO SPEAK ON ANYTHING BETWEEN 1 THROUGH 9.
5:07:34PM [OATH ADMINISTERED]
5:07:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MR. SHELBY.
5:07:40PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: IF I COULD HAVE A QUICK MOTION TO RECEIVE
5:07:43PM AND FILE ALL EX PARTE COMMUNICATIONS THAT WERE IN WRITING
5:07:46PM THAT HAVE BEEN MADE AVAILABLE FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION.
5:07:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION TO FILE THOSE ITEMS
5:07:53PM FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
5:07:55PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:07:56PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:07:57PM AYE.
5:07:58PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THANK YOU.
5:07:59PM IF THERE ARE ANY VERBAL EX PARTE COMMUNICATIONS, COUNCIL,
5:08:02PM PLEASE BE REMINDED TO DISCLOSE THOSE PRIOR TO THE START OF
5:08:05PM ANY OF THE HEARINGS THAT MAY BE INVOLVED.
5:08:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I SEE NONE.
5:08:09PM YES, MA'AM.
5:08:12PM GO AHEAD, ITEM NUMBER 1.
5:08:15PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: ITEM NUMBER 1 IS REZ 24-45 FOR THE
5:08:19PM PROPERTIES AT 3807 AND 3811 WEST SWANN AVENUE.
5:08:23PM THE REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY FROM PD, PLANNED
5:08:26PM DEVELOPMENT FOR BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL OFFICE TO PD PLANNED
5:08:29PM DEVELOPMENT RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED USES.
5:08:32PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO PLANNING COMMISSION TO GIVE THEIR
5:08:35PM REPORT.
5:08:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:08:38PM LET THE RECORD REFLECT COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON IS HERE.
5:08:41PM YES, MA'AM.
5:08:42PM GO AHEAD.
5:08:44PM >> JENNIFER MALONE WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
5:08:47PM THIS IS IN THE SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT.
5:08:49PM THIS IS A TRADER JOE'S RIGHT HERE TO THE SOUTH, SOUTH DALE
5:08:53PM MABRY HIGHWAY AND WEST SWANN AVENUE.
5:08:56PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS OUTLINED IN PURPLE.
5:08:58PM WE HAVE SOME DRIVE-THROUGH RESTAURANTS ON THE BLOCK AS WELL.
5:09:00PM SOME TOWNHOMES TO THE WEST OF THE SITE AND THEN TO THE
5:09:05PM NORTH.
5:09:05PM THE FUTURE LAND USE -- TWO FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORIES.
5:09:10PM SOME OF YOU MAY REMEMBER THAT ONE OF THESE PARCELS WAS THE
5:09:14PM SUBJECT OF A PLAN AMENDMENT A COUPLE OF YEARS AGO TO
5:09:16PM COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35.
5:09:18PM THAT WAS PRE-COVID TIMES.
5:09:19PM PART OF THE SITE IS COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35, WHICH IS THE
5:09:24PM PINK AND THEN SLIVER OF THE RESIDENTIAL 20 WHICH IS THE
5:09:27PM BROWN COLOR.
5:09:28PM COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35 IS WHAT WE SEE ALONG OUR CORRIDORS.
5:09:32PM SOUTH DALE MABRY HIGHWAY IS A TRANSIT EMPHASIS CORRIDOR.
5:09:37PM WE WANT TO PROMOTE DENSITIES TO UTILIZE ANY FUTURE TRANSIT
5:09:41PM SERVICE.
5:09:42PM RESIDENTIAL 20 ALLOWS FOR TOWNHOMES, MULTIFAMILY STYLE
5:09:46PM DEVELOPMENTS, LIMITED NEIGHBORHOOD SERVING COMMERCIAL USES
5:09:49PM IN THE AREA AS WELL.
5:09:50PM SO THE APPLICANT HAS PROPOSED AND LaCHONE WILL POINT OUT,
5:09:56PM SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED UNITS.
5:10:00PM WHEN THEY SUBMITTED THE SITE PLAN, WE DID ENSURE THAT THE
5:10:03PM DENSITY WAS LAID OUT CORRECTLY BECAUSE THERE IS A DIFFERENT
5:10:07PM DENSITY FOR THE RESIDENTIAL 20 IN THE CMU 35 PORTION.
5:10:11PM STAFF WORKED WITH THE APPLICANT ON THAT.
5:10:13PM WE FOUND THAT THIS WAS CONSISTENT WITH THE SURROUNDING AREA.
5:10:16PM IT'S GOING TO PROVIDE INFILL DEVELOPMENT ON A SITE THAT IS
5:10:18PM PRESENTLY UNDERUTILIZED WHICH IS ENCOURAGED BY THE
5:10:21PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
5:10:22PM IT'S ALSO GOING TO PROVIDE A TRANSITION FROM THE COMMERCIAL
5:10:24PM USES TO THE EAST AND SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED RESIDENCES OR
5:10:29PM ANY TOWNHOMES TO THE WEST.
5:10:30PM THE REQUEST IS CONSISTENT WITH LU POLICY 9.7.3 WHICH
5:10:35PM ENCOURAGES A TRANSITION IN DENSITY BETWEEN SINGLE-FAMILY
5:10:38PM NEIGHBORHOODS AND THE MORE INTENSE COMMERCIAL AND
5:10:41PM RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOODS.
5:10:41PM WE ALSO FOUND THAT THE ORIENTATION OF THE UNITS PROVIDING
5:10:45PM THAT PEDESTRIAN CONNECTION FROM THE FRONT DOOR TO THE
5:10:47PM SIDEWALK ALONG SWANN WAS CONSISTENT WITH OUR POLICIES ABOUT
5:10:50PM THAT AS WELL.
5:10:51PM I'M AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
5:10:52PM THANK YOU.
5:10:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:10:58PM YES, MA'AM.
5:10:59PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:11:01PM THIS PD REQUEST, THIS REZONING REQUEST WOULD ALLOW FOR
5:11:06PM DEVELOPMENT OF 12 UNITS ON-SITE.
5:11:09PM THAT IS RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED UNITS.
5:11:12PM THEY ARE COMPRISED OF THREE BUILDINGS ON-SITE.
5:11:16PM THE MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT PROPOSED IS 38 FEET.
5:11:19PM THE PROPERTY ITSELF CONTAINS 26,515 SQUARE FEET.
5:11:24PM THE SETBACKS ARE TO THE NORTH THREE FEET, TO THE SOUTH FIVE
5:11:27PM FEET, TO THE WEST THREE FEET, AND THE EAST SEVEN FEET.
5:11:30PM 27 PARKING SPACES ARE REQUIRED AND 28 PARKING SPACES ARE
5:11:35PM PROVIDED.
5:11:35PM SO ON THE SITE PLAN THAT'S SUBMITTED BY THE APPLICANT, THIS
5:11:39PM IS SWANN AVENUE.
5:11:42PM THIS IS THE PROPERTY BOUNDARY WHICH IS IDENTIFIED HERE IN
5:11:44PM THE DOTTED LINE.
5:11:46PM THIS DARK DOTTED LINE HERE DELINEATES THE FUTURE LAND USE.
5:11:51PM AS JENNIFER HAS MENTIONED, THERE ARE TWO FUTURE LAND USE
5:11:54PM DESIGNATIONS ON THE PROPERTY.
5:11:56PM TO THE EAST OF THE LINE IS CMU 35.
5:11:58PM TO THE WEST OF THE LINE IS THE R-20 DESIGNATION.
5:12:01PM SO THIS IS THE BUILDING ONE, BUILDING TWO, AND BUILDING
5:12:06PM THREE.
5:12:06PM THE END UNITS OF EACH BUILDING YOU CAN SEE ARE ORIENTED TO
5:12:11PM SWANN AVENUE.
5:12:12PM THE INTERNAL UNITS ARE ORIENTED WITH THE FRONT DOOR TO THE
5:12:16PM INTERNAL SPACE BETWEEN THE TWO BUILDINGS.
5:12:20PM THERE'S ALSO A WALKWAY WITH LEADS TO THE ADJOINING SIDEWALK
5:12:25PM ON-SITE.
5:12:26PM THESE BUILDINGS HAVE FRONT DOOR ORIENTATION TO THE SIDE
5:12:29PM YARD, SO THERE IS A WAIVER ON THE SITE PLAN FOR THAT.
5:12:33PM YOU CAN SEE SURFACE PARKING SPACES ARE PROVIDED HERE, THE
5:12:36PM VISITOR PARKING SPACES.
5:12:38PM THIS IS A SITE WHICH WAS REDESIGNED INITIALLY.
5:12:41PM THE APPLICANT SUBMITTED A REQUEST THAT HAD THE BUILDINGS
5:12:44PM FURTHER NORTH ON THE SITE.
5:12:46PM AND THEN NORTH OF THE SITE, WHICH I WILL SHOW YOU THE
5:12:49PM SURROUNDING PICTURES SHORTLY, THERE ARE TOWNHOME
5:12:53PM DEVELOPMENTS THAT ARE TO THE NORTH.
5:12:55PM BUT THE RESUBMITTAL WAS TO HAVE THE BUILDINGS PUSHED FURTHER
5:12:58PM SOUTH TOWARDS THE STREET TO ORIENT THE DOORS TO THE
5:13:01PM RIGHT-OF-WAY AND TO ALLOW THE PRESERVATION OF TREES THAT
5:13:05PM EXIST ALONG THE NORTH.
5:13:06PM ALONG WITH THE PLACEMENT OF THE SOLID WASTE.
5:13:08PM I JUST WANTED TO EXPLAIN THAT THE APPLICANT DID WORK WITH
5:13:13PM STAFF SOME ON THAT.
5:13:14PM THE ELEVATIONS, I'LL PROVIDE YOU THE ELEVATIONS FOR THE
5:13:20PM THREE UNIT BUILDING AND THEN THE FOUR UNIT BUILDING, THE
5:13:23PM FIVE UNIT BUILDING IS SIMILAR.
5:13:24PM SO THIS IS THE WEST ELEVATION.
5:13:28PM AND THEN THIS IS THE EAST ELEVATION.
5:13:32PM AGAIN, THIS IS THE THREE UNIT BUILDING AND THEN THIS IS THE
5:13:36PM NORTH ELEVATION AND THE SOUTH ELEVATION.
5:13:38PM AND THEN THE TOP PICTURES ARE THE WEST AND THE EAST
5:13:47PM ELEVATION AND THEN THIS IS THE NORTH AND THE SOUTH
5:13:52PM ELEVATION.
5:13:54PM THEN I HAVE THE ZONING ATLAS.
5:13:59PM THE ZONING MAP FOR THE PROPERTY.
5:14:04PM SO THIS IS THE PROPERTY WHICH IS OUTLINED HERE IN RED.
5:14:07PM THIS IS SWANN AVENUE.
5:14:08PM FOR ORIENTATION, THIS IS SOUTH DALE MABRY.
5:14:11PM THIS IS De LEON.
5:14:13PM THIS IS CHURCH AVENUE.
5:14:14PM AND THIS IS HENDERSON BOULEVARD.
5:14:16PM SO THE SUBJECT SITE YOU CAN SEE IS SURROUNDED WITH
5:14:21PM PROPERTIES THAT HAVE BEEN REZONED.
5:14:23PM YOU HAVE TO THE NORTH PD AND RO DEVELOPMENT WHICH IS
5:14:27PM SINGLE-FAMILY SEMI DETACHED.
5:14:30PM TO THE WEST YOU HAVE THE RM 16 ZONING WITH THE SINGLE-FAMILY
5:14:34PM ATTACHED AND SEMI DETACHED USES.
5:14:37PM FURTHER WEST OF THE SITE, WEST OF CHURCH AVENUE, YOU HAVE
5:14:41PM YOUR RS 60 ZONING AND THE DEVELOPMENT IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
5:14:44PM ZONING AS RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED.
5:14:48PM WHEN YOU MOVE FURTHER EAST, YOU HAVE SOUTH DALE MABRY
5:14:52PM HIGHWAY.
5:14:52PM THAT'S WHERE YOU HAVE, OF COURSE, YOUR MORE INTENSIVE USES,
5:14:55PM YOUR COMMERCIAL USES.
5:14:57PM THIS EAST OF THE PROPERTY IS THE PARKING ACCESS THAT GOES TO
5:15:00PM BURGER KING.
5:15:02PM THIS NORTH OF THE SITE, THIS IS THE CHICK-FIL-A SITE AND
5:15:06PM THIS IS THE TAHITIAN INN.
5:15:09PM TO THE SOUTH IS TRADER JOE'S AND YOU HAVE RESIDENTIAL OFFICE
5:15:15PM WITH THE MULTIFAMILY -- THE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED USES.
5:15:17PM I HAVE PICTURES OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND THE SURROUNDING
5:15:26PM AREA.
5:15:26PM THIS IS THE SITE WHICH IS CURRENTLY VACANT.
5:15:32PM THIS IS ANOTHER IMAGE OF THE SITE, FURTHER IN THE SITE.
5:15:38PM THIS IS A VIEW IF YOU'RE LOOKING WEST ON SWANN.
5:15:42PM THE SITE IS HERE IN THE PICTURE.
5:15:46PM THIS IS IF YOU'RE LOOKING EAST ON SWANN.
5:15:48PM THIS IS TO TURN THE OPPOSITE WAY LOOKING TOWARDS DALE MABRY.
5:15:51PM THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE.
5:16:00PM THIS IS EAST OF THE SITE.
5:16:02PM THIS IS THE PARKING ACCESS THAT'S LOCATED DIRECTLY.
5:16:05PM THE SITE IS HERE.
5:16:05PM THIS IS AT DALE MABRY EAST OF THE SITE.
5:16:12PM YOU CAN SEE THE COMMERCIAL USES IN THAT VIEW LOOKING EAST.
5:16:16PM THIS IS SOUTH.
5:16:18PM THIS IS THE TRADER JOE'S ENTRY.
5:16:22PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW SOUTH.
5:16:26PM THIS IS THE RESIDENTIAL THAT'S LOCATED SOUTH.
5:16:28PM YOU CAN SEE THE ATTACHED USES, SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED.
5:16:31PM THIS IS A VIEW, TURN AROUND AND LOOK WEST ON SWANN.
5:16:34PM THE SITE IS HERE IN THE PICTURE OFF TO THE RIGHT.
5:16:38PM THIS IS DIRECTLY WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
5:16:42PM AND THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW IF YOU'RE LOOKING DOWN THE STREET,
5:16:45PM BUT YOU CAN SEE THE HOMES THAT ARE LOCATED WEST OF THE SITE.
5:16:49PM DRC STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FINDS THE REQUEST
5:17:02PM CONSISTENT.
5:17:02PM THERE ARE MODIFICATIONS TO BE MADE TO THE SITE PLAN BETWEEN
5:17:05PM FIRST AND SECOND READING.
5:17:06PM I WOULD LIKE TO TURN IT OVER TO ERIN SO SHE CAN REVIEW
5:17:10PM NATURAL RESOURCES COMMENT AND FINDINGS.
5:17:13PM I'M AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS.
5:17:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
5:17:14PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:17:15PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:17:19PM >> ERIN MAEHR, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:17:22PM I'M JUST GOING TO SPEAK ON NATURAL RESOURCES FINDING OF
5:17:26PM CONSISTENCY FOR REZ 24-45.
5:17:28PM SO HERE ON THE OVERHEAD I'M GOING TO POINT OUT, THERE IS ONE
5:17:31PM NON-HAZARDOUS GRAND LIVE OAK ON THE SITE LOCATED ON THE
5:17:37PM EASTERN PARCEL.
5:17:40PM JUST TO CLARIFY, SO IN THE PREVIOUS REZONING, REZ 21-27, THE
5:17:46PM REZONING WAS FOR AN OFFICE USE.
5:17:48PM AND THEY REQUESTED THE WAIVER TO REMOVE THE GRAND TREE.
5:17:51PM IT WAS GRANTED.
5:17:52PM ALL THE TREES ON THE SITE WERE REQUESTED FOR REMOVAL AND
5:17:56PM THAT WAS APPROVED.
5:17:58PM BECAUSE THE USE HAS CHANGED, WE'RE REQUIRING THE WAIVER
5:18:03PM AGAIN FOR THEM TO REQUEST THAT AGAIN.
5:18:05PM BUT NATURAL RESOURCES DOES SUPPORT THE WAIVER AS THEY CAN
5:18:09PM PROVIDE SEVEN TYPE 1 TREES AND SEVEN TYPE 2 TREES ON THE
5:18:13PM SITE.
5:18:14PM AND THEY CAN MEET ALL THEIR TREE PLANTING REQUIREMENTS.
5:18:17PM SO THIS IS JUST THE GREENSPACE PLAN AND THE LANDSCAPE PLAN
5:18:22PM BEING SHOWN.
5:18:23PM THE TYPE 1 AND TYPE 2 TREES THAT THEY ARE PROVIDING, THEY
5:18:27PM ARE SIZING THEM UP TO FOUR INCH CALIPER, SO THESE HERE ALONG
5:18:31PM THE BACK ARE TYPE 2, LIKE YOUR CYPRESS TREES, PODOCARPUS.
5:18:36PM THE TYPE 1 TREES ARE HERE, LIKE YOUR LIVE OAKS ALONG THE
5:18:40PM RIGHT-OF-WAY AND BACK HERE IN THE BUFFER.
5:18:45PM THE PROJECT ALSO EXCEEDS THE REQUIRED GREENSPACE.
5:18:48PM SO THE SITE REQUIRES 5900 SQUARE FEET AND THEY ARE PROVIDING
5:18:52PM 6489 SQUARE FEET.
5:18:54PM SO BASED ON WHAT THEY HAVE PROPOSED, NATURAL RESOURCES FOUND
5:18:59PM IT CONSISTENT.
5:19:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:19:02PM ANY QUESTIONS?
5:19:03PM NO.
5:19:03PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:19:04PM DOES THAT COMPLETE THE PRESENTATION?
5:19:07PM ALL RIGHT.
5:19:07PM IF WE HAVE AN APPLICANT, MR. MECHANIK, PLEASE COME UP AND
5:19:11PM STATE YOUR NAME.
5:19:12PM >> MR. CHAIRMAN, COUNCIL MEMBERS, MY NAME IS DAVID MECHANIK.
5:19:16PM 305 SOUTH BOULEVARD, TAMPA, FLORIDA, HERE ON BEHALF OF THE
5:19:22PM APPLICANT.
5:19:23PM I HAVE WITH ME THIS EVENING STEVE SCHALL WHO IS THE PROPERTY
5:19:27PM OWNER.
5:19:28PM I HAVE RICKY PETERIKA WHO IS THE ARBORIST ON THE PROJECT,
5:19:33PM AND I WILL ASK HIM TO SPEAK IN JUST A MOMENT.
5:19:37PM OUR CIVIL ENGINEER IS HERE, AZAM ELSHEIKH.
5:19:43PM FINALLY, FOR ANY TRAFFIC QUESTIONS, AND I DON'T PLAN ON
5:19:47PM HAVING HIM DOING A PRESENTATION BUT I HAVE SOME INFORMATION
5:19:51PM REGARDING TRAFFIC THAT I WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT TO YOU LATER
5:19:54PM ON IN MY PRESENTATION.
5:19:56PM REGARDING THE PROJECT ITSELF, WE AGREE WITH ALL THE CHANGES
5:20:03PM THAT ARE BEING REQUESTED BY THE STAFF.
5:20:05PM WE WOULD MAKE THOSE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
5:20:09PM THE STAFF HAS FOUND THE PROJECT TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE
5:20:13PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE AND ALSO
5:20:18PM FOUND THAT IT IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE IMMEDIATE SURROUNDING
5:20:23PM AREA.
5:20:24PM IN ADDITION, THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FOUND THE PROJECT
5:20:28PM CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND SPECIFICALLY
5:20:33PM REMARKED THAT IT FURTHERS THE GOAL OF PROVIDING HOUSING IN
5:20:38PM THIS AREA OF THE CITY.
5:20:42PM SO ALL OF OUR COMMENTS ARE FAVORABLE AND INDICATE A
5:20:48PM CONSISTENCY WITH THE REGULATIONS.
5:20:51PM AT THIS TIME, I'D LIKE TO TALK ABOUT OUR TWO WAIVERS.
5:20:56PM THE FIRST I'LL ADDRESS AND THE SECOND ONE I'LL ASK RICKY TO
5:21:01PM SPEAK TO.
5:21:03PM WE ARE ASKING FOR A WAIVER TO ALLOW FOR ALL BUT THREE OF THE
5:21:07PM UNITS TO NOT FACE THE SWANN AVENUE RIGHT-OF-WAY.
5:21:13PM THIS IS A REGULATION IN THE CODE.
5:21:16PM YOU FREQUENTLY WAIVE THIS REQUIREMENT BECAUSE OF
5:21:20PM CONFIGURATIONS OF PROPERTY, IT'S NOT POSSIBLE FOR AN
5:21:27PM APPLICANT TO ALWAYS FACE THE TOWNHOMES DIRECTLY TO THE
5:21:32PM RIGHT-OF-WAY.
5:21:32PM IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE, THE PROPERTY IS QUITE DEEP.
5:21:39PM A TYPICAL TOWN HOUSE LOT IS ABOUT 75 FEET DEEP.
5:21:43PM SO IF YOU WERE TO ASK MY CLIENT TO PUT TOWNHOMES ALL IN A
5:21:48PM ROW FACING SWANN AVENUE, YOU'D HAVE A STRIP OF ABOUT 60 FEET
5:21:55PM OF LAND THAT HAD NO PARTICULAR USEFUL PURPOSE TO IT AND WE
5:22:01PM WOULD LOSE ABOUT THREE TOWNHOMES IN ORDER TO ADHERE TO THAT
5:22:05PM PARTICULAR REQUIREMENT.
5:22:08PM I WOULD ALSO JUST POINT OUT THAT IF YOU HAD GARAGES ALL
5:22:12PM BACKING UP TO SWANN AVENUE, ALL OF THOSE WOULD BECOME ACCESS
5:22:18PM POINTS ONTO SWANN AVENUE.
5:22:22PM AS YOU ALL KNOW, BEING ACROSS FROM TRADER JOE'S, THIS AREA
5:22:26PM IS A LITTLE BIT CHALLENGED AT CERTAIN TIMES OF DAY WHEN
5:22:30PM THERE'S TRUCK CONGESTION AND PEOPLE LOOKING FOR PARKING.
5:22:34PM WE DON'T WANT TO EXACERBATE THE PROBLEM BY HAVING TOWN HOUSE
5:22:38PM OWNERS BACKING INTO SWANN AVENUE IF WE CAN AVOID IT.
5:22:42PM SO WITH THAT, LET ME ASK RICKY PETERIKA TO JUST SPEAK
5:22:49PM BRIEFLY ABOUT THE WAIVER FOR THE GRAND TREE.
5:22:52PM AND I WOULD SAY, EMPHASIZE THAT ERIN DID INDICATE THAT WE
5:22:57PM WERE FULLY CONSISTENT WITH THE CODE, ALTHOUGH WE DO NEED THE
5:23:02PM WAIVER BUT WE EXCEEDED OTHER REQUIREMENTS, AND THAT WAS A
5:23:08PM FACTOR IN HER FINDING.
5:23:13PM >> THANK YOU, MR. MECHANIK.
5:23:14PM THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
5:23:15PM RICKY PETERIKA, 308 EAST 7TH AVENUE WITH DARK MOSS.
5:23:19PM I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
5:23:20PM INTRODUCE YOU TO THE TREE QUICKLY.
5:23:22PM 36-INCH GRAND LIVE OAK RATED C-5.
5:23:28PM SUBJECT TO 13 MITIGATION TREES.
5:23:32PM WE PREPARED TWO REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION OPTIONS.
5:23:38PM I'LL GO THROUGH THOSE NOW.
5:23:41PM THIS OPTION, THE TREE IN QUESTION IS HERE.
5:23:44PM IN ORDER TO REDUCE THE AMOUNT OF IMPACT IN THE TPZ, THE TREE
5:23:49PM PROTECTION ZONE, WE PROPOSE MOVING THIS UNIT TO THIS END OF
5:23:56PM THIS BUILDING.
5:23:58PM THIS PROVIDES MORE ROOTING VOLUME WITHIN THE TPZ, REQUIRES
5:24:01PM SOME SPECIAL DESIGN TECHNIQUES ON THE BUILDING, BUT THEN
5:24:04PM RESULTS IN 50% OF CANOPY LOSS OF THESE TWO ALMOST GRAND 30
5:24:09PM AND 31-INCH TREES.
5:24:10PM THAT ARE SHARED WITH THE NORTHERN PROPERTY LINE.
5:24:14PM SO WE FOUND THAT WAS -- AND IT ALSO IMPACTED THE ONLY
5:24:18PM SURFACE STORMWATER MANAGEMENT ON THE SITE.
5:24:20PM THE SECOND OPTION, WHICH IS MORE INTERESTING ESOTERIC OPTION
5:24:28PM FROM WHAT WE'RE NORMALLY DOING, SIMILAR CONCEPT OF
5:24:31PM RELOCATING A UNIT TO ANOTHER BUILDING.
5:24:35PM SO HERE MOVED IT TO THIS UNIT, SHIFTED THE BUILDING OVER AS
5:24:40PM THE CRITERIA ALLOWS, ALSO TO THE SOUTH.
5:24:44PM HOWEVER, THIS ARRANGEMENT OF FOUR UNITS BEYOND THE COMP PLAN
5:24:52PM BOUNDARY WOULDN'T BE ALLOWED PER THE COMP PLAN.
5:24:55PM IT WOULD EXCEED THE ALLOWABLE DENSITY OF I THINK RES 20 ON
5:25:01PM THIS SIDE.
5:25:02PM WHILE IT SEEMED TO WORK ON FACE VALUE, IT DIDN'T WORK FROM A
5:25:06PM COMP PLAN PERSPECTIVE.
5:25:09PM THE TREE POSITION IS UNIQUE.
5:25:16PM IT ALREADY BEING APPROVED FOR REMOVAL IS UNIQUE, AND THE
5:25:22PM ARRANGEMENT OF THE SITE PLAN, LOSS OF POTENTIAL PARKING OR
5:25:26PM STORMWATER OR VIOLATION OF COMP PLAN AMENDMENT MAKE THIS,
5:25:33PM OUR REQUEST CONSISTENT WITH THE CODE AND IN MY PROFESSIONAL
5:25:39PM OPINION AS WELL AS WITH THE COMP PLAN.
5:25:42PM I'LL TURN IT BACK OVER TO MR. MECHANIK.
5:25:50PM >> I'M JUST GOING TO HAND SOMETHING OUT TO COUNCIL AND THEN
5:25:53PM I'LL DESCRIBE IT VERY BRIEFLY.
5:25:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
5:25:57PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I ACTUALLY HAVE A QUESTION FOR MR. PETERIKA.
5:26:00PM WITH THOSE -- THE ALTERNATE DESIGNS YOU PUT UP, IS THERE A
5:26:12PM REASON -- IT SEEMS LIKE JUST REMOVING ONE OF THE TOWNHOMES
5:26:16PM WOULD HAVE SOLVED THE PROBLEM.
5:26:21PM >> THE REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION CRITERIA DOESN'T LIST
5:26:25PM REDUCING DENSITY OR INTENSITY AS ONE OF THE OPTIONS THAT --
5:26:32PM AS THE CRITERIA.
5:26:33PM AS I UNDERSTAND IT, IT'S AN ADJUSTMENT OF -- IT'S A
5:26:41PM RECONFIGURATION OF WHAT THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT WAS.
5:26:48PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OKAY.
5:26:49PM IT JUST SEEMS AWFULLY ODD YOU WOULDN'T HAVE JUST REMOVED A
5:26:53PM TOWNHOME.
5:26:54PM >> YES, THANK YOU.
5:26:55PM THE CODE MAY NOT ASK US TO.
5:27:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:27:00PM MR. MECHANIK.
5:27:03PM >> THIS IS DAVID MECHANIK AGAIN, FOR THE RECORD.
5:27:05PM I'LL BE BRIEF.
5:27:07PM WE ARE ABOUT TO CONCLUDE THE PRESENTATION.
5:27:11PM WHAT I JUST HANDED OUT IS A TRIP COMPARISON THAT WAS
5:27:17PM PREPARED BY MR. COEN.
5:27:20PM THE FINDINGS ARE FAIRLY SELF-EVIDENT, AND I WON'T ASK HIM TO
5:27:26PM DO A PRESENTATION ALTHOUGH YOU ALL ARE FREE TO ASK HIM
5:27:30PM QUESTIONS IF YOU LIKE.
5:27:32PM WHAT WE ARE SHOWING YOU IS THE NUMBER OF TRIPS THAT ARE
5:27:36PM ALLOWED AND THOSE ARE SHOWN IN BLUE.
5:27:41PM UNDER THE CURRENT ZONING APPROVAL OF OFFICE FOR THIS
5:27:44PM PROPERTY -- I'M SORRY.
5:27:45PM THE BLUE IS THE ORIGINAL USE OF A DAY CARE CENTER.
5:27:50PM THE RED IS THE CURRENTLY APPROVED OFFICE SCENARIO FOR THE
5:27:56PM SITE.
5:27:56PM AND THE GREEN IS WHAT WE ARE PROPOSING TONIGHT.
5:28:00PM AS YOU COULD SEE, THE TRAFFIC FROM THE STANDPOINT OF THIS
5:28:05PM PARTICULAR PROJECT IS FAR LESS THAN ANY OF THE OTHER
5:28:10PM SCENARIOS THAT WERE AVAILABLE TO THIS PROPERTY.
5:28:16PM I ONLY MENTION TRAFFIC BECAUSE OF THE FACT WE KNOW THERE ARE
5:28:20PM SOME ISSUES WITH TRADER JOE'S, AND WE ARE NOT IN ANY WAY
5:28:25PM EXACERBATING THAT PROBLEM.
5:28:27PM I JUST WANTED COUNCIL TO KNOW THAT.
5:28:30PM WE'LL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
5:28:31PM AND BE HERE TO REBUT ANY COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC.
5:28:39PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SO, MR. MECHANIK, IS ANYBODY HERE FROM
5:28:45PM TRANSPORTATION, FROM STAFF?
5:28:49PM >>JONATHAN SCOTT: JONATHAN SCOTT, MOBILITY.
5:28:50PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MY QUESTION IS, INTUITIVELY, HOW DID THIS
5:28:53PM PASS TRANSPORTATION?
5:28:54PM BECAUSE ANYBODY THAT LIVES HERE KNOWS THAT'S A NIGHTMARE.
5:28:59PM MR. MECHANIK INSINUATED THAT IN THE PRESENTATION.
5:29:02PM TRADER JOE'S IS ONE OF THOSE THINGS THAT YOU HEAR ALL THE
5:29:06PM TIME, HOW DID THIS GET BUILT HERE?
5:29:08PM BECAUSE OF THE NIGHTMARE GOING IN AND OUT OF THAT.
5:29:12PM I CAN'T IMAGINE ADDING THE DENSITY ON THE PROPERTY RIGHT
5:29:14PM ACROSS THE WAY THAT ANYBODY WOULD LOOK AT THIS AND THINK,
5:29:17PM OH, THIS IS A GOOD IDEA.
5:29:19PM HOW IN THE WORLD DID THIS PASS TRANSPORTATION?
5:29:21PM >>JONATHAN SCOTT: JONATHAN SCOTT.
5:29:22PM THAT IS A CRAZY AREA.
5:29:23PM I KNOW THAT LOCATION VERY WELL.
5:29:25PM WE DID LOOK AT THE TRIPS ON THERE.
5:29:32PM I THINK THAT IT WAS MORE OF A DE MINIMIS USE AT THE TIME FOR
5:29:39PM THEIR USE.
5:29:41PM SO IT WASN'T AN IMPACT -- YOU DIDN'T HAVE A MEMO.
5:29:50PM >> WE DEMONSTRATED THAT --
5:29:52PM >> YEAH, THEY HAD A DE MINIMIS.
5:29:55PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: DO YOU HAVE THAT IN THE PRESENTATION?
5:29:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COME ON UP TO THE MICROPHONE, SIR, SO WE
5:30:01PM CAN HEAR YOU.
5:30:03PM >> YOU COULD SEE THE NUMBER OF TRIPS, AND IT IS BELOW THE
5:30:09PM THRESHOLD OF THE CITY OF TAMPA CODE FOR REQUIRING A TRAFFIC
5:30:15PM STUDY.
5:30:16PM IT'S DE MINIMIS.
5:30:18PM A STUDY WAS NOT REQUIRED OF THIS CASE.
5:30:22PM AGAIN, THE PROBLEMS THAT YOU'RE SEEING ARE NOT CAUSED BY MY
5:30:27PM CLIENT'S PROPERTY.
5:30:28PM HIS PROPERTY IS VACANT.
5:30:31PM SO THERE'S NO -- WE'RE NOT CONTRIBUTING TO ANY PROBLEM OUT
5:30:35PM THERE TODAY AND 12 TOWNHOMES ARE CERTAINLY, WHILE I'M NOT
5:30:41PM GOING TO SAY THERE IS NO TRAFFIC, THIS IS ABOUT THE LEAST
5:30:45PM IMPACTFUL USE YOU COULD IMAGINE PUTTING ON THIS PIECE OF
5:30:50PM PROPERTY AND NOT CAUSING ANY FURTHER PROBLEMS IN THAT AREA.
5:30:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
5:31:01PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: IF I COULD ASK FOR CLARITY.
5:31:02PM I'M NOT GOING BACK IN THE HISTORY BOOK.
5:31:04PM WHEN THAT PROPERTY CHANGED HANDS, TRADER JOE'S CAME IN, NO
5:31:09PM HEARING ON IT BECAUSE THAT LAND WAS ALREADY ZONED FOR WHAT
5:31:11PM THEY NEEDED.
5:31:12PM NO TRAFFIC STUDY WAS DONE, NOTHING WAS DONE.
5:31:15PM THEY CAME IN AND DID WHAT THEY HAD TO DO.
5:31:18PM HOWEVER, THIS IS ONE OF THE RARE CASES I'VE SEEN WHERE THE
5:31:22PM IDEA OF BEING SUCCESSFUL HAS CAUSED HEARTACHE TO A LOT OF
5:31:28PM PEOPLE.
5:31:28PM I CAN TELL YOU THAT I DRIVE THERE.
5:31:30PM I HAVE FAMILY IN THAT AREA, NOT NEAR THE ZONING OR ANYTHING
5:31:33PM ELSE, BUT WHEN I DRIVE THROUGH DALE MABRY HEADING SOUTH, AND
5:31:37PM I APPROACH SWANN AND I SEE THE CARS BACKED UP TO DALE MABRY
5:31:42PM AND COMING AT ME, WE GOT A PROBLEM.
5:31:45PM NOT ME.
5:31:46PM WE HAVE A PROBLEM.
5:31:46PM AND I APPLAUD THEM FOR DOING WHAT THEY HAVE DONE.
5:31:50PM THEY HAVE DONE A GREAT JOB WITH THE MARKETING.
5:31:52PM GREAT JOB WITH THEIR PRODUCT.
5:31:54PM I'VE BEEN THERE ONCE OR TWICE.
5:31:56PM I DON'T GO OFTEN BECAUSE I LIVE ON THE OTHER SIDE OF TOWN,
5:31:59PM BUT I CAN TELL YOU THAT IT'S THINGS LIKE THIS THAT MAKE ME
5:32:04PM BELIEVE SOMEWHERE ALONG THE LINE, I'M TALKING DIRECTLY TO
5:32:07PM OUR STAFF, SOMETHING HAS TO HAPPEN IN THE CITY OF TAMPA TO
5:32:09PM MAKE SOMEBODY RESPONSIBLE FOR THESE THINGS.
5:32:14PM SUCCESS -- BRINGS FAILURE TO SOMEBODY ELSE.
5:32:19PM THAT'S WHAT WE HAVE HERE TODAY.
5:32:20PM I'M NOT BLAMING TRADER JOE'S.
5:32:22PM THEIR BUSINESS, THE PEOPLE LOVE IT.
5:32:24PM IF NOT, THEY WOULDN'T GO THERE.
5:32:26PM THEY REALLY, REALLY ENJOY IT.
5:32:29PM NOT ONE COMPLAINT ON THEIR PRODUCT OR NOTHING.
5:32:31PM BUT I'VE HAD A LOT OF COMPLAINTS ON THE TRAFFIC SOMETIME
5:32:37PM BACK TO PRESENT TIME.
5:32:39PM IT'S NOT FROM MY FAMILY MEMBERS.
5:32:40PM THEY DON'T SPEAK TO ME ABOUT NONE OF THAT STUFF.
5:32:43PM I CAN TELL YOU WHAT I SEE AND THAT'S WITHOUT GLASSES.
5:32:52PM SUCCESS SOMETIMES BRINGS FAILURE OR LACK OF OPPORTUNITY TO
5:32:56PM SOMEONE ELSE.
5:33:03PM >> IF I COULD CLOSE OUR PRESENTATION BY SAYING WHILE TRADER
5:33:08PM JOE'S MAY, IN FACT, BE CAUSING A PROBLEM, MY CLIENT DIDN'T
5:33:11PM CAUSE THIS PROBLEM AND THE LEGAL ANSWER IS NOT TO SAY
5:33:18PM MR. SCHALL, YOU CAN'T LIVE OR YOU CAN'T BUILD ANYTHING ON
5:33:22PM YOUR PROPERTY.
5:33:23PM WE HAVE THE LEAST IMPACTFUL USE YOU COULD POSSIBLY PUT ON
5:33:29PM THIS PROPERTY, AND WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST COUNCIL APPROVE
5:33:35PM OUR APPLICATION.
5:33:35PM AND WE WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
5:33:39PM THANK YOU.
5:33:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:33:40PM BEFORE I GO TO THE PUBLIC COMMENT IN THE ROOM, WE HAVE THREE
5:33:44PM REGISTERED PUBLIC SPEAKERS.
5:33:45PM ARE THEY ON?
5:33:46PM ROBERT, IF YOU ARE ON, PLEASE TURN YOUR CAMERA ON, UNMUTE
5:33:55PM YOURSELF, RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND.
5:33:59PM WE'LL SWEAR YOU IN.
5:34:00PM ALSO, QUITE A FEW PEOPLE CAME INTO THE ROOM IN THE LAST FEW
5:34:03PM MINUTES.
5:34:03PM IF YOU WERE NOT SWORN IN AND RECENTLY CAME IN WITHIN THE
5:34:06PM LAST FEW MINUTES AND YOU WISH TO SPEAK TONIGHT ON ANY OF THE
5:34:09PM HEARINGS, PLEASE STAND AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND WE'LL
5:34:12PM SWEAR YOU IN.
5:34:27PM [OATH ADMINISTERED]
5:34:34PM ALL RIGHT.
5:34:35PM GO AHEAD, ROBERT, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:34:37PM YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES.
5:34:39PM >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR HAVING ME.
5:34:42PM IS MY AUDIO OKAY?
5:34:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, WE CAN HEAR YOU.
5:34:45PM GO AHEAD.
5:34:45PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:34:46PM >> PERFECT.
5:34:47PM ROBERT COMENSA.
5:34:50PM 3813 WEST SWANN UNIT 1 WHICH IS DIRECTLY FIRST UNIT TO THE
5:34:55PM LEFT OF THE DEVELOPMENT AND MY BROTHER IS ACTUALLY UNIT 2,
5:34:58PM SO RIGHT ADJACENT TO THAT.
5:35:01PM I VOUCH FOR KIND OF THE CONGESTION ON WEST SWANN, ESPECIALLY
5:35:07PM DURING THE DAYTIME, ON THE WEEKENDS, IT'S PRETTY BACKED UP.
5:35:12PM CONSTRUCTION ITSELF, HOWEVER HOW LONG THAT TAKES WILL
5:35:17PM OBVIOUSLY BE A LITTLE MORE IMPACTFUL.
5:35:20PM MY MAIN CONCERN IS KIND OF THE DUMPSTER LOCATION, WHICH IS
5:35:25PM THE TOP LEFT CORNER OF THE DEVELOPMENT, WHICH IS JUST A FOOT
5:35:30PM OR SO AWAY FROM THE FENCE LINE TO THE PROPERTY.
5:35:34PM AS YOU CAN IMAGINE, A LOT OF NOISE AND THAT SOMETIMES BRINGS
5:35:38PM IN RODENTS AND LIKE ANIMALS, WHICH WOULD BE IMPACTED TO THE
5:35:43PM UNIT BEHIND ME AS WELL.
5:35:44PM SO I THINK JUST TRAFFIC ISSUES AND KIND OF THE DUMPSTER
5:35:49PM LOCATION, I WAS WONDERING IF IT KIND OF MADE MORE SENSE TO
5:35:52PM KEEP IT AWAY FROM KIND OF THE EXISTING UNITS ON KIND OF WEST
5:35:56PM SWANN, IF THAT WOULD AT ALL BE POSSIBLE.
5:36:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYTHING ELSE, SIR?
5:36:06PM >> THAT WAS IT.
5:36:06PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:36:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
5:36:07PM IS THERE ANYBODY IN THIS ROOM THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM
5:36:13PM NUMBER 1?
5:36:14PM COME ON UP.
5:36:15PM YES, SIR.
5:36:23PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:36:24PM >> GOOD EVENING, MR. CHAIRMAN AND COUNCIL.
5:36:27PM KYLE ROSS.
5:36:27PM I'M ALSO A LOCAL HERE DIRECTLY IMPACTED BY THIS PROGRAM.
5:36:31PM MY HOME IS A STONE'S THROW AWAY FROM THIS PROJECT.
5:36:38PM I WANT TO START BY GETTING ORGANIZED HERE.
5:36:40PM I BROUGHT SOME DOCUMENTS I WOULD LIKE TO SHARE WITH THE
5:36:43PM PANEL.
5:36:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SURE.
5:36:44PM DO YOU WANT TO HAND THEM TO US OR PUT THEM ON THE OVERHEAD?
5:36:48PM >> I WILL USE THE ELMO, IF THAT IS OKAY.
5:36:51PM I REVIEWED THE STAFF REPORT.
5:36:59PM I REVIEWED THE PROPOSALS.
5:37:01PM I'M GOING TO ASK THIS PANEL TO DO TWO THINGS TONIGHT.
5:37:03PM NUMBER ONE IS MANDATE THAT THAT DUMPSTER THAT IS CURRENTLY
5:37:06PM LOCATED IN THE NORTHWESTERN PORTION OF THIS PARCEL BE
5:37:10PM RELOCATED TO THE NORTHEASTERN PORTION OF THE PARCEL.
5:37:16PM AS ROBERT RECENTLY STATED, IT'S FEET AWAY FROM ABUTTING
5:37:20PM THREE DIFFERENT RESIDENTIAL HOUSES.
5:37:22PM IT'S LITERALLY FEET AWAY FROM WHERE CHILDREN ARE PLAYING.
5:37:25PM AND IT DOES NOT TAKE A CREATIVE MIND TO THINK HOW THIS COULD
5:37:29PM QUICKLY TURN INTO NOT ONLY A NUISANCE THROUGH NOISE AND
5:37:33PM SMELLS BUT ALSO A PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY CONCERN GIVEN THE
5:37:37PM KIND OF ANIMALS THAT WOULD BE ATTRACTED AND GRAVITATE
5:37:41PM TOWARDS A STRUCTURE LIKE THAT.
5:37:42PM NOW, I LOOK FOR GUIDANCE ON THIS ISSUE THROUGH TAMPA
5:37:46PM ORDINANCES.
5:37:47PM I COULDN'T FIND ANYTHING DIRECTLY ON POINT, SO I LOOKED AT
5:37:50PM OTHER SIMILARLY SITUATED CITIES IN THE STATE OF FLORIDA.
5:37:53PM I FOUND BROWARD COUNTY HAS A SIMILAR ORDINANCE.
5:37:57PM WISH TAMPA HAD THIS.
5:37:59PM I THINK THIS IS PRETTY ON POINT FOR WHAT WE'RE DEALING WITH.
5:38:02PM IT TALKS ABOUT THE PLACEMENT OF DUMPSTERS.
5:38:04PM WHEN ADJACENT TO A RESIDENTIALLY ZONED PROPERTY, ENCLOSURE
5:38:08PM SHALL BE PLACED AS FAR AS POSSIBLE FROM THE ABUTTING
5:38:13PM RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY LINE.
5:38:14PM SO THE PANEL CAN GET A GOOD PICTURE OF WHERE THE DUMPSTER
5:38:17PM IS, THIS IS IT.
5:38:19PM THIS IS THE DUMPSTER.
5:38:20PM THAT IS A HOUSE.
5:38:21PM THAT IS A HOUSE.
5:38:22PM THAT IS A HOUSE.
5:38:23PM THOSE ARE ALL YARDS FEET AWAY.
5:38:24PM THERE IS AN EASY SOLUTION TO THIS.
5:38:28PM IT'S MOVE IT TO THE NORTHWEST CORNER.
5:38:31PM -- EXCUSE ME, NORTHEAST CORNER.
5:38:32PM THAT'S WHERE THIS DUMPSTER BELONGS.
5:38:36PM LAST EVENING, ABOUT 24 HOURS AGO, I WENT ON A WALK WITH MY
5:38:40PM WIFE AND SIX-MONTH-OLD.
5:38:42PM THERE'S CURRENTLY TRASH CANS SITTING THERE RIGHT NOW.
5:38:45PM THIS PICTURE WAS TAKEN ABOUT 24 HOURS AGO.
5:38:47PM YOU CAN SEE A TRASH CAN AND A BARN.
5:38:51PM IT'S BASICALLY SHARING A WALL WITH A COMMERCIAL DUMPSTER
5:38:54PM RIGHT NOW.
5:38:55PM SO IT MAKES ALL THE SENSE IN THE WORLD TO KEEP THE DUMPSTERS
5:39:00PM CLOSE TOGETHER.
5:39:00PM NOW, IF YOU LOOK AT THESE PLANS, THERE IS A PLOT, I BELIEVE
5:39:06PM OWNED BY THE SAME OWNER ZONED R 0-1.
5:39:11PM IN THE NORTHWEST QUADRANT, NOT A PART OF THE PLAN.
5:39:14PM I THINK IT PLAYS AN IMPORTANT ROLE IN THIS DISCUSSION TODAY
5:39:17PM BECAUSE IT IS CURRENTLY ZONED AS RESIDENTIAL.
5:39:19PM I CERTAINLY WOULD HOPE THE COUNCIL WOULD NOT LET THESE
5:39:22PM BUILDERS PLACE THE PRIORITIES OF FUTURE POTENTIAL RESIDENTS
5:39:24PM OVER THE HEALTH AND WELFARE OF CURRENT RESIDENTS.
5:39:26PM THAT'S NUMBER ONE.
5:39:27PM NUMBER TWO, I HAVE TO TOUCH ON THE TRAFFIC.
5:39:36PM THIS IS A BIG ONE.
5:39:37PM THE TRAFFIC HERE IS A DISASTER.
5:39:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
5:39:40PM ANYBODY ELSE WISH TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 1?
5:39:45PM >> CAN I AT LEAST APPROACH WITH THE ARTICLES THAT TALK ABOUT
5:39:48PM THE TRAFFIC?
5:39:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
5:39:52PM >> I ALSO HAVE PHOTOGRAPHS OF IMPACTS.
5:39:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, GIVE THEM WHATEVER YOU WANT TO GIVE
5:39:59PM THEM.
5:39:59PM >> THAT THREE MINUTES GOES QUICK.
5:40:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR, COME ON UP.
5:40:03PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:40:05PM >> HELLO.
5:40:06PM RYAN CANELLIS.
5:40:09PM I LIVE IN ONE OF THE UNITS ALSO MAYBE TWO DOORS DOWN, THREE
5:40:12PM DOORS DOWN FROM WHERE THIS DEVELOPMENT IS GOING TO BE BUILT.
5:40:17PM CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND THAT AT SOME POINT SOMETHING HAS TO BE
5:40:20PM DONE ON THIS OPEN LOT.
5:40:24PM I DO APPRECIATE IT BEING A RESIDENTIAL UNIT VERSUS WHAT
5:40:27PM COULD HAVE BEEN ANYTHING WITH A COMMERCIAL UNIT.
5:40:31PM MY CONCERN IS IN LINE WITH KYLE WHEN WE TALK ABOUT THE
5:40:34PM GARBAGE CANS.
5:40:35PM GOT A TWO-YEAR-OLD.
5:40:36PM GOT A FOUR-YEAR-OLD, THEY ARE RUNNING AROUND OUTSIDE ALL
5:40:40PM DAY.
5:40:41PM RATS, RODENTS, THE POSSIBILITY OF THAT IS NOT A GREAT
5:40:44PM THOUGHT.
5:40:47PM I DON'T KNOW WHAT RUNS OFF WITH RAINWATER AND WHATNOT INTO
5:40:49PM THE YARDS FROM A DUMPSTER.
5:40:52PM SMELL, NOISE WHEN THEY COME AT 5 IN THE MORNING TO PICK UP A
5:40:57PM COMMERCIAL DUMPSTER OR WHATEVER THAT WOULD BE CALLED, A
5:41:00PM PUBLIC DUMPSTER UNIT.
5:41:02PM SO I ECHO THAT.
5:41:05PM AND MY OTHER CONCERN, WE JOKE ALL THE TIME IN THE
5:41:08PM NEIGHBORHOOD ABOUT HOW WHEN THE WATER BACKS UP ON SWANN,
5:41:10PM IT'S KIND OF LIKE SWANN RIVER WE CALL IT.
5:41:14PM WITH ALL THE FLOODING THAT'S TAKEN PLACE RECENTLY WITHIN A
5:41:19PM HALF A MILE OF OUR NEIGHBORHOOD, IT IS A CONCERN THAT SUCH A
5:41:22PM DENSE DEVELOPMENT COULD NOT ALLOW FOR ENOUGH RUNOFF.
5:41:26PM I DON'T KNOW WHAT KIND OF STUDIES ARE BEING DONE THERE, IS
5:41:29PM BUT I'D LIKE TO LEARN MORE ON THAT.
5:41:32PM AND, OF COURSE, TRAFFIC, EVERYONE KNOWS THE TRADER JOE'S
5:41:35PM TRAFFIC ISSUE.
5:41:39PM I DON'T REALLY HAVE A REQUEST, BUT I GUESS MY REQUEST WOULD
5:41:42PM BE OTHER THAN THE GARBAGE CAN, IT WOULD BE BASICALLY TO SEE
5:41:48PM IF WE COULD DO SOMETHING WITH THE PROPERTY THAT'S MAYBE NOT
5:41:50PM AS DENSE AS IS BEING PLANNED NOW.
5:41:52PM THAT'S REALLY ALL I HAVE TO SAY.
5:41:55PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:41:56PM ANYBODY ELSE HERE TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 1?
5:41:57PM ANYBODY ELSE, IF YOU'RE GOING TO SPEAK, JUST LINE UP AGAINST
5:42:03PM THE WALL SO WE KNOW.
5:42:07PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:42:09PM >> GOOD EVENING.
5:42:10PM STEVEN ALT.
5:42:11PM 3815 WEST SWANN, RIGHT IN THAT NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:42:15PM I'M GOING TO ECHO THE LAST TWO SPEAKERS.
5:42:18PM BIGGEST CONCERN I HAVE IS THE PLACEMENT OF THE DUMPSTER.
5:42:20PM I REALLY WOULD IMPLORE THE BUILDER TO MOVE THAT TO THE EAST
5:42:25PM SIDE OF THE PROPERTY AWAY FROM THE RESIDENCES THERE.
5:42:28PM I DON'T HAVE CHILDREN, AS YOU CAN -- I DO HAVE CHILDREN,
5:42:32PM GRANDCHILDREN I HAVE.
5:42:32PM MY DAUGHTERS DON'T REALLY PLAY IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD MUCH.
5:42:35PM THEY ARE IN THEIR 30s.
5:42:36PM BUT THE GRANDCHILDREN DO.
5:42:37PM MY KIDS CAN PLAY IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD IF THEY WANT, BUT
5:42:42PM WOULDN'T BECAUSE THEY ARE IN THE 30s.
5:42:46PM I WAS PLAYING WITH MY GRANDSON RIGHT BEFORE COMING HERE AND
5:42:50PM THERE IS CONCERN ABOUT THAT.
5:42:51PM I ALSO ECHO RYAN'S CONCERN ABOUT THE WATER IN THE STREET.
5:42:54PM JUST THE NORMAL SUMMER RAINFALL AND THAT TURNS INTO A RIVER.
5:42:59PM STUFF SPLASHING UP INTO OUR DRIVEWAYS.
5:43:02PM IT'S HORRIFIC.
5:43:03PM AND THAT PROPERTY NOW BEING VACANT IS SOAKING IN SOMETHING.
5:43:06PM IT IS A BIG VACANT PROPERTY UNCOVERED.
5:43:09PM IT'S SOAKING IN SOMETHING.
5:43:11PM THAT RUNOFF ISN'T CERTAINLY GOING TO BE HANDLED BY THE SMALL
5:43:17PM RETENTION POND DESIGNED IN THE CORNER OF THE PROPERTY NOW.
5:43:21PM EVERYBODY AGREES THE TRAFFIC THERE IS HORRIFIC.
5:43:23PM THE UNITS, LESS DENSE DEVELOPMENT I THINK WOULD BE
5:43:28PM BENEFICIAL.
5:43:29PM THAT'S ALL I HAVE.
5:43:29PM THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
5:43:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
5:43:32PM ANYBODY ELSE WISH TO SPEAK ON ITEM 1?
5:43:36PM ANYBODY ELSE?
5:43:42PM YES, SIR.
5:43:48PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:43:50PM >> STEVE SCHALL.
5:43:51PM I'M THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY.
5:43:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU WOULD BE PART OF THE PRESENTATION
5:43:56PM WITH MR. MECHANIK.
5:43:58PM SO ONCE WE ASK QUESTIONS, YOU'LL HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO
5:44:02PM SPEAK DURING REBUTTAL.
5:44:04PM IT WILL JUST BE A MOMENT.
5:44:06PM ALL RIGHT.
5:44:06PM IF THERE'S NOBODY ELSE TO SPEAK I'LL ASK, COUNCIL MEMBER
5:44:09PM CLENDENIN.
5:44:10PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: STAFF, LaCHONE.
5:44:12PM DO YOU HAVE THE PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE ADJACENT PROPERTIES?
5:44:21PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: YES.
5:44:22PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:44:24PM THIS IS THE SITE.
5:44:36PM ARE YOU LOOKING ADJACENT HERE OR THE RESIDENTIAL?
5:44:39PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HOW THAT'S DEVELOPED THERE AND ON THE BACK
5:44:42PM SIDE, IF YOU HAVE ANYTHING ON THE BACK SIDE, TOO.
5:44:45PM I KNOW THE BURGER KING.
5:44:48PM THIS IS THE RESIDENTIAL WHICH IS ACROSS THE STREET, FURTHER
5:45:00PM DOWN.
5:45:00PM THIS IS ON THE SITE HERE.
5:45:04PM THAT'S THIS RESIDENTIAL HERE.
5:45:06PM AND THEN I'LL SHOW YOU A PHOTO OF THIS.
5:45:10PM THIS IS ON THE OTHER SIDE.
5:45:17PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THEY ARE ALL TOWN HOUSES THAT FACE SWANN.
5:45:20PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CORRECT.
5:45:21PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
5:45:22PM THIS PICTURE IS THIS DIRECTLY WEST.
5:45:24PM AND IN THE FIRST PICTURE IS --
5:45:26PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THOSE TOWN HOUSES ALL FACE SWANN AS WELL?
5:45:30PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: CORRECT.
5:45:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ARE THERE ANY EXAMPLES THERE OF
5:45:34PM MULTIFAMILY THAT'S BUILT LIKE AN APARTMENT COMPLEX?
5:45:38PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: NOT THAT I HAVE PICTURES OF.
5:45:41PM THIS SHOWS THE BACK OF THE PROPERTY, BUT I DON'T HAVE IT OF
5:45:47PM THE FRONT VIEW OF THE OPPOSITE SIDE OF THE BLOCK.
5:45:51PM I'M SORRY.
5:45:52PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: GOTCHA.
5:45:53PM HOW WIDE AND DEEP IS THIS PARTICULAR PARCEL?
5:45:59PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: SO THIS PARCEL, I CAN PUT UP THE PLAN FOR
5:46:01PM YOU AND SHOW YOU.
5:46:04PM THERE IS 192 FEET OF FRONTAGE APPROXIMATELY, AND THEN THE
5:46:12PM DEPTH IS 137 -- LET ME LOOK.
5:46:16PM ABOUT 137 APPROXIMATELY IS THE DEPTH.
5:46:24PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IT'S JUST SHY, IF IT WAS EUCLIDEAN ZONING
5:46:27PM WITH FRONT FACING DOORS, IT WOULD BE JUST SHY OF FOUR LOTS,
5:46:34PM 50-FOOT --
5:46:35PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: UNDER EUCLIDEAN ZONING.
5:46:38PM KEEP IN MIND THIS IS CURRENTLY ZONED PD AND IT IS APPROVED
5:46:40PM FOR BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL OFFICE.
5:46:45PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IT WASN'T ZONED PD.
5:46:47PM IT WAS ZONED PROFESSIONAL OFFICE.
5:46:52PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IT WAS A PD FOR PROFESSIONAL OFFICE, IS
5:46:54PM THAT WHAT THE ZONING WAS OR PROFESSIONAL OFFICE?
5:46:56PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL -- YES, A PD.
5:47:01PM CORRECT.
5:47:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HOW LONG AGO WAS IT ZONED THAT WAY?
5:47:08PM >> [INAUDIBLE]
5:47:10PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:47:12PM THAT IS IN '21.
5:47:14PM REZ 21-27.
5:47:16PM AND THAT APPROVED THE USE OF BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL OFFICE.
5:47:18PM SO THIS REQUEST WOULD BE FROM PD TO PD.
5:47:22PM EXCEPT GOING FROM THE OFFICE TO THE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED.
5:47:27PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU SO MUCH.
5:47:28PM I APPRECIATE IT.
5:47:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:47:29PM NO OTHER QUESTIONS, MR. MECHANIK, YOU HAVE REBUTTAL, WHICH
5:47:35PM IS FIVE MINUTES, AND THEN THE PROPERTY OWNER, IF HE WISHES
5:47:39PM TO BE PART OF YOUR FIVE MINUTES MAY COME UP AND SPEAK.
5:47:42PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME AGAIN.
5:47:45PM >> I'M GOING TO ASK MR. SCHALL TO SPEAK VERY BRIEFLY.
5:47:49PM BUT I DO WANT TO MAKE A FEW POINTS IN REBUTTAL.
5:47:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
5:47:56PM >> STEVE SCHALL.
5:47:57PM I'M THE OWNER.
5:47:57PM A COUPLE OF THINGS I HEARD A LOT ABOUT THE TRAFFIC AND
5:48:00PM TRADER JOE'S VERY EASY FOR THEM TO SOLVE THIS PROBLEM.
5:48:03PM ALL THEY HAVE TO DO IS PUT A GARAGE UP JUST LIKE BAY CARE
5:48:07PM DID ON THE OTHER SIDE.
5:48:08PM THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT THEY DID.
5:48:09PM THEY PUT A GARAGE UP AND THE WHOLE PROBLEM WAS SOLVED.
5:48:13PM SAME THING WITH CHICK-FIL-A ON De LEON.
5:48:16PM THEY BOUGHT ANOTHER LOT AND THEY KIND OF SOLVED THE PROBLEM.
5:48:20PM IT'S STILL THERE WITH CHICK-FIL-A.
5:48:22PM A LOT OF TIMES WHEN PEOPLE SEE TRAFFIC, IT'S NOT ALL TRADER
5:48:25PM JOE'S.
5:48:26PM IT'S ALSO CHICK-FIL-A'S TRAFFIC.
5:48:28PM AS FAR AS THE TRASH CAN, I'M MORE THAN HAPPY TO EITHER MOVE
5:48:33PM IT OR PUT A COMPACTOR IN THERE OR DO BOTH.
5:48:36PM I'M FINE WITH EITHER OPTION.
5:48:38PM IT'S UP TO YOU TO TELL ME WHETHER THIS IS ACCEPTABLE.
5:48:43PM THE THIRD THING I WANT TO SAY IS WE DO HAVE A PERMIT READY,
5:48:47PM PLANNED FOR 14,500 SQUARE FOOT OFFICE BUILDING IN THAT SPOT.
5:48:52PM IT'S READY.
5:48:52PM I CAN BREAK GROUND TOMORROW ON IT IF I WANT TO.
5:48:56PM BUT WE'RE CHOOSING THIS OPTION MAINLY BECAUSE TO MAKE A
5:49:00PM LITTLE BIT EASIER.
5:49:01PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
5:49:05PM >> THANK YOU.
5:49:06PM AS MR. SCHALL JUST SAID, HE WILL MOVE THE DUMPSTER ANYWHERE
5:49:13PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD WOULD LIKE.
5:49:14PM I WOULD ASK THAT WE NOT DELAY THIS HEARING TO DEBATE THE
5:49:20PM POINT.
5:49:21PM IF THERE'S SOME OTHER LOCATION THAT STAFF WOULD RECOMMEND,
5:49:24PM WE'LL LOCATE THE DUMPSTER THERE OR INSTALL A COMPACTOR IF
5:49:28PM THAT MAKES IT LESS INTRUSIVE.
5:49:33PM WE DON'T REALLY WANT TO HAVE TO CONTINUE A HEARING FOR
5:49:36PM SOMETHING AS -- I DON'T WANT TO SAY MINOR -- BUT SOMETHING
5:49:40PM AS SIMPLE AS LOCATING A DUMPSTER.
5:49:43PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHAT IS IN THE NORTHEAST QUADRANT OF
5:49:46PM THAT PARCEL, THE EAST SIDE?
5:49:48PM >> THE NORTHEAST QUADRANT?
5:49:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHAT BUSINESS DOES IT TOUCH?
5:49:52PM CHICK-FIL-A?
5:49:54PM >> ON THE NEXT STREET OVER IS CHICK-FIL-A.
5:49:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHAT IS IT BEHIND?
5:49:58PM THE BURGER KING?
5:50:00PM >> THERE IS A BURGER KING FACING DALE MABRY.
5:50:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: OPPOSITE OF -- THE DUMPSTER IS OVER HERE
5:50:05PM IN THE NORTHWEST QUADRANT.
5:50:10PM IF YOU PUT IT IN THE NORTHEAST, THE DUMPSTER WOULD BE ON THE
5:50:12PM BACK -- IT WOULD HAVE A PARKING LOT ON THE OTHER SIDE,
5:50:15PM CORRECT?
5:50:17PM >> OUR ENGINEER MIGHT BE ABLE TO SPEAK TO THAT.
5:50:20PM I DON'T KNOW WHETHER THE CODE ALLOWS THAT.
5:50:24PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
5:50:26PM THE DUMPSTER CAN BE PLACED ON THE NORTHEAST SECTION OF THE
5:50:30PM SITE, AND THAT CHANGE CAN BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
5:50:34PM READING.
5:50:36PM IF I CAN PUT THIS UP TO SHOW.
5:50:38PM THIS IS THE ENTRY TO THE BURGER KING PARKING LOT, AND THEN
5:50:46PM THIS IS THE BURGER KING THAT'S HERE.
5:50:48PM SO THIS IS THE COMMERCIAL USE.
5:50:50PM THERE'S NO RESIDENTIAL HERE ON THE NORTHEAST SECTION.
5:50:52PM THE RESIDENTIAL IS TO THE NORTH OF THE SITE.
5:50:55PM SO THAT CHANGE CAN BE MADE BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
5:51:00PM ASIDE -- WHICH THE ENGINEER CAN CONFIRM, I DON'T KNOW ABOUT
5:51:03PM RETENTION OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT, BUT I THINK THERE IS PLENTY
5:51:06PM OF ROOM FOR IT TO EITHER BE LOCATED HERE OR EVEN HERE,
5:51:09PM ORIENTED THIS WAY.
5:51:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHAT DOES THE ENGINEER SAY, SIR?
5:51:14PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: IF THEY CAN DO THAT, IF THEY ARE WILLING TO
5:51:17PM DO IT AND IF POSSIBLE, THEY CAN DO THAT BETWEEN FIRST AND
5:51:19PM SECOND READING.
5:51:20PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME, SIR.
5:51:22PM >> AZAM ELSHEIKH WITH GLOBAL ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES.
5:51:26PM WE CAN RELOCATE THE DUMPSTER, INSTEAD OF TO THE WEST PUT IT
5:51:29PM ON THE EAST OF THE PARKING SPACES.
5:51:31PM RETENTION IS GOING TO BE UNDERGROUND.
5:51:34PM IT WON'T BE IN THE CANOPY OF THAT TREE.
5:51:37PM WE WILL HAVE TO MEET THE DECK MANUAL.
5:51:45PM THE PERMITS ALREADY MEET THAT.
5:51:46PM THE PERMITS EXISTING TODAY FOR THE OFFICE BUILDING, AND
5:51:49PM WE'RE GOING TO COMPLY AND PUT ALL THE RETENTION UNDERGROUND
5:51:55PM IN THAT AREA TO MEET THE CODE.
5:52:01PM >> I'LL ASK RANDY COEN TO ADDRESS THE TRAFFIC COMMENTS VERY
5:52:05PM BRIEFLY.
5:52:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD.
5:52:07PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME, SIR.
5:52:08PM >> RANDY COEN, 4121 WEST CYPRESS, I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
5:52:13PM I WANT TO GO BACK TO THE CHART FOR JUST A MINUTE THAT'S ON
5:52:15PM THE ELMO.
5:52:16PM THE BLUE IS THE LAST USE ON THE PROPERTY, WHICH WAS THE DAY
5:52:20PM CARE.
5:52:21PM IT WAS THEN REZONED FOR THE OFFICE, WHICH IS THE CURRENT
5:52:24PM REZONING ON THE PROPERTY.
5:52:25PM AS YOU'VE HEARD FROM THE APPLICANT, COULD BE BUILT TODAY.
5:52:28PM THE RED IS DAILY TRAFFIC HERE, A.M. PEAK HOUR TRAFFIC
5:52:34PM HERE, P.M. PEAK HOUR TRAFFIC THERE.
5:52:36PM THE TOWN HOUSE PROPOSAL, THAT IS THEIR DAILY TRAFFIC, FOUR
5:52:41PM TIMES LESS THAN WHAT IT WOULD BE FOR THE OFFICE.
5:52:43PM THIS IS THE MORNING TRAFFIC WHICH IS ABOUT FIVE TIMES LESS
5:52:47PM THAN IT WOULD BE WITH THE OFFICE, SAME IN THE AFTERNOON.
5:52:51PM SO WE'RE TALKING ABOUT BUILD THE OFFICE AND HAVE A LOT MORE
5:52:54PM TRAFFIC THERE OR BUILD THE TOWN HOUSES AND HAVE
5:52:57PM SUBSTANTIALLY LESS TRAFFIC THAN IS APPROVED FOR THE SITE
5:53:01PM TODAY.
5:53:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
5:53:03PM ANYTHING ELSE IN YOUR REBUTTAL, SIR?
5:53:06PM >> NO.
5:53:07PM I WOULD JUST CONCLUDE BY RESPECTFULLY REQUESTING YOUR
5:53:10PM APPROVAL OF THIS APPLICATION.
5:53:12PM I WOULD RESPECTFULLY SUGGEST TO YOU THAT SAYING THAT MY
5:53:18PM CLIENT CAN'T BUILD ANYTHING ON THIS PROPERTY IS NOT A LEGAL
5:53:23PM ANSWER TO THE QUESTION.
5:53:26PM I THINK WE HAVE PROPOSED THE LEAST IMPACTFUL USE WE COULD
5:53:32PM POSSIBLY HAVE PROPOSED FOR THIS SITE.
5:53:35PM THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION.
5:53:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
5:53:37PM ANYTHING ELSE?
5:53:38PM IF NOT, I'LL TAKE A MOTION TO CLOSE.
5:53:40PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
5:53:43PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
5:53:44PM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA, WOULD YOU LIKE TO -- OH.
5:53:52PM ALL IN FAVOR?
5:53:52PM AYE.
5:53:53PM NOW, COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA, WOULD YOU LIKE TO READ ITEM
5:53:56PM NUMBER 1.
5:53:56PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: BOY, I'M SO LUCKY.
5:53:58PM I'LL TELL YOU WHAT, MR. CHAIRMAN --
5:54:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WOULD LIKE TO TALK ABOUT THIS, ACTUALLY.
5:54:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THAT'S WHY I'M TALKING SLOWLY.
5:54:10PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YOU KNOW I WANT TO TALK ABOUT IT.
5:54:13PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: GO ON.
5:54:17PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THIS IS A CLASSIC EXAMPLE OF TOO MUCH ON
5:54:21PM TOO LITTLE.
5:54:21PM WE DO HAVE A POLICY IN THE CITY OF TAMPA ABOUT CONSTRUCTION
5:54:24PM AND DOORS FACING STREETS FOR A REASON BECAUSE WE WANT TO
5:54:27PM ENCOURAGE INTERACTIVE NEIGHBORHOODS AND CONSTRUCTION SO THAT
5:54:31PM WHEN WE BUILD THESE THINGS IN NEIGHBORHOODS, PEOPLE CAN, YOU
5:54:36PM KNOW, AGAIN INTEGRATE WITH THE STREET.
5:54:38PM INTEGRATE WITH THEIR NEIGHBORS.
5:54:41PM AND THAT'S WHY WE HAVE THAT POLICY THAT YOU'VE REQUESTED A
5:54:44PM WAIVER FOR.
5:54:49PM THIS IS OBVIOUSLY SUCH AN INTENSIVE PROJECT.
5:54:52PM GRANTED, IT ABUTS UP A COMMERCIAL PROPERTY, WHICH LENDS ME
5:54:59PM KIND OF GIVE IT AT LEAST A CONSIDERATION.
5:55:01PM HOWEVER WITH ALL THE PROBLEMATICS, JUST BECAUSE OF SINS OF
5:55:08PM THE PAST DOESN'T MEAN WE COMPOUND THEM.
5:55:12PM MR. MECHANIK SAID YOU CAN'T BUILD SOMETHING HERE.
5:55:15PM YOU CAN BUILD LOTS OF THINGS ON HERE.
5:55:16PM YOU COULD BUILD TOWN HOUSES THAT FACE SWANN AND THEY COULD
5:55:21PM BE GENEROUS AND BEAUTIFUL AND PROBABLY DAMN EXPENSIVE TOWN
5:55:25PM HOUSES THAT FACE SWANN AS YOU SEE OTHER EXAMPLES IN THAT
5:55:28PM PARTICULAR NEIGHBORHOOD.
5:55:29PM THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN IN THAT NEIGHBORHOOD IS TOWN HOUSES
5:55:31PM THAT FACE THE STREET.
5:55:32PM AND THERE ARE SOME BEAUTIFUL TOWN HOUSES THAT FACE THAT
5:55:36PM STREET.
5:55:36PM I THINK THERE'S LOTS OF OPPORTUNITY HERE.
5:55:39PM THE FACT THAT SOME COUNCIL IN THE PAST PUT A PD ON HERE,
5:55:44PM ZONED IT FOR AN OFFICE BUILDING, IF IT WAS -- OBVIOUSLY, THE
5:55:51PM MARKET HAS CHANGED.
5:55:52PM OFFICE BUILDINGS AREN'T WHAT THEY WERE TEN YEARS AGO OR EVEN
5:55:56PM FIVE YEARS AGO AND I UNDERSTAND THAT AS WELL.
5:55:58PM THE CASH COW IS CRAMMING A WHOLE BUNCH OF MULTIFAMILY HOUSES
5:56:03PM ON A VERY SMALL PIECE OF PROPERTY AND THAT MAKES DEVELOPERS
5:56:06PM AND PROPERTY OWNERS A LOT OF MONEY, BUT THAT'S NOT WHAT
5:56:09PM WE'RE HERE FOR.
5:56:10PM WE'RE HERE TO ENHANCE THE CITY OF TAMPA, ENHANCE THE
5:56:12PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND THIS IS TOO MUCH ON TOO LITTLE.
5:56:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
5:56:26PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: MR. CLENDENIN, THAT IS SO INTERESTING
5:56:29PM BECAUSE I CAN NAME SO MANY PROPERTIES WHERE THE FRONT
5:56:33PM DOESN'T FACE THE STREET IN MY NEIGHBORHOOD WE'VE APPROVED.
5:56:38PM YEAH, THIS BOARD, BUT NEVERTHELESS.
5:56:43PM I THINK IT'S NOT A WHOLE LOT.
5:56:47PM ONLY THREE OF THEM DON'T FACE SWANN, AM I CORRECT -- THREE
5:56:52PM OF THEM DO FACE AND THE OTHERS DON'T.
5:56:55PM THAT'S WHAT I'M THINKING ABOUT.
5:56:57PM RIGHT NEXT TO MY BOOKSTORE, FIVE OF THEM THAT DON'T FACE --
5:57:01PM WELL, THEY FACE THE STREET, YOU JUST CAN'T SEE THEM.
5:57:04PM I DON'T KNOW.
5:57:05PM IT'S KIND OF INTERESTING.
5:57:06PM IT IS WHAT I CONSIDER REASONABLE IF YOU MOVE THE DUMPSTER,
5:57:16PM SO I CAN SUPPORT IT AND I'LL JUST LEAVE IT AT THAT.
5:57:18PM I KNOW IT'S IN SOUTH TAMPA.
5:57:23PM >>BILL CARLSON: I WOULD JUST ASK IF COUNCILMAN MIRANDA MAKES
5:57:27PM A MOTION THAT HE ADD THAT CHANGE OF THE DUMPSTER BETWEEN
5:57:30PM FIRST AND SECOND READING.
5:57:35PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: [INAUDIBLE]
5:57:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOVE THE DUMPSTER --
5:57:39PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I GOT THAT WRITTEN DOWN.
5:57:41PM MOVE THE DUMPSTER.
5:57:43PM WHAT WAS THE OTHER ONE?
5:57:45PM >>BILL CARLSON: MOVE THE DUMPSTER TO THE NORTHEAST.
5:57:49PM >>LUIS VIERA: MR. CHAIR, IF I MAY.
5:57:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA, YES, SIR.
5:57:52PM >>LUIS VIERA: THANK YOU.
5:57:53PM I INTEND TO SUPPORT THIS, BUT I HAVE MY REASONINGS I CAN
5:58:02PM TALK ABOUT WITH THE 12 RESIDENCES, I DON'T THINK IT'S TOO
5:58:06PM INTENSIVE FOR THE PARTICULAR AREA UNDER THE CIRCUMSTANCES.
5:58:09PM BUT THERE IS ONE THING I DO WANT TO SAY THIS.
5:58:12PM I HAVE TO LEAVE IN FIVE MINUTES.
5:58:15PM JUST FYI FOR COUNCIL.
5:58:19PM THAT'S ALL.
5:58:22PM >>BILL CARLSON: WE HAD A SESSION A FEW WEEKS AGO ABOUT
5:58:24PM CONSTRUCTION PLANNING, BUT WE ALREADY GET A LOT OF
5:58:26PM COMPLAINTS ABOUT THIS INTERSECTION.
5:58:29PM IF THIS PASSES, I HOPE THE DEVELOPER WILL MANAGE THAT
5:58:32PM CAREFULLY SO THAT THE CONSTRUCTION AND THE CONSTRUCTION
5:58:35PM PARKING DOESN'T JAM UP THE ROADS AS WELL.
5:58:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
5:58:40PM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
5:58:42PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: JUST REMEMBER, THIS IS AISLE-STYLE
5:58:45PM DEVELOPMENT.
5:58:45PM WE ALREADY HAD THAT CONVERSATION ABOUT AISLE-STYLE
5:58:48PM DEVELOPMENTS.
5:58:48PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: LET ME JUST SAY THIS AS WE ARE DEBATING
5:58:52PM AMONG OURSELVES.
5:58:53PM NO MATTER WHAT YOU PUT HERE, IT'S NOT GOING TO BE ACCEPTABLE
5:58:57PM TO A LOT OF PEOPLE BECAUSE OF SOMETHING NO ONE DID.
5:59:04PM I DON'T KNOW THE DEVELOPER.
5:59:05PM I DON'T KNOW THE GUY WHO SOLD THE LOT OR BOUGHT THE LOT OR
5:59:09PM WHATEVER.
5:59:10PM IF I DID, IT MAKES NO DIFFERENCE ANYWAY TO ME.
5:59:13PM LET ME SAY THIS, YOU CANNOT FROM WHAT I READ HERE, IN THE
5:59:18PM CITY AND THE PLANNING COMMISSION BOTH, AND I VOTED AGAINST
5:59:22PM SOME OF THESE IN THE PAST, YOU KNOW WHAT, I HAVEN'T WON YET.
5:59:26PM WHEN IT GOES TO MEDIATOR, MY TEETH ARE IN THE BACK OF MY
5:59:32PM NECK.
5:59:33PM THAT'S NOT TO SAY THAT THEY ARE RIGHT OR WRONG.
5:59:35PM THAT'S TO SAY THIS IS WHAT I HAVE TO WORK WITH IN FRONT OF
5:59:38PM US, ALL OF US TODAY.
5:59:40PM YES, I COULD SAY THIS DOESN'T FIT THAT AND I'M GOING TO MAKE
5:59:43PM THAT MOTION BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING FOR THAT
5:59:47PM DUMPSTER TO BE MOVED TO THE OPPOSITE SIDE, WHICH IS THE EAST
5:59:50PM SIDE, I BELIEVE.
5:59:51PM MR. CHAIRMAN, WITH THAT, I'LL READ, NUMBER ONE --
5:59:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
5:59:58PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I'M SORRY, BUT WHEN YOU SAID JUST BECAUSE
6:00:03PM STAFF APPROVES IT, IF THAT'S THE CASE, THOUGH --
6:00:05PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THAT'S NOT HOW I VOTE ON THINGS.
6:00:07PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I KNOW.
6:00:08PM YOU SAID THAT STAFF, BOTH STAFFS THINK IT'S OKAY AND THAT WE
6:00:12PM SHOULD CONSIDER THAT.
6:00:13PM IF THAT'S THE CASE, THEN THEY DON'T NEED US.
6:00:16PM I JUST WANTED TO CLARIFY THAT.
6:00:19PM AND I WANTED TO SAY I'M NOT VOTING FOR THIS BECAUSE IT'S TOO
6:00:22PM MUCH IN TOO LITTLE SPACE.
6:00:24PM I AGREE WHOLEHEARTEDLY WITH COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
6:00:26PM I THINK THE TOWNHOMES THAT ARE NEXT DOOR ARE BEAUTIFUL,
6:00:31PM FACING THE STREET AND JUST ENGAGING THE COMMUNITY, AND THIS
6:00:35PM PARTICULAR DEVELOPMENT PUSHES THAT AWAY AND MAKES IT INSULAR
6:00:39PM AND NOT FOCUSING ON THE STREET, WHICH IS WHAT THE REST OF
6:00:42PM THE STREET DOES, SO IT IS NOT IN AGREEMENT WITH WHAT THE
6:00:48PM REST OF THE DEVELOPMENT IS OR THE PLAN FOR THE CITY.
6:00:52PM SO I WON'T VOTE FOR IT EITHER.
6:00:55PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
6:00:57PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: MY THOUGHT ON THAT IS BECAUSE IT IS SWANN
6:01:00PM AVENUE, I CAN SEE WHY.
6:01:02PM I THINK IT'S MORE PROTECTIVE OF THE PEOPLE WHO DECIDE TO
6:01:05PM PURCHASE THE PROPERTIES THAT THEY ARE NOT NECESSARILY FACING
6:01:07PM SWANN, BECAUSE THAT IS A VERY INTENSE AREA, WHICH IS WHY I
6:01:12PM DON'T SHOP AT TRADER JOE'S.
6:01:13PM I CAN SEE THEM BEING ISOLATED IN A SENSE AND NOT FACING
6:01:16PM SWANN BECAUSE OF THAT REASON.
6:01:18PM I KNOW THAT'S ABNORMAL IN MANY REGARDS, BUT SWANN --
6:01:22PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IF YOU HAVE DRIVEN DOWN THAT STREET, EVERY
6:01:26PM HOUSE FACES THE STREET.
6:01:27PM THIS IS A DEVELOPMENT THAT WILL BE SO DIFFERENT THAN
6:01:31PM EVERYTHING AROUND IT.
6:01:33PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: JUST LIKE THE PROPERTY YOU ALL VOTED ON A
6:01:35PM COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO THAT IS THE ONLY DEVELOPMENT LIKE THAT
6:01:37PM IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
6:01:38PM EVERYTHING ELSE WAS SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES.
6:01:39PM I UNDERSTAND BUT YOU ALL VOTED FOR THAT ONE TO BE BUILT AND
6:01:43PM IT WAS INCONSISTENT.
6:01:45PM I UNDERSTAND.
6:01:46PM THIS IS SOUTH TAMPA.
6:01:49PM I WOULDN'T WANT TO LIVE ON A CROWDED STREET LIKE THAT.
6:01:52PM THERE ARE PEOPLE DYING TO LIVE IN SOUTH TAMPA AND IT'S NOT
6:01:55PM UNREASONABLE.
6:01:55PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THERE'S ALSO NOT A REASON THAT YOU CAN'T
6:01:57PM BUILD SIX OR SEVEN BEAUTIFUL TOWNHOMES.
6:02:00PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THAT'S TRUE, BUT ALL OF THEM ARE GREEDY.
6:02:03PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: EXCUSE ME, IF I CAN INTERRUPT FOR A MINUTE,
6:02:06PM MR. CHAIRMAN, OBVIOUSLY, THIS IS A PUBLIC HEARING.
6:02:11PM JUST TO BE SURE WE DID THIS FOR THE RECORD, CAN WE HAVE THE
6:02:14PM MOTION TO OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING.
6:02:17PM >>LUIS VIERA: MR. CHAIR, IF I MAY --
6:02:19PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THIS WAS COUNCIL DEBATE.
6:02:21PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: NOT THIS PUBLIC HEARING.
6:02:23PM OKAY.
6:02:23PM LET'S JUST CONTINUE BECAUSE I DON'T WANT TO MESS UP THE
6:02:25PM RECORD.
6:02:27PM I WANTED TO LET YOU KNOW, COUNCIL MEMBERS, JUST, IF YOU
6:02:31PM HAVEN'T NOTICED, THERE IS A COURT REPORTER HERE WHO IS
6:02:34PM TAKING DOWN EVERY COMMENT THAT'S BEING SAID TONIGHT.
6:02:37PM THE REASON I'M SAYING THIS IS TO ENSURE THAT YOU MAKE
6:02:40PM WHATEVER DECISION YOU MAKE BASED ON COMPETENT SUBSTANTIAL
6:02:44PM EVIDENCE IN THE RECORD.
6:02:47PM THE LOCATION WITHIN THE CITY, IF IT'S NOT RELEVANT TO THE
6:02:51PM CRITERIA AND IT'S NOT PARTICULARLY RELEVANT TO THE CASE AND
6:02:54PM THE EVIDENCE THAT YOU HAVE TO RELY UPON, IT IS NOT RELEVANT
6:02:56PM TO YOUR DECISION.
6:03:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA HAS BEEN
6:03:03PM RECOGNIZED.
6:03:04PM >>LUIS VIERA: POINT OF ORDER, IF I MAY.
6:03:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN VIERA.
6:03:07PM >>LUIS VIERA: GUYS, I HAVE TO LEAVE.
6:03:10PM I SAID THAT FIVE MINUTES AGO.
6:03:12PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HE'S READING IT RIGHT NOW.
6:03:14PM >>LUIS VIERA: OKAY.
6:03:15PM I DON'T MEAN TO RUSH PEOPLE.
6:03:17PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I'M GOING TO READ FILE REZ 24-45,
6:03:21PM ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION,
6:03:23PM AN ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF
6:03:25PM 3807 AND 3811 WEST SWANN AVENUE IN THE CITY OF TAMPA,
6:03:30PM FLORIDA, AND MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1,
6:03:32PM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION PD PLANNED DEVELOPMENT TO PD
6:03:35PM PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY, ATTACHED,
6:03:37PM PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
6:03:38PM UNDER SECTION 27-136 PROMOTES THE EFFICIENCY AND SUSTAINABLE
6:03:43PM USE OF LAND AND INFRASTRUCTURE WITH CAREFUL CONSIDERATION OF
6:03:47PM POTENTIAL ADVERSE IMPACT TO OUTSIDE NATURAL ELEMENTS,
6:03:53PM SURROUNDING IMPACTED NEIGHBORHOODS AND CULTURAL RESOURCES.
6:03:54PM TWO, ALLOWS INTEGRATION OF DIFFERENT LAND USES AND DENSITY
6:03:58PM IN ONE DEVELOPMENT THAT WOULD NOT OTHERWISE BE PROVIDED FOR
6:04:01PM OR ALLOWED UNDER GENERAL ZONING DISTRICTS ESTABLISHMENT IN
6:04:05PM THIS CHAPTER WHICH ENCOURAGES COMPATIBILITY AND SITE DESIGN
6:04:09PM AND SCALE, BOTH INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL TO THE PROJECT SITE.
6:04:12PM THREE, PROVIDES PROCEDURE WHICH CAN RELATE THE TYPE, DESIGN
6:04:16PM AND LAYOUT OF RESIDENTIAL, NONRESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT OF THE
6:04:20PM PARTICULAR SITE.
6:04:21PM FOUR, ACKNOWLEDGES CHANGING NEEDS, TECHNOLOGY, ECONOMIC AND
6:04:25PM CONSUMER PREFERENCE AND ALLOWS THE INGENUITY AND IMAGINATION
6:04:29PM IN THE PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT OF RELATIVE LARGE TRACT
6:04:34PM UNIFIED CONTROL AS WELL AS ALLOWING FLEXIBILITY IN THE
6:04:37PM REDEVELOPMENT OF OLDER AREAS IN THE CITY.
6:04:40PM SIX, PROMOTES AND ENCOURAGES DEVELOPMENT WHERE APPROPRIATE
6:04:42PM AND LOCATION, CHARACTER, COMPATIBILITY WITH THE SURROUNDING
6:04:46PM IMPACTED NEIGHBORHOODS, BUILT ENVIRONMENTALLY EXISTING
6:04:50PM GEOGRAPHICALLY.
6:04:50PM SEVEN, PROMOTE MOST DESIRABLE LIVING AND WORKING ENVIRONMENT
6:04:55PM --
6:04:55PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SECOND.
6:04:57PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: PARDON ME?
6:04:58PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I JUST SECONDED IT FOR YOU.
6:05:00PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I THOUGHT SOMEBODY ELSE WANTED TO READ 7
6:05:04PM AND 8.
6:05:04PM I WANTED TO DO THIS ON RECORD SINCE I'VE BEEN CHALLENGED.
6:05:10PM DESIRABLE LIVING AND WORKING ENVIRONMENT THAT WOULD BE
6:05:13PM POSSIBLE, STRICT APPLICATION AND MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS OF
6:05:16PM OTHER ZONING DISTRICTS.
6:05:17PM EIGHT PROMOTES ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES AND ELEMENTS WHICH
6:05:20PM COMPLEMENTS THE SURROUNDING COMMUNITY AND ENHANCE THE
6:05:22PM OVERALL QUALITY OF THE DEVELOPMENT.
6:05:23PM NINE, PROMOTES RETENTION OF REUSE OF EXISTING BUILDING
6:05:27PM STOCK.
6:05:28PM AS FAR AS I KNOW, THERE ARE NO WAIVERS.
6:05:31PM AM I CORRECT?
6:05:33PM >> THERE ARE TWO WAIVERS.
6:05:35PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THANK YOU.
6:05:41PM >>LUIS VIERA: COUNCIL, I HAVE TO LEAVE IN 30 SECONDS.
6:05:45PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I BELIEVE THAT IS SUFFICIENT FOR THE
6:05:47PM RECORD.
6:05:47PM MY SUGGESTION WOULD BE TO ADD IT IS CONSISTENT WITH STAFF
6:05:52PM REPORTS.
6:05:52PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: CHANGING OF THE DUMPSTER BETWEEN FIRST
6:05:55PM AND SECOND READING AS DISCUSSED BY THE PROPERTY OWNER.
6:05:57PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: CAN YOU SAY IT GOES TO THE NORTHEAST
6:06:00PM SECTION.
6:06:00PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: NORTHEAST.
6:06:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
6:06:03PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
6:06:08PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
6:06:12PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
6:06:14PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
6:06:15PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I'M GOING TO VOTE NO BECAUSE SECTION 27-136,
6:06:21PM IT'S FUNNY THAT YOU READ ALL OF THEM BECAUSE NUMBER 9
6:06:24PM ACTUALLY THEY ARE NOT REUSING ANY BUILDING STOCK, SO YOU
6:06:27PM JUST READ IT TO READ IT.
6:06:28PM BUT NUMBER 6, PROMOTING AND ENCOURAGING DEVELOPMENT WHERE
6:06:32PM APPROPRIATE IN LOCATION, CHARACTER, COMPATIBILITY WITH
6:06:33PM SURROUNDING IMPACTED NEIGHBORHOOD, BUILT ENVIRONMENT, AND
6:06:36PM EXISTING GEOGRAPHY IS CLEARLY NOT DOING THAT.
6:06:39PM THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT WE'RE SPEAKING ABOUT.
6:06:41PM NO.
6:06:45PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I'LL HIT ON NUMBER 8 ABOUT PROMOTING THE
6:06:49PM ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES AND ELEMENTS WHICH COMPLEMENT THE
6:06:51PM SURROUNDING COMMUNITY AND ENHANCE THE OVERALL QUALITY OF
6:06:53PM DEVELOPMENT.
6:06:53PM I DON'T BELIEVE THAT MEETS THAT REQUIREMENT AS WELL.
6:06:58PM AND I ALSO AM OPPOSED TO WAIVING THE DOOR FOR THE POSITIONS
6:07:03PM THAT I STATED IN MY EARLIER DISCUSSION THAT IT DOES NOT
6:07:06PM PROMOTE THE SENSE OF NEIGHBORHOOD AND IT IS NOT COMPATIBLE
6:07:10PM WITH POLICIES OF THIS CITY COUNCIL OR THE CITY OF TAMPA.
6:07:13PM SO I VOTE NO.
6:07:15PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
6:07:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
6:07:19PM >>THE CLERK: THE MOTION CARRIES WITH HURTAK AND CLENDENIN
6:07:22PM VOTING NO.
6:07:22PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MARCH 27, 2025,
6:07:27PM AT 10 A.M., LOCATED AT 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD
6:07:32PM FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
6:07:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:07:35PM >>LUIS VIERA: I'LL BE BACK, COUNCIL.
6:07:37PM THANK YOU.
6:07:37PM I APOLOGIZE FOR RUSHING THAT.
6:07:39PM THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
6:07:40PM THANK YOU.
6:07:43PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: MR. CHAIRMAN, COULD WE HAVE A MOTION TO
6:07:45PM OPEN THE REST OF THE PUBLIC HEARINGS?
6:07:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION TO OPEN THE REST OF THE PUBLIC
6:07:49PM HEARINGS?
6:07:50PM MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:07:51PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
6:07:52PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:07:53PM AYE.
6:07:54PM ANY OPPOSED?
6:07:54PM IF WE COULD PLEASE ELIMINATE THE CONVERSATION IN THE ROOM.
6:08:09PM WE CAN'T HEAR.
6:08:10PM IT ECHOS THROUGH THE CHAMBER.
6:08:14PM [ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
6:08:14PM IF WE COULD PLEASE LIMIT -- I'M SORRY.
6:08:17PM PLEASE NOT HAVE CONVERSATIONS IN THE CHAMBER BECAUSE WE
6:08:20PM CAN'T HEAR.
6:08:21PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:08:21PM YES, MA'AM.
6:08:22PM ITEM NUMBER 2.
6:08:23PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, CHAIRMAN AND COUNCIL.
6:08:25PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:08:27PM ITEM 2 IS REZ 24-70 FOR THE PROPERTY AT 3602 WEST AZEELE
6:08:32PM STREET.
6:08:33PM THE REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY FROM PD PLANNED
6:08:35PM DEVELOPMENT FOR BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL OFFICE TO PD PLANNED
6:08:39PM DEVELOPMENT FOR BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL AND MEDICAL OFFICE.
6:08:42PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO JENNIFER TO GIVE HER REPORT AND THEN
6:08:46PM COME BACK AND GIVE MY REPORT.
6:08:47PM THANK YOU.
6:08:47PM >>JENNIFER MALONE: JENNIFER MALONE WITH YOUR PLANNING
6:08:53PM COMMISSION STAFF.
6:08:53PM THIS IS IN THE SOUTH TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT ALONG WEST
6:08:56PM AZEELE STREET AT THE CORNER OF WEST AZEELE STREET AND SOUTH
6:09:02PM HIMES AVENUE.
6:09:04PM WE HAVE A VARIETY OF OFFICE USES ON THIS PORTION OF SOUTH
6:09:07PM AZEELE STREET ALREADY, BUT WE ALSO HAVE SOME RESIDENTIAL TO
6:09:09PM THE EAST AND THEN TO THE SOUTH.
6:09:12PM THE FUTURE LAND USE IS RESIDENTIAL 20.
6:09:17PM THAT IS THE BROWN COLOR.
6:09:18PM THAT'S PREDOMINANT ALONG WEST AZEELE STREET THIS WAY,
6:09:21PM RESIDENTIAL 35 IS DARKER BROWN, RESIDENTIAL 10 TO THE SOUTH
6:09:24PM IS YOUR SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY.
6:09:28PM THAT IS THE ORANGE COLOR.
6:09:29PM PINK IS COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35 ALONG HENDERSON.
6:09:32PM THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT BEFORE YOU AS LaCHONE OPENED IS
6:09:36PM FOR A BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL OFFICE WITH THE MEDICAL OFFICE
6:09:40PM USE.
6:09:40PM THIS WAS REZONED IN 2021 FOR PROFESSIONAL OFFICE USES.
6:09:46PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FOUND IT CONSISTENT.
6:09:48PM IT WAS APPROVED.
6:09:51PM THE PLAN LIMITS WHERE OFFICE USES SHOULD GO IF YOU ARE IN A
6:09:56PM RESIDENTIAL LAND USE CATEGORY.
6:09:57PM ONE OF THOSE CRITERIA, IF YOU ARE IN THE RESIDENTIAL 20
6:10:00PM CATEGORY IS THAT YOU SHOULD HAVE FRONTAGE ALONG A COLLECTOR
6:10:03PM ROADWAY OR HIGHER.
6:10:05PM AZEELE IS AN ARTERIAL ROADWAY THAT IS A FUNCTIONAL
6:10:09PM CLASSIFICATION HIGHER THAN A COLLECTOR.
6:10:11PM BUT THE PLAN ALSO SAYS THAT IF YOU HAVE ALREADY MET YOUR
6:10:13PM LOCATIONAL CRITERIA THE FIRST TIME YOU SHOULDN'T HAVE TO
6:10:16PM MEET IT AGAIN.
6:10:17PM SO THIS DOES MEET THE LOCATIONAL CRITERIA, BUT I WANT TO
6:10:20PM STATE FOR THE RECORD THEY WERE NOT SUBJECT TO THAT A SECOND
6:10:23PM TIME.
6:10:24PM HAD THEY BEEN, IT WOULD HAVE MET IT SINCE AZEELE IS AN
6:10:27PM ARTERIAL AND ALREADY OFFICE USES IN THE SURROUNDING AREA.
6:10:30PM WE FOUND IT CONSISTENT WITH THE PLAN.
6:10:33PM I'M AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
6:10:35PM THANK YOU.
6:10:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MS. MALONE?
6:10:38PM NO.
6:10:39PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:10:39PM YES, MA'AM.
6:10:40PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
6:10:41PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:10:46PM THIS SITE IS CURRENTLY ZONED PD.
6:10:50PM IT DOES ALLOW FOR BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL OFFICE USE.
6:10:52PM THIS REQUEST WOULD ALLOW THE ADDITION OF MEDICAL OFFICE.
6:10:55PM THE ADDITIONAL USE OF MEDICAL OFFICE ON-SITE.
6:10:58PM SO THE BUILDING THAT'S ON-SITE WILL REMAIN.
6:11:01PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:11:02PM THIS IS THE SITE PLAN WHICH IS SUBMITTED.
6:11:04PM THIS IS HIMES AVENUE.
6:11:07PM THIS IS AZEELE TO THE NORTH.
6:11:09PM SO THIS IS THE EXISTING BUILDING WHICH I'LL SHOW YOU
6:11:12PM PICTURES OF THAT WOULD REMAIN.
6:11:14PM THAT BUILDING CONTAINS 1,818 SQUARE FEET.
6:11:18PM THE SITE ITSELF CONTAINS 7,414 SQUARE FEET.
6:11:22PM THE SETBACKS ARE TO THE NORTH 20 FEET, TO THE SOUTH 68 FEET.
6:11:26PM TO THE EAST 10 FEET AND TO THE WEST 5 FEET.
6:11:28PM THE MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT IS 35 FEET.
6:11:32PM AND THE PARKING REQUIRED IS 11 SPACES, AND THEN 9 SPACES ARE
6:11:38PM PROVIDED.
6:11:39PM SO ON THE SITE ITSELF, THE EXISTING BUILDING AGAIN WILL
6:11:42PM REMAIN ON-SITE.
6:11:44PM SURFACE PARKING EXISTED IN THE REAR OF THE SITE, REAR OF THE
6:11:48PM BUILDING.
6:11:49PM THERE IS ONE POINT OF ACCESS TO THE SITE, AND THAT'S ON
6:11:52PM HIMES.
6:11:52PM THE ENTRY TO THE BUILDING IS HERE, AND YOU CAN SEE THAT
6:11:55PM THERE ARE WALKWAYS PROVIDED TO THE SURROUNDING SIDEWALK, THE
6:12:00PM SIDEWALKS THAT ARE SURROUNDING THE SITE.
6:12:02PM I HAVE THE ZONING MAP.
6:12:08PM SO THIS IS THE PARCEL THAT'S IDENTIFIED HERE IN RED ON THE
6:12:12PM CORNER OF AZEELE, THIS IS HIMES.
6:12:14PM THIS IS HENDERSON FOR ORIENTATION OF THE SITE, AND THEN THIS
6:12:18PM IS STERLING AVENUE.
6:12:19PM SO YOU CAN SEE THAT THIS SITE ALONG AZEELE YOU HAVE NUMEROUS
6:12:23PM REZONINGS THAT HAVE OCCURRED THROUGH THE YEARS.
6:12:26PM YOU HAVE PDs TO THE WEST AND FURTHER WEST YOU HAVE YOUR
6:12:30PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY DEVELOPMENT.
6:12:32PM NORTH OF THE SITE YOU HAVE THE PD AND RO USES, WHICH ARE
6:12:35PM LIKE YOUR MEDICAL OFFICE OR THE BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL OFFICE
6:12:40PM USES THAT RUN ALONG AZEELE.
6:12:43PM FURTHER NORTH OF THAT, YOU HAVE YOUR SINGLE-FAMILY
6:12:47PM DEVELOPMENT, RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED DEVELOPMENT.
6:12:50PM AND THEN FURTHER SOUTH, YOU HAVE THE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED
6:12:53PM AND YOU HAVE A COUPLE OF RM ZONING DESIGNATIONS, RO,
6:12:57PM RESIDENTIAL OFFICE AND PD.
6:12:59PM THERE IS LIKE A MIXTURE OF USES WITHIN THE AREA.
6:13:01PM BUT MOSTLY THE BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL AND MEDICAL OFFICE
6:13:04PM USES.
6:13:05PM SO THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:13:12PM THIS IS AT THE CORNER OF HIMES AND AZEELE.
6:13:17PM AND THIS WILL REMAIN.
6:13:19PM SO THIS IS THE ENTRY TO THE SITE.
6:13:21PM THIS IS SHOWING YOU THE EAST SIDE OF THE BUILDING.
6:13:25PM THIS IS IF YOU ARE ON-SITE LOOKING TOWARDS AZEELE TO THE
6:13:29PM NORTH, THE PARKING IS LOCATED HERE.
6:13:33PM THIS IS THE ACCESS TO THE SITE.
6:13:37PM THIS IS ON-SITE LOOKING TOWARDS HIMES.
6:13:39PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTH.
6:13:44PM THAT'S LOOKING NORTH ON HIMES.
6:13:49PM THAT IS ANOTHER VIEW OUTSIDE OF THE SITE LOOKING NORTH ON
6:13:52PM HIMES.
6:13:55PM THIS IS NORTH OF THE SITE.
6:14:00PM THIS IS IF YOU ARE AT THE POINT OF THE SITE WHICH IS OFF TO
6:14:02PM THE RIGHT IN THIS PICTURE AND YOU'RE LOOKING EAST ON AZEELE.
6:14:05PM AND THAT'S EAST OF THE SITE.
6:14:11PM AND THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW OF THE SITE.
6:14:15PM THIS IS IF YOU ARE LOOKING SOUTH ON HIMES.
6:14:17PM AND THAT'S ANOTHER VIEW ON HIMES LOOKING SOUTH.
6:14:22PM FURTHER SOUTH ON HIMES, AND THEN WE SWING BACK AROUND AND
6:14:29PM THIS IS LOOKING WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:14:32PM SO WITH THAT, THE DRC STAFF REVIEWED THE REQUEST, FINDS THE
6:14:38PM REQUEST INCONSISTENT.
6:14:39PM IT IS DUE TO THE WAIVER REQUESTED.
6:14:42PM YOU CAN SEE THE FINDINGS FROM TRANSPORTATION.
6:14:44PM THE WAIVER IS TO REDUCE THE PARKING FROM 11 SPACES REQUIRED
6:14:48PM TO 9 SPACES.
6:14:49PM AND ALSO, THERE ARE SITE PLAN MODIFICATIONS TO BE MADE
6:14:54PM BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
6:14:55PM SO WITH THAT, THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
6:14:58PM I'M AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
6:15:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
6:15:00PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:15:02PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU.
6:15:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS THERE AN APPLICANT FOR THIS ITEM?
6:15:09PM COME ON UP.
6:15:10PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:15:11PM >> TOM SZUMLIC, ARCHITECT, 619 LUZON AVENUE, TAMPA, FLORIDA,
6:15:16PM 33606.
6:15:17PM I'VE BEEN SWORN IN.
6:15:20PM MR. CHAIRMAN, CITY COUNCIL, CITY OF TAMPA STAFF, GOOD
6:15:24PM EVENING, GOOD TO SEE EVERYONE.
6:15:25PM THIS IS A REZONING, A PD TO PD.
6:15:33PM WE'RE ASKING FOR THE ADDITIONAL USE FOR MEDICAL OFFICE.
6:15:39PM ON THE FACE OF IT, AS IT STANDS THE NINE SPACES ARE REQUIRED
6:15:44PM AND WE PROVIDED SIX.
6:15:48PM I'D LIKE TO DRAW YOUR ATTENTION TO THE ADJACENT PROPERTY AND
6:15:54PM MY FOOTNOTE ON THE DOCUMENT I POINTED OUT THAT THE ADJACENT
6:16:02PM PROPERTY A SURGICAL CENTER AND PD REZONING REZ 22-53, THEY
6:16:08PM USED A METRIC OF 4.5 SPACES PER THOUSAND UNDER THE PD FOR
6:16:17PM THE REZONING -- FOR THE PARKING SPACES.
6:16:20PM IF WE APPLY THE SAME 4.5 TO 1800 SQUARE FEET, WHICH BY ANY
6:16:27PM STANDARD A SMALL BUILDING, THAT'S 8.18 SPACES.
6:16:31PM SO WE MEET THE STANDARD OF 9 SPACES USING THE SAME STANDARD
6:16:37PM APPLIED TO THE ADJACENT PROPERTY.
6:16:39PM SO I THINK ON THE FACE OF IT, IT'S A REASONABLE REQUEST JUST
6:16:43PM EVEN BY THE NINE SPACES BEING SHORT TWO.
6:16:46PM BUT I THINK GOING FURTHER WITH THE PRECEDENT OF THE ADJACENT
6:16:52PM PROPERTY, I THINK IT'S A REASONABLE REQUEST.
6:16:56PM AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO YOUR AFFIRMING VOTE OF YES.
6:17:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:17:01PM ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTLEMAN?
6:17:02PM I SEE NONE.
6:17:04PM IS THERE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM
6:17:07PM NUMBER 2?
6:17:07PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:17:10PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
6:17:12PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:17:13PM AYE.
6:17:13PM ANY OPPOSED?
6:17:14PM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON, WOULD YOU LIKE TO READ ITEM NUMBER
6:17:17PM 2?
6:17:17PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES, CHAIR.
6:17:18PM I MOVE FILE NUMBER REZ-24-70, ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR
6:17:23PM FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY
6:17:26PM IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 3602 WEST AZEELE STREET IN THE
6:17:30PM CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, AND MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN
6:17:32PM SECTION 1 FROM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION PD, PLANNED
6:17:36PM DEVELOPMENT, TO PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, BUSINESS
6:17:39PM PROFESSIONAL AND MEDICAL OFFICE; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
6:17:41PM DATE.
6:17:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS THERE A REVISION SHEET ON THIS
6:17:51PM MS. DOCK?
6:17:52PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: WITH THE REVISION SHEET.
6:17:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND WE HAVE A SECOND.
6:17:58PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
6:18:01PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
6:18:02PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
6:18:03PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
6:18:05PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
6:18:06PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
6:18:08PM >> VIERA?
6:18:09PM MANISCALCO?
6:18:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
6:18:11PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION CARRIED WITH VIERA ABSENT AT VOTE.
6:18:13PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MARCH 27, 2025,
6:18:17PM AT 10 A.M. LOCATED AT 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD
6:18:22PM FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
6:18:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:18:25PM ITEM NUMBER 3.
6:18:28PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
6:18:29PM LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:18:31PM ITEM 3 IS REZ 24-101 FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 8813 BROOKS
6:18:36PM STREET, 8901 NORTH 13th STREET AND 8814 NORTH 1th
6:18:42PM STREET.
6:18:43PM THIS REQUEST IS TO REZONE PROPERTY FROM IG INDUSTRIAL
6:18:45PM GENERAL AND RS 50 RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY TO IG INDUSTRIAL
6:18:50PM GENERAL.
6:18:50PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO JENNIFER TO GIVE HER REPORT.
6:18:57PM >>JENNIFER MALONE: JENNIFER MALONE WITH THE PLANNING
6:19:00PM COMMISSION.
6:19:00PM THIS IS IN THE UNIVERSITY PLANNING DISTRICT.
6:19:02PM ANOTHER RECENT PLAN AMENDMENT BEFORE THIS COUNCIL, SO THE
6:19:08PM AREA MIGHT LOOK FAMILIAR TO YOU, BUT IT IS THE PARCELS
6:19:11PM OUTLINED IN PURPLE.
6:19:13PM WE HAVE -- WE'RE JUST SOUTH OF EAST BUSCH BOULEVARD ALONG
6:19:17PM NORTH BROOKS STREET AND NORTH 14th STREET.
6:19:19PM I DO WANT TO POINT OUT THIS IS AN AREA WITH A VAST VARIETY
6:19:25PM OF USES OF INDUSTRIAL AND SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED IN CLOSE
6:19:30PM PROXIMITY TO ONE ANOTHER, WHICH IS REFLECTED ON THE FUTURE
6:19:34PM LAND USE MAP.
6:19:34PM I'M SURE LaCHONE OR MS. DOCK WILL GO INTO THIS IN MORE
6:19:38PM DETAIL.
6:19:38PM WE DO HAVE SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES ACROSS THE STREET, BUT WE
6:19:41PM ALSO HAVE THE INDUSTRIAL USES IN THE AREA AS WELL.
6:19:45PM SO WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP, THE FUTURE LAND
6:19:49PM USE IS LIGHT INDUSTRIAL.
6:19:53PM WHERE SOME OF THOSE SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES ARE IS THE
6:19:55PM RESIDENTIAL 10, WHICH IS THE ORANGE COLOR.
6:19:58PM SO -- BUT THE AREA IS LIGHT INDUSTRIAL AS WE MOVE SOUTH OF
6:20:03PM EAST BUSCH BOULEVARD.
6:20:04PM THE REQUEST BEFORE YOU CHANGED THESE PARCELS TO LIGHT
6:20:08PM INDUSTRIAL THROUGH A PLAN AMENDMENT EARLIER, AND NOW THE
6:20:10PM APPLICANT IS REQUESTING FOR THE IG ZONING DISTRICT.
6:20:13PM I DO WANT TO READ A PORTION OF THE REPORT JUST FOR THE
6:20:18PM RECORD.
6:20:19PM THE REPORT POINTS OUT THAT THE SURROUNDING AREA DOES CONTAIN
6:20:21PM A RANGE OF USES INCLUDING INDUSTRIAL, COMMERCIAL AND
6:20:24PM SINGLE-FAMILY.
6:20:25PM THE SUBJECT PROPERTIES DO BORDER DETACHED SINGLE-FAMILY
6:20:28PM HOMES ZONED RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY 50 AND RECOGNIZED
6:20:30PM UNDER THAT RESIDENTIAL 10 DESIGNATION.
6:20:35PM GIVEN THE WIDE RANGE OF USES IN THE IMMEDIATE AREA, PLANNING
6:20:37PM COMMISSION STAFF HAS DETERMINED THAT THE PROPOSED IG ZONING
6:20:40PM DISTRICT IS CONSISTENT WITH THE CHARACTER OF THE SURROUNDING
6:20:44PM AREA, BUT I WANT TO NOTE LU POLICY 15.2.4 REQUIRES
6:20:48PM APPROPRIATE BUFFERING BETWEEN NONRESIDENTIAL AND RESIDENTIAL
6:20:51PM DEVELOPMENTS.
6:20:52PM THIS IS A EUCLIDEAN REZONING.
6:20:54PM THE APPLICANT WILL BE REQUIRED TO MEET THOSE REQUIREMENTS
6:20:57PM DURING THE SITE PLAN REVIEW PROCESS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE
6:21:00PM WITH THESE POLICIES.
6:21:01PM I JUST WANT TO STATE FOR THE RECORD THAT THAT IS SOMETHING
6:21:04PM THAT WE TOOK INTO CONSIDERATION IS THAT THEY WOULD NEED TO
6:21:07PM MEET THOSE DURING THAT REVIEW.
6:21:09PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ALSO ENCOURAGES INDUSTRIAL
6:21:12PM DEVELOPMENT AS A MEANS OF GENERATING EMPLOYMENT TO SUPPORT
6:21:15PM THE CITY'S GROWING POPULATION.
6:21:17PM SO THE PROPOSED REZONING TO IG WILL FACILITATE THE
6:21:20PM INDUSTRIAL USE OF THIS POLICY CONSISTENT WITH THE
6:21:23PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:21:23PM THANK YOU.
6:21:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
6:21:27PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WHAT YOU JUST STATED, THAT'S NOTHING THAT
6:21:30PM REQUIRES COUNCIL'S READING INTO THE RECORD, IS IT?
6:21:33PM IS THAT SUFFICIENT?
6:21:35PM >>JENNIFER MALONE: I DON'T BELIEVE SO, NO.
6:21:37PM I'LL DEFINITELY REFER TO MS. DOCK.
6:21:39PM I WANT IT ON THE RECORD THAT WE DID LOOK AT THAT WHEN WE
6:21:44PM REVIEWED THE REQUEST ABOUT THE PROXIMITY TO SINGLE-FAMILY.
6:21:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
6:21:48PM YES, MA'AM.
6:21:49PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:21:51PM THAT IS CORRECT, COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
6:21:55PM IT WOULD BE ADDRESSED AT THE TIME OF PERMITTING, THE
6:21:58PM BUFFERING THE APPLICANT WILL BE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE PROPER
6:22:01PM BUFFERING ACCORDING TO CODE, YES.
6:22:03PM WITH THAT, THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
6:22:06PM THIS IS THE EASIEST WAY THAT I CAN SHOW YOU THESE PARCELS
6:22:09PM BEFORE I GET TO THE ZONING MAP.
6:22:11PM THERE ARE THREE PARCELS CONTAINED WITHIN THIS REQUEST.
6:22:14PM THIS WAS SUBMITTED BY THE APPLICANT, BUT IT SHOWS CLEARLY
6:22:17PM THE PARCELS.
6:22:18PM THERE IS ONE PARCEL ON 13th STREET.
6:22:21PM THIS IS BUSCH BOULEVARD.
6:22:23PM THIS IS BROOKS STREET AND THIS IS 14th STREET.
6:22:25PM SO THE PARCELS THAT ARE OUTLINED IN RED ARE THE SUBJECT SITE
6:22:31PM AND THESE ARE THE PARCELS WHICH ARE REQUESTED TO REZONE TO
6:22:34PM IG, INDUSTRIAL GENERAL.
6:22:36PM JUST NOTE THAT BROOKS STREET GOES THROUGH TO BUSCH
6:22:39PM BOULEVARD, BUT 13th AND 14th, THOSE STREETS ACTUALLY
6:22:43PM DEAD END.
6:22:45PM BUT I'LL SHOW YOU PICTURES SURROUNDING THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:22:49PM EACH OF THE PARCELS, THE PARCEL THAT'S ON 13th STREET AND
6:22:53PM 14th STREET, BOTH OF THESE HAVE 50 FEET OF FRONTAGE.
6:22:57PM ON BROOKS STREET, THERE'S A HUNDRED FEET OF FRONTAGE.
6:23:00PM ALL THREE HAVE THE SAME DEPTH OF APPROXIMATELY 104 FEET.
6:23:04PM 60 FEET WOULD BE THE MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT WITH THIS
6:23:07PM ZONING DESIGNATION.
6:23:10PM WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO DO IS ALSO PUT UP THE ZONING MAP.
6:23:15PM AGAIN, HERE ARE THE PARCELS THAT ARE IN RED IDENTIFIED ON
6:23:19PM THE SITE.
6:23:20PM THIS IS BUSCH BOULEVARD.
6:23:22PM NEBRASKA IS OFF TO THE WEST OFF OF THIS MAP.
6:23:28PM THIS SITE ON 13th STREET, BROOKS STREET, AND THEN 14th
6:23:32PM STREET.
6:23:32PM YOU CAN SEE ALONG BUSCH BOULEVARD, ON THE NORTH SIDE OF
6:23:36PM BUSCH BOULEVARD ARE THE MORE INTENSE COMMERCIAL USES.
6:23:40PM ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF BUSCH BOULEVARD, YOU GET INTO YOUR MORE
6:23:43PM INTENSIVE USES OF THE INDUSTRIAL GENERAL.
6:23:46PM SO THE ZONING IS REFLECTIVE OF THAT.
6:23:48PM YOU HAVE INDUSTRIAL GENERAL ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF BUSCH.
6:23:51PM NORTH SIDE OF BUSCH, YOU HAVE COMMERCIAL INTENSIVE.
6:23:53PM FURTHER NORTH OF THIS SITE YOU GET INTO YOUR RESIDENTIAL
6:23:57PM ZONING AND USES.
6:23:59PM AND THE SAME GOES FOR THE SOUTH OF BUSCH BOULEVARD.
6:24:01PM WHEN YOU MOVE SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE, YOU MOVE INTO YOUR
6:24:05PM RESIDENTIAL, THE RS 50 ZONE AND THE RESIDENTIAL
6:24:08PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED USES FURTHER SOUTH.
6:24:11PM AND THEN FOR THE PICTURES OF THE SITE, I'LL JUST SHOW YOU,
6:24:15PM NORMALLY IT IS THE SITE FIRST, THEN THE SURROUNDING USES BUT
6:24:19PM THREE PARCELS ON THREE DIFFERENT STREETS.
6:24:21PM I'LL SHOW YOU THIS SITE, SURROUNDING THE SITE AND THEN GO TO
6:24:24PM THIS SITE, SURROUNDING THE SITE AND THIS SITE SURROUNDING
6:24:27PM AND END THERE.
6:24:28PM THIS IS ON THE WEST SIDE.
6:24:33PM THIS IS THE SITE THAT'S ON 13th.
6:24:35PM THAT'S WEST OF THAT SITE, THE RESIDENTIAL.
6:24:39PM THIS IS ALSO WEST OF THAT, STILL ON 13th STREET.
6:24:44PM THIS IS MOVING TOWARDS BUSCH.
6:24:46PM THAT'S THE INDUSTRIAL.
6:24:47PM THAT'S TO THE WEST.
6:24:50PM THIS IS SHOWING YOU THE DEAD END, 13th DEAD ENDS.
6:24:53PM BUSCH BOULEVARD IS OFF IN THE PICTURE THERE.
6:24:56PM THE SITE IS OFF TO THE RIGHT.
6:25:01PM WE SWING AROUND, NORTH OF THE SITE ON 13th.
6:25:04PM HERE IS THE SITE ON 13th.
6:25:06PM THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE, THE RESIDENTIAL THAT EXISTS.
6:25:12PM AND THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE ON 13th.
6:25:17PM NOW THIS TAKES US TO THE PARCEL ON BROOKS.
6:25:21PM THIS IS NORTH OF THE SITE.
6:25:26PM THIS IS ANOTHER PICTURE NORTH OF THE SITE.
6:25:30PM YOU CAN SEE THE OPEN STORAGE, THE INDUSTRIAL USE ON THE
6:25:33PM SITE.
6:25:34PM THIS IS THE SITE ON BROOKS STREET.
6:25:37PM AND THIS IS IF YOU'RE LOOKING SOUTH ON BROOKS.
6:25:42PM THE SITE IS OFF TO THE LEFT.
6:25:43PM THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE.
6:25:46PM AND ANOTHER VIEW TO THE SOUTH.
6:25:50PM AND THEN THIS TAKES US AROUND TO THE SITE ON 14th.
6:25:54PM SO THAT'S THE SITE ON 14th.
6:25:58PM AND THEN THIS IS MAKING OUR WAY TOWARDS BUSCH, AS YOU HEAD
6:26:02PM NORTH.
6:26:03PM PHOTOS OF THE USES.
6:26:05PM THIS IS LOOKING NORTH TOWARD BUSCH.
6:26:09PM THEN WE SWING BACK AROUND.
6:26:11PM THAT'S ACROSS THE STREET EAST OF THE SITE.
6:26:12PM AND THEN THIS IS EAST.
6:26:15PM AS WE HEAD FURTHER SOUTH BACK ON THE BLOCK, THERE ARE OTHER
6:26:19PM PICTURES OF THE RESIDENTIAL THAT EXIST.
6:26:21PM EAST.
6:26:22PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTH ON 14th.
6:26:25PM THAT'S SOUTH OF THE SITE ON 14th.
6:26:29PM AND THEN LASTLY, THIS IS IF YOU ARE AT HUMPHREY ON THE OTHER
6:26:33PM END OF THE BLOCK AND YOU'RE LOOKING DOWN TOWARDS THE SITE,
6:26:36PM TOWARDS BUSCH.
6:26:37PM AND WITH THAT, THE DRC STAFF REVIEWED THE REQUEST AND FINDS
6:26:42PM THE REQUEST CONSISTENT.
6:26:44PM THIS IS A EUCLIDEAN REZONING REQUEST, SO THERE'S NO SITE
6:26:46PM PLAN ASSOCIATED WITH THIS REQUEST.
6:26:49PM I'M AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
6:26:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
6:26:51PM ANY QUESTIONS?
6:26:52PM NO.
6:26:53PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:26:53PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:26:55PM >> GOOD EVENING, CITY COUNCIL.
6:26:56PM RYAN MANASSE WITH JOHNSON POPE, DIRECTOR OF DEVELOPMENT AND
6:26:59PM PLANNING, 400 NORTH ASHLEY DRIVE, SUITE 3100.
6:27:02PM IF CTTV CAN PULL UP MY PRESENTATION.
6:27:05PM IT'S IN EDIT MODE.
6:27:10PM YOU GUYS SEE THE FULL SCREEN?
6:27:13PM THERE WE GO.
6:27:15PM AGAIN, JUST TO REITERATE A COUPLE OF POINTS, WE'RE HERE
6:27:21PM REGARDING THE PARCEL LOCATED AT 8813 BROOKS STREET, 8901
6:27:26PM NORTH 13th STREET AND 8814 NORTH 14th STREET.
6:27:29PM AS STAFF STATED WE'RE HERE REQUESTING THAT CHANGE FROM IG
6:27:32PM AND RS 50 TO ALL IG.
6:27:35PM OUR FIRM'S CLIENT IS JOHN MESSINA, OWNER OF TAMPA SPRING
6:27:39PM COMPANY WHICH HAS BEEN OPERATING AT THIS LOCATION SINCE
6:27:41PM 1969.
6:27:43PM UTILIZE MULTIPLE YARDS AND BUILDINGS FOR VEHICLES, VEHICLE
6:27:46PM REPAIR OPERATION WITH STORAGE OF SAID VEHICLES BEFORE AND
6:27:49PM AFTER THOSE REPAIRS, WHICH IS PRETTY TYPICAL FOR THAT TYPE
6:27:51PM OF USE.
6:27:52PM NOW, AS FAR AS SOME PROPERTY DETAILS, I'LL TRY NOT TO BE TOO
6:27:57PM REDUNDANT BUT POINT OUT CSX IS TO THE NORTH AS WELL AS EAST
6:28:00PM BUSCH BOULEVARD.
6:28:01PM THEY ARE ARTERIAL ROADWAYS AS WELL AS -- I'M SORRY, BUSCH
6:28:05PM BOULEVARD IS, AS WELL AS BUSCH IS A TRANSIT EMPHASIS
6:28:10PM CORRIDOR.
6:28:11PM THESE -- THE PARCEL REQUEST IS OUTLINED IN RED AND LaCHONE
6:28:14PM STOLE MY VISUAL, BUT THAT'S OKAY.
6:28:17PM IT MAKES SENSE OF THE ZONING LOTS BEFORE YOU.
6:28:20PM ONE THING I DID WANT TO POINT OUT IS THE BLUE SHADED AREA TO
6:28:23PM THE NORTH, THAT IS THE SAME OWNER.
6:28:25PM SO THIS ALL CONSISTS OF TAMPA SPRING COMPANY.
6:28:28PM IT'S JUST THESE SUBJECT SITES ARE THE REQUESTS BEFORE YOU
6:28:32PM BECAUSE THEIR LAND USE DIDN'T MATCH UP WITH THE ZONING, VICE
6:28:35PM VERSA.
6:28:36PM AGAIN, THAT'S WHY WE'RE HERE.
6:28:38PM JUST A LITTLE HISTORY ON THAT, JENNIFER DIDN'T MENTION IT,
6:28:42PM BUT WE WERE BEFORE YOU BACK IN SEPTEMBER OF 2024 FOR THE
6:28:45PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN MAP AMENDMENT.
6:28:47PM TA/CPA 2403.
6:28:49PM IT WAS TO RECOGNIZE AND ENCOURAGE THAT L.I. FUTURE LAND USE
6:28:54PM CATEGORY FOR THE LOTS IN QUESTION.
6:28:56PM THE REZONING THAT'S HERE TONIGHT IS JUST THAT.
6:29:00PM WE'RE TRYING TO IMPLEMENT THE COMPATIBLE ZONING DISTRICT
6:29:02PM WITH THE NEWLY APPROVED L.I. CATEGORY.
6:29:05PM AS STAFF STATED, ANY DEVELOPMENT HAS TO MEET THE IG ZONING
6:29:10PM DISTRICT FOR BUFFERING, SCREENING, SETBACKS, ET CETERA,
6:29:12PM HEIGHT, USES AND THERE ARE NO WAIVERS BEING SOUGHT.
6:29:18PM NONE COULD BE ADDED TO THIS.
6:29:19PM NOW, OUR APPLICATION IS CONSISTENT WITH SEVERAL OBJECTIVES
6:29:22PM AND POLICIES FROM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND STAFF -- PC
6:29:26PM STAFF HAS ANNOTATED THAT AS WELL.
6:29:29PM MOST OF THE OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES PRIMARILY ADDRESS
6:29:31PM COMPATIBILITY AND PRESERVATION OF THE INDUSTRIAL LANDS,
6:29:34PM WHICH I THINK WE CAN ALL AGREE IS NEEDED IN THE CITY OF
6:29:37PM TAMPA.
6:29:39PM THE REVIEW FINDINGS, ALL CITY AGENCIES AND PLANNING
6:29:41PM COMMISSION STAFF FOUND OUR REQUEST CONSISTENT AS OUTLINED IN
6:29:45PM YOUR CITY STAFF REPORT, USES ALLOWED IN IG ZONING
6:29:48PM DESIGNATION ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE EXISTING USES IN THE
6:29:51PM BUILT ENVIRONMENT.
6:29:52PM ADDITIONALLY, THE PC STAFF REPORT STATED THE REQUEST IS
6:29:55PM CONSISTENT WITH THE CHARACTER OF THE SURROUNDING AREA AND
6:29:58PM WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERNS ANTICIPATED UNDER THE L.I.
6:30:00PM DESIGNATION.
6:30:01PM SO WITH THAT, IN CONCLUSION, APPROVING THE REZONING WILL
6:30:06PM ALLOW FOR A ZONING DISTRICT CONSISTENT WITH L.I. CATEGORY.
6:30:10PM ALSO APPROVAL PROVIDE OPPORTUNITIES FOR INDUSTRIAL
6:30:12PM DEVELOPMENT AS INDUSTRIAL IS A SCARCE COMMODITY IN THE CITY
6:30:15PM OF TAMPA.
6:30:16PM AGAIN, NO WAIVERS ARE BEING REQUESTED.
6:30:17PM THIS IS A EUCLIDEAN ZONING REQUEST.
6:30:20PM CITY AND PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FOUND THE REQUEST
6:30:22PM CONSISTENT.
6:30:23PM AND TO MY KNOWLEDGE, I HAVE NOT RECEIVED ANY OPPOSITION TO
6:30:26PM OUR REQUEST.
6:30:27PM WITH THAT, I WOULD BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS SHOULD
6:30:29PM YOU HAVE ANY BUT WOULD REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL.
6:30:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
6:30:33PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:30:34PM IS THERE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM
6:30:40PM 3?
6:30:40PM WE HAVE A MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:30:42PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
6:30:43PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:30:44PM AYE.
6:30:44PM ANY OPPOSED?
6:30:45PM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:30:47PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I MOVE FILE REZ 24-101, ORDINANCE BEING
6:30:51PM PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE
6:30:53PM REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 8813 BROOKS
6:30:57PM STREET, 8901 NORTH 13th STREET AND 8814 NORTH 14th
6:31:02PM STREET IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, MORE PARTICULARLY
6:31:04PM DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1, FROM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATIONS
6:31:08PM IG INDUSTRIAL GENERAL AND RS 50 RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY,
6:31:12PM TO IG, INDUSTRIAL GENERAL, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
6:31:15PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SECOND.
6:31:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND SECOND.
6:31:17PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
6:31:19PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
6:31:20PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
6:31:21PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
6:31:22PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
6:31:24PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
6:31:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
6:31:26PM >>THE CLERK: MOTION CARRIED WITH VIERA ABSENT AT VOTE.
6:31:29PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MARCH 27, 2025,
6:31:33PM AT 10 A.M. LOCATED AT 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD
6:31:37PM FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
6:31:41PM >> THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME, CITY COUNCIL.
6:31:42PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:31:43PM YES, SIR.
6:31:49PM ITEM NUMBER 4.
6:31:52PM >> CHRISTOPHER DEMANCHE, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:31:55PM ITEM 4 IS REZ 24-102, REQUEST TO REZONE 3604 TEMPLE STREET
6:32:01PM FROM RM 16 TO RM 18.
6:32:03PM I'LL TURN IT OVER NOW TO PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
6:32:10PM >>JENNIFER MALONE: JENNIFER MALONE WITH THE PLANNING
6:32:12PM COMMISSION.
6:32:13PM WE HAVE TRAVELED TO THE EAST TAMPA URBAN VILLAGE IN THE
6:32:17PM CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT.
6:32:18PM WE'RE OFF OF NORTH 50th STREET AND TEMPLE STREET JUST
6:32:24PM NORTH OF EAST 28th.
6:32:26PM THE SURROUNDING AREA -- I MEAN, THIS BLOCK IS EITHER VACANT
6:32:32PM OR COMMERCIAL.
6:32:33PM THERE IS A COMMERCIAL USE AT THE CORNER HERE, BUT THERE'S
6:32:36PM RESIDENTIAL USES, ONE RIGHT HERE AND THEN ONE RIGHT HERE.
6:32:39PM TO THE SOUTH WE ALSO HAVE COMMERCIAL USES AND RESIDENTIAL
6:32:42PM USES TO THE EAST OF THE SITE.
6:32:44PM THE FUTURE LAND USE IS COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35.
6:32:47PM THAT'S YOUR PINK COLOR, WHICH ALLOWS A BROAD VARIETY OF USES
6:32:53PM FROM RESIDENTIAL ALL THE WAY UP TO COMMERCIAL GENERAL USES.
6:32:56PM RESIDENTIAL 20 IS RIGHT BEHIND THE SITE TO THE EAST.
6:32:58PM THAT'S OUR SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED MULTIFAMILY CATEGORY.
6:33:01PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REVIEWED THIS FOR CONSISTENCY WITH
6:33:05PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
6:33:06PM THIS IS A REALLY UNDERUTILIZED AREA OF THE CITY.
6:33:10PM THERE ARE A LOT OF VACANT SITES AND THE DENSITY IS VERY LOW
6:33:14PM FOR WHAT WE WOULD EXPECT IN THIS FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY.
6:33:16PM OUR PLAN HAS POLICIES ABOUT UTILIZING OUR VACANT LAND AND
6:33:22PM BRINGING OUR PARCELS UP TO DENSITY BECAUSE WE NEED TO PLAN
6:33:26PM FOR THAT GROWING POPULATION.
6:33:27PM SO THIS REQUEST FROM RM 16 TO RM 18 IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
6:33:33PM PLAN.
6:33:33PM IT ALSO IS CONSISTENT WITH OUR POLICIES, LIKE I SAID,
6:33:36PM ENCOURAGES NEW HOUSING ON VACANT AND UNDERUTILIZED LAND, AND
6:33:43PM IT WOULD NOT CAUSE ANY INCOMPATIBLE IMPACTS SINCE THE
6:33:48PM PARCELS TO THE SOUTH AND EAST OF THE SITE ARE ZONED RM 16
6:33:51PM BUT THIS JUMP TO RM 18 WE FOUND WAS IN LINE WITH WHAT WE'RE
6:33:57PM PLANNING FOR IN THIS AREA OF THE CITY.
6:33:58PM THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
6:34:00PM THANK YOU.
6:34:00PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR MS. MALONE?
6:34:01PM OKAY.
6:34:02PM SIR.
6:34:15PM >>CHRISTOPHER DEMANCHE: FOR THE RECORD, CHRISTOPHER
6:34:17PM DEMANCHE, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:34:19PM WE'LL START WITH AN AERIAL OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND THE
6:34:22PM SURROUNDING AREA.
6:34:22PM SUBJECT PARCEL OUTLINED IN RED ON THE WEST SIDE OF TEMPLE
6:34:27PM STREET.
6:34:28PM SUBJECT SITE IS LOCATED NORTH OF EAST 28th STREET, SOUTH
6:34:32PM OF 30th STREET AND EAST OF NORTH 50th STREET.
6:34:36PM THE SURROUNDING AREA DEVELOPMENT PATTERN IS CHARACTERIZED BY
6:34:39PM MULTIFAMILY, SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED, SINGLE-FAMILY SEMI
6:34:42PM DETACHED, SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED AND COMMERCIAL USES, GIVEN
6:34:46PM THE SIZE OF THE PARCEL AT 5,350 SQUARE FEET, THE MAXIMUM
6:34:51PM NUMBER OF UNITS ALLOWED BY RM 18 ZONING DISTRICT IS TWO
6:34:54PM DWELLING UNITS.
6:34:55PM THIS IS A SURVEY OF THE SUBJECT SITE OUTLINED IN YELLOW.
6:35:04PM THE SUBJECT BLOCK BETWEEN EAST 28th AVENUE AND EAST 30th
6:35:15PM AVENUE IS COMPRISED OF VARIOUS USES, AS I'VE MENTIONED,
6:35:19PM RESIDENTIAL AS WELL AS COMMERCIAL.
6:35:20PM THERE HAVE BEEN MULTIPLE REZONINGS IN THE AREA, IMMEDIATE
6:35:25PM SURROUNDING AREA OF THE SUBJECT SITE OVER THE PAST TEN
6:35:28PM YEARS.
6:35:28PM DIRECTLY NORTH AND SOUTH OF THE SITE IS PROPERTY ZONED FOR
6:35:31PM COMMERCIAL GENERAL.
6:35:32PM THE REZONING DIRECTLY NORTH OF THE SITE WAS APPROVED IN
6:35:35PM 2018.
6:35:37PM DIRECTLY WEST OF THE SITE, ACROSS NORTH 50th STREET IS A
6:35:42PM PROPERTY THAT WAS REZONED TO PLANNED DEVELOPMENT FOR A
6:35:45PM FUNERAL PARLOR AND CEMETERY USES.
6:35:48PM OF COURSE, EAST OF THE SUBJECT SITE ACROSS TEMPLE WE HAVE
6:35:51PM MULTIFAMILY DWELLINGS.
6:35:52PM GIVEN THE MIX OF THE USES IN THE IMMEDIATE AREA SURROUNDING
6:35:56PM THE SUBJECT BLOCK, THE REQUESTED RM-18 ZONING, IT'S
6:36:01PM CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN.
6:36:02PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS IN THE EAST TAMPA OVERLAY AND
6:36:05PM DEVELOPMENT MUST COMPLY WITH THE REQUIREMENTS SET FORTH IN
6:36:08PM SECTION 27-240, EAST TAMPA OVERLAY DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT
6:36:12PM DESIGN STANDARDS AT THE TIME OF PERMITTING.
6:36:14PM SINCE THIS IS EUCLIDEAN REZONING, THERE IS NO SITE PLAN OR
6:36:18PM ELEVATIONS TO BE SHOWN, BUT WE DO HAVE SOME PHOTOS OF THE
6:36:22PM SUBJECT SITE, WHICH I'LL SHARE.
6:36:23PM THIS IS A PHOTO OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:36:29PM WE HAVE TWO PHOTOS OF IT.
6:36:33PM THE SITE IS VACANT.
6:36:36PM NORTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:36:42PM ONE ADDITIONAL, THE NORTH PARCEL.
6:36:45PM SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE, WE HAVE A SINGLE-FAMILY SEMI
6:36:52PM DETACHED DWELLING.
6:36:53PM EAST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:36:59PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTHEAST FROM THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:37:07PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTH ACROSS 28th AVENUE.
6:37:15PM NEXT PHOTO WAS TAKEN ON NORTH 50th STREET AND LOOKING
6:37:18PM SOUTHEAST.
6:37:19PM YOU CAN SEE THE SUBJECT SITE ON THE LEFT SIDE OF THE PHOTO
6:37:22PM AND THE SEMI DETACHED DWELLING TO THE IMMEDIATE SOUTH IN THE
6:37:26PM PHOTO AS WELL.
6:37:27PM THIS IS LOOKING NORTH ON NORTH 50th STREET.
6:37:31PM THE SUBJECT PARCEL IS ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE PHOTO.
6:37:35PM WE ALSO HAVE ONE MORE PHOTO FROM NORTH 50th STREET OF THE
6:37:41PM SUBJECT SITE.
6:37:42PM DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION AND COMPLIANCE STAFF HAS REVIEWED
6:37:46PM THE APPLICATION.
6:37:46PM WE FIND THE REQUEST TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE LAND
6:37:49PM DEVELOPMENT CODE AND STAFF IS AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS
6:37:51PM YOU MIGHT HAVE.
6:37:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
6:37:53PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:37:54PM DO WE HAVE AN APPLICANT FOR ITEM NUMBER 4?
6:37:57PM YES, SIR, COME ON UP.
6:38:00PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
6:38:01PM >> GOOD EVENING, CITY COUNCIL.
6:38:02PM I'M THE OWNER, ROBERT LAWRY THE II.
6:38:07PM REQUESTING REZONING FROM RM 16 TO RM 18.
6:38:10PM I REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL.
6:38:11PM APPRECIATE IT.
6:38:12PM THANK YOU.
6:38:12PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE APPLICANT?
6:38:15PM IS THERE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON ITEM
6:38:18PM 4.
6:38:18PM MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
6:38:20PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON.
6:38:21PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:38:22PM AYE.
6:38:23PM ANY OPPOSED.
6:38:23PM COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
6:38:25PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
6:38:26PM FILE REZ 24-102, ORDINANCE BEING PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING
6:38:30PM CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL
6:38:33PM VICINITY OF 3604 TEMPLE STREET, IN THE CITY OF TAMPA,
6:38:37PM FLORIDA, AND MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1, FROM
6:38:41PM ZONING DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION RM 16, RESIDENTIAL,
6:38:44PM MULTIFAMILY, TO RM 18, RESIDENTIAL, MULTIFAMILY, PROVIDING
6:38:49PM AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
6:38:52PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SECOND.
6:38:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
6:38:54PM ROLL CALL VOTE.
6:38:55PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
6:38:58PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
6:38:59PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
6:39:00PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
6:39:02PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
6:39:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
6:39:04PM >>THE CLERK: THE MOTION CARRIED WITH VIERA ABSENT AT VOTE.
6:39:07PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MARCH 27, 2025,
6:39:12PM AT 10 A.M., LOCATED AT 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD
6:39:16PM FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
6:39:21PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WE HAVE ARRIVED AT NUMBER 5.
6:39:24PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:39:26PM ITEM 5 IS REZ 24-104 FOR THE PROPERTY AT 402 SOUTH OREGON
6:39:31PM AVENUE.
6:39:32PM THE REQUEST IS TO REZONE THE PROPERTY FROM RM 12,
6:39:36PM RESIDENTIAL, MULTIFAMILY, TO PD, RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY,
6:39:40PM DETACHED.
6:39:40PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO MS. MALONE WITH THE PLANNING
6:39:43PM COMMISSION.
6:39:57PM >>JENNIFER MALONE: JENNIFER MALONE WITH YOUR PLANNING
6:39:58PM COMMISSION STAFF.
6:39:59PM THIS IS IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT.
6:40:04PM IT IS LOCATED ON SOUTH OREGON AVENUE.
6:40:07PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE OUTLINED IN PURPLE AT THE CORNER OF
6:40:10PM SOUTH OREGON AVENUE AND WEST AZEELE STREET.
6:40:12PM IT IS WITHIN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO THE SELMON EXPRESSWAY AS YOU
6:40:17PM CAN SEE, AS WELL AS WEST PLATT STREET.
6:40:19PM THE CHARACTER OF THE STREET IS -- THERE ARE THESE TOWNHOMES
6:40:27PM THAT INTERFACES RIGHT ACROSS THE STREET.
6:40:29PM SO THERE IS A VARIETY OF TOWNHOMES AND SINGLE-FAMILY
6:40:33PM ATTACHED USES IN THE SURROUNDING AREA.
6:40:35PM AS WELL AS LIKE SOME MULTIFAMILY IN THE AREA AS WELL.
6:40:39PM I THINK IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT TO POINT OUT ON THE FUTURE
6:40:42PM LAND USE MAP, THE FUTURE LAND USE IS RESIDENTIAL 20.
6:40:48PM THE SITE IS RIGHT INTERFACING COMMUNITY COMMERCIAL 35 IN THE
6:40:53PM RED.
6:40:54PM THIS IS AN INTENSIVE FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY.
6:40:57PM THIS FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY IN THE RED ALLOWS CI USES
6:41:01PM WHICH COULD BE AUTO REPAIR.
6:41:03PM SO THAT'S THE CONTEXT ON THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP IS THAT IT
6:41:07PM IS A LITTLE BIT, WAS PLANNED FOR A LITTLE BIT MORE INTENSITY
6:41:12PM ACROSS THE STREET BUT THEY ARE DEVELOPED WITH TOWNHOMES.
6:41:14PM THAT IS THE EXISTING CHARACTER.
6:41:17PM RESIDENTIAL 20, THE FUTURE LAND USE OF THE SITE IS,
6:41:20PM ANTICIPATES SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED HOUSING, SUCH AS
6:41:25PM TOWNHOMES, DUPLEXES, SOME MULTIFAMILY.
6:41:29PM IT DOESN'T QUITE HAVE THE DENSITY FOR THAT ALWAYS.
6:41:31PM AND THEN SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED IF THAT'S APPROPRIATE.
6:41:34PM SO WE DID REVIEW THIS FOR CONSISTENCY WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE
6:41:39PM PLAN.
6:41:40PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FOUND IT CONSISTENT.
6:41:42PM WE LOOKED AT THE EXISTING DENSITY ALONG THE SEGMENT OF THE
6:41:50PM STREET, AND WE FOUND THAT IT WAS DEVELOPED THE RESIDENTIAL
6:41:55PM 20 PIECES OR AS A WHOLE, EXCLUDING THE SUBJECT SITE
6:41:58PM APPROXIMATELY 49% OF THE DENSITY ANTICIPATED UNDER THIS
6:42:01PM DESIGNATION.
6:42:02PM THIS REZONING WOULD ALLOW A DENSITY OF THE SITE OF 17.54
6:42:07PM UNITS PER ACRE IN AN AREA PLANNED FOR 20 DWELLING UNITS AN
6:42:11PM ACRE.
6:42:12PM SO IT'S GETTING CLOSER TO THAT DENSITY THAT WE WOULD
6:42:15PM ANTICIPATE UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL 20 FUTURE LAND USE
6:42:17PM CATEGORY.
6:42:17PM AS I SAID, THIS IS THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT, AND
6:42:21PM IT'S NOT FAR FROM THE CBD, FROM THE CENTRAL BUSINESS
6:42:26PM DISTRICT AS WELL.
6:42:28PM WE FOUND THAT IT WAS CONSISTENT WITH THE POLICIES ABOUT
6:42:32PM PROVIDING ADDITIONAL INFILL HOUSING ON AN UNDERUTILIZED
6:42:36PM PARCEL WITHIN THE CENTRAL PLANNING DISTRICT.
6:42:37PM WE'VE ALSO CITED IN OUR REPORT POLICIES RELATED TO THE
6:42:42PM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW COMMISSION BECAUSE I UNDERSTAND ITS
6:42:45PM HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE AND WE FOUND IT WAS CONSISTENT WITH
6:42:47PM THOSE AS WELL.
6:42:48PM SO THOSE ARE IN THE REPORT FOR THE RECORD.
6:42:50PM I'M AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
6:42:51PM THANK YOU.
6:42:52PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ANY QUESTIONS?
6:42:52PM THANK YOU.
6:42:55PM MS. LaCHONE.
6:42:56PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
6:42:58PM I'LL PUT UP THE SITE PLAN THAT WAS SUBMITTED.
6:43:01PM THE PD REQUEST BEFORE YOU WOULD ALLOW FOR TWO SINGLE-FAMILY
6:43:12PM DETACHED HOMES ON THE SITE.
6:43:14PM SO THE LOT ITSELF HAS A FRONTAGE OF 64 FEET AND THEN A DEPTH
6:43:19PM OF 77 FEET.
6:43:22PM THE MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT THAT'S ALLOWED IS 35 FEET FOR
6:43:27PM THE TWO DWELLINGS ON-SITE.
6:43:28PM AND THEN FOUR PARKING SPACES ARE REQUIRED FOR THE OVERALL
6:43:32PM USE AND FOUR SPACES ARE PROVIDED.
6:43:34PM THIS IS THE SITE PLAN.
6:43:35PM THIS IS THE SITE WHICH IS OUTLINED IN THE DOTTED LINE.
6:43:38PM THIS IS AZEELE STREET.
6:43:40PM THIS IS OREGON AVENUE.
6:43:43PM SO THIS OUTLINE IS THE EXISTING STRUCTURE ON-SITE, WHICH
6:43:48PM I'LL SHOW YOU MOMENTARILY PHOTOS OF.
6:43:51PM THE PROPOSAL IS TO ADD IN ADDITION TO THIS EXISTING
6:43:55PM STRUCTURE AND THEN THIS WOULD PROPOSE ACCESS TO THE SITE
6:43:58PM FROM AZEELE WITH THE SPACES HERE.
6:44:02PM THIS IS A CARPORT AND THEN THIS IS A SURFACE SPACE LOCATED
6:44:08PM HERE.
6:44:08PM THIS IS PROPOSED AS NEW DEVELOPMENT.
6:44:10PM SO THIS IS BUILDING TWO, WHICH IS THE SINGLE-FAMILY HOUSE
6:44:14PM LOCATED ON THE SOUTHERN END OF THE SITE.
6:44:16PM THIS WOULD HAVE ACCESS ON OREGON AVENUE.
6:44:19PM SO ONE HAS VEHICULAR ACCESS ON AZEELE AND THE OTHER ON
6:44:23PM OREGON.
6:44:24PM THIS WOULD HAVE A CARPORT ALSO ON-SITE.
6:44:29PM YOU CAN SEE THE FRONT DOOR ORIENTATION HERE, AND THEN THIS
6:44:34PM HAS THE ACCESS HERE.
6:44:35PM YOU CAN ALSO SEE THE SIDEWALK SURROUNDS THE SITE ON BOTH THE
6:44:40PM NORTH AND THE WEST.
6:44:41PM ALSO, THIS LOT IS A PART OF DOBYVILLE.
6:44:48PM IT'S IN THE HYDE PARK LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT.
6:44:52PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS A PART OF REVISED WATROUS SUBDIVISION.
6:44:57PM WEST 77 FEET OF LOT 12, BLOCK 2.
6:45:01PM IT WAS PLATTED IN 1915 WITH 12 LOTS, BUT IT HAS BEEN
6:45:06PM DEVELOPED TODAY.
6:45:08PM IT WAS PLATTED AT A LOT WIDTH AVERAGE OF 64 FEET OF
6:45:12PM FRONTAGE, 12 LOTS.
6:45:13PM TODAY, BLOCK 2 CONTAINS 27 LOTS.
6:45:17PM THOSE LOTS WE TOOK THE MEASUREMENTS AND ASSESSED THAT BLOCK
6:45:21PM FACE.
6:45:21PM THOSE LOTS ARE MEASURING IN WIDTH UP TO 54 FEET.
6:45:26PM SO WITHIN THE BLOCK FACE ITSELF, OVER 50% OF THE BLOCK FACE
6:45:31PM HAS LOTS THAT ARE BETWEEN ZERO TO 34 FEET IN WIDTH.
6:45:37PM 34 FEET IS THE WIDEST WIDTH ON THAT BLOCK FACE.
6:45:40PM I WANT TO SHOW YOU THE ELEVATIONS FOR THE SITE.
6:45:49PM SO THIS IS THE CURRENT STRUCTURE.
6:45:52PM THIS IS THE WEST ELEVATION.
6:45:55PM THIS SHOWS YOU THE NORTH ELEVATION.
6:46:05PM THIS IS THE EAST ELEVATION AT THE TOP AND THIS IS THE SOUTH
6:46:10PM ELEVATION AT THE BOTTOM.
6:46:12PM AND THEN THIS ONE IS FOR THE STRUCTURE ON-SITE.
6:46:26PM THIS IS THE SOUTH ELEVATION AND THEN THIS PHOTO IS THE WEST
6:46:31PM ELEVATION.
6:46:36PM THIS IS THE NORTH ELEVATION AND THEN THIS IS THE EAST
6:46:41PM ELEVATION.
6:46:42PM THEN I HAVE THE ZONING ATLAS OF THE SITE TO SHOW YOU.
6:46:49PM SO THIS IS THE ZONING.
6:46:52PM THIS IS THE PROPERTY WHICH IS OUTLINED HERE IN RED.
6:46:55PM THIS IS AZEELE STREET.
6:46:58PM THIS IS ORLEANS.
6:47:03PM THIS IS OREGON AVENUE.
6:47:05PM PLATT STREET IS TO THE NORTH.
6:47:06PM BUT YOU CAN SEE SURROUNDING THE SITE YOU HAVE THE
6:47:09PM RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY ZONES.
6:47:10PM SOME OF THE PD ZONINGS.
6:47:12PM THE USES ARE EITHER SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED OR MULTIFAMILY.
6:47:16PM TO THE WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE IS A PD.
6:47:18PM THIS WAS A PD APPROVED IN 04.
6:47:21PM THIS IS SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED AND MULTIFAMILY USES.
6:47:24PM AS YOU ARE, ALONG PLATT STREET, YOU HAVE YOUR COMMERCIAL
6:47:28PM USES WITH THE CG AND THE PD ZONING AND THOSE USES ALONG
6:47:33PM PLATT.
6:47:34PM BUT AS YOU MOVE SOUTH OF THE SITE AND SOUTH OF HORATIO, YOU
6:47:38PM HAVE YOUR RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ZONING AND DEVELOPMENT.
6:47:42PM YOU STILL HAVE YOUR RM ZONINGS, THE RM 24s THAT ARE
6:47:47PM THROUGH HERE PLUS SOME PDs.
6:47:50PM AS YOU'RE ALONG SWANN, YOU'RE NOW AT THE POINT OF HYDE PARK
6:47:53PM VILLAGE.
6:47:54PM I HAVE PHOTOS OF THE SITE.
6:48:00PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE.
6:48:04PM THAT IS THE HOME TO REMAIN.
6:48:06PM SO THE NEW HOME IS PROPOSED ON THE LOT NEXT TO THAT EXISTING
6:48:12PM STRUCTURE.
6:48:12PM SO THIS IS A VIEW OF THE NORTH SIDE OF THE SITE.
6:48:15PM THIS IS THAT ACCESS POINT THAT'S ON AZEELE.
6:48:20PM THIS IS LOOKING WEST ON AZEELE.
6:48:25PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW OF THE NORTH SIDE OF THE SITE LOOKING
6:48:28PM WEST ON AZEELE.
6:48:31PM THIS IS IF WE TURN AROUND THE SITE, AND THIS IS FROM OREGON
6:48:37PM LOOKING NORTH ON AZEELE.
6:48:38PM THIS IS THE NORTH END OF THE SITE, ANOTHER VIEW OF AZEELE.
6:48:46PM YOU'LL SEE THE DOBY HOUSE THAT'S FURTHER DOWN, BUT I HAVE A
6:48:50PM PICTURE OF THAT ALSO TO SHOW YOU IN THE SURROUNDING PHOTOS.
6:48:54PM THIS IS NORTH OF THE SITE.
6:48:57PM YOU CAN SEE THE SELMON EXPRESSWAY IS ACROSS THE STREET.
6:49:01PM THIS IS THE DOBY HOUSE, WHICH IS LOCATED ON AZEELE.
6:49:04PM THIS IS NORTH OF THE SITE.
6:49:07PM THIS IS ON AZEELE IF YOU'RE LOOKING EAST.
6:49:12PM THAT RESIDENCE IS OFF TO THE RIGHT IN THE PHOTO.
6:49:17PM THIS IS EAST OF THE SITE.
6:49:18PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS THERE.
6:49:24PM THIS IS EAST, THE OTHER SIDE OF THE SITE ONE BLOCK OVER FROM
6:49:27PM THE SITE.
6:49:28PM THIS IS THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF AZEELE AND ORLEANS.
6:49:33PM THIS IS ON OREGON SOUTH OF THE SITE.
6:49:34PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS HERE ON THE LEFT IN THE PICTURE.
6:49:40PM AND THIS IS SHOWING YOU SOME OF THE SINGLE-FAMILY
6:49:42PM RESIDENCES.
6:49:43PM YOU CAN SEE SOME OF THE LOT WIDTHS THAT ARE THERE ON SOME OF
6:49:46PM THE HOMES THAT ARE LOCATED NEXT DOOR AND ON THIS BLOCK FACE.
6:49:51PM SO THIS IS AS WE HEAD FURTHER SOUTH, SOME OF THE
6:49:55PM RESIDENTIAL.
6:49:56PM SHOWING YOU SOME MORE OF THE RESIDENTIAL THAT'S THERE.
6:49:59PM THIS IS ACROSS THE STREET, SWINGING AROUND WEST OF THE SITE,
6:50:02PM AND THEN THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW WEST OF THE SITE.
6:50:05PM SINCE THE SITE IS LOCATED IN THE LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT,
6:50:12PM THIS CASE WENT BEFORE THE ARC ON FEBRUARY 10.
6:50:17PM THE COMMISSION VOTED TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL WITH THE
6:50:19PM CONDITION THAT THE PROPOSED PVC FENCE, WHICH IS IDENTIFIED
6:50:22PM ON THE SITE PLAN, ACTUALLY BE CHANGED TO WOOD.
6:50:26PM SO WITH THAT, RON VILA IS HERE FROM HISTORIC PRESERVATION IF
6:50:31PM THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING THE ARC RECOMMENDATION,
6:50:34PM HE'S AVAILABLE IF THERE ARE QUESTIONS.
6:50:36PM THERE ARE NO WAIVERS WITH THIS REQUEST.
6:50:39PM THE DRC STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE APPLICATION AND FINDS IT
6:50:42PM CONSISTENT.
6:50:43PM THERE ARE CHANGES THAT ARE REQUIRED TO BE MADE TO THE SITE
6:50:45PM PLAN BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING.
6:50:47PM WITH THAT, THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
6:50:51PM I'M AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
6:50:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
6:50:53PM THANK YOU.
6:50:56PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
6:50:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
6:50:59PM APPLICANT, COME ON UP, SIR.
6:51:01PM WERE YOU SWORN IN, SIR?
6:51:04PM >> NO, SIR.
6:51:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I SAW A LOT OF PEOPLE COME IN SINCE I
6:51:08PM ASKED THE LAST TIME.
6:51:09PM IF YOU ARE GOING TO SPEAK ON ANY OF THE CASES TONIGHT AND
6:51:12PM YOU HAVE NOT BEEN SWORN IN, PLEASE STAND AND RAISE YOUR
6:51:15PM RIGHT HAND AND WE WILL SWEAR YOU IN.
6:51:22PM [OATH ADMINISTERED]
6:51:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6:51:28PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME AND GO AHEAD.
6:51:30PM >> SURE.
6:51:31PM MY NAME IS ASSAD SHAIKH.
6:51:34PM APPLICANT AND OWNER OF THE PROPERTY.
6:51:36PM >> STEVE MICHELINI.
6:51:38PM AGENT.
6:51:41PM >> I NEED HELP PLUGGING THIS IN.
6:51:44PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: CAN WE STOP THE CLOCK WHILE HE SETS UP?
6:51:53PM >> COUNCIL, WHENEVER THE CLOCK CAN START, I PREPARED THIS
6:52:43PM VIDEO FOR YOU GUYS KIND OF TO SHOW A MORE VISUAL VERSUS THE
6:52:47PM STILL RENDERINGS.
6:52:48PM I'LL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS AFTER.
6:52:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS IT A GREEN SCREEN THAT YOU HAVE?
6:53:08PM T AND I, CAN SOMEONE GIVE THEM A HAND SETTING THIS UP?
6:53:11PM PLUG IN A LAPTOP OR USB?
6:53:15PM >> I HAVE BOTH BUT RIGHT NOW WE'RE PLUGGED IN WITH A LAPTOP.
6:53:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SOMEONE WILL COME OUT REAL QUICK.
6:53:20PM CTTV, ANYBODY IN THE BACK THAT CAN HELP PERHAPS?
6:54:43PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: MR. CHAIRMAN, I'M GOING TO REMIND THE
6:54:46PM PUBLIC THE RULE REGARDING THE USE OF MEDIA.
6:54:55PM AND THAT WOULD BE RULE 5E.
6:55:00PM TO REFRESH THE PUBLIC'S RECOLLECTION, PERSONS REQUESTING TO
6:55:04PM USE ELECTRONIC MEDIA FOR PUBLIC HEARINGS BEFORE CITY
6:55:07PM COUNCIL, ARE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE THE ELECTRONIC MEDIA TO THE
6:55:10PM CITY OF TAMPA DIGITAL MEDIA PRODUCTION CTTV AT LEAST 48
6:55:13PM HOURS PRIOR TO BROADCAST.
6:55:15PM SUCH MATERIAL MUST COMPLY WITH THE ESTABLISHED TIME LIMITS
6:55:18PM AND COMPLY WITH THE RULES OF PROCEDURE AND SUBMISSIONS ARE
6:55:21PM NOT PERMITTED FOR USE UNDER GENERAL PUBLIC COMMENT.
6:55:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GENERAL PUBLIC COMMENT.
6:55:26PM BUT THIS IS PART OF --
6:55:27PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: JUST A REMINDER, THAT THIS IS --
6:55:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: AS PETITIONER IS ALLOWED TO.
6:55:34PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: 48 HOURS IN ADVANCE.
6:55:36PM OBVIOUSLY, THE REASON I'M BRINGING THIS TO COUNCIL'S
6:55:40PM ATTENTION IS SO THAT THE PUBLIC IS AWARE THAT THE TIME THAT
6:55:46PM IS TAKEN CAN BE EXTENSIVE.
6:55:52PM I UNDERSTAND GIVING THE PETITIONER LATITUDE BUT JUST A
6:55:55PM REMINDER.
6:55:57PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: [INAUDIBLE] -- THAT TELLS THEM WHAT THE
6:56:02PM RULES ARE?
6:56:03PM THAT IS THE ONLY TIME THEY ARE GOING TO KNOW.
6:56:05PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: I DON'T KNOW WHETHER IT IS ON THE DOCUMENTS
6:56:06PM THAT YOU GET ON THE RULES OF PROCEDURE WITH REGARD TO
6:56:10PM ELECTRONIC EQUIPMENT.
6:56:10PM I AM NOT FAMILIAR WITH WHAT LAND DEVELOPMENT HAS.
6:56:14PM >> MR. CHAIRMAN, I'D LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO WAIVE THE
6:56:17PM RULES FOR THIS APPLICANT.
6:56:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
6:56:20PM ALL IN FAVOR?
6:56:21PM AYE.
6:56:22PM ANY OPPOSED?
6:56:23PM OKAY, MR. SHELBY.
6:56:26PM BUT IN THE FUTURE, WE'LL KNOW.
6:56:28PM GO AHEAD, IF YOU WANT TO START THE VIDEO.
6:56:29PM MAKE SURE THE VOLUME IS UP.
6:56:30PM I DON'T KNOW IF CTTV NEEDS TO GET -- YEAH, GET THE -- THERE
6:57:03PM WE GO.
6:57:04PM THE VOLUME.
6:57:09PM IT SHOULD WORK.
6:57:17PM WE'LL TRY.
6:57:20PM IF NOT, WE'LL CHANGE THE OUTPUT DEVICE.
6:57:24PM CHECK THE OTHER SETTING THAT HAS THE OTHER OUTPUT.
6:57:40PM >> APOLOGIES, COUNCIL.
6:57:41PM WE PLAYED A VIDEO LAST TIME.
6:57:46PM >>STEVE MICHELINI: JUST SO YOU KNOW, THIS WAS REVIEWED
6:57:49PM PREVIOUSLY.
6:57:50PM BEFORE 48 HOURS.
6:57:52PM HE TOOK IT IN.
6:57:58PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THAT TO MY
6:58:00PM ATTENTION.
6:58:04PM >> PLAY IT AND TALK OVER IT.
6:58:06PM >> ARE YOU ABLE TO SEE THE VIDEO AT LEAST?
6:58:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE CAN SEE IT.
6:58:11PM >> HI.
6:58:11PM I'M ASSAD SHAIKH.
6:58:13PM I'M THE OWNER OF 402 SOUTH OREGON AVENUE.
6:58:16PM THE PROJECT WE'RE PROPOSING HERE IS SIMPLE.
6:58:18PM WE'RE GOING TO PRESERVE THE EXISTING HISTORIC STRUCTURE ON
6:58:22PM THE SITE AND WE'RE GOING TO DO A SMALL ADDITION IN THE REAR
6:58:25PM THAT PROVIDES COVERED PARKING AND ALSO RESPECTS THE TWO OAK
6:58:29PM TREES THAT ARE IN THE BACK WHICH WE WILL BE KEEPING.
6:58:32PM IN ADDITION, ON THE VACANT PORTION OF THE LOT WE'RE GOING TO
6:58:35PM RESTORE THE HISTORIC FABRIC.
6:58:37PM THERE USED TO BE A HOME LOCATED HERE THAT WAS BUILT IN THE
6:58:41PM 1910s.
6:58:42PM SOMETIMES IN THE MID 1990s, THAT HOME WAS DEMOLISHED.
6:58:46PM WE ARE SEEKING TO BUILD A NEW CONSTRUCTION HOME WHERE THE
6:58:48PM OLD HOME USED TO SIT.
6:58:50PM NOW, OUR NEIGHBORS ON THIS SITE ARE THE TOWNHOMES ACROSS THE
6:58:56PM STREET, THE SELMON EXPRESSWAY, AND ALL THE GREENSPACE AND
6:59:02PM 406 SOUTH OREGON AVENUE.
6:59:06PM OUR NEIGHBORING HOUSE AT 406 SOUTH OREGON WAS BUILT IN 1925
6:59:10PM AND SITS ON A 26-FOOT WIDE LOT.
6:59:12PM THE NEIGHBOR SUPPORTS OUR PROJECT, AND THE ARCHITECTURAL
6:59:17PM STYLE OF THEIR HOME, WHICH HAS A SMALL AT THE FRONT AND
6:59:22PM SECOND STORY RECESSED IN THE BACK WAS A GREAT INSPIRATION
6:59:25PM FOR OUR PLAN.
6:59:26PM OUR NEIGHBOR AT 408 SOUTH OREGON ALSO SUPPORTS OUR PROJECT.
6:59:30PM OUR NEIGHBORS AT 410, 412, AND --
6:59:33PM >> 410 AND 414 SUPPORT US NOW AFTER THE DEAL.
6:59:37PM >> VIDEO: THEY ALL SIT ON AN APPROXIMATELY 30-FOOT WIDE
6:59:41PM LOT.
6:59:43PM -- ONLY OTHER CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC STRUCTURE THAT'S LEFT ON
6:59:47PM THE BLOCK.
6:59:47PM PAY ATTENTION TO THEIR METAL ROOF AND THE GABLE SHAPE OF THE
6:59:52PM ROOF.
6:59:53PM NEIGHBOR AT 420 SOUTH OREGON WAS BUILT IN 2008, AND IT KIND
6:59:58PM OF STANDS OUT FROM THE OTHER HOMES ON THE BLOCK BECAUSE OF
7:00:01PM ITS WIDE, WIDE FACADE.
7:00:03PM OUR NEIGHBOR AT 422 SOUTH OREGON SITS ON ABOUT A 32-FOOT WIDE
7:00:08PM LOT, ALSO HAS THE METAL ROOF AND GABLED SHAPE
7:00:11PM CHARACTERISTICS OF THE BLOCK.
7:00:12PM 426 SOUTH OREGON, WHICH IS STILL UNDER CONSTRUCTION, WHICH
7:00:18PM WAS PERMITTED BEFORE THE HISTORIC DISTRICT EXPANSION WHICH
7:00:22PM STICKS OUT ON THE BLOCK.
07:00:29PM AND YOU CAN SEE OUR PROJECT IS MEANT
07:00:31PM TO BE A MUCH MORE INTENSIVE INFILL NEW CONSTRUCTION.
07:00:34PM HERE WE ARE BACK AT SOUTH OREGON.
07:00:37PM LIKE I SAID, WE ARE PRESERVING THESE OAK TREES.
07:00:40PM OUR NEIGHBORS HERE AT 1408 WEST AZEELE STREET ALSO SUPPORTS
07:00:45PM OUR PROJECT AND HAVE WRITTEN A LETTER OF SUPPORT.
07:00:48PM 1406 WEST AZEELE AND 1404 WEST AZEELE.
07:00:52PM THESE ARE BOTH CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURES THAT ARE 1406 FEET AND
07:01:00PM THE LOT IS 1800 SQUARE FEET.
07:01:01PM 1404 IS ONLY 32 FEET WIDE AND THE LOT IS 1600 SQUARE FEET TOTAL.
07:01:06PM NOW WE ARE AT 401 SOUTH ORLEANS.
07:01:09PM THE EARLY 1900'S STRUCTURE ON THE LOT WAS TORN DOWN PRIOR TO
07:01:15PM THE EXPANSION OF THE HISTORIC DISTRICT.
07:01:19PM SOUTH ARE BOTH CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURES AND NARROW LOTS.
07:01:26PM 417 SOUTH ORLEANS WAS BUILT IN 1991 AND LOOKS LIKE IT WAS HERE
07:01:32PM FOR OVER 100 YEARS.
07:01:34PM A 22-FOOT-WIDE LOT AND SENSITIVE INFILL CONSTRUCTION.
07:01:40PM HERE WE HAVE 421, 423 AND 425 SOUTH ORLEANS WITH ALL CONTRIBUTING
07:01:46PM STRUCTURES ALSO ON NARROW LOTS ALL.
07:01:51PM BIMETAL ROOFS AND GABLE ROOFS AS WELL.
07:01:52PM HERE WE HAVE A SOUTH ORLEANS.
07:01:55PM A CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE BUILT IN 1908.
07:01:59PM I MET THE OWNERS, AND THEY SUPPORT OUR PROJECT.
07:02:02PM THIS WAS ONE OF OUR BIGGEST INSPIRATIONS FOR THE NEW HOME
07:02:05PM THAT WE ARE BUILDING.
07:02:06PM WE LOOKED AT THE GABLE ROOF STRUCTURE OF THIS HOME.
07:02:09PM WE LOOKED AT THE FIRST FLOOR OF HOME.
07:02:12PM AND IT LOOKED DIMINUTIVE FROM THE STREET LEVEL, AND SECOND
07:02:16PM STORY RISES IN THE BACK, AND WE TOOK A LOT OF REFERENCING
07:02:19PM FROM THE HOME.
07:02:19PM WE HAVE 400 SOUTH ORLEANS ON A CORNER LOT, A MODERN HOME
07:02:25PM THAT WAS BUILT PRIOR TO THE HISTORIC DISTRICT SO AS WE LOOK
07:02:29PM OVERHEAD, YOU CAN SEE THAT THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN OF
07:02:33PM DOBYVILLE, BOTH HISTORICALLY AND MODERN TIMES IS
07:02:37PM CHARACTERIZED BY NARROW LOTS, REDUCED SIDE-YARD SETBACKS
07:02:42PM AROUND THREE FEET, AND MANY ACCESSORY STRUCTURES BUILT ALL
07:02:46PM THE WAY INTO THE REAR ALLEY.
07:02:49PM AND AS WE MOVE SOUTH OF SWANN AVENUE, IT IS IMPORTANT TO
07:02:53PM NOTE THAT THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN OF HYDE PARK IN THIS AREA
07:02:59PM DIFFERS SIGNIFICANTLY FROM DOBYVILLE.
07:03:01PM NEIGHBORHOOD HERE IS CHARACTERIZED BY LARGER LOTS, LOWER
07:03:05PM DENSITY AND LOWER FUTURE LAND USE.
07:03:07PM OUR REZONING AT 400 SOUTH OREGON HAS BEEN FOUND CONSISTENT BY
07:03:13PM CITY STAFF INCLUDING THE PLANNING COMMISSION, NATURAL
07:03:16PM RESOURCES, TRANSPORTATION, HISTORIC PRESERVATION, AND THE
07:03:23PM ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW COMMISSION WHO VOTED 4-1 TO RECOMMEND
07:03:27PM APPROVAL OF OUR PROJECT.
07:03:28PM THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION.
07:03:30PM >> THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION, COUNCIL.
07:03:33PM THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE WITH THE VIDEO.
07:03:37PM HOPEFULLY OPENING THIS POWERPOINT -ILL BE MUCH EASIER.
07:03:40PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: LET ME SAY, WHAT A BEAUTIFUL NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:03:46PM SEEING IT LIKE THAT, ALL THE DIFFERENT COLORS AND ALL THE
07:03:51PM ARCHITECTURAL STYLE, IT IS REALLY A GEM.
07:03:53PM >> THANK YOU.
07:03:55PM OKAY.
07:03:58PM SO HOW WE HAVE THE PRESENTATION PORTION.
07:04:03PM AND WE HAVE SOME COPIES OF THIS.
07:04:06PM IF I CAN HAND THEM OUT TO COUNCIL.
07:04:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE DON'T NEED THE SEVENTH ONE.
07:04:33PM >> OKAY.
07:04:41PM WE ALREADY WENT OVER THIS.
07:04:42PM WHAT I WANT TO FOCUS ON OUR PROPOSAL INSPIRED BY HISTORY.
07:04:45PM WHERE WE ARE SEEKING TO BUILD THE NEW CONSTRUCTION
07:04:48PM STRUCTURE, THERE USED TO BE A HOME BUILT IN 1913.
07:04:52PM SO WE BELIEVE WE ARE HONORING THE NEIGHBORHOOD'S HISTORICAL
07:04:56PM DEVELOPMENT PATTERN.
07:04:57PM REBUILDING THE HOME ON A FOOTPRINT WHERE THE HOME PREVIOUSLY
07:05:00PM EXISTED.
07:05:00PM BEFORE I BOUGHT THE HOUSE, THE PROPERTY WAS COMPLETELY
07:05:04PM UNMAINTAINED, OVERGROWN, AND YOU CAN SEE IN THE PHOTOS THAT
07:05:07PM IS THE BEFORE AND THE AFTER WE CLEARED UP THE SITE.
07:05:12PM OUR SITE PLAN.
07:05:13PM STAFF ALREADY KIND OF WENT OVER THAT.
07:05:16PM AND I WILL SCROLL BY THAT.
07:05:17PM THE ELEVATIONS THAT STAFF ALREADY WENT OVER.
07:05:21PM THESE ARE SOME RENDERING OF THE PROPOSED NEW RESIDENCE.
07:05:25PM THE PROPOSED ADDITION TO THE EXISTING RESIDENCE AS WELL.
07:05:28PM THESE ARE RENDERINGS SHOWING THE TWO STRUCTURES SIDE BY
07:05:35PM SIDE.
07:05:38PM I THINK THAT THE VIDEO DID A LOT BETTER JOB THAN THESE STILL
07:05:41PM PHOTOS, AND I WILL SCROLL PAST THESE.
07:05:43PM BUT I JUST WANT TO POINT OUT THAT -- THAT THE CONTRIBUTING
07:05:48PM STRUCTURES ALL HAVE A CERTAIN ARCHITECTURAL VERNACULAR AND
07:05:52PM CHOSE TO FOLLOW THAT AND ARC RECOGNIZED THAT.
07:05:55PM MOST OF THESE HOMES HAVE VERY NARROW SIDE YARD SETBACKS.
07:05:59PM THAT KIND OF WAS DEMONSTRATED IN THE VIDEO AS WELL.
07:06:02PM AND THEN AS WE MENTIONED, IT IS VERY IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT
07:06:05PM ALTHOUGH THIS WAS ADDED TO THE HISTORIC DISTRICT,
07:06:09PM DOBYVILLE'S DEVELOPMENT PATTERN WAS COMPLETELY DIFFERENT
07:06:12PM THAN THE REST OF HYDE PARK AND WE ARE TRYING TO RESPECT
07:06:14PM THAT.
07:06:15PM OUR FRONT YARD SETBACK IS BASED ON THE TWO CONTRIBUTING
07:06:22PM STRUCTURE FRONT YARD QUARTERBACKS.
07:06:23PM TWO ARE 15 FOOT, 5 INCHES AND 16 FOOT, 8 INCHES FOR FRONT
07:06:29PM YARD SETBACK.
07:06:29PM SO WE PROPOSED A FRONT YARD SETBACK OF 15 FOOT, 6 INCHES FOR
07:06:34PM THE NEW CONSTRUCTION RESIDENCE.
07:06:36PM SO IT IS BASICALLY LINED UP WITH THE EXISTING HISTORIC HOME.
07:06:40PM TO KIND OF DOCUMENT THAT THERE WAS -- THIS IS THE VERY
07:06:46PM IMPORTANT PART OF -- OF OUR -- OUR REZONING.
07:06:50PM IF YOU LOOK AT THE SANBORN FIRE MAP, THE STRUCTURE THAT IS
07:06:55PM CURRENTLY THERE NOW IS ACTUALLY A NEWER STRUCTURE THAN THE
07:06:58PM STRUCTURE THAT WAS ORIGINALLY THERE AND THE SANBORN FIRE MAP
07:07:02PM IF YOU LOOK WHERE THE CURSOR WAS SHOWING, WHERE WE WERE
07:07:06PM PROPOSING TO BUILD A HOME, THERE USED TO BE A HOME.
07:07:09PM WENT TO THE LIBRARY AND PULLED OUT THE POLK DIRECTORY AND
07:07:12PM CONFIRMED 402 OR 404 OREGON WHERE IT WAS SEPARATELY
07:07:16PM ADDRESSED.
07:07:16PM AND I EVEN HAD PROPERTY APPRAISER CARDS THAT SHOWED THAT
07:07:21PM BOTH OF STRUCTURES HAVE EXISTED AT THE SAME TIME.
07:07:26PM AND THESE ARE ALL IN YUCK PACKETS.
07:07:30PM WE GOT -- I WENT TO FDOT.COM.
07:07:33PM THEY HAVE A REALLY NICE AERIAL DATABASE AND FOUND AN
07:07:38PM AERIAL, LITTLE BIT BLURRY, SHOWING TWO STRUCTURES SIDE BY
07:07:41PM SIDE IN 1909 AND DEMOLISHED SOME TIME AFTER 1909.
07:07:48PM IT IS IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT THERE ARE PEOPLE WHO LIVED ON
07:07:51PM 404 OREGON, THE VACANT POURING OF THE SITE.
07:07:54PM WE WENT INTO THE NEWSPAPER FOUND MR. JOHN JOLO, WHO USED TO
07:07:59PM WORK FOR LIGHTHOUSE OF THE BLIND.
07:08:01PM SERGEANT JAMES COLEMAN CAME BACK FROM HIS NAVY SERVICE BACK
07:08:04PM IN 1952.
07:08:05PM AND THESE PEOPLE HAD MEMORIES IN THE HOUSE THAT WAS
07:08:08PM DEMOLISHED AND -- AND THAT WAS DEMOLISHED PRIOR TO THE
07:08:13PM HISTORIC DISTRICT EXPANSION.
07:08:14PM THESE ARE THE DOBYVILLE MAPS.
07:08:17PM SHOWING THE DOBYVILLE BOUNDARIES.
07:08:20PM >> SHOW THEM THE LOCATION.
07:08:25PM >> YES, OUR PROPERTY IS RIGHT HERE AT THE CORNER OF OREGON
07:08:30PM AND AZEELE.
07:08:34PM RIGHT IN THE BOUNDARY.
07:08:35PM THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT.
07:08:36PM OUR PROPERTY IS AT THE TOP LEFT, AND WANTED TO SHOW
07:08:40PM PROPERTIES THAT HAD LESS OR SIMILAR WIDTH.
07:08:43PM AS YOU CAN SEE, THIS IS VERY UNIQUE AREA WHERE YOU HAVE LOTS
07:08:48PM -- LOTS AS NARROW AS 22 FEET AND 27, ETC.
07:08:54PM IT IS IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT THE CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC
07:08:56PM STRUCTURES EVEN ARE ON LOTS AS NARROW AS 27, 29 AND 32 FEET.
07:09:01PM AS A MATTER OF FACT, NONCONTRIBUTING STRUCTURES THAT ARE ON
07:09:04PM NARROW LOTS WERE PROBABLY BELT -- WERE -- WERE HISTORIC
07:09:09PM HOMES WERE TORN DOWN.
07:09:09PM THESE ARE LOTS THAT HAVE LESS DEPTH.
07:09:12PM AGAIN WE ARE IN THE TOP LEFT CORNER.
07:09:14PM AND THE RED PIN SHOWS LOTS THAT HAVE LESS DEPTH.
07:09:18PM NOW THIS IS PRIOR -- PROBABLY MOST IMPORTANT PART, THE
07:09:23PM SUPPORT.
07:09:23PM WHERE THE RED PIN.
07:09:25PM OUR DIRECT NEIGHBORS SUPPORT US.
07:09:27PM THESE ARE THE PEOPLE WHO WILL BE MOST AFFECTED BY THE
07:09:29PM CONSTRUCTION AND RENOVATION WE ARE DOING.
07:09:31PM AND WE HAVE THEIR SUPPORT.
07:09:32PM AS A MATTER OF FACT, 406 OREGON, 408, 410, 414 OREGON ALL
07:09:39PM SUPPORT OUR PROJECT.
07:09:39PM THE NEIGHBORS MOST AFFECTED BY OUR PROJECT SUPPORT OUR
07:09:43PM PROJECT.
07:09:43PM HAVE WRITTEN LETTERS OF SUPPORT.
07:09:45PM TWO OF THEM ARE EVEN HERE TODAY TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THE
07:09:48PM PROJECT.
07:09:48PM THIS IS AN OVERALL MAP SHOWING OUR SUPPORT IN ALL OF TAMPA
07:09:54PM WITH PINS AND THAT WILL WRAP UP MY PORTION.
07:09:59PM STEVE.
07:09:59PM >> WE HAVE BEEN FOUND CONSISTENT BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION,
07:10:03PM CITY STAFF AND THE ARC.
07:10:05PM WE HAVE NO WAIVERS.
07:10:06PM WE ARE IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO THE CROSSTOWN EXPRESSWAY
07:10:12PM IMMEDIATELY TO THE NORTH.
07:10:13PM AND WE -- WE DO PLAN TO SAVE AND RENOVATE THE EXISTING
07:10:18PM CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE.
07:10:20PM AND THEN ADD ANOTHER STRUCTURE THAT WILL HAVE TO GO THROUGH
07:10:23PM THE ARC AND HAVE TO BE FOUND IN TERMS OF ITS DESIGN.
07:10:27PM IT WOULD HAVE TO BE FOUND CONSISTENT WITH ALL OF THOSE
07:10:30PM GUIDELINES.
07:10:31PM WE SPENT A LOT OF TIME WORKING WITH STAFF TO DEVELOP A PLAN
07:10:38PM WHICH WE FEEL IS VERY SENSITIVE TO THE AREA AND HAVE TO KEEP
07:10:42PM IN MIND THAT DOBYVILLE WAS BUILT AND DESIGNED AND DEVELOPED
07:10:46PM UNDER VERY DIFFERENT GUIDELINES THAN THE OTHER HYDE PARK
07:10:49PM AREAS SOUTH OF SWANN.
07:10:51PM WE HAVE SHOWN YOU ON THE VIDEO AND ON THE SLIDES THAT --
07:10:56PM THAT THE LOTS ARE IRREGULARLY SHAPED.
07:10:59PM AND YOU HAVE TO ALSO REMEMBER THAT THESE -- THESE AREAS WERE
07:11:02PM DESIGNED FOR -- FOR THE WORKERS THAT -- THAT ACTUALLY WERE
07:11:07PM SERVICING AND -- AND THE AREAS THAT WERE SOUTH OF -- OF
07:11:13PM SWANN.
07:11:13PM AND I UNDERSTAND -- I WAS TRYING TO PICK THAT -- PICK A
07:11:16PM CAREFUL --
07:11:17PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: PICKING GOOD WORDS.
07:11:19PM >> CAREFUL EXPLANATION.
07:11:21PM BUT THESE --
07:11:27PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: DON'T LET ALAN HELP YOU.
07:11:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NO HELPING.
07:11:30PM >> WORKER WHO DIDN'T RELY ON TRANSPORTATION TO GET TO THEIR
07:11:35PM JOBS SOUTH OF SWANN.
07:11:36PM DISTINCT AREA DEVELOPED IN A VERY DIFFERENT MANNER AND WE
07:11:40PM HAVE BEEN SENSITIVE TO THAT.
07:11:42PM WE HAVE SHOWN YOU THAT THERE WERE TWO STRUCTURES HERE
07:11:45PM BEFORE.
07:11:45PM AND THE CURRENT ROAD, WE ARE PROPOSING TO RENOVATE THE ONE
07:11:50PM VERY SENSITIVELY AND ADD ANOTHER STRUCTURE THAT IS ALSO
07:11:53PM SENSITIVE.
07:11:53PM WE -- WE HAVE BEEN FOUND TO IT BE CONSISTENT BY THE PLANNING
07:11:58PM COMMISSION.
07:11:58PM THERE ARE PROBABLY 30 OR 40 DIFFERENT LAND USE CODES THAT WE
07:12:06PM ARE BEING FOUND CONSISTENT WITH.
07:12:07PM SAYS TO PROMOTE THE EFFICIENT AND SUSTAINABLE USE OF LAND,
07:12:11PM WE HAVE BEEN FOUND CONSISTENT WITH THAT.
07:12:13PM AND THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT PRESERVE SHARED 30-FOOT LIVE
07:12:18PM OAK, 24-INCH LIVE OAK.
07:12:20PM ADVERSE IMPACTS ARE NOT ANTICIPATED FOR THE SURROUNDING
07:12:23PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND CULTURAL SOURCES OF DOBYVILLE BY PRESERVING
07:12:27PM THE EXISTING HOME AND CONSTRUCTION OF A NEW HOME.
07:12:29PM THAT IS -- ENCOURAGE FLEXIBLE LAND DEVELOPMENT WHICH REDUCES
07:12:34PM TRANSPORTATION NEEDS.
07:12:35PM THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT IS PRESERVING TREES AND MEETING THE
07:12:40PM REQUIRED GREEN SPACE.
07:12:41PM WE ARE NOT ASKING FOR ANY GREEN SPACE WAIVERS.
07:12:44PM WE, BY CODE, MUST MEET ALL THE DRAINAGE REQUIREMENTS.
07:12:48PM THERE ARE NO WAIVERS THAT YOU CAN OBTAIN FOR THAT.
07:12:50PM PROMOTE AND ENCOURAGE THE DEVELOPMENT WHERE APPROPRIATE AN
07:12:54PM LOCATION AND CHARACTER.
07:12:55PM AND I AM READING FROM THE STAFF REPORT.
07:12:57PM THE AREA SURROUNDING THE SUBJECT AREA IS ZONED RM-12 AND PD
07:13:02PM AND DEVELOPED WITH A MIX OF SMALL LOTS AND SINGLE FAMILY AND
07:13:09PM MULTIFAMILY.
07:13:10PM THE DEVELOPMENT TO HAVE TWO STRUCTURES AND BUILDS A NEW
07:13:14PM SINGLE-FAMILY HOME WHICH IS BEING FOUND CONSISTENT.
07:13:16PM PROMOTE MORE DESIRABLE LIVING CONDITIONS, THE SMALLER HOMES
07:13:20PM ARE MORE AFFORDABLE AND WILL PROVIDE ADDITIONAL HOUSING AS
07:13:24PM REQUESTED AND ONE OF THE OBJECTIVES OF THE CITY.
07:13:27PM PROMOTING ARCHITECTURE FEATURES AND STANDARDS.
07:13:30PM WE STILL HAVE TO GO THROUGH ARC AND STILL HAVE TO MEET ALL
07:13:34PM OF THEIR GUIDELINES AND ALL OF THEIR REQUIREMENTS.
07:13:36PM THOSE ARE NOT WAIVABLE ISSUES.
07:13:37PM I WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
07:13:40PM AND AT THIS POINT, I WILL SURRENDER TO SPEAKERS.
07:13:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
07:13:48PM COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON.
07:13:49PM >>BILL CARLSON: I WANT TO ASK THE APPLICANT FOR QUESTION.
07:13:52PM FOR DISCLOSURE, I SPENT YEARS LIVING TWO BLOCKS AWAY AT EDGE
07:13:58PM OF HYDE PARK AND DOBYVILLE.
07:14:00PM MY KID GREW UP WALKING THROUGH THIS AREA EVERY DAY.
07:14:03PM SO I KNOW IT WELL.
07:14:04PM YOU OBVIOUSLY HAVE DONE A LOT OF RESEARCH ON THIS.
07:14:08PM AND I APPRECIATE THE SENSITIVITY TO ALL THAT.
07:14:10PM DID YOU -- HAVE YOU MET WITH THE NEIGHBOR ASSOCIATIONS?
07:14:16PM AND WHAT FEEDBACK DID YOU GET. IF THERE IS NEGATIVE
07:14:22PM FEEDBACK, YOU WILL HAVE A CHANCE FOR REBUTTAL LATER.
07:14:24PM BUT BEFORE ANYBODY ELSE SPEAKS, CAN YOU TELL US KIND OF WHAT
07:14:27PM YOUR -- WHAT YOUR RESPONSE IS?
07:14:30PM >> WE DID AND THEY SAID THEY DIDN'T LIKE PDs.
07:14:37PM >> NEIGHBORS ARE GREAT.
07:14:38PM I THOUGHT THE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATIONS REALLY RESPECT WHAT
07:14:43PM THEY DO.
07:14:44PM TOOK UP A CONFERENCE ROOM FOR TWO HOURS IN HYDE PARK AND MET
07:14:48PM WITH ALL THE MAJOR NEIGHBORHOOD LEADERS.
07:14:51PM PAT CIMINO, ETC.
07:14:55PM INITIALLY A LIST OF CONCERNS THEY SUBMITTED, YOU KNOW, GREEN
07:14:59PM SPACE.
07:15:01PM LITANY OF ITEMS.
07:15:02PM AND I CAN ACTUALLY BRING THOSE UP HERE.
07:15:05PM SO IN CONSISTENCY WITH CITY CODE WAS A CONCERN.
07:15:10PM WE WERE FOUND CONSISTENT BY STAFF.
07:15:12PM HISTORICAL GUIDELINES.
07:15:14PM CONSISTENT BY ARC.
07:15:16PM LACK OF GREEN PEACE.
07:15:18PM WE ARE PROVIDING MORE GREEN SPACE THAN WHAT WOULD BE
07:15:21PM REQUIRED.
07:15:21PM PARCEL HISTORY AND ZONING.
07:15:22PM THIS WAS VERY IMPORTANT.
07:15:23PM HE WAS ABLE TO SHOW THEM ALL THE DOCUMENTATION OF HOW THE
07:15:27PM ORIGINAL SITE CONFIGURATION WAS.
07:15:28PM IMPACT ON HISTORIC DISTRICT.
07:15:35PM AND STAFF FOUND AND ARC FOUND POSITIVE IMPACT AND FLOODING
07:15:40PM WE WILL ABIDE BY ALL CODES.
07:15:43PM THAT IS A BULLET POINT.
07:15:45PM I ASKED THE NEIGHBORHOOD, WHAT CAN WE CHANGE TO EARN YOUR
07:15:48PM SUPPORT FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A NEW RESIDENCE.
07:15:52PM AND I RESPECT THIS POSITION, BUT FRANKLY THEY SAID NOTHING
07:15:55PM WE COULD CHANGE FOR THEM TO GIVE THEIR SUPPORT FOR US
07:15:58PM BUILDING A NEW RESIDENCE.
07:15:59PM THEY PREFERRED US TO ADD ON TO THE EXISTING RESIDENCE AND
07:16:05PM JUST MAKE A LARGER -- ONE LARGER RESIDENCE, WHICH WE FEEL IS
07:16:09PM NOT IN CHARACTER WITH DOBYVILLE.
07:16:12PM THAT IS IN CHARACTER WITH THE NEIGHBORHOOD SOUTH OF SWANN.
07:16:15PM AND WE ARE LITERALLY BUILDING A HOUSE WHETHER A HOME USED TO
07:16:18PM BE.
07:16:18PM I TRIED TO CONVEY THAT.
07:16:20PM A DIFFERENCE OF OPINION IN WHAT THE HISTORIC DISTRICT
07:16:23PM EXPANSION SEEKS TO ACCOMPLISH.
07:16:24PM I BELIEVE IT SEEKS TO ACCOMPLISH MAINTAINING THE HISTORIC
07:16:28PM FABRIC.
07:16:29PM I HOPE THAT HELPS AND IF YOU HAVE ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS.
07:16:32PM >> WE ALSO FOLLOWED THE ARC STAFF'S GUIDELINES IN THEIR
07:16:36PM DIRECTION WHAT WITH AS APPROPRIATE FOR THAT AREA.
07:16:38PM I DON'T WANT TO SPEAK FOR THEM DIRECTLY, BUT OUR IMPRESSION
07:16:41PM WAS THAT A LARGER.
07:16:44PM A VERY LARGE HOME ON THIS LOT WILL BE COMPLETELY
07:16:47PM INCONSISTENT WITH THE DOBYVILLE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN AND WHAT
07:16:50PM WAS PREVIOUSLY THERE.
07:16:52PM WE ARE TRYING TO BE RESPECTFUL OF WHAT WAS THERE.
07:16:55PM AND BE CONSISTENT WITH WHAT WE NORMALLY WOULD BE APPROVED BY
07:16:58PM THE ARC.
07:16:59PM AND AS I SAID, WE STILL HAVE TO GO THROUGH THAT PROCESS.
07:17:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
07:17:05PM OKAY, WE WILL OPEN IT UP FOR PUBLIC COMMENT.
07:17:09PM IF YOU ARE HERE AND ARE GOING TO SPEAK ON ITEM NUMBER 5,
07:17:13PM PLEASE COME UP.
07:17:13PM AND IF WE COULD LINE UP AGAINST THE WALL SO WE CAN SEE --
07:17:18PM HAS EVERYBODY BEEN SWORN IN THAT IS GOING TO BE SPEAKING
07:17:21PM TONIGHT?
07:17:22PM I SAW TWO MORE PEOPLE COME IN.
07:17:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: FIRST SPEAKER, COME ON UP.
07:17:53PM IF YOU HAVE A SPEAKER WAIVER FORM.
07:17:56PM BRING IT UP TO THE ATTORNEY AND HE WILL CALL THE NAMES OUT.
07:18:00PM AND IF YOU ARE HERE ONCE HE CALLS YOUR NAME, PLEASE RAISE
07:18:03PM YOUR HAND.
07:18:04PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: PAT HENDERSON.
07:18:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PAT HENDERSON.
07:18:11PM I SEE A HAND, YES.
07:18:13PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: SCOTT HENDERSON.
07:18:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THEY ARE HERE.
07:18:17PM THEY RAISED THEIR HANDS.
07:18:19PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: PATRICIA SUMMERVILLE.
07:18:22PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: SHE, IS SHE STILL HERE?
07:18:24PM RIGHT THERE, YES.
07:18:25PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THANK YOU, THREE ADDITIONAL MINUTES FOR A TOTAL
07:18:28PM OF SIX, PLEASE.
07:18:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:18:32PM BLESS YOU.
07:18:35PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
07:18:36PM MY NAME IS JANE GRAHAM, ATTORNEY AND FOUNDER OF SUNSHINE
07:18:39PM CITY LAW.
07:18:40PM I AM REPRESENTING HISTORIC HYDE PARK NEIGHBORHOOD
07:18:43PM ASSOCIATION TONIGHT.
07:18:44PM WE RESPECTFULLY REQUESTING THAT YOU VOTE TO DENY THIS ACTION
07:18:48PM FOR A PD.
07:18:49PM THERE IS A TIME AND PLACE FOR PDs, BUT PLANNED DEVELOPMENT
07:18:55PM IS AN INAPPROPRIATE TOOL IN THIS SPECIFIC CASE.
07:18:58PM THIS IS A BACK-DOOR WAY TO GET A LOT SPLIT THAT DOESN'T,
07:19:02PM DOESN'T MEET LOT SIZE REQUIREMENTS.
07:19:04PM SIGNIFICANTLY DECREASES PERVIOUS SURFACE AND GREEN SPACE ON
07:19:08PM THE SITE FROM 86% TO 45%.
07:19:11PM AND A ROAD TO THE INTENT TO PROTECT THE HISTORIC INTEGRITY
07:19:16PM OF DOBYVILLE.
07:19:17PM A SQUARE PEG IN A ROUND HOLE.
07:19:20PM AND THEY HAVE RESORTED TO A PD BUT IT STILL DOESN'T FIT.
07:19:24PM MY CLIENT IS DEDICATED TO PROMOTING AND CULTIVATING HISTORIC
07:19:35PM AND COMMUNAL CHARACTERISTICS OF THE HYDE PARK AREA.
07:19:39PM WHY WOULD THEY GO TO THE TROUBLE TO HIRE A LAWYER TO SPEAK
07:19:43PM TO YOU TONIGHT OF A PARCEL OF LAND THAT IS JUST OVER 1/10 OF
07:19:46PM AN ACRE?
07:19:47PM THE REASON, BECAUSE IT IS IN DOBYVILLE.
07:19:50PM AND MY CLIENT HAS BEEN A HUGE ADVOCATE FOR EXPANSION OF THE
07:19:56PM DOBYVILLE DISTRICT AND FOR THE RECENT DESIGNATION OF THE
07:19:59PM DOBY HOUSE AS A LANDMARK.
07:20:01PM THIS PROPERTY IS JUST AROUND THE CORNER FROM IT, A PROPERTY
07:20:05PM DATING BACK TO THE 1950s AND RELEVANT AND IMPORTANT TO THE
07:20:09PM FUTURE OF THE HISTORIC DISTRICT.
07:20:11PM THIS IS WHERE THE DOBY HOUSE IT.
07:20:13PM AND THIS IS A THIS PROPERTY HERE.
07:20:15PM AS A QUASI JUDICIAL HEARING.
07:20:17PM APPLICANT HAS THE BURDEN TO SHOW THAT HE HAS MET ALL THE
07:20:21PM REQUIRED ZONING CRITERIA WITH COMPETENT SUBSTANTIAL
07:20:24PM EVIDENCE.
07:20:24PM IN THIS CASE, HE CAN NOT.
07:20:26PM TONIGHT, YOU WILL HEAR TESTIMONY FROM EXPERTS IN
07:20:30PM ARCHITECTURE AND HISTORY, AS WELL AS LAYPERSON TESTIMONY AND
07:20:34PM FIRSTHAND ACCOUNTS OF CHARACTER OF A YEAR.
07:20:38PM THE EVIDENCE SHOWS THAT THIS ACTION FAILS TO MEET THE
07:20:41PM PURPOSE OF A PD, SPECIFICALLY IF DOES NOT PROMOTE THE
07:20:44PM SUSTAINABLE USE OF LAND AND IMPACTS CULTURAL RESOURCES.
07:20:49PM DOES NOT MAXIMIZE PRESERVATION OF GREEN SPACE.
07:20:52PM NOT APPROPRIATE FOR THE LOCATION AND DOES NOT COMPLEMENT THE
07:20:57PM SURROUNDING COMMUNITY.
07:20:57PM NOT AN UNIQUE USE ON ANOTHER ZONING DISTRICT THAT CANNOT BE
07:21:01PM ACCOMMODATED.
07:21:05PM SIMPLE TERMS, TO JAM IN ANOTHER SINGLE-FAMILY HOME ON A LOT
07:21:11PM THAT IS SMALLER THAN THE ZONING DISTRICT ALLOWS.
07:21:13PM THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PROHIBITS PLANNED DEVELOPMENTS FROM
07:21:21PM BEING USED FOR THE SOLE PURPOSE OF WAIVING ESTABLISHED LAND
07:21:25PM DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS.
07:21:26PM HERE, THE PROPERTY IS ZONED RM-12, WHICH HAS MINIMUM LOT
07:21:32PM SIZES, SETBACK REQUIREMENT AND LOT SIZE WIDTHS.
07:21:35PM I THINK IT COMES DOWN TO REALLY LOOKING AT THE NUMBERS.
07:21:38PM BECAUSE IF YOU LOOK AT THE SITE PLAN, FIRST OF ALL, FOR LOT
07:21:42PM AREA, IN RM-12, THE LOT AREA NEED TO BE 5,000.
07:21:46PM NOW CURRENTLY THE TOTAL SITE IS 4967.
07:21:51PM IF YOU LOOK AT THE INDIVIDUAL LOTS, THERE ARE 56% OF IT AND
07:21:55PM 42% OF IT.
07:21:57PM IT IS REALLY SMALLER THAN WHAT IS REQUIRED.
07:22:00PM THIS IS A LOT SPLIT IN SHEEP'S CLOTHING THAT DOESN'T MEET
07:22:04PM CURRENT REQUIREMENTS.
07:22:05PM THE SETBACKS ARE ALSO FAR TOO SMALL AT THREE FEET
07:22:12PM AND WHILE THERE IS -- LOOKING AT THE AREA.
07:22:15PM AND YOU WILL HEAR MORE FROM HISTORIC EXPERTS, THEY WILL LOOK
07:22:19PM AT WHAT IS ACTUALLY REQUIRED.
07:22:22PM SOME THE DWELLING UNIT SIZE IS ALSO SMALLER.
07:22:26PM AND REALLY INTERESTING ISSUE IS PERVIOUS AREA.
07:22:29PM WHICH I THINK IS THE MOST COMPELLING ISSUE HERE, WHERE THE
07:22:32PM PERVIOUS AREA IS A HUGE REDUCTION.
07:22:35PM CURRENTLY IT IS 84% OF THE EXISTING SITE VERSES 45% OF THE
07:22:40PM PROPOSED SITE.
07:22:41PM CLEARLY, THIS IS A VERY SIGNIFICANT REDUCTION.
07:22:44PM AND THIS IS THE EXISTING FOOTPRINT, SIDE BY SIDE WHICH IS
07:22:53PM THE LANDSCAPE PLAN VERSUS THE PROPOSED FOOTPRINT.
07:22:58PM SOMETHING YOU HAVEN'T BEEN PRESENTED SIDE BY SIDE TO SHOW
07:23:01PM THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN OPEN PEACE AND WHAT IS THERE NOW
07:23:05PM VERSUS WHAT IS PROPOSED.
07:23:06PM THIS IS NOT WHAT PDs ARE FOR.
07:23:10PM THEY ARE MEANT TO PROTECT AND ENHANCE GREEN SPACE.
07:23:13PM THEY ARE NOT MEANT TO PAVE OVER EVERY INCH.
07:23:18PM YOU WILL HEAR COMPETENT SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE FROM THE
07:23:22PM COMMUNITY OF THE DOBYVILLE EXPANSION AND PROTECTIONS TO
07:23:25PM PRESERVE IT.
07:23:26PM JUST BECAUSE PROPERTIES HAVE BEEN GRANTED THE OPPORTUNITY TO
07:23:29PM DEVELOP IN AREA IN A HAPHAZARD AND NONCONFORMING MATTER IN
07:23:33PM THE PAST, BEFORE THIS HAS BEEN HISTORICALLY DESIGNATED, THAT
07:23:37PM DOESN'T MEAN THAT NOW THAT THE AREA IS PROTECTED, THAT YOU
07:23:40PM DON'T NEED TO TAKE A CLOSER LOOK TO ENSURE ADEQUATE
07:23:43PM PROTECTIONS FOR TODAY AND THE FUTURE.
07:23:45PM AND TO EDUCATE OUR COMMUNITY ABOUT THE PAST.
07:23:47PM ONE LAST THING I DO WANT TO HIGHLIGHT TO YOU IS THAT, AS YOU
07:23:53PM HAVE SEEN AND YOU WILL HEAR, THE ACTION DOES NOT COMPLY WITH
07:23:57PM CODE REQUIREMENTS AND IN U.S. BE DENIED ON THIS.
07:24:00PM TO EXTENT YOU HEAR CONCERNS ABOUT AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND,
07:24:04PM YOU KNOW, OTHER OPPORTUNITIES FOR HOUSING, THAT IS A
07:24:09PM LEGISLATIVE ISSUE THAT -- THAT NEEDS TO BE LOOKED AT AS FAR
07:24:13PM AS CHANGES TO LOT SPLITS OR ACCESSORY UNITS.
07:24:16PM AND SHOULD BE DEALT WITH LEGISLATIVELY AND HERE YOU ARE IN A
07:24:20PM QUASI-JUDICIAL GRAVITY AND SIMPLY DOES NOT MEET THE CODE.
07:24:24PM WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST DENIAL.
07:24:25PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:24:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:24:28PM >> I HAVE COPIES OF THE PRESENTATION AND ALSO THE HYDE PARK
07:24:33PM NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION.
07:24:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE ATTORNEY WILL TAKE IT AND PUT IT
07:24:38PM INTO THE RECORD.
07:24:38PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:24:39PM YES, SIR.
07:24:47PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:24:48PM >> SHOULD I BEGIN?
07:25:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: JUST A MOMENT.
07:25:10PM HE HAS TO READ THE NAMES.
07:25:11PM GO AHEAD FROM MR. SHELBY.
07:25:13PM >> MY NAME IS ROGER --
07:25:16PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: RENEE MARY.
07:25:19PM O'BRIAN, THREE MINUTES.
07:25:23PM TOTAL OF SIX, PLEASE.
07:25:25PM >> MY NAME IS ROGER GURNCA.
07:25:29PM NORTH ELSINOR, TAMPA HEIGHTS, PRESERVATIONIST AND BUILDING
07:25:36PM CONTRACTOR.
07:25:36PM MY ARCHITECTURAL DESIGNS HAVE BEEN HONORED BY BOTH THE
07:25:40PM FLORIDA TRUST FOR HISTORIC PRESENTATION AND THE TAMPA
07:25:43PM HILLSBOROUGH PLANNING COMMISSION, SPECIFICALLY FOR
07:25:47PM EXCELLENCE IN NEW CONSTRUCTION WITHIN HISTORIC DISTRICTS.
07:25:50PM URBAN INFILL.
07:25:53PM THAT'S WHAT THIS IS ABOUT.
07:25:54PM THE APPLICANT'S PROPOSAL DOES NOT CONFORM TO THE CITY OF
07:25:58PM TAMPA'S ORDINANCE 2002-230 THAT IS THE HYDE PARK DESIGN
07:26:05PM GUIDELINES.
07:26:05PM NOR DOES IS CONFORM TO THE SECRETARY OF INTERIOR STANDARDS
07:26:10PM FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION IN A HISTORIC DISTRICT.
07:26:13PM THE NATIONAL PARK SERVICE STATES THAT IT IS POSSIBLE TO ADD
07:26:19PM NEW CONSTRUCTION WITHIN THE BOUNDARIES OF HISTORIC
07:26:23PM PROPERTIES IF SITE CONDITIONS ALLOW AND IF, ONE, THE DESIGN,
07:26:27PM TWO, DENSITY, AND THREE, PLACEMENT OF THE NEW CONSTRUCTION
07:26:32PM RESPECTS THE OVERALL CHARACTER OF THE SITE.
07:26:36PM THE SECRETARY OF INTERIOR STANDARD NUMBER NINE ALSO GOES AND
07:26:41PM SAYS, NEW CONSTRUCTION NEED TO BE BUILT IN A MANNER THAT
07:26:45PM PROTECTS THE INTEGRITY OF HISTORIC BUILDINGS AND THE
07:26:52PM PROPERTY'S SETTINGS.
07:26:54PM EVALUATING THROUGH THE LENS OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD'S PERIOD OF
07:26:58PM HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE, WHICH IS 1896-19 33.
07:27:07PM THIS PROPOSED PROJECT DOES NOT CONFORM TO THE PRESERVATION
07:27:11PM STANDARDS.
07:27:11PM WHAT WAS BELT AFTER 1933 CANNOT BE CITED AS NEIGHBORHOOD'S
07:27:19PM HISTORIC CHARACTER.
07:27:20PM WE MUST GO BACK TO THE BEGINNING OF 19 -- OF THE 20th
07:27:23PM CENTURY AND STOP IN THE BEGINNING OF THE 1930s.
07:27:26PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD'S CHARACTER WAS THAT OF SMALL, NARROW AND
07:27:30PM USUALLY ONE-STORY BUILDINGS THAT WERE NOTABLY WITHOUT
07:27:35PM AUTOMOBILE INFRASTRUCTURE.
07:27:36PM THAT IS, NO DRIVEWAYS IN THE FRONT.
07:27:39PM NO PARKING IN THE FRONT.
07:27:41PM NO PAVED FRONT YARDS.
07:27:43PM NO GARAGE IN THE FRONT.
07:27:45PM DOBYVILLE WAS THE QUINTESSENTIAL WALK-TO-WORK NEIGHBORHOOD
07:27:51PM BECAUSE THE ECONOMIC CONDITIONS REQUIRED IT.
07:27:53PM DOBYVILLE WAS BUILT BY WEALTHY WHITE HOMEOWNER WHO ELEVEN
07:27:59PM SOUTH OF SWANN AVENUE, AND TO ENABLE THEIR AFRICAN-AMERICAN
07:28:04PM SERVANTS TO WALK TO THE GRAND HOMES WHERE THEY SERVED AS
07:28:08PM MAIDS, COOKS, GARDENERS AND NANNIES.
07:28:11PM DOBYVILLE WAS REALLY A SERVANT'S GHETTO.
07:28:16PM AUTOMOBILES WERE NOT PART OF THE, QUOTE -- THE PART OF THE
07:28:23PM SCENE.
07:28:23PM I -- AM I INTERPRETING THE SECRETARY OF INTERIOR STANDARDS
07:28:29PM IS IMPLYING THAT RESIDENTS IN DOBYVILLE SHOULD NOT BE ALLOW
07:28:32PM TO HAVE CARS?
07:28:33PM OF COURSE NOT.
07:28:34PM BUT CARS NEED TO BE RESTRICTED TO THE REAR OF THE
07:28:37PM RESIDENCES.
07:28:38PM THAT IS, WITH ACCESS OFF OF THE ALLEYS.
07:28:41PM SO AS TO NOT BE VISIBLE FROM THE FRONT OF THE HOMES
07:28:48PM PROPERTIES NOT ON ALLEYS SHOULD ACCESS FROM SIDE STREETS.
07:28:54PM THE MASS AND SCALE, AS WELL AS THE FRONT YARD TREATMENT,
07:28:59PM SIDE YARD SETBACKS, AND PARKING SOLUTIONS MUST BE
07:29:03PM APPROPRIATE FOR ANY NEW PROJECT IN THE DISTRICT.
07:29:06PM THE APPLICANT'S PROPOSED PROJECT DOES NOT FLESH THIS OUT.
07:29:11PM LET'S LOOK QUICKLY AT SOME PHOTOS HERE.
07:29:14PM THIS IS APPROPRIATE.
07:29:20PM NO PARKING IN THE FRONT.
07:29:24PM NO PAVED PARKING SAME THING HERE.
07:29:33PM HERE.
07:29:34PM AND HERE AGAIN.
07:29:35PM THESE ARE REPRESENTATIVE OF THE WAY THE SITES WERE USED
07:29:42PM DURING THE PERIOD OF HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE.
07:29:44PM NOW IF WE LOOK AT THE NEIGHBORING HOUSE, THIS MASS -- HERE
07:29:53PM IS THE ORIGINAL HOUSE.
07:29:53PM THE FRONT PORCH WAS CLOSED IN WHICH IS INAPPROPRIATE AND THE
07:29:58PM LARGE MASS ON THE BACK IS SLAPPED UP AGAINST THE BUILDING
07:30:03PM AND INAPPROPRIATE.
07:30:04PM WHEN YOU LOOK AT IT FROM THE FRONT, IT IS A PARKING LOT.
07:30:08PM DOBYVILLE IS UNIQUE TO THE CITY AS A WHOLE.
07:30:13PM AND IN PARTICULAR, TO OUR SOCIAL HISTORY, AS IT PERSONIFIES
07:30:19PM THE CONDITIONS THAT PEOPLE OF COLOR ENDURED DURING THE JIM
07:30:24PM CROW ERA.
07:30:24PM HISTORIC PRESERVATION IS MORE THAN THE PRESERVATION OF
07:30:28PM ARCHITECTURAL WORKMANSHIP.
07:30:30PM THE PRESERVATION OF THOSE BUILDINGS, STREETS AND OPEN SPACES
07:30:34PM THAT STAND AS REMINDERS TO OUR CULTURAL PAST.
07:30:39PM BOTH THE GOOD AND THE REGRETTABLE.
07:30:42PM WE HAVE A MORAL OBLIGATION HERE TO PUT A STOP TO THE ERASING
07:30:50PM OF DOBYVILLE'S SIGNIFICANCE.
07:30:53PM GRANTING THE APPLICANT'S REZONING WOULD ONLY FURTHER
07:30:58PM DIMINISH OUR COLLECTIVE HISTORY.
07:31:00PM A YEAR AGO, COUNCIL VOTED IN FAVOR OF INCLUSION OF THIS
07:31:04PM NEIGHBORHOOD INTO THE HYDE PARK HISTORIC DISTRICT.
07:31:07PM NOW WE LOOK TO YOU TO SUPPORT THE CONTENT AND THE MEANING
07:31:11PM BEHIND YOUR PAST VOTE.
07:31:13PM PLEASE DENY THIS ACTION.
07:31:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU, SIR.
07:31:17PM PATRICK CIMINO.
07:31:23PM DO YOU HAVE A SPEAKER WAIVER FORM?
07:31:26PM >> NO.
07:31:26PM >> I AM USED TO TALKING FOR THREE MINUTES AND I TRY TO
07:31:30PM RESPECT YOU ALL FOR TIME.
07:31:33PM SORRY ABOUT THAT.
07:31:44PM WELL, I WILL GET YOU -- HERE IT IS.
07:31:50PM IT IS THE BOTTOM.
07:31:52PM I DON'T KNOW IF THIS IS VISIBLE.
07:32:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IF YOU CAN ZOOM OUT A LITTLE BIT SO WE
07:32:07PM BELIEVE GET EVERYTHING IN THE FRAME.
07:32:08PM >> ZOOM?
07:32:13PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE WHEEL AT THE TOP.
07:32:14PM AT THE TOP.
07:32:15PM >> OKAY.
07:32:16PM THANK YOU.
07:32:17PM PERFECT.
07:32:17PM I THINK THAT GETS THIS SO I CAN SEE IT BETTER.
07:32:20PM WELL, I AM PAT CIMINO, CHAIR OF THE LAND USE COMMITTEE FOR
07:32:28PM HISTORIC HYDE PARK NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION.
07:32:30PM 064 SOUTH OREGON AVENUE.
07:32:32PM AND THIS TO TELL YOU OUR BOARD IS OPPOSED TO THIS ZONING.
07:32:38PM THIS IS REMNANT OF PAST RECONFIGURING AND THEY WANT TO PUT
07:32:42PM TWO INDEPENDENT UNIT ON IT.
07:32:43PM IT DOES NOT MEET ANY CURRENT LAND USE.
07:32:46PM THE RM-12 WON'T ALLOW FOR TWO UNITS.
07:32:51PM THE LOT SPLIT CODE WON'T ALLOW FOR IT.
07:32:54PM EVEN IT WOULDN'T QUALIFY.
07:32:56PM WE FEEL THIS IS RESORTING TO AN INAPPROPRIATE USE OF PD TO
07:33:01PM SQUEEZE IN ANOTHER UNIT AND EVADE THE -- THE CODES OF TODAY.
07:33:05PM SO -- SO FOUR OF YOU WERE HERE TWO YEARS AGO WHEN WE
07:33:10PM EXPANDED THE HISTORIC DISTRICT.
07:33:13PM THIS IS JUST A MAP.
07:33:14PM I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR THAT.
07:33:15PM BECAUSE WE TOOK THAT VERY SERIOUSLY.
07:33:17PM IT TOOK US REALLY ALMOST TEN YEARS -- BILL STILL MAY HAVE
07:33:21PM BEEN LIVING IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD WHEN THAT HAPPENED, I DON'T
07:33:23PM KNOW.
07:33:23PM BUT WE CLEARLY ARTICULATED OBJECTIVES FOR DOING THAT.
07:33:30PM ONE IS TO PROTECT THE REMAINING STRUCTURE.
07:33:35PM ONE TO ERADICATE THE LAND USE PRACTICES.
07:33:37PM AND UNFORTUNATELY THIS -- PARTICULARLY THE SECOND ONE, THIS
07:33:41PM PROPOSAL BETRAYS THAT.
07:33:43PM THAT WAS THE BIG INTENT OF OUR EXPANSION.
07:33:46PM THERE IS ALSO A DISCONNECT FROM THE ARC AND STAFF
07:33:51PM RECOMMENDATIONS JUST AS YOU ALL HAVE DEALT WITH SORT OF
07:33:54PM DIFFERENCES WITH THE STAFF OPINIONS AND THE GARDEN CLUB AND
07:33:58PM STORMWATER WORKSHOP, WE FEEL VERY DIFFERENT THAN THE ARC
07:34:04PM STAFF.
07:34:04PM WE INVESTED A LOT OF MONEY, ENERGY, TIME, ETC. IN THIS
07:34:08PM EXPANSION.
07:34:09PM SO WE TAKE IT VERY SERIOUSLY.
07:34:11PM AND WE DON'T FEEL LIKE OUR GOALS ARE BEING RESPECTED IN
07:34:15PM THIS.
07:34:17PM WE FEEL THERE IS A DISCONNECT FROM PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT.
07:34:20PM AND THAT IS NOT JUST US BUT OUR PEOPLE.
07:34:23PM WE NEED MORE DENSITY.
07:34:25PM TAMPA IS FIXATED ON THIS.
07:34:27PM AND THIS PROBABLY WOULD DECREASE THE ANNUAL HOUSING NEED BY
07:34:31PM ONE.
07:34:32PM 36,500 TO 36,499.
07:34:36PM AND HYDE PARK IS, AS MISS GRAHAM MENTIONED, REALLY THE ISSUE
07:34:42PM OF AFFORDABILITY IS BEYOND THE SCOPE OF THIS DISCUSSION.
07:34:46PM SO WE -- TO PRESERVE THE -- HAS FOUND THAT HISTORIC
07:34:53PM DISTRICTS ARE MORE DENSE AND ADVERSE IN ACTIVITIES ALREADY.
07:34:56PM WE DON'T NEED MORE OF THAT.
07:34:57PM FINALLY, PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT SHOULD FOCUS ON THINGS
07:35:01PM LIKE WHAT YOU ALL ARE DOING, THANK GOODNESS, STORMWATER
07:35:04PM MAINTENANCE.
07:35:05PM BECAUSE THAT IS MORE IMPORTANT.
07:35:06PM AND THEN WORK ON PRACTICAL SOLUTIONS.
07:35:11PM SO AT ANY RATE, WE FEEL THIS PROPOSAL IS INCONSISTENT WITH
07:35:16PM THE GOALS OF OUR HISTORIC EXPANSION THAT YOU VOTED FOR, FOUR
07:35:19PM OF YOU ANYWAY WHO ARE HERE OF WHICH I HOPE YOU WOULD OPPOSE
07:35:25PM THIS REZONING.
07:35:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU, SIR.
07:35:27PM ALL RIGHT, NEXT SPEAKER.
07:35:30PM COME ON UP.
07:35:31PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:35:32PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: TUCKER TURNER.
07:35:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE TO READ THE NAMES.
07:35:47PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: MR. TUCKER TURNER HERE?
07:35:50PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS TUCKER TURNER HERE.
07:35:52PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: PLEASE RAISE YOUR HAND IF THAT IS THE CASE.
07:35:54PM EXCUSE ME, SIR.
07:35:58PM CAN YOU TELL ME IF MR. TURNER IN THE ROOM?
07:36:02PM MR. TURNER PRESENT?
07:36:04PM >> I DON'T KNOW MR. TURNER.
07:36:05PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: HIS NAME IS ON THIS LIST.
07:36:08PM >> HE STEPPED OUT.
07:36:11PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: HE STEPPED OUT, OKAY, THANK YOU.
07:36:13PM DEREK FRIGA.
07:36:16PM ARE YOU PRESENT?
07:36:19PM I DON'T SEE MR. FRIGA.
07:36:21PM DO YOU KNOW IF MR. FRIGA IS PRESENT IN THE ROOM?
07:36:25PM OKAY, THREE MINUTES.
07:36:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:36:29PM >> BARRY NICOLA.
07:36:31PM I'M THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY ADJOINING THE PROPOSED
07:36:35PM REZONING.
07:36:36PM 1408 WEST AZEELE.
07:36:40PM THE APPLICANT HAD APPROACHED ME MANY MONTHS AGO.
07:36:44PM AND ENGAGED IN A DISCUSSION EXPLAIN WHAT HIS PLANS WERE.
07:36:48PM HE HAS BEEN VERY GOOD ABOUT CONTINUING TO KEEP ME APPRISED
07:36:54PM OF WHAT IS GOING ON AND VERY RESPECTFUL, I BELIEVE.
07:36:58PM ESSENTIALLY THE CONTENTION POINT WHETHER THIS PROPERTY IS IN
07:37:02PM THE HISTORICAL CONTEXT OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:37:04PM AS A NEIGHBORHOOD RESIDENT WHO LIVED HERE TEN YEARS AND WALK
07:37:08PM IT REGULARLY, I DO FIND IT VERY CONSISTENT.
07:37:10PM I THINK HE HAS MADE A VERY GOOD CASE.
07:37:13PM HYDE PARK IS SUBSTANTIALLY DIFFERENT THAN DOBYVILLE, EVEN
07:37:17PM JUST A FEW BLOCKS AWAY.
07:37:19PM AND I DO FIND THAT HIS PROPOSED RESIDENCE DOES SEEM TO BE IN
07:37:25PM KEEPING WITH THE STREET.
07:37:26PM I THINK WHEN IT IS COMPLETED -- IF IT IS COMPLETED, YOU
07:37:29PM WOULDN'T EVEN NOTICE IT AS ANY DIFFERENT THAN THE HOUSES ON
07:37:32PM THE STREET.
07:37:32PM SO I DO SUPPORT HIS -- HIS PROPOSAL.
07:37:35PM AND I DON'T SEE ANY ISSUES.
07:37:38PM AS FAR AS STORMWATER IS CONCERNED, WE ALSO CONSTRUCTED THE
07:37:42PM HOME NEXT DOOR.
07:37:43PM AND WE DID A VERY EXTENSIVE STUDY OF THE LOTS IN QUESTION.
07:37:48PM AND WE FOUND THAT WE ARE AT ONE OF THE HIGHEST POINTS IN
07:37:52PM HYDE PARK OR NORTH HYDE PARK.
07:37:54PM AND THE STORMWATER ESSENTIALLY DRAINS AWAY THESE PROPERTIES.
07:37:58PM AND WE HAVE NEVER HAD AN ISSUE, EVEN WITH THE RECENT TWO
07:38:02PM HURRICANES WE HAD.
07:38:02PM SO STORMWATER IS NOT A CONCERN TO ME AND WHERE THE DENSITY
07:38:07PM IS.
07:38:07PM AND THAT IS ESSENTIALLY ALL I HAVE TO SAY.
07:38:10PM HOPE DO YOU SUPPORT THIS REZONING.
07:38:12PM I FIND IT IN KEEPING WITH THE CHARACTER OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:38:16PM AND THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:38:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
07:38:20PM ALL RIGHT, NEXT SPEAKER.
07:38:22PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:38:24PM >> MY NAME IS CHRIS.
07:38:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOUR LAST NAME.
07:38:27PM >> VALIENTE, WITH A V.
07:38:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD.
07:38:32PM >> I'M HERE TO SUPPORT THIS REZONING.
07:38:34PM I TRULY BELIEVE IT IS A GREAT FIT FOR THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:38:36PM THE PROJECT ISN'T JUST ABOUT NEW CONSTRUCTION, IT IS ABOUT
07:38:40PM PRESERVING AND ENHANCING THE CHARACTER OF THE AREA AS WE CAN
07:38:43PM ALL AGREE WITH EXISTING HOME AS WE SAW AND.
07:38:52PM AND GIVEN HIS BEAUTIFUL PRESENTATION WITH THE VIDEO, I THINK
07:38:55PM IT IS VERY CLEAR THAT HE IS CAREFULLY THOUGHTFUL.
07:39:00PM FROM WHAT WE SAW OF THE NEW HOME, BLEND RIGHT IN.
07:39:07PM KIND OF BRINGS BACK THE CHARM FROM THE 1910.
07:39:11PM I COULDN'T TELL THE DIFFERENCE FROM THE HOMES THAT ARE
07:39:13PM ACTUALLY THERE AND WHAT HE PRESENTED.
07:39:16PM BLEND RIGHT IN.
07:39:18PM AS YOU KNOW, TAMPA IS GROWING AS WELL AS COSTS.
07:39:23PM THIS ALSO GIVES US OPPORTUNITY FOR MORE PEOPLE A CHANCE TO
07:39:26PM LIVE AND ENJOY THIS AMAZING PART OF TAMPA WITH ALL GREAT
07:39:33PM THINGS THAT HYDE PARK AND BAYSHORE HAVE TO OFFER, THE
07:39:36PM DEVELOPER HAS WORKED CLOSELY WITH THE CITY AS WE SAW.
07:39:39PM TO MAKE SURE EVERYTHING IS DONE RIGHT -- THE RIGHT WAY.
07:39:43PM AND I THINK THAT SPEAKS VOLUMES AGAIN HIS -- HIS
07:39:47PM PRESENTATION.
07:39:48PM SO I HOPE YOU WILL SUPPORT THIS REQUEST.
07:39:50PM IT IS A POSITIVE STEP TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD, FOR TAMPA IT IS A
07:39:54PM GREAT WAY TO BRING THE PAST INTO THE FUTURE.
07:39:57PM BECAUSE I THINK -- YOU KNOW, THAT IS WHAT IT IS ABOUT.
07:40:01PM SO THANK YOU.
07:40:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
07:40:03PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:40:04PM NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
07:40:06PM YES, MA'AM, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:40:08PM SHELBY ANDREA WATERS.
07:40:23PM ONE EXTRA MINUTE.
07:40:24PM >> ARISA CANELLA AND 502 SOUTH FREMONT AVENUE.
07:40:30PM OTHER SPEAKERS TONIGHT HAVE ALREADY DISCUSSED OR WILL BE
07:40:35PM DISCUSSING PROBLEMS WITH FLOODING, DENSITY, ETC.
07:40:37PM I WON'T USE MY TIME.
07:40:40PM APPEARS MR. SHEIKH TRIED TO GET SUPPORT BY POST ON SOCIAL
07:40:44PM MEDIA AND SENDING E-MAILS WITH A BLATANT DISREGARD IF THEY
07:40:48PM LIVE IN OR NEAR THE COMMUNITY DIRECTLY AFFECTED BY THE
07:40:50PM PROPOSED PROBABLY AT 402 SOUTH OREGON AVENUE.
07:40:57PM A PICTURE OF THE E-MAIL FOR REFERENCE.
07:40:59PM AS HIS E-MAIL CLEARLY STATES, QUOTE, PLEASE AVOID MENTIONING
07:41:03PM WHERE YOU LIVE IF IT IS NOT NEAR SOUTH TAMPA OR WITHIN A
07:41:06PM TEN-MINUTE DRIVE FROM DOWNTOWN TAMPA.
07:41:07PM IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT THE LARGE SOUTH TAMPA COMMUNITY
07:41:10PM APPROXIMATELY 35,000 PEOPLE AND EVEN THOSE INDIVIDUALS WHO
07:41:14PM LIVE WITHIN TEN MINUTES OF DOWNTOWN WE INCLUDE PEOPLE LIVING
07:41:18PM MILES AWAY FROM THE PARCEL ARE NOT THE PEOPLE WHO WILL
07:41:20PM DIRECTLY IMPACTED BY THE REZONING, THE PEOPLE BEHIND USED TO
07:41:23PM AND OTHERS FROM THE HYDE PARK COMMUNITY, THE PEOPLE IN THIS
07:41:29PM COMMUNITY FORCING YOU TO VOTE IN SOME INSTANCES.
07:41:32PM IN THE INTEREST OF TIME, I AM GOING TO DISCUSS ONLY A FEW OF
07:41:36PM THE POINTS MENTIONED.
07:41:37PM HE STATED BY INTRODUCING DIVERSE HOUSING OPTIONS IN THIS ALLOWS
07:41:42PM PEOPLE TO ENJOY ALL THAT TAMPA HAS TO OFFER,
07:41:45PM THE AMENITIES OF HYDE PARK VILLAGE AND BAYSHORE
07:41:50PM BOULEVARD.
07:41:50PM THE MEMBERS SUPPORTED PROBABLY SAYING IT WOULD BRING MORE
07:41:54PM HOUSING TO THE AREA EVEN GOING AS FAR TO BRING AFFORD
07:41:59PM HOUSING, WILL SHEIKH THAT HE CARES OF OUR COMMUNITY BUT THAT
07:42:05PM IS NOT TRUE.
07:42:06PM A LOOK AT HIS WORK ON OTHER HOMES IN SOUTH OREGON.
07:42:09PM IN 2020, HIS FAMILY OR SOMEONE ASSOCIATED WITH HIM BOUGHT A
07:42:13PM SHOTGUN HOME SIMILAR TO THE PARCEL THAT IS OF THIS HEARING.
07:42:17PM AND HE WAS THE APPLICANT IN THE HOME AND INVOLVED IN THAT
07:42:20PM REDEVELOPMENT.
07:42:21PM 426 SOUTH OREGON THE SAME STREET AS OUR PARCEL.
07:42:25PM A QUICK SEARCH SHOWS THE OPENER OF THE PARCEL.
07:42:27PM WHAT AND TO BE HIS GOAL FOR SHOTGUN TO SELL IT UPWARDS FOR
07:42:33PM $2 MILLION.
07:42:34PM SCREEN SHOT FROM THE LINKEDIN AND EXPECTED A VALUE ON
07:42:40PM COMPLETION OF $2 MILLION.
07:42:41PM REZONE 402 APPEARS TO BE NOTHING MORE AN ATTEMPT TO MAXIMIZE
07:42:46PM HIS PROFITS ON THAT PROPERTY PUT TWO HOMES ON ONE PIECE OF
07:42:49PM LINE IN VIOLATION OF THE GOALS OF TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
07:42:52PM AND HISTORIC DESIGNATION OF THE STRUCTURE.
07:42:54PM HE ALSO STATED IN HIS E-MAIL, QUOTE, PROJECT NOT ONLY
07:42:58PM RESPECTS OR REVITALIZES OUR ARCHITECTURE BY EXPANDING THE
07:43:03PM EXISTING STRUCTURE TO MEET TODAY'S NEEDS.
07:43:06PM BEFORE AND AFTER PICTURES OF OTHER PROPERTY ON SOUTH OREGON.
07:43:09PM THERE WAS A SHOTGUN HOME, IT WAS TORN DOWN AND AN OVERSIZED
07:43:15PM MODERN HOME.
07:43:16PM MR. SHEIKH AND MR. MICHELINI MAY COME UP DURING THE REBUTTAL
07:43:22PM AND WHAT HE HAD DONE ON OTHER WAS NOT SATURDAY.
07:43:26PM AND TO TAKE ACTIONS THAT ARE NOT CONSISTENT WITH THE HISTORIC
07:43:31PM PRESERVATION OF OUR NEIGHBORHOOD AND COMPREHENSIVE PLANS AND
07:43:33PM SUBJECT PARCEL OWED.
07:43:34PM TO SQUEEZE ANOTHER STRUCTURE ON A SMALL HISTORICAL
07:43:39PM PIECE OF LAND IN OUR COMMUNITY TO MAXIMIZE PROFIT.
07:43:42PM HAVING ANOTHER STRUCTURE IS A DANGEROUS PRECEDENT AND
07:43:47PM SLIPPERY SLOPE TO HAVING OTHER DEVELOPERS COME IN OUR
07:43:50PM NEIGHBORHOOD WITH THEIR ATTEMPT TO HELP OUR COMMUNITY.
07:43:56PM HE CAN EASILY DO SO IN A NONHISTORICAL AREA OF TOWN AND A
07:44:03PM LAND THAT DOES NOT HAVE A HOME.
07:44:05PM I AM NOT SPEAKING FOR MYSELF, WE, PEOPLE STANDING AND
07:44:09PM SITTING BEHIND ME WHO LIVE IN THE AREA THAT COME OUT TO
07:44:13PM VEHEMENTLY EXPRESS OPPOSITION AND COUNTLESS WHO COULDN'T BE
07:44:17PM HERE TONIGHT.
07:44:18PM WE IMPLORE YOU TO VOTE WITH THE LAW, THE FACTS AND CONSIDER
07:44:21PM THE NEGATIVE IMPACT THIS PROJECT WILL HAVE ON OUR COMMUNITY.
07:44:24PM WE IMPLORE TO YOU VOTE TO OPPOSE THIS REZONING.
07:44:26PM THANK YOU.
07:44:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:44:28PM YES, MA'AM.
07:44:29PM NEXT SPEAKER.
07:44:30PM >> ARE YOU READY?
07:45:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE SPEAKER WAIVER.
07:45:50PM >> I AM SORRY DID YOU SAY YOU WERE WAITING.
07:45:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HE NEEDS TO READ THE SPEAKER WAIVER
07:45:56PM FORM.
07:45:56PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: TWO ADDITIONAL MINUTES, PLEASE.
07:46:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:46:08PM >> PAM CANELLA, 604 SOUTH ORLEANS.
07:46:12PM 402 SOUTH OREGON IS LOCATED IN DOBYVILLE IN OUR HISTORIC
07:46:17PM HYDE PARK DISTRICT.
07:46:19PM THIS APPLICANT WOULD LIKE TO YOU BELIEVE THAT THIS ACTION TO
07:46:21PM REZONE TO PD TO ALLOW ANOTHER HOME ON THIS LOT IS JUSTIFIED.
07:46:27PM AND CONSISTENT WITH CHAPTER 27 -- SECTION 27-113-A 2J.
07:46:35PM BUT NOT CONSISTENT.
07:46:36PM HIS PROPOSAL HAS NO SIGNIFICANT HISTORICAL VALUE.
07:46:40PM IT IS THE EXISTING HOME -- THE EXISTING HOME ON 402 SOUTH
07:46:45PM OREGON THAT HAS CONTRIBUTING STATUS.
07:46:47PM AND PROTECTED UNDER THE NATIONAL AND LOCAL HISTORIC
07:46:52PM PRESERVATION REGISTER.
07:46:53PM THE HOME IS HISTORICALLY SIGNIFICANT.
07:46:57PM THE HOME CONTRIBUTES TO THE OVERALL CHARACTER OF THE
07:47:01PM HISTORIC HOMES IN DOBYVILLE.
07:47:03PM THIS PROPOSAL DOES NOT PRESERVE THE HISTORICAL INTEGRITY OF
07:47:07PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:47:08PM BUT RESULTS IN A LOSS OF THE AREA'S UNIQUE, ARCHITECTURAL
07:47:13PM CHARACTER.
07:47:14PM THAT IS TIED TO THE OLD HOME.
07:47:16PM IMPACTING THE NEIGHBORHOOD'S OVERALL APPEAL.
07:47:19PM THIS PROPOSAL HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH HISTORIC PRESERVATION,
07:47:24PM BUT ONLY HIS WANT TO MAXIMIZE HIS PROFITS.
07:47:28PM BUT HIS WANTS DO NOT JUSTIFY THIS REZONING TO PD.
07:47:33PM THIS APPLICANT IS PROPOSING TO DO EXACTLY WHAT ALL THE OTHER
07:47:37PM DEVELOPERS HAVE DONE BEFORE THE HISTORIC BOUNDARY EXPANSION
07:47:42PM AMENDMENT.
07:47:42PM FOR DECADES, DOBYVILLE WENT THROUGH ZONING CHANGES, SPLIT
07:47:48PM LOTS, VARIANCES, HARDSHIP AND DEMOLISH OF OUR
07:47:52PM HISTORIC HOMES FROM NEGLECT.
07:47:53PM THE END RESULT IS A NEIGHBORHOOD OF MISMATCHED DWELLINGS,
07:48:00PM LOTS WITH THREE OR FOUR HOMES ON NONCONFORMING LOTS.
07:48:02PM BUT THEY DO NOT SET A PRECEDENCE.
07:48:05PM UNDER THE PRESENT HISTORIC PRESERVATION LAWS, THE GOALS ARE
07:48:09PM TO PROTECT THE INTEGRITY AND CHARACTER OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:48:13PM REHABILITATE AND PRESERVE THE REMAINING HISTORIC DOBYVILLE
07:48:21PM AND PROTECT THE QUALITY OF LIFE FOR THE RESIDENTS.
07:48:23PM INTEGRITY.
07:48:24PM NEIGHBORHOOD INTEGRITY.
07:48:26PM IT MEANS EVERYTHING THAT AFFECTS THE QUALITY OF LIFE OF THE
07:48:31PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND ITS RESIDENTS, NOT JUST THE OUTER CHARACTER
07:48:35PM OF THE DWELLING, BUT ALL THE ELEMENT THAT MAKE THE
07:48:37PM NEIGHBORHOOD WORK OR NOT.
07:48:39PM NEIGHBORHOODS ARE STRUGGLING FROM OVERDEVELOPMENT.
07:48:44PM THE RESIDENTS ARE IMPACTED DAILY.
07:48:46PM THE TAMPA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN UNDER URBAN VILLAGES CLEARLY
07:48:51PM STATES HYDE PARK SHOULD ONLY HAVE MODEST DENSITY.
07:48:54PM AND THE PLAN DOESN'T CALL FOR A LOT OF GROWTH AND CHANGE.
07:48:59PM HYDE PARK HISTORIC DISTRICT IS A HISTORIC RESIDENTIAL
07:49:04PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:49:05PM AND THE LAWS PROVIDE FOR PROTECTION OF THIS NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:49:10PM FLORIDA STATUTE OUGHT 163-77 AND THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN GOAL
07:49:18PM ONE STATES, PROVIDES ADEQUATE INFRASTRUCTURE TO SUPPORT NEW
07:49:21PM GROWTH, BUT MAINTAIN EXISTING DEVELOPMENT.
07:49:24PM BUT OUR INFRASTRUCTURE IS FAILING AND CANNOT SUPPORT
07:49:33PM EXISTING NEIGHBORHOODS.
07:49:34PM WATER AND SEWER PIPES ARE COLLAPSING.
07:49:37PM ROADS AND SIDEWALKS ARE CRUMBLING.
07:49:38PM POTHOLES AND CAVE INS.
07:49:41PM STORMWATER DRAINAGE SYSTEM HAS FAILED US.
07:49:44PM STORMWATER RUNOFF FROM 402 SOUTH OREGON AND SURROUNDING
07:49:49PM AREAS FLOW SOUTH TO DeLEON.
07:49:53PM THAT IS WHY IT DOESN'T FLOOD UP THERE.
07:49:55PM BECAUSE IT COMES TO US.
07:49:56PM AND FLOODS DeLEON AND THE HOME.
07:50:03PM ADDS MORE CONCRETE, LESS GREEN SPACE AND MORE FLOODING AND
07:50:08PM INCONSISTENT WITH POLICY 12.2 AND WE KNOW THAT HYDE PARK
07:50:13PM FLOODS.
07:50:14PM OUR AREA IS SO DENSE THAT EVACUATION WILL BE DEFENSE.
07:50:18PM NOT ENOUGH SHELTERS TO SUPPORT THEM ALL IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:50:21PM I HAPPEN TO KNOW THAT, BECAUSE I WENT TO ONE AND THEY TURNED
07:50:24PM ME AROUND.
07:50:26PM THERE IS NO STREET PARKING AVAILABLE ON SOUTH OREGON FOR
07:50:29PM RESIDENTS.
07:50:30PM FOUR PARKING SPACES ARE REARED ON THIS SMALL NONCONFORMING
07:50:34PM ILLEGAL LOT FOR TWO HOMES, WE ONLY ONE SUPPOSED TO BE HERE.
07:50:40PM APPLICANT HAS INTENDED TO SQUEEZE THEM IN ON-SITE PLAN, BUT
07:50:43PM NO PARKING FOR GUESTS.
07:50:45PM STAFF TOLD ME THAT PARKING ISSUES ARE A CODE ENFORCEMENT
07:50:49PM PROBLEM, NOT TRUE.
07:50:50PM THIS BECOMES A NEIGHBORHOOD PROBLEM.
07:50:52PM WHERE RESIDENT, VICTIMS.
07:50:55PM TRAFFIC IN SWANN.
07:50:57PM TRAFFIC IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD MAKE IT UNSAFE FOR EVERYONE.
07:51:00PM IT IS DIFFICULT TO LEAVE OR ENTER THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:51:02PM THESE IMPACTS AFFECT NEIGHBORHOOD INTEGRITY.
07:51:05PM AND INCONSISTENT WITH -- WITH LAND USE POLICY 19.1 --
07:51:12PM ANYWAY, YOU CAN LOOK THEM UP.
07:51:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:51:16PM YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU.
07:51:19PM >> GOOD EVENING.
07:51:22PM THIS WILL BE BRIEF.
07:51:24PM NO SPEECH.
07:51:25PM BROOKE GAST.
07:51:28PM GRAY STREET.
07:51:29PM PROPERTY 1,000 WEST HORATIO.
07:51:34PM I'M HERE TO SUPPORT WHAT THE DEVELOPER IS DOING.
07:51:37PM WE ACTUALLY TRIED TO -- MY HUSBAND AND I TRIED TO PURCHASE
07:51:41PM 423 SOUTH ORLEANS A COUPLE OF YEARS AGO.
07:51:44PM IF YOU DIDN'T KNOW IT WAS THE TINIEST HOUSE IN TAMPA IF YOU
07:51:48PM HAVEN'T BEEN IN DOBYVILLE, THAT AREA IS SO UNIQUE.
07:51:51PM HAS SO MUCH CHARM.
07:51:52PM I WISH THERE WAS A DEVELOPER COMING TO ARMORY GARDENS AND
07:51:56PM DOING WHAT THIS DEVELOPER IS DOING, BECAUSE EVERY TIME I
07:51:59PM TURN A CORNER A BEAUTIFUL MID CENTURY HOUSE BEING KNOCKED
07:52:06PM DOWN FOR A GIANT MONSTROSITY.
07:52:08PM I HAVE A LOT OF RESPECT FOR WHAT HE IS DOING.
07:52:11PM IT HE TAIL AND CHARACTER OF THE DESIGN FITS RIGHT INTO THE
07:52:14PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
07:52:15PM OF COURSE UNDERSTANDING NOT WANTING THAT DEVELOPMENT OF
07:52:19PM DEVELOPMENT AND SOMETHING NEW COMING TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD,
07:52:21PM BUT PERSONALLY, I WISH THE SAME THING WAS HAPPENING NEAR ME.
07:52:24PM I JUST WANTED TO SHOW MY SUPPORT.
07:52:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:52:27PM NEXT SPEAKER.
07:52:29PM HELLO, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:52:35PM >> MIRIAM COLLINS.
07:52:37PM GOOD EVENING.
07:52:38PM I HAVE A SPEECH PREPARED, BUT I WILL KEEP IT BRIEF.
07:52:41PM THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO SPEAK TODAY.
07:52:43PM HE WANT TO ADVOCATE ON BEHALF OF THIS DEVELOPMENT AT 402
07:52:47PM SOUTH OREGON.
07:52:48PM I DO BELIEVE DESPITE THE INITIAL RESERVATIONS HAS BEEN
07:52:51PM ME TECH US WILLY PLANNED TO HONOR OUR CITY'S HISTORY AND
07:52:55PM FOSTERING GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT PROCESS.
07:52:57PM CORNERSTONES OF THE PROJECT ARE KEEPING THE TWO MAJESTIC OAK
07:53:01PM TREES ON THE LOT.
07:53:03PM NOT ONLY THE THAT ARE THE HOME THAT WAS THERE WAS PREVIOUS
07:53:06PM LEAVE BUILT IN 1913.
07:53:08PM AND THERE WAS A HOME ON THE PROPERTY PREVIOUSLY.
07:53:10PM THIS PROJECT IS ALSO BEEN ENDORSED BY THE MAJORITY OF THE
07:53:14PM NEIGHBORING PROPERTY OWNER WHO STAND TO BE THE MOST DIRECTLY
07:53:17PM AFFECTED.
07:53:18PM THEY HAVE RECOGNIZED THE THOUGHT AND THE CARE THAT HAS GONE
07:53:22PM INTO THE PLANNING OF THIS PROJECT AND THE POTENTIAL BENEFITS
07:53:25PM IT COULD BRING TO THE COMMUNITY.
07:53:26PM MOREOVER, OUR CITY'S OWN STAFF, NATURAL RESOURCES,
07:53:30PM TRANSPORTATION AS MENTIONED BEFORE AND THE HISTORIC
07:53:33PM PRESERVATION DEPARTMENTS FOUND IT CONSISTENT WITH THE
07:53:37PM LONG-TERM VISION AND GOALS.
07:53:37PM THESE ARE PROFESSIONALS THAT HAVE DEDICATED THEIR CAREERS IN
07:53:41PM ENSURING THAT THE CITY'S DEVELOPMENT IN LINE WITH
07:53:44PM SUSTAINABILITY, HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND TRANSPORTATION
07:53:47PM EFFICIENCY.
07:53:48PM ARC COMMISSION, COMPRISED OF EXPERTS THIS FIELD VOTED 4-1 IN
07:53:55PM FAVOR OF THE 402 SOUTH OREGON.
07:53:58PM IN ALIGNMENT WITH THE ARCHITECTURAL LAND SCAPE AND ZONING
07:54:01PM REQUIREMENTS.
07:54:02PM IN ESSENCE, WE ARE NOT ASKING TO DEMOLISH OR CHANGE HISTORY
07:54:06PM AT ALL OR BUILDING UPON IT.
07:54:08PM WE ARE NOT AIL PROVING EVERYTHING AND AROUND THEM, A
07:54:12PM DEVELOPMENT OF OUR PROJECT IS A SYMBOL OF THE RESPECT TO THE
07:54:15PM PAST AND A COMMITMENT TO THE FUTURE.
07:54:16PM A PROBABLY THAT REPRESENTS HARMONY BETWEEN GROWTH AND
07:54:19PM RESERVATION.
07:54:19PM AND IN ORDER TO CONSIDER THE WIDESPREAD SUPPORT OF THIS
07:54:23PM PROJECT IT HAS GARNERED CAREFUL PLANNING THAT HAS GONE INTO
07:54:26PM IT AND THE POTENTIAL ENHANCE OUR CITY AND PRESERVING THEIR
07:54:31PM RICH OF THE RE.
07:54:32PM THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND CONSIDERING.
07:54:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NEXT SPEAKER.
07:54:36PM YES, MA'AM, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:54:38PM >> GOOD EVENING, MARIA BANASI.
07:54:41PM HERE TODAY BECAUSE I AM A PROUD MEMBER OF THE SOUTH TAMPA
07:54:47PM COMMUNITY.
07:54:47PM HERE TODAY BECAUSE I BELIEVE THAT THIS PROBABLY WILL
07:54:51PM REVITALIZE A HISTORIC PROPERTY WHILE PRESERVING THE CHARMING
07:54:55PM CHARACTER THAT MAKES HYDE PARK SO SPECIAL.
07:54:56PM THIS DEVELOPMENT IS NOT ABOUT REPLACING HISTORY, IT IS ABOUT
07:55:00PM RESTORING IT AND ENHANCING IT.
07:55:03PM THOUGHTFUL RENOVATION AND EXPANSION OF EXISTING HOME WILL
07:55:06PM MAINTAIN ITS HISTORIC INTEGRITY WHILE ADAPTING TO A MODERN
07:55:11PM LIVING STANDARD THAT A PROUD HOMEOWNER CAN ENJOY.
07:55:14PM FURTHERMORE, THE PLAN TO BUILD A NEW HOME ON THIS LOT IS A
07:55:17PM RESPECTFUL NOD TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD'S PAST.
07:55:20PM A HOME ONCE STOOD ON THIS VERY SPOT FOR OVER A CENTURY.
07:55:24PM THIS PROBABLY ENSURES THAT THE SPACE WILL ONCE AGAIN CORRECT
07:55:27PM TO THE FABRIC OF HYDE PARK, MIRRORING THE HISTORIC
07:55:32PM AESTHETIC THAT DEFINE THIS AREA.
07:55:34PM PROBLEMS LOOK THIS CREATE OPPORTUNITIES FOR MORE PEOPLE TO
07:55:37PM EXPERIENCE THE UNIQUE CHARACTER OF HYDE PARK AND ENJOY ITS
07:55:43PM INCREDIBLE AMENITIES FROM HYDE PARK VILLAGE TO BAYSHORE
07:55:46PM BOULEVARD.
07:55:47PM OFFERING DIVERSE OPTIONS THAT BLEND SEAMLESSLY INTO THE
07:55:52PM NEIGHBORHOOD AND WE ENCOURAGE GROWTH THAT STRENGTHENS OUR
07:55:55PM COMMUNITY.
07:55:56PM IMPORTANT TO RECOGNIZE THAT THIS PROBABLY HAS GONE THROUGH
07:55:58PM THE APPROPRIATE CHANNELS AND RECEIVED THE ELSE IN APPROVALS
07:56:01PM FROM THE CITY STAFF, AS WELL AS MANY OF THE NEIGHBORS.
07:56:05PM THIS REFLECTS MR. SHIEKH'S COMMITMENT TO FOLLOWING THE
07:56:09PM CITY'S PLANNING GUIDELINES AND WORKING COLLABORATIVELY WITH
07:56:13PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND THE COMMUNITY AROUND HIM.
07:56:15PM I APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THIS
07:56:17PM PROBABLY, AND I URGE YOU ALL TO CONSIDER THE POSITIVE IMPACT
07:56:20PM IT WILL HAVE ON BOTH THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND GREATER TAMPA
07:56:24PM THANK YOU.
07:56:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:56:25PM NEXT SPEAKER.
07:56:28PM YES, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
07:56:30PM >> HI.
07:56:30PM MY NAME IS ROSA TEWIL.
07:56:33PM I'M A REAL ESTATE ATTORNEY.
07:56:34PM I LIVE ON BAYSHORE.
07:56:36PM I PREVIOUSLY LIVED ON ROLAND NEAR DALE MABRY HIGHWAY AND
07:56:39PM KENNEDY.
07:56:40PM USED TO WORK AT 701 AZEELE THAT HAS BEEN IN SINCE THE
07:56:48PM EXPANSION.
07:56:48PM I WILL SAY ON THAT STREET ALL HISTORIC COMMERCIAL BUILDINGS
07:56:52PM THAT ONCE WERE HOMES.
07:56:53PM WILSON MIDDLE SCHOOL DOWN THE STREET.
07:56:55PM THOSE COULD HAVE ALL SERVED AS FAMILY HOMES HAD THEY BEEN
07:57:00PM UPDATED, REPAIRED PROPERLY AND CONSTRUCTION TO THIS THEY ALL
07:57:07PM HAVE BEEN DENIED AND TURNED INTO COMMERCIAL.
07:57:09PM A DISSERVICE TO THE SOUTH TAMPA COMMUNITY AND TO THE HOUSING
07:57:12PM NEED.
07:57:12PM THAT MIDDLE SCHOOL COULD BE SERVED BETTER BY HAVING FAMILIES
07:57:15PM THAT CAN WALK TO AND FROM THE SCHOOL.
07:57:17PM I THINK WHEN WE LOOK AT THE HISTORIC COMMUNITY AND WHAT THEY
07:57:21PM SEEK TO DO, I FEEL THERE ARE CHANNELS THAT THOSE NEED CAN BE
07:57:24PM MET SUCH AS WHAT THIS PROPOSAL HAS BROUGHT.
07:57:26PM I ALSO HEARD A FEW TALKING POINTS I WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON.
07:57:30PM LIKE I SAID A REAL ESTATE ATTORNEY AND MY CURRENT OFFICE ON
07:57:34PM ARMENIA.
07:57:34PM I AM A SOUTH TAMPA PERSON.
07:57:36PM I WOULD LIKE TO SAY THAT A LOT OF NEGATIVE IMPACTS THAT HAVE
07:57:39PM BEEN MENTIONED ARE IMPACTS SUCH AS PUTTING PAVEMENT, WHICH,
07:57:42PM AS WE KNOW, SOUTH TAMPA IS IN NEED OF MORE PARKING.
07:57:45PM THEY ALSO MENTIONED IN THE SAME, YOU KNOW, FOLD, THAT THERE
07:57:49PM IS NOT SUFFICIENT PARKING.
07:57:50PM THEY WANT TO MAINTAIN THE -- THE ONLY NEGATIVE IMPACT THAT
07:57:56PM HAS BEEN MENTIONED THAT HAVEN'T BEEN CONSTRUCTIVELY APPROACH
07:58:00PM BY MISS MALONE AND OTHER CITY STAFF IS THAT THEY WANT TO
07:58:04PM MAINTAIN THE JIM CROW ERA OF NOT HAVING PARKING LOTS.
07:58:08PM THEY ARE TALKING OF PROTECTING THE HISTORIC BUILDING AND
07:58:11PM PROPERTY SETTING FROM 1896 TO 1933.
07:58:14PM THERE WAS A HOME ON THAT LOT IN 1913.
07:58:17PM THEY ARE TALKING OF THE DESIGN, THE DENSITY AND THE OVERALL
07:58:21PM CHARACTER.
07:58:21PM MISS MALONE MENTIONED THAT THE AMPLE DENSITY IS 20.
07:58:25PM THIS IS ONLY 17.5.
07:58:27PM BENEATH WHAT THE DENSITY IS.
07:58:31PM AGAIN, I THINK THERE ARE A LOT OF NEGATIVE IMPACTS WE HAVE
07:58:35PM SEEN IN HISTORIC -- LIKE IN THE HISTORIC DISTRICT OVERALL.
07:58:38PM BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT ALLOWING THOSE REPAIRS.
07:58:40PM SOMETHING THAT WORK WITH A LOT ON A BONO BASIS IN REAL
07:58:45PM ESTATE, REAL ESTATE, A LOT PEOPLE ARE HAVING LANDLORD-TENANT
07:58:49PM ISSUES.
07:58:50PM TENANTS NOT HAVE THE NECESSITY BECAUSE THE HOMES REAR A LOT
07:58:53PM OF REPAIR AND MAINTENANCE AND NEW BUILDS SUPPORT THE NEEDS
07:58:56PM BETTER.
07:58:57PM YOU CAN'T HAVE THESE PLACES RENTED OUT BECAUSE PEOPLE EXPECT
07:59:00PM MEET THE LIVING STANDARDS SO THEY GET TURNED COMMERCIAL.
07:59:03PM THANK YOU.
07:59:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:59:08PM NEXT MA'AM, STATE YOUR NAME.
07:59:10PM NEXT SPEAKER.
07:59:11PM >> MY NAME IS AMINA.
07:59:13PM FOR ALL THE AFOREMENTIONED --
07:59:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: LAST NAME.
07:59:17PM >> AMINA SPACH.
07:59:20PM 20-PLUS-YEAR RESIDENT OF TAMPA AND THE AFOREMENTIONED
07:59:26PM REASONS, I'M HERE IN SUPPORT OF THE PROPOSAL TONIGHT.
07:59:28PM ONLY THING I THINK I CAN ADD IS THAT BEING A ADVOCATE IN
07:59:33PM THIS COMMUNITY, I CAN SAY WE NEED CONSCIOUS DEVELOPMENT.
07:59:35PM AND I DON'T THINK THAT SOMEONE WHO HAS GOTTEN COMMUNITY
07:59:39PM INPUT OBVIOUSLY AN EXCELLENT COMMUNITY ORGANIZER AND DONE
07:59:44PM THE WORK TO BE RESPECTFUL OF THE AESTHETICS AND THE HISTORY
07:59:49PM OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD SHOULD BE DENIED THE OPPORTUNITY TO DO
07:59:51PM SOMETHING WITH THE LAND.
07:59:52PM THANK YOU.
07:59:53PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:59:55PM YES, SIR, PLEASE COME ON UP AND STATE YOUR NAME.
07:59:59PM >> HELLO, SHEVIR HASHMI.
08:00:07PM AFTER ARE REVIEWING ALL THE INFORMATION THAT EVERYBODY HAS
08:00:11PM SHARED.
08:00:11PM I AM IN SUPPORT OF THE DEVELOPMENT.
08:00:12PM IF IT HAS BEEN APPROVED BY THE ARC AND DOES MEET FUTURE LAND
08:00:17PM USE AND -- AND IS ESTHETICALLY PLEASING.
08:00:20PM IT DOES APPEAL TO ALL THE CODES FOR THE AREA.
08:00:24PM IT DOES FIX THE NEED OF HOUSING AND DENSITY IS ONE WAY TO DO
08:00:29PM THAT.
08:00:29PM SO IT PRESERVES THE STRUCTURE FOR PRESERVATION.
08:00:34PM AND DOES PRESERVE THE ORIGINAL STRUCTURE AND ADDING BEAUTY
08:00:38PM TO IT TO SUPPORT THE LOOK THE NEIGHBORHOOD WHEEL ADDING A
08:00:41PM CREATIVE STRUCTURE SO -- THE -- IT IS MORE ENGAGING.
08:00:47PM AND -- AND THE SIDES AND THE BACK.
08:00:51PM I DO SUPPORT THIS DEVELOPMENT.
08:00:52PM AND I HOPE IT GETS APPROVED.
08:00:55PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:00:56PM YES, SIR.
08:00:57PM NEXT SPEAKER.
08:00:58PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
08:00:59PM >> MY NAME IS SHANDON KIYA.
08:01:05PM I'M HERE IN SUPPORT OF THIS PROBABLY.
08:01:06PM I HAVE BEEN THIS REAL ESTATE -- I AM A REAL ESTATE AGENT AND
08:01:09PM HAS BEEN IN IT FOR FOUR AND A HALF YEARS.
08:01:11PM I HAVE STUDIED AND FOLLOWED THESE DEVELOPERS.
08:01:14PM AND TYPICALLY MORE TIMES THAN NOT, YOU WOULD SEE A PROPERTY
08:01:18PM LIKE THIS BE TORN DOWN.
08:01:20PM AND A LUXURY NEW CONSTRUCTION WHICH SEEMS TO BE THE MOTIF IN
08:01:26PM THE TAMPA BAY AREA, ESPECIALLY IN SOUTH TAMPA, WOULD BE WHAT
08:01:29PM IS CONSTRUCTED, BUT I FEEL THIS DEVELOPER HAS FOUND A
08:01:32PM CREATIVE WAY TO BOTH CONFORM TO THE NEIGHBORING HISTORIC
08:01:38PM PROPERTIES AND PROVIDE ATTAINABLE AND AFFORDABLE, IF YOU
08:01:44PM WOULD, HOUSING COMPARED TO THE MUCH LARGER PROPERTIES THAT
08:01:48PM WE ARE SEEING BEING DEVELOPED IN AREA.
08:01:51PM AS MENTIONED EARLIER, SMALLER PROPERTIES TEND TO BE MORE
08:01:55PM AFFORDABLE THAN LUXURY NEW CONSTRUCTION.
08:01:57PM THANK YOU.
08:01:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:01:59PM NEXT SPEAKER.
08:02:00PM YES, SIR.
08:02:02PM >> MY NAME IS MESH BAUL.
08:02:07PM I AM IN SUPPORT OF THIS MOVEMENT.
08:02:09PM I GET STAGE FRIGHT, SORRY.
08:02:14PM BUT I BELIEVE -- I BELIEVE WITH EVERYTHING THAT HAS BEEN
08:02:16PM SAID EARLIER, IF HE -- IF HE PLAN ON STAYING CONSISTENT WITH
08:02:22PM EVERYTHING THAT IS PLANNED AND BUILDS IT -- BUILDS IT THE
08:02:26PM WAY HE SAYS HE IS GOING TO DO IT, I DON'T SEE A PROBLEM WITH
08:02:30PM ANYTHING GOING THROUGH WHICH IS WHY I AM IN SUPPORT.
08:02:32PM I DON'T KNOW -- I BELIEVE I HEARD THAT WHEN HE WENT TO GO
08:02:37PM SPEAK WITH THE ASSOCIATION, THEY SAID THAT THEY WANTED HIM
08:02:42PM TO BUILD ONE BIGGER UNIT, WHICH SEEMS PRETTY CONTRADICTING.
08:02:46PM BUT THAT IS ALL HE TO SAY.
08:02:49PM I'M IN SUPPORT.
08:02:50PM AND I HOPE YOU GUYS AGREE.
08:02:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:02:53PM NEXT SPEAKER, COME ON UP.
08:02:56PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
08:02:57PM >> HELLO, GOOD EVENING.
08:03:00PM KADER AND I WANT TO EXPRESS OUR SUPPORT OF THIS DEVELOPMENT.
08:03:06PM THIS PROJECT NOT ONLY REQUIREMENTS BUT REVITALIZES OUR
08:03:11PM HISTORICAL ARCHITECTURE.
08:03:13PM AND I THINK IT IS IMPORTANT TO RECOGNIZE THAT.
08:03:17PM I DON'T WANT TO SPEAK TO THE DETAILS OF HOW IT DOES IT,
08:03:20PM BECAUSE MR. SHEIKH GAVE US A VERY COMPREHENSIVE PRESENTATION
08:03:26PM OF IT.
08:03:26PM SO I WANTED TO VOICE MY SUPPORT.
08:03:28PM IN ADDITION, I WOULD LIKE TO SAY THE EXTENT TO WHICH HE IS
08:03:33PM EMPHASIZING TO MAINTAIN THE HISTORICAL ARCHITECTURE.
08:03:37PM I THINK THAT IS VERY IMPORTANT, ESPECIALLY IF YOU DRIVE
08:03:40PM AROUND THE LOCAL ROADS IN THE AREA.
08:03:42PM YOU WILL SEE SOMETIMES A HISTORICAL HOUSE.
08:03:45PM AND RIGHT NEXT TO IT A VERY MODERN SQUARE-LOOKING HOUSE,
08:03:52PM AND THEY DON'T GO FORGET.
08:03:54PM IN THIS CASE, WE ARE NOT DOING THAT, AND I THINK IT IS VERY
08:03:58PM IMPORTANT TO RECOGNIZE THAT.
08:03:59PM THE THIRD THING, I DON'T THINK THERE SHOULD BE ANY
08:04:02PM OPPOSITION FOR MORE DIVERSE HOUSING IN THE AREA, ESPECIALLY
08:04:05PM WHEN WE ARE SEEING SUCH EXTENSIVE EVIDENCE THAT CARE HAS
08:04:10PM BEEN DONE IN MEETING THE NEIGHBORS, THE NEIGHBORHOOD
08:04:13PM ASSOCIATIONS, DISCUSSING WITH VARIOUS ORGANIZATIONS.
08:04:17PM A LOT OF GROUNDWORK.
08:04:18PM A LOT OF DEDICATION HAS BEEN PUT INTO THIS.
08:04:21PM AND THAT IS SOMETHING THAT YOU SHOULD RESPECT IN TERMS OF A
08:04:25PM DEVELOPER.
08:04:25PM BECAUSE I DON'T FEEL LIKE A LOT OF TIMES THAT IS DONE.
08:04:28PM SO I APPLAUD MR. SHEIK FOR DOING THAT.
08:04:35PM LASTLY, I WOULD LIKE TO ASK THE CITY COUNCIL TO PLEASE
08:04:41PM SUPPORT THIS MOVEMENT.
08:04:43PM I THINK IT IS -- IT IS SUBSTANTIALLY VERY GOOD ONE.
08:04:47PM THANK YOU.
08:04:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:04:49PM YES, SIR, YES, SIR.
08:04:51PM NEXT SPEAKER.
08:04:53PM >> GOOD EVENING, CITY COUNCIL.
08:04:54PM MY NAME IS DR. MICHAEL POBAT.
08:04:57PM AND I LIVE IN THE SPANISH TOWN CREEK AREA.
08:05:00PM AND I AM ALSO THE PRESIDENT OF THE HYDE PARK SPANISH TOWN
08:05:05PM CREEK CIVIC ASSOCIATION WITH A GROUP OF PASSIONATE RESIDENTS
08:05:10PM FOCUSED ON THE CHARACTER OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:05:11PM HOME LOCATED 402 SOUTH OREGON AVENUE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE
08:05:16PM HYDE PARK SPANISH TOWN CREEK BOUNDARIES.
08:05:18PM THE HYDE PARK SPANISH TOWN CREEK BOARD OPPOSES THE REZONING
08:05:22PM ASK OF THE 402, 404 OREGON AVENUE FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONS.
08:05:26PM INCONSISTENT WITH CITY CODE.
08:05:29PM PROPOSAL VIOLATES CITY CODE 27-11 BY ATTEMPT TO SPLIT THE
08:05:35PM PARCEL IN AN UNREASONABLE MANNER.
08:05:37PM HISTORIC GUIDELINES VIOLATIONS.
08:05:38PM PROPOSALS DISREGARDS LOCAL HISTORIC GUIDELINES BY
08:05:44PM ELIMINATING ALL SETBACKS EXCEPT THE FRONT WHICH IS NOT IN
08:05:48PM KEEPING WITH THE AREA'S CHARACTER LACK GREEN SPACE, THE
08:05:52PM PROJECT FAILS TO EN CORPS REAL GREEN SPACE BY THE NATURAL
08:05:56PM RESOURCES DEPARTMENT AND DOES NOT MEET THE MINIMUM
08:05:59PM REQUIREMENTS FOR SETBACK OR GREEN SPACE PRESERVATION.
08:06:02PM PARCEL HISTORY AND ZONING.
08:06:04PM PARCEL 40 SOUTH OREGON A CONSOLIDATED LOT FROM 402 AND 404
08:06:11PM SPLIT TO CREATE 1408 WEST AZEELE.
08:06:15PM IF THE ORIGINAL LOTS WERE INTACT ALLOW FOR TWO UNITS.
08:06:18PM CURRENT CONFIGURATION IS SMALL TO SUPPORT AN ADDITIONAL
08:06:25PM DWELLING.
08:06:25PM DOES NOT RESTORE THE HISTORICAL CONFIGURATION OF THESE LOTS.
08:06:28PM IMPACT ON HISTORIC DISTRICT.
08:06:30PM THE AREA, PART OF DOBYVILLE HISTORIC DISTRICT MUST COMPLY
08:06:35PM WITH MODERN CITY CODES AND DESIGN GUIDELINES WHICH THIS
08:06:38PM PROPOSAL FAILS TO DO.
08:06:39PM DEVELOPMENT OF DEVELOPMENT IS SEEN AS AN ATTEMPT TO BYPASS
08:06:43PM CURRENT STANDARDS AND THE INTEGRITY OF THE HISTORIC
08:06:47PM DISTRICT.
08:06:47PM FLOODING CONCERNS.
08:06:48PM THE PROPOSED CHANGES, PARTICULARLY SPLITTING THE PARCEL
08:06:51PM FURTHER WOULD CREATE THE SMALLEST LOT IN THE AREA,
08:06:55PM INCREASING VULNERABILITY OF FLOODING.
08:06:58PM THE HYDE PARK SPANISH TOWN CREEK BOARD REQUESTS THAT YOU
08:07:03PM DENY THE REZONING REQUEST AS IT UNDERMINES ESTABLISHED
08:07:07PM ZONING LAWS, HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND GUIDELINES AND
08:07:10PM ENVIRONMENTAL CONSIDERATIONS.
08:07:11PM THANK YOU, COUNCIL, FOR THE PRIVILEGE OF YOUR TIME.
08:07:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
08:07:17PM NEXT SPEAKER, COME ON UP.
08:07:22PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
08:07:23PM >> GOOD EVENING, MR. CHAIR, COUNCIL, JOSH BAUMGARTNER.
08:07:29PM 506 SOUTH OREGON.
08:07:33PM I COME IN SUPPORT OF APPLICANT AND A PROJECT I BELIEVE ENHANCES
08:07:36PM COMMUNITY, VITALIZES THAT SITE, WHILE ALSO ENHANCING THE
08:07:39PM SITE AS WELL.
08:07:41PM I THINK WE CAN ALL AGREE THAT HOUSING ON ALL FRONTS IS
08:07:44PM NEEDED NOW MORE THAN EVER.
08:07:46PM THIS PROBABLY DOES THAT, WHEEL STAYING CONSISTENT WITH THE
08:07:50PM MULTI AND SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES AND RESIDENCES ON OREGON.
08:07:55PM PER THE PLANS I HAVE SEEN TODAY AND RECOMMENDATIONS FROM
08:07:59PM STAFF, SEEMS CONSISTENT WITH STAFF'S RECOMMENDATION ON
08:08:02PM PREVIOUS BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS.
08:08:03PM NEIGHBORS DIRECTLY ADJACENT AND MOST IMPACTED.
08:08:06PM I FULLY SUPPORT THIS.
08:08:08PM AND I HOPE YOU WILL SUPPORT AS WELL.
08:08:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU SO MUCH.
08:08:12PM YES, SIR, PLEASE COME ON UP AND STATE YOUR NAME.
08:08:15PM >> GOOD AFTERNOON.
08:08:16PM MY NAME IS ADAM SHEIKH.
08:08:20PM I WANT TO SPEAK IN FAVOR OF THIS STRONG PROJECT.
08:08:24PM MEMBERS OF COUNCIL, THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO SPEAK
08:08:28PM TODAY.
08:08:28PM I WILL STEP OUT TO THE SIDE --
08:08:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE NEED YOU THERE BECAUSE OF THE
08:08:32PM MICROPHONE.
08:08:32PM >> I WILL LEAN SLIGHTLY TO THE SIDE AND LOOK AT THIS ENTIRE
08:08:37PM ROOM.
08:08:38PM NOW BY FAR, I'M YOUNGEST PERSON IN THIS ROOM.
08:08:41PM YOU REPRESENT A DIVERSE --
08:08:45PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HE IS 21.
08:08:47PM >> ME TOO.
08:08:48PM ME TOO.
08:08:48PM >> WHAT ARE YOU TRYING TO SAY?
08:08:53PM >> I DO APOLOGIZE.
08:08:54PM I DO APOLOGIZE.
08:08:56PM I DO APOLOGIZE.
08:08:58PM I WOULD JUST BRIEFLY LIKE TO EXPLAIN WHY I SAID THAT.
08:09:01PM I OFFER A DIVERSE PERSPECTIVE.
08:09:03PM I OFFER A PERSPECTIVE THAT HAVEN'T BEEN BROUGHT HERE BEFORE
08:09:06PM THIS COUNCIL TODAY.
08:09:07PM I AM THE YOUTH, ALONGSIDE YOURSELF AND YOURSELF.
08:09:12PM NOW -- I WOULD LIKE TO SAY THAT I AM IN SUPPORT OF THIS
08:09:19PM PROJECT.
08:09:20PM AND I WOULD LIKE TO REMIND THIS COUNCIL OF THEIR VISION,
08:09:23PM WHICH I FOUND ON YOUR WEB SITE EARLIER THIS MORNING.
08:09:26PM THE CITY OF TAMPA'S VISION IS TO BE RECOGNIZED AS A DIVERSE
08:09:32PM CITY SELL RATED AS A PLACE TO LIVE, WORK, LEARN AND PLAY.
08:09:35PM NOW I WANT TO HIGHLIGHT THAT IN ORDER TO EMBODY THE PART OF
08:09:39PM THE VISION STATEMENT THAT MENTIONS BEING RECOGNIZED AS
08:09:42PM PROGRESSIVE, YOU HAVE TO LOOK PAST SOCIAL -- THIS DOES
08:09:46PM CONTRIBUTE TO ECONOMIC, BUT I AM TALKING OF REAL ESTATE.
08:09:49PM THIS IS A PROGRESS IN REAL ESTATE.
08:09:51PM AND WE NEED TO BE MINDFUL THAT FURTHER DEVELOPMENTS ARE ONLY
08:09:56PM GOING TO FURTHER TAMPA AND FURTHER TAMPA'S GROWTH.
08:10:00PM NOW ADDITIONALLY, I ALSO WANT TO SAY THAT CITY COUNCIL
08:10:08PM SERVES THE CITIZENS BY POLICIES THAT PROMOTE ECONOMIC
08:10:13PM DEVELOPMENT.
08:10:13PM THAT DOES JUST THAT.
08:10:15PM ALLOWING THESE NEW PROJECTS -- STRONG PROJECTS TO CONTINUE
08:10:19PM TO ELEVATE TAMPA AS A WHOLE FURTHERING OUR ECONOMIC FOAMS AS
08:10:23PM A CITY.
08:10:24PM WE NODE TO ALLOW THESE TO CONTINUE.
08:10:26PM THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
08:10:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:10:28PM YES, SIR, PLEASE COME UP.
08:10:30PM STATE YOUR NAME.
08:10:33PM >> GOOD EVENING, HASAN HALIBY.
08:10:39PM I WANT TO SPEAK IN FAVOR OF THE PROPOSAL.
08:10:42PM I WILL KEEP IT BRIEF.
08:10:45PM FIRST TIME IN THE ROOM WITHOUT A TIE.
08:10:47PM BUT AFTER 5 P.M., I WANT TO REMARK THAT I HAVE NO TIE TO
08:10:54PM ITEM 1.
08:10:55PM I JOIN WITH MISS HENDERSON.
08:11:00PM I WAS A LITTLE APPALLED BY WHAT THE OPPOSITION SAID.
08:11:04PM LOW STANDARDS AND INTEGRITY, INTEGRITY, INTEGRITY.
08:11:10PM I WILL STOP THE MORAL CODE AND WHY THE MAJORITY ATTACKING
08:11:15PM THE DEVELOPER NOT THE DEVELOPMENT ITSELF, BUT I SHARE A LOT
08:11:18PM OF SENTIMENTS AND FEARS WITH THE COUNCIL AND THE OPPOSITION
08:11:22PM BECAUSE I AM WARY OF AGGRESSIVE AND OUT-OF-STATE BUILDING
08:11:27PM GLASS AND STUCCO AND HAPHAZARDLY PLACING THEM.
08:11:30PM THIS IS NOT THAT.
08:11:31PM A TASTEFUL PROJECT AND CLEAR THAT THE DEVELOPER HAS DONE
08:11:35PM EVERYTHING, HIS DUE DILIGENCE, HOMEWORK AND ETC.
08:11:39PM STRONGLY ADVISE -- OR STRONGLY IMPLORE YOU TO SUPPORT THE
08:11:44PM MATTER.
08:11:44PM I THINK IT IS TASTEFUL.
08:11:46PM I THINK IT WILL BE A BENEFIT TO THE CITY OF TAMPA.
08:11:48PM THANK YOU SO MUCH.
08:11:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:11:52PM COUNCIL MEMBER VIERA, ARE YOU BACK WITH US?
08:11:54PM THERE HE IS.
08:11:55PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES, I AM.
08:11:58PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NEXT SPEAKER.
08:12:00PM PLEASE COME UP AND STATE YOUR NAME.
08:12:02PM >> DR. ADAM ADAWAWI, WEST KATHLEEN AVENUE.
08:12:08PM BASICALLY, I APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TODAY IN
08:12:12PM SUPPORT OF OUR PROJECT THAT REFLECTS THE CAREFUL BALANCE
08:12:15PM BETWEEN HONORING THE NEIGHBORHOOD'S PAST AND ENSURING ITS
08:12:19PM CONTINUED VITALITY FOR THE FUTURE.
08:12:21PM THIS IS NOT JUST ABOUT DEVELOPMENT.
08:12:23PM IT IS ABOUT STEWARDSHIP.
08:12:24PM MAKING THOSE CHANGES IN OUR COMMUNITY ARE THOUGHFUL,
08:12:27PM INTENTIONAL AND RESPECTFUL OF THE ARCHITECTURAL
08:12:30PM CHARACTER THAT IS CORRECT MAKES THIS AREA SO UNIQUE.
08:12:32PM PRESERVING THE INTEGRITY OF OUR HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:12:36PM PROBABLY EMBRACES THAT RESPONSIBILITY BE ENSURING THAT ANY
08:12:39PM UPDATES TO THE EXISTING HOME WITHIN THE COMMUNITY AND
08:12:43PM MAINTAINING ITS HISTORIC CHARM.
08:12:46PM AT THE SAME TIME, THE ADDITION OF THE NEW HOME IS DESIGNED
08:12:48PM TO FEEL LIKE A NATURAL EXTENSION.
08:12:51PM HISTORY AND PROGRESS DOESN'T HAVE TO BE AT TO ODDS.
08:12:55PM THIS PRODUCT DEMONSTRATES HOW THEY CAN WORK TOGETHER.
08:12:57PM BEYOND AESTHETICS, RESPONSIBLE GROWTH BENEFITS OUR COMMUNITY
08:13:02PM THAT BENEFIT CURRENT AND FUTURE RESIDENTS.
08:13:05PM A BEAUTIFUL NEIGHBORHOOD AND A DESIRABLE CITY.
08:13:08PM PROJECTS LOOKING THIS MAKE SURE MORE PEOPLE HAVE AN
08:13:11PM OPPORTUNITY TO BE PART OF IT.
08:13:12PM DEVELOPMENT IS DONE WITH CARE RESPECTING THE PHYSICAL
08:13:15PM LANDSCAPE AND HISTORY IT REPRESENTS, IT ONLY ADDS TO THE
08:13:18PM CHARACTER OF THE PLACE.
08:13:19PM I ENCOURAGE YOU TO YOU SUPPORT THIS PROJECT NOT JUST AS A
08:13:21PM PRACTICAL DECISION, BUT AS A COMMITMENT TO THOUGHTFUL,
08:13:25PM HISTORICALLY MINDFUL GROWTH.
08:13:27PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:13:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:13:29PM YES, SIR, COME ON UP.
08:13:31PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
08:13:32PM SIR -- AT THE END OF LINE.
08:13:34PM WILL YOU BE LAST SPEAKER?
08:13:36PM ANYBODY ELSE THAT WILL BE GETTING UP TO SPEAK?
08:13:40PM >> SOMEBODY WENT TO THE REST ROOM.
08:13:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE WILL HOLD HER SPOT.
08:13:43PM THE GENTLEMAN IN THE BACK SHIRT THAT JUST GOT UP WILL BE THE
08:13:47PM LAST SPEAKER.
08:13:48PM >> JAMES LASCARA.
08:13:51PM LIVE NEARBY IN THE NORTH HYDE PARK AREA.
08:13:53PM I SUPPORT THE PROBABLY.
08:13:54PM WHAT A GREAT VIDEO.
08:13:55PM THANK YOU, MR. SHEIKH.
08:13:57PM HOW INFORMATIVE AND INCREDIBLE THE PREPARATION THAT PUT
08:14:01PM INTO IN.
08:14:02PM THE WORDS THAT CAME TO MIND WATCHING THIS VIDEO, SENSITIVITY,
08:14:05PM THOUGHTFUL AND CONSIDERATE.
08:14:07PM HE TOOK INPUT FROM THE NEIGHBORS BEFORE COMING BEFORE
08:14:11PM COUNCIL.
08:14:11PM HE HEARD LACK OF GREEN SPACE AS A COMPLAINT.
08:14:13PM I HEARD ALSO THAT HE IS COMPLYING WITH MORE THAN THE
08:14:16PM REQUIRED GREEN SPACE WITH THIS PLAN.
08:14:18PM AND THEN SOMETHING I HEARD A LOT TONIGHT, WE NEED TO HEAR
08:14:21PM FROM THE EXPERTS.
08:14:22PM THE CITY STAFF DID WEIGH IN, AND I HEARD THEIR TESTIMONY.
08:14:26PM THEY ARE THE EXPERTS AND FOUND THIS CONSISTENT ACROSS THE
08:14:29PM BOARD.
08:14:29PM I AM ALSO EXCITED TO HEAR THEY FOUND IT CONSISTENT AND I
08:14:32PM REALLY SUPPORT THE PROJECT.
08:14:33PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SIR.
08:14:35PM YES, MA'AM, PLEASE COME ON UP.
08:14:38PM >> I AM TARYN NEYLAND AT 1405 WEST AZEELE.
08:14:42PM I WAS AT THE MEETING IN DECEMBER THAT THE ARC REQUIRED THE
08:14:47PM APPLICANT TO HAVE WITH THE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATIONS.
08:14:49PM JUST AS I WAS THEN, I STAND BEFORE YOU TODAY OPPOSED TO
08:14:54PM REZONING OF 402 SOUTH OREGON FROM RM-12 TO PD AND
08:15:01PM CONTRADICTS THE PRINCIPLES OF OUR HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:15:05PM I LIVE IN HYDE PARK SINCE JANUARY 2009 AND LIVE AND OWN A
08:15:09PM HOME IN SPANISH TOWN CREEK SINCE APRIL 020.
08:15:12PM I LOVE OUR NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:15:13PM I AM PROUD OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATIONS AND ALL THOSE
08:15:17PM THAT AIDED IN EXPANSION OF THE LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT TO
08:15:21PM INCLUDE PARTS OF SPANISH TOWN CREEK AND PARTS OF DOBYVILLE.
08:15:26PM THIS IN THE LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT AND CAN EVOLVE UNDER
08:15:30PM R-12.
08:15:32PM I LIVE 40 STEPS FROM 402 SOUTH OREGON AVENUE.
08:15:37PM 40 STEPS.
08:15:37PM AS YOU MAY RECALL IN A RECENT AGENDA ITEM BEFORE YOU AND IN
08:15:42PM THE NEWS EARLIER THIS WEEK, MY HOME 1405 AZEELE IS
08:15:47PM DESIGNATED A LOCAL HISTORIC LANDMARK AND ACROSS THE STREET.
08:15:52PM ACTION TO REZONE FROM RM-12 TO PD UNDERMINES THE LOCAL
08:15:58PM HISTORIC DISTRICT AND THE CODE ASSIGNED TO THE PROPERTY.
08:16:00PM ACTION TO REZONE THE PROPERTY TO SKIRT RULES AND CODES AND
08:16:04PM PROMOTE ERRATIC LAND USE.
08:16:06PM STOPPING ERRATIC LAND USE OF THE INCLUSION OF MY
08:16:11PM NEIGHBORHOOD INTO THE LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT.
08:16:12PM IN SUMMARY, FOUR KEY POINTS.
08:16:14PM ONE, ALLOWING THE PARCEL TO BE REZONED ALLOWS THE USE OF
08:16:18PM UNCONTROLLED USE OF LAND.
08:16:19PM TWO, INCLUDED SEVERAL EXAMPLES TO BOLSTER THEIR CASE.
08:16:24PM HOPE THE COUNCIL RECOGNIZE AS THAT ECLECTIC CHARACTER AND
08:16:29PM SIMILAR DEVELOPMENTS LISTED WERE BUILT PRIOR TO THE AREA
08:16:33PM DESIGNATED IN THE LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT.
08:16:36PM APPLICANT CLAIMS THAT TWO HOMES FOR DOBYVILLE HISTORY
08:16:41PM IT DOES NOT.
08:16:42PM PLANS TO RECONSTRUCT THE DOBYVILLE IS IMPRACTICAL GIVEN
08:16:47PM MODERN DEVELOPMENT.
08:16:48PM PRIORITIZES THE AUTHENTICITY OF HOMES THAT STILL EXIST.
08:16:53PM LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT HOPES TO HONOR THE STORIES OF THOSE
08:16:58PM LIVE IT THERE AND HIGHLIGHTING THE HISTORICAL CONTEXT OF
08:17:02PM DOBYVILLE'S RUSS LOUIS.
08:17:06PM AND SITS 40 STEPS FROM WHAT IS NOW A LOCAL HISTORIC
08:17:10PM LANDMARK.
08:17:11PM I BEG YOU TO HELP US.
08:17:12PM IMPORTANT TO PROTECT THE SPACES AND PRESERVE THE INTEGRITY
08:17:16PM OF OUR HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:17:17PM I IMPLORE YOU TO DENY THE REZONING REQUEST.
08:17:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:17:23PM NEXT SPEAKER.
08:17:25PM >> HAMERA APSAL.
08:17:29PM I'M HERE FOR THIS PROJECT AND FOR SOME OF THE REASONS THAT
08:17:34PM MANY HAVE SPOKEN ON.
08:17:35PM I RAISE SOME OF ISSUES RAISED IN THE E-MAILS AND COMMENTS.
08:17:41PM I CAME HERE SPENDING ME THREE HOURS OF MY EVENING BECAUSE
08:17:43PM I'M VERY FRUSTRATED TO SEE CONTINUOUS OPPOSITION TO AREAS
08:17:49PM WHERE A PERSON CAN EASILY GET BY WITH ONE OR NO CARS.
08:17:53PM LOTS OF COMPLAINTS ABOUT PARKING.
08:17:54PM TAKE THIS NUMBER.
08:17:56PM 813-274-8523.
08:17:59PM THAT IS THE PARKING DIVISION.
08:18:01PM CALL THEM IF THERE IS PARKING VIOLATIONS.
08:18:03PM THEY WILL COME OUT AND TAKE CARE OF IT.
08:18:06PM IN PARTICULAR, HYDE PARK GETS A LOT OF SPECIAL ATTENTION
08:18:09PM REGARDING PARKING.
08:18:11PM CALL PARKING DIVISION.
08:18:12PM IF IT IS ILLEGALLY PARK, THEY WILL COME AN TAKE CARE OF IT.
08:18:16PM PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION.
08:18:18PM JUST ENCOURAGING PEOPLE THAT IF YOU DRIVE OR IF YOU PARK,
08:18:23PM YOU ARE PART OF THE PARKING TRAFFIC PROBLEM.
08:18:26PM THERE IS A BUS STOP A SHORT WALK AWAY AT PLATT AND DELAWARE.
08:18:30PM IT IS A 16-MINUTE BUS DRIVE FROM THAT LOCATION TO CITY COUNCIL.
08:18:34PM USE THE BIKE INFRASTRUCTURE ON NEARBY CLEVELAND.
08:18:38PM CITY DID A VERY NICE QUICK BUILD PROJECT.
08:18:41PM AREA IS ALSO CLOSE TO SOME VERY BIKABLE NEIGHBORHOODS.
08:18:45PM IT IS AN 11-MINUTE BIKE RIDE FROM THAT LOCATION TO HERE.
08:18:50PM THAT IS ONLY ONE MINUTE LONGER THAN IT TOOK ME TO BIKE HERE.
08:18:55PM WALKING.
08:18:56PM THAT LOCATION -- THAT -- THAT WOULD ADD DENSITY TO AN AREA
08:19:02PM THAT IS APPEALING, BECAUSE IT IS SO WALKABLE.
08:19:05PM IT IS LITERALLY A FIVE-MINUTE WALK TO HYDE PARK VILLAGE.
08:19:10PM THESE ARE THE KIND OF NEIGHBORHOODS WHERE WE NEED MORE
08:19:13PM DENSITY.
08:19:13PM SHORT-TERM RENTALS.
08:19:15PM A LOT OF COMPLAINTS OF SHORT-TERM RENTALS.
08:19:19PM AND E-MAILS.
08:19:20PM I UNDERSTAND.
08:19:20PM I HAVE A FULL-TIME AIR B&B ACROSS THE STREET FROM ME.
08:19:25PM I HAVE ONE NEXT DOOR TO ME.
08:19:26PM BUT I WOULD ENCOURAGE THE PEOPLE BOTHER BY THAT TO TAKE
08:19:30PM THEIR CONCERN UP WITH THE FLORIDA LEGISLATURE.
08:19:32PM CITY CANNOT RESTRICT SHORT-TERM RENTALS BECAUSE OF A
08:19:36PM PREEMPTION PASS BY THE FLORIDA GOVERNMENT.
08:19:38PM SO IF PEOPLE ARE NOT HAPPY OF THE SHORT-TERM RENTALS IN
08:19:46PM THEIR NEIGHBORHOOD, I URGE THEM TO CONTACT THEIR
08:19:49PM REPRESENTATIVES.
08:19:49PM THAT SENATOR FOR THE FLORIDA HOUSE, KAREN GONZALEZ BETMAN.
08:19:56PM FLORIDA SENATE, JAY COLLINS 813-281-2538.
08:20:02PM THOSE CONCERNS NEED TO BE DIRECTED NOT AGAINST THIS
08:20:05PM DEVELOPMENT, THEY NEED TO BE DIRECTED TO PEOPLE WHO CAN
08:20:08PM ACTUALLY CHANGE THAT.
08:20:09PM I COMMEND MR. SHEIKH FOR THOUGHTFULLY DESIGNED INFILL
08:20:15PM PROJECT AND STRONGLY ENCOURAGE TO YOU APPROVE IT.
08:20:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:20:19PM YES, MA'AM, COME ON UP AND STATE YOUR NAME.
08:20:22PM >> TATYANA MORALES, CHAPTER LEAGUE.
08:20:26PM LEVIS 111 SOUTH NEWPORT AND HE CAN SAY, YES, HE WANT THIS
08:20:31PM PROJECT IN MY BACK YARD.
08:20:32PM BUT THE REASON WHY IS BECAUSE WHEN WE LOOK AT INFILL
08:20:36PM DEVELOPMENT.
08:20:36PM LOOK AT LOTS THAT HAVE OLD LITTLE HOME THAT OWNER OF THE
08:20:39PM HOUSE SOLD BECAUSE THEY WANTED THIS TO BE THE FUTURE.
08:20:41PM I WENT YESTERDAY AND TODAY TO THAT LOT TO SEE HOW BAD IS
08:20:44PM PARKING BECAUSE I LIVE IN THAT AREA THINKING I BIKE ARMED
08:20:48PM HERE.
08:20:48PM I TOOK MY CAR AND DROVE THERE AND WATCHED AS MOST OF THE
08:20:51PM CARS IN THE TOWN HOMES PARK BEHIND IN THE PARKING LOT BEHIND
08:20:54PM THAT BUILDING.
08:20:55PM THE STREET WAS MOSTLY EMPTY BECAUSE ON THAT LITTLE CORNER,
08:20:58PM NOBODY GOES THERE BECAUSE THE EXPRESSWAY.
08:21:00PM SO PARKING ISN'T REALLY A PROBLEM IF PEOPLE WANT TO WALK
08:21:04PM MORE, CLEVELAND STREET ON THE SAME BIKEWAY, THEY ADDED A TON
08:21:10PM OF PARKING THAT IS ALWAYS AVAILABLE.
08:21:11PM NEWSCAST OF N.I.M.B.Y.ISM.
08:21:13PM NEIGHBORS COME OUT PROTECTING THEIR MULTIMILLION DOLLAR
08:21:16PM HOUSES AND DEFENDING NEIGHBORHOODS THAT ARE BLACK
08:21:19PM NEIGHBORHOODS WHEN NONE OF THEM HERE ARE BLACK.
08:21:20PM SOMETHING REALLY IRONIC ABOUT THAT.
08:21:22PM SOMETHING THAT REALLY GETS TO MY BONES ABOUT THAT.
08:21:25PM AND THE REASON THAT WHICH HAVE SINGLE-FAMILY ZONING IS SO
08:21:29PM CORRELATED WITH THE NOT DIVERSE NEIGHBORHOODS.
08:21:31PM I LIVE IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD -- IF YOU PRETEND THAT HYDE PARK
08:21:34PM IS DIVERSE, THE ONLY DIVERSITY IN HYDE PARK ARE PEOPLE'S
08:21:39PM DOGS.
08:21:39PM I LIVE IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD
08:21:40PM I LOVE THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:21:41PM I WANT TO LIVE IT MORE, BUT NO ONE THAT LOOKS LIKE ME AND IT
08:21:44PM HAPPENS WHEN WE LET THESE HOUSES BE McMANSIONS AND $2
08:21:49PM MILLION AND NEIGHBORS HERE, YOU KNOW, CAN REAP THE BENEFITS
08:21:52PM TO SELL OUT FOR $2 MILLION ONE DAY.
08:21:54PM PROBLEM IS WE HAVE A FUTURE AND TALK OF THE PEOPLE COMING IN
08:21:57PM AND LITTLE INFILL PROJECTS.
08:21:59PM ONE PROJECT.
08:22:00PM ONE HOME.
08:22:00PM BUT THAT HOME WILL HOME A FAMILY.
08:22:02PM MAYBE THE FAMILY THAT FESS OUT WHAT HAPPENS ON THAT GOODY
08:22:06PM GOODY CORNER AND ESTABLISH THEMSELVES IN THE FUTURE.
08:22:09PM WHAT HAPPENED WHAT HAPPENS TO YOUR KIDS WHEN THEY ARE
08:22:11PM LOOKING FOR OPPORTUNITIES IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:22:13PM WHEN WE TALK OF FLOODING, HE LIVE FURTHER DOWN THE STREET.
08:22:17PM FURTHER SOUTH PROBLEM.
08:22:18PM A LOT OF CONCERNS -- I GET IT.
08:22:20PM I LOVE THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:22:22PM I WANT IT TO BE BETTER.
08:22:23PM THIS IS A SMALL INFILL HOME.
08:22:25PM ADDITIONAL INFILL HOME MAKING SURE THIS IS A BEAUTIFUL
08:22:28PM THING.
08:22:29PM I WANT TO TALK OF SINGLE-FAMILY ZONING AND WHY SOMETIMES WE
08:22:32PM COME BACK TO IT, SINGLE-FAMILY ZONING ALWAYS HAD EXPLICITLY
08:22:35PM RACIST ROOTS.
08:22:36PM OWN EQUITY AND DISCRIMINATION PLAN.
08:22:39PM COLOR OF LAW, THE BOOK THAT NEIGHBORHOODS ARE MEANT TO BE
08:22:43PM SEGREGATED AND KEPT WHITE.
08:22:45PM IT WAS INTENTIONAL.
08:22:47PM NEIGHBORS WITH LAWYERS SAYING -- OH, WHATEVER.
08:22:50PM WISH THE NEIGHBORS WOULD SPEND ALL THIS MONEY AND ENERGY
08:22:53PM THEY HAVE TO COME HERE TO SAY, HEY, WHAT IF I FOUND A LOT
08:22:56PM AND -- IN FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN THIS COMMUNITY.
08:22:59PM I FEEL LIKE THE NEIGHBORS ARE CONCERN -- AND
08:23:02PM FIGHTING WITH OTHER NEIGHBORS LOOKING FOR OTHER OPPORTUNITY.
08:23:05PM LAST THING I WANT TO SAY IS THAT I THINK ITS REALLY
08:23:08PM IMPORTANT THAT WHEN WE DECIDE WHAT IS HAPPENING WITH LAND
08:23:10PM USE.
08:23:11PM WE ARE TALKING OF THE FUTURE.
08:23:12PM RIGHT NOW THIS IS A CORNER OVERGROWN.
08:23:14PM DEVELOPER HAS DONE A GREAT JOB OF TAKING CARE OF IT.
08:23:18PM I THINK IT IS BETTER TO SUPPORT THIS AND IGNORE SOME
08:23:22PM NEIGHBORS THAT HAVE LEGAL IDEAS IN THEIR BACK YARD.
08:23:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:23:27PM YES, SIR, STATE YOUR NAME.
08:23:29PM >> SHABAZ KHAN.
08:23:32PM I GO BY SHABBY, LIKE NOT TOO SHABBY.
08:23:35PM I WILL GO QUICK.
08:23:36PM A HARD ABILITY TO FOLLOW.
08:23:37PM I AM IN FAVOR OF THIS DEVELOPMENT.
08:23:39PM I THINK THE DEVELOPER DID A GOOD JOB RESEARCHING IT AND
08:23:43PM HISTORICAL ROUTES AND RESPECT IT AND RESPECT THE
08:23:46PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:23:46PM UP THINK IT WILL PROVIDE TREMENDOUS OPPORTUNITY FOR THEN WHO
08:23:51PM WANTS TO COME TO THIS GREAT CITY OF TAMPA AND HYDE PARK.
08:23:55PM A MOVIE OF "FIELD OF DREAMS" IF YOU BUILD IT, THEY WILL
08:24:00PM COME.
08:24:00PM I WANT GREAT INNOVATION, GREAT MIND AND FABULOUS HEARTS AND
08:24:04PM WHY NOT HERE IN THE GREAT CITY OF TAMPA.
08:24:06PM THAT IS ALL I HAVE TO SPAY.
08:24:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NOT TOO SHABBY.
08:24:11PM >> TOBIN GREEN.
08:24:12PM I LIVE AT 400 SOUTH ORLEANS, JUST ONE BLOCK TO THE PROJECT
08:24:18PM THAT THEY ARE TALKING IT SHALL THE PROPERTY WE ARE TALKING
08:24:21PM ABOUT.
08:24:21PM I LIVE IN DOBYVILLE.
08:24:23PM MY WIFE AND I LIVED HERE ALMOST A DECADE.
08:24:26PM THIS IN ADDITION TO BEING RESIDENTS ACTIVE COMMUNITY MEMBER WITH
08:24:29PM THE HYDE PARK TOWN CIVIC ASSOCIATION.
08:24:34PM MY WIFE AND I HAVE COME TO LOVE OUR NEIGHBORHOOD AND TAKEN
08:24:38PM PERSONAL RISKS AND INVESTED.
08:24:40PM WE FINISHED A TWO-UNIT URBAN TOWN HOME AT THE END OF THE
08:24:44PM BLOCK AND END OF THE YEAR FOR ANOTHER SINGLE-FAMILY HOME
08:24:47PM PROJECT.
08:24:48PM WE ARE INVESTED IN OUR COMMUNITY, OUR NEIGHBORHOOD, AND OUR
08:24:50PM BLOCK.
08:24:51PM PHYSICALLY, FINANCIALLY AND EMOTIONALLY.
08:24:54PM I BUILT HERE WITH MY BARE HAND AND BLEED FOR MY BLOCK.
08:24:59PM I AM NOT AGAINST NEW DEVELOPMENT.
08:25:01PM QUITE THE OPPOSITE, BUT THE DEVELOPMENT WE ARE TALKING ABOUT
08:25:04PM HERE IS MISGUIDED AT BEST.
08:25:06PM I HAVE INDEED HEARD A LOT OF PERSPECTIVES TONIGHT.
08:25:09PM AND MOST OF WHICH I RESPECT.
08:25:11PM UNFORTUNATELY ,THE MOST HARD-FOUGHT AGREEMENT OF NEIGHBOR'S
08:25:16PM HISTORY.
08:25:16PM BEAUTIFUL THING OF HISTORY HOW IT TEACHES US AND HOW WE CAN
08:25:19PM LEARN FROM ITS PAST.
08:25:20PM I DON'T KNOW ABOUT ANY OF YOU GUYS OR ANYBODY ELSE IN THE
08:25:23PM ROOM, HAD THE INCREDIBLE OPPORTUNITY TO SIT WITH ONE OF --
08:25:27PM IF NOT THE LAST MATRIARCH LIVING IN DOBYVILLE MISS ROSE SASS
08:25:33PM LEE BROWN.
08:25:34PM SHE WAS LIVING PART OF HISTORY.
08:25:36PM I WANTED TO LIVE IN HYDE PARK SINCE A KID.
08:25:39PM I HAVE A LOT TO SAY AND SKIP THIS SO I CAN GET IT ALL IN.
08:25:43PM I CAN TELL THAT YOU WHEN I DID GET THE OPPORTUNITY TO BUY
08:25:46PM HERE A DECADE AGO, I ADMITTEDLY KNEW NOTHING OF DOBYVILLE.
08:25:51PM KNEW NOTHING ABOUT IT WHATSOEVER.
08:25:53PM BUT IT WAS MY TIME WITH MISS ROSALIE BROWN HERSELF, WHICH I,
08:25:58PM AGAIN, HAD THE PLEASURE OF SETTING ON HER FRONT PORCH A HALF
08:26:01PM DOZEN TIMES.
08:26:02PM IT WAS HER THAT TAUGHT ME ABOUT THE HISTORY HERE.
08:26:04PM SHE THANKED -- THANKED US FOR BEING HERE AND WELCOMED US TO
08:26:09PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:26:09PM AFTER SEEING THE CITY TURN ITS BACK ON THAT PART OF
08:26:14PM NEIGHBORHOOD FOR SO LONG, WE WERE WELCOMED HERE.
08:26:17PM AND IT REALLY MEANT THE WORLD TO ME.
08:26:19PM I HAD THE GREAT PLEASURE TO SPEAKING WITH MR. DOBY -- MR.
08:26:24PM DOBY'S GREAT, GREAT GRANDDAUGHTER.
08:26:26PM AND ONE OF THE MOST TELL THINGS I HEARD HER SAY WITH -- I
08:26:31PM THINK IT WAS MAYBE HER COUSIN THAT WAS WITH THEM, THE BEST
08:26:34PM THING WE COULD DO IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD TO HONOR RICHARD DOBY
08:26:37PM AND THE PEOPLE WHO LIVED BEFORE TO BUILD IT BACK BETTER THAN
08:26:40PM IT WAS IN THE PAST.
08:26:41PM I THINK ABOUT THAT.
08:26:43PM WE DON'T WANT TO BUILD FAUX VERSIONS OF WHAT USED TO BE
08:26:48PM HERE.
08:26:48PM DOBYVILLE WASN'T FILLED WITH MICRO HOMES BECAUSE IT WAS
08:26:53PM BECAUSE OF SYSTEMIC RACISM.
08:26:55PM HONOR THE HISTORY OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND PEOPLE RESIDED
08:26:57PM HERE IN THE PAST, WE NEED TO TALK OF BUILDING IT BACK BETTER
08:27:00PM THAN IT EVER WAS BEFORE AND NOT MAKE THE SAME SOCIAL
08:27:04PM MISGUIDED MISTAKES THAT WERE MADE DECADES AGO.
08:27:06PM WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOU TO DENY THIS ASK.
08:27:09PM THANK YOU.
08:27:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:27:16PM THAT CONCLUDES PUBLIC COMMENT.
08:27:18PM REBUTTAL.
08:27:19PM MR. VILA, I HAVE A QUESTION FOR YOU.
08:27:22PM SO WE VOTED -- WHEN WAS IT -- JUST OVER TWO YEARS AGO TO
08:27:30PM EXPAND THE BOUNDARIES OR ESTABLISH THE BOUNDARIES OF THE
08:27:32PM HISTORIC DISTRICT.
08:27:33PM IT WAS SHOWN IN ONE OF THE PACKETS, ONE OF THE SPEAKERS THIS
08:27:38PM GENTLEMAN BUILT A HOUSE CIRCA 2020 AND VERY MODERN HOME.
08:27:46PM CAN A HOME LIKE THAT BE BUILT TODAY NOW THAT YOU HAVE THE
08:27:49PM HISTORIC GUIDELINES?
08:27:52PM >>RON VILA: THE SHORT ANSWER IS NO.
08:27:53PM RON VILA WITH HISTORIC PRESERVATION.
08:27:56PM SANBORN MAP FROM 1929.
08:27:58PM I WANT TO ILLUSTRATE HERE, THE HATCHED IN AREA IS THE
08:28:03PM EXPANSION IN 2023.
08:28:05PM ANYTHING AFTER 2023 WILL HAVE TO GO IN FRONT OF THE A IT
08:28:10PM TECHNICAL REVIEW COMMISSION AND GET APPROVAL AND BE KENT
08:28:13PM WITH OUR CRITERIA.
08:28:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THE ARC LOOKED AT EXISTING DESIGN AND
08:28:19PM THAT IS WHAT THE ARC APPROVED?
08:28:21PM >> AT THE TIME ARC LOOKED AT IT, THEIR CHARGE WAS
08:28:25PM CHAPTER 27.113, THEIR DUTIES AND POWERS.
08:28:30PM THIS IS WHAT THEY TOOK INTO CONSIDERATION.
08:28:32PM THE ACTION FOR REZONINGS CHANGES TO LAND USE CLASSIFICATION
08:28:36PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENTS TO REVIEW AND RECOMMEND
08:28:42PM REASONABLE LAND USE TO PRESERVE THE HIS I CAN INTEGRITY AND
08:28:46PM APPEARANCE.
08:28:47PM THAT IS WHAT THEY USED TO BASE THEIR DECISION ON.
08:28:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MY LAST QUESTION IS, IS THERE ANY WAY TO
08:28:53PM CIRCUMVENT OUR CODE AND OUR RULES THAT SOMEONE CAN COME IN
08:28:56PM AND BUILD WHATEVER THEY WANTED?
08:28:59PM >>RON VILA: NO.
08:28:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THEY WOULD BE STOPPED IN THEIR TRACKS?
08:29:02PM >>RON VILA: ABSOLUTELY.
08:29:02PM THEY HAVE TO GET APPROVAL PRIOR TO GET PERMIT.
08:29:05PM SO THERE IS A PROCESS FOR IT.
08:29:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: NOTHING LIKE THE 2020 STRUCTURE COULD BE
08:29:09PM A BELT WITHIN THOSE BOUNDARIES THAT WE HAVE APPROVED?
08:29:13PM >>RON VILA: THAT IS AN ACCURATE STATEMENT.
08:29:14PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:29:20PM COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON --
08:29:23PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I HAVE A QUESTION DURING PUB CHICK
08:29:27PM COMMENT, A LOT OF REFERENCE TO THE SECRETARY OF INTERIOR
08:29:30PM STANDARDS AND VARIOUS CITY OF TAMPA HISTORICAL GUIDELINES.
08:29:33PM SOMEONE WHO HAS GONE THROUGH YOUR PROCESS PAINFULLY BEFORE
08:29:42PM ARE -- I BELIEVE THAT EXTRAPOLATE THAT THE COMPETENT AND
08:29:54PM SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE THAT YOU WEIGHED THE SECRETARY OF
08:29:57PM STANDARDS.
08:29:58PM >>RON VILA: THE SECRETARY OF INTERIOR STANDARDS HAS LITTLE
08:30:01PM VERY BANAL ON NEW CONSTRUCTION.
08:30:03PM IT TALKS OF SETTING AND THE DISTRICT IN GENERAL.
08:30:06PM I HAVE SOME ILLUSTRATIONS IF YOU WOULD LIKE FOR ME TO GO
08:30:09PM THROUGH IT AT THIS TIME.
08:30:10PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SURE.
08:30:11PM ABSOLUTELY.
08:30:12PM >>RON VILA: THE SAME MATERIAL I SHOWED ARC THAT I WILL SHOW
08:30:18PM YOU THIS EVENING.
08:30:19PM THIS IS JUST THE GENERAL OVERHEAD OF SUBJECT SITE.
08:30:23PM YOU SEE THE PROXIMITY TO THE CROSSTOWN.
08:30:25PM AND YOU SEE SOME OF THE DENSITY ACROSS THE STREET AND THE
08:30:28PM FABRIC THAT IS LOW -- LOCATED WITHIN THAT BLOCK.
08:30:35PM THIS IS THE HISTORIC DISTRICT OF HYDE PARK AS ILLUSTRATED IN
08:30:40PM THE RED TO SHOW IT WITHIN THE BOUNDARIES.
08:30:42PM IT IS ON THE NORTHWEST CORNER NOW THIS IS -- THIS IS THE
08:30:48PM CORRECTING STRUCTURE THAT IS ON THE SITE NOW DATES BACK TO
08:30:51PM 1930 WITHIN THE PERIOD.
08:30:53PM SO THIS IS CONTRIBUTING AS I STATED.
08:30:57PM THIS IS THE SIDE SHOT AND THIS -- THIS SHOWS THE CURRENT
08:31:02PM STRUCTURE WITH WHAT IS PROPOSED TO BE THE INFILL AT THIS
08:31:07PM PORTION HERE.
08:31:08PM AND I AM GOING TO SHOW OUT SANBORN MAP IN A MINUTE THAT
08:31:12PM SHOWED THERE WAS A HOUSE HERE IN THE EARLY 1900s.
08:31:15PM THIS WAS BUILT IN THE '20s AND KNOCKED DOWN IN THE '90s
08:31:20PM STYLES.
08:31:20PM THERE WERE TWO HOMES THAT EXISTED AT THIS PARTICULAR SITE.
08:31:24PM THIS IS CONTINUING DOWN THE BLOCK TO THE SOUTH.
08:31:27PM SOME OF THE INVENTORY OUT THERE.
08:31:30PM PERIOD HOMES ADDED ON TO.
08:31:32PM AND NEW CONSTRUCTION AS PART OF THE INFILL.
08:31:35PM THIS INFILL PRODUCTION WILL NOT BE CONSISTENT WITH OUR
08:31:40PM CRITERIA TODAY.
08:31:41PM PARKING IN THE FRONT THAT IS PROHIBITED BY OUR STANDARD.
08:31:44PM GOING BACK TO THE 1929 SANBORN MAP, I WANTED TO ZOOM IN
08:31:52PM HERE.
08:31:52PM THIS IS HYDE PARK.
08:31:53PM YOU SEE THE DENSITY HERE?
08:31:56PM HOW THE STRUCTURES ARE SPACED APART, AND THEN WHEN YOU LOOK
08:32:02PM AT DOBYVILLE, YOU LOOK AT THE CONCENTRATION, HOW THEY ARE
08:32:06PM TOGETHER.
08:32:07PM YOU ZOOM IN THAT AREA, I THINK IT IS IMPORTANT TO FOCUS ON
08:32:14PM THIS PARTICULAR BLOCK HERE.
08:32:17PM IF YOU LOOK AT THE CORNER PARCELS.
08:32:20PM OKAY, THEY ALL HAVE -- THEY ALL FACE -- THE ORIENTATION IS
08:32:24PM ONE WAY FOR THE HOUSES ON EACH BLOCK.
08:32:27PM AND THEN YOU SEE THE CORNER PARCELS THAT THEY ARE INTEGRATED
08:32:31PM WITH ADDITIONAL STRUCTURES.
08:32:31PM THESE ARE DWELLINGS.
08:32:32PM THE D IS DWELLING.
08:32:34PM SINGLE-FAMILY STRUCTURES THAT ARE UNDER DIFFERENT OR
08:32:37PM INSTALLATION.
08:32:37PM SO THESE CORNER PARCELS DO NOT HAVE ALLEY ACCESS AND THESE
08:32:41PM HAVE A SUBSTANDARD DEPTH.
08:32:43PM THIS IS IN 1929.
08:32:46PM ONCE AGAIN, IF YOU LOOK AT THE FRONT YARD, THEY ALL LINE UP
08:32:51PM PRETTY MUCH IN TANDEM.
08:32:52PM THIS IS THE DOCUMENTATION THAT WE USED TO PROVIDE GUIDANCE
08:32:56PM TO THE APPLICANTS AS THEY COME IN.
08:32:58PM LOOK AT THE SEPARATION FROM THE STRUCTURES TO EACH STRUCTURE
08:33:03PM AND LOOK OUTSIDE OF THE DISTRICT.
08:33:05PM MAYBE OVER HERE.
08:33:07PM YOU SEE HOW THEY ARE SPACED OUT MORE GENEROUSLY.
08:33:14PM HERE YOU SEE THE DENSE DOBYVILLE.
08:33:21PM YOU SEE WITHIN EACH BLOCK TWO, YOU HAVE THESE LOTS.
08:33:29PM TWO STRUCTURES ON ONE LOT.
08:33:30PM TWO STRUCTURES ON ONE LOT.
08:33:33PM THERE ARE TWO STRUCTURES ON ONE LOT.
08:33:35PM TWO STRUCTURE ON ONE LOT.
08:33:39PM TWO STRUCTURES ON ONE LOT.
08:33:40PM THIS IS THE PATTERN ESTABLISHED IN DOBYVILLE.
08:33:44PM HOUSE THAT REMOVED IN THE '90s.
08:33:46PM CURRENT HOUSE HERE NOW THAT WAS BUILT IN 1930.
08:33:54PM CONTINUING SHOWING ADDITIONAL ILLUSTRATIONS.
08:33:57PM PROPERTY IN QUESTION HAS THE RED DOT ON IT.
08:34:04PM SO MOVING FROM -- FROM 1929 TO CURRENTLY, YOU SEE THE
08:34:09PM ORIENTATION OF THIS HOUSE THAT FACES WEST.
08:34:12PM THERE IS THE HOUSE BEHIND IT THAT FACES NORTH.
08:34:16PM ONCE AGAIN ON THE CORNERS.
08:34:18PM A STRUCTURE THAT STAYS WEST HERE.
08:34:20PM ONE THAT FACES SOUTH.
08:34:22PM A STRUCTURE THAT FACES EAST HERE.
08:34:24PM AND A STRUCTURE THAT FACES SOUTH HERE.
08:34:26PM MY POINT IS, THAT THESE CORNER PARCELS HAVE BEEN BIFURCATED.
08:34:31PM THEY DON'T HAVE THE ACCESS TO THE ALLEY, AND THEY DON'T HAVE
08:34:35PM THE DEPTH OF SOME OF THE OTHER LOTS.
08:34:36PM THIS IS THE NEW SITE PLAN THAT WAS PRESENTED.
08:34:41PM FOR TODAY TO MEET CURRENT CODE, EACH SINGLE-FAMILY
08:34:44PM STRUCTURES THAT TO HAVE TWO CARS ON-SITE.
08:34:47PM THIS REQUEST CAME FORWARD WITH NO VARIANCES.
08:34:50PM THIS IS THE 1930s STRUCTURE THAT HAS A LITTLE ADDITION.
08:34:55PM THAT SHOWS THE FOOTPRINT WITH TWO PARKING.
08:34:58PM THIS IS THE NEW LINEAR CONSTRUCTION THAT ALSO HAS TWO
08:35:02PM PARKING SPOTS OFF THE STREET.
08:35:04PM THAT IS TO MEET CITY OF TAMPA CODE.
08:35:06PM I'M GOING TO CLOSE WITH THIS HERE.
08:35:09PM THIS IS PART OF THE FILE.
08:35:12PM THIS IS FROM FDOT SHOWING IN 1990, THE SUBJECT SITE HAD THE
08:35:19PM TWO STRUCTURES ON THE SITE.
08:35:21PM AND THAT CONCLUDES MY PORTION OF PRESENTATION.
08:35:23PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SO HE FULLY UNDERSTAND AND YOU GUYS ARE
08:35:31PM THE SUBJECT MATTER EXPERTS ON HISTORICAL PRESERVATION.
08:35:34PM YOU EVALUATE NOT JUST ON THE -- IF I UNDERSTAND YOU
08:35:38PM CORRECTLY, YOU EVALUATE THESE PROBLEMS NOT JUST ON
08:35:42PM ARCHITECTURAL CHARACTERS AND FEATURES BUT ALSO THE PATTERN
08:35:46PM AND THE SETBACKS AND THE -- SO YOU -- IS IT ALL ENCOMPASSING
08:35:51PM OVER -- LOOK AT EACH ONE OF THESE PROBLEMS OF HOW -- LIKE
08:35:54PM YOU JUST DESCRIBED, THESE CORNERS, HOW THEY WERE DEVELOPED.
08:35:59PM THAT PART OF YOUR REVIEW AND EVALUATION OF THIS YOU RECEIVE
08:36:03PM THE ARC ARE APPROVAL?
08:36:06PM >>RON VILA: FOR PD, YOU LOOK FOOTPRINT AND THE MASSING THROUGH THE
08:36:11PM HISTORIC FABRIC.
08:36:13PM SETBACK IS CONSISTENT WITH THE HISTORIC SETBACK WITHIN THAT
08:36:17PM BLOCK AND SETBACKS ARE CLOSE TO THE PROPERTY LINE
08:36:20PM HISTORICALLY ALL THE HOUSES CLOSE TO THE PROPERTY LINE AS
08:36:25PM WELL.
08:36:25PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: PART OF WHAT YOU ARE REQUIRED TO EVALUATE
08:36:28PM WHEN LOOKING AT THESE PROJECTS.
08:36:31PM >>RON VILA: PD HAS INTEGRITY.
08:36:38PM WE LOOK AT THE PATTERNS THAT WERE ESTABLISHED TO MOVE
08:36:41PM FORWARD AND WANT TO COPY THOSE PATTERNS.
08:36:44PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:36:45PM APPRECIATE IT.
08:36:46PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MR. CARLSON.
08:36:48PM >>BILL CARLSON: YOU TALK OF THE PATTERNS, THE STUDY PERIOD
08:36:52PM WHERE IT WAS HISTORICALLY, NOT THE NONCONTRIBUTING
08:36:55PM STRUCTURES BUILT.
08:36:56PM >>RON VILA: ABSOLUTELY.
08:36:59PM WE GO BACK TO THE SANBORN MAPS AND HISTORIC REFERENCING THAT
08:37:03PM WE CAN.
08:37:03PM WE TRY TO ELIMINATE SOME OF THE NONCONTRIBUTING STRUCTURES
08:37:07PM BUILT IN THE '60s AND '70s.
08:37:09PM THEY DIDN'T HAVE THE CRITERIA THAT WE DO TODAY.
08:37:13PM >>BILL CARLSON: WHAT HAPPENS IF ONE OF THESE NONCONTRIBUTING
08:37:16PM STRUCTURES IN AN ADJACENT PROPERTY, IF THEY CAME BACK TO
08:37:20PM MAKE MAJOR CHANGES TO IT.
08:37:22PM WILL THEY BE FORCED TO REBUILD TO THIS NEW STANDARD OR.
08:37:28PM >>RON VILA: IF THERE IS A NONCONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE LOOK AT
08:37:33PM THE SCALE AND MASSING AND WREN IT WAS BUILT.
08:37:35PM WE DON'T MAKE THEM GO BACK TO 1920s.
08:37:38PM >>BILL CARLSON: IF A BUILDING GOT KNOCKED DOWN, WOULD THEY
08:37:41PM THEN HAVE TO FOLLOW THE NEW STANDARDS.
08:37:43PM >>RON VILA: YES, SIR, ABSOLUTELY.
08:37:46PM YES, SIR.
08:37:47PM >>BILL CARLSON: AND CONSIDERING THE RESEARCH YOU DID ON THIS
08:37:51PM ADDITIONAL HOUSE, FROM THE -- FROM THE SANBORN MAP, IT WAS
08:37:56PM IT A SEPARATE LOT?
08:37:58PM WAS IT SEPARATELY DESIGNATED AND TITLED?
08:38:02PM TWO DIFFERENT OWNERS?
08:38:03PM DO YOU KNOW?
08:38:08PM AND MY LAST QUESTION WHILE YOU ARE LOOKING THAT UP.
08:38:12PM YOU HEARD THAT PARKING IN THE BACK IS A REQUIREMENT.
08:38:15PM >>RON VILA: SAY THAT AGAIN?
08:38:17PM >>BILL CARLSON: PARKING IN THE BACK IS A REQUIREMENT.
08:38:19PM >>RON VILA: BEHIND THE FRONT YARD SETBACK.
08:38:21PM WHERE THE PORCH IS, TWO CARS.
08:38:23PM THE CARS SHOULD BE SUBORDINATE TO THE STRUCTURES AND
08:38:27PM CHALLENGING LOTS, HE DOES NOT HAVE ALLEY ACCESS.
08:38:31PM I TRIED TO SHOW IN THE DEMOCRAT ADMINISTRATION NO VEHICULAR
08:38:34PM ACCESS FROM THE REAR BUT FROM THE PRIMARY STREET.
08:38:37PM >>BILL CARLSON: THE CURRENT ACTUAL IT -- PARKING LOT IN
08:38:42PM FRONT.
08:38:42PM >>RON VILA: THAT WOULD NOT BE COMPATIBLE WITH OUR CRITERIA.
08:38:46PM >>BILL CARLSON: THE HOUSE THERE RIGHT NOW YOU SAID IS A
08:38:49PM CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE.
08:38:50PM DOESN'T HAVE A THINKS TORIC DESIGNATION.
08:38:55PM >> CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE WITHIN THE HISTORIC DISTRICT.
08:38:58PM IT HAS PROTECTION.
08:39:00PM >>BILL CARLSON: CAN THEY MOVE IT?
08:39:01PM A LITTLE BIT WITHIN THE LOT?
08:39:03PM >>RON VILA: AND CAN MOVE IT SOMEWHERE HE WAS.
08:39:05PM WE LOOK AT REQUESTS THAT COME IN.
08:39:07PM DEMOLITION IS THE WORSE THING TO HAPPEN WITH THE
08:39:10PM CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE.
08:39:11PM WE LOSE THAT FABRIC.
08:39:12PM VERY LOCATION.
08:39:13PM IF THEY HAD VISIONS OF DOING SOMETHING MORE GRAND ON THAT
08:39:16PM SITE, WE WOULD TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION.
08:39:19PM WE MOVED HOUSES IN YBOR CITY AND HYDE PARK AS WELL.
08:39:25PM >>BILL CARLSON: THE DESIGNATION PARTICULARLY FOR DOBYVILLE,
08:39:28PM ANY KEEP OF OVERRIDING STATEMENT OR MISSION STATEMENT.
08:39:33PM >>RON VILA: PART OF THE OVERALL HYDE PARK DISTRICT.
08:39:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
08:39:40PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YOU SAID SOMETHING MORE GRAND.
08:39:42PM WHAT I AM HEARING THAT DOBYVILLE WAS NOT A GRAND
08:39:45PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:39:45PM A MODEST NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:39:47PM WOULD THAT BE IN -- IF SOMEBODY CAME TO YOU AND WANTED TO
08:39:51PM BUILD A GRAND STATELY SOUTH OF SWANN TPD OF HOME, WOULD YOU
08:39:56PM FIND THAT APPROPRIATE.
08:39:57PM >>RON VILA: I THINK IT WOULD BE INCONSISTENT WITH THE FABRIC ALONG
08:40:00PM THAT BLOCK.
08:40:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THAT IS WHAT I WAS THINKING.
08:40:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU, MR. VILA.
08:40:05PM OKAY, MR. MICHELINI, YOU AND YOUR CLIENT FOR REBUTTAL.
08:40:08PM YOU HAVE FIVE MINUTES.
08:40:09PM >> QUITE HONESTLY --
08:40:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME AGAIN.
08:40:31PM >> I AM PERPLEXED THAT SOMEONE WILL COME UP AFTER THE ARC
08:40:37PM AND SAID THAT IS CONSISTENT.
08:40:38PM WE WENT THROUGH THE WHOLE EVALUATION.
08:40:40PM WE SPENT ALMOST A YEAR WORKING WITH THE -- WORKING WITH
08:40:44PM THE ARC STAFF TO COME UP WITH A PLAN THAT WAS CONSISTENT
08:40:46PM WITH THEIR GUIDELINES.
08:40:48PM WE WORKED WITH THE CITY STAFF AND ZONING.
08:40:53PM AND I'M APPALLED FOR THEM TO SAYS IT NOT CONSISTENT WITH
08:40:57PM ZONING OR VIOLATES ALL THESE OTHER CODES OR THAT IT VIOLATES
08:41:01PM THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S LAND USE DESIGNATION.
08:41:04PM YOU HAD JENNIFER COME UP AND TELL YOU IT IS CONSISTENT.
08:41:06PM LACHONE SAID IT WAS CONSISTENT AND RON VILA COME UP AND SAID
08:41:15PM IT WAS CONSISTENT.
08:41:16PM WE ARE ADJACENT ON THE VERY NORTH SIDE TO THE CROSSTOWN
08:41:20PM EXPRESSWAY.
08:41:21PM AND -- I WANT TO SHOW YOU A COUPLE OF PICTURES.
08:41:25PM THEY HAVE THROWN AROUND ISSUE OF GREEN SPACE.
08:41:28PM BOTH OF THESE LOTS EXCEED THE REQUIREMENTS FOR GREEN SPACE.
08:41:31PM 710 SQUARE FEET IS REQUIRED.
08:41:34PM AND WE ARE PROVIDING 1367 SQUARE FEET ON THE ONE DWELLING.
08:41:39PM AND 531 SQUARE IS REQUIRED AND PROVIDING 567 ON THE OTHER.
08:41:47PM LET ME JUST DRAW YOUR ATTENTION TO A COUPLE OF THINGS.
08:41:53PM WE ARE MIMICKING THIS DESIGN ADJACENT TO IT.
08:41:57PM THIS WAS SO OVER GROWN YOU COULDN'T SEE THE HOUSE THIS THOSE
08:42:06PM INDIVIDUALS CAME FORWARD AND TOLD YOU THEY SUPPORTED THIS
08:42:08PM PROBABLY.
08:42:08PM DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET IS A TOWN HOUSE PROJECT.
08:42:12PM THIS IS THE -- THIS IS THE SUBJECT PROPERTY HERE.
08:42:16PM THERE IS THE TOWN HOUSES.
08:42:19PM THIS IS WHAT AZEELE LOOKS LIKE LOOKING EASTWARD.
08:42:25PM SUBJECT PROPERTY.
08:42:26PM CROSSTOWN EXPRESSWAY AUTHORITY HERE.
08:42:29PM SUBJECT PROPERTY HERE.
08:42:33PM DEAD-END INTO AZEELE AND THE CROSSTOWN.
08:42:37PM ANOTHER VIEW.
08:42:38PM SUBJECT PROPERTY HERE.
08:42:40PM TOWN HOUSES OVER HERE.
08:42:42PM SUBJECT PROPERTY.
08:42:45PM HERE.
08:42:46PM AERIAL PHOTOGRAPH SHOWING YOU THE PROXIMITY OF TOWN HOUSES.
08:42:53PM THE SMALLER LOTS ALL AROUND THAT RON VILA POINTED OUT TO
08:42:59PM YOU.
08:42:59PM SUBJECT PROPERTY IS HERE.
08:43:00PM CROSSTOWN IS RIGHT HERE.
08:43:02PM THIS AREA IS NOT THIS.
08:43:05PM AND THE PEOPLE WHO CAME UP AND SPOKE TO YOU FROM SOUTH
08:43:08PM ORLEANS AND FROM OTHER AREAS IN HYDE PARK WANT DOBYVILLE --
08:43:14PM WHICH WILL BE INCONSISTENT TO DEVELOP SOMETHING LIKE THIS --
08:43:18PM SIMPLY DOESN'T WORK.
08:43:19PM WE HAVE GIVEN YOU THE BOUNDARIES.
08:43:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE ZOOM OUT.
08:43:25PM >> THIS PROPERTY IS LOCATE JUST DOWN HERE.
08:43:38PM ANYWAY, WE HAVE GONE THROUGH THE PROCESS.
08:43:43PM WE HAVE MET THE CRITERIA.
08:43:45PM THERE ARE NO WAIVERS BEING REQUESTED.
08:43:47PM WE HAVE BEEN FOUND CONSISTENT BY ALL OF THE REVIEWING
08:43:51PM AGENCIES.
08:43:51PM WE CANNOT WAIVE DRAINAGE.
08:43:54PM I KNOW THAT IS A BIG ISSUE THESE DAYS.
08:43:58PM YOU HAVE TO MEET DRAINAGE.
08:44:00PM NO WAIVERS ALLOWED FOR THAT.
08:44:01PM NO EXCEPTIONS.
08:44:02PM WITH RESPECT TO THE LOTS, YOU KNOW, WE HAVE DEMONSTRATED
08:44:07PM THAT THEY WERE THERE.
08:44:08PM THAT THE HOUSING WAS THERE.
08:44:11PM IT IS AN APPROPRIATE USE AT AN APPROPRIATE LOCATION AND
08:44:14PM A SENSITIVE USE.
08:44:16PM WE STILL HAVE TO GO THROUGH THE ARC FOR ALL THE DESIGN WORK.
08:44:20PM ONE OF THE SPEAKERS CAME UP AND TALKING TO BUT DESIGNS.
08:44:24PM THAT IS PREMATURE.
08:44:26PM WE HAVEN'T GOT TO THAT POINT.
08:44:27PM ZONING HAS TO BE APPROVED FIRST AND THEN WE CAN START
08:44:30PM APPLYING TO THE CRA FOR DESIGN CRITERIA MAKE SURE WE ARE
08:44:36PM COMPATIBLE.
08:44:37PM WE WILL SHOW YOU WHAT WE WOULD LIKE TO HAVE IT LOOK LIKE.
08:44:39PM AND -- SO WE PLAN TO HAVE A VERY ATTRACTIVE INFILL PIECE
08:44:46PM THAT LOOKS LIKE THE OTHER HOUSES THAT WERE INFILL PIECES.
08:44:50PM AND WHEN RON VILA SHOWED YOU THERE WERE TWO HOUSE ON ALL
08:44:54PM THOSE CORNER LOTS.
08:44:56PM THIS IS THE SAME THING.
08:44:57PM WE ARE PROPOSING TWO HOUSES ON THE CORNER LOT, WHICH IS
08:45:00PM CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT GUIDELINES, DEVELOPMENT
08:45:04PM PATTERN OF DOBYVILLE AND PROTECTS IT.
08:45:06PM IT DOESN'T DO ANYTHING TO HURT IT.
08:45:08PM YOU WANT TO SAY SOMETHING?
08:45:11PM >> NO, STEVE IS GREAT.
08:45:12PM THANK YOU, STEVE.
08:45:13PM >> WE APPRECIATE IT.
08:45:15PM WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL.
08:45:17PM AS I SAID, WE HAVE BEEN THROUGH THE DUE DILIGENCE AND SPENT
08:45:23PM A LOT OF TIME TO MAKE SURE WE DOTTED EVERY I AND CROSSED
08:45:27PM EVERY T REGARDING REGULATIONS THAT GOVERN IT.
08:45:30PM DOBYVILLE IS NOT SOUTH OF SWANN.
08:45:33PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:45:35PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MOTION TO CLOSE.
08:45:36PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SECOND.
08:45:38PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
08:45:40PM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
08:45:42PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THIS IS A REALLY INTERESTING CASE.
08:45:45PM AND I WILL BE HONEST YOU WITH, I -- YOU KNOW, I -- OBVIOUSLY
08:45:49PM I DO MY RESEARCH AND I LOOK AT ALL THESE DOCUMENTS AND
08:45:53PM EVERYTHING AHEAD OF TIME, BUT, OF COURSE, WE KEEP AN OPEN
08:45:57PM MIND AND WALK IN AND LISTEN TO THE TESTIMONY.
08:45:59PM BUT I HAD MY THOUGHTS.
08:46:00PM AND I THOUGHT WHEN I FIRST LOOKED AT THIS CASE, OH, THESE
08:46:03PM PEOPLE ARE CRAZY COMING IN HERE ASKING FOR THIS REZONING FOR
08:46:07PM THIS PROPERTY ON A LOT THAT IS -- THAT THIS -- THIS SMALL.
08:46:11PM BUT THEN I -- I LISTENED TO THE PRESENTATIONS.
08:46:14PM I LISTEN TO THE COMPETENT SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE.
08:46:17PM QUITE HONESTLY -- I KNOW THIS IS GOING TO SURPRISE A LOT
08:46:21PM PEOPLE BECAUSE THEY KNOW MY POSITION ON A LOT THESE ISSUES
08:46:24PM ESPECIALLY WITH PDs AND I AM NOT IN FAVOR OF LOT SPLITS AND
08:46:28PM OVERDEVELOPMENT.
08:46:29PM AND THIS IS PROBABLY GOING TO SHOCK MR. MICHELINI AS MUCH AS
08:46:33PM ANYBODY ELSE, BUT I THINK THIS IS A REASONABLE REQUEST.
08:46:36PM WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT PATTERN OF THE
08:46:40PM NEIGHBORHOOD.
08:46:40PM AND WE SAW THE COMPETENT SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE FROM -- FROM
08:46:46PM -- RON REPRESENTS THE ARC WHO -- I TELL YOU THAT IS A TOUGH
08:46:50PM -- TOUGH STAFF AND GOOD TO GET THROUGH WHEN THEY LOOK
08:46:54PM AT THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT PATTERN AND HOUSES THAT
08:46:58PM EXISTED THERE DURING THAT HISTORICAL TIME PERIOD 1896 TO
08:47:04PM 1933.
08:47:05PM BOTH OF THESE EXISTING CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURES EXISTED AND
08:47:12PM THERE WAS A CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE THAT WE LOST THAT WAS
08:47:15PM THERE DURING THAT PERIOD OF TIME.
08:47:17PM MAKE SENSE AND CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE IT IS THEY ARE
08:47:20PM CONTRIBUTING OR NONCONTRIBUTING ON THIS BLOCK OR ADJACENT.
08:47:31PM IT IS AN ADDED AREA.
08:47:32PM THEY ARE ACCOMMODATING OFF-STREET PARKING WHICH WOULD HAVE
08:47:36PM OPINION ONE OF MY BIGGEST OBJECTIONS.
08:47:39PM I'M FAMILIAR WITH AREA AND I KNOW THAT PARKING IS A PROBLEM.
08:47:42PM SO THE FACT THEY ARE ABLE TO ACCOMMODATE THE PARKING ON-SITE
08:47:46PM WITH THIS DEVELOPMENT IS -- I THINK IT IS ADMIRABLE.
08:47:50PM I THINK THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE TO THROUGH THE ARC FOR THE
08:47:54PM DESIGN STANDARDS FOR THE HISTORICAL NEIGHBORHOOD AND I HAVE
08:47:58PM FULL FAITH AND CONFIDENCE THAT THE FOLKS THAT ARE CHARGED
08:48:01PM WITH THAT TASK WILL DO WHAT THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO DO.
08:48:03PM AND, AGAIN, THIS WAS A TOUGH ONE.
08:48:06PM I AM TELL YOU, I TOTALLY -- THIS IS WHY WE LISTEN TO THE
08:48:10PM COMPETENT SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE WHEN WE WALK IN HERE.
08:48:13PM I LISTENED TO THE EVIDENCE.
08:48:16PM I LISTEN CAREFULLY AND FAMILIAR ENOUGH WITH THE RULES AND
08:48:19PM REGULATIONS THAT THERE IS REALLY ONLY ONE WAY TO GO AND THAT
08:48:24PM IS TO SUPPORT THE REQUEST.
08:48:25PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
08:48:28PM ALL RIGHT, THEN WHO WISHES TO READ THIS ITEM.
08:48:31PM COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON.
08:48:32PM YOU WERE UP.
08:48:33PM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
08:48:34PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I MUST HAVE CHANGED MY MIND WITHOUT
08:48:37PM SAYING A WORD FIVE TIMES.
08:48:38PM I HEARD FROM ONE SIDE, IT WAS WONDERFUL.
08:48:41PM HEARD FROM OTHER.
08:48:41PM IT WAS WONDERFUL.
08:48:42PM I HEARD SPEECHES FROM BOTH SIDES.
08:48:45PM IT WAS WONDERFUL.
08:48:45PM PEOPLE NOT CRITICIZING EACH OTHER, THAT IS WONDERFUL.
08:48:48PM AND IT COMES TO -- THEN BE MR. VILA COMES UP.
08:48:52PM AND SAID SOMETHING I NEVER HEARD HIM SAY.
08:48:55PM IT WAS ACTUALLY FOR SOMETHING.
08:48:57PM EVERY TIME HE COMES HERE, HE IS AGAINST SOMETHING.
08:49:00PM I WILL BE HONEST YOU WITH.
08:49:01PM I KNOWN MR. VILA -- I AM NOT GOING TO SAY HOW OLD HE IS.
08:49:06PM BUT IT IS ALSO THAT YOU FEEL THAT BOTH SIDES ARE RIGHT, AND
08:49:10PM HOW CAN ANYBODY BE WRONG.
08:49:11PM BOTH SIDES WERE WRONG AND HOW CAN ANYBODY BE RIGHT.
08:49:14PM ONE OF THE TWO.
08:49:15PM BUT I KNOW THE STANDARD WE SET.
08:49:19PM WHEN YOU TALK OF THE CARS, IT IS PARKED FROM BASE OF THE
08:49:24PM FRONT OF THE HOUSE TO THE BACK.
08:49:25PM NOT IN FRONT OF THE HOUSE.
08:49:27PM SO IMPLORE THAN LIKELY GOING TO SUPPORT IF SOMEBODY MAKES A
08:49:31PM MOTION.
08:49:31PM NOT MY TURN TO SPEAK.
08:49:33PM MOTION TO GO TO -- REALLY WHEN THEY GO TO THE ARC, YOU
08:49:37PM REALLY GOT TO BE PREPARED.
08:49:38PM AND YOU GOT TO BE PREPARED BOTH SIDE WERE VERY WELL PREPARED
08:49:42PM FOR BOTH OF US.
08:49:43PM FOR ALL OF US.
08:49:43PM BUT THIS IS NOT EASY.
08:49:46PM NOT AT ALL.
08:49:48PM BUT I GUESS THAT IS WHY WE GOT ELECTED TO DO WHAT WE THINK
08:49:53PM IS RIGHT.
08:49:53PM NOT THAT I LIKE IT 200%.
08:49:56PM BUT I FEEL THEY HAVE DO WHAT THE LAW REQUIRES US TO DO.
08:50:00PM AND IT IS INCUMBENT TO SO HE BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT THAT
08:50:11PM THERE COULD BE -- AND ARC WILL DO THEIR JOB AND I AM SURE
08:50:17PM THEY WILL.
08:50:17PM I'M LOOKING TO SAY -- IT HAS BEEN VERY HARD TO MAKE A
08:50:20PM DECISION, BECAUSE IN THIS CASE, I HEARD TESTIMONY FROM BOTH
08:50:23PM SIDE THAT -- PEOPLE THAT I REALLY VALUE WHAT THEY SAY.
08:50:28PM AND TO MAKE A DECISION.
08:50:30PM SO I WILL BE MORE LIKELY SUPPORTING THIS.
08:50:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILWOMAN HENDERSON.
08:50:35PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: THANK YOU, CHAIR.
08:50:36PM MY MIND IS SAYING, GWEN DON'T SAY IT.
08:50:44PM BUT, I DON'T KNOW, I WAS THINKING OF THE HISTORIC HYDE PARK
08:50:50PM NEIGHBORHOOD SOCIAL DISTANCING WHEN THEY CREATED THEIR RULES
08:50:54PM AND REGULATIONS FOR HOUSING IN THE COMMUNITY.
08:50:57PM AND WHEN IT CAME TO DOBYVILLE.
08:50:59PM DID THEY FEET TO -- TO REALLY VALUE THE HISTORIC NATURE OF
08:51:06PM DOBYVILLE.
08:51:07PM IN THIS -- IN THIS SPACE TO NOW OCCUPY THIS SPACE IN A WAY
08:51:16PM THAT THE -- THAT THE DEVELOPERS ARE REQUESTING.
08:51:19PM I THINK WHEN I HEARD ONE OF THE MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY WHO
08:51:25PM IS AGAINST THE PROBABLY SAY GHETTO AND SERVANTS, I HAD TO
08:51:30PM GET UP AND LEAVE AND GATHER MYSELF.
08:51:32PM BECAUSE THERE IS SOME TRUTH TO THAT.
08:51:37PM UNFORTUNATELY, THERE IS.
08:51:39PM MR. DOBY'S HOUSE, IN FACT, PROBABLY WAS CONSIDERED, YOU
08:51:44PM KNOW, THE MAN SON WHO OF THE PARTICULAR AREA AT THE TIME --
08:51:48PM MANSION OF THE PARTICULAR AREA AT THE TIME.
08:51:51PM I BELIEVE I BELIEVE THAT THE PROJECT IS EXTREMELY THOUGHTFUL
08:51:55PM TO THE CHARACTER OF WHAT DOBYVILLE WAS.
08:51:57PM AND THE -- ONE OF THE PEOPLE WHO SPOKE AGAINST THE PROBABLY
08:52:04PM SAID IT IS NOT APPROPRIATE ANYMORE.
08:52:06PM NOW THAT WORD "ANYMORE" DEFINES THE GENTRIFICATION OF YOUR
08:52:14PM COMMUNITY.
08:52:14PM BECAUSE "ANYMORE" WOULD BE CORRECT.
08:52:19PM YOU CAN'T BUILD WHAT YOU ONCE CREATED AS A COMMUNITY OF
08:52:24PM HOUSING FOR SERVANTS IN THE GHETTO.
08:52:28PM YOU CAN'T DO THAT ANYMORE BECAUSE THAT IS NOT WHAT WE WANT.
08:52:31PM SO I AM JUST ACTUALLY PRETTY PLEASED ABOUT THE LEVEL OF WORK
08:52:37PM THAT WENT INTO THE PRESENTATION OF THE DEVELOPER TO BRING IT
08:52:41PM BACK TO THIS NICE LITTLE TINY HOME OPPORTUNITY IN DOBYVILLE
08:52:51PM BECAUSE DOBYVILLE, IN MY MIND IS VERY DIFFICULT TO FIND.
08:52:55PM YOU HAVE TO KIND OF SEARCH FOR IT WITHIN THE BLOCKS OF, YOU
08:53:02PM KNOW, WHAT IS CLASSIFIED AS DOBYVILLE.
08:53:06PM IT -- IT MAKES ME QUESTION EVEN WITH THE PEOPLE WHO GOT UP
08:53:12PM AND SPOKE TODAY, DOES ANY BLACK PEOPLE LIVE IN THIS
08:53:16PM NEIGHBORHOOD THAT OWN HOMES?
08:53:19PM AND SO THE PEOPLE WHO ARE FIGHTING FOR IT, I REALLY
08:53:23PM APPRECIATE IT, BECAUSE THAT IS SO RARE IN SOUTH TAMPA, THAT
08:53:27PM YOU ALL WANT SOMETHING.
08:53:29PM AND I REALLY APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS TOWARD THAT.
08:53:33PM FOR THOSE WHO SPOKE AGAINST IT, IT -- IT CLEARLY SAYS TO ME
08:53:38PM THAT THE MIND SET THAT DOBYVILLE IS GONE.
08:53:54PM >> WHAT I COULD HEAR IN A LOT OF PRESENTATIONS.
08:53:56PM EVEN THOUGH YOU WERE SAILING THAT YOU WANT TO RESPECT IT.
08:53:59PM IF YOU DID, THEN I BELIEVE THAT THE CHARACTER OF IT BEING
08:54:04PM THE SERVANT QUARTERS THAT IT WAS COULD BE REPLICATED IN A
08:54:09PM VERY THOUGHTFUL WAY THAT IS MODERNIZED, AND I BELIEVE THAT
08:54:14PM DEVELOPER MET THE CRITERIA TODAY AND I WILL BE SUPPORTING
08:54:17PM IT.
08:54:17PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: DO YOU WANT TO READ IT?
08:54:20PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: IT IS NOT MY TURN, AND I DON'T WANT TO
08:54:25PM JUMP THE GUN.
08:54:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
08:54:29PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: SURE.
08:54:30PM SO I AM GOING TO MOVE FILE NUMBER REZ 24 104, ORDER
08:54:35PM CONTINUES INTO FOR FIRST CONSIDERATION REZONING PROPERTY IN
08:54:38PM 402 SOUTH OREGON AVENUE IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, MORE
08:54:43PM PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED EXCEPTION 1, RM-12 RESIDENTIAL
08:54:47PM MULTIFAMILY TO PD, RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED
08:54:51PM PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
08:54:53PM >> SECOND.
08:54:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ROLL CALL VOTE.
08:54:56PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
08:54:57PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
08:54:58PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
08:55:01PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
08:55:03PM >>BILL CARLSON: NO.
08:55:05PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
08:55:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
08:55:10PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED WITH CARLSON VOTING NO.
08:55:14PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MARCH 27, 2025
08:55:18PM AT 10 A.M. LOCATED 315 E. KENNEDY, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA,
08:55:24PM FLORIDA, 36602.
08:55:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WOULD YOU ALL LIKE A FIVE-MINUTE RECESS.
08:55:30PM WE WILL BE IN RECESS FOR FIVE TO SEVEN MINUTES.
09:12:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE TO WAIT FOR THE CLERK.
09:12:08PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WILL BE THE CLERK.
09:12:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE ARE WAITING FOR THE OTHER CLERK.
09:12:25PM TELL ME WHEN YOU ARE GOOD TO GO.
09:12:27PM ARE WE GOOD?
09:12:30PM ALL RIGHT.
09:12:30PM [GAVEL SOUNDING]
09:12:34PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I WOULD LIKE TO CALL THIS TAMPA CITY
09:12:37PM COUNCIL MEETING TO ORDER.
09:12:38PM ROLL CALL PLEASE.
09:12:40PM >>BILL CARLSON: HERE.
09:12:41PM >>LYNN HURTAK: HERE.
09:12:42PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: HERE.
09:12:43PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: PRESENT.
09:12:45PM >>LUIS VIERA: HERE.
09:12:47PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: HERE.
09:12:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: HERE.
09:12:49PM >>CLERK: WE HAVE A PHYSICAL QUORUM.
09:12:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER 6.
09:12:55PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:12:57PM ITEM 6 FOR THE PROPERTY AT 2902 MELBOURNE BOULEVARD.
09:13:05PM REQUEST FROM RM-16 RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY AND CI TO CG,
09:13:12PM COMMERCIAL GENERAL AND TURN IT OVER TO MISS MALONE TO GIVE
09:13:15PM HER REPORT.
09:13:16PM >>JENNIFER MALONE: GOOD EVENING, CITY COUNCIL.
09:13:19PM JENNIFER MALONE WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
09:13:22PM THE AERIAL OF THE SUBJECT SITE LOCATED AT THE INTERSTATE 4
09:13:26PM AND NORTH 50th STREET INTERCHANGE.
09:13:28PM THERE IS SOME RESIDENTIAL USES IN THE SURROUNDING AREA, AS
09:13:32PM WELL AS SOME COMMERCIAL USES WHICH ARE REFLECTED WHEN YOU
09:13:35PM LOOK AT THE FUTURE LAND USE.
09:13:37PM IT IS ALSO IN THE EAST TAMPA URBAN VILLAGE.
09:13:40PM FUTURE LAND USE IS COMMUNITY COMMERCIAL 35 THAT ALLOWS FOR
09:13:44PM RESIDENTIAL BUT ALSO SOME INTENSIVE COMMERCIAL USES.
09:13:48PM THIS APPLICANT IS ASKING FOR COMMERCIAL GENERAL WHICH IS NOT
09:13:51PM EVEN AS INTENSE AS THEY COULD GO.
09:13:54PM SO A NICE -- IT WILL FIT NICELY WITH THE INTENT OF THE
09:13:59PM FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY.
09:14:00PM PATTERN OF THE SURROUNDING AREA ESPECIALLY SINCE GIVEN THE
09:14:07PM SURROUNDING ZONING AND DEVELOPMENT PATTERN.
09:14:09PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FOUND THE PROPOSED CG IS
09:14:12PM COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE WITH THE AREA AND ALLOW FOR INFILL
09:14:15PM DEVELOPMENT AND REDEVELOPMENT OF A MOSTLY VACANT SITE WHICH
09:14:19PM IS CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.
09:14:21PM THANK YOU.
09:14:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
09:14:22PM YES, MA'AM.
09:14:28PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, LaCHONE DOCK, DEVELOPMENT
09:14:31PM COORDINATION.
09:14:31PM NO SITE PLAN.
09:14:32PM IT IS A EUCLIDIAN REQUEST.
09:14:34PM PROPERTY CONTAINS 46,173 SQUARE FEET APPROXIMATELY.
09:14:39PM THIS IS THE SURVEY SUBMITTED BY THE APPLICANT.
09:14:42PM THE SUBJECT SITE IS OUTLINED IN BLUE.
09:14:45PM THIS IS 49th STREET.
09:14:48PM THIS IS EAST 18th AVENUE.
09:14:50PM AND YOU CAN SEE THIS IS THE WESTERN BOUNDARY OF THE SITE.
09:14:58PM YOU CAN SEE 200 FEET ON THE WEST.
09:15:05PM LARGE PARCEL WITH 330 ON THE EAST.
09:15:09PM SO THE SOUTH IS 280 FEET AND BOUNDARY TO THE NORTH HAVE 408
09:15:14PM FEET.
09:15:15PM WITH THE REQUESTED ZONING, MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT ALLOWABLE
09:15:18PM WOULD BE 45 FEET.
09:15:19PM AND THIS IS THE ZONING MAP OF THE PROPERTY.
09:15:23PM SO THIS IS THE PROPERTY WE IS OUTLINED IN RED.
09:15:26PM THESE ARE THE INDIVIDUAL PARCELS WITHIN THE OVERALL.
09:15:31PM BUT THE OUTSIDE BOUNDARY IS THAT PROPERTY PRE.
09:15:34PM SO YOU CAN SEE ALONG -- THIS IS MELBOURNE.
09:15:37PM AND I-40 -- I-40 TO THE SOUTH.
09:15:46PM NORTH OF THE SITE OF CG COMMERCIAL GENERAL.
09:15:50PM HOTEL USE.
09:15:51PM HE WILL SHOW YOU PICTURES.
09:15:52PM GAS STATION WITH THE COMMERCIAL USE ALONG THIS SEGMENT OF
09:15:56PM MELBOURNE.
09:15:57PM AS YOU MOVE FURTHER WEST AND NORTHWEST OF YOUR SITE, YOU GET
09:16:00PM INTO YOUR RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY DEVELOPMENT.
09:16:02PM SOUTH OF THE SITE, YOU HAVE A COMMERCIAL USE, A HOTEL TO THE
09:16:06PM SOUTH.
09:16:06PM AND THEN YOU HAVE RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY ZONING AND USES TO
09:16:11PM THE WEST.
09:16:11PM THEN I HAVE PICTURES OF THE SITE TO SHOW.
09:16:16PM OUT THE SITE VISUALLY, HARD TO TELL THE PROPERTY BOUNDARY
09:16:21PM BECAUSE NOT A COMPLETELY SEPARATE PARCEL.
09:16:23PM WHEN YOU ENTERED THE SITE, THIS PARKING AREA IS REALLY JUST
09:16:29PM SPLIT.
09:16:29PM THIS IS THE BEGINNING OF THE PARCEL.
09:16:30PM SO WE WILL START AT THE NORTH END OF THE SITE, MAKE OUR WAY
09:16:35PM AROUND THE EAST, TO THE SOUTH.
09:16:36PM COME AROUND TO THE WEST AND THEN TO THE NORTH AND CIRCLE
09:16:39PM BACK TO THE SITE AGAIN.
09:16:40PM SO THIS IS THE SITE.
09:16:44PM THIS IS THE EAST END OF THE SITE.
09:16:45PM THIS IS THE VEHICULAR ENTRANCE TO THE SITE.
09:16:47PM THAT IS THE HOTEL THAT EXISTS THERE, THE ROADWAY INN.
09:16:53PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW.
09:16:54PM THE CLOSE-UP OF ENTRY OF THE SITE SO THE SUBJECT SITE IS
09:16:58PM HERE ON THIS SITE.
09:17:03PM THIS IS THE VIEW INTERNAL TO THE SITE THAT IS JUST THE
09:17:06PM NORTH.
09:17:07PM NORTH OF THE SITE.
09:17:08PM SO THIS IS CIRCUMSTANCE LENGTH EAST OF THE SITE.
09:17:11PM THIS IS THE SOUTHEAST PORTION OF THE SITE.
09:17:13PM THIS IS LOOKING SOUTH.
09:17:15PM THIS IS HEADED FURTHER SOUTH AND THIS IS TO THE SOUTH END.
09:17:24PM WE ARE ON 18th AVENUE HOOKING AT THE SITE.
09:17:27PM THIS IS SOUTH SUBJECT SITE AND THE HOTEL AND THE ENTRANCE TO
09:17:34PM THE HOTEL.
09:17:35PM THIS IS LOOK HAD WEST ON EAST 18th AVENUE.
09:17:41PM THIS IS ON EAST 18th AVENUE, SOUTHWEST OF THE SITE.
09:17:47PM ANOTHER VIEW.
09:17:50PM THIS IS THE WEST END OF THE SITE WHICH, OF COURSE, IS
09:17:59PM HEAVILY WOODED HERE.
09:18:01PM THIS WEST OF SITE.
09:18:03PM THE WE WERE PORTION OF IT.
09:18:04PM ANOTHER VIEW LEFT TO THE NORTH.
09:18:12PM ANOTHER VIEW OF, WEST END AND CIRCLING BACK TO THE SITE, THE
09:18:23PM HOTEL THERE.
09:18:24PM SUBJECT SITE.
09:18:25PM AND ANOTHER BOUNDARY OF THE SITE ITSELF THE ARC VERY SCREWED
09:18:34PM AND FOUND IT CONSISTENT.
09:18:36PM AND I AM AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
09:18:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
09:18:40PM NO.
09:18:41PM THANK YOU.
09:18:42PM APPLICANT.
09:18:42PM >> GOOD EVENING, MR. CHAIRMAN, COUNCIL MEMBERS.
09:18:51PM I HAVE A QUICK POWERPOINT, AND I WILL KEEP IT TO MINIMUM IF
09:18:55PM YOU PULL IT UP PLEASE.
09:18:57PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COMING OUT THE SCREEN.
09:18:59PM >> I THINK STAFF DID A GOOD JOB PRESENTING TO YOU RM-16
09:19:04PM FROM CI TO CG.
09:19:06PM ALL CONSISTENT FINDING FROM PLANNING COMMISSION, ZONING AND
09:19:08PM ALL THE DEPARTMENTS.
09:19:09PM I AM NOT AWARE OF ANY ON CITIZENS ON THE RECORD.
09:19:15PM YOU SEE THE SITE IS LOCATED A VERY EN TEN SIEVE AREA NORTH
09:19:19PM 50th AND I-4 WHICH BRANCHES TO THE NORTH AND SOUTH RAMPS.
09:19:25PM CLOSER VIEW OF IT.
09:19:26PM VERY INTENSE.
09:19:31PM IT IS ABUTTING TO THE NORTH WE IS THE MOST INTENSIVE LAND
09:19:37PM USE SATURDAY IN THE CITY.
09:19:38PM ZONING CATEGORIES MUCH THAT AS A CI.
09:19:42PM AND CGs IN THE AREA.
09:19:44PM PLANNING COMMISSION INDICATED TO YOU THAT GIVEN THE
09:19:48PM SURROUNDING PATTERN, THEY FIND THE PROPOSED CG IS COMPARABLE
09:19:53PM AND COMPATIBLE.
09:19:54PM IN CONCLUSION WILL ALLOW FOR DEVELOPMENT COMPARABLE AND
09:19:57PM COMPATIBLE WITH THE CHARACTER OF SURROUNDING USES AND
09:20:00PM CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN IN THE AREA.
09:20:02PM AND THESE ARE JUST A COUPLE OF PICTURES, AGAIN, THE SITE IS
09:20:07PM VERY INTENSIVE.
09:20:09PM WE ARE ALL FAMILIAR WITH 50th.
09:20:10PM A MULTILANE SEPARATED ROADWAY.
09:20:13PM I-4 IS RUNNING RIGHT ACROSS IN FRONT.
09:20:17PM 50th INTO MELBOURNE STREET AND I-4 WHICH IS IN ON FROM AS
09:20:22PM WELL.
09:20:22PM HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MIGHT HAVE.
09:20:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS.
09:20:27PM ANYONE IN PUBLIC WISH TO SPEAK.
09:20:30PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MOTION TO CLOSE.
09:20:31PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
09:20:33PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CARLSON, YOUR TURN.
09:20:37PM >>BILL CARLSON: MOVE NUMBER 6, REZ 24-108.
09:20:42PM ORDINANCE PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION.
09:20:44PM ORDINANCE REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 2902
09:20:50PM MELBOURNE BOULEVARD IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, MORE
09:20:52PM TECHNICALLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1 FROM ZONING
09:20:55PM CLASSIFICATION RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY AND CI TO CG.
09:21:02PM PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
09:21:04PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: SECOND.
09:21:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ROLL CALL.
09:21:07PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
09:21:10PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
09:21:11PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
09:21:13PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
09:21:14PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
09:21:15PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
09:21:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
09:21:17PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY SECOND READING AND
09:21:21PM ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MARCH 27, 2025 AT 10 A.M. LOCATED
09:21:26PM 315 E. KENNEDY, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
09:21:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU, ITEM 67.
09:21:34PM >>CHRIS DEMANCHE: GOOD EVENING AGAIN FOR THE RECORD,
09:21:37PM CHRISTOPHER DEMANCHE, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:21:40PM REZ 24-110.
09:21:43PM REQUEST TO REZONE 622 AND 642 WEST DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING,
09:21:48PM JR. AND 3912, 3915 AND 3917 TO PLANNED DEVELOPMENT TO CG
09:21:56PM AND RS-50.
09:21:57PM I WILL TURN IT OVER TO PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
09:22:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:22:06PM YES, MA'AM.
09:22:07PM >>JENNIFER MALONE: JENNIFER MALONE.
09:22:09PM PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
09:22:10PM AT THE CORNER OF N. BOULEVARD AND WEST MARTIN LUTHER KING,
09:22:15PM JR. BOULEVARD.
09:22:16PM BOTH OF THOSE ROADS ARE ARTERIAL ROADWAYS.
09:22:24PM SURROUNDING AREA IS EITHER RESIDENCES OR OFFICES AND MARTIN
09:22:31PM LUTHER KING, JR. IS PRIMARILY COMMERCIAL.
09:22:32PM WE LOOK AT THE FUTURE LAND USE, IT HAS TWO FUTURE LAND USES
09:22:36PM ON THE SITE, COMMUNITY MIXED USE 35 IS THE PINK.
09:22:39PM THAT IS WHAT WE SEE ALONG MOST OF OUR MAJOR CORRIDORS ALONG
09:22:46PM WEST DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. BOULEVARD.
09:22:48PM RESIDENTIAL-10.
09:22:49PM THIS PORTION DOWN HERE IS TYPICALLY OUR SINGLE-FAMILY
09:22:53PM DETACHED FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY.
09:22:56PM AND THAT IS REALLY PREDOMINANTLY ON N. BOULEVARD.
09:22:59PM SO THAT APPLICANT HAS REQUESTED FOR COMMERCIAL GENERAL
09:23:03PM ZONING ON THE COMMUNITY MIXED-35 FLU AND THE SINGLE-FAMILY
09:23:11PM ON THE RESIDENTIAL-10 FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION.
09:23:14PM THE ZONING IS IN LINE WITH THE FUTURE LAND USE
09:23:19PM DESIGNATION FOR THOSE PARCELS.
09:23:22PM THIS IS KENT WITH OUR URBAN VILLAGE POLICIES WHICH SEEK TO
09:23:26PM DIRECT THE GROWTH TO URBAN VILLAGES THROUGH APPROVAL OF THIS
09:23:30PM REZONING.
09:23:30PM WE WOULD EXPECT THE -- THE GROWTH TO OCCUR AT THIS
09:23:36PM INTERSECTION.
09:23:36PM HE JUST ALSO WOULD LIKE TO SAYS IT COMPARABLE AND COMPATIBLE
09:23:40PM WITH THE SURROUNDING USES AND CONSISTENT WITH THE
09:23:44PM DEVELOPMENT PATTERN AND CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE
09:23:48PM PLAN.
09:23:48PM THANK YOU.
09:23:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:23:50PM YES, SIR.
09:23:51PM >>CHRIS DEMANCHE: FOR THE RECORD, CHRIS DEMANCHE, LAND
09:24:08PM DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:24:08PM START WITH AN AERIAL OF SUBJECT SITE.
09:24:10PM AND YOU CAN SEE THE SUBJECT SITE OUTLINED IN RED.
09:24:13PM AND IT IS LOCATED AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF THE
09:24:17PM INTERSECTION OF N. BOULEVARD AND WEST DR. MARTIN LUTHER
09:24:21PM KING, JR. BOULEVARD.
09:24:21PM SUBJECT SITE SUN DEVELOPED AND LOCATED IN THE TAMPA HEIGHTS
09:24:25PM OVERLAY DISTRICT.
09:24:26PM REQUESTED CG AND RS ZONING DISTRICTS ARE ALLOCATED AS
09:24:32PM FOLLOWS, LOTS 4-9 ARE PROPOSED FOR CG ZONING.
09:24:36PM AND LOT 10 ON THE SOUTHERN PORTION OF THE SITE IS PROPOSED
09:24:40PM FOR RS-50 ZONING.
09:24:42PM SURROUND WILLING -- SURROUNDING DEVELOPMENT PATTERN IS
09:24:49PM COMPRISE OF TO THE NORTH OF SUBJECT SITE.
09:24:52PM AN OFFICE DEVELOPMENT LOCATED NORTHWEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
09:24:55PM EAST OF THE SUBJECT SITE, WE HAVE A VACANT PARCEL.
09:24:59PM WE ALSO HAVE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED DWELLS LOCATED ALONG
09:25:03PM NORTH CLEARFIELD AVENUE.
09:25:05PM WE HAVE A DENTAL OFFICE TO THE SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT
09:25:09PM PROPERTY.
09:25:11PM WEST OF THE PROPERTY, WE HAVE OF A GAS STATION, A
09:25:14PM DRY-CLEANING BUSINESS, AND SOUTHWEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE, WE
09:25:18PM HAVE SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED DWELLS.
09:25:20PM IT IS ALSO SHOULD BE NOTED THAT -- THAT FURTHER SOUTH ON
09:25:25PM SUBJECT PROPERTY ON NORTH BOULEVARD.
09:25:31PM WE HAVE THREE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT SITES.
09:25:34PM THESE PROPERTIES HAVE BEEN REZONED OVER THE PAST 0 YEARS.
09:25:37PM INCLUDE BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL OFFICE USES.
09:25:39PM THOSE SEATS HAVE ATTAINED A RESIDENTIAL CHARACTER TO THEM.
09:25:43PM CURRENT PD FOR THE SUBJECT PROPERTY OF SPELLINGS TEE RETAIL
09:25:48PM WITH RETAIL SALES AND DOES NOT ALLOW FOR ALL THE CG AND
09:25:52PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY USES WHICH IS -- WHICH IS THE
09:25:56PM PURPOSE FOR THE APPLICANT'S REQUEST IS TO ALLOW THOSE CG
09:26:01PM AND RS-50 USES.
09:26:03PM THIS IS A SURVEY OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY.
09:26:08PM IT IS OUTLINED -- LET ME FIX THAT.
09:26:11PM SURVEY OF SUBJECT PROPERTY OUTLINED IN YELLOW.
09:26:17PM WE HAVE N. BOULEVARD.
09:26:18PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: BRING IT UP A LITTLE BIT.
09:26:20PM >> WHOOPS.
09:26:20PM THERE WE GO.
09:26:21PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
09:26:22PM >> THE SURVEY THE SUBJECT PROPERTY OUTLINED IN YELLOW.
09:26:25PM WE HAVE N. BOULEVARD ALONG THE WESTERN PORTION OF THE
09:26:29PM SUBJECT SITE.
09:26:30PM THERE IS APPROXIMATELY 295 FEET OF STREET FRONTAGE.
09:26:34PM WE ALSO HAVE WEST MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. BOULEVARD.
09:26:37PM ON THE NORTHERN PORTION PRESIDENT OF PROPERTY AND
09:26:41PM APPROXIMATELY 121 FEET OF STREET FRONTAGE ALONG THAT
09:26:46PM ROADWAY.
09:26:47PM GIVEN THE SURROUNDING USES, THE REQUESTED USE OF CG
09:26:54PM AND RS-50 ZONING IS APPROPRIATE IN LOCATION AND PRO VOIDS AN
09:26:58PM OPPORTUNITY -- PROVIDES AN APPROPRIATE TRANSITION WITH THE
09:27:01PM SURROUNDING PARCELS.
09:27:02PM SINCE THIS IS AN EUCLIDIAN ZONING, NO SITE PLAN OR
09:27:07PM ELEVATIONS PROVIDED.
09:27:08PM WE DO HAVE SOME PHOTOS OF THE SUBJECT SITE.
09:27:11PM THIS IS LOOKING AT THE SUBJECT PARCEL FROM THE NORTH SIDE OF
09:27:22PM WEST DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. BOULEVARD.
09:27:25PM THIS IS MORE OF A CLOSE-UP IF YOU ARE ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF
09:27:30PM THAT SAME ROADWAY.
09:27:31PM THIS IS THE SUBJECT SITE FROM THE SOUTHWEST CORNER.
09:27:37PM THIS IS THE VIEW OF SUBJECT PROPERTY IF YOU ARE ON THE WEST
09:27:40PM SIDE OF NORTH -- N. BOULEVARD.
09:27:41PM LOOKING NORTH, WE HAVE CVS PHARMACY.
09:27:46PM LOOKING NORTHWEST, WE HAVE AN OFFICE COMPLEX.
09:27:50PM SOUTH OF THE SUBJECT PARCEL, WE HAVE AN EXISTING DENTAL
09:27:56PM OFFICE.
09:27:56PM EAST OF THE SUBJECT SITE, WE HAVE A VACANT PARCEL.
09:27:59PM AND THEN ADJACENT TO THE SITE ALONG NORTH CLEARFIELD AVENUE
09:28:07PM TO THE EAST, WE HAVE SEVERAL SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED
09:28:11PM DWELLINGS.
09:28:11PM THESE ARE ALL ALONG NORTH CLEARFIELD AVENUE.
09:28:18PM LOOKING WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE, WE HAVE A GAS STATION.
09:28:22PM AND TO THE SOUTH OF THE GAS STATION, WE HAVE A DRY-CLEANING
09:28:26PM BUSINESS.
09:28:26PM AND THEN LOOKING SOUTHWEST FROM THE SUBJECT SITE, WE HAVE
09:28:30PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED DWELLS.
09:28:32PM THESE ARE ALONG WEST ORIENT STREET.
09:28:36PM OF COURSE, THIS IS LOOKING DOWN WEST ORIENT STREET LOOKING
09:28:40PM WEST ACTUALLY.
09:28:40PM DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION AND STAFF REVIEWED THE ACTION AND
09:28:47PM FIND IT CONSISTENT WITH THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, AND WE
09:28:49PM ARE AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS YOU MIGHT HAVE.
09:28:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
09:28:52PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:28:53PM YES, SIR.
09:28:57PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
09:29:00PM STEVE MICHELINI, REPRESENTING THE PETITIONER.
09:29:02PM THIS IS A DOWNZONING TAKING THE PD BACK TO THE ORIGINAL CG
09:29:08PM AND THE RS-50.
09:29:10PM I DON'T KNOW WHAT ELSE I CAN SAY.
09:29:14PM IT IS CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY STAFF AND THE PLANNING
09:29:16PM COMMISSION.
09:29:16PM I DON'T WANT TO BELABOR THIS.
09:29:18PM BUT IT -- WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL.
09:29:22PM IT IS ON A MIXED-USE CORRIDOR, SO IT IS CONSISTENT WITH ALL
09:29:28PM YOUR DEVELOPMENT GUIDELINES AND PROVIDE A SINGLE-FAMILY
09:29:30PM RESIDENCE AS A BUFFER ON THE SOUTH SEED OF THE PROPERTY.
09:29:33PM I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL.
09:29:35PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
09:29:37PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: MR. CHAIRMAN, IF YOU DIDN'T KNOW THIS
09:29:40PM CORNER, YOU DIDN'T KNOW TAMPA IT WAS AN OLD PLACE WHERE ALL
09:29:44PM THE PEOPLE WOULD BUY THEIR FLOWERS ON SUNDAY TO TAKE TO THE
09:29:47PM GRAVE SITE FOR THEIR WE WILL TESTIFIES AND FRIENDS.
09:29:50PM IN THE BACK, THE FIRST ONE TO PUT A ONE-PUMP GAS -- SO PITCH
09:29:56PM YOUR OWN GAS AND GET IN THE CAR AND LEFT.
09:29:58PM IT IS VERY UNIQUE AND THERE FOR 20 SOME YEARS.
09:30:01PM MAYBE 20, 30 YEARS AND THEN OF COURSE CAME LITTLE GENERAL
09:30:05PM AND 7-ELEVEN AND EVERYTHING ELSE.
09:30:08PM CHANGES DO HAPPEN AND THAT'S HOW IT WAS.
09:30:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YEP, WHEN I WAS A KID MY GRAND MOTHER
09:30:15PM WOULD GO TO HUTTO TO TAKE TO THE CEMETERY IN MYRTLE HILL.
09:30:19PM THAT IS WHY WE WOULD STOP THERE.
09:30:21PM BACK IN DAY.
09:30:22PM >> BACK IN THE DAY.
09:30:24PM THEY ALSO HAVE SANDWICHES AND --
09:30:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YEAH, I WOULD GET COMIC BOOKS TOO.
09:30:29PM ANYTHING ELSE?
09:30:31PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: NO.
09:30:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYONE IN THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO
09:30:37PM SPEAK.
09:30:37PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MOTION TO CLOSE --
09:30:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WAIT, WE HAVE PEOPLE HERE.
09:30:40PM THAT IS YOU.
09:30:42PM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
09:30:43PM >> ARI FITZGERALD AND I LIVE IN RIVERSIDE HEIGHT JUST A
09:30:48PM STONE'S THROW AWAY FROM -- FROM THE FORMER HUTTO'S CORNER.
09:30:53PM Y'ALL KNOW THIS FRONT MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. BOULEVARD AND
09:30:56PM SURROUNDED BY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT.
09:30:58PM AS STAFF NOTED, IT IS A COMMERCIAL ARTERY ON BOTH SIDE.
09:31:05PM DEVELOPMENT SHOULD BE MORE INTENSE.
09:31:07PM THERE IS A BUSY CVS ACROSS MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. FROM THE
09:31:12PM SUBJECT PROPERTY.
09:31:13PM I WALK TO IT ALL THE TIME.
09:31:14PM I HAVE TO CROSS MLK TO DO IT.
09:31:17PM I WOULD REALLY BE HAPPY TO WALK TO SOMETHING I DON'T HAVE TO
09:31:21PM CROSS MLK TO VISIT.
09:31:23PM I WOULD LIKE TO MEET OTHER NEED OTHER THAN PHARMACEUTICAL
09:31:27PM ONES BY HAVING SOME COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT ON THAT PROPERTY.
09:31:30PM WITH THE ADDITION OF A -- OF A REAL COMMERCIAL PROBABLY THAT
09:31:35PM IS MORE INTENSE.
09:31:36PM BASED ON FACEBOOK POST THAT I UNFORTUNATELY CAN'T SHOW YOU
09:31:41PM BECAUSE OF A BUSTED PHONE, I LEARNED ABOUT THIS FROM A POST
09:31:46PM ON MY NEIGHBORHOOD PAGE WHERE A LOT OF PEOPLE WERE KIND OF
09:31:51PM BEMOANING THE FACT THERE IS LESS COMMERCIAL THAN WHAT WE
09:31:55PM REALLY ACTUALLY NEED AND WANT.
09:31:56PM OUR AREA IS A COMMERCIAL DEAD ZONE.
09:31:59PM AND THE COMMERCIAL GENERAL DESIGNATION ISN'T REALLY FOOLING
09:32:03PM ANYONE.
09:32:04PM AND REALLY ISN'T HELPING US THAT MUCH.
09:32:06PM A RESIDENTIALLY DENSE AREA LIKE OURS DOESN'T NEED MORE
09:32:12PM RESIDENCES, IT NEEDS MORE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT.
09:32:15PM WE NEED TO LOOK TO THE FUTURE ON THIS AND PLAN FOR THE
09:32:18PM FUTURE.
09:32:19PM AND WE ARE UNDERGOING A REVITALIZATION WHERE A LOT MORE
09:32:25PM RESIDENTS ARE BEING PUT IN NEIGHBORHOOD.
09:32:27PM BUT COMMERCIAL ARTERIES REALLY SHOULD PREFER COMMERCIAL
09:32:35PM DEVELOPMENT.
09:32:36PM THE TAMPA HEIGHTS CIVIC ASSOCIATION OPPOSED THIS EARLIER
09:32:41PM INCARNATION BECAUSE IT WOULDN'T WORK.
09:32:44PM THIS PROBABLY IS REALLY JUST MORE OF THE SAME.
09:32:47PM THEY DIDN'T HOLD A GOOD NEIGHBOR MEETING WITH THE
09:32:51PM ASSOCIATION.
09:32:51PM I DO ATTEND MEETINGS REGULARLY, AND THEY DID NOT HOLD A GOOD
09:32:55PM NEIGHBOR MEETING WITH TAMPA HEIGHTS CIVIC ASSOCIATION.
09:32:58PM AND THEY ARE USING A VALUABLE COMMERCIAL LOCATION THAT WOULD
09:33:02PM BE WALKABLE FOR RESIDENTS BETWEEN COLUMBUS AND EVEN SEMINOLE
09:33:10PM HEIGHTS FOR SOMETHING PEOPLE PROBABLY WON'T WANT TO WALK TO.
09:33:13PM IF THE CITY IS BEING ASKED BY THE WAY TO VACATE THEIR ALLY
09:33:22PM TO DO THIS, I WOULD SUGGEST THAT YOU DISAPPROVE THIS
09:33:25PM REZONING.
09:33:26PM AND THAT YOU HAVE VIRTUALLY UNFETTERED DISCRETION OF THE
09:33:34PM ALLEY.
09:33:35PM I'M FAMILIAR WITH CASE THAT AROSE FROM THE PREVIOUS REZONING
09:33:39PM REQUEST.
09:33:39PM AND HE KNOW YOU CAN DO THAT.
09:33:41PM ALSO, WITH REGARD TO TOWN HOUSES AND BUSINESSES, I SEE WHAT
09:33:47PM IS GOING ON IN SEMINOLE HEIGHTS.
09:33:48PM AND IT IS NOT PRETTY.
09:33:50PM PLEASE DENY THIS.
09:33:51PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
09:33:53PM ANYBODY ELSE?
09:33:54PM YES, SIR.
09:33:54PM COME ON UP.
09:33:56PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
09:34:01PM >> FIRST I HAVE TO ASK, IS THIS THE PROPERTY ON THE CORNER
09:34:05PM OF HIGHLAND AND --
09:34:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. AND N.
09:34:10PM BOULEVARD.
09:34:10PM >> OKAY, THANK YOU.
09:34:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL RIGHT.
09:34:12PM ANYBODY ELSE?
09:34:14PM IS THERE REBUTTAL?
09:34:18PM >> JUST AN EXPLANATION, COUNCIL.
09:34:20PM IT IS GOING TO CG ON THOSE AREAS THAT ARE AYE BUTTING THE
09:34:26PM COMMERCIAL, COMMERCIAL CORRIDOR AND RESIDENTIAL FURTHER DOWN
09:34:31PM ON N. BOULEVARD.
09:34:32PM I THINK THERE IS SOME CONFUSION WHAT IS BEING REQUESTED, BUT
09:34:36PM ANYWAY, I THINK I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR APPROVAL.
09:34:39PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CAN EITHER STAFF OR MR. MICHELINI EXPLAIN
09:34:44PM WHAT CG -- WHAT WILL BE DEVELOPED ON IN CG PROPERTY SO THE
09:34:49PM PERSON WHO EXPRESSED CONCERN.
09:34:50PM >> GENERAL COMMERCIAL, ALL TYPES OF RETAIL.
09:34:55PM I THINK -- YOU KNOW, OFFICE CAN GO IN THERE AS WELL.
09:34:59PM IT'S -- IT IS FAIRLY LOW INTENSIVE.
09:35:01PM CI IS MUCH MORE INTENSIVE.
09:35:04PM I HAVE A WHOLE LIST OF THE PROPOSED -- OF THE POSSIBLE USES,
09:35:08PM BUT -- YOU WANT TO EXPLAIN ANYMORE OR I GOT IT COVERED.
09:35:19PM >>CHRIS DEMANCHE: CHRIS DEMANCHE, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:35:21PM THERE IS A HOST OF USES THAT ARE PERMITTED WITHIN THE CG
09:35:26PM ZONING.
09:35:26PM IF WE WANT TO GO THROUGH SOME OF THEM.
09:35:30PM >> THAT IS FINE.
09:35:31PM BOOK STORE, GAS STATION, ALL KINDS OF STUFF.
09:35:35PM BANK.
09:35:37PM IS THAT ENOUGH OR YOU WANT ME TO KEEP GOING.
09:35:41PM >> PERSONAL SERVICES, PHARMACY, MEDICAL OFFICE.
09:35:45PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I WILL SAVE YOU SOME TIME.
09:35:48PM IT WOULD NOT BE RESIDENTIAL SOME TYPE OF COMMERCIAL ACTION.
09:35:54PM >> IN THE COMMERCIAL ZONE.
09:35:56PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: DEVELOPED IN A COMMERCIAL WAY.
09:35:58PM >> THE REMAINING LOT TO THE BOTTOM -- TO THE FAR SOUTH HAS A
09:36:03PM RESIDENTIAL-10 LAND USE DESIGNATION SO CAN ONLY BE
09:36:07PM SINGLE-FAMILY.
09:36:07PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: GOT IT, THANK YOU.
09:36:09PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYTHING ELSE.
09:36:10PM A MOTION TO CLOSE.
09:36:11PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: MOTION TO CLOSE.
09:36:13PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SECOND.
09:36:14PM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
09:36:17PM READ HUTTO'S.
09:36:21PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: ITEM NUMBER 7, FILE NUMBER REZ-24-110.
09:36:27PM ORDINANCE FOR IN FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, ORDINANCE
09:36:33PM REZONING FROM 622 AND 462 WEST MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR.
09:36:37PM BOULEVARD AND 3912, 3915, 3917 N. BOULEVARD IN THE CITY OF
09:36:45PM TAMPA, FLORIDA, AND MORE TECHNICALLY DESCRIBED AS SECTION 1
09:36:49PM ZONING DISTRICT PD TO CG AND RS-50 PROVIDE AN EFFECTIVE
09:36:56PM DATE.
09:36:56PM SECOND BY CLENDENIN.
09:36:59PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
09:37:01PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
09:37:03PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
09:37:04PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES CLEAN CLENDENIN YES.
09:37:06PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
09:37:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
09:37:08PM >>CLERK: MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY SECOND READING AND
09:37:12PM ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MARCH 27, 2025 AT 10 A.M. LOCATED
09:37:16PM AT 315 E. KENNEDY, THIRD FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33612.
09:37:24PM >> THANK YOU, COUNCIL.
09:37:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ITEM NUMBER.
09:37:29PM YES, MA'AM.
09:37:30PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK.
09:37:32PM ITEM NUMBER 8 REZ 25-13.
09:37:36PM 4601 AND 4611 WEST NORTH A STREET.
09:37:44PM REZONE FROM RO-1 RESIDENTIAL OFFICE AND PD TO PD,
09:37:53PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED.
09:37:55PM I WILL TURN IT OVER TO MISS MALONE TO GIVE HER REPORT.
09:38:00PM >>JENNIFER MALONE: PLANNING COMMISSION, THIS IS JENNIFER
09:38:03PM MALONE.
09:38:03PM WE TRAVELED TO THE WEST SHORE PLANNING DISTRICT WITHIN THE
09:38:06PM WEST SHORE EMPLOYMENT AREA.
09:38:08PM THIS IS THE WEST SHORE MALL TO THE WEST OF THE SITE WE HAVE
09:38:17PM -- WHAT IS INTERESTING ABOUT THIS SITE IT IS ONE BLOCK NORTH
09:38:19PM OF WEST KENNEDY BOULEVARD.
09:38:21PM AND I AM HOUR MISS DOCK WILL GO OVER THIS IN HER ANALYSIS OF
09:38:26PM THE SURROUNDING AREA, BUT THE SITE ENDS UP INTERFACING THE
09:38:30PM COMMERCIAL USES THAT FRONT WEST KENNEDY BOULEVARD.
09:38:35PM STREET ALONG WEST NORTH A STREET IS DEVELOPED WITH ALL
09:38:39PM OFFICES AND THERE IS NO -- I DIDN'T DO A RESIDENTIAL DENSITY
09:38:43PM CALCULATION OF THE EXISTING DENSITY ON THE SITE, ON THE
09:38:46PM STREET, BECAUSE NO OTHER RESIDENTIAL.
09:38:47PM IT IS EITHER OFFICES OR THE BACK SIDE OF THE COMMERCIAL USES
09:38:51PM THAT ARE ALONG KENNEDY.
09:38:52PM THERE IS RESIDENTIAL ALONG -- AT THE CORNER OF TRASK.
09:38:56PM AND THEN NORTH OF THE SITE WHAT WILL BE AROUND THE SITE
09:39:02PM ALONG WEST NORTH B STREET.
09:39:04PM IF YOU LOOK IN THE FUTURE LAND USE, IT IS INTERFACING THE
09:39:08PM REGIONAL MIXED USE-100 FUTURE LAND USE WHICH IS -- THE
09:39:13PM SECOND HIGHEST FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY OF THE ENTIRE CITY.
09:39:16PM HIGHEST ONE IN THE CENTRAL BUSINESS DISTRICT WHICH IS
09:39:21PM DOWNTOWN.
09:39:21PM FUTURE LAND USE IS RESIDENTIAL-35 AND RESIDENTIAL-20 TO THE
09:39:25PM EAST.
09:39:25PM SO AS -- AS THE -- THE PATTERN CHANGES AS ONE MOVES NORTH.
09:39:33PM THE RESIDENTIAL-35 WAS PROVIDING THAT TRANSITION AS WE MOVED
09:39:37PM OFF OF A CORRIDOR FROM THOSE INTENSIVE USES.
09:39:40PM IT IS ALSO WITHIN PROXIMITY TO TWO TRANSIT EMPHASIS
09:39:50PM CORRIDORS.
09:39:51PM RIGHT KIND OF OFF THE CORNER OF WEST KENNEDY AND NORTH
09:39:55PM WESTSHORE BOULEVARD.
09:39:56PM COMPREHENSIVE PLAN SUPPORTS PUTTING HOUSING IN THESE
09:40:01PM STRATEGIC LOCATION.
09:40:01PM ALSO A EMPLOYMENT CENTER.
09:40:03PM WE WANT OUR HOUSING IN PLACES THAT HAVE AMPLE ACCESS TO
09:40:07PM TRANSIT SERVICES AND EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES.
09:40:09PM ABOUT THE DESIGN, THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ENCOURAGES THESE
09:40:15PM USES TO BE DESIGNED FRONT DOORS ORIENTED TOWARD NEIGHBORHOOD
09:40:19PM SIDEWALKS AND STREETS.
09:40:20PM I AM SURE AS MISS DOCK WILL GO THROUGH HER PRESENTATION AS
09:40:24PM WELL.
09:40:24PM MOST UNITS HAVE THE ORIENTATION TOWARD THE STREETS EITHER
09:40:28PM TOWARD WEST NORTH A STREET AND NORTH TRASK STREET.
09:40:32PM ONE COUNTY BUILDINGS IS SET BACK.
09:40:34PM HOWEVER, WE FOUND IT CONSISTENT WITH THIS POLICY, BECAUSE
09:40:38PM THEY PROVIDED A CLEAR PEDESTRIAN CONNECTION FROM THOSE UNITS
09:40:43PM ON THE NORTHERN PORTION OF THE SITE.
09:40:45PM A WAY FOR PEDESTRIAN TO GET SAFELY FROM THOSE UNITS TO THE
09:40:48PM SIDEWALK ALL THE WAY DOWN TO WEST NORTH A STREET.
09:40:52PM SO WE ANALYZED THAT.
09:40:53PM WE DISCUSSED IT.
09:40:55PM AND WE FOUND IT WAS CONSISTENT WITH THAT POLICY.
09:40:58PM SO I AM AVAILABLE FOR ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS IF YOU HAVE ANY.
09:41:02PM THANK YOU.
09:41:02PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS AS SOON AS THANK YOU VERY
09:41:04PM MUCH.
09:41:04PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: THANK YOU, AGAIN.
09:41:07PM LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:41:09PM I WILL PUT UP THE SITE PLAN THAT WAS SUBMITTED WITH THIS
09:41:14PM REQUEST BY THE APPLICANT.
09:41:15PM LET ME ZOOM OUT JUST A LITTLE BIT.
09:41:17PM THIS REZONING.
09:41:20PM IN PD REZONING WILL ALLOW FOR A DEVELOPMENT OF 21 UNIT
09:41:25PM REASON RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY UNITS TO BE CONTAINED
09:41:28PM WITHIN THREE BUILDINGS ON-SITE.
09:41:29PM THIS IS THE ON THE SITE, THIS IS TRASK STREET.
09:41:39PM LET ME ZOOM OUT A LITTLE MORE SO YOU CAN SEE THE STREET TO
09:41:42PM THE SOUTH WHICH IS NORTH A. THIS IS TRASK.
09:41:50PM THIS IS NORTH A.
09:41:52PM YOU CAN SEE THE THREE BUILDINGS ON-SITE.
09:41:54PM THIS CONTAINS FIVE UNITS AND THESE TWO BUILDINGS CONTAIN
09:41:57PM EIGHT UNITS.
09:41:58PM THE BUILDING -- THIS IS BUILDING TWO.
09:42:00PM THIS IS BUILDING ONE.
09:42:02PM THIS IS BUILDING TWO.
09:42:03PM AND BUILDING THREE.
09:42:04PM BUILDING TWO AND BUILDING ONE HAS FRONT DOOR ORIENTATION TO
09:42:08PM THE RIGHT-OF-WAY.
09:42:12PM BUILDING ONE, THESE DOORS FRONT TRASK AND THE WALKWAY
09:42:17PM CONNECTION AND THE SAME WITH THE BUILDING, THE FRONT DOORS
09:42:20PM ORIENT TO THE RIGHT AWAY TO NORTH A STREET.
09:42:29PM FRONT DOORS ORIENT TO THE ETERNAL DRIVE AISLE.
09:42:34PM THERE IS ACCESS TWO POINTS OF VEHICULAR ACCESS AND BOTH ON
09:42:38PM NORTH A STREET.
09:42:41PM YOU CAN ENTER THE SITE AND CIRCLE THE SITE AND EXIT HERE.
09:42:44PM BOTH POINTS OF ENTRY -- BOTH POINTS OF ACCESS FROM TWO-WAY
09:42:50PM VEHICULAR TRAVEL.
09:42:51PM AN THEN THE SOLID WASTE IS LOCATED HERE ON-SITE.
09:42:55PM 21 PARKING SPACES AND 42 SPACES ARE PROVIDED.
09:43:04PM THE SITE MENTIONED IN THE WEST SHORE OVERLAY.
09:43:08PM R-35 LAND USE DESIGNATION.
09:43:11PM A MAXIMUM OF 23 DWELLING UNITS CAN BE DEVELOPED BY RIGHT ON
09:43:15PM THE SITE.
09:43:15PM AND THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING 21 DWELLING UNITS ON-SITE.
09:43:19PM AND THIS DENSITY SAY LOWED WITHIN THE R-35 CATEGORY.
09:43:25PM AND THERE ARE ELEVATIONS PROVIDED.
09:43:28PM SOME I WILL SHOW YOU ONE SET OF ELEVATIONS.
09:43:32PM THEY ARE SIMILAR TO EACH BUILDING.
09:43:33PM SOME THIS IS THE -- THE REAR ELEVATION.
09:43:37PM THAT IS LOCATED THERE.
09:43:38PM THIS IS THE FRONT ELEVATION AND THIS IS THE SIDE.
09:43:45PM AND THEN THIS IS -- THIS IS THE OTHER SIDE ELEVATION THAT IS
09:43:49PM LOCATED THERE.
09:43:50PM THEN WE HAVE THE ZONING ATLAS THAT I WILL SHOW.
09:43:59PM THIS IS THE PROPERTY THAT IS IDENTIFIED ON THE SITE IN RED.
09:44:02PM THIS IS NORTH A STREET.
09:44:04PM THIS IS WEST SHORE BOULEVARD.
09:44:06PM THIS IS KENNEDY BOULEVARD.
09:44:08PM SO THIS SITE AS MISS MALONE MENTIONED ON THE BLOCK FACE TO
09:44:13PM THE WEST, YOU HAVE YOUR OFFICE USES THAT EXIST.
09:44:17PM AND THESE ARE PRIOR PDs.
09:44:21PM SOUTH AND REALLY SOUTHWEST, THE SITE.
09:44:23PM YOU HAVE THE COMMERCIAL USES.
09:44:25PM AND THESE USES ALONG KENNEDY.
09:44:28PM THEY FRONT KENNEDY.
09:44:29PM AND THIS BLOCK DIRECTLY SOUTH, THIS IS THE PARKING FOR THE
09:44:33PM USES THAT FRONT.
09:44:34PM SOME THIS IS, LIKE, THE DRIVE THROUGH AND THE BANK PARKING
09:44:38PM FOR THE BANK THAT FRONTS KENNEDY.
09:44:41PM NORTH OF THE SITE, YOU HAVE SOME OF THE RESIDENTIAL
09:44:45PM SINGLE-FAMILY.
09:44:46PM BUT I WILL SHOW YOU PICTURES.
09:44:47PM YOU WILL YOU WILL HAVE SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED.
09:44:51PM RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY AND A BLOCK NORTH OF THE SITE AND
09:44:54PM THE ZONINGS WHERE THE PDs HAVE COME THROUGH.
09:44:57PM ALONG THE EAST, YOU HAVE RESIDENTIAL MULTIFAMILY AND
09:45:00PM RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ATTACHED THAT HAVE BEEN APPROVED.
09:45:03PM WEST OF THE SITE AS YOU APPROACH WESTSHORE BOULEVARD, YOU
09:45:08PM HAVE YOUR COMMERCIAL USES AND THIS IS THE MALL THAT WILL IS
09:45:10PM LOCATED HERE.
09:45:13PM AND I HAVE A FEW PICTURES OF THE SITE AND THE SURROUNDING
09:45:17PM AREA.
09:45:21PM THIS IS THE SITE.
09:45:23PM THIS IS TRASK AT WEST NORTH A.
09:45:26PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW.
09:45:27PM THIS IS SHOWING THE SIDE VIEW AND THIS IS HEADED TO THE
09:45:34PM WEST.
09:45:34PM AND THIS IS AS WE HEAD WEST DOWN THE BLOCK.
09:45:41PM THE STRUCTURE ON THE SITE AND THE OFFICE USES.
09:45:47PM AND THEN THIS -- THIS IS IF YOU TURN AROUND AND LOOK NORTH
09:45:51PM ON TRASK ON THE CORNER, THE SUBJECT SITE IS OFF TO THE -- TO
09:45:56PM THE WEST IN THIS PICTURE.
09:45:57PM THIS OF NORTH OF THE SUBJECT SITE, SO THIS IS THE SIDE VIEW
09:46:03PM OF THE ACTUALLY THE SINGLE-FAMILY SEMI DETACHED USES THAT
09:46:10PM ARE LOCATED NORTH OF THE SITE AND A FRONT VIEW, THOSE.
09:46:12PM THIS IS THE BLOCK DIRECTLY NORTH OF THE SITE.
09:46:15PM THIS IS ANOTHER VIEW OF THE DEVELOPMENT NORTH OF THE SITE
09:46:20PM AND YOU CAN SEE SOME OF THE MULTIFAMILY THIS THERE.
09:46:23PM A GREATER VIEW OF THAT MULTIFAMILY THAT IS ALONG THE NORTH.
09:46:27PM YOU COME BACK EAST OF THE SITE, THIS IS ONE THE PDs THAT ARE
09:46:32PM APPROVED WITH A SINGLE FAMILY SEMI DETACHED.
09:46:36PM THIS IS SOUTH OF THE SITE.
09:46:38PM THE BANK PARKING AND ANOTHER VIEW SOUTH OF THE SITE WITH
09:46:46PM REVIEW, THE DRC STAFF REVIEW THE REQUEST AND A FINDING OF
09:46:51PM INCONSISTENT WITH THE REQUEST.
09:46:53PM I WOULD LIKE TO HAVE HER GO OVER HER COMMENTS BUT FOUR
09:46:57PM WAIVERS THAT HIGHWAY REQUESTED.
09:46:58PM THREE OF THE WAIVERS REQUESTED ARE RELATED TO NATURAL
09:47:01PM RESOURCES AND ONE OF THE WAVERS ARE RELATED TO THE
09:47:05PM FRONT-DOOR ORIENTATION ON THE SITE.
09:47:07PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: BEFORE WE GET THERE, I HAVE A QUESTION.
09:47:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: GO AHEAD.
09:47:15PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: CONFUSED OF THE PARKING REQUIREMENTS.
09:47:17PM 21 UNITS AND SAID ONLY REQUIRED TO HAVE 21 PARKING SPOTS AND
09:47:24PM REQUESTING A WAIVER IT SHALL WHAT IS HAPPENING?
09:47:26PM SO WHY -- IF THERE ARE 21 UNITS, WHY ONLY A REQUIREMENT FOR
09:47:30PM LESS THAN 42 SPOTS?
09:47:36PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: SO SHOULD BE BASED ON THE NUMBER OF BEDROOM
09:47:39PM UNITS THAT ARE PROVIDED.
09:47:41PM BECAUSE THEY ARE REQUESTING THE PARKING.
09:47:50PM >>JONATHAN SCOTT: JONATHAN SCOTT, MOBILITY.
09:47:52PM I GUESS THAT IS BECAUSE OF THE OVERLY.
09:47:54PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THEY ARE ONLY REQUIRED TO HAVE ONE PARKING
09:47:58PM SPOT PER UNIT.
09:47:59PM >>JONATHAN SCOTT: THAT'S CORRECT.
09:48:01PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: INTERESTING, THE FIRST TIME I HAVE SEEN
09:48:04PM THAT SINCE I WENT ON COUNCIL.
09:48:06PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, MA'AM.
09:48:10PM ANYTHING ELSE?
09:48:12PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: NO.
09:48:13PM I DIDN'T KNOW IF THERE ARE OTHER QUESTIONS.
09:48:15PM SITE PLAN IN MODIFICATIONS BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING
09:48:19PM AND TURN IT OVER TO ERIN TO GO OVER HER COMMENTS.
09:48:22PM AND THEN I AM AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS.
09:48:24PM THANK YOU.
09:48:25PM >>ERIN MAHER: ERIN MAHER, DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
09:48:29PM I WILL SPEAK TO NATURAL RESOURCES TYPING OF INCONSISTENCY.
09:48:34PM HERE ON THE OVERHEAD, YOU CAN SEE THE AERIAL OF THE SITE.
09:48:38PM DO WANT TO POINT OUT THESE TEARDROPS IN RED, THESE ARE THE
09:48:42PM TWO NONHAZARDOUS GRAND LIVE OAKS THEY ARE REQUESTING A
09:48:47PM WAIVER TO REMOVE.
09:48:48PM RIGHT NOW THE SITE PLAN ACTUALLY REQUESTS A WAIVER FOR
09:48:52PM THREE, BUT I JUST WANT TO FIX ON THE RECORD THEIR SHOULD BE
09:48:55PM TWO.
09:48:56PM THIS RED TRIANGLE HERE WAS NONHAZARDOUS LIVE OAK THAT
09:49:02PM UPROOTED DURING THE HURRICANE.
09:49:04PM THAT ONE IS NO LONGER THERE.
09:49:06PM THESE TWO TREE REQUIRE A 19 MITIGATION TREES.
09:49:11PM I AM JUST GOING TO SHOW YOU SOME PICTURES.
09:49:14PM THIS IS POST HURRICANE TOO, SO THERE HAVE BEEN SOME
09:49:17PM SIGNIFICANT DEFOLIATION AS THERE HAS BEEN WITH LOTS OF TREES
09:49:21PM THROUGHOUT THE CITY.
09:49:22PM THIS IS TREE 527.
09:49:24PM A GRAND LIVE OAK.
09:49:26PM 42-INCH DIAMETER RATED B-7.
09:49:30PM I WANT TO POINT OUT THIS TREE HAD A FEW LIMB FAILURES IN THE
09:49:35PM UPPER CAM KNOW BEE AND THIS LARGE LIMB HERE.
09:49:40PM IT REQUIRES A WAIVER TO REF MOVE THE TREE, HOWEVER.
09:49:44PM AND THIS IS BEING REQUESTED.
09:49:46PM THIS IS THROW TESTIMONY FROM 548.
09:49:48PM ALONG THE ALLEY ALONG THE FENCE HERE.
09:49:52PM 36-INCH LIVE OAK RATED C-5.
09:49:56PM SETBACK THAT IS BEING REQUESTED HERE IS APPROXIMATELY 10
09:50:00PM FEET.
09:50:00PM AND AS YOU CAN SEE, SIGNIFICANT PROPORTION OF THE TREE'S
09:50:06PM CANOPY WOULD REQUIRE REMOVAL, HENCE THE REASON FOR THE
09:50:10PM WAIVER THAT IS BEING REQUESTED FOR THIS TREE.
09:50:16PM I AM GOING SHOW YOU SITE PLAN AND WHERE THE TWO GRAND TREES
09:50:22PM ARE ON THE SITE PLAN.
09:50:23PM BUILDING THREE IS THE FIRST I SHOWED YOU APPROXIMATELY 15
09:50:27PM FEET JUST NORTH OF THE SOUTHERN PROPERTY LINE.
09:50:29PM AND HERE IS THE SECOND GRAND TREE.
09:50:33PM THIS TREE WOULD REQUIRE AT LEAST A 10-FOOT SETBACK IN ORDER
09:50:37PM FOR THE PRUNING TO NOT BE ADVERSE TO THE TREE'S CANOPY.
09:50:43PM AGAIN THIS IS AN UPROOTED GRAND TREE RIGHT HERE.
09:50:46PM THIS PROBABLY REQUIRES A WAIVER TO GREEN SPACE.
09:50:54PM THEY ARE REQUESTING A WAIVER FROM THE REQUIRED 350 SQUARE
09:50:57PM FEET OF GREEN SPACE PER UNIT TO 240 SQUARE FEET PER UNIT.
09:51:02PM TOTAL REQUIRED FOR THE SITE IS 8945 SQUARE FEET.
09:51:06PM AND THE APPLICANT IS PROVIDING 6646 SQUARE FEET WITH A TOTAL
09:51:13PM DEFICIT OF 2298.
09:51:19PM FURTHERMORE, THE SITE CANNOT 'COME DATE ANY TYPE TREES ON
09:51:23PM THE SITE.
09:51:24PM THE MAJORITY OF THE TREES THAT ARE BEING REMOVED ON THE SITE
09:51:27PM ARE TYPE ONE.
09:51:28PM GRANTED SOME OF THEM ARE IN DECLINING CONDITION, BUT, YOU
09:51:32PM KNOW, IT IS STILL REMOVING TYPE ONE TREE CANOPY.
09:51:36PM IT IS -- THERE ARE OVERHEAD WEIRS ON BOTH THE FRONTAGES TO
09:51:42PM THE EAST AND TO THE NORTH.
09:51:43PM SO THEY DO NEED TO PLANT TYPE THREE TREES IN THOSE
09:51:48PM LOCATIONS.
09:51:48PM THE ONLY LOCATIONS THAT CAN PROVIDE FOUR TYPE ONE TREES IS
09:51:54PM ALONG THE SOUTHERN PART OF THE STREET HERE.
09:51:56PM THIS SETBACK IS ONLY -- THE GREEN SPACE AREA IS ONLY FIVE
09:52:02PM FEET AND CAN'T ACCOMMODATE TYPE ONE TREES.
09:52:05PM SAME FOR THE WESTERN BORDER.
09:52:08PM SETBACK MAY BE SEVEN OR FIVE.
09:52:09PM BUT THE SOIL VOLUME IS SUFFICIENT TO SUSTAIN AND SUPPORT
09:52:14PM MATURE TREE CANOPY AND GROWTH.
09:52:17PM SO JUST FOR CONTEXT, TYPICALLY WHAT I -- WHAT WE REAR WHEN
09:52:25PM PEOPLE PLANT A TYPE 1 IS 20 X 20 WHICH IS 400 SQUARE FEET.
09:52:31PM A LOT TIME WE GO OFF THE CUBIC SOIL VOLUME WHICH IS 1200
09:52:36PM CUBIC FEET.
09:52:37PM 1300 CUBIC FEET IS WHAT WE USUALLY WILL ASK FOR.
09:52:41PM BASED ON THE FACT NOT ANY TIME ONE TREES AND NOTING THE
09:52:47PM GREEN SPACE.
09:52:48PM WE FOUND THE PROBABLY EN CONSISTENT.
09:52:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU INVEST MUCH.
09:52:55PM DOES THAT CONCLUDE THE PRESENTATION BEFORE I GO TO THE
09:52:58PM APPLICANT?
09:52:59PM YES, COME ON UP.
09:53:00PM >> WHERE IS THE HDMI CONNECTION?
09:53:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: JONATHAN SCOTT HAS BEEN OUR I.T. GUY.
09:53:31PM >> AM I RUNNING OFF OF HERE OR HERE?
09:54:09PM >> EITHER ONE.
09:54:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
09:54:22PM WE KNOW WHO YOU ARE.
09:54:23PM >> I AM ROB ROSNER WITH FLORIDA DESIGN CONSULTANTS.
09:54:28PM PROFESSIONAL PLANNER AND LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT REPRESENTING
09:54:32PM OUR CLIENT FOR THIS.
09:54:33PM RECENTLY THE AGENT OF RECORD WAS ALEX RIOS FROM RIOS
09:54:38PM ARCHITECTURE.
09:54:39PM WE RECENTLY PICKED THIS PROJECT UP.
09:54:41PM CONSULTING ON IT PREVIOUSLY AND WE ARE HERE TO
09:54:47PM REPRESENT THE PROBABLY.
09:54:48PM THE ITEMS THAT WERE FOUND INCONSISTENT, WE ARE HAPPY TO
09:54:51PM SOLVE BETWEEN FIRST READING AND SECOND READING.
09:54:53PM IN PROJECT HAS BEEN GOING FOR ABOUT TWO YEARS.
09:54:57PM AND WE WERE SUPPOSED TO BE HEARD BACK IN NOVEMBER WITH
09:55:01PM CHANGES AND THINGS THAT NEEDED TO HAPPEN.
09:55:02PM WITHER NOW BEING HEARD TODAY.
09:55:04PM SO WE HAVE BEEN WORKING WITH STAFF TO TRY TO RESOLVE SOME OF
09:55:08PM THE ISSUES IDENTIFIED AS INCONSISTENT.
09:55:11PM PART OF MY PRESENTATION, I WILL SHARE THAT YOU WITH.
09:55:13PM CAN YOU SEE THIS ON YOUR SCREENS?
09:55:18PM OKAY, GREAT.
09:55:18PM SOME THIS IS -- THIS IS 4061 NORTH A STREET.
09:55:23PM 4611 IS HERE.
09:55:33PM WE WENT OUT AND TOOK PICTURES BACK IN SEPTEMBER BEFORE THE
09:55:36PM HURRICANE.
09:55:37PM AND THEN WE WENT OUT TWO DAYS AGO AND TOOK PICTURES AND DID
09:55:41PM A 360 CAMERA AND SHOWED WHAT THE CONDITIONS OF THE TREES
09:55:44PM WERE SO YOU CAN SEE THEM IN PERSON.
09:55:46PM BECAUSE WE DID A 360, SEE THE CANOPY SEE IT IN ALL
09:55:54PM DIRECTIONS.
09:55:54PM THE ONE WE TALK.
09:55:57PM WE HAVE SOME PHOTOS THAT THAT.
09:55:59PM SO THIS IS THOSE -- FROM LOOKING FROM INSIDE THE SITE, 545
09:56:06PM IS UNDER THESE WORDS.
09:56:07PM BUT IT IS GAP.
09:56:10PM IT IS GAP IN THE FENCE WHERE THAT USED TO BE.
09:56:13PM 546 IS THE NEXT ONE.
09:56:15PM THAT ONE IS IN POOR CONDITION, BUT NOT A GRAND TREE.
09:56:18PM WE ARE NOT ASKING FOR THAT ONE.
09:56:20PM 548 IS HARD TO SEE IN THIS PARTICULAR PHOTO, BUT WE WILL GO
09:56:24PM BACK.
09:56:25PM AND THEN SO 548, WE DID A VIDEO OF THIS.
09:56:30PM SO WE TOOK THIS BACK IN SEPTEMBER.
09:56:33PM HAD A PRETTY GOOD-LOOKING HEAD.
09:56:35PM YOU CAN SEE THERE ARE WIRES THAT CROSS THROUGH THAT.
09:56:38PM WHEN LOOK AT THE SITE PLAN, ACCESS WIRES THAT ARE FEEDING
09:56:43PM THE BUILDING GO THROUGH THE CANOPY.
09:56:45PM WHEN TECO -- USUALLY BUTCHER THE TREES WHICH IS A SHAME AND
09:56:50PM WE TRY TO SAVE TREES WHEN WE CAN.
09:56:52PM THIS TREE LOOKS GOOD TO THAT ANGLE.
09:56:55PM DOESN'T LOOK A WHOLE LOT WORSE AND WE DID SEE DAMAGE FROM
09:56:58PM THE HURRICANE THAT WAS DONE TWO DAYS AGO.
09:57:00PM AND THIS IS THIS ONE HERE.
09:57:05PM GO BACK TO THERE.
09:57:09PM TO SHOW WHAT YOU THAT LOOKS LIKE, CLICK ON THIS GUY.
09:57:14PM 10.
09:57:16PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHAT A GREAT INTERACTIVE TOOL TO JUMP
09:57:22PM AROUND.
09:57:23PM >> THIS IS ME WALKING THE SITE SO WE CAN LOOK UP -- I AM
09:57:33PM SORRY.
09:57:34PM I SHOULD BE SLOWER AT THIS.
09:57:35PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: LIKE A VIDEO GAME.
09:57:37PM SO THIS IS THE TREE.
09:57:42PM THIS IS 548.
09:57:43PM YOU CAN SEE THAT TECO IS -- YOU KNOW, BUTCHERED THIS TREE ON
09:57:47PM ONE SIDE FOR MANY YEARS.
09:57:48PM THAT IS WHY THAT CANOPY HANGS OVER TO ONE SIDE BECAUSE IT IS
09:57:52PM TRYING TO SURVIVE BY LEANING OVER.
09:57:56PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YOU ARE DRAGGING --
09:57:59PM >> THIS IS LIKE STREET VIEW.
09:58:00PM I WALKED AROUND WITH A 360 CAMERA ABOVE MY HEAD.
09:58:04PM IF YOU WANT TO SEE MY GOOFY HAT, I WILL SHOW IT TO YOU.
09:58:07PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: VERY NEAT.
09:58:10PM >> WE DID THIS BECAUSE WE KNOW THAT TRYING TO FIGURE OUT
09:58:24PM STOP MOVING, PLEASE.
09:58:25PM WE WORKED WITH ERIN IN THE PAST.
09:58:29PM 20-FOOT.
09:58:30PM WE TOOK FROM THE AERIALS WHAT THE CANOPIES WERE.
09:58:34PM TYPICALLY A CIRCLE.
09:58:35PM BUT NO ONE HAS A PERFECTLY ROUND TREE EVER.
09:58:38PM AND ON OUR PLAN, WE ARE HAPPY TO TRY TO SHOW THAT, BUT WITH
09:58:42PM THE DEVELOPMENT, WE REALIZED THAT SOME OF THESE -- WE DID
09:58:46PM REASONABLE RECONFIGURATION PLANS WHICH GOING BACK TO THAT.
09:58:52PM SO THIS IS THE PLANS THAT WERE SUBMIT.
09:58:58PM SAME ISSUES THAT -- THAT SHE SHARED.
09:59:02PM SO ON THE LANDSCAPE PLAN, WE HAVE BEEN WORKING WITH CLIENT
09:59:08PM ON THE LANDSCAPE PLAN TO FIND PLACES TO PUT TYPE ONE TREES.
09:59:12PM AND WE HAVE LITTLE MORE OPPORTUNITY ALONG THIS END.
09:59:16PM AND WE ARE REMOVING A DRIVEWAY HERE.
09:59:18PM THE DRIVEWAY THAT IS BEING REMOVED HERE GIVES US AN
09:59:24PM OPPORTUNITY TO PUT A COUPLE OF TYPE 1 TREES HERE THAT WE WILL
09:59:28PM SHOW YOU IN JUST A MOMENT.
09:59:30PM WE PREPARED A COMMENT RESPONSE LETTER TO TALK ABOUT THE --
09:59:35PM THE REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION AND -- AGAIN, I'M NOT GOING TO
09:59:38PM GO THROUGH EVERY COMMENT, BUT WE DID A CHART THAT TALKED
09:59:42PM ABOUT THE TWO OPTIONS AND BOTH OPTIONS HAVING A SIGNIFICANT
09:59:45PM REDUCTION OF UNITS IN ORDER TO HAVE THAT HAPPEN WHICH WE
09:59:49PM WILL SHOW NEW A MOMENT.
09:59:50PM FIRST RECONFIGURATION PLAN.
09:59:53PM LOST UNITS AND TRIED TO SAVE THE TREES AND PUT IN A GREAT
09:59:58PM BEAM TO SPAN OVER THE THING.
10:00:00PM THIS IS SOMEWHAT DOABLE.
10:00:03PM THIS ONE USING UNITS AND RECONFIGURING.
10:00:06PM AND OUR SECOND PLAN WAS -- WE REARRANGED THE UNITS TO BE
10:00:10PM HORIZONTAL, EVEN THOUGH WE WOULD STILL BE TAKING OUT ONE.
10:00:14PM THEY GAVE US MORE ROOM TO HAVE -- TO SAVE THE TWO TREES TO
10:00:17PM THE NORTH.
10:00:18PM BUT STILL A REDUCTION IN UNITS.
10:00:20PM KNOW THAT IS NOT A REQUIREMENT, BUT WE FOUND THAT 21 UNITS
10:00:25PM ARE IS WHAT MAKES THIS PROBABLY FEASIBLE FOR OUR CLIENT.
10:00:28PM LOSING UNITS WAS NOT AN INTENTION, BUT IF WE WERE TRYING TO
10:00:33PM REASONABLY ACCOMMODATE THOSE, THAT IS WHAT IT WILL COST.
10:00:36PM SO WE ARE ASKING TO, YOU KNOW, SUBMIT FOR OUR ORIGINAL
10:00:40PM REQUEST FOR THE 21 UNITS.
10:00:42PM WE CAN WORK WITH STAFF BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND READING TO
10:00:46PM MAKE THIS CLOSER TO CONSISTENT, IF NOT COMPLETELY
10:00:50PM CONSISTENT.
10:00:50PM WE MAY HAVE A LITTLE TROUBLE GETTING TO THE FULL GREEN SPACE
10:00:53PM NUMBER BECAUSE A VOA NUMBER THAT ADDS TO THAT.
10:00:56PM BUT WE BELIEVE WE CAN HELP WITH THE TPD ONE TREES.
10:00:58PM AND THE CONDITIONS OF THESE TWO GRAND TREES.
10:01:05PM A LOT OF WORK TO SAVE A TREE AND IT NOT SURVIVE.
10:01:08PM AND THAT WOULD BE A SHAME.
10:01:10PM DO YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS?
10:01:14PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: MAKES NO DIFFERENCE.
10:01:16PM GO ON.
10:01:17PM I AM JUST -- I AM JUST A TAD CONCERNED.
10:01:19PM I NEVER SEEN A PROPERTY WITH JUST ONE CAR.
10:01:22PM MR. CLENDENIN BROUGHT THAT UP.
10:01:23PM AND I WAS AMAZED THAT YOU HAVE.
10:01:27PM >> EVERY GARAGE HAS TWO CARS.
10:01:28PM WE ARE PROVIDING MORE THAT REQUIRED, BUT THE WEST SHORE
10:01:34PM OVERLAY ONLY REQUIRES ONE.
10:01:36PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I UNDERSTOOD.
10:01:38PM >> 21 UNITS WITH TWO-CAR GARAGE.
10:01:41PM ONLY 21 IS BEING REQUIRED.
10:01:43PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YOU DON'T HAVE TWO-CAR GARAGE.
10:01:51PM BECAUSE WIDTH OF 17 OR 18 FEET WILL NOT FIT TWO CARS.
10:01:55PM WE JUST HAD A HUGE THING ABOUT THAT LAST WEEK OR TWO WEEKS
10:01:58PM AGO.
10:01:58PM THOSE THAT ARE FACING NORTH A, NO WAY YOU ARE FIT TWO CARS
10:02:02PM IN THOSE.
10:02:02PM SO KNOWING THAT IS AN OVERLAY ISSUE.
10:02:05PM BUT FOR ME, THE BIGGER ISSUE IS, YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT THE
10:02:09PM TREES.
10:02:09PM I MEAN, THE TREES ARE ONE THING, BUT 25% OF GREEN SPACE AND
10:02:14PM THE GARAGE THAT ARE TOO SMALL?
10:02:17PM IT JUST SEEMS LIKE YOU ARE PUTTING A LOT IN.
10:02:20PM WHY CAN'T YOU MEET THE GREEN SPACE REQUIREMENT.
10:02:22PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: IF I MAY ALSO --
10:02:24PM >>LYNN HURTAK: OH, SORRY.
10:02:27PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: 2900 IN REDUCTION.
10:02:29PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IT IS EXTREME.
10:02:31PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THIS RIGHT HERE.
10:02:32PM 50 X 60 IS HALF THE LOT.
10:02:36PM THIS IS ABOUT IT, WHAT YOU ARE LOOKING AT THIS HALL OR
10:02:38PM WHATEVER YOU CALL.
10:02:39PM >> IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK.
10:02:45PM I WANT -- I WOULD LIKE TO INTRODUCE HER.
10:02:49PM ONE OF THINGS WE WERE OFFER FOR CONCESSION, UPROOTED TREE
10:02:58PM WILL DAMAGE THE ALLEY AND WILL BE HAPPY TO HELP REPAIR THAT.
10:03:04PM TO GET MORE GREEN SPACE WHAT WE CAN TO DO SACRIFICE TO DO
10:03:08PM THAT.
10:03:09PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I AM ALSO CURIOUS.
10:03:10PM THERE IS ANOTHER PART TO MY QUESTION.
10:03:12PM YOU HAVE AN ALLEY.
10:03:14PM WHY IN THE WORLD WOULDN'T YOU HAVE GARAGES THAT FACE THE
10:03:17PM ALLEY?
10:03:18PM WHY IN THE WORLD WOULD YOU PUT MORE ASPHALT ON THIS
10:03:25PM PROBABLY.
10:03:25PM THIS SEEMS COMPLETELY BACKWARD.
10:03:27PM >> OKAY, COMING LATE AND COMING TO THIS PROJECT A LITTLE
10:03:30PM LATE, BUT IF STAFF MIGHT RECALL -- THEY ASKED US NOT TO USE
10:03:35PM THE ALLEY TO KEEP -- IF WE WERE TO DO THAT, WE WOULD HAVE TO
10:03:39PM TAKE ALL THE TREES OUT TO PUT ALL GARAGE -- IT WAS A TREE
10:03:43PM SAVING EFFORT IN THE FIRST ROUND.
10:03:45PM AND REALLY A SUBSTANDARD ALLEY -- YOU ASKED A QUESTION.
10:03:49PM I AM TRYING TO ANSWER.
10:03:50PM AND THAT FACING THOSE TO THE ALLEY WAS NOT WHAT STAFF WAS
10:03:53PM CYCLING FOR.
10:03:54PM THEY SAID CAN YOU DO INTERNAL CIRCULATION.
10:03:57PM FIRE CODE BIG DEAL THAT THE ALLEY WAS SUBSTANDARD.
10:04:00PM HAD THESE ISSUES.
10:04:01PM AND IF WE WERE TO DO THAT, THEN FIRE MARSHAL WAS SAYING THAT
10:04:06PM WOULD BE A PROBLEM FOR THEM.
10:04:07PM FOR US TO RECONFIGURE, THAT IS WHY WE HAVE THE U-SHAPED/ T
10:04:15PM CONFIGURATION.
10:04:16PM LIKE A BACKWARD H.
10:04:18PM TRYING TO MEET THE REQUIREMENTS FOR STAFF ASKING FOR THOSE
10:04:21PM OVER THE YEARS.
10:04:22PM AGAIN, I AM COMING LATE TO THE PROCESS.
10:04:24PM SO I WASN'T THERE FOR THE FIRST ROUND, BUT THAT IS MY
10:04:30PM RECOLLECTION OF WHAT THE EXPLANATION IS.
10:04:32PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU FOR THE EXPLANATION, BUT TELL ME
10:04:36PM YOUR TAKING AWAY A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF GREEN SPACE, THAT
10:04:40PM WILL BE GREAT.
10:04:41PM >> YOU WANT ME TO OFFER MORE GREEN SPACE?
10:04:46PM >> I WOULD LOVE TO OFFER MORE GREEN SPACE -- THIS IS MY
10:04:50PM FIRST MEETING.
10:04:51PM I APOLOGIZE -- I WAS TOLD I NEED TO -- ROSALYN MG.
10:04:57PM 4830 WEST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, TAMPA, 33069.
10:05:03PM THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO SPEAK.
10:05:05PM I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF THE OWNER COMPANY.
10:05:08PM AND I AM EXCITED ABOUT THE PROBABLY.
10:05:12PM I UNDERSTAND THERE IS SOME DEFICIENCY WITH GREEN SPACE, AND
10:05:15PM THAT IS SOMETHING WE ARE COMMITTED TO ADDRESSING IN ANY WAY
10:05:17PM THAT WE CAN.
10:05:18PM ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE JUST RECENTLY TALKED ABOUT WAS
10:05:21PM WHAT IS ALLOWABLE FOR ADDING GREEN SPACE FOR ROOFTOP
10:05:27PM GARDENS AND VERTICALLY.
10:05:28PM CREATIVE WAYS TO ADD GREEN SPACE TO NIGHT THE NEED OF
10:05:32PM COMMUNITY WHILE ALSO PROVIDING THIS HOUSING THAT IS SO
10:05:36PM NECESSARY, THEN WE ARE INVESTED IN DOING THAT.
10:05:37PM THAT IS WHY WE HAVE BEEN WORKING WITH THE COMMUNITY AND WITH
10:05:41PM ROB HERE, WITH HIS EXPERTISE SEEING WHAT TREES WE CAN SAVE
10:05:46PM AND WHAT AREAS WE CAN ADD GREEN SPACE TOO.
10:05:49PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I DON'T THINK THE CITY OF TAMPA ALLOWS
10:05:53PM ROOFTOP SPACE TO BE CONSIDERED GREEN SPACE.
10:05:56PM GREEN SPACE IS FOR THE GROUND.
10:06:00PM YEAH.
10:06:00PM >> I APOLOGIZE, I DIDN'T KNOW.
10:06:03PM THANK YOU FOR TELL ME.
10:06:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN AND THEN BACK
10:06:07PM TO MIRANDA.
10:06:08PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: LET'S RIGHT SET THIS.
10:06:12PM I KNOW -- OBVIOUSLY YOU GUYS HAVE COME LATE INTO THIS
10:06:15PM PROJECT, BUT -- YEAH, THIS IS -- THIS IS ALMOST LIKE A
10:06:19PM NONSTARTER.
10:06:20PM WHEN YOU LOOK AT THIS -- I MEAN, IT IS OBVIOUSLY IN AN AREA
10:06:25PM THAT WE WOULD BE -- WE WOULD BE ACCEPTABLE TO INCREASE
10:06:29PM CONSIDERING, YOU KNOW, DENSITY BECAUSE IT IS -- IT IS IN
10:06:32PM THAT -- THIS TYPE OF AN AREA.
10:06:34PM BUT IT HAS TO BE THE RIGHT TYPE OF PROJECT.
10:06:37PM AND WHAT -- AS COUNCILWOMAN SAID, YOU REALLY -- THERE IS --
10:06:44PM THERE IS JUST TOO MUCH ON TOO LITTLE WITHOUT ANY KIND OF
10:06:48PM CONCESSIONS.
10:06:48PM AND IT IS PUZZLING, AGAIN -- THIS IS ONE OF THE THINGS.
10:06:52PM YOU GOT TO GO BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD, BECAUSE YOU HAVE AN
10:06:55PM ALLEY SITTING THERE.
10:06:56PM AND YOUR NOT UTILIZING THAT ALLEY FOR GARAGE ACCESS IS
10:07:01PM BEYOND ME.
10:07:01PM I CAN'T IMAGINE ANYBODY IN THE CITY OF TAMPA T TELLING YOU
10:07:04PM NOT TO USE THE ALLEY FOR GARAGE ACCESS.
10:07:07PM STAFF, ANYBODY -- IS THAT SOMETHING THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN
10:07:11PM SAID SOMETHING LONG WITH THAT ALLEY THAT PREVENTS IT FROM
10:07:15PM BEING UTILIZED.
10:07:15PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:07:18PM I BELIEVE INITIALLY WHEN THIS WAS FIRST -- IF I CAN HAVE THE
10:07:21PM OVERHEAD, WHEN IT WAS FIRST SUBMITTED UNDER A DIFFERENT
10:07:25PM AGENT THAT WAS HANDLING THE CASE, THERE WERE -- THE TREES
10:07:31PM THAT WERE ALONG THE NORTH BOUNDARY OF SITE, THERE WAS AN
10:07:33PM EFFORT TO TRY TO PRESERVE THOSE TREES.
10:07:35PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: NOT LONGER THE CASE.
10:07:40PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: ONE VERSION OF THE PLAN THAT ACCESSED THE
10:07:42PM ALLEY, BUT I THINK IT WAS SOMETHING ABOUT A TURN AND THIS
10:07:46PM BUILDING DIDN'T HAVE AS MUCH OF A SETBACK AS IT DOES HERE.
10:07:49PM SO THEN THE -- THEY RESUBMITTED A PLAN WHICH WOULD HAVE
10:07:53PM PRESERVED THESE TREES WHICH I THINK NOW AREN'T BEING
10:07:57PM PRESERVED, BUT THAT WAS THE INITIAL REASON FOR THE CHANGE TO
10:08:00PM PRESERVE THE TREES ALONG THE NORTH.
10:08:03PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: OKAY.
10:08:04PM I MEAN -- YEAH, I AM SORRY THAT -- THIS IS AN INTERESTING
10:08:10PM SCENARIO THAT YOU ARE PUTTING AN AWFUL LOT AND IT IS SO
10:08:16PM LITTLE.
10:08:16PM WHEN LOOK AT THE SIZE OF THE GARAGE.
10:08:19PM I GET THE FACT -- A SURPRISE OF ALL OF US WITH THE OVERLAY
10:08:24PM DISTRICT AND THE PARKING REQUIREMENTS.
10:08:26PM THE GREEN SPACE, THE DOOR ORIENTATION.
10:08:30PM JUST -- AND JUST -- IT IS NOT PROVIDING ANYTHING REALLY TO
10:08:34PM THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
10:08:34PM AND ACCESS.
10:08:36PM THIS IS JUST A PROBLEMATIC PROPOSAL.
10:08:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
10:08:44PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I WILL JUST -- CERTAINLY THE TREES HOLD
10:08:46PM WATER.
10:08:46PM THEY WILL BE GONE.
10:08:47PM YOU ARE CUTTING DOWN ON THE FLOOR SPACE WHERE WATER CAN
10:08:50PM DRAIN.
10:08:50PM THAT IS GOING TO BE GONE.
10:08:52PM I MEAN WHAT ARE WE GOING TO HAVE?
10:08:54PM I'M NOT TRYING TO BE IN ANY WAY ARGUMENTATIVE.
10:08:58PM IF THE GARAGE IS 18.7 INCHES, TWO CARS CAN'T FIT IN AND OPEN
10:09:04PM THE DOORS.
10:09:04PM THE CARS ARE NINE FOOT WIDE BY THE TIME YOU OPEN THE DOORS.
10:09:08PM YOU CAN'T GET IN OR OUT.
10:09:11PM THE WAY I -- IF I RECALL 20 FOOT, WHAT, SEVEN INCHES?
10:09:17PM >> SOME OF THEM 17.
10:09:19PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: WE ARE LOOKING 20 FOOT, 7 INCHES WITH TWO
10:09:23PM CARS.
10:09:23PM >> YOU ARE WILLING TO MAKE CHANGES -- IF YOU WANT TO MAKE
10:09:35PM CHANGES, WE CAN ASK TO MAKE CHANGES BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
10:09:38PM READING.
10:09:39PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: THE CHANGES HAVE TO BE MADE.
10:09:41PM IF THESE ARE SUBSTANTIVE CHANGES, I BELIEVE YOU WOULD HAVE
10:09:44PM TO ASK FOR A CONTINUANCE AND COME BACK AND PERHAPS GO
10:09:48PM THROUGH DRC IF THAT IS THE PROCESS AND THEN MISS DOCK CAN
10:09:53PM INFORM COUNCIL AND THE APPLICANT.
10:09:56PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:09:59PM AT THIS POINT, THE OPTIONS ARE FOR THE APPLICANT TO ONLY
10:10:02PM MAKE THE CHANGES AS LISTED IN THE SITE PLAN MODIFICATION
10:10:05PM SHEET -- THE SITE PLAN REVISION SHEET.
10:10:08PM IF THEY WANT TO WORK TO TRY TO INCREASE THE GREEN SPACE,
10:10:11PM THEIR WOULD REQUIRE PROBABLY ELIMINATION OF A UNIT,
10:10:16PM REDUCTION OF A SETBACK ARE, WHICH COULD BE DONE, BUT WE
10:10:20PM WOULD STILL NEED SOME DIRECTION WHAT THE APPLICANT IS
10:10:24PM WORKING ON BETWEEN THESE HEARINGS.
10:10:26PM HE COULD -- CERTAIN CHANGES YOU CAN GO LESS NOT MORE BETWEEN
10:10:31PM FIRST AND SECOND READING OR IT CAN BE CONTINUED TO COME BACK
10:10:35PM FOR ANOTHER FIRST READING.
10:10:37PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I WOULD BE MORE COMFORTABLE WITH ANOTHER
10:10:39PM FIRST READING BECAUSE THING IS TOO SUBSTANTIAL OF A CHANGE
10:10:42PM TO COME -- AND NORMALLY WE DON'T DO THAT, BUT I WOULD
10:10:46PM ABSOLUTELY PREFER THAT -- I MEAN, THIS IS -- THIS IS
10:10:51PM DEVELOPMENT THAT IS NEEDED.
10:10:52PM IT IS JUST NOT FULLY BAKED.
10:10:54PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: IN THE RIGHT AREA.
10:10:56PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THAT IS A WIN, BY THE WAY.
10:10:58PM >>LYNN HURTAK: IT REALLY IS.
10:11:00PM I WOULD COME BACK AGAIN.
10:11:03PM RECONSIDER THE ALLEY SINCE YOU ARE NOT GOING TO BE ABLE TO
10:11:06PM SAVE THE TREES AND MORE GREEN SPACE.
10:11:08PM AND GARAGE -- EVEN THOUGH YOU ARE NOT REQUIRED TO, WE ARE
10:11:13PM FIND A LOT OF COMPLAINTS OF PEOPLE WHO BUY A HOUSE OR A
10:11:17PM CONDO AND CANNOT -- AND BELIEVE THAT THEY ARE GOING TO BE
10:11:20PM ABLE TO FIT TWO CARS AND CAN NOT.
10:11:22PM WE ARE HEARING IT FROM THE OTHER SIDE AS WELL.
10:11:24PM WE ARE COMMITTED TO MAKING SURE THAT GARAGE SIZES ARE
10:11:29PM CORRECT.
10:11:29PM WE HAD A BIG CONVERSATION ABOUT IT LAST WEEK.
10:11:31PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
10:11:34PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I WISH THEM WELL.
10:11:36PM BECAUSE THE LOCATION IS FINE.
10:11:38PM EVERYTHING ELSE IS FINE.
10:11:39PM IT IS LIKE TOO MUCH FOR TOO LITTLE LAND.
10:11:42PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I THINK WHAT WE WOULD BE LOOKING FOR YOU
10:11:47PM ALL TO REQUEST A CONTINUANCE.
10:11:49PM >> WOULD YOU LIKE TO DO IT.
10:11:52PM >> MEMBERS OF COUNCIL, I WOULD RESPECTFULLY REQUEST A
10:11:56PM CONTINUANCE ON THIS MATTER.
10:11:57PM >>LYNN HURTAK: WHAT DATE DO WE HAVE FOR THAT.
10:12:00PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: HOW MUCH TIME --
10:12:02PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:12:04PM FOR THE CHANGES WE DISCUSSED, THE ACCESS FROM THE ALLEY, THE
10:12:08PM REORIENTATION OF THE BUILDINGS ON-SITE, ANOTHER DRC WILL BE
10:12:14PM NEEDED.
10:12:15PM AND THEN WE WOULD COME BACK.
10:12:16PM SO NEED AT LEAST TWO-MONTH TIME FRAME.
10:12:20PM LOOKING FOR A CONTINUANCE -- WE ARE IN FEBRUARY.
10:12:23PM MAY 8 FOR -- JUNE 12 IS FULL.
10:12:28PM >>LYNN HURTAK: DOES MAY 8 WORK?
10:12:34PM >> IT DOES, RESPECTFULLY, I AM GOING TO ASK IF THERE IS ANY
10:12:38PM EARLIER DATE.
10:12:40PM ANYTHING THIS APRIL?
10:12:42PM >>LYNN HURTAK: BECAUSE OF WHAT YOU ARE GOING TO HAVE TO GO
10:12:45PM THROUGH, MAY IS YOUR BEST BET.
10:12:47PM >> THANK YOU.
10:12:48PM LaCHONE DOCK: LOOKING AT SCHEDULING-WISE, DRC MAYBE IN
10:12:53PM MARCH AND THEN REVISE THE PLAN AND SUBMIT THEM.
10:12:56PM DRC STAFF WILL REVIEW THEM AGAIN.
10:12:59PM >>LYNN HURTAK: HAS TO HAVE 30 DAY' NOTICE.
10:13:03PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON.
10:13:05PM >>BILL CARLSON: CAN I SAY FOR YOUR CLIENTS.
10:13:08PM USUALLY NOW WE DON'T DO CONTINUANCES THIS LATE AFTER
10:13:11PM SOMETHING HAS BEEN HEARD, AND SO I THINK MY COLLEAGUES ARE
10:13:15PM SUGGESTING IT OUT OF -- OUT OF THE THOUGHT THAT THE PROJECT
10:13:18PM COULD COME BACK BETTER.
10:13:19PM AND LACHONE AND SOMEBODY -- IF WE TURN IT DOWN, HOW LONG
10:13:26PM WILL IT WOULD BE BEFORE THEY COULD COME BACK -- JUST SO
10:13:32PM THEIR --
10:13:33PM >>LaCHONE DOCK: LaCHONE DOCK, LAND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION.
10:13:35PM CORRECT, THEY WILL HAVE TO WAIT A YEAR TO COME BACK BEFORE
10:13:39PM COUNCIL WITH THE REQUEST.
10:13:44PM >>BILL CARLSON: IF WE WERE STRICTLY FOLLOWING THE RULES AND
10:13:46PM VOTE IT DOWN, IT WOULD BE A YEAR.
10:13:48PM SO BY -- BY ALLOWING A CONTINUANCE, IT IS SAVING A LOT TIME.
10:13:53PM >> WE APPRECIATE IT.
10:13:55PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I WILL MAKE A MOTION.
10:14:00PM >>MARTIN SHELBY: TO GRANT THE CONTINUANCE YOU NEED TO WAIVE
10:14:03PM YOUR RULES -- IF BUT MAKE -- IF COUNCIL --
10:14:06PM >> MOTION TO WAIVE THE RULES.
10:14:07PM >>LYNN HURTAK: SECOND.
10:14:08PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: A MOTION AND A SECOND.
10:14:10PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:14:10PM MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE.
10:14:14PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I MOVE TO CONTINUE FILE NUMBER REZ 25-13 TO
10:14:19PM THE MAY 8 CITY COUNCIL EVENING SESSION AT 5:01 P.M. -- I SHOULD
10:14:26PM HAVE THIS MEMORIZED BY NOW -- 315 E. KENNEDY, THIRD FLOOR AT
10:14:35PM 5:01.
10:14:36PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
10:14:38PM ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE.
10:14:39PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:14:40PM SEE YOU BACK ON THE 8th.
10:14:45PM >> LAST ITEM OF THE NIGHT, 9.
10:14:47PM >>CHRISTOPHER DEMANCHE: AGENDA ITEM 9 IS REZ 25-19.
10:14:51PM THIS IS A REQUEST TO REZONE 3502 NORTH LINCOLN AVENUE FROM
10:14:56PM RS 50 TO PLANNED DEVELOPMENT FOR RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY
10:14:59PM DETACHED USES.
10:15:00PM I'LL TURN IT OVER TO PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
10:15:06PM >> JENNIFER MALONE WITH YOUR PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF.
10:15:09PM WE ARE IN THE CENTRAL TAMPA PLANNING DISTRICT.
10:15:11PM THIS IS THE MacFARLANE PARK NEIGHBORHOOD.
10:15:13PM I THINK THE IMAGE SPEAKS FOR ITSELF.
10:15:16PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED ALL AROUND IT AT THE CORNER OF NORTH
10:15:20PM LINCOLN AVENUE AND WEST -- IT'S LATE.
10:15:25PM I'M GOING TO MESS IT UP.
10:15:26PM ABDELLA STREET.
10:15:30PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THAT'S FINE.
10:15:31PM >> IT IS A FUTURE LAND USE OF RESIDENTIAL 10.
10:15:33PM IT IS THE ORANGE COLOR.
10:15:35PM IT IS THE PREDOMINANT FUTURE LAND USE IN THE SURROUNDING
10:15:38PM AREA, AND THAT'S CONSISTENT WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PATTERN
10:15:41PM BEING TYPICALLY VERY SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED.
10:15:43PM I WILL BE BRIEF, BUT I DO JUST WANT TO PUT ON THE RECORD
10:15:48PM THAT THE, IF YOU LOOK AT THE LOT SIZES OF THE SURROUNDING
10:15:52PM AREA, MS. DOCK WILL GO -- SORRY, MR. DEMANCHE WILL GO INTO
10:15:58PM MORE DETAIL HERE, BUT THIS IS DEVELOPED, THE STREET, AT 78%
10:16:03PM OF THE DENSITY ANTICIPATED UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL 10
10:16:06PM DESIGNATION.
10:16:06PM SO WE DO SEE THIS AREA OF THE CITY IS REACHING ITS
10:16:11PM DEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL UNDER THIS DESIGNATION, PLANNED FOR
10:16:14PM TEN DWELLING UNITS AN ACRE.
10:16:16PM THE TWO DWELLING UNITS ON THE SUBJECT SITE WILL JUST FURTHER
10:16:19PM THAT.
10:16:19PM SUPPORTED BY THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN POLICIES TO PROVIDE MORE
10:16:23PM HOUSING FOR TAMPA'S GROWING POPULATION.
10:16:25PM THANK YOU.
10:16:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:16:27PM ALL RIGHT.
10:16:39PM >> WE'LL START WITH AN AERIAL OF THE SUBJECT SITE AND THE
10:16:42PM SURROUNDING AREA.
10:16:44PM YOU CAN SEE THE SUBJECT SITE OUTLINED IN RED.
10:16:48PM IT'S LOCATED ON THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF WEST OF ABDELLA
10:16:52PM STREET AND NORTH LINCOLN AVENUE.
10:16:54PM THE SURROUNDING DEVELOPMENT PATTERN TO THE NORTH, SOUTH, AND
10:16:57PM EAST AND WEST OF THE SUBJECT SITE IS COMPRISED OF
10:17:00PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED DWELLINGS WITH RS 50 ZONING.
10:17:03PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED DWELLING DEVELOPMENT CONTINUES WEST
10:17:07PM OF THE SUBJECT SITE, ALL THE WAY UP TO NORTH HIMES AVENUE,
10:17:11PM ALONG NORTH HIMES AVENUE, WE SEE A MIX OF NOT JUST THE
10:17:15PM RESIDENTIAL USES, BUT WE DO SEE SOME BUSINESS PROFESSIONAL
10:17:19PM OFFICE USES SPRINKLED IN AND LOCATED ADJACENT TO THE
10:17:24PM RESIDENTIAL USES.
10:17:25PM HERE WE HAVE THE SITE PLAN PROVIDED BY THE APPLICANT.
10:17:36PM THERE IS AN EXISTING SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED DWELLING LOCATED
10:17:40PM ON THE SOUTHERN PORTION OF THE SITE.
10:17:42PM IT'S ONE STORY.
10:17:43PM IT'S A LITTLE OVER 1500 SQUARE FEET.
10:17:46PM THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING THE CONSTRUCTION OF A TWO-STORY
10:17:50PM SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED STRUCTURE, TOTALING 1,806 SQUARE FEET
10:17:55PM TO BE LOCATED ON THE NORTHERN PORTION OF THE SITE.
10:17:57PM THE EXISTING SITE OVERALL WITH FRONTAGE ALONG WEST ABDELLA
10:18:04PM STREET AND NORTH LINCOLN AVENUE WOULD BE SPLIT CREATING AN
10:18:08PM INDIVIDUAL LOT FOR EACH DWELLING.
10:18:10PM THE PROPOSED SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED DWELLING WOULD HAVE
10:18:13PM FRONTAGE ALONG NORTH LINCOLN AVENUE WITH BOTH THE FRONT DOOR
10:18:17PM AND TWO CAR GARAGE FACING THE RIGHT-OF-WAY OF NORTH LINCOLN
10:18:21PM AVENUE.
10:18:22PM HERE WE HAVE SOME ELEVATIONS.
10:18:28PM WE HAVE THE EAST ELEVATION SHOWING.
10:18:32PM THE FRONT ENTRYWAY, THE TWO-CAR GARAGE.
10:18:35PM THE OVERALL HEIGHT FOR THE PROPOSED DWELLING WOULD BE 24
10:18:39PM FEET, 9 INCHES.
10:18:40PM SO WE HAVE THE EAST AND WEST ELEVATIONS.
10:18:45PM THEN WE HAVE THE NORTH AND SOUTH ELEVATIONS.
10:18:49PM THERE ARE NO WAIVERS REQUESTED WITH THIS APPLICATION.
10:18:55PM I DO HAVE SOME PHOTOS SHOWING THE EXISTING SITE AND
10:18:58PM SURROUNDING AREA.
10:18:59PM WE'LL GET TO THOSE NOW.
10:19:01PM THIS IS THE EXISTING SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED DWELLING THAT
10:19:05PM WOULD BE LOCATED ON THE SOUTHERN PORTION OF THE SITE.
10:19:09PM THIS WAS TAKEN FROM WEST OF DELLA STREET.
10:19:12PM THE NEXT PHOTO SHOWS THE BACKYARD OF THE SINGLE-FAMILY
10:19:15PM DWELLING.
10:19:15PM THIS IS THE PROPOSED LOCATION FOR THE PROPOSED DWELLING,
10:19:19PM WHICH WOULD BE ON THE NORTHERN PORTION OF THE SITE.
10:19:23PM JUST NORTH OF THE PROPOSED SITE WE HAVE ANOTHER DETACHED
10:19:27PM DWELLING.
10:19:29PM NEXT PHOTO SHOWS FROM THE SUBJECT PROPERTY, THE SOUTHERN
10:19:33PM PORTION OF THE SITE LOOKING SOUTH ACROSS WEST OF DELLA
10:19:38PM STREET.
10:19:38PM THIS IS THE PARCEL ADJACENT ON THE WEST FROM THE SUBJECT
10:19:41PM SITE.
10:19:44PM THE NEXT PHOTO SHOWS LOOKING EAST ACROSS NORTH LINCOLN
10:19:49PM AVENUE.
10:19:51PM NEXT WE HAVE LOOKING DOWN, LOOKING EAST DOWN WEST ABDELLA
10:19:57PM STREET.
10:19:58PM LOOKING WEST DOWN WEST ABDELLA STREET.
10:20:04PM THE LAST PHOTO I HAVE HERE IS LOOKING SOUTHEAST FROM THE
10:20:07PM SUBJECT SITE.
10:20:08PM DEVELOPMENT COORDINATION AND COMPLIANCE STAFF HAVE REVIEWED
10:20:12PM THIS APPLICATION.
10:20:12PM WE FIND IT TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
10:20:17PM SHOULD IT BE THE PLEASURE OF CITY COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE
10:20:19PM APPLICATION, MODIFICATIONS TO THE SITE PLAN AS SHOWN ON THE
10:20:22PM SUBMITTED REVISION SHEET MUST BE COMPLETED BETWEEN FIRST AND
10:20:25PM SECOND READING.
10:20:26PM I'M AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
10:20:28PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS?
10:20:29PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:20:30PM APPLICANT.
10:20:35PM YES, SIR, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
10:20:36PM >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL.
10:20:37PM MIKE NOLAN, ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS, AGENT FOR
10:20:41PM THE APPLICANT.
10:20:42PM OWNER'S INTENTION TO PUT AN ADDITIONAL ONE-STORY -- EXCUSE
10:20:47PM ME, ONE SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE ON THE NORTHERN PORTION OF
10:20:50PM THE LOT.
10:20:55PM STAFF AND PLANNING COMMISSION HAVE FOUND IT CONSISTENT.
10:20:57PM I DON'T REALLY HAVE TOO MUCH TO ADD, BUT I WILL BE HERE
10:21:00PM AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS.
10:21:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANY QUESTIONS, YES, MA'AM.
10:21:02PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I DON'T KNOW IF THIS IS FOR YOU OR STAFF, BUT
10:21:05PM CAN YOU -- WHAT WILL THE SIZE OF THE LOTS BE?
10:21:09PM WILL THEY BE CONFORMING?
10:21:12PM >> SO THE EXISTING ZONING IS RS 50, WHICH THE MINIMUM LOT
10:21:17PM WIDTH IS 50 FEET.
10:21:20PM SO THE NORTHERN LOT THAT WE'RE PROPOSING IS ONLY 45 FEET
10:21:24PM WIDE.
10:21:25PM >>LYNN HURTAK: THANK YOU.
10:21:26PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:21:28PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THAT AREA THERE, I'M NOT SURE IN THAT
10:21:30PM AREA, BUT RIGHT TO THE EAST OF YOU, THERE IS A LOT OF
10:21:33PM DITCHES.
10:21:34PM I DON'T KNOW IF THERE ARE DITCHES IN FRONT OF THESE HOUSES
10:21:36PM OR NOT.
10:21:37PM >> NO.
10:21:37PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YOU ARE ON LINCOLN THEN, LINCOLN AND
10:21:40PM ABDELLA?
10:21:42PM >> NORTHWEST CORNER.
10:21:44PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THOSE CORRESPONDENCE ARE USUALLY A --
10:21:47PM THOSE CORNERS ARE USUALLY A LITTLE LARGER.
10:21:50PM WHAT IS THE TOTAL SQUARE FOOTAGE OF THE LOT?
10:21:53PM >> TOTAL LOT CURRENTLY IS A LITTLE MORE THAN -- YEAH, SORRY.
10:22:00PM IT'S 10,700 SQUARE FEET.
10:22:05PM IT IS A LITTLE BIT MORE THAN A DOUBLE LOT.
10:22:07PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: THE OTHER RESIDENCE WILL STAY THE WAY IT
10:22:10PM IS.
10:22:11PM >> EXISTING RESIDENCE IS TO REMAIN.
10:22:14PM JUST WHERE THE LOCATION IS --
10:22:16PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: -- HAD ABOUT THREE AIR-CONDITIONERS IN
10:22:19PM THE BACK.
10:22:19PM HOPE IT IS NOT A RENTAL PROPERTY OR A HOUSING UNIT IN A
10:22:23PM RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT.
10:22:25PM I'M NOT TALKING ABOUT -- I SAW SOMETHING THAT HAD LIKE
10:22:29PM THREE --
10:22:29PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YEAH, YOU SHOWED THE BACKYARD OF THE
10:22:32PM PROPERTY AND IT HAD THE EXTERIOR AC UNITS, THE INDIVIDUAL
10:22:36PM ONES BY EACH WINDOW.
10:22:38PM >> OH, ON THE NORTH SIDE OF THE EXISTING RESIDENCE.
10:22:44PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SPLIT UNITS THEY CALL THEM, I THINK.
10:22:52PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS THAT WHAT THE SPLIT UNIT IS?
10:22:57PM >> [INAUDIBLE]
10:23:00PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: AT THE OTHER HOUSE?
10:23:01PM >> THAT IS THE EXISTING HOUSE.
10:23:03PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE OR DOUBLE
10:23:05PM APARTMENT BUILDING?
10:23:06PM >> IT'S A SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE AS FAR AS I'M AWARE.
10:23:11PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THOSE ARE CALLED SPLITS.
10:23:13PM THEN YOU HAVE THE INDIVIDUAL UNIT.
10:23:15PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:23:16PM IS THERE ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS
10:23:19PM ITEM?
10:23:20PM I SEE NO ONE.
10:23:21PM MOTION TO CLOSE FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
10:23:22PM DO WE HAVE A SECOND?
10:23:23PM SECOND FROM COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:23:25PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:23:25PM AYE.
10:23:26PM WHO WOULD LIKE TO READ THIS?
10:23:28PM GO AHEAD, SIR.
10:23:32PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I MOVE FILE REZ 25-19, AN ORDINANCE BEING
10:23:36PM PRESENTED FOR FIRST READING CONSIDERATION, AN ORDINANCE
10:23:39PM REZONING PROPERTY IN THE GENERAL VICINITY OF 3502 NORTH
10:23:43PM LINCOLN AVENUE IN THE CITY OF TAMPA, FLORIDA, MORE
10:23:45PM PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN SECTION 1 FROM ZONING DISTRICT
10:23:47PM CLASSIFICATION RS 50 RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY, TO PD,
10:23:51PM PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED,
10:23:54PM PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
10:23:54PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: IS THERE A SECOND?
10:23:55PM SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CARLSON.
10:23:59PM ROLL CALL VOTE, PLEASE?
10:24:02PM >>BILL CARLSON: YES.
10:24:03PM >>LYNN HURTAK: YES.
10:24:04PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: YES.
10:24:06PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: YES.
10:24:07PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES.
10:24:08PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: YES.
10:24:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES.
10:24:11PM >>THE CLERK: THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
10:24:13PM SECOND READING AND ADOPTION WILL BE HELD ON MARCH 27, 2025,
10:24:17PM AT 10 A.M. LOCATED AT 315 EAST KENNEDY BOULEVARD, THIRD
10:24:21PM FLOOR, TAMPA, FLORIDA, 33602.
10:24:24PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
10:24:25PM THAT CONCLUDES OUR AGENDA.
10:24:27PM NEW BUSINESS, COUNCILMAN MIRANDA.
10:24:28PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: IF I MAY.
10:24:30PM THIS IS JUST A THOUGHT.
10:24:31PM THE MEETING WE HAD TODAY WAS GREAT REGARDING THE BUDGETS AND
10:24:34PM SO FORTH AND EVERYTHING.
10:24:35PM I WAS JUST THINKING IF WE COULD GET MS. HAGAR, THE BUDGET
10:24:39PM ANALYST FROM THE CITY, TO MEET DOWN STAIRS WITH THE BUDGET
10:24:42PM COMMITTEE WE FORMED AND WORK SO WELL, EXPLAIN, MAYBE GET
10:24:46PM FEEDBACK WHAT WE TALKED ABOUT TODAY, ESPECIALLY ON THE CIT
10:24:49PM TAX, BECAUSE I DON'T KNOW IF THAT CAN BE DONE.
10:24:52PM BUT IF WE CAN PAY THAT LITTLE BY LITTLE AS THE MONEY COMES
10:24:55PM IN, WE CAN SAVE A LOT OF MONEY, THE INTEREST THAT WILL BE
10:24:58PM ABSORBED TO US.
10:25:01PM >>LYNN HURTAK: MS. KOPESKY GOES TO EVERY ONE OF THE
10:25:04PM MEETINGS.
10:25:04PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: MAKE A MOTION TO GET WITH THE CHAIRMAN OR
10:25:06PM YOURSELF OR SOMEBODY AND MEET -- MEET WITH THE COUNCIL
10:25:11PM INDIVIDUALLY TO GET IDEAS SO SHE CAN GO DOWN AND MEET AND
10:25:15PM PRESENT SOMETHING TO THEM SO THEY CAN UNDERSTAND WHAT WE'RE
10:25:17PM DOING AND WORK OUT SOMETHING BETTER FOR THE CITIZENS.
10:25:21PM >>LYNN HURTAK: SHE COULD COME TO ALL OF US.
10:25:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION, AND DO WE HAVE A
10:25:24PM SECOND?
10:25:30PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I DON'T KNOW THAT WE NEED A MOTION.
10:25:31PM THEN I'LL SECOND.
10:25:32PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: MOTION AND SECOND.
10:25:33PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:25:33PM ANY OPPOSED?
10:25:34PM COUNCILMAN --
10:25:37PM >>BILL CARLSON: DID YOU MENTION A SPECIFIC IDEA YOU WANT
10:25:39PM THEM TO TALK ABOUT?
10:25:41PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: SPECIFIC IDEA WHEN I ASKED A QUESTION,
10:25:45PM DOES THAT MONEY PAY, NO, IT PAYS AS IT COMES IN.
10:25:49PM IF IT COMES IN, WHY DO WE HAVE TO PAY THE INTEREST?
10:25:51PM WHY BOND IT?
10:25:56PM >>BILL CARLSON: THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT I BELIEVE AS WELL.
10:25:58PM I HOPE THEY'LL ASK, IF SHE'LL ASK THAT SPECIFIC QUESTION.
10:26:02PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I'LL MAKE SURE THEY DO.
10:26:04PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN VIERA, DO YOU HAVE ANY NEW
10:26:06PM BUSINESS?
10:26:07PM >>LUIS VIERA: NO, SIR.
10:26:08PM THANK YOU.
10:26:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WHAT?
10:26:17PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: FEBRUARY 27, 2025, 10:26 P.M., HISTORY WAS
10:26:21PM MADE.
10:26:24PM >>LUIS VIERA: LET'S WRITE THE POPE AND DECLARE A MIRACLE.
10:26:27PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN.
10:26:28PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I HAVE A COUPLE OF THINGS.
10:26:30PM ON FEBRUARY 16, 2025, I ACCEPTED THE RESIGNATION OF JONATHAN
10:26:37PM BRILL FROM THE CITY COUNCIL CITIZENS ADVISORY BUDGET AND
10:26:40PM FINANCE COMMITTEE.
10:26:41PM I WANTED TO THANK HIM FOR HIS SERVICE TO THE COMMITTEE.
10:26:46PM JONATHAN IS A GREAT GUY.
10:26:47PM PERSONAL COMMITMENTS THAT PRECLUDED HIM FROM BEING ABLE TO
10:26:50PM SERVE IN THAT CAPACITY.
10:26:51PM SO I WOULD LIKE TO MOTION TO APPOINT HOYT PRINDLE TO SERVE
10:26:56PM AS REPRESENTATIVE FOR DISTRICT ONE FOR THE CITY COUNCIL
10:26:58PM ADVISORY BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE TO SERVE THE REMAINDER
10:27:04PM OF THAT TERM.
10:27:05PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND SECOND.
10:27:06PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:27:08PM >>CHARLIE MIRANDA: I'VE GOT NO PROBLEM WITH THAT.
10:27:10PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ALL IN FAVOR?
10:27:10PM AYE.
10:27:11PM ANY OPPOSED?
10:27:14PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: ONE MORE THING, THIS AFTERNOON, I READ
10:27:17PM THAT MY PROPOSED RESOLUTION HONORING MUSLIM HERITAGE MONTH
10:27:22PM IN CONJUNCTION WITH RAMADAN 2025.
10:27:25PM I WON'T READ ALL THE ENTIRE WHEREASES BUT I WOULD LIKE TO
10:27:28PM READ THE THEREFORES BECAUSE WE HAVE MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY
10:27:32PM HERE TO TALK ABOUT THIS.
10:27:33PM BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TAMPA,
10:27:36PM FLORIDA, TAMPA CITY COUNCIL HEREBY CELEBRATES THE PERIOD OF
10:27:39PM FEBRUARY 28, 2025, TO MARCH 29, 2025, AS MUSLIM HERITAGE
10:27:44PM MONTH IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE OBSERVANCE OF RAMADAN.
10:27:47PM TAMPA CITY COUNCIL ENCOURAGES EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS,
10:27:50PM COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS, BUSINESSES AND RESIDENTS TO
10:27:52PM PARTICIPATE IN ACTIVITIES AND PROGRAMS THAT HONOR AND
10:27:55PM CELEBRATE THE CONTRIBUTIONS OF THE MUSLIM COMMUNITY.
10:27:59PM TAMPA CITY COUNCIL SUPPORTS INITIATIVES THAT PROMOTE
10:28:01PM UNDERSTANDING, RESPECT AND COLLABORATION AMONG ALL CULTURAL
10:28:03PM AND RELIGIOUS GROUPS WITHIN TAMPA.
10:28:06PM THIS RESOLUTION WILL TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY UPON ITS
10:28:09PM ADOPTION.
10:28:12PM THAT IS THAT.
10:28:13PM AND WOULD YOU MIND -- I'M MOVING THE RESOLUTION, BUT WHAT I
10:28:17PM WOULD LIKE TO DO, BECAUSE WE HAVE MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY
10:28:19PM THAT CAME TONIGHT, WOULD YOU MIND HAVING THEM COME UP AS A
10:28:23PM GROUP.
10:28:23PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY WISH TO SPEAK, SAY ANYTHING?
10:28:27PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: WOULD SOMEBODY LIKE TO COME UP AND TALK
10:28:29PM VERY BRIEFLY BECAUSE IT IS SO LATE.
10:28:32PM I KNOW YOU GUYS SAT HERE ALL NIGHT LONG WAITING FOR THIS.
10:28:37PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME.
10:28:39PM >> MY NAME IS GASSER.
10:28:41PM I PRESENT THE COMMUNITY OF THE MUSLIMS AND THE TAMPA BAY
10:28:46PM AREA.
10:28:47PM WE WOULD LIKE TO RECOGNIZE THE GREATNESS OF THE CITY OF
10:28:52PM TAMPA FOR RECOGNIZING OUR MUSLIM HERITAGE MONTH.
10:28:56PM WE REALLY APPRECIATE IT AND THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:28:59PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: ANYBODY ELSE?
10:29:00PM YES, MA'AM.
10:29:04PM >> MY NAME IS TANYA ABDEL.
10:29:07PM THANK YOU SO MUCH.
10:29:07PM I KNOW IT'S LATE, BUT WE ARE ECSTATIC, EXCITED AND HAPPY TO
10:29:13PM CELEBRATE THIS.
10:29:15PM IN A COUPLE OF DAYS WE ARE STARTING THE MONTH OF RAMADAN
10:29:18PM WHICH WE WILL BE FASTING.
10:29:20PM I WANT TO THANK THE MEMBERS OF MY COMMUNITY FOR BRINGING
10:29:25PM THIS TO YOUR ATTENTION AND FOR YOU TO ACCEPT IT AND TO MAKE
10:29:30PM US FEEL AS MUSLIMS INCLUDED AND ACTIVE IN THIS COMMUNITY AND
10:29:35PM WE ARE HONORED TO BE YOUR NEIGHBORS AND YOUR DOCTORS AND
10:29:40PM YOUR FELLOW MEMBERS OF THE SOCIETY.
10:29:42PM THANK YOU FOR MAKING TAMPA DIVERSE AND SAFE AND PROSPEROUS,
10:29:47PM THANK YOU.
10:29:47PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:29:48PM YES, SIR.
10:29:48PM COME ON UP.
10:29:52PM >> I JUST WANTED TO -- I FORGOT TO INVITE YOU ALL FOR THE
10:29:57PM PINNACLE THAT WE'RE HAVING FOR THE MONTH OF RAMADAN.
10:30:01PM HAPPENING ON THE 16th OF MARCH.
10:30:06PM GOING TO BE SENDING YOU THE INVITATION INDIVIDUALLY.
10:30:10PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:30:11PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU.
10:30:11PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: THANK YOU.
10:30:12PM I SAID THIS AFTERNOON, IT'S ONE OF THE REASONS I CHOSE TO
10:30:15PM RAISE MY CHILDREN IN TAMPA BECAUSE I THINK THIS IS ONE OF
10:30:18PM THE MOST INCREDIBLE CITIES.
10:30:20PM IT'S A CITY THAT IS DIVERSE, AND WE HONOR AND WE APPRECIATE
10:30:23PM THE DIVERSITY IN THE CITY OF TAMPA AND WE APPRECIATE EVERY
10:30:29PM ELEMENT OF THAT IN EVERY PART OF THAT COMMUNITY AND THE
10:30:31PM RICHNESS THAT IT BRINGS.
10:30:33PM AND IT REALLY MAKES ALL OF OUR LIVES BETTER TO BE ABLE TO
10:30:36PM LIVE SHOULDER TO SHOULDER AND HAND IN HAND WITH EVERYBODY
10:30:39PM THAT LIVES HERE.
10:30:39PM SO I PROUDLY MOVE THIS RESOLUTION.
10:30:41PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
10:30:43PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:30:44PM AYE.
10:30:45PM ANY OPPOSED.
10:30:47PM >>LUIS VIERA: MAY I, MR. CHAIR?
10:30:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, SIR.
10:30:50PM >>LUIS VIERA: THANK YOU.
10:30:51PM AND THANK YOU, COUNCILMAN CLENDENIN FOR THAT.
10:30:53PM ALSO, I MENTIONED THAT WE ALWAYS -- WE'RE GOING TO HAVE THE
10:30:58PM NEW TAMPA RECREATION CENTER A GET-TOGETHER.
10:31:01PM OBVIOUSLY, EVERYBODY FROM COUNCIL IS INVITED THERE IN
10:31:04PM PARTICULAR.
10:31:05PM IF COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN, IF YOU WANTED TO PRESENT THE
10:31:07PM RESOLUTION TO FOLKS THERE, IT'S GOING TO BE MONDAY AT 4:30.
10:31:10PM I KNOW WE'RE ALSO WORKING WITH THE MAYOR'S OFFICE TO
10:31:16PM HOPEFULLY GET A PROCLAMATION OUT OF THEM AS WELL, ONE FROM
10:31:20PM COUNCIL AND ONE FROM THE ADMINISTRATION, AND I SEE NO REASON
10:31:24PM AS TO WHY THAT WON'T HAPPEN.
10:31:27PM YEAH, JUST THANK YOU.
10:31:28PM THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR.
10:31:31PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: IF IT IS THIS MONDAY AT 4:30, I CAN'T.
10:31:34PM IF YOU'RE ABLE TO DO THAT ON OUR BEHALF, REALLY APPRECIATE
10:31:37PM THAT.
10:31:38PM >>LUIS VIERA: YES, SIR, THANK YOU.
10:31:39PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:31:40PM I'VE SIGNED THE RESOLUTION.
10:31:42PM I'M GIVING IT BACK TO YOU.
10:31:44PM IT'S OFFICIAL THERE.
10:31:45PM THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
10:31:46PM ANYTHING ELSE, SIR?
10:31:48PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: I'M DONE.
10:31:48PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I DON'T HAVE A MOTION.
10:31:50PM I WANT TO OFFER MY CONDOLENCES TO THE FAMILY OF NORMA BEAN,
10:31:54PM WHICH MANY OF US KNOW.
10:31:56PM SHE PASSED AWAY YESTERDAY MORNING.
10:32:03PM SHE WAS MARRIED TO GEORGE BEAN, WHO WAS BASICALLY THE FATHER
10:32:07PM OF THE MODERN TAMPA INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT.
10:32:10PM AND SHE WAS ACTUALLY MARRIED TO COOKIE GARCIA, ANOTHER
10:32:13PM GENTLEMAN WHO WE ALL KNEW WHO PASSED AWAY.
10:32:16PM WONDERFUL PEOPLE.
10:32:17PM I WANT TO OFFER MY CONDOLENCES.
10:32:19PM SHE WAS VERY, VERY INVOLVED IN THE COMMUNITY AND, YOU KNOW,
10:32:22PM ALL THE GOOD ONES GO.
10:32:23PM YES, MA'AM.
10:32:24PM >>LYNN HURTAK: I DON'T HAVE ANYTHING.
10:32:27PM >>BILL CARLSON: BEFORE SHE WENT INTO THE MEMORY CARE CENTER,
10:32:32PM WE ALL USED TO HANG OUT ALL THE TIME.
10:32:36PM SHE WAS SUCH A DELIGHTFUL, GREAT PERSON AND HAD ALL THE
10:32:39PM HISTORY OF GEORGE BEAN IN THE AIRPORT, WHICH IS REALLY
10:32:42PM FASCINATING.
10:32:43PM WHEN IS THE SERVICE?
10:32:44PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: I DON'T KNOW YET.
10:32:45PM IT'S GOING TO BE AT THE FUNERAL HOME ON ARMENIA AND OSBORNE.
10:32:50PM THE DETAILS HAVEN'T BEEN POSTED YET.
10:32:55PM >>BILL CARLSON: PROBLEM WITH GETTING OLDER IS NOW ALL OF OUR
10:32:58PM FRIENDS ARE PASSING AWAY.
10:32:59PM A COUPLE OF THINGS, THANK YOU TO OUR FRIENDS FROM THE MUSLIM
10:33:03PM COMMUNITY FOR COMING HERE.
10:33:06PM WISH YOU A GREAT MUSLIM HERITAGE MONTH.
10:33:11PM ALSO, COUNCIL MEMBER HENDERSON GOT AN AWARD TONIGHT,
10:33:14PM ALTHOUGH SHE WAS HERE AND SKIPPED GETTING THE AWARD.
10:33:18PM CAN YOU TELL US WHAT THE AWARD WAS AGAIN, DOWNTOWN
10:33:20PM PARTNERSHIP?
10:33:21PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: DOWNTOWN PARTNERSHIP -- IT WAS FOR BLACK
10:33:30PM ENGLISH BOOKSTORE.
10:33:32PM IT WAS FOR SMALL BUSINESSES I GUESS IN THE DOWNTOWN
10:33:34PM PARTNERSHIP AREA.
10:33:35PM AND I WON.
10:33:37PM ARIEL WENT AND PICKED UP THE AWARD FOR ME.
10:33:40PM >>BILL CARLSON: IT IS A BIG DEAL TO WIN ONE OF THE AWARDS.
10:33:44PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: I COULDN'T BE THERE.
10:33:45PM WE'RE HERE.
10:33:46PM IT WAS SOUTH TAMPA.
10:33:52PM THANK YOU FOR SHARING THAT.
10:33:55PM >>BILL CARLSON: GOT A TROPHY.
10:33:58PM >>GWEN HENDERSON: LOOKS LIKE A RAILROAD TRACK OR SOMETHING.
10:34:00PM IT'S VERY NICE.
10:34:06PM GWEN MYERS' HUSBAND HAS PASSED AWAY.
10:34:11PM CONDOLENCES TO HER.
10:34:12PM THE WAKE IS TOMORROW.
10:34:13PM I DID WRITE A LETTER ON BEHALF OF TAMPA CITY COUNCIL.
10:34:21PM >>BILL CARLSON: SHE SPOKE AT CAFE TAMPA.
10:34:27PM I'VE HAD A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT KILEY GARDEN AND THE
10:34:30PM PARKING GARAGE UNDER IT.
10:34:32PM I DON'T REMEMBER THAT WE'VE HAD AN UPDATE ON THAT LATELY.
10:34:34PM UNLESS SOMEBODY REMEMBERS THAT WE HAVE.
10:34:36PM I'D LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO ASK STAFF TO PRESENT A
10:34:40PM FIVE-MINUTE UPDATE ON THE STATUS OF KILEY GARDEN AND THE
10:34:43PM PARKING GARAGE BENEATH IT ON JULY 31st TO INCLUDE PLANS
10:34:47PM AND TIMELINE TO REPAIR THE DAMAGE.
10:34:49PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: WE HAVE A MOTION AND WE HAVE A SECOND
10:34:51PM FROM COUNCIL MEMBER HURTAK.
10:34:52PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:34:53PM AYE.
10:34:54PM ANY OPPOSED?
10:34:57PM >>ALAN CLENDENIN: TODAY IS JIM PORTER'S BIRTHDAY.
10:34:59PM HAPPY BIRTHDAY, MR. PORTER.
10:35:01PM >>GUIDO MANISCALCO: YES, IT IS.
10:35:03PM HAPPY BIRTHDAY.
10:35:03PM MOTION TO RECEIVE AND FILE?
10:35:04PM MOTION FROM COUNCIL MEMBER MIRANDA.
10:35:09PM WE HAVE A SECOND FROM COUNCIL MEMBER CLENDENIN.
10:35:14PM ALL IN FAVOR?
10:35:15PM AYE.
10:35:15PM WE ARE ADJOURNED.
10:35:16PM [ SOUNDING GAVEL ]
DISCLAIMER:
THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME
CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE
ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE
PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER.